[
  {
    "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252732",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252732,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1990,
      "AgendaID": 2053,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Role of Scientific Evidence and Advice in Public Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05154.2",
      "ID": 5299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1926,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian",
      "DisplayName": "Brian Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7511644+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2615E213P388VM258943",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258943,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1990,
      "AgendaID": 2053,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Role of Scientific Evidence and Advice in Public Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05154.2",
      "ID": 5299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2615,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George",
      "DisplayName": "George Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3349325+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319589",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319589,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1990,
      "AgendaID": 2053,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Role of Scientific Evidence and Advice in Public Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05154.2",
      "ID": 5299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4940,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare",
      "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9327911+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249533",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 249533,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1990,
      "AgendaID": 2053,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Role of Scientific Evidence and Advice in Public Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05154.2",
      "ID": 5299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2641,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair",
      "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9309728+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1783E21P273VM227850",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227850,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1990,
      "AgendaID": 2053,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Role of Scientific Evidence and Advice in Public Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05154.2",
      "ID": 5299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1783,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie",
      "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5683481+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2633E97P136VM280871",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280871,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1990,
      "AgendaID": 2053,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Role of Scientific Evidence and Advice in Public Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05154.2",
      "ID": 5299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2633,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire",
      "DisplayName": "Claire Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.785927+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262767",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262767,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1990,
      "AgendaID": 2053,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Role of Scientific Evidence and Advice in Public Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05154.2",
      "ID": 5299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2603,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6159643+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5038E96P110VM288151",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 288151,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1990,
      "AgendaID": 2053,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Role of Scientific Evidence and Advice in Public Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05154.2",
      "ID": 5299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5038,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baxter, Jayne",
      "DisplayName": "Jayne Baxter",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.9091179+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1759E91P115VM229856",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229856,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1990,
      "AgendaID": 2053,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Role of Scientific Evidence and Advice in Public Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05154.2",
      "ID": 5299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia",
      "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.1003677+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3751E243P383VM269774",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269774,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1990,
      "AgendaID": 2053,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Role of Scientific Evidence and Advice in Public Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05154.2",
      "ID": 5299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3751,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5623798+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322572",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 322572,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1990,
      "AgendaID": 2053,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Role of Scientific Evidence and Advice in Public Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05154.2",
      "ID": 5299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5109,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco",
      "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6944842+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5060E86P124VM295303",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295303,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1990,
      "AgendaID": 2053,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Role of Scientific Evidence and Advice in Public Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05154.2",
      "ID": 5299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5060,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5061988+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242980",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242980,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1990,
      "AgendaID": 2053,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Role of Scientific Evidence and Advice in Public Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05154.2",
      "ID": 5299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1866,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah",
      "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.043779+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235147",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235147,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1990,
      "AgendaID": 2053,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Role of Scientific Evidence and Advice in Public Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05154.2",
      "ID": 5299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1943,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic",
      "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4214084+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302421",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 302421,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1990,
      "AgendaID": 2053,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Role of Scientific Evidence and Advice in Public Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05154.2",
      "ID": 5299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2595,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin",
      "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5236998+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244236",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244236,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1990,
      "AgendaID": 2053,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Role of Scientific Evidence and Advice in Public Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05154.2",
      "ID": 5299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2103,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith",
      "DisplayName": "Keith Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5459315+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327086",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 327086,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1990,
      "AgendaID": 2053,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Role of Scientific Evidence and Advice in Public Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05154.2",
      "ID": 5299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7982366+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277106",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277106,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1990,
      "AgendaID": 2053,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Role of Scientific Evidence and Advice in Public Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05154.2",
      "ID": 5299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.7013584+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264223",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264223,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1990,
      "AgendaID": 2053,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Role of Scientific Evidence and Advice in Public Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05154.2",
      "ID": 5299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2673,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick",
      "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1240371+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248681",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248681,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1990,
      "AgendaID": 2053,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Role of Scientific Evidence and Advice in Public Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05154.2",
      "ID": 5299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2678,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson",
      "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6652615+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2123E27P233VM294933",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 294933,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1990,
      "AgendaID": 2053,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Role of Scientific Evidence and Advice in Public Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05154.2",
      "ID": 5299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2123,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm",
      "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1849993+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285270",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285270,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1990,
      "AgendaID": 2053,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Role of Scientific Evidence and Advice in Public Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05154.2",
      "ID": 5299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3907,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3157566+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230745",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230745,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1990,
      "AgendaID": 2053,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Role of Scientific Evidence and Advice in Public Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05154.2",
      "ID": 5299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1735,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela",
      "DisplayName": "Angela Constance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3437225+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243738",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 243738,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1990,
      "AgendaID": 2053,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Role of Scientific Evidence and Advice in Public Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05154.2",
      "ID": 5299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1932,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce",
      "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3176863+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254825",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254825,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1990,
      "AgendaID": 2053,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Role of Scientific Evidence and Advice in Public Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05154.2",
      "ID": 5299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1863,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna",
      "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2853686+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323693",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 323693,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1990,
      "AgendaID": 2053,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Role of Scientific Evidence and Advice in Public Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05154.2",
      "ID": 5299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4976,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth",
      "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9678166+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5107E223P379VM291239",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291239,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1990,
      "AgendaID": 2053,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Role of Scientific Evidence and Advice in Public Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05154.2",
      "ID": 5299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5107,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1102985+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3743E222P391VM265443",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265443,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1990,
      "AgendaID": 2053,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Role of Scientific Evidence and Advice in Public Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05154.2",
      "ID": 5299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3743,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel",
      "DisplayName": "Nigel Don",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4394005+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262344",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262344,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1990,
      "AgendaID": 2053,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Role of Scientific Evidence and Advice in Public Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05154.2",
      "ID": 5299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3771,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob",
      "DisplayName": "Bob Doris",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.5974335+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281868",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 281868,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1990,
      "AgendaID": 2053,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Role of Scientific Evidence and Advice in Public Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05154.2",
      "ID": 5299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2826,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Dornan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1610564+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298259",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298259,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1990,
      "AgendaID": 2053,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Role of Scientific Evidence and Advice in Public Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05154.2",
      "ID": 5299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3812,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia",
      "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3380449+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231194",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231194,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1990,
      "AgendaID": 2053,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Role of Scientific Evidence and Advice in Public Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05154.2",
      "ID": 5299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1778,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen",
      "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3698749+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4955E240P389VM285019",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285019,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1990,
      "AgendaID": 2053,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Role of Scientific Evidence and Advice in Public Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05154.2",
      "ID": 5299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4955,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0577308+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219484",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 219484,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1990,
      "AgendaID": 2053,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Role of Scientific Evidence and Advice in Public Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05154.2",
      "ID": 5299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1742,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle",
      "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3012756+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238483",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 238483,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1990,
      "AgendaID": 2053,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Role of Scientific Evidence and Advice in Public Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05154.2",
      "ID": 5299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1994,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus",
      "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4560518+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225187",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225187,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1990,
      "AgendaID": 2053,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Role of Scientific Evidence and Advice in Public Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05154.2",
      "ID": 5299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1814,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda",
      "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7482029+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321888",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 321888,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1990,
      "AgendaID": 2053,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Role of Scientific Evidence and Advice in Public Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05154.2",
      "ID": 5299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Fee",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4556614+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292762",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 292762,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1990,
      "AgendaID": 2053,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Role of Scientific Evidence and Advice in Public Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05154.2",
      "ID": 5299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia",
      "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5570731+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227208",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227208,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1990,
      "AgendaID": 2053,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Role of Scientific Evidence and Advice in Public Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05154.2",
      "ID": 5299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5354856+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5054E95P118VM313243",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313243,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1990,
      "AgendaID": 2053,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Role of Scientific Evidence and Advice in Public Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05154.2",
      "ID": 5299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5054,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.3840458+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4947E152P8VM257749",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257749,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1990,
      "AgendaID": 2053,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Role of Scientific Evidence and Advice in Public Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05154.2",
      "ID": 5299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4947,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Finnie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0759686+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271151",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271151,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1990,
      "AgendaID": 2053,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Role of Scientific Evidence and Advice in Public Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05154.2",
      "ID": 5299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3901,
      "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe",
      "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8446753+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278006",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 278006,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1990,
      "AgendaID": 2053,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Role of Scientific Evidence and Advice in Public Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05154.2",
      "ID": 5299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2394,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo",
      "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9829464+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2110E220P414VM287316",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 287316,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1990,
      "AgendaID": 2053,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Role of Scientific Evidence and Advice in Public Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05154.2",
      "ID": 5299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth",
      "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8589219+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250566",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250566,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1990,
      "AgendaID": 2053,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Role of Scientific Evidence and Advice in Public Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05154.2",
      "ID": 5299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2675,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob",
      "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1950884+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221030",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221030,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1990,
      "AgendaID": 2053,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Role of Scientific Evidence and Advice in Public Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05154.2",
      "ID": 5299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1741,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel",
      "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6720608+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220161",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220161,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1990,
      "AgendaID": 2053,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Role of Scientific Evidence and Advice in Public Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05154.2",
      "ID": 5299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1756,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine",
      "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3369775+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1860E104P150VM252442",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252442,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1990,
      "AgendaID": 2053,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Role of Scientific Evidence and Advice in Public Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05154.2",
      "ID": 5299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1860,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda",
      "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7293216+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2033E20P141VM253775",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253775,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1990,
      "AgendaID": 2053,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Role of Scientific Evidence and Advice in Public Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05154.2",
      "ID": 5299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2033,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain",
      "DisplayName": "Iain Gray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0203777+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324712",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324712,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1990,
      "AgendaID": 2053,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Role of Scientific Evidence and Advice in Public Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05154.2",
      "ID": 5299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5042,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2346688+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259628",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 259628,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1990,
      "AgendaID": 2053,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Role of Scientific Evidence and Advice in Public Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05154.2",
      "ID": 5299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick",
      "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6176571+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239413",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239413,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1990,
      "AgendaID": 2053,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Role of Scientific Evidence and Advice in Public Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05154.2",
      "ID": 5299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2029,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh",
      "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7357409+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273694",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 273694,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1990,
      "AgendaID": 2053,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Role of Scientific Evidence and Advice in Public Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05154.2",
      "ID": 5299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3758,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6313809+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304064",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 304064,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1990,
      "AgendaID": 2053,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Role of Scientific Evidence and Advice in Public Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05154.2",
      "ID": 5299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4086,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Hume",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8479013+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221665",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221665,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1990,
      "AgendaID": 2053,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Role of Scientific Evidence and Advice in Public Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05154.2",
      "ID": 5299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1773,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9425334+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1882E227P459VM241895",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241895,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1990,
      "AgendaID": 2053,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Role of Scientific Evidence and Advice in Public Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05154.2",
      "ID": 5299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1882,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam",
      "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7846477+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223459",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223459,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1990,
      "AgendaID": 2053,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Role of Scientific Evidence and Advice in Public Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05154.2",
      "ID": 5299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1893,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4589053+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307842",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307842,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1990,
      "AgendaID": 2053,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Role of Scientific Evidence and Advice in Public Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05154.2",
      "ID": 5299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4934,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8532545+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272302",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 272302,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1990,
      "AgendaID": 2053,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Role of Scientific Evidence and Advice in Public Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05154.2",
      "ID": 5299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4956,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Keir",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3238936+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244991",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244991,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1990,
      "AgendaID": 2053,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Role of Scientific Evidence and Advice in Public Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05154.2",
      "ID": 5299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Kelly",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5873125+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315159",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315159,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1990,
      "AgendaID": 2053,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Role of Scientific Evidence and Advice in Public Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05154.2",
      "ID": 5299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3129,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.676862+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247855",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247855,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1990,
      "AgendaID": 2053,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Role of Scientific Evidence and Advice in Public Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05154.2",
      "ID": 5299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann",
      "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4313112+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4016E11P36VM275089",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 275089,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1990,
      "AgendaID": 2053,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Role of Scientific Evidence and Advice in Public Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05154.2",
      "ID": 5299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4016,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1407147+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255551",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255551,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1990,
      "AgendaID": 2053,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Role of Scientific Evidence and Advice in Public Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05154.2",
      "ID": 5299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2180,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5361873+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4938E158P374VM277000",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277000,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1990,
      "AgendaID": 2053,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Role of Scientific Evidence and Advice in Public Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05154.2",
      "ID": 5299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4938,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.696779+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2112E250P486VM253413",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253413,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1990,
      "AgendaID": 2053,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Role of Scientific Evidence and Advice in Public Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05154.2",
      "ID": 5299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2112,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny",
      "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.9953583+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4939E258P394VM276745",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276745,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1990,
      "AgendaID": 2053,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Role of Scientific Evidence and Advice in Public Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05154.2",
      "ID": 5299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4939,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus",
      "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6792872+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325419",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 325419,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1990,
      "AgendaID": 2053,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Role of Scientific Evidence and Advice in Public Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05154.2",
      "ID": 5299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5074,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon",
      "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.4978871+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1828E3P10VM233246",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 233246,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1990,
      "AgendaID": 2053,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Role of Scientific Evidence and Advice in Public Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05154.2",
      "ID": 5299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1828,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo",
      "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1157385+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311687",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311687,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1990,
      "AgendaID": 2053,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Role of Scientific Evidence and Advice in Public Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05154.2",
      "ID": 5299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4948,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike",
      "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8899461+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2117E90P107VM229696",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229696,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1990,
      "AgendaID": 2053,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Role of Scientific Evidence and Advice in Public Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05154.2",
      "ID": 5299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2117,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis",
      "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0927542+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267469",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 267469,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1990,
      "AgendaID": 2053,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Role of Scientific Evidence and Advice in Public Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05154.2",
      "ID": 5299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken",
      "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0211908+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313474",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313474,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1990,
      "AgendaID": 2053,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Role of Scientific Evidence and Advice in Public Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05154.2",
      "ID": 5299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4966,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek",
      "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.3969354+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3101E102P129VM294969",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 294969,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1990,
      "AgendaID": 2053,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Role of Scientific Evidence and Advice in Public Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05154.2",
      "ID": 5299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3101,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala",
      "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.18654+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319137",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319137,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1990,
      "AgendaID": 2053,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Role of Scientific Evidence and Advice in Public Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05154.2",
      "ID": 5299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5034,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny",
      "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6940287+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306328",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306328,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1990,
      "AgendaID": 2053,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Role of Scientific Evidence and Advice in Public Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05154.2",
      "ID": 5299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2159,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Martin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5473299+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5110E252P395VM310765",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 310765,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1990,
      "AgendaID": 2053,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Role of Scientific Evidence and Advice in Public Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05154.2",
      "ID": 5299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Mason",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5850854+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268135",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 268135,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1990,
      "AgendaID": 2053,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Role of Scientific Evidence and Advice in Public Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05154.2",
      "ID": 5299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2133,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0576885+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2876E141P433VM286440",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286440,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1990,
      "AgendaID": 2053,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Role of Scientific Evidence and Advice in Public Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05154.2",
      "ID": 5299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2876,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5793039+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4951E147P368VM258569",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258569,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1990,
      "AgendaID": 2053,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Role of Scientific Evidence and Advice in Public Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05154.2",
      "ID": 5299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4951,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan",
      "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3129034+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3896E175P307VM263793",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 263793,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1990,
      "AgendaID": 2053,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Role of Scientific Evidence and Advice in Public Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05154.2",
      "ID": 5299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3896,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam",
      "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9049761+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308723",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 308723,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1990,
      "AgendaID": 2053,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Role of Scientific Evidence and Advice in Public Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05154.2",
      "ID": 5299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0681697+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4964E143P375VM279757",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279757,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1990,
      "AgendaID": 2053,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Role of Scientific Evidence and Advice in Public Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05154.2",
      "ID": 5299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4964,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5213044+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279567",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279567,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1990,
      "AgendaID": 2053,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Role of Scientific Evidence and Advice in Public Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05154.2",
      "ID": 5299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3824,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5132503+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2066E22P91VM260996",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 260996,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1990,
      "AgendaID": 2053,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Role of Scientific Evidence and Advice in Public Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05154.2",
      "ID": 5299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2066,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.1070368+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299559",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 299559,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1990,
      "AgendaID": 2053,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Role of Scientific Evidence and Advice in Public Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05154.2",
      "ID": 5299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7026605+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306755",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306755,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1990,
      "AgendaID": 2053,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Role of Scientific Evidence and Advice in Public Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05154.2",
      "ID": 5299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina",
      "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5660094+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300580",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 300580,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1990,
      "AgendaID": 2053,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Role of Scientific Evidence and Advice in Public Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05154.2",
      "ID": 5299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2487,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0047209+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223933",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223933,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1990,
      "AgendaID": 2053,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Role of Scientific Evidence and Advice in Public Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05154.2",
      "ID": 5299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4848328+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237883",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237883,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1990,
      "AgendaID": 2053,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Role of Scientific Evidence and Advice in Public Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05154.2",
      "ID": 5299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1961,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David",
      "DisplayName": "David McLetchie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2301741+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305540",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 305540,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1990,
      "AgendaID": 2053,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Role of Scientific Evidence and Advice in Public Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05154.2",
      "ID": 5299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2134,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.328723+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320133",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 320133,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1990,
      "AgendaID": 2053,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Role of Scientific Evidence and Advice in Public Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05154.2",
      "ID": 5299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5041,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan",
      "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9631097+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315923",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315923,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1990,
      "AgendaID": 2053,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Role of Scientific Evidence and Advice in Public Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05154.2",
      "ID": 5299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3763,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart",
      "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9380875+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1986E23P197VM236734",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 236734,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1990,
      "AgendaID": 2053,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Role of Scientific Evidence and Advice in Public Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05154.2",
      "ID": 5299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1986,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan",
      "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9377693+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5047E100P130VM289771",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289771,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1990,
      "AgendaID": 2053,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Role of Scientific Evidence and Advice in Public Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05154.2",
      "ID": 5299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5047,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne",
      "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4584175+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234494",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234494,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1990,
      "AgendaID": 2053,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Role of Scientific Evidence and Advice in Public Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05154.2",
      "ID": 5299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1845,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette",
      "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3866836+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313183",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313183,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1990,
      "AgendaID": 2053,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Role of Scientific Evidence and Advice in Public Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05154.2",
      "ID": 5299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3061,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1672464+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1768E19P265VM289357",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289357,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1990,
      "AgendaID": 2053,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Role of Scientific Evidence and Advice in Public Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05154.2",
      "ID": 5299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1768,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4337794+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225328",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225328,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1990,
      "AgendaID": 2053,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Role of Scientific Evidence and Advice in Public Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05154.2",
      "ID": 5299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1894,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Neil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9698264+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265782",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265782,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1990,
      "AgendaID": 2053,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Role of Scientific Evidence and Advice in Public Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05154.2",
      "ID": 5299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2010,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil",
      "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4542616+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283231",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283231,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1990,
      "AgendaID": 2053,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Role of Scientific Evidence and Advice in Public Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05154.2",
      "ID": 5299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5057,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.6915214+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2853E33P128VM252019",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252019,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1990,
      "AgendaID": 2053,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Role of Scientific Evidence and Advice in Public Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05154.2",
      "ID": 5299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Pentland",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4990749+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317355",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317355,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1990,
      "AgendaID": 2053,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Role of Scientific Evidence and Advice in Public Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05154.2",
      "ID": 5299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5009,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4185463+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254286",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254286,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1990,
      "AgendaID": 2053,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Role of Scientific Evidence and Advice in Public Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05154.2",
      "ID": 5299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3745,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis",
      "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2490086+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1870E225P478VM296259",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 296259,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1990,
      "AgendaID": 2053,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Role of Scientific Evidence and Advice in Public Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05154.2",
      "ID": 5299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1870,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona",
      "DisplayName": "Shona Robison",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.840945+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2135E254P450VM235462",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235462,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1990,
      "AgendaID": 2053,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Role of Scientific Evidence and Advice in Public Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05154.2",
      "ID": 5299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2135,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Russell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6788983+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1895E232P431VM257674",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257674,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1990,
      "AgendaID": 2053,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Role of Scientific Evidence and Advice in Public Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05154.2",
      "ID": 5299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1895,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0666858+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228527",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 228527,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1990,
      "AgendaID": 2053,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Role of Scientific Evidence and Advice in Public Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05154.2",
      "ID": 5299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1839,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.8029283+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2345E10P55VM291578",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291578,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1990,
      "AgendaID": 2053,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Role of Scientific Evidence and Advice in Public Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05154.2",
      "ID": 5299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2345,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1334058+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311128",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311128,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1990,
      "AgendaID": 2053,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Role of Scientific Evidence and Advice in Public Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05154.2",
      "ID": 5299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2223,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish",
      "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.6066101+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246442",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 246442,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1990,
      "AgendaID": 2053,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Role of Scientific Evidence and Advice in Public Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05154.2",
      "ID": 5299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2182,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1288958+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298066",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298066,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1990,
      "AgendaID": 2053,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Role of Scientific Evidence and Advice in Public Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05154.2",
      "ID": 5299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5079,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew",
      "DisplayName": "Drew Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1368049+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234096",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234096,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1990,
      "AgendaID": 2053,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Role of Scientific Evidence and Advice in Public Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05154.2",
      "ID": 5299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1769,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1664646+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274673",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274673,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1990,
      "AgendaID": 2053,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Role of Scientific Evidence and Advice in Public Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05154.2",
      "ID": 5299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4014,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz",
      "DisplayName": "Liz Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1167753+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269635",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269635,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1990,
      "AgendaID": 2053,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Role of Scientific Evidence and Advice in Public Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05154.2",
      "ID": 5299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2215,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5564029+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317501",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317501,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1990,
      "AgendaID": 2053,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Role of Scientific Evidence and Advice in Public Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05154.2",
      "ID": 5299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3806,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.42514+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326411",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 326411,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1990,
      "AgendaID": 2053,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Role of Scientific Evidence and Advice in Public Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05154.2",
      "ID": 5299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5106,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin",
      "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7574052+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241233",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241233,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1990,
      "AgendaID": 2053,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Role of Scientific Evidence and Advice in Public Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05154.2",
      "ID": 5299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1848,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola",
      "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7487406+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2098E237P531VM290350",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 290350,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1990,
      "AgendaID": 2053,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Role of Scientific Evidence and Advice in Public Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05154.2",
      "ID": 5299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2098,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Swinney",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7430885+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248028",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248028,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1990,
      "AgendaID": 2053,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Role of Scientific Evidence and Advice in Public Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05154.2",
      "ID": 5299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2674,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave",
      "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.438658+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5075E234P371VM287480",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 287480,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1990,
      "AgendaID": 2053,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Role of Scientific Evidence and Advice in Public Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05154.2",
      "ID": 5299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5075,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Torrance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8659805+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1793E151P9VM222572",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 222572,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1990,
      "AgendaID": 2053,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Role of Scientific Evidence and Advice in Public Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05154.2",
      "ID": 5299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1793,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean",
      "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1947051+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5078E245P7VM306958",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306958,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1990,
      "AgendaID": 2053,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Role of Scientific Evidence and Advice in Public Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05154.2",
      "ID": 5299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5078,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Walker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5812193+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1841E231P426VM239891",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239891,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1990,
      "AgendaID": 2053,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Role of Scientific Evidence and Advice in Public Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05154.2",
      "ID": 5299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1841,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen",
      "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7637763+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283739",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283739,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1990,
      "AgendaID": 2053,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Role of Scientific Evidence and Advice in Public Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05154.2",
      "ID": 5299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4952,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7211919+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1865E263P500VM231810",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231810,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1990,
      "AgendaID": 2053,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Role of Scientific Evidence and Advice in Public Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05154.2",
      "ID": 5299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1865,
      "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra",
      "DisplayName": "Sandra White",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6164979+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237376",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237376,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1990,
      "AgendaID": 2053,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Role of Scientific Evidence and Advice in Public Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05154.2",
      "ID": 5299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2610,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Wilson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2015365+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4941E150P382VM308995",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 308995,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1990,
      "AgendaID": 2053,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Role of Scientific Evidence and Advice in Public Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05154.2",
      "ID": 5299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4941,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza",
      "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0870006+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252688",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252688,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1988,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.2",
      "ID": 5249
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1926,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian",
      "DisplayName": "Brian Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7493104+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2615E213P388VM258885",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258885,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1988,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.2",
      "ID": 5249
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2615,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George",
      "DisplayName": "George Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3324137+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319662",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319662,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1988,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.2",
      "ID": 5249
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4940,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare",
      "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9359303+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249570",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 249570,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1988,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.2",
      "ID": 5249
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2641,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair",
      "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9325476+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1783E21P273VM227799",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227799,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1988,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.2",
      "ID": 5249
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1783,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie",
      "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5661324+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2633E97P136VM280802",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280802,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1988,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.2",
      "ID": 5249
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2633,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire",
      "DisplayName": "Claire Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7830065+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262717",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262717,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1988,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.2",
      "ID": 5249
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2603,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6138422+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1759E91P115VM229837",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229837,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1988,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.2",
      "ID": 5249
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia",
      "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.099546+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270142",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270142,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1988,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.2",
      "ID": 5249
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3751,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5833696+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322670",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 322670,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1988,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.2",
      "ID": 5249
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5109,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco",
      "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6986749+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5060E86P124VM295255",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295255,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1988,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.2",
      "ID": 5249
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5060,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5041355+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242937",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242937,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1988,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.2",
      "ID": 5249
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1866,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah",
      "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0419389+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235206",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235206,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1988,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.2",
      "ID": 5249
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1943,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic",
      "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6599887+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302369",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 302369,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1988,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.2",
      "ID": 5249
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2595,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin",
      "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5214322+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244286",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244286,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1988,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.2",
      "ID": 5249
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2103,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith",
      "DisplayName": "Keith Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5481205+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327157",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 327157,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1988,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.2",
      "ID": 5249
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.801633+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277056",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277056,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1988,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.2",
      "ID": 5249
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6991993+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264273",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264273,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1988,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.2",
      "ID": 5249
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2673,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick",
      "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1261776+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248739",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248739,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1988,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.2",
      "ID": 5249
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2678,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson",
      "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6677062+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2123E27P233VM295744",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295744,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1988,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.2",
      "ID": 5249
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2123,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm",
      "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5340451+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285221",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285221,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1988,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.2",
      "ID": 5249
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3907,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3135933+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230698",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230698,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1988,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.2",
      "ID": 5249
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1735,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela",
      "DisplayName": "Angela Constance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3414505+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243782",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 243782,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1988,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.2",
      "ID": 5249
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1932,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce",
      "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3195297+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254877",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254877,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1988,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.2",
      "ID": 5249
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1863,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna",
      "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2876298+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323764",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 323764,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1988,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.2",
      "ID": 5249
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4976,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth",
      "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9709162+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5107E223P379VM291301",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291301,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1988,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.2",
      "ID": 5249
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5107,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1130451+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3743E222P391VM265393",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265393,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1988,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.2",
      "ID": 5249
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3743,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel",
      "DisplayName": "Nigel Don",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4372548+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262285",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262285,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1988,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.2",
      "ID": 5249
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3771,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob",
      "DisplayName": "Bob Doris",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.5948994+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281938",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 281938,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1988,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.2",
      "ID": 5249
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2826,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Dornan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1642515+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298188",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298188,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1988,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.2",
      "ID": 5249
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3812,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia",
      "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1423155+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231201",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231201,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1988,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.2",
      "ID": 5249
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1778,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen",
      "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.5846395+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4955E240P389VM285906",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285906,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1988,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.2",
      "ID": 5249
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4955,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3496315+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219421",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 219421,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1988,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.2",
      "ID": 5249
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1742,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle",
      "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.2980814+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238541",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 238541,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1988,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.2",
      "ID": 5249
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1994,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus",
      "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4585464+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225224",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225224,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1988,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.2",
      "ID": 5249
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1814,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda",
      "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.96014+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321790",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 321790,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1988,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.2",
      "ID": 5249
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Fee",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4514934+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292817",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 292817,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1988,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.2",
      "ID": 5249
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia",
      "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5593965+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227148",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227148,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1988,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.2",
      "ID": 5249
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2698943+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5054E95P118VM312729",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 312729,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1988,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.2",
      "ID": 5249
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5054,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1408244+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4947E152P8VM257250",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257250,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1988,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.2",
      "ID": 5249
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4947,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Finnie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0480285+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271261",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271261,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1988,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.2",
      "ID": 5249
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3901,
      "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe",
      "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0626581+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278075",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 278075,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1988,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.2",
      "ID": 5249
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2394,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo",
      "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9859199+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2110E220P414VM287264",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 287264,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1988,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.2",
      "ID": 5249
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth",
      "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8566896+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250529",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250529,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1988,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.2",
      "ID": 5249
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2675,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob",
      "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1935028+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1741E10P50VM220993",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220993,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1988,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.2",
      "ID": 5249
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1741,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel",
      "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6704802+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220222",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220222,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1988,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.2",
      "ID": 5249
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1756,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine",
      "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6290885+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1860E104P150VM252389",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252389,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1988,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.2",
      "ID": 5249
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1860,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda",
      "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7270566+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2033E20P141VM253844",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253844,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1988,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.2",
      "ID": 5249
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2033,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain",
      "DisplayName": "Iain Gray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0233042+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324641",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324641,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1988,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.2",
      "ID": 5249
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5042,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2316985+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259686",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 259686,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1988,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.2",
      "ID": 5249
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick",
      "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6201456+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239355",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239355,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1988,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.2",
      "ID": 5249
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2029,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh",
      "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7332431+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273744",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 273744,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1988,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.2",
      "ID": 5249
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3758,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6338084+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304116",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 304116,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1988,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.2",
      "ID": 5249
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4086,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Hume",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8503605+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221702",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221702,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1988,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.2",
      "ID": 5249
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1773,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9441222+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1882E227P459VM241934",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241934,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1988,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.2",
      "ID": 5249
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1882,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam",
      "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7863287+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223520",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223520,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1988,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.2",
      "ID": 5249
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1893,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4619765+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307617",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307617,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1988,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.2",
      "ID": 5249
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4934,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8375305+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272265",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 272265,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1988,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.2",
      "ID": 5249
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4956,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Keir",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3221957+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244947",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244947,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1988,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.2",
      "ID": 5249
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Kelly",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5854018+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315117",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315117,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1988,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.2",
      "ID": 5249
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3129,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6750328+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247913",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247913,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1988,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.2",
      "ID": 5249
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann",
      "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4337543+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4016E11P36VM274824",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274824,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1988,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.2",
      "ID": 5249
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4016,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1233192+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255763",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255763,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1988,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.2",
      "ID": 5249
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2180,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5558276+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4938E158P374VM277421",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277421,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1988,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.2",
      "ID": 5249
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4938,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9526554+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2112E250P486VM253049",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253049,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1988,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.2",
      "ID": 5249
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2112,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny",
      "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7646479+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4939E258P394VM276806",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276806,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1988,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.2",
      "ID": 5249
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4939,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus",
      "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6818819+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325490",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 325490,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1988,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.2",
      "ID": 5249
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5074,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon",
      "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5086191+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1828E3P10VM232926",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232926,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1988,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.2",
      "ID": 5249
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1828,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo",
      "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8825903+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311462",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311462,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1988,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.2",
      "ID": 5249
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4948,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike",
      "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8798712+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2117E90P107VM230374",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230374,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1988,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.2",
      "ID": 5249
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2117,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis",
      "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3269743+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267400",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 267400,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1988,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.2",
      "ID": 5249
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken",
      "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0181836+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313700",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313700,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1988,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.2",
      "ID": 5249
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4966,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek",
      "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4067459+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3101E102P129VM295040",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295040,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1988,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.2",
      "ID": 5249
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3101,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala",
      "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.189614+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319040",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319040,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1988,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.2",
      "ID": 5249
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5034,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny",
      "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6898476+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306369",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306369,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1988,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.2",
      "ID": 5249
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2159,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Martin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5491255+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5110E252P395VM310819",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 310819,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1988,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.2",
      "ID": 5249
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Mason",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5873962+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268203",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 268203,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1988,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.2",
      "ID": 5249
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2133,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.25329+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2876E141P433VM286370",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286370,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1988,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.2",
      "ID": 5249
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2876,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.575972+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4951E147P368VM258606",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258606,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1988,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.2",
      "ID": 5249
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4951,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan",
      "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.314504+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3896E175P307VM263854",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 263854,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1988,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.2",
      "ID": 5249
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3896,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam",
      "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9136244+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308513",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 308513,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1988,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.2",
      "ID": 5249
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0591587+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4964E143P375VM279696",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279696,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1988,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.2",
      "ID": 5249
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4964,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5187433+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279616",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279616,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1988,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.2",
      "ID": 5249
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3824,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5153035+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2066E22P91VM261041",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261041,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1988,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.2",
      "ID": 5249
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2066,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.1092542+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299630",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 299630,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1988,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.2",
      "ID": 5249
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7060103+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306699",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306699,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1988,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.2",
      "ID": 5249
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina",
      "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5635955+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2487E146P369VM301095",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 301095,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1988,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.2",
      "ID": 5249
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2487,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0329951+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223896",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223896,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1988,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.2",
      "ID": 5249
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4784194+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237526",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237526,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1988,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.2",
      "ID": 5249
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1961,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David",
      "DisplayName": "David McLetchie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2146415+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305499",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 305499,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1988,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.2",
      "ID": 5249
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2134,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3269544+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320386",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 320386,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1988,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.2",
      "ID": 5249
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5041,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan",
      "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1641857+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315965",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315965,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1988,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.2",
      "ID": 5249
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3763,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart",
      "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9399083+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1986E23P197VM236684",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 236684,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1988,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.2",
      "ID": 5249
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1986,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan",
      "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9356094+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5047E100P130VM289820",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289820,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1988,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.2",
      "ID": 5249
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5047,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne",
      "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4604699+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234514",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234514,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1988,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.2",
      "ID": 5249
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1845,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette",
      "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3875588+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313225",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313225,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1988,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.2",
      "ID": 5249
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3061,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.3831413+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1768E19P265VM289303",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289303,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1988,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.2",
      "ID": 5249
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1768,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4314707+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225267",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225267,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1988,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.2",
      "ID": 5249
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1894,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Neil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9620235+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3815E98P134VM270928",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270928,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1988,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.2",
      "ID": 5249
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3815,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Park, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Park",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8351238+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265834",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265834,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1988,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.2",
      "ID": 5249
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2010,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil",
      "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4565187+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283292",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283292,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1988,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.2",
      "ID": 5249
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5057,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.6942058+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2853E33P128VM251500",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251500,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1988,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.2",
      "ID": 5249
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Pentland",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4663603+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317607",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317607,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1988,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.2",
      "ID": 5249
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5009,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4297014+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254322",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254322,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1988,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.2",
      "ID": 5249
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3745,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis",
      "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2505641+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1870E225P478VM296204",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 296204,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1988,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.2",
      "ID": 5249
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1870,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona",
      "DisplayName": "Shona Robison",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8383978+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2135E254P450VM235403",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235403,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1988,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.2",
      "ID": 5249
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2135,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Russell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6691065+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1895E232P431VM257622",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257622,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1988,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.2",
      "ID": 5249
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1895,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0644445+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228489",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 228489,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1988,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.2",
      "ID": 5249
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1839,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.8012825+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2345E10P55VM291630",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291630,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1988,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.2",
      "ID": 5249
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2345,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1355839+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311086",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311086,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1988,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.2",
      "ID": 5249
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2223,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish",
      "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.604813+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246403",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 246403,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1988,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.2",
      "ID": 5249
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2182,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.127226+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298113",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298113,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1988,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.2",
      "ID": 5249
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5079,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew",
      "DisplayName": "Drew Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1387944+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234145",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234145,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1988,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.2",
      "ID": 5249
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1769,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1685856+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274611",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274611,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1988,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.2",
      "ID": 5249
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4014,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz",
      "DisplayName": "Liz Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1140909+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269567",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269567,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1988,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.2",
      "ID": 5249
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2215,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5531989+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317428",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317428,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1988,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.2",
      "ID": 5249
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3806,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4216847+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326340",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 326340,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1988,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.2",
      "ID": 5249
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5106,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin",
      "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7542267+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241194",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241194,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1988,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.2",
      "ID": 5249
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1848,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola",
      "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7470627+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2098E237P531VM289692",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289692,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1988,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.2",
      "ID": 5249
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2098,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Swinney",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4550827+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2674E247P401VM247817",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247817,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1988,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.2",
      "ID": 5249
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2674,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave",
      "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4296953+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5075E234P371VM287418",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 287418,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1988,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.2",
      "ID": 5249
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5075,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Torrance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8633649+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1793E151P9VM222511",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 222511,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1988,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.2",
      "ID": 5249
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1793,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean",
      "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1921125+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5078E245P7VM307006",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307006,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1988,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.2",
      "ID": 5249
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5078,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Walker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5832566+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1841E231P426VM239929",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239929,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1988,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.2",
      "ID": 5249
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1841,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen",
      "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7654141+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283475",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283475,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1988,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.2",
      "ID": 5249
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4952,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7094917+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1865E263P500VM231861",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231861,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1988,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.2",
      "ID": 5249
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1865,
      "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra",
      "DisplayName": "Sandra White",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6187059+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237736",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237736,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1988,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.2",
      "ID": 5249
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2610,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Wilson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.223611+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309222",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 309222,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1988,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.2",
      "ID": 5249
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4941,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza",
      "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3200381+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252689",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252689,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1989,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 78,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.1",
      "ID": 5241
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1926,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian",
      "DisplayName": "Brian Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7493523+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2615E213P388VM258886",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258886,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1989,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 78,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.1",
      "ID": 5241
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2615,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George",
      "DisplayName": "George Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3324547+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319653",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319653,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1989,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 78,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.1",
      "ID": 5241
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4940,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare",
      "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9355422+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249569",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 249569,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1989,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 78,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.1",
      "ID": 5241
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2641,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair",
      "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9325062+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1783E21P273VM227800",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227800,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1989,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 78,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.1",
      "ID": 5241
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1783,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie",
      "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5661735+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2633E97P136VM280803",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280803,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1989,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 78,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.1",
      "ID": 5241
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2633,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire",
      "DisplayName": "Claire Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7830469+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262718",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262718,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1989,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 78,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.1",
      "ID": 5241
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2603,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6138831+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1759E91P115VM229804",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229804,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1989,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 78,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.1",
      "ID": 5241
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia",
      "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.097765+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270141",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270141,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1989,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 78,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.1",
      "ID": 5241
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3751,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5833261+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322671",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 322671,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1989,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 78,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.1",
      "ID": 5241
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5109,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco",
      "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6987154+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5060E86P124VM295256",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295256,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1989,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 78,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.1",
      "ID": 5241
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5060,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5041764+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242939",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242939,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1989,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 78,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.1",
      "ID": 5241
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1866,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah",
      "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0420211+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235205",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235205,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1989,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 78,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.1",
      "ID": 5241
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1943,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic",
      "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6599357+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302368",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 302368,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1989,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 78,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.1",
      "ID": 5241
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2595,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin",
      "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5213911+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244285",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244285,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1989,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 78,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.1",
      "ID": 5241
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2103,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith",
      "DisplayName": "Keith Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5480786+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327166",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 327166,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1989,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 78,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.1",
      "ID": 5241
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.8020273+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277057",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277057,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1989,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 78,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.1",
      "ID": 5241
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6992409+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264272",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264272,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1989,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 78,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.1",
      "ID": 5241
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2673,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick",
      "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1261363+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248738",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248738,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1989,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 78,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.1",
      "ID": 5241
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2678,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson",
      "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6676657+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2123E27P233VM295734",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295734,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1989,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 78,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.1",
      "ID": 5241
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2123,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm",
      "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5336199+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285222",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285222,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1989,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 78,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.1",
      "ID": 5241
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3907,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3136364+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230699",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230699,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1989,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 78,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.1",
      "ID": 5241
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1735,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela",
      "DisplayName": "Angela Constance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3414941+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243780",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 243780,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1989,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 78,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.1",
      "ID": 5241
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1932,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce",
      "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3194483+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254878",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254878,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1989,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 78,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.1",
      "ID": 5241
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1863,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna",
      "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2876903+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323773",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 323773,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1989,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 78,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.1",
      "ID": 5241
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4976,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth",
      "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9713043+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5107E223P379VM291300",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291300,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1989,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 78,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.1",
      "ID": 5241
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5107,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1130034+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3743E222P391VM265394",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265394,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1989,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 78,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.1",
      "ID": 5241
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3743,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel",
      "DisplayName": "Nigel Don",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4372972+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262286",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262286,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1989,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 78,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.1",
      "ID": 5241
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3771,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob",
      "DisplayName": "Bob Doris",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.5949415+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281937",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 281937,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1989,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 78,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.1",
      "ID": 5241
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2826,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Dornan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1642091+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298189",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298189,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1989,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 78,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.1",
      "ID": 5241
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3812,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia",
      "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1423568+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231234",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231234,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1989,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 78,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.1",
      "ID": 5241
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1778,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen",
      "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.5861853+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4955E240P389VM285905",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285905,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1989,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 78,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.1",
      "ID": 5241
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4955,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3495898+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219422",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 219422,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1989,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 78,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.1",
      "ID": 5241
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1742,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle",
      "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.2981297+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238540",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 238540,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1989,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 78,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.1",
      "ID": 5241
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1994,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus",
      "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4585036+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225223",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225223,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1989,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 78,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.1",
      "ID": 5241
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1814,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda",
      "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9600972+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321789",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 321789,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1989,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 78,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.1",
      "ID": 5241
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Fee",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.451451+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292816",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 292816,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1989,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 78,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.1",
      "ID": 5241
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia",
      "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5593559+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227149",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227149,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1989,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 78,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.1",
      "ID": 5241
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2699358+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5054E95P118VM312728",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 312728,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1989,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 78,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.1",
      "ID": 5241
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5054,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1407831+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4947E152P8VM257251",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257251,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1989,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 78,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.1",
      "ID": 5241
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4947,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Finnie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0480705+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271260",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271260,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1989,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 78,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.1",
      "ID": 5241
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3901,
      "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe",
      "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0626154+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278074",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 278074,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1989,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 78,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.1",
      "ID": 5241
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2394,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo",
      "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.985878+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2110E220P414VM287263",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 287263,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1989,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 78,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.1",
      "ID": 5241
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth",
      "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8566488+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250530",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250530,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1989,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 78,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.1",
      "ID": 5241
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2675,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob",
      "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1935442+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1741E10P50VM220994",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220994,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1989,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 78,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.1",
      "ID": 5241
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1741,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel",
      "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6705217+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220221",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220221,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1989,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 78,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.1",
      "ID": 5241
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1756,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine",
      "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.629046+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1860E104P150VM252388",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252388,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1989,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 78,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.1",
      "ID": 5241
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1860,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda",
      "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7270155+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2033E20P141VM253843",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253843,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1989,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 78,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.1",
      "ID": 5241
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2033,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain",
      "DisplayName": "Iain Gray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0232625+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324632",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324632,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1989,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 78,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.1",
      "ID": 5241
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5042,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2313116+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259685",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 259685,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1989,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 78,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.1",
      "ID": 5241
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick",
      "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6201038+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239356",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239356,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1989,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 78,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.1",
      "ID": 5241
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2029,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh",
      "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7332845+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273743",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 273743,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1989,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 78,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.1",
      "ID": 5241
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3758,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.633766+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304117",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 304117,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1989,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 78,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.1",
      "ID": 5241
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4086,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Hume",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8504013+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221701",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221701,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1989,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 78,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.1",
      "ID": 5241
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1773,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9440816+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1882E227P459VM241933",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241933,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1989,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 78,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.1",
      "ID": 5241
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1882,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam",
      "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7862867+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223519",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223519,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1989,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 78,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.1",
      "ID": 5241
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1893,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4619347+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307618",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307618,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1989,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 78,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.1",
      "ID": 5241
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4934,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8375721+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272266",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 272266,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1989,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 78,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.1",
      "ID": 5241
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4956,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Keir",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3222371+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244949",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244949,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1989,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 78,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.1",
      "ID": 5241
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Kelly",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5855035+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315127",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315127,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1989,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 78,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.1",
      "ID": 5241
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3129,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6754668+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247912",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247912,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1989,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 78,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.1",
      "ID": 5241
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann",
      "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4337134+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4016E11P36VM274825",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274825,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1989,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 78,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.1",
      "ID": 5241
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4016,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1233606+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255762",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255762,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1989,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 78,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.1",
      "ID": 5241
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2180,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5557874+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4938E158P374VM277420",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277420,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1989,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 78,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.1",
      "ID": 5241
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4938,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9526137+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2112E250P486VM253050",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253050,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1989,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 78,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.1",
      "ID": 5241
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2112,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny",
      "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7646894+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4939E258P394VM276805",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276805,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1989,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 78,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.1",
      "ID": 5241
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4939,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus",
      "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6818414+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325499",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 325499,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1989,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 78,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.1",
      "ID": 5241
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5074,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon",
      "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5090038+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1828E3P10VM232893",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232893,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1989,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 78,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.1",
      "ID": 5241
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1828,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo",
      "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.881172+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311463",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311463,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1989,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 78,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.1",
      "ID": 5241
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4948,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike",
      "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8799134+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2117E90P107VM230373",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230373,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1989,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 78,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.1",
      "ID": 5241
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2117,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis",
      "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3269324+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267401",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 267401,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1989,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 78,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.1",
      "ID": 5241
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken",
      "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0182247+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313699",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313699,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1989,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 78,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.1",
      "ID": 5241
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4966,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek",
      "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.406704+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3101E102P129VM295039",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295039,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1989,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 78,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.1",
      "ID": 5241
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3101,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala",
      "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1895729+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319039",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319039,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1989,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 78,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.1",
      "ID": 5241
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5034,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny",
      "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6898063+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306359",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306359,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1989,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 78,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.1",
      "ID": 5241
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2159,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Martin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5487162+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5110E252P395VM310818",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 310818,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1989,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 78,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.1",
      "ID": 5241
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Mason",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5873553+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268202",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 268202,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1989,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 78,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.1",
      "ID": 5241
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2133,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.253247+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2876E141P433VM286371",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286371,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1989,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 78,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.1",
      "ID": 5241
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2876,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5760418+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4951E147P368VM258605",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258605,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1989,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 78,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.1",
      "ID": 5241
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4951,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan",
      "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3144618+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3896E175P307VM263853",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 263853,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1989,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 78,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.1",
      "ID": 5241
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3896,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam",
      "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.913466+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308514",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 308514,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1989,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 78,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.1",
      "ID": 5241
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0592006+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4964E143P375VM279697",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279697,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1989,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 78,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.1",
      "ID": 5241
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4964,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5187845+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279615",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279615,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1989,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 78,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.1",
      "ID": 5241
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3824,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5152628+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2066E22P91VM261039",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261039,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1989,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 78,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.1",
      "ID": 5241
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2066,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.1091701+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299629",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 299629,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1989,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 78,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.1",
      "ID": 5241
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7059691+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306700",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306700,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1989,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 78,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.1",
      "ID": 5241
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina",
      "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5636407+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2487E146P369VM301094",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 301094,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1989,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 78,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.1",
      "ID": 5241
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2487,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0329436+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223897",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223897,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1989,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 78,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.1",
      "ID": 5241
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.478461+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237527",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237527,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1989,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 78,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.1",
      "ID": 5241
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1961,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David",
      "DisplayName": "David McLetchie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2146844+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305509",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 305509,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1989,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 78,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.1",
      "ID": 5241
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2134,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3273926+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320387",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 320387,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1989,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 78,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.1",
      "ID": 5241
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5041,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan",
      "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1642277+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315955",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315955,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1989,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 78,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.1",
      "ID": 5241
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3763,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart",
      "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9394758+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1986E23P197VM236685",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 236685,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1989,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 78,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.1",
      "ID": 5241
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1986,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan",
      "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9356511+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5047E100P130VM289819",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289819,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1989,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 78,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.1",
      "ID": 5241
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5047,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne",
      "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4604293+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234548",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234548,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1989,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 78,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.1",
      "ID": 5241
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1845,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette",
      "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3890434+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313214",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313214,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1989,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 78,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.1",
      "ID": 5241
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3061,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.3826543+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1768E19P265VM289304",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289304,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1989,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 78,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.1",
      "ID": 5241
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1768,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4315118+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225268",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225268,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1989,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 78,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.1",
      "ID": 5241
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1894,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Neil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9620652+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3815E98P134VM270929",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270929,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1989,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 78,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.1",
      "ID": 5241
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3815,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Park, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Park",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8351651+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265835",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265835,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1989,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 78,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.1",
      "ID": 5241
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2010,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil",
      "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4565613+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283291",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283291,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1989,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 78,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.1",
      "ID": 5241
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5057,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.6941562+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2853E33P128VM251501",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251501,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1989,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 78,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.1",
      "ID": 5241
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Pentland",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4664025+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317608",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317608,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1989,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 78,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.1",
      "ID": 5241
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5009,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4297433+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254321",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254321,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1989,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 78,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.1",
      "ID": 5241
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3745,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis",
      "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2505216+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1870E225P478VM296205",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 296205,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1989,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 78,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.1",
      "ID": 5241
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1870,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona",
      "DisplayName": "Shona Robison",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8384951+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2135E254P450VM235404",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235404,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1989,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 78,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.1",
      "ID": 5241
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2135,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Russell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6691516+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1895E232P431VM257621",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257621,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1989,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 78,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.1",
      "ID": 5241
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1895,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0644033+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228490",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 228490,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1989,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 78,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.1",
      "ID": 5241
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1839,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.8013242+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2345E10P55VM291631",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291631,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1989,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 78,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.1",
      "ID": 5241
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2345,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1356258+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311097",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311097,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1989,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 78,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.1",
      "ID": 5241
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2223,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish",
      "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.6052855+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246404",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 246404,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1989,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 78,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.1",
      "ID": 5241
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2182,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1272676+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298112",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298112,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1989,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 78,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.1",
      "ID": 5241
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5079,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew",
      "DisplayName": "Drew Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1387532+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234144",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234144,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1989,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 78,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.1",
      "ID": 5241
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1769,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.168526+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274612",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274612,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1989,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 78,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.1",
      "ID": 5241
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4014,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz",
      "DisplayName": "Liz Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1141328+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269568",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269568,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1989,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 78,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.1",
      "ID": 5241
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2215,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.553241+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317438",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317438,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1989,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 78,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.1",
      "ID": 5241
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3806,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4221171+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326331",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 326331,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1989,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 78,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.1",
      "ID": 5241
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5106,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin",
      "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7538376+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241195",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241195,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1989,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 78,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.1",
      "ID": 5241
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1848,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola",
      "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7471057+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2098E237P531VM290318",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 290318,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1989,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 78,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.1",
      "ID": 5241
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2098,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Swinney",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.741659+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2674E247P401VM247818",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247818,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1989,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 78,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.1",
      "ID": 5241
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2674,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave",
      "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4297537+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5075E234P371VM287419",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 287419,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1989,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 78,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.1",
      "ID": 5241
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5075,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Torrance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8634071+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1793E151P9VM222512",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 222512,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1989,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 78,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.1",
      "ID": 5241
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1793,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean",
      "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1921539+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5078E245P7VM307005",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307005,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1989,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 78,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.1",
      "ID": 5241
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5078,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Walker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5832157+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1841E231P426VM239928",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239928,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1989,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 78,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.1",
      "ID": 5241
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1841,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen",
      "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7653517+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283476",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283476,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1989,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 78,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.1",
      "ID": 5241
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4952,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7095586+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1865E263P500VM231860",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231860,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1989,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 78,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.1",
      "ID": 5241
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1865,
      "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra",
      "DisplayName": "Sandra White",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6186637+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237735",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237735,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1989,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 78,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.1",
      "ID": 5241
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2610,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Wilson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2235696+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309221",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 309221,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1989,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 78,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109.1",
      "ID": 5241
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4941,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza",
      "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3199938+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252690",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252690,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1987,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 76,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109",
      "ID": 5236
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1926,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian",
      "DisplayName": "Brian Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7493929+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2615E213P388VM258912",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258912,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1987,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 76,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109",
      "ID": 5236
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2615,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George",
      "DisplayName": "George Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3335672+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319652",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319652,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1987,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 76,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109",
      "ID": 5236
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4940,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare",
      "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9355013+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249568",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 249568,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1987,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 76,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109",
      "ID": 5236
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2641,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair",
      "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9324645+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1783E21P273VM227801",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227801,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1987,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 76,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109",
      "ID": 5236
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1783,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie",
      "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5662149+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2633E97P136VM280804",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280804,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1987,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 76,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109",
      "ID": 5236
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2633,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire",
      "DisplayName": "Claire Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7830871+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262719",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262719,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1987,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 76,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109",
      "ID": 5236
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2603,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6139238+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1759E91P115VM229805",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229805,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1987,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 76,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109",
      "ID": 5236
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia",
      "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0978071+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270114",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270114,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1987,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 76,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109",
      "ID": 5236
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3751,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5821534+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322672",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 322672,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1987,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 76,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109",
      "ID": 5236
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5109,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco",
      "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6987561+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5060E86P124VM295257",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295257,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1987,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 76,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109",
      "ID": 5236
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5060,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5042369+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242948",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242948,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1987,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 76,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109",
      "ID": 5236
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1866,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah",
      "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0424098+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235204",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235204,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1987,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 76,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109",
      "ID": 5236
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1943,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic",
      "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6598828+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302370",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 302370,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1987,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 76,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109",
      "ID": 5236
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2595,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin",
      "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5214728+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244284",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244284,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1987,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 76,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109",
      "ID": 5236
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2103,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith",
      "DisplayName": "Keith Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5480357+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327167",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 327167,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1987,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 76,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109",
      "ID": 5236
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.8020688+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277058",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277058,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1987,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 76,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109",
      "ID": 5236
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6992813+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264271",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264271,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1987,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 76,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109",
      "ID": 5236
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2673,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick",
      "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1260942+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248737",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248737,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1987,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 76,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109",
      "ID": 5236
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2678,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson",
      "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6676249+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2123E27P233VM295733",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295733,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1987,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 76,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109",
      "ID": 5236
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2123,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm",
      "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.533579+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285223",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285223,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1987,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 76,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109",
      "ID": 5236
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3907,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3136796+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230700",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230700,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1987,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 76,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109",
      "ID": 5236
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1735,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela",
      "DisplayName": "Angela Constance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3415357+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243771",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 243771,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1987,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 76,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109",
      "ID": 5236
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1932,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce",
      "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3190683+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254876",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254876,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1987,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 76,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109",
      "ID": 5236
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1863,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna",
      "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2875878+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323774",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 323774,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1987,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 76,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109",
      "ID": 5236
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4976,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth",
      "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9713455+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5107E223P379VM291271",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291271,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1987,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 76,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109",
      "ID": 5236
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5107,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1117526+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3743E222P391VM265395",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265395,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1987,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 76,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109",
      "ID": 5236
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3743,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel",
      "DisplayName": "Nigel Don",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4373401+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262312",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262312,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1987,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 76,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109",
      "ID": 5236
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3771,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob",
      "DisplayName": "Bob Doris",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.5960629+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281936",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 281936,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1987,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 76,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109",
      "ID": 5236
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2826,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Dornan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1641494+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298190",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298190,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1987,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 76,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109",
      "ID": 5236
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3812,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia",
      "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1423988+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231233",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231233,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1987,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 76,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109",
      "ID": 5236
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1778,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen",
      "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.5861434+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4955E240P389VM285866",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285866,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1987,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 76,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109",
      "ID": 5236
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4955,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3479025+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219423",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 219423,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1987,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 76,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109",
      "ID": 5236
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1742,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle",
      "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.2981833+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238539",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 238539,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1987,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 76,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109",
      "ID": 5236
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1994,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus",
      "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.458443+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225222",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225222,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1987,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 76,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109",
      "ID": 5236
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1814,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda",
      "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9600537+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321788",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 321788,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1987,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 76,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109",
      "ID": 5236
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Fee",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4513917+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292815",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 292815,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1987,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 76,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109",
      "ID": 5236
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia",
      "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5593149+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227150",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227150,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1987,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 76,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109",
      "ID": 5236
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2699768+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5054E95P118VM312730",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 312730,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1987,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 76,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109",
      "ID": 5236
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5054,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1408661+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4947E152P8VM257252",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257252,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1987,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 76,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109",
      "ID": 5236
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4947,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Finnie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0481116+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271221",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271221,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1987,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 76,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109",
      "ID": 5236
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3901,
      "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe",
      "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.060858+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278073",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 278073,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1987,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 76,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109",
      "ID": 5236
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2394,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo",
      "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9858358+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2110E220P414VM287265",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 287265,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1987,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 76,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109",
      "ID": 5236
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth",
      "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8567511+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250531",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250531,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1987,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 76,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109",
      "ID": 5236
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2675,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob",
      "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1935854+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1741E10P50VM220995",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220995,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1987,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 76,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109",
      "ID": 5236
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1741,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel",
      "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6705629+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220220",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220220,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1987,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 76,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109",
      "ID": 5236
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1756,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine",
      "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6290024+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1860E104P150VM252390",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252390,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1987,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 76,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109",
      "ID": 5236
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1860,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda",
      "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7270973+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2033E20P141VM253842",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253842,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1987,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 76,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109",
      "ID": 5236
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2033,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain",
      "DisplayName": "Iain Gray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0232028+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324631",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324631,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1987,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 76,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109",
      "ID": 5236
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5042,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2312706+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259684",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 259684,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1987,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 76,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109",
      "ID": 5236
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick",
      "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6200623+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239357",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239357,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1987,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 76,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109",
      "ID": 5236
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2029,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh",
      "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7333266+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273742",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 273742,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1987,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 76,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109",
      "ID": 5236
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3758,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6337043+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304115",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 304115,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1987,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 76,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109",
      "ID": 5236
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4086,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Hume",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.850318+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221700",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221700,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1987,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 76,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109",
      "ID": 5236
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1773,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9440408+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1882E227P459VM241932",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241932,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1987,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 76,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109",
      "ID": 5236
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1882,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam",
      "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.786244+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223518",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223518,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1987,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 76,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109",
      "ID": 5236
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1893,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4618932+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307619",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307619,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1987,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 76,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109",
      "ID": 5236
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4934,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8376388+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272267",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 272267,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1987,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 76,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109",
      "ID": 5236
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4956,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Keir",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3222783+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244958",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244958,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1987,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 76,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109",
      "ID": 5236
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Kelly",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5858805+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315128",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315128,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1987,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 76,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109",
      "ID": 5236
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3129,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6755082+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247911",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247911,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1987,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 76,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109",
      "ID": 5236
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann",
      "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4336728+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4016E11P36VM275019",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 275019,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1987,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 76,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109",
      "ID": 5236
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4016,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.137672+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255736",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255736,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1987,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 76,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109",
      "ID": 5236
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2180,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5547033+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4938E158P374VM277380",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277380,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1987,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 76,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109",
      "ID": 5236
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4938,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9508971+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2112E250P486VM253051",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253051,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1987,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 76,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109",
      "ID": 5236
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2112,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny",
      "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7647308+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4939E258P394VM276777",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276777,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1987,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 76,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109",
      "ID": 5236
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4939,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus",
      "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6806542+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325500",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 325500,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1987,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 76,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109",
      "ID": 5236
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5074,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon",
      "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5090444+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1828E3P10VM232894",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232894,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1987,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 76,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109",
      "ID": 5236
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1828,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo",
      "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8812138+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311464",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311464,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1987,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 76,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109",
      "ID": 5236
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4948,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike",
      "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8799553+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2117E90P107VM230372",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230372,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1987,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 76,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109",
      "ID": 5236
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2117,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis",
      "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3268903+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267402",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 267402,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1987,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 76,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109",
      "ID": 5236
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken",
      "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0182653+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313698",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313698,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1987,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 76,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109",
      "ID": 5236
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4966,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek",
      "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4066616+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3101E102P129VM295038",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295038,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1987,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 76,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109",
      "ID": 5236
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3101,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala",
      "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1895316+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319038",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319038,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1987,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 76,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109",
      "ID": 5236
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5034,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny",
      "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6897649+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306358",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306358,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1987,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 76,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109",
      "ID": 5236
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2159,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Martin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.548652+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5110E252P395VM310817",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 310817,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1987,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 76,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109",
      "ID": 5236
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Mason",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5873147+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268201",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 268201,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1987,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 76,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109",
      "ID": 5236
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2133,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2532005+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2876E141P433VM286372",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286372,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1987,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 76,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109",
      "ID": 5236
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2876,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5760902+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4951E147P368VM258604",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258604,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1987,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 76,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109",
      "ID": 5236
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4951,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan",
      "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3144203+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3896E175P307VM263825",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 263825,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1987,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 76,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109",
      "ID": 5236
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3896,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam",
      "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9120315+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308515",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 308515,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1987,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 76,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109",
      "ID": 5236
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0592424+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4964E143P375VM279725",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279725,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1987,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 76,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109",
      "ID": 5236
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4964,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5199444+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279614",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279614,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1987,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 76,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109",
      "ID": 5236
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3824,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5152226+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2066E22P91VM261030",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261030,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1987,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 76,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109",
      "ID": 5236
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2066,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.1087779+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299628",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 299628,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1987,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 76,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109",
      "ID": 5236
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7059265+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306701",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306701,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1987,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 76,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109",
      "ID": 5236
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina",
      "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5636827+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300633",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 300633,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1987,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 76,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109",
      "ID": 5236
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2487,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0069969+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223898",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223898,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1987,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 76,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109",
      "ID": 5236
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4785024+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237528",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237528,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1987,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 76,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109",
      "ID": 5236
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1961,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David",
      "DisplayName": "David McLetchie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2147255+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305510",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 305510,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1987,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 76,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109",
      "ID": 5236
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2134,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3274557+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320388",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 320388,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1987,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 76,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109",
      "ID": 5236
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5041,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan",
      "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1642686+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315954",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315954,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1987,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 76,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109",
      "ID": 5236
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3763,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart",
      "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9394333+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1986E23P197VM236686",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 236686,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1987,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 76,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109",
      "ID": 5236
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1986,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan",
      "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9357104+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5047E100P130VM289818",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289818,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1987,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 76,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109",
      "ID": 5236
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5047,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne",
      "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.460389+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234547",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234547,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1987,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 76,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109",
      "ID": 5236
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1845,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette",
      "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3890014+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313213",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313213,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1987,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 76,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109",
      "ID": 5236
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3061,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.38261+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1768E19P265VM289305",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289305,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1987,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 76,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109",
      "ID": 5236
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1768,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4315535+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225269",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225269,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1987,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 76,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109",
      "ID": 5236
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1894,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Neil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9621073+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3815E98P134VM270957",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270957,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1987,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 76,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109",
      "ID": 5236
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3815,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Park, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Park",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8363702+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265833",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265833,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1987,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 76,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109",
      "ID": 5236
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2010,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil",
      "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4564589+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283263",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283263,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1987,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 76,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109",
      "ID": 5236
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5057,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.6929414+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2853E33P128VM251502",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251502,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1987,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 76,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109",
      "ID": 5236
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Pentland",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4664441+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317609",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317609,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1987,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 76,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109",
      "ID": 5236
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5009,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.429803+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254320",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254320,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1987,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 76,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109",
      "ID": 5236
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3745,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis",
      "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2504797+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1870E225P478VM296206",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 296206,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1987,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 76,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109",
      "ID": 5236
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1870,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona",
      "DisplayName": "Shona Robison",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8385522+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2135E254P450VM235405",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235405,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1987,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 76,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109",
      "ID": 5236
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2135,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Russell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.669311+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1895E232P431VM257623",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257623,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1987,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 76,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109",
      "ID": 5236
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1895,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0644862+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228491",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 228491,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1987,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 76,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109",
      "ID": 5236
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1839,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.8013663+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2345E10P55VM291629",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291629,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1987,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 76,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109",
      "ID": 5236
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2345,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1355237+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311098",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311098,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1987,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 76,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109",
      "ID": 5236
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2223,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish",
      "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.6053266+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246405",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 246405,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1987,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 76,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109",
      "ID": 5236
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2182,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1273088+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298111",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298111,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1987,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 76,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109",
      "ID": 5236
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5079,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew",
      "DisplayName": "Drew Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1387122+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234143",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234143,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1987,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 76,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109",
      "ID": 5236
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1769,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1684838+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274640",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274640,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1987,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 76,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109",
      "ID": 5236
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4014,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz",
      "DisplayName": "Liz Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1153459+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269569",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269569,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1987,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 76,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109",
      "ID": 5236
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2215,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5532829+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317439",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317439,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1987,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 76,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109",
      "ID": 5236
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3806,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4221583+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326330",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 326330,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1987,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 76,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109",
      "ID": 5236
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5106,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin",
      "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7537958+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241196",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241196,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1987,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 76,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109",
      "ID": 5236
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1848,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola",
      "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7471474+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2098E237P531VM290319",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 290319,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1987,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 76,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109",
      "ID": 5236
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2098,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Swinney",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7417007+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2674E247P401VM247819",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247819,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1987,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 76,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109",
      "ID": 5236
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2674,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave",
      "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4297954+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5075E234P371VM287448",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 287448,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1987,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 76,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109",
      "ID": 5236
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5075,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Torrance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8646234+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1793E151P9VM222513",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 222513,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1987,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 76,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109",
      "ID": 5236
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1793,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean",
      "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1921951+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5078E245P7VM307004",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307004,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1987,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 76,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109",
      "ID": 5236
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5078,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Walker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5831746+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1841E231P426VM239927",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239927,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1987,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 76,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109",
      "ID": 5236
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1841,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen",
      "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.76531+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283670",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283670,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1987,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 76,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109",
      "ID": 5236
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4952,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7182228+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1865E263P500VM231859",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231859,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1987,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 76,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109",
      "ID": 5236
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1865,
      "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra",
      "DisplayName": "Sandra White",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6186035+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237734",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237734,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1987,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 76,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109",
      "ID": 5236
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2610,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Wilson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2235286+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309220",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 309220,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1987,
      "AgendaID": 2456,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 76,
      "VoteAgainst": 33,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Modernisation of Scotland’s Career Services",
      "Reference": "S4M-05109",
      "ID": 5236
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4941,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza",
      "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3199298+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252729",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252729,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1984,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088.1",
      "ID": 5233
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1926,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian",
      "DisplayName": "Brian Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7510426+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2615E213P388VM258940",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258940,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1984,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088.1",
      "ID": 5233
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2615,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George",
      "DisplayName": "George Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3348101+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319624",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319624,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1984,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088.1",
      "ID": 5233
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4940,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare",
      "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9343104+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249536",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 249536,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1984,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088.1",
      "ID": 5233
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2641,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair",
      "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9310952+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1783E21P273VM227847",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227847,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1984,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088.1",
      "ID": 5233
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1783,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie",
      "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5682046+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2633E97P136VM280847",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280847,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1984,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088.1",
      "ID": 5233
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2633,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire",
      "DisplayName": "Claire Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.784916+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262764",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262764,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1984,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088.1",
      "ID": 5233
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2603,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6158406+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1759E91P115VM229853",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229853,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1984,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088.1",
      "ID": 5233
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia",
      "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.1002263+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3751E243P383VM269777",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269777,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1984,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088.1",
      "ID": 5233
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3751,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5625009+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322599",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 322599,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1984,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088.1",
      "ID": 5233
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5109,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco",
      "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6956487+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5060E86P124VM295300",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295300,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1984,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088.1",
      "ID": 5233
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5060,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5060563+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242977",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242977,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1984,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088.1",
      "ID": 5233
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1866,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah",
      "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0436561+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235150",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235150,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1984,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088.1",
      "ID": 5233
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1943,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic",
      "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4215331+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302418",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 302418,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1984,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088.1",
      "ID": 5233
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2595,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin",
      "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5235086+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244239",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244239,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1984,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088.1",
      "ID": 5233
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2103,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith",
      "DisplayName": "Keith Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.546057+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327123",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 327123,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1984,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088.1",
      "ID": 5233
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.8001134+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277103",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277103,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1984,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088.1",
      "ID": 5233
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.7012144+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264226",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264226,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1984,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088.1",
      "ID": 5233
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2673,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick",
      "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1241606+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248684",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248684,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1984,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088.1",
      "ID": 5233
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2678,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson",
      "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6653841+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2123E27P233VM294936",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 294936,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1984,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088.1",
      "ID": 5233
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2123,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm",
      "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1851236+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285267",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285267,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1984,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088.1",
      "ID": 5233
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3907,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3156105+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230742",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230742,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1984,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088.1",
      "ID": 5233
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1735,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela",
      "DisplayName": "Angela Constance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3435997+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243741",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 243741,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1984,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088.1",
      "ID": 5233
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1932,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce",
      "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3178255+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254828",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254828,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1984,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088.1",
      "ID": 5233
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1863,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna",
      "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2854933+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323730",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 323730,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1984,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088.1",
      "ID": 5233
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4976,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth",
      "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9694372+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5107E223P379VM291242",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291242,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1984,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088.1",
      "ID": 5233
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5107,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1104227+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3743E222P391VM265440",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265440,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1984,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088.1",
      "ID": 5233
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3743,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel",
      "DisplayName": "Nigel Don",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4392769+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262341",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262341,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1984,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088.1",
      "ID": 5233
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3771,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob",
      "DisplayName": "Bob Doris",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.597286+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281892",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 281892,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1984,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088.1",
      "ID": 5233
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2826,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Dornan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1621353+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298234",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298234,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1984,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088.1",
      "ID": 5233
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3812,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia",
      "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3369708+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231197",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231197,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1984,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088.1",
      "ID": 5233
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1778,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen",
      "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.370016+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4955E240P389VM285021",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285021,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1984,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088.1",
      "ID": 5233
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4955,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0578134+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219481",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 219481,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1984,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088.1",
      "ID": 5233
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1742,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle",
      "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3011308+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238486",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 238486,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1984,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088.1",
      "ID": 5233
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1994,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus",
      "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.456196+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225190",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225190,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1984,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088.1",
      "ID": 5233
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1814,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda",
      "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7483454+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321861",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 321861,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1984,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088.1",
      "ID": 5233
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Fee",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4544951+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292842",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 292842,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1984,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088.1",
      "ID": 5233
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia",
      "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5604442+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227205",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227205,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1984,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088.1",
      "ID": 5233
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5353585+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5054E95P118VM313240",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313240,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1984,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088.1",
      "ID": 5233
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5054,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.3838784+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4947E152P8VM257746",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257746,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1984,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088.1",
      "ID": 5233
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4947,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Finnie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0758442+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271153",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271153,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1984,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088.1",
      "ID": 5233
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3901,
      "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe",
      "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8447558+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278029",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 278029,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1984,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088.1",
      "ID": 5233
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2394,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo",
      "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9839398+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2110E220P414VM287313",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 287313,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1984,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088.1",
      "ID": 5233
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth",
      "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8587982+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250563",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250563,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1984,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088.1",
      "ID": 5233
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2675,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob",
      "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1949655+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221027",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221027,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1984,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088.1",
      "ID": 5233
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1741,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel",
      "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6719374+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220164",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220164,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1984,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088.1",
      "ID": 5233
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1756,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine",
      "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3371024+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1860E104P150VM252439",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252439,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1984,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088.1",
      "ID": 5233
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1860,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda",
      "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7291994+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2033E20P141VM253797",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253797,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1984,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088.1",
      "ID": 5233
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2033,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain",
      "DisplayName": "Iain Gray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0213002+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324675",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324675,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1984,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088.1",
      "ID": 5233
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5042,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2331251+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259631",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 259631,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1984,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088.1",
      "ID": 5233
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick",
      "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6177813+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239410",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239410,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1984,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088.1",
      "ID": 5233
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2029,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh",
      "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7355992+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273697",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 273697,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1984,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088.1",
      "ID": 5233
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3758,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6315032+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304067",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 304067,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1984,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088.1",
      "ID": 5233
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4086,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Hume",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8480542+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221668",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221668,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1984,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088.1",
      "ID": 5233
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1773,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9426587+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1882E227P459VM241898",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241898,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1984,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088.1",
      "ID": 5233
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1882,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam",
      "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7847718+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223462",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223462,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1984,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088.1",
      "ID": 5233
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1893,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4591219+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307817",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307817,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1984,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088.1",
      "ID": 5233
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4934,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.852169+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272299",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 272299,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1984,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088.1",
      "ID": 5233
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4956,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Keir",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.32367+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244988",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244988,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1984,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088.1",
      "ID": 5233
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Kelly",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.587188+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315156",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315156,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1984,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088.1",
      "ID": 5233
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3129,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6767398+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247858",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247858,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1984,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088.1",
      "ID": 5233
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann",
      "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4314325+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4016E11P36VM275087",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 275087,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1984,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088.1",
      "ID": 5233
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4016,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1406311+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255554",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255554,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1984,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088.1",
      "ID": 5233
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2180,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5363181+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4938E158P374VM277002",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277002,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1984,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088.1",
      "ID": 5233
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4938,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6968608+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2112E250P486VM253410",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253410,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1984,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088.1",
      "ID": 5233
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2112,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny",
      "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.9952323+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4939E258P394VM276748",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276748,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1984,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088.1",
      "ID": 5233
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4939,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus",
      "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6794282+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325456",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 325456,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1984,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088.1",
      "ID": 5233
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5074,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon",
      "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5071703+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1828E3P10VM233243",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 233243,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1984,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088.1",
      "ID": 5233
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1828,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo",
      "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1156143+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311662",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311662,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1984,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088.1",
      "ID": 5233
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4948,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike",
      "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8888382+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2117E90P107VM229699",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229699,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1984,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088.1",
      "ID": 5233
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2117,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis",
      "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0928755+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267446",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 267446,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1984,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088.1",
      "ID": 5233
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken",
      "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0201628+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313499",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313499,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1984,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088.1",
      "ID": 5233
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4966,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek",
      "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.3980081+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3101E102P129VM294993",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 294993,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1984,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088.1",
      "ID": 5233
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3101,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala",
      "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1875848+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319110",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319110,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1984,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088.1",
      "ID": 5233
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5034,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny",
      "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6928808+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306331",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306331,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1984,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088.1",
      "ID": 5233
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2159,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Martin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5474537+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5110E252P395VM310845",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 310845,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1984,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088.1",
      "ID": 5233
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Mason",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5885112+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268158",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 268158,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1984,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088.1",
      "ID": 5233
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2133,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0587119+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2876E141P433VM286416",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286416,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1984,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088.1",
      "ID": 5233
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2876,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5782058+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4951E147P368VM258572",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258572,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1984,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088.1",
      "ID": 5233
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4951,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan",
      "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3130339+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3896E175P307VM263796",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 263796,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1984,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088.1",
      "ID": 5233
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3896,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam",
      "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9050991+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308487",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 308487,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1984,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088.1",
      "ID": 5233
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0580427+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4964E143P375VM279754",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279754,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1984,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088.1",
      "ID": 5233
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4964,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5211806+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279570",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279570,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1984,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088.1",
      "ID": 5233
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3824,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5133716+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2066E22P91VM260999",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 260999,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1984,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088.1",
      "ID": 5233
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2066,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.1071937+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299584",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 299584,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1984,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088.1",
      "ID": 5233
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7037383+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306674",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306674,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1984,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088.1",
      "ID": 5233
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina",
      "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5624899+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2487E146P369VM301120",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 301120,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1984,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088.1",
      "ID": 5233
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2487,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0343362+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223930",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223930,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1984,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088.1",
      "ID": 5233
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4846718+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237880",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237880,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1984,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088.1",
      "ID": 5233
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1961,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David",
      "DisplayName": "David McLetchie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2300496+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305537",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 305537,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1984,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088.1",
      "ID": 5233
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2134,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3286001+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320316",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 320316,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1984,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088.1",
      "ID": 5233
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5041,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan",
      "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1547461+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315926",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315926,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1984,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088.1",
      "ID": 5233
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3763,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart",
      "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9382343+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1986E23P197VM236731",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 236731,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1984,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088.1",
      "ID": 5233
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1986,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan",
      "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9376463+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5047E100P130VM289774",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289774,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1984,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088.1",
      "ID": 5233
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5047,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne",
      "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4585407+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234497",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234497,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1984,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088.1",
      "ID": 5233
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1845,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette",
      "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3868098+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313186",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313186,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1984,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088.1",
      "ID": 5233
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3061,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.167371+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1768E19P265VM289276",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289276,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1984,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088.1",
      "ID": 5233
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1768,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4303001+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225325",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225325,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1984,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088.1",
      "ID": 5233
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1894,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Neil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9697018+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3815E98P134VM270970",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270970,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1984,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088.1",
      "ID": 5233
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3815,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Park, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Park",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8369438+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265785",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265785,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1984,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088.1",
      "ID": 5233
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2010,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil",
      "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4543863+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283234",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283234,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1984,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088.1",
      "ID": 5233
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5057,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.691646+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2853E33P128VM252016",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252016,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1984,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088.1",
      "ID": 5233
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Pentland",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4989516+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317537",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317537,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1984,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088.1",
      "ID": 5233
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5009,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4267216+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254289",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254289,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1984,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088.1",
      "ID": 5233
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3745,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis",
      "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2491335+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1870E225P478VM296179",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 296179,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1984,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088.1",
      "ID": 5233
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1870,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona",
      "DisplayName": "Shona Robison",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5527677+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2135E254P450VM235459",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235459,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1984,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088.1",
      "ID": 5233
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2135,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Russell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6787536+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1895E232P431VM257671",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257671,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1984,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088.1",
      "ID": 5233
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1895,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0665613+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228524",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 228524,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1984,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088.1",
      "ID": 5233
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1839,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.8028027+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2345E10P55VM291581",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291581,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1984,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088.1",
      "ID": 5233
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2345,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1335282+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311125",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311125,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1984,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088.1",
      "ID": 5233
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2223,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish",
      "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.6064859+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246439",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 246439,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1984,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088.1",
      "ID": 5233
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2182,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1287713+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298069",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298069,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1984,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088.1",
      "ID": 5233
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5079,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew",
      "DisplayName": "Drew Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1369275+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234099",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234099,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1984,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088.1",
      "ID": 5233
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1769,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1665898+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274670",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274670,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1984,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088.1",
      "ID": 5233
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4014,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz",
      "DisplayName": "Liz Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1166511+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269612",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269612,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1984,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088.1",
      "ID": 5233
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2215,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.555374+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317467",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317467,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1984,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088.1",
      "ID": 5233
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3806,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4234546+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326374",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 326374,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1984,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088.1",
      "ID": 5233
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5106,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin",
      "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7557326+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241230",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241230,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1984,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088.1",
      "ID": 5233
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1848,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola",
      "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7486166+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2098E237P531VM290347",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 290347,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1984,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088.1",
      "ID": 5233
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2098,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Swinney",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7429655+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248025",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248025,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1984,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088.1",
      "ID": 5233
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2674,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave",
      "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4385336+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5075E234P371VM287477",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 287477,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1984,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088.1",
      "ID": 5233
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5075,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Torrance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8658585+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1793E151P9VM222569",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 222569,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1984,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088.1",
      "ID": 5233
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1793,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean",
      "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.194582+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5078E245P7VM307031",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307031,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1984,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088.1",
      "ID": 5233
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5078,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Walker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5843187+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1841E231P426VM239894",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239894,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1984,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088.1",
      "ID": 5233
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1841,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen",
      "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7639003+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283737",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283737,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1984,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088.1",
      "ID": 5233
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4952,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.721087+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1865E263P500VM231813",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231813,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1984,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088.1",
      "ID": 5233
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1865,
      "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra",
      "DisplayName": "Sandra White",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6166227+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237379",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237379,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1984,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088.1",
      "ID": 5233
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2610,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Wilson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2016618+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309175",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 309175,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1984,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088.1",
      "ID": 5233
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4941,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza",
      "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0952438+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252731",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252731,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1986,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088",
      "ID": 5218
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1926,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian",
      "DisplayName": "Brian Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.751124+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2615E213P388VM258942",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258942,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1986,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088",
      "ID": 5218
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2615,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George",
      "DisplayName": "George Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3348914+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319621",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319621,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1986,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088",
      "ID": 5218
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4940,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare",
      "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9341855+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249534",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 249534,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1986,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088",
      "ID": 5218
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2641,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair",
      "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9310141+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1783E21P273VM227849",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227849,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1986,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088",
      "ID": 5218
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1783,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie",
      "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5683065+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2633E97P136VM280851",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280851,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1986,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088",
      "ID": 5218
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2633,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire",
      "DisplayName": "Claire Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.785097+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262766",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262766,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1986,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088",
      "ID": 5218
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2603,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.615923+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1759E91P115VM229855",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229855,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1986,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088",
      "ID": 5218
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia",
      "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.1003083+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3751E243P383VM269775",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269775,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1986,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088",
      "ID": 5218
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3751,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5624204+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322594",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 322594,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1986,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088",
      "ID": 5218
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5109,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco",
      "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6954399+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5060E86P124VM295302",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295302,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1986,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088",
      "ID": 5218
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5060,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5061574+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242979",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242979,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1986,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088",
      "ID": 5218
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1866,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah",
      "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0437375+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235148",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235148,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1986,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088",
      "ID": 5218
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1943,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic",
      "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.42145+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302420",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 302420,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1986,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088",
      "ID": 5218
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2595,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin",
      "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5236567+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244237",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244237,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1986,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088",
      "ID": 5218
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2103,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith",
      "DisplayName": "Keith Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5459732+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327116",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 327116,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1986,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088",
      "ID": 5218
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7996177+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277105",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277105,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1986,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088",
      "ID": 5218
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.7013156+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264224",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264224,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1986,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088",
      "ID": 5218
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2673,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick",
      "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.124079+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248682",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248682,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1986,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088",
      "ID": 5218
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2678,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson",
      "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6653024+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2123E27P233VM294934",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 294934,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1986,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088",
      "ID": 5218
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2123,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm",
      "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1850408+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285269",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285269,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1986,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088",
      "ID": 5218
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3907,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3157124+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230744",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230744,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1986,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088",
      "ID": 5218
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1735,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela",
      "DisplayName": "Angela Constance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3436818+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243739",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 243739,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1986,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088",
      "ID": 5218
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1932,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce",
      "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3177271+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254826",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254826,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1986,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088",
      "ID": 5218
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1863,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna",
      "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2854113+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323723",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 323723,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1986,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088",
      "ID": 5218
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4976,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth",
      "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9691248+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5107E223P379VM291240",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291240,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1986,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088",
      "ID": 5218
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5107,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1103407+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3743E222P391VM265442",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265442,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1986,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088",
      "ID": 5218
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3743,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel",
      "DisplayName": "Nigel Don",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4393593+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262343",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262343,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1986,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088",
      "ID": 5218
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3771,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob",
      "DisplayName": "Bob Doris",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.5973911+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281888",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 281888,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1986,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088",
      "ID": 5218
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2826,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Dornan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1619685+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298238",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298238,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1986,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088",
      "ID": 5218
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3812,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia",
      "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3371381+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231195",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231195,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1986,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088",
      "ID": 5218
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1778,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen",
      "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3699164+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4955E240P389VM285018",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285018,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1986,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088",
      "ID": 5218
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4955,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0576895+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219483",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 219483,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1986,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088",
      "ID": 5218
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1742,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle",
      "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3012144+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238484",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 238484,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1986,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088",
      "ID": 5218
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1994,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus",
      "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4560937+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225188",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225188,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1986,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088",
      "ID": 5218
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1814,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda",
      "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7482439+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321866",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 321866,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1986,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088",
      "ID": 5218
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Fee",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4547181+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292763",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 292763,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1986,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088",
      "ID": 5218
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia",
      "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5571141+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227207",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227207,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1986,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088",
      "ID": 5218
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5354432+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5054E95P118VM313242",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313242,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1986,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088",
      "ID": 5218
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5054,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.3840021+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4947E152P8VM257748",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257748,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1986,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088",
      "ID": 5218
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4947,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Finnie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0759269+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271150",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271150,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1986,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088",
      "ID": 5218
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3901,
      "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe",
      "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8446319+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278025",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 278025,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1986,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088",
      "ID": 5218
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2394,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo",
      "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9837732+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2110E220P414VM287315",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 287315,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1986,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088",
      "ID": 5218
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth",
      "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8588798+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250565",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250565,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1986,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088",
      "ID": 5218
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2675,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob",
      "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1950472+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221029",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221029,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1986,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088",
      "ID": 5218
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1741,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel",
      "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6720189+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220162",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220162,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1986,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088",
      "ID": 5218
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1756,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine",
      "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3370189+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1860E104P150VM252441",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252441,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1986,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088",
      "ID": 5218
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1860,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda",
      "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7292809+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2033E20P141VM253793",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253793,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1986,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088",
      "ID": 5218
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2033,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain",
      "DisplayName": "Iain Gray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0211396+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324682",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324682,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1986,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088",
      "ID": 5218
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5042,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2334068+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259629",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 259629,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1986,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088",
      "ID": 5218
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick",
      "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6176986+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239412",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239412,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1986,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088",
      "ID": 5218
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2029,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh",
      "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7356814+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273695",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 273695,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1986,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088",
      "ID": 5218
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3758,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6314218+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304065",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 304065,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1986,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088",
      "ID": 5218
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4086,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Hume",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8479427+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221666",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221666,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1986,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088",
      "ID": 5218
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1773,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9425761+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1882E227P459VM241896",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241896,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1986,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088",
      "ID": 5218
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1882,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam",
      "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.784689+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223460",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223460,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1986,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088",
      "ID": 5218
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1893,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4589466+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307821",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307821,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1986,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088",
      "ID": 5218
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4934,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8523376+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272301",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 272301,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1986,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088",
      "ID": 5218
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4956,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Keir",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3237517+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244990",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244990,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1986,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088",
      "ID": 5218
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Kelly",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5872696+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315158",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315158,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1986,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088",
      "ID": 5218
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3129,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.676821+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247856",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247856,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1986,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088",
      "ID": 5218
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann",
      "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4313522+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4016E11P36VM275090",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 275090,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1986,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088",
      "ID": 5218
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4016,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1408578+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255552",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255552,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1986,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088",
      "ID": 5218
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2180,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5362291+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4938E158P374VM276999",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276999,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1986,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088",
      "ID": 5218
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4938,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6967376+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2112E250P486VM253412",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253412,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1986,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088",
      "ID": 5218
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2112,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny",
      "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.995317+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4939E258P394VM276746",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276746,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1986,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088",
      "ID": 5218
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4939,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus",
      "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6793461+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325449",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 325449,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1986,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088",
      "ID": 5218
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5074,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon",
      "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.506882+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1828E3P10VM233245",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 233245,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1986,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088",
      "ID": 5218
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1828,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo",
      "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.115697+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311666",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311666,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1986,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088",
      "ID": 5218
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4948,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike",
      "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8890269+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2117E90P107VM229697",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229697,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1986,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088",
      "ID": 5218
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2117,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis",
      "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0927949+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267450",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 267450,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1986,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088",
      "ID": 5218
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken",
      "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0203665+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313495",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313495,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1986,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088",
      "ID": 5218
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4966,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek",
      "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.3978415+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3101E102P129VM294989",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 294989,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1986,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088",
      "ID": 5218
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3101,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala",
      "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1874181+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319115",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319115,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1986,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088",
      "ID": 5218
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5034,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny",
      "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6930896+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306329",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306329,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1986,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088",
      "ID": 5218
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2159,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Martin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.547371+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5110E252P395VM310767",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 310767,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1986,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088",
      "ID": 5218
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Mason",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5851695+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268154",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 268154,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1986,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088",
      "ID": 5218
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2133,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0585234+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2876E141P433VM286420",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286420,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1986,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088",
      "ID": 5218
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2876,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5783916+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4951E147P368VM258570",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258570,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1986,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088",
      "ID": 5218
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4951,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan",
      "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3129449+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3896E175P307VM263794",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 263794,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1986,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088",
      "ID": 5218
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3896,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam",
      "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9050178+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308720",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 308720,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1986,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088",
      "ID": 5218
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0680452+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4964E143P375VM279756",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279756,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1986,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088",
      "ID": 5218
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4964,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5212628+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279568",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279568,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1986,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088",
      "ID": 5218
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3824,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5132915+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2066E22P91VM260997",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 260997,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1986,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088",
      "ID": 5218
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2066,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.1070789+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299580",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 299580,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1986,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088",
      "ID": 5218
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7035693+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306754",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306754,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1986,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088",
      "ID": 5218
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina",
      "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5659673+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300581",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 300581,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1986,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088",
      "ID": 5218
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2487,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0047619+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223932",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223932,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1986,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088",
      "ID": 5218
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4847896+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237882",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237882,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1986,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088",
      "ID": 5218
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1961,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David",
      "DisplayName": "David McLetchie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2301324+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305539",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 305539,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1986,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088",
      "ID": 5218
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2134,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.328682+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320311",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 320311,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1986,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088",
      "ID": 5218
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5041,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan",
      "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.154537+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315924",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315924,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1986,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088",
      "ID": 5218
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3763,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart",
      "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9381487+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1986E23P197VM236733",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 236733,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1986,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088",
      "ID": 5218
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1986,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan",
      "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9377282+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5047E100P130VM289772",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289772,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1986,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088",
      "ID": 5218
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5047,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne",
      "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4584596+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234495",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234495,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1986,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088",
      "ID": 5218
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1845,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette",
      "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3867254+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313184",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313184,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1986,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088",
      "ID": 5218
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3061,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1672881+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1768E19P265VM289356",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289356,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1986,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088",
      "ID": 5218
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1768,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4337183+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225327",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225327,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1986,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088",
      "ID": 5218
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1894,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Neil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9697847+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3815E98P134VM270972",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270972,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1986,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088",
      "ID": 5218
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3815,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Park, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Park",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8370256+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265783",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265783,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1986,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088",
      "ID": 5218
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2010,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil",
      "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4543037+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283232",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283232,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1986,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088",
      "ID": 5218
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5057,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.6915627+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2853E33P128VM252018",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252018,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1986,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088",
      "ID": 5218
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Pentland",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4990335+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317532",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317532,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1986,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088",
      "ID": 5218
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5009,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4264958+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254287",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254287,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1986,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088",
      "ID": 5218
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3745,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis",
      "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2490506+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1870E225P478VM296258",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 296258,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1986,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088",
      "ID": 5218
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1870,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona",
      "DisplayName": "Shona Robison",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8408838+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2135E254P450VM235461",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235461,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1986,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088",
      "ID": 5218
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2135,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Russell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6788573+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1895E232P431VM257673",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257673,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1986,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088",
      "ID": 5218
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1895,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0666443+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228526",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 228526,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1986,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088",
      "ID": 5218
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1839,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.8028858+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2345E10P55VM291579",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291579,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1986,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088",
      "ID": 5218
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2345,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1334466+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311127",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311127,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1986,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088",
      "ID": 5218
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2223,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish",
      "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.606569+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246441",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 246441,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1986,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088",
      "ID": 5218
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2182,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1288544+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298067",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298067,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1986,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088",
      "ID": 5218
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5079,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew",
      "DisplayName": "Drew Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1368457+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234097",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234097,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1986,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088",
      "ID": 5218
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1769,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1665067+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274672",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274672,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1986,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088",
      "ID": 5218
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4014,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz",
      "DisplayName": "Liz Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1167338+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269616",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269616,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1986,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088",
      "ID": 5218
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2215,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5555417+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317469",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317469,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1986,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088",
      "ID": 5218
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3806,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4235618+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326381",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 326381,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1986,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088",
      "ID": 5218
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5106,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin",
      "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7560443+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241232",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241232,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1986,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088",
      "ID": 5218
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1848,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola",
      "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7486993+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2098E237P531VM290349",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 290349,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1986,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088",
      "ID": 5218
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2098,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Swinney",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7430475+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248027",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248027,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1986,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088",
      "ID": 5218
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2674,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave",
      "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4386169+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5075E234P371VM287479",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 287479,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1986,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088",
      "ID": 5218
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5075,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Torrance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8659398+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1793E151P9VM222571",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 222571,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1986,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088",
      "ID": 5218
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1793,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean",
      "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.194664+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5078E245P7VM306959",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306959,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1986,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088",
      "ID": 5218
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5078,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Walker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5812603+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1841E231P426VM239892",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239892,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1986,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088",
      "ID": 5218
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1841,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen",
      "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7638175+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283740",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283740,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1986,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088",
      "ID": 5218
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4952,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7212349+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1865E263P500VM231811",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231811,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1986,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088",
      "ID": 5218
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1865,
      "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra",
      "DisplayName": "Sandra White",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6165395+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237377",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237377,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1986,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088",
      "ID": 5218
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2610,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Wilson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2015791+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309016",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 309016,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1986,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Health Service",
      "Reference": "S4M-05088",
      "ID": 5218
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4941,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza",
      "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0880091+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252728",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252728,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1983,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087.2",
      "ID": 5234
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1926,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian",
      "DisplayName": "Brian Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7510019+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2615E213P388VM258939",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258939,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1983,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087.2",
      "ID": 5234
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2615,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George",
      "DisplayName": "George Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3347692+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319625",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319625,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1983,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087.2",
      "ID": 5234
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4940,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare",
      "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9343517+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249537",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 249537,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1983,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087.2",
      "ID": 5234
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2641,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair",
      "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9311366+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1783E21P273VM227846",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227846,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1983,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087.2",
      "ID": 5234
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1783,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie",
      "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5681637+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2633E97P136VM280846",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280846,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1983,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087.2",
      "ID": 5234
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2633,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire",
      "DisplayName": "Claire Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7848757+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262763",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262763,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1983,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087.2",
      "ID": 5234
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2603,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6157945+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1759E91P115VM229852",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229852,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1983,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087.2",
      "ID": 5234
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia",
      "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.100186+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3751E243P383VM269778",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269778,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1983,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087.2",
      "ID": 5234
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3751,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5625417+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322598",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 322598,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1983,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087.2",
      "ID": 5234
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5109,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco",
      "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6956076+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5060E86P124VM295299",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295299,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1983,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087.2",
      "ID": 5234
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5060,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5060143+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242976",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242976,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1983,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087.2",
      "ID": 5234
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1866,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah",
      "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0436133+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235151",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235151,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1983,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087.2",
      "ID": 5234
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1943,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic",
      "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4215748+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302417",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 302417,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1983,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087.2",
      "ID": 5234
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2595,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin",
      "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5234678+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244240",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244240,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1983,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087.2",
      "ID": 5234
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2103,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith",
      "DisplayName": "Keith Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5460983+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327122",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 327122,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1983,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087.2",
      "ID": 5234
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.8000698+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277102",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277102,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1983,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087.2",
      "ID": 5234
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.7011738+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264227",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264227,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1983,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087.2",
      "ID": 5234
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2673,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick",
      "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1242021+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248685",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248685,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1983,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087.2",
      "ID": 5234
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2678,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson",
      "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6654242+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2123E27P233VM294937",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 294937,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1983,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087.2",
      "ID": 5234
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2123,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm",
      "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1851646+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285266",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285266,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1983,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087.2",
      "ID": 5234
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3907,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3155685+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230741",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230741,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1983,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087.2",
      "ID": 5234
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1735,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela",
      "DisplayName": "Angela Constance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3435577+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243742",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 243742,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1983,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087.2",
      "ID": 5234
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1932,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce",
      "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3178667+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254829",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254829,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1983,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087.2",
      "ID": 5234
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1863,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna",
      "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2855339+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323729",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 323729,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1983,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087.2",
      "ID": 5234
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4976,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth",
      "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9693953+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5107E223P379VM291243",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291243,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1983,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087.2",
      "ID": 5234
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5107,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.110464+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3743E222P391VM265439",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265439,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1983,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087.2",
      "ID": 5234
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3743,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel",
      "DisplayName": "Nigel Don",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4392357+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262340",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262340,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1983,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087.2",
      "ID": 5234
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3771,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob",
      "DisplayName": "Bob Doris",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.5972454+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281893",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 281893,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1983,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087.2",
      "ID": 5234
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2826,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Dornan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1621769+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298233",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298233,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1983,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087.2",
      "ID": 5234
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3812,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia",
      "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3369288+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231198",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231198,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1983,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087.2",
      "ID": 5234
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1778,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen",
      "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.370058+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4955E240P389VM285850",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285850,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1983,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087.2",
      "ID": 5234
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4955,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3472259+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219480",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 219480,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1983,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087.2",
      "ID": 5234
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1742,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle",
      "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3010882+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238487",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 238487,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1983,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087.2",
      "ID": 5234
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1994,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus",
      "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4562396+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225191",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225191,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1983,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087.2",
      "ID": 5234
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1814,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda",
      "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7483864+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321862",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 321862,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1983,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087.2",
      "ID": 5234
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Fee",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4545356+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292843",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 292843,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1983,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087.2",
      "ID": 5234
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia",
      "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.560485+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227204",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227204,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1983,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087.2",
      "ID": 5234
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5353159+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5054E95P118VM313239",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313239,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1983,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087.2",
      "ID": 5234
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5054,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.3838353+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4947E152P8VM257745",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257745,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1983,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087.2",
      "ID": 5234
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4947,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Finnie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0758021+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271205",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271205,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1983,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087.2",
      "ID": 5234
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3901,
      "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe",
      "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0601599+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278030",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 278030,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1983,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087.2",
      "ID": 5234
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2394,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo",
      "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9839803+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2110E220P414VM287312",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 287312,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1983,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087.2",
      "ID": 5234
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth",
      "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8587567+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250562",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250562,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1983,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087.2",
      "ID": 5234
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2675,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob",
      "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1949244+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221026",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221026,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1983,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087.2",
      "ID": 5234
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1741,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel",
      "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6718953+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220165",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220165,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1983,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087.2",
      "ID": 5234
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1756,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine",
      "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3371434+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1860E104P150VM252438",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252438,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1983,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087.2",
      "ID": 5234
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1860,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda",
      "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7291583+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2033E20P141VM253798",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253798,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1983,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087.2",
      "ID": 5234
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2033,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain",
      "DisplayName": "Iain Gray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0213399+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324676",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324676,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1983,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087.2",
      "ID": 5234
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5042,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2331653+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259632",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 259632,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1983,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087.2",
      "ID": 5234
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick",
      "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6178226+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239409",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239409,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1983,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087.2",
      "ID": 5234
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2029,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh",
      "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7355578+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273698",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 273698,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1983,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087.2",
      "ID": 5234
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3758,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6315431+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304068",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 304068,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1983,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087.2",
      "ID": 5234
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4086,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Hume",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8480988+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221669",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221669,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1983,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087.2",
      "ID": 5234
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1773,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9427003+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1882E227P459VM241899",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241899,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1983,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087.2",
      "ID": 5234
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1882,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam",
      "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7848128+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223463",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223463,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1983,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087.2",
      "ID": 5234
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1893,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4591738+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307816",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307816,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1983,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087.2",
      "ID": 5234
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4934,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8521272+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272298",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 272298,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1983,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087.2",
      "ID": 5234
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4956,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Keir",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3236281+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244987",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244987,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1983,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087.2",
      "ID": 5234
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Kelly",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5871469+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315155",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315155,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1983,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087.2",
      "ID": 5234
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3129,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6766981+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247859",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247859,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1983,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087.2",
      "ID": 5234
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann",
      "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4314723+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4016E11P36VM275035",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 275035,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1983,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087.2",
      "ID": 5234
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4016,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1383626+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255555",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255555,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1983,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087.2",
      "ID": 5234
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2180,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5363585+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4938E158P374VM277364",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277364,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1983,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087.2",
      "ID": 5234
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4938,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9502095+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2112E250P486VM253409",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253409,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1983,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087.2",
      "ID": 5234
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2112,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny",
      "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.9951715+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4939E258P394VM276749",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276749,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1983,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087.2",
      "ID": 5234
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4939,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus",
      "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6794695+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325455",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 325455,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1983,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087.2",
      "ID": 5234
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5074,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon",
      "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.507128+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1828E3P10VM232933",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232933,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1983,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087.2",
      "ID": 5234
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1828,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo",
      "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8828999+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311661",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311661,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1983,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087.2",
      "ID": 5234
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4948,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike",
      "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8887959+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2117E90P107VM229700",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229700,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1983,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087.2",
      "ID": 5234
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2117,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis",
      "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0929155+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267445",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 267445,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1983,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087.2",
      "ID": 5234
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken",
      "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0201222+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313500",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313500,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1983,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087.2",
      "ID": 5234
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4966,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek",
      "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.3980489+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3101E102P129VM294994",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 294994,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1983,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087.2",
      "ID": 5234
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3101,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala",
      "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1876272+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319111",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319111,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1983,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087.2",
      "ID": 5234
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5034,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny",
      "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6929238+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306332",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306332,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1983,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087.2",
      "ID": 5234
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2159,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Martin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5474943+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5110E252P395VM310846",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 310846,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1983,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087.2",
      "ID": 5234
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Mason",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5885527+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268159",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 268159,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1983,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087.2",
      "ID": 5234
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2133,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0587545+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2876E141P433VM286415",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286415,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1983,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087.2",
      "ID": 5234
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2876,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5781647+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4951E147P368VM258573",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258573,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1983,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087.2",
      "ID": 5234
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4951,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan",
      "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.313076+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3896E175P307VM263797",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 263797,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1983,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087.2",
      "ID": 5234
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3896,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam",
      "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9051399+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308486",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 308486,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1983,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087.2",
      "ID": 5234
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0580006+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4964E143P375VM279753",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279753,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1983,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087.2",
      "ID": 5234
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4964,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5211339+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279571",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279571,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1983,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087.2",
      "ID": 5234
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3824,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5134116+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2066E22P91VM261000",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261000,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1983,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087.2",
      "ID": 5234
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2066,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.1072419+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299585",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 299585,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1983,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087.2",
      "ID": 5234
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7037987+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306673",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306673,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1983,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087.2",
      "ID": 5234
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina",
      "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.562448+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2487E146P369VM301121",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 301121,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1983,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087.2",
      "ID": 5234
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2487,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0343857+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223929",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223929,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1983,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087.2",
      "ID": 5234
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4846103+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237879",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237879,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1983,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087.2",
      "ID": 5234
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1961,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David",
      "DisplayName": "David McLetchie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2300085+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305536",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 305536,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1983,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087.2",
      "ID": 5234
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2134,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3285586+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320315",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 320315,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1983,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087.2",
      "ID": 5234
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5041,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan",
      "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1547043+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315927",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315927,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1983,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087.2",
      "ID": 5234
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3763,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart",
      "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9382761+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1986E23P197VM236730",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 236730,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1983,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087.2",
      "ID": 5234
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1986,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan",
      "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9376053+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5047E100P130VM289775",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289775,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1983,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087.2",
      "ID": 5234
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5047,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne",
      "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4585863+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234498",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234498,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1983,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087.2",
      "ID": 5234
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1845,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette",
      "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3868509+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313187",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313187,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1983,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087.2",
      "ID": 5234
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3061,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1674125+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1768E19P265VM289275",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289275,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1983,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087.2",
      "ID": 5234
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1768,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.430259+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225324",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225324,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1983,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087.2",
      "ID": 5234
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1894,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Neil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.96966+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3815E98P134VM270969",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270969,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1983,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087.2",
      "ID": 5234
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3815,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Park, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Park",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8369023+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265786",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265786,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1983,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087.2",
      "ID": 5234
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2010,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil",
      "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4544273+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283235",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283235,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1983,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087.2",
      "ID": 5234
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5057,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.6916864+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2853E33P128VM252015",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252015,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1983,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087.2",
      "ID": 5234
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Pentland",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4989097+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317536",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317536,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1983,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087.2",
      "ID": 5234
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5009,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.42668+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254290",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254290,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1983,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087.2",
      "ID": 5234
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3745,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis",
      "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2491749+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1870E225P478VM296178",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 296178,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1983,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087.2",
      "ID": 5234
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1870,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona",
      "DisplayName": "Shona Robison",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5527267+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2135E254P450VM235458",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235458,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1983,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087.2",
      "ID": 5234
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2135,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Russell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6787129+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1895E232P431VM257670",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257670,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1983,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087.2",
      "ID": 5234
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1895,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0665201+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228523",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 228523,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1983,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087.2",
      "ID": 5234
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1839,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.8027592+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2345E10P55VM291582",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291582,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1983,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087.2",
      "ID": 5234
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2345,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.133568+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311124",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311124,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1983,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087.2",
      "ID": 5234
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2223,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish",
      "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.6064264+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246438",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 246438,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1983,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087.2",
      "ID": 5234
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2182,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1287288+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298070",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298070,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1983,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087.2",
      "ID": 5234
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5079,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew",
      "DisplayName": "Drew Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.136968+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234100",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234100,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1983,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087.2",
      "ID": 5234
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1769,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1666305+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274669",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274669,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1983,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087.2",
      "ID": 5234
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4014,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz",
      "DisplayName": "Liz Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1166094+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269611",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269611,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1983,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087.2",
      "ID": 5234
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2215,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5553322+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317466",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317466,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1983,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087.2",
      "ID": 5234
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3806,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4234069+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326375",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 326375,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1983,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087.2",
      "ID": 5234
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5106,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin",
      "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7557734+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241229",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241229,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1983,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087.2",
      "ID": 5234
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1848,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola",
      "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7485751+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2098E237P531VM290346",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 290346,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1983,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087.2",
      "ID": 5234
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2098,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Swinney",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7429246+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248024",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248024,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1983,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087.2",
      "ID": 5234
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2674,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave",
      "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4384906+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5075E234P371VM287476",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 287476,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1983,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087.2",
      "ID": 5234
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5075,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Torrance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.865818+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1793E151P9VM222568",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 222568,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1983,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087.2",
      "ID": 5234
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1793,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean",
      "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1945413+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5078E245P7VM307032",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307032,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1983,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087.2",
      "ID": 5234
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5078,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Walker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.584359+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1841E231P426VM239895",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239895,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1983,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087.2",
      "ID": 5234
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1841,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen",
      "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7639404+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283686",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283686,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1983,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087.2",
      "ID": 5234
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4952,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7189068+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1865E263P500VM231814",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231814,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1983,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087.2",
      "ID": 5234
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1865,
      "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra",
      "DisplayName": "Sandra White",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6166646+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237380",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237380,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1983,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087.2",
      "ID": 5234
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2610,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Wilson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2017027+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309176",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 309176,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1983,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087.2",
      "ID": 5234
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4941,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza",
      "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0952845+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252730",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252730,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1985,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087",
      "ID": 5217
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1926,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian",
      "DisplayName": "Brian Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7510832+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2615E213P388VM258941",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258941,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1985,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087",
      "ID": 5217
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2615,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George",
      "DisplayName": "George Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3348503+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319623",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319623,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1985,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087",
      "ID": 5217
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4940,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare",
      "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9342689+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249535",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 249535,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1985,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087",
      "ID": 5217
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2641,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair",
      "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9310544+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1783E21P273VM227848",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227848,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1985,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087",
      "ID": 5217
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1783,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie",
      "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5682641+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2633E97P136VM280848",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280848,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1985,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087",
      "ID": 5217
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2633,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire",
      "DisplayName": "Claire Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.784956+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262765",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262765,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1985,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087",
      "ID": 5217
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2603,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.615882+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1759E91P115VM229854",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229854,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1985,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087",
      "ID": 5217
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia",
      "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.1002675+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3751E243P383VM269776",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269776,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1985,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087",
      "ID": 5217
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3751,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5624604+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322600",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 322600,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1985,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087",
      "ID": 5217
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5109,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco",
      "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6956892+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5060E86P124VM295301",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295301,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1985,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087",
      "ID": 5217
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5060,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5061147+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242978",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242978,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1985,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087",
      "ID": 5217
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1866,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah",
      "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0436966+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235149",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235149,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1985,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087",
      "ID": 5217
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1943,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic",
      "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4214915+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302419",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 302419,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1985,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087",
      "ID": 5217
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2595,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin",
      "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5236053+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244238",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244238,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1985,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087",
      "ID": 5217
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2103,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith",
      "DisplayName": "Keith Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5460152+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327124",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 327124,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1985,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087",
      "ID": 5217
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.8001551+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277104",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277104,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1985,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087",
      "ID": 5217
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.7012549+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264225",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264225,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1985,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087",
      "ID": 5217
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2673,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick",
      "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.12412+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248683",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248683,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1985,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087",
      "ID": 5217
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2678,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson",
      "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6653428+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2123E27P233VM294935",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 294935,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1985,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087",
      "ID": 5217
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2123,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm",
      "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1850817+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285268",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285268,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1985,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087",
      "ID": 5217
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3907,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3156515+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230743",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230743,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1985,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087",
      "ID": 5217
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1735,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela",
      "DisplayName": "Angela Constance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3436411+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243740",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 243740,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1985,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087",
      "ID": 5217
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1932,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce",
      "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3177671+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254827",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254827,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1985,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087",
      "ID": 5217
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1863,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna",
      "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2854527+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323731",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 323731,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1985,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087",
      "ID": 5217
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4976,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth",
      "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9694791+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5107E223P379VM291241",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291241,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1985,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087",
      "ID": 5217
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5107,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1103815+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3743E222P391VM265441",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265441,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1985,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087",
      "ID": 5217
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3743,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel",
      "DisplayName": "Nigel Don",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.439318+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262342",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262342,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1985,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087",
      "ID": 5217
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3771,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob",
      "DisplayName": "Bob Doris",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.5973263+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281891",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 281891,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1985,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087",
      "ID": 5217
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2826,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Dornan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1620928+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298235",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298235,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1985,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087",
      "ID": 5217
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3812,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia",
      "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3370121+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231196",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231196,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1985,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087",
      "ID": 5217
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1778,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen",
      "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3699568+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4955E240P389VM285020",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285020,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1985,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087",
      "ID": 5217
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4955,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.057772+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219482",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 219482,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1985,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087",
      "ID": 5217
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1742,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle",
      "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3011728+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238485",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 238485,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1985,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087",
      "ID": 5217
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1994,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus",
      "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4561344+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225189",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225189,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1985,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087",
      "ID": 5217
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1814,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda",
      "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7483025+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321860",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 321860,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1985,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087",
      "ID": 5217
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Fee",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4544542+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292841",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 292841,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1985,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087",
      "ID": 5217
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia",
      "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5604027+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227206",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227206,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1985,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087",
      "ID": 5217
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.535401+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5054E95P118VM313241",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313241,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1985,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087",
      "ID": 5217
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5054,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.3839532+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4947E152P8VM257747",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257747,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1985,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087",
      "ID": 5217
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4947,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Finnie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0758853+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271152",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271152,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1985,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087",
      "ID": 5217
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3901,
      "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe",
      "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8447155+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278028",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 278028,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1985,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087",
      "ID": 5217
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2394,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo",
      "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9838986+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2110E220P414VM287314",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 287314,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1985,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087",
      "ID": 5217
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth",
      "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8588387+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250564",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250564,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1985,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087",
      "ID": 5217
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2675,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob",
      "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1950057+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221028",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221028,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1985,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087",
      "ID": 5217
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1741,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel",
      "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.671978+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220163",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220163,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1985,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087",
      "ID": 5217
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1756,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine",
      "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.337061+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1860E104P150VM252440",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252440,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1985,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087",
      "ID": 5217
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1860,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda",
      "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7292399+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2033E20P141VM253796",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253796,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1985,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087",
      "ID": 5217
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2033,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain",
      "DisplayName": "Iain Gray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0212597+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324674",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324674,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1985,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087",
      "ID": 5217
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5042,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2330842+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259630",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 259630,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1985,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087",
      "ID": 5217
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick",
      "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6177399+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239411",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239411,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1985,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087",
      "ID": 5217
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2029,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh",
      "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7356404+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273696",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 273696,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1985,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087",
      "ID": 5217
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3758,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6314622+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304066",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 304066,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1985,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087",
      "ID": 5217
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4086,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Hume",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.847983+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221667",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221667,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1985,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087",
      "ID": 5217
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1773,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9426171+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1882E227P459VM241897",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241897,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1985,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087",
      "ID": 5217
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1882,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam",
      "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7847302+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223461",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223461,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1985,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087",
      "ID": 5217
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1893,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.458988+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307818",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307818,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1985,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087",
      "ID": 5217
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4934,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8522114+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272300",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 272300,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1985,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087",
      "ID": 5217
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4956,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Keir",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3237107+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244989",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244989,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1985,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087",
      "ID": 5217
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Kelly",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5872289+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315157",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315157,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1985,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087",
      "ID": 5217
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3129,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6767801+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247857",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247857,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1985,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087",
      "ID": 5217
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann",
      "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4313923+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4016E11P36VM275088",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 275088,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1985,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087",
      "ID": 5217
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4016,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.140673+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255553",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255553,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1985,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087",
      "ID": 5217
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2180,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5362762+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4938E158P374VM277001",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277001,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1985,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087",
      "ID": 5217
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4938,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6968196+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2112E250P486VM253411",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253411,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1985,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087",
      "ID": 5217
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2112,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny",
      "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.9952754+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4939E258P394VM276747",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276747,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1985,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087",
      "ID": 5217
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4939,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus",
      "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6793876+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325457",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 325457,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1985,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087",
      "ID": 5217
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5074,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon",
      "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.507211+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1828E3P10VM233244",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 233244,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1985,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087",
      "ID": 5217
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1828,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo",
      "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.115655+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311663",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311663,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1985,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087",
      "ID": 5217
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4948,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike",
      "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8888794+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2117E90P107VM229698",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229698,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1985,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087",
      "ID": 5217
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2117,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis",
      "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0928351+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267447",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 267447,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1985,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087",
      "ID": 5217
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken",
      "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0202335+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313498",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313498,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1985,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087",
      "ID": 5217
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4966,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek",
      "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.3979666+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3101E102P129VM294992",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 294992,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1985,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087",
      "ID": 5217
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3101,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala",
      "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1875422+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319109",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319109,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1985,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087",
      "ID": 5217
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5034,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny",
      "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6928201+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306330",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306330,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1985,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087",
      "ID": 5217
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2159,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Martin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5474124+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5110E252P395VM310759",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 310759,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1985,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087",
      "ID": 5217
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Mason",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5848375+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268157",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 268157,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1985,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087",
      "ID": 5217
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2133,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0586481+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2876E141P433VM286417",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286417,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1985,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087",
      "ID": 5217
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2876,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5782461+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4951E147P368VM258571",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258571,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1985,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087",
      "ID": 5217
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4951,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan",
      "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3129911+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3896E175P307VM263795",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 263795,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1985,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087",
      "ID": 5217
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3896,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam",
      "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9050582+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308729",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 308729,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1985,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087",
      "ID": 5217
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.068444+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4964E143P375VM279755",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279755,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1985,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087",
      "ID": 5217
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4964,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5212218+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279569",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279569,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1985,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087",
      "ID": 5217
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3824,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5133314+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2066E22P91VM260998",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 260998,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1985,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087",
      "ID": 5217
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2066,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.1071201+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299583",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 299583,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1985,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087",
      "ID": 5217
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7036961+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306761",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306761,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1985,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087",
      "ID": 5217
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina",
      "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5662754+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300574",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 300574,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1985,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087",
      "ID": 5217
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2487,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0044557+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223931",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223931,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1985,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087",
      "ID": 5217
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4847447+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237881",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237881,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1985,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087",
      "ID": 5217
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1961,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David",
      "DisplayName": "David McLetchie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2300908+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305538",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 305538,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1985,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087",
      "ID": 5217
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2134,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.328641+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320317",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 320317,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1985,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087",
      "ID": 5217
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5041,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan",
      "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1548075+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315925",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315925,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1985,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087",
      "ID": 5217
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3763,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart",
      "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9381921+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1986E23P197VM236732",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 236732,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1985,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087",
      "ID": 5217
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1986,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan",
      "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9376867+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5047E100P130VM289773",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289773,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1985,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087",
      "ID": 5217
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5047,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne",
      "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4585005+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234496",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234496,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1985,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087",
      "ID": 5217
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1845,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette",
      "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.386767+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313185",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313185,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1985,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087",
      "ID": 5217
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3061,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1673297+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1768E19P265VM289278",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289278,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1985,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087",
      "ID": 5217
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1768,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4303843+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225326",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225326,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1985,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087",
      "ID": 5217
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1894,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Neil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.969743+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3815E98P134VM270971",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270971,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1985,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087",
      "ID": 5217
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3815,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Park, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Park",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8369846+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265784",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265784,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1985,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087",
      "ID": 5217
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2010,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil",
      "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4543449+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283233",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283233,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1985,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087",
      "ID": 5217
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5057,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.6916045+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2853E33P128VM252017",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252017,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1985,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087",
      "ID": 5217
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Pentland",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4989923+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317538",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317538,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1985,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087",
      "ID": 5217
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5009,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4267621+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254288",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254288,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1985,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087",
      "ID": 5217
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3745,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis",
      "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2490919+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1870E225P478VM296180",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 296180,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1985,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087",
      "ID": 5217
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1870,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona",
      "DisplayName": "Shona Robison",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5528088+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2135E254P450VM235460",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235460,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1985,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087",
      "ID": 5217
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2135,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Russell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6788148+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1895E232P431VM257672",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257672,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1985,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087",
      "ID": 5217
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1895,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0666027+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228525",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 228525,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1985,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087",
      "ID": 5217
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1839,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.8028442+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2345E10P55VM291580",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291580,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1985,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087",
      "ID": 5217
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2345,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1334868+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311126",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311126,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1985,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087",
      "ID": 5217
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2223,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish",
      "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.6065277+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246440",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 246440,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1985,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087",
      "ID": 5217
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2182,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.128813+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298068",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298068,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1985,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087",
      "ID": 5217
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5079,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew",
      "DisplayName": "Drew Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1368864+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234098",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234098,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1985,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087",
      "ID": 5217
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1769,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1665479+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274671",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274671,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1985,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087",
      "ID": 5217
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4014,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz",
      "DisplayName": "Liz Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1166921+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269613",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269613,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1985,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087",
      "ID": 5217
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2215,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5554149+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317468",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317468,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1985,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087",
      "ID": 5217
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3806,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.423496+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326373",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 326373,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1985,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087",
      "ID": 5217
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5106,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin",
      "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7556913+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241231",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241231,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1985,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087",
      "ID": 5217
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1848,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola",
      "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7486574+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2098E237P531VM290348",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 290348,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1985,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087",
      "ID": 5217
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2098,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Swinney",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7430057+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248026",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248026,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1985,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087",
      "ID": 5217
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2674,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave",
      "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4385752+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5075E234P371VM287478",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 287478,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1985,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087",
      "ID": 5217
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5075,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Torrance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8658985+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1793E151P9VM222570",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 222570,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1985,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087",
      "ID": 5217
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1793,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean",
      "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1946228+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5078E245P7VM306952",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306952,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1985,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087",
      "ID": 5217
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5078,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Walker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5809489+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1841E231P426VM239893",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239893,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1985,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087",
      "ID": 5217
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1841,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen",
      "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7638588+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283738",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283738,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1985,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087",
      "ID": 5217
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4952,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7211281+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1865E263P500VM231812",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231812,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1985,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087",
      "ID": 5217
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1865,
      "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra",
      "DisplayName": "Sandra White",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6165803+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237378",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237378,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1985,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087",
      "ID": 5217
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2610,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Wilson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2016206+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309174",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 309174,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1985,
      "AgendaID": 3032,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 41,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Policing in Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-05087",
      "ID": 5217
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4941,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza",
      "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-12-05T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0952026+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252631",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252631,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1982,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.2",
      "ID": 5173
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1926,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian",
      "DisplayName": "Brian Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7377843+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2615E213P388VM258854",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258854,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1982,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.2",
      "ID": 5173
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2615,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George",
      "DisplayName": "George Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3307509+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319876",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319876,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1982,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.2",
      "ID": 5173
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4940,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare",
      "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9451985+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249650",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 249650,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1982,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.2",
      "ID": 5173
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2641,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair",
      "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9439597+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1783E21P273VM227736",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227736,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1982,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.2",
      "ID": 5173
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1783,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie",
      "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5634301+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2633E97P136VM280737",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280737,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1982,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.2",
      "ID": 5173
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2633,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire",
      "DisplayName": "Claire Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7802863+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262509",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262509,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1982,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.2",
      "ID": 5173
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2603,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6049972+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1759E91P115VM229759",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229759,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1982,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.2",
      "ID": 5173
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia",
      "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0954693+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270173",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270173,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1982,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.2",
      "ID": 5173
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3751,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5846828+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322726",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 322726,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1982,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.2",
      "ID": 5173
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5109,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco",
      "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.7010146+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5060E86P124VM294741",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 294741,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1982,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.2",
      "ID": 5173
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5060,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1763285+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242878",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242878,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1982,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.2",
      "ID": 5173
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1866,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah",
      "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0394709+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235546",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235546,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1982,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.2",
      "ID": 5173
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1943,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic",
      "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6824606+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302168",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 302168,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1982,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.2",
      "ID": 5173
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2595,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin",
      "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.3003385+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244491",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244491,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1982,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.2",
      "ID": 5173
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2103,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith",
      "DisplayName": "Keith Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5570744+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327204",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 327204,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1982,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.2",
      "ID": 5173
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:46.0255295+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3775E216P435VM276692",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276692,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1982,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.2",
      "ID": 5173
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6770568+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264325",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264325,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1982,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.2",
      "ID": 5173
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2673,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick",
      "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1286412+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248770",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248770,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1982,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.2",
      "ID": 5173
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2678,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson",
      "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6691445+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2123E27P233VM295806",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295806,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1982,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.2",
      "ID": 5173
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2123,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm",
      "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5366662+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285170",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285170,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1982,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.2",
      "ID": 5173
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3907,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.069444+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230648",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230648,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1982,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.2",
      "ID": 5173
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1735,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela",
      "DisplayName": "Angela Constance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3392234+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243841",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 243841,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1982,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.2",
      "ID": 5173
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1932,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce",
      "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3222259+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254921",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254921,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1982,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.2",
      "ID": 5173
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1863,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna",
      "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2895237+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323811",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 323811,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1982,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.2",
      "ID": 5173
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4976,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth",
      "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9729327+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5107E223P379VM291328",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291328,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1982,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.2",
      "ID": 5173
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5107,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1142171+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3743E222P391VM265341",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265341,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1982,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.2",
      "ID": 5173
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3743,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel",
      "DisplayName": "Nigel Don",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4349975+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262254",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262254,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1982,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.2",
      "ID": 5173
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3771,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob",
      "DisplayName": "Bob Doris",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.5935804+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2826E262P384VM282004",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 282004,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1982,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.2",
      "ID": 5173
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2826,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Dornan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1670667+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3812E94P117VM297996",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 297996,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1982,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.2",
      "ID": 5173
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3812,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia",
      "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1338146+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231585",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231585,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1982,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.2",
      "ID": 5173
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1778,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen",
      "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6069471+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4955E240P389VM285934",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285934,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1982,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.2",
      "ID": 5173
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4955,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3508446+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219391",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 219391,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1982,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.2",
      "ID": 5173
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1742,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle",
      "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.2966414+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238573",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 238573,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1982,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.2",
      "ID": 5173
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1994,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus",
      "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4599569+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225456",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225456,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1982,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.2",
      "ID": 5173
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1814,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda",
      "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9755096+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321733",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 321733,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1982,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.2",
      "ID": 5173
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Fee",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4490685+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292892",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 292892,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1982,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.2",
      "ID": 5173
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia",
      "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5627111+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227117",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227117,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1982,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.2",
      "ID": 5173
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2685477+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5054E95P118VM312684",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 312684,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1982,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.2",
      "ID": 5173
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5054,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1388936+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4947E152P8VM257169",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257169,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1982,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.2",
      "ID": 5173
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4947,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Finnie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.826271+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271289",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271289,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1982,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.2",
      "ID": 5173
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3901,
      "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe",
      "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0638561+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278448",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 278448,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1982,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.2",
      "ID": 5173
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2394,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo",
      "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2192528+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2110E220P414VM286756",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286756,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1982,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.2",
      "ID": 5173
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth",
      "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5993445+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250447",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250447,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1982,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.2",
      "ID": 5173
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2675,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob",
      "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1899307+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1741E10P50VM220759",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220759,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1982,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.2",
      "ID": 5173
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1741,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel",
      "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6558169+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220252",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220252,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1982,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.2",
      "ID": 5173
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1756,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine",
      "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6304045+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1860E104P150VM252344",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252344,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1982,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.2",
      "ID": 5173
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1860,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda",
      "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7251294+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2033E20P141VM266135",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 266135,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1982,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.2",
      "ID": 5173
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2033,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain",
      "DisplayName": "Iain Gray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4758307+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324594",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324594,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1982,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.2",
      "ID": 5173
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5042,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2296819+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259717",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 259717,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1982,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.2",
      "ID": 5173
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick",
      "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6215012+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239324",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239324,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1982,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.2",
      "ID": 5173
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2029,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh",
      "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7319042+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273796",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 273796,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1982,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.2",
      "ID": 5173
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3758,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6360167+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304161",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 304161,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1982,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.2",
      "ID": 5173
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4086,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Hume",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8523459+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221780",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221780,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1982,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.2",
      "ID": 5173
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1773,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9474918+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1882E227P459VM242013",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242013,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1982,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.2",
      "ID": 5173
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1882,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam",
      "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7900639+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223705",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223705,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1982,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.2",
      "ID": 5173
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1893,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4702396+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307580",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307580,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1982,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.2",
      "ID": 5173
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4934,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8356459+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272186",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 272186,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1982,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.2",
      "ID": 5173
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4956,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Keir",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.115273+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244886",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244886,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1982,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.2",
      "ID": 5173
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Kelly",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5828314+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315056",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315056,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1982,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.2",
      "ID": 5173
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3129,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6721836+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247944",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247944,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1982,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.2",
      "ID": 5173
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann",
      "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4350667+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4016E11P36VM274796",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274796,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1982,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.2",
      "ID": 5173
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4016,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1221287+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255794",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255794,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1982,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.2",
      "ID": 5173
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2180,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5572449+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4938E158P374VM277449",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277449,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1982,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.2",
      "ID": 5173
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4938,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9538367+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2112E250P486VM253018",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253018,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1982,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.2",
      "ID": 5173
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2112,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny",
      "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7633075+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4939E258P394VM276837",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276837,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1982,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.2",
      "ID": 5173
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4939,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus",
      "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6832034+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325537",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 325537,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1982,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.2",
      "ID": 5173
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5074,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon",
      "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5106329+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1828E3P10VM232849",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232849,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1982,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.2",
      "ID": 5173
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1828,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo",
      "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8792391+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311426",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311426,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1982,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.2",
      "ID": 5173
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4948,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike",
      "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8782789+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2117E90P107VM230405",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230405,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1982,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.2",
      "ID": 5173
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2117,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis",
      "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3283844+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267336",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 267336,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1982,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.2",
      "ID": 5173
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken",
      "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0150401+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313735",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313735,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1982,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.2",
      "ID": 5173
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4966,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek",
      "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4084099+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3101E102P129VM295078",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295078,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1982,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.2",
      "ID": 5173
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3101,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala",
      "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.191255+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5034E88P114VM318982",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 318982,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1982,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.2",
      "ID": 5173
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5034,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny",
      "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6873579+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306430",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306430,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1982,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.2",
      "ID": 5173
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2159,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Martin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5517354+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5110E252P395VM311200",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311200,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1982,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.2",
      "ID": 5173
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Mason",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.6099957+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268267",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 268267,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1982,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.2",
      "ID": 5173
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2133,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2596914+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2876E141P433VM286304",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286304,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1982,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.2",
      "ID": 5173
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2876,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5730362+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4951E147P368VM260698",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 260698,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1982,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.2",
      "ID": 5173
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4951,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan",
      "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.0884051+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3896E175P307VM263885",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 263885,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1982,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.2",
      "ID": 5173
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3896,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam",
      "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9149685+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308439",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 308439,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1982,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.2",
      "ID": 5173
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0559681+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4964E143P375VM279670",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279670,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1982,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.2",
      "ID": 5173
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4964,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5175902+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279978",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279978,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1982,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.2",
      "ID": 5173
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3824,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5310275+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2066E22P91VM261101",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261101,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1982,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.2",
      "ID": 5173
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2066,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.1118614+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299667",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 299667,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1982,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.2",
      "ID": 5173
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7075776+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306625",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306625,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1982,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.2",
      "ID": 5173
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina",
      "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5601336+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2487E146P369VM301170",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 301170,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1982,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.2",
      "ID": 5173
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2487,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0369783+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223664",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223664,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1982,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.2",
      "ID": 5173
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4685035+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237496",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237496,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1982,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.2",
      "ID": 5173
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1961,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David",
      "DisplayName": "David McLetchie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2131196+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305437",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 305437,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1982,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.2",
      "ID": 5173
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2134,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3239846+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320444",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 320444,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1982,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.2",
      "ID": 5173
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5041,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan",
      "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1666666+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3763E142P397VM316026",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 316026,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1982,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.2",
      "ID": 5173
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3763,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart",
      "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9426532+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1986E23P197VM236632",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 236632,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1982,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.2",
      "ID": 5173
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1986,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan",
      "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9333846+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5047E100P130VM291411",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291411,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1982,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.2",
      "ID": 5173
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5047,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne",
      "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.118145+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234592",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234592,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1982,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.2",
      "ID": 5173
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1845,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette",
      "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3909462+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313596",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313596,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1982,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.2",
      "ID": 5173
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3061,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.402205+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1768E19P265VM288610",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 288610,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1982,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.2",
      "ID": 5173
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1768,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1508316+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225080",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225080,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1982,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.2",
      "ID": 5173
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1894,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Neil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7436291+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3815E98P134VM270912",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270912,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1982,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.2",
      "ID": 5173
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3815,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Park, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Park",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8288018+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265878",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265878,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1982,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.2",
      "ID": 5173
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2010,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil",
      "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.464466+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283319",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283319,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1982,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.2",
      "ID": 5173
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5057,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.6955753+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2853E33P128VM251469",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251469,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1982,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.2",
      "ID": 5173
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Pentland",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4649997+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317665",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317665,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1982,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.2",
      "ID": 5173
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5009,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4321719+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254716",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254716,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1982,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.2",
      "ID": 5173
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3745,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis",
      "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2806603+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1870E225P478VM295668",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295668,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1982,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.2",
      "ID": 5173
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1870,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona",
      "DisplayName": "Shona Robison",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.530737+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2135E254P450VM234912",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234912,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1982,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.2",
      "ID": 5173
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2135,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Russell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4051101+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1895E232P431VM257577",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257577,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1982,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.2",
      "ID": 5173
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1895,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0625161+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228103",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 228103,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1982,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.2",
      "ID": 5173
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1839,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5844865+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2345E10P55VM291675",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291675,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1982,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.2",
      "ID": 5173
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2345,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1374831+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311025",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311025,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1982,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.2",
      "ID": 5173
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2223,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish",
      "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.602198+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246324",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 246324,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1982,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.2",
      "ID": 5173
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2182,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1238053+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298164",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298164,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1982,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.2",
      "ID": 5173
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5079,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew",
      "DisplayName": "Drew Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1409717+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234349",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234349,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1982,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.2",
      "ID": 5173
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1769,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3734539+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274580",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274580,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1982,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.2",
      "ID": 5173
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4014,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz",
      "DisplayName": "Liz Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1127495+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269503",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269503,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1982,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.2",
      "ID": 5173
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2215,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.550444+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317367",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317367,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1982,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.2",
      "ID": 5173
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3806,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4190687+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326293",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 326293,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1982,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.2",
      "ID": 5173
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5106,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin",
      "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7522084+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241115",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241115,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1982,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.2",
      "ID": 5173
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1848,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola",
      "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.4026213+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2098E237P531VM289630",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289630,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1982,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.2",
      "ID": 5173
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2098,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Swinney",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4522781+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2674E247P401VM247786",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247786,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1982,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.2",
      "ID": 5173
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2674,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave",
      "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4283955+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5075E234P371VM287391",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 287391,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1982,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.2",
      "ID": 5173
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5075,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Torrance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.862203+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1793E151P9VM222481",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 222481,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1982,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.2",
      "ID": 5173
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1793,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean",
      "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1908169+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5078E245P7VM307074",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307074,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1982,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.2",
      "ID": 5173
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5078,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Walker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5861543+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1841E231P426VM240163",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 240163,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1982,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.2",
      "ID": 5173
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1841,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen",
      "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7816556+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283447",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283447,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1982,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.2",
      "ID": 5173
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4952,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7082846+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1865E263P500VM232228",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232228,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1982,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.2",
      "ID": 5173
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1865,
      "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra",
      "DisplayName": "Sandra White",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8456646+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237767",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237767,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1982,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.2",
      "ID": 5173
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2610,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Wilson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.225249+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309258",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 309258,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1982,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.2",
      "ID": 5173
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4941,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza",
      "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3215776+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252310",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252310,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1981,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.1",
      "ID": 5168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1926,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian",
      "DisplayName": "Brian Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7236294+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2615E213P388VM258818",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258818,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1981,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.1",
      "ID": 5168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2615,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George",
      "DisplayName": "George Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3292289+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319877",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319877,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1981,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.1",
      "ID": 5168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4940,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare",
      "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.945239+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249651",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 249651,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1981,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.1",
      "ID": 5168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2641,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair",
      "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9439996+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1783E21P273VM227723",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227723,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1981,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.1",
      "ID": 5168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1783,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie",
      "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5628831+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2633E97P136VM280412",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280412,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1981,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.1",
      "ID": 5168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2633,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire",
      "DisplayName": "Claire Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7658698+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262508",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262508,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1981,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.1",
      "ID": 5168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2603,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6049571+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1759E91P115VM229758",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229758,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1981,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.1",
      "ID": 5168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia",
      "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0954291+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270209",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270209,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1981,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.1",
      "ID": 5168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3751,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.7940091+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322688",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 322688,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1981,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.1",
      "ID": 5168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5109,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco",
      "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6994133+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5060E86P124VM294740",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 294740,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1981,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.1",
      "ID": 5168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5060,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1762882+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242877",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242877,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1981,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.1",
      "ID": 5168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1866,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah",
      "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0394302+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235581",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235581,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1981,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.1",
      "ID": 5168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1943,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic",
      "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.683963+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302167",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 302167,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1981,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.1",
      "ID": 5168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2595,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin",
      "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.3002891+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244492",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244492,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1981,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.1",
      "ID": 5168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2103,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith",
      "DisplayName": "Keith Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5571174+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327203",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 327203,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1981,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.1",
      "ID": 5168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:46.0254719+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3775E216P435VM276691",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276691,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1981,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.1",
      "ID": 5168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6770154+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264326",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264326,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1981,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.1",
      "ID": 5168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2673,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick",
      "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.128682+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248772",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248772,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1981,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.1",
      "ID": 5168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2678,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson",
      "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6693865+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2123E27P233VM295807",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295807,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1981,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.1",
      "ID": 5168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2123,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm",
      "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5367061+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285169",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285169,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1981,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.1",
      "ID": 5168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3907,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0694027+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230647",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230647,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1981,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.1",
      "ID": 5168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1735,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela",
      "DisplayName": "Angela Constance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3391834+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243842",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 243842,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1981,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.1",
      "ID": 5168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1932,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce",
      "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3222661+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254922",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254922,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1981,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.1",
      "ID": 5168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1863,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna",
      "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2895649+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323810",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 323810,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1981,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.1",
      "ID": 5168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4976,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth",
      "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.972892+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5107E223P379VM291329",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291329,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1981,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.1",
      "ID": 5168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5107,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1142582+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3743E222P391VM265340",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265340,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1981,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.1",
      "ID": 5168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3743,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel",
      "DisplayName": "Nigel Don",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4349565+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262252",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262252,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1981,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.1",
      "ID": 5168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3771,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob",
      "DisplayName": "Bob Doris",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.5934802+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2826E262P384VM282019",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 282019,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1981,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.1",
      "ID": 5168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2826,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Dornan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1677023+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3812E94P117VM297954",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 297954,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1981,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.1",
      "ID": 5168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3812,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia",
      "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1320639+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231586",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231586,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1981,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.1",
      "ID": 5168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1778,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen",
      "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6069871+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4955E240P389VM285935",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285935,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1981,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.1",
      "ID": 5168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4955,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.350886+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219365",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 219365,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1981,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.1",
      "ID": 5168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1742,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle",
      "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.2954619+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238608",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 238608,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1981,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.1",
      "ID": 5168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1994,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus",
      "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4614401+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225457",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225457,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1981,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.1",
      "ID": 5168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1814,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda",
      "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.97555+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321772",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 321772,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1981,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.1",
      "ID": 5168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Fee",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4507282+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292893",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 292893,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1981,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.1",
      "ID": 5168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia",
      "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5627515+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1892E12P64VM226933",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 226933,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1981,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.1",
      "ID": 5168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2532324+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5054E95P118VM312683",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 312683,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1981,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.1",
      "ID": 5168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5054,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1388531+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4947E152P8VM257168",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257168,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1981,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.1",
      "ID": 5168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4947,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Finnie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.8262301+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271290",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271290,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1981,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.1",
      "ID": 5168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3901,
      "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe",
      "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0639168+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278463",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 278463,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1981,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.1",
      "ID": 5168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2394,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo",
      "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2198968+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2110E220P414VM286755",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286755,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1981,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.1",
      "ID": 5168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth",
      "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5993051+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250446",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250446,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1981,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.1",
      "ID": 5168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2675,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob",
      "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1898897+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1741E10P50VM220758",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220758,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1981,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.1",
      "ID": 5168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1741,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel",
      "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6557589+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220280",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220280,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1981,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.1",
      "ID": 5168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1756,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine",
      "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.631634+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1860E104P150VM252343",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252343,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1981,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.1",
      "ID": 5168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1860,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda",
      "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.725089+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2033E20P141VM266148",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 266148,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1981,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.1",
      "ID": 5168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2033,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain",
      "DisplayName": "Iain Gray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4763987+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324595",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324595,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1981,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.1",
      "ID": 5168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5042,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2297221+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259719",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 259719,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1981,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.1",
      "ID": 5168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick",
      "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6215831+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239289",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239289,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1981,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.1",
      "ID": 5168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2029,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh",
      "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7303924+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273797",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 273797,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1981,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.1",
      "ID": 5168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3758,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6360576+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304162",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 304162,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1981,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.1",
      "ID": 5168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4086,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Hume",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.852397+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221781",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221781,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1981,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.1",
      "ID": 5168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1773,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9475318+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1882E227P459VM242014",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242014,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1981,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.1",
      "ID": 5168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1882,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam",
      "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7901042+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223739",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223739,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1981,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.1",
      "ID": 5168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1893,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4716979+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307538",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307538,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1981,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.1",
      "ID": 5168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4934,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8338415+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272185",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 272185,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1981,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.1",
      "ID": 5168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4956,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Keir",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.1152316+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244885",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244885,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1981,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.1",
      "ID": 5168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Kelly",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5827915+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315055",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315055,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1981,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.1",
      "ID": 5168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3129,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6721434+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247979",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247979,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1981,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.1",
      "ID": 5168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann",
      "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4365472+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4016E11P36VM274795",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274795,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1981,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.1",
      "ID": 5168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4016,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.122088+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255829",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255829,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1981,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.1",
      "ID": 5168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2180,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5588378+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4938E158P374VM277450",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277450,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1981,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.1",
      "ID": 5168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4938,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.953877+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2112E250P486VM252983",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252983,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1981,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.1",
      "ID": 5168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2112,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny",
      "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7616641+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4939E258P394VM276838",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276838,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1981,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.1",
      "ID": 5168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4939,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus",
      "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6832743+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325536",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 325536,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1981,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.1",
      "ID": 5168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5074,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon",
      "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5105914+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1828E3P10VM232848",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232848,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1981,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.1",
      "ID": 5168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1828,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo",
      "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.879198+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311385",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311385,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1981,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.1",
      "ID": 5168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4948,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike",
      "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8764491+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2117E90P107VM230434",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230434,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1981,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.1",
      "ID": 5168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2117,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis",
      "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.329654+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267323",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 267323,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1981,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.1",
      "ID": 5168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken",
      "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0144792+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313776",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313776,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1981,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.1",
      "ID": 5168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4966,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek",
      "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4101746+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3101E102P129VM295428",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295428,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1981,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.1",
      "ID": 5168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3101,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala",
      "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5117401+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319022",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319022,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1981,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.1",
      "ID": 5168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5034,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny",
      "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6890791+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306431",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306431,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1981,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.1",
      "ID": 5168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2159,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Martin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5517759+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5110E252P395VM311201",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311201,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1981,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.1",
      "ID": 5168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Mason",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.6100552+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268281",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 268281,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1981,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.1",
      "ID": 5168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2133,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.260338+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2876E141P433VM286133",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286133,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1981,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.1",
      "ID": 5168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2876,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3651968+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4951E147P368VM260699",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 260699,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1981,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.1",
      "ID": 5168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4951,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan",
      "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.0884526+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3896E175P307VM263887",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 263887,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1981,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.1",
      "ID": 5168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3896,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam",
      "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9150749+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308438",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 308438,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1981,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.1",
      "ID": 5168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0559277+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4964E143P375VM279669",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279669,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1981,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.1",
      "ID": 5168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4964,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5175501+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279979",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279979,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1981,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.1",
      "ID": 5168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3824,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5310677+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2066E22P91VM261102",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261102,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1981,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.1",
      "ID": 5168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2066,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.1119047+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299709",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 299709,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1981,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.1",
      "ID": 5168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7192397+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306624",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306624,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1981,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.1",
      "ID": 5168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina",
      "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5600928+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2487E146P369VM301171",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 301171,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1981,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.1",
      "ID": 5168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2487,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.037027+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223663",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223663,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1981,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.1",
      "ID": 5168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4684633+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237461",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237461,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1981,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.1",
      "ID": 5168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1961,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David",
      "DisplayName": "David McLetchie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2115748+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305436",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 305436,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1981,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.1",
      "ID": 5168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2134,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.323944+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320404",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 320404,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1981,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.1",
      "ID": 5168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5041,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan",
      "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1649648+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3763E142P397VM316027",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 316027,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1981,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.1",
      "ID": 5168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3763,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart",
      "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9426937+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1986E23P197VM236631",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 236631,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1981,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.1",
      "ID": 5168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1986,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan",
      "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9333416+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5047E100P130VM291412",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291412,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1981,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.1",
      "ID": 5168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5047,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne",
      "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1181862+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234593",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234593,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1981,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.1",
      "ID": 5168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1845,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette",
      "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.390988+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313597",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313597,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1981,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.1",
      "ID": 5168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3061,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4022461+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1768E19P265VM288609",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 288609,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1981,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.1",
      "ID": 5168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1768,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1507906+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225046",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225046,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1981,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.1",
      "ID": 5168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1894,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Neil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7421978+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3815E98P134VM270884",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270884,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1981,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.1",
      "ID": 5168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3815,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Park, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Park",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8272664+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265879",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265879,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1981,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.1",
      "ID": 5168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2010,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil",
      "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.464508+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283320",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283320,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1981,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.1",
      "ID": 5168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5057,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.6956165+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2853E33P128VM251467",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251467,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1981,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.1",
      "ID": 5168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Pentland",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.464917+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317624",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317624,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1981,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.1",
      "ID": 5168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5009,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4304287+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254717",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254717,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1981,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.1",
      "ID": 5168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3745,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis",
      "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2807007+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1870E225P478VM295667",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295667,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1981,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.1",
      "ID": 5168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1870,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona",
      "DisplayName": "Shona Robison",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5306972+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2135E254P450VM234883",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234883,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1981,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.1",
      "ID": 5168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2135,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Russell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4038523+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1895E232P431VM257576",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257576,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1981,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.1",
      "ID": 5168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1895,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0624756+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228102",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 228102,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1981,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.1",
      "ID": 5168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1839,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5844463+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2345E10P55VM291676",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291676,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1981,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.1",
      "ID": 5168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2345,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1375236+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311024",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311024,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1981,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.1",
      "ID": 5168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2223,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish",
      "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.6021578+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246323",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 246323,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1981,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.1",
      "ID": 5168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2182,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1237628+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298165",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298165,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1981,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.1",
      "ID": 5168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5079,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew",
      "DisplayName": "Drew Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.141012+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234350",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234350,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1981,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.1",
      "ID": 5168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1769,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3734959+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274579",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274579,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1981,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.1",
      "ID": 5168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4014,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz",
      "DisplayName": "Liz Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1127082+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269179",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269179,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1981,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.1",
      "ID": 5168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2215,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.3071091+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317366",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317366,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1981,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.1",
      "ID": 5168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3806,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4190285+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326294",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 326294,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1981,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.1",
      "ID": 5168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5106,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin",
      "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.752249+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241114",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241114,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1981,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.1",
      "ID": 5168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1848,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola",
      "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.4025791+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2098E237P531VM289629",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289629,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1981,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.1",
      "ID": 5168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2098,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Swinney",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4522376+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2674E247P401VM247757",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247757,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1981,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.1",
      "ID": 5168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2674,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave",
      "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4271099+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5075E234P371VM287390",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 287390,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1981,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.1",
      "ID": 5168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5075,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Torrance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8621624+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1793E151P9VM222447",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 222447,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1981,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.1",
      "ID": 5168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1793,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean",
      "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1893566+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5078E245P7VM307075",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307075,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1981,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.1",
      "ID": 5168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5078,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Walker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5861952+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1841E231P426VM240164",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 240164,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1981,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.1",
      "ID": 5168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1841,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen",
      "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7817051+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283446",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283446,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1981,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.1",
      "ID": 5168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4952,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7082416+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1865E263P500VM232241",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232241,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1981,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.1",
      "ID": 5168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1865,
      "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra",
      "DisplayName": "Sandra White",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8462292+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237796",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237796,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1981,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.1",
      "ID": 5168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2610,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Wilson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2264581+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309300",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 309300,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1981,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019.1",
      "ID": 5168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4941,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza",
      "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3233789+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252651",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252651,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1980,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019",
      "ID": 5146
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1926,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian",
      "DisplayName": "Brian Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7386438+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2615E213P388VM258855",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258855,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1980,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019",
      "ID": 5146
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2615,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George",
      "DisplayName": "George Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3307907+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319875",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319875,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1980,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019",
      "ID": 5146
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4940,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare",
      "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9451578+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249649",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 249649,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1980,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019",
      "ID": 5146
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2641,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair",
      "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9439185+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1783E21P273VM227756",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227756,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1980,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019",
      "ID": 5146
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1783,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie",
      "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.564278+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2633E97P136VM280762",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280762,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1980,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019",
      "ID": 5146
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2633,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire",
      "DisplayName": "Claire Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7813271+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262510",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262510,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1980,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019",
      "ID": 5146
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2603,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6050371+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1759E91P115VM229760",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229760,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1980,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019",
      "ID": 5146
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia",
      "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0955096+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270172",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270172,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1980,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019",
      "ID": 5146
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3751,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.584642+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322723",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 322723,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1980,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019",
      "ID": 5146
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5109,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco",
      "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.700894+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5060E86P124VM294742",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 294742,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1980,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019",
      "ID": 5146
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5060,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1763692+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242879",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242879,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1980,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019",
      "ID": 5146
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1866,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah",
      "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0395106+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235545",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235545,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1980,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019",
      "ID": 5146
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1943,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic",
      "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6824201+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302169",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 302169,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1980,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019",
      "ID": 5146
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2595,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin",
      "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.3003888+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244490",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244490,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1980,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019",
      "ID": 5146
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2103,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith",
      "DisplayName": "Keith Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5570147+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327200",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 327200,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1980,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019",
      "ID": 5146
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.803495+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3775E216P435VM276693",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276693,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1980,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019",
      "ID": 5146
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6770972+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264324",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264324,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1980,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019",
      "ID": 5146
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2673,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick",
      "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1286009+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248769",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248769,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1980,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019",
      "ID": 5146
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2678,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson",
      "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.669104+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2123E27P233VM295805",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295805,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1980,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019",
      "ID": 5146
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2123,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm",
      "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5366259+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285171",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285171,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1980,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019",
      "ID": 5146
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3907,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0694843+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230649",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230649,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1980,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019",
      "ID": 5146
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1735,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela",
      "DisplayName": "Angela Constance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3392636+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243840",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 243840,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1980,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019",
      "ID": 5146
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1932,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce",
      "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3221826+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254920",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254920,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1980,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019",
      "ID": 5146
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1863,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna",
      "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2894819+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323807",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 323807,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1980,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019",
      "ID": 5146
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4976,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth",
      "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9727674+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5107E223P379VM291327",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291327,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1980,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019",
      "ID": 5146
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5107,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1141758+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3743E222P391VM265342",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265342,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1980,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019",
      "ID": 5146
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3743,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel",
      "DisplayName": "Nigel Don",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4350382+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262255",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262255,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1980,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019",
      "ID": 5146
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3771,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob",
      "DisplayName": "Bob Doris",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.5936224+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281979",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 281979,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1980,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019",
      "ID": 5146
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2826,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Dornan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1659846+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3812E94P117VM297993",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 297993,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1980,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019",
      "ID": 5146
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3812,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia",
      "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1336947+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231584",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231584,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1980,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019",
      "ID": 5146
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1778,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen",
      "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6069062+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4955E240P389VM285932",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285932,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1980,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019",
      "ID": 5146
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4955,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3507618+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219392",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 219392,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1980,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019",
      "ID": 5146
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1742,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle",
      "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.2966821+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238572",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 238572,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1980,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019",
      "ID": 5146
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1994,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus",
      "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4598981+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225455",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225455,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1980,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019",
      "ID": 5146
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1814,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda",
      "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9754691+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321736",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 321736,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1980,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019",
      "ID": 5146
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Fee",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4492098+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292891",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 292891,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1980,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019",
      "ID": 5146
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia",
      "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5626702+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227118",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227118,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1980,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019",
      "ID": 5146
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2685891+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5054E95P118VM312685",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 312685,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1980,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019",
      "ID": 5146
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5054,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1389335+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4947E152P8VM257170",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257170,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1980,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019",
      "ID": 5146
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4947,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Finnie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.8263114+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271287",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271287,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1980,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019",
      "ID": 5146
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3901,
      "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe",
      "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0637725+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278424",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 278424,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1980,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019",
      "ID": 5146
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2394,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo",
      "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2182123+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2110E220P414VM286757",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286757,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1980,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019",
      "ID": 5146
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth",
      "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5993841+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250448",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250448,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1980,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019",
      "ID": 5146
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2675,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob",
      "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1899723+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1741E10P50VM220760",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220760,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1980,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019",
      "ID": 5146
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1741,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel",
      "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6558584+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220251",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220251,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1980,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019",
      "ID": 5146
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1756,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine",
      "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6303634+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1860E104P150VM252345",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252345,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1980,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019",
      "ID": 5146
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1860,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda",
      "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7251704+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2033E20P141VM266111",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 266111,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1980,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019",
      "ID": 5146
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2033,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain",
      "DisplayName": "Iain Gray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4748078+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324598",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324598,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1980,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019",
      "ID": 5146
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5042,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2298639+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259716",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 259716,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1980,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019",
      "ID": 5146
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick",
      "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.621459+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239325",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239325,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1980,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019",
      "ID": 5146
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2029,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh",
      "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7319451+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273795",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 273795,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1980,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019",
      "ID": 5146
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3758,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6359759+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304160",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 304160,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1980,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019",
      "ID": 5146
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4086,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Hume",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8522933+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221779",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221779,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1980,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019",
      "ID": 5146
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1773,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9474518+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1882E227P459VM242012",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242012,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1980,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019",
      "ID": 5146
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1882,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam",
      "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7900231+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223704",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223704,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1980,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019",
      "ID": 5146
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1893,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4701996+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307577",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307577,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1980,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019",
      "ID": 5146
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4934,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8355227+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272187",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 272187,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1980,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019",
      "ID": 5146
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4956,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Keir",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.1153134+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244887",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244887,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1980,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019",
      "ID": 5146
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Kelly",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5828717+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315057",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315057,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1980,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019",
      "ID": 5146
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3129,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6722248+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247943",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247943,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1980,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019",
      "ID": 5146
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann",
      "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4350263+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4016E11P36VM274798",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274798,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1980,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019",
      "ID": 5146
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4016,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1222098+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255793",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255793,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1980,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019",
      "ID": 5146
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2180,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5572046+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4938E158P374VM277447",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277447,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1980,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019",
      "ID": 5146
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4938,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9537556+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2112E250P486VM253019",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253019,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1980,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019",
      "ID": 5146
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2112,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny",
      "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7633488+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4939E258P394VM276836",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276836,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1980,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019",
      "ID": 5146
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4939,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus",
      "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6831627+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325533",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 325533,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1980,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019",
      "ID": 5146
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5074,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon",
      "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5104477+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1828E3P10VM232850",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232850,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1980,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019",
      "ID": 5146
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1828,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo",
      "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8793021+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311423",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311423,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1980,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019",
      "ID": 5146
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4948,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike",
      "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8781543+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2117E90P107VM230404",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230404,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1980,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019",
      "ID": 5146
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2117,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis",
      "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3283429+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267360",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 267360,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1980,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019",
      "ID": 5146
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken",
      "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0160932+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313738",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313738,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1980,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019",
      "ID": 5146
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4966,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek",
      "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4085533+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3101E102P129VM295081",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295081,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1980,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019",
      "ID": 5146
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3101,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala",
      "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1913788+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5034E88P114VM318985",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 318985,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1980,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019",
      "ID": 5146
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5034,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny",
      "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6874811+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306429",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306429,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1980,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019",
      "ID": 5146
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2159,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Martin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5516955+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5110E252P395VM311199",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311199,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1980,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019",
      "ID": 5146
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Mason",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.6099555+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268243",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 268243,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1980,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019",
      "ID": 5146
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2133,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2550301+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2876E141P433VM286329",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286329,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1980,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019",
      "ID": 5146
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2876,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5741206+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4951E147P368VM260697",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 260697,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1980,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019",
      "ID": 5146
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4951,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan",
      "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.0883643+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3896E175P307VM263884",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 263884,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1980,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019",
      "ID": 5146
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3896,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam",
      "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9149087+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308440",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 308440,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1980,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019",
      "ID": 5146
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0560081+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4964E143P375VM279671",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279671,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1980,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019",
      "ID": 5146
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4964,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5176303+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279977",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279977,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1980,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019",
      "ID": 5146
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3824,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5309861+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2066E22P91VM261100",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261100,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1980,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019",
      "ID": 5146
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2066,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.1118014+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299670",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 299670,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1980,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019",
      "ID": 5146
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7077003+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306626",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306626,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1980,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019",
      "ID": 5146
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina",
      "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.560174+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2487E146P369VM301169",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 301169,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1980,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019",
      "ID": 5146
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2487,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0369287+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223665",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223665,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1980,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019",
      "ID": 5146
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4685618+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237497",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237497,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1980,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019",
      "ID": 5146
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1961,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David",
      "DisplayName": "David McLetchie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2131603+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305438",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 305438,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1980,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019",
      "ID": 5146
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2134,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3240324+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320441",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 320441,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1980,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019",
      "ID": 5146
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5041,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan",
      "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1665448+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3763E142P397VM316025",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 316025,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1980,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019",
      "ID": 5146
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3763,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart",
      "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9426118+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1986E23P197VM236633",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 236633,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1980,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019",
      "ID": 5146
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1986,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan",
      "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9334253+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5047E100P130VM291410",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291410,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1980,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019",
      "ID": 5146
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5047,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne",
      "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1181034+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234591",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234591,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1980,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019",
      "ID": 5146
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1845,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette",
      "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3909053+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313595",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313595,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1980,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019",
      "ID": 5146
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3061,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4021637+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1768E19P265VM288611",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 288611,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1980,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019",
      "ID": 5146
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1768,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1508723+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225081",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225081,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1980,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019",
      "ID": 5146
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1894,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Neil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7436876+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3815E98P134VM270913",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270913,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1980,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019",
      "ID": 5146
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3815,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Park, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Park",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8288438+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265877",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265877,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1980,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019",
      "ID": 5146
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2010,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil",
      "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4644017+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283318",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283318,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1980,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019",
      "ID": 5146
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5057,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.6955344+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2853E33P128VM251470",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251470,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1980,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019",
      "ID": 5146
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Pentland",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4650412+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317662",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317662,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1980,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019",
      "ID": 5146
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5009,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4320325+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254715",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254715,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1980,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019",
      "ID": 5146
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3745,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis",
      "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2806197+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1870E225P478VM295669",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295669,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1980,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019",
      "ID": 5146
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1870,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona",
      "DisplayName": "Shona Robison",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5307773+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2135E254P450VM234913",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234913,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1980,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019",
      "ID": 5146
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2135,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Russell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.405151+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1895E232P431VM257578",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257578,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1980,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019",
      "ID": 5146
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1895,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0625565+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228104",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 228104,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1980,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019",
      "ID": 5146
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1839,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5845265+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2345E10P55VM291674",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291674,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1980,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019",
      "ID": 5146
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2345,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1374412+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311026",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311026,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1980,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019",
      "ID": 5146
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2223,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish",
      "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.6022383+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246325",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 246325,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1980,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019",
      "ID": 5146
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2182,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1238463+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298163",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298163,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1980,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019",
      "ID": 5146
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5079,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew",
      "DisplayName": "Drew Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1409297+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234348",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234348,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1980,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019",
      "ID": 5146
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1769,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3733938+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274581",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274581,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1980,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019",
      "ID": 5146
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4014,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz",
      "DisplayName": "Liz Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1127902+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269527",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269527,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1980,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019",
      "ID": 5146
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2215,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5514763+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317368",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317368,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1980,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019",
      "ID": 5146
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3806,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4191099+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326297",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 326297,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1980,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019",
      "ID": 5146
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5106,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin",
      "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7523714+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241116",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241116,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1980,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019",
      "ID": 5146
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1848,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola",
      "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.4026628+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2098E237P531VM289631",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289631,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1980,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019",
      "ID": 5146
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2098,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Swinney",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4523179+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2674E247P401VM247787",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247787,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1980,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019",
      "ID": 5146
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2674,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave",
      "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4284371+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5075E234P371VM287392",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 287392,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1980,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019",
      "ID": 5146
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5075,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Torrance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8622433+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1793E151P9VM222482",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 222482,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1980,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019",
      "ID": 5146
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1793,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean",
      "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1908579+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5078E245P7VM307073",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307073,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1980,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019",
      "ID": 5146
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5078,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Walker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5861137+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1841E231P426VM240162",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 240162,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1980,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019",
      "ID": 5146
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1841,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen",
      "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7816153+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283449",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283449,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1980,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019",
      "ID": 5146
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4952,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7083684+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1865E263P500VM232208",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232208,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1980,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019",
      "ID": 5146
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1865,
      "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra",
      "DisplayName": "Sandra White",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8447695+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237766",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237766,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1980,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019",
      "ID": 5146
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2610,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Wilson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2252089+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309261",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 309261,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1980,
      "AgendaID": 2928,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-05019",
      "ID": 5146
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4941,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza",
      "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3217015+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252761",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252761,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1979,
      "AgendaID": 2369,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04970.1",
      "ID": 5105
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1926,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian",
      "DisplayName": "Brian Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7521671+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2615E213P388VM259158",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 259158,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1979,
      "AgendaID": 2369,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04970.1",
      "ID": 5105
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2615,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George",
      "DisplayName": "George Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3442075+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319548",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319548,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1979,
      "AgendaID": 2369,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04970.1",
      "ID": 5105
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4940,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare",
      "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9307009+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249473",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 249473,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1979,
      "AgendaID": 2369,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04970.1",
      "ID": 5105
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2641,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair",
      "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9282593+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1783E21P273VM228372",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 228372,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1979,
      "AgendaID": 2369,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04970.1",
      "ID": 5105
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1783,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie",
      "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.7957672+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2633E97P136VM281066",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 281066,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1979,
      "AgendaID": 2369,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04970.1",
      "ID": 5105
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2633,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire",
      "DisplayName": "Claire Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.8045405+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262996",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262996,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1979,
      "AgendaID": 2369,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04970.1",
      "ID": 5105
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2603,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6321729+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1759E91P115VM230555",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230555,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1979,
      "AgendaID": 2369,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04970.1",
      "ID": 5105
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia",
      "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3354425+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3751E243P383VM269713",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269713,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1979,
      "AgendaID": 2369,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04970.1",
      "ID": 5105
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3751,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5597904+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322534",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 322534,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1979,
      "AgendaID": 2369,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04970.1",
      "ID": 5105
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5109,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco",
      "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6928555+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5060E86P124VM295379",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295379,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1979,
      "AgendaID": 2369,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04970.1",
      "ID": 5105
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5060,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5096621+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1866E93P239VM243051",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 243051,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1979,
      "AgendaID": 2369,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04970.1",
      "ID": 5105
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1866,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah",
      "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0468113+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235086",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235086,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1979,
      "AgendaID": 2369,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04970.1",
      "ID": 5105
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1943,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic",
      "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4187637+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2595E12P30VM303086",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 303086,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1979,
      "AgendaID": 2369,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04970.1",
      "ID": 5105
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2595,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin",
      "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5580054+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244162",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244162,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1979,
      "AgendaID": 2369,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04970.1",
      "ID": 5105
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2103,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith",
      "DisplayName": "Keith Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3414213+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327037",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 327037,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1979,
      "AgendaID": 2369,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04970.1",
      "ID": 5105
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7908876+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277491",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277491,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1979,
      "AgendaID": 2369,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04970.1",
      "ID": 5105
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9556369+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2673E236P377VM263994",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 263994,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1979,
      "AgendaID": 2369,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04970.1",
      "ID": 5105
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2673,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick",
      "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.919661+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248647",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248647,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1979,
      "AgendaID": 2369,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04970.1",
      "ID": 5105
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2678,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson",
      "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6638135+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2123E27P233VM294860",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 294860,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1979,
      "AgendaID": 2369,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04970.1",
      "ID": 5105
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2123,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm",
      "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1815738+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285346",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285346,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1979,
      "AgendaID": 2369,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04970.1",
      "ID": 5105
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3907,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3190631+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1735E248P405VM231284",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231284,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1979,
      "AgendaID": 2369,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04970.1",
      "ID": 5105
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1735,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela",
      "DisplayName": "Angela Constance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.5883119+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243667",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 243667,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1979,
      "AgendaID": 2369,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04970.1",
      "ID": 5105
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1932,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce",
      "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3147238+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254441",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254441,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1979,
      "AgendaID": 2369,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04970.1",
      "ID": 5105
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1863,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna",
      "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2562471+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323489",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 323489,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1979,
      "AgendaID": 2369,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04970.1",
      "ID": 5105
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4976,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth",
      "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9585784+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5107E223P379VM290896",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 290896,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1979,
      "AgendaID": 2369,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04970.1",
      "ID": 5105
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5107,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7767564+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3743E222P391VM273043",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 273043,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1979,
      "AgendaID": 2369,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04970.1",
      "ID": 5105
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3743,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel",
      "DisplayName": "Nigel Don",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3670972+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262532",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262532,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1979,
      "AgendaID": 2369,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04970.1",
      "ID": 5105
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3771,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob",
      "DisplayName": "Bob Doris",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6059813+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281826",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 281826,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1979,
      "AgendaID": 2369,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04970.1",
      "ID": 5105
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2826,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Dornan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1592556+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298301",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298301,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1979,
      "AgendaID": 2369,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04970.1",
      "ID": 5105
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3812,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia",
      "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3398532+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231136",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231136,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1979,
      "AgendaID": 2369,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04970.1",
      "ID": 5105
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1778,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen",
      "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3671512+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4955E240P389VM284957",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 284957,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1979,
      "AgendaID": 2369,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04970.1",
      "ID": 5105
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4955,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0549732+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219519",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 219519,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1979,
      "AgendaID": 2369,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04970.1",
      "ID": 5105
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1742,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle",
      "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3028553+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238269",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 238269,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1979,
      "AgendaID": 2369,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04970.1",
      "ID": 5105
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1994,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus",
      "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4391078+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225126",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225126,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1979,
      "AgendaID": 2369,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04970.1",
      "ID": 5105
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1814,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda",
      "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7455984+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321926",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 321926,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1979,
      "AgendaID": 2369,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04970.1",
      "ID": 5105
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Fee",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4572987+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292733",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 292733,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1979,
      "AgendaID": 2369,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04970.1",
      "ID": 5105
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia",
      "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5554827+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227244",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227244,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1979,
      "AgendaID": 2369,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04970.1",
      "ID": 5105
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5370841+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5054E95P118VM313313",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313313,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1979,
      "AgendaID": 2369,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04970.1",
      "ID": 5105
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5054,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.3899368+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4947E152P8VM257809",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257809,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1979,
      "AgendaID": 2369,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04970.1",
      "ID": 5105
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4947,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Finnie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0785242+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271089",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271089,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1979,
      "AgendaID": 2369,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04970.1",
      "ID": 5105
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3901,
      "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe",
      "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8420207+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2394E15P47VM277964",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277964,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1979,
      "AgendaID": 2369,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04970.1",
      "ID": 5105
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2394,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo",
      "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9763508+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2110E220P414VM288315",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 288315,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1979,
      "AgendaID": 2369,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04970.1",
      "ID": 5105
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth",
      "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1295381+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250626",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250626,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1979,
      "AgendaID": 2369,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04970.1",
      "ID": 5105
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2675,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob",
      "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1976627+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221090",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221090,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1979,
      "AgendaID": 2369,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04970.1",
      "ID": 5105
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1741,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel",
      "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6746495+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220125",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220125,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1979,
      "AgendaID": 2369,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04970.1",
      "ID": 5105
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1756,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine",
      "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3354154+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1860E104P150VM252817",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252817,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1979,
      "AgendaID": 2369,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04970.1",
      "ID": 5105
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1860,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda",
      "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7545149+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2033E20P141VM253732",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253732,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1979,
      "AgendaID": 2369,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04970.1",
      "ID": 5105
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2033,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain",
      "DisplayName": "Iain Gray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0185935+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324762",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324762,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1979,
      "AgendaID": 2369,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04970.1",
      "ID": 5105
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5042,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2367789+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259594",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 259594,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1979,
      "AgendaID": 2369,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04970.1",
      "ID": 5105
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick",
      "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6161811+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239473",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239473,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1979,
      "AgendaID": 2369,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04970.1",
      "ID": 5105
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2029,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh",
      "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7452155+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273620",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 273620,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1979,
      "AgendaID": 2369,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04970.1",
      "ID": 5105
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3758,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6282235+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4086E128P311VM303994",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 303994,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1979,
      "AgendaID": 2369,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04970.1",
      "ID": 5105
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4086,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Hume",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8448262+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221604",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221604,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1979,
      "AgendaID": 2369,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04970.1",
      "ID": 5105
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1773,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9399051+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1882E227P459VM241836",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241836,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1979,
      "AgendaID": 2369,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04970.1",
      "ID": 5105
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1882,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam",
      "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7821394+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223399",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223399,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1979,
      "AgendaID": 2369,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04970.1",
      "ID": 5105
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1893,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4562067+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307883",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307883,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1979,
      "AgendaID": 2369,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04970.1",
      "ID": 5105
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4934,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8550388+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272361",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 272361,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1979,
      "AgendaID": 2369,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04970.1",
      "ID": 5105
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4956,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Keir",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.332026+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2059E26P131VM245062",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 245062,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1979,
      "AgendaID": 2369,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04970.1",
      "ID": 5105
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Kelly",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5903772+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315231",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315231,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1979,
      "AgendaID": 2369,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04970.1",
      "ID": 5105
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3129,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.8995875+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247488",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247488,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1979,
      "AgendaID": 2369,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04970.1",
      "ID": 5105
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann",
      "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4059905+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4016E11P36VM275151",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 275151,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1979,
      "AgendaID": 2369,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04970.1",
      "ID": 5105
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4016,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1437819+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255490",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255490,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1979,
      "AgendaID": 2369,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04970.1",
      "ID": 5105
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2180,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5335636+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4938E158P374VM276938",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276938,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1979,
      "AgendaID": 2369,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04970.1",
      "ID": 5105
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4938,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6875431+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2112E250P486VM253474",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253474,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1979,
      "AgendaID": 2369,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04970.1",
      "ID": 5105
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2112,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny",
      "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.9979914+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4939E258P394VM276710",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276710,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1979,
      "AgendaID": 2369,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04970.1",
      "ID": 5105
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4939,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus",
      "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6778086+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325369",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 325369,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1979,
      "AgendaID": 2369,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04970.1",
      "ID": 5105
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5074,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon",
      "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.4957211+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1828E3P10VM233307",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 233307,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1979,
      "AgendaID": 2369,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04970.1",
      "ID": 5105
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1828,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo",
      "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1184601+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311727",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311727,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1979,
      "AgendaID": 2369,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04970.1",
      "ID": 5105
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4948,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike",
      "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8916533+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2117E90P107VM229660",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229660,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1979,
      "AgendaID": 2369,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04970.1",
      "ID": 5105
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2117,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis",
      "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0912393+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267511",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 267511,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1979,
      "AgendaID": 2369,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04970.1",
      "ID": 5105
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken",
      "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0229846+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313433",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313433,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1979,
      "AgendaID": 2369,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04970.1",
      "ID": 5105
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4966,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek",
      "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.3951613+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3101E102P129VM294462",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 294462,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1979,
      "AgendaID": 2369,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04970.1",
      "ID": 5105
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3101,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala",
      "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1393424+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319175",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319175,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1979,
      "AgendaID": 2369,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04970.1",
      "ID": 5105
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5034,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny",
      "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6956637+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306255",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306255,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1979,
      "AgendaID": 2369,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04970.1",
      "ID": 5105
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2159,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Martin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5442035+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5110E252P395VM310735",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 310735,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1979,
      "AgendaID": 2369,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04970.1",
      "ID": 5105
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Mason",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5837856+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268093",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 268093,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1979,
      "AgendaID": 2369,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04970.1",
      "ID": 5105
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2133,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0558562+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2876E141P433VM292964",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 292964,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1979,
      "AgendaID": 2369,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04970.1",
      "ID": 5105
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2876,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.56579+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4951E147P368VM258510",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258510,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1979,
      "AgendaID": 2369,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04970.1",
      "ID": 5105
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4951,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan",
      "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3103646+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3896E175P307VM263759",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 263759,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1979,
      "AgendaID": 2369,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04970.1",
      "ID": 5105
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3896,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam",
      "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9035115+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308753",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 308753,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1979,
      "AgendaID": 2369,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04970.1",
      "ID": 5105
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0694955+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4964E143P375VM279791",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279791,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1979,
      "AgendaID": 2369,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04970.1",
      "ID": 5105
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4964,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.522956+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279492",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279492,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1979,
      "AgendaID": 2369,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04970.1",
      "ID": 5105
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3824,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5100435+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2066E22P91VM260459",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 260459,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1979,
      "AgendaID": 2369,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04970.1",
      "ID": 5105
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2066,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.0777885+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299363",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 299363,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1979,
      "AgendaID": 2369,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04970.1",
      "ID": 5105
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.6942286+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306785",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306785,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1979,
      "AgendaID": 2369,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04970.1",
      "ID": 5105
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina",
      "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5735414+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300550",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 300550,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1979,
      "AgendaID": 2369,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04970.1",
      "ID": 5105
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2487,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0032184+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223994",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223994,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1979,
      "AgendaID": 2369,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04970.1",
      "ID": 5105
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.487443+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237928",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237928,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1979,
      "AgendaID": 2369,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04970.1",
      "ID": 5105
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1961,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David",
      "DisplayName": "David McLetchie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2321413+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305612",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 305612,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1979,
      "AgendaID": 2369,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04970.1",
      "ID": 5105
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2134,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3318686+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320095",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 320095,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1979,
      "AgendaID": 2369,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04970.1",
      "ID": 5105
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5041,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan",
      "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9614583+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315851",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315851,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1979,
      "AgendaID": 2369,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04970.1",
      "ID": 5105
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3763,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart",
      "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9297944+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1986E23P197VM237120",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237120,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1979,
      "AgendaID": 2369,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04970.1",
      "ID": 5105
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1986,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan",
      "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9666941+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5047E100P130VM288925",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 288925,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1979,
      "AgendaID": 2369,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04970.1",
      "ID": 5105
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5047,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne",
      "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1642576+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234269",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234269,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1979,
      "AgendaID": 2369,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04970.1",
      "ID": 5105
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1845,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette",
      "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3699759+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313111",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313111,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1979,
      "AgendaID": 2369,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04970.1",
      "ID": 5105
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3061,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1641226+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1768E19P265VM289386",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289386,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1979,
      "AgendaID": 2369,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04970.1",
      "ID": 5105
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1768,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4350078+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225388",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225388,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1979,
      "AgendaID": 2369,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04970.1",
      "ID": 5105
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1894,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Neil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9725831+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3815E98P134VM270996",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270996,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1979,
      "AgendaID": 2369,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04970.1",
      "ID": 5105
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3815,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Park, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Park",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8380499+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265709",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265709,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1979,
      "AgendaID": 2369,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04970.1",
      "ID": 5105
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2010,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil",
      "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4509364+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283040",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283040,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1979,
      "AgendaID": 2369,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04970.1",
      "ID": 5105
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5057,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.445167+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2853E33P128VM252053",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252053,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1979,
      "AgendaID": 2369,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04970.1",
      "ID": 5105
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Pentland",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.5005384+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317317",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317317,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1979,
      "AgendaID": 2369,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04970.1",
      "ID": 5105
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5009,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4169203+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254225",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254225,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1979,
      "AgendaID": 2369,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04970.1",
      "ID": 5105
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3745,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis",
      "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2463281+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1870E225P478VM296288",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 296288,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1979,
      "AgendaID": 2369,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04970.1",
      "ID": 5105
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1870,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona",
      "DisplayName": "Shona Robison",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8423203+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2135E254P450VM235498",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235498,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1979,
      "AgendaID": 2369,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04970.1",
      "ID": 5105
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2135,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Russell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6804212+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1895E232P431VM258056",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258056,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1979,
      "AgendaID": 2369,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04970.1",
      "ID": 5105
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1895,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0895397+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228587",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 228587,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1979,
      "AgendaID": 2369,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04970.1",
      "ID": 5105
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1839,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.8055279+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2345E10P55VM291041",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291041,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1979,
      "AgendaID": 2369,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04970.1",
      "ID": 5105
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2345,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.782929+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311513",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311513,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1979,
      "AgendaID": 2369,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04970.1",
      "ID": 5105
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2223,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish",
      "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8821014+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246809",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 246809,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1979,
      "AgendaID": 2369,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04970.1",
      "ID": 5105
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2182,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.154323+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5079E101P119VM297680",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 297680,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1979,
      "AgendaID": 2369,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04970.1",
      "ID": 5105
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5079,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew",
      "DisplayName": "Drew Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1201103+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234020",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234020,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1979,
      "AgendaID": 2369,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04970.1",
      "ID": 5105
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1769,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1566791+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274860",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274860,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1979,
      "AgendaID": 2369,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04970.1",
      "ID": 5105
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4014,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz",
      "DisplayName": "Liz Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1249665+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269987",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269987,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1979,
      "AgendaID": 2369,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04970.1",
      "ID": 5105
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2215,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5766663+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317697",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317697,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1979,
      "AgendaID": 2369,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04970.1",
      "ID": 5105
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3806,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.433524+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326461",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 326461,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1979,
      "AgendaID": 2369,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04970.1",
      "ID": 5105
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5106,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin",
      "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7656884+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241292",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241292,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1979,
      "AgendaID": 2369,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04970.1",
      "ID": 5105
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1848,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola",
      "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7516533+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2098E237P531VM290422",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 290422,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1979,
      "AgendaID": 2369,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04970.1",
      "ID": 5105
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2098,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Swinney",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7464209+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248062",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248062,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1979,
      "AgendaID": 2369,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04970.1",
      "ID": 5105
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2674,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave",
      "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4401427+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5075E234P371VM287515",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 287515,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1979,
      "AgendaID": 2369,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04970.1",
      "ID": 5105
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5075,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Torrance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8743003+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1793E151P9VM222632",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 222632,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1979,
      "AgendaID": 2369,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04970.1",
      "ID": 5105
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1793,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean",
      "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1972839+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5078E245P7VM306941",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306941,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1979,
      "AgendaID": 2369,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04970.1",
      "ID": 5105
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5078,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Walker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5804754+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1841E231P426VM239679",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239679,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1979,
      "AgendaID": 2369,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04970.1",
      "ID": 5105
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1841,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen",
      "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7542848+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283801",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283801,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1979,
      "AgendaID": 2369,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04970.1",
      "ID": 5105
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4952,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7240388+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1865E263P500VM231749",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231749,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1979,
      "AgendaID": 2369,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04970.1",
      "ID": 5105
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1865,
      "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra",
      "DisplayName": "Sandra White",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6138712+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237341",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237341,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1979,
      "AgendaID": 2369,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04970.1",
      "ID": 5105
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2610,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Wilson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2000128+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4941E150P382VM308954",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 308954,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1979,
      "AgendaID": 2369,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04970.1",
      "ID": 5105
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4941,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza",
      "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0852408+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252309",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252309,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1978,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914.1",
      "ID": 5056
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1926,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian",
      "DisplayName": "Brian Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.723589+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2615E213P388VM258817",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258817,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1978,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914.1",
      "ID": 5056
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2615,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George",
      "DisplayName": "George Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3291887+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319879",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319879,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1978,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914.1",
      "ID": 5056
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4940,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare",
      "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9453215+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249652",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 249652,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1978,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914.1",
      "ID": 5056
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2641,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair",
      "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9440396+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1783E21P273VM227722",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227722,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1978,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914.1",
      "ID": 5056
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1783,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie",
      "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5628427+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2633E97P136VM280411",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280411,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1978,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914.1",
      "ID": 5056
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2633,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire",
      "DisplayName": "Claire Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7658293+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262507",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262507,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1978,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914.1",
      "ID": 5056
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2603,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.604916+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1759E91P115VM229757",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229757,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1978,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914.1",
      "ID": 5056
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia",
      "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0953879+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270210",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270210,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1978,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914.1",
      "ID": 5056
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3751,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.7940506+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322687",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 322687,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1978,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914.1",
      "ID": 5056
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5109,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco",
      "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6993736+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5060E86P124VM294739",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 294739,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1978,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914.1",
      "ID": 5056
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5060,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1762476+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242843",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242843,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1978,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914.1",
      "ID": 5056
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1866,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah",
      "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0379795+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235582",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235582,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1978,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914.1",
      "ID": 5056
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1943,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic",
      "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6840032+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302166",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 302166,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1978,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914.1",
      "ID": 5056
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2595,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin",
      "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.3002376+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244493",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244493,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1978,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914.1",
      "ID": 5056
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2103,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith",
      "DisplayName": "Keith Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.557159+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327201",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 327201,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1978,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914.1",
      "ID": 5056
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.803536+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3775E216P435VM276690",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276690,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1978,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914.1",
      "ID": 5056
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6769571+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264327",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264327,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1978,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914.1",
      "ID": 5056
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2673,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick",
      "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1287225+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248816",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248816,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1978,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914.1",
      "ID": 5056
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2678,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson",
      "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.67129+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2123E27P233VM295809",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295809,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1978,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914.1",
      "ID": 5056
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2123,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm",
      "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5367871+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285168",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285168,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1978,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914.1",
      "ID": 5056
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3907,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0693623+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230646",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230646,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1978,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914.1",
      "ID": 5056
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1735,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela",
      "DisplayName": "Angela Constance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3391423+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243876",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 243876,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1978,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914.1",
      "ID": 5056
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1932,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce",
      "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3237023+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254923",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254923,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1978,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914.1",
      "ID": 5056
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1863,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna",
      "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2896054+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323808",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 323808,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1978,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914.1",
      "ID": 5056
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4976,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth",
      "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9728097+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5107E223P379VM291375",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291375,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1978,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914.1",
      "ID": 5056
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5107,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1165956+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3743E222P391VM265339",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265339,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1978,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914.1",
      "ID": 5056
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3743,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel",
      "DisplayName": "Nigel Don",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4349157+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3771E149P417VM261745",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261745,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1978,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914.1",
      "ID": 5056
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3771,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob",
      "DisplayName": "Bob Doris",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3709923+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2826E262P384VM282020",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 282020,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1978,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914.1",
      "ID": 5056
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2826,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Dornan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1677428+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3812E94P117VM297953",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 297953,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1978,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914.1",
      "ID": 5056
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3812,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia",
      "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1320231+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231587",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231587,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1978,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914.1",
      "ID": 5056
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1778,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen",
      "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6070283+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4955E240P389VM285972",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285972,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1978,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914.1",
      "ID": 5056
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4955,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3524642+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219348",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 219348,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1978,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914.1",
      "ID": 5056
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1742,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle",
      "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.2947306+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238609",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 238609,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1978,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914.1",
      "ID": 5056
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1994,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus",
      "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4614802+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225458",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225458,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1978,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914.1",
      "ID": 5056
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1814,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda",
      "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9755907+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321773",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 321773,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1978,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914.1",
      "ID": 5056
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Fee",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4507687+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292894",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 292894,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1978,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914.1",
      "ID": 5056
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia",
      "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5627914+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1892E12P64VM226915",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 226915,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1978,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914.1",
      "ID": 5056
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2522721+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5054E95P118VM312682",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 312682,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1978,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914.1",
      "ID": 5056
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5054,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.138813+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4947E152P8VM257167",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257167,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1978,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914.1",
      "ID": 5056
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4947,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Finnie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.8261897+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271328",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271328,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1978,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914.1",
      "ID": 5056
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3901,
      "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe",
      "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0707657+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278464",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 278464,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1978,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914.1",
      "ID": 5056
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2394,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo",
      "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2199378+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2110E220P414VM286754",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286754,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1978,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914.1",
      "ID": 5056
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth",
      "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5992646+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250445",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250445,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1978,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914.1",
      "ID": 5056
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2675,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob",
      "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1898484+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1741E10P50VM220757",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220757,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1978,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914.1",
      "ID": 5056
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1741,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel",
      "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6557183+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220297",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220297,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1978,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914.1",
      "ID": 5056
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1756,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine",
      "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6352427+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1860E104P150VM252342",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252342,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1978,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914.1",
      "ID": 5056
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1860,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda",
      "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7250482+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2033E20P141VM266149",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 266149,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1978,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914.1",
      "ID": 5056
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2033,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain",
      "DisplayName": "Iain Gray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4764397+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324597",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324597,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1978,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914.1",
      "ID": 5056
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5042,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2298241+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259918",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 259918,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1978,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914.1",
      "ID": 5056
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick",
      "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6356471+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239288",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239288,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1978,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914.1",
      "ID": 5056
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2029,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh",
      "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7303511+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273798",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 273798,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1978,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914.1",
      "ID": 5056
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3758,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6360988+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304163",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 304163,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1978,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914.1",
      "ID": 5056
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4086,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Hume",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8524464+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221782",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221782,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1978,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914.1",
      "ID": 5056
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1773,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9475723+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1882E227P459VM242015",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242015,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1978,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914.1",
      "ID": 5056
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1882,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam",
      "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7901448+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223740",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223740,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1978,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914.1",
      "ID": 5056
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1893,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.47174+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307537",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307537,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1978,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914.1",
      "ID": 5056
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4934,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8338005+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272184",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 272184,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1978,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914.1",
      "ID": 5056
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4956,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Keir",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.1151907+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244851",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244851,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1978,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914.1",
      "ID": 5056
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Kelly",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5813525+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315053",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315053,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1978,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914.1",
      "ID": 5056
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3129,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6720619+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247980",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247980,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1978,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914.1",
      "ID": 5056
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann",
      "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4365878+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4016E11P36VM274758",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274758,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1978,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914.1",
      "ID": 5056
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4016,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1204541+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255830",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255830,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1978,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914.1",
      "ID": 5056
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2180,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5588776+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4938E158P374VM277796",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277796,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1978,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914.1",
      "ID": 5056
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4938,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9687859+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2112E250P486VM252982",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252982,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1978,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914.1",
      "ID": 5056
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2112,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny",
      "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7616236+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4939E258P394VM277191",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277191,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1978,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914.1",
      "ID": 5056
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4939,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus",
      "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.7051099+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325534",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 325534,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1978,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914.1",
      "ID": 5056
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5074,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon",
      "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5104888+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1828E3P10VM232847",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232847,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1978,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914.1",
      "ID": 5056
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1828,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo",
      "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8791568+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311384",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311384,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1978,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914.1",
      "ID": 5056
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4948,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike",
      "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8764063+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2117E90P107VM230451",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230451,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1978,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914.1",
      "ID": 5056
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2117,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis",
      "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.330387+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267322",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 267322,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1978,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914.1",
      "ID": 5056
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken",
      "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.014438+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313777",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313777,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1978,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914.1",
      "ID": 5056
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4966,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek",
      "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4102148+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3101E102P129VM295429",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295429,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1978,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914.1",
      "ID": 5056
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3101,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala",
      "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5117805+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319023",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319023,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1978,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914.1",
      "ID": 5056
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5034,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny",
      "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6891219+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306433",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306433,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1978,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914.1",
      "ID": 5056
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2159,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Martin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5518575+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5110E252P395VM311202",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311202,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1978,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914.1",
      "ID": 5056
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Mason",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8662708+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268282",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 268282,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1978,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914.1",
      "ID": 5056
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2133,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2603796+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2876E141P433VM286132",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286132,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1978,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914.1",
      "ID": 5056
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2876,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3651489+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4951E147P368VM260700",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 260700,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1978,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914.1",
      "ID": 5056
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4951,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan",
      "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.0884943+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3896E175P307VM264085",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264085,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1978,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914.1",
      "ID": 5056
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3896,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam",
      "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9235559+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308437",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 308437,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1978,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914.1",
      "ID": 5056
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0558872+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4964E143P375VM279318",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279318,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1978,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914.1",
      "ID": 5056
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4964,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.4970076+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279980",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279980,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1978,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914.1",
      "ID": 5056
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3824,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.531108+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2066E22P91VM261104",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261104,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1978,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914.1",
      "ID": 5056
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2066,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.1119888+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299710",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 299710,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1978,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914.1",
      "ID": 5056
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7192799+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306623",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306623,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1978,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914.1",
      "ID": 5056
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina",
      "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.560052+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2487E146P369VM301172",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 301172,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1978,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914.1",
      "ID": 5056
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2487,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0370795+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223662",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223662,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1978,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914.1",
      "ID": 5056
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4684225+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237460",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237460,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1978,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914.1",
      "ID": 5056
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1961,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David",
      "DisplayName": "David McLetchie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2115338+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305434",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 305434,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1978,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914.1",
      "ID": 5056
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2134,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3238611+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320403",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 320403,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1978,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914.1",
      "ID": 5056
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5041,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan",
      "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1649061+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3763E142P397VM316029",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 316029,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1978,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914.1",
      "ID": 5056
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3763,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart",
      "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9427767+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1986E23P197VM236630",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 236630,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1978,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914.1",
      "ID": 5056
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1986,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan",
      "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9332818+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5047E100P130VM291413",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291413,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1978,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914.1",
      "ID": 5056
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5047,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne",
      "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1182472+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234594",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234594,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1978,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914.1",
      "ID": 5056
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1845,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette",
      "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3910295+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313599",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313599,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1978,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914.1",
      "ID": 5056
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3061,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4023288+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1768E19P265VM288608",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 288608,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1978,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914.1",
      "ID": 5056
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1768,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.150749+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225045",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225045,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1978,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914.1",
      "ID": 5056
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1894,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Neil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7421581+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3815E98P134VM270883",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270883,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1978,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914.1",
      "ID": 5056
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3815,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Park, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Park",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8272248+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265880",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265880,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1978,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914.1",
      "ID": 5056
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2010,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil",
      "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4645483+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283522",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283522,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1978,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914.1",
      "ID": 5056
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5057,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7115347+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2853E33P128VM251423",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251423,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1978,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914.1",
      "ID": 5056
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Pentland",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4629558+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317623",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317623,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1978,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914.1",
      "ID": 5056
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5009,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4303872+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254718",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254718,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1978,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914.1",
      "ID": 5056
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3745,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis",
      "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2807679+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1870E225P478VM295666",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295666,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1978,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914.1",
      "ID": 5056
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1870,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona",
      "DisplayName": "Shona Robison",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5306571+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2135E254P450VM234866",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234866,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1978,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914.1",
      "ID": 5056
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2135,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Russell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4031285+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1895E232P431VM257575",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257575,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1978,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914.1",
      "ID": 5056
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1895,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0624339+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228101",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 228101,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1978,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914.1",
      "ID": 5056
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1839,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5844059+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2345E10P55VM291677",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291677,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1978,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914.1",
      "ID": 5056
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2345,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1375653+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2223E176P333VM310710",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 310710,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1978,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914.1",
      "ID": 5056
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2223,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish",
      "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5827057+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246322",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 246322,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1978,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914.1",
      "ID": 5056
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2182,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1237136+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298166",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298166,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1978,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914.1",
      "ID": 5056
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5079,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew",
      "DisplayName": "Drew Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1410524+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234351",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234351,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1978,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914.1",
      "ID": 5056
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1769,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3735367+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4014E14P26VM269946",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269946,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1978,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914.1",
      "ID": 5056
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4014,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz",
      "DisplayName": "Liz Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5746592+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269178",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269178,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1978,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914.1",
      "ID": 5056
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2215,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.307066+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317364",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317364,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1978,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914.1",
      "ID": 5056
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3806,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4189471+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326296",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 326296,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1978,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914.1",
      "ID": 5056
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5106,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin",
      "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7523308+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241113",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241113,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1978,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914.1",
      "ID": 5056
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1848,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola",
      "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.402535+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2098E237P531VM289627",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289627,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1978,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914.1",
      "ID": 5056
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2098,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Swinney",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4521389+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2674E247P401VM247740",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247740,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1978,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914.1",
      "ID": 5056
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2674,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave",
      "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4263785+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5075E234P371VM284858",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 284858,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1978,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914.1",
      "ID": 5056
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5075,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Torrance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0507494+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1793E151P9VM222446",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 222446,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1978,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914.1",
      "ID": 5056
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1793,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean",
      "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1893156+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5078E245P7VM307076",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307076,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1978,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914.1",
      "ID": 5056
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5078,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Walker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5862353+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1841E231P426VM240165",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 240165,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1978,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914.1",
      "ID": 5056
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1841,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen",
      "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7817667+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283409",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283409,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1978,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914.1",
      "ID": 5056
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4952,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.6994549+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1865E263P500VM232242",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232242,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1978,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914.1",
      "ID": 5056
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1865,
      "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra",
      "DisplayName": "Sandra White",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8462893+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237813",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237813,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1978,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914.1",
      "ID": 5056
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2610,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Wilson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2271849+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309301",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 309301,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1978,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914.1",
      "ID": 5056
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4941,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza",
      "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3234203+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252308",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252308,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1977,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914",
      "ID": 5037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1926,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian",
      "DisplayName": "Brian Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7235482+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2615E213P388VM258816",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258816,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1977,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914",
      "ID": 5037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2615,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George",
      "DisplayName": "George Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3291473+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319910",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319910,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1977,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914",
      "ID": 5037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4940,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare",
      "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9466608+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249653",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 249653,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1977,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914",
      "ID": 5037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2641,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair",
      "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9440793+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1783E21P273VM227415",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227415,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1977,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914",
      "ID": 5037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1783,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie",
      "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5491929+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2633E97P136VM280410",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280410,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1977,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914",
      "ID": 5037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2633,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire",
      "DisplayName": "Claire Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7657888+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262506",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262506,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1977,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914",
      "ID": 5037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2603,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.604875+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1759E91P115VM229720",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229720,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1977,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914",
      "ID": 5037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia",
      "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0937635+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270211",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270211,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1977,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914",
      "ID": 5037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3751,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.7940922+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322686",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 322686,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1977,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914",
      "ID": 5037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5109,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco",
      "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6993338+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5060E86P124VM294738",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 294738,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1977,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914",
      "ID": 5037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5060,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1762065+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242842",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242842,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1977,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914",
      "ID": 5037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1866,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah",
      "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0379396+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235583",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235583,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1977,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914",
      "ID": 5037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1943,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic",
      "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6840439+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302165",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 302165,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1977,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914",
      "ID": 5037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2595,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin",
      "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.3001855+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244494",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244494,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1977,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914",
      "ID": 5037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2103,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith",
      "DisplayName": "Keith Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5572002+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327221",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 327221,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1977,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914",
      "ID": 5037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:46.0264646+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3775E216P435VM276689",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276689,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1977,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914",
      "ID": 5037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6769171+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264328",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264328,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1977,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914",
      "ID": 5037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2673,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick",
      "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1287861+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248817",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248817,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1977,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914",
      "ID": 5037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2678,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson",
      "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6713307+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2123E27P233VM295841",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295841,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1977,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914",
      "ID": 5037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2123,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm",
      "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5381438+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285167",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285167,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1977,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914",
      "ID": 5037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3907,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.069322+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230645",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230645,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1977,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914",
      "ID": 5037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1735,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela",
      "DisplayName": "Angela Constance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3391022+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243877",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 243877,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1977,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914",
      "ID": 5037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1932,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce",
      "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3237441+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254924",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254924,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1977,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914",
      "ID": 5037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1863,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna",
      "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2896458+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323828",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 323828,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1977,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914",
      "ID": 5037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4976,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth",
      "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9738058+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5107E223P379VM291376",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291376,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1977,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914",
      "ID": 5037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5107,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1166367+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3743E222P391VM265338",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265338,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1977,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914",
      "ID": 5037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3743,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel",
      "DisplayName": "Nigel Don",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.434873+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3771E149P417VM261744",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261744,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1977,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914",
      "ID": 5037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3771,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob",
      "DisplayName": "Bob Doris",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.370952+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2826E262P384VM282021",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 282021,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1977,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914",
      "ID": 5037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2826,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Dornan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1677834+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3812E94P117VM297952",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 297952,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1977,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914",
      "ID": 5037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3812,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia",
      "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1319639+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231624",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231624,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1977,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914",
      "ID": 5037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1778,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen",
      "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6086146+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4955E240P389VM285973",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285973,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1977,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914",
      "ID": 5037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4955,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3525054+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219347",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 219347,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1977,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914",
      "ID": 5037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1742,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle",
      "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.2946895+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238610",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 238610,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1977,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914",
      "ID": 5037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1994,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus",
      "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4615208+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225459",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225459,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1977,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914",
      "ID": 5037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1814,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda",
      "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9756307+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321774",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 321774,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1977,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914",
      "ID": 5037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Fee",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4508084+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292895",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 292895,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1977,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914",
      "ID": 5037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia",
      "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5628315+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1892E12P64VM226914",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 226914,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1977,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914",
      "ID": 5037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2522297+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5054E95P118VM312681",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 312681,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1977,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914",
      "ID": 5037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5054,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1387716+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4947E152P8VM257166",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257166,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1977,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914",
      "ID": 5037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4947,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Finnie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.8261491+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271329",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271329,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1977,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914",
      "ID": 5037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3901,
      "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe",
      "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0708067+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278465",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 278465,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1977,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914",
      "ID": 5037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2394,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo",
      "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2199794+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2110E220P414VM286753",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286753,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1977,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914",
      "ID": 5037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth",
      "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5992068+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250444",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250444,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1977,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914",
      "ID": 5037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2675,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob",
      "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1898071+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1741E10P50VM220756",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220756,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1977,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914",
      "ID": 5037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1741,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel",
      "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6556775+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220298",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220298,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1977,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914",
      "ID": 5037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1756,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine",
      "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6352832+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1860E104P150VM252341",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252341,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1977,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914",
      "ID": 5037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1860,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda",
      "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7250075+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2033E20P141VM266150",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 266150,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1977,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914",
      "ID": 5037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2033,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain",
      "DisplayName": "Iain Gray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4764799+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324577",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324577,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1977,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914",
      "ID": 5037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5042,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2289713+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259919",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 259919,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1977,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914",
      "ID": 5037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick",
      "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6356883+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239287",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239287,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1977,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914",
      "ID": 5037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2029,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh",
      "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7303104+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273799",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 273799,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1977,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914",
      "ID": 5037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3758,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6361597+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304164",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 304164,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1977,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914",
      "ID": 5037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4086,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Hume",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.852495+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221783",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221783,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1977,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914",
      "ID": 5037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1773,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9476124+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1882E227P459VM242016",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242016,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1977,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914",
      "ID": 5037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1882,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam",
      "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7901854+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223741",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223741,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1977,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914",
      "ID": 5037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1893,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4717804+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307536",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307536,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1977,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914",
      "ID": 5037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4934,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8337595+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272183",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 272183,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1977,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914",
      "ID": 5037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4956,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Keir",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.1151488+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244850",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244850,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1977,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914",
      "ID": 5037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Kelly",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5813127+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315022",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315022,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1977,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914",
      "ID": 5037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3129,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6707214+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247981",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247981,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1977,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914",
      "ID": 5037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann",
      "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4366462+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4016E11P36VM274757",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274757,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1977,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914",
      "ID": 5037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4016,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1204133+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255831",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255831,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1977,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914",
      "ID": 5037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2180,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5589349+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4938E158P374VM277797",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277797,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1977,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914",
      "ID": 5037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4938,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9688445+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2112E250P486VM252981",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252981,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1977,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914",
      "ID": 5037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2112,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny",
      "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7615831+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4939E258P394VM277192",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277192,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1977,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914",
      "ID": 5037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4939,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus",
      "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.7052735+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325554",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 325554,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1977,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914",
      "ID": 5037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5074,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon",
      "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5113408+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1828E3P10VM232846",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232846,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1977,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914",
      "ID": 5037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1828,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo",
      "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8791163+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311383",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311383,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1977,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914",
      "ID": 5037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4948,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike",
      "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8763463+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2117E90P107VM230452",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230452,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1977,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914",
      "ID": 5037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2117,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis",
      "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3305291+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267321",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 267321,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1977,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914",
      "ID": 5037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken",
      "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0143972+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313778",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313778,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1977,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914",
      "ID": 5037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4966,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek",
      "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4102555+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3101E102P129VM295430",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295430,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1977,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914",
      "ID": 5037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3101,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala",
      "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5118208+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319024",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319024,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1977,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914",
      "ID": 5037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5034,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny",
      "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6891631+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306465",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306465,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1977,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914",
      "ID": 5037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2159,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Martin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5532384+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5110E252P395VM311203",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311203,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1977,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914",
      "ID": 5037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Mason",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8663465+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268283",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 268283,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1977,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914",
      "ID": 5037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2133,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2604203+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2876E141P433VM286131",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286131,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1977,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914",
      "ID": 5037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2876,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3650681+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4951E147P368VM260701",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 260701,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1977,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914",
      "ID": 5037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4951,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan",
      "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.0885543+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3896E175P307VM264086",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264086,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1977,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914",
      "ID": 5037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3896,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam",
      "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9235966+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308436",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 308436,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1977,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914",
      "ID": 5037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0558459+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4964E143P375VM279317",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279317,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1977,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914",
      "ID": 5037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4964,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.496965+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279981",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279981,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1977,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914",
      "ID": 5037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3824,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5311486+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2066E22P91VM261757",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261757,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1977,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914",
      "ID": 5037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2066,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3715036+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299711",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 299711,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1977,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914",
      "ID": 5037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7193202+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306622",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306622,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1977,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914",
      "ID": 5037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina",
      "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5600102+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2487E146P369VM301173",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 301173,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1977,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914",
      "ID": 5037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2487,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0371527+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223661",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223661,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1977,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914",
      "ID": 5037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4683817+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237459",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237459,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1977,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914",
      "ID": 5037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1961,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David",
      "DisplayName": "David McLetchie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.211492+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2134E34P201VM297849",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 297849,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1977,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914",
      "ID": 5037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2134,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1276418+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320402",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 320402,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1977,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914",
      "ID": 5037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5041,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan",
      "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.164865+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3763E142P397VM316060",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 316060,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1977,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914",
      "ID": 5037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3763,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart",
      "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9444418+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1986E23P197VM236629",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 236629,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1977,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914",
      "ID": 5037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1986,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan",
      "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9332407+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5047E100P130VM291414",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291414,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1977,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914",
      "ID": 5037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5047,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne",
      "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1182903+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234595",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234595,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1977,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914",
      "ID": 5037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1845,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette",
      "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3910899+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313630",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313630,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1977,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914",
      "ID": 5037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3061,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4036676+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1768E19P265VM288607",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 288607,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1977,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914",
      "ID": 5037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1768,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1507062+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225044",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225044,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1977,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914",
      "ID": 5037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1894,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Neil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7421184+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3815E98P134VM270882",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270882,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1977,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914",
      "ID": 5037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3815,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Park, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Park",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8271838+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265881",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265881,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1977,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914",
      "ID": 5037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2010,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil",
      "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4645889+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283523",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283523,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1977,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914",
      "ID": 5037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5057,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7115764+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2853E33P128VM251422",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251422,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1977,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914",
      "ID": 5037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Pentland",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4629149+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317622",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317622,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1977,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914",
      "ID": 5037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5009,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4303469+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254719",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254719,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1977,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914",
      "ID": 5037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3745,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis",
      "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2808118+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1870E225P478VM295665",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295665,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1977,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914",
      "ID": 5037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1870,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona",
      "DisplayName": "Shona Robison",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.530617+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2135E254P450VM234865",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234865,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1977,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914",
      "ID": 5037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2135,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Russell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4030874+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1895E232P431VM257574",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257574,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1977,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914",
      "ID": 5037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1895,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0623932+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228100",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 228100,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1977,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914",
      "ID": 5037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1839,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5843646+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2345E10P55VM291678",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291678,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1977,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914",
      "ID": 5037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2345,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.137606+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2223E176P333VM310679",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 310679,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1977,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914",
      "ID": 5037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2223,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish",
      "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5813747+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246321",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 246321,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1977,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914",
      "ID": 5037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2182,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1236714+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298167",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298167,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1977,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914",
      "ID": 5037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5079,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew",
      "DisplayName": "Drew Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1410935+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234352",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234352,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1977,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914",
      "ID": 5037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1769,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3735777+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4014E14P26VM269945",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269945,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1977,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914",
      "ID": 5037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4014,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz",
      "DisplayName": "Liz Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5746184+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269177",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269177,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1977,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914",
      "ID": 5037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2215,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.3070058+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317180",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317180,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1977,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914",
      "ID": 5037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3806,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.1851356+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326276",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 326276,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1977,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914",
      "ID": 5037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5106,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin",
      "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7514679+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241112",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241112,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1977,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914",
      "ID": 5037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1848,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola",
      "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.4024723+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2098E237P531VM289595",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289595,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1977,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914",
      "ID": 5037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2098,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Swinney",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4507944+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2674E247P401VM247739",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247739,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1977,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914",
      "ID": 5037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2674,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave",
      "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4263382+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5075E234P371VM284857",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 284857,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1977,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914",
      "ID": 5037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5075,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Torrance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0507096+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1793E151P9VM222445",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 222445,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1977,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914",
      "ID": 5037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1793,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean",
      "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1892729+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5078E245P7VM307077",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307077,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1977,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914",
      "ID": 5037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5078,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Walker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5862944+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1841E231P426VM240166",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 240166,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1977,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914",
      "ID": 5037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1841,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen",
      "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7818084+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283408",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283408,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1977,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914",
      "ID": 5037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4952,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.6994138+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1865E263P500VM232243",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232243,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1977,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914",
      "ID": 5037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1865,
      "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra",
      "DisplayName": "Sandra White",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8463313+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237814",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237814,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1977,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914",
      "ID": 5037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2610,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Wilson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2272248+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309302",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 309302,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1977,
      "AgendaID": 2532,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Further Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04914",
      "ID": 5037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4941,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza",
      "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3234616+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252711",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252711,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1973,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.4",
      "ID": 5016
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1926,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian",
      "DisplayName": "Brian Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7502775+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2615E213P388VM258935",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258935,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1973,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.4",
      "ID": 5016
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2615,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George",
      "DisplayName": "George Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3346059+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319582",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319582,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1973,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.4",
      "ID": 5016
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4940,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare",
      "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.932244+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249490",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 249490,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1973,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.4",
      "ID": 5016
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2641,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair",
      "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.929128+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1783E21P273VM227829",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227829,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1973,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.4",
      "ID": 5016
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1783,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie",
      "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5674404+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2633E97P136VM280830",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280830,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1973,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.4",
      "ID": 5016
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2633,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire",
      "DisplayName": "Claire Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.784212+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262737",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262737,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1973,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.4",
      "ID": 5016
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2603,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6146938+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1759E91P115VM229823",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229823,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1973,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.4",
      "ID": 5016
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia",
      "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0989478+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3751E243P383VM269782",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269782,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1973,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.4",
      "ID": 5016
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3751,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5627209+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322636",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 322636,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1973,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.4",
      "ID": 5016
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5109,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco",
      "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6972391+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5060E86P124VM295274",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295274,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1973,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.4",
      "ID": 5016
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5060,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5049511+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242916",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242916,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1973,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.4",
      "ID": 5016
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1866,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah",
      "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0410572+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235154",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235154,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1973,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.4",
      "ID": 5016
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1943,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic",
      "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4217172+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302389",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 302389,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1973,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.4",
      "ID": 5016
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2595,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin",
      "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5222839+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244266",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244266,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1973,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.4",
      "ID": 5016
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2103,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith",
      "DisplayName": "Keith Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5472468+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327069",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 327069,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1973,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.4",
      "ID": 5016
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7975131+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277076",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277076,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1973,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.4",
      "ID": 5016
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.7000658+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264253",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264253,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1973,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.4",
      "ID": 5016
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2673,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick",
      "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1253375+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248689",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248689,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1973,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.4",
      "ID": 5016
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2678,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson",
      "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6656056+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2123E27P233VM295768",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295768,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1973,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.4",
      "ID": 5016
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2123,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm",
      "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5350587+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285241",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285241,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1973,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.4",
      "ID": 5016
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3907,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3144814+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230717",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230717,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1973,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.4",
      "ID": 5016
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1735,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela",
      "DisplayName": "Angela Constance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3425081+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243803",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 243803,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1973,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.4",
      "ID": 5016
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1932,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce",
      "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3204123+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254857",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254857,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1973,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.4",
      "ID": 5016
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1863,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna",
      "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2867558+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323522",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 323522,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1973,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.4",
      "ID": 5016
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4976,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth",
      "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9600096+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5107E223P379VM291247",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291247,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1973,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.4",
      "ID": 5016
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5107,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1106302+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3743E222P391VM265413",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265413,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1973,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.4",
      "ID": 5016
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3743,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel",
      "DisplayName": "Nigel Don",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4381007+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262336",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262336,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1973,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.4",
      "ID": 5016
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3771,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob",
      "DisplayName": "Bob Doris",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.5970835+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281910",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 281910,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1973,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.4",
      "ID": 5016
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2826,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Dornan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1630444+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298216",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298216,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1973,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.4",
      "ID": 5016
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3812,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia",
      "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3361758+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231215",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231215,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1973,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.4",
      "ID": 5016
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1778,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen",
      "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.5853427+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4955E240P389VM285854",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285854,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1973,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.4",
      "ID": 5016
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4955,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3473889+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219476",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 219476,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1973,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.4",
      "ID": 5016
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1742,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle",
      "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3009149+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238491",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 238491,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1973,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.4",
      "ID": 5016
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1994,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus",
      "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4564029+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225145",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225145,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1973,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.4",
      "ID": 5016
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1814,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda",
      "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7463819+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321824",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 321824,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1973,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.4",
      "ID": 5016
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Fee",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4529291+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292790",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 292790,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1973,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.4",
      "ID": 5016
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia",
      "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5582451+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227200",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227200,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1973,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.4",
      "ID": 5016
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5351464+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5054E95P118VM312748",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 312748,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1973,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.4",
      "ID": 5016
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5054,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1416382+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4947E152P8VM257792",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257792,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1973,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.4",
      "ID": 5016
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4947,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Finnie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0778091+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271209",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271209,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1973,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.4",
      "ID": 5016
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3901,
      "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe",
      "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0603293+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278047",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 278047,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1973,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.4",
      "ID": 5016
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2394,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo",
      "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9847212+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2110E220P414VM287284",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 287284,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1973,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.4",
      "ID": 5016
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth",
      "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8575459+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250609",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250609,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1973,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.4",
      "ID": 5016
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2675,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob",
      "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1969338+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221072",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221072,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1973,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.4",
      "ID": 5016
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1741,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel",
      "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6738693+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220169",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220169,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1973,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.4",
      "ID": 5016
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1756,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine",
      "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3373278+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1860E104P150VM252409",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252409,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1973,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.4",
      "ID": 5016
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1860,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda",
      "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7279099+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2033E20P141VM253814",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253814,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1973,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.4",
      "ID": 5016
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2033,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain",
      "DisplayName": "Iain Gray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0220448+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324729",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324729,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1973,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.4",
      "ID": 5016
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5042,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2353888+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259636",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 259636,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1973,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.4",
      "ID": 5016
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick",
      "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6180049+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239405",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239405,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1973,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.4",
      "ID": 5016
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2029,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh",
      "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7353935+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273724",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 273724,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1973,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.4",
      "ID": 5016
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3758,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6329524+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304096",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 304096,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1973,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.4",
      "ID": 5016
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4086,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Hume",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8495096+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221622",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221622,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1973,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.4",
      "ID": 5016
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1773,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9406813+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1882E227P459VM241853",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241853,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1973,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.4",
      "ID": 5016
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1882,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam",
      "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7828546+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223467",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223467,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1973,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.4",
      "ID": 5016
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1893,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4593641+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307799",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307799,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1973,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.4",
      "ID": 5016
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4934,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8454174+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272344",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 272344,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1973,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.4",
      "ID": 5016
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4956,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Keir",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3312915+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244925",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244925,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1973,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.4",
      "ID": 5016
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Kelly",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5844688+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315197",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315197,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1973,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.4",
      "ID": 5016
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3129,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6785065+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247863",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247863,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1973,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.4",
      "ID": 5016
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann",
      "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4316528+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4016E11P36VM275031",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 275031,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1973,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.4",
      "ID": 5016
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4016,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1381967+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255559",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255559,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1973,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.4",
      "ID": 5016
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2180,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5365201+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4938E158P374VM277368",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277368,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1973,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.4",
      "ID": 5016
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4938,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9503749+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2112E250P486VM253405",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253405,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1973,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.4",
      "ID": 5016
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2112,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny",
      "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.9949989+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4939E258P394VM276753",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276753,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1973,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.4",
      "ID": 5016
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4939,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus",
      "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.67963+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325402",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 325402,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1973,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.4",
      "ID": 5016
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5074,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon",
      "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.4971423+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1828E3P10VM232912",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232912,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1973,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.4",
      "ID": 5016
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1828,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo",
      "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8819971+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311643",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311643,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1973,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.4",
      "ID": 5016
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4948,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike",
      "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8880137+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2117E90P107VM229705",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229705,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1973,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.4",
      "ID": 5016
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2117,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis",
      "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0931368+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267429",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 267429,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1973,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.4",
      "ID": 5016
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken",
      "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.019441+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313518",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313518,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1973,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.4",
      "ID": 5016
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4966,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek",
      "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.3988345+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3101E102P129VM295011",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295011,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1973,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.4",
      "ID": 5016
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3101,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala",
      "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1883812+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319074",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319074,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1973,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.4",
      "ID": 5016
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5034,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny",
      "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6913008+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306289",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306289,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1973,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.4",
      "ID": 5016
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2159,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Martin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5456527+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5110E252P395VM310792",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 310792,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1973,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.4",
      "ID": 5016
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Mason",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5862553+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268175",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 268175,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1973,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.4",
      "ID": 5016
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2133,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0594368+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2876E141P433VM286398",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286398,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1973,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.4",
      "ID": 5016
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2876,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.577447+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4951E147P368VM258527",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258527,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1973,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.4",
      "ID": 5016
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4951,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan",
      "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3110879+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3896E175P307VM263801",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 263801,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1973,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.4",
      "ID": 5016
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3896,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam",
      "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9053212+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308540",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 308540,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1973,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.4",
      "ID": 5016
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0603182+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4964E143P375VM279749",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279749,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1973,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.4",
      "ID": 5016
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4964,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5209696+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279596",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279596,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1973,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.4",
      "ID": 5016
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3824,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.514483+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2066E22P91VM261064",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261064,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1973,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.4",
      "ID": 5016
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2066,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.1102486+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299602",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 299602,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1973,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.4",
      "ID": 5016
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7046468+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306726",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306726,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1973,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.4",
      "ID": 5016
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina",
      "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5647721+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300608",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 300608,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1973,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.4",
      "ID": 5016
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2487,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0059264+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223976",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223976,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1973,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.4",
      "ID": 5016
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4866863+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237875",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237875,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1973,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.4",
      "ID": 5016
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1961,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David",
      "DisplayName": "David McLetchie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2298439+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305475",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 305475,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1973,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.4",
      "ID": 5016
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2134,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3257114+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320352",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 320352,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1973,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.4",
      "ID": 5016
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5041,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan",
      "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1626724+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315885",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315885,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1973,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.4",
      "ID": 5016
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3763,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart",
      "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9314155+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1986E23P197VM236704",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 236704,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1973,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.4",
      "ID": 5016
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1986,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan",
      "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.936476+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5047E100P130VM289800",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289800,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1973,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.4",
      "ID": 5016
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5047,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne",
      "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4596319+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234528",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234528,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1973,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.4",
      "ID": 5016
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1845,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette",
      "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3881694+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313144",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313144,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1973,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.4",
      "ID": 5016
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3061,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.165553+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1768E19P265VM289330",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289330,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1973,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.4",
      "ID": 5016
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1768,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4326165+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225320",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225320,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1973,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.4",
      "ID": 5016
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1894,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Neil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9694923+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3815E98P134VM270965",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270965,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1973,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.4",
      "ID": 5016
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3815,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Park, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Park",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8366938+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265814",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265814,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1973,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.4",
      "ID": 5016
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2010,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil",
      "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4556531+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283239",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283239,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1973,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.4",
      "ID": 5016
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5057,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.6918713+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2853E33P128VM252011",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252011,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1973,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.4",
      "ID": 5016
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Pentland",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4987207+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317573",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317573,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1973,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.4",
      "ID": 5016
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5009,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4282473+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254242",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254242,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1973,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.4",
      "ID": 5016
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3745,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis",
      "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2470831+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1870E225P478VM296231",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 296231,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1973,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.4",
      "ID": 5016
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1870,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona",
      "DisplayName": "Shona Robison",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8397144+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2135E254P450VM235454",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235454,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1973,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.4",
      "ID": 5016
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2135,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Russell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6785511+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1895E232P431VM257642",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257642,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1973,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.4",
      "ID": 5016
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1895,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0653064+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228569",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 228569,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1973,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.4",
      "ID": 5016
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1839,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.8047458+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2345E10P55VM291610",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291610,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1973,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.4",
      "ID": 5016
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2345,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1347489+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311167",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311167,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1973,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.4",
      "ID": 5016
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2223,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish",
      "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.6085858+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246792",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 246792,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1973,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.4",
      "ID": 5016
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2182,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1536015+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298094",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298094,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1973,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.4",
      "ID": 5016
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5079,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew",
      "DisplayName": "Drew Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1379827+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234126",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234126,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1973,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.4",
      "ID": 5016
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1769,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1677658+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274665",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274665,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1973,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.4",
      "ID": 5016
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4014,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz",
      "DisplayName": "Liz Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1164283+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269595",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269595,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1973,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.4",
      "ID": 5016
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2215,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.554629+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317508",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317508,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1973,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.4",
      "ID": 5016
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3806,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4254283+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326428",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 326428,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1973,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.4",
      "ID": 5016
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5106,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin",
      "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7582883+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241275",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241275,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1973,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.4",
      "ID": 5016
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1848,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola",
      "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7509129+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2098E237P531VM289668",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289668,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1973,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.4",
      "ID": 5016
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2098,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Swinney",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4538508+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248020",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248020,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1973,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.4",
      "ID": 5016
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2674,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave",
      "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4383092+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5075E234P371VM287472",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 287472,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1973,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.4",
      "ID": 5016
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5075,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Torrance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8656365+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1793E151P9VM222564",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 222564,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1973,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.4",
      "ID": 5016
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1793,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean",
      "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1943766+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5078E245P7VM306979",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306979,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1973,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.4",
      "ID": 5016
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5078,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Walker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5821142+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1841E231P426VM239849",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239849,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1973,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.4",
      "ID": 5016
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1841,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen",
      "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.761576+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283682",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283682,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1973,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.4",
      "ID": 5016
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4952,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7187261+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1865E263P500VM231831",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231831,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1973,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.4",
      "ID": 5016
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1865,
      "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra",
      "DisplayName": "Sandra White",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6174107+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237384",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237384,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1973,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.4",
      "ID": 5016
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2610,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Wilson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2018664+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309194",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 309194,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1973,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.4",
      "ID": 5016
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4941,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza",
      "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0963635+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252709",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252709,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1976,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 69,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.3",
      "ID": 5015
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1926,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian",
      "DisplayName": "Brian Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7501973+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2615E213P388VM258933",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258933,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1976,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 69,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.3",
      "ID": 5015
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2615,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George",
      "DisplayName": "George Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.334506+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319840",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319840,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1976,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 69,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.3",
      "ID": 5015
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4940,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare",
      "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.943656+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249594",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 249594,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1976,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 69,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.3",
      "ID": 5015
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2641,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair",
      "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.933558+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1783E21P273VM227827",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227827,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1976,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 69,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.3",
      "ID": 5015
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1783,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie",
      "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.567357+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2633E97P136VM280828",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280828,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1976,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 69,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.3",
      "ID": 5015
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2633,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire",
      "DisplayName": "Claire Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7841102+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262735",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262735,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1976,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 69,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.3",
      "ID": 5015
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2603,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6145938+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1759E91P115VM229821",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229821,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1976,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 69,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.3",
      "ID": 5015
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia",
      "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0988471+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3751E243P383VM269784",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269784,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1976,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 69,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.3",
      "ID": 5015
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3751,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5628+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322634",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 322634,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1976,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 69,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.3",
      "ID": 5015
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5109,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco",
      "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6971568+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5060E86P124VM295272",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295272,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1976,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 69,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.3",
      "ID": 5015
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5060,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5048698+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242913",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242913,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1976,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 69,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.3",
      "ID": 5015
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1866,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah",
      "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0409371+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235156",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235156,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1976,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 69,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.3",
      "ID": 5015
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1943,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic",
      "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4217986+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302387",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 302387,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1976,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 69,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.3",
      "ID": 5015
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2595,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin",
      "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5222014+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244268",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244268,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1976,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 69,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.3",
      "ID": 5015
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2103,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith",
      "DisplayName": "Keith Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5473304+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327156",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 327156,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1976,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 69,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.3",
      "ID": 5015
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.8015913+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277074",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277074,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1976,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 69,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.3",
      "ID": 5015
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6999837+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264255",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264255,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1976,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 69,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.3",
      "ID": 5015
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2673,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick",
      "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.125419+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248691",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248691,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1976,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 69,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.3",
      "ID": 5015
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2678,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson",
      "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6656855+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2123E27P233VM295771",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295771,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1976,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 69,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.3",
      "ID": 5015
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2123,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm",
      "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5352011+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285239",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285239,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1976,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 69,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.3",
      "ID": 5015
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3907,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3143991+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230715",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230715,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1976,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 69,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.3",
      "ID": 5015
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1735,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela",
      "DisplayName": "Angela Constance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3424262+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243806",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 243806,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1976,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 69,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.3",
      "ID": 5015
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1932,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce",
      "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3205321+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254859",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254859,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1976,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 69,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.3",
      "ID": 5015
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1863,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna",
      "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2868392+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323763",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 323763,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1976,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 69,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.3",
      "ID": 5015
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4976,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth",
      "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.970874+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5107E223P379VM291249",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291249,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1976,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 69,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.3",
      "ID": 5015
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5107,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1107311+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3743E222P391VM265411",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265411,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1976,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 69,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.3",
      "ID": 5015
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3743,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel",
      "DisplayName": "Nigel Don",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4380182+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262334",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262334,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1976,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 69,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.3",
      "ID": 5015
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3771,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob",
      "DisplayName": "Bob Doris",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.5970028+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281912",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 281912,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1976,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 69,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.3",
      "ID": 5015
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2826,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Dornan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1631263+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298214",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298214,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1976,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 69,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.3",
      "ID": 5015
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3812,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia",
      "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.336093+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231217",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231217,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1976,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 69,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.3",
      "ID": 5015
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1778,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen",
      "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.5854249+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4955E240P389VM285856",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285856,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1976,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 69,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.3",
      "ID": 5015
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4955,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3474886+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219474",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 219474,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1976,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 69,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.3",
      "ID": 5015
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1742,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle",
      "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3008322+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238493",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 238493,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1976,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 69,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.3",
      "ID": 5015
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1994,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus",
      "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.456484+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225247",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225247,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1976,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 69,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.3",
      "ID": 5015
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1814,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda",
      "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9611539+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321826",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 321826,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1976,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 69,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.3",
      "ID": 5015
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Fee",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4530098+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292792",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 292792,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1976,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 69,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.3",
      "ID": 5015
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia",
      "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5583251+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227198",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227198,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1976,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 69,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.3",
      "ID": 5015
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5350249+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5054E95P118VM312746",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 312746,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1976,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 69,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.3",
      "ID": 5015
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5054,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.141557+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4947E152P8VM257226",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257226,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1976,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 69,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.3",
      "ID": 5015
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4947,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Finnie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0470031+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271211",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271211,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1976,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 69,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.3",
      "ID": 5015
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3901,
      "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe",
      "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0604127+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278049",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 278049,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1976,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 69,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.3",
      "ID": 5015
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2394,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo",
      "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9848028+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2110E220P414VM287282",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 287282,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1976,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 69,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.3",
      "ID": 5015
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth",
      "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8574647+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250504",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250504,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1976,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 69,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.3",
      "ID": 5015
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2675,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob",
      "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1923976+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1741E10P50VM220970",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220970,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1976,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 69,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.3",
      "ID": 5015
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1741,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel",
      "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6695011+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220171",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220171,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1976,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 69,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.3",
      "ID": 5015
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1756,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine",
      "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3374098+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1860E104P150VM252407",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252407,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1976,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 69,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.3",
      "ID": 5015
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1860,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda",
      "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7278296+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2033E20P141VM253816",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253816,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1976,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 69,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.3",
      "ID": 5015
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2033,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain",
      "DisplayName": "Iain Gray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0221241+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324642",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324642,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1976,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 69,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.3",
      "ID": 5015
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5042,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2317394+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259638",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 259638,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1976,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 69,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.3",
      "ID": 5015
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick",
      "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.618089+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239403",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239403,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1976,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 69,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.3",
      "ID": 5015
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2029,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh",
      "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7353113+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273726",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 273726,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1976,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 69,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.3",
      "ID": 5015
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3758,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6330337+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304098",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 304098,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1976,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 69,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.3",
      "ID": 5015
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4086,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Hume",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8495904+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221725",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221725,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1976,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 69,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.3",
      "ID": 5015
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1773,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9450953+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1882E227P459VM241957",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241957,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1976,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 69,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.3",
      "ID": 5015
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1882,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam",
      "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.787653+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223469",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223469,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1976,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 69,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.3",
      "ID": 5015
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1893,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.459452+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307797",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307797,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1976,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 69,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.3",
      "ID": 5015
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4934,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8453353+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272241",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 272241,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1976,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 69,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.3",
      "ID": 5015
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4956,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Keir",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3211216+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244922",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244922,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1976,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 69,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.3",
      "ID": 5015
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Kelly",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5843478+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315092",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315092,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1976,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 69,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.3",
      "ID": 5015
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3129,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.673715+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247865",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247865,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1976,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 69,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.3",
      "ID": 5015
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann",
      "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.431733+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4016E11P36VM275029",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 275029,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1976,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 69,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.3",
      "ID": 5015
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4016,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1381128+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255561",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255561,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1976,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 69,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.3",
      "ID": 5015
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2180,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5366214+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4938E158P374VM277370",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277370,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1976,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 69,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.3",
      "ID": 5015
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4938,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9504576+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2112E250P486VM253403",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253403,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1976,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 69,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.3",
      "ID": 5015
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2112,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny",
      "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.9949171+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4939E258P394VM276755",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276755,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1976,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 69,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.3",
      "ID": 5015
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4939,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus",
      "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6797172+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325489",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 325489,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1976,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 69,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.3",
      "ID": 5015
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5074,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon",
      "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5085783+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1828E3P10VM232910",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232910,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1976,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 69,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.3",
      "ID": 5015
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1828,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo",
      "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8819162+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311641",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311641,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1976,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 69,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.3",
      "ID": 5015
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4948,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike",
      "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8879111+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2117E90P107VM229707",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229707,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1976,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 69,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.3",
      "ID": 5015
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2117,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis",
      "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0932171+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267427",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 267427,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1976,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 69,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.3",
      "ID": 5015
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken",
      "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0193576+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313520",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313520,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1976,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 69,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.3",
      "ID": 5015
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4966,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek",
      "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.3989165+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3101E102P129VM295013",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295013,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1976,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 69,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.3",
      "ID": 5015
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3101,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala",
      "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1884626+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319076",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319076,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1976,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 69,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.3",
      "ID": 5015
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5034,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny",
      "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6913822+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306394",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306394,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1976,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 69,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.3",
      "ID": 5015
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2159,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Martin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5502149+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5110E252P395VM310794",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 310794,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1976,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 69,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.3",
      "ID": 5015
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Mason",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5863362+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268177",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 268177,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1976,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 69,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.3",
      "ID": 5015
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2133,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0595191+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2876E141P433VM286396",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286396,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1976,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 69,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.3",
      "ID": 5015
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2876,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5773451+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4951E147P368VM258630",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258630,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1976,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 69,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.3",
      "ID": 5015
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4951,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan",
      "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3157844+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3896E175P307VM263803",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 263803,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1976,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 69,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.3",
      "ID": 5015
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3896,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam",
      "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9054028+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308538",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 308538,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1976,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 69,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.3",
      "ID": 5015
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0602176+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4964E143P375VM279747",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279747,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1976,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 69,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.3",
      "ID": 5015
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4964,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5208697+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279598",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279598,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1976,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 69,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.3",
      "ID": 5015
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3824,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5145652+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2066E22P91VM261067",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261067,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1976,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 69,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.3",
      "ID": 5015
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2066,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.1103742+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299604",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 299604,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1976,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 69,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.3",
      "ID": 5015
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7047296+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306724",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306724,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1976,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 69,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.3",
      "ID": 5015
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina",
      "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5646711+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300610",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 300610,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1976,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 69,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.3",
      "ID": 5015
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2487,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0060257+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223873",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223873,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1976,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 69,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.3",
      "ID": 5015
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4774438+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237873",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237873,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1976,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 69,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.3",
      "ID": 5015
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1961,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David",
      "DisplayName": "David McLetchie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2297425+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305473",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 305473,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1976,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 69,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.3",
      "ID": 5015
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2134,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3256234+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320350",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 320350,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1976,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 69,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.3",
      "ID": 5015
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5041,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan",
      "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1562425+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315990",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315990,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1976,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 69,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.3",
      "ID": 5015
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3763,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart",
      "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9410049+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1986E23P197VM236702",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 236702,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1976,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 69,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.3",
      "ID": 5015
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1986,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan",
      "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9363924+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5047E100P130VM289802",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289802,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1976,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 69,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.3",
      "ID": 5015
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5047,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne",
      "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4597114+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234530",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234530,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1976,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 69,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.3",
      "ID": 5015
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1845,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette",
      "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.388252+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313560",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313560,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1976,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 69,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.3",
      "ID": 5015
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3061,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4006618+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1768E19P265VM289328",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289328,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1976,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 69,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.3",
      "ID": 5015
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1768,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4325352+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225318",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225318,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1976,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 69,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.3",
      "ID": 5015
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1894,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Neil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9693636+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3815E98P134VM270963",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270963,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1976,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 69,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.3",
      "ID": 5015
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3815,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Park, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Park",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8366122+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265816",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265816,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1976,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 69,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.3",
      "ID": 5015
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2010,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil",
      "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.455736+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283241",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283241,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1976,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 69,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.3",
      "ID": 5015
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5057,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.691954+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2853E33P128VM251548",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251548,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1976,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 69,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.3",
      "ID": 5015
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Pentland",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4684662+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317571",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317571,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1976,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 69,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.3",
      "ID": 5015
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5009,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4281675+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254659",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254659,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1976,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 69,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.3",
      "ID": 5015
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3745,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis",
      "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2661078+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1870E225P478VM296229",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 296229,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1976,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 69,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.3",
      "ID": 5015
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1870,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona",
      "DisplayName": "Shona Robison",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8396324+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2135E254P450VM235452",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235452,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1976,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 69,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.3",
      "ID": 5015
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2135,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Russell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6784697+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1895E232P431VM257640",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257640,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1976,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 69,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.3",
      "ID": 5015
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1895,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0652246+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228158",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 228158,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1976,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 69,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.3",
      "ID": 5015
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1839,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5868389+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2345E10P55VM291612",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291612,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1976,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 69,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.3",
      "ID": 5015
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2345,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1348275+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311061",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311061,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1976,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 69,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.3",
      "ID": 5015
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2223,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish",
      "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.6037404+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246379",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 246379,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1976,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 69,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.3",
      "ID": 5015
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2182,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1261866+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298096",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298096,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1976,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 69,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.3",
      "ID": 5015
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5079,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew",
      "DisplayName": "Drew Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1380825+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234128",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234128,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1976,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 69,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.3",
      "ID": 5015
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1769,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1678482+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274663",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274663,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1976,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 69,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.3",
      "ID": 5015
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4014,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz",
      "DisplayName": "Liz Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1163459+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269593",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269593,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1976,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 69,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.3",
      "ID": 5015
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2215,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5545481+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317403",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317403,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1976,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 69,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.3",
      "ID": 5015
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3806,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4206213+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326341",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 326341,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1976,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 69,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.3",
      "ID": 5015
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5106,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin",
      "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7542679+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241171",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241171,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1976,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 69,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.3",
      "ID": 5015
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1848,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola",
      "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.4050846+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2098E237P531VM289665",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289665,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1976,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 69,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.3",
      "ID": 5015
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2098,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Swinney",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4537315+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248018",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248018,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1976,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 69,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.3",
      "ID": 5015
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2674,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave",
      "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4382277+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5075E234P371VM287470",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 287470,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1976,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 69,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.3",
      "ID": 5015
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5075,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Torrance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8655556+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1793E151P9VM222562",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 222562,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1976,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 69,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.3",
      "ID": 5015
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1793,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean",
      "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1942764+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5078E245P7VM306981",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306981,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1976,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 69,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.3",
      "ID": 5015
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5078,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Walker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5821961+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1841E231P426VM239952",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239952,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1976,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 69,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.3",
      "ID": 5015
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1841,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen",
      "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7663931+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283680",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283680,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1976,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 69,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.3",
      "ID": 5015
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4952,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7186463+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1865E263P500VM231833",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231833,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1976,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 69,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.3",
      "ID": 5015
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1865,
      "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra",
      "DisplayName": "Sandra White",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6174936+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237386",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237386,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1976,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 69,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.3",
      "ID": 5015
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2610,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Wilson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2019496+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309196",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 309196,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1976,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 69,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.3",
      "ID": 5015
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4941,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza",
      "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0964448+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252710",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252710,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1972,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.2",
      "ID": 5013
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1926,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian",
      "DisplayName": "Brian Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7502378+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2615E213P388VM258934",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258934,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1972,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.2",
      "ID": 5013
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2615,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George",
      "DisplayName": "George Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3345464+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319839",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319839,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1972,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.2",
      "ID": 5013
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4940,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare",
      "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9436139+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249491",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 249491,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1972,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.2",
      "ID": 5013
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2641,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair",
      "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9291692+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1783E21P273VM227828",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227828,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1972,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.2",
      "ID": 5013
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1783,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie",
      "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5673986+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2633E97P136VM280829",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280829,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1972,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.2",
      "ID": 5013
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2633,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire",
      "DisplayName": "Claire Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7841708+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262736",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262736,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1972,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.2",
      "ID": 5013
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2603,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6146353+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1759E91P115VM229822",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229822,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1972,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.2",
      "ID": 5013
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia",
      "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0988872+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3751E243P383VM269783",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269783,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1972,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.2",
      "ID": 5013
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3751,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5627607+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322635",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 322635,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1972,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.2",
      "ID": 5013
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5109,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco",
      "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6971983+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5060E86P124VM295273",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295273,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1972,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.2",
      "ID": 5013
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5060,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5049104+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242914",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242914,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1972,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.2",
      "ID": 5013
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1866,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah",
      "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0409773+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235155",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235155,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1972,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.2",
      "ID": 5013
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1943,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic",
      "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4217578+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302388",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 302388,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1972,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.2",
      "ID": 5013
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2595,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin",
      "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5222431+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244267",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244267,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1972,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.2",
      "ID": 5013
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2103,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith",
      "DisplayName": "Keith Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5472892+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327147",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 327147,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1972,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.2",
      "ID": 5013
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.8011713+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277075",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277075,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1972,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.2",
      "ID": 5013
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.7000243+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264254",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264254,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1972,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.2",
      "ID": 5013
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2673,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick",
      "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1253784+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248690",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248690,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1972,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.2",
      "ID": 5013
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2678,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson",
      "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6656452+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2123E27P233VM295770",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295770,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1972,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.2",
      "ID": 5013
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2123,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm",
      "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5351603+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285240",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285240,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1972,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.2",
      "ID": 5013
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3907,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3144403+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230716",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230716,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1972,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.2",
      "ID": 5013
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1735,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela",
      "DisplayName": "Angela Constance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3424669+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243805",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 243805,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1972,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.2",
      "ID": 5013
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1932,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce",
      "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3204924+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254858",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254858,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1972,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.2",
      "ID": 5013
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1863,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna",
      "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.286798+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323754",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 323754,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1972,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.2",
      "ID": 5013
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4976,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth",
      "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9704743+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5107E223P379VM291248",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291248,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1972,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.2",
      "ID": 5013
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5107,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1106887+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3743E222P391VM265412",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265412,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1972,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.2",
      "ID": 5013
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3743,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel",
      "DisplayName": "Nigel Don",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4380596+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262335",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262335,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1972,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.2",
      "ID": 5013
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3771,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob",
      "DisplayName": "Bob Doris",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.5970435+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281911",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 281911,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1972,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.2",
      "ID": 5013
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2826,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Dornan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1630857+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298215",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298215,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1972,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.2",
      "ID": 5013
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3812,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia",
      "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3361343+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231216",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231216,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1972,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.2",
      "ID": 5013
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1778,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen",
      "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.5853841+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4955E240P389VM285855",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285855,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1972,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.2",
      "ID": 5013
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4955,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.347429+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219475",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 219475,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1972,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.2",
      "ID": 5013
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1742,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle",
      "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3008737+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238492",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 238492,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1972,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.2",
      "ID": 5013
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1994,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus",
      "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4564438+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225146",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225146,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1972,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.2",
      "ID": 5013
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1814,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda",
      "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7464402+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321825",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 321825,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1972,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.2",
      "ID": 5013
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Fee",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4529694+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292791",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 292791,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1972,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.2",
      "ID": 5013
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia",
      "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5582848+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227199",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227199,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1972,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.2",
      "ID": 5013
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5351023+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5054E95P118VM312747",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 312747,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1972,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.2",
      "ID": 5013
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5054,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1415972+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4947E152P8VM257791",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257791,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1972,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.2",
      "ID": 5013
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4947,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Finnie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0777684+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271210",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271210,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1972,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.2",
      "ID": 5013
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3901,
      "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe",
      "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0603714+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278048",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 278048,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1972,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.2",
      "ID": 5013
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2394,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo",
      "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9847623+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2110E220P414VM287283",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 287283,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1972,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.2",
      "ID": 5013
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth",
      "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8575058+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250608",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250608,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1972,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.2",
      "ID": 5013
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2675,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob",
      "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1968937+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221071",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221071,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1972,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.2",
      "ID": 5013
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1741,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel",
      "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.673823+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220170",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220170,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1972,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.2",
      "ID": 5013
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1756,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine",
      "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3373688+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1860E104P150VM252408",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252408,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1972,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.2",
      "ID": 5013
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1860,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda",
      "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7278699+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2033E20P141VM253815",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253815,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1972,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.2",
      "ID": 5013
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2033,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain",
      "DisplayName": "Iain Gray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0220843+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324651",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324651,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1972,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.2",
      "ID": 5013
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5042,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2321211+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259637",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 259637,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1972,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.2",
      "ID": 5013
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick",
      "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6180471+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239404",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239404,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1972,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.2",
      "ID": 5013
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2029,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh",
      "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7353526+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273725",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 273725,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1972,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.2",
      "ID": 5013
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3758,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6329928+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304097",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 304097,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1972,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.2",
      "ID": 5013
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4086,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Hume",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8495499+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221623",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221623,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1972,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.2",
      "ID": 5013
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1773,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9407239+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1882E227P459VM241854",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241854,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1972,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.2",
      "ID": 5013
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1882,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam",
      "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7828944+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223468",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223468,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1972,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.2",
      "ID": 5013
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1893,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4594102+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307798",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307798,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1972,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.2",
      "ID": 5013
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4934,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8453763+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272343",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 272343,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1972,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.2",
      "ID": 5013
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4956,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Keir",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3312514+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244923",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244923,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1972,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.2",
      "ID": 5013
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Kelly",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5843873+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315093",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315093,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1972,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.2",
      "ID": 5013
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3129,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6737555+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247864",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247864,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1972,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.2",
      "ID": 5013
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann",
      "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4316929+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4016E11P36VM275030",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 275030,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1972,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.2",
      "ID": 5013
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4016,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1381545+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255560",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255560,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1972,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.2",
      "ID": 5013
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2180,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5365607+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4938E158P374VM277369",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277369,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1972,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.2",
      "ID": 5013
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4938,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9504163+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2112E250P486VM253404",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253404,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1972,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.2",
      "ID": 5013
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2112,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny",
      "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.9949581+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4939E258P394VM276754",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276754,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1972,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.2",
      "ID": 5013
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4939,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus",
      "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6796702+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325480",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 325480,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1972,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.2",
      "ID": 5013
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5074,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon",
      "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5081918+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1828E3P10VM232911",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232911,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1972,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.2",
      "ID": 5013
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1828,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo",
      "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8819566+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311642",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311642,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1972,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.2",
      "ID": 5013
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4948,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike",
      "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8879531+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2117E90P107VM229706",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229706,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1972,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.2",
      "ID": 5013
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2117,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis",
      "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0931769+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267428",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 267428,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1972,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.2",
      "ID": 5013
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken",
      "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0193994+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313519",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313519,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1972,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.2",
      "ID": 5013
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4966,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek",
      "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.3988751+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3101E102P129VM295012",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295012,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1972,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.2",
      "ID": 5013
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3101,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala",
      "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.188422+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319075",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319075,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1972,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.2",
      "ID": 5013
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5034,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny",
      "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6913417+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306393",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306393,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1972,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.2",
      "ID": 5013
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2159,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Martin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5501741+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5110E252P395VM310793",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 310793,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1972,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.2",
      "ID": 5013
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Mason",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5862963+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268176",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 268176,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1972,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.2",
      "ID": 5013
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2133,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0594777+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2876E141P433VM286397",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286397,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1972,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.2",
      "ID": 5013
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2876,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5774051+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4951E147P368VM258528",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258528,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1972,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.2",
      "ID": 5013
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4951,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan",
      "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3111296+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3896E175P307VM263802",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 263802,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1972,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.2",
      "ID": 5013
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3896,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam",
      "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9053624+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308539",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 308539,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1972,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.2",
      "ID": 5013
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0602762+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4964E143P375VM279748",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279748,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1972,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.2",
      "ID": 5013
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4964,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.52091+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279597",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279597,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1972,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.2",
      "ID": 5013
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3824,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5145246+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2066E22P91VM261066",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261066,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1972,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.2",
      "ID": 5013
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2066,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.1103322+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299603",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 299603,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1972,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.2",
      "ID": 5013
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7046882+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306725",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306725,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1972,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.2",
      "ID": 5013
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina",
      "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5647298+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300609",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 300609,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1972,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.2",
      "ID": 5013
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2487,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.005985+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223975",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223975,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1972,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.2",
      "ID": 5013
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4866443+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237874",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237874,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1972,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.2",
      "ID": 5013
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1961,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David",
      "DisplayName": "David McLetchie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2298017+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305474",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 305474,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1972,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.2",
      "ID": 5013
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2134,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3256698+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320351",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 320351,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1972,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.2",
      "ID": 5013
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5041,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan",
      "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1562842+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315989",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315989,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1972,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.2",
      "ID": 5013
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3763,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart",
      "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9409445+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1986E23P197VM236703",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 236703,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1972,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.2",
      "ID": 5013
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1986,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan",
      "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9364332+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5047E100P130VM289801",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289801,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1972,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.2",
      "ID": 5013
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5047,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne",
      "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4596716+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234529",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234529,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1972,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.2",
      "ID": 5013
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1845,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette",
      "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3882102+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313559",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313559,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1972,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.2",
      "ID": 5013
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3061,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.400621+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1768E19P265VM289329",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289329,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1972,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.2",
      "ID": 5013
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1768,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.432576+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225319",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225319,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1972,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.2",
      "ID": 5013
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1894,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Neil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9694055+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3815E98P134VM270964",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270964,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1972,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.2",
      "ID": 5013
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3815,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Park, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Park",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8366535+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265815",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265815,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1972,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.2",
      "ID": 5013
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2010,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil",
      "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4556945+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283240",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283240,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1972,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.2",
      "ID": 5013
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5057,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.6919128+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2853E33P128VM251549",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251549,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1972,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.2",
      "ID": 5013
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Pentland",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.468509+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317572",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317572,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1972,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.2",
      "ID": 5013
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5009,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4282074+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254243",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254243,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1972,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.2",
      "ID": 5013
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3745,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis",
      "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2471241+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1870E225P478VM296230",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 296230,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1972,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.2",
      "ID": 5013
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1870,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona",
      "DisplayName": "Shona Robison",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8396731+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2135E254P450VM235453",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235453,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1972,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.2",
      "ID": 5013
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2135,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Russell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.678511+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1895E232P431VM257641",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257641,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1972,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.2",
      "ID": 5013
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1895,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0652656+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228568",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 228568,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1972,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.2",
      "ID": 5013
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1839,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.8047049+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2345E10P55VM291611",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291611,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1972,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.2",
      "ID": 5013
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2345,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1347883+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311062",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311062,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1972,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.2",
      "ID": 5013
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2223,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish",
      "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.603787+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246791",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 246791,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1972,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.2",
      "ID": 5013
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2182,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1535611+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298095",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298095,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1972,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.2",
      "ID": 5013
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5079,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew",
      "DisplayName": "Drew Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1380229+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234127",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234127,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1972,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.2",
      "ID": 5013
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1769,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1678073+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274664",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274664,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1972,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.2",
      "ID": 5013
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4014,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz",
      "DisplayName": "Liz Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1163872+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269594",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269594,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1972,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.2",
      "ID": 5013
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2215,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5545884+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317404",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317404,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1972,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.2",
      "ID": 5013
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3806,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4206627+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326350",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 326350,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1972,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.2",
      "ID": 5013
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5106,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin",
      "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7546952+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241274",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241274,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1972,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.2",
      "ID": 5013
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1848,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola",
      "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7508718+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2098E237P531VM289666",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289666,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1972,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.2",
      "ID": 5013
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2098,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Swinney",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4537712+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248019",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248019,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1972,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.2",
      "ID": 5013
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2674,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave",
      "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4382692+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5075E234P371VM287471",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 287471,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1972,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.2",
      "ID": 5013
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5075,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Torrance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8655961+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1793E151P9VM222563",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 222563,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1972,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.2",
      "ID": 5013
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1793,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean",
      "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.194317+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5078E245P7VM306980",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306980,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1972,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.2",
      "ID": 5013
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5078,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Walker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5821557+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1841E231P426VM239850",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239850,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1972,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.2",
      "ID": 5013
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1841,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen",
      "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7616169+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283681",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283681,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1972,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.2",
      "ID": 5013
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4952,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7186865+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1865E263P500VM231832",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231832,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1972,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.2",
      "ID": 5013
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1865,
      "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra",
      "DisplayName": "Sandra White",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6174522+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237385",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237385,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1972,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.2",
      "ID": 5013
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2610,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Wilson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2019084+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309195",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 309195,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1972,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.2",
      "ID": 5013
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4941,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza",
      "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0964046+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252712",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252712,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1974,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 2,
      "VoteAgainst": 110,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.1",
      "ID": 5006
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1926,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian",
      "DisplayName": "Brian Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7503181+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2615E213P388VM258936",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258936,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1974,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 2,
      "VoteAgainst": 110,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.1",
      "ID": 5006
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2615,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George",
      "DisplayName": "George Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3346476+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319581",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319581,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1974,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 2,
      "VoteAgainst": 110,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.1",
      "ID": 5006
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4940,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare",
      "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9322027+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249489",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 249489,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1974,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 2,
      "VoteAgainst": 110,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.1",
      "ID": 5006
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2641,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair",
      "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9290858+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1783E21P273VM227830",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227830,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1974,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 2,
      "VoteAgainst": 110,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.1",
      "ID": 5006
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1783,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie",
      "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5674821+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2633E97P136VM280864",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280864,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1974,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 2,
      "VoteAgainst": 110,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.1",
      "ID": 5006
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2633,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire",
      "DisplayName": "Claire Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7856476+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262804",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262804,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1974,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 2,
      "VoteAgainst": 110,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.1",
      "ID": 5006
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2603,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6236713+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1759E91P115VM229824",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229824,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1974,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 2,
      "VoteAgainst": 110,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.1",
      "ID": 5006
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia",
      "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0989894+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3751E243P383VM269781",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269781,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1974,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 2,
      "VoteAgainst": 110,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.1",
      "ID": 5006
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3751,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5626805+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322587",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 322587,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1974,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 2,
      "VoteAgainst": 110,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.1",
      "ID": 5006
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5109,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco",
      "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6951226+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5060E86P124VM295341",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295341,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1974,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 2,
      "VoteAgainst": 110,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.1",
      "ID": 5006
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5060,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5080367+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1866E93P239VM243021",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 243021,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1974,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 2,
      "VoteAgainst": 110,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.1",
      "ID": 5006
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1866,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah",
      "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0455359+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235153",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235153,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1974,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 2,
      "VoteAgainst": 110,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.1",
      "ID": 5006
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1943,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic",
      "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4216762+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302390",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 302390,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1974,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 2,
      "VoteAgainst": 110,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.1",
      "ID": 5006
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2595,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin",
      "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5223241+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244199",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244199,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1974,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 2,
      "VoteAgainst": 110,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.1",
      "ID": 5006
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2103,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith",
      "DisplayName": "Keith Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5442297+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327070",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 327070,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1974,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 2,
      "VoteAgainst": 110,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.1",
      "ID": 5006
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7975539+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277143",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277143,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1974,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 2,
      "VoteAgainst": 110,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.1",
      "ID": 5006
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.7029433+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264031",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264031,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1974,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 2,
      "VoteAgainst": 110,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.1",
      "ID": 5006
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2673,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick",
      "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9212401+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248688",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248688,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1974,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 2,
      "VoteAgainst": 110,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.1",
      "ID": 5006
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2678,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson",
      "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6655658+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2123E27P233VM294891",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 294891,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1974,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 2,
      "VoteAgainst": 110,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.1",
      "ID": 5006
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2123,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm",
      "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1831849+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285308",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285308,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1974,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 2,
      "VoteAgainst": 110,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.1",
      "ID": 5006
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3907,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3174103+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230749",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230749,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1974,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 2,
      "VoteAgainst": 110,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.1",
      "ID": 5006
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1735,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela",
      "DisplayName": "Angela Constance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3438845+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243697",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 243697,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1974,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 2,
      "VoteAgainst": 110,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.1",
      "ID": 5006
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1932,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce",
      "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3159837+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254856",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254856,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1974,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 2,
      "VoteAgainst": 110,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.1",
      "ID": 5006
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1863,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna",
      "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2866956+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323523",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 323523,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1974,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 2,
      "VoteAgainst": 110,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.1",
      "ID": 5006
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4976,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth",
      "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.960051+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5107E223P379VM291246",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291246,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1974,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 2,
      "VoteAgainst": 110,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.1",
      "ID": 5006
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5107,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1105884+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3743E222P391VM273006",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 273006,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1974,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 2,
      "VoteAgainst": 110,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.1",
      "ID": 5006
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3743,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel",
      "DisplayName": "Nigel Don",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3652604+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262337",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262337,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1974,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 2,
      "VoteAgainst": 110,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.1",
      "ID": 5006
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3771,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob",
      "DisplayName": "Bob Doris",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.5971241+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281875",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 281875,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1974,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 2,
      "VoteAgainst": 110,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.1",
      "ID": 5006
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2826,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Dornan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1613605+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298251",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298251,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1974,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 2,
      "VoteAgainst": 110,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.1",
      "ID": 5006
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3812,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia",
      "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3377152+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231214",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231214,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1974,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 2,
      "VoteAgainst": 110,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.1",
      "ID": 5006
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1778,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen",
      "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.5853004+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4955E240P389VM285853",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285853,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1974,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 2,
      "VoteAgainst": 110,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.1",
      "ID": 5006
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4955,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3473484+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219477",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 219477,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1974,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 2,
      "VoteAgainst": 110,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.1",
      "ID": 5006
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1742,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle",
      "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3009564+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238490",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 238490,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1974,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 2,
      "VoteAgainst": 110,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.1",
      "ID": 5006
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1994,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus",
      "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4563614+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225144",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225144,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1974,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 2,
      "VoteAgainst": 110,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.1",
      "ID": 5006
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1814,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda",
      "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.746342+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321873",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 321873,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1974,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 2,
      "VoteAgainst": 110,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.1",
      "ID": 5006
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Fee",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4550043+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292789",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 292789,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1974,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 2,
      "VoteAgainst": 110,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.1",
      "ID": 5006
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia",
      "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5582055+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227201",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227201,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1974,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 2,
      "VoteAgainst": 110,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.1",
      "ID": 5006
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5351886+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5054E95P118VM312749",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 312749,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1974,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 2,
      "VoteAgainst": 110,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.1",
      "ID": 5006
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5054,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1416781+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4947E152P8VM257793",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257793,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1974,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 2,
      "VoteAgainst": 110,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.1",
      "ID": 5006
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4947,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Finnie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0778494+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271208",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271208,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1974,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 2,
      "VoteAgainst": 110,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.1",
      "ID": 5006
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3901,
      "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe",
      "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0602877+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278045",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 278045,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1974,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 2,
      "VoteAgainst": 110,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.1",
      "ID": 5006
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2394,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo",
      "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9846365+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2110E220P414VM287285",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 287285,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1974,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 2,
      "VoteAgainst": 110,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.1",
      "ID": 5006
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth",
      "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8575861+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250610",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250610,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1974,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 2,
      "VoteAgainst": 110,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.1",
      "ID": 5006
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2675,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob",
      "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1969739+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221073",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221073,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1974,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 2,
      "VoteAgainst": 110,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.1",
      "ID": 5006
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1741,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel",
      "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6739118+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220168",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220168,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1974,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 2,
      "VoteAgainst": 110,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.1",
      "ID": 5006
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1756,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine",
      "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3372863+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1860E104P150VM252410",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252410,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1974,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 2,
      "VoteAgainst": 110,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.1",
      "ID": 5006
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1860,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda",
      "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.727951+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2033E20P141VM253813",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253813,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1974,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 2,
      "VoteAgainst": 110,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.1",
      "ID": 5006
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2033,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain",
      "DisplayName": "Iain Gray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0220045+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324728",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324728,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1974,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 2,
      "VoteAgainst": 110,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.1",
      "ID": 5006
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5042,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2353489+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259635",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 259635,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1974,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 2,
      "VoteAgainst": 110,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.1",
      "ID": 5006
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick",
      "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6179468+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239406",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239406,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1974,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 2,
      "VoteAgainst": 110,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.1",
      "ID": 5006
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2029,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh",
      "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7354344+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273657",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 273657,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1974,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 2,
      "VoteAgainst": 110,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.1",
      "ID": 5006
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3758,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6297937+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304095",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 304095,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1974,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 2,
      "VoteAgainst": 110,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.1",
      "ID": 5006
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4086,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Hume",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8494687+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221621",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221621,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1974,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 2,
      "VoteAgainst": 110,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.1",
      "ID": 5006
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1773,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9406185+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1882E227P459VM241852",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241852,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1974,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 2,
      "VoteAgainst": 110,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.1",
      "ID": 5006
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1882,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam",
      "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7828142+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223466",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223466,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1974,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 2,
      "VoteAgainst": 110,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.1",
      "ID": 5006
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1893,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4592996+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307834",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307834,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1974,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 2,
      "VoteAgainst": 110,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.1",
      "ID": 5006
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4934,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.852904+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272345",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 272345,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1974,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 2,
      "VoteAgainst": 110,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.1",
      "ID": 5006
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4956,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Keir",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3313508+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2059E26P131VM245032",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 245032,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1974,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 2,
      "VoteAgainst": 110,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.1",
      "ID": 5006
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Kelly",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5890877+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315198",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315198,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1974,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 2,
      "VoteAgainst": 110,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.1",
      "ID": 5006
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3129,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.678548+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247862",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247862,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1974,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 2,
      "VoteAgainst": 110,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.1",
      "ID": 5006
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann",
      "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4316115+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4016E11P36VM275032",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 275032,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1974,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 2,
      "VoteAgainst": 110,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.1",
      "ID": 5006
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4016,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1382376+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255558",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255558,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1974,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 2,
      "VoteAgainst": 110,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.1",
      "ID": 5006
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2180,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5364802+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4938E158P374VM277367",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277367,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1974,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 2,
      "VoteAgainst": 110,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.1",
      "ID": 5006
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4938,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9503345+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2112E250P486VM253406",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253406,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1974,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 2,
      "VoteAgainst": 110,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.1",
      "ID": 5006
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2112,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny",
      "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.9950403+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4939E258P394VM276752",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276752,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1974,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 2,
      "VoteAgainst": 110,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.1",
      "ID": 5006
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4939,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus",
      "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.67959+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325403",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 325403,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1974,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 2,
      "VoteAgainst": 110,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.1",
      "ID": 5006
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5074,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon",
      "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.4971841+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1828E3P10VM232913",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232913,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1974,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 2,
      "VoteAgainst": 110,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.1",
      "ID": 5006
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1828,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo",
      "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8820375+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311679",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311679,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1974,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 2,
      "VoteAgainst": 110,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.1",
      "ID": 5006
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4948,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike",
      "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8895942+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2117E90P107VM229704",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229704,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1974,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 2,
      "VoteAgainst": 110,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.1",
      "ID": 5006
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2117,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis",
      "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0930965+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267430",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 267430,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1974,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 2,
      "VoteAgainst": 110,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.1",
      "ID": 5006
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken",
      "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0194818+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313482",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313482,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1974,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 2,
      "VoteAgainst": 110,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.1",
      "ID": 5006
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4966,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek",
      "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.3972642+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3101E102P129VM294976",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 294976,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1974,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 2,
      "VoteAgainst": 110,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.1",
      "ID": 5006
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3101,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala",
      "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1868437+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319122",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319122,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1974,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 2,
      "VoteAgainst": 110,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.1",
      "ID": 5006
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5034,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny",
      "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6933957+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306288",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306288,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1974,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 2,
      "VoteAgainst": 110,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.1",
      "ID": 5006
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2159,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Martin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5456123+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5110E252P395VM310791",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 310791,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1974,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 2,
      "VoteAgainst": 110,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.1",
      "ID": 5006
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Mason",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5862129+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268174",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 268174,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1974,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 2,
      "VoteAgainst": 110,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.1",
      "ID": 5006
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2133,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0593961+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2876E141P433VM286433",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286433,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1974,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 2,
      "VoteAgainst": 110,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.1",
      "ID": 5006
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2876,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5789542+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4951E147P368VM258526",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258526,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1974,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 2,
      "VoteAgainst": 110,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.1",
      "ID": 5006
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4951,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan",
      "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3110471+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3896E175P307VM263800",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 263800,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1974,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 2,
      "VoteAgainst": 110,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.1",
      "ID": 5006
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3896,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam",
      "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9052795+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308541",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 308541,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1974,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 2,
      "VoteAgainst": 110,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.1",
      "ID": 5006
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0603583+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4964E143P375VM279750",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279750,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1974,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 2,
      "VoteAgainst": 110,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.1",
      "ID": 5006
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4964,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5210118+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279530",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279530,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1974,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 2,
      "VoteAgainst": 110,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.1",
      "ID": 5006
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3824,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5116599+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2066E22P91VM260488",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 260488,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1974,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 2,
      "VoteAgainst": 110,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.1",
      "ID": 5006
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2066,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.0790563+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299567",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 299567,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1974,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 2,
      "VoteAgainst": 110,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.1",
      "ID": 5006
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.703009+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306727",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306727,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1974,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 2,
      "VoteAgainst": 110,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.1",
      "ID": 5006
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina",
      "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5648131+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300607",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 300607,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1974,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 2,
      "VoteAgainst": 110,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.1",
      "ID": 5006
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2487,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0058862+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223977",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223977,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1974,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 2,
      "VoteAgainst": 110,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.1",
      "ID": 5006
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4867278+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237876",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237876,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1974,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 2,
      "VoteAgainst": 110,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.1",
      "ID": 5006
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1961,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David",
      "DisplayName": "David McLetchie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2298849+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305579",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 305579,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1974,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 2,
      "VoteAgainst": 110,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.1",
      "ID": 5006
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2134,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3304603+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320304",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 320304,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1974,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 2,
      "VoteAgainst": 110,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.1",
      "ID": 5006
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5041,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan",
      "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1542212+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315884",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315884,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1974,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 2,
      "VoteAgainst": 110,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.1",
      "ID": 5006
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3763,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart",
      "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9313743+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1986E23P197VM236772",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 236772,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1974,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 2,
      "VoteAgainst": 110,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.1",
      "ID": 5006
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1986,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan",
      "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9394068+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5047E100P130VM289733",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289733,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1974,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 2,
      "VoteAgainst": 110,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.1",
      "ID": 5006
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5047,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne",
      "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4568124+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234527",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234527,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1974,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 2,
      "VoteAgainst": 110,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.1",
      "ID": 5006
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1845,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette",
      "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3881278+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313143",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313143,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1974,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 2,
      "VoteAgainst": 110,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.1",
      "ID": 5006
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3061,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.165511+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1768E19P265VM289331",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289331,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1974,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 2,
      "VoteAgainst": 110,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.1",
      "ID": 5006
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1768,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4326577+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225321",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225321,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1974,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 2,
      "VoteAgainst": 110,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.1",
      "ID": 5006
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1894,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Neil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.969536+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3815E98P134VM270966",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270966,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1974,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 2,
      "VoteAgainst": 110,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.1",
      "ID": 5006
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3815,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Park, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Park",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8367525+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265813",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265813,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1974,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 2,
      "VoteAgainst": 110,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.1",
      "ID": 5006
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2010,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil",
      "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.455611+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283238",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283238,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1974,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 2,
      "VoteAgainst": 110,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.1",
      "ID": 5006
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5057,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.6918303+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2853E33P128VM252012",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252012,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1974,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 2,
      "VoteAgainst": 110,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.1",
      "ID": 5006
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Pentland",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4987852+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317525",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317525,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1974,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 2,
      "VoteAgainst": 110,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.1",
      "ID": 5006
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5009,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4262082+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254241",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254241,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1974,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 2,
      "VoteAgainst": 110,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.1",
      "ID": 5006
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3745,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis",
      "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.247041+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1870E225P478VM296232",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 296232,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1974,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 2,
      "VoteAgainst": 110,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.1",
      "ID": 5006
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1870,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona",
      "DisplayName": "Shona Robison",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8397555+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2135E254P450VM235455",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235455,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1974,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 2,
      "VoteAgainst": 110,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.1",
      "ID": 5006
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2135,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Russell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6785916+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1895E232P431VM257643",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257643,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1974,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 2,
      "VoteAgainst": 110,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.1",
      "ID": 5006
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1895,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0653466+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228570",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 228570,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1974,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 2,
      "VoteAgainst": 110,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.1",
      "ID": 5006
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1839,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.8047864+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2345E10P55VM291609",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291609,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1974,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 2,
      "VoteAgainst": 110,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.1",
      "ID": 5006
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2345,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1347085+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311168",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311168,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1974,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 2,
      "VoteAgainst": 110,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.1",
      "ID": 5006
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2223,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish",
      "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.6086266+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246793",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 246793,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1974,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 2,
      "VoteAgainst": 110,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.1",
      "ID": 5006
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2182,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1536414+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298026",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298026,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1974,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 2,
      "VoteAgainst": 110,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.1",
      "ID": 5006
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5079,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew",
      "DisplayName": "Drew Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1350883+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234092",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234092,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1974,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 2,
      "VoteAgainst": 110,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.1",
      "ID": 5006
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1769,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1662994+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274666",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274666,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1974,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 2,
      "VoteAgainst": 110,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.1",
      "ID": 5006
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4014,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz",
      "DisplayName": "Liz Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1164689+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269596",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269596,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1974,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 2,
      "VoteAgainst": 110,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.1",
      "ID": 5006
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2215,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5546695+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317509",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317509,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1974,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 2,
      "VoteAgainst": 110,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.1",
      "ID": 5006
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3806,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4254683+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326427",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 326427,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1974,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 2,
      "VoteAgainst": 110,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.1",
      "ID": 5006
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5106,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin",
      "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.758248+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241276",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241276,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1974,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 2,
      "VoteAgainst": 110,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.1",
      "ID": 5006
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1848,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola",
      "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7509539+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2098E237P531VM290391",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 290391,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1974,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 2,
      "VoteAgainst": 110,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.1",
      "ID": 5006
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2098,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Swinney",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7450871+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248021",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248021,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1974,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 2,
      "VoteAgainst": 110,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.1",
      "ID": 5006
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2674,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave",
      "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4383497+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5075E234P371VM287473",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 287473,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1974,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 2,
      "VoteAgainst": 110,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.1",
      "ID": 5006
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5075,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Torrance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8656951+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1793E151P9VM222565",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 222565,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1974,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 2,
      "VoteAgainst": 110,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.1",
      "ID": 5006
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1793,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean",
      "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1944184+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5078E245P7VM306978",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306978,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1974,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 2,
      "VoteAgainst": 110,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.1",
      "ID": 5006
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5078,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Walker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5820725+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1841E231P426VM239848",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239848,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1974,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 2,
      "VoteAgainst": 110,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.1",
      "ID": 5006
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1841,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen",
      "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.761534+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283683",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283683,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1974,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 2,
      "VoteAgainst": 110,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.1",
      "ID": 5006
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4952,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7187657+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1865E263P500VM231830",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231830,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1974,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 2,
      "VoteAgainst": 110,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.1",
      "ID": 5006
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1865,
      "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra",
      "DisplayName": "Sandra White",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6173686+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237383",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237383,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1974,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 2,
      "VoteAgainst": 110,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.1",
      "ID": 5006
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2610,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Wilson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2018257+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309003",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 309003,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1974,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 2,
      "VoteAgainst": 110,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874.1",
      "ID": 5006
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4941,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza",
      "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0873281+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252739",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252739,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1975,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 19,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874",
      "ID": 4999
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1926,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian",
      "DisplayName": "Brian Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7512442+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2615E213P388VM259192",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 259192,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1975,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 19,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874",
      "ID": 4999
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2615,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George",
      "DisplayName": "George Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3456473+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319580",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319580,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1975,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 19,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874",
      "ID": 4999
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4940,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare",
      "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9321619+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249488",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 249488,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1975,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 19,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874",
      "ID": 4999
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2641,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair",
      "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.929026+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1783E21P273VM227864",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227864,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1975,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 19,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874",
      "ID": 4999
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1783,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie",
      "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5689468+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2633E97P136VM280865",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280865,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1975,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 19,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874",
      "ID": 4999
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2633,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire",
      "DisplayName": "Claire Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7856885+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262805",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262805,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1975,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 19,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874",
      "ID": 4999
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2603,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6237136+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1759E91P115VM229825",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229825,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1975,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 19,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874",
      "ID": 4999
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia",
      "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0990311+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3751E243P383VM269679",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269679,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1975,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 19,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874",
      "ID": 4999
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3751,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5583354+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322589",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 322589,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1975,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 19,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874",
      "ID": 4999
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5109,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco",
      "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6952116+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5060E86P124VM295342",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295342,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1975,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 19,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874",
      "ID": 4999
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5060,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5080776+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1866E93P239VM243022",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 243022,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1975,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 19,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874",
      "ID": 4999
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1866,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah",
      "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0455774+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1943E145P367VM227104",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227104,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1975,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 19,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874",
      "ID": 4999
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1943,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic",
      "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2676875+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302391",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 302391,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1975,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 19,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874",
      "ID": 4999
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2595,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin",
      "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5223647+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244198",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244198,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1975,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 19,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874",
      "ID": 4999
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2103,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith",
      "DisplayName": "Keith Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5441831+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327071",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 327071,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1975,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 19,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874",
      "ID": 4999
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.797596+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277144",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277144,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1975,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 19,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874",
      "ID": 4999
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.7029836+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264030",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264030,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1975,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 19,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874",
      "ID": 4999
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2673,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick",
      "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9211984+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248637",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248637,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1975,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 19,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874",
      "ID": 4999
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2678,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson",
      "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6633898+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2123E27P233VM294890",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 294890,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1975,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 19,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874",
      "ID": 4999
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2123,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm",
      "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1831445+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285309",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285309,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1975,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 19,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874",
      "ID": 4999
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3907,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3174518+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230785",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230785,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1975,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 19,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874",
      "ID": 4999
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1735,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela",
      "DisplayName": "Angela Constance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.345427+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243696",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 243696,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1975,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 19,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874",
      "ID": 4999
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1932,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce",
      "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3159258+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254855",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254855,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1975,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 19,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874",
      "ID": 4999
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1863,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna",
      "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2866551+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323524",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 323524,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1975,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 19,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874",
      "ID": 4999
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4976,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth",
      "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9600919+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5107E223P379VM290886",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 290886,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1975,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 19,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874",
      "ID": 4999
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5107,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7763352+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3743E222P391VM273007",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 273007,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1975,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 19,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874",
      "ID": 4999
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3743,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel",
      "DisplayName": "Nigel Don",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3653339+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262542",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262542,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1975,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 19,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874",
      "ID": 4999
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3771,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob",
      "DisplayName": "Bob Doris",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6064085+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281874",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 281874,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1975,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 19,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874",
      "ID": 4999
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2826,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Dornan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1613205+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298253",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298253,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1975,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 19,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874",
      "ID": 4999
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3812,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia",
      "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3377986+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231213",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231213,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1975,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 19,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874",
      "ID": 4999
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1778,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen",
      "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.5852592+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4955E240P389VM284924",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 284924,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1975,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 19,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874",
      "ID": 4999
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4955,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0535484+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219478",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 219478,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1975,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 19,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874",
      "ID": 4999
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1742,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle",
      "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3009977+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238236",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 238236,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1975,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 19,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874",
      "ID": 4999
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1994,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus",
      "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4376869+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225143",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225143,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1975,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 19,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874",
      "ID": 4999
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1814,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda",
      "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7463021+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321871",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 321871,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1975,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 19,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874",
      "ID": 4999
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Fee",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4549236+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292788",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 292788,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1975,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 19,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874",
      "ID": 4999
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia",
      "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5581654+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227202",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227202,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1975,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 19,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874",
      "ID": 4999
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5352317+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5054E95P118VM312750",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 312750,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1975,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 19,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874",
      "ID": 4999
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5054,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1417182+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4947E152P8VM257794",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257794,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1975,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 19,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874",
      "ID": 4999
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4947,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Finnie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0778901+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271056",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271056,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1975,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 19,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874",
      "ID": 4999
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3901,
      "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe",
      "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8406211+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278012",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 278012,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1975,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 19,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874",
      "ID": 4999
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2394,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo",
      "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9831931+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2110E220P414VM287286",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 287286,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1975,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 19,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874",
      "ID": 4999
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth",
      "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8576263+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250611",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250611,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1975,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 19,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874",
      "ID": 4999
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2675,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob",
      "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1970323+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221074",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221074,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1975,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 19,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874",
      "ID": 4999
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1741,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel",
      "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6739526+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220167",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220167,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1975,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 19,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874",
      "ID": 4999
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1756,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine",
      "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3372441+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1860E104P150VM252411",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252411,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1975,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 19,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874",
      "ID": 4999
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1860,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda",
      "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7279915+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2033E20P141VM253781",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253781,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1975,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 19,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874",
      "ID": 4999
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2033,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain",
      "DisplayName": "Iain Gray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0206378+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324727",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324727,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1975,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 19,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874",
      "ID": 4999
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5042,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.235308+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259428",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 259428,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1975,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 19,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874",
      "ID": 4999
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick",
      "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6086864+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239507",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239507,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1975,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 19,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874",
      "ID": 4999
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2029,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh",
      "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7467632+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273656",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 273656,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1975,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 19,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874",
      "ID": 4999
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3758,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6297533+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304094",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 304094,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1975,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 19,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874",
      "ID": 4999
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4086,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Hume",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8494285+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221620",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221620,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1975,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 19,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874",
      "ID": 4999
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1773,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9405783+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1882E227P459VM241851",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241851,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1975,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 19,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874",
      "ID": 4999
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1882,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam",
      "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7827738+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223465",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223465,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1975,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 19,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874",
      "ID": 4999
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1893,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4592583+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307836",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307836,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1975,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 19,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874",
      "ID": 4999
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4934,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8530072+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272346",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 272346,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1975,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 19,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874",
      "ID": 4999
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4956,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Keir",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3313924+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2059E26P131VM245033",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 245033,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1975,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 19,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874",
      "ID": 4999
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Kelly",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5891283+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315199",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315199,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1975,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 19,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874",
      "ID": 4999
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3129,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6785888+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247454",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247454,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1975,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 19,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874",
      "ID": 4999
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann",
      "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4045091+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4016E11P36VM275494",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 275494,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1975,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 19,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874",
      "ID": 4999
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4016,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.3776893+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255456",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255456,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1975,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 19,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874",
      "ID": 4999
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2180,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5321192+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4938E158P374VM276905",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276905,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1975,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 19,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874",
      "ID": 4999
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4938,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6861383+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2112E250P486VM253508",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253508,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1975,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 19,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874",
      "ID": 4999
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2112,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny",
      "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.9994567+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4939E258P394VM276391",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276391,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1975,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 19,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874",
      "ID": 4999
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4939,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus",
      "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6635982+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325404",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 325404,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1975,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 19,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874",
      "ID": 4999
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5074,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon",
      "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.497225+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1828E3P10VM232914",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232914,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1975,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 19,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874",
      "ID": 4999
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1828,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo",
      "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8820795+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311681",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311681,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1975,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 19,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874",
      "ID": 4999
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4948,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike",
      "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.889677+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2117E90P107VM229702",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229702,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1975,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 19,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874",
      "ID": 4999
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2117,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis",
      "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0929961+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267463",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 267463,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1975,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 19,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874",
      "ID": 4999
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken",
      "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0209238+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313480",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313480,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1975,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 19,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874",
      "ID": 4999
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4966,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek",
      "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.397183+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3101E102P129VM294975",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 294975,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1975,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 19,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874",
      "ID": 4999
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3101,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala",
      "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1868021+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319120",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319120,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1975,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 19,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874",
      "ID": 4999
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5034,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny",
      "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6932938+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306287",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306287,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1975,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 19,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874",
      "ID": 4999
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2159,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Martin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5455716+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5110E252P395VM310790",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 310790,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1975,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 19,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874",
      "ID": 4999
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Mason",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5861539+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268141",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 268141,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1975,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 19,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874",
      "ID": 4999
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2133,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0579636+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2876E141P433VM286434",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286434,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1975,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 19,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874",
      "ID": 4999
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2876,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5789963+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4951E147P368VM258525",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258525,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1975,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 19,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874",
      "ID": 4999
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4951,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan",
      "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3110064+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3896E175P307VM263596",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 263596,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1975,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 19,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874",
      "ID": 4999
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3896,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam",
      "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.896291+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308542",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 308542,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1975,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 19,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874",
      "ID": 4999
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0603988+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4964E143P375VM279801",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279801,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1975,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 19,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874",
      "ID": 4999
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4964,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5233807+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279529",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279529,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1975,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 19,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874",
      "ID": 4999
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3824,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5116192+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2066E22P91VM260487",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 260487,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1975,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 19,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874",
      "ID": 4999
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2066,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.0789971+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299565",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 299565,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1975,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 19,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874",
      "ID": 4999
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7029271+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306728",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306728,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1975,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 19,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874",
      "ID": 4999
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina",
      "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5648548+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300606",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 300606,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1975,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 19,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874",
      "ID": 4999
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2487,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0058453+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223978",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223978,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1975,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 19,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874",
      "ID": 4999
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.486769+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237937",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237937,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1975,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 19,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874",
      "ID": 4999
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1961,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David",
      "DisplayName": "David McLetchie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2325095+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305580",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 305580,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1975,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 19,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874",
      "ID": 4999
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2134,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3305015+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320306",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 320306,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1975,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 19,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874",
      "ID": 4999
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5041,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan",
      "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1543265+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315883",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315883,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1975,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 19,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874",
      "ID": 4999
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3763,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart",
      "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9313332+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1986E23P197VM236773",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 236773,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1975,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 19,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874",
      "ID": 4999
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1986,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan",
      "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.939449+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5047E100P130VM289732",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289732,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1975,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 19,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874",
      "ID": 4999
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5047,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne",
      "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4567728+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234526",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234526,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1975,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 19,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874",
      "ID": 4999
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1845,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette",
      "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3880863+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313142",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313142,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1975,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 19,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874",
      "ID": 4999
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3061,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1654699+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1768E19P265VM289332",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289332,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1975,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 19,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874",
      "ID": 4999
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1768,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4326979+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225322",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225322,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1975,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 19,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874",
      "ID": 4999
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1894,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Neil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9695775+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3815E98P134VM270997",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270997,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1975,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 19,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874",
      "ID": 4999
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3815,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Park, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Park",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8380905+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265812",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265812,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1975,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 19,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874",
      "ID": 4999
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2010,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil",
      "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4555509+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283030",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283030,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1975,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 19,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874",
      "ID": 4999
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5057,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.4447577+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2853E33P128VM252063",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252063,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1975,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 19,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874",
      "ID": 4999
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Pentland",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.5009693+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317527",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317527,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1975,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 19,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874",
      "ID": 4999
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5009,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4262904+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254240",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254240,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1975,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 19,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874",
      "ID": 4999
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3745,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis",
      "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2469999+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1870E225P478VM296233",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 296233,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1975,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 19,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874",
      "ID": 4999
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1870,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona",
      "DisplayName": "Shona Robison",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8397974+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2135E254P450VM235509",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235509,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1975,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 19,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874",
      "ID": 4999
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2135,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Russell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6808883+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1895E232P431VM257644",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257644,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1975,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 19,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874",
      "ID": 4999
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1895,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.065388+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228571",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 228571,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1975,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 19,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874",
      "ID": 4999
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1839,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.80485+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2345E10P55VM291608",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291608,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1975,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 19,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874",
      "ID": 4999
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2345,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1346679+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311169",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311169,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1975,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 19,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874",
      "ID": 4999
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2223,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish",
      "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.608691+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246794",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 246794,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1975,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 19,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874",
      "ID": 4999
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2182,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1537002+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298025",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298025,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1975,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 19,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874",
      "ID": 4999
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5079,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew",
      "DisplayName": "Drew Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.135048+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234057",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234057,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1975,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 19,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874",
      "ID": 4999
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1769,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1647757+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274870",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274870,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1975,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 19,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874",
      "ID": 4999
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4014,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz",
      "DisplayName": "Liz Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1255663+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269629",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269629,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1975,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 19,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874",
      "ID": 4999
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2215,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5561539+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317510",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317510,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1975,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 19,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874",
      "ID": 4999
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3806,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4255089+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326426",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 326426,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1975,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 19,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874",
      "ID": 4999
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5106,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin",
      "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7582073+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241277",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241277,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1975,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 19,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874",
      "ID": 4999
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1848,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola",
      "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7509943+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2098E237P531VM290392",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 290392,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1975,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 19,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874",
      "ID": 4999
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2098,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Swinney",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7451287+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248072",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248072,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1975,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 19,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874",
      "ID": 4999
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2674,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave",
      "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4406559+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5075E234P371VM287525",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 287525,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1975,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 19,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874",
      "ID": 4999
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5075,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Torrance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8747302+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1793E151P9VM222566",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 222566,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1975,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 19,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874",
      "ID": 4999
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1793,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean",
      "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.194459+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5078E245P7VM306977",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306977,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1975,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 19,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874",
      "ID": 4999
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5078,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Walker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5820134+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1841E231P426VM239847",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239847,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1975,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 19,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874",
      "ID": 4999
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1841,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen",
      "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7614935+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283987",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283987,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1975,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 19,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874",
      "ID": 4999
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4952,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7320932+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1865E263P500VM231797",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231797,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1975,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 19,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874",
      "ID": 4999
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1865,
      "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra",
      "DisplayName": "Sandra White",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6159461+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237331",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237331,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1975,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 19,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874",
      "ID": 4999
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2610,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Wilson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.1995824+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309001",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 309001,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1975,
      "AgendaID": 2078,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 19,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Air Passenger Duty",
      "Reference": "S4M-04874",
      "ID": 4999
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4941,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza",
      "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-20T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0872465+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1926E229P470VM253115",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253115,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1969,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.2",
      "ID": 4938
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1926,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian",
      "DisplayName": "Brian Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.767426+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2615E213P388VM259556",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 259556,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1969,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.2",
      "ID": 4938
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2615,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George",
      "DisplayName": "George Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6141879+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4940E159P373VM318057",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 318057,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1969,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.2",
      "ID": 4938
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4940,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare",
      "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4550785+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2641E256P403VM250099",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250099,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1969,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.2",
      "ID": 4938
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2641,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair",
      "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9633168+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1783E21P273VM229443",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229443,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1969,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.2",
      "ID": 4938
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1783,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie",
      "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0820138+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2633E97P136VM281596",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 281596,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1969,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.2",
      "ID": 4938
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2633,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire",
      "DisplayName": "Claire Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1495728+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2603E89P148VM263413",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 263413,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1969,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.2",
      "ID": 4938
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2603,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.8883529+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1759E91P115VM227549",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227549,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1969,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.2",
      "ID": 4938
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia",
      "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5549315+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270625",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270625,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1969,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.2",
      "ID": 4938
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3751,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8158453+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322991",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 322991,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1969,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.2",
      "ID": 4938
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5109,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco",
      "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.7125189+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5060E86P124VM297264",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 297264,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1969,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.2",
      "ID": 4938
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5060,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.0922007+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242620",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242620,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1969,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.2",
      "ID": 4938
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1866,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah",
      "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0281556+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1943E145P367VM236597",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 236597,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1969,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.2",
      "ID": 4938
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1943,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic",
      "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9318634+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2595E12P30VM301682",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 301682,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1969,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.2",
      "ID": 4938
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2595,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin",
      "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.272955+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2103E244P421VM261218",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261218,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1969,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.2",
      "ID": 4938
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2103,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith",
      "DisplayName": "Keith Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3479152+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5108E221P387VM326652",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 326652,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1969,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.2",
      "ID": 4938
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7740173+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3775E216P435VM278240",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 278240,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1969,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.2",
      "ID": 4938
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.203684+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264839",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264839,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1969,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.2",
      "ID": 4938
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2673,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick",
      "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1569048+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2678E11P28VM249163",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 249163,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1969,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.2",
      "ID": 4938
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2678,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson",
      "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6865975+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2123E27P233VM291235",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291235,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1969,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.2",
      "ID": 4938
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2123,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm",
      "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1101109+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285630",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285630,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1969,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.2",
      "ID": 4938
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3907,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.337539+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1735E248P405VM233392",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 233392,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1969,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.2",
      "ID": 4938
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1735,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela",
      "DisplayName": "Angela Constance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1222264+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243256",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 243256,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1969,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.2",
      "ID": 4938
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1932,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce",
      "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.2895424+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1863E238P523VM253967",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253967,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1969,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.2",
      "ID": 4938
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1863,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna",
      "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0287952+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4976E20P31VM321375",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 321375,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1969,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.2",
      "ID": 4938
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4976,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth",
      "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4331258+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5107E223P379VM300751",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 300751,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1969,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.2",
      "ID": 4938
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5107,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0173226+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3743E222P391VM273319",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 273319,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1969,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.2",
      "ID": 4938
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3743,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel",
      "DisplayName": "Nigel Don",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6101386+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3771E149P417VM263177",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 263177,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1969,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.2",
      "ID": 4938
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3771,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob",
      "DisplayName": "Bob Doris",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6402587+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2826E262P384VM282286",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 282286,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1969,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.2",
      "ID": 4938
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2826,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Dornan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.4062447+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298984",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298984,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1969,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.2",
      "ID": 4938
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3812,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia",
      "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3807294+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1778E28P260VM230612",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230612,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1969,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.2",
      "ID": 4938
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1778,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen",
      "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3378871+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4955E240P389VM287209",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 287209,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1969,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.2",
      "ID": 4938
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4955,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8543181+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219856",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 219856,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1969,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.2",
      "ID": 4938
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1742,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle",
      "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3176153+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1994E257P537VM239027",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239027,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1969,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.2",
      "ID": 4938
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1994,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus",
      "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4796218+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1814E269P519VM226216",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 226216,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1969,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.2",
      "ID": 4938
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1814,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda",
      "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2149692+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5059E85P123VM322304",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 322304,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1969,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.2",
      "ID": 4938
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Fee",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6770072+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1853E35P216VM291816",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291816,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1969,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.2",
      "ID": 4938
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia",
      "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1437148+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1892E12P64VM228331",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 228331,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1969,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.2",
      "ID": 4938
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.788304+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5054E95P118VM304387",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 304387,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1969,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.2",
      "ID": 4938
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5054,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.0360785+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4947E152P8VM258027",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258027,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1969,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.2",
      "ID": 4938
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4947,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Finnie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0881677+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271619",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271619,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1969,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.2",
      "ID": 4938
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3901,
      "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe",
      "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0839865+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2394E15P47VM279351",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279351,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1969,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.2",
      "ID": 4938
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2394,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo",
      "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.4984378+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2110E220P414VM266496",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 266496,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1969,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.2",
      "ID": 4938
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth",
      "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.7436711+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250832",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250832,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1969,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.2",
      "ID": 4938
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2675,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob",
      "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.2153977+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221297",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221297,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1969,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.2",
      "ID": 4938
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1741,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel",
      "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9259164+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220798",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220798,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1969,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.2",
      "ID": 4938
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1756,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine",
      "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6574638+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1860E104P150VM239806",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239806,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1969,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.2",
      "ID": 4938
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1860,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda",
      "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7597089+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2033E20P141VM266672",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 266672,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1969,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.2",
      "ID": 4938
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2033,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain",
      "DisplayName": "Iain Gray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.7513566+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324326",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324326,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1969,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.2",
      "ID": 4938
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5042,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2119398+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2892E76P97VM260266",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 260266,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1969,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.2",
      "ID": 4938
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick",
      "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.0691219+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2029E24P170VM246493",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 246493,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1969,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.2",
      "ID": 4938
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2029,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh",
      "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1310926+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3758E268P409VM275717",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 275717,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1969,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.2",
      "ID": 4938
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3758,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.3875533+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4086E128P311VM303186",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 303186,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1969,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.2",
      "ID": 4938
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4086,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Hume",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5628385+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1773E242P494VM222231",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 222231,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1969,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.2",
      "ID": 4938
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1773,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1739817+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1882E227P459VM242445",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242445,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1969,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.2",
      "ID": 4938
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1882,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam",
      "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0135662+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1893E16P69VM224471",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 224471,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1969,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.2",
      "ID": 4938
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1893,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7062588+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4934E77P103VM308568",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 308568,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1969,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.2",
      "ID": 4938
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4934,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.061502+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272570",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 272570,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1969,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.2",
      "ID": 4938
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4956,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Keir",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.341078+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244469",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244469,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1969,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.2",
      "ID": 4938
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Kelly",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5560941+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3129E261P419VM314645",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 314645,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1969,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.2",
      "ID": 4938
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3129,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6491529+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2080E36P220VM251953",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251953,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1969,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.2",
      "ID": 4938
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann",
      "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4962259+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4016E11P36VM275588",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 275588,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1969,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.2",
      "ID": 4938
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4016,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.3819924+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2180E246P463VM257010",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257010,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1969,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.2",
      "ID": 4938
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2180,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.8194567+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4938E158P374VM283058",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283058,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1969,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.2",
      "ID": 4938
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4938,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.450489+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2112E250P486VM254174",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254174,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1969,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.2",
      "ID": 4938
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2112,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny",
      "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0378131+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4939E258P394VM278311",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 278311,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1969,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.2",
      "ID": 4938
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4939,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus",
      "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2067503+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5074E251P385VM324959",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324959,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1969,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.2",
      "ID": 4938
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5074,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon",
      "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2451405+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1828E3P10VM231984",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231984,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1969,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.2",
      "ID": 4938
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1828,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo",
      "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6242255+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4948E153P363VM312386",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 312386,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1969,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.2",
      "ID": 4938
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4948,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike",
      "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1256014+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2117E90P107VM232482",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232482,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1969,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.2",
      "ID": 4938
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2117,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis",
      "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8627562+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267789",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 267789,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1969,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.2",
      "ID": 4938
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken",
      "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0350751+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4966E214P378VM314463",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 314463,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1969,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.2",
      "ID": 4938
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4966,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek",
      "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6410745+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3101E102P129VM296158",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 296158,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1969,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.2",
      "ID": 4938
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3101,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala",
      "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.551863+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319709",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319709,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1969,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.2",
      "ID": 4938
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5034,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny",
      "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.937973+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2159E25P205VM305865",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 305865,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1969,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.2",
      "ID": 4938
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2159,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Martin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3486623+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5110E252P395VM309866",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 309866,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1969,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.2",
      "ID": 4938
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Mason",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3543133+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268651",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 268651,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1969,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.2",
      "ID": 4938
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2133,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2767872+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2876E141P433VM293775",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 293775,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1969,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.2",
      "ID": 4938
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2876,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8683789+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4951E147P368VM271368",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271368,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1969,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.2",
      "ID": 4938
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4951,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan",
      "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0727934+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3896E175P307VM268932",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 268932,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1969,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.2",
      "ID": 4938
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3896,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam",
      "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2962967+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5080E110P121VM307412",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307412,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1969,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.2",
      "ID": 4938
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8283257+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4964E143P375VM282588",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 282588,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1969,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.2",
      "ID": 4938
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4964,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.425437+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3824E84P113VM280960",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280960,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1969,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.2",
      "ID": 4938
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3824,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7897371+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2066E22P91VM245260",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 245260,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1969,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.2",
      "ID": 4938
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2066,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8270357+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299977",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 299977,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1969,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.2",
      "ID": 4938
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.731019+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3759E260P411VM302775",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 302775,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1969,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.2",
      "ID": 4938
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina",
      "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5446521+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300100",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 300100,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1969,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.2",
      "ID": 4938
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2487,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7363166+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1775E215P453VM224509",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 224509,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1969,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.2",
      "ID": 4938
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.707898+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237979",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237979,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1969,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.2",
      "ID": 4938
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1961,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David",
      "DisplayName": "David McLetchie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2343377+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2134E34P201VM297477",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 297477,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1969,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.2",
      "ID": 4938
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2134,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1018982+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5041E99P122VM321018",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 321018,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1969,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.2",
      "ID": 4938
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5041,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan",
      "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1986948+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315436",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315436,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1969,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.2",
      "ID": 4938
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3763,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart",
      "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9119382+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1986E23P197VM238004",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 238004,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1969,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.2",
      "ID": 4938
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1986,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan",
      "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2354242+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5047E100P130VM293418",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 293418,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1969,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.2",
      "ID": 4938
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5047,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne",
      "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8442139+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1845E17P40VM233955",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 233955,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1969,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.2",
      "ID": 4938
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1845,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette",
      "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1535928+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3061E19P43VM312028",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 312028,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1969,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.2",
      "ID": 4938
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3061,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.9106191+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1768E19P265VM286855",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286855,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1969,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.2",
      "ID": 4938
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1768,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.6037301+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1894E267P527VM226095",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 226095,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1969,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.2",
      "ID": 4938
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1894,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Neil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.0098191+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3815E98P134VM271017",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271017,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1969,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.2",
      "ID": 4938
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3815,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Park, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Park",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8389476+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265548",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265548,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1969,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.2",
      "ID": 4938
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2010,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil",
      "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4439228+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5057E92P116VM284267",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 284267,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1969,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.2",
      "ID": 4938
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5057,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.018995+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2853E33P128VM259022",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 259022,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1969,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.2",
      "ID": 4938
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Pentland",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3383296+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5009E126P306VM318237",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 318237,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1969,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.2",
      "ID": 4938
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5009,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6440566+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3745E233P381VM256073",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 256073,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1969,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.2",
      "ID": 4938
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3745,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis",
      "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5694723+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1870E225P478VM294519",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 294519,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1969,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.2",
      "ID": 4938
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1870,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona",
      "DisplayName": "Shona Robison",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1419257+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2135E254P450VM236453",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 236453,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1969,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.2",
      "ID": 4938
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2135,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Russell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9255104+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1895E232P431VM256006",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 256006,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1969,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.2",
      "ID": 4938
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1895,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5663182+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1839E21P87VM229410",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229410,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1969,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.2",
      "ID": 4938
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1839,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0806082+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2345E10P55VM288389",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 288389,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1969,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.2",
      "ID": 4938
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2345,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1327457+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2223E176P333VM310457",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 310457,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1969,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.2",
      "ID": 4938
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2223,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish",
      "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5717146+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2182E87P175VM247167",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247167,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1969,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.2",
      "ID": 4938
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2182,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1699652+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298776",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298776,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1969,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.2",
      "ID": 4938
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5079,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew",
      "DisplayName": "Drew Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3716798+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1769E32P285VM235343",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235343,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1969,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.2",
      "ID": 4938
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1769,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6663986+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4014E14P26VM275816",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 275816,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1969,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.2",
      "ID": 4938
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4014,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz",
      "DisplayName": "Liz Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.392164+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2215E224P447VM274175",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274175,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1969,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.2",
      "ID": 4938
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2215,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6579296+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3806E103P127VM316804",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 316804,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1969,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.2",
      "ID": 4938
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3806,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.1642039+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326024",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 326024,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1969,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.2",
      "ID": 4938
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5106,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin",
      "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.531961+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241512",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241512,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1969,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.2",
      "ID": 4938
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1848,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola",
      "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7680128+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2098E237P531VM287983",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 287983,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1969,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.2",
      "ID": 4938
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2098,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Swinney",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8949861+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248388",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248388,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1969,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.2",
      "ID": 4938
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2674,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave",
      "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6438314+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5075E234P371VM289141",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289141,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1969,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.2",
      "ID": 4938
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5075,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Torrance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1792079+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1793E151P9VM222863",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 222863,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1969,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.2",
      "ID": 4938
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1793,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean",
      "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.2079353+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5078E245P7VM306862",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306862,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1969,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.2",
      "ID": 4938
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5078,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Walker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5769256+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1841E231P426VM240763",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 240763,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1969,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.2",
      "ID": 4938
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1841,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen",
      "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3812532+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4952E148P370VM284082",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 284082,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1969,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.2",
      "ID": 4938
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4952,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7422257+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1865E263P500VM251647",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251647,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1969,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.2",
      "ID": 4938
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1865,
      "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra",
      "DisplayName": "Sandra White",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4826975+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2610E160P413VM246294",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 246294,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1969,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.2",
      "ID": 4938
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2610,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Wilson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1224892+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309720",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 309720,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1969,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.2",
      "ID": 4938
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4941,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza",
      "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3418081+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1926E229P470VM253116",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253116,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1970,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.1",
      "ID": 4936
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1926,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian",
      "DisplayName": "Brian Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7674668+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2615E213P388VM259557",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 259557,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1970,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.1",
      "ID": 4936
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2615,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George",
      "DisplayName": "George Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6142282+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4940E159P373VM318056",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 318056,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1970,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.1",
      "ID": 4936
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4940,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare",
      "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4550377+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2641E256P403VM250098",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250098,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1970,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.1",
      "ID": 4936
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2641,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair",
      "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9632765+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1783E21P273VM229444",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229444,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1970,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.1",
      "ID": 4936
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1783,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie",
      "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0820541+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2633E97P136VM281597",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 281597,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1970,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.1",
      "ID": 4936
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2633,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire",
      "DisplayName": "Claire Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1496122+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2603E89P148VM263414",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 263414,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1970,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.1",
      "ID": 4936
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2603,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.8883935+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1759E91P115VM227550",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227550,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1970,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.1",
      "ID": 4936
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia",
      "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5549721+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270624",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270624,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1970,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.1",
      "ID": 4936
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3751,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8158045+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322989",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 322989,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1970,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.1",
      "ID": 4936
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5109,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco",
      "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.7124182+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5060E86P124VM297265",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 297265,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1970,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.1",
      "ID": 4936
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5060,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.0922422+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242621",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242621,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1970,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.1",
      "ID": 4936
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1866,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah",
      "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0281951+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1943E145P367VM236596",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 236596,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1970,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.1",
      "ID": 4936
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1943,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic",
      "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9318216+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2595E12P30VM301683",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 301683,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1970,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.1",
      "ID": 4936
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2595,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin",
      "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.2730148+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2103E244P421VM261217",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261217,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1970,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.1",
      "ID": 4936
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2103,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith",
      "DisplayName": "Keith Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3478547+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5108E221P387VM326653",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 326653,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1970,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.1",
      "ID": 4936
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7740578+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3775E216P435VM278241",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 278241,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1970,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.1",
      "ID": 4936
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2037265+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264838",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264838,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1970,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.1",
      "ID": 4936
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2673,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick",
      "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1568629+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2678E11P28VM249162",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 249162,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1970,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.1",
      "ID": 4936
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2678,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson",
      "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6865568+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2123E27P233VM291234",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291234,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1970,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.1",
      "ID": 4936
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2123,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm",
      "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1100706+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285631",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285631,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1970,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.1",
      "ID": 4936
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3907,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3375807+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1735E248P405VM233393",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 233393,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1970,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.1",
      "ID": 4936
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1735,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela",
      "DisplayName": "Angela Constance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1222864+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243255",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 243255,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1970,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.1",
      "ID": 4936
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1932,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce",
      "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.2895021+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1863E238P523VM253966",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253966,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1970,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.1",
      "ID": 4936
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1863,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna",
      "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0287552+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4976E20P31VM321376",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 321376,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1970,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.1",
      "ID": 4936
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4976,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth",
      "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4331665+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5107E223P379VM300750",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 300750,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1970,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.1",
      "ID": 4936
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5107,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.017278+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3743E222P391VM273320",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 273320,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1970,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.1",
      "ID": 4936
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3743,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel",
      "DisplayName": "Nigel Don",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6101787+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3771E149P417VM263178",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 263178,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1970,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.1",
      "ID": 4936
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3771,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob",
      "DisplayName": "Bob Doris",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6403+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2826E262P384VM282285",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 282285,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1970,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.1",
      "ID": 4936
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2826,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Dornan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.4062037+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298985",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298985,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1970,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.1",
      "ID": 4936
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3812,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia",
      "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3807692+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1778E28P260VM230611",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230611,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1970,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.1",
      "ID": 4936
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1778,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen",
      "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3378459+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4955E240P389VM287208",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 287208,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1970,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.1",
      "ID": 4936
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4955,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8542765+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219857",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 219857,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1970,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.1",
      "ID": 4936
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1742,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle",
      "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.317656+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1994E257P537VM239026",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239026,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1970,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.1",
      "ID": 4936
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1994,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus",
      "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.479581+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1814E269P519VM226215",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 226215,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1970,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.1",
      "ID": 4936
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1814,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda",
      "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2149272+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5059E85P123VM322306",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 322306,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1970,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.1",
      "ID": 4936
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Fee",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6771077+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1853E35P216VM291815",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291815,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1970,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.1",
      "ID": 4936
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia",
      "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1436749+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1892E12P64VM228332",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 228332,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1970,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.1",
      "ID": 4936
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.7883593+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5054E95P118VM304385",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 304385,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1970,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.1",
      "ID": 4936
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5054,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.0359951+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4947E152P8VM258028",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258028,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1970,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.1",
      "ID": 4936
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4947,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Finnie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0882083+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271618",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271618,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1970,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.1",
      "ID": 4936
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3901,
      "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe",
      "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.083946+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2394E15P47VM279350",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279350,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1970,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.1",
      "ID": 4936
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2394,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo",
      "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.4983963+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2110E220P414VM266497",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 266497,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1970,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.1",
      "ID": 4936
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth",
      "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.7437137+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250833",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250833,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1970,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.1",
      "ID": 4936
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2675,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob",
      "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.2154374+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221298",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221298,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1970,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.1",
      "ID": 4936
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1741,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel",
      "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.925958+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220797",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220797,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1970,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.1",
      "ID": 4936
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1756,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine",
      "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6574243+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1860E104P150VM239807",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239807,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1970,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.1",
      "ID": 4936
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1860,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda",
      "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7597485+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2033E20P141VM266671",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 266671,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1970,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.1",
      "ID": 4936
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2033,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain",
      "DisplayName": "Iain Gray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.751293+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324325",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324325,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1970,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.1",
      "ID": 4936
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5042,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2118986+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2892E76P97VM260265",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 260265,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1970,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.1",
      "ID": 4936
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick",
      "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.0690816+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2029E24P170VM246494",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 246494,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1970,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.1",
      "ID": 4936
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2029,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh",
      "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1311329+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3758E268P409VM275716",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 275716,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1970,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.1",
      "ID": 4936
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3758,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.387512+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4086E128P311VM303185",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 303185,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1970,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.1",
      "ID": 4936
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4086,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Hume",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5627892+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1773E242P494VM222230",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 222230,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1970,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.1",
      "ID": 4936
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1773,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1739384+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1882E227P459VM242444",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242444,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1970,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.1",
      "ID": 4936
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1882,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam",
      "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0135255+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1893E16P69VM224470",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 224470,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1970,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.1",
      "ID": 4936
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1893,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7062164+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4934E77P103VM308569",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 308569,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1970,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.1",
      "ID": 4936
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4934,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0615428+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272571",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 272571,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1970,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.1",
      "ID": 4936
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4956,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Keir",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3411179+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244626",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244626,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1970,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.1",
      "ID": 4936
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Kelly",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5713775+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3129E261P419VM314646",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 314646,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1970,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.1",
      "ID": 4936
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3129,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6491956+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2080E36P220VM251952",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251952,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1970,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.1",
      "ID": 4936
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann",
      "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4961856+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4016E11P36VM275589",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 275589,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1970,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.1",
      "ID": 4936
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4016,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.3820329+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2180E246P463VM257009",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257009,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1970,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.1",
      "ID": 4936
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2180,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.8194166+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4938E158P374VM283057",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283057,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1970,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.1",
      "ID": 4936
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4938,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.4459003+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2112E250P486VM254487",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254487,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1970,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.1",
      "ID": 4936
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2112,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny",
      "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2582502+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4939E258P394VM278310",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 278310,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1970,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.1",
      "ID": 4936
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4939,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus",
      "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2067094+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5074E251P385VM324960",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324960,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1970,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.1",
      "ID": 4936
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5074,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon",
      "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2451814+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1828E3P10VM231985",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231985,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1970,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.1",
      "ID": 4936
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1828,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo",
      "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6242663+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4948E153P363VM312387",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 312387,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1970,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.1",
      "ID": 4936
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4948,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike",
      "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1256418+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2117E90P107VM232481",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232481,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1970,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.1",
      "ID": 4936
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2117,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis",
      "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8626927+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267790",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 267790,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1970,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.1",
      "ID": 4936
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken",
      "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0351159+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4966E214P378VM314462",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 314462,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1970,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.1",
      "ID": 4936
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4966,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek",
      "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6410315+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3101E102P129VM296157",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 296157,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1970,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.1",
      "ID": 4936
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3101,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala",
      "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5518227+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319711",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319711,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1970,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.1",
      "ID": 4936
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5034,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny",
      "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9380555+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2159E25P205VM305864",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 305864,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1970,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.1",
      "ID": 4936
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2159,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Martin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3486221+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5110E252P395VM309865",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 309865,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1970,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.1",
      "ID": 4936
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Mason",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3542724+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268650",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 268650,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1970,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.1",
      "ID": 4936
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2133,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2767461+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2876E141P433VM293776",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 293776,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1970,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.1",
      "ID": 4936
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2876,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8684191+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4951E147P368VM271367",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271367,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1970,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.1",
      "ID": 4936
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4951,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan",
      "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0727523+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3896E175P307VM268931",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 268931,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1970,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.1",
      "ID": 4936
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3896,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam",
      "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2962563+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5080E110P121VM307413",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307413,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1970,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.1",
      "ID": 4936
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8283867+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4964E143P375VM282589",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 282589,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1970,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.1",
      "ID": 4936
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4964,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.4254778+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3824E84P113VM280959",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280959,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1970,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.1",
      "ID": 4936
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3824,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7896954+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2066E22P91VM245259",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 245259,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1970,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.1",
      "ID": 4936
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2066,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8269942+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299976",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 299976,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1970,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.1",
      "ID": 4936
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7309786+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3759E260P411VM302776",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 302776,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1970,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.1",
      "ID": 4936
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina",
      "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5446946+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300099",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 300099,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1970,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.1",
      "ID": 4936
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2487,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7362741+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1775E215P453VM224510",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 224510,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1970,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.1",
      "ID": 4936
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7079386+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237980",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237980,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1970,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.1",
      "ID": 4936
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1961,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David",
      "DisplayName": "David McLetchie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2343786+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2134E34P201VM297478",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 297478,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1970,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.1",
      "ID": 4936
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2134,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1019392+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5041E99P122VM321016",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 321016,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1970,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.1",
      "ID": 4936
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5041,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan",
      "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1986127+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315435",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315435,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1970,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.1",
      "ID": 4936
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3763,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart",
      "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9118976+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1986E23P197VM238005",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 238005,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1970,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.1",
      "ID": 4936
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1986,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan",
      "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2354661+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5047E100P130VM293417",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 293417,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1970,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.1",
      "ID": 4936
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5047,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne",
      "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8441731+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1845E17P40VM233954",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 233954,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1970,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.1",
      "ID": 4936
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1845,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette",
      "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1535519+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3061E19P43VM312027",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 312027,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1970,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.1",
      "ID": 4936
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3061,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.9105772+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1768E19P265VM286856",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286856,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1970,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.1",
      "ID": 4936
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1768,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.6037756+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1894E267P527VM226096",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 226096,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1970,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.1",
      "ID": 4936
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1894,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Neil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.0098598+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3815E98P134VM271018",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271018,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1970,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.1",
      "ID": 4936
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3815,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Park, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Park",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8389879+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265547",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265547,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1970,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.1",
      "ID": 4936
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2010,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil",
      "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.443882+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5057E92P116VM284266",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 284266,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1970,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.1",
      "ID": 4936
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5057,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0189527+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2853E33P128VM259023",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 259023,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1970,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.1",
      "ID": 4936
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Pentland",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3383716+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5009E126P306VM318235",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 318235,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1970,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.1",
      "ID": 4936
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5009,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6439721+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3745E233P381VM256072",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 256072,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1970,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.1",
      "ID": 4936
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3745,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis",
      "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5694317+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1870E225P478VM294520",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 294520,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1970,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.1",
      "ID": 4936
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1870,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona",
      "DisplayName": "Shona Robison",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1419666+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2135E254P450VM236454",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 236454,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1970,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.1",
      "ID": 4936
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2135,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Russell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9255515+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1895E232P431VM256007",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 256007,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1970,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.1",
      "ID": 4936
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1895,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5663584+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1839E21P87VM229872",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229872,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1970,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.1",
      "ID": 4936
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1839,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.1010497+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2345E10P55VM288388",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 288388,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1970,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.1",
      "ID": 4936
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2345,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1326855+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2223E176P333VM310458",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 310458,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1970,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.1",
      "ID": 4936
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2223,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish",
      "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5717554+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2182E87P175VM247168",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247168,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1970,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.1",
      "ID": 4936
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2182,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1700055+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298775",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298775,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1970,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.1",
      "ID": 4936
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5079,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew",
      "DisplayName": "Drew Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3716401+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1769E32P285VM235342",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235342,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1970,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.1",
      "ID": 4936
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1769,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6663571+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4014E14P26VM275817",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 275817,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1970,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.1",
      "ID": 4936
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4014,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz",
      "DisplayName": "Liz Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.392205+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2215E224P447VM274176",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274176,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1970,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.1",
      "ID": 4936
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2215,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6579707+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3806E103P127VM316805",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 316805,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1970,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.1",
      "ID": 4936
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3806,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.1642444+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326023",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 326023,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1970,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.1",
      "ID": 4936
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5106,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin",
      "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5319203+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241513",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241513,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1970,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.1",
      "ID": 4936
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1848,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola",
      "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7680532+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2098E237P531VM287984",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 287984,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1970,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.1",
      "ID": 4936
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2098,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Swinney",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.895027+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248389",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248389,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1970,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.1",
      "ID": 4936
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2674,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave",
      "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6438726+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5075E234P371VM289142",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289142,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1970,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.1",
      "ID": 4936
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5075,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Torrance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1792516+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1793E151P9VM222864",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 222864,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1970,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.1",
      "ID": 4936
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1793,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean",
      "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.2079761+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5078E245P7VM306861",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306861,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1970,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.1",
      "ID": 4936
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5078,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Walker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5768662+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1841E231P426VM240762",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 240762,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1970,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.1",
      "ID": 4936
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1841,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen",
      "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3812125+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4952E148P370VM284083",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 284083,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1970,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.1",
      "ID": 4936
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4952,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7422664+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1865E263P500VM251646",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251646,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1970,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.1",
      "ID": 4936
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1865,
      "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra",
      "DisplayName": "Sandra White",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.482655+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2610E160P413VM246293",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 246293,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1970,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.1",
      "ID": 4936
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2610,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Wilson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1224472+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309719",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 309719,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1970,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787.1",
      "ID": 4936
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4941,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza",
      "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3417576+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1926E229P470VM253117",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253117,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1971,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787",
      "ID": 4911
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1926,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian",
      "DisplayName": "Brian Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7675074+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2615E213P388VM259558",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 259558,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1971,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787",
      "ID": 4911
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2615,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George",
      "DisplayName": "George Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6142689+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4940E159P373VM318055",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 318055,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1971,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787",
      "ID": 4911
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4940,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare",
      "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4549977+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2641E256P403VM250097",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250097,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1971,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787",
      "ID": 4911
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2641,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair",
      "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9632357+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1783E21P273VM229445",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229445,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1971,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787",
      "ID": 4911
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1783,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie",
      "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.082094+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2633E97P136VM281598",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 281598,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1971,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787",
      "ID": 4911
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2633,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire",
      "DisplayName": "Claire Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1496518+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2603E89P148VM263415",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 263415,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1971,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787",
      "ID": 4911
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2603,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.8884334+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1759E91P115VM227551",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227551,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1971,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787",
      "ID": 4911
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia",
      "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5550127+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270623",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270623,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1971,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787",
      "ID": 4911
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3751,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8157641+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322880",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 322880,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1971,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787",
      "ID": 4911
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5109,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco",
      "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.7075108+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5060E86P124VM297266",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 297266,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1971,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787",
      "ID": 4911
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5060,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.0922829+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242622",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242622,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1971,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787",
      "ID": 4911
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1866,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah",
      "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0282355+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1943E145P367VM236595",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 236595,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1971,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787",
      "ID": 4911
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1943,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic",
      "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9317811+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2595E12P30VM300430",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 300430,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1971,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787",
      "ID": 4911
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2595,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin",
      "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.9978524+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2103E244P421VM261216",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261216,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1971,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787",
      "ID": 4911
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2103,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith",
      "DisplayName": "Keith Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.347814+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5108E221P387VM326654",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 326654,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1971,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787",
      "ID": 4911
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7740977+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3775E216P435VM278242",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 278242,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1971,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787",
      "ID": 4911
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2037675+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264837",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264837,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1971,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787",
      "ID": 4911
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2673,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick",
      "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1568213+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2678E11P28VM249161",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 249161,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1971,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787",
      "ID": 4911
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2678,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson",
      "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6865168+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2123E27P233VM291233",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291233,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1971,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787",
      "ID": 4911
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2123,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm",
      "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1100295+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285632",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285632,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1971,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787",
      "ID": 4911
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3907,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3376209+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1735E248P405VM233394",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 233394,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1971,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787",
      "ID": 4911
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1735,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela",
      "DisplayName": "Angela Constance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1223279+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243254",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 243254,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1971,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787",
      "ID": 4911
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1932,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce",
      "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.2894617+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1863E238P523VM253965",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253965,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1971,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787",
      "ID": 4911
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1863,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna",
      "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0287145+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4976E20P31VM321377",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 321377,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1971,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787",
      "ID": 4911
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4976,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth",
      "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4332276+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5107E223P379VM300749",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 300749,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1971,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787",
      "ID": 4911
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5107,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0172159+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3743E222P391VM273321",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 273321,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1971,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787",
      "ID": 4911
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3743,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel",
      "DisplayName": "Nigel Don",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6102197+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3771E149P417VM263179",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 263179,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1971,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787",
      "ID": 4911
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3771,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob",
      "DisplayName": "Bob Doris",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6403602+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2826E262P384VM282284",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 282284,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1971,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787",
      "ID": 4911
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2826,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Dornan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.4061612+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298986",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298986,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1971,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787",
      "ID": 4911
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3812,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia",
      "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3808085+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1778E28P260VM230610",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230610,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1971,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787",
      "ID": 4911
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1778,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen",
      "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3378054+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4955E240P389VM287206",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 287206,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1971,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787",
      "ID": 4911
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4955,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8541763+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219858",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 219858,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1971,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787",
      "ID": 4911
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1742,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle",
      "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3176966+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1994E257P537VM239025",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239025,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1971,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787",
      "ID": 4911
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1994,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus",
      "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4795395+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1814E269P519VM226214",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 226214,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1971,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787",
      "ID": 4911
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1814,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda",
      "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2148861+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5059E85P123VM322415",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 322415,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1971,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787",
      "ID": 4911
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Fee",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6872812+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1853E35P216VM291814",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291814,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1971,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787",
      "ID": 4911
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia",
      "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1436345+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1892E12P64VM228333",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 228333,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1971,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787",
      "ID": 4911
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.7884016+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5054E95P118VM304737",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 304737,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1971,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787",
      "ID": 4911
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5054,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.0512305+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4947E152P8VM258029",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258029,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1971,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787",
      "ID": 4911
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4947,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Finnie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0882487+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271616",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271616,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1971,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787",
      "ID": 4911
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3901,
      "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe",
      "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0838652+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2394E15P47VM279349",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279349,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1971,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787",
      "ID": 4911
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2394,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo",
      "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.4983537+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2110E220P414VM266498",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 266498,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1971,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787",
      "ID": 4911
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth",
      "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.7437549+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250834",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250834,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1971,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787",
      "ID": 4911
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2675,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob",
      "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.215477+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221299",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221299,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1971,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787",
      "ID": 4911
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1741,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel",
      "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9259989+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220796",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220796,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1971,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787",
      "ID": 4911
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1756,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine",
      "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6573838+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1860E104P150VM239808",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239808,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1971,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787",
      "ID": 4911
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1860,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda",
      "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7597888+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2033E20P141VM266670",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 266670,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1971,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787",
      "ID": 4911
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2033,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain",
      "DisplayName": "Iain Gray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.751251+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324324",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324324,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1971,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787",
      "ID": 4911
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5042,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2118573+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2892E76P97VM260264",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 260264,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1971,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787",
      "ID": 4911
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick",
      "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.0690403+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2029E24P170VM246495",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 246495,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1971,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787",
      "ID": 4911
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2029,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh",
      "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1311733+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3758E268P409VM275715",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 275715,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1971,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787",
      "ID": 4911
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3758,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.3874686+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4086E128P311VM303823",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 303823,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1971,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787",
      "ID": 4911
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4086,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Hume",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8374726+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1773E242P494VM222229",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 222229,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1971,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787",
      "ID": 4911
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1773,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.173875+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1882E227P459VM242443",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242443,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1971,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787",
      "ID": 4911
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1882,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam",
      "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0134846+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1893E16P69VM224469",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 224469,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1971,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787",
      "ID": 4911
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1893,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7061575+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4934E77P103VM308570",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 308570,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1971,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787",
      "ID": 4911
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4934,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0615831+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272572",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 272572,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1971,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787",
      "ID": 4911
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4956,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Keir",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3411581+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244627",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244627,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1971,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787",
      "ID": 4911
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Kelly",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5714179+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3129E261P419VM314647",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 314647,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1971,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787",
      "ID": 4911
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3129,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6493303+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2080E36P220VM251951",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251951,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1971,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787",
      "ID": 4911
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann",
      "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4961454+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4016E11P36VM275591",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 275591,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1971,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787",
      "ID": 4911
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4016,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.3821145+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2180E246P463VM257008",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257008,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1971,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787",
      "ID": 4911
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2180,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.8193754+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4938E158P374VM283055",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283055,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1971,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787",
      "ID": 4911
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4938,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.4458194+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2112E250P486VM254488",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254488,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1971,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787",
      "ID": 4911
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2112,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny",
      "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2582917+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4939E258P394VM278309",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 278309,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1971,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787",
      "ID": 4911
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4939,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus",
      "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2066694+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5074E251P385VM324961",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324961,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1971,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787",
      "ID": 4911
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5074,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon",
      "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2452219+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1828E3P10VM231986",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231986,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1971,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787",
      "ID": 4911
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1828,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo",
      "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6243067+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4948E153P363VM313001",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313001,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1971,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787",
      "ID": 4911
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4948,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike",
      "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1591623+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2117E90P107VM232480",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232480,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1971,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787",
      "ID": 4911
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2117,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis",
      "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.862651+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267791",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 267791,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1971,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787",
      "ID": 4911
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken",
      "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0351564+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4966E214P378VM314200",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 314200,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1971,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787",
      "ID": 4911
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4966,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek",
      "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4340514+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3101E102P129VM296156",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 296156,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1971,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787",
      "ID": 4911
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3101,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala",
      "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.551782+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319820",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319820,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1971,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787",
      "ID": 4911
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5034,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny",
      "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9427906+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2159E25P205VM305863",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 305863,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1971,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787",
      "ID": 4911
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2159,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Martin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3485818+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5110E252P395VM309818",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 309818,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1971,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787",
      "ID": 4911
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Mason",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3462838+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268649",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 268649,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1971,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787",
      "ID": 4911
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2133,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2767056+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2876E141P433VM293777",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 293777,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1971,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787",
      "ID": 4911
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2876,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8684589+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4951E147P368VM271366",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271366,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1971,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787",
      "ID": 4911
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4951,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan",
      "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0727104+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3896E175P307VM268930",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 268930,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1971,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787",
      "ID": 4911
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3896,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam",
      "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.296216+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5080E110P121VM307461",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307461,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1971,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787",
      "ID": 4911
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8305166+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4964E143P375VM282590",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 282590,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1971,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787",
      "ID": 4911
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4964,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.4255186+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3824E84P113VM280958",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280958,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1971,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787",
      "ID": 4911
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3824,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7896367+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2066E22P91VM245258",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 245258,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1971,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787",
      "ID": 4911
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2066,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8269487+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299975",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 299975,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1971,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787",
      "ID": 4911
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7309378+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3759E260P411VM302777",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 302777,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1971,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787",
      "ID": 4911
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina",
      "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5447354+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300098",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 300098,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1971,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787",
      "ID": 4911
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2487,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7362149+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1775E215P453VM224511",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 224511,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1971,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787",
      "ID": 4911
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7079795+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237981",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237981,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1971,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787",
      "ID": 4911
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1961,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David",
      "DisplayName": "David McLetchie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2344376+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2134E34P201VM297479",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 297479,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1971,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787",
      "ID": 4911
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2134,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1019801+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320752",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 320752,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1971,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787",
      "ID": 4911
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5041,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan",
      "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1800115+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315434",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315434,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1971,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787",
      "ID": 4911
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3763,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart",
      "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9118557+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1986E23P197VM238006",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 238006,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1971,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787",
      "ID": 4911
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1986,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan",
      "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2355066+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5047E100P130VM293416",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 293416,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1971,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787",
      "ID": 4911
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5047,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne",
      "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8441321+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1845E17P40VM233953",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 233953,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1971,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787",
      "ID": 4911
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1845,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette",
      "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1535104+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3061E19P43VM312026",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 312026,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1971,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787",
      "ID": 4911
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3061,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.9105181+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1768E19P265VM286857",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286857,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1971,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787",
      "ID": 4911
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1768,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.6038175+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1894E267P527VM226097",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 226097,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1971,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787",
      "ID": 4911
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1894,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Neil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.0099002+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3815E98P134VM271019",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271019,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1971,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787",
      "ID": 4911
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3815,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Park, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Park",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8390279+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265546",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265546,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1971,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787",
      "ID": 4911
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2010,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil",
      "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4438414+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5057E92P116VM284265",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 284265,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1971,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787",
      "ID": 4911
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5057,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0189071+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2853E33P128VM259024",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 259024,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1971,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787",
      "ID": 4911
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Pentland",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3384126+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317971",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317971,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1971,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787",
      "ID": 4911
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5009,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4514038+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3745E233P381VM256071",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 256071,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1971,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787",
      "ID": 4911
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3745,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis",
      "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5693916+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1870E225P478VM294521",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 294521,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1971,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787",
      "ID": 4911
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1870,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona",
      "DisplayName": "Shona Robison",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.142007+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2135E254P450VM236455",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 236455,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1971,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787",
      "ID": 4911
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2135,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Russell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9255926+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1895E232P431VM256008",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 256008,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1971,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787",
      "ID": 4911
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1895,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5663979+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1839E21P87VM229873",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229873,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1971,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787",
      "ID": 4911
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1839,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.1010915+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2345E10P55VM290582",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 290582,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1971,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787",
      "ID": 4911
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2345,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7631632+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2223E176P333VM310459",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 310459,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1971,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787",
      "ID": 4911
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2223,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish",
      "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.571798+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2182E87P175VM247169",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247169,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1971,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787",
      "ID": 4911
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2182,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1700464+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298774",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298774,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1971,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787",
      "ID": 4911
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5079,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew",
      "DisplayName": "Drew Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3715999+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1769E32P285VM235341",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235341,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1971,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787",
      "ID": 4911
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1769,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6663144+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4014E14P26VM275818",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 275818,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1971,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787",
      "ID": 4911
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4014,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz",
      "DisplayName": "Liz Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.3922463+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2215E224P447VM274177",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274177,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1971,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787",
      "ID": 4911
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2215,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6580119+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3806E103P127VM316806",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 316806,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1971,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787",
      "ID": 4911
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3806,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.1642843+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326022",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 326022,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1971,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787",
      "ID": 4911
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5106,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin",
      "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5318785+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241514",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241514,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1971,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787",
      "ID": 4911
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1848,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola",
      "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7680945+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2098E237P531VM287985",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 287985,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1971,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787",
      "ID": 4911
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2098,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Swinney",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8950674+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248390",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248390,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1971,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787",
      "ID": 4911
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2674,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave",
      "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6439134+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5075E234P371VM289143",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289143,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1971,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787",
      "ID": 4911
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5075,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Torrance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1792934+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1793E151P9VM222865",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 222865,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1971,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787",
      "ID": 4911
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1793,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean",
      "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.2080173+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5078E245P7VM306860",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306860,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1971,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787",
      "ID": 4911
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5078,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Walker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5768259+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1841E231P426VM240761",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 240761,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1971,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787",
      "ID": 4911
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1841,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen",
      "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3811725+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4952E148P370VM284085",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 284085,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1971,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787",
      "ID": 4911
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4952,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7423479+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1865E263P500VM251645",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251645,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1971,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787",
      "ID": 4911
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1865,
      "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra",
      "DisplayName": "Sandra White",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4826082+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2610E160P413VM246292",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 246292,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1971,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787",
      "ID": 4911
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2610,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Wilson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1223876+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309460",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 309460,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1971,
      "AgendaID": 2960,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Education",
      "Reference": "S4M-04787",
      "ID": 4911
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4941,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza",
      "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3303195+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252755",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252755,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1966,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.4",
      "ID": 4919
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1926,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian",
      "DisplayName": "Brian Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.751928+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2615E213P388VM259155",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 259155,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1966,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.4",
      "ID": 4919
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2615,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George",
      "DisplayName": "George Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3440869+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319584",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319584,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1966,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.4",
      "ID": 4919
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4940,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare",
      "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9323609+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249476",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 249476,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1966,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.4",
      "ID": 4919
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2641,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair",
      "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9284935+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1783E21P273VM228342",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 228342,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1966,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.4",
      "ID": 4919
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1783,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie",
      "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.7942638+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2633E97P136VM281037",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 281037,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1966,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.4",
      "ID": 4919
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2633,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire",
      "DisplayName": "Claire Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.8033162+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262993",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262993,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1966,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.4",
      "ID": 4919
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2603,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6320488+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1759E91P115VM230491",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230491,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1966,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.4",
      "ID": 4919
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia",
      "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3324267+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3751E243P383VM269716",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269716,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1966,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.4",
      "ID": 4919
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3751,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5599298+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322524",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 322524,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1966,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.4",
      "ID": 4919
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5109,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco",
      "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6924106+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5060E86P124VM295376",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295376,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1966,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.4",
      "ID": 4919
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5060,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5095224+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1866E93P239VM243018",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 243018,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1966,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.4",
      "ID": 4919
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1866,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah",
      "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0453924+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235089",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235089,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1966,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.4",
      "ID": 4919
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1943,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic",
      "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4189079+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2595E12P30VM303088",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 303088,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1966,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.4",
      "ID": 4919
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2595,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin",
      "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5580867+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244165",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244165,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1966,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.4",
      "ID": 4919
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2103,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith",
      "DisplayName": "Keith Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3415476+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327091",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 327091,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1966,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.4",
      "ID": 4919
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7984655+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277488",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277488,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1966,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.4",
      "ID": 4919
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9555141+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2673E236P377VM263997",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 263997,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1966,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.4",
      "ID": 4919
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2673,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick",
      "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.919785+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248650",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248650,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1966,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.4",
      "ID": 4919
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2678,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson",
      "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6639355+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2123E27P233VM294894",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 294894,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1966,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.4",
      "ID": 4919
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2123,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm",
      "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1833077+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285343",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285343,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1966,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.4",
      "ID": 4919
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3907,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3189189+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1735E248P405VM231281",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231281,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1966,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.4",
      "ID": 4919
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1735,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela",
      "DisplayName": "Angela Constance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.5881897+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243700",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 243700,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1966,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.4",
      "ID": 4919
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1932,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce",
      "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3161038+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254439",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254439,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1966,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.4",
      "ID": 4919
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1863,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna",
      "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.256162+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323698",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 323698,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1966,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.4",
      "ID": 4919
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4976,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth",
      "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9680456+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5107E223P379VM290899",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 290899,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1966,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.4",
      "ID": 4919
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5107,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.776878+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3743E222P391VM273040",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 273040,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1966,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.4",
      "ID": 4919
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3743,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel",
      "DisplayName": "Nigel Don",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3669744+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262529",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262529,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1966,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.4",
      "ID": 4919
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3771,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob",
      "DisplayName": "Bob Doris",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6058587+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281855",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 281855,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1966,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.4",
      "ID": 4919
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2826,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Dornan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1605061+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298272",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298272,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1966,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.4",
      "ID": 4919
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3812,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia",
      "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3386031+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231176",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231176,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1966,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.4",
      "ID": 4919
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1778,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen",
      "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3691015+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4955E240P389VM284960",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 284960,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1966,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.4",
      "ID": 4919
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4955,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0551146+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219516",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 219516,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1966,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.4",
      "ID": 4919
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1742,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle",
      "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3027271+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238272",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 238272,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1966,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.4",
      "ID": 4919
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1994,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus",
      "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4392491+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225129",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225129,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1966,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.4",
      "ID": 4919
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1814,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda",
      "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7457192+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321936",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 321936,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1966,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.4",
      "ID": 4919
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Fee",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4577829+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292736",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 292736,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1966,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.4",
      "ID": 4919
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia",
      "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5556033+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227241",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227241,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1966,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.4",
      "ID": 4919
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5369381+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5054E95P118VM313315",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313315,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1966,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.4",
      "ID": 4919
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5054,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.3900191+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4947E152P8VM257806",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257806,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1966,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.4",
      "ID": 4919
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4947,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Finnie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0784023+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271093",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271093,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1966,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.4",
      "ID": 4919
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3901,
      "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe",
      "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8421829+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2394E15P47VM277993",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277993,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1966,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.4",
      "ID": 4919
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2394,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo",
      "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9823523+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2110E220P414VM288317",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 288317,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1966,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.4",
      "ID": 4919
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth",
      "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1296206+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250623",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250623,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1966,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.4",
      "ID": 4919
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2675,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob",
      "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1975411+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221087",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221087,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1966,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.4",
      "ID": 4919
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1741,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel",
      "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.674525+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220128",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220128,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1966,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.4",
      "ID": 4919
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1756,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine",
      "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3355414+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1860E104P150VM252819",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252819,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1966,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.4",
      "ID": 4919
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1860,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda",
      "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7546161+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2033E20P141VM253762",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253762,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1966,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.4",
      "ID": 4919
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2033,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain",
      "DisplayName": "Iain Gray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0198388+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324707",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324707,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1966,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.4",
      "ID": 4919
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5042,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2344678+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259597",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 259597,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1966,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.4",
      "ID": 4919
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick",
      "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6163076+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239470",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239470,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1966,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.4",
      "ID": 4919
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2029,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh",
      "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7381914+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273623",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 273623,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1966,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.4",
      "ID": 4919
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3758,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6283447+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4086E128P311VM303992",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 303992,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1966,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.4",
      "ID": 4919
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4086,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Hume",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8447223+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221607",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221607,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1966,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.4",
      "ID": 4919
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1773,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9400275+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1882E227P459VM241839",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241839,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1966,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.4",
      "ID": 4919
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1882,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam",
      "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7822643+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223402",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223402,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1966,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.4",
      "ID": 4919
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1893,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.45633+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307855",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307855,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1966,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.4",
      "ID": 4919
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4934,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8538232+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272358",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 272358,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1966,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.4",
      "ID": 4919
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4956,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Keir",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3319037+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2059E26P131VM245029",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 245029,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1966,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.4",
      "ID": 4919
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Kelly",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5889644+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315195",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315195,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1966,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.4",
      "ID": 4919
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3129,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6784249+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247491",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247491,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1966,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.4",
      "ID": 4919
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann",
      "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4061134+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4016E11P36VM275147",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 275147,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1966,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.4",
      "ID": 4919
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4016,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1436173+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255493",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255493,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1966,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.4",
      "ID": 4919
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2180,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5336865+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4938E158P374VM276942",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276942,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1966,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.4",
      "ID": 4919
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4938,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6877888+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2112E250P486VM253471",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253471,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1966,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.4",
      "ID": 4919
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2112,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny",
      "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.9978492+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4939E258P394VM276713",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276713,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1966,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.4",
      "ID": 4919
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4939,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus",
      "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6779478+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325424",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 325424,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1966,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.4",
      "ID": 4919
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5074,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon",
      "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5057517+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1828E3P10VM233264",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 233264,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1966,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.4",
      "ID": 4919
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1828,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo",
      "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1165228+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311738",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311738,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1966,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.4",
      "ID": 4919
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4948,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike",
      "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.892125+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2117E90P107VM229663",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229663,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1966,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.4",
      "ID": 4919
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2117,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis",
      "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0913621+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267482",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 267482,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1966,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.4",
      "ID": 4919
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken",
      "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0217433+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313422",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313422,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1966,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.4",
      "ID": 4919
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4966,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek",
      "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.3946863+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3101E102P129VM294956",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 294956,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1966,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.4",
      "ID": 4919
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3101,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala",
      "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.185986+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319185",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319185,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1966,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.4",
      "ID": 4919
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5034,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny",
      "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6960743+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306291",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306291,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1966,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.4",
      "ID": 4919
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2159,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Martin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5457344+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5110E252P395VM310738",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 310738,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1966,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.4",
      "ID": 4919
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Mason",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.583931+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268122",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 268122,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1966,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.4",
      "ID": 4919
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2133,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0571144+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2876E141P433VM286453",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286453,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1966,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.4",
      "ID": 4919
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2876,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5798696+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4951E147P368VM258513",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258513,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1966,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.4",
      "ID": 4919
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4951,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan",
      "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3104888+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3896E175P307VM263762",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 263762,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1966,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.4",
      "ID": 4919
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3896,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam",
      "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9036353+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308750",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 308750,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1966,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.4",
      "ID": 4919
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.069373+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4964E143P375VM279788",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279788,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1966,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.4",
      "ID": 4919
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4964,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5228353+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279495",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279495,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1966,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.4",
      "ID": 4919
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3824,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5101669+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2066E22P91VM260491",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 260491,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1966,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.4",
      "ID": 4919
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2066,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.0791803+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299392",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 299392,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1966,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.4",
      "ID": 4919
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.6954652+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306782",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306782,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1966,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.4",
      "ID": 4919
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina",
      "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5671855+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300553",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 300553,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1966,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.4",
      "ID": 4919
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2487,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0035228+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223991",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223991,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1966,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.4",
      "ID": 4919
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4873216+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237925",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237925,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1966,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.4",
      "ID": 4919
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1961,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David",
      "DisplayName": "David McLetchie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2319892+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305577",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 305577,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1966,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.4",
      "ID": 4919
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2134,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3303773+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320085",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 320085,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1966,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.4",
      "ID": 4919
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5041,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan",
      "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9610248+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315887",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315887,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1966,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.4",
      "ID": 4919
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3763,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart",
      "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9314982+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1986E23P197VM237117",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237117,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1966,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.4",
      "ID": 4919
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1986,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan",
      "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9665723+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5047E100P130VM288928",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 288928,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1966,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.4",
      "ID": 4919
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5047,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne",
      "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1643789+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234267",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234267,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1966,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.4",
      "ID": 4919
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1845,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette",
      "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3698926+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313146",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313146,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1966,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.4",
      "ID": 4919
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3061,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1656356+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1768E19P265VM289383",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289383,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1966,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.4",
      "ID": 4919
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1768,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4348864+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225385",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225385,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1966,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.4",
      "ID": 4919
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1894,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Neil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9724587+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3815E98P134VM270993",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270993,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1966,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.4",
      "ID": 4919
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3815,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Park, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Park",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8379293+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265707",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265707,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1966,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.4",
      "ID": 4919
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2010,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil",
      "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4508543+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283043",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283043,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1966,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.4",
      "ID": 4919
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5057,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.4453077+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2853E33P128VM252050",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252050,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1966,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.4",
      "ID": 4919
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Pentland",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.5004166+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317307",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317307,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1966,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.4",
      "ID": 4919
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5009,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4164815+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254228",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254228,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1966,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.4",
      "ID": 4919
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3745,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis",
      "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2464769+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1870E225P478VM296285",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 296285,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1966,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.4",
      "ID": 4919
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1870,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona",
      "DisplayName": "Shona Robison",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8421888+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2135E254P450VM235495",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235495,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1966,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.4",
      "ID": 4919
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2135,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Russell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6802998+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1895E232P431VM258058",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258058,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1966,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.4",
      "ID": 4919
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1895,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0896418+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228584",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 228584,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1966,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.4",
      "ID": 4919
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1839,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.805405+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2345E10P55VM291039",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291039,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1966,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.4",
      "ID": 4919
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2345,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.782847+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311165",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311165,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1966,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.4",
      "ID": 4919
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2223,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish",
      "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.6085038+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246806",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 246806,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1966,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.4",
      "ID": 4919
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2182,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1542031+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5079E101P119VM297683",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 297683,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1966,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.4",
      "ID": 4919
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5079,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew",
      "DisplayName": "Drew Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.120251+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234023",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234023,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1966,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.4",
      "ID": 4919
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1769,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1568035+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274857",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274857,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1966,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.4",
      "ID": 4919
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4014,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz",
      "DisplayName": "Liz Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1248287+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269958",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269958,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1966,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.4",
      "ID": 4919
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2215,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5752828+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317506",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317506,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1966,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.4",
      "ID": 4919
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3806,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4253477+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326406",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 326406,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1966,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.4",
      "ID": 4919
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5106,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin",
      "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7571221+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241289",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241289,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1966,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.4",
      "ID": 4919
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1848,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola",
      "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7515088+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2098E237P531VM290388",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 290388,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1966,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.4",
      "ID": 4919
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2098,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Swinney",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7449579+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248059",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248059,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1966,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.4",
      "ID": 4919
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2674,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave",
      "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4400209+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5075E234P371VM287512",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 287512,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1966,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.4",
      "ID": 4919
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5075,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Torrance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8741783+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1793E151P9VM222629",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 222629,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1966,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.4",
      "ID": 4919
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1793,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean",
      "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1971595+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5078E245P7VM306944",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306944,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1966,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.4",
      "ID": 4919
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5078,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Walker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5806169+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1841E231P426VM239682",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239682,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1966,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.4",
      "ID": 4919
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1841,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen",
      "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7544256+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283797",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283797,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1966,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.4",
      "ID": 4919
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4952,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.723877+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1865E263P500VM231779",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231779,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1966,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.4",
      "ID": 4919
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1865,
      "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra",
      "DisplayName": "Sandra White",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6151423+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237344",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237344,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1966,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.4",
      "ID": 4919
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2610,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Wilson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2001555+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4941E150P382VM308982",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 308982,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1966,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.4",
      "ID": 4919
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4941,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza",
      "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0864272+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252759",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252759,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1967,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.3",
      "ID": 4917
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1926,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian",
      "DisplayName": "Brian Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7520873+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2615E213P388VM259156",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 259156,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1967,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.3",
      "ID": 4917
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2615,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George",
      "DisplayName": "George Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3441272+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319583",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319583,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1967,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.3",
      "ID": 4917
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4940,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare",
      "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9322845+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249475",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 249475,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1967,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.3",
      "ID": 4917
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2641,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair",
      "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9283468+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1783E21P273VM228370",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 228370,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1967,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.3",
      "ID": 4917
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1783,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie",
      "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.7956186+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2633E97P136VM281064",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 281064,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1967,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.3",
      "ID": 4917
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2633,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire",
      "DisplayName": "Claire Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.8044595+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262994",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262994,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1967,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.3",
      "ID": 4917
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2603,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6320904+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1759E91P115VM230553",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230553,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1967,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.3",
      "ID": 4917
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia",
      "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3353609+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3751E243P383VM269715",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269715,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1967,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.3",
      "ID": 4917
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3751,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5598882+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322532",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 322532,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1967,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.3",
      "ID": 4917
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5109,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco",
      "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6927735+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5060E86P124VM295377",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295377,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1967,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.3",
      "ID": 4917
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5060,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5095626+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1866E93P239VM243019",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 243019,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1967,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.3",
      "ID": 4917
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1866,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah",
      "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0454331+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235088",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235088,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1967,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.3",
      "ID": 4917
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1943,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic",
      "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4188669+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2595E12P30VM303084",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 303084,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1967,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.3",
      "ID": 4917
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2595,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin",
      "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5579042+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244164",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244164,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1967,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.3",
      "ID": 4917
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2103,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith",
      "DisplayName": "Keith Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3415054+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327092",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 327092,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1967,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.3",
      "ID": 4917
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7985064+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277489",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277489,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1967,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.3",
      "ID": 4917
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.955556+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2673E236P377VM263996",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 263996,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1967,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.3",
      "ID": 4917
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2673,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick",
      "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9197443+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248649",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248649,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1967,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.3",
      "ID": 4917
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2678,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson",
      "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6638953+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2123E27P233VM294893",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 294893,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1967,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.3",
      "ID": 4917
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2123,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm",
      "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1832675+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285344",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285344,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1967,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.3",
      "ID": 4917
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3907,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3189792+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1735E248P405VM231282",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231282,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1967,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.3",
      "ID": 4917
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1735,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela",
      "DisplayName": "Angela Constance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.5882309+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243699",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 243699,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1967,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.3",
      "ID": 4917
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1932,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce",
      "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3160641+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254443",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254443,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1967,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.3",
      "ID": 4917
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1863,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna",
      "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2563305+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323699",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 323699,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1967,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.3",
      "ID": 4917
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4976,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth",
      "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9680866+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5107E223P379VM290898",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 290898,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1967,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.3",
      "ID": 4917
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5107,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7768383+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3743E222P391VM273041",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 273041,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1967,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.3",
      "ID": 4917
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3743,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel",
      "DisplayName": "Nigel Don",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.367015+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262530",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262530,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1967,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.3",
      "ID": 4917
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3771,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob",
      "DisplayName": "Bob Doris",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6058996+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281828",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 281828,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1967,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.3",
      "ID": 4917
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2826,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Dornan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1593373+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298299",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298299,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1967,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.3",
      "ID": 4917
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3812,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia",
      "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3397714+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231138",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231138,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1967,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.3",
      "ID": 4917
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1778,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen",
      "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3672329+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4955E240P389VM284959",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 284959,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1967,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.3",
      "ID": 4917
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4955,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0550559+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219517",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 219517,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1967,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.3",
      "ID": 4917
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1742,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle",
      "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3027711+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238271",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 238271,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1967,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.3",
      "ID": 4917
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1994,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus",
      "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4391898+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225128",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225128,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1967,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.3",
      "ID": 4917
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1814,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda",
      "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7456793+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321928",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 321928,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1967,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.3",
      "ID": 4917
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Fee",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4573796+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292735",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 292735,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1967,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.3",
      "ID": 4917
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia",
      "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5555633+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227242",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227242,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1967,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.3",
      "ID": 4917
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5369998+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5054E95P118VM313311",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313311,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1967,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.3",
      "ID": 4917
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5054,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.3898545+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4947E152P8VM257807",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257807,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1967,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.3",
      "ID": 4917
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4947,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Finnie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0784425+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271092",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271092,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1967,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.3",
      "ID": 4917
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3901,
      "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe",
      "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8421424+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2394E15P47VM277966",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277966,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1967,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.3",
      "ID": 4917
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2394,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo",
      "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.976434+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2110E220P414VM288313",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 288313,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1967,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.3",
      "ID": 4917
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth",
      "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1294363+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250624",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250624,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1967,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.3",
      "ID": 4917
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2675,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob",
      "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1975823+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221088",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221088,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1967,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.3",
      "ID": 4917
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1741,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel",
      "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6745669+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220127",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220127,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1967,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.3",
      "ID": 4917
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1756,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine",
      "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3355003+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1860E104P150VM252815",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252815,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1967,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.3",
      "ID": 4917
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1860,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda",
      "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7544343+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2033E20P141VM253734",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253734,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1967,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.3",
      "ID": 4917
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2033,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain",
      "DisplayName": "Iain Gray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0186748+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324706",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324706,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1967,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.3",
      "ID": 4917
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5042,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2344277+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259596",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 259596,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1967,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.3",
      "ID": 4917
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick",
      "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6162661+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239471",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239471,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1967,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.3",
      "ID": 4917
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2029,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh",
      "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7382326+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273622",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 273622,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1967,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.3",
      "ID": 4917
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3758,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6283045+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4086E128P311VM303996",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 303996,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1967,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.3",
      "ID": 4917
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4086,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Hume",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.844933+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221606",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221606,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1967,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.3",
      "ID": 4917
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1773,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9399875+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1882E227P459VM241838",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241838,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1967,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.3",
      "ID": 4917
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1882,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam",
      "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.782223+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223401",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223401,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1967,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.3",
      "ID": 4917
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1893,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4562893+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307881",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307881,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1967,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.3",
      "ID": 4917
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4934,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8549567+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272359",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 272359,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1967,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.3",
      "ID": 4917
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4956,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Keir",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3319449+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2059E26P131VM245030",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 245030,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1967,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.3",
      "ID": 4917
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Kelly",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.589005+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315196",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315196,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1967,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.3",
      "ID": 4917
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3129,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6784656+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247490",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247490,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1967,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.3",
      "ID": 4917
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann",
      "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4060729+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4016E11P36VM275148",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 275148,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1967,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.3",
      "ID": 4917
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4016,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1436594+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255492",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255492,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1967,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.3",
      "ID": 4917
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2180,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5336456+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4938E158P374VM276941",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276941,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1967,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.3",
      "ID": 4917
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4938,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.687745+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2112E250P486VM253472",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253472,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1967,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.3",
      "ID": 4917
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2112,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny",
      "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.9978897+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4939E258P394VM276712",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276712,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1967,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.3",
      "ID": 4917
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4939,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus",
      "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6778891+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325425",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 325425,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1967,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.3",
      "ID": 4917
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5074,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon",
      "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5057948+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1828E3P10VM233305",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 233305,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1967,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.3",
      "ID": 4917
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1828,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo",
      "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1183554+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311725",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311725,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1967,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.3",
      "ID": 4917
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4948,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike",
      "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8915719+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2117E90P107VM229662",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229662,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1967,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.3",
      "ID": 4917
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2117,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis",
      "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0913213+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267509",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 267509,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1967,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.3",
      "ID": 4917
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken",
      "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0229025+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313435",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313435,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1967,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.3",
      "ID": 4917
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4966,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek",
      "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.3952442+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3101E102P129VM294464",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 294464,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1967,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.3",
      "ID": 4917
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3101,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala",
      "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.139443+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319177",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319177,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1967,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.3",
      "ID": 4917
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5034,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny",
      "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6957463+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306290",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306290,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1967,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.3",
      "ID": 4917
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2159,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Martin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5456941+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5110E252P395VM310737",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 310737,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1967,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.3",
      "ID": 4917
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Mason",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5838888+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268095",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 268095,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1967,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.3",
      "ID": 4917
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2133,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0559454+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2876E141P433VM292962",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 292962,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1967,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.3",
      "ID": 4917
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2876,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5656902+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4951E147P368VM258512",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258512,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1967,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.3",
      "ID": 4917
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4951,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan",
      "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3104477+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3896E175P307VM263761",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 263761,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1967,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.3",
      "ID": 4917
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3896,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam",
      "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9035947+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308751",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 308751,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1967,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.3",
      "ID": 4917
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0694143+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4964E143P375VM279789",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279789,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1967,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.3",
      "ID": 4917
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4964,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5228749+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279494",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279494,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1967,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.3",
      "ID": 4917
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3824,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5101263+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2066E22P91VM260490",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 260490,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1967,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.3",
      "ID": 4917
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2066,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.0791395+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299365",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 299365,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1967,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.3",
      "ID": 4917
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.6943097+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306783",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306783,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1967,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.3",
      "ID": 4917
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina",
      "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5672262+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300552",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 300552,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1967,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.3",
      "ID": 4917
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2487,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0033902+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223992",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223992,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1967,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.3",
      "ID": 4917
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4873619+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237926",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237926,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1967,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.3",
      "ID": 4917
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1961,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David",
      "DisplayName": "David McLetchie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2320301+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305578",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 305578,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1967,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.3",
      "ID": 4917
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2134,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3304185+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320093",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 320093,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1967,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.3",
      "ID": 4917
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5041,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan",
      "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9613758+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315886",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315886,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1967,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.3",
      "ID": 4917
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3763,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart",
      "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9314564+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1986E23P197VM237118",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237118,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1967,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.3",
      "ID": 4917
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1986,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan",
      "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9666148+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5047E100P130VM288927",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 288927,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1967,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.3",
      "ID": 4917
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5047,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne",
      "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1643387+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234271",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234271,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1967,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.3",
      "ID": 4917
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1845,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette",
      "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.370059+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313145",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313145,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1967,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.3",
      "ID": 4917
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3061,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.165594+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1768E19P265VM289384",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289384,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1967,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.3",
      "ID": 4917
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1768,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4349272+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225386",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225386,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1967,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.3",
      "ID": 4917
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1894,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Neil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.972501+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3815E98P134VM270994",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270994,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1967,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.3",
      "ID": 4917
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3815,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Park, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Park",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8379691+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265711",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265711,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1967,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.3",
      "ID": 4917
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2010,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil",
      "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4510586+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283042",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283042,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1967,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.3",
      "ID": 4917
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5057,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.4452676+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2853E33P128VM252051",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252051,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1967,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.3",
      "ID": 4917
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Pentland",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.5004571+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317315",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317315,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1967,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.3",
      "ID": 4917
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5009,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4168156+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254227",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254227,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1967,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.3",
      "ID": 4917
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3745,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis",
      "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.246433+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1870E225P478VM296286",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 296286,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1967,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.3",
      "ID": 4917
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1870,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona",
      "DisplayName": "Shona Robison",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8422369+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2135E254P450VM235496",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235496,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1967,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.3",
      "ID": 4917
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2135,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Russell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6803401+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1895E232P431VM258054",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258054,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1967,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.3",
      "ID": 4917
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1895,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0894354+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228585",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 228585,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1967,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.3",
      "ID": 4917
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1839,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.8054457+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2345E10P55VM291043",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291043,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1967,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.3",
      "ID": 4917
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2345,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7830319+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311166",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311166,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1967,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.3",
      "ID": 4917
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2223,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish",
      "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.6085443+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246807",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 246807,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1967,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.3",
      "ID": 4917
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2182,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1542433+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5079E101P119VM297682",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 297682,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1967,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.3",
      "ID": 4917
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5079,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew",
      "DisplayName": "Drew Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1202102+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234022",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234022,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1967,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.3",
      "ID": 4917
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1769,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1567626+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274858",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274858,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1967,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.3",
      "ID": 4917
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4014,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz",
      "DisplayName": "Liz Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1248828+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269985",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269985,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1967,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.3",
      "ID": 4917
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2215,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5765842+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317507",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317507,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1967,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.3",
      "ID": 4917
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3806,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4253877+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326405",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 326405,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1967,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.3",
      "ID": 4917
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5106,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin",
      "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7570807+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241290",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241290,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1967,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.3",
      "ID": 4917
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1848,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola",
      "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7515698+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2098E237P531VM290389",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 290389,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1967,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.3",
      "ID": 4917
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2098,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Swinney",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.745004+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248060",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248060,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1967,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.3",
      "ID": 4917
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2674,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave",
      "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4400612+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5075E234P371VM287513",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 287513,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1967,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.3",
      "ID": 4917
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5075,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Torrance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8742189+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1793E151P9VM222630",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 222630,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1967,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.3",
      "ID": 4917
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1793,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean",
      "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1972023+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5078E245P7VM306943",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306943,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1967,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.3",
      "ID": 4917
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5078,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Walker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5805577+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1841E231P426VM239681",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239681,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1967,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.3",
      "ID": 4917
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1841,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen",
      "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7543667+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283798",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283798,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1967,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.3",
      "ID": 4917
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4952,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7239175+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1865E263P500VM231751",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231751,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1967,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.3",
      "ID": 4917
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1865,
      "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra",
      "DisplayName": "Sandra White",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6139504+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237343",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237343,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1967,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.3",
      "ID": 4917
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2610,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Wilson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2000948+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4941E150P382VM308956",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 308956,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1967,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778.3",
      "ID": 4917
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4941,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza",
      "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0853236+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252760",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252760,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1968,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778",
      "ID": 4900
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1926,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian",
      "DisplayName": "Brian Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7521272+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2615E213P388VM259157",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 259157,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1968,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778",
      "ID": 4900
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2615,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George",
      "DisplayName": "George Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3441672+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319549",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319549,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1968,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778",
      "ID": 4900
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4940,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare",
      "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9307418+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249474",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 249474,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1968,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778",
      "ID": 4900
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2641,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair",
      "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9283051+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1783E21P273VM228371",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 228371,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1968,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778",
      "ID": 4900
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1783,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie",
      "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.7956598+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2633E97P136VM281065",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 281065,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1968,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778",
      "ID": 4900
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2633,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire",
      "DisplayName": "Claire Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.8044999+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262995",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262995,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1968,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778",
      "ID": 4900
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2603,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6321315+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1759E91P115VM230554",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230554,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1968,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778",
      "ID": 4900
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia",
      "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3354017+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3751E243P383VM269714",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269714,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1968,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778",
      "ID": 4900
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3751,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.55983+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322533",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 322533,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1968,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778",
      "ID": 4900
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5109,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco",
      "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6928144+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5060E86P124VM295378",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295378,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1968,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778",
      "ID": 4900
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5060,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5096027+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1866E93P239VM243020",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 243020,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1968,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778",
      "ID": 4900
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1866,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah",
      "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0454927+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235087",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235087,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1968,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778",
      "ID": 4900
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1943,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic",
      "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4188243+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2595E12P30VM303085",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 303085,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1968,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778",
      "ID": 4900
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2595,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin",
      "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5579636+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244163",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244163,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1968,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778",
      "ID": 4900
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2103,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith",
      "DisplayName": "Keith Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3414635+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327046",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 327046,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1968,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778",
      "ID": 4900
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7912751+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277490",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277490,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1968,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778",
      "ID": 4900
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9555966+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2673E236P377VM263995",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 263995,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1968,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778",
      "ID": 4900
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2673,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick",
      "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9197036+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248648",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248648,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1968,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778",
      "ID": 4900
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2678,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson",
      "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6638547+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2123E27P233VM294892",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 294892,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1968,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778",
      "ID": 4900
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2123,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm",
      "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1832266+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285345",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285345,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1968,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778",
      "ID": 4900
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3907,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3190221+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1735E248P405VM231283",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231283,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1968,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778",
      "ID": 4900
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1735,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela",
      "DisplayName": "Angela Constance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.5882714+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243698",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 243698,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1968,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778",
      "ID": 4900
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1932,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce",
      "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3160245+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254442",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254442,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1968,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778",
      "ID": 4900
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1863,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna",
      "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2562886+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323498",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 323498,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1968,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778",
      "ID": 4900
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4976,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth",
      "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9589732+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5107E223P379VM290897",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 290897,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1968,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778",
      "ID": 4900
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5107,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7767974+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3743E222P391VM273042",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 273042,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1968,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778",
      "ID": 4900
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3743,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel",
      "DisplayName": "Nigel Don",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3670565+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262531",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262531,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1968,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778",
      "ID": 4900
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3771,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob",
      "DisplayName": "Bob Doris",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6059408+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281827",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 281827,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1968,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778",
      "ID": 4900
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2826,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Dornan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1592965+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298300",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298300,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1968,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778",
      "ID": 4900
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3812,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia",
      "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.339812+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231137",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231137,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1968,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778",
      "ID": 4900
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1778,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen",
      "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3671927+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4955E240P389VM284958",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 284958,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1968,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778",
      "ID": 4900
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4955,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0550145+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219518",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 219518,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1968,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778",
      "ID": 4900
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1742,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle",
      "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3028136+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238270",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 238270,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1968,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778",
      "ID": 4900
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1994,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus",
      "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4391494+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225127",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225127,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1968,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778",
      "ID": 4900
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1814,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda",
      "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7456387+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321927",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 321927,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1968,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778",
      "ID": 4900
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Fee",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4573388+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292734",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 292734,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1968,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778",
      "ID": 4900
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia",
      "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5555232+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227243",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227243,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1968,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778",
      "ID": 4900
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5370429+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5054E95P118VM313312",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313312,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1968,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778",
      "ID": 4900
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5054,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.3898961+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4947E152P8VM257808",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257808,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1968,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778",
      "ID": 4900
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4947,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Finnie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0784832+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271091",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271091,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1968,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778",
      "ID": 4900
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3901,
      "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe",
      "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.842102+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2394E15P47VM277965",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277965,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1968,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778",
      "ID": 4900
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2394,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo",
      "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9763923+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2110E220P414VM288314",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 288314,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1968,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778",
      "ID": 4900
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth",
      "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1294956+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250625",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250625,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1968,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778",
      "ID": 4900
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2675,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob",
      "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1976227+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221089",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221089,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1968,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778",
      "ID": 4900
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1741,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel",
      "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6746088+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220126",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220126,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1968,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778",
      "ID": 4900
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1756,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine",
      "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.335458+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1860E104P150VM252816",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252816,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1968,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778",
      "ID": 4900
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1860,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda",
      "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7544746+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2033E20P141VM253733",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253733,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1968,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778",
      "ID": 4900
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2033,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain",
      "DisplayName": "Iain Gray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0186346+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324753",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324753,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1968,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778",
      "ID": 4900
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5042,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2363959+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259595",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 259595,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1968,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778",
      "ID": 4900
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick",
      "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6162243+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239472",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239472,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1968,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778",
      "ID": 4900
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2029,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh",
      "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7382728+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273621",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 273621,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1968,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778",
      "ID": 4900
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3758,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6282644+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4086E128P311VM303995",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 303995,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1968,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778",
      "ID": 4900
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4086,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Hume",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8448908+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221605",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221605,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1968,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778",
      "ID": 4900
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1773,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9399457+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1882E227P459VM241837",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241837,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1968,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778",
      "ID": 4900
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1882,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam",
      "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7821823+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223400",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223400,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1968,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778",
      "ID": 4900
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1893,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4562478+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307882",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307882,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1968,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778",
      "ID": 4900
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4934,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8549981+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272360",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 272360,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1968,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778",
      "ID": 4900
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4956,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Keir",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3319854+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2059E26P131VM245031",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 245031,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1968,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778",
      "ID": 4900
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Kelly",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5890467+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315230",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315230,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1968,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778",
      "ID": 4900
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3129,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.8995459+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247489",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247489,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1968,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778",
      "ID": 4900
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann",
      "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4060321+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4016E11P36VM275149",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 275149,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1968,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778",
      "ID": 4900
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4016,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1437005+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255491",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255491,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1968,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778",
      "ID": 4900
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2180,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5336046+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4938E158P374VM276940",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276940,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1968,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778",
      "ID": 4900
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4938,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6876248+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2112E250P486VM253473",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253473,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1968,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778",
      "ID": 4900
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2112,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny",
      "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.9979306+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4939E258P394VM276711",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276711,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1968,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778",
      "ID": 4900
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4939,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus",
      "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6778491+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325378",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 325378,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1968,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778",
      "ID": 4900
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5074,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon",
      "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.4961102+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1828E3P10VM233306",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 233306,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1968,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778",
      "ID": 4900
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1828,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo",
      "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1183963+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311726",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311726,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1968,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778",
      "ID": 4900
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4948,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike",
      "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8916127+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2117E90P107VM229661",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229661,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1968,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778",
      "ID": 4900
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2117,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis",
      "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0912811+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267510",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 267510,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1968,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778",
      "ID": 4900
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken",
      "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.022943+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313434",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313434,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1968,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778",
      "ID": 4900
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4966,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek",
      "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.395203+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3101E102P129VM294463",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 294463,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1968,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778",
      "ID": 4900
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3101,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala",
      "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1393833+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319176",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319176,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1968,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778",
      "ID": 4900
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5034,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny",
      "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6957056+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306256",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306256,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1968,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778",
      "ID": 4900
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2159,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Martin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5442437+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5110E252P395VM310736",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 310736,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1968,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778",
      "ID": 4900
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Mason",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5838285+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268094",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 268094,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1968,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778",
      "ID": 4900
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2133,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0559015+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2876E141P433VM292963",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 292963,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1968,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778",
      "ID": 4900
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2876,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5657491+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4951E147P368VM258511",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258511,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1968,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778",
      "ID": 4900
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4951,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan",
      "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3104063+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3896E175P307VM263760",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 263760,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1968,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778",
      "ID": 4900
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3896,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam",
      "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9035534+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308752",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 308752,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1968,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778",
      "ID": 4900
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0694549+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4964E143P375VM279790",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279790,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1968,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778",
      "ID": 4900
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4964,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5229157+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279493",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279493,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1968,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778",
      "ID": 4900
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3824,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5100855+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2066E22P91VM260489",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 260489,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1968,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778",
      "ID": 4900
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2066,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.0790985+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299364",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 299364,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1968,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778",
      "ID": 4900
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.6942693+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306784",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306784,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1968,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778",
      "ID": 4900
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina",
      "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5672666+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300551",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 300551,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1968,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778",
      "ID": 4900
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2487,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0032596+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223993",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223993,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1968,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778",
      "ID": 4900
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4874029+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237927",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237927,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1968,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778",
      "ID": 4900
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1961,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David",
      "DisplayName": "David McLetchie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2320993+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305611",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 305611,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1968,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778",
      "ID": 4900
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2134,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3318282+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320094",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 320094,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1968,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778",
      "ID": 4900
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5041,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan",
      "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9614167+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315852",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315852,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1968,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778",
      "ID": 4900
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3763,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart",
      "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9298356+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1986E23P197VM237119",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237119,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1968,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778",
      "ID": 4900
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1986,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan",
      "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9666547+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5047E100P130VM288926",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 288926,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1968,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778",
      "ID": 4900
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5047,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne",
      "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.164298+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234270",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234270,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1968,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778",
      "ID": 4900
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1845,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette",
      "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3700174+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313112",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313112,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1968,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778",
      "ID": 4900
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3061,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1641647+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1768E19P265VM289385",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289385,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1968,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778",
      "ID": 4900
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1768,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4349673+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225387",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225387,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1968,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778",
      "ID": 4900
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1894,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Neil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9725416+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3815E98P134VM270995",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270995,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1968,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778",
      "ID": 4900
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3815,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Park, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Park",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8380097+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265710",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265710,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1968,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778",
      "ID": 4900
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2010,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil",
      "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4510139+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283041",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283041,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1968,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778",
      "ID": 4900
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5057,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.4452264+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2853E33P128VM252052",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252052,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1968,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778",
      "ID": 4900
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Pentland",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.5004977+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317316",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317316,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1968,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778",
      "ID": 4900
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5009,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4168777+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254226",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254226,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1968,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778",
      "ID": 4900
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3745,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis",
      "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.24637+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1870E225P478VM296287",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 296287,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1968,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778",
      "ID": 4900
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1870,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona",
      "DisplayName": "Shona Robison",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8422787+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2135E254P450VM235497",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235497,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1968,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778",
      "ID": 4900
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2135,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Russell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6803803+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1895E232P431VM258055",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258055,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1968,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778",
      "ID": 4900
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1895,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0894874+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228586",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 228586,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1968,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778",
      "ID": 4900
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1839,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.8054866+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2345E10P55VM291042",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291042,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1968,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778",
      "ID": 4900
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2345,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7829895+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311512",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311512,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1968,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778",
      "ID": 4900
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2223,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish",
      "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8820415+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246808",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 246808,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1968,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778",
      "ID": 4900
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2182,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1542833+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5079E101P119VM297681",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 297681,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1968,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778",
      "ID": 4900
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5079,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew",
      "DisplayName": "Drew Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1201502+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234021",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234021,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1968,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778",
      "ID": 4900
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1769,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1567215+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274859",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274859,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1968,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778",
      "ID": 4900
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4014,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz",
      "DisplayName": "Liz Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1249256+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269986",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269986,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1968,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778",
      "ID": 4900
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2215,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5766253+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317696",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317696,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1968,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778",
      "ID": 4900
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3806,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4334833+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326452",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 326452,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1968,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778",
      "ID": 4900
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5106,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin",
      "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7653006+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241291",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241291,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1968,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778",
      "ID": 4900
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1848,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola",
      "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7516125+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2098E237P531VM290390",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 290390,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1968,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778",
      "ID": 4900
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2098,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Swinney",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7450459+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248061",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248061,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1968,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778",
      "ID": 4900
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2674,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave",
      "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4401019+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5075E234P371VM287514",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 287514,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1968,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778",
      "ID": 4900
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5075,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Torrance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8742595+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1793E151P9VM222631",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 222631,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1968,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778",
      "ID": 4900
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1793,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean",
      "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1972433+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5078E245P7VM306942",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306942,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1968,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778",
      "ID": 4900
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5078,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Walker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5805162+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1841E231P426VM239680",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239680,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1968,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778",
      "ID": 4900
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1841,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen",
      "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7543261+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283799",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283799,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1968,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778",
      "ID": 4900
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4952,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7239579+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1865E263P500VM231750",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231750,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1968,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778",
      "ID": 4900
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1865,
      "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra",
      "DisplayName": "Sandra White",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6139108+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237342",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237342,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1968,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778",
      "ID": 4900
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2610,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Wilson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2000541+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4941E150P382VM308955",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 308955,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1968,
      "AgendaID": 2229,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Universal Benefits",
      "Reference": "S4M-04778",
      "ID": 4900
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4941,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza",
      "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0852829+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252708",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252708,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1965,
      "AgendaID": 2598,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 34,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Road to Recovery, Drugs Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-04719.3",
      "ID": 4859
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1926,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian",
      "DisplayName": "Brian Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7501574+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2615E213P388VM258932",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258932,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1965,
      "AgendaID": 2598,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 34,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Road to Recovery, Drugs Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-04719.3",
      "ID": 4859
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2615,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George",
      "DisplayName": "George Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3344661+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319841",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319841,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1965,
      "AgendaID": 2598,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 34,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Road to Recovery, Drugs Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-04719.3",
      "ID": 4859
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4940,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare",
      "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9436971+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249596",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 249596,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1965,
      "AgendaID": 2598,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 34,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Road to Recovery, Drugs Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-04719.3",
      "ID": 4859
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2641,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair",
      "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9336565+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1783E21P273VM227826",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227826,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1965,
      "AgendaID": 2598,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 34,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Road to Recovery, Drugs Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-04719.3",
      "ID": 4859
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1783,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie",
      "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5673143+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2633E97P136VM280827",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280827,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1965,
      "AgendaID": 2598,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 34,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Road to Recovery, Drugs Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-04719.3",
      "ID": 4859
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2633,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire",
      "DisplayName": "Claire Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7840707+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262734",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262734,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1965,
      "AgendaID": 2598,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 34,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Road to Recovery, Drugs Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-04719.3",
      "ID": 4859
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2603,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6145539+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1759E91P115VM229820",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229820,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1965,
      "AgendaID": 2598,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 34,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Road to Recovery, Drugs Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-04719.3",
      "ID": 4859
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia",
      "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0988056+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3751E243P383VM269785",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269785,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1965,
      "AgendaID": 2598,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 34,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Road to Recovery, Drugs Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-04719.3",
      "ID": 4859
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3751,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5628399+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322633",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 322633,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1965,
      "AgendaID": 2598,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 34,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Road to Recovery, Drugs Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-04719.3",
      "ID": 4859
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5109,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco",
      "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6970978+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5060E86P124VM295271",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295271,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1965,
      "AgendaID": 2598,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 34,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Road to Recovery, Drugs Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-04719.3",
      "ID": 4859
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5060,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5048289+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242912",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242912,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1965,
      "AgendaID": 2598,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 34,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Road to Recovery, Drugs Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-04719.3",
      "ID": 4859
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1866,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah",
      "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0408968+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235157",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235157,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1965,
      "AgendaID": 2598,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 34,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Road to Recovery, Drugs Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-04719.3",
      "ID": 4859
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1943,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic",
      "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4218396+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302386",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 302386,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1965,
      "AgendaID": 2598,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 34,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Road to Recovery, Drugs Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-04719.3",
      "ID": 4859
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2595,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin",
      "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5221424+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244269",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244269,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1965,
      "AgendaID": 2598,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 34,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Road to Recovery, Drugs Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-04719.3",
      "ID": 4859
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2103,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith",
      "DisplayName": "Keith Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5473716+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327155",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 327155,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1965,
      "AgendaID": 2598,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 34,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Road to Recovery, Drugs Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-04719.3",
      "ID": 4859
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.8015495+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277073",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277073,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1965,
      "AgendaID": 2598,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 34,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Road to Recovery, Drugs Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-04719.3",
      "ID": 4859
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6999428+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264256",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264256,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1965,
      "AgendaID": 2598,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 34,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Road to Recovery, Drugs Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-04719.3",
      "ID": 4859
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2673,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick",
      "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.12546+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248692",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248692,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1965,
      "AgendaID": 2598,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 34,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Road to Recovery, Drugs Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-04719.3",
      "ID": 4859
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2678,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson",
      "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6657269+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2123E27P233VM295772",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295772,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1965,
      "AgendaID": 2598,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 34,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Road to Recovery, Drugs Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-04719.3",
      "ID": 4859
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2123,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm",
      "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.535242+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285238",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285238,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1965,
      "AgendaID": 2598,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 34,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Road to Recovery, Drugs Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-04719.3",
      "ID": 4859
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3907,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3143571+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230714",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230714,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1965,
      "AgendaID": 2598,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 34,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Road to Recovery, Drugs Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-04719.3",
      "ID": 4859
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1735,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela",
      "DisplayName": "Angela Constance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3423858+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243807",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 243807,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1965,
      "AgendaID": 2598,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 34,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Road to Recovery, Drugs Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-04719.3",
      "ID": 4859
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1932,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce",
      "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.32059+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254860",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254860,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1965,
      "AgendaID": 2598,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 34,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Road to Recovery, Drugs Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-04719.3",
      "ID": 4859
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1863,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna",
      "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2868799+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323762",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 323762,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1965,
      "AgendaID": 2598,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 34,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Road to Recovery, Drugs Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-04719.3",
      "ID": 4859
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4976,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth",
      "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9708328+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5107E223P379VM291250",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291250,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1965,
      "AgendaID": 2598,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 34,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Road to Recovery, Drugs Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-04719.3",
      "ID": 4859
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5107,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1107721+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3743E222P391VM265410",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265410,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1965,
      "AgendaID": 2598,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 34,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Road to Recovery, Drugs Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-04719.3",
      "ID": 4859
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3743,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel",
      "DisplayName": "Nigel Don",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4379774+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262333",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262333,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1965,
      "AgendaID": 2598,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 34,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Road to Recovery, Drugs Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-04719.3",
      "ID": 4859
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3771,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob",
      "DisplayName": "Bob Doris",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.5969619+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281913",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 281913,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1965,
      "AgendaID": 2598,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 34,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Road to Recovery, Drugs Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-04719.3",
      "ID": 4859
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2826,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Dornan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.163167+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298213",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298213,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1965,
      "AgendaID": 2598,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 34,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Road to Recovery, Drugs Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-04719.3",
      "ID": 4859
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3812,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia",
      "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3360515+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231218",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231218,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1965,
      "AgendaID": 2598,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 34,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Road to Recovery, Drugs Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-04719.3",
      "ID": 4859
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1778,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen",
      "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.5854663+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4955E240P389VM285857",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285857,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1965,
      "AgendaID": 2598,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 34,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Road to Recovery, Drugs Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-04719.3",
      "ID": 4859
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4955,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3475315+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219473",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 219473,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1965,
      "AgendaID": 2598,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 34,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Road to Recovery, Drugs Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-04719.3",
      "ID": 4859
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1742,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle",
      "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3007883+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238494",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 238494,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1965,
      "AgendaID": 2598,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 34,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Road to Recovery, Drugs Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-04719.3",
      "ID": 4859
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1994,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus",
      "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4565253+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225248",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225248,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1965,
      "AgendaID": 2598,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 34,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Road to Recovery, Drugs Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-04719.3",
      "ID": 4859
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1814,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda",
      "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9611958+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321827",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 321827,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1965,
      "AgendaID": 2598,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 34,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Road to Recovery, Drugs Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-04719.3",
      "ID": 4859
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Fee",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4530507+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292793",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 292793,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1965,
      "AgendaID": 2598,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 34,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Road to Recovery, Drugs Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-04719.3",
      "ID": 4859
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia",
      "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5583838+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227197",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227197,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1965,
      "AgendaID": 2598,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 34,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Road to Recovery, Drugs Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-04719.3",
      "ID": 4859
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5349807+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5054E95P118VM312745",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 312745,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1965,
      "AgendaID": 2598,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 34,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Road to Recovery, Drugs Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-04719.3",
      "ID": 4859
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5054,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1415165+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4947E152P8VM257224",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257224,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1965,
      "AgendaID": 2598,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 34,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Road to Recovery, Drugs Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-04719.3",
      "ID": 4859
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4947,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Finnie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.046899+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271212",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271212,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1965,
      "AgendaID": 2598,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 34,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Road to Recovery, Drugs Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-04719.3",
      "ID": 4859
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3901,
      "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe",
      "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.060454+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278050",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 278050,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1965,
      "AgendaID": 2598,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 34,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Road to Recovery, Drugs Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-04719.3",
      "ID": 4859
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2394,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo",
      "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9848436+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2110E220P414VM287281",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 287281,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1965,
      "AgendaID": 2598,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 34,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Road to Recovery, Drugs Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-04719.3",
      "ID": 4859
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth",
      "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8574244+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250502",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250502,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1965,
      "AgendaID": 2598,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 34,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Road to Recovery, Drugs Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-04719.3",
      "ID": 4859
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2675,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob",
      "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1922963+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1741E10P50VM220969",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220969,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1965,
      "AgendaID": 2598,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 34,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Road to Recovery, Drugs Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-04719.3",
      "ID": 4859
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1741,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel",
      "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.669459+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220172",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220172,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1965,
      "AgendaID": 2598,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 34,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Road to Recovery, Drugs Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-04719.3",
      "ID": 4859
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1756,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine",
      "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3374506+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1860E104P150VM252406",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252406,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1965,
      "AgendaID": 2598,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 34,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Road to Recovery, Drugs Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-04719.3",
      "ID": 4859
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1860,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda",
      "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7277894+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2033E20P141VM253817",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253817,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1965,
      "AgendaID": 2598,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 34,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Road to Recovery, Drugs Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-04719.3",
      "ID": 4859
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2033,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain",
      "DisplayName": "Iain Gray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0221639+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324643",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324643,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1965,
      "AgendaID": 2598,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 34,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Road to Recovery, Drugs Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-04719.3",
      "ID": 4859
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5042,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2317801+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259639",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 259639,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1965,
      "AgendaID": 2598,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 34,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Road to Recovery, Drugs Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-04719.3",
      "ID": 4859
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick",
      "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6181304+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239402",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239402,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1965,
      "AgendaID": 2598,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 34,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Road to Recovery, Drugs Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-04719.3",
      "ID": 4859
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2029,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh",
      "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7352683+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273727",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 273727,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1965,
      "AgendaID": 2598,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 34,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Road to Recovery, Drugs Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-04719.3",
      "ID": 4859
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3758,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6330743+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304099",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 304099,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1965,
      "AgendaID": 2598,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 34,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Road to Recovery, Drugs Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-04719.3",
      "ID": 4859
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4086,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Hume",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8496309+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221726",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221726,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1965,
      "AgendaID": 2598,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 34,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Road to Recovery, Drugs Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-04719.3",
      "ID": 4859
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1773,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9451358+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1882E227P459VM241959",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241959,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1965,
      "AgendaID": 2598,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 34,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Road to Recovery, Drugs Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-04719.3",
      "ID": 4859
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1882,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam",
      "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7877351+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223470",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223470,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1965,
      "AgendaID": 2598,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 34,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Road to Recovery, Drugs Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-04719.3",
      "ID": 4859
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1893,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4594934+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307796",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307796,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1965,
      "AgendaID": 2598,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 34,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Road to Recovery, Drugs Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-04719.3",
      "ID": 4859
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4934,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8452939+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272239",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 272239,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1965,
      "AgendaID": 2598,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 34,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Road to Recovery, Drugs Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-04719.3",
      "ID": 4859
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4956,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Keir",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3210401+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244921",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244921,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1965,
      "AgendaID": 2598,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 34,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Road to Recovery, Drugs Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-04719.3",
      "ID": 4859
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Kelly",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5843076+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315091",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315091,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1965,
      "AgendaID": 2598,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 34,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Road to Recovery, Drugs Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-04719.3",
      "ID": 4859
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3129,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6736737+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247866",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247866,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1965,
      "AgendaID": 2598,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 34,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Road to Recovery, Drugs Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-04719.3",
      "ID": 4859
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann",
      "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4317733+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4016E11P36VM275028",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 275028,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1965,
      "AgendaID": 2598,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 34,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Road to Recovery, Drugs Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-04719.3",
      "ID": 4859
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4016,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1380718+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255562",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255562,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1965,
      "AgendaID": 2598,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 34,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Road to Recovery, Drugs Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-04719.3",
      "ID": 4859
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2180,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5366631+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4938E158P374VM277371",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277371,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1965,
      "AgendaID": 2598,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 34,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Road to Recovery, Drugs Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-04719.3",
      "ID": 4859
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4938,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9504989+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2112E250P486VM253402",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253402,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1965,
      "AgendaID": 2598,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 34,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Road to Recovery, Drugs Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-04719.3",
      "ID": 4859
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2112,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny",
      "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.9948758+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4939E258P394VM276756",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276756,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1965,
      "AgendaID": 2598,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 34,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Road to Recovery, Drugs Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-04719.3",
      "ID": 4859
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4939,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus",
      "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6797596+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325488",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 325488,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1965,
      "AgendaID": 2598,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 34,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Road to Recovery, Drugs Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-04719.3",
      "ID": 4859
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5074,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon",
      "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5085375+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1828E3P10VM232909",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232909,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1965,
      "AgendaID": 2598,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 34,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Road to Recovery, Drugs Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-04719.3",
      "ID": 4859
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1828,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo",
      "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8818756+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311640",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311640,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1965,
      "AgendaID": 2598,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 34,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Road to Recovery, Drugs Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-04719.3",
      "ID": 4859
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4948,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike",
      "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8878696+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2117E90P107VM229708",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229708,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1965,
      "AgendaID": 2598,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 34,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Road to Recovery, Drugs Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-04719.3",
      "ID": 4859
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2117,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis",
      "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0932575+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267426",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 267426,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1965,
      "AgendaID": 2598,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 34,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Road to Recovery, Drugs Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-04719.3",
      "ID": 4859
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken",
      "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0193165+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313521",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313521,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1965,
      "AgendaID": 2598,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 34,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Road to Recovery, Drugs Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-04719.3",
      "ID": 4859
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4966,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek",
      "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.3989571+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3101E102P129VM295014",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295014,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1965,
      "AgendaID": 2598,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 34,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Road to Recovery, Drugs Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-04719.3",
      "ID": 4859
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3101,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala",
      "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1885036+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319077",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319077,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1965,
      "AgendaID": 2598,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 34,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Road to Recovery, Drugs Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-04719.3",
      "ID": 4859
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5034,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny",
      "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6914617+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306395",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306395,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1965,
      "AgendaID": 2598,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 34,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Road to Recovery, Drugs Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-04719.3",
      "ID": 4859
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2159,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Martin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5502554+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5110E252P395VM310795",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 310795,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1965,
      "AgendaID": 2598,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 34,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Road to Recovery, Drugs Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-04719.3",
      "ID": 4859
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Mason",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5863762+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268178",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 268178,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1965,
      "AgendaID": 2598,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 34,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Road to Recovery, Drugs Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-04719.3",
      "ID": 4859
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2133,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0595611+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2876E141P433VM286395",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286395,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1965,
      "AgendaID": 2598,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 34,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Road to Recovery, Drugs Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-04719.3",
      "ID": 4859
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2876,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5773039+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4951E147P368VM258632",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258632,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1965,
      "AgendaID": 2598,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 34,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Road to Recovery, Drugs Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-04719.3",
      "ID": 4859
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4951,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan",
      "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3158684+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3896E175P307VM263804",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 263804,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1965,
      "AgendaID": 2598,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 34,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Road to Recovery, Drugs Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-04719.3",
      "ID": 4859
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3896,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam",
      "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9054435+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308537",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 308537,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1965,
      "AgendaID": 2598,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 34,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Road to Recovery, Drugs Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-04719.3",
      "ID": 4859
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0601772+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4964E143P375VM279746",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279746,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1965,
      "AgendaID": 2598,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 34,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Road to Recovery, Drugs Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-04719.3",
      "ID": 4859
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4964,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5208288+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279599",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279599,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1965,
      "AgendaID": 2598,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 34,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Road to Recovery, Drugs Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-04719.3",
      "ID": 4859
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3824,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5146052+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2066E22P91VM261068",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261068,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1965,
      "AgendaID": 2598,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 34,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Road to Recovery, Drugs Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-04719.3",
      "ID": 4859
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2066,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.1104352+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299605",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 299605,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1965,
      "AgendaID": 2598,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 34,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Road to Recovery, Drugs Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-04719.3",
      "ID": 4859
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7047706+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306723",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306723,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1965,
      "AgendaID": 2598,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 34,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Road to Recovery, Drugs Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-04719.3",
      "ID": 4859
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina",
      "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5646307+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300611",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 300611,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1965,
      "AgendaID": 2598,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 34,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Road to Recovery, Drugs Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-04719.3",
      "ID": 4859
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2487,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.006066+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223872",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223872,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1965,
      "AgendaID": 2598,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 34,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Road to Recovery, Drugs Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-04719.3",
      "ID": 4859
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4774032+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237872",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237872,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1965,
      "AgendaID": 2598,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 34,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Road to Recovery, Drugs Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-04719.3",
      "ID": 4859
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1961,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David",
      "DisplayName": "David McLetchie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2297016+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305472",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 305472,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1965,
      "AgendaID": 2598,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 34,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Road to Recovery, Drugs Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-04719.3",
      "ID": 4859
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2134,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3255575+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320349",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 320349,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1965,
      "AgendaID": 2598,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 34,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Road to Recovery, Drugs Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-04719.3",
      "ID": 4859
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5041,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan",
      "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1561831+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315991",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315991,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1965,
      "AgendaID": 2598,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 34,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Road to Recovery, Drugs Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-04719.3",
      "ID": 4859
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3763,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart",
      "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9410481+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1986E23P197VM236701",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 236701,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1965,
      "AgendaID": 2598,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 34,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Road to Recovery, Drugs Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-04719.3",
      "ID": 4859
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1986,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan",
      "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9363509+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5047E100P130VM289803",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289803,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1965,
      "AgendaID": 2598,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 34,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Road to Recovery, Drugs Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-04719.3",
      "ID": 4859
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5047,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne",
      "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4597516+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234531",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234531,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1965,
      "AgendaID": 2598,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 34,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Road to Recovery, Drugs Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-04719.3",
      "ID": 4859
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1845,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette",
      "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3883136+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313561",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313561,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1965,
      "AgendaID": 2598,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 34,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Road to Recovery, Drugs Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-04719.3",
      "ID": 4859
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3061,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4007041+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1768E19P265VM289327",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289327,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1965,
      "AgendaID": 2598,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 34,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Road to Recovery, Drugs Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-04719.3",
      "ID": 4859
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1768,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4324946+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225317",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225317,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1965,
      "AgendaID": 2598,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 34,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Road to Recovery, Drugs Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-04719.3",
      "ID": 4859
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1894,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Neil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9693208+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3815E98P134VM270962",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270962,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1965,
      "AgendaID": 2598,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 34,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Road to Recovery, Drugs Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-04719.3",
      "ID": 4859
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3815,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Park, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Park",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8365718+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265817",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265817,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1965,
      "AgendaID": 2598,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 34,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Road to Recovery, Drugs Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-04719.3",
      "ID": 4859
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2010,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil",
      "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4557773+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283242",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283242,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1965,
      "AgendaID": 2598,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 34,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Road to Recovery, Drugs Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-04719.3",
      "ID": 4859
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5057,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.6919964+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2853E33P128VM251547",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251547,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1965,
      "AgendaID": 2598,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 34,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Road to Recovery, Drugs Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-04719.3",
      "ID": 4859
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Pentland",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4684065+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317570",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317570,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1965,
      "AgendaID": 2598,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 34,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Road to Recovery, Drugs Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-04719.3",
      "ID": 4859
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5009,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4281271+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254661",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254661,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1965,
      "AgendaID": 2598,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 34,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Road to Recovery, Drugs Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-04719.3",
      "ID": 4859
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3745,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis",
      "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2661891+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1870E225P478VM296228",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 296228,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1965,
      "AgendaID": 2598,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 34,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Road to Recovery, Drugs Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-04719.3",
      "ID": 4859
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1870,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona",
      "DisplayName": "Shona Robison",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8395907+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2135E254P450VM235451",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235451,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1965,
      "AgendaID": 2598,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 34,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Road to Recovery, Drugs Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-04719.3",
      "ID": 4859
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2135,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Russell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6784296+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1895E232P431VM257639",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257639,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1965,
      "AgendaID": 2598,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 34,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Road to Recovery, Drugs Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-04719.3",
      "ID": 4859
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1895,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0651833+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228157",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 228157,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1965,
      "AgendaID": 2598,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 34,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Road to Recovery, Drugs Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-04719.3",
      "ID": 4859
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1839,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5867981+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2345E10P55VM291613",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291613,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1965,
      "AgendaID": 2598,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 34,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Road to Recovery, Drugs Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-04719.3",
      "ID": 4859
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2345,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1348674+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311060",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311060,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1965,
      "AgendaID": 2598,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 34,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Road to Recovery, Drugs Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-04719.3",
      "ID": 4859
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2223,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish",
      "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.6036984+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246377",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 246377,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1965,
      "AgendaID": 2598,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 34,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Road to Recovery, Drugs Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-04719.3",
      "ID": 4859
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2182,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1261054+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298097",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298097,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1965,
      "AgendaID": 2598,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 34,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Road to Recovery, Drugs Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-04719.3",
      "ID": 4859
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5079,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew",
      "DisplayName": "Drew Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1381247+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234129",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234129,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1965,
      "AgendaID": 2598,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 34,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Road to Recovery, Drugs Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-04719.3",
      "ID": 4859
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1769,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1678889+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274662",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274662,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1965,
      "AgendaID": 2598,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 34,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Road to Recovery, Drugs Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-04719.3",
      "ID": 4859
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4014,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz",
      "DisplayName": "Liz Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1163054+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269592",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269592,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1965,
      "AgendaID": 2598,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 34,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Road to Recovery, Drugs Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-04719.3",
      "ID": 4859
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2215,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5545064+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317402",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317402,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1965,
      "AgendaID": 2598,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 34,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Road to Recovery, Drugs Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-04719.3",
      "ID": 4859
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3806,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4205608+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326342",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 326342,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1965,
      "AgendaID": 2598,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 34,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Road to Recovery, Drugs Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-04719.3",
      "ID": 4859
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5106,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin",
      "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7543091+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241170",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241170,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1965,
      "AgendaID": 2598,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 34,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Road to Recovery, Drugs Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-04719.3",
      "ID": 4859
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1848,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola",
      "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.4050434+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2098E237P531VM289664",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289664,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1965,
      "AgendaID": 2598,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 34,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Road to Recovery, Drugs Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-04719.3",
      "ID": 4859
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2098,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Swinney",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4536916+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248017",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248017,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1965,
      "AgendaID": 2598,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 34,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Road to Recovery, Drugs Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-04719.3",
      "ID": 4859
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2674,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave",
      "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4381869+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5075E234P371VM287469",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 287469,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1965,
      "AgendaID": 2598,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 34,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Road to Recovery, Drugs Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-04719.3",
      "ID": 4859
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5075,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Torrance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8655149+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1793E151P9VM222561",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 222561,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1965,
      "AgendaID": 2598,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 34,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Road to Recovery, Drugs Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-04719.3",
      "ID": 4859
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1793,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean",
      "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.194236+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5078E245P7VM306982",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306982,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1965,
      "AgendaID": 2598,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 34,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Road to Recovery, Drugs Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-04719.3",
      "ID": 4859
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5078,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Walker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5822364+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1841E231P426VM239953",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239953,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1965,
      "AgendaID": 2598,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 34,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Road to Recovery, Drugs Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-04719.3",
      "ID": 4859
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1841,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen",
      "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7664337+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283679",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283679,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1965,
      "AgendaID": 2598,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 34,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Road to Recovery, Drugs Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-04719.3",
      "ID": 4859
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4952,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7186063+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1865E263P500VM231834",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231834,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1965,
      "AgendaID": 2598,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 34,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Road to Recovery, Drugs Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-04719.3",
      "ID": 4859
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1865,
      "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra",
      "DisplayName": "Sandra White",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6175351+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237387",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237387,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1965,
      "AgendaID": 2598,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 34,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Road to Recovery, Drugs Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-04719.3",
      "ID": 4859
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2610,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Wilson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2020097+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309197",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 309197,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1965,
      "AgendaID": 2598,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 34,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Road to Recovery, Drugs Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-04719.3",
      "ID": 4859
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4941,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza",
      "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.096486+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252752",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252752,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1962,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.2",
      "ID": 4759
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1926,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian",
      "DisplayName": "Brian Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7518058+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2615E213P388VM259152",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 259152,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1962,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.2",
      "ID": 4759
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2615,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George",
      "DisplayName": "George Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3439623+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319587",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319587,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1962,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.2",
      "ID": 4759
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4940,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare",
      "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9325857+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249479",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 249479,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1962,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.2",
      "ID": 4759
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2641,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair",
      "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9286563+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1783E21P273VM228339",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 228339,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1962,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.2",
      "ID": 4759
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1783,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie",
      "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.7940865+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2633E97P136VM280881",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280881,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1962,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.2",
      "ID": 4759
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2633,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire",
      "DisplayName": "Claire Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7863501+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262781",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262781,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1962,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.2",
      "ID": 4759
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2603,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.616577+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1759E91P115VM230488",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230488,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1962,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.2",
      "ID": 4759
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia",
      "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3321333+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3751E243P383VM269719",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269719,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1962,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.2",
      "ID": 4759
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3751,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5600502+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322566",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 322566,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1962,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.2",
      "ID": 4759
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5109,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco",
      "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6942169+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5060E86P124VM295318",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295318,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1962,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.2",
      "ID": 4759
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5060,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5068357+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1866E93P239VM243015",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 243015,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1962,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.2",
      "ID": 4759
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1866,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah",
      "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0452678+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235092",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235092,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1962,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.2",
      "ID": 4759
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1943,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic",
      "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.419031+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302437",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 302437,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1962,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.2",
      "ID": 4759
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2595,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin",
      "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5245465+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244222",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244222,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1962,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.2",
      "ID": 4759
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2103,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith",
      "DisplayName": "Keith Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5452359+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327088",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 327088,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1962,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.2",
      "ID": 4759
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7983406+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277120",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277120,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1962,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.2",
      "ID": 4759
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.7019626+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264054",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264054,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1962,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.2",
      "ID": 4759
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2673,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick",
      "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9222182+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248653",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248653,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1962,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.2",
      "ID": 4759
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2678,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson",
      "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6640752+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2123E27P233VM294897",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 294897,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1962,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.2",
      "ID": 4759
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2123,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm",
      "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1834308+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285285",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285285,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1962,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.2",
      "ID": 4759
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3907,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3164056+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230762",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230762,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1962,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.2",
      "ID": 4759
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1735,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela",
      "DisplayName": "Angela Constance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3444322+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243703",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 243703,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1962,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.2",
      "ID": 4759
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1932,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce",
      "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3162237+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254809",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254809,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1962,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.2",
      "ID": 4759
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1863,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna",
      "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2846654+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323695",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 323695,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1962,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.2",
      "ID": 4759
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4976,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth",
      "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.967899+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5107E223P379VM290904",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 290904,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1962,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.2",
      "ID": 4759
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5107,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7770985+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3743E222P391VM265457",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265457,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1962,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.2",
      "ID": 4759
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3743,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel",
      "DisplayName": "Nigel Don",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4400176+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262371",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262371,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1962,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.2",
      "ID": 4759
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3771,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob",
      "DisplayName": "Bob Doris",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.5985802+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281858",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 281858,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1962,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.2",
      "ID": 4759
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2826,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Dornan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1606267+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298269",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298269,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1962,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.2",
      "ID": 4759
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3812,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia",
      "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3384793+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231179",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231179,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1962,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.2",
      "ID": 4759
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1778,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen",
      "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3692356+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4955E240P389VM284963",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 284963,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1962,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.2",
      "ID": 4759
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4955,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0552373+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219513",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 219513,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1962,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.2",
      "ID": 4759
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1742,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle",
      "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3025781+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238275",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 238275,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1962,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.2",
      "ID": 4759
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1994,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus",
      "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4393728+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225132",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225132,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1962,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.2",
      "ID": 4759
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1814,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda",
      "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7458382+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321894",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 321894,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1962,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.2",
      "ID": 4759
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Fee",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4559114+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292739",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 292739,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1962,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.2",
      "ID": 4759
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia",
      "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5557239+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227238",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227238,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1962,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.2",
      "ID": 4759
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5368076+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5054E95P118VM313258",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313258,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1962,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.2",
      "ID": 4759
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5054,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.3875407+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4947E152P8VM257803",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257803,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1962,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.2",
      "ID": 4759
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4947,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Finnie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0782785+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271096",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271096,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1962,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.2",
      "ID": 4759
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3901,
      "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe",
      "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8423221+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2394E15P47VM277996",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277996,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1962,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.2",
      "ID": 4759
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2394,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo",
      "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9824966+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2110E220P414VM287333",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 287333,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1962,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.2",
      "ID": 4759
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth",
      "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8596709+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250620",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250620,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1962,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.2",
      "ID": 4759
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2675,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob",
      "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1974004+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221084",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221084,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1962,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.2",
      "ID": 4759
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1741,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel",
      "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6743829+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220131",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220131,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1962,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.2",
      "ID": 4759
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1756,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine",
      "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3356654+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1860E104P150VM252458",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252458,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1962,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.2",
      "ID": 4759
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1860,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda",
      "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7300216+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2033E20P141VM253765",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253765,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1962,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.2",
      "ID": 4759
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2033,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain",
      "DisplayName": "Iain Gray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.019959+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324710",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324710,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1962,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.2",
      "ID": 4759
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5042,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2345877+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259600",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 259600,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1962,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.2",
      "ID": 4759
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick",
      "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6164298+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239467",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239467,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1962,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.2",
      "ID": 4759
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2029,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh",
      "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7380682+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273680",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 273680,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1962,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.2",
      "ID": 4759
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3758,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.630785+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304049",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 304049,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1962,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.2",
      "ID": 4759
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4086,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Hume",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8471726+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221610",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221610,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1962,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.2",
      "ID": 4759
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1773,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9401497+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1882E227P459VM241842",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241842,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1962,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.2",
      "ID": 4759
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1882,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam",
      "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7823865+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223405",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223405,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1962,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.2",
      "ID": 4759
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1893,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.456453+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307852",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307852,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1962,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.2",
      "ID": 4759
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4934,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8536983+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272355",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 272355,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1962,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.2",
      "ID": 4759
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4956,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Keir",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3317587+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2059E26P131VM245026",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 245026,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1962,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.2",
      "ID": 4759
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Kelly",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.588833+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315192",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315192,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1962,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.2",
      "ID": 4759
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3129,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.678281+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247494",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247494,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1962,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.2",
      "ID": 4759
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann",
      "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4062358+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4016E11P36VM275144",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 275144,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1962,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.2",
      "ID": 4759
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4016,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1434921+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255496",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255496,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1962,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.2",
      "ID": 4759
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2180,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.533832+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4938E158P374VM276945",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276945,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1962,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.2",
      "ID": 4759
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4938,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6879251+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2112E250P486VM253468",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253468,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1962,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.2",
      "ID": 4759
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2112,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny",
      "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.9977241+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4939E258P394VM276718",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276718,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1962,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.2",
      "ID": 4759
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4939,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus",
      "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6781508+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325421",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 325421,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1962,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.2",
      "ID": 4759
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5074,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon",
      "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.4979693+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1828E3P10VM233261",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 233261,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1962,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.2",
      "ID": 4759
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1828,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo",
      "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1163784+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311697",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311697,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1962,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.2",
      "ID": 4759
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4948,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike",
      "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8903847+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2117E90P107VM229666",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229666,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1962,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.2",
      "ID": 4759
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2117,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis",
      "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0914825+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267479",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 267479,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1962,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.2",
      "ID": 4759
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken",
      "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.021601+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313464",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313464,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1962,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.2",
      "ID": 4759
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4966,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek",
      "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.3964994+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3101E102P129VM294959",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 294959,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1962,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.2",
      "ID": 4759
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3101,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala",
      "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.186109+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319143",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319143,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1962,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.2",
      "ID": 4759
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5034,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny",
      "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6942936+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306294",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306294,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1962,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.2",
      "ID": 4759
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2159,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Martin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5458758+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5110E252P395VM310741",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 310741,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1962,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.2",
      "ID": 4759
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Mason",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5840541+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268125",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 268125,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1962,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.2",
      "ID": 4759
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2133,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0572376+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2876E141P433VM286450",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286450,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1962,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.2",
      "ID": 4759
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2876,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.579725+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4951E147P368VM258516",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258516,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1962,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.2",
      "ID": 4759
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4951,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan",
      "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.310613+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3896E175P307VM263766",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 263766,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1962,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.2",
      "ID": 4759
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3896,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam",
      "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9037995+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308747",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 308747,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1962,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.2",
      "ID": 4759
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0692498+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4964E143P375VM279783",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279783,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1962,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.2",
      "ID": 4759
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4964,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5226328+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279553",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279553,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1962,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.2",
      "ID": 4759
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3824,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5126547+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2066E22P91VM260494",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 260494,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1962,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.2",
      "ID": 4759
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2066,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.0793045+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299395",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 299395,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1962,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.2",
      "ID": 4759
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.6955894+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306779",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306779,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1962,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.2",
      "ID": 4759
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina",
      "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5670606+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300556",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 300556,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1962,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.2",
      "ID": 4759
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2487,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0036925+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223988",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223988,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1962,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.2",
      "ID": 4759
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4871985+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237922",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237922,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1962,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.2",
      "ID": 4759
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1961,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David",
      "DisplayName": "David McLetchie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.231867+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305574",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 305574,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1962,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.2",
      "ID": 4759
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2134,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3302325+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320127",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 320127,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1962,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.2",
      "ID": 4759
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5041,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan",
      "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9628423+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315890",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315890,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1962,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.2",
      "ID": 4759
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3763,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart",
      "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.931622+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1986E23P197VM236749",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 236749,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1962,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.2",
      "ID": 4759
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1986,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan",
      "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9384025+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5047E100P130VM289756",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289756,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1962,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.2",
      "ID": 4759
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5047,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne",
      "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4577731+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234478",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234478,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1962,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.2",
      "ID": 4759
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1845,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette",
      "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3859889+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313149",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313149,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1962,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.2",
      "ID": 4759
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3061,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1657781+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1768E19P265VM289380",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289380,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1962,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.2",
      "ID": 4759
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1768,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.434763+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225382",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225382,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1962,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.2",
      "ID": 4759
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1894,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Neil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9723096+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3815E98P134VM270990",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270990,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1962,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.2",
      "ID": 4759
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3815,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Park, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Park",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8378051+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265765",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265765,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1962,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.2",
      "ID": 4759
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2010,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil",
      "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4535134+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283204",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283204,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1962,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.2",
      "ID": 4759
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5057,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.6903425+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2853E33P128VM252047",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252047,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1962,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.2",
      "ID": 4759
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Pentland",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.5002918+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317349",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317349,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1962,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.2",
      "ID": 4759
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5009,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4182982+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254231",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254231,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1962,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.2",
      "ID": 4759
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3745,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis",
      "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2466029+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1870E225P478VM296282",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 296282,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1962,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.2",
      "ID": 4759
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1870,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona",
      "DisplayName": "Shona Robison",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.842036+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2135E254P450VM235492",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235492,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1962,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.2",
      "ID": 4759
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2135,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Russell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6801553+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1895E232P431VM257690",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257690,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1962,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.2",
      "ID": 4759
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1895,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0673619+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228581",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 228581,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1962,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.2",
      "ID": 4759
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1839,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.8052609+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2345E10P55VM291562",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291562,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1962,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.2",
      "ID": 4759
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2345,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.132683+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311162",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311162,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1962,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.2",
      "ID": 4759
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2223,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish",
      "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.6083808+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246803",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 246803,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1962,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.2",
      "ID": 4759
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2182,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1540641+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298049",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298049,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1962,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.2",
      "ID": 4759
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5079,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew",
      "DisplayName": "Drew Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1360637+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234079",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234079,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1962,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.2",
      "ID": 4759
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1769,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1657202+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274700",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274700,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1962,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.2",
      "ID": 4759
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4014,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz",
      "DisplayName": "Liz Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1179326+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269645",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269645,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1962,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.2",
      "ID": 4759
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2215,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5568493+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317503",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317503,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1962,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.2",
      "ID": 4759
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3806,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4252242+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326409",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 326409,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1962,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.2",
      "ID": 4759
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5106,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin",
      "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7572475+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241286",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241286,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1962,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.2",
      "ID": 4759
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1848,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola",
      "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7513848+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2098E237P531VM290385",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 290385,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1962,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.2",
      "ID": 4759
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2098,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Swinney",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7446924+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248056",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248056,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1962,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.2",
      "ID": 4759
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2674,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave",
      "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4398948+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5075E234P371VM287507",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 287507,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1962,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.2",
      "ID": 4759
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5075,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Torrance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.873973+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1793E151P9VM222626",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 222626,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1962,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.2",
      "ID": 4759
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1793,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean",
      "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1970186+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5078E245P7VM306947",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306947,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1962,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.2",
      "ID": 4759
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5078,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Walker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.58074+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1841E231P426VM239838",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239838,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1962,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.2",
      "ID": 4759
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1841,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen",
      "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7610782+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283794",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283794,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1962,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.2",
      "ID": 4759
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4952,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7237536+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1865E263P500VM231782",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231782,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1962,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.2",
      "ID": 4759
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1865,
      "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra",
      "DisplayName": "Sandra White",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6152635+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237347",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237347,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1962,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.2",
      "ID": 4759
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2610,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Wilson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.20028+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4941E150P382VM308985",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 308985,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1962,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 64,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.2",
      "ID": 4759
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4941,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza",
      "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0865701+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252753",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252753,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1963,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.1",
      "ID": 4757
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1926,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian",
      "DisplayName": "Brian Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7518473+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2615E213P388VM259153",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 259153,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1963,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.1",
      "ID": 4757
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2615,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George",
      "DisplayName": "George Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3440044+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319586",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319586,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1963,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.1",
      "ID": 4757
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4940,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare",
      "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9324483+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249478",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 249478,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1963,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.1",
      "ID": 4757
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2641,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair",
      "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9286135+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1783E21P273VM228340",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 228340,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1963,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.1",
      "ID": 4757
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1783,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie",
      "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.7941322+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2633E97P136VM281035",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 281035,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1963,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.1",
      "ID": 4757
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2633,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire",
      "DisplayName": "Claire Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.8032312+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262991",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262991,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1963,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.1",
      "ID": 4757
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2603,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6319648+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1759E91P115VM230489",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230489,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1963,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.1",
      "ID": 4757
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia",
      "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3321738+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3751E243P383VM269718",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269718,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1963,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.1",
      "ID": 4757
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3751,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5600103+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322567",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 322567,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1963,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.1",
      "ID": 4757
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5109,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco",
      "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6942577+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5060E86P124VM295374",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295374,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1963,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.1",
      "ID": 4757
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5060,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5094414+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1866E93P239VM243016",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 243016,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1963,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.1",
      "ID": 4757
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1866,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah",
      "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0453103+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235091",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235091,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1963,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.1",
      "ID": 4757
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1943,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic",
      "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4189903+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302438",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 302438,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1963,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.1",
      "ID": 4757
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2595,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin",
      "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5245876+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244167",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244167,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1963,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.1",
      "ID": 4757
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2103,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith",
      "DisplayName": "Keith Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3416634+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327089",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 327089,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1963,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.1",
      "ID": 4757
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7983832+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277486",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277486,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1963,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.1",
      "ID": 4757
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9554323+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2673E236P377VM263999",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 263999,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1963,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.1",
      "ID": 4757
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2673,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick",
      "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9198664+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248652",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248652,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1963,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.1",
      "ID": 4757
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2678,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson",
      "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6640159+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2123E27P233VM294896",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 294896,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1963,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.1",
      "ID": 4757
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2123,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm",
      "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1833898+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285341",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285341,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1963,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.1",
      "ID": 4757
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3907,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3188357+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1735E248P405VM231279",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231279,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1963,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.1",
      "ID": 4757
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1735,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela",
      "DisplayName": "Angela Constance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.5881077+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243702",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 243702,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1963,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.1",
      "ID": 4757
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1932,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce",
      "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3161838+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254808",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254808,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1963,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.1",
      "ID": 4757
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1863,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna",
      "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2846167+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323696",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 323696,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1963,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.1",
      "ID": 4757
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4976,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth",
      "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9679612+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5107E223P379VM290901",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 290901,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1963,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.1",
      "ID": 4757
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5107,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7769762+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3743E222P391VM273038",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 273038,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1963,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.1",
      "ID": 4757
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3743,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel",
      "DisplayName": "Nigel Don",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3668915+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262527",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262527,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1963,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.1",
      "ID": 4757
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3771,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob",
      "DisplayName": "Bob Doris",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6057485+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281857",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 281857,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1963,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.1",
      "ID": 4757
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2826,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Dornan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1605864+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298270",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298270,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1963,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.1",
      "ID": 4757
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3812,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia",
      "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3385205+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231178",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231178,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1963,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.1",
      "ID": 4757
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1778,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen",
      "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3691942+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4955E240P389VM284962",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 284962,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1963,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.1",
      "ID": 4757
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4955,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0551968+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219514",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 219514,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1963,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.1",
      "ID": 4757
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1742,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle",
      "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3026201+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238274",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 238274,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1963,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.1",
      "ID": 4757
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1994,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus",
      "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4393319+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225131",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225131,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1963,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.1",
      "ID": 4757
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1814,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda",
      "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7457986+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321893",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 321893,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1963,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.1",
      "ID": 4757
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Fee",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4558706+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292738",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 292738,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1963,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.1",
      "ID": 4757
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia",
      "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5556837+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227239",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227239,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1963,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.1",
      "ID": 4757
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5368515+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5054E95P118VM313259",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313259,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1963,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.1",
      "ID": 4757
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5054,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.3875851+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4947E152P8VM257804",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257804,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1963,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.1",
      "ID": 4757
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4947,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Finnie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0783203+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271095",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271095,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1963,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.1",
      "ID": 4757
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3901,
      "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe",
      "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8422636+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2394E15P47VM277995",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277995,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1963,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.1",
      "ID": 4757
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2394,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo",
      "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9824534+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2110E220P414VM287334",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 287334,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1963,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.1",
      "ID": 4757
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth",
      "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8597119+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250621",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250621,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1963,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.1",
      "ID": 4757
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2675,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob",
      "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.197441+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221085",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221085,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1963,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.1",
      "ID": 4757
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1741,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel",
      "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6744247+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220130",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220130,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1963,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.1",
      "ID": 4757
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1756,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine",
      "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3356238+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1860E104P150VM252459",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252459,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1963,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.1",
      "ID": 4757
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1860,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda",
      "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7300627+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2033E20P141VM253764",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253764,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1963,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.1",
      "ID": 4757
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2033,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain",
      "DisplayName": "Iain Gray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.019919+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324709",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324709,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1963,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.1",
      "ID": 4757
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5042,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2345476+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259599",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 259599,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1963,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.1",
      "ID": 4757
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick",
      "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6163888+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239468",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239468,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1963,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.1",
      "ID": 4757
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2029,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh",
      "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7381104+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273625",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 273625,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1963,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.1",
      "ID": 4757
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3758,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.628426+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304048",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 304048,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1963,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.1",
      "ID": 4757
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4086,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Hume",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8471321+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221609",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221609,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1963,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.1",
      "ID": 4757
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1773,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9401083+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1882E227P459VM241841",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241841,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1963,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.1",
      "ID": 4757
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1882,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam",
      "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7823459+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223404",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223404,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1963,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.1",
      "ID": 4757
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1893,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4564117+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307853",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307853,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1963,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.1",
      "ID": 4757
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4934,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8537399+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272356",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 272356,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1963,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.1",
      "ID": 4757
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4956,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Keir",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3318191+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2059E26P131VM245027",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 245027,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1963,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.1",
      "ID": 4757
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Kelly",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5888826+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315193",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315193,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1963,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.1",
      "ID": 4757
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3129,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6783223+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247493",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247493,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1963,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.1",
      "ID": 4757
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann",
      "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4061952+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4016E11P36VM275145",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 275145,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1963,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.1",
      "ID": 4757
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4016,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1435344+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255495",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255495,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1963,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.1",
      "ID": 4757
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2180,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5337901+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4938E158P374VM276944",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276944,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1963,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.1",
      "ID": 4757
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4938,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.687884+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2112E250P486VM253469",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253469,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1963,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.1",
      "ID": 4757
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2112,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny",
      "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.9977661+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4939E258P394VM276715",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276715,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1963,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.1",
      "ID": 4757
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4939,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus",
      "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6780287+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325422",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 325422,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1963,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.1",
      "ID": 4757
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5074,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon",
      "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5056197+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1828E3P10VM233262",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 233262,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1963,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.1",
      "ID": 4757
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1828,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo",
      "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1164391+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311698",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311698,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1963,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.1",
      "ID": 4757
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4948,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike",
      "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.890427+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2117E90P107VM229665",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229665,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1963,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.1",
      "ID": 4757
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2117,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis",
      "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0914423+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267480",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 267480,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1963,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.1",
      "ID": 4757
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken",
      "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0216602+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313463",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313463,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1963,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.1",
      "ID": 4757
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4966,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek",
      "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.3964587+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3101E102P129VM294958",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 294958,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1963,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.1",
      "ID": 4757
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3101,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala",
      "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1860669+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319142",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319142,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1963,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.1",
      "ID": 4757
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5034,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny",
      "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6942512+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306293",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306293,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1963,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.1",
      "ID": 4757
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2159,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Martin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5458339+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5110E252P395VM310740",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 310740,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1963,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.1",
      "ID": 4757
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Mason",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5840133+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268124",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 268124,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1963,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.1",
      "ID": 4757
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2133,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.057196+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2876E141P433VM286451",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286451,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1963,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.1",
      "ID": 4757
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2876,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5797859+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4951E147P368VM258515",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258515,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1963,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.1",
      "ID": 4757
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4951,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan",
      "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.310572+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3896E175P307VM263764",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 263764,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1963,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.1",
      "ID": 4757
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3896,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam",
      "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9037165+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308748",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 308748,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1963,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.1",
      "ID": 4757
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.069291+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4964E143P375VM279786",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279786,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1963,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.1",
      "ID": 4757
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4964,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5227544+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279497",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279497,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1963,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.1",
      "ID": 4757
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3824,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5102481+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2066E22P91VM260493",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 260493,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1963,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.1",
      "ID": 4757
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2066,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.0792633+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299394",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 299394,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1963,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.1",
      "ID": 4757
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.6955478+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306780",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306780,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1963,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.1",
      "ID": 4757
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina",
      "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5671021+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300555",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 300555,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1963,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.1",
      "ID": 4757
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2487,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0036511+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223989",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223989,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1963,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.1",
      "ID": 4757
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4872401+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237923",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237923,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1963,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.1",
      "ID": 4757
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1961,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David",
      "DisplayName": "David McLetchie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2319072+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305575",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 305575,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1963,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.1",
      "ID": 4757
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2134,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3302935+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320128",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 320128,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1963,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.1",
      "ID": 4757
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5041,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan",
      "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9628839+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315889",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315889,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1963,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.1",
      "ID": 4757
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3763,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart",
      "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9315805+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1986E23P197VM237115",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237115,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1963,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.1",
      "ID": 4757
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1986,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan",
      "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.966473+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5047E100P130VM288930",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 288930,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1963,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.1",
      "ID": 4757
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5047,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne",
      "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1644591+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234477",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234477,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1963,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.1",
      "ID": 4757
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1845,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette",
      "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3859288+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313148",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313148,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1963,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.1",
      "ID": 4757
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3061,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1657185+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1768E19P265VM289381",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289381,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1963,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.1",
      "ID": 4757
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1768,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4348042+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225383",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225383,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1963,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.1",
      "ID": 4757
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1894,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Neil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9723568+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3815E98P134VM270991",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270991,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1963,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.1",
      "ID": 4757
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3815,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Park, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Park",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.837847+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265764",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265764,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1963,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.1",
      "ID": 4757
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2010,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil",
      "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4534719+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283201",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283201,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1963,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.1",
      "ID": 4757
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5057,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.6901651+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2853E33P128VM252048",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252048,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1963,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.1",
      "ID": 4757
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Pentland",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.5003327+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317350",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317350,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1963,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.1",
      "ID": 4757
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5009,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4183404+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254230",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254230,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1963,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.1",
      "ID": 4757
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3745,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis",
      "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2465617+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1870E225P478VM296283",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 296283,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1963,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.1",
      "ID": 4757
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1870,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona",
      "DisplayName": "Shona Robison",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.842078+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2135E254P450VM235493",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235493,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1963,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.1",
      "ID": 4757
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2135,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Russell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6802159+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1895E232P431VM257691",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257691,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1963,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.1",
      "ID": 4757
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1895,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0674224+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228582",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 228582,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1963,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.1",
      "ID": 4757
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1839,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.8053211+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2345E10P55VM291561",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291561,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1963,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.1",
      "ID": 4757
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2345,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1326407+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311163",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311163,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1963,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.1",
      "ID": 4757
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2223,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish",
      "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.6084219+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246804",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 246804,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1963,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.1",
      "ID": 4757
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2182,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.154104+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5079E101P119VM297685",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 297685,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1963,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.1",
      "ID": 4757
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5079,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew",
      "DisplayName": "Drew Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1203305+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234025",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234025,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1963,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.1",
      "ID": 4757
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1769,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1568853+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274855",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274855,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1963,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.1",
      "ID": 4757
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4014,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz",
      "DisplayName": "Liz Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1246665+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269646",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269646,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1963,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.1",
      "ID": 4757
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2215,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.556891+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317504",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317504,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1963,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.1",
      "ID": 4757
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3806,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4252663+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326408",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 326408,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1963,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.1",
      "ID": 4757
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5106,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin",
      "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7572052+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241287",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241287,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1963,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.1",
      "ID": 4757
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1848,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola",
      "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7514262+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2098E237P531VM290386",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 290386,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1963,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.1",
      "ID": 4757
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2098,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Swinney",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7447339+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248057",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248057,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1963,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.1",
      "ID": 4757
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2674,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave",
      "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4399366+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5075E234P371VM287510",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 287510,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1963,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.1",
      "ID": 4757
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5075,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Torrance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.874096+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1793E151P9VM222627",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 222627,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1963,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.1",
      "ID": 4757
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1793,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean",
      "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1970592+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5078E245P7VM306946",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306946,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1963,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.1",
      "ID": 4757
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5078,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Walker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5806992+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1841E231P426VM239837",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239837,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1963,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.1",
      "ID": 4757
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1841,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen",
      "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7610368+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283795",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283795,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1963,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.1",
      "ID": 4757
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4952,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7237949+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1865E263P500VM231781",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231781,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1963,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.1",
      "ID": 4757
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1865,
      "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra",
      "DisplayName": "Sandra White",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6152228+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237346",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237346,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1963,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.1",
      "ID": 4757
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2610,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Wilson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2002391+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4941E150P382VM308984",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 308984,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1963,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 100,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627.1",
      "ID": 4757
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4941,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza",
      "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0865272+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252754",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252754,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1964,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 12,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627",
      "ID": 4746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1926,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian",
      "DisplayName": "Brian Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7518876+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2615E213P388VM259154",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 259154,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1964,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 12,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627",
      "ID": 4746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2615,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George",
      "DisplayName": "George Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.344046+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319585",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319585,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1964,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 12,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627",
      "ID": 4746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4940,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare",
      "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9324069+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249477",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 249477,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1964,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 12,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627",
      "ID": 4746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2641,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair",
      "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.928546+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1783E21P273VM228341",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 228341,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1964,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 12,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627",
      "ID": 4746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1783,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie",
      "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.7941765+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2633E97P136VM281036",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 281036,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1964,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 12,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627",
      "ID": 4746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2633,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire",
      "DisplayName": "Claire Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.8032749+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262992",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262992,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1964,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 12,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627",
      "ID": 4746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2603,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6320075+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1759E91P115VM230490",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230490,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1964,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 12,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627",
      "ID": 4746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia",
      "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3323728+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3751E243P383VM269717",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269717,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1964,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 12,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627",
      "ID": 4746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3751,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5599705+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322569",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 322569,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1964,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 12,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627",
      "ID": 4746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5109,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco",
      "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6943587+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5060E86P124VM295375",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295375,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1964,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 12,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627",
      "ID": 4746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5060,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5094822+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1866E93P239VM243017",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 243017,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1964,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 12,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627",
      "ID": 4746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1866,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah",
      "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0453515+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235090",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235090,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1964,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 12,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627",
      "ID": 4746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1943,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic",
      "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4189498+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302440",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 302440,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1964,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 12,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627",
      "ID": 4746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2595,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin",
      "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5246697+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244166",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244166,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1964,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 12,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627",
      "ID": 4746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2103,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith",
      "DisplayName": "Keith Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3416202+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327090",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 327090,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1964,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 12,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627",
      "ID": 4746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7984247+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277487",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277487,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1964,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 12,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627",
      "ID": 4746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9554733+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2673E236P377VM263998",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 263998,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1964,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 12,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627",
      "ID": 4746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2673,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick",
      "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9198257+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248651",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248651,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1964,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 12,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627",
      "ID": 4746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2678,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson",
      "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6639756+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2123E27P233VM294895",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 294895,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1964,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 12,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627",
      "ID": 4746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2123,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm",
      "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.183348+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285342",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285342,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1964,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 12,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627",
      "ID": 4746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3907,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3188772+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1735E248P405VM231280",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231280,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1964,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 12,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627",
      "ID": 4746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1735,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela",
      "DisplayName": "Angela Constance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.5881488+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243701",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 243701,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1964,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 12,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627",
      "ID": 4746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1932,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce",
      "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3161439+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254806",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254806,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1964,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 12,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627",
      "ID": 4746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1863,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna",
      "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2845351+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323697",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 323697,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1964,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 12,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627",
      "ID": 4746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4976,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth",
      "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9680035+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5107E223P379VM290900",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 290900,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1964,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 12,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627",
      "ID": 4746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5107,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7769182+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3743E222P391VM273039",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 273039,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1964,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 12,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627",
      "ID": 4746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3743,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel",
      "DisplayName": "Nigel Don",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3669327+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262528",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262528,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1964,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 12,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627",
      "ID": 4746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3771,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob",
      "DisplayName": "Bob Doris",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6058091+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281856",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 281856,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1964,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 12,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627",
      "ID": 4746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2826,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Dornan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1605462+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298271",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298271,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1964,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 12,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627",
      "ID": 4746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3812,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia",
      "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3385618+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231177",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231177,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1964,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 12,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627",
      "ID": 4746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1778,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen",
      "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3691516+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4955E240P389VM284961",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 284961,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1964,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 12,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627",
      "ID": 4746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4955,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0551566+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219515",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 219515,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1964,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 12,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627",
      "ID": 4746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1742,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle",
      "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3026618+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238273",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 238273,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1964,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 12,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627",
      "ID": 4746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1994,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus",
      "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4392912+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225130",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225130,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1964,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 12,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627",
      "ID": 4746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1814,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda",
      "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7457592+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321891",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 321891,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1964,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 12,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627",
      "ID": 4746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Fee",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4557886+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292737",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 292737,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1964,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 12,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627",
      "ID": 4746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia",
      "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5556435+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227240",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227240,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1964,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 12,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627",
      "ID": 4746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5368962+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5054E95P118VM313261",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313261,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1964,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 12,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627",
      "ID": 4746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5054,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.3876698+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4947E152P8VM257805",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257805,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1964,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 12,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627",
      "ID": 4746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4947,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Finnie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0783614+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271094",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271094,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1964,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 12,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627",
      "ID": 4746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3901,
      "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe",
      "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8422233+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2394E15P47VM277994",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277994,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1964,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 12,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627",
      "ID": 4746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2394,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo",
      "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9824096+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2110E220P414VM287336",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 287336,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1964,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 12,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627",
      "ID": 4746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth",
      "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8597932+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250622",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250622,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1964,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 12,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627",
      "ID": 4746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2675,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob",
      "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1974997+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221086",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221086,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1964,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 12,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627",
      "ID": 4746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1741,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel",
      "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6744657+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220129",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220129,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1964,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 12,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627",
      "ID": 4746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1756,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine",
      "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3355828+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1860E104P150VM252460",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252460,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1964,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 12,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627",
      "ID": 4746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1860,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda",
      "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7301036+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2033E20P141VM253763",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253763,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1964,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 12,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627",
      "ID": 4746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2033,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain",
      "DisplayName": "Iain Gray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0198792+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324708",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324708,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1964,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 12,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627",
      "ID": 4746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5042,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2345075+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259598",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 259598,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1964,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 12,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627",
      "ID": 4746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick",
      "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6163486+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239469",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239469,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1964,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 12,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627",
      "ID": 4746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2029,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh",
      "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.738151+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273624",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 273624,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1964,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 12,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627",
      "ID": 4746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3758,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6283857+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304046",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 304046,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1964,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 12,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627",
      "ID": 4746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4086,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Hume",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8470507+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221608",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221608,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1964,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 12,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627",
      "ID": 4746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1773,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9400679+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1882E227P459VM241840",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241840,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1964,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 12,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627",
      "ID": 4746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1882,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam",
      "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7823049+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223403",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223403,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1964,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 12,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627",
      "ID": 4746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1893,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4563711+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307854",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307854,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1964,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 12,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627",
      "ID": 4746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4934,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8537814+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272357",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 272357,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1964,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 12,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627",
      "ID": 4746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4956,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Keir",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3318616+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2059E26P131VM245028",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 245028,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1964,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 12,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627",
      "ID": 4746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Kelly",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5889237+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315194",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315194,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1964,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 12,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627",
      "ID": 4746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3129,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6783827+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247492",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247492,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1964,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 12,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627",
      "ID": 4746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann",
      "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4061541+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4016E11P36VM275146",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 275146,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1964,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 12,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627",
      "ID": 4746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4016,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1435759+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255494",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255494,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1964,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 12,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627",
      "ID": 4746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2180,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.533728+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4938E158P374VM276943",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276943,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1964,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 12,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627",
      "ID": 4746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4938,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6878417+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2112E250P486VM253470",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253470,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1964,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 12,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627",
      "ID": 4746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2112,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny",
      "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.9978074+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4939E258P394VM276714",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276714,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1964,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 12,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627",
      "ID": 4746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4939,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus",
      "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6779887+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325423",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 325423,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1964,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 12,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627",
      "ID": 4746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5074,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon",
      "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5057033+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1828E3P10VM233263",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 233263,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1964,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 12,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627",
      "ID": 4746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1828,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo",
      "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1164818+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311699",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311699,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1964,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 12,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627",
      "ID": 4746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4948,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike",
      "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8904685+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2117E90P107VM229664",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229664,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1964,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 12,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627",
      "ID": 4746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2117,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis",
      "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0914024+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267481",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 267481,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1964,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 12,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627",
      "ID": 4746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken",
      "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0217025+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313461",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313461,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1964,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 12,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627",
      "ID": 4746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4966,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek",
      "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.3963744+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3101E102P129VM294957",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 294957,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1964,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 12,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627",
      "ID": 4746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3101,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala",
      "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1860261+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319140",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319140,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1964,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 12,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627",
      "ID": 4746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5034,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny",
      "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6941515+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306292",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306292,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1964,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 12,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627",
      "ID": 4746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2159,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Martin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5457747+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5110E252P395VM310739",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 310739,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1964,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 12,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627",
      "ID": 4746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Mason",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5839723+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268123",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 268123,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1964,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 12,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627",
      "ID": 4746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2133,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.057155+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2876E141P433VM286452",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286452,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1964,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 12,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627",
      "ID": 4746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2876,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5798285+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4951E147P368VM258514",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258514,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1964,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 12,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627",
      "ID": 4746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4951,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan",
      "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3105304+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3896E175P307VM263763",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 263763,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1964,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 12,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627",
      "ID": 4746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3896,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam",
      "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.903676+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308749",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 308749,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1964,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 12,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627",
      "ID": 4746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0693319+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4964E143P375VM279787",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279787,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1964,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 12,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627",
      "ID": 4746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4964,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5227952+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279496",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279496,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1964,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 12,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627",
      "ID": 4746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3824,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5102074+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2066E22P91VM260492",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 260492,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1964,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 12,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627",
      "ID": 4746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2066,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.0792225+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299393",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 299393,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1964,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 12,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627",
      "ID": 4746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.6955068+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306781",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306781,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1964,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 12,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627",
      "ID": 4746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina",
      "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5671442+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300554",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 300554,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1964,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 12,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627",
      "ID": 4746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2487,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0036077+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223990",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223990,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1964,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 12,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627",
      "ID": 4746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4872808+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237924",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237924,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1964,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 12,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627",
      "ID": 4746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1961,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David",
      "DisplayName": "David McLetchie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2319483+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305576",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 305576,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1964,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 12,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627",
      "ID": 4746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2134,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3303364+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320130",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 320130,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1964,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 12,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627",
      "ID": 4746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5041,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan",
      "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9629661+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315888",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315888,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1964,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 12,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627",
      "ID": 4746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3763,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart",
      "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9315394+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1986E23P197VM237116",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237116,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1964,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 12,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627",
      "ID": 4746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1986,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan",
      "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9665126+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5047E100P130VM288929",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 288929,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1964,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 12,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627",
      "ID": 4746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5047,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne",
      "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1644191+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234476",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234476,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1964,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 12,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627",
      "ID": 4746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1845,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette",
      "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3858876+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313147",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313147,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1964,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 12,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627",
      "ID": 4746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3061,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1656773+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1768E19P265VM289382",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289382,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1964,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 12,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627",
      "ID": 4746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1768,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4348453+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225384",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225384,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1964,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 12,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627",
      "ID": 4746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1894,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Neil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9723981+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3815E98P134VM270992",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270992,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1964,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 12,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627",
      "ID": 4746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3815,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Park, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Park",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8378884+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265762",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265762,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1964,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 12,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627",
      "ID": 4746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2010,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil",
      "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4533891+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283200",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283200,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1964,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 12,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627",
      "ID": 4746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5057,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.6901045+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2853E33P128VM252049",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252049,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1964,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 12,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627",
      "ID": 4746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Pentland",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.5003738+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317352",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317352,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1964,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 12,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627",
      "ID": 4746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5009,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4184227+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254229",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254229,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1964,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 12,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627",
      "ID": 4746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3745,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis",
      "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2465201+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1870E225P478VM296284",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 296284,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1964,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 12,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627",
      "ID": 4746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1870,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona",
      "DisplayName": "Shona Robison",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.84212+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2135E254P450VM235494",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235494,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1964,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 12,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627",
      "ID": 4746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2135,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Russell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6802587+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1895E232P431VM257693",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257693,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1964,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 12,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627",
      "ID": 4746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1895,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0675065+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228583",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 228583,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1964,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 12,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627",
      "ID": 4746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1839,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.8053641+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2345E10P55VM291559",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291559,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1964,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 12,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627",
      "ID": 4746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2345,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1325537+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311164",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311164,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1964,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 12,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627",
      "ID": 4746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2223,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish",
      "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.6084632+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246805",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 246805,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1964,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 12,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627",
      "ID": 4746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2182,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.154162+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5079E101P119VM297684",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 297684,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1964,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 12,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627",
      "ID": 4746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5079,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew",
      "DisplayName": "Drew Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1202911+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234024",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234024,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1964,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 12,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627",
      "ID": 4746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1769,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1568443+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274856",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274856,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1964,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 12,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627",
      "ID": 4746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4014,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz",
      "DisplayName": "Liz Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1247075+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269647",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269647,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1964,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 12,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627",
      "ID": 4746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2215,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5569328+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317505",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317505,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1964,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 12,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627",
      "ID": 4746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3806,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4253072+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326407",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 326407,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1964,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 12,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627",
      "ID": 4746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5106,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin",
      "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7571635+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241288",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241288,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1964,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 12,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627",
      "ID": 4746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1848,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola",
      "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7514676+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2098E237P531VM290387",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 290387,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1964,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 12,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627",
      "ID": 4746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2098,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Swinney",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7447758+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248058",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248058,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1964,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 12,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627",
      "ID": 4746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2674,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave",
      "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4399802+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5075E234P371VM287511",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 287511,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1964,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 12,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627",
      "ID": 4746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5075,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Torrance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8741374+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1793E151P9VM222628",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 222628,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1964,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 12,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627",
      "ID": 4746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1793,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean",
      "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1971002+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5078E245P7VM306945",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306945,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1964,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 12,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627",
      "ID": 4746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5078,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Walker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5806587+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1841E231P426VM239836",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239836,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1964,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 12,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627",
      "ID": 4746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1841,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen",
      "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.760996+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283796",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283796,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1964,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 12,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627",
      "ID": 4746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4952,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7238358+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1865E263P500VM231780",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231780,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1964,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 12,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627",
      "ID": 4746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1865,
      "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra",
      "DisplayName": "Sandra White",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6151826+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237345",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237345,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1964,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 12,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627",
      "ID": 4746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2610,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Wilson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2001982+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4941E150P382VM308983",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 308983,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1964,
      "AgendaID": 2476,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 12,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Drink Driving",
      "Reference": "S4M-04627",
      "ID": 4746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4941,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza",
      "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-11-01T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0864679+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252307",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252307,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1961,
      "AgendaID": 3020,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04598",
      "ID": 4717
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1926,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian",
      "DisplayName": "Brian Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7235072+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2615E213P388VM258815",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258815,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1961,
      "AgendaID": 3020,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04598",
      "ID": 4717
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2615,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George",
      "DisplayName": "George Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3291072+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319911",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319911,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1961,
      "AgendaID": 3020,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04598",
      "ID": 4717
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4940,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare",
      "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.946702+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249654",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 249654,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1961,
      "AgendaID": 3020,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04598",
      "ID": 4717
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2641,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair",
      "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9441197+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1783E21P273VM227414",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227414,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1961,
      "AgendaID": 3020,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04598",
      "ID": 4717
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1783,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie",
      "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5491523+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2633E97P136VM280409",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280409,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1961,
      "AgendaID": 3020,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04598",
      "ID": 4717
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2633,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire",
      "DisplayName": "Claire Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7657485+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262505",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262505,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1961,
      "AgendaID": 3020,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04598",
      "ID": 4717
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2603,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6048152+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1759E91P115VM229247",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229247,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1961,
      "AgendaID": 3020,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04598",
      "ID": 4717
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia",
      "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0684225+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270212",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270212,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1961,
      "AgendaID": 3020,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04598",
      "ID": 4717
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3751,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.7941343+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322685",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 322685,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1961,
      "AgendaID": 3020,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04598",
      "ID": 4717
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5109,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco",
      "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6992942+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5060E86P124VM294737",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 294737,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1961,
      "AgendaID": 3020,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04598",
      "ID": 4717
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5060,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1761652+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242841",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242841,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1961,
      "AgendaID": 3020,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04598",
      "ID": 4717
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1866,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah",
      "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0379+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235584",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235584,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1961,
      "AgendaID": 3020,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04598",
      "ID": 4717
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1943,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic",
      "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6840852+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302116",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 302116,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1961,
      "AgendaID": 3020,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04598",
      "ID": 4717
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2595,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin",
      "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.2977344+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244495",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244495,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1961,
      "AgendaID": 3020,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04598",
      "ID": 4717
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2103,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith",
      "DisplayName": "Keith Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5572432+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327378",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 327378,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1961,
      "AgendaID": 3020,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04598",
      "ID": 4717
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:46.0336514+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3775E216P435VM276688",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276688,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1961,
      "AgendaID": 3020,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04598",
      "ID": 4717
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6768767+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264329",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264329,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1961,
      "AgendaID": 3020,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04598",
      "ID": 4717
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2673,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick",
      "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1288285+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248818",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248818,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1961,
      "AgendaID": 3020,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04598",
      "ID": 4717
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2678,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson",
      "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6713719+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2123E27P233VM295842",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295842,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1961,
      "AgendaID": 3020,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04598",
      "ID": 4717
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2123,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm",
      "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5381843+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285166",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285166,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1961,
      "AgendaID": 3020,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04598",
      "ID": 4717
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3907,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0692816+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230644",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230644,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1961,
      "AgendaID": 3020,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04598",
      "ID": 4717
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1735,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela",
      "DisplayName": "Angela Constance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3390612+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243878",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 243878,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1961,
      "AgendaID": 3020,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04598",
      "ID": 4717
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1932,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce",
      "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.323786+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1863E238P523VM255280",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255280,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1961,
      "AgendaID": 3020,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04598",
      "ID": 4717
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1863,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna",
      "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5241208+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4976E20P31VM324013",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324013,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1961,
      "AgendaID": 3020,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04598",
      "ID": 4717
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4976,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth",
      "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9822294+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5107E223P379VM291377",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291377,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1961,
      "AgendaID": 3020,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04598",
      "ID": 4717
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5107,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1166791+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3743E222P391VM265337",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265337,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1961,
      "AgendaID": 3020,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04598",
      "ID": 4717
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3743,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel",
      "DisplayName": "Nigel Don",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4348126+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3771E149P417VM261743",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261743,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1961,
      "AgendaID": 3020,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04598",
      "ID": 4717
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3771,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob",
      "DisplayName": "Bob Doris",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3709113+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2826E262P384VM282022",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 282022,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1961,
      "AgendaID": 3020,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04598",
      "ID": 4717
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2826,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Dornan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1678258+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3812E94P117VM297951",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 297951,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1961,
      "AgendaID": 3020,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04598",
      "ID": 4717
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3812,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia",
      "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1319236+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231636",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231636,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1961,
      "AgendaID": 3020,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04598",
      "ID": 4717
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1778,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen",
      "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6091204+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4955E240P389VM285974",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285974,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1961,
      "AgendaID": 3020,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04598",
      "ID": 4717
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4955,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3525468+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219346",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 219346,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1961,
      "AgendaID": 3020,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04598",
      "ID": 4717
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1742,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle",
      "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.2946483+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238611",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 238611,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1961,
      "AgendaID": 3020,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04598",
      "ID": 4717
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1994,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus",
      "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4615621+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225460",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225460,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1961,
      "AgendaID": 3020,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04598",
      "ID": 4717
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1814,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda",
      "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9756721+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321775",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 321775,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1961,
      "AgendaID": 3020,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04598",
      "ID": 4717
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Fee",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4508489+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292896",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 292896,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1961,
      "AgendaID": 3020,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04598",
      "ID": 4717
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia",
      "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5628726+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1892E12P64VM226913",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 226913,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1961,
      "AgendaID": 3020,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04598",
      "ID": 4717
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2521758+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5054E95P118VM312632",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 312632,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1961,
      "AgendaID": 3020,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04598",
      "ID": 4717
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5054,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1366694+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4947E152P8VM257165",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257165,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1961,
      "AgendaID": 3020,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04598",
      "ID": 4717
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4947,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Finnie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.8261082+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271330",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271330,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1961,
      "AgendaID": 3020,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04598",
      "ID": 4717
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3901,
      "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe",
      "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0708489+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278466",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 278466,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1961,
      "AgendaID": 3020,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04598",
      "ID": 4717
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2394,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo",
      "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2200211+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2110E220P414VM286705",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286705,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1961,
      "AgendaID": 3020,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04598",
      "ID": 4717
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth",
      "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5972086+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250443",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250443,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1961,
      "AgendaID": 3020,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04598",
      "ID": 4717
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2675,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob",
      "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1897653+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1741E10P50VM220755",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220755,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1961,
      "AgendaID": 3020,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04598",
      "ID": 4717
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1741,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel",
      "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6556366+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220299",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220299,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1961,
      "AgendaID": 3020,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04598",
      "ID": 4717
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1756,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine",
      "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6353253+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1860E104P150VM251833",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251833,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1961,
      "AgendaID": 3020,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04598",
      "ID": 4717
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1860,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda",
      "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4911031+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2033E20P141VM266151",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 266151,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1961,
      "AgendaID": 3020,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04598",
      "ID": 4717
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2033,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain",
      "DisplayName": "Iain Gray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4765205+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324420",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324420,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1961,
      "AgendaID": 3020,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04598",
      "ID": 4717
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5042,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2218771+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259920",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 259920,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1961,
      "AgendaID": 3020,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04598",
      "ID": 4717
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick",
      "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6357297+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239286",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239286,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1961,
      "AgendaID": 3020,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04598",
      "ID": 4717
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2029,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh",
      "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.730269+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273800",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 273800,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1961,
      "AgendaID": 3020,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04598",
      "ID": 4717
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3758,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6362029+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304213",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 304213,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1961,
      "AgendaID": 3020,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04598",
      "ID": 4717
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4086,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Hume",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.0285882+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221784",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221784,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1961,
      "AgendaID": 3020,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04598",
      "ID": 4717
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1773,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9476533+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1882E227P459VM242017",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242017,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1961,
      "AgendaID": 3020,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04598",
      "ID": 4717
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1882,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam",
      "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7902461+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223742",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223742,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1961,
      "AgendaID": 3020,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04598",
      "ID": 4717
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1893,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4718212+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307535",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307535,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1961,
      "AgendaID": 3020,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04598",
      "ID": 4717
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4934,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8337188+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272182",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 272182,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1961,
      "AgendaID": 3020,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04598",
      "ID": 4717
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4956,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Keir",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.1151069+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244849",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244849,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1961,
      "AgendaID": 3020,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04598",
      "ID": 4717
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Kelly",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5812703+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315021",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315021,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1961,
      "AgendaID": 3020,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04598",
      "ID": 4717
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3129,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6706803+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247982",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247982,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1961,
      "AgendaID": 3020,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04598",
      "ID": 4717
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann",
      "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4366893+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4016E11P36VM274756",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274756,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1961,
      "AgendaID": 3020,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04598",
      "ID": 4717
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4016,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1203726+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255832",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255832,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1961,
      "AgendaID": 3020,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04598",
      "ID": 4717
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2180,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5589771+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4938E158P374VM277798",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277798,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1961,
      "AgendaID": 3020,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04598",
      "ID": 4717
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4938,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9688864+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2112E250P486VM252980",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252980,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1961,
      "AgendaID": 3020,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04598",
      "ID": 4717
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2112,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny",
      "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7615427+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4939E258P394VM277193",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277193,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1961,
      "AgendaID": 3020,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04598",
      "ID": 4717
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4939,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus",
      "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.7053233+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325711",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 325711,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1961,
      "AgendaID": 3020,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04598",
      "ID": 4717
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5074,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon",
      "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.518043+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1828E3P10VM232798",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232798,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1961,
      "AgendaID": 3020,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04598",
      "ID": 4717
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1828,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo",
      "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8767041+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311382",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311382,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1961,
      "AgendaID": 3020,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04598",
      "ID": 4717
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4948,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike",
      "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.876305+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2117E90P107VM230453",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230453,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1961,
      "AgendaID": 3020,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04598",
      "ID": 4717
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2117,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis",
      "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3305744+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267320",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 267320,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1961,
      "AgendaID": 3020,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04598",
      "ID": 4717
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken",
      "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0143568+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313779",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313779,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1961,
      "AgendaID": 3020,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04598",
      "ID": 4717
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4966,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek",
      "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4102965+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3101E102P129VM295431",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295431,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1961,
      "AgendaID": 3020,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04598",
      "ID": 4717
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3101,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala",
      "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5118615+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319025",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319025,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1961,
      "AgendaID": 3020,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04598",
      "ID": 4717
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5034,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny",
      "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6892045+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306466",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306466,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1961,
      "AgendaID": 3020,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04598",
      "ID": 4717
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2159,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Martin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5532803+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5110E252P395VM311204",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311204,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1961,
      "AgendaID": 3020,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04598",
      "ID": 4717
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Mason",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8664044+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268284",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 268284,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1961,
      "AgendaID": 3020,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04598",
      "ID": 4717
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2133,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2604629+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2876E141P433VM286130",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286130,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1961,
      "AgendaID": 3020,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04598",
      "ID": 4717
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2876,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3650262+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4951E147P368VM260702",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 260702,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1961,
      "AgendaID": 3020,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04598",
      "ID": 4717
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4951,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan",
      "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.088598+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3896E175P307VM264087",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264087,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1961,
      "AgendaID": 3020,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04598",
      "ID": 4717
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3896,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam",
      "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9236378+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308435",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 308435,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1961,
      "AgendaID": 3020,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04598",
      "ID": 4717
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0558062+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4964E143P375VM279316",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279316,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1961,
      "AgendaID": 3020,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04598",
      "ID": 4717
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4964,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.4969019+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279982",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279982,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1961,
      "AgendaID": 3020,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04598",
      "ID": 4717
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3824,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5311973+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2066E22P91VM261758",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261758,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1961,
      "AgendaID": 3020,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04598",
      "ID": 4717
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2066,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3715454+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299712",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 299712,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1961,
      "AgendaID": 3020,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04598",
      "ID": 4717
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7193615+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306621",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306621,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1961,
      "AgendaID": 3020,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04598",
      "ID": 4717
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina",
      "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5599681+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2487E146P369VM301174",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 301174,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1961,
      "AgendaID": 3020,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04598",
      "ID": 4717
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2487,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0372057+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223660",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223660,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1961,
      "AgendaID": 3020,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04598",
      "ID": 4717
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4683408+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237458",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237458,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1961,
      "AgendaID": 3020,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04598",
      "ID": 4717
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1961,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David",
      "DisplayName": "David McLetchie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2114512+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2134E34P201VM297848",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 297848,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1961,
      "AgendaID": 3020,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04598",
      "ID": 4717
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2134,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1276019+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320401",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 320401,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1961,
      "AgendaID": 3020,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04598",
      "ID": 4717
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5041,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan",
      "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.164824+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3763E142P397VM316061",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 316061,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1961,
      "AgendaID": 3020,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04598",
      "ID": 4717
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3763,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart",
      "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9444832+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1986E23P197VM236628",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 236628,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1961,
      "AgendaID": 3020,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04598",
      "ID": 4717
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1986,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan",
      "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9331993+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5047E100P130VM291415",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291415,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1961,
      "AgendaID": 3020,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04598",
      "ID": 4717
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5047,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne",
      "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1183333+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234949",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234949,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1961,
      "AgendaID": 3020,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04598",
      "ID": 4717
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1845,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette",
      "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4068212+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313631",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313631,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1961,
      "AgendaID": 3020,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04598",
      "ID": 4717
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3061,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4037269+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1768E19P265VM288606",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 288606,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1961,
      "AgendaID": 3020,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04598",
      "ID": 4717
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1768,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1506349+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225043",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225043,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1961,
      "AgendaID": 3020,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04598",
      "ID": 4717
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1894,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Neil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.742078+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3815E98P134VM270881",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270881,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1961,
      "AgendaID": 3020,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04598",
      "ID": 4717
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3815,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Park, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Park",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.827143+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265927",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265927,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1961,
      "AgendaID": 3020,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04598",
      "ID": 4717
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2010,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil",
      "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.466569+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283524",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283524,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1961,
      "AgendaID": 3020,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04598",
      "ID": 4717
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5057,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7116174+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2853E33P128VM251421",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251421,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1961,
      "AgendaID": 3020,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04598",
      "ID": 4717
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Pentland",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4628738+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317621",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317621,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1961,
      "AgendaID": 3020,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04598",
      "ID": 4717
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5009,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4303065+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254720",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254720,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1961,
      "AgendaID": 3020,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04598",
      "ID": 4717
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3745,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis",
      "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2808536+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1870E225P478VM295664",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295664,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1961,
      "AgendaID": 3020,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04598",
      "ID": 4717
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1870,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona",
      "DisplayName": "Shona Robison",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5305772+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2135E254P450VM234864",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234864,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1961,
      "AgendaID": 3020,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04598",
      "ID": 4717
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2135,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Russell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4030464+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1895E232P431VM257373",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257373,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1961,
      "AgendaID": 3020,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04598",
      "ID": 4717
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1895,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0534003+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228099",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 228099,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1961,
      "AgendaID": 3020,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04598",
      "ID": 4717
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1839,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5843243+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2345E10P55VM292035",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 292035,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1961,
      "AgendaID": 3020,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04598",
      "ID": 4717
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2345,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1530742+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2223E176P333VM310678",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 310678,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1961,
      "AgendaID": 3020,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04598",
      "ID": 4717
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2223,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish",
      "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5813336+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246320",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 246320,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1961,
      "AgendaID": 3020,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04598",
      "ID": 4717
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2182,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1236237+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298168",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298168,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1961,
      "AgendaID": 3020,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04598",
      "ID": 4717
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5079,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew",
      "DisplayName": "Drew Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1411347+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234353",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234353,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1961,
      "AgendaID": 3020,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04598",
      "ID": 4717
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1769,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3736192+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4014E14P26VM269944",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269944,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1961,
      "AgendaID": 3020,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04598",
      "ID": 4717
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4014,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz",
      "DisplayName": "Liz Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.574577+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269176",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269176,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1961,
      "AgendaID": 3020,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04598",
      "ID": 4717
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2215,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.3069654+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317179",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317179,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1961,
      "AgendaID": 3020,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04598",
      "ID": 4717
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3806,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.185095+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326119",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 326119,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1961,
      "AgendaID": 3020,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04598",
      "ID": 4717
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5106,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin",
      "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5406992+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241111",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241111,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1961,
      "AgendaID": 3020,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04598",
      "ID": 4717
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1848,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola",
      "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3965565+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2098E237P531VM289594",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289594,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1961,
      "AgendaID": 3020,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04598",
      "ID": 4717
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2098,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Swinney",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4507549+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2674E247P401VM247738",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247738,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1961,
      "AgendaID": 3020,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04598",
      "ID": 4717
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2674,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave",
      "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4262975+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5075E234P371VM284856",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 284856,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1961,
      "AgendaID": 3020,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04598",
      "ID": 4717
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5075,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Torrance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0506697+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1793E151P9VM222444",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 222444,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1961,
      "AgendaID": 3020,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04598",
      "ID": 4717
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1793,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean",
      "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1892135+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5078E245P7VM307078",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307078,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1961,
      "AgendaID": 3020,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04598",
      "ID": 4717
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5078,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Walker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5863374+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1841E231P426VM240167",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 240167,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1961,
      "AgendaID": 3020,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04598",
      "ID": 4717
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1841,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen",
      "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7818496+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283407",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283407,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1961,
      "AgendaID": 3020,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04598",
      "ID": 4717
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4952,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.6993732+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1865E263P500VM232244",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232244,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1961,
      "AgendaID": 3020,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04598",
      "ID": 4717
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1865,
      "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra",
      "DisplayName": "Sandra White",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8463728+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237815",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237815,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1961,
      "AgendaID": 3020,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04598",
      "ID": 4717
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2610,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Wilson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2272655+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309303",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 309303,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1961,
      "AgendaID": 3020,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04598",
      "ID": 4717
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4941,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza",
      "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.323503+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252698",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252698,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1960,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.3",
      "ID": 4731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1926,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian",
      "DisplayName": "Brian Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7497395+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2615E213P388VM258903",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258903,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1960,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.3",
      "ID": 4731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2615,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George",
      "DisplayName": "George Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3331963+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319628",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319628,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1960,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.3",
      "ID": 4731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4940,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare",
      "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9344736+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249540",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 249540,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1960,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.3",
      "ID": 4731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2641,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair",
      "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9312582+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1783E21P273VM227809",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227809,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1960,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.3",
      "ID": 4731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1783,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie",
      "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5665679+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2633E97P136VM280814",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280814,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1960,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.3",
      "ID": 4731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2633,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire",
      "DisplayName": "Claire Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.783507+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262760",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262760,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1960,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.3",
      "ID": 4731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2603,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6156729+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1759E91P115VM229801",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229801,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1960,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.3",
      "ID": 4731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia",
      "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0976383+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270124",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270124,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1960,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.3",
      "ID": 4731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3751,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5825883+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322588",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 322588,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1960,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.3",
      "ID": 4731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5109,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco",
      "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6951712+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5060E86P124VM295296",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295296,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1960,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.3",
      "ID": 4731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5060,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5058928+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242973",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242973,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1960,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.3",
      "ID": 4731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1866,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah",
      "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0434728+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235186",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235186,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1960,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.3",
      "ID": 4731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1943,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic",
      "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4230926+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302366",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 302366,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1960,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.3",
      "ID": 4731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2595,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin",
      "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5213067+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244243",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244243,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1960,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.3",
      "ID": 4731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2103,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith",
      "DisplayName": "Keith Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5462443+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327119",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 327119,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1960,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.3",
      "ID": 4731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7997942+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277099",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277099,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1960,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.3",
      "ID": 4731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.7010495+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264230",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264230,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1960,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.3",
      "ID": 4731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2673,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick",
      "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1243237+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248721",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248721,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1960,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.3",
      "ID": 4731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2678,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson",
      "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6669586+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2123E27P233VM294940",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 294940,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1960,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.3",
      "ID": 4731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2123,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm",
      "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1852884+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285263",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285263,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1960,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.3",
      "ID": 4731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3907,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3154428+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230696",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230696,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1960,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.3",
      "ID": 4731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1735,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela",
      "DisplayName": "Angela Constance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3412565+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243745",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 243745,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1960,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.3",
      "ID": 4731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1932,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce",
      "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3179878+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254880",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254880,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1960,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.3",
      "ID": 4731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1863,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna",
      "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2877723+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323726",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 323726,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1960,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.3",
      "ID": 4731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4976,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth",
      "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9692501+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5107E223P379VM291281",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291281,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1960,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.3",
      "ID": 4731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5107,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1121991+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3743E222P391VM265436",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265436,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1960,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.3",
      "ID": 4731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3743,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel",
      "DisplayName": "Nigel Don",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.439112+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262303",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262303,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1960,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.3",
      "ID": 4731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3771,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob",
      "DisplayName": "Bob Doris",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.5956685+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281926",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 281926,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1960,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.3",
      "ID": 4731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2826,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Dornan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1637392+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298252",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298252,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1960,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.3",
      "ID": 4731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3812,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia",
      "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3377577+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231236",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231236,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1960,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.3",
      "ID": 4731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1778,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen",
      "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.5862667+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4955E240P389VM285886",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285886,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1960,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.3",
      "ID": 4731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4955,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.348762+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219442",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 219442,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1960,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.3",
      "ID": 4731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1742,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle",
      "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.2992528+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238522",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 238522,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1960,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.3",
      "ID": 4731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1994,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus",
      "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4577307+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225194",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225194,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1960,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.3",
      "ID": 4731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1814,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda",
      "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7485092+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321872",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 321872,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1960,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.3",
      "ID": 4731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Fee",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4549638+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292846",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 292846,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1960,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.3",
      "ID": 4731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia",
      "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5606242+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227167",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227167,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1960,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.3",
      "ID": 4731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2707084+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5054E95P118VM312726",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 312726,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1960,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.3",
      "ID": 4731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5054,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1407021+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4947E152P8VM257742",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257742,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1960,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.3",
      "ID": 4731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4947,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Finnie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0756595+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271242",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271242,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1960,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.3",
      "ID": 4731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3901,
      "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe",
      "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0618228+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278063",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 278063,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1960,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.3",
      "ID": 4731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2394,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo",
      "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9853982+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2110E220P414VM287261",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 287261,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1960,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.3",
      "ID": 4731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth",
      "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.856567+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250559",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250559,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1960,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.3",
      "ID": 4731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2675,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob",
      "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1947958+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221023",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221023,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1960,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.3",
      "ID": 4731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1741,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel",
      "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6717723+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220202",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220202,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1960,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.3",
      "ID": 4731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1756,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine",
      "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3387456+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1860E104P150VM252386",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252386,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1960,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.3",
      "ID": 4731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1860,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda",
      "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7269333+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2033E20P141VM253832",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253832,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1960,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.3",
      "ID": 4731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2033,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain",
      "DisplayName": "Iain Gray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0228007+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324679",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324679,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1960,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.3",
      "ID": 4731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5042,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2332849+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259668",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 259668,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1960,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.3",
      "ID": 4731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick",
      "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6193652+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239374",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239374,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1960,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.3",
      "ID": 4731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2029,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh",
      "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.73406+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273701",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 273701,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1960,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.3",
      "ID": 4731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3758,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6316699+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304119",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 304119,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1960,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.3",
      "ID": 4731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4086,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Hume",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8504824+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221672",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221672,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1960,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.3",
      "ID": 4731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1773,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9428234+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1882E227P459VM241902",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241902,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1960,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.3",
      "ID": 4731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1882,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam",
      "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7849558+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223500",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223500,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1960,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.3",
      "ID": 4731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1893,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4611048+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307835",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307835,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1960,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.3",
      "ID": 4731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4934,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8529649+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272295",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 272295,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1960,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.3",
      "ID": 4731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4956,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Keir",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3235051+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244984",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244984,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1960,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.3",
      "ID": 4731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Kelly",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5870229+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315152",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315152,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1960,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.3",
      "ID": 4731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3129,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6765768+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247894",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247894,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1960,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.3",
      "ID": 4731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann",
      "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4329679+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4016E11P36VM274844",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274844,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1960,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.3",
      "ID": 4731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4016,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1241855+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255745",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255745,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1960,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.3",
      "ID": 4731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2180,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.555088+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4938E158P374VM277401",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277401,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1960,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.3",
      "ID": 4731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4938,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9517948+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2112E250P486VM253067",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253067,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1960,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.3",
      "ID": 4731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2112,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny",
      "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7654372+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4939E258P394VM276787",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276787,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1960,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.3",
      "ID": 4731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4939,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus",
      "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6810763+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325452",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 325452,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1960,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.3",
      "ID": 4731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5074,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon",
      "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5070072+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1828E3P10VM232891",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232891,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1960,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.3",
      "ID": 4731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1828,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo",
      "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8810905+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311680",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311680,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1960,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.3",
      "ID": 4731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4948,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike",
      "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8896359+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2117E90P107VM230355",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230355,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1960,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.3",
      "ID": 4731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2117,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis",
      "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3194273+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267412",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 267412,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1960,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.3",
      "ID": 4731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken",
      "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0186991+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313481",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313481,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1960,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.3",
      "ID": 4731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4966,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek",
      "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.3972234+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3101E102P129VM295027",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295027,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1960,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.3",
      "ID": 4731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3101,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala",
      "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1890581+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319121",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319121,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1960,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.3",
      "ID": 4731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5034,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny",
      "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6933538+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306335",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306335,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1960,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.3",
      "ID": 4731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2159,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Martin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5476168+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5110E252P395VM310849",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 310849,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1960,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.3",
      "ID": 4731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Mason",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5886752+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268191",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 268191,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1960,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.3",
      "ID": 4731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2133,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0601457+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2876E141P433VM286382",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286382,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1960,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.3",
      "ID": 4731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2876,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5767424+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4951E147P368VM258576",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258576,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1960,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.3",
      "ID": 4731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4951,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan",
      "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3132185+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3896E175P307VM263835",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 263835,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1960,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.3",
      "ID": 4731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3896,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam",
      "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9124725+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308483",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 308483,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1960,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.3",
      "ID": 4731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0578543+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4964E143P375VM279715",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279715,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1960,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.3",
      "ID": 4731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4964,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5195232+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279574",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279574,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1960,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.3",
      "ID": 4731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3824,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5135326+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2066E22P91VM261003",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261003,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1960,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.3",
      "ID": 4731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2066,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.1073667+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299566",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 299566,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1960,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.3",
      "ID": 4731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7029679+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306670",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306670,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1960,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.3",
      "ID": 4731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina",
      "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5623042+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2487E146P369VM301124",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 301124,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1960,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.3",
      "ID": 4731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2487,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0345377+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223926",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223926,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1960,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.3",
      "ID": 4731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4797085+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237852",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237852,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1960,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.3",
      "ID": 4731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1961,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David",
      "DisplayName": "David McLetchie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2288586+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305533",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 305533,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1960,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.3",
      "ID": 4731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2134,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3284368+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320305",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 320305,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1960,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.3",
      "ID": 4731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5041,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan",
      "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1542632+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315930",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315930,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1960,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.3",
      "ID": 4731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3763,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart",
      "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9384006+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1986E23P197VM236727",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 236727,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1960,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.3",
      "ID": 4731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1986,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan",
      "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9374644+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5047E100P130VM289778",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289778,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1960,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.3",
      "ID": 4731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5047,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne",
      "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4587065+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234550",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234550,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1960,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.3",
      "ID": 4731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1845,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette",
      "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3891267+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313190",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313190,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1960,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.3",
      "ID": 4731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3061,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1675362+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1768E19P265VM289272",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289272,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1960,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.3",
      "ID": 4731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1768,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4301326+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225287",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225287,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1960,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.3",
      "ID": 4731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1894,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Neil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9628877+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3815E98P134VM270947",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270947,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1960,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.3",
      "ID": 4731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3815,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Park, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Park",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8359419+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265837",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265837,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1960,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.3",
      "ID": 4731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2010,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil",
      "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4566438+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283273",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283273,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1960,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.3",
      "ID": 4731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5057,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.693378+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2853E33P128VM251518",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251518,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1960,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.3",
      "ID": 4731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Pentland",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4671536+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317526",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317526,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1960,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.3",
      "ID": 4731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5009,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4262497+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254293",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254293,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1960,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.3",
      "ID": 4731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3745,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis",
      "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2493188+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1870E225P478VM296175",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 296175,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1960,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.3",
      "ID": 4731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1870,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona",
      "DisplayName": "Shona Robison",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5526042+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2135E254P450VM235422",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235422,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1960,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.3",
      "ID": 4731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2135,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Russell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6700827+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1895E232P431VM257619",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257619,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1960,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.3",
      "ID": 4731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1895,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0643208+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228520",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 228520,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1960,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.3",
      "ID": 4731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1839,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.8026353+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2345E10P55VM291633",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291633,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1960,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.3",
      "ID": 4731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2345,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1357071+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311121",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311121,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1960,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.3",
      "ID": 4731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2223,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish",
      "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.6063049+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246435",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 246435,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1960,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.3",
      "ID": 4731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2182,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.128606+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298073",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298073,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1960,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.3",
      "ID": 4731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5079,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew",
      "DisplayName": "Drew Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1370895+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234103",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234103,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1960,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.3",
      "ID": 4731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1769,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1667741+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274630",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274630,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1960,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.3",
      "ID": 4731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4014,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz",
      "DisplayName": "Liz Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1149125+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269579",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269579,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1960,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.3",
      "ID": 4731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2215,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5537119+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317463",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317463,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1960,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.3",
      "ID": 4731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3806,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4232569+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326378",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 326378,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1960,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.3",
      "ID": 4731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5106,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin",
      "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7559181+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241226",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241226,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1960,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.3",
      "ID": 4731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1848,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola",
      "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7484519+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2098E237P531VM290343",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 290343,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1960,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.3",
      "ID": 4731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2098,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Swinney",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7427768+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2674E247P401VM247835",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247835,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1960,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.3",
      "ID": 4731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2674,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave",
      "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4304607+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5075E234P371VM287438",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 287438,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1960,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.3",
      "ID": 4731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5075,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Torrance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8641948+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1793E151P9VM222531",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 222531,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1960,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.3",
      "ID": 4731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1793,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean",
      "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1929682+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5078E245P7VM307035",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307035,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1960,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.3",
      "ID": 4731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5078,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Walker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5845011+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1841E231P426VM239898",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239898,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1960,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.3",
      "ID": 4731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1841,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen",
      "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7640821+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283495",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283495,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1960,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.3",
      "ID": 4731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4952,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7103642+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1865E263P500VM231851",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231851,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1960,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.3",
      "ID": 4731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1865,
      "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra",
      "DisplayName": "Sandra White",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6182748+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237717",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237717,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1960,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.3",
      "ID": 4731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2610,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Wilson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2228047+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309002",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 309002,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1960,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.3",
      "ID": 4731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4941,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza",
      "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0872878+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252726",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252726,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1958,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.2",
      "ID": 4730
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1926,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian",
      "DisplayName": "Brian Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7509202+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2615E213P388VM258937",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258937,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1958,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.2",
      "ID": 4730
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2615,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George",
      "DisplayName": "George Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3346887+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319627",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319627,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1958,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.2",
      "ID": 4730
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4940,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare",
      "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9344329+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249539",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 249539,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1958,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.2",
      "ID": 4730
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2641,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair",
      "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9312178+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1783E21P273VM227844",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227844,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1958,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.2",
      "ID": 4730
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1783,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie",
      "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5680819+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2633E97P136VM280844",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280844,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1958,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.2",
      "ID": 4730
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2633,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire",
      "DisplayName": "Claire Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7847962+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262761",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262761,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1958,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.2",
      "ID": 4730
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2603,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.615713+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1759E91P115VM229802",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229802,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1958,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.2",
      "ID": 4730
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia",
      "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0976824+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3751E243P383VM269780",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269780,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1958,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.2",
      "ID": 4730
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3751,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5626404+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322609",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 322609,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1958,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.2",
      "ID": 4730
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5109,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco",
      "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6960755+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5060E86P124VM295297",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295297,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1958,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.2",
      "ID": 4730
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5060,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5059338+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242974",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242974,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1958,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.2",
      "ID": 4730
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1866,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah",
      "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0435134+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235177",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235177,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1958,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.2",
      "ID": 4730
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1943,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic",
      "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4227008+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302367",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 302367,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1958,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.2",
      "ID": 4730
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2595,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin",
      "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5213485+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244242",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244242,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1958,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.2",
      "ID": 4730
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2103,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith",
      "DisplayName": "Keith Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5462022+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327120",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 327120,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1958,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.2",
      "ID": 4730
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7999443+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277100",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277100,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1958,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.2",
      "ID": 4730
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.7010904+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264229",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264229,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1958,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.2",
      "ID": 4730
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2673,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick",
      "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1242835+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248687",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248687,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1958,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.2",
      "ID": 4730
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2678,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson",
      "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6655249+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2123E27P233VM294939",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 294939,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1958,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.2",
      "ID": 4730
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2123,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm",
      "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1852468+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285264",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285264,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1958,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.2",
      "ID": 4730
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3907,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.315485+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230739",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230739,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1958,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.2",
      "ID": 4730
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1735,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela",
      "DisplayName": "Angela Constance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3434577+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243744",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 243744,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1958,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.2",
      "ID": 4730
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1932,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce",
      "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3179473+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254879",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254879,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1958,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.2",
      "ID": 4730
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1863,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna",
      "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2877319+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323727",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 323727,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1958,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.2",
      "ID": 4730
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4976,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth",
      "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9692916+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5107E223P379VM291245",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291245,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1958,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.2",
      "ID": 4730
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5107,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1105465+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3743E222P391VM265437",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265437,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1958,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.2",
      "ID": 4730
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3743,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel",
      "DisplayName": "Nigel Don",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4391544+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262338",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262338,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1958,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.2",
      "ID": 4730
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3771,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob",
      "DisplayName": "Bob Doris",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.5971646+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281895",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 281895,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1958,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.2",
      "ID": 4730
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2826,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Dornan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1622804+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298231",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298231,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1958,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.2",
      "ID": 4730
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3812,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia",
      "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3368469+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231235",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231235,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1958,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.2",
      "ID": 4730
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1778,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen",
      "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.5862263+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4955E240P389VM285852",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285852,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1958,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.2",
      "ID": 4730
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4955,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3473077+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219451",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 219451,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1958,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.2",
      "ID": 4730
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1742,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle",
      "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.2997381+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238489",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 238489,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1958,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.2",
      "ID": 4730
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1994,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus",
      "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4563206+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225193",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225193,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1958,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.2",
      "ID": 4730
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1814,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda",
      "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7484684+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321851",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 321851,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1958,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.2",
      "ID": 4730
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Fee",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4540654+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292845",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 292845,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1958,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.2",
      "ID": 4730
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia",
      "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5605647+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227176",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227176,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1958,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.2",
      "ID": 4730
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2710843+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5054E95P118VM312727",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 312727,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1958,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.2",
      "ID": 4730
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5054,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1407423+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4947E152P8VM257743",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257743,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1958,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.2",
      "ID": 4730
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4947,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Finnie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0757012+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271207",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271207,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1958,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.2",
      "ID": 4730
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3901,
      "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe",
      "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0602463+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278032",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 278032,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1958,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.2",
      "ID": 4730
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2394,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo",
      "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9840626+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2110E220P414VM287262",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 287262,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1958,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.2",
      "ID": 4730
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth",
      "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8566075+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250560",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250560,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1958,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.2",
      "ID": 4730
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2675,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob",
      "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1948363+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221024",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221024,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1958,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.2",
      "ID": 4730
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1741,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel",
      "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.671814+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220193",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220193,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1958,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.2",
      "ID": 4730
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1756,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine",
      "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3383555+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1860E104P150VM252387",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252387,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1958,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.2",
      "ID": 4730
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1860,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda",
      "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7269735+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2033E20P141VM253800",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253800,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1958,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.2",
      "ID": 4730
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2033,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain",
      "DisplayName": "Iain Gray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0214627+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324678",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324678,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1958,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.2",
      "ID": 4730
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5042,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2332453+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259634",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 259634,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1958,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.2",
      "ID": 4730
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick",
      "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.617906+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239407",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239407,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1958,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.2",
      "ID": 4730
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2029,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh",
      "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.735476+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273700",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 273700,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1958,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.2",
      "ID": 4730
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3758,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6316297+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304118",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 304118,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1958,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.2",
      "ID": 4730
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4086,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Hume",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8504423+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221671",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221671,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1958,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.2",
      "ID": 4730
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1773,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9427824+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1882E227P459VM241901",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241901,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1958,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.2",
      "ID": 4730
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1882,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam",
      "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7849143+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223491",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223491,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1958,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.2",
      "ID": 4730
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1893,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.460713+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307814",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307814,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1958,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.2",
      "ID": 4730
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4934,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8520441+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272296",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 272296,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1958,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.2",
      "ID": 4730
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4956,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Keir",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.323546+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244985",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244985,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1958,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.2",
      "ID": 4730
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Kelly",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5870638+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315153",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315153,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1958,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.2",
      "ID": 4730
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3129,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6766169+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247861",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247861,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1958,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.2",
      "ID": 4730
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann",
      "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4315526+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4016E11P36VM275033",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 275033,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1958,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.2",
      "ID": 4730
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4016,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.13828+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255557",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255557,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1958,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.2",
      "ID": 4730
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2180,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5364399+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4938E158P374VM277366",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277366,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1958,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.2",
      "ID": 4730
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4938,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9502928+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2112E250P486VM253407",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253407,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1958,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.2",
      "ID": 4730
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2112,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny",
      "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.9950894+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4939E258P394VM276751",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276751,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1958,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.2",
      "ID": 4730
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4939,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus",
      "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6795498+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325453",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 325453,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1958,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.2",
      "ID": 4730
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5074,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon",
      "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5070473+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1828E3P10VM232892",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232892,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1958,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.2",
      "ID": 4730
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1828,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo",
      "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8811306+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311659",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311659,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1958,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.2",
      "ID": 4730
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4948,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike",
      "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8887128+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2117E90P107VM229703",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229703,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1958,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.2",
      "ID": 4730
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2117,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis",
      "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.093055+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267443",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 267443,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1958,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.2",
      "ID": 4730
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken",
      "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0200401+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313502",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313502,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1958,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.2",
      "ID": 4730
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4966,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek",
      "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.3981318+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3101E102P129VM294996",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 294996,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1958,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.2",
      "ID": 4730
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3101,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala",
      "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1877092+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319100",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319100,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1958,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.2",
      "ID": 4730
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5034,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny",
      "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6924535+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306334",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306334,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1958,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.2",
      "ID": 4730
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2159,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Martin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5475757+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5110E252P395VM310848",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 310848,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1958,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.2",
      "ID": 4730
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Mason",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5886346+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268161",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 268161,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1958,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.2",
      "ID": 4730
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2133,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0588379+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2876E141P433VM286413",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286413,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1958,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.2",
      "ID": 4730
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2876,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5780828+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4951E147P368VM258575",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258575,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1958,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.2",
      "ID": 4730
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4951,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan",
      "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3131778+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3896E175P307VM263799",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 263799,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1958,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.2",
      "ID": 4730
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3896,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam",
      "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9052214+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308484",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 308484,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1958,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.2",
      "ID": 4730
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.057895+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4964E143P375VM279751",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279751,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1958,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.2",
      "ID": 4730
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4964,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5210525+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279573",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279573,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1958,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.2",
      "ID": 4730
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3824,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5134925+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2066E22P91VM261002",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261002,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1958,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.2",
      "ID": 4730
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2066,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.1073251+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299587",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 299587,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1958,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.2",
      "ID": 4730
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7038836+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306671",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306671,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1958,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.2",
      "ID": 4730
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina",
      "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5623454+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2487E146P369VM301123",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 301123,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1958,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.2",
      "ID": 4730
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2487,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0344891+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223927",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223927,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1958,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.2",
      "ID": 4730
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.479749+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237877",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237877,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1958,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.2",
      "ID": 4730
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1961,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David",
      "DisplayName": "David McLetchie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2299264+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305534",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 305534,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1958,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.2",
      "ID": 4730
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2134,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3284775+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320326",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 320326,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1958,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.2",
      "ID": 4730
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5041,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan",
      "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1551803+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315929",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315929,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1958,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.2",
      "ID": 4730
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3763,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart",
      "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9383588+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1986E23P197VM236728",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 236728,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1958,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.2",
      "ID": 4730
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1986,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan",
      "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9375046+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5047E100P130VM289777",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289777,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1958,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.2",
      "ID": 4730
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5047,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne",
      "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4586667+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234549",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234549,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1958,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.2",
      "ID": 4730
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1845,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette",
      "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3890855+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313189",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313189,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1958,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.2",
      "ID": 4730
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3061,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1674951+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1768E19P265VM289273",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289273,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1958,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.2",
      "ID": 4730
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1768,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4301762+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225296",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225296,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1958,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.2",
      "ID": 4730
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1894,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Neil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9632595+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3815E98P134VM270967",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270967,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1958,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.2",
      "ID": 4730
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3815,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Park, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Park",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8367945+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265836",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265836,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1958,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.2",
      "ID": 4730
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2010,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil",
      "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4566028+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283237",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283237,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1958,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.2",
      "ID": 4730
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5057,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.6917895+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2853E33P128VM252013",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252013,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1958,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.2",
      "ID": 4730
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Pentland",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4988275+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317547",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317547,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1958,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.2",
      "ID": 4730
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5009,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4271475+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254292",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254292,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1958,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.2",
      "ID": 4730
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3745,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis",
      "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2492777+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1870E225P478VM296176",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 296176,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1958,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.2",
      "ID": 4730
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1870,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona",
      "DisplayName": "Shona Robison",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5526457+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2135E254P450VM235456",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235456,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1958,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.2",
      "ID": 4730
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2135,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Russell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6786319+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1895E232P431VM257620",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257620,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1958,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.2",
      "ID": 4730
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1895,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0643616+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228521",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 228521,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1958,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.2",
      "ID": 4730
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1839,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.8026764+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2345E10P55VM291632",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291632,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1958,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.2",
      "ID": 4730
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2345,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1356665+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311122",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311122,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1958,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.2",
      "ID": 4730
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2223,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish",
      "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.6063453+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246436",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 246436,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1958,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.2",
      "ID": 4730
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2182,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1286473+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298072",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298072,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1958,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.2",
      "ID": 4730
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5079,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew",
      "DisplayName": "Drew Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1370487+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234102",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234102,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1958,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.2",
      "ID": 4730
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1769,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1667317+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274667",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274667,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1958,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.2",
      "ID": 4730
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4014,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz",
      "DisplayName": "Liz Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.11651+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269609",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269609,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1958,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.2",
      "ID": 4730
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2215,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5552505+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317464",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317464,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1958,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.2",
      "ID": 4730
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3806,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4232974+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326377",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 326377,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1958,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.2",
      "ID": 4730
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5106,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin",
      "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7558759+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241227",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241227,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1958,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.2",
      "ID": 4730
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1848,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola",
      "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7484937+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2098E237P531VM290344",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 290344,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1958,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.2",
      "ID": 4730
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2098,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Swinney",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7428173+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248022",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248022,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1958,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.2",
      "ID": 4730
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2674,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave",
      "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4383901+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5075E234P371VM287474",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 287474,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1958,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.2",
      "ID": 4730
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5075,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Torrance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8657372+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1793E151P9VM222540",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 222540,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1958,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.2",
      "ID": 4730
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1793,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean",
      "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.193336+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5078E245P7VM307034",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307034,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1958,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.2",
      "ID": 4730
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5078,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Walker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5844605+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1841E231P426VM239897",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239897,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1958,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.2",
      "ID": 4730
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1841,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen",
      "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7640398+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283684",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283684,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1958,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.2",
      "ID": 4730
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4952,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7188059+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1865E263P500VM231816",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231816,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1958,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.2",
      "ID": 4730
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1865,
      "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra",
      "DisplayName": "Sandra White",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6167667+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237382",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237382,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1958,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.2",
      "ID": 4730
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2610,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Wilson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2017844+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309178",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 309178,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1958,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594.2",
      "ID": 4730
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4941,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza",
      "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.095387+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252727",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252727,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1959,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594",
      "ID": 4713
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1926,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian",
      "DisplayName": "Brian Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7509618+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2615E213P388VM258938",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258938,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1959,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594",
      "ID": 4713
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2615,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George",
      "DisplayName": "George Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.334729+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319626",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319626,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1959,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594",
      "ID": 4713
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4940,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare",
      "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9343924+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249538",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 249538,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1959,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594",
      "ID": 4713
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2641,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair",
      "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9311775+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1783E21P273VM227845",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227845,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1959,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594",
      "ID": 4713
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1783,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie",
      "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5681225+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2633E97P136VM280845",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280845,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1959,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594",
      "ID": 4713
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2633,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire",
      "DisplayName": "Claire Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7848359+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262762",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262762,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1959,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594",
      "ID": 4713
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2603,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6157533+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1759E91P115VM229803",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229803,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1959,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594",
      "ID": 4713
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia",
      "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0977233+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3751E243P383VM269779",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269779,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1959,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594",
      "ID": 4713
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3751,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5625994+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322597",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 322597,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1959,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594",
      "ID": 4713
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5109,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco",
      "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6955641+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5060E86P124VM295298",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295298,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1959,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594",
      "ID": 4713
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5060,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.505974+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242975",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242975,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1959,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594",
      "ID": 4713
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1866,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah",
      "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0435542+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235152",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235152,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1959,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594",
      "ID": 4713
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1943,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic",
      "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4216339+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302416",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 302416,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1959,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594",
      "ID": 4713
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2595,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin",
      "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5234274+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244241",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244241,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1959,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594",
      "ID": 4713
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2103,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith",
      "DisplayName": "Keith Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.546159+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327121",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 327121,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1959,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594",
      "ID": 4713
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.800024+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277101",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277101,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1959,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594",
      "ID": 4713
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.7011324+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264228",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264228,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1959,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594",
      "ID": 4713
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2673,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick",
      "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1242427+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248686",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248686,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1959,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594",
      "ID": 4713
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2678,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson",
      "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6654833+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2123E27P233VM294938",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 294938,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1959,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594",
      "ID": 4713
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2123,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm",
      "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1852058+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285265",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285265,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1959,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594",
      "ID": 4713
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3907,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3155267+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230740",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230740,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1959,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594",
      "ID": 4713
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1735,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela",
      "DisplayName": "Angela Constance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3434979+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243743",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 243743,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1959,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594",
      "ID": 4713
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1932,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce",
      "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3179072+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254830",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254830,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1959,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594",
      "ID": 4713
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1863,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna",
      "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.285575+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323728",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 323728,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1959,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594",
      "ID": 4713
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4976,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth",
      "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9693526+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5107E223P379VM291244",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291244,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1959,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594",
      "ID": 4713
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5107,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1105056+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3743E222P391VM265438",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265438,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1959,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594",
      "ID": 4713
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3743,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel",
      "DisplayName": "Nigel Don",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4391952+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262339",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262339,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1959,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594",
      "ID": 4713
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3771,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob",
      "DisplayName": "Bob Doris",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.5972048+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281894",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 281894,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1959,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594",
      "ID": 4713
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2826,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Dornan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.162238+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298232",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298232,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1959,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594",
      "ID": 4713
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3812,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia",
      "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3368879+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231199",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231199,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1959,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594",
      "ID": 4713
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1778,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen",
      "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.5845098+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4955E240P389VM285851",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285851,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1959,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594",
      "ID": 4713
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4955,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3472662+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219479",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 219479,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1959,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594",
      "ID": 4713
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1742,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle",
      "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3010386+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238488",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 238488,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1959,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594",
      "ID": 4713
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1994,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus",
      "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4562805+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225192",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225192,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1959,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594",
      "ID": 4713
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1814,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda",
      "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7484272+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321863",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 321863,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1959,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594",
      "ID": 4713
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Fee",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4545764+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292844",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 292844,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1959,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594",
      "ID": 4713
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia",
      "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5605248+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227203",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227203,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1959,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594",
      "ID": 4713
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5352739+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5054E95P118VM313238",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313238,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1959,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594",
      "ID": 4713
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5054,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.3837943+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4947E152P8VM257744",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257744,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1959,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594",
      "ID": 4713
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4947,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Finnie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0757416+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271206",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271206,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1959,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594",
      "ID": 4713
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3901,
      "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe",
      "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0602043+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278031",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 278031,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1959,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594",
      "ID": 4713
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2394,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo",
      "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9840216+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2110E220P414VM287311",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 287311,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1959,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594",
      "ID": 4713
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth",
      "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8587156+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250561",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250561,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1959,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594",
      "ID": 4713
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2675,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob",
      "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.194883+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221025",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221025,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1959,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594",
      "ID": 4713
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1741,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel",
      "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6718547+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220166",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220166,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1959,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594",
      "ID": 4713
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1756,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine",
      "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3371849+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1860E104P150VM252437",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252437,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1959,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594",
      "ID": 4713
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1860,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda",
      "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7291177+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2033E20P141VM253799",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253799,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1959,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594",
      "ID": 4713
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2033,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain",
      "DisplayName": "Iain Gray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0214207+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324677",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324677,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1959,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594",
      "ID": 4713
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5042,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2332054+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259633",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 259633,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1959,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594",
      "ID": 4713
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick",
      "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6178642+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239408",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239408,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1959,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594",
      "ID": 4713
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2029,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh",
      "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7355168+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273699",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 273699,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1959,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594",
      "ID": 4713
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3758,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6315833+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304069",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 304069,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1959,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594",
      "ID": 4713
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4086,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Hume",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8481402+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221670",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221670,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1959,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594",
      "ID": 4713
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1773,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9427412+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1882E227P459VM241900",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241900,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1959,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594",
      "ID": 4713
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1882,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam",
      "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7848718+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223464",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223464,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1959,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594",
      "ID": 4713
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1893,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4592163+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307815",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307815,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1959,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594",
      "ID": 4713
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4934,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8520857+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272297",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 272297,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1959,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594",
      "ID": 4713
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4956,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Keir",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3235863+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244986",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244986,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1959,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594",
      "ID": 4713
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Kelly",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5871046+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315154",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315154,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1959,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594",
      "ID": 4713
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3129,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6766576+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247860",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247860,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1959,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594",
      "ID": 4713
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann",
      "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4315123+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4016E11P36VM275034",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 275034,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1959,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594",
      "ID": 4713
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4016,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1383208+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255556",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255556,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1959,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594",
      "ID": 4713
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2180,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5363992+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4938E158P374VM277365",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277365,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1959,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594",
      "ID": 4713
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4938,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9502518+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2112E250P486VM253408",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253408,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1959,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594",
      "ID": 4713
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2112,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny",
      "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.9951306+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4939E258P394VM276750",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276750,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1959,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594",
      "ID": 4713
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4939,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus",
      "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6795093+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325454",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 325454,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1959,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594",
      "ID": 4713
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5074,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon",
      "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5070875+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1828E3P10VM232932",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232932,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1959,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594",
      "ID": 4713
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1828,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo",
      "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8828592+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311660",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311660,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1959,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594",
      "ID": 4713
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4948,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike",
      "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8887548+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2117E90P107VM229701",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229701,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1959,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594",
      "ID": 4713
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2117,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis",
      "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0929558+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267444",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 267444,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1959,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594",
      "ID": 4713
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken",
      "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0200816+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313501",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313501,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1959,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594",
      "ID": 4713
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4966,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek",
      "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.39809+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3101E102P129VM294995",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 294995,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1959,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594",
      "ID": 4713
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3101,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala",
      "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1876682+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319112",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319112,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1959,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594",
      "ID": 4713
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5034,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny",
      "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.692965+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306333",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306333,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1959,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594",
      "ID": 4713
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2159,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Martin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5475351+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5110E252P395VM310847",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 310847,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1959,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594",
      "ID": 4713
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Mason",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5885934+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268160",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 268160,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1959,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594",
      "ID": 4713
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2133,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0587963+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2876E141P433VM286414",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286414,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1959,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594",
      "ID": 4713
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2876,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5781237+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4951E147P368VM258574",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258574,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1959,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594",
      "ID": 4713
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4951,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan",
      "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3131358+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3896E175P307VM263798",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 263798,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1959,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594",
      "ID": 4713
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3896,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam",
      "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9051809+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308485",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 308485,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1959,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594",
      "ID": 4713
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0579581+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4964E143P375VM279752",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279752,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1959,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594",
      "ID": 4713
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4964,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5210928+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279572",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279572,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1959,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594",
      "ID": 4713
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3824,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5134522+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2066E22P91VM261001",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261001,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1959,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594",
      "ID": 4713
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2066,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.1072841+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299586",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 299586,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1959,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594",
      "ID": 4713
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7038416+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306672",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306672,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1959,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594",
      "ID": 4713
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina",
      "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5624055+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2487E146P369VM301122",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 301122,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1959,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594",
      "ID": 4713
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2487,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0344398+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223928",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223928,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1959,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594",
      "ID": 4713
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4797893+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237878",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237878,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1959,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594",
      "ID": 4713
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1961,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David",
      "DisplayName": "David McLetchie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2299676+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305535",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 305535,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1959,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594",
      "ID": 4713
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2134,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3285182+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320314",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 320314,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1959,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594",
      "ID": 4713
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5041,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan",
      "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1546627+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315928",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315928,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1959,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594",
      "ID": 4713
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3763,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart",
      "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9383173+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1986E23P197VM236729",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 236729,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1959,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594",
      "ID": 4713
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1986,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan",
      "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9375637+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5047E100P130VM289776",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289776,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1959,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594",
      "ID": 4713
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5047,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne",
      "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4586269+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234499",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234499,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1959,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594",
      "ID": 4713
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1845,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette",
      "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3869101+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313188",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313188,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1959,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594",
      "ID": 4713
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3061,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1674535+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1768E19P265VM289274",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289274,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1959,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594",
      "ID": 4713
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1768,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4302177+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225323",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225323,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1959,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594",
      "ID": 4713
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1894,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Neil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9696192+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3815E98P134VM270968",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270968,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1959,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594",
      "ID": 4713
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3815,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Park, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Park",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8368589+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265787",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265787,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1959,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594",
      "ID": 4713
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2010,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil",
      "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.454469+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283236",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283236,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1959,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594",
      "ID": 4713
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5057,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.6917465+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2853E33P128VM252014",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252014,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1959,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594",
      "ID": 4713
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Pentland",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4988684+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317535",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317535,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1959,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594",
      "ID": 4713
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5009,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4266398+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254291",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254291,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1959,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594",
      "ID": 4713
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3745,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis",
      "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2492354+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1870E225P478VM296177",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 296177,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1959,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594",
      "ID": 4713
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1870,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona",
      "DisplayName": "Shona Robison",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5526864+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2135E254P450VM235457",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235457,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1959,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594",
      "ID": 4713
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2135,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Russell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6786729+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1895E232P431VM257669",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257669,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1959,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594",
      "ID": 4713
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1895,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0664781+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228522",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 228522,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1959,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594",
      "ID": 4713
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1839,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.802718+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2345E10P55VM291583",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291583,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1959,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594",
      "ID": 4713
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2345,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1336077+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311123",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311123,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1959,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594",
      "ID": 4713
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2223,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish",
      "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.6063862+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246437",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 246437,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1959,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594",
      "ID": 4713
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2182,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1286879+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298071",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298071,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1959,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594",
      "ID": 4713
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5079,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew",
      "DisplayName": "Drew Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1370081+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234101",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234101,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1959,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594",
      "ID": 4713
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1769,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1666709+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274668",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274668,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1959,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594",
      "ID": 4713
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4014,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz",
      "DisplayName": "Liz Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1165506+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269610",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269610,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1959,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594",
      "ID": 4713
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2215,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5552917+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317465",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317465,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1959,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594",
      "ID": 4713
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3806,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.423338+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326376",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 326376,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1959,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594",
      "ID": 4713
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5106,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin",
      "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7558148+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241228",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241228,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1959,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594",
      "ID": 4713
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1848,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola",
      "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7485345+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2098E237P531VM290345",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 290345,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1959,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594",
      "ID": 4713
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2098,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Swinney",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7428827+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248023",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248023,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1959,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594",
      "ID": 4713
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2674,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave",
      "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4384315+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5075E234P371VM287475",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 287475,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1959,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594",
      "ID": 4713
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5075,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Torrance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8657777+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1793E151P9VM222567",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 222567,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1959,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594",
      "ID": 4713
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1793,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean",
      "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1945008+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5078E245P7VM307033",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307033,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1959,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594",
      "ID": 4713
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5078,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Walker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5844184+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1841E231P426VM239896",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239896,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1959,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594",
      "ID": 4713
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1841,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen",
      "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.763981+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283685",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283685,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1959,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594",
      "ID": 4713
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4952,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7188656+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1865E263P500VM231815",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231815,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1959,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594",
      "ID": 4713
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1865,
      "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra",
      "DisplayName": "Sandra White",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6167067+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237381",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237381,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1959,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594",
      "ID": 4713
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2610,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Wilson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2017435+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309177",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 309177,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1959,
      "AgendaID": 2382,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 53,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Future of Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-04594",
      "ID": 4713
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4941,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza",
      "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0953252+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252667",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252667,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1957,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.3",
      "ID": 4664
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1926,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian",
      "DisplayName": "Brian Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7484037+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2615E213P388VM258868",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258868,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1957,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.3",
      "ID": 4664
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2615,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George",
      "DisplayName": "George Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3316832+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319864",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319864,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1957,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.3",
      "ID": 4664
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4940,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare",
      "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9446837+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249582",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 249582,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1957,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.3",
      "ID": 4664
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2641,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair",
      "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9330536+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1783E21P273VM227778",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227778,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1957,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.3",
      "ID": 4664
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1783,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie",
      "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5652296+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2633E97P136VM280781",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280781,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1957,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.3",
      "ID": 4664
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2633,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire",
      "DisplayName": "Claire Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7821267+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262782",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262782,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1957,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.3",
      "ID": 4664
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2603,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6166184+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1759E91P115VM229756",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229756,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1957,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.3",
      "ID": 4664
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia",
      "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0953299+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270159",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270159,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1957,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.3",
      "ID": 4664
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3751,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5840882+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322650",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 322650,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1957,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.3",
      "ID": 4664
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5109,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco",
      "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6978269+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5060E86P124VM295319",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295319,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1957,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.3",
      "ID": 4664
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5060,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5068759+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242889",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242889,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1957,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.3",
      "ID": 4664
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1866,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah",
      "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0399315+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235223",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235223,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1957,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.3",
      "ID": 4664
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1943,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic",
      "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6611046+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302164",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 302164,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1957,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.3",
      "ID": 4664
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2595,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin",
      "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.3001339+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244221",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244221,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1957,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.3",
      "ID": 4664
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2103,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith",
      "DisplayName": "Keith Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.545193+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327196",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 327196,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1957,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.3",
      "ID": 4664
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.8033262+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277121",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277121,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1957,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.3",
      "ID": 4664
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.7020041+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264053",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264053,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1957,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.3",
      "ID": 4664
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2673,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick",
      "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.922177+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248757",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248757,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1957,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.3",
      "ID": 4664
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2678,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson",
      "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6684737+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2123E27P233VM295794",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295794,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1957,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.3",
      "ID": 4664
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2123,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm",
      "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5361628+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285286",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285286,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1957,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.3",
      "ID": 4664
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3907,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3164476+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230763",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230763,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1957,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.3",
      "ID": 4664
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1735,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela",
      "DisplayName": "Angela Constance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3444907+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243830",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 243830,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1957,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.3",
      "ID": 4664
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1932,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce",
      "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3215885+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254925",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254925,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1957,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.3",
      "ID": 4664
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1863,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna",
      "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2896858+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323803",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 323803,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1957,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.3",
      "ID": 4664
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4976,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth",
      "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9725821+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5107E223P379VM291319",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291319,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1957,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.3",
      "ID": 4664
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5107,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1138255+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3743E222P391VM265458",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265458,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1957,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.3",
      "ID": 4664
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3743,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel",
      "DisplayName": "Nigel Don",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4400595+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262267",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262267,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1957,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.3",
      "ID": 4664
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3771,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob",
      "DisplayName": "Bob Doris",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.5941474+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281960",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 281960,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1957,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.3",
      "ID": 4664
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2826,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Dornan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1651894+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298012",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298012,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1957,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.3",
      "ID": 4664
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3812,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia",
      "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1345009+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231588",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231588,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1957,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.3",
      "ID": 4664
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1778,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen",
      "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6070685+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4955E240P389VM285915",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285915,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1957,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.3",
      "ID": 4664
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4955,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3500237+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219404",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 219404,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1957,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.3",
      "ID": 4664
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1742,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle",
      "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.2972497+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238558",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 238558,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1957,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.3",
      "ID": 4664
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1994,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus",
      "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4593028+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225235",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225235,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1957,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.3",
      "ID": 4664
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1814,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda",
      "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9606246+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321810",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 321810,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1957,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.3",
      "ID": 4664
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Fee",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4523209+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292781",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 292781,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1957,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.3",
      "ID": 4664
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia",
      "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5578663+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227130",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227130,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1957,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.3",
      "ID": 4664
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2691099+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5054E95P118VM312680",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 312680,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1957,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.3",
      "ID": 4664
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5054,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1387313+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4947E152P8VM257237",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257237,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1957,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.3",
      "ID": 4664
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4947,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Finnie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0474737+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271270",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271270,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1957,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.3",
      "ID": 4664
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3901,
      "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe",
      "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0630517+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278096",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 278096,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1957,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.3",
      "ID": 4664
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2394,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo",
      "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9868323+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2110E220P414VM286752",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286752,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1957,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.3",
      "ID": 4664
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth",
      "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5991673+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250516",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250516,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1957,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.3",
      "ID": 4664
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2675,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob",
      "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1929068+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1741E10P50VM220982",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220982,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1957,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.3",
      "ID": 4664
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1741,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel",
      "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.670012+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220239",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220239,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1957,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.3",
      "ID": 4664
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1756,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine",
      "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6298379+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1860E104P150VM252340",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252340,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1957,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.3",
      "ID": 4664
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1860,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda",
      "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7249666+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2033E20P141VM266092",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 266092,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1957,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.3",
      "ID": 4664
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2033,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain",
      "DisplayName": "Iain Gray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4740108+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324602",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324602,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1957,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.3",
      "ID": 4664
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5042,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2300273+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259704",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 259704,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1957,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.3",
      "ID": 4664
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick",
      "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6209293+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239338",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239338,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1957,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.3",
      "ID": 4664
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2029,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh",
      "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7325273+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273679",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 273679,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1957,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.3",
      "ID": 4664
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3758,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6307269+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304165",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 304165,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1957,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.3",
      "ID": 4664
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4086,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Hume",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.852549+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221713",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221713,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1957,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.3",
      "ID": 4664
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1773,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9445885+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1882E227P459VM241945",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241945,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1957,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.3",
      "ID": 4664
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1882,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam",
      "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7869141+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223536",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223536,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1957,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.3",
      "ID": 4664
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1893,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.462653+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307596",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307596,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1957,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.3",
      "ID": 4664
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4934,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8363232+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272252",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 272252,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1957,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.3",
      "ID": 4664
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4956,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Keir",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3216434+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244898",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244898,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1957,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.3",
      "ID": 4664
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Kelly",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5833389+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315068",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315068,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1957,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.3",
      "ID": 4664
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3129,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6726973+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247930",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247930,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1957,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.3",
      "ID": 4664
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann",
      "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4344762+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4016E11P36VM274815",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274815,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1957,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.3",
      "ID": 4664
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4016,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1229471+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255780",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255780,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1957,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.3",
      "ID": 4664
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2180,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5565589+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4938E158P374VM277430",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277430,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1957,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.3",
      "ID": 4664
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4938,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9530472+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2112E250P486VM253032",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253032,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1957,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.3",
      "ID": 4664
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2112,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny",
      "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7639281+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4939E258P394VM276824",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276824,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1957,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.3",
      "ID": 4664
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4939,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus",
      "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6826518+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325529",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 325529,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1957,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.3",
      "ID": 4664
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5074,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon",
      "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5102812+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1828E3P10VM232845",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232845,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1957,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.3",
      "ID": 4664
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1828,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo",
      "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8790761+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311441",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311441,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1957,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.3",
      "ID": 4664
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4948,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike",
      "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8789565+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2117E90P107VM230392",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230392,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1957,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.3",
      "ID": 4664
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2117,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis",
      "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3278258+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267379",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 267379,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1957,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.3",
      "ID": 4664
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken",
      "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.017272+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313720",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313720,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1957,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.3",
      "ID": 4664
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4966,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek",
      "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4077691+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3101E102P129VM295062",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295062,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1957,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.3",
      "ID": 4664
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3101,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala",
      "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1905605+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319060",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319060,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1957,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.3",
      "ID": 4664
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5034,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny",
      "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6907062+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306418",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306418,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1957,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.3",
      "ID": 4664
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2159,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Martin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5512284+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5110E252P395VM310783",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 310783,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1957,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.3",
      "ID": 4664
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Mason",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5858655+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268224",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 268224,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1957,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.3",
      "ID": 4664
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2133,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2542153+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2876E141P433VM286348",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286348,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1957,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.3",
      "ID": 4664
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2876,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5749437+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4951E147P368VM258619",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258619,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1957,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.3",
      "ID": 4664
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4951,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan",
      "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3151332+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3896E175P307VM263872",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 263872,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1957,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.3",
      "ID": 4664
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3896,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam",
      "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9143972+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308549",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 308549,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1957,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.3",
      "ID": 4664
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.060701+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4964E143P375VM279678",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279678,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1957,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.3",
      "ID": 4664
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4964,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.517934+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279552",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279552,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1957,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.3",
      "ID": 4664
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3824,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.512596+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2066E22P91VM261089",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261089,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1957,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.3",
      "ID": 4664
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2066,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.1113221+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299651",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 299651,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1957,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.3",
      "ID": 4664
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7069092+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306736",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306736,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1957,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.3",
      "ID": 4664
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina",
      "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5652067+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300599",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 300599,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1957,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.3",
      "ID": 4664
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2487,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.005561+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223885",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223885,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1957,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.3",
      "ID": 4664
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4779493+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237509",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237509,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1957,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.3",
      "ID": 4664
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1961,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David",
      "DisplayName": "David McLetchie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2137343+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305449",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 305449,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1957,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.3",
      "ID": 4664
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2134,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3245082+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320366",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 320366,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1957,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.3",
      "ID": 4664
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5041,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan",
      "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1633169+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3763E142P397VM316014",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 316014,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1957,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.3",
      "ID": 4664
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3763,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart",
      "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9421366+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1986E23P197VM236750",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 236750,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1957,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.3",
      "ID": 4664
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1986,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan",
      "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9384654+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5047E100P130VM289755",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289755,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1957,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.3",
      "ID": 4664
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5047,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne",
      "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4577326+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234596",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234596,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1957,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.3",
      "ID": 4664
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1845,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette",
      "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3911323+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313584",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313584,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1957,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.3",
      "ID": 4664
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3061,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4016894+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1768E19P265VM289339",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289339,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1957,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.3",
      "ID": 4664
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1768,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4330036+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225250",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225250,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1957,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.3",
      "ID": 4664
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1894,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Neil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.961278+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3815E98P134VM270921",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270921,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1957,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.3",
      "ID": 4664
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3815,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Park, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Park",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8347894+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265882",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265882,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1957,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.3",
      "ID": 4664
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2010,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil",
      "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4646296+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283310",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283310,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1957,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.3",
      "ID": 4664
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5057,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.6950551+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2853E33P128VM251482",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251482,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1957,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.3",
      "ID": 4664
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Pentland",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4655834+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317587",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317587,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1957,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.3",
      "ID": 4664
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5009,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4288666+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254647",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254647,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1957,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.3",
      "ID": 4664
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3745,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis",
      "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2654841+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1870E225P478VM296240",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 296240,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1957,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.3",
      "ID": 4664
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1870,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona",
      "DisplayName": "Shona Robison",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8401111+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2135E254P450VM234925",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234925,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1957,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.3",
      "ID": 4664
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2135,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Russell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4056757+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1895E232P431VM257573",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257573,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1957,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.3",
      "ID": 4664
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1895,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.062352+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228170",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 228170,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1957,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.3",
      "ID": 4664
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1839,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5873429+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2345E10P55VM291679",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291679,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1957,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.3",
      "ID": 4664
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2345,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1376465+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311037",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311037,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1957,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.3",
      "ID": 4664
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2223,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish",
      "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.6027074+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246391",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 246391,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1957,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.3",
      "ID": 4664
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2182,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1267151+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298048",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298048,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1957,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.3",
      "ID": 4664
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5079,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew",
      "DisplayName": "Drew Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1360232+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234078",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234078,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1957,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.3",
      "ID": 4664
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1769,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1656796+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274593",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274593,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1957,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.3",
      "ID": 4664
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4014,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz",
      "DisplayName": "Liz Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1133275+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269546",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269546,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1957,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.3",
      "ID": 4664
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2215,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5522986+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317379",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317379,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1957,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.3",
      "ID": 4664
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3806,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4195809+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326301",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 326301,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1957,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.3",
      "ID": 4664
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5106,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin",
      "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7525559+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241183",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241183,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1957,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.3",
      "ID": 4664
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1848,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola",
      "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.4056129+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2098E237P531VM289642",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289642,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1957,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.3",
      "ID": 4664
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2098,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Swinney",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4527783+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2674E247P401VM247799",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247799,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1957,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.3",
      "ID": 4664
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2674,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave",
      "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4289497+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5075E234P371VM287400",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 287400,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1957,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.3",
      "ID": 4664
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5075,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Torrance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8625955+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1793E151P9VM222495",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 222495,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1957,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.3",
      "ID": 4664
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1793,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean",
      "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1914127+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5078E245P7VM306970",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306970,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1957,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.3",
      "ID": 4664
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5078,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Walker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5817282+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1841E231P426VM239940",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239940,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1957,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.3",
      "ID": 4664
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1841,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen",
      "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7658826+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283466",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283466,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1957,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.3",
      "ID": 4664
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4952,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7091173+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1865E263P500VM232186",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232186,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1957,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.3",
      "ID": 4664
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1865,
      "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra",
      "DisplayName": "Sandra White",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6385213+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237754",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237754,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1957,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.3",
      "ID": 4664
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2610,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Wilson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2244755+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309243",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 309243,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1957,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.3",
      "ID": 4664
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4941,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza",
      "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.320936+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252666",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252666,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1956,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 43,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.1",
      "ID": 4653
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1926,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian",
      "DisplayName": "Brian Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7483632+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2615E213P388VM258867",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258867,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1956,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 43,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.1",
      "ID": 4653
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2615,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George",
      "DisplayName": "George Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3315272+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319865",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319865,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1956,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 43,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.1",
      "ID": 4653
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4940,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare",
      "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9447251+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249583",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 249583,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1956,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 43,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.1",
      "ID": 4653
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2641,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair",
      "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9330936+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1783E21P273VM227777",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227777,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1956,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 43,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.1",
      "ID": 4653
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1783,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie",
      "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5651891+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2633E97P136VM280780",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280780,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1956,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 43,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.1",
      "ID": 4653
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2633,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire",
      "DisplayName": "Claire Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7820876+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262504",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262504,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1956,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 43,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.1",
      "ID": 4653
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2603,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6047744+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1759E91P115VM229755",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229755,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1956,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 43,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.1",
      "ID": 4653
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia",
      "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0952899+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270160",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270160,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1956,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 43,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.1",
      "ID": 4653
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3751,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.584129+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322649",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 322649,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1956,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 43,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.1",
      "ID": 4653
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5109,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco",
      "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6977869+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5060E86P124VM294735",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 294735,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1956,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 43,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.1",
      "ID": 4653
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5060,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1760623+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242888",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242888,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1956,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 43,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.1",
      "ID": 4653
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1866,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah",
      "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0398901+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235224",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235224,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1956,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 43,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.1",
      "ID": 4653
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1943,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic",
      "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6611464+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302163",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 302163,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1956,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 43,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.1",
      "ID": 4653
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2595,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin",
      "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.3000621+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244496",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244496,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1956,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 43,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.1",
      "ID": 4653
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2103,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith",
      "DisplayName": "Keith Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5572846+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327195",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 327195,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1956,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 43,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.1",
      "ID": 4653
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.8032655+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3775E216P435VM276687",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276687,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1956,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 43,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.1",
      "ID": 4653
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6768361+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264330",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264330,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1956,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 43,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.1",
      "ID": 4653
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2673,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick",
      "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1288703+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248758",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248758,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1956,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 43,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.1",
      "ID": 4653
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2678,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson",
      "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.668514+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2123E27P233VM295795",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295795,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1956,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 43,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.1",
      "ID": 4653
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2123,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm",
      "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5362028+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285165",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285165,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1956,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 43,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.1",
      "ID": 4653
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3907,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0692392+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230643",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230643,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1956,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 43,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.1",
      "ID": 4653
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1735,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela",
      "DisplayName": "Angela Constance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3390203+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243831",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 243831,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1956,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 43,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.1",
      "ID": 4653
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1932,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce",
      "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3216374+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254926",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254926,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1956,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 43,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.1",
      "ID": 4653
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1863,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna",
      "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2897266+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323802",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 323802,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1956,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 43,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.1",
      "ID": 4653
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4976,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth",
      "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9725416+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5107E223P379VM291320",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291320,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1956,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 43,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.1",
      "ID": 4653
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5107,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1138662+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3743E222P391VM265336",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265336,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1956,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 43,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.1",
      "ID": 4653
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3743,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel",
      "DisplayName": "Nigel Don",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4347713+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262266",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262266,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1956,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 43,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.1",
      "ID": 4653
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3771,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob",
      "DisplayName": "Bob Doris",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.5941063+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281961",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 281961,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1956,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 43,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.1",
      "ID": 4653
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2826,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Dornan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.16523+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298011",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298011,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1956,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 43,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.1",
      "ID": 4653
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3812,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia",
      "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.134461+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231589",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231589,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1956,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 43,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.1",
      "ID": 4653
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1778,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen",
      "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6071313+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4955E240P389VM285916",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285916,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1956,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 43,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.1",
      "ID": 4653
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4955,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3500646+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219403",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 219403,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1956,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 43,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.1",
      "ID": 4653
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1742,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle",
      "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.2972062+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238559",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 238559,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1956,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 43,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.1",
      "ID": 4653
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1994,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus",
      "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4593439+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225236",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225236,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1956,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 43,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.1",
      "ID": 4653
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1814,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda",
      "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9606659+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321811",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 321811,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1956,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 43,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.1",
      "ID": 4653
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Fee",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4523793+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292782",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 292782,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1956,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 43,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.1",
      "ID": 4653
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia",
      "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5579241+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227129",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227129,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1956,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 43,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.1",
      "ID": 4653
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2690689+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5054E95P118VM312679",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 312679,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1956,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 43,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.1",
      "ID": 4653
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5054,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1386911+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4947E152P8VM257236",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257236,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1956,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 43,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.1",
      "ID": 4653
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4947,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Finnie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0474317+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271271",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271271,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1956,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 43,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.1",
      "ID": 4653
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3901,
      "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe",
      "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0630924+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278097",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 278097,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1956,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 43,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.1",
      "ID": 4653
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2394,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo",
      "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9868741+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2110E220P414VM286751",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286751,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1956,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 43,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.1",
      "ID": 4653
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth",
      "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5991275+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250515",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250515,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1956,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 43,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.1",
      "ID": 4653
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2675,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob",
      "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1928662+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1741E10P50VM220981",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220981,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1956,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 43,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.1",
      "ID": 4653
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1741,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel",
      "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.669971+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220240",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220240,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1956,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 43,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.1",
      "ID": 4653
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1756,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine",
      "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6298814+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1860E104P150VM252339",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252339,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1956,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 43,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.1",
      "ID": 4653
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1860,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda",
      "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7249259+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2033E20P141VM266093",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 266093,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1956,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 43,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.1",
      "ID": 4653
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2033,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain",
      "DisplayName": "Iain Gray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4740524+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324603",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324603,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1956,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 43,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.1",
      "ID": 4653
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5042,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2300679+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259705",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 259705,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1956,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 43,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.1",
      "ID": 4653
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick",
      "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6209714+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239337",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239337,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1956,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 43,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.1",
      "ID": 4653
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2029,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh",
      "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7324852+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273801",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 273801,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1956,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 43,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.1",
      "ID": 4653
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3758,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6362454+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304166",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 304166,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1956,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 43,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.1",
      "ID": 4653
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4086,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Hume",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8525976+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221714",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221714,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1956,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 43,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.1",
      "ID": 4653
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1773,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9446291+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1882E227P459VM241946",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241946,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1956,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 43,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.1",
      "ID": 4653
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1882,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam",
      "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7869819+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223537",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223537,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1956,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 43,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.1",
      "ID": 4653
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1893,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4627118+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307595",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307595,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1956,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 43,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.1",
      "ID": 4653
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4934,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8362831+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272251",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 272251,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1956,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 43,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.1",
      "ID": 4653
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4956,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Keir",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.321602+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244897",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244897,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1956,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 43,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.1",
      "ID": 4653
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Kelly",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5832989+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315067",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315067,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1956,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 43,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.1",
      "ID": 4653
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3129,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6726569+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247931",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247931,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1956,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 43,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.1",
      "ID": 4653
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann",
      "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4345165+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4016E11P36VM274814",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274814,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1956,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 43,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.1",
      "ID": 4653
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4016,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1228877+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255781",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255781,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1956,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 43,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.1",
      "ID": 4653
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2180,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5565988+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4938E158P374VM277431",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277431,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1956,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 43,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.1",
      "ID": 4653
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4938,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.953088+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2112E250P486VM253031",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253031,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1956,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 43,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.1",
      "ID": 4653
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2112,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny",
      "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7638867+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4939E258P394VM276825",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276825,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1956,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 43,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.1",
      "ID": 4653
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4939,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus",
      "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6826935+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325528",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 325528,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1956,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 43,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.1",
      "ID": 4653
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5074,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon",
      "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5102407+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1828E3P10VM232844",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232844,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1956,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 43,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.1",
      "ID": 4653
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1828,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo",
      "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.879036+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311440",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311440,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1956,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 43,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.1",
      "ID": 4653
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4948,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike",
      "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8789142+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2117E90P107VM230393",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230393,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1956,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 43,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.1",
      "ID": 4653
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2117,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis",
      "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3278664+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267378",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 267378,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1956,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 43,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.1",
      "ID": 4653
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken",
      "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.017222+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313721",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313721,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1956,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 43,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.1",
      "ID": 4653
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4966,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek",
      "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4078096+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3101E102P129VM295063",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295063,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1956,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 43,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.1",
      "ID": 4653
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3101,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala",
      "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1906196+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319061",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319061,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1956,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 43,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.1",
      "ID": 4653
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5034,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny",
      "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6907462+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306419",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306419,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1956,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 43,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.1",
      "ID": 4653
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2159,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Martin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5512684+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5110E252P395VM310784",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 310784,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1956,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 43,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.1",
      "ID": 4653
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Mason",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5859064+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268225",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 268225,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1956,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 43,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.1",
      "ID": 4653
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2133,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2542564+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2876E141P433VM286347",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286347,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1956,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 43,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.1",
      "ID": 4653
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2876,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5749029+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4951E147P368VM258620",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258620,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1956,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 43,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.1",
      "ID": 4653
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4951,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan",
      "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3151757+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3896E175P307VM263873",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 263873,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1956,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 43,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.1",
      "ID": 4653
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3896,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam",
      "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9144372+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308548",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 308548,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1956,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 43,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.1",
      "ID": 4653
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0606423+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4964E143P375VM279677",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279677,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1956,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 43,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.1",
      "ID": 4653
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4964,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5178941+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279983",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279983,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1956,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 43,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.1",
      "ID": 4653
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3824,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5312378+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2066E22P91VM261090",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261090,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1956,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 43,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.1",
      "ID": 4653
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2066,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.1113818+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299652",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 299652,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1956,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 43,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.1",
      "ID": 4653
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7069504+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306735",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306735,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1956,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 43,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.1",
      "ID": 4653
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina",
      "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5651648+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300600",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 300600,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1956,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 43,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.1",
      "ID": 4653
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2487,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0056017+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223884",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223884,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1956,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 43,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.1",
      "ID": 4653
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4779088+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237508",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237508,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1956,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 43,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.1",
      "ID": 4653
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1961,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David",
      "DisplayName": "David McLetchie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2136924+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305448",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 305448,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1956,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 43,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.1",
      "ID": 4653
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2134,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3244676+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320365",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 320365,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1956,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 43,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.1",
      "ID": 4653
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5041,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan",
      "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1632755+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3763E142P397VM316015",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 316015,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1956,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 43,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.1",
      "ID": 4653
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3763,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart",
      "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.942178+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1986E23P197VM236627",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 236627,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1956,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 43,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.1",
      "ID": 4653
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1986,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan",
      "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9331568+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5047E100P130VM291416",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291416,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1956,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 43,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.1",
      "ID": 4653
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5047,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne",
      "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1183746+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234597",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234597,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1956,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 43,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.1",
      "ID": 4653
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1845,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette",
      "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3911745+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313585",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313585,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1956,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 43,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.1",
      "ID": 4653
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3061,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.401731+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1768E19P265VM289338",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289338,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1956,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 43,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.1",
      "ID": 4653
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1768,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4329629+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225093",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225093,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1956,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 43,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.1",
      "ID": 4653
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1894,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Neil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7442023+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3815E98P134VM270920",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270920,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1956,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 43,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.1",
      "ID": 4653
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3815,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Park, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Park",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8291331+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265883",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265883,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1956,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 43,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.1",
      "ID": 4653
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2010,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil",
      "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4646709+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283311",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283311,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1956,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 43,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.1",
      "ID": 4653
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5057,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.6952049+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2853E33P128VM251481",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251481,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1956,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 43,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.1",
      "ID": 4653
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Pentland",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.465524+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317586",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317586,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1956,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 43,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.1",
      "ID": 4653
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5009,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.428806+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254648",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254648,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1956,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 43,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.1",
      "ID": 4653
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3745,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis",
      "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2655246+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1870E225P478VM296239",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 296239,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1956,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 43,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.1",
      "ID": 4653
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1870,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona",
      "DisplayName": "Shona Robison",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8400685+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2135E254P450VM234924",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234924,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1956,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 43,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.1",
      "ID": 4653
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2135,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Russell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4056348+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1895E232P431VM257572",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257572,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1956,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 43,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.1",
      "ID": 4653
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1895,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0623097+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228169",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 228169,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1956,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 43,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.1",
      "ID": 4653
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1839,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5873031+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2345E10P55VM291680",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291680,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1956,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 43,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.1",
      "ID": 4653
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2345,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1376883+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311036",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311036,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1956,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 43,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.1",
      "ID": 4653
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2223,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish",
      "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.6026669+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246390",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 246390,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1956,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 43,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.1",
      "ID": 4653
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2182,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1266562+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298050",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298050,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1956,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 43,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.1",
      "ID": 4653
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5079,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew",
      "DisplayName": "Drew Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.136104+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234354",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234354,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1956,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 43,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.1",
      "ID": 4653
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1769,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3736594+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274592",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274592,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1956,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 43,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.1",
      "ID": 4653
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4014,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz",
      "DisplayName": "Liz Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1132676+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269545",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269545,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1956,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 43,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.1",
      "ID": 4653
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2215,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5522576+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317378",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317378,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1956,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 43,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.1",
      "ID": 4653
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3806,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4195407+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326302",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 326302,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1956,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 43,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.1",
      "ID": 4653
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5106,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin",
      "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7525985+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241182",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241182,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1956,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 43,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.1",
      "ID": 4653
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1848,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola",
      "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.4055491+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2098E237P531VM289641",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289641,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1956,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 43,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.1",
      "ID": 4653
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2098,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Swinney",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4527389+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2674E247P401VM247798",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247798,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1956,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 43,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.1",
      "ID": 4653
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2674,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave",
      "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4289087+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5075E234P371VM287399",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 287399,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1956,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 43,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.1",
      "ID": 4653
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5075,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Torrance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8625553+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1793E151P9VM222494",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 222494,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1956,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 43,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.1",
      "ID": 4653
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1793,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean",
      "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1913724+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5078E245P7VM306971",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306971,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1956,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 43,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.1",
      "ID": 4653
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5078,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Walker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5817692+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1841E231P426VM239941",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239941,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1956,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 43,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.1",
      "ID": 4653
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1841,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen",
      "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7659236+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283465",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283465,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1956,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 43,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.1",
      "ID": 4653
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4952,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7090543+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1865E263P500VM232187",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232187,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1956,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 43,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.1",
      "ID": 4653
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1865,
      "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra",
      "DisplayName": "Sandra White",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6385614+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237755",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237755,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1956,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 43,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.1",
      "ID": 4653
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2610,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Wilson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2245163+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309244",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 309244,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1956,
      "AgendaID": 2775,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 43,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Winter Resilience",
      "Reference": "S4M-04518.1",
      "ID": 4653
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4941,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza",
      "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3209791+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252305",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252305,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1954,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.3",
      "ID": 4500
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1926,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian",
      "DisplayName": "Brian Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7234256+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2615E213P388VM258813",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258813,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1954,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.3",
      "ID": 4500
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2615,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George",
      "DisplayName": "George Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3290247+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319913",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319913,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1954,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.3",
      "ID": 4500
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4940,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare",
      "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9467842+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249656",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 249656,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1954,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.3",
      "ID": 4500
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2641,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair",
      "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9441988+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1783E21P273VM227412",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227412,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1954,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.3",
      "ID": 4500
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1783,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie",
      "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5490566+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2633E97P136VM280407",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280407,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1954,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.3",
      "ID": 4500
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2633,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire",
      "DisplayName": "Claire Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7656657+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262459",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262459,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1954,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.3",
      "ID": 4500
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2603,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6028422+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1759E91P115VM229245",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229245,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1954,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.3",
      "ID": 4500
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia",
      "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0683319+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270214",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270214,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1954,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.3",
      "ID": 4500
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3751,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.7942183+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322683",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 322683,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1954,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.3",
      "ID": 4500
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5109,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco",
      "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6992146+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5060E86P124VM294691",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 294691,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1954,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.3",
      "ID": 4500
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5060,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1741727+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242839",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242839,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1954,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.3",
      "ID": 4500
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1866,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah",
      "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0378204+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235586",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235586,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1954,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.3",
      "ID": 4500
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1943,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic",
      "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6841659+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302114",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 302114,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1954,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.3",
      "ID": 4500
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2595,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin",
      "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.2976526+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244541",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244541,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1954,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.3",
      "ID": 4500
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2103,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith",
      "DisplayName": "Keith Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5593354+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327376",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 327376,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1954,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.3",
      "ID": 4500
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:46.0335443+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3775E216P435VM276642",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276642,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1954,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.3",
      "ID": 4500
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6749102+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264375",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264375,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1954,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.3",
      "ID": 4500
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2673,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick",
      "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1307849+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248820",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248820,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1954,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.3",
      "ID": 4500
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2678,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson",
      "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6714521+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2123E27P233VM295844",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295844,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1954,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.3",
      "ID": 4500
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2123,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm",
      "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5382644+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285120",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285120,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1954,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.3",
      "ID": 4500
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3907,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0673149+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230136",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230136,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1954,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.3",
      "ID": 4500
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1735,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela",
      "DisplayName": "Angela Constance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.1177936+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243880",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 243880,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1954,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.3",
      "ID": 4500
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1932,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce",
      "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3238676+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1863E238P523VM255282",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255282,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1954,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.3",
      "ID": 4500
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1863,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna",
      "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5242024+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4976E20P31VM324011",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324011,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1954,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.3",
      "ID": 4500
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4976,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth",
      "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.982147+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5107E223P379VM291379",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291379,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1954,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.3",
      "ID": 4500
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5107,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1167606+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3743E222P391VM265135",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265135,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1954,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.3",
      "ID": 4500
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3743,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel",
      "DisplayName": "Nigel Don",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1699922+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3771E149P417VM261741",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261741,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1954,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.3",
      "ID": 4500
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3771,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob",
      "DisplayName": "Bob Doris",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3708303+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2826E262P384VM282024",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 282024,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1954,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.3",
      "ID": 4500
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2826,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Dornan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1679262+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3812E94P117VM297949",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 297949,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1954,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.3",
      "ID": 4500
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3812,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia",
      "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1318426+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231638",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231638,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1954,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.3",
      "ID": 4500
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1778,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen",
      "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6092004+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4955E240P389VM285976",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285976,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1954,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.3",
      "ID": 4500
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4955,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3526464+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219344",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 219344,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1954,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.3",
      "ID": 4500
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1742,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle",
      "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.2945634+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238613",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 238613,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1954,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.3",
      "ID": 4500
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1994,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus",
      "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4616422+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225491",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225491,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1954,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.3",
      "ID": 4500
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1814,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda",
      "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9770103+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321777",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 321777,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1954,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.3",
      "ID": 4500
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Fee",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4509293+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292898",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 292898,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1954,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.3",
      "ID": 4500
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia",
      "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5629532+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1892E12P64VM226911",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 226911,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1954,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.3",
      "ID": 4500
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2520446+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5054E95P118VM312630",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 312630,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1954,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.3",
      "ID": 4500
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5054,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1365874+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4947E152P361VM257163",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257163,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1954,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.3",
      "ID": 4500
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4947,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Finnie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.8260251+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271332",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271332,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1954,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.3",
      "ID": 4500
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3901,
      "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe",
      "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0709529+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278468",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 278468,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1954,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.3",
      "ID": 4500
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2394,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo",
      "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.220123+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2110E220P414VM286703",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286703,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1954,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.3",
      "ID": 4500
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth",
      "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5971278+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250441",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250441,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1954,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.3",
      "ID": 4500
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2675,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob",
      "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.189683+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1741E10P50VM220724",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220724,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1954,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.3",
      "ID": 4500
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1741,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel",
      "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6543125+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220301",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220301,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1954,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.3",
      "ID": 4500
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1756,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine",
      "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6354295+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1860E104P150VM251831",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251831,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1954,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.3",
      "ID": 4500
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1860,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda",
      "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4910174+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2033E20P141VM266153",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 266153,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1954,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.3",
      "ID": 4500
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2033,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain",
      "DisplayName": "Iain Gray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4766022+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324422",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324422,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1954,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.3",
      "ID": 4500
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5042,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2219816+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259922",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 259922,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1954,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.3",
      "ID": 4500
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick",
      "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6358305+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239284",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239284,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1954,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.3",
      "ID": 4500
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2029,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh",
      "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7301733+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273846",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 273846,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1954,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.3",
      "ID": 4500
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3758,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6381874+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304215",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 304215,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1954,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.3",
      "ID": 4500
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4086,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Hume",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.0286703+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221815",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221815,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1954,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.3",
      "ID": 4500
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1773,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.948989+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1882E227P459VM242019",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242019,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1954,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.3",
      "ID": 4500
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1882,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam",
      "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7903291+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223744",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223744,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1954,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.3",
      "ID": 4500
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1893,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4719094+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307533",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307533,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1954,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.3",
      "ID": 4500
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4934,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8336359+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272180",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 272180,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1954,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.3",
      "ID": 4500
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4956,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Keir",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.1150077+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244847",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244847,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1954,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.3",
      "ID": 4500
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Kelly",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5811708+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315019",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315019,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1954,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.3",
      "ID": 4500
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3129,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6705782+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247984",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247984,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1954,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.3",
      "ID": 4500
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann",
      "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4367709+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4016E11P36VM274754",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274754,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1954,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.3",
      "ID": 4500
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4016,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1202907+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255834",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255834,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1954,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.3",
      "ID": 4500
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2180,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5590571+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4938E158P374VM277800",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277800,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1954,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.3",
      "ID": 4500
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4938,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9689685+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2112E250P486VM252978",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252978,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1954,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.3",
      "ID": 4500
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2112,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny",
      "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.761449+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4939E258P394VM277195",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277195,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1954,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.3",
      "ID": 4500
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4939,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus",
      "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.7055158+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325709",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 325709,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1954,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.3",
      "ID": 4500
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5074,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon",
      "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5179629+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1828E3P10VM232796",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232796,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1954,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.3",
      "ID": 4500
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1828,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo",
      "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8766167+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311380",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311380,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1954,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.3",
      "ID": 4500
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4948,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike",
      "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8762216+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2117E90P107VM230455",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230455,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1954,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.3",
      "ID": 4500
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2117,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis",
      "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3306575+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267318",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 267318,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1954,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.3",
      "ID": 4500
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken",
      "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0142752+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313781",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313781,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1954,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.3",
      "ID": 4500
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4966,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek",
      "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4103968+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3101E102P129VM295433",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295433,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1954,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.3",
      "ID": 4500
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3101,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala",
      "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5119413+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319027",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319027,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1954,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.3",
      "ID": 4500
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5034,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny",
      "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6892868+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306468",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306468,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1954,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.3",
      "ID": 4500
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2159,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Martin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5533612+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5110E252P395VM311206",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311206,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1954,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.3",
      "ID": 4500
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Mason",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8665067+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268286",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 268286,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1954,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.3",
      "ID": 4500
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2133,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2605455+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2876E141P433VM286128",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286128,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1954,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.3",
      "ID": 4500
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2876,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3649425+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4951E147P368VM260704",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 260704,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1954,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.3",
      "ID": 4500
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4951,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan",
      "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.0886786+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3896E175P307VM264089",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264089,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1954,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.3",
      "ID": 4500
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3896,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam",
      "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9237193+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308433",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 308433,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1954,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.3",
      "ID": 4500
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0557245+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4964E143P375VM279314",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279314,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1954,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.3",
      "ID": 4500
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4964,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.4968162+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3824E84P113VM280028",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280028,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1954,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.3",
      "ID": 4500
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3824,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5383381+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2066E22P91VM261760",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261760,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1954,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.3",
      "ID": 4500
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2066,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3716269+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299714",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 299714,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1954,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.3",
      "ID": 4500
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7194625+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306619",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306619,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1954,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.3",
      "ID": 4500
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina",
      "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5598627+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2487E146P369VM301176",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 301176,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1954,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.3",
      "ID": 4500
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2487,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0373047+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223629",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223629,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1954,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.3",
      "ID": 4500
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4670069+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237456",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237456,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1954,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.3",
      "ID": 4500
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1961,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David",
      "DisplayName": "David McLetchie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2113677+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2134E34P201VM297846",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 297846,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1954,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.3",
      "ID": 4500
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2134,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1275211+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320399",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 320399,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1954,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.3",
      "ID": 4500
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5041,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan",
      "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1647401+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3763E142P397VM316063",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 316063,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1954,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.3",
      "ID": 4500
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3763,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart",
      "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9445646+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1986E23P197VM236273",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 236273,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1954,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.3",
      "ID": 4500
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1986,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan",
      "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9092966+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5047E100P130VM291461",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291461,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1954,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.3",
      "ID": 4500
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5047,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne",
      "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1203149+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234951",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234951,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1954,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.3",
      "ID": 4500
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1845,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette",
      "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4069056+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313633",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313633,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1954,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.3",
      "ID": 4500
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3061,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4038111+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1768E19P265VM288604",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 288604,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1954,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.3",
      "ID": 4500
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1768,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.150553+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225041",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225041,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1954,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.3",
      "ID": 4500
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1894,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Neil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7419973+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3815E98P134VM270879",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270879,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1954,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.3",
      "ID": 4500
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3815,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Park, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Park",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8270598+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265929",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265929,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1954,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.3",
      "ID": 4500
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2010,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil",
      "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4666502+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283526",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283526,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1954,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.3",
      "ID": 4500
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5057,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7116989+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2853E33P128VM251419",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251419,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1954,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.3",
      "ID": 4500
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Pentland",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4627893+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317619",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317619,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1954,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.3",
      "ID": 4500
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5009,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4302059+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254722",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254722,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1954,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.3",
      "ID": 4500
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3745,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis",
      "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2809357+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1870E225P478VM295662",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295662,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1954,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.3",
      "ID": 4500
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1870,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona",
      "DisplayName": "Shona Robison",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5304969+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2135E254P450VM234862",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234862,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1954,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.3",
      "ID": 4500
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2135,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Russell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4029443+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1895E232P431VM257371",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257371,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1954,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.3",
      "ID": 4500
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1895,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0533185+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228097",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 228097,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1954,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.3",
      "ID": 4500
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1839,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5842412+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2345E10P55VM292037",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 292037,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1954,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.3",
      "ID": 4500
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2345,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1531552+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2223E176P333VM310676",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 310676,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1954,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.3",
      "ID": 4500
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2223,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish",
      "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5812516+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246318",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 246318,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1954,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.3",
      "ID": 4500
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2182,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1235139+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298367",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298367,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1954,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.3",
      "ID": 4500
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5079,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew",
      "DisplayName": "Drew Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3426842+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234401",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234401,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1954,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.3",
      "ID": 4500
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1769,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3756828+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4014E14P26VM269942",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269942,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1954,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.3",
      "ID": 4500
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4014,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz",
      "DisplayName": "Liz Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5744946+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269174",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269174,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1954,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.3",
      "ID": 4500
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2215,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.3068833+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317177",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317177,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1954,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.3",
      "ID": 4500
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3806,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.1850122+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326121",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 326121,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1954,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.3",
      "ID": 4500
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5106,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin",
      "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5407812+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241109",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241109,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1954,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.3",
      "ID": 4500
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1848,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola",
      "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3964725+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2098E237P531VM289592",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289592,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1954,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.3",
      "ID": 4500
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2098,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Swinney",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4506744+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2674E247P401VM247736",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247736,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1954,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.3",
      "ID": 4500
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2674,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave",
      "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4262156+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5075E234P371VM284854",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 284854,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1954,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.3",
      "ID": 4500
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5075,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Torrance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0505884+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1793E151P362VM222442",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 222442,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1954,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.3",
      "ID": 4500
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1793,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean",
      "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1891303+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5078E245P7VM307080",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307080,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1954,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.3",
      "ID": 4500
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5078,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Walker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5864184+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1841E231P426VM240169",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 240169,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1954,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.3",
      "ID": 4500
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1841,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen",
      "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7819311+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283405",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283405,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1954,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.3",
      "ID": 4500
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4952,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.6992906+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1865E263P500VM232246",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232246,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1954,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.3",
      "ID": 4500
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1865,
      "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra",
      "DisplayName": "Sandra White",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8464557+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237817",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237817,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1954,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.3",
      "ID": 4500
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2610,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Wilson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2273457+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309305",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 309305,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1954,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 50,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.3",
      "ID": 4500
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4941,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza",
      "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3235844+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252306",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252306,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1955,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.2",
      "ID": 4495
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1926,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian",
      "DisplayName": "Brian Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7234661+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2615E213P388VM258814",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258814,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1955,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.2",
      "ID": 4495
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2615,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George",
      "DisplayName": "George Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3290659+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319912",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319912,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1955,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.2",
      "ID": 4495
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4940,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare",
      "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9467436+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249655",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 249655,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1955,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.2",
      "ID": 4495
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2641,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair",
      "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9441592+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1783E21P273VM227413",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227413,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1955,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.2",
      "ID": 4495
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1783,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie",
      "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.549109+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2633E97P136VM280408",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280408,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1955,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.2",
      "ID": 4495
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2633,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire",
      "DisplayName": "Claire Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7657076+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262460",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262460,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1955,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.2",
      "ID": 4495
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2603,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6028828+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1759E91P115VM229246",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229246,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1955,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.2",
      "ID": 4495
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia",
      "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0683739+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270213",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270213,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1955,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.2",
      "ID": 4495
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3751,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.7941769+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322684",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 322684,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1955,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.2",
      "ID": 4495
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5109,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco",
      "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.699254+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5060E86P124VM294736",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 294736,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1955,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.2",
      "ID": 4495
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5060,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1761226+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242840",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242840,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1955,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.2",
      "ID": 4495
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1866,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah",
      "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0378596+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235585",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235585,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1955,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.2",
      "ID": 4495
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1943,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic",
      "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6841259+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302115",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 302115,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1955,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.2",
      "ID": 4495
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2595,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin",
      "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.2976932+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244540",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244540,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1955,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.2",
      "ID": 4495
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2103,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith",
      "DisplayName": "Keith Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5592944+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327377",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 327377,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1955,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.2",
      "ID": 4495
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:46.0335853+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3775E216P435VM276643",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276643,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1955,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.2",
      "ID": 4495
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6749514+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264374",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264374,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1955,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.2",
      "ID": 4495
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2673,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick",
      "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1307449+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248819",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248819,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1955,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.2",
      "ID": 4495
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2678,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson",
      "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6714118+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2123E27P233VM295843",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295843,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1955,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.2",
      "ID": 4495
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2123,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm",
      "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5382247+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285121",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285121,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1955,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.2",
      "ID": 4495
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3907,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0673567+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230137",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230137,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1955,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.2",
      "ID": 4495
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1735,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela",
      "DisplayName": "Angela Constance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.1178343+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243879",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 243879,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1955,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.2",
      "ID": 4495
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1932,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce",
      "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3238269+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1863E238P523VM255281",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255281,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1955,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.2",
      "ID": 4495
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1863,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna",
      "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5241616+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4976E20P31VM324012",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324012,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1955,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.2",
      "ID": 4495
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4976,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth",
      "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9821875+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5107E223P379VM291378",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291378,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1955,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.2",
      "ID": 4495
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5107,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1167201+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3743E222P391VM265136",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265136,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1955,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.2",
      "ID": 4495
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3743,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel",
      "DisplayName": "Nigel Don",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1700336+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3771E149P417VM261742",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261742,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1955,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.2",
      "ID": 4495
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3771,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob",
      "DisplayName": "Bob Doris",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3708705+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2826E262P384VM282023",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 282023,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1955,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.2",
      "ID": 4495
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2826,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Dornan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1678671+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3812E94P117VM297950",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 297950,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1955,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.2",
      "ID": 4495
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3812,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia",
      "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1318827+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231637",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231637,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1955,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.2",
      "ID": 4495
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1778,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen",
      "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6091605+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4955E240P389VM285975",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285975,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1955,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.2",
      "ID": 4495
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4955,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3526045+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219345",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 219345,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1955,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.2",
      "ID": 4495
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1742,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle",
      "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.2946059+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238612",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 238612,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1955,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.2",
      "ID": 4495
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1994,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus",
      "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4616025+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225461",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225461,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1955,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.2",
      "ID": 4495
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1814,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda",
      "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9757346+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321776",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 321776,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1955,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.2",
      "ID": 4495
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Fee",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4508894+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292897",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 292897,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1955,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.2",
      "ID": 4495
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia",
      "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5629132+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1892E12P64VM226912",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 226912,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1955,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.2",
      "ID": 4495
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.252086+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5054E95P118VM312631",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 312631,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1955,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.2",
      "ID": 4495
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5054,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1366279+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4947E152P361VM257164",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257164,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1955,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.2",
      "ID": 4495
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4947,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Finnie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.8260659+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271331",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271331,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1955,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.2",
      "ID": 4495
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3901,
      "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe",
      "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0708903+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278467",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 278467,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1955,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.2",
      "ID": 4495
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2394,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo",
      "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2200804+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2110E220P414VM286704",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286704,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1955,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.2",
      "ID": 4495
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth",
      "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5971672+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250442",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250442,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1955,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.2",
      "ID": 4495
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2675,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob",
      "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1897238+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1741E10P50VM220754",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220754,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1955,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.2",
      "ID": 4495
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1741,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel",
      "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6555955+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220300",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220300,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1955,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.2",
      "ID": 4495
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1756,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine",
      "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6353664+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1860E104P150VM251832",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251832,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1955,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.2",
      "ID": 4495
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1860,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda",
      "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4910604+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2033E20P141VM266152",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 266152,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1955,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.2",
      "ID": 4495
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2033,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain",
      "DisplayName": "Iain Gray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4765609+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324421",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324421,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1955,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.2",
      "ID": 4495
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5042,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2219387+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259921",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 259921,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1955,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.2",
      "ID": 4495
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick",
      "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6357704+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239285",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239285,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1955,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.2",
      "ID": 4495
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2029,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh",
      "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7302192+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273845",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 273845,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1955,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.2",
      "ID": 4495
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3758,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6381474+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304214",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 304214,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1955,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.2",
      "ID": 4495
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4086,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Hume",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.0286295+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221785",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221785,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1955,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.2",
      "ID": 4495
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1773,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.947714+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1882E227P459VM242018",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242018,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1955,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.2",
      "ID": 4495
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1882,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam",
      "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7902883+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223743",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223743,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1955,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.2",
      "ID": 4495
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1893,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4718677+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307534",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307534,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1955,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.2",
      "ID": 4495
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4934,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8336775+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272181",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 272181,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1955,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.2",
      "ID": 4495
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4956,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Keir",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.1150477+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244848",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244848,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1955,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.2",
      "ID": 4495
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Kelly",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.581211+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315020",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315020,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1955,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.2",
      "ID": 4495
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3129,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.670638+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247983",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247983,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1955,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.2",
      "ID": 4495
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann",
      "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4367301+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4016E11P36VM274755",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274755,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1955,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.2",
      "ID": 4495
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4016,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1203309+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255833",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255833,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1955,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.2",
      "ID": 4495
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2180,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5590171+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4938E158P374VM277799",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277799,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1955,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.2",
      "ID": 4495
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4938,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9689272+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2112E250P486VM252979",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252979,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1955,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.2",
      "ID": 4495
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2112,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny",
      "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.761501+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4939E258P394VM277194",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277194,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1955,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.2",
      "ID": 4495
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4939,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus",
      "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.7054634+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325710",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 325710,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1955,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.2",
      "ID": 4495
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5074,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon",
      "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5180027+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1828E3P10VM232797",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232797,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1955,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.2",
      "ID": 4495
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1828,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo",
      "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8766594+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311381",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311381,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1955,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.2",
      "ID": 4495
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4948,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike",
      "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8762633+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2117E90P107VM230454",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230454,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1955,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.2",
      "ID": 4495
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2117,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis",
      "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3306165+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267319",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 267319,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1955,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.2",
      "ID": 4495
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken",
      "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0143155+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313780",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313780,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1955,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.2",
      "ID": 4495
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4966,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek",
      "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4103555+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3101E102P129VM295432",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295432,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1955,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.2",
      "ID": 4495
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3101,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala",
      "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5119014+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319026",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319026,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1955,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.2",
      "ID": 4495
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5034,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny",
      "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6892453+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306467",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306467,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1955,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.2",
      "ID": 4495
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2159,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Martin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5533207+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5110E252P395VM311205",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311205,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1955,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.2",
      "ID": 4495
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Mason",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8664587+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268285",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 268285,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1955,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.2",
      "ID": 4495
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2133,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2605043+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2876E141P433VM286129",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286129,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1955,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.2",
      "ID": 4495
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2876,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3649851+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4951E147P368VM260703",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 260703,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1955,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.2",
      "ID": 4495
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4951,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan",
      "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.0886385+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3896E175P307VM264088",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264088,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1955,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.2",
      "ID": 4495
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3896,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam",
      "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9236785+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308434",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 308434,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1955,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.2",
      "ID": 4495
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.055765+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4964E143P375VM279315",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279315,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1955,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.2",
      "ID": 4495
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4964,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.4968593+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3824E84P113VM280027",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280027,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1955,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.2",
      "ID": 4495
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3824,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5382771+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2066E22P91VM261759",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261759,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1955,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.2",
      "ID": 4495
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2066,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3715859+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299713",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 299713,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1955,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.2",
      "ID": 4495
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7194015+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306620",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306620,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1955,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.2",
      "ID": 4495
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina",
      "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5599247+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2487E146P369VM301175",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 301175,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1955,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.2",
      "ID": 4495
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2487,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0372557+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223659",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223659,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1955,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.2",
      "ID": 4495
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4682992+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237457",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237457,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1955,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.2",
      "ID": 4495
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1961,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David",
      "DisplayName": "David McLetchie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2114095+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2134E34P201VM297847",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 297847,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1955,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.2",
      "ID": 4495
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2134,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1275611+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320400",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 320400,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1955,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.2",
      "ID": 4495
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5041,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan",
      "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.164782+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3763E142P397VM316062",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 316062,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1955,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.2",
      "ID": 4495
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3763,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart",
      "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9445239+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1986E23P197VM236274",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 236274,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1955,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.2",
      "ID": 4495
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1986,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan",
      "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9093407+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5047E100P130VM291460",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291460,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1955,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.2",
      "ID": 4495
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5047,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne",
      "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1202734+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234950",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234950,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1955,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.2",
      "ID": 4495
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1845,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette",
      "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4068635+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313632",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313632,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1955,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.2",
      "ID": 4495
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3061,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.40377+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1768E19P265VM288605",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 288605,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1955,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.2",
      "ID": 4495
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1768,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1505933+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225042",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225042,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1955,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.2",
      "ID": 4495
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1894,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Neil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7420373+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3815E98P134VM270880",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270880,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1955,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.2",
      "ID": 4495
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3815,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Park, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Park",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8271013+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265928",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265928,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1955,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.2",
      "ID": 4495
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2010,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil",
      "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4666098+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283525",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283525,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1955,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.2",
      "ID": 4495
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5057,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7116584+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2853E33P128VM251420",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251420,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1955,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.2",
      "ID": 4495
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Pentland",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4628318+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317620",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317620,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1955,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.2",
      "ID": 4495
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5009,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4302639+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254721",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254721,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1955,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.2",
      "ID": 4495
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3745,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis",
      "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2808949+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1870E225P478VM295663",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295663,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1955,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.2",
      "ID": 4495
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1870,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona",
      "DisplayName": "Shona Robison",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5305367+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2135E254P450VM234863",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234863,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1955,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.2",
      "ID": 4495
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2135,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Russell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4030031+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1895E232P431VM257372",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257372,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1955,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.2",
      "ID": 4495
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1895,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0533592+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228098",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 228098,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1955,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.2",
      "ID": 4495
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1839,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5842829+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2345E10P55VM292036",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 292036,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1955,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.2",
      "ID": 4495
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2345,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1531145+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2223E176P333VM310677",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 310677,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1955,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.2",
      "ID": 4495
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2223,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish",
      "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5812923+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246319",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 246319,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1955,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.2",
      "ID": 4495
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2182,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1235547+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298169",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298169,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1955,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.2",
      "ID": 4495
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5079,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew",
      "DisplayName": "Drew Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1411754+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234400",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234400,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1955,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.2",
      "ID": 4495
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1769,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3756415+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4014E14P26VM269943",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269943,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1955,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.2",
      "ID": 4495
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4014,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz",
      "DisplayName": "Liz Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5745354+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269175",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269175,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1955,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.2",
      "ID": 4495
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2215,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.3069237+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317178",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317178,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1955,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.2",
      "ID": 4495
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3806,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.1850535+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326120",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 326120,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1955,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.2",
      "ID": 4495
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5106,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin",
      "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5407398+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241110",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241110,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1955,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.2",
      "ID": 4495
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1848,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola",
      "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3965139+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2098E237P531VM289593",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289593,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1955,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.2",
      "ID": 4495
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2098,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Swinney",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.450714+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2674E247P401VM247737",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247737,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1955,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.2",
      "ID": 4495
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2674,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave",
      "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4262556+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5075E234P371VM284855",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 284855,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1955,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.2",
      "ID": 4495
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5075,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Torrance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0506278+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1793E151P362VM222443",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 222443,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1955,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.2",
      "ID": 4495
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1793,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean",
      "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1891712+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5078E245P7VM307079",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307079,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1955,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.2",
      "ID": 4495
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5078,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Walker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5863783+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1841E231P426VM240168",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 240168,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1955,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.2",
      "ID": 4495
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1841,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen",
      "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7818908+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283406",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283406,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1955,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.2",
      "ID": 4495
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4952,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.6993316+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1865E263P500VM232245",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232245,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1955,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.2",
      "ID": 4495
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1865,
      "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra",
      "DisplayName": "Sandra White",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.846414+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237816",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237816,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1955,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.2",
      "ID": 4495
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2610,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Wilson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2273059+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309304",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 309304,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1955,
      "AgendaID": 2753,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Employability",
      "Reference": "S4M-04365.2",
      "ID": 4495
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4941,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza",
      "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-04T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3235436+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252750",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252750,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1952,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340.4",
      "ID": 4483
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1926,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian",
      "DisplayName": "Brian Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7517073+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2615E213P388VM258954",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258954,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1952,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340.4",
      "ID": 4483
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2615,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George",
      "DisplayName": "George Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3354014+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319590",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319590,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1952,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340.4",
      "ID": 4483
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4940,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare",
      "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9328396+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249481",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 249481,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1952,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340.4",
      "ID": 4483
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2641,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair",
      "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9287401+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1783E21P273VM228337",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 228337,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1952,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340.4",
      "ID": 4483
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1783,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie",
      "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.7886246+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2633E97P136VM280879",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280879,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1952,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340.4",
      "ID": 4483
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2633,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire",
      "DisplayName": "Claire Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7862692+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262779",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262779,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1952,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340.4",
      "ID": 4483
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2603,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.616475+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1759E91P115VM229870",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229870,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1952,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340.4",
      "ID": 4483
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia",
      "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.1009658+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3751E243P383VM269763",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269763,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1952,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340.4",
      "ID": 4483
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3751,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5619112+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322564",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 322564,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1952,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340.4",
      "ID": 4483
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5109,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco",
      "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6941352+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5060E86P124VM295316",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295316,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1952,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340.4",
      "ID": 4483
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5060,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.506753+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1866E93P239VM243013",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 243013,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1952,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340.4",
      "ID": 4483
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1866,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah",
      "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0451869+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235137",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235137,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1952,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340.4",
      "ID": 4483
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1943,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic",
      "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4209724+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302435",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 302435,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1952,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340.4",
      "ID": 4483
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2595,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin",
      "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5244634+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244224",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244224,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1952,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340.4",
      "ID": 4483
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2103,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith",
      "DisplayName": "Keith Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5453644+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327085",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 327085,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1952,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340.4",
      "ID": 4483
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7981948+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277118",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277118,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1952,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340.4",
      "ID": 4483
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.7018809+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264056",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264056,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1952,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340.4",
      "ID": 4483
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2673,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick",
      "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9222991+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248672",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248672,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1952,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340.4",
      "ID": 4483
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2678,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson",
      "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6648736+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2123E27P233VM294899",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 294899,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1952,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340.4",
      "ID": 4483
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2123,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm",
      "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1835313+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285283",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285283,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1952,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340.4",
      "ID": 4483
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3907,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3163218+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230760",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230760,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1952,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340.4",
      "ID": 4483
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1735,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela",
      "DisplayName": "Angela Constance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3443507+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243705",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 243705,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1952,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340.4",
      "ID": 4483
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1932,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce",
      "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.316304+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254811",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254811,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1952,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340.4",
      "ID": 4483
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1863,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna",
      "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2847494+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323692",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 323692,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1952,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340.4",
      "ID": 4483
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4976,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth",
      "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9677736+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5107E223P379VM290922",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 290922,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1952,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340.4",
      "ID": 4483
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5107,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7778412+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3743E222P391VM265455",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265455,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1952,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340.4",
      "ID": 4483
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3743,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel",
      "DisplayName": "Nigel Don",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4399168+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262353",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262353,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1952,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340.4",
      "ID": 4483
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3771,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob",
      "DisplayName": "Bob Doris",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.5978017+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281860",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 281860,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1952,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340.4",
      "ID": 4483
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2826,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Dornan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1607084+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298267",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298267,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1952,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340.4",
      "ID": 4483
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3812,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia",
      "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3383964+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231181",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231181,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1952,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340.4",
      "ID": 4483
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1778,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen",
      "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3693171+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4955E240P389VM285008",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285008,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1952,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340.4",
      "ID": 4483
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4955,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0572573+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219492",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 219492,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1952,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340.4",
      "ID": 4483
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1742,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle",
      "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3016108+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238473",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 238473,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1952,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340.4",
      "ID": 4483
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1994,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus",
      "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4555982+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225136",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225136,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1952,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340.4",
      "ID": 4483
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1814,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda",
      "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.746019+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321896",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 321896,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1952,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340.4",
      "ID": 4483
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Fee",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4559934+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292741",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 292741,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1952,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340.4",
      "ID": 4483
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia",
      "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5558984+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227217",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227217,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1952,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340.4",
      "ID": 4483
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5358912+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5054E95P118VM313256",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313256,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1952,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340.4",
      "ID": 4483
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5054,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.3848492+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4947E152P361VM257801",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257801,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1952,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340.4",
      "ID": 4483
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4947,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Finnie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0781961+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271140",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271140,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1952,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340.4",
      "ID": 4483
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3901,
      "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe",
      "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.844205+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2394E15P47VM277998",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277998,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1952,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340.4",
      "ID": 4483
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2394,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo",
      "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9825801+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2110E220P414VM287331",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 287331,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1952,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340.4",
      "ID": 4483
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth",
      "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8595894+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250618",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250618,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1952,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340.4",
      "ID": 4483
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2675,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob",
      "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1973186+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221051",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221051,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1952,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340.4",
      "ID": 4483
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1741,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel",
      "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6729607+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220152",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220152,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1952,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340.4",
      "ID": 4483
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1756,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine",
      "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3365823+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1860E104P150VM252456",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252456,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1952,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340.4",
      "ID": 4483
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1860,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda",
      "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7299386+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2033E20P141VM253767",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253767,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1952,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340.4",
      "ID": 4483
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2033,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain",
      "DisplayName": "Iain Gray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0200575+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324713",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324713,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1952,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340.4",
      "ID": 4483
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5042,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2347085+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259619",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 259619,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1952,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340.4",
      "ID": 4483
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick",
      "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6172604+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239424",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239424,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1952,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340.4",
      "ID": 4483
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2029,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh",
      "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7362141+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273682",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 273682,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1952,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340.4",
      "ID": 4483
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3758,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6308691+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304051",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 304051,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1952,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340.4",
      "ID": 4483
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4086,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Hume",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8472738+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221644",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221644,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1952,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340.4",
      "ID": 4483
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1773,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.941627+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1882E227P459VM241844",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241844,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1952,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340.4",
      "ID": 4483
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1882,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam",
      "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7824695+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223449",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223449,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1952,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340.4",
      "ID": 4483
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1893,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4584692+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307850",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307850,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1952,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340.4",
      "ID": 4483
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4934,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.853615+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272353",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 272353,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1952,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340.4",
      "ID": 4483
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4956,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Keir",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3316764+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2059E26P131VM245024",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 245024,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1952,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340.4",
      "ID": 4483
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Kelly",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5887299+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315190",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315190,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1952,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340.4",
      "ID": 4483
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3129,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6781986+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247844",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247844,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1952,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340.4",
      "ID": 4483
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann",
      "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.430844+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4016E11P36VM275100",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 275100,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1952,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340.4",
      "ID": 4483
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4016,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1414762+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255540",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255540,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1952,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340.4",
      "ID": 4483
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2180,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5357154+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4938E158P374VM276989",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276989,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1952,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340.4",
      "ID": 4483
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4938,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6963035+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2112E250P486VM253424",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253424,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1952,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340.4",
      "ID": 4483
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2112,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny",
      "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.9958307+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4939E258P394VM276736",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276736,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1952,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340.4",
      "ID": 4483
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4939,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus",
      "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.678921+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325418",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 325418,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1952,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340.4",
      "ID": 4483
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5074,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon",
      "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.4978442+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1828E3P10VM233259",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 233259,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1952,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340.4",
      "ID": 4483
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1828,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo",
      "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1162969+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311695",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311695,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1952,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340.4",
      "ID": 4483
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4948,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike",
      "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8902796+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2117E90P107VM229687",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229687,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1952,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340.4",
      "ID": 4483
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2117,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis",
      "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0923686+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267477",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 267477,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1952,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340.4",
      "ID": 4483
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken",
      "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0215186+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313466",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313466,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1952,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340.4",
      "ID": 4483
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4966,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek",
      "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.3965816+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3101E102P129VM294961",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 294961,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1952,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340.4",
      "ID": 4483
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3101,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala",
      "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1861906+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319145",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319145,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1952,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340.4",
      "ID": 4483
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5034,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny",
      "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6943768+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306296",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306296,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1952,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340.4",
      "ID": 4483
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2159,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Martin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5459581+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5110E252P395VM310743",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 310743,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1952,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340.4",
      "ID": 4483
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Mason",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5841375+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268127",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 268127,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1952,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340.4",
      "ID": 4483
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2133,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0573492+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2876E141P433VM286448",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286448,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1952,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340.4",
      "ID": 4483
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2876,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5796425+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4951E147P368VM258518",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258518,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1952,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340.4",
      "ID": 4483
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4951,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan",
      "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3106961+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3896E175P307VM263784",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 263784,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1952,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340.4",
      "ID": 4483
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3896,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam",
      "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.904583+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308745",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 308745,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1952,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340.4",
      "ID": 4483
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0691661+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4964E143P375VM279766",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279766,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1952,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340.4",
      "ID": 4483
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4964,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.521772+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279555",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279555,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1952,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340.4",
      "ID": 4483
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3824,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5127367+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2066E22P91VM260496",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 260496,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1952,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340.4",
      "ID": 4483
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2066,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.079387+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299551",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 299551,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1952,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340.4",
      "ID": 4483
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7023056+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306777",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306777,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1952,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340.4",
      "ID": 4483
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina",
      "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5669765+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300558",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 300558,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1952,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340.4",
      "ID": 4483
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2487,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0037754+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223954",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223954,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1952,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340.4",
      "ID": 4483
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4857362+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237893",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237893,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1952,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340.4",
      "ID": 4483
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1961,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David",
      "DisplayName": "David McLetchie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2306079+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305572",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 305572,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1952,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340.4",
      "ID": 4483
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2134,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3301493+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320125",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 320125,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1952,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340.4",
      "ID": 4483
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5041,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan",
      "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9627601+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315892",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315892,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1952,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340.4",
      "ID": 4483
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3763,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart",
      "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9317238+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1986E23P197VM236747",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 236747,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1952,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340.4",
      "ID": 4483
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1986,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan",
      "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9383203+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5047E100P130VM289758",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289758,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1952,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340.4",
      "ID": 4483
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5047,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne",
      "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4578529+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234480",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234480,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1952,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340.4",
      "ID": 4483
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1845,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette",
      "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3860738+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313151",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313151,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1952,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340.4",
      "ID": 4483
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3061,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1658605+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1768E19P265VM289378",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289378,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1952,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340.4",
      "ID": 4483
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1768,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4346801+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225338",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225338,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1952,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340.4",
      "ID": 4483
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1894,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Neil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9702656+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3815E98P134VM270980",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270980,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1952,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340.4",
      "ID": 4483
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3815,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Park, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Park",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8373763+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265767",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265767,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1952,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340.4",
      "ID": 4483
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2010,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil",
      "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4535963+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283222",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283222,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1952,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340.4",
      "ID": 4483
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5057,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.6911244+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2853E33P128VM252028",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252028,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1952,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340.4",
      "ID": 4483
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Pentland",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.499468+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317347",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317347,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1952,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340.4",
      "ID": 4483
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5009,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4181974+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254233",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254233,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1952,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340.4",
      "ID": 4483
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3745,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis",
      "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.246686+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1870E225P478VM296280",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 296280,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1952,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340.4",
      "ID": 4483
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1870,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona",
      "DisplayName": "Shona Robison",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8419378+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2135E254P450VM235471",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235471,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1952,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340.4",
      "ID": 4483
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2135,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Russell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6792837+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1895E232P431VM257688",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257688,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1952,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340.4",
      "ID": 4483
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1895,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0672808+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228578",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 228578,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1952,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340.4",
      "ID": 4483
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1839,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.8051374+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2345E10P55VM291564",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291564,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1952,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340.4",
      "ID": 4483
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2345,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1327662+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311160",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311160,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1952,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340.4",
      "ID": 4483
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2223,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish",
      "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.6082994+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246801",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 246801,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1952,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340.4",
      "ID": 4483
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2182,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1539837+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298052",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298052,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1952,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340.4",
      "ID": 4483
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5079,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew",
      "DisplayName": "Drew Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.136204+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234081",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234081,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1952,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340.4",
      "ID": 4483
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1769,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1658239+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274682",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274682,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1952,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340.4",
      "ID": 4483
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4014,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz",
      "DisplayName": "Liz Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1171685+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269643",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269643,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1952,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340.4",
      "ID": 4483
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2215,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5567665+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317500",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317500,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1952,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340.4",
      "ID": 4483
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3806,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4250804+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326412",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 326412,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1952,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340.4",
      "ID": 4483
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5106,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin",
      "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7574491+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241284",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241284,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1952,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340.4",
      "ID": 4483
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1848,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola",
      "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7513023+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2098E237P531VM290383",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 290383,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1952,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340.4",
      "ID": 4483
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2098,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Swinney",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7446036+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248037",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248037,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1952,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340.4",
      "ID": 4483
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2674,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave",
      "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4390474+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5075E234P371VM287489",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 287489,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1952,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340.4",
      "ID": 4483
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5075,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Torrance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8663692+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1793E151P362VM222582",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 222582,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1952,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340.4",
      "ID": 4483
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1793,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean",
      "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.195136+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5078E245P7VM306949",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306949,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1952,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340.4",
      "ID": 4483
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5078,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Walker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5808236+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1841E231P426VM239840",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239840,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1952,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340.4",
      "ID": 4483
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1841,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen",
      "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7611603+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283750",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283750,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1952,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340.4",
      "ID": 4483
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4952,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7218739+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1865E263P500VM231784",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231784,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1952,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340.4",
      "ID": 4483
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1865,
      "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra",
      "DisplayName": "Sandra White",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.615388+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237367",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237367,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1952,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340.4",
      "ID": 4483
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2610,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Wilson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2011445+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4941E150P382VM308987",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 308987,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1952,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340.4",
      "ID": 4483
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4941,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza",
      "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.086651+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252751",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252751,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1953,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340",
      "ID": 4458
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1926,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian",
      "DisplayName": "Brian Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7517475+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2615E213P388VM259148",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 259148,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1953,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340",
      "ID": 4458
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2615,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George",
      "DisplayName": "George Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3437811+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319588",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319588,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1953,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340",
      "ID": 4458
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4940,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare",
      "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.932742+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249480",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 249480,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1953,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340",
      "ID": 4458
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2641,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair",
      "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.928699+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1783E21P273VM228338",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 228338,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1953,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340",
      "ID": 4458
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1783,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie",
      "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.7940152+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2633E97P136VM280880",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280880,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1953,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340",
      "ID": 4458
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2633,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire",
      "DisplayName": "Claire Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7863097+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262780",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262780,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1953,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340",
      "ID": 4458
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2603,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6165345+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1759E91P115VM229871",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229871,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1953,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340",
      "ID": 4458
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia",
      "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.1010077+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3751E243P383VM269723",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269723,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1953,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340",
      "ID": 4458
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3751,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5602158+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322565",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 322565,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1953,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340",
      "ID": 4458
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5109,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco",
      "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6941762+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5060E86P124VM295317",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295317,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1953,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340",
      "ID": 4458
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5060,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5067947+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1866E93P239VM243014",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 243014,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1953,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340",
      "ID": 4458
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1866,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah",
      "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0452276+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235135",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235135,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1953,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340",
      "ID": 4458
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1943,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic",
      "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4208892+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302436",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 302436,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1953,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340",
      "ID": 4458
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2595,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin",
      "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5245053+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244223",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244223,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1953,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340",
      "ID": 4458
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2103,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith",
      "DisplayName": "Keith Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5452791+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327087",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 327087,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1953,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340",
      "ID": 4458
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7982777+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277119",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277119,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1953,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340",
      "ID": 4458
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.7019219+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264055",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264055,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1953,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340",
      "ID": 4458
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2673,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick",
      "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9222589+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248670",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248670,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1953,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340",
      "ID": 4458
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2678,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson",
      "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6647926+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2123E27P233VM294898",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 294898,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1953,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340",
      "ID": 4458
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2123,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm",
      "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1834725+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285284",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285284,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1953,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340",
      "ID": 4458
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3907,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3163634+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230761",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230761,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1953,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340",
      "ID": 4458
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1735,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela",
      "DisplayName": "Angela Constance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3443918+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243704",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 243704,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1953,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340",
      "ID": 4458
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1932,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce",
      "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3162638+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254810",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254810,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1953,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340",
      "ID": 4458
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1863,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna",
      "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2847076+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323694",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 323694,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1953,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340",
      "ID": 4458
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4976,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth",
      "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9678574+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5107E223P379VM290902",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 290902,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1953,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340",
      "ID": 4458
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5107,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7770185+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3743E222P391VM265456",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265456,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1953,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340",
      "ID": 4458
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3743,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel",
      "DisplayName": "Nigel Don",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4399582+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262526",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262526,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1953,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340",
      "ID": 4458
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3771,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob",
      "DisplayName": "Bob Doris",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6057077+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281859",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 281859,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1953,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340",
      "ID": 4458
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2826,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Dornan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1606678+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298268",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298268,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1953,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340",
      "ID": 4458
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3812,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia",
      "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3384377+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231180",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231180,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1953,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340",
      "ID": 4458
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1778,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen",
      "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3692763+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4955E240P389VM284964",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 284964,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1953,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340",
      "ID": 4458
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4955,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0552854+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219494",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 219494,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1953,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340",
      "ID": 4458
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1742,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle",
      "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3016949+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238471",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 238471,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1953,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340",
      "ID": 4458
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1994,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus",
      "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4555144+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225133",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225133,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1953,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340",
      "ID": 4458
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1814,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda",
      "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.745879+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321895",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 321895,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1953,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340",
      "ID": 4458
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Fee",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4559524+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292740",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 292740,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1953,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340",
      "ID": 4458
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia",
      "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5558553+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227219",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227219,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1953,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340",
      "ID": 4458
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5359762+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5054E95P118VM313257",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313257,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1953,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340",
      "ID": 4458
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5054,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.3874825+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4947E152P361VM257802",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257802,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1953,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340",
      "ID": 4458
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4947,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Finnie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0782377+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271097",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271097,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1953,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340",
      "ID": 4458
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3901,
      "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe",
      "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8423636+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2394E15P47VM277997",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277997,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1953,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340",
      "ID": 4458
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2394,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo",
      "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9825389+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2110E220P414VM287332",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 287332,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1953,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340",
      "ID": 4458
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth",
      "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8596306+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250619",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250619,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1953,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340",
      "ID": 4458
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2675,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob",
      "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1973591+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221083",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221083,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1953,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340",
      "ID": 4458
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1741,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel",
      "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6743412+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220150",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220150,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1953,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340",
      "ID": 4458
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1756,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine",
      "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3364997+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1860E104P150VM252457",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252457,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1953,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340",
      "ID": 4458
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1860,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda",
      "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7299809+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2033E20P141VM253766",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253766,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1953,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340",
      "ID": 4458
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2033,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain",
      "DisplayName": "Iain Gray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0200167+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324711",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324711,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1953,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340",
      "ID": 4458
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5042,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2346283+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259617",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 259617,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1953,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340",
      "ID": 4458
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick",
      "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6171775+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239426",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239426,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1953,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340",
      "ID": 4458
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2029,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh",
      "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7362979+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273681",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 273681,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1953,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340",
      "ID": 4458
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3758,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6308273+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304050",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 304050,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1953,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340",
      "ID": 4458
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4086,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Hume",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8472317+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221611",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221611,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1953,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340",
      "ID": 4458
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1773,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9402097+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1882E227P459VM241843",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241843,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1953,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340",
      "ID": 4458
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1882,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam",
      "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7824281+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223448",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223448,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1953,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340",
      "ID": 4458
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1893,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.458427+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307851",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307851,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1953,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340",
      "ID": 4458
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4934,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8536571+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272354",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 272354,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1953,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340",
      "ID": 4458
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4956,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Keir",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3317182+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2059E26P131VM245025",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 245025,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1953,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340",
      "ID": 4458
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Kelly",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5887894+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315191",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315191,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1953,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340",
      "ID": 4458
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3129,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6782395+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247535",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247535,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1953,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340",
      "ID": 4458
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann",
      "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4079911+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4016E11P36VM275143",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 275143,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1953,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340",
      "ID": 4458
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4016,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1434505+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255500",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255500,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1953,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340",
      "ID": 4458
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2180,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5339967+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4938E158P374VM276946",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276946,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1953,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340",
      "ID": 4458
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4938,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6879667+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2112E250P486VM253426",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253426,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1953,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340",
      "ID": 4458
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2112,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny",
      "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.9959144+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4939E258P394VM276716",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276716,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1953,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340",
      "ID": 4458
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4939,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus",
      "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6780694+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325420",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 325420,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1953,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340",
      "ID": 4458
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5074,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon",
      "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.4979282+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1828E3P10VM233260",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 233260,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1953,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340",
      "ID": 4458
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1828,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo",
      "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1163376+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311696",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311696,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1953,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340",
      "ID": 4458
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4948,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike",
      "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8903415+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2117E90P107VM229685",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229685,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1953,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340",
      "ID": 4458
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2117,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis",
      "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0922875+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267478",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 267478,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1953,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340",
      "ID": 4458
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken",
      "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.02156+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313465",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313465,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1953,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340",
      "ID": 4458
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4966,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek",
      "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.3965404+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3101E102P129VM294960",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 294960,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1953,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340",
      "ID": 4458
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3101,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala",
      "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1861496+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319144",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319144,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1953,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340",
      "ID": 4458
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5034,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny",
      "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6943358+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306295",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306295,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1953,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340",
      "ID": 4458
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2159,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Martin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5459173+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5110E252P395VM310742",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 310742,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1953,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340",
      "ID": 4458
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Mason",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5840962+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268126",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 268126,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1953,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340",
      "ID": 4458
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2133,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0573069+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2876E141P433VM286449",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286449,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1953,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340",
      "ID": 4458
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2876,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5796836+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4951E147P368VM258517",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258517,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1953,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340",
      "ID": 4458
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4951,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan",
      "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3106548+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3896E175P307VM263765",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 263765,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1953,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340",
      "ID": 4458
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3896,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam",
      "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9037582+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308746",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 308746,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1953,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340",
      "ID": 4458
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0692083+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4964E143P375VM279785",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279785,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1953,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340",
      "ID": 4458
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4964,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.522714+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279554",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279554,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1953,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340",
      "ID": 4458
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3824,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5126966+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2066E22P91VM260495",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 260495,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1953,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340",
      "ID": 4458
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2066,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.0793453+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299396",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 299396,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1953,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340",
      "ID": 4458
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.6956303+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306778",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306778,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1953,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340",
      "ID": 4458
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina",
      "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.567019+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300557",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 300557,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1953,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340",
      "ID": 4458
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2487,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0037345+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223987",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223987,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1953,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340",
      "ID": 4458
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4871574+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237895",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237895,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1953,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340",
      "ID": 4458
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1961,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David",
      "DisplayName": "David McLetchie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2307073+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305573",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 305573,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1953,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340",
      "ID": 4458
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2134,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3301914+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320126",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 320126,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1953,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340",
      "ID": 4458
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5041,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan",
      "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9628012+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315891",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315891,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1953,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340",
      "ID": 4458
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3763,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart",
      "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9316645+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1986E23P197VM236748",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 236748,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1953,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340",
      "ID": 4458
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1986,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan",
      "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9383611+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5047E100P130VM289757",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289757,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1953,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340",
      "ID": 4458
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5047,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne",
      "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4578131+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234479",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234479,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1953,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340",
      "ID": 4458
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1845,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette",
      "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3860318+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313150",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313150,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1953,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340",
      "ID": 4458
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3061,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1658197+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1768E19P265VM289379",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289379,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1953,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340",
      "ID": 4458
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1768,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4347225+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225339",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225339,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1953,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340",
      "ID": 4458
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1894,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Neil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9703065+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3815E98P134VM270989",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270989,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1953,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340",
      "ID": 4458
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3815,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Park, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Park",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8377642+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265766",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265766,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1953,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340",
      "ID": 4458
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2010,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil",
      "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4535548+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283202",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283202,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1953,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340",
      "ID": 4458
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5057,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.6902102+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2853E33P128VM252030",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252030,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1953,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340",
      "ID": 4458
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Pentland",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4995504+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317348",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317348,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1953,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340",
      "ID": 4458
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5009,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4182382+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254232",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254232,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1953,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340",
      "ID": 4458
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3745,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis",
      "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2466446+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1870E225P478VM296281",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 296281,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1953,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340",
      "ID": 4458
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1870,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona",
      "DisplayName": "Shona Robison",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8419917+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2135E254P450VM235473",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235473,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1953,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340",
      "ID": 4458
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2135,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Russell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6793663+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1895E232P431VM257689",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257689,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1953,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340",
      "ID": 4458
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1895,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0673212+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228580",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 228580,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1953,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340",
      "ID": 4458
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1839,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.8052201+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2345E10P55VM291563",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291563,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1953,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340",
      "ID": 4458
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2345,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1327248+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311161",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311161,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1953,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340",
      "ID": 4458
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2223,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish",
      "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.6083403+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246802",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 246802,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1953,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340",
      "ID": 4458
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2182,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.154024+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298051",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298051,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1953,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340",
      "ID": 4458
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5079,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew",
      "DisplayName": "Drew Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1361453+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234080",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234080,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1953,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340",
      "ID": 4458
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1769,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1657611+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274854",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274854,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1953,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340",
      "ID": 4458
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4014,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz",
      "DisplayName": "Liz Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1246251+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269644",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269644,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1953,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340",
      "ID": 4458
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2215,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5568082+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317502",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317502,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1953,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340",
      "ID": 4458
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3806,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.425183+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326410",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 326410,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1953,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340",
      "ID": 4458
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5106,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin",
      "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7573524+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241285",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241285,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1953,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340",
      "ID": 4458
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1848,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola",
      "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7513434+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2098E237P531VM290384",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 290384,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1953,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340",
      "ID": 4458
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2098,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Swinney",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7446508+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248039",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248039,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1953,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340",
      "ID": 4458
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2674,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave",
      "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4391295+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5075E234P371VM287509",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 287509,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1953,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340",
      "ID": 4458
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5075,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Torrance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8740544+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1793E151P362VM222583",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 222583,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1953,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340",
      "ID": 4458
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1793,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean",
      "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1951778+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5078E245P7VM306948",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306948,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1953,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340",
      "ID": 4458
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5078,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Walker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.580782+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1841E231P426VM239839",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239839,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1953,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340",
      "ID": 4458
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1841,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen",
      "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7611195+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283793",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283793,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1953,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340",
      "ID": 4458
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4952,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.723712+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1865E263P500VM231783",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231783,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1953,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340",
      "ID": 4458
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1865,
      "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra",
      "DisplayName": "Sandra White",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6153195+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237365",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237365,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1953,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340",
      "ID": 4458
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2610,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Wilson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2010417+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4941E150P382VM308986",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 308986,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1953,
      "AgendaID": 2564,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-04340",
      "ID": 4458
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4941,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza",
      "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-03T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0866107+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1926E229P470VM253114",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253114,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1951,
      "AgendaID": 2298,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 73,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Employment Summit",
      "Reference": "S4M-04314.1",
      "ID": 4452
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1926,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian",
      "DisplayName": "Brian Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.767385+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2615E213P388VM259555",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 259555,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1951,
      "AgendaID": 2298,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 73,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Employment Summit",
      "Reference": "S4M-04314.1",
      "ID": 4452
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2615,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George",
      "DisplayName": "George Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6141474+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4940E159P373VM318058",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 318058,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1951,
      "AgendaID": 2298,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 73,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Employment Summit",
      "Reference": "S4M-04314.1",
      "ID": 4452
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4940,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare",
      "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4551195+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2641E256P403VM250100",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250100,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1951,
      "AgendaID": 2298,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 73,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Employment Summit",
      "Reference": "S4M-04314.1",
      "ID": 4452
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2641,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair",
      "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.963359+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1783E21P273VM229442",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229442,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1951,
      "AgendaID": 2298,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 73,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Employment Summit",
      "Reference": "S4M-04314.1",
      "ID": 4452
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1783,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie",
      "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0819719+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2633E97P136VM281595",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 281595,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1951,
      "AgendaID": 2298,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 73,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Employment Summit",
      "Reference": "S4M-04314.1",
      "ID": 4452
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2633,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire",
      "DisplayName": "Claire Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.149533+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2603E89P148VM263119",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 263119,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1951,
      "AgendaID": 2298,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 73,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Employment Summit",
      "Reference": "S4M-04314.1",
      "ID": 4452
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2603,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6375785+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1759E91P115VM227548",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227548,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1951,
      "AgendaID": 2298,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 73,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Employment Summit",
      "Reference": "S4M-04314.1",
      "ID": 4452
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia",
      "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5548912+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270626",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270626,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1951,
      "AgendaID": 2298,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 73,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Employment Summit",
      "Reference": "S4M-04314.1",
      "ID": 4452
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3751,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8158874+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322990",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 322990,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1951,
      "AgendaID": 2298,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 73,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Employment Summit",
      "Reference": "S4M-04314.1",
      "ID": 4452
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5109,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco",
      "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.7124593+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5060E86P124VM295962",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295962,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1951,
      "AgendaID": 2298,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 73,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Employment Summit",
      "Reference": "S4M-04314.1",
      "ID": 4452
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5060,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5432502+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242619",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242619,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1951,
      "AgendaID": 2298,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 73,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Employment Summit",
      "Reference": "S4M-04314.1",
      "ID": 4452
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1866,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah",
      "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0281157+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1943E145P367VM236598",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 236598,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1951,
      "AgendaID": 2298,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 73,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Employment Summit",
      "Reference": "S4M-04314.1",
      "ID": 4452
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1943,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic",
      "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.931905+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2595E12P30VM301681",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 301681,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1951,
      "AgendaID": 2298,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 73,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Employment Summit",
      "Reference": "S4M-04314.1",
      "ID": 4452
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2595,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin",
      "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.2729144+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2103E244P421VM261999",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261999,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1951,
      "AgendaID": 2298,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 73,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Employment Summit",
      "Reference": "S4M-04314.1",
      "ID": 4452
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2103,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith",
      "DisplayName": "Keith Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3872564+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5108E221P387VM326651",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 326651,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1951,
      "AgendaID": 2298,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 73,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Employment Summit",
      "Reference": "S4M-04314.1",
      "ID": 4452
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7739764+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277617",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277617,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1951,
      "AgendaID": 2298,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 73,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Employment Summit",
      "Reference": "S4M-04314.1",
      "ID": 4452
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9610055+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264990",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264990,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1951,
      "AgendaID": 2298,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 73,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Employment Summit",
      "Reference": "S4M-04314.1",
      "ID": 4452
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2673,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick",
      "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1633922+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2678E11P28VM249164",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 249164,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1951,
      "AgendaID": 2298,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 73,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Employment Summit",
      "Reference": "S4M-04314.1",
      "ID": 4452
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2678,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson",
      "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6866388+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2123E27P233VM291236",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291236,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1951,
      "AgendaID": 2298,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 73,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Employment Summit",
      "Reference": "S4M-04314.1",
      "ID": 4452
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2123,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm",
      "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1101527+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285470",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285470,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1951,
      "AgendaID": 2298,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 73,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Employment Summit",
      "Reference": "S4M-04314.1",
      "ID": 4452
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3907,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3306325+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1735E248P405VM231408",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231408,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1951,
      "AgendaID": 2298,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 73,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Employment Summit",
      "Reference": "S4M-04314.1",
      "ID": 4452
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1735,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela",
      "DisplayName": "Angela Constance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.5990018+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243257",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 243257,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1951,
      "AgendaID": 2298,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 73,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Employment Summit",
      "Reference": "S4M-04314.1",
      "ID": 4452
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1932,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce",
      "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.2895838+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1863E238P523VM253968",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253968,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1951,
      "AgendaID": 2298,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 73,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Employment Summit",
      "Reference": "S4M-04314.1",
      "ID": 4452
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1863,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna",
      "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0288363+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4976E20P31VM321374",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 321374,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1951,
      "AgendaID": 2298,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 73,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Employment Summit",
      "Reference": "S4M-04314.1",
      "ID": 4452
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4976,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth",
      "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4330846+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5107E223P379VM300752",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 300752,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1951,
      "AgendaID": 2298,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 73,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Employment Summit",
      "Reference": "S4M-04314.1",
      "ID": 4452
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5107,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.017364+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3743E222P391VM273169",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 273169,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1951,
      "AgendaID": 2298,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 73,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Employment Summit",
      "Reference": "S4M-04314.1",
      "ID": 4452
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3743,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel",
      "DisplayName": "Nigel Don",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3725604+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3771E149P417VM263176",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 263176,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1951,
      "AgendaID": 2298,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 73,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Employment Summit",
      "Reference": "S4M-04314.1",
      "ID": 4452
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3771,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob",
      "DisplayName": "Bob Doris",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6402178+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2826E262P384VM282287",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 282287,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1951,
      "AgendaID": 2298,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 73,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Employment Summit",
      "Reference": "S4M-04314.1",
      "ID": 4452
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2826,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Dornan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.4062868+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298983",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298983,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1951,
      "AgendaID": 2298,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 73,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Employment Summit",
      "Reference": "S4M-04314.1",
      "ID": 4452
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3812,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia",
      "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3806895+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1778E28P260VM230613",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230613,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1951,
      "AgendaID": 2298,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 73,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Employment Summit",
      "Reference": "S4M-04314.1",
      "ID": 4452
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1778,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen",
      "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3379278+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4955E240P389VM287210",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 287210,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1951,
      "AgendaID": 2298,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 73,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Employment Summit",
      "Reference": "S4M-04314.1",
      "ID": 4452
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4955,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8543822+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219855",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 219855,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1951,
      "AgendaID": 2298,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 73,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Employment Summit",
      "Reference": "S4M-04314.1",
      "ID": 4452
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1742,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle",
      "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3175733+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1994E257P537VM239028",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239028,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1951,
      "AgendaID": 2298,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 73,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Employment Summit",
      "Reference": "S4M-04314.1",
      "ID": 4452
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1994,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus",
      "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4796629+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1814E269P519VM226217",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 226217,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1951,
      "AgendaID": 2298,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 73,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Employment Summit",
      "Reference": "S4M-04314.1",
      "ID": 4452
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1814,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda",
      "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2154228+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5059E85P123VM322305",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 322305,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1951,
      "AgendaID": 2298,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 73,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Employment Summit",
      "Reference": "S4M-04314.1",
      "ID": 4452
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Fee",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.677049+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1853E35P216VM291817",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291817,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1951,
      "AgendaID": 2298,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 73,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Employment Summit",
      "Reference": "S4M-04314.1",
      "ID": 4452
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia",
      "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1437564+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1892E12P64VM228330",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 228330,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1951,
      "AgendaID": 2298,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 73,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Employment Summit",
      "Reference": "S4M-04314.1",
      "ID": 4452
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.7882078+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5054E95P118VM304386",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 304386,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1951,
      "AgendaID": 2298,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 73,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Employment Summit",
      "Reference": "S4M-04314.1",
      "ID": 4452
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5054,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.0360379+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4947E152P361VM258026",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258026,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1951,
      "AgendaID": 2298,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 73,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Employment Summit",
      "Reference": "S4M-04314.1",
      "ID": 4452
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4947,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Finnie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0881272+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271620",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271620,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1951,
      "AgendaID": 2298,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 73,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Employment Summit",
      "Reference": "S4M-04314.1",
      "ID": 4452
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3901,
      "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe",
      "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0840274+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2394E15P47VM279352",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279352,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1951,
      "AgendaID": 2298,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 73,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Employment Summit",
      "Reference": "S4M-04314.1",
      "ID": 4452
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2394,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo",
      "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.4984805+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2110E220P414VM266495",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 266495,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1951,
      "AgendaID": 2298,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 73,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Employment Summit",
      "Reference": "S4M-04314.1",
      "ID": 4452
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth",
      "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.7436103+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250831",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250831,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1951,
      "AgendaID": 2298,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 73,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Employment Summit",
      "Reference": "S4M-04314.1",
      "ID": 4452
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2675,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob",
      "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.2153569+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221296",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221296,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1951,
      "AgendaID": 2298,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 73,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Employment Summit",
      "Reference": "S4M-04314.1",
      "ID": 4452
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1741,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel",
      "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9258743+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220799",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220799,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1951,
      "AgendaID": 2298,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 73,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Employment Summit",
      "Reference": "S4M-04314.1",
      "ID": 4452
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1756,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine",
      "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6575046+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1860E104P150VM239805",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239805,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1951,
      "AgendaID": 2298,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 73,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Employment Summit",
      "Reference": "S4M-04314.1",
      "ID": 4452
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1860,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda",
      "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7596685+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2033E20P141VM266673",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 266673,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1951,
      "AgendaID": 2298,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 73,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Employment Summit",
      "Reference": "S4M-04314.1",
      "ID": 4452
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2033,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain",
      "DisplayName": "Iain Gray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.7514004+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324327",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324327,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1951,
      "AgendaID": 2298,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 73,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Employment Summit",
      "Reference": "S4M-04314.1",
      "ID": 4452
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5042,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2119818+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2892E76P97VM260267",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 260267,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1951,
      "AgendaID": 2298,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 73,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Employment Summit",
      "Reference": "S4M-04314.1",
      "ID": 4452
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick",
      "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.0691629+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2029E24P170VM246492",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 246492,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1951,
      "AgendaID": 2298,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 73,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Employment Summit",
      "Reference": "S4M-04314.1",
      "ID": 4452
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2029,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh",
      "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1310516+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3758E268P409VM276185",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276185,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1951,
      "AgendaID": 2298,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 73,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Employment Summit",
      "Reference": "S4M-04314.1",
      "ID": 4452
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3758,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.4141564+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4086E128P311VM303187",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 303187,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1951,
      "AgendaID": 2298,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 73,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Employment Summit",
      "Reference": "S4M-04314.1",
      "ID": 4452
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4086,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Hume",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5628876+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1773E242P494VM222232",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 222232,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1951,
      "AgendaID": 2298,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 73,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Employment Summit",
      "Reference": "S4M-04314.1",
      "ID": 4452
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1773,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1740246+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1882E227P459VM242446",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242446,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1951,
      "AgendaID": 2298,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 73,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Employment Summit",
      "Reference": "S4M-04314.1",
      "ID": 4452
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1882,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam",
      "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0136085+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1893E16P69VM224472",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 224472,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1951,
      "AgendaID": 2298,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 73,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Employment Summit",
      "Reference": "S4M-04314.1",
      "ID": 4452
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1893,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7063009+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4934E77P103VM308567",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 308567,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1951,
      "AgendaID": 2298,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 73,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Employment Summit",
      "Reference": "S4M-04314.1",
      "ID": 4452
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4934,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.061462+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272569",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 272569,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1951,
      "AgendaID": 2298,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 73,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Employment Summit",
      "Reference": "S4M-04314.1",
      "ID": 4452
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4956,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Keir",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3410371+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244468",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244468,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1951,
      "AgendaID": 2298,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 73,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Employment Summit",
      "Reference": "S4M-04314.1",
      "ID": 4452
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Kelly",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5560532+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3129E261P419VM314644",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 314644,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1951,
      "AgendaID": 2298,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 73,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Employment Summit",
      "Reference": "S4M-04314.1",
      "ID": 4452
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3129,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6490873+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2080E36P220VM251954",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251954,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1951,
      "AgendaID": 2298,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 73,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Employment Summit",
      "Reference": "S4M-04314.1",
      "ID": 4452
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann",
      "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4962672+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4016E11P36VM275587",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 275587,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1951,
      "AgendaID": 2298,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 73,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Employment Summit",
      "Reference": "S4M-04314.1",
      "ID": 4452
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4016,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.3819503+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2180E246P463VM257011",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257011,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1951,
      "AgendaID": 2298,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 73,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Employment Summit",
      "Reference": "S4M-04314.1",
      "ID": 4452
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2180,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.8194975+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4938E158P374VM283059",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283059,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1951,
      "AgendaID": 2298,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 73,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Employment Summit",
      "Reference": "S4M-04314.1",
      "ID": 4452
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4938,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.4505443+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2112E250P486VM254173",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254173,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1951,
      "AgendaID": 2298,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 73,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Employment Summit",
      "Reference": "S4M-04314.1",
      "ID": 4452
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2112,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny",
      "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.037771+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4939E258P394VM278312",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 278312,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1951,
      "AgendaID": 2298,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 73,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Employment Summit",
      "Reference": "S4M-04314.1",
      "ID": 4452
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4939,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus",
      "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2067916+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5074E251P385VM324958",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324958,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1951,
      "AgendaID": 2298,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 73,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Employment Summit",
      "Reference": "S4M-04314.1",
      "ID": 4452
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5074,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon",
      "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2450989+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1828E3P10VM231983",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231983,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1951,
      "AgendaID": 2298,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 73,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Employment Summit",
      "Reference": "S4M-04314.1",
      "ID": 4452
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1828,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo",
      "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6241845+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4948E153P363VM312385",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 312385,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1951,
      "AgendaID": 2298,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 73,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Employment Summit",
      "Reference": "S4M-04314.1",
      "ID": 4452
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4948,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike",
      "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1255608+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2117E90P107VM232483",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232483,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1951,
      "AgendaID": 2298,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 73,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Employment Summit",
      "Reference": "S4M-04314.1",
      "ID": 4452
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2117,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis",
      "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8628013+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267788",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 267788,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1951,
      "AgendaID": 2298,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 73,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Employment Summit",
      "Reference": "S4M-04314.1",
      "ID": 4452
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken",
      "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0350318+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4966E214P378VM314464",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 314464,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1951,
      "AgendaID": 2298,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 73,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Employment Summit",
      "Reference": "S4M-04314.1",
      "ID": 4452
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4966,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek",
      "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6411162+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3101E102P129VM296159",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 296159,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1951,
      "AgendaID": 2298,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 73,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Employment Summit",
      "Reference": "S4M-04314.1",
      "ID": 4452
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3101,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala",
      "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5519045+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319710",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319710,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1951,
      "AgendaID": 2298,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 73,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Employment Summit",
      "Reference": "S4M-04314.1",
      "ID": 4452
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5034,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny",
      "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9380148+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2159E25P205VM305866",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 305866,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1951,
      "AgendaID": 2298,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 73,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Employment Summit",
      "Reference": "S4M-04314.1",
      "ID": 4452
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2159,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Martin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3487215+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5110E252P395VM309867",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 309867,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1951,
      "AgendaID": 2298,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 73,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Employment Summit",
      "Reference": "S4M-04314.1",
      "ID": 4452
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Mason",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3543551+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268652",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 268652,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1951,
      "AgendaID": 2298,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 73,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Employment Summit",
      "Reference": "S4M-04314.1",
      "ID": 4452
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2133,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.276828+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2876E141P433VM293774",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 293774,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1951,
      "AgendaID": 2298,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 73,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Employment Summit",
      "Reference": "S4M-04314.1",
      "ID": 4452
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2876,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8683382+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4951E147P368VM271369",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271369,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1951,
      "AgendaID": 2298,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 73,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Employment Summit",
      "Reference": "S4M-04314.1",
      "ID": 4452
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4951,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan",
      "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0728351+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3896E175P307VM268933",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 268933,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1951,
      "AgendaID": 2298,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 73,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Employment Summit",
      "Reference": "S4M-04314.1",
      "ID": 4452
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3896,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam",
      "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2963564+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5080E110P121VM307411",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307411,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1951,
      "AgendaID": 2298,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 73,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Employment Summit",
      "Reference": "S4M-04314.1",
      "ID": 4452
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8282845+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4964E143P375VM282587",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 282587,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1951,
      "AgendaID": 2298,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 73,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Employment Summit",
      "Reference": "S4M-04314.1",
      "ID": 4452
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4964,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.425392+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3824E84P113VM281263",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 281263,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1951,
      "AgendaID": 2298,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 73,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Employment Summit",
      "Reference": "S4M-04314.1",
      "ID": 4452
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3824,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1272706+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2066E22P91VM245261",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 245261,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1951,
      "AgendaID": 2298,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 73,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Employment Summit",
      "Reference": "S4M-04314.1",
      "ID": 4452
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2066,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8270779+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299978",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 299978,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1951,
      "AgendaID": 2298,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 73,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Employment Summit",
      "Reference": "S4M-04314.1",
      "ID": 4452
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7310602+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3759E260P411VM302774",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 302774,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1951,
      "AgendaID": 2298,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 73,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Employment Summit",
      "Reference": "S4M-04314.1",
      "ID": 4452
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina",
      "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5445919+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300101",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 300101,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1951,
      "AgendaID": 2298,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 73,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Employment Summit",
      "Reference": "S4M-04314.1",
      "ID": 4452
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2487,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7363583+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1775E215P453VM224508",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 224508,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1951,
      "AgendaID": 2298,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 73,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Employment Summit",
      "Reference": "S4M-04314.1",
      "ID": 4452
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7078565+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237978",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237978,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1951,
      "AgendaID": 2298,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 73,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Employment Summit",
      "Reference": "S4M-04314.1",
      "ID": 4452
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1961,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David",
      "DisplayName": "David McLetchie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2342967+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2134E34P201VM297476",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 297476,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1951,
      "AgendaID": 2298,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 73,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Employment Summit",
      "Reference": "S4M-04314.1",
      "ID": 4452
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2134,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1018568+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5041E99P122VM321017",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 321017,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1951,
      "AgendaID": 2298,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 73,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Employment Summit",
      "Reference": "S4M-04314.1",
      "ID": 4452
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5041,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan",
      "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1986543+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315437",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315437,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1951,
      "AgendaID": 2298,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 73,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Employment Summit",
      "Reference": "S4M-04314.1",
      "ID": 4452
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3763,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart",
      "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9119798+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1986E23P197VM237550",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237550,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1951,
      "AgendaID": 2298,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 73,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Employment Summit",
      "Reference": "S4M-04314.1",
      "ID": 4452
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1986,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan",
      "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2156614+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5047E100P130VM294242",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 294242,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1951,
      "AgendaID": 2298,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 73,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Employment Summit",
      "Reference": "S4M-04314.1",
      "ID": 4452
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5047,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne",
      "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1298999+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1845E17P40VM233956",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 233956,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1951,
      "AgendaID": 2298,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 73,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Employment Summit",
      "Reference": "S4M-04314.1",
      "ID": 4452
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1845,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette",
      "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.153634+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3061E19P43VM312029",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 312029,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1951,
      "AgendaID": 2298,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 73,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Employment Summit",
      "Reference": "S4M-04314.1",
      "ID": 4452
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3061,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.9106611+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1768E19P265VM286854",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286854,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1951,
      "AgendaID": 2298,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 73,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Employment Summit",
      "Reference": "S4M-04314.1",
      "ID": 4452
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1768,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.6036899+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1894E267P527VM226094",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 226094,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1951,
      "AgendaID": 2298,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 73,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Employment Summit",
      "Reference": "S4M-04314.1",
      "ID": 4452
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1894,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Neil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.0097782+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3815E98P134VM271016",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271016,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1951,
      "AgendaID": 2298,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 73,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Employment Summit",
      "Reference": "S4M-04314.1",
      "ID": 4452
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3815,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Park, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Park",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8389072+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265549",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265549,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1951,
      "AgendaID": 2298,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 73,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Employment Summit",
      "Reference": "S4M-04314.1",
      "ID": 4452
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2010,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil",
      "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4439642+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5057E92P116VM284268",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 284268,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1951,
      "AgendaID": 2298,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 73,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Employment Summit",
      "Reference": "S4M-04314.1",
      "ID": 4452
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5057,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.019037+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2853E33P128VM259021",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 259021,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1951,
      "AgendaID": 2298,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 73,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Employment Summit",
      "Reference": "S4M-04314.1",
      "ID": 4452
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Pentland",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3382698+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5009E126P306VM318236",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 318236,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1951,
      "AgendaID": 2298,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 73,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Employment Summit",
      "Reference": "S4M-04314.1",
      "ID": 4452
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5009,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6440152+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3745E233P381VM256074",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 256074,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1951,
      "AgendaID": 2298,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 73,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Employment Summit",
      "Reference": "S4M-04314.1",
      "ID": 4452
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3745,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis",
      "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5695134+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1870E225P478VM294518",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 294518,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1951,
      "AgendaID": 2298,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 73,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Employment Summit",
      "Reference": "S4M-04314.1",
      "ID": 4452
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1870,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona",
      "DisplayName": "Shona Robison",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1418834+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2135E254P450VM236452",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 236452,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1951,
      "AgendaID": 2298,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 73,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Employment Summit",
      "Reference": "S4M-04314.1",
      "ID": 4452
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2135,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Russell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9254688+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1895E232P431VM256005",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 256005,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1951,
      "AgendaID": 2298,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 73,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Employment Summit",
      "Reference": "S4M-04314.1",
      "ID": 4452
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1895,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5662766+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1839E21P87VM229409",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229409,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1951,
      "AgendaID": 2298,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 73,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Employment Summit",
      "Reference": "S4M-04314.1",
      "ID": 4452
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1839,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0805657+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2345E10P55VM288390",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 288390,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1951,
      "AgendaID": 2298,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 73,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Employment Summit",
      "Reference": "S4M-04314.1",
      "ID": 4452
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2345,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1327895+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2223E176P333VM310456",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 310456,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1951,
      "AgendaID": 2298,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 73,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Employment Summit",
      "Reference": "S4M-04314.1",
      "ID": 4452
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2223,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish",
      "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5716719+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2182E87P175VM247166",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247166,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1951,
      "AgendaID": 2298,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 73,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Employment Summit",
      "Reference": "S4M-04314.1",
      "ID": 4452
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2182,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1699243+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5079E101P119VM299447",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 299447,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1951,
      "AgendaID": 2298,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 73,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Employment Summit",
      "Reference": "S4M-04314.1",
      "ID": 4452
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5079,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew",
      "DisplayName": "Drew Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.6978201+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1769E32P285VM235815",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235815,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1951,
      "AgendaID": 2298,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 73,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Employment Summit",
      "Reference": "S4M-04314.1",
      "ID": 4452
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1769,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6941566+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4014E14P26VM275815",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 275815,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1951,
      "AgendaID": 2298,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 73,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Employment Summit",
      "Reference": "S4M-04314.1",
      "ID": 4452
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4014,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz",
      "DisplayName": "Liz Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.3921213+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2215E224P447VM274174",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274174,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1951,
      "AgendaID": 2298,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 73,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Employment Summit",
      "Reference": "S4M-04314.1",
      "ID": 4452
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2215,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6578879+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3806E103P127VM316803",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 316803,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1951,
      "AgendaID": 2298,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 73,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Employment Summit",
      "Reference": "S4M-04314.1",
      "ID": 4452
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3806,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.1641632+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326025",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 326025,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1951,
      "AgendaID": 2298,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 73,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Employment Summit",
      "Reference": "S4M-04314.1",
      "ID": 4452
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5106,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin",
      "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5320024+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241511",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241511,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1951,
      "AgendaID": 2298,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 73,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Employment Summit",
      "Reference": "S4M-04314.1",
      "ID": 4452
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1848,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola",
      "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7679722+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2098E237P531VM287982",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 287982,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1951,
      "AgendaID": 2298,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 73,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Employment Summit",
      "Reference": "S4M-04314.1",
      "ID": 4452
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2098,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Swinney",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8949447+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248387",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248387,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1951,
      "AgendaID": 2298,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 73,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Employment Summit",
      "Reference": "S4M-04314.1",
      "ID": 4452
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2674,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave",
      "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6437883+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5075E234P371VM289140",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289140,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1951,
      "AgendaID": 2298,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 73,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Employment Summit",
      "Reference": "S4M-04314.1",
      "ID": 4452
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5075,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Torrance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1791503+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1793E151P362VM222862",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 222862,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1951,
      "AgendaID": 2298,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 73,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Employment Summit",
      "Reference": "S4M-04314.1",
      "ID": 4452
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1793,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean",
      "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.2078941+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5078E245P7VM306863",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306863,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1951,
      "AgendaID": 2298,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 73,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Employment Summit",
      "Reference": "S4M-04314.1",
      "ID": 4452
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5078,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Walker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5769682+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1841E231P426VM240764",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 240764,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1951,
      "AgendaID": 2298,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 73,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Employment Summit",
      "Reference": "S4M-04314.1",
      "ID": 4452
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1841,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen",
      "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3812939+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4952E148P370VM284081",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 284081,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1951,
      "AgendaID": 2298,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 73,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Employment Summit",
      "Reference": "S4M-04314.1",
      "ID": 4452
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4952,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7421842+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1865E263P500VM251648",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251648,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1951,
      "AgendaID": 2298,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 73,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Employment Summit",
      "Reference": "S4M-04314.1",
      "ID": 4452
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1865,
      "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra",
      "DisplayName": "Sandra White",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.48274+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2610E160P413VM246295",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 246295,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1951,
      "AgendaID": 2298,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 73,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Employment Summit",
      "Reference": "S4M-04314.1",
      "ID": 4452
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2610,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Wilson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.122531+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309721",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 309721,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1951,
      "AgendaID": 2298,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 73,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Employment Summit",
      "Reference": "S4M-04314.1",
      "ID": 4452
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4941,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza",
      "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-10-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3418508+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252291",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252291,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1950,
      "AgendaID": 2432,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Green Bus Fund",
      "Reference": "S4M-04247.2",
      "ID": 4370
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1926,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian",
      "DisplayName": "Brian Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.722812+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2615E213P388VM258812",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258812,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1950,
      "AgendaID": 2432,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Green Bus Fund",
      "Reference": "S4M-04247.2",
      "ID": 4370
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2615,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George",
      "DisplayName": "George Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3289665+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319914",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319914,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1950,
      "AgendaID": 2432,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Green Bus Fund",
      "Reference": "S4M-04247.2",
      "ID": 4370
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4940,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare",
      "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9468248+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249689",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 249689,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1950,
      "AgendaID": 2432,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Green Bus Fund",
      "Reference": "S4M-04247.2",
      "ID": 4370
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2641,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair",
      "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.945577+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1783E21P273VM227398",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227398,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1950,
      "AgendaID": 2432,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Green Bus Fund",
      "Reference": "S4M-04247.2",
      "ID": 4370
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1783,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie",
      "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5484365+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2633E97P136VM280394",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280394,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1950,
      "AgendaID": 2432,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Green Bus Fund",
      "Reference": "S4M-04247.2",
      "ID": 4370
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2633,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire",
      "DisplayName": "Claire Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7588277+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262458",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262458,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1950,
      "AgendaID": 2432,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Green Bus Fund",
      "Reference": "S4M-04247.2",
      "ID": 4370
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2603,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6028014+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1759E91P115VM229244",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229244,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1950,
      "AgendaID": 2432,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Green Bus Fund",
      "Reference": "S4M-04247.2",
      "ID": 4370
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia",
      "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0682908+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270215",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270215,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1950,
      "AgendaID": 2432,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Green Bus Fund",
      "Reference": "S4M-04247.2",
      "ID": 4370
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3751,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.7942596+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322616",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 322616,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1950,
      "AgendaID": 2432,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Green Bus Fund",
      "Reference": "S4M-04247.2",
      "ID": 4370
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5109,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco",
      "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6963818+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5060E86P124VM294690",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 294690,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1950,
      "AgendaID": 2432,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Green Bus Fund",
      "Reference": "S4M-04247.2",
      "ID": 4370
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5060,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.174132+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242838",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242838,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1950,
      "AgendaID": 2432,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Green Bus Fund",
      "Reference": "S4M-04247.2",
      "ID": 4370
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1866,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah",
      "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0377806+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235587",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235587,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1950,
      "AgendaID": 2432,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Green Bus Fund",
      "Reference": "S4M-04247.2",
      "ID": 4370
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1943,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic",
      "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6842058+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302113",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 302113,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1950,
      "AgendaID": 2432,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Green Bus Fund",
      "Reference": "S4M-04247.2",
      "ID": 4370
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2595,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin",
      "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.2976114+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244542",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244542,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1950,
      "AgendaID": 2432,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Green Bus Fund",
      "Reference": "S4M-04247.2",
      "ID": 4370
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2103,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith",
      "DisplayName": "Keith Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5593762+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327375",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 327375,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1950,
      "AgendaID": 2432,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Green Bus Fund",
      "Reference": "S4M-04247.2",
      "ID": 4370
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:46.0335031+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3775E216P435VM276641",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276641,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1950,
      "AgendaID": 2432,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Green Bus Fund",
      "Reference": "S4M-04247.2",
      "ID": 4370
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6748697+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264376",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264376,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1950,
      "AgendaID": 2432,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Green Bus Fund",
      "Reference": "S4M-04247.2",
      "ID": 4370
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2673,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick",
      "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1308251+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248821",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248821,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1950,
      "AgendaID": 2432,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Green Bus Fund",
      "Reference": "S4M-04247.2",
      "ID": 4370
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2678,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson",
      "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6714918+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2123E27P233VM295845",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295845,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1950,
      "AgendaID": 2432,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Green Bus Fund",
      "Reference": "S4M-04247.2",
      "ID": 4370
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2123,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm",
      "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5383228+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285119",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285119,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1950,
      "AgendaID": 2432,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Green Bus Fund",
      "Reference": "S4M-04247.2",
      "ID": 4370
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3907,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.067255+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230135",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230135,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1950,
      "AgendaID": 2432,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Green Bus Fund",
      "Reference": "S4M-04247.2",
      "ID": 4370
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1735,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela",
      "DisplayName": "Angela Constance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.1177516+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243881",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 243881,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1950,
      "AgendaID": 2432,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Green Bus Fund",
      "Reference": "S4M-04247.2",
      "ID": 4370
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1932,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce",
      "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3239086+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1863E238P523VM255283",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255283,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1950,
      "AgendaID": 2432,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Green Bus Fund",
      "Reference": "S4M-04247.2",
      "ID": 4370
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1863,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna",
      "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5242614+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4976E20P31VM324010",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324010,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1950,
      "AgendaID": 2432,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Green Bus Fund",
      "Reference": "S4M-04247.2",
      "ID": 4370
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4976,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth",
      "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9821064+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5107E223P379VM291380",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291380,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1950,
      "AgendaID": 2432,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Green Bus Fund",
      "Reference": "S4M-04247.2",
      "ID": 4370
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5107,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.116819+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3743E222P391VM265134",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265134,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1950,
      "AgendaID": 2432,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Green Bus Fund",
      "Reference": "S4M-04247.2",
      "ID": 4370
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3743,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel",
      "DisplayName": "Nigel Don",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1699493+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3771E149P417VM261740",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261740,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1950,
      "AgendaID": 2432,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Green Bus Fund",
      "Reference": "S4M-04247.2",
      "ID": 4370
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3771,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob",
      "DisplayName": "Bob Doris",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.37079+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2826E262P384VM282037",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 282037,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1950,
      "AgendaID": 2432,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Green Bus Fund",
      "Reference": "S4M-04247.2",
      "ID": 4370
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2826,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Dornan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1684902+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3812E94P117VM297934",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 297934,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1950,
      "AgendaID": 2432,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Green Bus Fund",
      "Reference": "S4M-04247.2",
      "ID": 4370
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3812,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia",
      "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1312197+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231639",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231639,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1950,
      "AgendaID": 2432,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Green Bus Fund",
      "Reference": "S4M-04247.2",
      "ID": 4370
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1778,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen",
      "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6092409+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4955E240P389VM285977",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285977,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1950,
      "AgendaID": 2432,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Green Bus Fund",
      "Reference": "S4M-04247.2",
      "ID": 4370
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4955,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3526873+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219343",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 219343,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1950,
      "AgendaID": 2432,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Green Bus Fund",
      "Reference": "S4M-04247.2",
      "ID": 4370
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1742,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle",
      "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.2944942+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238614",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 238614,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1950,
      "AgendaID": 2432,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Green Bus Fund",
      "Reference": "S4M-04247.2",
      "ID": 4370
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1994,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus",
      "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4616824+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225492",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225492,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1950,
      "AgendaID": 2432,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Green Bus Fund",
      "Reference": "S4M-04247.2",
      "ID": 4370
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1814,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda",
      "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9770509+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321844",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 321844,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1950,
      "AgendaID": 2432,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Green Bus Fund",
      "Reference": "S4M-04247.2",
      "ID": 4370
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Fee",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.453778+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292899",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 292899,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1950,
      "AgendaID": 2432,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Green Bus Fund",
      "Reference": "S4M-04247.2",
      "ID": 4370
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia",
      "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5630136+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1892E12P64VM226910",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 226910,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1950,
      "AgendaID": 2432,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Green Bus Fund",
      "Reference": "S4M-04247.2",
      "ID": 4370
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2520017+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5054E95P118VM312629",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 312629,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1950,
      "AgendaID": 2432,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Green Bus Fund",
      "Reference": "S4M-04247.2",
      "ID": 4370
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5054,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1365468+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4947E152P361VM257132",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257132,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1950,
      "AgendaID": 2432,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Green Bus Fund",
      "Reference": "S4M-04247.2",
      "ID": 4370
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4947,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Finnie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.8246857+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271333",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271333,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1950,
      "AgendaID": 2432,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Green Bus Fund",
      "Reference": "S4M-04247.2",
      "ID": 4370
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3901,
      "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe",
      "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0709948+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278481",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 278481,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1950,
      "AgendaID": 2432,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Green Bus Fund",
      "Reference": "S4M-04247.2",
      "ID": 4370
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2394,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo",
      "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.22068+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2110E220P414VM286702",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286702,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1950,
      "AgendaID": 2432,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Green Bus Fund",
      "Reference": "S4M-04247.2",
      "ID": 4370
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth",
      "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5970884+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250410",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250410,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1950,
      "AgendaID": 2432,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Green Bus Fund",
      "Reference": "S4M-04247.2",
      "ID": 4370
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2675,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob",
      "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1883299+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1741E10P50VM220723",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220723,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1950,
      "AgendaID": 2432,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Green Bus Fund",
      "Reference": "S4M-04247.2",
      "ID": 4370
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1741,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel",
      "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.654272+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220302",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220302,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1950,
      "AgendaID": 2432,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Green Bus Fund",
      "Reference": "S4M-04247.2",
      "ID": 4370
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1756,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine",
      "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6354726+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1860E104P150VM251830",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251830,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1950,
      "AgendaID": 2432,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Green Bus Fund",
      "Reference": "S4M-04247.2",
      "ID": 4370
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1860,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda",
      "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.490977+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2033E20P141VM266166",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 266166,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1950,
      "AgendaID": 2432,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Green Bus Fund",
      "Reference": "S4M-04247.2",
      "ID": 4370
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2033,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain",
      "DisplayName": "Iain Gray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4771474+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324423",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324423,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1950,
      "AgendaID": 2432,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Green Bus Fund",
      "Reference": "S4M-04247.2",
      "ID": 4370
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5042,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2220224+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259923",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 259923,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1950,
      "AgendaID": 2432,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Green Bus Fund",
      "Reference": "S4M-04247.2",
      "ID": 4370
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick",
      "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.635873+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239283",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239283,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1950,
      "AgendaID": 2432,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Green Bus Fund",
      "Reference": "S4M-04247.2",
      "ID": 4370
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2029,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh",
      "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7301078+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273847",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 273847,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1950,
      "AgendaID": 2432,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Green Bus Fund",
      "Reference": "S4M-04247.2",
      "ID": 4370
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3758,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6382283+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304216",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 304216,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1950,
      "AgendaID": 2432,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Green Bus Fund",
      "Reference": "S4M-04247.2",
      "ID": 4370
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4086,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Hume",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.0287105+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221816",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221816,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1950,
      "AgendaID": 2432,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Green Bus Fund",
      "Reference": "S4M-04247.2",
      "ID": 4370
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1773,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.94903+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1882E227P459VM242052",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242052,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1950,
      "AgendaID": 2432,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Green Bus Fund",
      "Reference": "S4M-04247.2",
      "ID": 4370
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1882,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam",
      "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7917449+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223745",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223745,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1950,
      "AgendaID": 2432,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Green Bus Fund",
      "Reference": "S4M-04247.2",
      "ID": 4370
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1893,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4719494+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307518",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307518,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1950,
      "AgendaID": 2432,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Green Bus Fund",
      "Reference": "S4M-04247.2",
      "ID": 4370
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4934,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.83298+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272149",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 272149,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1950,
      "AgendaID": 2432,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Green Bus Fund",
      "Reference": "S4M-04247.2",
      "ID": 4370
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4956,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Keir",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.113683+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244846",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244846,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1950,
      "AgendaID": 2432,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Green Bus Fund",
      "Reference": "S4M-04247.2",
      "ID": 4370
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Kelly",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5811306+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315018",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315018,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1950,
      "AgendaID": 2432,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Green Bus Fund",
      "Reference": "S4M-04247.2",
      "ID": 4370
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3129,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6705346+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247985",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247985,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1950,
      "AgendaID": 2432,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Green Bus Fund",
      "Reference": "S4M-04247.2",
      "ID": 4370
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann",
      "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4368114+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4016E11P36VM274753",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274753,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1950,
      "AgendaID": 2432,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Green Bus Fund",
      "Reference": "S4M-04247.2",
      "ID": 4370
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4016,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1202492+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255835",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255835,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1950,
      "AgendaID": 2432,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Green Bus Fund",
      "Reference": "S4M-04247.2",
      "ID": 4370
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2180,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5590968+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4938E158P374VM277801",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277801,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1950,
      "AgendaID": 2432,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Green Bus Fund",
      "Reference": "S4M-04247.2",
      "ID": 4370
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4938,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9690095+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2112E250P486VM252977",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252977,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1950,
      "AgendaID": 2432,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Green Bus Fund",
      "Reference": "S4M-04247.2",
      "ID": 4370
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2112,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny",
      "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7614057+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4939E258P394VM277196",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277196,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1950,
      "AgendaID": 2432,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Green Bus Fund",
      "Reference": "S4M-04247.2",
      "ID": 4370
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4939,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus",
      "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.7055588+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325708",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 325708,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1950,
      "AgendaID": 2432,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Green Bus Fund",
      "Reference": "S4M-04247.2",
      "ID": 4370
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5074,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon",
      "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5179227+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1828E3P10VM232795",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232795,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1950,
      "AgendaID": 2432,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Green Bus Fund",
      "Reference": "S4M-04247.2",
      "ID": 4370
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1828,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo",
      "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8765749+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311365",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311365,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1950,
      "AgendaID": 2432,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Green Bus Fund",
      "Reference": "S4M-04247.2",
      "ID": 4370
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4948,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike",
      "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8755813+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2117E90P107VM230456",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230456,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1950,
      "AgendaID": 2432,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Green Bus Fund",
      "Reference": "S4M-04247.2",
      "ID": 4370
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2117,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis",
      "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3306988+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267305",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 267305,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1950,
      "AgendaID": 2432,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Green Bus Fund",
      "Reference": "S4M-04247.2",
      "ID": 4370
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken",
      "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0137189+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313796",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313796,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1950,
      "AgendaID": 2432,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Green Bus Fund",
      "Reference": "S4M-04247.2",
      "ID": 4370
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4966,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek",
      "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4110287+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3101E102P129VM295448",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295448,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1950,
      "AgendaID": 2432,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Green Bus Fund",
      "Reference": "S4M-04247.2",
      "ID": 4370
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3101,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala",
      "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5125924+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5034E88P114VM318856",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 318856,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1950,
      "AgendaID": 2432,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Green Bus Fund",
      "Reference": "S4M-04247.2",
      "ID": 4370
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5034,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny",
      "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6763542+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306469",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306469,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1950,
      "AgendaID": 2432,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Green Bus Fund",
      "Reference": "S4M-04247.2",
      "ID": 4370
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2159,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Martin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5534204+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5110E252P395VM311207",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311207,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1950,
      "AgendaID": 2432,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Green Bus Fund",
      "Reference": "S4M-04247.2",
      "ID": 4370
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Mason",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.86655+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268299",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 268299,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1950,
      "AgendaID": 2432,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Green Bus Fund",
      "Reference": "S4M-04247.2",
      "ID": 4370
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2133,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2611277+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2876E141P433VM286114",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286114,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1950,
      "AgendaID": 2432,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Green Bus Fund",
      "Reference": "S4M-04247.2",
      "ID": 4370
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2876,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.364257+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4951E147P368VM260735",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 260735,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1950,
      "AgendaID": 2432,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Green Bus Fund",
      "Reference": "S4M-04247.2",
      "ID": 4370
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4951,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan",
      "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.0900076+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3896E175P307VM264090",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264090,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1950,
      "AgendaID": 2432,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Green Bus Fund",
      "Reference": "S4M-04247.2",
      "ID": 4370
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3896,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam",
      "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9237597+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308432",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 308432,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1950,
      "AgendaID": 2432,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Green Bus Fund",
      "Reference": "S4M-04247.2",
      "ID": 4370
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0556835+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4964E143P375VM279313",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279313,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1950,
      "AgendaID": 2432,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Green Bus Fund",
      "Reference": "S4M-04247.2",
      "ID": 4370
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4964,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.496768+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3824E84P113VM280029",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280029,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1950,
      "AgendaID": 2432,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Green Bus Fund",
      "Reference": "S4M-04247.2",
      "ID": 4370
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3824,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5383799+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2066E22P91VM261761",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261761,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1950,
      "AgendaID": 2432,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Green Bus Fund",
      "Reference": "S4M-04247.2",
      "ID": 4370
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2066,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3716855+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299729",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 299729,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1950,
      "AgendaID": 2432,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Green Bus Fund",
      "Reference": "S4M-04247.2",
      "ID": 4370
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7201164+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306618",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306618,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1950,
      "AgendaID": 2432,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Green Bus Fund",
      "Reference": "S4M-04247.2",
      "ID": 4370
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina",
      "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5598159+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2487E146P369VM301177",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 301177,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1950,
      "AgendaID": 2432,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Green Bus Fund",
      "Reference": "S4M-04247.2",
      "ID": 4370
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2487,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0373563+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223628",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223628,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1950,
      "AgendaID": 2432,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Green Bus Fund",
      "Reference": "S4M-04247.2",
      "ID": 4370
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4669665+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237455",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237455,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1950,
      "AgendaID": 2432,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Green Bus Fund",
      "Reference": "S4M-04247.2",
      "ID": 4370
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1961,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David",
      "DisplayName": "David McLetchie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2113263+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2134E34P201VM297845",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 297845,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1950,
      "AgendaID": 2432,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Green Bus Fund",
      "Reference": "S4M-04247.2",
      "ID": 4370
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2134,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1274813+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320725",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 320725,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1950,
      "AgendaID": 2432,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Green Bus Fund",
      "Reference": "S4M-04247.2",
      "ID": 4370
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5041,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan",
      "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1787719+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3763E142P397VM316064",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 316064,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1950,
      "AgendaID": 2432,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Green Bus Fund",
      "Reference": "S4M-04247.2",
      "ID": 4370
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3763,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart",
      "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.944605+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1986E23P197VM236272",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 236272,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1950,
      "AgendaID": 2432,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Green Bus Fund",
      "Reference": "S4M-04247.2",
      "ID": 4370
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1986,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan",
      "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9092304+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5047E100P130VM291462",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291462,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1950,
      "AgendaID": 2432,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Green Bus Fund",
      "Reference": "S4M-04247.2",
      "ID": 4370
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5047,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne",
      "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1203562+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234952",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234952,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1950,
      "AgendaID": 2432,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Green Bus Fund",
      "Reference": "S4M-04247.2",
      "ID": 4370
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1845,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette",
      "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4069467+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313634",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313634,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1950,
      "AgendaID": 2432,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Green Bus Fund",
      "Reference": "S4M-04247.2",
      "ID": 4370
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3061,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4038518+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1768E19P265VM288603",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 288603,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1950,
      "AgendaID": 2432,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Green Bus Fund",
      "Reference": "S4M-04247.2",
      "ID": 4370
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1768,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1505123+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225040",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225040,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1950,
      "AgendaID": 2432,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Green Bus Fund",
      "Reference": "S4M-04247.2",
      "ID": 4370
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1894,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Neil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7419571+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3815E98P134VM270878",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270878,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1950,
      "AgendaID": 2432,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Green Bus Fund",
      "Reference": "S4M-04247.2",
      "ID": 4370
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3815,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Park, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Park",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.827018+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265930",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265930,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1950,
      "AgendaID": 2432,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Green Bus Fund",
      "Reference": "S4M-04247.2",
      "ID": 4370
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2010,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil",
      "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.466691+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283527",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283527,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1950,
      "AgendaID": 2432,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Green Bus Fund",
      "Reference": "S4M-04247.2",
      "ID": 4370
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5057,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7117397+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2853E33P128VM251418",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251418,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1950,
      "AgendaID": 2432,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Green Bus Fund",
      "Reference": "S4M-04247.2",
      "ID": 4370
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Pentland",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4627465+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317944",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317944,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1950,
      "AgendaID": 2432,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Green Bus Fund",
      "Reference": "S4M-04247.2",
      "ID": 4370
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5009,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4502445+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254753",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254753,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1950,
      "AgendaID": 2432,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Green Bus Fund",
      "Reference": "S4M-04247.2",
      "ID": 4370
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3745,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis",
      "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2822631+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1870E225P478VM295661",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295661,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1950,
      "AgendaID": 2432,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Green Bus Fund",
      "Reference": "S4M-04247.2",
      "ID": 4370
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1870,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona",
      "DisplayName": "Shona Robison",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5304557+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2135E254P450VM234861",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234861,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1950,
      "AgendaID": 2432,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Green Bus Fund",
      "Reference": "S4M-04247.2",
      "ID": 4370
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2135,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Russell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4029035+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1895E232P431VM257370",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257370,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1950,
      "AgendaID": 2432,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Green Bus Fund",
      "Reference": "S4M-04247.2",
      "ID": 4370
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1895,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0532774+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228066",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 228066,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1950,
      "AgendaID": 2432,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Green Bus Fund",
      "Reference": "S4M-04247.2",
      "ID": 4370
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1839,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5829012+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2345E10P55VM292038",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 292038,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1950,
      "AgendaID": 2432,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Green Bus Fund",
      "Reference": "S4M-04247.2",
      "ID": 4370
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2345,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1531964+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2223E176P333VM310675",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 310675,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1950,
      "AgendaID": 2432,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Green Bus Fund",
      "Reference": "S4M-04247.2",
      "ID": 4370
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2223,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish",
      "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5812101+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2182E87P175VM245978",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 245978,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1950,
      "AgendaID": 2432,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Green Bus Fund",
      "Reference": "S4M-04247.2",
      "ID": 4370
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2182,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8669395+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298368",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298368,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1950,
      "AgendaID": 2432,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Green Bus Fund",
      "Reference": "S4M-04247.2",
      "ID": 4370
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5079,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew",
      "DisplayName": "Drew Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3427253+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234402",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234402,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1950,
      "AgendaID": 2432,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Green Bus Fund",
      "Reference": "S4M-04247.2",
      "ID": 4370
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1769,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3757231+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4014E14P26VM269941",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269941,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1950,
      "AgendaID": 2432,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Green Bus Fund",
      "Reference": "S4M-04247.2",
      "ID": 4370
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4014,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz",
      "DisplayName": "Liz Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5744536+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269161",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269161,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1950,
      "AgendaID": 2432,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Green Bus Fund",
      "Reference": "S4M-04247.2",
      "ID": 4370
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2215,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.3063269+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317176",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317176,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1950,
      "AgendaID": 2432,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Green Bus Fund",
      "Reference": "S4M-04247.2",
      "ID": 4370
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3806,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.1849531+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326122",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 326122,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1950,
      "AgendaID": 2432,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Green Bus Fund",
      "Reference": "S4M-04247.2",
      "ID": 4370
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5106,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin",
      "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5408218+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241076",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241076,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1950,
      "AgendaID": 2432,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Green Bus Fund",
      "Reference": "S4M-04247.2",
      "ID": 4370
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1848,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola",
      "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3950453+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2098E237P531VM289591",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289591,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1950,
      "AgendaID": 2432,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Green Bus Fund",
      "Reference": "S4M-04247.2",
      "ID": 4370
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2098,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Swinney",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4506342+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2674E247P401VM247735",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247735,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1950,
      "AgendaID": 2432,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Green Bus Fund",
      "Reference": "S4M-04247.2",
      "ID": 4370
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2674,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave",
      "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4261755+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5075E234P371VM284853",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 284853,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1950,
      "AgendaID": 2432,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Green Bus Fund",
      "Reference": "S4M-04247.2",
      "ID": 4370
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5075,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Torrance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0505482+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1793E151P362VM222441",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 222441,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1950,
      "AgendaID": 2432,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Green Bus Fund",
      "Reference": "S4M-04247.2",
      "ID": 4370
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1793,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean",
      "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1890891+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5078E245P7VM307081",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307081,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1950,
      "AgendaID": 2432,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Green Bus Fund",
      "Reference": "S4M-04247.2",
      "ID": 4370
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5078,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Walker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.586459+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1841E231P426VM240202",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 240202,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1950,
      "AgendaID": 2432,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Green Bus Fund",
      "Reference": "S4M-04247.2",
      "ID": 4370
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1841,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen",
      "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3492585+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283404",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283404,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1950,
      "AgendaID": 2432,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Green Bus Fund",
      "Reference": "S4M-04247.2",
      "ID": 4370
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4952,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.6992492+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1865E263P500VM232260",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232260,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1950,
      "AgendaID": 2432,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Green Bus Fund",
      "Reference": "S4M-04247.2",
      "ID": 4370
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1865,
      "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra",
      "DisplayName": "Sandra White",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.847058+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237818",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237818,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1950,
      "AgendaID": 2432,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Green Bus Fund",
      "Reference": "S4M-04247.2",
      "ID": 4370
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2610,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Wilson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2273857+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309320",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 309320,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1950,
      "AgendaID": 2432,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Green Bus Fund",
      "Reference": "S4M-04247.2",
      "ID": 4370
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4941,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza",
      "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3242326+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252718",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252718,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1949,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.2",
      "ID": 4359
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1926,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian",
      "DisplayName": "Brian Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7505807+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2615E213P388VM258952",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258952,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1949,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.2",
      "ID": 4359
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2615,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George",
      "DisplayName": "George Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3353194+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319630",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319630,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1949,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.2",
      "ID": 4359
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4940,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare",
      "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9345573+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249524",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 249524,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1949,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.2",
      "ID": 4359
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2641,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair",
      "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.930583+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1783E21P273VM227836",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227836,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1949,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.2",
      "ID": 4359
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1783,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie",
      "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5677321+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2633E97P136VM280837",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280837,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1949,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.2",
      "ID": 4359
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2633,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire",
      "DisplayName": "Claire Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7844955+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262777",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262777,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1949,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.2",
      "ID": 4359
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2603,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6163918+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1759E91P115VM229868",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229868,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1949,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.2",
      "ID": 4359
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia",
      "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.1008823+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3751E243P383VM269765",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269765,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1949,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.2",
      "ID": 4359
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3751,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5619934+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322643",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 322643,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1949,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.2",
      "ID": 4359
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5109,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco",
      "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.697525+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5060E86P124VM295314",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295314,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1949,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.2",
      "ID": 4359
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5060,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.506671+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242969",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242969,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1949,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.2",
      "ID": 4359
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1866,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah",
      "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0433073+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235139",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235139,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1949,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.2",
      "ID": 4359
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1943,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic",
      "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4210559+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302433",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 302433,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1949,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.2",
      "ID": 4359
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2595,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin",
      "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5243808+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244226",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244226,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1949,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.2",
      "ID": 4359
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2103,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith",
      "DisplayName": "Keith Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5454707+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327117",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 327117,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1949,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.2",
      "ID": 4359
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7996602+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277116",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277116,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1949,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.2",
      "ID": 4359
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.7017953+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264058",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264058,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1949,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.2",
      "ID": 4359
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2673,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick",
      "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9223822+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248674",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248674,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1949,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.2",
      "ID": 4359
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2678,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson",
      "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6649567+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2123E27P233VM295711",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295711,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1949,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.2",
      "ID": 4359
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2123,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm",
      "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5326402+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285281",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285281,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1949,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.2",
      "ID": 4359
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3907,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3162379+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230758",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230758,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1949,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.2",
      "ID": 4359
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1735,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela",
      "DisplayName": "Angela Constance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3442687+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243749",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 243749,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1949,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.2",
      "ID": 4359
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1932,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce",
      "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3181488+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254813",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254813,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1949,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.2",
      "ID": 4359
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1863,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna",
      "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2848333+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323724",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 323724,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1949,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.2",
      "ID": 4359
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4976,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth",
      "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9691674+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5107E223P379VM290924",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 290924,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1949,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.2",
      "ID": 4359
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5107,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7779431+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3743E222P391VM265453",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265453,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1949,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.2",
      "ID": 4359
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3743,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel",
      "DisplayName": "Nigel Don",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4398343+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262351",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262351,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1949,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.2",
      "ID": 4359
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3771,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob",
      "DisplayName": "Bob Doris",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.5977192+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281903",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 281903,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1949,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.2",
      "ID": 4359
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2826,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Dornan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1627326+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298223",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298223,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1949,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.2",
      "ID": 4359
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3812,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia",
      "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3364929+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231183",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231183,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1949,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.2",
      "ID": 4359
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1778,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen",
      "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3694004+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4955E240P389VM285010",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285010,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1949,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.2",
      "ID": 4359
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4955,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0573412+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219490",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 219490,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1949,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.2",
      "ID": 4359
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1742,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle",
      "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3015275+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238475",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 238475,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1949,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.2",
      "ID": 4359
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1994,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus",
      "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.45572+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225178",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225178,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1949,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.2",
      "ID": 4359
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1814,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda",
      "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7478354+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321817",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 321817,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1949,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.2",
      "ID": 4359
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Fee",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4526245+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292743",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 292743,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1949,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.2",
      "ID": 4359
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia",
      "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5559929+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227215",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227215,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1949,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.2",
      "ID": 4359
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5358055+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5054E95P118VM313254",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313254,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1949,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.2",
      "ID": 4359
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5054,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.3847403+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4947E152P361VM257758",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257758,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1949,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.2",
      "ID": 4359
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4947,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Finnie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0763595+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271142",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271142,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1949,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.2",
      "ID": 4359
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3901,
      "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe",
      "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8442884+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278039",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 278039,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1949,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.2",
      "ID": 4359
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2394,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo",
      "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9843716+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2110E220P414VM287329",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 287329,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1949,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.2",
      "ID": 4359
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth",
      "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8594858+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250575",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250575,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1949,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.2",
      "ID": 4359
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2675,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob",
      "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1954781+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221039",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221039,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1949,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.2",
      "ID": 4359
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1741,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel",
      "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6724508+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220154",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220154,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1949,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.2",
      "ID": 4359
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1756,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine",
      "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3366665+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1860E104P150VM252454",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252454,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1949,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.2",
      "ID": 4359
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1860,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda",
      "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7298384+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2033E20P141VM253807",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253807,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1949,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.2",
      "ID": 4359
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2033,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain",
      "DisplayName": "Iain Gray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0217446+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324681",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324681,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1949,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.2",
      "ID": 4359
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5042,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2333665+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259621",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 259621,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1949,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.2",
      "ID": 4359
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick",
      "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6173448+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239422",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239422,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1949,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.2",
      "ID": 4359
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2029,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh",
      "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7361128+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273684",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 273684,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1949,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.2",
      "ID": 4359
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3758,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6309526+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304053",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 304053,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1949,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.2",
      "ID": 4359
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4086,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Hume",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8473568+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221656",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221656,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1949,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.2",
      "ID": 4359
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1773,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9421445+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1882E227P459VM241886",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241886,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1949,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.2",
      "ID": 4359
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1882,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam",
      "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7842582+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223451",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223451,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1949,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.2",
      "ID": 4359
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1893,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4585542+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307806",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307806,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1949,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.2",
      "ID": 4359
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4934,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8516635+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272311",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 272311,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1949,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.2",
      "ID": 4359
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4956,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Keir",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3243062+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244980",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244980,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1949,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.2",
      "ID": 4359
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Kelly",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5868383+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315150",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315150,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1949,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.2",
      "ID": 4359
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3129,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6764754+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247846",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247846,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1949,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.2",
      "ID": 4359
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann",
      "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4309279+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4016E11P36VM275098",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 275098,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1949,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.2",
      "ID": 4359
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4016,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1412498+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255542",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255542,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1949,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.2",
      "ID": 4359
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2180,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5357986+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4938E158P374VM276991",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276991,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1949,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.2",
      "ID": 4359
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4938,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.696387+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2112E250P486VM253422",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253422,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1949,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.2",
      "ID": 4359
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2112,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny",
      "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.9957481+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4939E258P394VM276738",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276738,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1949,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.2",
      "ID": 4359
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4939,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus",
      "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6790033+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325450",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 325450,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1949,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.2",
      "ID": 4359
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5074,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon",
      "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5069249+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1828E3P10VM233257",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 233257,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1949,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.2",
      "ID": 4359
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1828,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo",
      "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.116215+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311650",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311650,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1949,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.2",
      "ID": 4359
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4948,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike",
      "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8883109+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2117E90P107VM229689",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229689,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1949,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.2",
      "ID": 4359
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2117,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis",
      "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0924505+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267436",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 267436,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1949,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.2",
      "ID": 4359
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken",
      "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0197506+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313511",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313511,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1949,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.2",
      "ID": 4359
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4966,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek",
      "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.3985254+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3101E102P129VM295004",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295004,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1949,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.2",
      "ID": 4359
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3101,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala",
      "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1880712+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319067",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319067,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1949,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.2",
      "ID": 4359
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5034,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny",
      "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6910135+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306336",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306336,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1949,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.2",
      "ID": 4359
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2159,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Martin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5476577+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5110E252P395VM310751",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 310751,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1949,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.2",
      "ID": 4359
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Mason",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5844887+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268168",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 268168,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1949,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.2",
      "ID": 4359
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2133,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.059126+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2876E141P433VM286405",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286405,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1949,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.2",
      "ID": 4359
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2876,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5777358+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4951E147P368VM258560",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258560,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1949,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.2",
      "ID": 4359
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4951,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan",
      "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3125114+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3896E175P307VM263786",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 263786,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1949,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.2",
      "ID": 4359
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3896,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam",
      "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9046672+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308737",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 308737,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1949,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.2",
      "ID": 4359
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0688143+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4964E143P375VM279764",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279764,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1949,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.2",
      "ID": 4359
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4964,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5216598+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279557",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279557,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1949,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.2",
      "ID": 4359
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3824,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5128203+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2066E22P91VM261007",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261007,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1949,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.2",
      "ID": 4359
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2066,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.1077507+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299595",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 299595,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1949,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.2",
      "ID": 4359
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.704274+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306775",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306775,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1949,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.2",
      "ID": 4359
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina",
      "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5668753+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300560",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 300560,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1949,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.2",
      "ID": 4359
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2487,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0038583+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223942",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223942,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1949,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.2",
      "ID": 4359
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4852235+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237891",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237891,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1949,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.2",
      "ID": 4359
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1961,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David",
      "DisplayName": "David McLetchie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2305238+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305532",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 305532,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1949,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.2",
      "ID": 4359
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2134,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3283939+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320359",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 320359,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1949,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.2",
      "ID": 4359
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5041,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan",
      "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.162991+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315932",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315932,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1949,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.2",
      "ID": 4359
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3763,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart",
      "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9384844+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1986E23P197VM236745",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 236745,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1949,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.2",
      "ID": 4359
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1986,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan",
      "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9382385+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5047E100P130VM289760",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289760,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1949,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.2",
      "ID": 4359
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5047,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne",
      "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4579544+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234482",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234482,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1949,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.2",
      "ID": 4359
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1845,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette",
      "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3861597+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313191",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313191,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1949,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.2",
      "ID": 4359
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3061,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1675967+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1768E19P265VM289376",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289376,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1949,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.2",
      "ID": 4359
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1768,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4345756+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225336",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225336,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1949,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.2",
      "ID": 4359
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1894,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Neil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9701824+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3815E98P134VM270978",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270978,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1949,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.2",
      "ID": 4359
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3815,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Park, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Park",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8372929+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265769",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265769,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1949,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.2",
      "ID": 4359
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2010,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil",
      "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4536817+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283224",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283224,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1949,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.2",
      "ID": 4359
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5057,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.6912087+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2853E33P128VM252026",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252026,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1949,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.2",
      "ID": 4359
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Pentland",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.499385+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317580",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317580,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1949,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.2",
      "ID": 4359
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5009,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4285554+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254277",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254277,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1949,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.2",
      "ID": 4359
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3745,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis",
      "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2486124+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1870E225P478VM296278",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 296278,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1949,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.2",
      "ID": 4359
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1870,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona",
      "DisplayName": "Shona Robison",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8417631+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2135E254P450VM235469",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235469,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1949,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.2",
      "ID": 4359
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2135,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Russell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6791843+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1895E232P431VM257686",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257686,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1949,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.2",
      "ID": 4359
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1895,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0671977+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228536",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 228536,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1949,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.2",
      "ID": 4359
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1839,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.8033225+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2345E10P55VM291566",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291566,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1949,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.2",
      "ID": 4359
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2345,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1328908+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311120",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311120,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1949,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.2",
      "ID": 4359
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2223,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish",
      "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.6062641+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246451",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 246451,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1949,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.2",
      "ID": 4359
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2182,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1292877+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298054",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298054,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1949,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.2",
      "ID": 4359
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5079,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew",
      "DisplayName": "Drew Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1362881+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234083",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234083,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1949,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.2",
      "ID": 4359
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1769,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1659086+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274680",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274680,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1949,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.2",
      "ID": 4359
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4014,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz",
      "DisplayName": "Liz Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1170847+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269602",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269602,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1949,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.2",
      "ID": 4359
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2215,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5549436+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317461",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317461,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1949,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.2",
      "ID": 4359
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3806,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4231734+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326380",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 326380,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1949,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.2",
      "ID": 4359
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5106,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin",
      "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7560028+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241242",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241242,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1949,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.2",
      "ID": 4359
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1848,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola",
      "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.749146+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2098E237P531VM290341",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 290341,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1949,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.2",
      "ID": 4359
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2098,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Swinney",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7426955+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248035",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248035,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1949,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.2",
      "ID": 4359
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2674,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave",
      "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4389633+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5075E234P371VM287487",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 287487,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1949,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.2",
      "ID": 4359
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5075,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Torrance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8662869+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1793E151P362VM222580",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 222580,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1949,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.2",
      "ID": 4359
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1793,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean",
      "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1950538+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5078E245P7VM306951",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306951,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1949,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.2",
      "ID": 4359
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5078,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Walker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5809071+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1841E231P426VM239882",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239882,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1949,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.2",
      "ID": 4359
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1841,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen",
      "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7633868+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283748",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283748,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1949,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.2",
      "ID": 4359
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4952,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7217613+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1865E263P500VM231824",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231824,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1949,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.2",
      "ID": 4359
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1865,
      "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra",
      "DisplayName": "Sandra White",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6171003+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237369",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237369,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1949,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.2",
      "ID": 4359
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2610,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Wilson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2012284+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309187",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 309187,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1949,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.2",
      "ID": 4359
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4941,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza",
      "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0957574+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252717",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252717,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1948,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.1",
      "ID": 4352
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1926,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian",
      "DisplayName": "Brian Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7505398+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2615E213P388VM258951",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258951,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1948,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.1",
      "ID": 4352
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2615,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George",
      "DisplayName": "George Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3352763+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319631",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319631,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1948,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.1",
      "ID": 4352
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4940,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare",
      "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9345986+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249525",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 249525,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1948,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.1",
      "ID": 4352
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2641,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair",
      "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9306249+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1783E21P273VM227835",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227835,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1948,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.1",
      "ID": 4352
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1783,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie",
      "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5676905+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2633E97P136VM280836",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280836,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1948,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.1",
      "ID": 4352
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2633,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire",
      "DisplayName": "Claire Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7844547+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262776",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262776,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1948,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.1",
      "ID": 4352
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2603,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6163511+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1759E91P115VM229867",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229867,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1948,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.1",
      "ID": 4352
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia",
      "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.1008392+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3751E243P383VM269766",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269766,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1948,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.1",
      "ID": 4352
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3751,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5620349+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322642",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 322642,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1948,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.1",
      "ID": 4352
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5109,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco",
      "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6974834+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5060E86P124VM295313",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295313,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1948,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.1",
      "ID": 4352
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5060,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5066297+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242968",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242968,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1948,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.1",
      "ID": 4352
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1866,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah",
      "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.043266+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235140",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235140,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1948,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.1",
      "ID": 4352
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1943,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic",
      "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4210975+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302432",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 302432,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1948,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.1",
      "ID": 4352
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2595,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin",
      "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5243387+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244227",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244227,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1948,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.1",
      "ID": 4352
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2103,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith",
      "DisplayName": "Keith Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5455153+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327188",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 327188,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1948,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.1",
      "ID": 4352
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.8029748+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277115",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277115,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1948,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.1",
      "ID": 4352
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.701728+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264059",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264059,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1948,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.1",
      "ID": 4352
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2673,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick",
      "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9224414+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248675",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248675,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1948,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.1",
      "ID": 4352
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2678,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson",
      "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.665017+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2123E27P233VM295712",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295712,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1948,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.1",
      "ID": 4352
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2123,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm",
      "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5326817+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285280",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285280,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1948,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.1",
      "ID": 4352
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3907,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3161934+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230757",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230757,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1948,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.1",
      "ID": 4352
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1735,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela",
      "DisplayName": "Angela Constance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.344228+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243750",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 243750,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1948,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.1",
      "ID": 4352
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1932,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce",
      "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3181892+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254814",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254814,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1948,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.1",
      "ID": 4352
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1863,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna",
      "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2848745+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323795",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 323795,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1948,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.1",
      "ID": 4352
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4976,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth",
      "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9722497+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5107E223P379VM290925",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 290925,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1948,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.1",
      "ID": 4352
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5107,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7779838+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3743E222P391VM265452",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265452,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1948,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.1",
      "ID": 4352
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3743,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel",
      "DisplayName": "Nigel Don",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4397924+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262350",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262350,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1948,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.1",
      "ID": 4352
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3771,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob",
      "DisplayName": "Bob Doris",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.597678+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281904",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 281904,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1948,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.1",
      "ID": 4352
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2826,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Dornan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1627747+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298222",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298222,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1948,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.1",
      "ID": 4352
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3812,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia",
      "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3364511+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231184",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231184,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1948,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.1",
      "ID": 4352
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1778,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen",
      "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3694416+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4955E240P389VM285011",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285011,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1948,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.1",
      "ID": 4352
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4955,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0573828+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219489",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 219489,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1948,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.1",
      "ID": 4352
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1742,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle",
      "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3014854+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238476",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 238476,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1948,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.1",
      "ID": 4352
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1994,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus",
      "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4557633+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225179",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225179,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1948,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.1",
      "ID": 4352
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1814,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda",
      "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7478773+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321818",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 321818,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1948,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.1",
      "ID": 4352
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Fee",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4526658+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292725",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 292725,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1948,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.1",
      "ID": 4352
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia",
      "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5551389+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227214",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227214,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1948,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.1",
      "ID": 4352
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5357632+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5054E95P118VM313253",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313253,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1948,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.1",
      "ID": 4352
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5054,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.3846984+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4947E152P361VM257757",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257757,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1948,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.1",
      "ID": 4352
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4947,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Finnie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.076318+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271143",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271143,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1948,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.1",
      "ID": 4352
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3901,
      "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe",
      "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8443299+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278040",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 278040,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1948,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.1",
      "ID": 4352
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2394,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo",
      "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9844128+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2110E220P414VM287328",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 287328,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1948,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.1",
      "ID": 4352
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth",
      "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8594447+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250574",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250574,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1948,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.1",
      "ID": 4352
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2675,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob",
      "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1954369+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221038",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221038,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1948,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.1",
      "ID": 4352
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1741,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel",
      "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6724091+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220155",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220155,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1948,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.1",
      "ID": 4352
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1756,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine",
      "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.336708+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1860E104P150VM252453",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252453,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1948,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.1",
      "ID": 4352
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1860,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda",
      "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7297965+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2033E20P141VM253808",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253808,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1948,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.1",
      "ID": 4352
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2033,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain",
      "DisplayName": "Iain Gray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0217848+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324610",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324610,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1948,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.1",
      "ID": 4352
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5042,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2303739+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259622",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 259622,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1948,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.1",
      "ID": 4352
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick",
      "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6173868+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239421",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239421,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1948,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.1",
      "ID": 4352
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2029,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh",
      "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7360714+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273685",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 273685,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1948,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.1",
      "ID": 4352
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3758,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6309943+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304054",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 304054,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1948,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.1",
      "ID": 4352
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4086,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Hume",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8473989+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221657",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221657,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1948,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.1",
      "ID": 4352
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1773,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9421863+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1882E227P459VM241887",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241887,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1948,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.1",
      "ID": 4352
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1882,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam",
      "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7843001+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223452",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223452,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1948,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.1",
      "ID": 4352
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1893,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4586153+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307805",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307805,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1948,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.1",
      "ID": 4352
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4934,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8515918+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272310",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 272310,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1948,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.1",
      "ID": 4352
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4956,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Keir",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.324264+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244979",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244979,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1948,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.1",
      "ID": 4352
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Kelly",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5867965+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315149",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315149,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1948,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.1",
      "ID": 4352
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3129,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6764345+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247847",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247847,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1948,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.1",
      "ID": 4352
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann",
      "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4309686+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4016E11P36VM275097",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 275097,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1948,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.1",
      "ID": 4352
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4016,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.141167+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255543",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255543,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1948,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.1",
      "ID": 4352
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2180,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5358406+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4938E158P374VM276992",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276992,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1948,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.1",
      "ID": 4352
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4938,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6964292+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2112E250P486VM253421",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253421,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1948,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.1",
      "ID": 4352
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2112,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny",
      "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.9957061+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4939E258P394VM276739",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276739,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1948,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.1",
      "ID": 4352
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4939,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus",
      "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6790448+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325521",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 325521,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1948,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.1",
      "ID": 4352
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5074,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon",
      "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5099361+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1828E3P10VM233256",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 233256,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1948,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.1",
      "ID": 4352
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1828,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo",
      "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1161725+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311649",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311649,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1948,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.1",
      "ID": 4352
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4948,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike",
      "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.888269+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2117E90P107VM229690",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229690,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1948,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.1",
      "ID": 4352
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2117,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis",
      "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0924914+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267435",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 267435,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1948,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.1",
      "ID": 4352
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken",
      "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0196906+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313512",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313512,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1948,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.1",
      "ID": 4352
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4966,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek",
      "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.3985672+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3101E102P129VM295005",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295005,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1948,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.1",
      "ID": 4352
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3101,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala",
      "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1881131+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319068",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319068,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1948,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.1",
      "ID": 4352
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5034,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny",
      "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6910549+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306337",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306337,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1948,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.1",
      "ID": 4352
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2159,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Martin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5477186+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5110E252P395VM310727",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 310727,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1948,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.1",
      "ID": 4352
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Mason",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5834499+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268169",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 268169,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1948,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.1",
      "ID": 4352
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2133,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0591875+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2876E141P433VM286404",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286404,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1948,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.1",
      "ID": 4352
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2876,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5776935+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4951E147P368VM258561",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258561,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1948,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.1",
      "ID": 4352
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4951,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan",
      "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3125534+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3896E175P307VM263787",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 263787,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1948,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.1",
      "ID": 4352
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3896,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam",
      "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9047085+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308761",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 308761,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1948,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.1",
      "ID": 4352
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0698509+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4964E143P375VM279763",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279763,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1948,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.1",
      "ID": 4352
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4964,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5216187+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279558",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279558,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1948,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.1",
      "ID": 4352
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3824,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5128614+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2066E22P91VM261008",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261008,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1948,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.1",
      "ID": 4352
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2066,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.1078006+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299596",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 299596,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1948,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.1",
      "ID": 4352
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.70439+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306793",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306793,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1948,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.1",
      "ID": 4352
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina",
      "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5739297+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300542",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 300542,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1948,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.1",
      "ID": 4352
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2487,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0027635+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223941",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223941,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1948,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.1",
      "ID": 4352
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.485162+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237890",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237890,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1948,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.1",
      "ID": 4352
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1961,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David",
      "DisplayName": "David McLetchie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2304823+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305531",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 305531,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1948,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.1",
      "ID": 4352
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2134,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3283349+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320358",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 320358,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1948,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.1",
      "ID": 4352
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5041,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan",
      "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1629485+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315933",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315933,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1948,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.1",
      "ID": 4352
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3763,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart",
      "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9385262+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1986E23P197VM236744",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 236744,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1948,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.1",
      "ID": 4352
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1986,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan",
      "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9381966+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5047E100P130VM289761",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289761,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1948,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.1",
      "ID": 4352
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5047,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne",
      "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4579966+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234483",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234483,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1948,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.1",
      "ID": 4352
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1845,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette",
      "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3862018+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313192",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313192,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1948,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.1",
      "ID": 4352
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3061,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1676407+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1768E19P265VM289277",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289277,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1948,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.1",
      "ID": 4352
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1768,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4303423+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225335",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225335,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1948,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.1",
      "ID": 4352
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1894,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Neil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9701411+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3815E98P134VM270977",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270977,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1948,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.1",
      "ID": 4352
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3815,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Park, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Park",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8372504+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265770",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265770,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1948,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.1",
      "ID": 4352
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2010,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil",
      "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.453743+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283225",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283225,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1948,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.1",
      "ID": 4352
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5057,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.6912703+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2853E33P128VM252025",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252025,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1948,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.1",
      "ID": 4352
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Pentland",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4993432+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317579",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317579,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1948,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.1",
      "ID": 4352
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5009,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4285146+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254278",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254278,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1948,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.1",
      "ID": 4352
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3745,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis",
      "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.248655+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1870E225P478VM296296",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 296296,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1948,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.1",
      "ID": 4352
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1870,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona",
      "DisplayName": "Shona Robison",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8428984+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2135E254P450VM235468",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235468,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1948,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.1",
      "ID": 4352
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2135,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Russell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6791431+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1895E232P431VM257685",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257685,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1948,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.1",
      "ID": 4352
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1895,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0671564+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228535",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 228535,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1948,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.1",
      "ID": 4352
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1839,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.8032813+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2345E10P55VM291567",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291567,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1948,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.1",
      "ID": 4352
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2345,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1329332+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311119",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311119,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1948,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.1",
      "ID": 4352
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2223,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish",
      "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.6062231+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246450",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 246450,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1948,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.1",
      "ID": 4352
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2182,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1292457+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298055",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298055,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1948,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.1",
      "ID": 4352
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5079,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew",
      "DisplayName": "Drew Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1363299+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234084",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234084,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1948,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.1",
      "ID": 4352
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1769,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1659499+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274679",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274679,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1948,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.1",
      "ID": 4352
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4014,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz",
      "DisplayName": "Liz Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1170419+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269601",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269601,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1948,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.1",
      "ID": 4352
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2215,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5549018+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317460",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317460,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1948,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.1",
      "ID": 4352
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3806,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4231229+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326309",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 326309,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1948,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.1",
      "ID": 4352
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5106,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin",
      "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7528898+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241241",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241241,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1948,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.1",
      "ID": 4352
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1848,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola",
      "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7491039+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2098E237P531VM290340",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 290340,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1948,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.1",
      "ID": 4352
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2098,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Swinney",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7426542+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248034",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248034,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1948,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.1",
      "ID": 4352
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2674,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave",
      "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4389041+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5075E234P371VM287486",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 287486,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1948,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.1",
      "ID": 4352
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5075,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Torrance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8662443+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1793E151P362VM222579",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 222579,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1948,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.1",
      "ID": 4352
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1793,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean",
      "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1950123+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5078E245P7VM306933",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306933,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1948,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.1",
      "ID": 4352
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5078,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Walker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5801484+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1841E231P426VM239883",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239883,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1948,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.1",
      "ID": 4352
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1841,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen",
      "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7634291+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283747",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283747,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1948,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.1",
      "ID": 4352
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4952,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7217197+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1865E263P500VM231825",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231825,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1948,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.1",
      "ID": 4352
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1865,
      "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra",
      "DisplayName": "Sandra White",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.617142+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237370",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237370,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1948,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.1",
      "ID": 4352
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2610,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Wilson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2012706+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309188",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 309188,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1948,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 33,
      "VoteAgainst": 59,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234.1",
      "ID": 4352
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4941,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza",
      "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0958219+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252749",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252749,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1947,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 92,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234",
      "ID": 4343
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1926,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian",
      "DisplayName": "Brian Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7516669+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2615E213P388VM258953",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258953,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1947,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 92,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234",
      "ID": 4343
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2615,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George",
      "DisplayName": "George Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3353602+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319558",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319558,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1947,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 92,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234",
      "ID": 4343
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4940,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare",
      "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9311307+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249523",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 249523,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1947,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 92,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234",
      "ID": 4343
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2641,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair",
      "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9305417+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1783E21P273VM228336",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 228336,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1947,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 92,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234",
      "ID": 4343
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1783,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie",
      "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.788579+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2633E97P136VM280878",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280878,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1947,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 92,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234",
      "ID": 4343
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2633,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire",
      "DisplayName": "Claire Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7862293+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262778",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262778,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1947,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 92,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234",
      "ID": 4343
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2603,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6164332+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1759E91P115VM229869",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229869,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1947,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 92,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234",
      "ID": 4343
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia",
      "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.1009238+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3751E243P383VM269764",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269764,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1947,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 92,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234",
      "ID": 4343
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3751,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5619524+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322563",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 322563,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1947,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 92,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234",
      "ID": 4343
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5109,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco",
      "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.694095+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5060E86P124VM295315",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295315,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1947,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 92,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234",
      "ID": 4343
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5060,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5067121+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242972",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242972,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1947,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 92,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234",
      "ID": 4343
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1866,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah",
      "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.043432+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235138",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235138,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1947,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 92,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234",
      "ID": 4343
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1943,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic",
      "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4210141+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302434",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 302434,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1947,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 92,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234",
      "ID": 4343
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2595,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin",
      "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5244222+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244225",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244225,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1947,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 92,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234",
      "ID": 4343
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2103,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith",
      "DisplayName": "Keith Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5454163+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327053",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 327053,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1947,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 92,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234",
      "ID": 4343
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.791564+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277117",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277117,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1947,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 92,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234",
      "ID": 4343
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.7018396+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264057",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264057,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1947,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 92,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234",
      "ID": 4343
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2673,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick",
      "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9223408+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248673",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248673,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1947,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 92,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234",
      "ID": 4343
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2678,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson",
      "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6649157+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2123E27P233VM294868",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 294868,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1947,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 92,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234",
      "ID": 4343
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2123,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm",
      "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1821771+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285282",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285282,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1947,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 92,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234",
      "ID": 4343
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3907,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3162803+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230759",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230759,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1947,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 92,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234",
      "ID": 4343
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1735,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela",
      "DisplayName": "Angela Constance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3443099+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243746",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 243746,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1947,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 92,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234",
      "ID": 4343
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1932,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce",
      "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3180279+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254812",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254812,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1947,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 92,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234",
      "ID": 4343
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1863,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna",
      "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2847912+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323506",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 323506,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1947,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 92,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234",
      "ID": 4343
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4976,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth",
      "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9593256+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5107E223P379VM290923",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 290923,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1947,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 92,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234",
      "ID": 4343
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5107,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7779006+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3743E222P391VM265454",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265454,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1947,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 92,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234",
      "ID": 4343
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3743,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel",
      "DisplayName": "Nigel Don",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4398755+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262352",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262352,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1947,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 92,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234",
      "ID": 4343
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3771,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob",
      "DisplayName": "Bob Doris",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.5977601+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281861",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 281861,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1947,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 92,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234",
      "ID": 4343
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2826,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Dornan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1607682+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298266",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298266,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1947,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 92,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234",
      "ID": 4343
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3812,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia",
      "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.338355+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231182",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231182,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1947,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 92,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234",
      "ID": 4343
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1778,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen",
      "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3693585+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4955E240P389VM285009",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285009,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1947,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 92,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234",
      "ID": 4343
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4955,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.057299+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219491",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 219491,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1947,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 92,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234",
      "ID": 4343
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1742,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle",
      "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3015695+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238474",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 238474,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1947,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 92,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234",
      "ID": 4343
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1994,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus",
      "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4556405+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225177",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225177,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1947,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 92,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234",
      "ID": 4343
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1814,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda",
      "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7477758+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321897",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 321897,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1947,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 92,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234",
      "ID": 4343
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Fee",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4560362+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292742",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 292742,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1947,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 92,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234",
      "ID": 4343
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia",
      "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.555951+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227216",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227216,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1947,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 92,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234",
      "ID": 4343
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5358486+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5054E95P118VM313255",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313255,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1947,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 92,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234",
      "ID": 4343
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5054,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.3848057+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4947E152P361VM257759",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257759,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1947,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 92,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234",
      "ID": 4343
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4947,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Finnie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0764019+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271141",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271141,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1947,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 92,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234",
      "ID": 4343
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3901,
      "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe",
      "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8442469+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2394E15P47VM277999",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277999,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1947,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 92,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234",
      "ID": 4343
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2394,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo",
      "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9826229+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2110E220P414VM287330",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 287330,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1947,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 92,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234",
      "ID": 4343
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth",
      "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8595468+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250576",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250576,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1947,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 92,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234",
      "ID": 4343
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2675,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob",
      "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1955199+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221040",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221040,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1947,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 92,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234",
      "ID": 4343
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1741,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel",
      "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6724923+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220153",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220153,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1947,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 92,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234",
      "ID": 4343
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1756,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine",
      "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3366244+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1860E104P150VM252455",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252455,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1947,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 92,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234",
      "ID": 4343
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1860,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda",
      "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7298795+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2033E20P141VM253768",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253768,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1947,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 92,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234",
      "ID": 4343
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2033,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain",
      "DisplayName": "Iain Gray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0200988+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324745",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324745,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1947,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 92,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234",
      "ID": 4343
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5042,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2360527+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259620",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 259620,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1947,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 92,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234",
      "ID": 4343
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick",
      "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6173031+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239423",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239423,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1947,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 92,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234",
      "ID": 4343
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2029,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh",
      "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7361548+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273683",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 273683,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1947,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 92,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234",
      "ID": 4343
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3758,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6309109+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304052",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 304052,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1947,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 92,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234",
      "ID": 4343
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4086,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Hume",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8473155+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221655",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221655,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1947,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 92,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234",
      "ID": 4343
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1773,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9421025+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1882E227P459VM241885",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241885,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1947,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 92,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234",
      "ID": 4343
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1882,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam",
      "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7842164+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223450",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223450,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1947,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 92,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234",
      "ID": 4343
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1893,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.458512+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307849",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307849,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1947,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 92,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234",
      "ID": 4343
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4934,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8535738+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272312",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 272312,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1947,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 92,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234",
      "ID": 4343
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4956,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Keir",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3244867+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244983",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244983,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1947,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 92,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234",
      "ID": 4343
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Kelly",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5869824+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315221",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315221,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1947,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 92,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234",
      "ID": 4343
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3129,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.8991499+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247845",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247845,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1947,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 92,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234",
      "ID": 4343
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann",
      "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4308858+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4016E11P36VM275099",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 275099,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1947,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 92,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234",
      "ID": 4343
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4016,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1413002+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255541",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255541,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1947,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 92,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234",
      "ID": 4343
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2180,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5357573+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4938E158P374VM276990",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276990,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1947,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 92,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234",
      "ID": 4343
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4938,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6963452+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2112E250P486VM253423",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253423,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1947,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 92,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234",
      "ID": 4343
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2112,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny",
      "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.9957894+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4939E258P394VM276737",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276737,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1947,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 92,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234",
      "ID": 4343
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4939,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus",
      "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6789622+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325386",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 325386,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1947,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 92,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234",
      "ID": 4343
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5074,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon",
      "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.4964581+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1828E3P10VM233258",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 233258,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1947,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 92,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234",
      "ID": 4343
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1828,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo",
      "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1162562+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311694",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311694,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1947,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 92,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234",
      "ID": 4343
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4948,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike",
      "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8902373+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2117E90P107VM229688",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229688,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1947,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 92,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234",
      "ID": 4343
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2117,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis",
      "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0924094+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267476",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 267476,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1947,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 92,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234",
      "ID": 4343
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken",
      "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0214782+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313467",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313467,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1947,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 92,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234",
      "ID": 4343
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4966,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek",
      "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.396624+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3101E102P129VM294962",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 294962,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1947,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 92,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234",
      "ID": 4343
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3101,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala",
      "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1862322+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319146",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319146,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1947,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 92,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234",
      "ID": 4343
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5034,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny",
      "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6944187+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306265",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306265,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1947,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 92,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234",
      "ID": 4343
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2159,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Martin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5446332+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5110E252P395VM310744",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 310744,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1947,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 92,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234",
      "ID": 4343
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Mason",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5841796+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268128",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 268128,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1947,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 92,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234",
      "ID": 4343
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2133,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0573918+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2876E141P433VM286447",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286447,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1947,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 92,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234",
      "ID": 4343
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2876,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5796015+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4951E147P368VM258559",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258559,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1947,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 92,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234",
      "ID": 4343
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4951,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan",
      "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.312469+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3896E175P307VM263785",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 263785,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1947,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 92,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234",
      "ID": 4343
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3896,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam",
      "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9046251+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308744",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 308744,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1947,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 92,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234",
      "ID": 4343
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0691049+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4964E143P375VM279765",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279765,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1947,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 92,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234",
      "ID": 4343
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4964,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5217008+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279556",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279556,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1947,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 92,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234",
      "ID": 4343
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3824,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5127783+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2066E22P91VM261004",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261004,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1947,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 92,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234",
      "ID": 4343
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2066,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.1075027+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299552",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 299552,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1947,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 92,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234",
      "ID": 4343
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7023481+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306776",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306776,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1947,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 92,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234",
      "ID": 4343
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina",
      "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.566917+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300559",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 300559,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1947,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 92,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234",
      "ID": 4343
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2487,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.003817+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223943",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223943,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1947,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 92,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234",
      "ID": 4343
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4852652+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237892",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237892,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1947,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 92,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234",
      "ID": 4343
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1961,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David",
      "DisplayName": "David McLetchie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2305656+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305602",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 305602,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1947,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 92,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234",
      "ID": 4343
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2134,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3314417+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320124",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 320124,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1947,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 92,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234",
      "ID": 4343
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5041,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan",
      "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.962719+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315861",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315861,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1947,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 92,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234",
      "ID": 4343
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3763,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart",
      "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9302311+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1986E23P197VM236746",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 236746,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1947,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 92,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234",
      "ID": 4343
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1986,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan",
      "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9382794+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5047E100P130VM289759",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289759,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1947,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 92,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234",
      "ID": 4343
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5047,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne",
      "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4578938+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234481",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234481,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1947,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 92,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234",
      "ID": 4343
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1845,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette",
      "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3861163+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313121",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313121,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1947,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 92,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234",
      "ID": 4343
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3061,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1645589+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1768E19P265VM289377",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289377,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1947,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 92,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234",
      "ID": 4343
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1768,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4346171+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225337",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225337,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1947,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 92,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234",
      "ID": 4343
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1894,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Neil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9702244+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3815E98P134VM270979",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270979,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1947,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 92,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234",
      "ID": 4343
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3815,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Park, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Park",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8373345+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265768",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265768,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1947,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 92,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234",
      "ID": 4343
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2010,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil",
      "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4536394+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283223",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283223,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1947,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 92,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234",
      "ID": 4343
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5057,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.6911666+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2853E33P128VM252027",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252027,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1947,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 92,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234",
      "ID": 4343
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Pentland",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4994269+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317346",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317346,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1947,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 92,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234",
      "ID": 4343
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5009,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4181558+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254276",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254276,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1947,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 92,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234",
      "ID": 4343
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3745,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis",
      "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2485703+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1870E225P478VM296279",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 296279,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1947,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 92,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234",
      "ID": 4343
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1870,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona",
      "DisplayName": "Shona Robison",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8418057+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2135E254P450VM235470",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235470,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1947,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 92,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234",
      "ID": 4343
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2135,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Russell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6792248+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1895E232P431VM257687",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257687,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1947,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 92,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234",
      "ID": 4343
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1895,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0672391+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228537",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 228537,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1947,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 92,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234",
      "ID": 4343
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1839,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.8033644+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2345E10P55VM291565",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291565,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1947,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 92,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234",
      "ID": 4343
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2345,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.132847+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311503",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311503,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1947,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 92,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234",
      "ID": 4343
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2223,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish",
      "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8816675+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246452",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 246452,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1947,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 92,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234",
      "ID": 4343
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2182,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1293293+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298053",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298053,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1947,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 92,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234",
      "ID": 4343
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5079,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew",
      "DisplayName": "Drew Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1362469+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234082",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234082,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1947,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 92,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234",
      "ID": 4343
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1769,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1658671+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274681",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274681,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1947,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 92,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234",
      "ID": 4343
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4014,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz",
      "DisplayName": "Liz Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1171263+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269642",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269642,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1947,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 92,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234",
      "ID": 4343
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2215,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5567244+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317687",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317687,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1947,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 92,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234",
      "ID": 4343
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3806,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4330995+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326444",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 326444,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1947,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 92,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234",
      "ID": 4343
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5106,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin",
      "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7649721+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241243",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241243,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1947,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 92,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234",
      "ID": 4343
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1848,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola",
      "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7491878+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2098E237P531VM290414",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 290414,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1947,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 92,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234",
      "ID": 4343
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2098,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Swinney",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7460752+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248036",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248036,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1947,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 92,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234",
      "ID": 4343
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2674,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave",
      "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4390058+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5075E234P371VM287488",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 287488,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1947,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 92,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234",
      "ID": 4343
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5075,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Torrance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.866329+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1793E151P362VM222581",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 222581,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1947,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 92,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234",
      "ID": 4343
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1793,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean",
      "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1950949+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5078E245P7VM306950",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306950,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1947,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 92,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234",
      "ID": 4343
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5078,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Walker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5808653+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1841E231P426VM239881",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239881,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1947,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 92,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234",
      "ID": 4343
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1841,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen",
      "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7633451+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283749",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283749,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1947,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 92,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234",
      "ID": 4343
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4952,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7218313+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1865E263P500VM231785",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231785,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1947,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 92,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234",
      "ID": 4343
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1865,
      "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra",
      "DisplayName": "Sandra White",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6154304+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237368",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237368,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1947,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 92,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234",
      "ID": 4343
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2610,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Wilson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2011866+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4941E150P382VM308988",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 308988,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1947,
      "AgendaID": 2880,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 92,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Consultation on the Carloway Report (Reforming Scots Criminal Law and Practice)",
      "Reference": "S4M-04234",
      "ID": 4343
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4941,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza",
      "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0866924+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252657",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252657,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1943,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165.2",
      "ID": 4299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1926,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian",
      "DisplayName": "Brian Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7388896+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2615E213P388VM258853",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258853,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1943,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165.2",
      "ID": 4299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2615,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George",
      "DisplayName": "George Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3307105+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319845",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319845,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1943,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165.2",
      "ID": 4299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4940,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare",
      "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.943861+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249600",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 249600,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1943,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165.2",
      "ID": 4299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2641,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair",
      "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9338211+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1783E21P273VM227768",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227768,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1943,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165.2",
      "ID": 4299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1783,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie",
      "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5648053+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2633E97P136VM280771",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280771,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1943,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165.2",
      "ID": 4299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2633,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire",
      "DisplayName": "Claire Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7817095+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262730",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262730,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1943,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165.2",
      "ID": 4299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2603,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6143919+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1759E91P115VM229816",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229816,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1943,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165.2",
      "ID": 4299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia",
      "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0986428+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270174",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270174,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1943,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165.2",
      "ID": 4299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3751,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5847423+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322734",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 322734,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1943,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165.2",
      "ID": 4299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5109,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco",
      "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.701356+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5060E86P124VM295267",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295267,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1943,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165.2",
      "ID": 4299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5060,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.504647+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242908",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242908,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1943,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165.2",
      "ID": 4299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1866,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah",
      "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0407166+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235547",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235547,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1943,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165.2",
      "ID": 4299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1943,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic",
      "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6825187+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302382",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 302382,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1943,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165.2",
      "ID": 4299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2595,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin",
      "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5219801+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244273",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244273,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1943,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165.2",
      "ID": 4299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2103,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith",
      "DisplayName": "Keith Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5475573+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327151",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 327151,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1943,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165.2",
      "ID": 4299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.8013364+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277069",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277069,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1943,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165.2",
      "ID": 4299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6997582+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264260",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264260,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1943,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165.2",
      "ID": 4299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2673,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick",
      "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1256229+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248771",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248771,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1943,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165.2",
      "ID": 4299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2678,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson",
      "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6692939+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2123E27P233VM295776",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295776,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1943,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165.2",
      "ID": 4299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2123,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm",
      "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5354036+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285234",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285234,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1943,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165.2",
      "ID": 4299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3907,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3141701+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230710",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230710,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1943,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165.2",
      "ID": 4299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1735,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela",
      "DisplayName": "Angela Constance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3422191+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243811",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 243811,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1943,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165.2",
      "ID": 4299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1932,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce",
      "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3207498+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254864",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254864,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1943,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165.2",
      "ID": 4299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1863,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna",
      "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2870756+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323758",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 323758,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1943,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165.2",
      "ID": 4299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4976,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth",
      "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.970643+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5107E223P379VM291254",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291254,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1943,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165.2",
      "ID": 4299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5107,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1109354+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3743E222P391VM265406",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265406,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1943,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165.2",
      "ID": 4299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3743,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel",
      "DisplayName": "Nigel Don",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4378118+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262253",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262253,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1943,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165.2",
      "ID": 4299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3771,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob",
      "DisplayName": "Bob Doris",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.5935208+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281970",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 281970,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1943,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165.2",
      "ID": 4299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2826,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Dornan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.165613+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298002",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298002,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1943,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165.2",
      "ID": 4299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3812,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia",
      "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.134078+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231222",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231222,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1943,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165.2",
      "ID": 4299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1778,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen",
      "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.585667+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4955E240P389VM285860",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285860,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1943,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165.2",
      "ID": 4299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4955,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3476537+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219390",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 219390,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1943,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165.2",
      "ID": 4299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1742,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle",
      "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.2965995+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238574",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 238574,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1943,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165.2",
      "ID": 4299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1994,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus",
      "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4599988+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225406",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225406,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1943,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165.2",
      "ID": 4299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1814,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda",
      "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9733492+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321726",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 321726,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1943,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165.2",
      "ID": 4299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Fee",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4487834+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292797",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 292797,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1943,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165.2",
      "ID": 4299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia",
      "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5585457+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227116",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227116,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1943,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165.2",
      "ID": 4299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2685047+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5054E95P118VM312741",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 312741,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1943,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165.2",
      "ID": 4299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5054,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1413301+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4947E152P361VM257220",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257220,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1943,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165.2",
      "ID": 4299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4947,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Finnie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0467346+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271215",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271215,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1943,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165.2",
      "ID": 4299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3901,
      "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe",
      "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0606059+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278415",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 278415,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1943,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165.2",
      "ID": 4299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2394,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo",
      "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.217815+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2110E220P414VM287277",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 287277,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1943,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165.2",
      "ID": 4299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth",
      "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8572611+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250498",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250498,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1943,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165.2",
      "ID": 4299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2675,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob",
      "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1921323+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1741E10P50VM220965",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220965,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1943,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165.2",
      "ID": 4299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1741,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel",
      "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6692782+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220253",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220253,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1943,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165.2",
      "ID": 4299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1756,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine",
      "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6304461+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1860E104P150VM252402",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252402,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1943,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165.2",
      "ID": 4299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1860,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda",
      "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7276258+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2033E20P141VM266102",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 266102,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1943,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165.2",
      "ID": 4299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2033,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain",
      "DisplayName": "Iain Gray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4744192+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324647",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324647,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1943,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165.2",
      "ID": 4299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5042,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2319404+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259718",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 259718,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1943,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165.2",
      "ID": 4299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick",
      "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6215421+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239323",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239323,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1943,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165.2",
      "ID": 4299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2029,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh",
      "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7318631+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273731",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 273731,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1943,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165.2",
      "ID": 4299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3758,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6332374+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304103",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 304103,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1943,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165.2",
      "ID": 4299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4086,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Hume",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8497937+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221730",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221730,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1943,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165.2",
      "ID": 4299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1773,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9453139+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1882E227P459VM241963",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241963,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1943,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165.2",
      "ID": 4299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1882,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam",
      "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7878978+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223706",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223706,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1943,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165.2",
      "ID": 4299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1893,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4702794+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307586",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307586,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1943,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165.2",
      "ID": 4299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4934,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8359137+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272235",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 272235,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1943,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165.2",
      "ID": 4299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4956,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Keir",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3208477+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244917",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244917,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1943,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165.2",
      "ID": 4299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Kelly",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5841463+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315087",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315087,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1943,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165.2",
      "ID": 4299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3129,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6735121+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247945",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247945,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1943,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165.2",
      "ID": 4299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann",
      "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4351072+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4016E11P36VM275025",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 275025,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1943,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165.2",
      "ID": 4299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4016,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1379228+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255795",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255795,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1943,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165.2",
      "ID": 4299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2180,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5572848+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4938E158P374VM277374",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277374,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1943,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165.2",
      "ID": 4299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4938,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9506439+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2112E250P486VM253017",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253017,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1943,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165.2",
      "ID": 4299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2112,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny",
      "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.763267+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4939E258P394VM276760",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276760,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1943,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165.2",
      "ID": 4299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4939,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus",
      "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6799456+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325484",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 325484,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1943,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165.2",
      "ID": 4299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5074,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon",
      "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5083757+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1828E3P10VM232905",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232905,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1943,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165.2",
      "ID": 4299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1828,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo",
      "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8816918+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311432",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311432,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1943,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165.2",
      "ID": 4299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4948,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike",
      "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8785578+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2117E90P107VM230406",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230406,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1943,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165.2",
      "ID": 4299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2117,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis",
      "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3284247+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267369",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 267369,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1943,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165.2",
      "ID": 4299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken",
      "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0165756+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313729",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313729,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1943,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165.2",
      "ID": 4299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4966,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek",
      "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4081511+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3101E102P129VM295072",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295072,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1943,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165.2",
      "ID": 4299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3101,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala",
      "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.190989+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5034E88P114VM318976",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 318976,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1943,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165.2",
      "ID": 4299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5034,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny",
      "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6870902+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306399",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306399,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1943,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165.2",
      "ID": 4299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2159,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Martin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5504184+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5110E252P395VM310799",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 310799,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1943,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165.2",
      "ID": 4299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Mason",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5865373+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268234",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 268234,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1943,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165.2",
      "ID": 4299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2133,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2546441+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2876E141P433VM286338",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286338,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1943,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165.2",
      "ID": 4299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2876,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5745149+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4951E147P368VM258636",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258636,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1943,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165.2",
      "ID": 4299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4951,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan",
      "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.316033+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3896E175P307VM263886",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 263886,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1943,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165.2",
      "ID": 4299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3896,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam",
      "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9150132+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308533",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 308533,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1943,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165.2",
      "ID": 4299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0600161+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4964E143P375VM279742",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279742,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1943,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165.2",
      "ID": 4299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4964,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.520668+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279603",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279603,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1943,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165.2",
      "ID": 4299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3824,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5147649+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2066E22P91VM261072",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261072,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1943,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165.2",
      "ID": 4299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2066,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.1106021+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299661",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 299661,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1943,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165.2",
      "ID": 4299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7073331+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306719",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306719,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1943,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165.2",
      "ID": 4299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina",
      "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5644673+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300615",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 300615,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1943,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165.2",
      "ID": 4299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2487,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.006227+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223868",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223868,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1943,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165.2",
      "ID": 4299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.477241+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237495",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237495,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1943,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165.2",
      "ID": 4299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1961,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David",
      "DisplayName": "David McLetchie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2130789+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305468",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 305468,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1943,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165.2",
      "ID": 4299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2134,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3253952+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320605",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 320605,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1943,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165.2",
      "ID": 4299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5041,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan",
      "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1735975+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315995",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315995,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1943,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165.2",
      "ID": 4299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3763,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart",
      "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9412138+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1986E23P197VM236697",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 236697,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1943,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165.2",
      "ID": 4299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1986,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan",
      "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9361848+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5047E100P130VM289807",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289807,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1943,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165.2",
      "ID": 4299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5047,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne",
      "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4599308+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234535",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234535,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1943,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165.2",
      "ID": 4299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1845,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette",
      "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3884807+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313565",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313565,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1943,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165.2",
      "ID": 4299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3061,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4008689+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1768E19P265VM289323",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289323,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1943,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165.2",
      "ID": 4299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1768,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4323299+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225079",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225079,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1943,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165.2",
      "ID": 4299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1894,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Neil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7435892+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3815E98P134VM270959",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270959,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1943,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165.2",
      "ID": 4299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3815,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Park, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Park",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8364513+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265821",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265821,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1943,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165.2",
      "ID": 4299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2010,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil",
      "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4559429+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283246",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283246,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1943,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165.2",
      "ID": 4299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5057,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.6921602+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2853E33P128VM251468",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251468,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1943,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165.2",
      "ID": 4299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Pentland",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4649579+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317824",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317824,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1943,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165.2",
      "ID": 4299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5009,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4389406+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254665",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254665,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1943,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165.2",
      "ID": 4299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3745,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis",
      "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2663762+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1870E225P478VM296224",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 296224,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1943,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165.2",
      "ID": 4299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1870,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona",
      "DisplayName": "Shona Robison",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8394035+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2135E254P450VM234911",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234911,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1943,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165.2",
      "ID": 4299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2135,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Russell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4050689+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1895E232P431VM257635",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257635,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1943,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165.2",
      "ID": 4299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1895,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.064999+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228153",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 228153,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1943,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165.2",
      "ID": 4299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1839,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5866352+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2345E10P55VM291617",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291617,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1943,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165.2",
      "ID": 4299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2345,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.135025+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311056",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311056,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1943,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165.2",
      "ID": 4299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2223,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish",
      "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.6035192+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246373",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 246373,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1943,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165.2",
      "ID": 4299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2182,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1259413+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298101",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298101,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1943,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165.2",
      "ID": 4299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5079,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew",
      "DisplayName": "Drew Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1382867+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234133",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234133,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1943,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165.2",
      "ID": 4299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1769,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1680522+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274658",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274658,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1943,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165.2",
      "ID": 4299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4014,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz",
      "DisplayName": "Liz Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1161366+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269536",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269536,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1943,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165.2",
      "ID": 4299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2215,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5518702+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317398",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317398,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1943,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165.2",
      "ID": 4299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3806,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4203991+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326346",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 326346,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1943,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165.2",
      "ID": 4299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5106,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin",
      "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7544933+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241166",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241166,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1943,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165.2",
      "ID": 4299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1848,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola",
      "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.4048802+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2098E237P531VM289660",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289660,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1943,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165.2",
      "ID": 4299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2098,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Swinney",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4535133+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2674E247P401VM247785",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247785,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1943,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165.2",
      "ID": 4299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2674,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave",
      "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4283367+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5075E234P371VM287465",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 287465,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1943,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165.2",
      "ID": 4299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5075,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Torrance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8653542+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1793E151P362VM222480",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 222480,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1943,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165.2",
      "ID": 4299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1793,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean",
      "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1907759+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5078E245P7VM306986",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306986,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1943,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165.2",
      "ID": 4299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5078,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Walker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.582399+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1841E231P426VM239957",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239957,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1943,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165.2",
      "ID": 4299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1841,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen",
      "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7665954+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283676",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283676,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1943,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165.2",
      "ID": 4299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4952,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7184863+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1865E263P500VM232196",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232196,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1943,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165.2",
      "ID": 4299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1865,
      "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra",
      "DisplayName": "Sandra White",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6389513+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237768",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237768,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1943,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165.2",
      "ID": 4299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2610,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Wilson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2252889+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309252",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 309252,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1943,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165.2",
      "ID": 4299
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4941,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza",
      "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3213097+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252658",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252658,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1944,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165",
      "ID": 4273
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1926,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian",
      "DisplayName": "Brian Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7389302+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2615E213P388VM258929",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258929,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1944,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165",
      "ID": 4273
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2615,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George",
      "DisplayName": "George Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3343444+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319844",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319844,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1944,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165",
      "ID": 4273
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4940,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare",
      "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9438206+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249599",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 249599,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1944,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165",
      "ID": 4273
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2641,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair",
      "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.93378+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1783E21P273VM227769",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227769,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1944,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165",
      "ID": 4273
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1783,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie",
      "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5648455+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2633E97P136VM280772",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280772,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1944,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165",
      "ID": 4273
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2633,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire",
      "DisplayName": "Claire Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7817491+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262731",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262731,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1944,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165",
      "ID": 4273
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2603,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6144321+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1759E91P115VM229817",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229817,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1944,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165",
      "ID": 4273
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia",
      "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0986837+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3751E243P383VM269788",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269788,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1944,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165",
      "ID": 4273
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3751,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5629606+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322601",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 322601,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1944,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165",
      "ID": 4273
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5109,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco",
      "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6957511+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5060E86P124VM295268",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295268,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1944,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165",
      "ID": 4273
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5060,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5047059+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242909",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242909,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1944,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165",
      "ID": 4273
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1866,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah",
      "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0407565+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235160",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235160,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1944,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165",
      "ID": 4273
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1943,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic",
      "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4219619+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302383",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 302383,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1944,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165",
      "ID": 4273
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2595,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin",
      "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5220201+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244272",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244272,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1944,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165",
      "ID": 4273
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2103,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith",
      "DisplayName": "Keith Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5474977+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327152",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 327152,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1944,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165",
      "ID": 4273
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.8013782+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277070",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277070,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1944,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165",
      "ID": 4273
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6997987+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264259",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264259,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1944,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165",
      "ID": 4273
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2673,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick",
      "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1255818+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248695",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248695,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1944,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165",
      "ID": 4273
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2678,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson",
      "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6658479+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2123E27P233VM295775",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295775,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1944,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165",
      "ID": 4273
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2123,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm",
      "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5353634+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285235",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285235,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1944,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165",
      "ID": 4273
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3907,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3142115+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230711",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230711,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1944,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165",
      "ID": 4273
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1735,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela",
      "DisplayName": "Angela Constance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3422629+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243810",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 243810,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1944,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165",
      "ID": 4273
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1932,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce",
      "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3207107+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254863",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254863,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1944,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165",
      "ID": 4273
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1863,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna",
      "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.287033+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323759",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 323759,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1944,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165",
      "ID": 4273
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4976,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth",
      "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9706835+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5107E223P379VM291253",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291253,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1944,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165",
      "ID": 4273
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5107,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1108943+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3743E222P391VM265407",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265407,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1944,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165",
      "ID": 4273
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3743,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel",
      "DisplayName": "Nigel Don",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4378533+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262330",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262330,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1944,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165",
      "ID": 4273
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3771,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob",
      "DisplayName": "Bob Doris",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.5968188+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281969",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 281969,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1944,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165",
      "ID": 4273
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2826,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Dornan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1655554+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298003",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298003,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1944,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165",
      "ID": 4273
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3812,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia",
      "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1341184+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231221",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231221,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1944,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165",
      "ID": 4273
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1778,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen",
      "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.5856257+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4955E240P389VM285861",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285861,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1944,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165",
      "ID": 4273
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4955,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3476942+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219470",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 219470,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1944,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165",
      "ID": 4273
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1742,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle",
      "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3006459+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238497",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 238497,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1944,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165",
      "ID": 4273
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1994,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus",
      "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4566671+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225405",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225405,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1944,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165",
      "ID": 4273
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1814,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda",
      "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9733079+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321859",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 321859,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1944,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165",
      "ID": 4273
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Fee",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.454413+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292796",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 292796,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1944,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165",
      "ID": 4273
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia",
      "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5585058+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227194",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227194,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1944,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165",
      "ID": 4273
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5348323+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5054E95P118VM312742",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 312742,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1944,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165",
      "ID": 4273
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5054,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1413703+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4947E152P361VM257221",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257221,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1944,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165",
      "ID": 4273
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4947,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Finnie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0467754+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271216",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271216,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1944,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165",
      "ID": 4273
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3901,
      "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe",
      "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0606476+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278414",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 278414,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1944,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165",
      "ID": 4273
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2394,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo",
      "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2177724+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2110E220P414VM287278",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 287278,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1944,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165",
      "ID": 4273
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth",
      "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8573032+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250499",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250499,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1944,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165",
      "ID": 4273
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2675,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob",
      "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1921729+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1741E10P50VM220966",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220966,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1944,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165",
      "ID": 4273
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1741,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel",
      "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6693189+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220175",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220175,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1944,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165",
      "ID": 4273
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1756,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine",
      "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3375745+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1860E104P150VM252403",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252403,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1944,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165",
      "ID": 4273
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1860,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda",
      "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7276671+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2033E20P141VM266101",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 266101,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1944,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165",
      "ID": 4273
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2033,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain",
      "DisplayName": "Iain Gray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4743787+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324646",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324646,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1944,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165",
      "ID": 4273
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5042,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2319008+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259642",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 259642,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1944,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165",
      "ID": 4273
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick",
      "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6182556+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239399",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239399,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1944,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165",
      "ID": 4273
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2029,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh",
      "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7351257+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273730",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 273730,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1944,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165",
      "ID": 4273
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3758,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.633197+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304102",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 304102,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1944,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165",
      "ID": 4273
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4086,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Hume",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8497536+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221729",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221729,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1944,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165",
      "ID": 4273
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1773,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9452552+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1882E227P459VM241962",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241962,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1944,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165",
      "ID": 4273
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1882,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam",
      "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7878573+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223473",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223473,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1944,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165",
      "ID": 4273
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1893,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4598569+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307587",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307587,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1944,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165",
      "ID": 4273
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4934,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8359576+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272236",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 272236,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1944,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165",
      "ID": 4273
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4956,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Keir",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3209142+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244918",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244918,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1944,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165",
      "ID": 4273
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Kelly",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5841864+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315088",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315088,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1944,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165",
      "ID": 4273
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3129,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6735528+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247869",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247869,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1944,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165",
      "ID": 4273
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann",
      "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4318933+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4016E11P36VM275024",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 275024,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1944,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165",
      "ID": 4273
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4016,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.137882+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255565",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255565,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1944,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165",
      "ID": 4273
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2180,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5367862+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4938E158P374VM277375",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277375,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1944,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165",
      "ID": 4273
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4938,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9506866+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2112E250P486VM253399",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253399,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1944,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165",
      "ID": 4273
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2112,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny",
      "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.9947482+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4939E258P394VM276759",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276759,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1944,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165",
      "ID": 4273
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4939,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus",
      "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6799045+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325485",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 325485,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1944,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165",
      "ID": 4273
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5074,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon",
      "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5084163+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1828E3P10VM232906",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232906,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1944,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165",
      "ID": 4273
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1828,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo",
      "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8817506+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311651",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311651,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1944,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165",
      "ID": 4273
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4948,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike",
      "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8883521+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2117E90P107VM229711",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229711,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1944,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165",
      "ID": 4273
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2117,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis",
      "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0933772+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267370",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 267370,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1944,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165",
      "ID": 4273
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken",
      "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0166221+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313510",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313510,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1944,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165",
      "ID": 4273
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4966,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek",
      "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.3984838+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3101E102P129VM295071",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295071,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1944,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165",
      "ID": 4273
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3101,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala",
      "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1909486+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319108",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319108,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1944,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165",
      "ID": 4273
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5034,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny",
      "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6927795+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306398",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306398,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1944,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165",
      "ID": 4273
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2159,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Martin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5503777+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5110E252P395VM310798",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 310798,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1944,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165",
      "ID": 4273
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Mason",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5864975+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268233",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 268233,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1944,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165",
      "ID": 4273
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2133,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2545839+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2876E141P433VM286339",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286339,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1944,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165",
      "ID": 4273
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2876,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5745555+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4951E147P368VM258635",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258635,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1944,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165",
      "ID": 4273
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4951,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan",
      "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3159919+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3896E175P307VM263807",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 263807,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1944,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165",
      "ID": 4273
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3896,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam",
      "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9055656+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308534",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 308534,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1944,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165",
      "ID": 4273
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0600563+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4964E143P375VM279743",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279743,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1944,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165",
      "ID": 4273
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4964,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5207081+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279602",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279602,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1944,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165",
      "ID": 4273
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3824,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5147249+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2066E22P91VM261071",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261071,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1944,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165",
      "ID": 4273
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2066,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.110561+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299660",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 299660,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1944,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165",
      "ID": 4273
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.707291+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306720",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306720,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1944,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165",
      "ID": 4273
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina",
      "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5645081+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300614",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 300614,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1944,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165",
      "ID": 4273
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2487,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0061873+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223869",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223869,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1944,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165",
      "ID": 4273
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4772812+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237869",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237869,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1944,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165",
      "ID": 4273
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1961,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David",
      "DisplayName": "David McLetchie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2295781+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305469",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 305469,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1944,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165",
      "ID": 4273
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2134,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3254362+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320318",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 320318,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1944,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165",
      "ID": 4273
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5041,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan",
      "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1548505+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315994",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315994,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1944,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165",
      "ID": 4273
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3763,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart",
      "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.941173+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1986E23P197VM236698",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 236698,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1944,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165",
      "ID": 4273
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1986,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan",
      "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9362263+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5047E100P130VM289806",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289806,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1944,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165",
      "ID": 4273
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5047,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne",
      "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4598912+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234534",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234534,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1944,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165",
      "ID": 4273
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1845,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette",
      "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3884388+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313564",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313564,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1944,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165",
      "ID": 4273
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3061,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.400827+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1768E19P265VM289324",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289324,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1944,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165",
      "ID": 4273
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1768,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4323716+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225314",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225314,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1944,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165",
      "ID": 4273
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1894,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Neil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9640471+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3815E98P134VM270958",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270958,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1944,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165",
      "ID": 4273
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3815,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Park, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Park",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8364105+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265820",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265820,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1944,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165",
      "ID": 4273
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2010,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil",
      "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4559015+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283245",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283245,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1944,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165",
      "ID": 4273
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5057,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.6921194+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2853E33P128VM251544",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251544,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1944,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165",
      "ID": 4273
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Pentland",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4682817+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317539",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317539,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1944,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165",
      "ID": 4273
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5009,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.426802+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254664",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254664,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1944,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165",
      "ID": 4273
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3745,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis",
      "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2663127+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1870E225P478VM296225",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 296225,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1944,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165",
      "ID": 4273
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1870,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona",
      "DisplayName": "Shona Robison",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8394452+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2135E254P450VM235448",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235448,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1944,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165",
      "ID": 4273
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2135,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Russell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6782821+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1895E232P431VM257636",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257636,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1944,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165",
      "ID": 4273
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1895,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0650397+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228154",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 228154,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1944,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165",
      "ID": 4273
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1839,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5866757+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2345E10P55VM291616",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291616,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1944,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165",
      "ID": 4273
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2345,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1349858+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311057",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311057,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1944,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165",
      "ID": 4273
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2223,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish",
      "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.6035594+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246374",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 246374,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1944,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165",
      "ID": 4273
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2182,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1259821+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298100",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298100,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1944,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165",
      "ID": 4273
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5079,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew",
      "DisplayName": "Drew Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1382458+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234132",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234132,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1944,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165",
      "ID": 4273
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1769,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1680113+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274659",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274659,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1944,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165",
      "ID": 4273
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4014,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz",
      "DisplayName": "Liz Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1161802+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269537",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269537,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1944,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165",
      "ID": 4273
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2215,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5519112+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317399",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317399,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1944,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165",
      "ID": 4273
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3806,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4204391+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326345",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 326345,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1944,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165",
      "ID": 4273
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5106,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin",
      "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7544515+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241167",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241167,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1944,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165",
      "ID": 4273
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1848,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola",
      "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.4049211+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2098E237P531VM289661",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289661,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1944,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165",
      "ID": 4273
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2098,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Swinney",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4535527+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248014",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248014,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1944,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165",
      "ID": 4273
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2674,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave",
      "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4380645+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5075E234P371VM287466",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 287466,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1944,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165",
      "ID": 4273
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5075,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Torrance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8653944+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1793E151P362VM222558",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 222558,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1944,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165",
      "ID": 4273
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1793,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean",
      "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1941137+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5078E245P7VM306985",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306985,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1944,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165",
      "ID": 4273
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5078,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Walker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.582359+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1841E231P426VM239956",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239956,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1944,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165",
      "ID": 4273
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1841,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen",
      "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7665556+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283675",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283675,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1944,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165",
      "ID": 4273
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4952,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7184459+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1865E263P500VM232195",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232195,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1944,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165",
      "ID": 4273
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1865,
      "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra",
      "DisplayName": "Sandra White",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6389108+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237390",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237390,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1944,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165",
      "ID": 4273
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2610,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Wilson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2021333+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309186",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 309186,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1944,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Rail",
      "Reference": "S4M-04165",
      "ID": 4273
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4941,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza",
      "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0957163+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252706",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252706,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1945,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161.1",
      "ID": 4298
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1926,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian",
      "DisplayName": "Brian Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7500778+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2615E213P388VM258930",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258930,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1945,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161.1",
      "ID": 4298
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2615,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George",
      "DisplayName": "George Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3343845+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319843",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319843,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1945,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161.1",
      "ID": 4298
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4940,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare",
      "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9437793+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249598",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 249598,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1945,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161.1",
      "ID": 4298
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2641,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair",
      "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9337399+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1783E21P273VM227824",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227824,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1945,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161.1",
      "ID": 4298
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1783,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie",
      "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5672128+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2633E97P136VM280825",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280825,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1945,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161.1",
      "ID": 4298
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2633,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire",
      "DisplayName": "Claire Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7839912+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262732",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262732,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1945,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161.1",
      "ID": 4298
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2603,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6144725+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1759E91P115VM229818",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229818,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1945,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161.1",
      "ID": 4298
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia",
      "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0987243+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3751E243P383VM269787",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269787,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1945,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161.1",
      "ID": 4298
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3751,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5629204+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322631",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 322631,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1945,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161.1",
      "ID": 4298
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5109,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco",
      "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6970172+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5060E86P124VM295269",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295269,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1945,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161.1",
      "ID": 4298
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5060,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5047478+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242910",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242910,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1945,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161.1",
      "ID": 4298
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1866,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah",
      "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0408154+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235159",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235159,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1945,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161.1",
      "ID": 4298
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1943,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic",
      "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4219215+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302384",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 302384,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1945,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161.1",
      "ID": 4298
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2595,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin",
      "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5220605+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244271",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244271,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1945,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161.1",
      "ID": 4298
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2103,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith",
      "DisplayName": "Keith Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5474561+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327153",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 327153,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1945,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161.1",
      "ID": 4298
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.801462+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277071",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277071,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1945,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161.1",
      "ID": 4298
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.699839+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264258",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264258,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1945,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161.1",
      "ID": 4298
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2673,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick",
      "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1255411+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248694",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248694,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1945,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161.1",
      "ID": 4298
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2678,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson",
      "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6658078+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2123E27P233VM295774",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295774,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1945,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161.1",
      "ID": 4298
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2123,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm",
      "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5353229+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285236",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285236,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1945,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161.1",
      "ID": 4298
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3907,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3142535+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230712",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230712,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1945,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161.1",
      "ID": 4298
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1735,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela",
      "DisplayName": "Angela Constance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3423039+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243809",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 243809,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1945,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161.1",
      "ID": 4298
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1932,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce",
      "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3206709+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254862",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254862,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1945,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161.1",
      "ID": 4298
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1863,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna",
      "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2869611+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323760",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 323760,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1945,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161.1",
      "ID": 4298
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4976,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth",
      "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9707256+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5107E223P379VM291252",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291252,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1945,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161.1",
      "ID": 4298
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5107,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1108537+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3743E222P391VM265408",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265408,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1945,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161.1",
      "ID": 4298
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3743,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel",
      "DisplayName": "Nigel Don",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4378945+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262331",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262331,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1945,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161.1",
      "ID": 4298
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3771,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob",
      "DisplayName": "Bob Doris",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.5968596+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281915",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 281915,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1945,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161.1",
      "ID": 4298
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2826,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Dornan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1632668+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298211",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298211,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1945,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161.1",
      "ID": 4298
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3812,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia",
      "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3359654+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231220",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231220,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1945,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161.1",
      "ID": 4298
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1778,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen",
      "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.585584+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4955E240P389VM285859",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285859,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1945,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161.1",
      "ID": 4298
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4955,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3476131+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219471",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 219471,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1945,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161.1",
      "ID": 4298
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1742,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle",
      "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3006871+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238496",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 238496,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1945,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161.1",
      "ID": 4298
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1994,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus",
      "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4566072+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225404",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225404,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1945,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161.1",
      "ID": 4298
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1814,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda",
      "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9732669+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321829",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 321829,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1945,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161.1",
      "ID": 4298
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Fee",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4531304+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292795",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 292795,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1945,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161.1",
      "ID": 4298
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia",
      "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5584655+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227195",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227195,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1945,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161.1",
      "ID": 4298
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5348899+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5054E95P118VM312743",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 312743,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1945,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161.1",
      "ID": 4298
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5054,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.141411+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4947E152P361VM257222",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257222,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1945,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161.1",
      "ID": 4298
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4947,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Finnie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0468166+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271214",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271214,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1945,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161.1",
      "ID": 4298
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3901,
      "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe",
      "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0605628+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278052",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 278052,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1945,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161.1",
      "ID": 4298
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2394,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo",
      "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9849265+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2110E220P414VM287279",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 287279,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1945,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161.1",
      "ID": 4298
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth",
      "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8573435+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250500",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250500,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1945,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161.1",
      "ID": 4298
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2675,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob",
      "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1922143+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1741E10P50VM220967",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220967,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1945,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161.1",
      "ID": 4298
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1741,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel",
      "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6693591+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220174",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220174,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1945,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161.1",
      "ID": 4298
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1756,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine",
      "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3375335+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1860E104P150VM252404",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252404,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1945,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161.1",
      "ID": 4298
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1860,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda",
      "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7277075+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2033E20P141VM253819",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253819,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1945,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161.1",
      "ID": 4298
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2033,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain",
      "DisplayName": "Iain Gray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0222431+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324645",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324645,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1945,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161.1",
      "ID": 4298
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5042,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2318611+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259641",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 259641,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1945,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161.1",
      "ID": 4298
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick",
      "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6182138+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239400",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239400,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1945,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161.1",
      "ID": 4298
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2029,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh",
      "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7351667+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273729",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 273729,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1945,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161.1",
      "ID": 4298
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3758,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6331561+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304101",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 304101,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1945,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161.1",
      "ID": 4298
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4086,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Hume",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8497137+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221728",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221728,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1945,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161.1",
      "ID": 4298
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1773,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9452153+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1882E227P459VM241961",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241961,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1945,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161.1",
      "ID": 4298
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1882,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam",
      "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7878163+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223472",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223472,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1945,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161.1",
      "ID": 4298
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1893,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4596848+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307794",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307794,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1945,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161.1",
      "ID": 4298
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4934,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8452108+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272237",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 272237,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1945,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161.1",
      "ID": 4298
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4956,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Keir",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3209567+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244919",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244919,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1945,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161.1",
      "ID": 4298
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Kelly",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5842261+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315089",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315089,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1945,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161.1",
      "ID": 4298
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3129,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6735931+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247868",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247868,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1945,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161.1",
      "ID": 4298
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann",
      "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.431853+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4016E11P36VM275026",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 275026,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1945,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161.1",
      "ID": 4298
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4016,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1379642+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255564",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255564,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1945,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161.1",
      "ID": 4298
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2180,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5367449+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4938E158P374VM277373",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277373,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1945,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161.1",
      "ID": 4298
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4938,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9505812+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2112E250P486VM253400",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253400,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1945,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161.1",
      "ID": 4298
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2112,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny",
      "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.9947915+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4939E258P394VM276758",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276758,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1945,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161.1",
      "ID": 4298
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4939,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus",
      "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6798639+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325486",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 325486,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1945,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161.1",
      "ID": 4298
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5074,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon",
      "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5084565+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1828E3P10VM232907",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232907,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1945,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161.1",
      "ID": 4298
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1828,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo",
      "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8817929+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311486",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311486,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1945,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161.1",
      "ID": 4298
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4948,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike",
      "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8809183+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2117E90P107VM229710",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229710,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1945,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161.1",
      "ID": 4298
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2117,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis",
      "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.093337+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267424",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 267424,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1945,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161.1",
      "ID": 4298
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken",
      "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0192135+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313523",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313523,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1945,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161.1",
      "ID": 4298
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4966,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek",
      "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.399039+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3101E102P129VM295016",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295016,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1945,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161.1",
      "ID": 4298
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3101,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala",
      "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.188586+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319079",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319079,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1945,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161.1",
      "ID": 4298
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5034,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny",
      "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6915475+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306397",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306397,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1945,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161.1",
      "ID": 4298
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2159,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Martin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5503365+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5110E252P395VM310797",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 310797,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1945,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161.1",
      "ID": 4298
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Mason",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.586457+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268180",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 268180,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1945,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161.1",
      "ID": 4298
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2133,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0596699+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2876E141P433VM286393",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286393,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1945,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161.1",
      "ID": 4298
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2876,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5772222+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4951E147P368VM258634",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258634,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1945,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161.1",
      "ID": 4298
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4951,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan",
      "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3159512+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3896E175P307VM263806",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 263806,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1945,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161.1",
      "ID": 4298
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3896,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam",
      "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9055246+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308535",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 308535,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1945,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161.1",
      "ID": 4298
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0600965+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4964E143P375VM279744",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279744,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1945,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161.1",
      "ID": 4298
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4964,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5207488+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279601",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279601,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1945,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161.1",
      "ID": 4298
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3824,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5146848+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2066E22P91VM261070",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261070,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1945,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161.1",
      "ID": 4298
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2066,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.1105188+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299607",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 299607,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1945,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161.1",
      "ID": 4298
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7050187+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306721",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306721,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1945,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161.1",
      "ID": 4298
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina",
      "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5645489+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300613",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 300613,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1945,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161.1",
      "ID": 4298
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2487,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0061475+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223870",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223870,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1945,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161.1",
      "ID": 4298
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4773218+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237870",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237870,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1945,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161.1",
      "ID": 4298
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1961,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David",
      "DisplayName": "David McLetchie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2296198+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305470",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 305470,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1945,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161.1",
      "ID": 4298
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2134,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3254761+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320347",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 320347,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1945,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161.1",
      "ID": 4298
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5041,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan",
      "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1561002+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315993",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315993,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1945,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161.1",
      "ID": 4298
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3763,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart",
      "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9411319+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1986E23P197VM236699",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 236699,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1945,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161.1",
      "ID": 4298
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1986,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan",
      "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9362675+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5047E100P130VM289805",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289805,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1945,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161.1",
      "ID": 4298
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5047,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne",
      "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4598515+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234533",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234533,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1945,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161.1",
      "ID": 4298
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1845,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette",
      "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3883973+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313563",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313563,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1945,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161.1",
      "ID": 4298
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3061,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4007862+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1768E19P265VM289325",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289325,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1945,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161.1",
      "ID": 4298
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1768,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.432412+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225315",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225315,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1945,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161.1",
      "ID": 4298
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1894,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Neil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9692128+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3815E98P134VM270960",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270960,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1945,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161.1",
      "ID": 4298
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3815,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Park, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Park",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8364913+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265819",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265819,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1945,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161.1",
      "ID": 4298
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2010,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil",
      "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4558605+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283244",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283244,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1945,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161.1",
      "ID": 4298
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5057,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.6920787+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2853E33P128VM251545",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251545,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1945,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161.1",
      "ID": 4298
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Pentland",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.468323+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317568",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317568,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1945,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161.1",
      "ID": 4298
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5009,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4280464+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254663",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254663,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1945,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161.1",
      "ID": 4298
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3745,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis",
      "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2662717+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1870E225P478VM296226",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 296226,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1945,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161.1",
      "ID": 4298
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1870,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona",
      "DisplayName": "Shona Robison",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8395063+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2135E254P450VM235449",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235449,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1945,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161.1",
      "ID": 4298
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2135,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Russell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6783464+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1895E232P431VM257637",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257637,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1945,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161.1",
      "ID": 4298
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1895,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0651015+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228155",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 228155,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1945,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161.1",
      "ID": 4298
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1839,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5867173+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2345E10P55VM291615",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291615,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1945,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161.1",
      "ID": 4298
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2345,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1349467+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311058",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311058,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1945,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161.1",
      "ID": 4298
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2223,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish",
      "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.6036001+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246375",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 246375,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1945,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161.1",
      "ID": 4298
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2182,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1260231+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298099",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298099,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1945,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161.1",
      "ID": 4298
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5079,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew",
      "DisplayName": "Drew Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1382059+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234131",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234131,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1945,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161.1",
      "ID": 4298
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1769,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1679703+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274660",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274660,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1945,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161.1",
      "ID": 4298
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4014,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz",
      "DisplayName": "Liz Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1162231+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269590",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269590,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1945,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161.1",
      "ID": 4298
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2215,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5544239+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317400",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317400,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1945,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161.1",
      "ID": 4298
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3806,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4204795+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326344",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 326344,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1945,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161.1",
      "ID": 4298
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5106,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin",
      "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7544097+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241168",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241168,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1945,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161.1",
      "ID": 4298
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1848,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola",
      "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.4049615+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2098E237P531VM289662",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289662,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1945,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161.1",
      "ID": 4298
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2098,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Swinney",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4536102+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248015",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248015,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1945,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161.1",
      "ID": 4298
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2674,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave",
      "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4381057+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5075E234P371VM287467",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 287467,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1945,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161.1",
      "ID": 4298
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5075,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Torrance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8654346+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1793E151P362VM222559",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 222559,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1945,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161.1",
      "ID": 4298
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1793,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean",
      "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1941541+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5078E245P7VM306984",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306984,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1945,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161.1",
      "ID": 4298
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5078,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Walker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5823181+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1841E231P426VM239955",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239955,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1945,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161.1",
      "ID": 4298
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1841,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen",
      "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7665149+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283677",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283677,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1945,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161.1",
      "ID": 4298
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4952,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7185262+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1865E263P500VM231836",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231836,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1945,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161.1",
      "ID": 4298
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1865,
      "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra",
      "DisplayName": "Sandra White",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6176183+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237389",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237389,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1945,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161.1",
      "ID": 4298
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2610,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Wilson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2020928+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309199",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 309199,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1945,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161.1",
      "ID": 4298
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4941,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza",
      "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0966116+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252707",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252707,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1946,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161",
      "ID": 4269
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1926,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian",
      "DisplayName": "Brian Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7501176+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2615E213P388VM258931",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258931,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1946,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161",
      "ID": 4269
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2615,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George",
      "DisplayName": "George Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3344251+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319842",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319842,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1946,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161",
      "ID": 4269
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4940,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare",
      "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9437378+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249597",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 249597,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1946,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161",
      "ID": 4269
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2641,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair",
      "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9336984+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1783E21P273VM227825",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227825,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1946,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161",
      "ID": 4269
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1783,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie",
      "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5672542+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2633E97P136VM280826",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280826,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1946,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161",
      "ID": 4269
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2633,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire",
      "DisplayName": "Claire Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7840313+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262733",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262733,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1946,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161",
      "ID": 4269
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2603,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6145135+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1759E91P115VM229819",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229819,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1946,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161",
      "ID": 4269
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia",
      "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0987651+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3751E243P383VM269786",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269786,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1946,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161",
      "ID": 4269
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3751,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5628805+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322632",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 322632,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1946,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161",
      "ID": 4269
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5109,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco",
      "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6970576+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5060E86P124VM295270",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295270,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1946,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161",
      "ID": 4269
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5060,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5047886+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242911",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242911,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1946,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161",
      "ID": 4269
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1866,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah",
      "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0408566+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235158",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235158,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1946,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161",
      "ID": 4269
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1943,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic",
      "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4218809+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302385",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 302385,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1946,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161",
      "ID": 4269
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2595,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin",
      "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5221018+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244270",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244270,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1946,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161",
      "ID": 4269
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2103,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith",
      "DisplayName": "Keith Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5474134+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327154",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 327154,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1946,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161",
      "ID": 4269
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.8015075+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277072",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277072,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1946,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161",
      "ID": 4269
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6999006+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264257",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264257,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1946,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161",
      "ID": 4269
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2673,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick",
      "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1255003+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248693",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248693,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1946,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161",
      "ID": 4269
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2678,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson",
      "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6657673+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2123E27P233VM295773",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295773,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1946,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161",
      "ID": 4269
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2123,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm",
      "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5352828+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285237",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285237,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1946,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161",
      "ID": 4269
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3907,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3143146+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230713",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230713,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1946,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161",
      "ID": 4269
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1735,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela",
      "DisplayName": "Angela Constance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3423451+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243808",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 243808,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1946,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161",
      "ID": 4269
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1932,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce",
      "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3206312+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254861",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254861,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1946,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161",
      "ID": 4269
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1863,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna",
      "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2869202+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323761",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 323761,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1946,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161",
      "ID": 4269
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4976,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth",
      "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9707905+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5107E223P379VM291251",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291251,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1946,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161",
      "ID": 4269
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5107,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1108127+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3743E222P391VM265409",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265409,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1946,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161",
      "ID": 4269
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3743,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel",
      "DisplayName": "Nigel Don",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4379358+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262332",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262332,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1946,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161",
      "ID": 4269
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3771,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob",
      "DisplayName": "Bob Doris",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.5969196+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281914",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 281914,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1946,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161",
      "ID": 4269
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2826,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Dornan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1632072+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298212",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298212,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1946,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161",
      "ID": 4269
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3812,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia",
      "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3360095+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231219",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231219,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1946,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161",
      "ID": 4269
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1778,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen",
      "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.5855387+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4955E240P389VM285858",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285858,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1946,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161",
      "ID": 4269
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4955,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3475725+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219472",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 219472,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1946,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161",
      "ID": 4269
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1742,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle",
      "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3007284+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238495",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 238495,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1946,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161",
      "ID": 4269
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1994,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus",
      "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4565663+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225249",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225249,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1946,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161",
      "ID": 4269
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1814,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda",
      "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9612368+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321828",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 321828,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1946,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161",
      "ID": 4269
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Fee",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4530907+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292794",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 292794,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1946,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161",
      "ID": 4269
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia",
      "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5584253+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227196",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227196,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1946,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161",
      "ID": 4269
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5349361+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5054E95P118VM312744",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 312744,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1946,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161",
      "ID": 4269
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5054,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1414743+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4947E152P361VM257223",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257223,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1946,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161",
      "ID": 4269
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4947,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Finnie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0468575+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271213",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271213,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1946,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161",
      "ID": 4269
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3901,
      "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe",
      "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0604956+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278051",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 278051,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1946,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161",
      "ID": 4269
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2394,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo",
      "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9848853+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2110E220P414VM287280",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 287280,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1946,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161",
      "ID": 4269
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth",
      "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8573839+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250501",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250501,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1946,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161",
      "ID": 4269
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2675,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob",
      "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1922548+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1741E10P50VM220968",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220968,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1946,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161",
      "ID": 4269
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1741,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel",
      "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6694006+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220173",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220173,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1946,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161",
      "ID": 4269
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1756,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine",
      "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.337492+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1860E104P150VM252405",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252405,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1946,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161",
      "ID": 4269
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1860,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda",
      "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7277479+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2033E20P141VM253818",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253818,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1946,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161",
      "ID": 4269
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2033,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain",
      "DisplayName": "Iain Gray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0222036+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324644",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324644,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1946,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161",
      "ID": 4269
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5042,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2318211+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259640",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 259640,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1946,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161",
      "ID": 4269
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick",
      "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.618172+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239401",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239401,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1946,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161",
      "ID": 4269
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2029,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh",
      "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7352072+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273728",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 273728,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1946,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161",
      "ID": 4269
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3758,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.633116+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304100",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 304100,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1946,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161",
      "ID": 4269
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4086,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Hume",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8496727+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221727",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221727,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1946,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161",
      "ID": 4269
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1773,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9451753+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1882E227P459VM241960",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241960,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1946,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161",
      "ID": 4269
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1882,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam",
      "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7877757+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223471",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223471,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1946,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161",
      "ID": 4269
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1893,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4596382+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307795",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307795,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1946,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161",
      "ID": 4269
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4934,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8452521+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272238",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 272238,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1946,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161",
      "ID": 4269
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4956,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Keir",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.320998+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244920",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244920,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1946,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161",
      "ID": 4269
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Kelly",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5842667+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315090",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315090,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1946,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161",
      "ID": 4269
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3129,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6736333+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247867",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247867,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1946,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161",
      "ID": 4269
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann",
      "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.431813+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4016E11P36VM275027",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 275027,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1946,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161",
      "ID": 4269
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4016,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.138029+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255563",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255563,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1946,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161",
      "ID": 4269
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2180,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5367039+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4938E158P374VM277372",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277372,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1946,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161",
      "ID": 4269
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4938,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9505401+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2112E250P486VM253401",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253401,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1946,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161",
      "ID": 4269
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2112,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny",
      "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.9948331+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4939E258P394VM276757",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276757,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1946,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161",
      "ID": 4269
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4939,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus",
      "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6798224+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325487",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 325487,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1946,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161",
      "ID": 4269
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5074,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon",
      "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5084964+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1828E3P10VM232908",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232908,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1946,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161",
      "ID": 4269
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1828,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo",
      "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8818338+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311639",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311639,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1946,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161",
      "ID": 4269
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4948,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike",
      "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8878274+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2117E90P107VM229709",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229709,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1946,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161",
      "ID": 4269
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2117,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis",
      "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0932971+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267425",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 267425,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1946,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161",
      "ID": 4269
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken",
      "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0192734+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313522",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313522,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1946,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161",
      "ID": 4269
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4966,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek",
      "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.3989982+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3101E102P129VM295015",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295015,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1946,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161",
      "ID": 4269
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3101,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala",
      "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1885452+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319078",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319078,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1946,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161",
      "ID": 4269
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5034,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny",
      "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6915061+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306396",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306396,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1946,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161",
      "ID": 4269
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2159,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Martin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5502959+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5110E252P395VM310796",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 310796,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1946,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161",
      "ID": 4269
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Mason",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5864172+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268179",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 268179,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1946,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161",
      "ID": 4269
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2133,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0596023+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2876E141P433VM286394",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286394,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1946,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161",
      "ID": 4269
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2876,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5772629+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4951E147P368VM258633",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258633,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1946,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161",
      "ID": 4269
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4951,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan",
      "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.31591+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3896E175P307VM263805",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 263805,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1946,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161",
      "ID": 4269
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3896,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam",
      "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9054841+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308536",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 308536,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1946,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161",
      "ID": 4269
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0601368+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4964E143P375VM279745",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279745,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1946,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161",
      "ID": 4269
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4964,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5207884+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279600",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279600,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1946,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161",
      "ID": 4269
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3824,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5146448+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2066E22P91VM261069",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261069,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1946,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161",
      "ID": 4269
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2066,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.1104777+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299606",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 299606,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1946,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161",
      "ID": 4269
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7049645+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306722",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306722,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1946,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161",
      "ID": 4269
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina",
      "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5645901+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300612",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 300612,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1946,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161",
      "ID": 4269
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2487,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.006107+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223871",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223871,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1946,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161",
      "ID": 4269
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4773622+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237871",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237871,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1946,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161",
      "ID": 4269
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1961,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David",
      "DisplayName": "David McLetchie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2296608+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305471",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 305471,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1946,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161",
      "ID": 4269
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2134,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3255169+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320348",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 320348,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1946,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161",
      "ID": 4269
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5041,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan",
      "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1561413+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315992",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315992,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1946,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161",
      "ID": 4269
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3763,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart",
      "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9410897+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1986E23P197VM236700",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 236700,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1946,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161",
      "ID": 4269
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1986,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan",
      "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9363093+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5047E100P130VM289804",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289804,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1946,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161",
      "ID": 4269
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5047,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne",
      "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4598102+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234532",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234532,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1946,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161",
      "ID": 4269
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1845,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette",
      "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3883558+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313562",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313562,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1946,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161",
      "ID": 4269
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3061,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4007451+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1768E19P265VM289326",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289326,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1946,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161",
      "ID": 4269
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1768,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4324536+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225316",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225316,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1946,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161",
      "ID": 4269
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1894,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Neil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9692751+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3815E98P134VM270961",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270961,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1946,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161",
      "ID": 4269
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3815,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Park, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Park",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8365312+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265818",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265818,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1946,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161",
      "ID": 4269
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2010,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil",
      "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4558184+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283243",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283243,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1946,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161",
      "ID": 4269
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5057,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.6920372+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2853E33P128VM251546",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251546,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1946,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161",
      "ID": 4269
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Pentland",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4683643+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317569",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317569,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1946,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161",
      "ID": 4269
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5009,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4280867+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254662",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254662,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1946,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161",
      "ID": 4269
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3745,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis",
      "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2662309+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1870E225P478VM296227",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 296227,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1946,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161",
      "ID": 4269
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1870,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona",
      "DisplayName": "Shona Robison",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8395489+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2135E254P450VM235450",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235450,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1946,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161",
      "ID": 4269
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2135,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Russell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6783885+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1895E232P431VM257638",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257638,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1946,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161",
      "ID": 4269
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1895,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0651427+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228156",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 228156,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1946,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161",
      "ID": 4269
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1839,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5867577+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2345E10P55VM291614",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291614,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1946,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161",
      "ID": 4269
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2345,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1349067+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311059",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311059,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1946,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161",
      "ID": 4269
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2223,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish",
      "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.6036403+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246376",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 246376,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1946,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161",
      "ID": 4269
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2182,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1260637+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298098",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298098,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1946,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161",
      "ID": 4269
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5079,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew",
      "DisplayName": "Drew Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1381652+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234130",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234130,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1946,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161",
      "ID": 4269
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1769,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1679289+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274661",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274661,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1946,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161",
      "ID": 4269
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4014,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz",
      "DisplayName": "Liz Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1162638+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269591",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269591,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1946,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161",
      "ID": 4269
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2215,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5544649+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317401",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317401,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1946,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161",
      "ID": 4269
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3806,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4205196+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326343",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 326343,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1946,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161",
      "ID": 4269
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5106,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin",
      "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7543504+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241169",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241169,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1946,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161",
      "ID": 4269
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1848,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola",
      "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.4050019+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2098E237P531VM289663",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289663,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1946,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161",
      "ID": 4269
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2098,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Swinney",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4536517+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248016",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248016,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1946,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161",
      "ID": 4269
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2674,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave",
      "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4381463+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5075E234P371VM287468",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 287468,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1946,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161",
      "ID": 4269
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5075,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Torrance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8654748+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1793E151P362VM222560",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 222560,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1946,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161",
      "ID": 4269
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1793,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean",
      "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1941949+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5078E245P7VM306983",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306983,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1946,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161",
      "ID": 4269
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5078,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Walker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5822772+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1841E231P426VM239954",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239954,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1946,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161",
      "ID": 4269
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1841,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen",
      "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7664744+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283678",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283678,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1946,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161",
      "ID": 4269
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4952,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.718566+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1865E263P500VM231835",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231835,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1946,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161",
      "ID": 4269
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1865,
      "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra",
      "DisplayName": "Sandra White",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.617577+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237388",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237388,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1946,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161",
      "ID": 4269
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2610,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Wilson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2020514+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309198",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 309198,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1946,
      "AgendaID": 2242,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Patient Care",
      "Reference": "S4M-04161",
      "ID": 4269
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4941,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza",
      "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0965266+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1926E229P470VM253111",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253111,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1940,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 108,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.2",
      "ID": 4189
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1926,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian",
      "DisplayName": "Brian Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7672592+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2615E213P388VM259469",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 259469,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1940,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 108,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.2",
      "ID": 4189
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2615,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George",
      "DisplayName": "George Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6104359+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4940E159P373VM318062",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 318062,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1940,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 108,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.2",
      "ID": 4189
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4940,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare",
      "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4553024+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2641E256P403VM250163",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250163,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1940,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 108,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.2",
      "ID": 4189
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2641,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair",
      "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9661115+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1783E21P273VM229439",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229439,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1940,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 108,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.2",
      "ID": 4189
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1783,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie",
      "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0818284+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2633E97P136VM281592",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 281592,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1940,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 108,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.2",
      "ID": 4189
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2633,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire",
      "DisplayName": "Claire Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1494115+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2603E89P148VM263116",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 263116,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1940,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 108,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.2",
      "ID": 4189
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2603,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6374541+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1759E91P115VM227545",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227545,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1940,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 108,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.2",
      "ID": 4189
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia",
      "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5547462+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270712",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270712,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1940,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 108,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.2",
      "ID": 4189
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3751,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8198424+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322992",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 322992,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1940,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 108,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.2",
      "ID": 4189
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5109,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco",
      "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.7125619+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5060E86P124VM297341",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 297341,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1940,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 108,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.2",
      "ID": 4189
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5060,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.0957764+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242702",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242702,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1940,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 108,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.2",
      "ID": 4189
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1866,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah",
      "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0319178+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1943E145P367VM236979",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 236979,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1940,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 108,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.2",
      "ID": 4189
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1943,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic",
      "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9485592+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2595E12P30VM301674",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 301674,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1940,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 108,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.2",
      "ID": 4189
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2595,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin",
      "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.2726276+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2103E244P421VM262002",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262002,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1940,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 108,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.2",
      "ID": 4189
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2103,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith",
      "DisplayName": "Keith Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3873794+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5108E221P387VM326656",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 326656,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1940,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 108,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.2",
      "ID": 4189
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.774219+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277614",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277614,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1940,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 108,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.2",
      "ID": 4189
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9608811+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264993",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264993,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1940,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 108,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.2",
      "ID": 4189
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2673,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick",
      "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1635165+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2678E11P28VM249325",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 249325,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1940,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 108,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.2",
      "ID": 4189
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2678,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson",
      "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9217067+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2123E27P233VM291152",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291152,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1940,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 108,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.2",
      "ID": 4189
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2123,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm",
      "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7879368+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285467",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285467,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1940,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 108,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.2",
      "ID": 4189
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3907,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3305054+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1735E248P405VM231405",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231405,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1940,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 108,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.2",
      "ID": 4189
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1735,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela",
      "DisplayName": "Angela Constance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.5988571+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243169",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 243169,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1940,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 108,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.2",
      "ID": 4189
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1932,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce",
      "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0571155+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1863E238P523VM253975",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253975,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1940,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 108,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.2",
      "ID": 4189
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1863,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna",
      "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.029143+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4976E20P31VM321379",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 321379,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1940,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 108,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.2",
      "ID": 4189
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4976,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth",
      "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4333122+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5107E223P379VM292431",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 292431,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1940,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 108,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.2",
      "ID": 4189
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5107,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5335011+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3743E222P391VM273166",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 273166,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1940,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 108,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.2",
      "ID": 4189
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3743,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel",
      "DisplayName": "Nigel Don",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3724348+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262864",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262864,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1940,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 108,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.2",
      "ID": 4189
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3771,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob",
      "DisplayName": "Bob Doris",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6262576+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2826E262P384VM282290",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 282290,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1940,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 108,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.2",
      "ID": 4189
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2826,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Dornan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.4064113+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298980",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298980,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1940,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 108,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.2",
      "ID": 4189
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3812,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia",
      "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3805681+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1778E28P260VM230616",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230616,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1940,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 108,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.2",
      "ID": 4189
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1778,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen",
      "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3380728+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4955E240P389VM287184",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 287184,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1940,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 108,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.2",
      "ID": 4189
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4955,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.6227739+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219696",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 219696,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1940,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 108,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.2",
      "ID": 4189
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1742,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle",
      "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3105515+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1994E257P537VM239112",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239112,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1940,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 108,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.2",
      "ID": 4189
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1994,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus",
      "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.495815+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1814E269P519VM226280",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 226280,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1940,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 108,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.2",
      "ID": 4189
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1814,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda",
      "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2187713+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5059E85P123VM322303",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 322303,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1940,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 108,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.2",
      "ID": 4189
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Fee",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6769656+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1853E35P216VM291820",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291820,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1940,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 108,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.2",
      "ID": 4189
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia",
      "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1438784+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1892E12P64VM228182",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 228182,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1940,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 108,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.2",
      "ID": 4189
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5878479+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5054E95P118VM304397",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 304397,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1940,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 108,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.2",
      "ID": 4189
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5054,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.0365056+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4947E152P361VM257963",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257963,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1940,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 108,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.2",
      "ID": 4189
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4947,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Finnie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0854282+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271690",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271690,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1940,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 108,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.2",
      "ID": 4189
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3901,
      "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe",
      "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0872805+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2394E15P47VM279355",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279355,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1940,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 108,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.2",
      "ID": 4189
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2394,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo",
      "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.4986058+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2110E220P414VM266488",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 266488,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1940,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 108,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.2",
      "ID": 4189
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth",
      "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.7433205+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250780",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250780,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1940,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 108,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.2",
      "ID": 4189
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2675,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob",
      "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.2132052+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221246",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221246,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1940,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 108,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.2",
      "ID": 4189
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1741,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel",
      "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.921051+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1756E218P467VM226368",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 226368,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1940,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 108,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.2",
      "ID": 4189
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1756,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine",
      "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2283199+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1860E104P150VM239798",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239798,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1940,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 108,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.2",
      "ID": 4189
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1860,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda",
      "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7593582+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2033E20P141VM266676",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 266676,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1940,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 108,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.2",
      "ID": 4189
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2033,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain",
      "DisplayName": "Iain Gray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.7516261+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324322",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324322,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1940,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 108,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.2",
      "ID": 4189
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5042,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2117723+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2892E76P97VM260893",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 260893,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1940,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 108,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.2",
      "ID": 4189
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick",
      "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.1025025+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2029E24P170VM246112",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 246112,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1940,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 108,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.2",
      "ID": 4189
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2029,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh",
      "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8727308+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3758E268P409VM276188",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276188,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1940,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 108,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.2",
      "ID": 4189
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3758,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.41428+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4086E128P311VM303194",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 303194,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1940,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 108,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.2",
      "ID": 4189
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4086,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Hume",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5632674+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1773E242P494VM222293",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 222293,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1940,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 108,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.2",
      "ID": 4189
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1773,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1824746+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1882E227P459VM245578",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 245578,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1940,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 108,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.2",
      "ID": 4189
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1882,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam",
      "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.849467+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1893E16P69VM224711",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 224711,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1940,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 108,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.2",
      "ID": 4189
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1893,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7166528+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4934E77P103VM308564",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 308564,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1940,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 108,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.2",
      "ID": 4189
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4934,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0613385+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272517",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 272517,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1940,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 108,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.2",
      "ID": 4189
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4956,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Keir",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3388011+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244711",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244711,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1940,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 108,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.2",
      "ID": 4189
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Kelly",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5749865+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3129E261P419VM314640",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 314640,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1940,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 108,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.2",
      "ID": 4189
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3129,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6488848+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2080E36P220VM252501",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252501,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1940,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 108,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.2",
      "ID": 4189
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann",
      "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7318664+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4016E11P36VM275615",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 275615,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1940,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 108,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.2",
      "ID": 4189
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4016,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.3831444+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2180E246P463VM257097",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257097,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1940,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 108,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.2",
      "ID": 4189
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2180,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.823183+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4938E158P374VM282877",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 282877,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1940,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 108,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.2",
      "ID": 4189
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4938,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.4381682+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2112E250P486VM254099",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254099,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1940,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 108,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.2",
      "ID": 4189
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2112,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny",
      "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0344713+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4939E258P394VM278778",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 278778,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1940,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 108,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.2",
      "ID": 4189
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4939,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus",
      "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2338511+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5074E251P385VM324963",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324963,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1940,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 108,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.2",
      "ID": 4189
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5074,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon",
      "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2453039+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1828E3P10VM231980",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231980,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1940,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 108,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.2",
      "ID": 4189
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1828,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo",
      "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6240584+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4948E153P363VM312382",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 312382,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1940,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 108,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.2",
      "ID": 4189
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4948,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike",
      "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1254353+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2117E90P107VM233098",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 233098,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1940,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 108,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.2",
      "ID": 4189
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2117,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis",
      "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.896744+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267785",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 267785,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1940,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 108,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.2",
      "ID": 4189
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken",
      "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0348872+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4966E214P378VM314467",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 314467,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1940,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 108,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.2",
      "ID": 4189
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4966,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek",
      "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6412427+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3101E102P129VM296162",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 296162,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1940,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 108,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.2",
      "ID": 4189
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3101,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala",
      "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5520477+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319707",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319707,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1940,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 108,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.2",
      "ID": 4189
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5034,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny",
      "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9378714+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2159E25P205VM305869",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 305869,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1940,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 108,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.2",
      "ID": 4189
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2159,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Martin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3488468+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5110E252P395VM309870",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 309870,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1940,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 108,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.2",
      "ID": 4189
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Mason",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3544802+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268655",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 268655,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1940,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 108,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.2",
      "ID": 4189
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2133,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2769721+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2876E141P433VM293771",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 293771,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1940,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 108,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.2",
      "ID": 4189
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2876,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8681921+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4951E147P368VM271432",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271432,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1940,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 108,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.2",
      "ID": 4189
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4951,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan",
      "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0755675+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3896E175P307VM269403",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269403,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1940,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 108,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.2",
      "ID": 4189
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3896,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam",
      "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5460326+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5080E110P121VM307408",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307408,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1940,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 108,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.2",
      "ID": 4189
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8281593+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4964E143P375VM280578",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280578,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1940,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 108,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.2",
      "ID": 4189
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4964,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7732553+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3824E84P113VM281266",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 281266,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1940,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 108,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.2",
      "ID": 4189
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3824,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1274202+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2066E22P91VM245177",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 245177,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1940,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 108,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.2",
      "ID": 4189
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2066,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5953528+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299981",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 299981,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1940,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 108,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.2",
      "ID": 4189
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7312015+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3759E260P411VM302771",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 302771,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1940,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 108,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.2",
      "ID": 4189
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina",
      "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.544467+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300104",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 300104,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1940,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 108,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.2",
      "ID": 4189
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2487,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7364829+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1775E215P453VM224303",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 224303,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1940,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 108,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.2",
      "ID": 4189
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.6931151+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237967",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237967,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1940,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 108,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.2",
      "ID": 4189
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1961,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David",
      "DisplayName": "David McLetchie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2338147+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2134E34P201VM297473",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 297473,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1940,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 108,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.2",
      "ID": 4189
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2134,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1017106+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5041E99P122VM321020",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 321020,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1940,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 108,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.2",
      "ID": 4189
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5041,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan",
      "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1988088+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315441",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315441,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1940,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 108,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.2",
      "ID": 4189
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3763,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart",
      "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9121454+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1986E23P197VM237547",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237547,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1940,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 108,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.2",
      "ID": 4189
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1986,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan",
      "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2155173+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5047E100P130VM292572",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 292572,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1940,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 108,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.2",
      "ID": 4189
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5047,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne",
      "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5485462+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1845E17P40VM233963",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 233963,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1940,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 108,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.2",
      "ID": 4189
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1845,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette",
      "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1539421+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3061E19P43VM312033",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 312033,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1940,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 108,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.2",
      "ID": 4189
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3061,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.9108281+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1768E19P265VM286851",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286851,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1940,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 108,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.2",
      "ID": 4189
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1768,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.6035455+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225698",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225698,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1940,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 108,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.2",
      "ID": 4189
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1894,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Neil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9865434+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3815E98P134VM271013",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271013,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1940,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 108,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.2",
      "ID": 4189
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3815,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Park, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Park",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.838783+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265556",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265556,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1940,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 108,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.2",
      "ID": 4189
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2010,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil",
      "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4442723+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283949",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283949,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1940,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 108,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.2",
      "ID": 4189
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5057,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7304551+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2853E33P128VM258715",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258715,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1940,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 108,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.2",
      "ID": 4189
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Pentland",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3195284+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5009E126P306VM318239",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 318239,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1940,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 108,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.2",
      "ID": 4189
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5009,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6441398+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3745E233P381VM256125",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 256125,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1940,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 108,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.2",
      "ID": 4189
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3745,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis",
      "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5716974+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1870E225P478VM294515",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 294515,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1940,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 108,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.2",
      "ID": 4189
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1870,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona",
      "DisplayName": "Shona Robison",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1417395+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2135E254P450VM235985",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235985,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1940,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 108,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.2",
      "ID": 4189
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2135,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Russell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.7014177+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1895E232P431VM255998",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255998,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1940,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 108,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.2",
      "ID": 4189
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1895,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5659661+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1839E21P87VM229357",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229357,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1940,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 108,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.2",
      "ID": 4189
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1839,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0782639+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2345E10P55VM288397",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 288397,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1940,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 108,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.2",
      "ID": 4189
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2345,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1330769+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2223E176P333VM310452",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 310452,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1940,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 108,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.2",
      "ID": 4189
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2223,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish",
      "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5714806+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2182E87P175VM247114",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247114,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1940,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 108,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.2",
      "ID": 4189
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2182,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1676589+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298700",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298700,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1940,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 108,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.2",
      "ID": 4189
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5079,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew",
      "DisplayName": "Drew Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3684783+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1769E32P285VM235818",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235818,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1940,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 108,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.2",
      "ID": 4189
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1769,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6942987+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4014E14P26VM275346",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 275346,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1940,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 108,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.2",
      "ID": 4189
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4014,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz",
      "DisplayName": "Liz Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.3712458+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2215E224P447VM274171",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274171,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1940,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 108,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.2",
      "ID": 4189
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2215,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6576428+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3806E103P127VM316799",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 316799,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1940,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 108,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.2",
      "ID": 4189
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3806,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.1639879+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326020",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 326020,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1940,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 108,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.2",
      "ID": 4189
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5106,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin",
      "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5317957+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241448",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241448,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1940,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 108,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.2",
      "ID": 4189
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1848,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola",
      "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7583935+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2098E237P531VM288688",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 288688,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1940,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 108,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.2",
      "ID": 4189
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2098,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Swinney",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1541401+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248237",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248237,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1940,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 108,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.2",
      "ID": 4189
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2674,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave",
      "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6372382+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5075E234P371VM290072",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 290072,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1940,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 108,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.2",
      "ID": 4189
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5075,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Torrance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4715607+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1793E151P362VM222789",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 222789,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1940,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 108,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.2",
      "ID": 4189
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1793,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean",
      "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.2047723+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5078E245P7VM306866",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306866,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1940,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 108,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.2",
      "ID": 4189
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5078,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Walker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5770933+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1841E231P426VM240827",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 240827,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1940,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 108,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.2",
      "ID": 4189
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1841,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen",
      "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.383982+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4952E148P370VM284108",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 284108,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1940,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 108,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.2",
      "ID": 4189
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4952,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7433384+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1865E263P500VM251651",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251651,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1940,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 108,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.2",
      "ID": 4189
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1865,
      "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra",
      "DisplayName": "Sandra White",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.482866+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2610E160P413VM246749",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 246749,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1940,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 108,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.2",
      "ID": 4189
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2610,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Wilson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1517652+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309724",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 309724,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1940,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 108,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.2",
      "ID": 4189
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4941,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza",
      "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3419975+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1926E229P470VM253112",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253112,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1941,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.1",
      "ID": 4183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1926,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian",
      "DisplayName": "Brian Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7673007+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2615E213P388VM259470",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 259470,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1941,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.1",
      "ID": 4183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2615,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George",
      "DisplayName": "George Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6104971+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4940E159P373VM318060",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 318060,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1941,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.1",
      "ID": 4183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4940,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare",
      "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4552018+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2641E256P403VM250102",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250102,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1941,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.1",
      "ID": 4183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2641,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair",
      "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9634408+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1783E21P273VM229440",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229440,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1941,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.1",
      "ID": 4183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1783,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie",
      "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0818702+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2633E97P136VM281593",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 281593,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1941,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.1",
      "ID": 4183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2633,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire",
      "DisplayName": "Claire Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1494528+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2603E89P148VM263117",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 263117,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1941,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.1",
      "ID": 4183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2603,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6374959+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1759E91P115VM227546",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227546,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1941,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.1",
      "ID": 4183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia",
      "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5547871+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270711",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270711,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1941,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.1",
      "ID": 4183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3751,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8198005+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322993",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 322993,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1941,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.1",
      "ID": 4183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5109,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco",
      "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.7126036+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5060E86P124VM297342",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 297342,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1941,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.1",
      "ID": 4183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5060,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.0958176+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242617",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242617,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1941,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.1",
      "ID": 4183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1866,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah",
      "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.028034+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1943E145P367VM236978",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 236978,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1941,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.1",
      "ID": 4183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1943,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic",
      "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9485183+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2595E12P30VM301675",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 301675,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1941,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.1",
      "ID": 4183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2595,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin",
      "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.2726694+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2103E244P421VM262001",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262001,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1941,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.1",
      "ID": 4183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2103,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith",
      "DisplayName": "Keith Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3873388+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5108E221P387VM326658",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 326658,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1941,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.1",
      "ID": 4183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7744094+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277615",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277615,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1941,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.1",
      "ID": 4183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9609231+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264992",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264992,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1941,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.1",
      "ID": 4183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2673,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick",
      "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1634756+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2678E11P28VM249324",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 249324,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1941,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.1",
      "ID": 4183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2678,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson",
      "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9216652+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2123E27P233VM291238",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291238,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1941,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.1",
      "ID": 4183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2123,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm",
      "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1102568+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285468",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285468,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1941,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.1",
      "ID": 4183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3907,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.330548+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1735E248P405VM231406",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231406,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1941,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.1",
      "ID": 4183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1735,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela",
      "DisplayName": "Angela Constance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.5989152+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243259",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 243259,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1941,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.1",
      "ID": 4183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1932,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce",
      "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.2896654+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1863E238P523VM253974",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253974,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1941,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.1",
      "ID": 4183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1863,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna",
      "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0291021+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4976E20P31VM321381",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 321381,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1941,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.1",
      "ID": 4183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4976,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth",
      "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4333959+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5107E223P379VM292430",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 292430,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1941,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.1",
      "ID": 4183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5107,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5334599+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3743E222P391VM273167",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 273167,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1941,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.1",
      "ID": 4183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3743,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel",
      "DisplayName": "Nigel Don",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.372477+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262865",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262865,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1941,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.1",
      "ID": 4183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3771,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob",
      "DisplayName": "Bob Doris",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6262993+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2826E262P384VM282289",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 282289,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1941,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.1",
      "ID": 4183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2826,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Dornan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.40637+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298981",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298981,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1941,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.1",
      "ID": 4183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3812,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia",
      "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3806087+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1778E28P260VM230615",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230615,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1941,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.1",
      "ID": 4183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1778,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen",
      "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3380295+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4955E240P389VM287183",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 287183,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1941,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.1",
      "ID": 4183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4955,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.622732+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219697",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 219697,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1941,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.1",
      "ID": 4183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1742,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle",
      "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.310594+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1994E257P537VM239111",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239111,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1941,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.1",
      "ID": 4183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1994,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus",
      "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4957722+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1814E269P519VM226219",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 226219,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1941,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.1",
      "ID": 4183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1814,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda",
      "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2155304+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5059E85P123VM322302",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 322302,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1941,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.1",
      "ID": 4183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Fee",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6769242+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1853E35P216VM291819",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291819,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1941,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.1",
      "ID": 4183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia",
      "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1438375+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1892E12P64VM228183",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 228183,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1941,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.1",
      "ID": 4183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5879079+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5054E95P118VM304398",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 304398,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1941,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.1",
      "ID": 4183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5054,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.0365475+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4947E152P361VM258024",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258024,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1941,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.1",
      "ID": 4183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4947,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Finnie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0880453+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271689",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271689,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1941,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.1",
      "ID": 4183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3901,
      "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe",
      "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0872366+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2394E15P47VM279354",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279354,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1941,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.1",
      "ID": 4183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2394,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo",
      "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.4985639+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2110E220P414VM266489",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 266489,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1941,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.1",
      "ID": 4183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth",
      "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.7433627+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250829",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250829,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1941,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.1",
      "ID": 4183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2675,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob",
      "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.2152757+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221293",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221293,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1941,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.1",
      "ID": 4183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1741,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel",
      "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9257492+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1756E218P467VM226367",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 226367,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1941,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.1",
      "ID": 4183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1756,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine",
      "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2282774+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1860E104P150VM239799",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239799,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1941,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.1",
      "ID": 4183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1860,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda",
      "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7594004+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2033E20P141VM266675",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 266675,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1941,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.1",
      "ID": 4183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2033,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain",
      "DisplayName": "Iain Gray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.7515818+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324320",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324320,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1941,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.1",
      "ID": 4183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5042,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2116698+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2892E76P97VM260892",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 260892,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1941,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.1",
      "ID": 4183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick",
      "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.1024617+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2029E24P170VM246113",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 246113,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1941,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.1",
      "ID": 4183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2029,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh",
      "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8727726+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3758E268P409VM276187",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276187,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1941,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.1",
      "ID": 4183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3758,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.4142389+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4086E128P311VM303193",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 303193,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1941,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.1",
      "ID": 4183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4086,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Hume",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5632175+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1773E242P494VM222235",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 222235,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1941,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.1",
      "ID": 4183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1773,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.174153+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1882E227P459VM242448",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242448,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1941,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.1",
      "ID": 4183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1882,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam",
      "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0136928+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1893E16P69VM224710",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 224710,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1941,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.1",
      "ID": 4183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1893,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7166109+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4934E77P103VM308565",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 308565,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1941,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.1",
      "ID": 4183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4934,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.06138+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272567",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 272567,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1941,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.1",
      "ID": 4183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4956,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Keir",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3409548+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244466",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244466,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1941,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.1",
      "ID": 4183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Kelly",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5559695+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3129E261P419VM314642",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 314642,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1941,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.1",
      "ID": 4183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3129,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6489681+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2080E36P220VM252500",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252500,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1941,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.1",
      "ID": 4183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann",
      "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7318252+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4016E11P36VM275616",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 275616,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1941,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.1",
      "ID": 4183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4016,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.3831857+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2180E246P463VM257096",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257096,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1941,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.1",
      "ID": 4183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2180,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.8231416+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4938E158P374VM282876",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 282876,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1941,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.1",
      "ID": 4183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4938,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.4381278+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2112E250P486VM254100",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254100,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1941,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.1",
      "ID": 4183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2112,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny",
      "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.034513+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4939E258P394VM278777",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 278777,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1941,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.1",
      "ID": 4183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4939,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus",
      "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2338105+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5074E251P385VM324965",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324965,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1941,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.1",
      "ID": 4183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5074,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon",
      "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2453866+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1828E3P10VM231981",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231981,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1941,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.1",
      "ID": 4183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1828,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo",
      "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6241007+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4948E153P363VM312383",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 312383,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1941,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.1",
      "ID": 4183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4948,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike",
      "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1254772+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2117E90P107VM233097",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 233097,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1941,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.1",
      "ID": 4183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2117,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis",
      "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8967018+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267786",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 267786,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1941,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.1",
      "ID": 4183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken",
      "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0349288+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4966E214P378VM314466",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 314466,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1941,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.1",
      "ID": 4183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4966,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek",
      "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6412002+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3101E102P129VM296161",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 296161,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1941,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.1",
      "ID": 4183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3101,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala",
      "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5520053+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319706",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319706,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1941,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.1",
      "ID": 4183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5034,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny",
      "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9378302+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2159E25P205VM305868",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 305868,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1941,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.1",
      "ID": 4183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2159,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Martin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3488061+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5110E252P395VM309869",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 309869,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1941,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.1",
      "ID": 4183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Mason",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3544385+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268654",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 268654,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1941,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.1",
      "ID": 4183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2133,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2769298+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2876E141P433VM293772",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 293772,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1941,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.1",
      "ID": 4183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2876,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8682534+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4951E147P368VM271371",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271371,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1941,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.1",
      "ID": 4183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4951,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan",
      "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0729194+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3896E175P307VM269402",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269402,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1941,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.1",
      "ID": 4183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3896,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam",
      "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5459912+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5080E110P121VM307409",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307409,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1941,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.1",
      "ID": 4183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8282008+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4964E143P375VM280579",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280579,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1941,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.1",
      "ID": 4183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4964,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7732984+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3824E84P113VM281265",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 281265,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1941,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.1",
      "ID": 4183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3824,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1273791+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2066E22P91VM245263",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 245263,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1941,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.1",
      "ID": 4183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2066,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8272892+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299980",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 299980,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1941,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.1",
      "ID": 4183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.73116+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3759E260P411VM302772",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 302772,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1941,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.1",
      "ID": 4183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina",
      "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5445086+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300103",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 300103,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1941,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.1",
      "ID": 4183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2487,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7364414+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1775E215P453VM224505",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 224505,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1941,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.1",
      "ID": 4183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7077326+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237968",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237968,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1941,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.1",
      "ID": 4183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1961,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David",
      "DisplayName": "David McLetchie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2338564+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2134E34P201VM297474",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 297474,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1941,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.1",
      "ID": 4183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2134,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1017524+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5041E99P122VM321021",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 321021,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1941,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.1",
      "ID": 4183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5041,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan",
      "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1988519+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315439",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315439,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1941,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.1",
      "ID": 4183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3763,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart",
      "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9120631+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1986E23P197VM237548",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237548,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1941,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.1",
      "ID": 4183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1986,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan",
      "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2155772+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5047E100P130VM292571",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 292571,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1941,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.1",
      "ID": 4183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5047,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne",
      "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5397221+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1845E17P40VM233962",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 233962,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1941,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.1",
      "ID": 4183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1845,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette",
      "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1538988+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3061E19P43VM312031",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 312031,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1941,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.1",
      "ID": 4183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3061,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.9107436+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1768E19P265VM286852",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286852,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1941,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.1",
      "ID": 4183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1768,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.6036068+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225699",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225699,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1941,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.1",
      "ID": 4183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1894,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Neil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9866142+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3815E98P134VM271014",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271014,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1941,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.1",
      "ID": 4183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3815,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Park, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Park",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8388248+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265555",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265555,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1941,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.1",
      "ID": 4183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2010,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil",
      "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4442311+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283948",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283948,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1941,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.1",
      "ID": 4183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5057,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7304134+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2853E33P128VM258716",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258716,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1941,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.1",
      "ID": 4183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Pentland",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.319572+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5009E126P306VM318240",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 318240,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1941,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.1",
      "ID": 4183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5009,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6441821+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3745E233P381VM256076",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 256076,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1941,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.1",
      "ID": 4183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3745,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis",
      "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5695965+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1870E225P478VM294516",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 294516,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1941,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.1",
      "ID": 4183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1870,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona",
      "DisplayName": "Shona Robison",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1417812+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2135E254P450VM235986",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235986,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1941,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.1",
      "ID": 4183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2135,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Russell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.7014591+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1895E232P431VM255999",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255999,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1941,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.1",
      "ID": 4183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1895,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5660073+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1839E21P87VM229407",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229407,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1941,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.1",
      "ID": 4183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1839,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0804597+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2345E10P55VM288396",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 288396,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1941,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.1",
      "ID": 4183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2345,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1330363+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2223E176P333VM310454",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 310454,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1941,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.1",
      "ID": 4183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2223,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish",
      "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5715639+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2182E87P175VM247164",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247164,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1941,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.1",
      "ID": 4183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2182,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1698403+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298699",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298699,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1941,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.1",
      "ID": 4183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5079,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew",
      "DisplayName": "Drew Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3684373+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1769E32P285VM235817",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235817,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1941,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.1",
      "ID": 4183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1769,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6942379+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4014E14P26VM275347",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 275347,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1941,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.1",
      "ID": 4183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4014,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz",
      "DisplayName": "Liz Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.3712885+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2215E224P447VM274172",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274172,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1941,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.1",
      "ID": 4183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2215,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6577929+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3806E103P127VM316801",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 316801,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1941,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.1",
      "ID": 4183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3806,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.1640796+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326018",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 326018,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1941,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.1",
      "ID": 4183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5106,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin",
      "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5316934+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241509",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241509,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1941,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.1",
      "ID": 4183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1848,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola",
      "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.767889+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2098E237P531VM287980",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 287980,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1941,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.1",
      "ID": 4183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2098,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Swinney",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8948596+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248238",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248238,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1941,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.1",
      "ID": 4183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2674,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave",
      "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.637283+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5075E234P371VM290073",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 290073,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1941,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.1",
      "ID": 4183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5075,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Torrance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4716025+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1793E151P362VM222790",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 222790,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1941,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.1",
      "ID": 4183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1793,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean",
      "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.2048136+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5078E245P7VM306865",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306865,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1941,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.1",
      "ID": 4183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5078,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Walker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.577052+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1841E231P426VM240766",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 240766,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1941,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.1",
      "ID": 4183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1841,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen",
      "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3813756+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4952E148P370VM284109",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 284109,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1941,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.1",
      "ID": 4183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4952,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7433797+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1865E263P500VM251650",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251650,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1941,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.1",
      "ID": 4183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1865,
      "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra",
      "DisplayName": "Sandra White",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.482824+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2610E160P413VM246748",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 246748,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1941,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.1",
      "ID": 4183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2610,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Wilson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1517244+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309723",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 309723,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1941,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061.1",
      "ID": 4183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4941,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza",
      "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3419329+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1926E229P470VM253113",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253113,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1942,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061",
      "ID": 4166
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1926,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian",
      "DisplayName": "Brian Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7673431+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2615E213P388VM259471",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 259471,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1942,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061",
      "ID": 4166
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2615,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George",
      "DisplayName": "George Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6105403+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4940E159P373VM318059",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 318059,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1942,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061",
      "ID": 4166
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4940,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare",
      "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4551611+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2641E256P403VM250101",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250101,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1942,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061",
      "ID": 4166
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2641,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair",
      "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9634+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1783E21P273VM229441",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229441,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1942,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061",
      "ID": 4166
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1783,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie",
      "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0819118+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2633E97P136VM281594",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 281594,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1942,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061",
      "ID": 4166
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2633,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire",
      "DisplayName": "Claire Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1494929+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2603E89P148VM263118",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 263118,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1942,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061",
      "ID": 4166
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2603,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6375373+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1759E91P115VM227547",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227547,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1942,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061",
      "ID": 4166
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia",
      "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5548484+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270710",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270710,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1942,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061",
      "ID": 4166
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3751,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8197583+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322994",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 322994,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1942,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061",
      "ID": 4166
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5109,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco",
      "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.7126451+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5060E86P124VM297343",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 297343,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1942,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061",
      "ID": 4166
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5060,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.0958583+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242618",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242618,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1942,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061",
      "ID": 4166
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1866,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah",
      "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0280745+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1943E145P367VM236977",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 236977,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1942,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061",
      "ID": 4166
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1943,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic",
      "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9484757+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2595E12P30VM301676",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 301676,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1942,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061",
      "ID": 4166
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2595,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin",
      "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.2727112+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2103E244P421VM262000",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262000,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1942,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061",
      "ID": 4166
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2103,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith",
      "DisplayName": "Keith Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3872976+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5108E221P387VM326659",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 326659,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1942,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061",
      "ID": 4166
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7744836+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277616",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277616,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1942,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061",
      "ID": 4166
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9609645+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264991",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264991,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1942,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061",
      "ID": 4166
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2673,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick",
      "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1634344+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2678E11P28VM249321",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 249321,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1942,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061",
      "ID": 4166
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2678,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson",
      "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9215418+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2123E27P233VM291237",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291237,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1942,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061",
      "ID": 4166
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2123,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm",
      "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1102131+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285469",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285469,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1942,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061",
      "ID": 4166
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3907,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3305901+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1735E248P405VM231407",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231407,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1942,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061",
      "ID": 4166
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1735,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela",
      "DisplayName": "Angela Constance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.5989584+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243258",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 243258,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1942,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061",
      "ID": 4166
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1932,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce",
      "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.2896246+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1863E238P523VM253973",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253973,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1942,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061",
      "ID": 4166
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1863,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna",
      "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0290613+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4976E20P31VM321382",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 321382,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1942,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061",
      "ID": 4166
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4976,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth",
      "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4334376+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5107E223P379VM300754",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 300754,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1942,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061",
      "ID": 4166
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5107,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0174474+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3743E222P391VM273168",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 273168,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1942,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061",
      "ID": 4166
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3743,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel",
      "DisplayName": "Nigel Don",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3725183+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262868",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262868,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1942,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061",
      "ID": 4166
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3771,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob",
      "DisplayName": "Bob Doris",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6264415+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2826E262P384VM282288",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 282288,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1942,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061",
      "ID": 4166
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2826,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Dornan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.4063284+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298982",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298982,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1942,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061",
      "ID": 4166
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3812,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia",
      "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3806492+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1778E28P260VM230614",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230614,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1942,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061",
      "ID": 4166
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1778,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen",
      "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.337969+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4955E240P389VM287211",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 287211,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1942,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061",
      "ID": 4166
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4955,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8544258+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219698",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 219698,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1942,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061",
      "ID": 4166
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1742,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle",
      "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3106551+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1994E257P537VM239110",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239110,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1942,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061",
      "ID": 4166
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1994,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus",
      "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4957301+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1814E269P519VM226218",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 226218,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1942,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061",
      "ID": 4166
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1814,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda",
      "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2154649+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5059E85P123VM322301",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 322301,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1942,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061",
      "ID": 4166
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Fee",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6768831+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1853E35P216VM291818",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291818,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1942,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061",
      "ID": 4166
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia",
      "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.143797+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1892E12P64VM228185",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 228185,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1942,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061",
      "ID": 4166
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5879918+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5054E95P118VM304399",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 304399,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1942,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061",
      "ID": 4166
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5054,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.0365887+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4947E152P361VM258025",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258025,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1942,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061",
      "ID": 4166
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4947,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Finnie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0880858+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271681",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271681,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1942,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061",
      "ID": 4166
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3901,
      "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe",
      "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0866236+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2394E15P47VM279353",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279353,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1942,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061",
      "ID": 4166
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2394,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo",
      "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.4985223+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2110E220P414VM266490",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 266490,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1942,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061",
      "ID": 4166
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth",
      "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.7434048+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250830",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250830,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1942,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061",
      "ID": 4166
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2675,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob",
      "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.2153156+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221295",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221295,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1942,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061",
      "ID": 4166
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1741,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel",
      "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9258324+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1756E218P467VM226365",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 226365,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1942,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061",
      "ID": 4166
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1756,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine",
      "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2281955+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1860E104P150VM239800",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239800,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1942,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061",
      "ID": 4166
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1860,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda",
      "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7594419+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2033E20P141VM266674",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 266674,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1942,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061",
      "ID": 4166
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2033,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain",
      "DisplayName": "Iain Gray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.7514424+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324319",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324319,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1942,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061",
      "ID": 4166
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5042,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2116283+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2892E76P97VM260889",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 260889,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1942,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061",
      "ID": 4166
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick",
      "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.1023388+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2029E24P170VM246114",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 246114,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1942,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061",
      "ID": 4166
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2029,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh",
      "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8728136+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3758E268P409VM276186",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276186,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1942,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061",
      "ID": 4166
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3758,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.4141981+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4086E128P311VM303192",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 303192,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1942,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061",
      "ID": 4166
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4086,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Hume",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5631605+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1773E242P494VM222233",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 222233,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1942,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061",
      "ID": 4166
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1773,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1740671+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1882E227P459VM242447",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242447,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1942,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061",
      "ID": 4166
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1882,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam",
      "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0136501+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1893E16P69VM224709",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 224709,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1942,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061",
      "ID": 4166
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1893,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7165696+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4934E77P103VM308566",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 308566,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1942,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061",
      "ID": 4166
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4934,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0614208+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272568",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 272568,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1942,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061",
      "ID": 4166
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4956,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Keir",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3409959+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244467",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244467,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1942,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061",
      "ID": 4166
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Kelly",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5560118+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3129E261P419VM314643",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 314643,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1942,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061",
      "ID": 4166
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3129,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6490429+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2080E36P220VM252499",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252499,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1942,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061",
      "ID": 4166
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann",
      "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7317824+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4016E11P36VM275934",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 275934,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1942,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061",
      "ID": 4166
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4016,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.397291+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2180E246P463VM257095",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257095,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1942,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061",
      "ID": 4166
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2180,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.8230995+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4938E158P374VM283060",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283060,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1942,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061",
      "ID": 4166
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4938,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.4505888+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2112E250P486VM254101",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254101,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1942,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061",
      "ID": 4166
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2112,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny",
      "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0345543+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4939E258P394VM278314",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 278314,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1942,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061",
      "ID": 4166
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4939,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus",
      "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2068734+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5074E251P385VM324966",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324966,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1942,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061",
      "ID": 4166
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5074,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon",
      "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2454462+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1828E3P10VM231982",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231982,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1942,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061",
      "ID": 4166
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1828,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo",
      "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6241432+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4948E153P363VM312384",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 312384,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1942,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061",
      "ID": 4166
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4948,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike",
      "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.125519+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2117E90P107VM233094",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 233094,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1942,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061",
      "ID": 4166
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2117,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis",
      "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.896574+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267787",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 267787,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1942,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061",
      "ID": 4166
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken",
      "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0349705+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4966E214P378VM314465",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 314465,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1942,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061",
      "ID": 4166
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4966,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek",
      "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.641158+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3101E102P129VM296160",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 296160,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1942,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061",
      "ID": 4166
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3101,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala",
      "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5519451+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319705",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319705,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1942,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061",
      "ID": 4166
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5034,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny",
      "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9377884+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2159E25P205VM305867",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 305867,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1942,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061",
      "ID": 4166
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2159,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Martin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.348764+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5110E252P395VM309868",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 309868,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1942,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061",
      "ID": 4166
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Mason",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3543971+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268653",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 268653,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1942,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061",
      "ID": 4166
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2133,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2768872+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2876E141P433VM293773",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 293773,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1942,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061",
      "ID": 4166
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2876,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8682967+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4951E147P368VM271370",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271370,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1942,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061",
      "ID": 4166
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4951,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan",
      "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0728771+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3896E175P307VM269399",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269399,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1942,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061",
      "ID": 4166
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3896,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam",
      "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5458673+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5080E110P121VM307410",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307410,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1942,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061",
      "ID": 4166
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8282427+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4964E143P375VM282585",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 282585,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1942,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061",
      "ID": 4166
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4964,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.4252392+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3824E84P113VM281264",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 281264,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1942,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061",
      "ID": 4166
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3824,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1273359+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2066E22P91VM245262",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 245262,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1942,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061",
      "ID": 4166
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2066,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8272337+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299979",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 299979,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1942,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061",
      "ID": 4166
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7311015+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3759E260P411VM302773",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 302773,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1942,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061",
      "ID": 4166
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina",
      "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5445498+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300102",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 300102,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1942,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061",
      "ID": 4166
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2487,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7363999+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1775E215P453VM224507",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 224507,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1942,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061",
      "ID": 4166
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7078152+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237969",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237969,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1942,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061",
      "ID": 4166
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1961,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David",
      "DisplayName": "David McLetchie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2338984+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2134E34P201VM297475",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 297475,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1942,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061",
      "ID": 4166
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2134,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1018127+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5041E99P122VM321022",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 321022,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1942,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061",
      "ID": 4166
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5041,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan",
      "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1988937+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315438",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315438,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1942,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061",
      "ID": 4166
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3763,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart",
      "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9120217+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1986E23P197VM237549",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237549,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1942,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061",
      "ID": 4166
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1986,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan",
      "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2156205+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5047E100P130VM292570",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 292570,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1942,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061",
      "ID": 4166
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5047,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne",
      "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5396814+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1845E17P40VM233961",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 233961,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1942,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061",
      "ID": 4166
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1845,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette",
      "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1538384+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3061E19P43VM312030",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 312030,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1942,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061",
      "ID": 4166
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3061,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.9107029+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1768E19P265VM286853",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286853,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1942,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061",
      "ID": 4166
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1768,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.6036487+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225700",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225700,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1942,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061",
      "ID": 4166
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1894,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Neil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9866575+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3815E98P134VM271015",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271015,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1942,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061",
      "ID": 4166
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3815,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Park, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Park",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8388657+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265554",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265554,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1942,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061",
      "ID": 4166
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2010,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil",
      "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.444187+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5057E92P116VM284270",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 284270,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1942,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061",
      "ID": 4166
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5057,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.01912+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2853E33P128VM258719",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258719,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1942,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061",
      "ID": 4166
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Pentland",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3196961+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5009E126P306VM318241",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 318241,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1942,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061",
      "ID": 4166
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5009,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6442236+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3745E233P381VM256075",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 256075,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1942,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061",
      "ID": 4166
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3745,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis",
      "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5695553+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1870E225P478VM294517",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 294517,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1942,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061",
      "ID": 4166
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1870,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona",
      "DisplayName": "Shona Robison",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1418223+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2135E254P450VM235989",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235989,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1942,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061",
      "ID": 4166
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2135,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Russell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.701581+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1895E232P431VM256000",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 256000,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1942,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061",
      "ID": 4166
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1895,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5660476+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1839E21P87VM229408",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229408,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1942,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061",
      "ID": 4166
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1839,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0805018+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2345E10P55VM288395",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 288395,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1942,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061",
      "ID": 4166
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2345,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1329953+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2223E176P333VM310455",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 310455,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1942,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061",
      "ID": 4166
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2223,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish",
      "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5716064+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2182E87P175VM247165",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247165,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1942,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061",
      "ID": 4166
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2182,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1698821+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298698",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298698,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1942,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061",
      "ID": 4166
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5079,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew",
      "DisplayName": "Drew Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3683966+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1769E32P285VM235816",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235816,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1942,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061",
      "ID": 4166
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1769,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6941972+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4014E14P26VM275350",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 275350,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1942,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061",
      "ID": 4166
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4014,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz",
      "DisplayName": "Liz Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.3714139+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2215E224P447VM274173",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274173,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1942,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061",
      "ID": 4166
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2215,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6578388+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3806E103P127VM316802",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 316802,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1942,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061",
      "ID": 4166
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3806,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.1641222+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326017",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 326017,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1942,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061",
      "ID": 4166
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5106,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin",
      "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5316519+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241510",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241510,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1942,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061",
      "ID": 4166
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1848,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola",
      "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7679302+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2098E237P531VM287981",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 287981,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1942,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061",
      "ID": 4166
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2098,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Swinney",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.894903+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248241",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248241,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1942,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061",
      "ID": 4166
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2674,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave",
      "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6374069+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5075E234P371VM289138",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289138,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1942,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061",
      "ID": 4166
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5075,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Torrance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1737423+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1793E151P362VM222791",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 222791,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1942,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061",
      "ID": 4166
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1793,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean",
      "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.2048546+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5078E245P7VM306864",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306864,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1942,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061",
      "ID": 4166
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5078,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Walker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5770103+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1841E231P426VM240765",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 240765,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1942,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061",
      "ID": 4166
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1841,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen",
      "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3813348+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4952E148P370VM284080",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 284080,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1942,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061",
      "ID": 4166
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4952,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7421423+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1865E263P500VM251649",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251649,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1942,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061",
      "ID": 4166
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1865,
      "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra",
      "DisplayName": "Sandra White",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4827825+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2610E160P413VM246745",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 246745,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1942,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061",
      "ID": 4166
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2610,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Wilson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.151603+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309722",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 309722,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1942,
      "AgendaID": 2403,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Consultation on the Proposed Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-04061",
      "ID": 4166
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4941,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza",
      "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3418918+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252637",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252637,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1938,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.3",
      "ID": 4170
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1926,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian",
      "DisplayName": "Brian Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7380306+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2615E213P388VM258865",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258865,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1938,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.3",
      "ID": 4170
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2615,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George",
      "DisplayName": "George Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3313382+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319867",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319867,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1938,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.3",
      "ID": 4170
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4940,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare",
      "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9448082+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249637",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 249637,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1938,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.3",
      "ID": 4170
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2641,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair",
      "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9433864+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1783E21P273VM227742",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227742,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1938,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.3",
      "ID": 4170
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1783,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie",
      "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5636904+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2633E97P136VM280744",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280744,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1938,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.3",
      "ID": 4170
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2633,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire",
      "DisplayName": "Claire Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7805866+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262502",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262502,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1938,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.3",
      "ID": 4170
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2603,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6046931+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1759E91P115VM229753",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229753,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1938,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.3",
      "ID": 4170
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia",
      "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0952089+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270162",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270162,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1938,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.3",
      "ID": 4170
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3751,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5842132+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322707",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 322707,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1938,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.3",
      "ID": 4170
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5109,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco",
      "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.7002137+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5060E86P124VM294733",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 294733,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1938,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.3",
      "ID": 4170
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5060,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1759801+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242886",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242886,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1938,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.3",
      "ID": 4170
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1866,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah",
      "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0397924+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235226",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235226,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1938,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.3",
      "ID": 4170
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1943,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic",
      "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.661229+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302161",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 302161,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1938,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.3",
      "ID": 4170
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2595,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin",
      "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.2999586+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244498",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244498,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1938,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.3",
      "ID": 4170
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2103,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith",
      "DisplayName": "Keith Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.557367+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327193",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 327193,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1938,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.3",
      "ID": 4170
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.8031835+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3775E216P435VM276685",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276685,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1938,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.3",
      "ID": 4170
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.676755+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264332",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264332,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1938,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.3",
      "ID": 4170
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2673,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick",
      "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1289525+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248760",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248760,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1938,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.3",
      "ID": 4170
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2678,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson",
      "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6685961+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2123E27P233VM295797",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295797,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1938,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.3",
      "ID": 4170
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2123,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm",
      "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5362837+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285163",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285163,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1938,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.3",
      "ID": 4170
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3907,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0691582+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230641",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230641,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1938,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.3",
      "ID": 4170
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1735,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela",
      "DisplayName": "Angela Constance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3389181+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243833",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 243833,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1938,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.3",
      "ID": 4170
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1932,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce",
      "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3217196+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254928",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254928,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1938,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.3",
      "ID": 4170
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1863,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna",
      "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2898086+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323800",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 323800,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1938,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.3",
      "ID": 4170
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4976,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth",
      "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9724594+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5107E223P379VM291322",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291322,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1938,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.3",
      "ID": 4170
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5107,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1139492+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3743E222P391VM265334",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265334,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1938,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.3",
      "ID": 4170
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3743,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel",
      "DisplayName": "Nigel Don",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4346891+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262264",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262264,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1938,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.3",
      "ID": 4170
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3771,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob",
      "DisplayName": "Bob Doris",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.59399+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281997",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 281997,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1938,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.3",
      "ID": 4170
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2826,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Dornan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1667602+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3812E94P117VM297975",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 297975,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1938,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.3",
      "ID": 4170
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3812,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia",
      "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.132946+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231591",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231591,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1938,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.3",
      "ID": 4170
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1778,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen",
      "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6072156+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4955E240P389VM285918",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285918,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1938,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.3",
      "ID": 4170
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4955,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3501481+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219401",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 219401,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1938,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.3",
      "ID": 4170
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1742,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle",
      "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.2971194+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238561",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 238561,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1938,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.3",
      "ID": 4170
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1994,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus",
      "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.459426+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225443",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225443,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1938,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.3",
      "ID": 4170
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1814,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda",
      "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9749572+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321752",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 321752,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1938,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.3",
      "ID": 4170
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Fee",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4498757+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292771",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 292771,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1938,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.3",
      "ID": 4170
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia",
      "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5574587+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227127",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227127,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1938,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.3",
      "ID": 4170
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2689865+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5054E95P118VM312677",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 312677,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1938,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.3",
      "ID": 4170
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5054,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1386082+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4947E152P361VM257182",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257182,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1938,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.3",
      "ID": 4170
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4947,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Finnie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.8268478+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271273",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271273,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1938,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.3",
      "ID": 4170
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3901,
      "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe",
      "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0631755+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278442",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 278442,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1938,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.3",
      "ID": 4170
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2394,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo",
      "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2189815+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2110E220P414VM286749",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286749,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1938,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.3",
      "ID": 4170
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth",
      "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5990479+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250460",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250460,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1938,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.3",
      "ID": 4170
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2675,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob",
      "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1905059+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1741E10P50VM220928",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220928,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1938,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.3",
      "ID": 4170
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1741,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel",
      "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6676865+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220242",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220242,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1938,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.3",
      "ID": 4170
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1756,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine",
      "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6299668+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1860E104P150VM252337",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252337,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1938,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.3",
      "ID": 4170
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1860,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda",
      "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.724844+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2033E20P141VM266129",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 266129,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1938,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.3",
      "ID": 4170
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2033,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain",
      "DisplayName": "Iain Gray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4755868+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324605",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324605,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1938,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.3",
      "ID": 4170
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5042,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2301496+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259707",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 259707,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1938,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.3",
      "ID": 4170
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick",
      "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6210575+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239335",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239335,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1938,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.3",
      "ID": 4170
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2029,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh",
      "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7323839+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273803",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 273803,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1938,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.3",
      "ID": 4170
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3758,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6363294+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304168",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 304168,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1938,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.3",
      "ID": 4170
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4086,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Hume",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8526996+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221767",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221767,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1938,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.3",
      "ID": 4170
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1773,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9469322+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1882E227P459VM242000",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242000,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1938,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.3",
      "ID": 4170
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1882,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam",
      "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7895078+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223539",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223539,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1938,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.3",
      "ID": 4170
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1893,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4627963+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307559",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307559,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1938,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.3",
      "ID": 4170
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4934,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8347451+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272199",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 272199,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1938,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.3",
      "ID": 4170
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4956,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Keir",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3191279+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244895",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244895,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1938,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.3",
      "ID": 4170
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Kelly",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5832171+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315065",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315065,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1938,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.3",
      "ID": 4170
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3129,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6725759+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247933",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247933,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1938,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.3",
      "ID": 4170
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann",
      "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4345982+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4016E11P36VM274812",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274812,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1938,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.3",
      "ID": 4170
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4016,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1228058+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255783",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255783,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1938,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.3",
      "ID": 4170
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2180,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5566794+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4938E158P374VM277433",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277433,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1938,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.3",
      "ID": 4170
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4938,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.95317+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2112E250P486VM253029",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253029,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1938,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.3",
      "ID": 4170
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2112,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny",
      "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7637841+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4939E258P394VM276827",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276827,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1938,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.3",
      "ID": 4170
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4939,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus",
      "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6827742+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325526",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 325526,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1938,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.3",
      "ID": 4170
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5074,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon",
      "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5101599+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1828E3P10VM232842",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232842,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1938,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.3",
      "ID": 4170
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1828,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo",
      "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8789532+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311406",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311406,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1938,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.3",
      "ID": 4170
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4948,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike",
      "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8774204+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2117E90P107VM230395",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230395,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1938,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.3",
      "ID": 4170
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2117,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis",
      "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3279492+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267342",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 267342,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1938,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.3",
      "ID": 4170
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken",
      "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0153093+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313755",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313755,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1938,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.3",
      "ID": 4170
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4966,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek",
      "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4092617+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3101E102P129VM295407",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295407,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1938,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.3",
      "ID": 4170
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3101,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala",
      "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5108471+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319001",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319001,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1938,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.3",
      "ID": 4170
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5034,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny",
      "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6881773+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306421",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306421,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1938,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.3",
      "ID": 4170
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2159,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Martin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5513497+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5110E252P395VM310773",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 310773,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1938,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.3",
      "ID": 4170
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Mason",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5854357+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268261",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 268261,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1938,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.3",
      "ID": 4170
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2133,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2558164+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2876E141P433VM286311",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286311,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1938,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.3",
      "ID": 4170
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2876,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5733463+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4951E147P368VM260685",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 260685,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1938,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.3",
      "ID": 4170
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4951,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan",
      "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.0878532+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3896E175P307VM263875",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 263875,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1938,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.3",
      "ID": 4170
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3896,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam",
      "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9145197+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308714",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 308714,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1938,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.3",
      "ID": 4170
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.067795+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4964E143P375VM279675",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279675,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1938,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.3",
      "ID": 4170
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4964,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5178132+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279985",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279985,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1938,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.3",
      "ID": 4170
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3824,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5313398+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2066E22P91VM261092",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261092,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1938,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.3",
      "ID": 4170
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2066,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.1114664+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299688",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 299688,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1938,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.3",
      "ID": 4170
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7084682+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306746",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306746,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1938,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.3",
      "ID": 4170
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina",
      "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5656359+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300589",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 300589,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1938,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.3",
      "ID": 4170
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2487,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0051332+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223677",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223677,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1938,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.3",
      "ID": 4170
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4690681+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237506",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237506,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1938,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.3",
      "ID": 4170
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1961,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David",
      "DisplayName": "David McLetchie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2135994+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305446",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 305446,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1938,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.3",
      "ID": 4170
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2134,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3243858+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320425",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 320425,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1938,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.3",
      "ID": 4170
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5041,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan",
      "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1658499+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3763E142P397VM316017",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 316017,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1938,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.3",
      "ID": 4170
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3763,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart",
      "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.942261+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1986E23P197VM236316",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 236316,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1938,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.3",
      "ID": 4170
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1986,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan",
      "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9111613+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5047E100P130VM291418",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291418,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1938,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.3",
      "ID": 4170
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5047,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne",
      "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1184565+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234599",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234599,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1938,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.3",
      "ID": 4170
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1845,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette",
      "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3912571+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313587",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313587,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1938,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.3",
      "ID": 4170
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3061,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4018133+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1768E19P265VM288583",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 288583,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1938,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.3",
      "ID": 4170
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1768,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1496458+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225091",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225091,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1938,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.3",
      "ID": 4170
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1894,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Neil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.744101+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3815E98P134VM270918",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270918,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1938,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.3",
      "ID": 4170
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3815,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Park, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Park",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8290508+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265885",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265885,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1938,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.3",
      "ID": 4170
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2010,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil",
      "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4647527+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283313",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283313,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1938,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.3",
      "ID": 4170
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5057,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.6953021+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2853E33P128VM251479",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251479,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1938,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.3",
      "ID": 4170
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Pentland",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4654405+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317645",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317645,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1938,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.3",
      "ID": 4170
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5009,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4313251+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254703",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254703,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1938,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.3",
      "ID": 4170
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3745,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis",
      "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2800972+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1870E225P478VM296250",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 296250,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1938,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.3",
      "ID": 4170
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1870,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona",
      "DisplayName": "Shona Robison",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8405479+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2135E254P450VM234922",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234922,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1938,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.3",
      "ID": 4170
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2135,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Russell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4055519+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1895E232P431VM257414",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257414,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1938,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.3",
      "ID": 4170
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1895,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0551773+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228116",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 228116,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1938,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.3",
      "ID": 4170
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1839,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5850409+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2345E10P55VM291682",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291682,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1938,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.3",
      "ID": 4170
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2345,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1377689+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311034",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311034,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1938,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.3",
      "ID": 4170
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2223,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish",
      "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.6025847+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246337",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 246337,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1938,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.3",
      "ID": 4170
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2182,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1243856+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298171",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298171,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1938,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.3",
      "ID": 4170
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5079,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew",
      "DisplayName": "Drew Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1412571+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234356",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234356,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1938,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.3",
      "ID": 4170
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1769,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3737411+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274590",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274590,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1938,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.3",
      "ID": 4170
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4014,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz",
      "DisplayName": "Liz Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1131843+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269509",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269509,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1938,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.3",
      "ID": 4170
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2215,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5506932+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317376",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317376,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1938,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.3",
      "ID": 4170
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3806,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4194595+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326304",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 326304,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1938,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.3",
      "ID": 4170
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5106,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin",
      "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7526818+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241128",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241128,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1938,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.3",
      "ID": 4170
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1848,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola",
      "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.4032311+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2098E237P531VM289639",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289639,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1938,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.3",
      "ID": 4170
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2098,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Swinney",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4526572+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2674E247P401VM247796",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247796,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1938,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.3",
      "ID": 4170
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2674,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave",
      "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4288066+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5075E234P371VM287397",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 287397,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1938,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.3",
      "ID": 4170
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5075,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Torrance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.862473+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1793E151P362VM222492",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 222492,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1938,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.3",
      "ID": 4170
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1793,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean",
      "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1912906+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5078E245P7VM306960",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306960,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1938,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.3",
      "ID": 4170
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5078,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Walker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5813017+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1841E231P426VM240149",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 240149,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1938,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.3",
      "ID": 4170
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1841,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen",
      "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7810592+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283463",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283463,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1938,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.3",
      "ID": 4170
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4952,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7089728+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1865E263P500VM232222",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232222,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1938,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.3",
      "ID": 4170
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1865,
      "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra",
      "DisplayName": "Sandra White",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8454085+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237757",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237757,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1938,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.3",
      "ID": 4170
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2610,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Wilson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2248019+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309279",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 309279,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1938,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 4,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.3",
      "ID": 4170
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4941,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza",
      "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3224773+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252636",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252636,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1937,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 10,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.2",
      "ID": 4168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1926,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian",
      "DisplayName": "Brian Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7379891+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2615E213P388VM258864",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258864,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1937,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 10,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.2",
      "ID": 4168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2615,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George",
      "DisplayName": "George Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3312976+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319868",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319868,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1937,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 10,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.2",
      "ID": 4168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4940,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare",
      "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9448491+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249638",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 249638,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1937,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 10,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.2",
      "ID": 4168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2641,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair",
      "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9434264+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1783E21P273VM227741",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227741,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1937,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 10,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.2",
      "ID": 4168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1783,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie",
      "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5636507+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2633E97P136VM280743",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280743,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1937,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 10,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.2",
      "ID": 4168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2633,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire",
      "DisplayName": "Claire Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7805463+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262501",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262501,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1937,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 10,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.2",
      "ID": 4168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2603,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6046526+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1759E91P115VM229752",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229752,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1937,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 10,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.2",
      "ID": 4168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia",
      "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0951689+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270163",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270163,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1937,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 10,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.2",
      "ID": 4168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3751,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5842726+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322706",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 322706,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1937,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 10,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.2",
      "ID": 4168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5109,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco",
      "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.7001737+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5060E86P124VM294732",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 294732,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1937,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 10,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.2",
      "ID": 4168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5060,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1759391+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242885",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242885,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1937,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 10,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.2",
      "ID": 4168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1866,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah",
      "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0397525+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235227",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235227,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1937,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 10,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.2",
      "ID": 4168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1943,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic",
      "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.661271+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302160",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 302160,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1937,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 10,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.2",
      "ID": 4168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2595,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin",
      "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.2999098+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244499",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244499,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1937,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 10,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.2",
      "ID": 4168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2103,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith",
      "DisplayName": "Keith Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5574083+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327192",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 327192,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1937,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 10,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.2",
      "ID": 4168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.8031423+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3775E216P435VM276684",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276684,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1937,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 10,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.2",
      "ID": 4168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6767145+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264333",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264333,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1937,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 10,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.2",
      "ID": 4168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2673,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick",
      "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1289933+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248761",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248761,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1937,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 10,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.2",
      "ID": 4168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2678,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson",
      "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.668711+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2123E27P233VM295798",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295798,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1937,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 10,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.2",
      "ID": 4168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2123,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm",
      "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5363236+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285162",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285162,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1937,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 10,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.2",
      "ID": 4168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3907,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0691165+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230181",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230181,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1937,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 10,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.2",
      "ID": 4168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1735,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela",
      "DisplayName": "Angela Constance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.1197189+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243834",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 243834,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1937,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 10,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.2",
      "ID": 4168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1932,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce",
      "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3217595+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254929",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254929,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1937,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 10,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.2",
      "ID": 4168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1863,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna",
      "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.28985+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323799",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 323799,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1937,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 10,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.2",
      "ID": 4168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4976,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth",
      "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9724177+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5107E223P379VM291323",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291323,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1937,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 10,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.2",
      "ID": 4168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5107,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1139906+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3743E222P391VM265333",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265333,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1937,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 10,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.2",
      "ID": 4168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3743,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel",
      "DisplayName": "Nigel Don",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4346483+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262263",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262263,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1937,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 10,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.2",
      "ID": 4168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3771,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob",
      "DisplayName": "Bob Doris",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.5939487+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281998",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 281998,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1937,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 10,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.2",
      "ID": 4168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2826,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Dornan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1668014+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3812E94P117VM297974",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 297974,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1937,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 10,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.2",
      "ID": 4168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3812,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia",
      "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.132888+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231592",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231592,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1937,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 10,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.2",
      "ID": 4168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1778,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen",
      "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.607257+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4955E240P389VM285919",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285919,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1937,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 10,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.2",
      "ID": 4168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4955,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3501893+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219400",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 219400,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1937,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 10,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.2",
      "ID": 4168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1742,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle",
      "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.2970733+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238562",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 238562,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1937,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 10,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.2",
      "ID": 4168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1994,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus",
      "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.459489+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225444",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225444,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1937,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 10,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.2",
      "ID": 4168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1814,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda",
      "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9749984+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321753",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 321753,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1937,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 10,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.2",
      "ID": 4168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Fee",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.449916+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292919",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 292919,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1937,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 10,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.2",
      "ID": 4168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia",
      "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5638558+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227126",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227126,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1937,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 10,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.2",
      "ID": 4168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2689457+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5054E95P118VM312676",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 312676,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1937,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 10,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.2",
      "ID": 4168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5054,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1385496+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4947E152P361VM257181",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257181,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1937,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 10,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.2",
      "ID": 4168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4947,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Finnie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.826805+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271274",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271274,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1937,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 10,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.2",
      "ID": 4168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3901,
      "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe",
      "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0632175+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278443",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 278443,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1937,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 10,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.2",
      "ID": 4168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2394,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo",
      "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.219023+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2110E220P414VM286748",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286748,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1937,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 10,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.2",
      "ID": 4168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth",
      "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5990084+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250459",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250459,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1937,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 10,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.2",
      "ID": 4168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2675,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob",
      "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1904456+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1741E10P50VM220927",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220927,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1937,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 10,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.2",
      "ID": 4168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1741,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel",
      "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6676448+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220243",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220243,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1937,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 10,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.2",
      "ID": 4168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1756,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine",
      "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6300088+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1860E104P150VM252336",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252336,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1937,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 10,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.2",
      "ID": 4168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1860,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda",
      "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7248023+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2033E20P141VM266130",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 266130,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1937,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 10,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.2",
      "ID": 4168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2033,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain",
      "DisplayName": "Iain Gray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4756274+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324606",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324606,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1937,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 10,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.2",
      "ID": 4168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5042,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.230208+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259708",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 259708,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1937,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 10,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.2",
      "ID": 4168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick",
      "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6210991+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239334",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239334,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1937,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 10,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.2",
      "ID": 4168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2029,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh",
      "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7323421+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273804",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 273804,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1937,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 10,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.2",
      "ID": 4168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3758,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6363706+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304169",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 304169,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1937,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 10,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.2",
      "ID": 4168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4086,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Hume",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.852776+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221768",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221768,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1937,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 10,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.2",
      "ID": 4168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1773,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.946973+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1882E227P459VM242001",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242001,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1937,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 10,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.2",
      "ID": 4168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1882,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam",
      "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7895491+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223540",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223540,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1937,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 10,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.2",
      "ID": 4168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1893,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4628372+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307558",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307558,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1937,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 10,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.2",
      "ID": 4168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4934,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8347043+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272198",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 272198,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1937,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 10,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.2",
      "ID": 4168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4956,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Keir",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3190709+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244894",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244894,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1937,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 10,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.2",
      "ID": 4168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Kelly",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5831769+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315064",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315064,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1937,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 10,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.2",
      "ID": 4168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3129,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6725346+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247934",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247934,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1937,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 10,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.2",
      "ID": 4168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann",
      "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4346401+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4016E11P36VM274811",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274811,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1937,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 10,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.2",
      "ID": 4168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4016,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1227654+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255784",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255784,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1937,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 10,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.2",
      "ID": 4168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2180,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5567193+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4938E158P374VM277434",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277434,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1937,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 10,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.2",
      "ID": 4168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4938,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.953211+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2112E250P486VM253028",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253028,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1937,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 10,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.2",
      "ID": 4168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2112,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny",
      "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7637428+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4939E258P394VM276828",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276828,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1937,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 10,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.2",
      "ID": 4168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4939,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus",
      "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6828157+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325525",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 325525,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1937,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 10,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.2",
      "ID": 4168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5074,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon",
      "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5101193+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1828E3P10VM232841",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232841,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1937,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 10,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.2",
      "ID": 4168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1828,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo",
      "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8789122+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311405",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311405,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1937,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 10,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.2",
      "ID": 4168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4948,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike",
      "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8773776+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2117E90P107VM230396",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230396,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1937,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 10,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.2",
      "ID": 4168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2117,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis",
      "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3279906+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267341",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 267341,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1937,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 10,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.2",
      "ID": 4168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken",
      "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0152683+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313756",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313756,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1937,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 10,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.2",
      "ID": 4168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4966,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek",
      "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4093017+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3101E102P129VM295408",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295408,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1937,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 10,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.2",
      "ID": 4168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3101,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala",
      "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5108886+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319002",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319002,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1937,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 10,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.2",
      "ID": 4168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5034,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny",
      "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6882202+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306422",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306422,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1937,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 10,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.2",
      "ID": 4168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2159,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Martin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5513905+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5110E252P395VM311227",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311227,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1937,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 10,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.2",
      "ID": 4168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Mason",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.867475+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268262",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 268262,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1937,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 10,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.2",
      "ID": 4168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2133,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2558568+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2876E141P433VM286310",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286310,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1937,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 10,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.2",
      "ID": 4168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2876,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5733051+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4951E147P368VM260686",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 260686,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1937,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 10,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.2",
      "ID": 4168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4951,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan",
      "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.0878935+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3896E175P307VM263876",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 263876,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1937,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 10,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.2",
      "ID": 4168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3896,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam",
      "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9145788+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308412",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 308412,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1937,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 10,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.2",
      "ID": 4168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0548274+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4964E143P375VM279674",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279674,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1937,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 10,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.2",
      "ID": 4168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4964,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.517773+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279986",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279986,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1937,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 10,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.2",
      "ID": 4168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3824,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5313826+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2066E22P91VM261093",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261093,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1937,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 10,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.2",
      "ID": 4168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2066,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.1115078+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299689",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 299689,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1937,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 10,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.2",
      "ID": 4168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7085088+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306598",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306598,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1937,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 10,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.2",
      "ID": 4168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina",
      "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5589469+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2487E146P369VM301197",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 301197,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1937,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 10,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.2",
      "ID": 4168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2487,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.2514096+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223676",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223676,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1937,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 10,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.2",
      "ID": 4168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4690269+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237505",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237505,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1937,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 10,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.2",
      "ID": 4168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1961,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David",
      "DisplayName": "David McLetchie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2135545+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305445",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 305445,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1937,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 10,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.2",
      "ID": 4168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2134,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3243428+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320424",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 320424,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1937,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 10,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.2",
      "ID": 4168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5041,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan",
      "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1658087+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3763E142P397VM316018",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 316018,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1937,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 10,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.2",
      "ID": 4168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3763,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart",
      "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.942302+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1986E23P197VM236315",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 236315,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1937,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 10,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.2",
      "ID": 4168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1986,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan",
      "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9111008+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5047E100P130VM291419",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291419,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1937,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 10,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.2",
      "ID": 4168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5047,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne",
      "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.118498+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234600",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234600,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1937,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 10,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.2",
      "ID": 4168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1845,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette",
      "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3912991+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313588",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313588,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1937,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 10,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.2",
      "ID": 4168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3061,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4018546+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1768E19P265VM288582",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 288582,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1937,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 10,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.2",
      "ID": 4168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1768,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1496044+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225090",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225090,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1937,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 10,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.2",
      "ID": 4168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1894,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Neil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7440608+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3815E98P134VM270917",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270917,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1937,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 10,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.2",
      "ID": 4168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3815,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Park, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Park",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8290094+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265886",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265886,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1937,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 10,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.2",
      "ID": 4168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2010,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil",
      "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4647944+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283314",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283314,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1937,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 10,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.2",
      "ID": 4168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5057,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.6953681+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2853E33P128VM251478",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251478,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1937,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 10,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.2",
      "ID": 4168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Pentland",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4653987+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317644",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317644,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1937,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 10,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.2",
      "ID": 4168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5009,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4312846+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254704",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254704,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1937,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 10,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.2",
      "ID": 4168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3745,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis",
      "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2801383+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1870E225P478VM295641",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295641,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1937,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 10,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.2",
      "ID": 4168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1870,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona",
      "DisplayName": "Shona Robison",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5295932+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2135E254P450VM234921",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234921,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1937,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 10,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.2",
      "ID": 4168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2135,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Russell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4055105+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1895E232P431VM257413",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257413,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1937,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 10,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.2",
      "ID": 4168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1895,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0551367+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228115",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 228115,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1937,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 10,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.2",
      "ID": 4168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1839,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5849994+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2345E10P55VM291683",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291683,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1937,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 10,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.2",
      "ID": 4168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2345,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.137809+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311033",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311033,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1937,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 10,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.2",
      "ID": 4168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2223,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish",
      "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.6025436+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246336",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 246336,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1937,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 10,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.2",
      "ID": 4168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2182,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1243259+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298325",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298325,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1937,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 10,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.2",
      "ID": 4168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5079,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew",
      "DisplayName": "Drew Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3408801+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234357",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234357,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1937,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 10,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.2",
      "ID": 4168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1769,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3737819+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274589",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274589,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1937,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 10,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.2",
      "ID": 4168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4014,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz",
      "DisplayName": "Liz Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1131426+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269508",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269508,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1937,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 10,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.2",
      "ID": 4168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2215,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5506525+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317375",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317375,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1937,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 10,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.2",
      "ID": 4168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3806,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4194185+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326305",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 326305,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1937,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 10,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.2",
      "ID": 4168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5106,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin",
      "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.752723+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241127",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241127,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1937,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 10,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.2",
      "ID": 4168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1848,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola",
      "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.40319+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2098E237P531VM289638",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289638,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1937,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 10,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.2",
      "ID": 4168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2098,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Swinney",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.452599+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2674E247P401VM247795",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247795,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1937,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 10,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.2",
      "ID": 4168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2674,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave",
      "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4287653+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5075E234P371VM287396",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 287396,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1937,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 10,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.2",
      "ID": 4168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5075,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Torrance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8624307+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1793E151P362VM222491",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 222491,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1937,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 10,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.2",
      "ID": 4168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1793,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean",
      "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1912496+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5078E245P7VM307101",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307101,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1937,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 10,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.2",
      "ID": 4168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5078,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Walker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.587321+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1841E231P426VM240150",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 240150,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1937,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 10,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.2",
      "ID": 4168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1841,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen",
      "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7811+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283462",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283462,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1937,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 10,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.2",
      "ID": 4168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4952,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7089312+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1865E263P500VM232223",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232223,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1937,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 10,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.2",
      "ID": 4168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1865,
      "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra",
      "DisplayName": "Sandra White",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8454507+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237758",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237758,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1937,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 10,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.2",
      "ID": 4168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2610,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Wilson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.224857+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309280",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 309280,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1937,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 10,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.2",
      "ID": 4168
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4941,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza",
      "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3225187+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252635",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252635,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1936,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 79,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.1",
      "ID": 4164
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1926,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian",
      "DisplayName": "Brian Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.737948+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2615E213P388VM258863",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258863,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1936,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 79,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.1",
      "ID": 4164
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2615,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George",
      "DisplayName": "George Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3312559+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319869",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319869,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1936,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 79,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.1",
      "ID": 4164
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4940,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare",
      "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9448899+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249639",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 249639,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1936,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 79,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.1",
      "ID": 4164
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2641,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair",
      "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9434949+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1783E21P273VM227740",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227740,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1936,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 79,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.1",
      "ID": 4164
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1783,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie",
      "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5636105+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2633E97P136VM280742",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280742,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1936,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 79,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.1",
      "ID": 4164
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2633,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire",
      "DisplayName": "Claire Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7805065+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262500",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262500,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1936,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 79,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.1",
      "ID": 4164
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2603,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6046122+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1759E91P115VM229751",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229751,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1936,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 79,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.1",
      "ID": 4164
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia",
      "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0951288+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270164",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270164,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1936,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 79,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.1",
      "ID": 4164
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3751,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5843145+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322705",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 322705,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1936,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 79,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.1",
      "ID": 4164
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5109,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco",
      "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.7001342+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5060E86P124VM294731",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 294731,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1936,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 79,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.1",
      "ID": 4164
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5060,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1758983+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242884",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242884,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1936,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 79,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.1",
      "ID": 4164
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1866,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah",
      "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0397122+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235228",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235228,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1936,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 79,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.1",
      "ID": 4164
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1943,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic",
      "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6613119+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302159",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 302159,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1936,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 79,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.1",
      "ID": 4164
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2595,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin",
      "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.2998594+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244500",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244500,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1936,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 79,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.1",
      "ID": 4164
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2103,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith",
      "DisplayName": "Keith Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5574509+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327191",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 327191,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1936,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 79,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.1",
      "ID": 4164
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.8031001+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3775E216P435VM276683",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276683,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1936,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 79,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.1",
      "ID": 4164
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6766741+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264334",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264334,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1936,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 79,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.1",
      "ID": 4164
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2673,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick",
      "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1290345+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248762",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248762,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1936,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 79,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.1",
      "ID": 4164
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2678,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson",
      "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6687658+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2123E27P233VM295799",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295799,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1936,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 79,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.1",
      "ID": 4164
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2123,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm",
      "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5363635+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285161",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285161,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1936,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 79,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.1",
      "ID": 4164
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3907,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0690573+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230180",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230180,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1936,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 79,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.1",
      "ID": 4164
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1735,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela",
      "DisplayName": "Angela Constance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.1196781+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243835",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 243835,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1936,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 79,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.1",
      "ID": 4164
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1932,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce",
      "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3218377+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254930",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254930,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1936,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 79,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.1",
      "ID": 4164
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1863,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna",
      "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2898916+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323798",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 323798,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1936,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 79,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.1",
      "ID": 4164
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4976,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth",
      "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9723766+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5107E223P379VM291324",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291324,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1936,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 79,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.1",
      "ID": 4164
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5107,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1140312+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3743E222P391VM265332",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265332,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1936,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 79,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.1",
      "ID": 4164
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3743,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel",
      "DisplayName": "Nigel Don",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4346076+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262262",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262262,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1936,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 79,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.1",
      "ID": 4164
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3771,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob",
      "DisplayName": "Bob Doris",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.5939082+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281999",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 281999,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1936,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 79,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.1",
      "ID": 4164
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2826,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Dornan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1668424+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3812E94P117VM297973",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 297973,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1936,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 79,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.1",
      "ID": 4164
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3812,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia",
      "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1328486+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231593",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231593,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1936,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 79,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.1",
      "ID": 4164
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1778,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen",
      "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6072984+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4955E240P389VM285920",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285920,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1936,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 79,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.1",
      "ID": 4164
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4955,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3502306+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219357",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 219357,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1936,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 79,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.1",
      "ID": 4164
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1742,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle",
      "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.2951318+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238563",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 238563,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1936,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 79,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.1",
      "ID": 4164
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1994,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus",
      "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4595324+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225445",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225445,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1936,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 79,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.1",
      "ID": 4164
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1814,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda",
      "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9750387+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321754",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 321754,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1936,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 79,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.1",
      "ID": 4164
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Fee",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4499564+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292920",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 292920,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1936,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 79,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.1",
      "ID": 4164
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia",
      "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5639178+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1892E12P64VM226924",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 226924,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1936,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 79,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.1",
      "ID": 4164
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2527466+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5054E95P118VM312675",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 312675,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1936,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 79,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.1",
      "ID": 4164
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5054,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1385093+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4947E152P361VM257180",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257180,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1936,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 79,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.1",
      "ID": 4164
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4947,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Finnie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.8267439+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271275",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271275,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1936,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 79,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.1",
      "ID": 4164
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3901,
      "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe",
      "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0632602+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278444",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 278444,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1936,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 79,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.1",
      "ID": 4164
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2394,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo",
      "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.219065+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2110E220P414VM286747",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286747,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1936,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 79,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.1",
      "ID": 4164
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth",
      "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5989681+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250458",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250458,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1936,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 79,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.1",
      "ID": 4164
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2675,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob",
      "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1904049+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1741E10P50VM220926",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220926,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1936,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 79,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.1",
      "ID": 4164
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1741,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel",
      "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6676013+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220288",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220288,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1936,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 79,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.1",
      "ID": 4164
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1756,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine",
      "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6348357+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1860E104P150VM252335",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252335,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1936,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 79,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.1",
      "ID": 4164
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1860,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda",
      "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7247391+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2033E20P141VM266131",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 266131,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1936,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 79,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.1",
      "ID": 4164
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2033,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain",
      "DisplayName": "Iain Gray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4756687+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324607",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324607,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1936,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 79,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.1",
      "ID": 4164
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5042,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2302507+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259709",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 259709,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1936,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 79,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.1",
      "ID": 4164
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick",
      "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6211408+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239333",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239333,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1936,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 79,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.1",
      "ID": 4164
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2029,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh",
      "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7323013+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273805",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 273805,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1936,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 79,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.1",
      "ID": 4164
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3758,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6364122+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304170",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 304170,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1936,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 79,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.1",
      "ID": 4164
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4086,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Hume",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8528276+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221769",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221769,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1936,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 79,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.1",
      "ID": 4164
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1773,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9470134+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1882E227P459VM242002",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242002,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1936,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 79,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.1",
      "ID": 4164
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1882,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam",
      "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7895907+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223541",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223541,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1936,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 79,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.1",
      "ID": 4164
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1893,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4628779+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307557",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307557,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1936,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 79,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.1",
      "ID": 4164
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4934,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8346628+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272197",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 272197,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1936,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 79,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.1",
      "ID": 4164
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4956,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Keir",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3189994+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244893",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244893,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1936,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 79,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.1",
      "ID": 4164
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Kelly",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5831344+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315063",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315063,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1936,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 79,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.1",
      "ID": 4164
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3129,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6724924+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247935",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247935,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1936,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 79,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.1",
      "ID": 4164
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann",
      "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4346807+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4016E11P36VM274810",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274810,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1936,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 79,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.1",
      "ID": 4164
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4016,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1227245+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255785",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255785,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1936,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 79,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.1",
      "ID": 4164
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2180,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5567595+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4938E158P374VM277435",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277435,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1936,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 79,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.1",
      "ID": 4164
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4938,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9532527+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2112E250P486VM253027",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253027,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1936,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 79,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.1",
      "ID": 4164
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2112,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny",
      "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7637019+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4939E258P394VM276829",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276829,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1936,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 79,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.1",
      "ID": 4164
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4939,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus",
      "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6828575+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325524",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 325524,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1936,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 79,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.1",
      "ID": 4164
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5074,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon",
      "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.510077+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1828E3P10VM232840",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232840,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1936,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 79,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.1",
      "ID": 4164
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1828,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo",
      "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8788696+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311404",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311404,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1936,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 79,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.1",
      "ID": 4164
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4948,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike",
      "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8773134+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2117E90P107VM230397",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230397,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1936,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 79,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.1",
      "ID": 4164
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2117,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis",
      "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3280318+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267340",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 267340,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1936,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 79,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.1",
      "ID": 4164
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken",
      "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0152269+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313757",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313757,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1936,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 79,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.1",
      "ID": 4164
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4966,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek",
      "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4093413+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3101E102P129VM295409",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295409,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1936,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 79,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.1",
      "ID": 4164
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3101,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala",
      "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5109291+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319003",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319003,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1936,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 79,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.1",
      "ID": 4164
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5034,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny",
      "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6882622+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306423",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306423,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1936,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 79,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.1",
      "ID": 4164
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2159,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Martin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5514305+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5110E252P395VM311228",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311228,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1936,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 79,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.1",
      "ID": 4164
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Mason",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8675158+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268263",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 268263,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1936,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 79,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.1",
      "ID": 4164
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2133,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2558976+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2876E141P433VM286309",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286309,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1936,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 79,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.1",
      "ID": 4164
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2876,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5732628+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4951E147P368VM260687",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 260687,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1936,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 79,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.1",
      "ID": 4164
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4951,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan",
      "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.0879342+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3896E175P307VM263877",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 263877,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1936,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 79,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.1",
      "ID": 4164
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3896,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam",
      "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9146214+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308411",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 308411,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1936,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 79,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.1",
      "ID": 4164
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0547865+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4964E143P375VM279673",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279673,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1936,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 79,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.1",
      "ID": 4164
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4964,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5177317+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279987",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279987,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1936,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 79,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.1",
      "ID": 4164
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3824,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5314233+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2066E22P91VM261094",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261094,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1936,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 79,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.1",
      "ID": 4164
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2066,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.1115495+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299690",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 299690,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1936,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 79,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.1",
      "ID": 4164
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7085505+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306597",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306597,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1936,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 79,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.1",
      "ID": 4164
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina",
      "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5589056+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2487E146P369VM301198",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 301198,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1936,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 79,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.1",
      "ID": 4164
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2487,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.2514807+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223675",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223675,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1936,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 79,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.1",
      "ID": 4164
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4689838+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237504",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237504,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1936,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 79,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.1",
      "ID": 4164
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1961,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David",
      "DisplayName": "David McLetchie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.213448+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305444",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 305444,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1936,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 79,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.1",
      "ID": 4164
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2134,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3242821+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320423",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 320423,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1936,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 79,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.1",
      "ID": 4164
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5041,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan",
      "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1657676+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3763E142P397VM316019",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 316019,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1936,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 79,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.1",
      "ID": 4164
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3763,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart",
      "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9423426+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1986E23P197VM236314",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 236314,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1936,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 79,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.1",
      "ID": 4164
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1986,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan",
      "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9110595+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5047E100P130VM291420",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291420,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1936,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 79,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.1",
      "ID": 4164
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5047,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne",
      "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1185387+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234601",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234601,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1936,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 79,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.1",
      "ID": 4164
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1845,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette",
      "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3913402+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313589",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313589,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1936,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 79,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.1",
      "ID": 4164
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3061,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4019146+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1768E19P265VM288581",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 288581,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1936,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 79,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.1",
      "ID": 4164
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1768,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1495634+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225089",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225089,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1936,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 79,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.1",
      "ID": 4164
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1894,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Neil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7440206+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3815E98P134VM270916",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270916,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1936,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 79,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.1",
      "ID": 4164
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3815,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Park, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Park",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8289681+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265887",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265887,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1936,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 79,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.1",
      "ID": 4164
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2010,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil",
      "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4648354+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283315",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283315,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1936,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 79,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.1",
      "ID": 4164
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5057,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.6954101+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2853E33P128VM251477",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251477,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1936,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 79,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.1",
      "ID": 4164
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Pentland",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4653566+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317643",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317643,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1936,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 79,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.1",
      "ID": 4164
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5009,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4312439+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254705",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254705,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1936,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 79,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.1",
      "ID": 4164
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3745,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis",
      "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2801795+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1870E225P478VM295640",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295640,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1936,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 79,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.1",
      "ID": 4164
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1870,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona",
      "DisplayName": "Shona Robison",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5295514+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2135E254P450VM234920",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234920,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1936,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 79,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.1",
      "ID": 4164
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2135,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Russell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4054693+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1895E232P431VM257412",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257412,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1936,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 79,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.1",
      "ID": 4164
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1895,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0550959+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228114",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 228114,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1936,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 79,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.1",
      "ID": 4164
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1839,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5849588+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2345E10P55VM291684",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291684,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1936,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 79,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.1",
      "ID": 4164
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2345,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1378496+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311032",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311032,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1936,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 79,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.1",
      "ID": 4164
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2223,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish",
      "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.6025029+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246335",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 246335,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1936,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 79,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.1",
      "ID": 4164
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2182,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.124285+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298326",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298326,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1936,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 79,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.1",
      "ID": 4164
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5079,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew",
      "DisplayName": "Drew Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3409211+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234358",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234358,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1936,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 79,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.1",
      "ID": 4164
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1769,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3738225+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274588",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274588,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1936,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 79,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.1",
      "ID": 4164
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4014,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz",
      "DisplayName": "Liz Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1131017+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269507",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269507,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1936,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 79,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.1",
      "ID": 4164
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2215,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5506108+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317374",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317374,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1936,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 79,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.1",
      "ID": 4164
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3806,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.419377+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326306",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 326306,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1936,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 79,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.1",
      "ID": 4164
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5106,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin",
      "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7527642+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241126",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241126,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1936,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 79,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.1",
      "ID": 4164
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1848,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola",
      "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.4031482+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2098E237P531VM289637",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289637,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1936,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 79,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.1",
      "ID": 4164
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2098,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Swinney",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4525597+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2674E247P401VM247794",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247794,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1936,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 79,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.1",
      "ID": 4164
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2674,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave",
      "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4287244+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5075E234P371VM287395",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 287395,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1936,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 79,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.1",
      "ID": 4164
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5075,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Torrance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8623672+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1793E151P362VM222456",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 222456,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1936,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 79,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.1",
      "ID": 4164
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1793,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean",
      "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1897457+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5078E245P7VM307102",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307102,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1936,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 79,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.1",
      "ID": 4164
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5078,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Walker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5873623+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1841E231P426VM240151",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 240151,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1936,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 79,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.1",
      "ID": 4164
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1841,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen",
      "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7811409+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283461",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283461,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1936,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 79,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.1",
      "ID": 4164
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4952,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7088899+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1865E263P500VM232224",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232224,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1936,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 79,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.1",
      "ID": 4164
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1865,
      "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra",
      "DisplayName": "Sandra White",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8454925+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237759",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237759,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1936,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 79,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.1",
      "ID": 4164
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2610,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Wilson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2248992+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309281",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 309281,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1936,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 79,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045.1",
      "ID": 4164
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4941,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza",
      "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3225592+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252665",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252665,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1939,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045",
      "ID": 4149
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1926,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian",
      "DisplayName": "Brian Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7483224+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2615E213P388VM258866",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258866,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1939,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045",
      "ID": 4149
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2615,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George",
      "DisplayName": "George Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3313798+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319866",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319866,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1939,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045",
      "ID": 4149
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4940,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare",
      "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9447671+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249636",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 249636,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1939,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045",
      "ID": 4149
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2641,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair",
      "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9433451+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1783E21P273VM227776",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227776,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1939,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045",
      "ID": 4149
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1783,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie",
      "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5651488+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2633E97P136VM280779",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280779,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1939,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045",
      "ID": 4149
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2633,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire",
      "DisplayName": "Claire Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7820476+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262503",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262503,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1939,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045",
      "ID": 4149
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2603,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6047337+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1759E91P115VM229754",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229754,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1939,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045",
      "ID": 4149
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia",
      "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0952492+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270161",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270161,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1939,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045",
      "ID": 4149
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3751,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5841706+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322648",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 322648,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1939,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045",
      "ID": 4149
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5109,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco",
      "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.697747+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5060E86P124VM294734",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 294734,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1939,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045",
      "ID": 4149
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5060,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1760209+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242887",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242887,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1939,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045",
      "ID": 4149
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1866,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah",
      "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0398322+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235225",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235225,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1939,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045",
      "ID": 4149
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1943,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic",
      "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6611879+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302162",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 302162,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1939,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045",
      "ID": 4149
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2595,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin",
      "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.3000126+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244497",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244497,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1939,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045",
      "ID": 4149
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2103,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith",
      "DisplayName": "Keith Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5573259+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327194",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 327194,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1939,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045",
      "ID": 4149
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.8032243+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3775E216P435VM276686",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276686,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1939,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045",
      "ID": 4149
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6767954+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264331",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264331,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1939,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045",
      "ID": 4149
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2673,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick",
      "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1289117+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248759",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248759,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1939,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045",
      "ID": 4149
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2678,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson",
      "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6685547+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2123E27P233VM295796",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295796,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1939,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045",
      "ID": 4149
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2123,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm",
      "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5362432+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285164",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285164,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1939,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045",
      "ID": 4149
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3907,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.069199+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230642",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230642,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1939,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045",
      "ID": 4149
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1735,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela",
      "DisplayName": "Angela Constance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3389779+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243832",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 243832,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1939,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045",
      "ID": 4149
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1932,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce",
      "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3216792+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254927",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254927,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1939,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045",
      "ID": 4149
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1863,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna",
      "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2897672+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323801",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 323801,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1939,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045",
      "ID": 4149
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4976,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth",
      "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9725002+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5107E223P379VM291321",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291321,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1939,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045",
      "ID": 4149
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5107,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.113908+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3743E222P391VM265335",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265335,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1939,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045",
      "ID": 4149
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3743,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel",
      "DisplayName": "Nigel Don",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4347311+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262265",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262265,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1939,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045",
      "ID": 4149
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3771,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob",
      "DisplayName": "Bob Doris",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.5940624+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281962",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 281962,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1939,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045",
      "ID": 4149
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2826,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Dornan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1652708+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298010",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298010,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1939,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045",
      "ID": 4149
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3812,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia",
      "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1344206+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231590",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231590,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1939,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045",
      "ID": 4149
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1778,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen",
      "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6071745+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4955E240P389VM285917",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285917,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1939,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045",
      "ID": 4149
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4955,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3501063+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219402",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 219402,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1939,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045",
      "ID": 4149
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1742,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle",
      "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.2971632+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238560",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 238560,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1939,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045",
      "ID": 4149
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1994,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus",
      "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4593849+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225442",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225442,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1939,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045",
      "ID": 4149
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1814,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda",
      "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9749163+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321812",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 321812,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1939,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045",
      "ID": 4149
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Fee",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4524212+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292783",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 292783,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1939,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045",
      "ID": 4149
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia",
      "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5579658+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227128",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227128,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1939,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045",
      "ID": 4149
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2690284+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5054E95P118VM312678",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 312678,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1939,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045",
      "ID": 4149
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5054,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1386507+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4947E152P361VM257248",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257248,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1939,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045",
      "ID": 4149
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4947,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Finnie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0479461+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271272",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271272,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1939,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045",
      "ID": 4149
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3901,
      "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe",
      "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0631337+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278098",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 278098,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1939,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045",
      "ID": 4149
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2394,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo",
      "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9869157+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2110E220P414VM286750",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286750,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1939,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045",
      "ID": 4149
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth",
      "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5990875+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250527",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250527,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1939,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045",
      "ID": 4149
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2675,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob",
      "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1934197+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1741E10P50VM220929",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220929,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1939,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045",
      "ID": 4149
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1741,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel",
      "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6677286+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220241",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220241,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1939,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045",
      "ID": 4149
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1756,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine",
      "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6299236+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1860E104P150VM252338",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252338,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1939,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045",
      "ID": 4149
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1860,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda",
      "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.724885+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2033E20P141VM266094",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 266094,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1939,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045",
      "ID": 4149
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2033,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain",
      "DisplayName": "Iain Gray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4740942+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324604",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324604,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1939,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045",
      "ID": 4149
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5042,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2301089+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259706",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 259706,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1939,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045",
      "ID": 4149
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick",
      "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6210152+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239336",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239336,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1939,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045",
      "ID": 4149
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2029,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh",
      "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.732425+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273802",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 273802,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1939,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045",
      "ID": 4149
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3758,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6362881+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304167",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 304167,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1939,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045",
      "ID": 4149
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4086,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Hume",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8526491+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221766",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221766,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1939,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045",
      "ID": 4149
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1773,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9468916+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1882E227P459VM241999",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241999,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1939,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045",
      "ID": 4149
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1882,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam",
      "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7894668+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223538",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223538,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1939,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045",
      "ID": 4149
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1893,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4627541+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307594",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307594,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1939,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045",
      "ID": 4149
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4934,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8362421+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272263",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 272263,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1939,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045",
      "ID": 4149
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4956,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Keir",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3221131+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244896",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244896,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1939,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045",
      "ID": 4149
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Kelly",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5832582+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315066",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315066,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1939,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045",
      "ID": 4149
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3129,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6726166+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247932",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247932,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1939,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045",
      "ID": 4149
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann",
      "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4345577+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4016E11P36VM274813",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274813,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1939,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045",
      "ID": 4149
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4016,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1228471+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255782",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255782,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1939,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045",
      "ID": 4149
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2180,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5566393+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4938E158P374VM277432",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277432,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1939,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045",
      "ID": 4149
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4938,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9531289+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2112E250P486VM253030",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253030,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1939,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045",
      "ID": 4149
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2112,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny",
      "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7638439+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4939E258P394VM276826",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276826,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1939,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045",
      "ID": 4149
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4939,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus",
      "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6827341+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325527",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 325527,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1939,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045",
      "ID": 4149
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5074,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon",
      "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5102004+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1828E3P10VM232843",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232843,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1939,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045",
      "ID": 4149
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1828,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo",
      "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8789946+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311439",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311439,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1939,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045",
      "ID": 4149
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4948,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike",
      "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.878872+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2117E90P107VM230394",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230394,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1939,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045",
      "ID": 4149
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2117,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis",
      "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3279076+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267377",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 267377,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1939,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045",
      "ID": 4149
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken",
      "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0170798+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313722",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313722,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1939,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045",
      "ID": 4149
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4966,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek",
      "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4078501+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3101E102P129VM295064",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295064,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1939,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045",
      "ID": 4149
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3101,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala",
      "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1906616+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319062",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319062,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1939,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045",
      "ID": 4149
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5034,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny",
      "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6907873+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306420",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306420,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1939,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045",
      "ID": 4149
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2159,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Martin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5513089+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5110E252P395VM310785",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 310785,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1939,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045",
      "ID": 4149
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Mason",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.585948+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268226",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 268226,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1939,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045",
      "ID": 4149
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2133,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2542988+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2876E141P433VM286346",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286346,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1939,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045",
      "ID": 4149
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2876,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5748624+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4951E147P368VM258608",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258608,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1939,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045",
      "ID": 4149
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4951,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan",
      "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.314607+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3896E175P307VM263874",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 263874,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1939,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045",
      "ID": 4149
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3896,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam",
      "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9144786+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308547",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 308547,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1939,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045",
      "ID": 4149
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0606015+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4964E143P375VM279676",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279676,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1939,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045",
      "ID": 4149
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4964,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5178539+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279984",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279984,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1939,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045",
      "ID": 4149
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3824,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.531279+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2066E22P91VM261091",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261091,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1939,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045",
      "ID": 4149
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2066,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.1114245+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299653",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 299653,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1939,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045",
      "ID": 4149
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7069912+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306734",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306734,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1939,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045",
      "ID": 4149
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina",
      "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5651062+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300601",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 300601,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1939,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045",
      "ID": 4149
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2487,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0056424+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223678",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223678,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1939,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045",
      "ID": 4149
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4691091+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237507",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237507,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1939,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045",
      "ID": 4149
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1961,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David",
      "DisplayName": "David McLetchie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2136411+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305447",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 305447,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1939,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045",
      "ID": 4149
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2134,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3244268+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320364",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 320364,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1939,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045",
      "ID": 4149
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5041,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan",
      "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1632346+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3763E142P397VM316016",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 316016,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1939,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045",
      "ID": 4149
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3763,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart",
      "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9422194+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1986E23P197VM236626",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 236626,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1939,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045",
      "ID": 4149
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1986,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan",
      "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9331158+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5047E100P130VM291417",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291417,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1939,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045",
      "ID": 4149
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5047,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne",
      "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1184155+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234598",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234598,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1939,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045",
      "ID": 4149
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1845,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette",
      "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3912157+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313586",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313586,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1939,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045",
      "ID": 4149
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3061,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4017716+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1768E19P265VM289337",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289337,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1939,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045",
      "ID": 4149
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1768,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4329225+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225092",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225092,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1939,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045",
      "ID": 4149
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1894,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Neil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7441612+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3815E98P134VM270919",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270919,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1939,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045",
      "ID": 4149
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3815,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Park, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Park",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8290918+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265884",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265884,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1939,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045",
      "ID": 4149
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2010,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil",
      "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4647119+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283312",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283312,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1939,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045",
      "ID": 4149
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5057,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.6952589+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2853E33P128VM251480",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251480,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1939,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045",
      "ID": 4149
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Pentland",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4654822+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317585",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317585,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1939,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045",
      "ID": 4149
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5009,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4287657+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254324",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254324,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1939,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045",
      "ID": 4149
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3745,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis",
      "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2506696+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1870E225P478VM296238",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 296238,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1939,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045",
      "ID": 4149
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1870,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona",
      "DisplayName": "Shona Robison",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8400266+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2135E254P450VM234923",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234923,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1939,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045",
      "ID": 4149
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2135,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Russell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4055932+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1895E232P431VM257415",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257415,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1939,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045",
      "ID": 4149
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1895,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0552186+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228117",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 228117,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1939,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045",
      "ID": 4149
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1839,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5850814+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2345E10P55VM291681",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291681,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1939,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045",
      "ID": 4149
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2345,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1377287+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311035",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311035,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1939,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045",
      "ID": 4149
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2223,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish",
      "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.6026264+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246338",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 246338,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1939,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045",
      "ID": 4149
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2182,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1244279+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298170",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298170,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1939,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045",
      "ID": 4149
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5079,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew",
      "DisplayName": "Drew Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1412158+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234355",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234355,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1939,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045",
      "ID": 4149
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1769,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3737+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274591",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274591,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1939,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045",
      "ID": 4149
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4014,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz",
      "DisplayName": "Liz Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1132261+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269544",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269544,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1939,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045",
      "ID": 4149
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2215,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5522161+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317377",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317377,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1939,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045",
      "ID": 4149
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3806,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4195003+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326303",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 326303,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1939,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045",
      "ID": 4149
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5106,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin",
      "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7526401+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241129",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241129,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1939,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045",
      "ID": 4149
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1848,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola",
      "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.4032949+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2098E237P531VM289640",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289640,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1939,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045",
      "ID": 4149
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2098,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Swinney",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4526987+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2674E247P401VM247797",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247797,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1939,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045",
      "ID": 4149
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2674,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave",
      "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4288663+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5075E234P371VM287398",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 287398,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1939,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045",
      "ID": 4149
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5075,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Torrance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8625148+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1793E151P362VM222493",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 222493,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1939,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045",
      "ID": 4149
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1793,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean",
      "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1913315+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5078E245P7VM306972",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306972,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1939,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045",
      "ID": 4149
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5078,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Walker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5818097+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1841E231P426VM240148",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 240148,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1939,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045",
      "ID": 4149
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1841,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen",
      "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7810175+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283464",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283464,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1939,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045",
      "ID": 4149
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4952,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7090137+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1865E263P500VM232188",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232188,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1939,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045",
      "ID": 4149
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1865,
      "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra",
      "DisplayName": "Sandra White",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6386228+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237756",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237756,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1939,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045",
      "ID": 4149
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2610,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Wilson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2246542+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309245",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 309245,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1939,
      "AgendaID": 2623,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Actions to Deliver a Sustainable Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-04045",
      "ID": 4149
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4941,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza",
      "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-11T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3210216+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252304",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252304,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1935,
      "AgendaID": 2234,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03924",
      "ID": 4037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1926,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian",
      "DisplayName": "Brian Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7233842+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2615E213P388VM258830",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258830,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1935,
      "AgendaID": 2234,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03924",
      "ID": 4037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2615,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George",
      "DisplayName": "George Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3297363+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319898",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319898,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1935,
      "AgendaID": 2234,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03924",
      "ID": 4037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4940,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare",
      "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.946148+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249669",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 249669,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1935,
      "AgendaID": 2234,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03924",
      "ID": 4037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2641,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair",
      "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9447394+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1783E21P273VM227411",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227411,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1935,
      "AgendaID": 2234,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03924",
      "ID": 4037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1783,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie",
      "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5489852+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2633E97P136VM280406",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280406,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1935,
      "AgendaID": 2234,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03924",
      "ID": 4037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2633,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire",
      "DisplayName": "Claire Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.765615+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262469",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262469,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1935,
      "AgendaID": 2234,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03924",
      "ID": 4037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2603,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6032852+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1759E91P115VM229255",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229255,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1935,
      "AgendaID": 2234,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03924",
      "ID": 4037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia",
      "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0687747+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270197",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270197,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1935,
      "AgendaID": 2234,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03924",
      "ID": 4037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3751,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.793319+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322682",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 322682,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1935,
      "AgendaID": 2234,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03924",
      "ID": 4037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5109,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco",
      "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6991747+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5060E86P124VM294700",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 294700,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1935,
      "AgendaID": 2234,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03924",
      "ID": 4037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5060,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1745607+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242854",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242854,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1935,
      "AgendaID": 2234,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03924",
      "ID": 4037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1866,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah",
      "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0384485+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235570",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235570,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1935,
      "AgendaID": 2234,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03924",
      "ID": 4037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1943,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic",
      "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6835017+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302124",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 302124,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1935,
      "AgendaID": 2234,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03924",
      "ID": 4037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2595,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin",
      "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.2980992+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244531",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244531,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1935,
      "AgendaID": 2234,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03924",
      "ID": 4037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2103,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith",
      "DisplayName": "Keith Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5587953+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327233",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 327233,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1935,
      "AgendaID": 2234,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03924",
      "ID": 4037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:46.0269897+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3775E216P435VM276652",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276652,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1935,
      "AgendaID": 2234,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03924",
      "ID": 4037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.675347+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264365",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264365,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1935,
      "AgendaID": 2234,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03924",
      "ID": 4037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2673,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick",
      "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1303598+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248805",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248805,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1935,
      "AgendaID": 2234,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03924",
      "ID": 4037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2678,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson",
      "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6708214+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2123E27P233VM295829",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295829,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1935,
      "AgendaID": 2234,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03924",
      "ID": 4037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2123,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm",
      "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5376396+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285130",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285130,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1935,
      "AgendaID": 2234,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03924",
      "ID": 4037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3907,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0677267+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230145",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230145,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1935,
      "AgendaID": 2234,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03924",
      "ID": 4037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1735,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela",
      "DisplayName": "Angela Constance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.118159+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243865",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 243865,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1935,
      "AgendaID": 2234,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03924",
      "ID": 4037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1932,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce",
      "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.323236+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1863E238P523VM255272",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255272,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1935,
      "AgendaID": 2234,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03924",
      "ID": 4037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1863,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna",
      "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5237908+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323868",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 323868,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1935,
      "AgendaID": 2234,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03924",
      "ID": 4037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4976,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth",
      "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9758438+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5107E223P379VM291364",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291364,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1935,
      "AgendaID": 2234,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03924",
      "ID": 4037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5107,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1161226+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3743E222P391VM265145",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265145,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1935,
      "AgendaID": 2234,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03924",
      "ID": 4037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3743,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel",
      "DisplayName": "Nigel Don",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1704263+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262220",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262220,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1935,
      "AgendaID": 2234,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03924",
      "ID": 4037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3771,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob",
      "DisplayName": "Bob Doris",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.5920983+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2826E262P384VM282025",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 282025,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1935,
      "AgendaID": 2234,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03924",
      "ID": 4037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2826,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Dornan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1679694+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3812E94P117VM297948",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 297948,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1935,
      "AgendaID": 2234,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03924",
      "ID": 4037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3812,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia",
      "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1318024+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231628",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231628,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1935,
      "AgendaID": 2234,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03924",
      "ID": 4037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1778,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen",
      "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6087782+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4955E240P389VM285955",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285955,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1935,
      "AgendaID": 2234,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03924",
      "ID": 4037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4955,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3517496+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219359",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 219359,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1935,
      "AgendaID": 2234,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03924",
      "ID": 4037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1742,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle",
      "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.2952145+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238597",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 238597,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1935,
      "AgendaID": 2234,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03924",
      "ID": 4037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1994,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus",
      "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4609748+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225473",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225473,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1935,
      "AgendaID": 2234,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03924",
      "ID": 4037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1814,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda",
      "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9762504+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321778",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 321778,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1935,
      "AgendaID": 2234,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03924",
      "ID": 4037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Fee",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.450988+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1853E35P216VM293265",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 293265,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1935,
      "AgendaID": 2234,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03924",
      "ID": 4037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia",
      "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8375207+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1892E12P64VM226927",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 226927,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1935,
      "AgendaID": 2234,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03924",
      "ID": 4037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2529506+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5054E95P118VM312640",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 312640,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1935,
      "AgendaID": 2234,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03924",
      "ID": 4037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5054,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1370148+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4947E152P361VM257152",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257152,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1935,
      "AgendaID": 2234,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03924",
      "ID": 4037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4947,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Finnie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.8255471+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271311",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271311,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1935,
      "AgendaID": 2234,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03924",
      "ID": 4037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3901,
      "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe",
      "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0700149+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278469",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 278469,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1935,
      "AgendaID": 2234,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03924",
      "ID": 4037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2394,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo",
      "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2201643+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2110E220P414VM286713",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286713,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1935,
      "AgendaID": 2234,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03924",
      "ID": 4037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth",
      "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5975463+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250430",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250430,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1935,
      "AgendaID": 2234,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03924",
      "ID": 4037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2675,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob",
      "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.189212+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1741E10P50VM220742",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220742,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1935,
      "AgendaID": 2234,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03924",
      "ID": 4037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1741,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel",
      "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6550848+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220286",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220286,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1935,
      "AgendaID": 2234,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03924",
      "ID": 4037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1756,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine",
      "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6347497+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1860E104P150VM251841",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251841,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1935,
      "AgendaID": 2234,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03924",
      "ID": 4037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1860,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda",
      "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4914492+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2033E20P141VM266154",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 266154,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1935,
      "AgendaID": 2234,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03924",
      "ID": 4037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2033,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain",
      "DisplayName": "Iain Gray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4766429+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324565",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324565,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1935,
      "AgendaID": 2234,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03924",
      "ID": 4037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5042,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2284648+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259907",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 259907,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1935,
      "AgendaID": 2234,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03924",
      "ID": 4037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick",
      "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6351754+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239300",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239300,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1935,
      "AgendaID": 2234,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03924",
      "ID": 4037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2029,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh",
      "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7308679+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273836",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 273836,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1935,
      "AgendaID": 2234,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03924",
      "ID": 4037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3758,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6377631+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304205",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 304205,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1935,
      "AgendaID": 2234,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03924",
      "ID": 4037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4086,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Hume",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.0282364+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221797",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221797,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1935,
      "AgendaID": 2234,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03924",
      "ID": 4037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1773,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9482365+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1882E227P459VM242032",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242032,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1935,
      "AgendaID": 2234,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03924",
      "ID": 4037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1882,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam",
      "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7908852+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223729",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223729,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1935,
      "AgendaID": 2234,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03924",
      "ID": 4037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1893,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.471273+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307532",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307532,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1935,
      "AgendaID": 2234,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03924",
      "ID": 4037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4934,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8335939+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272169",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 272169,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1935,
      "AgendaID": 2234,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03924",
      "ID": 4037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4956,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Keir",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.1145392+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244862",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244862,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1935,
      "AgendaID": 2234,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03924",
      "ID": 4037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Kelly",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5818157+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315034",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315034,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1935,
      "AgendaID": 2234,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03924",
      "ID": 4037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3129,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6712336+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247968",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247968,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1935,
      "AgendaID": 2234,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03924",
      "ID": 4037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann",
      "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4360797+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4016E11P36VM274775",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274775,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1935,
      "AgendaID": 2234,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03924",
      "ID": 4037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4016,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.121219+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255818",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255818,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1935,
      "AgendaID": 2234,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03924",
      "ID": 4037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2180,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5583781+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4938E158P374VM277470",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277470,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1935,
      "AgendaID": 2234,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03924",
      "ID": 4037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4938,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9547387+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2112E250P486VM252994",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252994,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1935,
      "AgendaID": 2234,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03924",
      "ID": 4037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2112,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny",
      "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7622765+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4939E258P394VM277180",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277180,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1935,
      "AgendaID": 2234,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03924",
      "ID": 4037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4939,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus",
      "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.7045201+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325566",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 325566,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1935,
      "AgendaID": 2234,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03924",
      "ID": 4037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5074,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon",
      "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5118507+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1828E3P10VM232806",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232806,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1935,
      "AgendaID": 2234,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03924",
      "ID": 4037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1828,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo",
      "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8770466+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311379",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311379,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1935,
      "AgendaID": 2234,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03924",
      "ID": 4037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4948,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike",
      "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8761806+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2117E90P107VM230440",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230440,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1935,
      "AgendaID": 2234,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03924",
      "ID": 4037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2117,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis",
      "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3299041+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267317",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 267317,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1935,
      "AgendaID": 2234,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03924",
      "ID": 4037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken",
      "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0142347+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313782",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313782,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1935,
      "AgendaID": 2234,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03924",
      "ID": 4037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4966,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek",
      "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4104389+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3101E102P129VM295434",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295434,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1935,
      "AgendaID": 2234,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03924",
      "ID": 4037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3101,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala",
      "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5119999+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319028",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319028,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1935,
      "AgendaID": 2234,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03924",
      "ID": 4037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5034,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny",
      "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6893278+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306453",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306453,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1935,
      "AgendaID": 2234,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03924",
      "ID": 4037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2159,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Martin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5527279+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5110E252P395VM310381",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 310381,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1935,
      "AgendaID": 2234,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03924",
      "ID": 4037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Mason",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5680781+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268287",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 268287,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1935,
      "AgendaID": 2234,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03924",
      "ID": 4037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2133,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2605872+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2876E141P433VM286127",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286127,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1935,
      "AgendaID": 2234,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03924",
      "ID": 4037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2876,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3648884+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4951E147P368VM260715",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 260715,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1935,
      "AgendaID": 2234,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03924",
      "ID": 4037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4951,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan",
      "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.0891509+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3896E175P307VM264074",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264074,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1935,
      "AgendaID": 2234,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03924",
      "ID": 4037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3896,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam",
      "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9230787+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308804",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 308804,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1935,
      "AgendaID": 2234,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03924",
      "ID": 4037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.071973+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4964E143P375VM279329",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279329,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1935,
      "AgendaID": 2234,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03924",
      "ID": 4037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4964,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.497481+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3824E84P113VM280018",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280018,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1935,
      "AgendaID": 2234,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03924",
      "ID": 4037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3824,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5379084+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2066E22P91VM261126",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261126,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1935,
      "AgendaID": 2234,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03924",
      "ID": 4037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2066,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.1129442+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299715",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 299715,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1935,
      "AgendaID": 2234,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03924",
      "ID": 4037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7195043+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306835",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306835,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1935,
      "AgendaID": 2234,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03924",
      "ID": 4037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina",
      "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5757564+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300499",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 300499,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1935,
      "AgendaID": 2234,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03924",
      "ID": 4037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2487,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0008061+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223647",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223647,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1935,
      "AgendaID": 2234,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03924",
      "ID": 4037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4677852+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237472",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237472,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1935,
      "AgendaID": 2234,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03924",
      "ID": 4037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1961,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David",
      "DisplayName": "David McLetchie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2120514+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2134E34P201VM297861",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 297861,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1935,
      "AgendaID": 2234,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03924",
      "ID": 4037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2134,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1281406+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320398",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 320398,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1935,
      "AgendaID": 2234,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03924",
      "ID": 4037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5041,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan",
      "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1646992+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3763E142P397VM316048",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 316048,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1935,
      "AgendaID": 2234,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03924",
      "ID": 4037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3763,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart",
      "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9436859+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1986E23P197VM236283",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 236283,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1935,
      "AgendaID": 2234,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03924",
      "ID": 4037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1986,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan",
      "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9097121+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5047E100P130VM291451",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291451,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1935,
      "AgendaID": 2234,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03924",
      "ID": 4037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5047,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne",
      "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1198815+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234941",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234941,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1935,
      "AgendaID": 2234,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03924",
      "ID": 4037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1845,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette",
      "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4064628+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313618",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313618,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1935,
      "AgendaID": 2234,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03924",
      "ID": 4037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3061,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4031533+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1768E19P265VM288544",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 288544,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1935,
      "AgendaID": 2234,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03924",
      "ID": 4037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1768,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1479813+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225056",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225056,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1935,
      "AgendaID": 2234,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03924",
      "ID": 4037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1894,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Neil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7426207+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3815E98P134VM270896",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270896,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1935,
      "AgendaID": 2234,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03924",
      "ID": 4037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3815,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Park, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Park",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8278881+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265919",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265919,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1935,
      "AgendaID": 2234,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03924",
      "ID": 4037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2010,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil",
      "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4662228+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283511",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283511,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1935,
      "AgendaID": 2234,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03924",
      "ID": 4037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5057,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7110633+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2853E33P128VM251434",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251434,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1935,
      "AgendaID": 2234,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03924",
      "ID": 4037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Pentland",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.463433+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317618",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317618,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1935,
      "AgendaID": 2234,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03924",
      "ID": 4037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5009,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4301661+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254733",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254733,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1935,
      "AgendaID": 2234,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03924",
      "ID": 4037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3745,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis",
      "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2814089+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1870E225P478VM296955",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 296955,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1935,
      "AgendaID": 2234,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03924",
      "ID": 4037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1870,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona",
      "DisplayName": "Shona Robison",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8811797+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2135E254P450VM234877",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234877,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1935,
      "AgendaID": 2234,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03924",
      "ID": 4037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2135,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Russell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4036057+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1895E232P431VM257381",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257381,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1935,
      "AgendaID": 2234,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03924",
      "ID": 4037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1895,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0537499+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228085",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 228085,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1935,
      "AgendaID": 2234,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03924",
      "ID": 4037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1839,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5836986+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2345E10P55VM292027",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 292027,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1935,
      "AgendaID": 2234,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03924",
      "ID": 4037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2345,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1527215+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2223E176P333VM310691",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 310691,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1935,
      "AgendaID": 2234,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03924",
      "ID": 4037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2223,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish",
      "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5818853+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2182E87P175VM245998",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 245998,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1935,
      "AgendaID": 2234,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03924",
      "ID": 4037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2182,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8678049+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298358",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298358,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1935,
      "AgendaID": 2234,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03924",
      "ID": 4037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5079,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew",
      "DisplayName": "Drew Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3422996+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234392",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234392,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1935,
      "AgendaID": 2234,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03924",
      "ID": 4037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1769,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3753075+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4014E14P26VM269957",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269957,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1935,
      "AgendaID": 2234,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03924",
      "ID": 4037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4014,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz",
      "DisplayName": "Liz Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5752401+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269173",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269173,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1935,
      "AgendaID": 2234,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03924",
      "ID": 4037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2215,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.306843+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317192",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317192,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1935,
      "AgendaID": 2234,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03924",
      "ID": 4037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3806,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.1856462+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326264",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 326264,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1935,
      "AgendaID": 2234,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03924",
      "ID": 4037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5106,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin",
      "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7509494+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241096",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241096,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1935,
      "AgendaID": 2234,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03924",
      "ID": 4037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1848,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola",
      "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3958973+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2098E237P531VM289607",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289607,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1935,
      "AgendaID": 2234,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03924",
      "ID": 4037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2098,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Swinney",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4513159+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2674E247P401VM247751",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247751,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1935,
      "AgendaID": 2234,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03924",
      "ID": 4037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2674,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave",
      "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4268451+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5075E234P371VM284869",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 284869,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1935,
      "AgendaID": 2234,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03924",
      "ID": 4037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5075,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Torrance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0512124+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1793E151P362VM222458",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 222458,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1935,
      "AgendaID": 2234,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03924",
      "ID": 4037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1793,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean",
      "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1898282+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5078E245P7VM306912",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306912,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1935,
      "AgendaID": 2234,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03924",
      "ID": 4037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5078,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Walker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5792283+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1841E231P426VM240182",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 240182,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1935,
      "AgendaID": 2234,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03924",
      "ID": 4037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1841,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen",
      "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7824886+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283426",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283426,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1935,
      "AgendaID": 2234,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03924",
      "ID": 4037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4952,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.700199+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1865E263P500VM232247",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232247,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1935,
      "AgendaID": 2234,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03924",
      "ID": 4037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1865,
      "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra",
      "DisplayName": "Sandra White",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8464975+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237802",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237802,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1935,
      "AgendaID": 2234,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03924",
      "ID": 4037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2610,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Wilson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2267216+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309306",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 309306,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1935,
      "AgendaID": 2234,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc.) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03924",
      "ID": 4037
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4941,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza",
      "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-09-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3236253+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252634",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252634,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1934,
      "AgendaID": 2297,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 6,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03407",
      "ID": 3512
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1926,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian",
      "DisplayName": "Brian Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7379074+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2615E213P388VM258827",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258827,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1934,
      "AgendaID": 2297,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 6,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03407",
      "ID": 3512
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2615,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George",
      "DisplayName": "George Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3296135+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319870",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319870,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1934,
      "AgendaID": 2297,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 6,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03407",
      "ID": 3512
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4940,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare",
      "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9449312+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249640",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 249640,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1934,
      "AgendaID": 2297,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 6,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03407",
      "ID": 3512
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2641,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair",
      "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9435371+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1783E21P273VM227739",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227739,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1934,
      "AgendaID": 2297,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 6,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03407",
      "ID": 3512
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1783,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie",
      "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5635701+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2633E97P136VM280741",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280741,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1934,
      "AgendaID": 2297,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 6,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03407",
      "ID": 3512
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2633,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire",
      "DisplayName": "Claire Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7804651+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262499",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262499,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1934,
      "AgendaID": 2297,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 6,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03407",
      "ID": 3512
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2603,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6045712+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1759E91P115VM229750",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229750,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1934,
      "AgendaID": 2297,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 6,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03407",
      "ID": 3512
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia",
      "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0950879+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270200",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270200,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1934,
      "AgendaID": 2297,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 6,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03407",
      "ID": 3512
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3751,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.7935142+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322704",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 322704,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1934,
      "AgendaID": 2297,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 6,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03407",
      "ID": 3512
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5109,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco",
      "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.7000945+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5060E86P124VM294730",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 294730,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1934,
      "AgendaID": 2297,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 6,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03407",
      "ID": 3512
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5060,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1758573+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242851",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242851,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1934,
      "AgendaID": 2297,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 6,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03407",
      "ID": 3512
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1866,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah",
      "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0383293+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235573",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235573,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1934,
      "AgendaID": 2297,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 6,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03407",
      "ID": 3512
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1943,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic",
      "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.683622+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302158",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 302158,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1934,
      "AgendaID": 2297,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 6,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03407",
      "ID": 3512
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2595,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin",
      "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.2998075+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244501",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244501,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1934,
      "AgendaID": 2297,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 6,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03407",
      "ID": 3512
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2103,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith",
      "DisplayName": "Keith Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5574925+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327190",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 327190,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1934,
      "AgendaID": 2297,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 6,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03407",
      "ID": 3512
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.8030584+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3775E216P435VM276682",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276682,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1934,
      "AgendaID": 2297,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 6,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03407",
      "ID": 3512
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6766337+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264335",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264335,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1934,
      "AgendaID": 2297,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 6,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03407",
      "ID": 3512
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2673,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick",
      "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1290755+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248808",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248808,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1934,
      "AgendaID": 2297,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 6,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03407",
      "ID": 3512
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2678,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson",
      "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6709443+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2123E27P233VM295800",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295800,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1934,
      "AgendaID": 2297,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 6,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03407",
      "ID": 3512
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2123,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm",
      "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.536404+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285160",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285160,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1934,
      "AgendaID": 2297,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 6,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03407",
      "ID": 3512
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3907,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0690165+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230179",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230179,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1934,
      "AgendaID": 2297,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 6,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03407",
      "ID": 3512
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1735,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela",
      "DisplayName": "Angela Constance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.1196357+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243868",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 243868,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1934,
      "AgendaID": 2297,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 6,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03407",
      "ID": 3512
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1932,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce",
      "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3233576+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254931",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254931,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1934,
      "AgendaID": 2297,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 6,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03407",
      "ID": 3512
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1863,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna",
      "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2899523+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323797",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 323797,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1934,
      "AgendaID": 2297,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 6,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03407",
      "ID": 3512
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4976,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth",
      "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9723352+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5107E223P379VM291367",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291367,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1934,
      "AgendaID": 2297,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 6,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03407",
      "ID": 3512
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5107,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1162455+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3743E222P391VM265331",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265331,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1934,
      "AgendaID": 2297,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 6,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03407",
      "ID": 3512
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3743,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel",
      "DisplayName": "Nigel Don",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4345663+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262217",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262217,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1934,
      "AgendaID": 2297,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 6,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03407",
      "ID": 3512
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3771,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob",
      "DisplayName": "Bob Doris",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.5919738+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2826E262P384VM282000",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 282000,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1934,
      "AgendaID": 2297,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 6,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03407",
      "ID": 3512
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2826,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Dornan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1668833+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3812E94P117VM297972",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 297972,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1934,
      "AgendaID": 2297,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 6,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03407",
      "ID": 3512
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3812,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia",
      "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1328083+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231594",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231594,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1934,
      "AgendaID": 2297,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 6,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03407",
      "ID": 3512
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1778,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen",
      "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6073402+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4955E240P389VM285963",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285963,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1934,
      "AgendaID": 2297,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 6,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03407",
      "ID": 3512
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4955,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3520764+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219356",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 219356,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1934,
      "AgendaID": 2297,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 6,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03407",
      "ID": 3512
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1742,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle",
      "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.2950908+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238600",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 238600,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1934,
      "AgendaID": 2297,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 6,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03407",
      "ID": 3512
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1994,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus",
      "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4610963+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225446",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225446,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1934,
      "AgendaID": 2297,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 6,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03407",
      "ID": 3512
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1814,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda",
      "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9750795+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321755",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 321755,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1934,
      "AgendaID": 2297,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 6,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03407",
      "ID": 3512
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Fee",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4499971+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292921",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 292921,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1934,
      "AgendaID": 2297,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 6,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03407",
      "ID": 3512
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia",
      "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5639602+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1892E12P64VM226923",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 226923,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1934,
      "AgendaID": 2297,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 6,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03407",
      "ID": 3512
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.252705+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5054E95P118VM312674",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 312674,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1934,
      "AgendaID": 2297,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 6,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03407",
      "ID": 3512
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5054,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1384686+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4947E152P361VM257179",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257179,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1934,
      "AgendaID": 2297,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 6,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03407",
      "ID": 3512
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4947,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Finnie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.8267026+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271319",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271319,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1934,
      "AgendaID": 2297,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 6,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03407",
      "ID": 3512
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3901,
      "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe",
      "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0703638+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278445",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 278445,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1934,
      "AgendaID": 2297,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 6,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03407",
      "ID": 3512
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2394,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo",
      "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2191063+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2110E220P414VM286746",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286746,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1934,
      "AgendaID": 2297,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 6,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03407",
      "ID": 3512
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth",
      "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5989275+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250457",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250457,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1934,
      "AgendaID": 2297,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 6,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03407",
      "ID": 3512
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2675,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob",
      "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1903638+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1741E10P50VM220769",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220769,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1934,
      "AgendaID": 2297,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 6,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03407",
      "ID": 3512
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1741,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel",
      "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6562251+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220289",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220289,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1934,
      "AgendaID": 2297,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 6,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03407",
      "ID": 3512
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1756,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine",
      "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6348776+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1860E104P150VM252334",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252334,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1934,
      "AgendaID": 2297,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 6,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03407",
      "ID": 3512
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1860,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda",
      "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7246974+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2033E20P141VM266132",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 266132,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1934,
      "AgendaID": 2297,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 6,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03407",
      "ID": 3512
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2033,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain",
      "DisplayName": "Iain Gray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4757091+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324608",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324608,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1934,
      "AgendaID": 2297,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 6,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03407",
      "ID": 3512
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5042,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.230292+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259910",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 259910,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1934,
      "AgendaID": 2297,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 6,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03407",
      "ID": 3512
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick",
      "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6352985+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239297",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239297,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1934,
      "AgendaID": 2297,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 6,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03407",
      "ID": 3512
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2029,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh",
      "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7307451+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273806",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 273806,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1934,
      "AgendaID": 2297,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 6,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03407",
      "ID": 3512
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3758,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6364535+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304171",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 304171,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1934,
      "AgendaID": 2297,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 6,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03407",
      "ID": 3512
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4086,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Hume",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8528774+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221770",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221770,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1934,
      "AgendaID": 2297,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 6,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03407",
      "ID": 3512
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1773,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9470546+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1882E227P459VM242003",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242003,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1934,
      "AgendaID": 2297,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 6,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03407",
      "ID": 3512
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1882,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam",
      "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7896319+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223731",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223731,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1934,
      "AgendaID": 2297,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 6,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03407",
      "ID": 3512
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1893,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4713553+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307556",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307556,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1934,
      "AgendaID": 2297,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 6,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03407",
      "ID": 3512
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4934,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8346213+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272196",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 272196,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1934,
      "AgendaID": 2297,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 6,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03407",
      "ID": 3512
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4956,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Keir",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.1157101+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244892",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244892,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1934,
      "AgendaID": 2297,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 6,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03407",
      "ID": 3512
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Kelly",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5830754+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315062",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315062,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1934,
      "AgendaID": 2297,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 6,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03407",
      "ID": 3512
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3129,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6724324+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247971",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247971,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1934,
      "AgendaID": 2297,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 6,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03407",
      "ID": 3512
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann",
      "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4362209+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4016E11P36VM274767",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274767,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1934,
      "AgendaID": 2297,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 6,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03407",
      "ID": 3512
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4016,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1208694+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255821",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255821,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1934,
      "AgendaID": 2297,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 6,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03407",
      "ID": 3512
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2180,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5585167+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4938E158P374VM277478",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277478,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1934,
      "AgendaID": 2297,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 6,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03407",
      "ID": 3512
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4938,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9550857+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2112E250P486VM252991",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252991,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1934,
      "AgendaID": 2297,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 6,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03407",
      "ID": 3512
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2112,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny",
      "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7621552+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4939E258P394VM277183",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277183,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1934,
      "AgendaID": 2297,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 6,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03407",
      "ID": 3512
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4939,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus",
      "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.7047582+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325523",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 325523,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1934,
      "AgendaID": 2297,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 6,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03407",
      "ID": 3512
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5074,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon",
      "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5100183+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1828E3P10VM232839",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232839,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1934,
      "AgendaID": 2297,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 6,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03407",
      "ID": 3512
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1828,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo",
      "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8787195+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311403",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311403,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1934,
      "AgendaID": 2297,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 6,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03407",
      "ID": 3512
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4948,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike",
      "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8772712+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2117E90P107VM230443",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230443,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1934,
      "AgendaID": 2297,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 6,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03407",
      "ID": 3512
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2117,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis",
      "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3300547+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267339",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 267339,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1934,
      "AgendaID": 2297,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 6,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03407",
      "ID": 3512
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken",
      "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0151856+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313758",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313758,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1934,
      "AgendaID": 2297,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 6,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03407",
      "ID": 3512
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4966,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek",
      "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4093813+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3101E102P129VM295410",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295410,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1934,
      "AgendaID": 2297,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 6,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03407",
      "ID": 3512
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3101,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala",
      "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5109698+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319004",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319004,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1934,
      "AgendaID": 2297,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 6,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03407",
      "ID": 3512
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5034,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny",
      "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6883037+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306424",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306424,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1934,
      "AgendaID": 2297,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 6,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03407",
      "ID": 3512
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2159,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Martin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5514709+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5110E252P395VM311229",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311229,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1934,
      "AgendaID": 2297,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 6,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03407",
      "ID": 3512
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Mason",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8675569+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268264",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 268264,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1934,
      "AgendaID": 2297,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 6,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03407",
      "ID": 3512
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2133,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2559385+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2876E141P433VM286308",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286308,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1934,
      "AgendaID": 2297,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 6,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03407",
      "ID": 3512
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2876,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5732022+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4951E147P368VM260688",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 260688,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1934,
      "AgendaID": 2297,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 6,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03407",
      "ID": 3512
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4951,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan",
      "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.0879751+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3896E175P307VM264077",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264077,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1934,
      "AgendaID": 2297,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 6,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03407",
      "ID": 3512
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3896,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam",
      "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9232003+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308410",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 308410,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1934,
      "AgendaID": 2297,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 6,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03407",
      "ID": 3512
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0547455+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4964E143P375VM279326",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279326,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1934,
      "AgendaID": 2297,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 6,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03407",
      "ID": 3512
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4964,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.4973378+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279988",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279988,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1934,
      "AgendaID": 2297,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 6,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03407",
      "ID": 3512
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3824,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5314646+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2066E22P91VM261095",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261095,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1934,
      "AgendaID": 2297,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 6,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03407",
      "ID": 3512
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2066,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.1115914+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299691",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 299691,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1934,
      "AgendaID": 2297,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 6,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03407",
      "ID": 3512
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7085912+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306596",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306596,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1934,
      "AgendaID": 2297,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 6,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03407",
      "ID": 3512
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina",
      "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.558864+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2487E146P369VM301199",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 301199,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1934,
      "AgendaID": 2297,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 6,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03407",
      "ID": 3512
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2487,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.2515386+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223674",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223674,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1934,
      "AgendaID": 2297,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 6,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03407",
      "ID": 3512
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.468925+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237469",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237469,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1934,
      "AgendaID": 2297,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 6,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03407",
      "ID": 3512
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1961,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David",
      "DisplayName": "David McLetchie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2119282+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305443",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 305443,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1934,
      "AgendaID": 2297,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 6,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03407",
      "ID": 3512
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2134,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3242412+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320422",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 320422,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1934,
      "AgendaID": 2297,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 6,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03407",
      "ID": 3512
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5041,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan",
      "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1657267+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3763E142P397VM316020",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 316020,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1934,
      "AgendaID": 2297,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 6,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03407",
      "ID": 3512
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3763,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart",
      "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9423839+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1986E23P197VM236313",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 236313,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1934,
      "AgendaID": 2297,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 6,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03407",
      "ID": 3512
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1986,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan",
      "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9110185+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5047E100P130VM291421",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291421,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1934,
      "AgendaID": 2297,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 6,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03407",
      "ID": 3512
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5047,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne",
      "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1185803+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234602",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234602,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1934,
      "AgendaID": 2297,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 6,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03407",
      "ID": 3512
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1845,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette",
      "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3913815+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313590",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313590,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1934,
      "AgendaID": 2297,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 6,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03407",
      "ID": 3512
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3061,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4019567+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1768E19P265VM288580",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 288580,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1934,
      "AgendaID": 2297,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 6,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03407",
      "ID": 3512
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1768,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1495227+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225054",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225054,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1934,
      "AgendaID": 2297,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 6,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03407",
      "ID": 3512
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1894,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Neil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7425402+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3815E98P134VM270893",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270893,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1934,
      "AgendaID": 2297,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 6,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03407",
      "ID": 3512
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3815,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Park, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Park",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8277314+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265888",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265888,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1934,
      "AgendaID": 2297,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 6,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03407",
      "ID": 3512
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2010,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil",
      "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4648763+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283514",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283514,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1934,
      "AgendaID": 2297,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 6,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03407",
      "ID": 3512
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5057,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7111869+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2853E33P128VM251431",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251431,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1934,
      "AgendaID": 2297,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 6,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03407",
      "ID": 3512
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Pentland",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.463309+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317642",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317642,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1934,
      "AgendaID": 2297,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 6,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03407",
      "ID": 3512
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5009,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4312035+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254706",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254706,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1934,
      "AgendaID": 2297,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 6,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03407",
      "ID": 3512
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3745,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis",
      "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2802215+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1870E225P478VM295639",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295639,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1934,
      "AgendaID": 2297,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 6,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03407",
      "ID": 3512
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1870,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona",
      "DisplayName": "Shona Robison",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5294911+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2135E254P450VM234874",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234874,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1934,
      "AgendaID": 2297,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 6,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03407",
      "ID": 3512
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2135,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Russell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4034804+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1895E232P431VM257411",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257411,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1934,
      "AgendaID": 2297,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 6,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03407",
      "ID": 3512
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1895,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0550545+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228113",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 228113,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1934,
      "AgendaID": 2297,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 6,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03407",
      "ID": 3512
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1839,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5849179+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2345E10P55VM291685",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291685,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1934,
      "AgendaID": 2297,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 6,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03407",
      "ID": 3512
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2345,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1379082+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311031",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311031,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1934,
      "AgendaID": 2297,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 6,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03407",
      "ID": 3512
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2223,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish",
      "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.6024627+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246334",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 246334,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1934,
      "AgendaID": 2297,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 6,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03407",
      "ID": 3512
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2182,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1242429+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298327",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298327,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1934,
      "AgendaID": 2297,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 6,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03407",
      "ID": 3512
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5079,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew",
      "DisplayName": "Drew Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3409622+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234359",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234359,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1934,
      "AgendaID": 2297,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 6,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03407",
      "ID": 3512
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1769,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.373864+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4014E14P26VM269954",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269954,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1934,
      "AgendaID": 2297,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 6,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03407",
      "ID": 3512
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4014,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz",
      "DisplayName": "Liz Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5750718+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269506",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269506,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1934,
      "AgendaID": 2297,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 6,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03407",
      "ID": 3512
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2215,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5505694+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317373",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317373,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1934,
      "AgendaID": 2297,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 6,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03407",
      "ID": 3512
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3806,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4193356+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326307",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 326307,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1934,
      "AgendaID": 2297,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 6,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03407",
      "ID": 3512
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5106,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin",
      "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7528053+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241125",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241125,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1934,
      "AgendaID": 2297,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 6,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03407",
      "ID": 3512
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1848,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola",
      "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.4031052+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2098E237P531VM289636",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289636,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1934,
      "AgendaID": 2297,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 6,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03407",
      "ID": 3512
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2098,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Swinney",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4525193+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2674E247P401VM247748",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247748,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1934,
      "AgendaID": 2297,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 6,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03407",
      "ID": 3512
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2674,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave",
      "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4267238+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5075E234P371VM284866",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 284866,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1934,
      "AgendaID": 2297,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 6,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03407",
      "ID": 3512
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5075,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Torrance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0510906+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1793E151P362VM222455",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 222455,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1934,
      "AgendaID": 2297,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 6,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03407",
      "ID": 3512
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1793,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean",
      "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1897039+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5078E245P7VM307103",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307103,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1934,
      "AgendaID": 2297,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 6,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03407",
      "ID": 3512
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5078,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Walker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5874029+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1841E231P426VM240152",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 240152,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1934,
      "AgendaID": 2297,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 6,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03407",
      "ID": 3512
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1841,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen",
      "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7811825+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283418",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283418,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1934,
      "AgendaID": 2297,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 6,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03407",
      "ID": 3512
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4952,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.6998482+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1865E263P500VM232225",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232225,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1934,
      "AgendaID": 2297,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 6,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03407",
      "ID": 3512
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1865,
      "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra",
      "DisplayName": "Sandra White",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8455346+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237805",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237805,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1934,
      "AgendaID": 2297,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 6,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03407",
      "ID": 3512
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2610,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Wilson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2268426+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309282",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 309282,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1934,
      "AgendaID": 2297,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 6,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-03407",
      "ID": 3512
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4941,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza",
      "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-27T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3226002+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252686",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252686,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1933,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.3",
      "ID": 3533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1926,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian",
      "DisplayName": "Brian Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7492298+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2615E213P388VM258883",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258883,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1933,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.3",
      "ID": 3533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2615,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George",
      "DisplayName": "George Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3323311+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319664",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319664,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1933,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.3",
      "ID": 3533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4940,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare",
      "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9360132+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249573",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 249573,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1933,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.3",
      "ID": 3533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2641,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair",
      "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9326694+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1783E21P273VM227797",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227797,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1933,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.3",
      "ID": 3533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1783,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie",
      "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.56605+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2633E97P136VM280800",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280800,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1933,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.3",
      "ID": 3533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2633,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire",
      "DisplayName": "Claire Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7829264+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262693",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262693,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1933,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.3",
      "ID": 3533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2603,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6128235+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1759E91P115VM229778",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229778,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1933,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.3",
      "ID": 3533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia",
      "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0966222+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270144",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270144,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1933,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.3",
      "ID": 3533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3751,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5834512+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322668",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 322668,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1933,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.3",
      "ID": 3533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5109,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco",
      "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6985931+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5060E86P124VM294768",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 294768,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1933,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.3",
      "ID": 3533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5060,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.177479+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242935",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242935,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1933,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.3",
      "ID": 3533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1866,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah",
      "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0418561+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235208",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235208,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1933,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.3",
      "ID": 3533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1943,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic",
      "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6601323+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302343",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 302343,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1933,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.3",
      "ID": 3533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2595,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin",
      "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5202981+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244310",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244310,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1933,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.3",
      "ID": 3533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2103,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith",
      "DisplayName": "Keith Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5491563+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327131",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 327131,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1933,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.3",
      "ID": 3533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.8004488+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277032",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277032,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1933,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.3",
      "ID": 3533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6981508+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264297",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264297,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1933,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.3",
      "ID": 3533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2673,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick",
      "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1272179+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248741",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248741,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1933,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.3",
      "ID": 3533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2678,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson",
      "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6678073+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2123E27P233VM295746",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295746,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1933,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.3",
      "ID": 3533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2123,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm",
      "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5341264+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285197",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285197,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1933,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.3",
      "ID": 3533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3907,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3122533+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230674",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230674,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1933,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.3",
      "ID": 3533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1735,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela",
      "DisplayName": "Angela Constance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.340322+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243784",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 243784,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1933,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.3",
      "ID": 3533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1932,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce",
      "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3196098+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254903",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254903,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1933,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.3",
      "ID": 3533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1863,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna",
      "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2887435+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323738",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 323738,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1933,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.3",
      "ID": 3533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4976,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth",
      "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9697689+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5107E223P379VM291303",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291303,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1933,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.3",
      "ID": 3533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5107,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1131271+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3743E222P391VM265369",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265369,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1933,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.3",
      "ID": 3533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3743,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel",
      "DisplayName": "Nigel Don",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4362089+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262283",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262283,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1933,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.3",
      "ID": 3533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3771,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob",
      "DisplayName": "Bob Doris",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.5948179+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281940",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 281940,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1933,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.3",
      "ID": 3533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2826,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Dornan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1643328+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298186",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298186,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1933,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.3",
      "ID": 3533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3812,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia",
      "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1422321+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231568",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231568,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1933,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.3",
      "ID": 3533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1778,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen",
      "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6062282+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4955E240P389VM285908",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285908,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1933,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.3",
      "ID": 3533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4955,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3497133+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219419",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 219419,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1933,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.3",
      "ID": 3533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1742,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle",
      "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.2979941+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238543",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 238543,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1933,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.3",
      "ID": 3533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1994,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus",
      "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4586287+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225226",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225226,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1933,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.3",
      "ID": 3533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1814,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda",
      "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9602237+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321792",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 321792,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1933,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.3",
      "ID": 3533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Fee",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4515737+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292819",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 292819,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1933,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.3",
      "ID": 3533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia",
      "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5594767+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227146",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227146,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1933,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.3",
      "ID": 3533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2698089+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5054E95P118VM312703",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 312703,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1933,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.3",
      "ID": 3533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5054,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1397163+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4947E152P361VM257246",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257246,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1933,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.3",
      "ID": 3533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4947,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Finnie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0478436+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271263",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271263,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1933,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.3",
      "ID": 3533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3901,
      "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe",
      "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0627407+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278077",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 278077,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1933,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.3",
      "ID": 3533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2394,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo",
      "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9860202+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2110E220P414VM287238",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 287238,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1933,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.3",
      "ID": 3533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth",
      "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8555814+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250525",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250525,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1933,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.3",
      "ID": 3533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2675,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob",
      "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1933271+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1741E10P50VM220991",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220991,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1933,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.3",
      "ID": 3533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1741,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel",
      "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6703962+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220224",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220224,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1933,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.3",
      "ID": 3533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1756,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine",
      "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6291737+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1860E104P150VM252363",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252363,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1933,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.3",
      "ID": 3533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1860,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda",
      "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7259588+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2033E20P141VM253846",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253846,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1933,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.3",
      "ID": 3533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2033,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain",
      "DisplayName": "Iain Gray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0233838+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324667",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324667,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1933,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.3",
      "ID": 3533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5042,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2327846+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259688",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 259688,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1933,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.3",
      "ID": 3533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick",
      "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6202284+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239353",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239353,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1933,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.3",
      "ID": 3533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2029,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh",
      "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7331607+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273768",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 273768,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1933,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.3",
      "ID": 3533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3758,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6348356+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304142",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 304142,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1933,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.3",
      "ID": 3533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4086,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Hume",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8514529+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221704",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221704,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1933,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.3",
      "ID": 3533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1773,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9442038+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1882E227P459VM241936",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241936,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1933,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.3",
      "ID": 3533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1882,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam",
      "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7864171+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223522",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223522,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1933,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.3",
      "ID": 3533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1893,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4620595+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307615",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307615,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1933,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.3",
      "ID": 3533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4934,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8374468+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272261",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 272261,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1933,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.3",
      "ID": 3533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4956,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Keir",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3220311+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244945",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244945,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1933,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.3",
      "ID": 3533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Kelly",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5853203+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315115",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315115,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1933,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.3",
      "ID": 3533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3129,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6749424+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247915",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247915,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1933,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.3",
      "ID": 3533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann",
      "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4338353+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4016E11P36VM274822",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274822,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1933,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.3",
      "ID": 3533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4016,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1232353+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255765",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255765,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1933,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.3",
      "ID": 3533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2180,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5559078+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4938E158P374VM277423",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277423,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1933,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.3",
      "ID": 3533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4938,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9527378+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2112E250P486VM253047",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253047,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1933,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.3",
      "ID": 3533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2112,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny",
      "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7645646+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4939E258P394VM276808",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276808,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1933,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.3",
      "ID": 3533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4939,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus",
      "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6819639+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325464",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 325464,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1933,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.3",
      "ID": 3533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5074,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon",
      "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5075171+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1828E3P10VM232868",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232868,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1933,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.3",
      "ID": 3533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1828,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo",
      "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8800681+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311460",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311460,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1933,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.3",
      "ID": 3533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4948,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike",
      "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8797863+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2117E90P107VM230376",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230376,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1933,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.3",
      "ID": 3533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2117,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis",
      "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.32712+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267398",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 267398,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1933,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.3",
      "ID": 3533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken",
      "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0181013+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313702",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313702,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1933,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.3",
      "ID": 3533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4966,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek",
      "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4068607+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3101E102P129VM295042",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295042,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1933,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.3",
      "ID": 3533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3101,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala",
      "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1897196+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319042",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319042,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1933,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.3",
      "ID": 3533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5034,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny",
      "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.689929+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306371",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306371,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1933,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.3",
      "ID": 3533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2159,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Martin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5492285+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5110E252P395VM310821",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 310821,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1933,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.3",
      "ID": 3533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Mason",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.587477+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268205",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 268205,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1933,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.3",
      "ID": 3533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2133,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2533758+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2876E141P433VM286368",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286368,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1933,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.3",
      "ID": 3533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2876,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.575889+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4951E147P368VM258610",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258610,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1933,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.3",
      "ID": 3533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4951,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan",
      "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3146903+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3896E175P307VM263856",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 263856,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1933,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.3",
      "ID": 3533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3896,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam",
      "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9137213+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308511",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 308511,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1933,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.3",
      "ID": 3533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0590748+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4964E143P375VM279694",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279694,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1933,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.3",
      "ID": 3533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4964,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5186606+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279640",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279640,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1933,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.3",
      "ID": 3533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3824,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5163284+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2066E22P91VM261043",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261043,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1933,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.3",
      "ID": 3533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2066,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.1093367+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299632",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 299632,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1933,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.3",
      "ID": 3533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7060922+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306697",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306697,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1933,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.3",
      "ID": 3533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina",
      "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.563478+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2487E146P369VM301097",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 301097,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1933,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.3",
      "ID": 3533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2487,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.033115+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223894",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223894,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1933,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.3",
      "ID": 3533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4783373+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237524",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237524,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1933,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.3",
      "ID": 3533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1961,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David",
      "DisplayName": "David McLetchie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2145393+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305497",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 305497,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1933,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.3",
      "ID": 3533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2134,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.326854+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320384",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 320384,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1933,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.3",
      "ID": 3533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5041,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan",
      "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1641026+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315967",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315967,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1933,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.3",
      "ID": 3533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3763,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart",
      "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9399913+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1986E23P197VM236660",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 236660,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1933,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.3",
      "ID": 3533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1986,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan",
      "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9345776+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5047E100P130VM289844",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289844,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1933,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.3",
      "ID": 3533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5047,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne",
      "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4614783+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234573",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234573,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1933,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.3",
      "ID": 3533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1845,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette",
      "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3901126+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313227",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313227,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1933,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.3",
      "ID": 3533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3061,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.3832256+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1768E19P265VM289301",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289301,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1933,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.3",
      "ID": 3533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1768,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4313689+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225265",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225265,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1933,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.3",
      "ID": 3533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1894,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Neil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9619384+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3815E98P134VM270926",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270926,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1933,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.3",
      "ID": 3533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3815,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Park, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Park",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8350409+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265860",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265860,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1933,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.3",
      "ID": 3533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2010,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil",
      "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4636784+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283294",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283294,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1933,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.3",
      "ID": 3533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5057,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.6942887+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2853E33P128VM251498",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251498,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1933,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.3",
      "ID": 3533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Pentland",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4662766+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317605",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317605,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1933,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.3",
      "ID": 3533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5009,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4296193+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254326",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254326,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1933,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.3",
      "ID": 3533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3745,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis",
      "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2507538+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1870E225P478VM296202",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 296202,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1933,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.3",
      "ID": 3533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1870,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona",
      "DisplayName": "Shona Robison",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8382926+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2135E254P450VM235401",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235401,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1933,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.3",
      "ID": 3533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2135,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Russell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6689828+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1895E232P431VM257595",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257595,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1933,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.3",
      "ID": 3533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1895,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0632962+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228179",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 228179,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1933,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.3",
      "ID": 3533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1839,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5877268+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2345E10P55VM291656",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291656,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1933,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.3",
      "ID": 3533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2345,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1366678+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311084",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311084,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1933,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.3",
      "ID": 3533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2223,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish",
      "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.604731+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246400",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 246400,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1933,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.3",
      "ID": 3533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2182,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1270833+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298136",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298136,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1933,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.3",
      "ID": 3533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5079,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew",
      "DisplayName": "Drew Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1397631+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234322",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234322,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1933,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.3",
      "ID": 3533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1769,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3722763+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274609",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274609,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1933,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.3",
      "ID": 3533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4014,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz",
      "DisplayName": "Liz Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.114008+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269565",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269565,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1933,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.3",
      "ID": 3533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2215,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5530949+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317426",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317426,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1933,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.3",
      "ID": 3533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3806,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4216026+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326366",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 326366,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1933,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.3",
      "ID": 3533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5106,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin",
      "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7554004+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241192",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241192,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1933,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.3",
      "ID": 3533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1848,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola",
      "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7469354+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2098E237P531VM289690",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289690,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1933,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.3",
      "ID": 3533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2098,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Swinney",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4550017+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2674E247P401VM247815",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247815,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1933,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.3",
      "ID": 3533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2674,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave",
      "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4296139+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5075E234P371VM287416",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 287416,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1933,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.3",
      "ID": 3533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5075,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Torrance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8632651+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1793E151P362VM222509",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 222509,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1933,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.3",
      "ID": 3533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1793,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean",
      "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1920286+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5078E245P7VM307008",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307008,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1933,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.3",
      "ID": 3533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5078,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Walker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5833389+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1841E231P426VM239931",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239931,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1933,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.3",
      "ID": 3533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1841,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen",
      "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7654967+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283473",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283473,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1933,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.3",
      "ID": 3533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4952,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7094092+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1865E263P500VM231863",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231863,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1933,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.3",
      "ID": 3533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1865,
      "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra",
      "DisplayName": "Sandra White",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6187877+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237738",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237738,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1933,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.3",
      "ID": 3533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2610,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Wilson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2236916+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309224",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 309224,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1933,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.3",
      "ID": 3533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4941,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza",
      "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3201205+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252685",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252685,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1932,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 60,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.1",
      "ID": 3529
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1926,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian",
      "DisplayName": "Brian Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7491894+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2615E213P388VM258882",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258882,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1932,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 60,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.1",
      "ID": 3529
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2615,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George",
      "DisplayName": "George Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3322902+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319665",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319665,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1932,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 60,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.1",
      "ID": 3529
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4940,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare",
      "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9360733+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249572",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 249572,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1932,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 60,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.1",
      "ID": 3529
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2641,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair",
      "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9326289+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1783E21P273VM227796",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227796,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1932,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 60,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.1",
      "ID": 3529
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1783,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie",
      "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5660082+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2633E97P136VM280799",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280799,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1932,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 60,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.1",
      "ID": 3529
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2633,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire",
      "DisplayName": "Claire Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7828866+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262692",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262692,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1932,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 60,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.1",
      "ID": 3529
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2603,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6127618+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1759E91P115VM229777",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229777,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1932,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 60,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.1",
      "ID": 3529
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia",
      "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0965814+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270145",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270145,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1932,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 60,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.1",
      "ID": 3529
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3751,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.583492+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322667",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 322667,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1932,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 60,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.1",
      "ID": 3529
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5109,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco",
      "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6985516+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5060E86P124VM294767",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 294767,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1932,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 60,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.1",
      "ID": 3529
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5060,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1774369+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242934",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242934,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1932,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 60,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.1",
      "ID": 3529
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1866,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah",
      "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0418162+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235209",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235209,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1932,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 60,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.1",
      "ID": 3529
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1943,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic",
      "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.660175+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302342",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 302342,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1932,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 60,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.1",
      "ID": 3529
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2595,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin",
      "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5202575+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244311",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244311,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1932,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 60,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.1",
      "ID": 3529
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2103,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith",
      "DisplayName": "Keith Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5491981+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327130",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 327130,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1932,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 60,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.1",
      "ID": 3529
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.8004065+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277031",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277031,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1932,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 60,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.1",
      "ID": 3529
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.69811+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264298",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264298,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1932,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 60,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.1",
      "ID": 3529
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2673,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick",
      "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1272583+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248742",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248742,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1932,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 60,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.1",
      "ID": 3529
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2678,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson",
      "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6678475+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2123E27P233VM295747",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295747,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1932,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 60,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.1",
      "ID": 3529
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2123,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm",
      "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5341664+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285196",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285196,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1932,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 60,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.1",
      "ID": 3529
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3907,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0705705+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230673",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230673,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1932,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 60,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.1",
      "ID": 3529
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1735,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela",
      "DisplayName": "Angela Constance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3402812+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243785",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 243785,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1932,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 60,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.1",
      "ID": 3529
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1932,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce",
      "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3196688+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254904",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254904,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1932,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 60,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.1",
      "ID": 3529
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1863,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna",
      "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2887842+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323737",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 323737,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1932,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 60,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.1",
      "ID": 3529
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4976,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth",
      "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9697279+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5107E223P379VM291304",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291304,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1932,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 60,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.1",
      "ID": 3529
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5107,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.113186+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3743E222P391VM265368",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265368,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1932,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 60,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.1",
      "ID": 3529
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3743,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel",
      "DisplayName": "Nigel Don",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4361672+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262282",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262282,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1932,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 60,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.1",
      "ID": 3529
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3771,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob",
      "DisplayName": "Bob Doris",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.5947763+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281941",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 281941,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1932,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 60,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.1",
      "ID": 3529
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2826,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Dornan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1643731+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298185",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298185,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1932,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 60,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.1",
      "ID": 3529
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3812,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia",
      "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1421885+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231569",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231569,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1932,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 60,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.1",
      "ID": 3529
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1778,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen",
      "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6062695+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4955E240P389VM285909",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285909,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1932,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 60,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.1",
      "ID": 3529
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4955,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3497552+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219418",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 219418,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1932,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 60,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.1",
      "ID": 3529
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1742,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle",
      "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.2979231+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238544",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 238544,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1932,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 60,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.1",
      "ID": 3529
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1994,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus",
      "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.458669+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225411",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225411,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1932,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 60,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.1",
      "ID": 3529
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1814,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda",
      "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9735754+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321793",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 321793,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1932,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 60,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.1",
      "ID": 3529
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Fee",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4516134+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292820",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 292820,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1932,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 60,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.1",
      "ID": 3529
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia",
      "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5595167+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227145",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227145,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1932,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 60,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.1",
      "ID": 3529
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2697487+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5054E95P118VM312702",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 312702,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1932,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 60,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.1",
      "ID": 3529
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5054,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1396759+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4947E152P361VM257247",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257247,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1932,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 60,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.1",
      "ID": 3529
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4947,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Finnie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0479038+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271264",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271264,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1932,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 60,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.1",
      "ID": 3529
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3901,
      "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe",
      "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.062782+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278078",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 278078,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1932,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 60,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.1",
      "ID": 3529
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2394,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo",
      "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9860622+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2110E220P414VM287237",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 287237,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1932,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 60,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.1",
      "ID": 3529
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth",
      "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8555404+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250526",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250526,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1932,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 60,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.1",
      "ID": 3529
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2675,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob",
      "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1933766+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1741E10P50VM220960",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220960,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1932,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 60,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.1",
      "ID": 3529
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1741,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel",
      "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6690707+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220225",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220225,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1932,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 60,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.1",
      "ID": 3529
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1756,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine",
      "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6292147+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1860E104P150VM252362",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252362,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1932,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 60,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.1",
      "ID": 3529
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1860,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda",
      "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7259176+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2033E20P141VM253847",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253847,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1932,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 60,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.1",
      "ID": 3529
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2033,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain",
      "DisplayName": "Iain Gray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0234238+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324668",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324668,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1932,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 60,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.1",
      "ID": 3529
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5042,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2328245+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259689",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 259689,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1932,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 60,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.1",
      "ID": 3529
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick",
      "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6202694+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239352",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239352,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1932,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 60,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.1",
      "ID": 3529
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2029,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh",
      "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7331199+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273769",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 273769,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1932,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 60,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.1",
      "ID": 3529
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3758,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6348756+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304143",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 304143,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1932,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 60,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.1",
      "ID": 3529
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4086,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Hume",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8514932+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221735",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221735,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1932,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 60,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.1",
      "ID": 3529
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1773,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9455205+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1882E227P459VM241968",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241968,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1932,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 60,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.1",
      "ID": 3529
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1882,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam",
      "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7881296+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223523",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223523,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1932,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 60,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.1",
      "ID": 3529
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1893,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4621003+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307614",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307614,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1932,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 60,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.1",
      "ID": 3529
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4934,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8374052+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272262",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 272262,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1932,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 60,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.1",
      "ID": 3529
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4956,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Keir",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3220722+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244944",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244944,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1932,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 60,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.1",
      "ID": 3529
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Kelly",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5852789+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315114",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315114,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1932,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 60,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.1",
      "ID": 3529
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3129,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.674902+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247916",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247916,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1932,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 60,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.1",
      "ID": 3529
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann",
      "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4338941+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4016E11P36VM274821",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274821,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1932,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 60,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.1",
      "ID": 3529
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4016,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1231947+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255766",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255766,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1932,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 60,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.1",
      "ID": 3529
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2180,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5559663+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4938E158P374VM277424",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277424,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1932,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 60,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.1",
      "ID": 3529
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4938,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9527786+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2112E250P486VM253046",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253046,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1932,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 60,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.1",
      "ID": 3529
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2112,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny",
      "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7645233+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4939E258P394VM276809",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276809,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1932,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 60,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.1",
      "ID": 3529
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4939,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus",
      "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6820041+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325463",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 325463,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1932,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 60,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.1",
      "ID": 3529
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5074,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon",
      "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5074768+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1828E3P10VM232867",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232867,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1932,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 60,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.1",
      "ID": 3529
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1828,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo",
      "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8800272+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311459",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311459,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1932,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 60,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.1",
      "ID": 3529
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4948,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike",
      "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8797437+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2117E90P107VM230377",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230377,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1932,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 60,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.1",
      "ID": 3529
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2117,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis",
      "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3271636+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267397",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 267397,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1932,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 60,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.1",
      "ID": 3529
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken",
      "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0180608+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313703",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313703,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1932,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 60,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.1",
      "ID": 3529
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4966,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek",
      "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4069078+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3101E102P129VM295043",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295043,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1932,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 60,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.1",
      "ID": 3529
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3101,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala",
      "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1897604+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319043",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319043,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1932,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 60,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.1",
      "ID": 3529
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5034,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny",
      "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6899693+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306372",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306372,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1932,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 60,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.1",
      "ID": 3529
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2159,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Martin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5492697+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5110E252P395VM310822",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 310822,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1932,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 60,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.1",
      "ID": 3529
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Mason",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5875179+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268206",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 268206,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1932,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 60,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.1",
      "ID": 3529
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2133,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2534177+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2876E141P433VM286367",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286367,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1932,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 60,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.1",
      "ID": 3529
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2876,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5758471+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4951E147P368VM258609",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258609,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1932,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 60,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.1",
      "ID": 3529
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4951,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan",
      "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3146488+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3896E175P307VM263857",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 263857,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1932,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 60,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.1",
      "ID": 3529
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3896,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam",
      "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9137626+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308510",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 308510,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1932,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 60,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.1",
      "ID": 3529
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0590343+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4964E143P375VM279693",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279693,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1932,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 60,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.1",
      "ID": 3529
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4964,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5185977+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279641",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279641,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1932,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 60,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.1",
      "ID": 3529
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3824,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5163702+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2066E22P91VM261044",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261044,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1932,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 60,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.1",
      "ID": 3529
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2066,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.1093782+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299633",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 299633,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1932,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 60,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.1",
      "ID": 3529
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7061322+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306696",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306696,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1932,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 60,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.1",
      "ID": 3529
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina",
      "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5634378+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2487E146P369VM301098",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 301098,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1932,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 60,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.1",
      "ID": 3529
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2487,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0331712+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223863",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223863,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1932,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 60,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.1",
      "ID": 3529
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4770137+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237523",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237523,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1932,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 60,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.1",
      "ID": 3529
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1961,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David",
      "DisplayName": "David McLetchie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2144986+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305496",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 305496,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1932,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 60,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.1",
      "ID": 3529
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2134,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3268129+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320383",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 320383,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1932,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 60,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.1",
      "ID": 3529
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5041,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan",
      "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1640614+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315968",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315968,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1932,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 60,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.1",
      "ID": 3529
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3763,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart",
      "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9400514+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1986E23P197VM236659",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 236659,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1932,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 60,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.1",
      "ID": 3529
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1986,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan",
      "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9345362+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5047E100P130VM289845",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289845,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1932,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 60,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.1",
      "ID": 3529
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5047,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne",
      "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4615183+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234574",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234574,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1932,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 60,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.1",
      "ID": 3529
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1845,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette",
      "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.390172+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313228",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313228,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1932,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 60,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.1",
      "ID": 3529
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3061,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.3832672+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1768E19P265VM289300",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289300,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1932,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 60,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.1",
      "ID": 3529
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1768,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4313275+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225264",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225264,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1932,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 60,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.1",
      "ID": 3529
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1894,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Neil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9618761+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3815E98P134VM270925",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270925,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1932,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 60,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.1",
      "ID": 3529
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3815,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Park, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Park",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8350001+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265861",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265861,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1932,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 60,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.1",
      "ID": 3529
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2010,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil",
      "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4637197+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283295",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283295,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1932,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 60,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.1",
      "ID": 3529
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5057,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.6943296+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2853E33P128VM251497",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251497,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1932,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 60,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.1",
      "ID": 3529
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Pentland",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4662352+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317604",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317604,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1932,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 60,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.1",
      "ID": 3529
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5009,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.429579+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254325",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254325,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1932,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 60,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.1",
      "ID": 3529
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3745,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis",
      "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2507122+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1870E225P478VM296201",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 296201,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1932,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 60,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.1",
      "ID": 3529
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1870,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona",
      "DisplayName": "Shona Robison",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8382408+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2135E254P450VM235400",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235400,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1932,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 60,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.1",
      "ID": 3529
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2135,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Russell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6689416+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1895E232P431VM257594",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257594,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1932,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 60,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.1",
      "ID": 3529
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1895,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0632551+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228148",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 228148,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1932,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 60,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.1",
      "ID": 3529
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1839,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.586407+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2345E10P55VM291657",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291657,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1932,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 60,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.1",
      "ID": 3529
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2345,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.136708+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311083",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311083,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1932,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 60,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.1",
      "ID": 3529
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2223,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish",
      "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.604691+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246401",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 246401,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1932,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 60,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.1",
      "ID": 3529
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2182,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1271237+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298138",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298138,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1932,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 60,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.1",
      "ID": 3529
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5079,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew",
      "DisplayName": "Drew Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1398446+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234323",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234323,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1932,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 60,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.1",
      "ID": 3529
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1769,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.372317+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274608",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274608,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1932,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 60,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.1",
      "ID": 3529
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4014,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz",
      "DisplayName": "Liz Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1139671+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269564",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269564,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1932,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 60,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.1",
      "ID": 3529
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2215,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5530542+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317425",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317425,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1932,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 60,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.1",
      "ID": 3529
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3806,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4215606+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326367",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 326367,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1932,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 60,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.1",
      "ID": 3529
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5106,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin",
      "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7554433+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241161",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241161,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1932,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 60,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.1",
      "ID": 3529
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1848,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola",
      "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.4046724+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2098E237P531VM289689",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289689,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1932,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 60,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.1",
      "ID": 3529
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2098,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Swinney",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4549612+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2674E247P401VM247814",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247814,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1932,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 60,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.1",
      "ID": 3529
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2674,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave",
      "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4295739+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5075E234P371VM287415",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 287415,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1932,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 60,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.1",
      "ID": 3529
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5075,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Torrance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8632237+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1793E151P362VM222508",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 222508,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1932,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 60,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.1",
      "ID": 3529
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1793,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean",
      "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1919686+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5078E245P7VM307009",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307009,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1932,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 60,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.1",
      "ID": 3529
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5078,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Walker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5833794+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1841E231P426VM239962",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239962,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1932,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 60,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.1",
      "ID": 3529
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1841,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen",
      "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7668206+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283472",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283472,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1932,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 60,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.1",
      "ID": 3529
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4952,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7093679+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1865E263P500VM231864",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231864,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1932,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 60,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.1",
      "ID": 3529
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1865,
      "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra",
      "DisplayName": "Sandra White",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.618829+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237739",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237739,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1932,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 60,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.1",
      "ID": 3529
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2610,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Wilson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2237313+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309225",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 309225,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1932,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 45,
      "VoteAgainst": 60,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400.1",
      "ID": 3529
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4941,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza",
      "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3201608+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252687",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252687,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1929,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 90,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400",
      "ID": 3505
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1926,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian",
      "DisplayName": "Brian Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7492692+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2615E213P388VM258884",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258884,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1929,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 90,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400",
      "ID": 3505
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2615,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George",
      "DisplayName": "George Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3323717+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319663",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319663,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1929,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 90,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400",
      "ID": 3505
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4940,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare",
      "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9359721+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249571",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 249571,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1929,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 90,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400",
      "ID": 3505
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2641,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair",
      "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9325884+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1783E21P273VM227798",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227798,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1929,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 90,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400",
      "ID": 3505
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1783,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie",
      "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5660912+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2633E97P136VM280801",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280801,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1929,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 90,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400",
      "ID": 3505
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2633,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire",
      "DisplayName": "Claire Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7829661+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262716",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262716,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1929,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 90,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400",
      "ID": 3505
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2603,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6138004+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1759E91P115VM229779",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229779,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1929,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 90,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400",
      "ID": 3505
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia",
      "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.096691+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270143",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270143,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1929,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 90,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400",
      "ID": 3505
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3751,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5834105+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322669",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 322669,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1929,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 90,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400",
      "ID": 3505
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5109,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco",
      "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6986332+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5060E86P124VM295254",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295254,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1929,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 90,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400",
      "ID": 3505
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5060,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5040945+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242936",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242936,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1929,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 90,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400",
      "ID": 3505
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1866,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah",
      "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0418974+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235207",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235207,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1929,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 90,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400",
      "ID": 3505
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1943,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic",
      "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6600869+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302344",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 302344,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1929,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 90,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400",
      "ID": 3505
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2595,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin",
      "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5203578+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244287",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244287,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1929,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 90,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400",
      "ID": 3505
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2103,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith",
      "DisplayName": "Keith Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5481623+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327132",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 327132,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1929,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 90,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400",
      "ID": 3505
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.8005112+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277055",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277055,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1929,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 90,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400",
      "ID": 3505
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6991581+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264274",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264274,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1929,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 90,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400",
      "ID": 3505
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2673,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick",
      "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1262372+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248740",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248740,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1929,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 90,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400",
      "ID": 3505
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2678,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson",
      "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6677658+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2123E27P233VM295745",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295745,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1929,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 90,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400",
      "ID": 3505
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2123,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm",
      "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5340856+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285220",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285220,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1929,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 90,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400",
      "ID": 3505
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3907,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3135493+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230697",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230697,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1929,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 90,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400",
      "ID": 3505
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1735,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela",
      "DisplayName": "Angela Constance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3413958+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243783",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 243783,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1929,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 90,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400",
      "ID": 3505
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1932,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce",
      "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.31957+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254902",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254902,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1929,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 90,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400",
      "ID": 3505
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1863,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna",
      "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2887032+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323739",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 323739,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1929,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 90,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400",
      "ID": 3505
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4976,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth",
      "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9698348+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5107E223P379VM291302",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291302,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1929,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 90,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400",
      "ID": 3505
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5107,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1130859+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3743E222P391VM265392",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265392,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1929,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 90,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400",
      "ID": 3505
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3743,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel",
      "DisplayName": "Nigel Don",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4371933+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262284",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262284,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1929,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 90,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400",
      "ID": 3505
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3771,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob",
      "DisplayName": "Bob Doris",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.5948583+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281939",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 281939,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1929,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 90,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400",
      "ID": 3505
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2826,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Dornan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1642922+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298187",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298187,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1929,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 90,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400",
      "ID": 3505
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3812,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia",
      "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1422739+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231567",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231567,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1929,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 90,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400",
      "ID": 3505
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1778,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen",
      "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6061865+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4955E240P389VM285907",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285907,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1929,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 90,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400",
      "ID": 3505
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4955,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3496723+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219420",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 219420,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1929,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 90,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400",
      "ID": 3505
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1742,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle",
      "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.2980372+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238542",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 238542,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1929,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 90,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400",
      "ID": 3505
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1994,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus",
      "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4585879+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225225",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225225,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1929,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 90,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400",
      "ID": 3505
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1814,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda",
      "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9601816+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321791",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 321791,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1929,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 90,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400",
      "ID": 3505
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Fee",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4515336+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292818",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 292818,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1929,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 90,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400",
      "ID": 3505
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia",
      "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5594366+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227147",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227147,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1929,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 90,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400",
      "ID": 3505
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2698519+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5054E95P118VM312704",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 312704,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1929,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 90,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400",
      "ID": 3505
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5054,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1397571+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4947E152P361VM257249",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257249,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1929,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 90,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400",
      "ID": 3505
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4947,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Finnie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0479868+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271262",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271262,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1929,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 90,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400",
      "ID": 3505
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3901,
      "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe",
      "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0626991+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278076",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 278076,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1929,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 90,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400",
      "ID": 3505
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2394,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo",
      "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9859612+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2110E220P414VM287239",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 287239,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1929,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 90,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400",
      "ID": 3505
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth",
      "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8556227+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250528",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250528,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1929,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 90,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400",
      "ID": 3505
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2675,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob",
      "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.193461+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1741E10P50VM220992",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220992,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1929,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 90,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400",
      "ID": 3505
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1741,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel",
      "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6704389+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220223",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220223,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1929,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 90,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400",
      "ID": 3505
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1756,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine",
      "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6291307+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1860E104P150VM252364",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252364,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1929,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 90,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400",
      "ID": 3505
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1860,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda",
      "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7259992+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2033E20P141VM253845",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253845,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1929,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 90,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400",
      "ID": 3505
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2033,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain",
      "DisplayName": "Iain Gray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.023344+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324666",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324666,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1929,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 90,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400",
      "ID": 3505
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5042,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.232744+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259687",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 259687,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1929,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 90,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400",
      "ID": 3505
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick",
      "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6201877+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239354",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239354,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1929,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 90,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400",
      "ID": 3505
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2029,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh",
      "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7332017+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273745",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 273745,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1929,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 90,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400",
      "ID": 3505
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3758,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6338682+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304141",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 304141,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1929,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 90,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400",
      "ID": 3505
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4086,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Hume",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8514122+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221703",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221703,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1929,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 90,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400",
      "ID": 3505
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1773,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9441634+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1882E227P459VM241935",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241935,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1929,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 90,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400",
      "ID": 3505
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1882,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam",
      "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7863698+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223521",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223521,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1929,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 90,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400",
      "ID": 3505
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1893,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4620184+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307616",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307616,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1929,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 90,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400",
      "ID": 3505
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4934,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8374879+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272264",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 272264,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1929,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 90,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400",
      "ID": 3505
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4956,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Keir",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3221537+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244946",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244946,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1929,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 90,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400",
      "ID": 3505
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Kelly",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5853606+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315116",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315116,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1929,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 90,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400",
      "ID": 3505
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3129,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6749895+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247914",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247914,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1929,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 90,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400",
      "ID": 3505
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann",
      "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4337951+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4016E11P36VM274823",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274823,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1929,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 90,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400",
      "ID": 3505
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4016,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.123277+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255764",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255764,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1929,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 90,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400",
      "ID": 3505
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2180,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5558679+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4938E158P374VM277422",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277422,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1929,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 90,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400",
      "ID": 3505
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4938,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9526971+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2112E250P486VM253048",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253048,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1929,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 90,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400",
      "ID": 3505
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2112,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny",
      "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7646065+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4939E258P394VM276807",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276807,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1929,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 90,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400",
      "ID": 3505
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4939,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus",
      "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6819234+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325465",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 325465,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1929,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 90,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400",
      "ID": 3505
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5074,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon",
      "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5075573+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1828E3P10VM232869",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232869,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1929,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 90,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400",
      "ID": 3505
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1828,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo",
      "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8801093+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311461",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311461,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1929,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 90,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400",
      "ID": 3505
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4948,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike",
      "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.879828+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2117E90P107VM230375",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230375,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1929,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 90,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400",
      "ID": 3505
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2117,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis",
      "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3270165+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267399",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 267399,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1929,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 90,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400",
      "ID": 3505
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken",
      "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0181426+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313701",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313701,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1929,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 90,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400",
      "ID": 3505
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4966,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek",
      "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4067869+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3101E102P129VM295041",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295041,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1929,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 90,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400",
      "ID": 3505
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3101,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala",
      "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1896762+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319041",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319041,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1929,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 90,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400",
      "ID": 3505
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5034,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny",
      "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6898884+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306370",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306370,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1929,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 90,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400",
      "ID": 3505
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2159,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Martin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5491864+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5110E252P395VM310820",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 310820,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1929,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 90,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400",
      "ID": 3505
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Mason",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5874364+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268204",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 268204,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1929,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 90,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400",
      "ID": 3505
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2133,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2533337+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2876E141P433VM286369",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286369,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1929,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 90,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400",
      "ID": 3505
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2876,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5759302+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4951E147P368VM258607",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258607,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1929,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 90,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400",
      "ID": 3505
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4951,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan",
      "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3145643+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3896E175P307VM263855",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 263855,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1929,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 90,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400",
      "ID": 3505
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3896,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam",
      "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9136777+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308512",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 308512,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1929,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 90,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400",
      "ID": 3505
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0591168+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4964E143P375VM279695",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279695,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1929,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 90,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400",
      "ID": 3505
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4964,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5187024+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279617",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279617,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1929,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 90,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400",
      "ID": 3505
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3824,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5153438+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2066E22P91VM261042",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261042,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1929,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 90,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400",
      "ID": 3505
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2066,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.1092955+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299631",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 299631,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1929,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 90,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400",
      "ID": 3505
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7060511+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306698",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306698,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1929,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 90,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400",
      "ID": 3505
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina",
      "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5635441+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2487E146P369VM301096",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 301096,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1929,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 90,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400",
      "ID": 3505
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2487,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0330453+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223895",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223895,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1929,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 90,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400",
      "ID": 3505
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4783777+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237525",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237525,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1929,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 90,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400",
      "ID": 3505
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1961,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David",
      "DisplayName": "David McLetchie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2145797+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305498",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 305498,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1929,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 90,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400",
      "ID": 3505
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2134,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3268944+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320385",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 320385,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1929,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 90,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400",
      "ID": 3505
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5041,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan",
      "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1641437+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315966",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315966,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1929,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 90,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400",
      "ID": 3505
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3763,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart",
      "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9399499+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1986E23P197VM236683",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 236683,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1929,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 90,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400",
      "ID": 3505
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1986,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan",
      "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9355674+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5047E100P130VM289821",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289821,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1929,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 90,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400",
      "ID": 3505
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5047,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne",
      "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4605103+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234572",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234572,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1929,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 90,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400",
      "ID": 3505
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1845,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette",
      "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3900699+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313226",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313226,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1929,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 90,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400",
      "ID": 3505
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3061,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.3831839+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1768E19P265VM289302",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289302,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1929,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 90,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400",
      "ID": 3505
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1768,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4314284+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225266",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225266,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1929,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 90,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400",
      "ID": 3505
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1894,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Neil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9619812+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3815E98P134VM270927",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270927,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1929,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 90,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400",
      "ID": 3505
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3815,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Park, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Park",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8350821+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265859",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265859,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1929,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 90,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400",
      "ID": 3505
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2010,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil",
      "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4636377+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283293",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283293,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1929,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 90,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400",
      "ID": 3505
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5057,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.6942476+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2853E33P128VM251499",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251499,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1929,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 90,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400",
      "ID": 3505
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Pentland",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4663182+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317606",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317606,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1929,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 90,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400",
      "ID": 3505
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5009,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4296602+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254323",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254323,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1929,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 90,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400",
      "ID": 3505
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3745,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis",
      "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2506055+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1870E225P478VM296203",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 296203,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1929,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 90,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400",
      "ID": 3505
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1870,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona",
      "DisplayName": "Shona Robison",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8383449+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2135E254P450VM235402",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235402,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1929,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 90,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400",
      "ID": 3505
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2135,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Russell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6690238+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1895E232P431VM257596",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257596,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1929,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 90,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400",
      "ID": 3505
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1895,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0633373+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228180",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 228180,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1929,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 90,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400",
      "ID": 3505
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1839,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5877667+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2345E10P55VM291655",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291655,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1929,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 90,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400",
      "ID": 3505
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2345,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1366275+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311085",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311085,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1929,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 90,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400",
      "ID": 3505
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2223,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish",
      "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.6047715+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246402",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 246402,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1929,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 90,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400",
      "ID": 3505
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2182,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1271834+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298114",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298114,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1929,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 90,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400",
      "ID": 3505
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5079,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew",
      "DisplayName": "Drew Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.138835+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234146",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234146,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1929,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 90,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400",
      "ID": 3505
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1769,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1686279+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274610",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274610,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1929,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 90,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400",
      "ID": 3505
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4014,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz",
      "DisplayName": "Liz Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1140491+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269566",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269566,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1929,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 90,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400",
      "ID": 3505
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2215,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5531556+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317427",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317427,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1929,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 90,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400",
      "ID": 3505
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3806,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4216431+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326365",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 326365,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1929,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 90,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400",
      "ID": 3505
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5106,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin",
      "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7553411+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241193",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241193,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1929,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 90,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400",
      "ID": 3505
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1848,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola",
      "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.747017+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2098E237P531VM289691",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289691,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1929,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 90,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400",
      "ID": 3505
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2098,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Swinney",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4550417+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2674E247P401VM247816",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247816,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1929,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 90,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400",
      "ID": 3505
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2674,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave",
      "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4296539+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5075E234P371VM287417",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 287417,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1929,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 90,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400",
      "ID": 3505
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5075,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Torrance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8633053+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1793E151P362VM222510",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 222510,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1929,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 90,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400",
      "ID": 3505
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1793,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean",
      "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1920704+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5078E245P7VM307007",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307007,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1929,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 90,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400",
      "ID": 3505
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5078,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Walker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5832983+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1841E231P426VM239930",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239930,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1929,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 90,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400",
      "ID": 3505
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1841,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen",
      "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7654563+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283474",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283474,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1929,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 90,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400",
      "ID": 3505
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4952,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.70945+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1865E263P500VM231862",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231862,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1929,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 90,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400",
      "ID": 3505
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1865,
      "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra",
      "DisplayName": "Sandra White",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6187468+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237737",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237737,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1929,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 90,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400",
      "ID": 3505
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2610,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Wilson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2236514+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309223",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 309223,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1929,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 90,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Growing the Visitor Economy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03400",
      "ID": 3505
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4941,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza",
      "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3200794+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252677",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252677,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1930,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397.1",
      "ID": 3525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1926,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian",
      "DisplayName": "Brian Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.748846+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2615E213P388VM258879",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258879,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1930,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397.1",
      "ID": 3525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2615,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George",
      "DisplayName": "George Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3321655+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319667",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319667,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1930,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397.1",
      "ID": 3525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4940,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare",
      "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9361569+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249606",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 249606,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1930,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397.1",
      "ID": 3525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2641,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair",
      "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9340678+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1783E21P273VM227788",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227788,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1930,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397.1",
      "ID": 3525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1783,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie",
      "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5656595+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2633E97P136VM280791",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280791,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1930,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397.1",
      "ID": 3525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2633,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire",
      "DisplayName": "Claire Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7825465+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262690",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262690,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1930,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397.1",
      "ID": 3525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2603,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6126802+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1759E91P115VM229775",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229775,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1930,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397.1",
      "ID": 3525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia",
      "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0964994+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270148",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270148,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1930,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397.1",
      "ID": 3525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3751,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.583616+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322659",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 322659,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1930,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397.1",
      "ID": 3525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5109,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco",
      "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6982111+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5060E86P124VM294765",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 294765,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1930,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397.1",
      "ID": 3525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5060,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1773548+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242932",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242932,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1930,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397.1",
      "ID": 3525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1866,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah",
      "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0417358+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235212",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235212,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1930,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397.1",
      "ID": 3525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1943,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic",
      "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6603018+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302340",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 302340,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1930,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397.1",
      "ID": 3525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2595,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin",
      "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5201733+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244313",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244313,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1930,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397.1",
      "ID": 3525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2103,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith",
      "DisplayName": "Keith Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5492811+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327128",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 327128,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1930,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397.1",
      "ID": 3525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.8003229+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277029",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277029,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1930,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397.1",
      "ID": 3525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6980278+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264300",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264300,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1930,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397.1",
      "ID": 3525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2673,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick",
      "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1273389+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248744",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248744,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1930,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397.1",
      "ID": 3525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2678,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson",
      "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6679284+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2123E27P233VM295749",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295749,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1930,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397.1",
      "ID": 3525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2123,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm",
      "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5342697+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285194",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285194,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1930,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397.1",
      "ID": 3525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3907,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0704881+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230671",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230671,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1930,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397.1",
      "ID": 3525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1735,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela",
      "DisplayName": "Angela Constance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3402004+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243787",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 243787,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1930,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397.1",
      "ID": 3525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1932,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce",
      "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3197502+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254906",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254906,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1930,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397.1",
      "ID": 3525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1863,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna",
      "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2888644+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323735",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 323735,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1930,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397.1",
      "ID": 3525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4976,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth",
      "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9696453+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5107E223P379VM291306",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291306,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1930,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397.1",
      "ID": 3525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5107,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1132691+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3743E222P391VM265366",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265366,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1930,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397.1",
      "ID": 3525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3743,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel",
      "DisplayName": "Nigel Don",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4360846+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262280",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262280,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1930,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397.1",
      "ID": 3525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3771,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob",
      "DisplayName": "Bob Doris",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.5946949+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281949",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 281949,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1930,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397.1",
      "ID": 3525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2826,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Dornan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1647171+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298177",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298177,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1930,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397.1",
      "ID": 3525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3812,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia",
      "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.141582+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231571",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231571,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1930,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397.1",
      "ID": 3525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1778,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen",
      "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6063514+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4955E240P389VM285912",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285912,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1930,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397.1",
      "ID": 3525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4955,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3498987+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219416",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 219416,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1930,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397.1",
      "ID": 3525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1742,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle",
      "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.2978386+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238547",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 238547,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1930,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397.1",
      "ID": 3525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1994,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus",
      "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4587926+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225413",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225413,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1930,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397.1",
      "ID": 3525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1814,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda",
      "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9736564+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321801",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 321801,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1930,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397.1",
      "ID": 3525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Fee",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4519524+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292900",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 292900,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1930,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397.1",
      "ID": 3525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia",
      "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5630556+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227143",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227143,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1930,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397.1",
      "ID": 3525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2696665+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5054E95P118VM312700",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 312700,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1930,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397.1",
      "ID": 3525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5054,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1395936+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4947E152P361VM257213",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257213,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1930,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397.1",
      "ID": 3525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4947,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Finnie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0464156+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271267",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271267,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1930,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397.1",
      "ID": 3525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3901,
      "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe",
      "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0629068+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278086",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 278086,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1930,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397.1",
      "ID": 3525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2394,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo",
      "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9863969+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2110E220P414VM287235",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 287235,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1930,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397.1",
      "ID": 3525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth",
      "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8554582+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250491",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250491,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1930,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397.1",
      "ID": 3525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2675,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob",
      "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1918223+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1741E10P50VM220958",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220958,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1930,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397.1",
      "ID": 3525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1741,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel",
      "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6689684+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220227",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220227,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1930,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397.1",
      "ID": 3525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1756,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine",
      "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6292974+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1860E104P150VM252360",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252360,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1930,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397.1",
      "ID": 3525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1860,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda",
      "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7258358+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2033E20P141VM253855",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253855,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1930,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397.1",
      "ID": 3525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2033,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain",
      "DisplayName": "Iain Gray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.02376+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324670",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324670,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1930,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397.1",
      "ID": 3525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5042,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2329036+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259691",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 259691,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1930,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397.1",
      "ID": 3525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick",
      "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6203689+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239349",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239349,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1930,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397.1",
      "ID": 3525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2029,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh",
      "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7329971+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273771",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 273771,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1930,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397.1",
      "ID": 3525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3758,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6349551+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304145",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 304145,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1930,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397.1",
      "ID": 3525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4086,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Hume",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8515747+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221737",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221737,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1930,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397.1",
      "ID": 3525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1773,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9456003+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1882E227P459VM241970",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241970,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1930,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397.1",
      "ID": 3525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1882,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam",
      "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7882115+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223525",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223525,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1930,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397.1",
      "ID": 3525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1893,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4621814+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307606",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307606,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1930,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397.1",
      "ID": 3525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4934,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.836862+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272228",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 272228,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1930,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397.1",
      "ID": 3525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4956,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Keir",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3205528+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244942",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244942,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1930,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397.1",
      "ID": 3525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Kelly",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5851978+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315112",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315112,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1930,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397.1",
      "ID": 3525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3129,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6748204+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247919",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247919,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1930,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397.1",
      "ID": 3525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann",
      "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4340165+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4016E11P36VM274818",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274818,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1930,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397.1",
      "ID": 3525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4016,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1230713+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255769",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255769,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1930,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397.1",
      "ID": 3525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2180,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5560893+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4938E158P374VM277427",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277427,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1930,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397.1",
      "ID": 3525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4938,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9529029+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2112E250P486VM253043",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253043,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1930,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397.1",
      "ID": 3525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2112,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny",
      "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7643983+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4939E258P394VM276811",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276811,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1930,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397.1",
      "ID": 3525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4939,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus",
      "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6821028+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325461",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 325461,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1930,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397.1",
      "ID": 3525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5074,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon",
      "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5073954+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1828E3P10VM232865",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232865,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1930,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397.1",
      "ID": 3525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1828,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo",
      "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8799447+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311451",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311451,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1930,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397.1",
      "ID": 3525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4948,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike",
      "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8793927+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2117E90P107VM230379",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230379,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1930,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397.1",
      "ID": 3525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2117,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis",
      "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3272485+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267389",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 267389,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1930,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397.1",
      "ID": 3525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken",
      "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0177113+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313711",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313711,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1930,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397.1",
      "ID": 3525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4966,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek",
      "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4073772+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3101E102P129VM295051",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295051,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1930,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397.1",
      "ID": 3525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3101,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala",
      "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1900873+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319051",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319051,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1930,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397.1",
      "ID": 3525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5034,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny",
      "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6903172+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306374",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306374,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1930,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397.1",
      "ID": 3525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2159,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Martin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.54935+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5110E252P395VM311208",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311208,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1930,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397.1",
      "ID": 3525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Mason",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8665941+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268214",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 268214,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1930,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397.1",
      "ID": 3525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2133,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2537772+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2876E141P433VM286359",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286359,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1930,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397.1",
      "ID": 3525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2876,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5754157+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4951E147P368VM258643",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258643,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1930,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397.1",
      "ID": 3525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4951,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan",
      "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3163439+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3896E175P307VM263859",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 263859,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1930,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397.1",
      "ID": 3525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3896,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam",
      "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9138436+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308431",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 308431,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1930,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397.1",
      "ID": 3525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0556431+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4964E143P375VM279691",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279691,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1930,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397.1",
      "ID": 3525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4964,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5185171+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279643",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279643,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1930,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397.1",
      "ID": 3525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3824,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5164515+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2066E22P91VM261046",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261046,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1930,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397.1",
      "ID": 3525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2066,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.1094598+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299641",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 299641,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1930,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397.1",
      "ID": 3525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7064745+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306617",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306617,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1930,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397.1",
      "ID": 3525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina",
      "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.559775+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2487E146P369VM301178",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 301178,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1930,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397.1",
      "ID": 3525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2487,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0374082+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223861",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223861,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1930,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397.1",
      "ID": 3525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4769324+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237520",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237520,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1930,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397.1",
      "ID": 3525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1961,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David",
      "DisplayName": "David McLetchie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2143748+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305494",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 305494,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1930,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397.1",
      "ID": 3525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2134,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3267322+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320375",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 320375,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1930,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397.1",
      "ID": 3525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5041,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan",
      "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1637113+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315970",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315970,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1930,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397.1",
      "ID": 3525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3763,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart",
      "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9401351+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1986E23P197VM236657",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 236657,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1930,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397.1",
      "ID": 3525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1986,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan",
      "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.934454+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5047E100P130VM289847",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289847,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1930,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397.1",
      "ID": 3525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5047,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne",
      "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4615973+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234576",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234576,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1930,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397.1",
      "ID": 3525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1845,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette",
      "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3902545+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313230",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313230,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1930,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397.1",
      "ID": 3525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3061,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.3833512+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1768E19P265VM288602",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 288602,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1930,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397.1",
      "ID": 3525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1768,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1504703+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225261",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225261,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1930,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397.1",
      "ID": 3525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1894,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Neil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9617521+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3815E98P134VM270922",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270922,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1930,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397.1",
      "ID": 3525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3815,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Park, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Park",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8348724+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265863",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265863,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1930,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397.1",
      "ID": 3525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2010,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil",
      "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4638015+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283297",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283297,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1930,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397.1",
      "ID": 3525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5057,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.694411+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2853E33P128VM251495",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251495,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1930,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397.1",
      "ID": 3525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Pentland",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4661478+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317596",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317596,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1930,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397.1",
      "ID": 3525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5009,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.429235+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254672",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254672,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1930,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397.1",
      "ID": 3525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3745,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis",
      "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2666659+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1870E225P478VM295660",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295660,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1930,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397.1",
      "ID": 3525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1870,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona",
      "DisplayName": "Shona Robison",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5303942+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2135E254P450VM235398",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235398,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1930,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397.1",
      "ID": 3525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2135,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Russell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6688592+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1895E232P431VM257592",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257592,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1930,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397.1",
      "ID": 3525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1895,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0631526+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228146",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 228146,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1930,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397.1",
      "ID": 3525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1839,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5863255+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2345E10P55VM291659",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291659,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1930,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397.1",
      "ID": 3525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2345,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1367884+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311081",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311081,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1930,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397.1",
      "ID": 3525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2223,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish",
      "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.6045895+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246367",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 246367,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1930,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397.1",
      "ID": 3525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2182,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1256689+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298140",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298140,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1930,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397.1",
      "ID": 3525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5079,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew",
      "DisplayName": "Drew Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1399262+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234325",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234325,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1930,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397.1",
      "ID": 3525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1769,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3723984+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274606",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274606,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1930,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397.1",
      "ID": 3525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4014,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz",
      "DisplayName": "Liz Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1138843+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269556",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269556,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1930,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397.1",
      "ID": 3525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2215,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5527288+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317423",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317423,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1930,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397.1",
      "ID": 3525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3806,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4214598+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326369",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 326369,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1930,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397.1",
      "ID": 3525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5106,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin",
      "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7555254+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241159",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241159,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1930,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397.1",
      "ID": 3525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1848,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola",
      "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.4045714+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2098E237P531VM289687",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289687,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1930,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397.1",
      "ID": 3525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2098,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Swinney",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4548811+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2674E247P401VM247812",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247812,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1930,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397.1",
      "ID": 3525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2674,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave",
      "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4294932+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5075E234P371VM287413",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 287413,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1930,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397.1",
      "ID": 3525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5075,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Torrance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8631435+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1793E151P362VM222506",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 222506,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1930,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397.1",
      "ID": 3525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1793,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean",
      "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1918869+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5078E245P7VM307082",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307082,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1930,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397.1",
      "ID": 3525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5078,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Walker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5864994+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1841E231P426VM239964",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239964,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1930,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397.1",
      "ID": 3525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1841,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen",
      "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7669023+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283469",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283469,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1930,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397.1",
      "ID": 3525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4952,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7092432+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1865E263P500VM231872",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231872,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1930,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397.1",
      "ID": 3525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1865,
      "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra",
      "DisplayName": "Sandra White",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6192252+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237741",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237741,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1930,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397.1",
      "ID": 3525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2610,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Wilson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.223812+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309233",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 309233,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1930,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 47,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397.1",
      "ID": 3525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4941,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza",
      "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3205068+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252678",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252678,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1931,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 46,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397",
      "ID": 3502
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1926,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian",
      "DisplayName": "Brian Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7488858+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2615E213P388VM258881",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258881,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1931,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 46,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397",
      "ID": 3502
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2615,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George",
      "DisplayName": "George Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3322492+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319666",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319666,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1931,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 46,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397",
      "ID": 3502
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4940,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare",
      "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9361158+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249605",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 249605,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1931,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 46,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397",
      "ID": 3502
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2641,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair",
      "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9340266+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1783E21P273VM227789",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227789,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1931,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 46,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397",
      "ID": 3502
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1783,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie",
      "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5656999+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2633E97P136VM280792",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280792,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1931,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 46,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397",
      "ID": 3502
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2633,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire",
      "DisplayName": "Claire Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7825865+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262691",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262691,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1931,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 46,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397",
      "ID": 3502
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2603,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6127209+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1759E91P115VM229776",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229776,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1931,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 46,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397",
      "ID": 3502
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia",
      "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.09654+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270146",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270146,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1931,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 46,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397",
      "ID": 3502
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3751,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5835334+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322660",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 322660,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1931,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 46,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397",
      "ID": 3502
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5109,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco",
      "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6982511+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5060E86P124VM294766",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 294766,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1931,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 46,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397",
      "ID": 3502
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5060,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1773959+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242933",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242933,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1931,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 46,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397",
      "ID": 3502
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1866,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah",
      "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0417762+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235210",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235210,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1931,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 46,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397",
      "ID": 3502
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1943,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic",
      "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6602168+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302341",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 302341,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1931,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 46,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397",
      "ID": 3502
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2595,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin",
      "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5202141+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244312",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244312,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1931,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 46,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397",
      "ID": 3502
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2103,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith",
      "DisplayName": "Keith Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5492389+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327129",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 327129,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1931,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 46,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397",
      "ID": 3502
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.8003647+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277030",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277030,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1931,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 46,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397",
      "ID": 3502
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6980687+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264299",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264299,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1931,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 46,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397",
      "ID": 3502
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2673,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick",
      "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1272986+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248743",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248743,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1931,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 46,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397",
      "ID": 3502
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2678,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson",
      "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6678876+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2123E27P233VM295748",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295748,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1931,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 46,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397",
      "ID": 3502
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2123,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm",
      "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5342283+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285195",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285195,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1931,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 46,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397",
      "ID": 3502
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3907,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0705299+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230672",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230672,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1931,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 46,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397",
      "ID": 3502
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1735,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela",
      "DisplayName": "Angela Constance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3402406+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243786",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 243786,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1931,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 46,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397",
      "ID": 3502
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1932,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce",
      "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3197103+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254905",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254905,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1931,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 46,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397",
      "ID": 3502
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1863,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna",
      "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2888241+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323736",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 323736,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1931,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 46,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397",
      "ID": 3502
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4976,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth",
      "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9696868+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5107E223P379VM291305",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291305,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1931,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 46,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397",
      "ID": 3502
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5107,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1132281+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3743E222P391VM265367",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265367,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1931,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 46,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397",
      "ID": 3502
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3743,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel",
      "DisplayName": "Nigel Don",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.436126+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262281",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262281,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1931,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 46,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397",
      "ID": 3502
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3771,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob",
      "DisplayName": "Bob Doris",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.5947356+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281948",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 281948,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1931,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 46,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397",
      "ID": 3502
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2826,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Dornan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1646757+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298178",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298178,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1931,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 46,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397",
      "ID": 3502
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3812,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia",
      "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1417179+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231570",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231570,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1931,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 46,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397",
      "ID": 3502
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1778,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen",
      "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6063103+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4955E240P389VM285910",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285910,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1931,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 46,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397",
      "ID": 3502
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4955,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3498137+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219417",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 219417,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1931,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 46,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397",
      "ID": 3502
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1742,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle",
      "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.2978817+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238545",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 238545,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1931,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 46,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397",
      "ID": 3502
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1994,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus",
      "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4587095+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225412",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225412,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1931,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 46,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397",
      "ID": 3502
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1814,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda",
      "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.973616+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321800",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 321800,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1931,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 46,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397",
      "ID": 3502
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Fee",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4519115+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292821",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 292821,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1931,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 46,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397",
      "ID": 3502
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia",
      "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5595563+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227144",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227144,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1931,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 46,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397",
      "ID": 3502
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2697081+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5054E95P118VM312701",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 312701,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1931,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 46,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397",
      "ID": 3502
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5054,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1396349+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4947E152P361VM257214",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257214,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1931,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 46,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397",
      "ID": 3502
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4947,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Finnie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0464789+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271265",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271265,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1931,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 46,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397",
      "ID": 3502
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3901,
      "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe",
      "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0628234+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278085",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 278085,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1931,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 46,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397",
      "ID": 3502
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2394,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo",
      "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9863562+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2110E220P414VM287236",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 287236,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1931,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 46,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397",
      "ID": 3502
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth",
      "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.855499+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250492",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250492,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1931,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 46,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397",
      "ID": 3502
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2675,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob",
      "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1918641+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1741E10P50VM220959",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220959,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1931,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 46,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397",
      "ID": 3502
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1741,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel",
      "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6690282+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220226",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220226,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1931,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 46,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397",
      "ID": 3502
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1756,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine",
      "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6292562+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1860E104P150VM252361",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252361,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1931,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 46,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397",
      "ID": 3502
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1860,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda",
      "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7258764+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2033E20P141VM253854",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253854,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1931,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 46,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397",
      "ID": 3502
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2033,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain",
      "DisplayName": "Iain Gray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0237194+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324669",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324669,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1931,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 46,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397",
      "ID": 3502
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5042,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.232864+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259690",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 259690,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1931,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 46,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397",
      "ID": 3502
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick",
      "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6203103+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239351",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239351,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1931,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 46,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397",
      "ID": 3502
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2029,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh",
      "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7330792+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273770",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 273770,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1931,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 46,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397",
      "ID": 3502
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3758,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6349154+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304144",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 304144,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1931,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 46,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397",
      "ID": 3502
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4086,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Hume",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8515339+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221736",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221736,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1931,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 46,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397",
      "ID": 3502
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1773,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9455604+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1882E227P459VM241969",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241969,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1931,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 46,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397",
      "ID": 3502
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1882,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam",
      "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7881704+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223524",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223524,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1931,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 46,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397",
      "ID": 3502
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1893,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4621412+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307607",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307607,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1931,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 46,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397",
      "ID": 3502
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4934,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.836903+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272229",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 272229,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1931,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 46,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397",
      "ID": 3502
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4956,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Keir",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.320595+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244943",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244943,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1931,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 46,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397",
      "ID": 3502
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Kelly",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5852382+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315113",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315113,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1931,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 46,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397",
      "ID": 3502
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3129,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6748607+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247917",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247917,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1931,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 46,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397",
      "ID": 3502
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann",
      "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4339352+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4016E11P36VM274820",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274820,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1931,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 46,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397",
      "ID": 3502
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4016,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1231529+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255767",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255767,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1931,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 46,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397",
      "ID": 3502
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2180,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5560075+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4938E158P374VM277425",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277425,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1931,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 46,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397",
      "ID": 3502
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4938,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9528195+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2112E250P486VM253045",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253045,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1931,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 46,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397",
      "ID": 3502
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2112,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny",
      "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7644821+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4939E258P394VM276810",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276810,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1931,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 46,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397",
      "ID": 3502
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4939,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus",
      "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6820444+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325462",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 325462,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1931,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 46,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397",
      "ID": 3502
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5074,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon",
      "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5074361+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1828E3P10VM232866",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232866,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1931,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 46,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397",
      "ID": 3502
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1828,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo",
      "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8799853+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311452",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311452,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1931,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 46,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397",
      "ID": 3502
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4948,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike",
      "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8794341+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2117E90P107VM230378",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230378,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1931,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 46,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397",
      "ID": 3502
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2117,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis",
      "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3272056+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267390",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 267390,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1931,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 46,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397",
      "ID": 3502
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken",
      "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0177512+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313710",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313710,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1931,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 46,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397",
      "ID": 3502
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4966,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek",
      "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4073364+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3101E102P129VM295050",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295050,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1931,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 46,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397",
      "ID": 3502
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3101,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala",
      "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1900458+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319050",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319050,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1931,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 46,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397",
      "ID": 3502
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5034,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny",
      "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6902761+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306373",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306373,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1931,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 46,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397",
      "ID": 3502
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2159,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Martin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5493099+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5110E252P395VM310823",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 310823,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1931,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 46,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397",
      "ID": 3502
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Mason",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5875757+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268213",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 268213,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1931,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 46,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397",
      "ID": 3502
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2133,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2537356+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2876E141P433VM286360",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286360,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1931,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 46,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397",
      "ID": 3502
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2876,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5754566+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4951E147P368VM258642",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258642,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1931,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 46,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397",
      "ID": 3502
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4951,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan",
      "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3163026+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3896E175P307VM263858",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 263858,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1931,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 46,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397",
      "ID": 3502
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3896,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam",
      "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9138033+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308509",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 308509,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1931,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 46,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397",
      "ID": 3502
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0589932+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4964E143P375VM279692",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279692,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1931,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 46,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397",
      "ID": 3502
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4964,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5185569+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279642",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279642,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1931,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 46,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397",
      "ID": 3502
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3824,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.516411+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2066E22P91VM261045",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261045,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1931,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 46,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397",
      "ID": 3502
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2066,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.109419+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299640",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 299640,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1931,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 46,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397",
      "ID": 3502
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7064342+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306695",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306695,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1931,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 46,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397",
      "ID": 3502
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina",
      "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5633969+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2487E146P369VM301099",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 301099,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1931,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 46,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397",
      "ID": 3502
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2487,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0332207+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223862",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223862,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1931,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 46,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397",
      "ID": 3502
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4769731+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237522",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237522,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1931,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 46,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397",
      "ID": 3502
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1961,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David",
      "DisplayName": "David McLetchie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2144579+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305495",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 305495,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1931,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 46,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397",
      "ID": 3502
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2134,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3267721+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320376",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 320376,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1931,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 46,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397",
      "ID": 3502
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5041,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan",
      "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.163752+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315969",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315969,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1931,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 46,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397",
      "ID": 3502
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3763,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart",
      "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9400943+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1986E23P197VM236658",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 236658,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1931,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 46,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397",
      "ID": 3502
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1986,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan",
      "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.934494+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5047E100P130VM289846",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289846,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1931,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 46,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397",
      "ID": 3502
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5047,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne",
      "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.461558+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234575",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234575,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1931,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 46,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397",
      "ID": 3502
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1845,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette",
      "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3902137+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313229",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313229,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1931,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 46,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397",
      "ID": 3502
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3061,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.3833096+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1768E19P265VM289299",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289299,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1931,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 46,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397",
      "ID": 3502
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1768,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4312862+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225263",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225263,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1931,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 46,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397",
      "ID": 3502
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1894,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Neil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9618351+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3815E98P134VM270924",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270924,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1931,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 46,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397",
      "ID": 3502
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3815,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Park, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Park",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8349593+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265862",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265862,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1931,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 46,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397",
      "ID": 3502
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2010,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil",
      "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.463761+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283296",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283296,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1931,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 46,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397",
      "ID": 3502
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5057,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.6943709+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2853E33P128VM251496",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251496,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1931,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 46,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397",
      "ID": 3502
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Pentland",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4661939+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317597",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317597,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1931,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 46,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397",
      "ID": 3502
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5009,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4292751+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254671",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254671,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1931,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 46,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397",
      "ID": 3502
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3745,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis",
      "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.266625+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1870E225P478VM296200",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 296200,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1931,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 46,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397",
      "ID": 3502
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1870,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona",
      "DisplayName": "Shona Robison",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8381868+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2135E254P450VM235399",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235399,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1931,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 46,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397",
      "ID": 3502
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2135,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Russell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6689004+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1895E232P431VM257593",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257593,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1931,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 46,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397",
      "ID": 3502
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1895,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0632125+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228147",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 228147,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1931,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 46,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397",
      "ID": 3502
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1839,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5863657+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2345E10P55VM291658",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291658,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1931,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 46,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397",
      "ID": 3502
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2345,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1367478+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311082",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311082,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1931,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 46,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397",
      "ID": 3502
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2223,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish",
      "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.6046489+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246368",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 246368,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1931,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 46,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397",
      "ID": 3502
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2182,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1257103+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298139",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298139,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1931,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 46,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397",
      "ID": 3502
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5079,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew",
      "DisplayName": "Drew Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1398854+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234324",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234324,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1931,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 46,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397",
      "ID": 3502
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1769,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3723579+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274607",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274607,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1931,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 46,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397",
      "ID": 3502
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4014,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz",
      "DisplayName": "Liz Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1139252+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269557",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269557,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1931,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 46,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397",
      "ID": 3502
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2215,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5527696+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317424",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317424,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1931,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 46,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397",
      "ID": 3502
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3806,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4214999+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326368",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 326368,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1931,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 46,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397",
      "ID": 3502
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5106,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin",
      "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7554842+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241160",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241160,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1931,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 46,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397",
      "ID": 3502
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1848,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola",
      "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.4046129+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2098E237P531VM289688",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289688,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1931,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 46,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397",
      "ID": 3502
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2098,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Swinney",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4549211+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2674E247P401VM247813",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247813,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1931,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 46,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397",
      "ID": 3502
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2674,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave",
      "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4295336+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5075E234P371VM287414",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 287414,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1931,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 46,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397",
      "ID": 3502
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5075,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Torrance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8631832+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1793E151P362VM222507",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 222507,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1931,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 46,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397",
      "ID": 3502
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1793,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean",
      "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1919281+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5078E245P7VM307010",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307010,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1931,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 46,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397",
      "ID": 3502
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5078,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Walker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5834195+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1841E231P426VM239963",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239963,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1931,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 46,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397",
      "ID": 3502
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1841,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen",
      "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7668614+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283471",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283471,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1931,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 46,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397",
      "ID": 3502
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4952,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7093263+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1865E263P500VM231871",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231871,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1931,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 46,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397",
      "ID": 3502
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1865,
      "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra",
      "DisplayName": "Sandra White",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6191762+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237740",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237740,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1931,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 46,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397",
      "ID": 3502
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2610,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Wilson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2237718+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309232",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 309232,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1931,
      "AgendaID": 2356,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 60,
      "VoteAgainst": 46,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government",
      "Reference": "S4M-03397",
      "ID": 3502
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4941,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza",
      "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3204654+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252277",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252277,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1925,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.3",
      "ID": 3425
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1926,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian",
      "DisplayName": "Brian Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7220905+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2615E213P388VM257545",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257545,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1925,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.3",
      "ID": 3425
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2615,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George",
      "DisplayName": "George Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0611495+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319945",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319945,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1925,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.3",
      "ID": 3425
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4940,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare",
      "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9481686+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249612",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 249612,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1925,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.3",
      "ID": 3425
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2641,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair",
      "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9343338+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1783E21P273VM227384",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227384,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1925,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.3",
      "ID": 3425
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1783,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie",
      "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5478447+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2633E97P136VM280379",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280379,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1925,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.3",
      "ID": 3425
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2633,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire",
      "DisplayName": "Claire Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7581876+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262684",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262684,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1925,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.3",
      "ID": 3425
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2603,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6124317+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1759E91P115VM229769",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229769,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1925,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.3",
      "ID": 3425
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia",
      "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0962488+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270249",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270249,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1925,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.3",
      "ID": 3425
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3751,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.7957953+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322839",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 322839,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1925,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.3",
      "ID": 3425
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5109,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco",
      "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.7057963+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5060E86P124VM294759",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 294759,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1925,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.3",
      "ID": 3425
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5060,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1771059+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242809",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242809,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1925,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.3",
      "ID": 3425
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1866,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah",
      "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0364513+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235619",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235619,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1925,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.3",
      "ID": 3425
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1943,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic",
      "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6855558+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302334",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 302334,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1925,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.3",
      "ID": 3425
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2595,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin",
      "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5199242+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244472",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244472,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1925,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.3",
      "ID": 3425
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2103,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith",
      "DisplayName": "Keith Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5562423+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327344",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 327344,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1925,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.3",
      "ID": 3425
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:46.0318211+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277023",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277023,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1925,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.3",
      "ID": 3425
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.697762+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264306",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264306,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1925,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.3",
      "ID": 3425
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2673,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick",
      "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1275861+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248844",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248844,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1925,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.3",
      "ID": 3425
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2678,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson",
      "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6724707+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2123E27P233VM296336",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 296336,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1925,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.3",
      "ID": 3425
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2123,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm",
      "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8446291+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285188",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285188,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1925,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.3",
      "ID": 3425
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3907,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0702229+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230665",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230665,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1925,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.3",
      "ID": 3425
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1735,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela",
      "DisplayName": "Angela Constance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3399556+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243910",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 243910,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1925,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.3",
      "ID": 3425
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1932,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce",
      "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3251662+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254912",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254912,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1925,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.3",
      "ID": 3425
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1863,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna",
      "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2891329+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323979",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 323979,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1925,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.3",
      "ID": 3425
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4976,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth",
      "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9807519+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5107E223P379VM291866",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291866,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1925,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.3",
      "ID": 3425
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5107,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1458568+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3743E222P391VM265360",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265360,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1925,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.3",
      "ID": 3425
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3743,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel",
      "DisplayName": "Nigel Don",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4358316+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3771E149P417VM261715",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261715,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1925,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.3",
      "ID": 3425
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3771,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob",
      "DisplayName": "Bob Doris",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3695021+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2826E262P384VM282051",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 282051,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1925,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.3",
      "ID": 3425
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2826,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Dornan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1734952+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3812E94P117VM297920",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 297920,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1925,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.3",
      "ID": 3425
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3812,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia",
      "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1306331+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231577",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231577,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1925,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.3",
      "ID": 3425
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1778,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen",
      "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.606599+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4955E240P389VM286167",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286167,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1925,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.3",
      "ID": 3425
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4955,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.366778+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219319",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 219319,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1925,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.3",
      "ID": 3425
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1742,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle",
      "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.2933919+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238646",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 238646,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1925,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.3",
      "ID": 3425
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1994,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus",
      "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4630308+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225419",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225419,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1925,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.3",
      "ID": 3425
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1814,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda",
      "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9739283+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321621",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 321621,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1925,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.3",
      "ID": 3425
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Fee",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4439664+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292906",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 292906,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1925,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.3",
      "ID": 3425
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia",
      "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5632969+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1892E12P64VM226887",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 226887,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1925,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.3",
      "ID": 3425
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2509828+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5054E95P118VM312694",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 312694,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1925,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.3",
      "ID": 3425
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5054,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1393278+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4947E152P361VM257207",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257207,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1925,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.3",
      "ID": 3425
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4947,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Finnie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0461627+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271522",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271522,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1925,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.3",
      "ID": 3425
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3901,
      "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe",
      "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0794552+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278496",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 278496,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1925,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.3",
      "ID": 3425
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2394,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo",
      "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2213592+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2110E220P414VM286766",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286766,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1925,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.3",
      "ID": 3425
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth",
      "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5997693+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250485",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250485,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1925,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.3",
      "ID": 3425
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2675,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob",
      "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1915722+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1741E10P50VM220952",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220952,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1925,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.3",
      "ID": 3425
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1741,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel",
      "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6687189+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220326",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220326,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1925,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.3",
      "ID": 3425
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1756,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine",
      "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6365069+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1860E104P150VM252354",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252354,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1925,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.3",
      "ID": 3425
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1860,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda",
      "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7255676+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2033E20P141VM266180",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 266180,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1925,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.3",
      "ID": 3425
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2033,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain",
      "DisplayName": "Iain Gray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.477799+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324454",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324454,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1925,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.3",
      "ID": 3425
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5042,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2233833+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259947",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 259947,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1925,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.3",
      "ID": 3425
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick",
      "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6368999+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239251",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239251,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1925,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.3",
      "ID": 3425
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2029,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh",
      "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.728707+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273777",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 273777,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1925,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.3",
      "ID": 3425
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3758,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6352167+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304151",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 304151,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1925,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.3",
      "ID": 3425
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4086,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Hume",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8518482+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221743",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221743,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1925,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.3",
      "ID": 3425
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1773,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9458772+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1882E227P459VM241976",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241976,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1925,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.3",
      "ID": 3425
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1882,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam",
      "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7884806+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223779",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223779,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1925,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.3",
      "ID": 3425
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1893,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.47339+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307504",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307504,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1925,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.3",
      "ID": 3425
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4934,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.832381+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272222",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 272222,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1925,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.3",
      "ID": 3425
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4956,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Keir",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3202783+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244816",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244816,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1925,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.3",
      "ID": 3425
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Kelly",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5798635+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3129E261P419VM314987",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 314987,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1925,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.3",
      "ID": 3425
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3129,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6691962+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2080E36P220VM251109",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251109,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1925,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.3",
      "ID": 3425
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann",
      "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.227485+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4016E11P36VM274719",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274719,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1925,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.3",
      "ID": 3425
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4016,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1187583+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255866",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255866,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1925,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.3",
      "ID": 3425
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2180,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5603956+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4938E158P374VM277835",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277835,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1925,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.3",
      "ID": 3425
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4938,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9704799+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2112E250P486VM252945",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252945,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1925,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.3",
      "ID": 3425
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2112,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny",
      "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7600003+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4939E258P394VM277221",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277221,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1925,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.3",
      "ID": 3425
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4939,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus",
      "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9388976+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325677",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 325677,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1925,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.3",
      "ID": 3425
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5074,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon",
      "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5165589+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1828E3P10VM232859",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232859,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1925,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.3",
      "ID": 3425
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1828,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo",
      "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8796766+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311350",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311350,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1925,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.3",
      "ID": 3425
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4948,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike",
      "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8749168+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2117E90P107VM230479",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230479,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1925,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.3",
      "ID": 3425
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2117,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis",
      "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3317008+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267291",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 267291,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1925,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.3",
      "ID": 3425
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken",
      "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0130931+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313811",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313811,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1925,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.3",
      "ID": 3425
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4966,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek",
      "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4116644+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3101E102P129VM295462",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295462,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1925,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.3",
      "ID": 3425
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3101,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala",
      "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5131818+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5034E88P114VM318871",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 318871,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1925,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.3",
      "ID": 3425
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5034,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny",
      "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6770678+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306500",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306500,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1925,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.3",
      "ID": 3425
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2159,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Martin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5547264+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5110E252P395VM311214",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311214,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1925,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.3",
      "ID": 3425
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Mason",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8669018+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268313",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 268313,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1925,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.3",
      "ID": 3425
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2133,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2617306+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2876E141P433VM286100",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286100,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1925,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.3",
      "ID": 3425
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2876,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3636557+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4951E147P368VM258649",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258649,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1925,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.3",
      "ID": 3425
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4951,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan",
      "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3165943+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3896E175P307VM264115",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264115,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1925,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.3",
      "ID": 3425
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3896,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam",
      "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9248901+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308425",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 308425,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1925,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.3",
      "ID": 3425
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0553793+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4964E143P375VM279288",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279288,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1925,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.3",
      "ID": 3425
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4964,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.4953719+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279959",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279959,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1925,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.3",
      "ID": 3425
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3824,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5302048+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2066E22P91VM261792",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261792,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1925,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.3",
      "ID": 3425
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2066,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3783661+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299743",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 299743,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1925,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.3",
      "ID": 3425
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7207069+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306611",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306611,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1925,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.3",
      "ID": 3425
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina",
      "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5595263+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2487E146P369VM301184",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 301184,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1925,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.3",
      "ID": 3425
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2487,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0377377+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223855",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223855,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1925,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.3",
      "ID": 3425
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4766634+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237423",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237423,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1925,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.3",
      "ID": 3425
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1961,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David",
      "DisplayName": "David McLetchie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2035731+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2134E34P201VM297814",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 297814,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1925,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.3",
      "ID": 3425
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2134,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1261679+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320710",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 320710,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1925,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.3",
      "ID": 3425
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5041,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan",
      "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1781344+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3763E142P397VM316095",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 316095,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1925,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.3",
      "ID": 3425
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3763,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart",
      "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9459443+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1986E23P197VM236651",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 236651,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1925,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.3",
      "ID": 3425
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1986,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan",
      "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9341872+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5047E100P130VM289853",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289853,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1925,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.3",
      "ID": 3425
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5047,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne",
      "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4618656+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234582",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234582,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1925,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.3",
      "ID": 3425
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1845,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette",
      "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3905077+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313665",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313665,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1925,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.3",
      "ID": 3425
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3061,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.405191+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1768E19P265VM288596",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 288596,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1925,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.3",
      "ID": 3425
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1768,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1502218+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225007",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225007,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1925,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.3",
      "ID": 3425
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1894,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Neil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7405621+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3815E98P134VM270844",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270844,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1925,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.3",
      "ID": 3425
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3815,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Park, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Park",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8255417+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265869",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265869,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1925,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.3",
      "ID": 3425
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2010,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil",
      "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4640705+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283552",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283552,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1925,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.3",
      "ID": 3425
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5057,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.713171+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2853E33P128VM251087",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251087,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1925,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.3",
      "ID": 3425
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Pentland",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.2264552+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317929",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317929,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1925,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.3",
      "ID": 3425
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5009,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4435869+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254678",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254678,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1925,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.3",
      "ID": 3425
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3745,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis",
      "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2669401+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1870E225P478VM295654",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295654,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1925,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.3",
      "ID": 3425
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1870,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona",
      "DisplayName": "Shona Robison",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5301517+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2135E254P450VM234838",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234838,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1925,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.3",
      "ID": 3425
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2135,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Russell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4019168+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1895E232P431VM257586",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257586,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1925,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.3",
      "ID": 3425
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1895,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0629067+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228140",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 228140,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1925,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.3",
      "ID": 3425
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1839,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5860771+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2345E10P55VM291665",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291665,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1925,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.3",
      "ID": 3425
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2345,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1370537+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2223E176P333VM310644",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 310644,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1925,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.3",
      "ID": 3425
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2223,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish",
      "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5798013+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246361",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 246361,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1925,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.3",
      "ID": 3425
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2182,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1254209+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298146",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298146,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1925,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.3",
      "ID": 3425
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5079,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew",
      "DisplayName": "Drew Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1401929+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234331",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234331,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1925,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.3",
      "ID": 3425
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1769,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3726674+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4014E14P26VM269916",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269916,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1925,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.3",
      "ID": 3425
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4014,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz",
      "DisplayName": "Liz Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5733404+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269147",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269147,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1925,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.3",
      "ID": 3425
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2215,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.3057266+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317145",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317145,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1925,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.3",
      "ID": 3425
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3806,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.1836324+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326153",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 326153,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1925,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.3",
      "ID": 3425
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5106,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin",
      "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.542157+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241153",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241153,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1925,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.3",
      "ID": 3425
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1848,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola",
      "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.4043215+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2098E237P531VM289560",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289560,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1925,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.3",
      "ID": 3425
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2098,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Swinney",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4493271+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2674E247P401VM247712",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247712,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1925,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.3",
      "ID": 3425
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2674,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave",
      "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4251979+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5075E234P371VM284829",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 284829,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1925,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.3",
      "ID": 3425
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5075,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Torrance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0495404+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1793E151P362VM222407",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 222407,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1925,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.3",
      "ID": 3425
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1793,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean",
      "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1876244+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5078E245P7VM307088",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307088,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1925,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.3",
      "ID": 3425
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5078,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Walker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5867634+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1841E231P426VM239970",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239970,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1925,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.3",
      "ID": 3425
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1841,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen",
      "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7671488+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283370",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283370,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1925,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.3",
      "ID": 3425
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4952,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.6977809+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1865E263P500VM232274",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232274,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1925,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.3",
      "ID": 3425
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1865,
      "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra",
      "DisplayName": "Sandra White",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8476636+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237841",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237841,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1925,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.3",
      "ID": 3425
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2610,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Wilson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.228386+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309334",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 309334,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1925,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.3",
      "ID": 3425
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4941,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza",
      "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3248316+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252279",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252279,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1926,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Young People and Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.2",
      "ID": 3414
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1926,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian",
      "DisplayName": "Brian Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7221731+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2615E213P388VM257546",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257546,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1926,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Young People and Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.2",
      "ID": 3414
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2615,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George",
      "DisplayName": "George Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0611899+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319944",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319944,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1926,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Young People and Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.2",
      "ID": 3414
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4940,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare",
      "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.948127+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249611",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 249611,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1926,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Young People and Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.2",
      "ID": 3414
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2641,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair",
      "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9342929+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1783E21P273VM227386",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227386,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1926,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Young People and Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.2",
      "ID": 3414
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1783,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie",
      "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5479271+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2633E97P136VM280380",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280380,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1926,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Young People and Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.2",
      "ID": 3414
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2633,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire",
      "DisplayName": "Claire Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7582291+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262685",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262685,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1926,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Young People and Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.2",
      "ID": 3414
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2603,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6124735+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1759E91P115VM229770",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229770,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1926,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Young People and Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.2",
      "ID": 3414
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia",
      "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0962915+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270248",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270248,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1926,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Young People and Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.2",
      "ID": 3414
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3751,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.7957515+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322654",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 322654,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1926,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Young People and Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.2",
      "ID": 3414
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5109,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco",
      "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6979869+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5060E86P124VM294760",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 294760,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1926,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Young People and Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.2",
      "ID": 3414
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5060,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1771473+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242810",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242810,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1926,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Young People and Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.2",
      "ID": 3414
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1866,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah",
      "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.036492+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235618",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235618,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1926,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Young People and Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.2",
      "ID": 3414
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1943,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic",
      "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6855154+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302335",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 302335,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1926,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Young People and Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.2",
      "ID": 3414
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2595,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin",
      "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5199659+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244471",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244471,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1926,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Young People and Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.2",
      "ID": 3414
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2103,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith",
      "DisplayName": "Keith Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5561995+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327345",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 327345,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1926,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Young People and Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.2",
      "ID": 3414
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:46.0318624+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277024",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277024,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1926,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Young People and Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.2",
      "ID": 3414
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6978026+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264305",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264305,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1926,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Young People and Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.2",
      "ID": 3414
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2673,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick",
      "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1275446+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248843",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248843,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1926,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Young People and Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.2",
      "ID": 3414
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2678,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson",
      "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.67243+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2123E27P233VM296335",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 296335,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1926,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Young People and Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.2",
      "ID": 3414
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2123,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm",
      "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8445878+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285189",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285189,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1926,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Young People and Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.2",
      "ID": 3414
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3907,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0702641+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230666",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230666,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1926,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Young People and Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.2",
      "ID": 3414
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1735,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela",
      "DisplayName": "Angela Constance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3399962+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243909",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 243909,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1926,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Young People and Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.2",
      "ID": 3414
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1932,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce",
      "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3251246+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254911",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254911,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1926,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Young People and Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.2",
      "ID": 3414
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1863,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna",
      "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2890918+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323980",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 323980,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1926,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Young People and Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.2",
      "ID": 3414
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4976,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth",
      "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9807932+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5107E223P379VM291865",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291865,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1926,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Young People and Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.2",
      "ID": 3414
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5107,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1458152+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3743E222P391VM265361",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265361,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1926,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Young People and Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.2",
      "ID": 3414
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3743,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel",
      "DisplayName": "Nigel Don",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4358739+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3771E149P417VM261716",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261716,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1926,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Young People and Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.2",
      "ID": 3414
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3771,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob",
      "DisplayName": "Bob Doris",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3695428+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281955",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 281955,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1926,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Young People and Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.2",
      "ID": 3414
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2826,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Dornan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1649647+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298017",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298017,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1926,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Young People and Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.2",
      "ID": 3414
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3812,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia",
      "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1347033+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231576",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231576,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1926,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Young People and Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.2",
      "ID": 3414
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1778,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen",
      "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.606558+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4955E240P389VM286166",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286166,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1926,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Young People and Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.2",
      "ID": 3414
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4955,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3667373+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219320",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 219320,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1926,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Young People and Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.2",
      "ID": 3414
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1742,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle",
      "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.293453+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238645",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 238645,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1926,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Young People and Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.2",
      "ID": 3414
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1994,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus",
      "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4629909+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225418",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225418,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1926,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Young People and Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.2",
      "ID": 3414
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1814,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda",
      "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9738853+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321806",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 321806,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1926,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Young People and Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.2",
      "ID": 3414
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Fee",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4521577+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292905",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 292905,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1926,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Young People and Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.2",
      "ID": 3414
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia",
      "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5632568+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1892E12P64VM226888",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 226888,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1926,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Young People and Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.2",
      "ID": 3414
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2510247+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5054E95P118VM312695",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 312695,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1926,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Young People and Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.2",
      "ID": 3414
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5054,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1393687+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4947E152P361VM257208",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257208,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1926,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Young People and Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.2",
      "ID": 3414
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4947,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Finnie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0462055+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271521",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271521,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1926,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Young People and Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.2",
      "ID": 3414
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3901,
      "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe",
      "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0794142+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278495",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 278495,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1926,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Young People and Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.2",
      "ID": 3414
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2394,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo",
      "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2213125+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2110E220P414VM287230",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 287230,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1926,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Young People and Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.2",
      "ID": 3414
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth",
      "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8552287+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250486",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250486,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1926,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Young People and Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.2",
      "ID": 3414
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2675,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob",
      "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1916136+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1741E10P50VM220953",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220953,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1926,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Young People and Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.2",
      "ID": 3414
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1741,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel",
      "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6687611+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220325",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220325,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1926,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Young People and Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.2",
      "ID": 3414
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1756,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine",
      "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6364653+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1860E104P150VM252355",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252355,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1926,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Young People and Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.2",
      "ID": 3414
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1860,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda",
      "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7256089+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2033E20P141VM266178",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 266178,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1926,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Young People and Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.2",
      "ID": 3414
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2033,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain",
      "DisplayName": "Iain Gray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4776933+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324453",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324453,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1926,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Young People and Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.2",
      "ID": 3414
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5042,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2232905+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259946",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 259946,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1926,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Young People and Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.2",
      "ID": 3414
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick",
      "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6368593+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239252",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239252,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1926,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Young People and Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.2",
      "ID": 3414
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2029,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh",
      "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7287482+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273776",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 273776,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1926,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Young People and Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.2",
      "ID": 3414
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3758,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.635158+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304150",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 304150,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1926,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Young People and Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.2",
      "ID": 3414
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4086,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Hume",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8518063+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221742",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221742,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1926,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Young People and Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.2",
      "ID": 3414
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1773,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9458354+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1882E227P459VM241975",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241975,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1926,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Young People and Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.2",
      "ID": 3414
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1882,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam",
      "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7884397+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223778",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223778,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1926,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Young People and Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.2",
      "ID": 3414
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1893,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4733491+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307601",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307601,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1926,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Young People and Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.2",
      "ID": 3414
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4934,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8366209+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272223",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 272223,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1926,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Young People and Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.2",
      "ID": 3414
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4956,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Keir",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3203194+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244817",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244817,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1926,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Young People and Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.2",
      "ID": 3414
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Kelly",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.579906+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3129E261P419VM314988",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 314988,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1926,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Young People and Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.2",
      "ID": 3414
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3129,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6692548+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2080E36P220VM251108",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251108,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1926,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Young People and Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.2",
      "ID": 3414
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann",
      "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.2274438+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4016E11P36VM274720",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274720,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1926,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Young People and Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.2",
      "ID": 3414
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4016,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1187995+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255865",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255865,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1926,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Young People and Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.2",
      "ID": 3414
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2180,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5603548+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4938E158P374VM277834",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277834,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1926,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Young People and Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.2",
      "ID": 3414
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4938,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9704388+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2112E250P486VM252946",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252946,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1926,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Young People and Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.2",
      "ID": 3414
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2112,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny",
      "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7600419+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4939E258P394VM277220",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277220,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1926,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Young People and Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.2",
      "ID": 3414
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4939,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus",
      "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9388565+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325678",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 325678,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1926,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Young People and Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.2",
      "ID": 3414
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5074,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon",
      "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5165991+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1828E3P10VM232860",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232860,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1926,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Young People and Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.2",
      "ID": 3414
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1828,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo",
      "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8797182+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311446",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311446,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1926,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Young People and Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.2",
      "ID": 3414
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4948,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike",
      "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8791639+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2117E90P107VM230478",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230478,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1926,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Young People and Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.2",
      "ID": 3414
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2117,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis",
      "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3316594+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267293",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 267293,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1926,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Young People and Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.2",
      "ID": 3414
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken",
      "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.013197+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313716",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313716,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1926,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Young People and Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.2",
      "ID": 3414
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4966,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek",
      "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4076054+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3101E102P129VM295057",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295057,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1926,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Young People and Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.2",
      "ID": 3414
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3101,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala",
      "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1903556+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319056",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319056,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1926,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Young People and Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.2",
      "ID": 3414
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5034,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny",
      "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6905434+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306499",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306499,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1926,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Young People and Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.2",
      "ID": 3414
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2159,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Martin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.554686+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5110E252P395VM311213",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311213,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1926,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Young People and Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.2",
      "ID": 3414
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Mason",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8668588+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268311",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 268311,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1926,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Young People and Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.2",
      "ID": 3414
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2133,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2616475+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2876E141P433VM286353",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286353,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1926,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Young People and Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.2",
      "ID": 3414
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2876,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5751665+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4951E147P368VM258648",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258648,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1926,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Young People and Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.2",
      "ID": 3414
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4951,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan",
      "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3165527+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3896E175P307VM264114",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264114,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1926,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Young People and Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.2",
      "ID": 3414
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3896,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam",
      "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9248489+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308426",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 308426,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1926,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Young People and Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.2",
      "ID": 3414
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0554199+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4964E143P375VM279289",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279289,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1926,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Young People and Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.2",
      "ID": 3414
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4964,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.4954138+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279958",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279958,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1926,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Young People and Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.2",
      "ID": 3414
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3824,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.530164+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2066E22P91VM261791",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261791,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1926,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Young People and Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.2",
      "ID": 3414
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2066,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3782933+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299646",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 299646,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1926,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Young People and Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.2",
      "ID": 3414
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7066866+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306612",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306612,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1926,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Young People and Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.2",
      "ID": 3414
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina",
      "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5595678+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2487E146P369VM301183",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 301183,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1926,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Young People and Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.2",
      "ID": 3414
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2487,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0376632+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223856",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223856,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1926,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Young People and Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.2",
      "ID": 3414
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4767254+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237424",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237424,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1926,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Young People and Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.2",
      "ID": 3414
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1961,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David",
      "DisplayName": "David McLetchie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2036139+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2134E34P201VM297815",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 297815,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1926,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Young People and Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.2",
      "ID": 3414
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2134,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.126208+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320370",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 320370,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1926,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Young People and Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.2",
      "ID": 3414
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5041,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan",
      "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1634815+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3763E142P397VM316094",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 316094,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1926,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Young People and Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.2",
      "ID": 3414
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3763,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart",
      "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9459028+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1986E23P197VM236652",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 236652,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1926,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Young People and Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.2",
      "ID": 3414
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1986,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan",
      "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9342285+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5047E100P130VM289852",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289852,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1926,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Young People and Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.2",
      "ID": 3414
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5047,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne",
      "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4618249+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234581",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234581,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1926,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Young People and Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.2",
      "ID": 3414
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1845,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette",
      "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3904654+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313664",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313664,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1926,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Young People and Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.2",
      "ID": 3414
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3061,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4051493+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1768E19P265VM288597",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 288597,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1926,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Young People and Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.2",
      "ID": 3414
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1768,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.150264+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225008",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225008,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1926,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Young People and Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.2",
      "ID": 3414
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1894,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Neil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7406025+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3815E98P134VM270845",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270845,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1926,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Young People and Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.2",
      "ID": 3414
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3815,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Park, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Park",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8255826+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265868",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265868,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1926,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Young People and Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.2",
      "ID": 3414
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2010,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil",
      "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4640297+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283551",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283551,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1926,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Young People and Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.2",
      "ID": 3414
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5057,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7131172+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2853E33P128VM251395",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251395,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1926,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Young People and Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.2",
      "ID": 3414
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Pentland",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4617232+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317591",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317591,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1926,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Young People and Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.2",
      "ID": 3414
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5009,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4290306+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254677",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254677,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1926,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Young People and Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.2",
      "ID": 3414
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3745,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis",
      "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2668978+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1870E225P478VM295655",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295655,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1926,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Young People and Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.2",
      "ID": 3414
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1870,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona",
      "DisplayName": "Shona Robison",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5301919+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2135E254P450VM234839",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234839,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1926,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Young People and Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.2",
      "ID": 3414
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2135,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Russell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4019574+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1895E232P431VM257587",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257587,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1926,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Young People and Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.2",
      "ID": 3414
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1895,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0629479+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228141",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 228141,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1926,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Young People and Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.2",
      "ID": 3414
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1839,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5861195+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2345E10P55VM291664",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291664,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1926,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Young People and Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.2",
      "ID": 3414
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2345,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.137013+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2223E176P333VM310645",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 310645,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1926,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Young People and Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.2",
      "ID": 3414
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2223,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish",
      "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5798425+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246362",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 246362,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1926,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Young People and Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.2",
      "ID": 3414
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2182,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1254625+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298145",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298145,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1926,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Young People and Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.2",
      "ID": 3414
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5079,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew",
      "DisplayName": "Drew Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1401522+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234330",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234330,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1926,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Young People and Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.2",
      "ID": 3414
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1769,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3726257+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4014E14P26VM269917",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269917,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1926,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Young People and Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.2",
      "ID": 3414
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4014,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz",
      "DisplayName": "Liz Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.573382+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269148",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269148,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1926,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Young People and Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.2",
      "ID": 3414
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2215,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.3057676+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317146",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317146,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1926,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Young People and Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.2",
      "ID": 3414
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3806,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.1836739+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326152",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 326152,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1926,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Young People and Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.2",
      "ID": 3414
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5106,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin",
      "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.542116+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241154",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241154,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1926,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Young People and Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.2",
      "ID": 3414
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1848,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola",
      "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.4043629+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2098E237P531VM289561",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289561,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1926,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Young People and Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.2",
      "ID": 3414
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2098,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Swinney",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4493667+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2674E247P401VM247713",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247713,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1926,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Young People and Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.2",
      "ID": 3414
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2674,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave",
      "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4252399+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5075E234P371VM284830",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 284830,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1926,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Young People and Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.2",
      "ID": 3414
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5075,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Torrance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0495819+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1793E151P362VM222408",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 222408,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1926,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Young People and Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.2",
      "ID": 3414
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1793,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean",
      "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1876653+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5078E245P7VM307087",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307087,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1926,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Young People and Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.2",
      "ID": 3414
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5078,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Walker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5867041+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1841E231P426VM239969",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239969,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1926,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Young People and Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.2",
      "ID": 3414
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1841,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen",
      "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7671082+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283371",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283371,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1926,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Young People and Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.2",
      "ID": 3414
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4952,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.6978221+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1865E263P500VM232272",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232272,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1926,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Young People and Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.2",
      "ID": 3414
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1865,
      "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra",
      "DisplayName": "Sandra White",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8475812+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237840",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237840,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1926,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Young People and Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.2",
      "ID": 3414
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2610,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Wilson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.228325+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309238",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 309238,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1926,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 40,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Young People and Economic Growth",
      "Reference": "S4M-03295.2",
      "ID": 3414
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4941,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza",
      "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3207133+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252674",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252674,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1928,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294.1",
      "ID": 3421
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1926,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian",
      "DisplayName": "Brian Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7487234+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2615E213P388VM257548",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257548,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1928,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294.1",
      "ID": 3421
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2615,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George",
      "DisplayName": "George Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0612717+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319942",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319942,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1928,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294.1",
      "ID": 3421
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4940,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare",
      "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9480452+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249609",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 249609,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1928,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294.1",
      "ID": 3421
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2641,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair",
      "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9342099+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1783E21P273VM227785",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227785,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1928,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294.1",
      "ID": 3421
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1783,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie",
      "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5655345+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2633E97P136VM280788",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280788,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1928,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294.1",
      "ID": 3421
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2633,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire",
      "DisplayName": "Claire Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7824255+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262687",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262687,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1928,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294.1",
      "ID": 3421
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2603,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6125561+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1759E91P115VM229772",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229772,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1928,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294.1",
      "ID": 3421
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia",
      "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0963756+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270246",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270246,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1928,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294.1",
      "ID": 3421
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3751,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.7956463+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322656",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 322656,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1928,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294.1",
      "ID": 3421
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5109,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco",
      "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6980867+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5060E86P124VM294762",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 294762,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1928,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294.1",
      "ID": 3421
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5060,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1772299+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242812",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242812,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1928,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294.1",
      "ID": 3421
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1866,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah",
      "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0365928+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235616",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235616,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1928,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294.1",
      "ID": 3421
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1943,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic",
      "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6854347+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302337",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 302337,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1928,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294.1",
      "ID": 3421
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2595,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin",
      "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5200477+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244316",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244316,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1928,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294.1",
      "ID": 3421
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2103,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith",
      "DisplayName": "Keith Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5494085+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327347",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 327347,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1928,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294.1",
      "ID": 3421
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:46.031966+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277026",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277026,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1928,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294.1",
      "ID": 3421
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6978853+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264303",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264303,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1928,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294.1",
      "ID": 3421
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2673,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick",
      "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1274631+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248841",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248841,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1928,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294.1",
      "ID": 3421
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2678,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson",
      "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6723482+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2123E27P233VM296333",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 296333,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1928,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294.1",
      "ID": 3421
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2123,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm",
      "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8444862+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285191",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285191,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1928,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294.1",
      "ID": 3421
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3907,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0703466+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230668",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230668,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1928,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294.1",
      "ID": 3421
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1735,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela",
      "DisplayName": "Angela Constance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3400776+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243907",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 243907,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1928,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294.1",
      "ID": 3421
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1932,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce",
      "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3250428+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254909",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254909,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1928,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294.1",
      "ID": 3421
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1863,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna",
      "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2889893+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323982",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 323982,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1928,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294.1",
      "ID": 3421
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4976,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth",
      "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.980877+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5107E223P379VM291863",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291863,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1928,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294.1",
      "ID": 3421
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5107,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1457162+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3743E222P391VM265363",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265363,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1928,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294.1",
      "ID": 3421
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3743,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel",
      "DisplayName": "Nigel Don",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.435957+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3771E149P417VM261718",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261718,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1928,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294.1",
      "ID": 3421
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3771,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob",
      "DisplayName": "Bob Doris",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3698301+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281952",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 281952,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1928,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294.1",
      "ID": 3421
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2826,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Dornan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1648415+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298174",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298174,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1928,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294.1",
      "ID": 3421
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3812,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia",
      "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1414444+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231574",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231574,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1928,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294.1",
      "ID": 3421
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1778,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen",
      "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6064754+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4955E240P389VM286164",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286164,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1928,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294.1",
      "ID": 3421
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4955,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3666557+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219322",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 219322,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1928,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294.1",
      "ID": 3421
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1742,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle",
      "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.2935417+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238643",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 238643,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1928,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294.1",
      "ID": 3421
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1994,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus",
      "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4629111+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225416",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225416,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1928,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294.1",
      "ID": 3421
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1814,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda",
      "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9737819+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321804",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 321804,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1928,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294.1",
      "ID": 3421
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Fee",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4520753+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292903",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 292903,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1928,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294.1",
      "ID": 3421
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia",
      "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.563177+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1892E12P64VM226890",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 226890,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1928,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294.1",
      "ID": 3421
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2511277+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5054E95P118VM312697",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 312697,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1928,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294.1",
      "ID": 3421
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5054,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1394518+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4947E152P361VM257210",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257210,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1928,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294.1",
      "ID": 3421
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4947,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Finnie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0462896+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271519",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271519,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1928,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294.1",
      "ID": 3421
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3901,
      "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe",
      "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0793319+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278089",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 278089,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1928,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294.1",
      "ID": 3421
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2394,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo",
      "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9865413+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2110E220P414VM287232",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 287232,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1928,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294.1",
      "ID": 3421
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth",
      "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8553312+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250488",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250488,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1928,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294.1",
      "ID": 3421
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2675,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob",
      "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.191697+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1741E10P50VM220955",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220955,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1928,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294.1",
      "ID": 3421
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1741,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel",
      "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6688441+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220323",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220323,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1928,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294.1",
      "ID": 3421
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1756,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine",
      "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6363813+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1860E104P150VM252357",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252357,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1928,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294.1",
      "ID": 3421
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1860,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda",
      "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7256911+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2033E20P141VM253858",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253858,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1928,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294.1",
      "ID": 3421
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2033,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain",
      "DisplayName": "Iain Gray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0238811+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324451",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324451,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1928,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294.1",
      "ID": 3421
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5042,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2232091+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259944",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 259944,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1928,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294.1",
      "ID": 3421
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick",
      "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6367755+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239254",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239254,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1928,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294.1",
      "ID": 3421
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2029,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh",
      "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7288311+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273774",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 273774,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1928,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294.1",
      "ID": 3421
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3758,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6350774+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304148",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 304148,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1928,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294.1",
      "ID": 3421
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4086,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Hume",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8517165+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221740",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221740,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1928,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294.1",
      "ID": 3421
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1773,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9457235+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1882E227P459VM241973",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241973,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1928,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294.1",
      "ID": 3421
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1882,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam",
      "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7883364+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223776",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223776,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1928,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294.1",
      "ID": 3421
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1893,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4732663+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307603",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307603,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1928,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294.1",
      "ID": 3421
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4934,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8367031+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272225",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 272225,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1928,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294.1",
      "ID": 3421
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4956,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Keir",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3204036+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244819",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244819,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1928,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294.1",
      "ID": 3421
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Kelly",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5799874+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3129E261P419VM314990",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 314990,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1928,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294.1",
      "ID": 3421
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3129,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6693383+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2080E36P220VM251106",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251106,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1928,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294.1",
      "ID": 3421
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann",
      "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.2273566+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4016E11P36VM274722",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274722,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1928,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294.1",
      "ID": 3421
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4016,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1189015+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255863",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255863,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1928,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294.1",
      "ID": 3421
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2180,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.560255+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4938E158P374VM277832",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277832,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1928,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294.1",
      "ID": 3421
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4938,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9703559+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2112E250P486VM252948",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252948,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1928,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294.1",
      "ID": 3421
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2112,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny",
      "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7601235+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4939E258P394VM277218",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277218,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1928,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294.1",
      "ID": 3421
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4939,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus",
      "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9387731+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325680",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 325680,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1928,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294.1",
      "ID": 3421
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5074,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon",
      "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5166794+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1828E3P10VM232862",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232862,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1928,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294.1",
      "ID": 3421
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1828,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo",
      "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8798208+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311448",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311448,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1928,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294.1",
      "ID": 3421
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4948,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike",
      "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8792652+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2117E90P107VM230476",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230476,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1928,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294.1",
      "ID": 3421
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2117,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis",
      "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3315751+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267386",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 267386,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1928,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294.1",
      "ID": 3421
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken",
      "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0175879+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313714",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313714,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1928,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294.1",
      "ID": 3421
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4966,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek",
      "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4075005+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3101E102P129VM295054",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295054,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1928,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294.1",
      "ID": 3421
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3101,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala",
      "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1902309+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319054",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319054,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1928,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294.1",
      "ID": 3421
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5034,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny",
      "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6904405+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306497",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306497,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1928,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294.1",
      "ID": 3421
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2159,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Martin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5546043+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5110E252P395VM311211",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311211,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1928,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294.1",
      "ID": 3421
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Mason",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8667227+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268217",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 268217,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1928,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294.1",
      "ID": 3421
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2133,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2539026+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2876E141P433VM286356",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286356,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1928,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294.1",
      "ID": 3421
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2876,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.575291+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4951E147P368VM258646",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258646,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1928,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294.1",
      "ID": 3421
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4951,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan",
      "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3164691+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3896E175P307VM264112",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264112,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1928,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294.1",
      "ID": 3421
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3896,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam",
      "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9247405+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308428",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 308428,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1928,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294.1",
      "ID": 3421
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0555012+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4964E143P375VM279291",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279291,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1928,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294.1",
      "ID": 3421
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4964,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.4954978+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279956",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279956,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1928,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294.1",
      "ID": 3421
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3824,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5300809+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2066E22P91VM261789",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261789,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1928,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294.1",
      "ID": 3421
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2066,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3782101+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299644",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 299644,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1928,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294.1",
      "ID": 3421
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7065994+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306614",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306614,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1928,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294.1",
      "ID": 3421
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina",
      "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5596505+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2487E146P369VM301181",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 301181,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1928,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294.1",
      "ID": 3421
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2487,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0375586+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223858",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223858,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1928,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294.1",
      "ID": 3421
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.476808+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237426",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237426,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1928,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294.1",
      "ID": 3421
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1961,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David",
      "DisplayName": "David McLetchie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.203696+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2134E34P201VM297817",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 297817,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1928,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294.1",
      "ID": 3421
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2134,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1262892+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320372",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 320372,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1928,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294.1",
      "ID": 3421
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5041,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan",
      "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1635864+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3763E142P397VM316092",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 316092,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1928,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294.1",
      "ID": 3421
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3763,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart",
      "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9458206+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1986E23P197VM236654",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 236654,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1928,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294.1",
      "ID": 3421
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1986,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan",
      "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9343307+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5047E100P130VM289850",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289850,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1928,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294.1",
      "ID": 3421
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5047,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne",
      "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4617443+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234579",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234579,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1928,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294.1",
      "ID": 3421
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1845,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette",
      "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3903813+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313662",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313662,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1928,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294.1",
      "ID": 3421
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3061,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4050483+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1768E19P265VM288599",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 288599,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1928,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294.1",
      "ID": 3421
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1768,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.150346+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225010",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225010,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1928,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294.1",
      "ID": 3421
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1894,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Neil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7406837+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3815E98P134VM270847",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270847,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1928,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294.1",
      "ID": 3421
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3815,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Park, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Park",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8256836+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265866",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265866,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1928,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294.1",
      "ID": 3421
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2010,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil",
      "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.463927+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283549",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283549,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1928,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294.1",
      "ID": 3421
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5057,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7128358+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2853E33P128VM251397",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251397,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1928,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294.1",
      "ID": 3421
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Pentland",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.461828+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317593",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317593,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1928,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294.1",
      "ID": 3421
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5009,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4291125+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254675",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254675,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1928,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294.1",
      "ID": 3421
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3745,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis",
      "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2668134+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1870E225P478VM295657",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295657,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1928,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294.1",
      "ID": 3421
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1870,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona",
      "DisplayName": "Shona Robison",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5302731+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2135E254P450VM234841",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234841,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1928,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294.1",
      "ID": 3421
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2135,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Russell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.402039+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1895E232P431VM257589",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257589,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1928,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294.1",
      "ID": 3421
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1895,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0630307+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228143",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 228143,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1928,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294.1",
      "ID": 3421
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1839,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5862024+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2345E10P55VM291662",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291662,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1928,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294.1",
      "ID": 3421
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2345,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1369114+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2223E176P333VM310647",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 310647,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1928,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294.1",
      "ID": 3421
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2223,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish",
      "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5799256+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246364",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 246364,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1928,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294.1",
      "ID": 3421
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2182,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1255457+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298143",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298143,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1928,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294.1",
      "ID": 3421
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5079,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew",
      "DisplayName": "Drew Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1400696+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234328",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234328,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1928,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294.1",
      "ID": 3421
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1769,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3725424+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4014E14P26VM269919",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269919,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1928,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294.1",
      "ID": 3421
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4014,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz",
      "DisplayName": "Liz Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.573499+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269553",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269553,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1928,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294.1",
      "ID": 3421
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2215,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5525859+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317148",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317148,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1928,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294.1",
      "ID": 3421
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3806,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.1837578+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326150",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 326150,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1928,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294.1",
      "ID": 3421
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5106,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin",
      "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5420326+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241156",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241156,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1928,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294.1",
      "ID": 3421
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1848,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola",
      "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.4044455+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2098E237P531VM289563",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289563,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1928,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294.1",
      "ID": 3421
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2098,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Swinney",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4494477+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2674E247P401VM247715",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247715,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1928,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294.1",
      "ID": 3421
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2674,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave",
      "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4253226+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5075E234P371VM284832",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 284832,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1928,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294.1",
      "ID": 3421
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5075,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Torrance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0496627+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1793E151P362VM222410",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 222410,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1928,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294.1",
      "ID": 3421
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1793,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean",
      "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1877478+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5078E245P7VM307085",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307085,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1928,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294.1",
      "ID": 3421
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5078,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Walker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5866222+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1841E231P426VM239967",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239967,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1928,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294.1",
      "ID": 3421
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1841,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen",
      "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7670265+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283373",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283373,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1928,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294.1",
      "ID": 3421
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4952,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.6979058+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1865E263P500VM232179",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232179,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1928,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294.1",
      "ID": 3421
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1865,
      "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra",
      "DisplayName": "Sandra White",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.638236+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237838",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237838,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1928,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294.1",
      "ID": 3421
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2610,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Wilson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2282421+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309236",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 309236,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1928,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294.1",
      "ID": 3421
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4941,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza",
      "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3206319+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252673",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252673,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1927,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294",
      "ID": 3398
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1926,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian",
      "DisplayName": "Brian Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7486834+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2615E213P388VM257547",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257547,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1927,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294",
      "ID": 3398
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2615,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George",
      "DisplayName": "George Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0612308+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319943",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319943,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1927,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294",
      "ID": 3398
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4940,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare",
      "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.948086+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249610",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 249610,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1927,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294",
      "ID": 3398
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2641,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair",
      "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9342518+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1783E21P273VM227784",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227784,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1927,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294",
      "ID": 3398
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1783,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie",
      "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5654934+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2633E97P136VM280787",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280787,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1927,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294",
      "ID": 3398
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2633,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire",
      "DisplayName": "Claire Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7823852+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262686",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262686,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1927,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294",
      "ID": 3398
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2603,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6125147+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1759E91P115VM229771",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229771,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1927,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294",
      "ID": 3398
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia",
      "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0963338+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270247",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270247,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1927,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294",
      "ID": 3398
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3751,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.7956883+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322655",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 322655,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1927,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294",
      "ID": 3398
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5109,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco",
      "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6980268+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5060E86P124VM294761",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 294761,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1927,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294",
      "ID": 3398
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5060,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1771891+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242811",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242811,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1927,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294",
      "ID": 3398
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1866,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah",
      "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.036551+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235617",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235617,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1927,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294",
      "ID": 3398
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1943,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic",
      "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6854749+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302336",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 302336,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1927,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294",
      "ID": 3398
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2595,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin",
      "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.520007+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244470",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244470,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1927,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294",
      "ID": 3398
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2103,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith",
      "DisplayName": "Keith Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5561563+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327346",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 327346,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1927,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294",
      "ID": 3398
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:46.0319227+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277025",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277025,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1927,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294",
      "ID": 3398
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6978444+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264304",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264304,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1927,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294",
      "ID": 3398
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2673,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick",
      "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1275039+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248842",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248842,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1927,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294",
      "ID": 3398
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2678,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson",
      "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6723891+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2123E27P233VM296334",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 296334,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1927,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294",
      "ID": 3398
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2123,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm",
      "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8445457+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285190",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285190,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1927,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294",
      "ID": 3398
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3907,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0703054+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230667",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230667,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1927,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294",
      "ID": 3398
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1735,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela",
      "DisplayName": "Angela Constance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3400371+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243908",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 243908,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1927,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294",
      "ID": 3398
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1932,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce",
      "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3250841+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254910",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254910,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1927,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294",
      "ID": 3398
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1863,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna",
      "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.289049+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323981",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 323981,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1927,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294",
      "ID": 3398
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4976,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth",
      "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9808349+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5107E223P379VM291864",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291864,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1927,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294",
      "ID": 3398
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5107,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1457568+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3743E222P391VM265362",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265362,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1927,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294",
      "ID": 3398
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3743,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel",
      "DisplayName": "Nigel Don",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4359153+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3771E149P417VM261717",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261717,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1927,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294",
      "ID": 3398
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3771,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob",
      "DisplayName": "Bob Doris",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3697031+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281953",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 281953,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1927,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294",
      "ID": 3398
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2826,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Dornan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1648831+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298173",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298173,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1927,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294",
      "ID": 3398
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3812,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia",
      "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1413384+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231575",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231575,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1927,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294",
      "ID": 3398
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1778,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen",
      "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6065164+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4955E240P389VM286165",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286165,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1927,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294",
      "ID": 3398
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4955,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3666966+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219321",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 219321,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1927,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294",
      "ID": 3398
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1742,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle",
      "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.2934989+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238644",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 238644,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1927,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294",
      "ID": 3398
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1994,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus",
      "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4629511+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225417",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225417,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1927,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294",
      "ID": 3398
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1814,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda",
      "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9738237+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321805",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 321805,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1927,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294",
      "ID": 3398
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Fee",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4521171+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292904",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 292904,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1927,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294",
      "ID": 3398
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia",
      "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5632173+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1892E12P64VM226889",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 226889,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1927,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294",
      "ID": 3398
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2510854+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5054E95P118VM312696",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 312696,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1927,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294",
      "ID": 3398
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5054,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1394105+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4947E152P361VM257209",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257209,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1927,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294",
      "ID": 3398
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4947,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Finnie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0462476+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271520",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271520,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1927,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294",
      "ID": 3398
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3901,
      "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe",
      "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.079373+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278090",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 278090,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1927,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294",
      "ID": 3398
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2394,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo",
      "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9865822+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2110E220P414VM287231",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 287231,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1927,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294",
      "ID": 3398
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth",
      "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8552699+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250487",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250487,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1927,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294",
      "ID": 3398
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2675,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob",
      "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1916553+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1741E10P50VM220954",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220954,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1927,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294",
      "ID": 3398
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1741,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel",
      "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6688027+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220324",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220324,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1927,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294",
      "ID": 3398
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1756,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine",
      "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6364229+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1860E104P150VM252356",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252356,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1927,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294",
      "ID": 3398
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1860,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda",
      "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7256499+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2033E20P141VM253859",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253859,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1927,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294",
      "ID": 3398
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2033,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain",
      "DisplayName": "Iain Gray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0239216+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324452",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324452,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1927,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294",
      "ID": 3398
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5042,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.22325+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259945",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 259945,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1927,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294",
      "ID": 3398
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick",
      "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6368183+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239253",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239253,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1927,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294",
      "ID": 3398
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2029,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh",
      "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7287898+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273775",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 273775,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1927,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294",
      "ID": 3398
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3758,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6351175+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304149",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 304149,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1927,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294",
      "ID": 3398
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4086,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Hume",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8517592+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221741",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221741,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1927,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294",
      "ID": 3398
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1773,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.94579+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1882E227P459VM241974",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241974,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1927,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294",
      "ID": 3398
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1882,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam",
      "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7883974+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223777",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223777,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1927,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294",
      "ID": 3398
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1893,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4733076+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307602",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307602,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1927,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294",
      "ID": 3398
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4934,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8366619+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272224",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 272224,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1927,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294",
      "ID": 3398
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4956,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Keir",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3203615+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244818",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244818,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1927,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294",
      "ID": 3398
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Kelly",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5799473+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3129E261P419VM314989",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 314989,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1927,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294",
      "ID": 3398
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3129,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.669297+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2080E36P220VM251107",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251107,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1927,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294",
      "ID": 3398
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann",
      "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.2274011+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4016E11P36VM274721",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274721,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1927,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294",
      "ID": 3398
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4016,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1188408+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255864",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255864,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1927,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294",
      "ID": 3398
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2180,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5603134+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4938E158P374VM277833",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277833,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1927,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294",
      "ID": 3398
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4938,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9703973+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2112E250P486VM252947",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252947,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1927,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294",
      "ID": 3398
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2112,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny",
      "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7600826+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4939E258P394VM277219",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277219,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1927,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294",
      "ID": 3398
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4939,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus",
      "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9388147+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325679",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 325679,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1927,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294",
      "ID": 3398
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5074,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon",
      "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5166391+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1828E3P10VM232861",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232861,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1927,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294",
      "ID": 3398
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1828,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo",
      "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8797775+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311447",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311447,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1927,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294",
      "ID": 3398
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4948,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike",
      "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8792054+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2117E90P107VM230477",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230477,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1927,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294",
      "ID": 3398
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2117,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis",
      "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3316173+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267385",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 267385,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1927,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294",
      "ID": 3398
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken",
      "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0175471+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313715",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313715,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1927,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294",
      "ID": 3398
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4966,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek",
      "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4075416+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3101E102P129VM295055",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295055,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1927,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294",
      "ID": 3398
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3101,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala",
      "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1902726+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319055",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319055,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1927,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294",
      "ID": 3398
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5034,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny",
      "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6905008+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306498",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306498,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1927,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294",
      "ID": 3398
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2159,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Martin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5546454+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5110E252P395VM311212",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311212,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1927,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294",
      "ID": 3398
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Mason",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8668144+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268218",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 268218,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1927,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294",
      "ID": 3398
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2133,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2539437+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2876E141P433VM286355",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286355,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1927,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294",
      "ID": 3398
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2876,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5752501+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4951E147P368VM258647",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258647,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1927,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294",
      "ID": 3398
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4951,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan",
      "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3165105+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3896E175P307VM264113",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264113,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1927,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294",
      "ID": 3398
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3896,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam",
      "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.924806+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308427",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 308427,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1927,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294",
      "ID": 3398
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0554611+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4964E143P375VM279290",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279290,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1927,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294",
      "ID": 3398
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4964,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.4954561+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279957",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279957,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1927,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294",
      "ID": 3398
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3824,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5301224+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2066E22P91VM261790",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261790,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1927,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294",
      "ID": 3398
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2066,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3782518+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299645",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 299645,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1927,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294",
      "ID": 3398
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7066395+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306613",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306613,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1927,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294",
      "ID": 3398
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina",
      "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5596091+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2487E146P369VM301182",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 301182,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1927,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294",
      "ID": 3398
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2487,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0376137+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223857",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223857,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1927,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294",
      "ID": 3398
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4767674+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237425",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237425,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1927,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294",
      "ID": 3398
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1961,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David",
      "DisplayName": "David McLetchie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.203655+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2134E34P201VM297816",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 297816,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1927,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294",
      "ID": 3398
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2134,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1262489+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320371",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 320371,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1927,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294",
      "ID": 3398
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5041,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan",
      "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1635438+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3763E142P397VM316093",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 316093,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1927,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294",
      "ID": 3398
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3763,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart",
      "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.945862+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1986E23P197VM236653",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 236653,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1927,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294",
      "ID": 3398
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1986,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan",
      "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9342886+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5047E100P130VM289851",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289851,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1927,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294",
      "ID": 3398
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5047,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne",
      "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4617849+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234580",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234580,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1927,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294",
      "ID": 3398
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1845,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette",
      "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.390423+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313663",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313663,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1927,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294",
      "ID": 3398
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3061,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4051074+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1768E19P265VM288598",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 288598,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1927,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294",
      "ID": 3398
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1768,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1503053+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225009",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225009,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1927,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294",
      "ID": 3398
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1894,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Neil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7406431+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3815E98P134VM270846",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270846,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1927,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294",
      "ID": 3398
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3815,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Park, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Park",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8256414+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265867",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265867,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1927,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294",
      "ID": 3398
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2010,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil",
      "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4639874+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283550",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283550,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1927,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294",
      "ID": 3398
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5057,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7129879+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2853E33P128VM251396",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251396,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1927,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294",
      "ID": 3398
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Pentland",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4617836+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317592",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317592,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1927,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294",
      "ID": 3398
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5009,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4290715+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254676",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254676,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1927,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294",
      "ID": 3398
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3745,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis",
      "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2668562+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1870E225P478VM295656",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295656,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1927,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294",
      "ID": 3398
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1870,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona",
      "DisplayName": "Shona Robison",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5302323+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2135E254P450VM234840",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234840,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1927,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294",
      "ID": 3398
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2135,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Russell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4019984+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1895E232P431VM257588",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257588,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1927,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294",
      "ID": 3398
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1895,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0629892+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228142",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 228142,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1927,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294",
      "ID": 3398
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1839,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5861607+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2345E10P55VM291663",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291663,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1927,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294",
      "ID": 3398
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2345,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1369713+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2223E176P333VM310646",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 310646,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1927,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294",
      "ID": 3398
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2223,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish",
      "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5798839+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246363",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 246363,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1927,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294",
      "ID": 3398
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2182,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1255043+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298144",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298144,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1927,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294",
      "ID": 3398
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5079,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew",
      "DisplayName": "Drew Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1401108+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234329",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234329,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1927,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294",
      "ID": 3398
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1769,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3725838+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4014E14P26VM269918",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269918,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1927,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294",
      "ID": 3398
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4014,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz",
      "DisplayName": "Liz Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.573455+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269552",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269552,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1927,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294",
      "ID": 3398
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2215,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.552545+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317147",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317147,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1927,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294",
      "ID": 3398
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3806,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.1837161+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326151",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 326151,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1927,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294",
      "ID": 3398
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5106,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin",
      "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5420748+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241155",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241155,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1927,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294",
      "ID": 3398
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1848,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola",
      "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.4044038+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2098E237P531VM289562",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289562,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1927,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294",
      "ID": 3398
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2098,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Swinney",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4494077+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2674E247P401VM247714",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247714,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1927,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294",
      "ID": 3398
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2674,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave",
      "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4252812+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5075E234P371VM284831",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 284831,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1927,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294",
      "ID": 3398
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5075,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Torrance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0496226+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1793E151P362VM222409",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 222409,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1927,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294",
      "ID": 3398
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1793,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean",
      "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1877064+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5078E245P7VM307086",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307086,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1927,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294",
      "ID": 3398
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5078,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Walker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5866631+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1841E231P426VM239968",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239968,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1927,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294",
      "ID": 3398
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1841,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen",
      "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7670676+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283372",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283372,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1927,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294",
      "ID": 3398
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4952,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.6978636+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1865E263P500VM232180",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232180,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1927,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294",
      "ID": 3398
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1865,
      "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra",
      "DisplayName": "Sandra White",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6382778+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237839",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237839,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1927,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294",
      "ID": 3398
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2610,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Wilson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2282842+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309237",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 309237,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1927,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 80,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women’s Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-03294",
      "ID": 3398
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4941,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza",
      "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3206728+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252676",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252676,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1924,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 73,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289.1",
      "ID": 3422
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1926,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian",
      "DisplayName": "Brian Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7488058+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2615E213P388VM258880",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258880,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1924,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 73,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289.1",
      "ID": 3422
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2615,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George",
      "DisplayName": "George Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3322083+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319668",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319668,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1924,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 73,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289.1",
      "ID": 3422
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4940,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare",
      "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9361994+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249607",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 249607,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1924,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 73,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289.1",
      "ID": 3422
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2641,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair",
      "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9341276+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1783E21P273VM227787",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227787,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1924,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 73,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289.1",
      "ID": 3422
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1783,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie",
      "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5656187+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2633E97P136VM280790",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280790,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1924,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 73,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289.1",
      "ID": 3422
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2633,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire",
      "DisplayName": "Claire Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7825061+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262689",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262689,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1924,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 73,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289.1",
      "ID": 3422
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2603,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6126395+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1759E91P115VM229774",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229774,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1924,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 73,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289.1",
      "ID": 3422
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia",
      "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0964582+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270147",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270147,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1924,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 73,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289.1",
      "ID": 3422
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3751,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5835749+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322658",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 322658,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1924,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 73,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289.1",
      "ID": 3422
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5109,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco",
      "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6981708+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5060E86P124VM294764",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 294764,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1924,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 73,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289.1",
      "ID": 3422
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5060,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1773137+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242931",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242931,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1924,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 73,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289.1",
      "ID": 3422
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1866,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah",
      "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0416774+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235211",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235211,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1924,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 73,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289.1",
      "ID": 3422
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1943,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic",
      "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6602596+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302339",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 302339,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1924,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 73,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289.1",
      "ID": 3422
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2595,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin",
      "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5201321+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244314",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244314,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1924,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 73,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289.1",
      "ID": 3422
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2103,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith",
      "DisplayName": "Keith Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5493239+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327127",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 327127,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1924,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 73,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289.1",
      "ID": 3422
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.8002815+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277028",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277028,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1924,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 73,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289.1",
      "ID": 3422
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6979854+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264301",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264301,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1924,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 73,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289.1",
      "ID": 3422
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2673,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick",
      "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1273799+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248745",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248745,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1924,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 73,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289.1",
      "ID": 3422
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2678,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson",
      "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6679695+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2123E27P233VM295750",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295750,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1924,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 73,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289.1",
      "ID": 3422
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2123,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm",
      "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5343104+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285193",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285193,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1924,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 73,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289.1",
      "ID": 3422
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3907,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0704284+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230670",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230670,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1924,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 73,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289.1",
      "ID": 3422
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1735,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela",
      "DisplayName": "Angela Constance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3401597+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243788",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 243788,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1924,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 73,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289.1",
      "ID": 3422
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1932,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce",
      "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3197911+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254907",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254907,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1924,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 73,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289.1",
      "ID": 3422
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1863,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna",
      "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2889059+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323734",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 323734,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1924,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 73,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289.1",
      "ID": 3422
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4976,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth",
      "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9696032+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5107E223P379VM291307",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291307,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1924,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 73,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289.1",
      "ID": 3422
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5107,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1133112+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3743E222P391VM265365",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265365,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1924,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 73,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289.1",
      "ID": 3422
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3743,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel",
      "DisplayName": "Nigel Don",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4360419+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262279",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262279,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1924,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 73,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289.1",
      "ID": 3422
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3771,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob",
      "DisplayName": "Bob Doris",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.5946539+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281950",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 281950,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1924,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 73,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289.1",
      "ID": 3422
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2826,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Dornan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1647583+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298176",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298176,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1924,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 73,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289.1",
      "ID": 3422
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3812,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia",
      "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1415411+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231572",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231572,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1924,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 73,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289.1",
      "ID": 3422
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1778,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen",
      "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6063927+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4955E240P389VM285911",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285911,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1924,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 73,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289.1",
      "ID": 3422
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4955,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3498566+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219332",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 219332,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1924,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 73,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289.1",
      "ID": 3422
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1742,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle",
      "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.2940065+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238546",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 238546,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1924,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 73,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289.1",
      "ID": 3422
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1994,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus",
      "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4587516+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225414",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225414,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1924,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 73,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289.1",
      "ID": 3422
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1814,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda",
      "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9736987+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321802",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 321802,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1924,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 73,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289.1",
      "ID": 3422
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Fee",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4519934+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292901",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 292901,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1924,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 73,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289.1",
      "ID": 3422
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia",
      "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5630963+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227142",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227142,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1924,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 73,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289.1",
      "ID": 3422
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2696249+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5054E95P118VM312699",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 312699,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1924,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 73,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289.1",
      "ID": 3422
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5054,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1395518+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4947E152P361VM257212",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257212,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1924,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 73,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289.1",
      "ID": 3422
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4947,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Finnie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0463743+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271266",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271266,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1924,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 73,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289.1",
      "ID": 3422
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3901,
      "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe",
      "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0628654+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278087",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 278087,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1924,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 73,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289.1",
      "ID": 3422
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2394,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo",
      "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9864385+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2110E220P414VM287234",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 287234,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1924,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 73,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289.1",
      "ID": 3422
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth",
      "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.855417+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250490",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250490,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1924,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 73,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289.1",
      "ID": 3422
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2675,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob",
      "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1917807+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1741E10P50VM220957",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220957,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1924,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 73,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289.1",
      "ID": 3422
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1741,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel",
      "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6689274+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220313",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220313,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1924,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 73,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289.1",
      "ID": 3422
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1756,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine",
      "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6359489+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1860E104P150VM252359",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252359,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1924,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 73,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289.1",
      "ID": 3422
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1860,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda",
      "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7257944+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2033E20P141VM253856",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253856,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1924,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 73,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289.1",
      "ID": 3422
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2033,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain",
      "DisplayName": "Iain Gray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0238006+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324671",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324671,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1924,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 73,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289.1",
      "ID": 3422
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5042,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2329435+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259692",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 259692,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1924,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 73,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289.1",
      "ID": 3422
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick",
      "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6204125+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239350",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239350,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1924,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 73,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289.1",
      "ID": 3422
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2029,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh",
      "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7330385+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273772",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 273772,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1924,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 73,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289.1",
      "ID": 3422
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3758,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6349962+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304146",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 304146,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1924,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 73,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289.1",
      "ID": 3422
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4086,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Hume",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8516155+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221738",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221738,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1924,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 73,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289.1",
      "ID": 3422
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1773,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9456421+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1882E227P459VM241971",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241971,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1924,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 73,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289.1",
      "ID": 3422
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1882,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam",
      "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.788253+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223773",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223773,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1924,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 73,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289.1",
      "ID": 3422
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1893,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4731445+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307605",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307605,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1924,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 73,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289.1",
      "ID": 3422
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4934,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8368201+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272227",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 272227,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1924,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 73,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289.1",
      "ID": 3422
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4956,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Keir",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.32051+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244941",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244941,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1924,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 73,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289.1",
      "ID": 3422
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Kelly",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5851577+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315111",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315111,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1924,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 73,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289.1",
      "ID": 3422
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3129,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6747791+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247918",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247918,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1924,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 73,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289.1",
      "ID": 3422
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann",
      "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4339758+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4016E11P36VM274819",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274819,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1924,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 73,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289.1",
      "ID": 3422
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4016,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1231123+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255768",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255768,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1924,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 73,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289.1",
      "ID": 3422
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2180,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5560485+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4938E158P374VM277426",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277426,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1924,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 73,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289.1",
      "ID": 3422
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4938,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9528615+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2112E250P486VM253044",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253044,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1924,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 73,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289.1",
      "ID": 3422
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2112,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny",
      "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7644406+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4939E258P394VM276812",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276812,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1924,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 73,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289.1",
      "ID": 3422
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4939,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus",
      "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6821454+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325460",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 325460,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1924,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 73,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289.1",
      "ID": 3422
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5074,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon",
      "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5073528+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1828E3P10VM232864",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232864,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1924,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 73,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289.1",
      "ID": 3422
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1828,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo",
      "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.879904+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311450",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311450,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1924,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 73,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289.1",
      "ID": 3422
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4948,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike",
      "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8793506+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2117E90P107VM230380",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230380,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1924,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 73,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289.1",
      "ID": 3422
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2117,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis",
      "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3272904+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267388",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 267388,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1924,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 73,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289.1",
      "ID": 3422
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken",
      "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0176704+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313712",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313712,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1924,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 73,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289.1",
      "ID": 3422
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4966,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek",
      "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4074182+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3101E102P129VM295052",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295052,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1924,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 73,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289.1",
      "ID": 3422
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3101,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala",
      "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1901469+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319052",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319052,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1924,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 73,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289.1",
      "ID": 3422
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5034,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny",
      "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6903583+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306375",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306375,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1924,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 73,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289.1",
      "ID": 3422
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2159,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Martin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5493911+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5110E252P395VM311209",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311209,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1924,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 73,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289.1",
      "ID": 3422
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Mason",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8666367+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268215",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 268215,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1924,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 73,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289.1",
      "ID": 3422
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2133,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2538189+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2876E141P433VM286358",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286358,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1924,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 73,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289.1",
      "ID": 3422
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2876,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5753735+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4951E147P368VM258644",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258644,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1924,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 73,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289.1",
      "ID": 3422
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4951,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan",
      "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3163861+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3896E175P307VM263860",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 263860,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1924,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 73,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289.1",
      "ID": 3422
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3896,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam",
      "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9138848+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308430",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 308430,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1924,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 73,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289.1",
      "ID": 3422
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0556012+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4964E143P375VM279690",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279690,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1924,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 73,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289.1",
      "ID": 3422
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4964,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5184767+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279644",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279644,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1924,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 73,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289.1",
      "ID": 3422
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3824,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5164932+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2066E22P91VM261047",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261047,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1924,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 73,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289.1",
      "ID": 3422
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2066,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.1095197+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299642",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 299642,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1924,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 73,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289.1",
      "ID": 3422
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7065159+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306616",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306616,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1924,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 73,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289.1",
      "ID": 3422
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina",
      "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5597337+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2487E146P369VM301179",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 301179,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1924,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 73,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289.1",
      "ID": 3422
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2487,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0374592+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223860",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223860,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1924,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 73,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289.1",
      "ID": 3422
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.476891+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237521",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237521,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1924,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 73,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289.1",
      "ID": 3422
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1961,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David",
      "DisplayName": "David McLetchie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2144163+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305493",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 305493,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1924,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 73,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289.1",
      "ID": 3422
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2134,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.326692+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320374",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 320374,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1924,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 73,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289.1",
      "ID": 3422
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5041,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan",
      "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.16367+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315971",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315971,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1924,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 73,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289.1",
      "ID": 3422
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3763,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart",
      "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9401767+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1986E23P197VM236656",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 236656,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1924,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 73,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289.1",
      "ID": 3422
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1986,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan",
      "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9344127+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5047E100P130VM289848",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289848,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1924,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 73,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289.1",
      "ID": 3422
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5047,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne",
      "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4616615+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234577",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234577,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1924,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 73,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289.1",
      "ID": 3422
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1845,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette",
      "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.390297+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313541",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313541,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1924,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 73,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289.1",
      "ID": 3422
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3061,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.3998276+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1768E19P265VM288601",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 288601,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1924,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 73,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289.1",
      "ID": 3422
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1768,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1504291+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225262",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225262,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1924,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 73,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289.1",
      "ID": 3422
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1894,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Neil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9617936+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3815E98P134VM270923",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270923,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1924,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 73,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289.1",
      "ID": 3422
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3815,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Park, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Park",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8349173+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265864",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265864,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1924,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 73,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289.1",
      "ID": 3422
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2010,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil",
      "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4638433+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283298",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283298,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1924,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 73,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289.1",
      "ID": 3422
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5057,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.6944522+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2853E33P128VM251494",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251494,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1924,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 73,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289.1",
      "ID": 3422
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Pentland",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4661056+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317595",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317595,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1924,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 73,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289.1",
      "ID": 3422
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5009,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4291947+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254673",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254673,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1924,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 73,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289.1",
      "ID": 3422
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3745,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis",
      "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2667078+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1870E225P478VM295659",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295659,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1924,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 73,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289.1",
      "ID": 3422
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1870,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona",
      "DisplayName": "Shona Robison",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5303541+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2135E254P450VM235397",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235397,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1924,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 73,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289.1",
      "ID": 3422
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2135,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Russell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6688172+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1895E232P431VM257591",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257591,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1924,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 73,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289.1",
      "ID": 3422
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1895,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0631123+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228145",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 228145,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1924,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 73,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289.1",
      "ID": 3422
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1839,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5862853+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2345E10P55VM291660",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291660,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1924,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 73,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289.1",
      "ID": 3422
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2345,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1368292+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311080",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311080,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1924,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 73,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289.1",
      "ID": 3422
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2223,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish",
      "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.6045489+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246366",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 246366,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1924,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 73,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289.1",
      "ID": 3422
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2182,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.125628+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298141",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298141,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1924,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 73,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289.1",
      "ID": 3422
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5079,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew",
      "DisplayName": "Drew Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1399849+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234326",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234326,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1924,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 73,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289.1",
      "ID": 3422
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1769,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3724394+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274605",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274605,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1924,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 73,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289.1",
      "ID": 3422
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4014,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz",
      "DisplayName": "Liz Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1138425+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269555",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269555,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1924,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 73,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289.1",
      "ID": 3422
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2215,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5526863+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317422",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317422,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1924,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 73,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289.1",
      "ID": 3422
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3806,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4214194+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326370",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 326370,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1924,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 73,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289.1",
      "ID": 3422
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5106,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin",
      "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7555666+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241158",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241158,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1924,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 73,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289.1",
      "ID": 3422
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1848,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola",
      "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.4045298+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2098E237P531VM289686",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289686,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1924,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 73,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289.1",
      "ID": 3422
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2098,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Swinney",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4548396+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2674E247P401VM247811",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247811,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1924,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 73,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289.1",
      "ID": 3422
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2674,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave",
      "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4294528+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5075E234P371VM287412",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 287412,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1924,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 73,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289.1",
      "ID": 3422
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5075,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Torrance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8631032+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1793E151P362VM222413",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 222413,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1924,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 73,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289.1",
      "ID": 3422
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1793,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean",
      "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1878907+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5078E245P7VM307083",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307083,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1924,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 73,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289.1",
      "ID": 3422
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5078,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Walker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5865399+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1841E231P426VM239965",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239965,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1924,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 73,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289.1",
      "ID": 3422
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1841,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen",
      "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.766944+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283470",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283470,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1924,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 73,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289.1",
      "ID": 3422
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4952,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7092854+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1865E263P500VM231873",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231873,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1924,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 73,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289.1",
      "ID": 3422
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1865,
      "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra",
      "DisplayName": "Sandra White",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6192686+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237742",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237742,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1924,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 73,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289.1",
      "ID": 3422
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2610,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Wilson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2238529+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309234",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 309234,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1924,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 73,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289.1",
      "ID": 3422
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4941,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza",
      "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3205479+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252675",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252675,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1923,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 81,
      "VoteAgainst": 34,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289",
      "ID": 3391
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1926,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian",
      "DisplayName": "Brian Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7487649+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2615E213P388VM257549",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257549,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1923,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 81,
      "VoteAgainst": 34,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289",
      "ID": 3391
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2615,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George",
      "DisplayName": "George Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0613125+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319669",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319669,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1923,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 81,
      "VoteAgainst": 34,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289",
      "ID": 3391
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4940,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare",
      "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9362416+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249608",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 249608,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1923,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 81,
      "VoteAgainst": 34,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289",
      "ID": 3391
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2641,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair",
      "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.934169+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1783E21P273VM227786",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227786,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1923,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 81,
      "VoteAgainst": 34,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289",
      "ID": 3391
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1783,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie",
      "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5655762+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2633E97P136VM280789",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280789,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1923,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 81,
      "VoteAgainst": 34,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289",
      "ID": 3391
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2633,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire",
      "DisplayName": "Claire Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.782466+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262688",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262688,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1923,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 81,
      "VoteAgainst": 34,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289",
      "ID": 3391
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2603,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6125976+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1759E91P115VM229773",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229773,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1923,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 81,
      "VoteAgainst": 34,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289",
      "ID": 3391
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia",
      "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0964168+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270243",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270243,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1923,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 81,
      "VoteAgainst": 34,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289",
      "ID": 3391
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3751,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.7955181+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322657",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 322657,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1923,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 81,
      "VoteAgainst": 34,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289",
      "ID": 3391
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5109,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco",
      "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6981296+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5060E86P124VM294763",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 294763,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1923,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 81,
      "VoteAgainst": 34,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289",
      "ID": 3391
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5060,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1772717+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242813",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242813,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1923,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 81,
      "VoteAgainst": 34,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289",
      "ID": 3391
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1866,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah",
      "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0366327+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235615",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235615,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1923,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 81,
      "VoteAgainst": 34,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289",
      "ID": 3391
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1943,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic",
      "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.685394+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302338",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 302338,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1923,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 81,
      "VoteAgainst": 34,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289",
      "ID": 3391
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2595,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin",
      "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5200905+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244315",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244315,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1923,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 81,
      "VoteAgainst": 34,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289",
      "ID": 3391
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2103,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith",
      "DisplayName": "Keith Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5493659+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327126",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 327126,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1923,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 81,
      "VoteAgainst": 34,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289",
      "ID": 3391
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.8002392+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277027",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277027,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1923,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 81,
      "VoteAgainst": 34,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289",
      "ID": 3391
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.697926+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264302",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264302,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1923,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 81,
      "VoteAgainst": 34,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289",
      "ID": 3391
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2673,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick",
      "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1274218+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248840",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248840,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1923,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 81,
      "VoteAgainst": 34,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289",
      "ID": 3391
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2678,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson",
      "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6723067+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2123E27P233VM295751",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295751,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1923,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 81,
      "VoteAgainst": 34,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289",
      "ID": 3391
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2123,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm",
      "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5343509+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285192",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285192,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1923,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 81,
      "VoteAgainst": 34,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289",
      "ID": 3391
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3907,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.070388+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230669",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230669,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1923,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 81,
      "VoteAgainst": 34,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289",
      "ID": 3391
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1735,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela",
      "DisplayName": "Angela Constance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3401189+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243906",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 243906,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1923,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 81,
      "VoteAgainst": 34,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289",
      "ID": 3391
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1932,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce",
      "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3250016+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254908",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254908,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1923,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 81,
      "VoteAgainst": 34,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289",
      "ID": 3391
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1863,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna",
      "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2889479+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323733",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 323733,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1923,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 81,
      "VoteAgainst": 34,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289",
      "ID": 3391
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4976,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth",
      "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9695617+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5107E223P379VM291862",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291862,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1923,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 81,
      "VoteAgainst": 34,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289",
      "ID": 3391
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5107,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1456756+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3743E222P391VM265364",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265364,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1923,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 81,
      "VoteAgainst": 34,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289",
      "ID": 3391
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3743,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel",
      "DisplayName": "Nigel Don",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4359999+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3771E149P417VM261719",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261719,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1923,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 81,
      "VoteAgainst": 34,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289",
      "ID": 3391
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3771,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob",
      "DisplayName": "Bob Doris",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3698821+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281951",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 281951,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1923,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 81,
      "VoteAgainst": 34,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289",
      "ID": 3391
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2826,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Dornan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1648003+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298175",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298175,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1923,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 81,
      "VoteAgainst": 34,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289",
      "ID": 3391
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3812,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia",
      "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.141498+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231573",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231573,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1923,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 81,
      "VoteAgainst": 34,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289",
      "ID": 3391
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1778,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen",
      "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6064341+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4955E240P389VM286161",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286161,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1923,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 81,
      "VoteAgainst": 34,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289",
      "ID": 3391
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4955,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3665317+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219323",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 219323,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1923,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 81,
      "VoteAgainst": 34,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289",
      "ID": 3391
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1742,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle",
      "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.2936269+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238642",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 238642,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1923,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 81,
      "VoteAgainst": 34,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289",
      "ID": 3391
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1994,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus",
      "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4628706+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225415",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225415,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1923,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 81,
      "VoteAgainst": 34,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289",
      "ID": 3391
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1814,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda",
      "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.97374+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321803",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 321803,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1923,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 81,
      "VoteAgainst": 34,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289",
      "ID": 3391
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Fee",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4520343+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292902",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 292902,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1923,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 81,
      "VoteAgainst": 34,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289",
      "ID": 3391
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia",
      "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5631365+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1892E12P64VM226891",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 226891,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1923,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 81,
      "VoteAgainst": 34,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289",
      "ID": 3391
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2511694+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5054E95P118VM312698",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 312698,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1923,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 81,
      "VoteAgainst": 34,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289",
      "ID": 3391
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5054,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1394931+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4947E152P361VM257211",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257211,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1923,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 81,
      "VoteAgainst": 34,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289",
      "ID": 3391
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4947,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Finnie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0463319+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271516",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271516,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1923,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 81,
      "VoteAgainst": 34,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289",
      "ID": 3391
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3901,
      "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe",
      "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.079205+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278088",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 278088,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1923,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 81,
      "VoteAgainst": 34,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289",
      "ID": 3391
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2394,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo",
      "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9864986+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2110E220P414VM287233",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 287233,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1923,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 81,
      "VoteAgainst": 34,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289",
      "ID": 3391
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth",
      "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8553743+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250489",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250489,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1923,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 81,
      "VoteAgainst": 34,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289",
      "ID": 3391
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2675,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob",
      "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1917388+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1741E10P50VM220956",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220956,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1923,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 81,
      "VoteAgainst": 34,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289",
      "ID": 3391
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1741,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel",
      "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6688854+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220322",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220322,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1923,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 81,
      "VoteAgainst": 34,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289",
      "ID": 3391
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1756,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine",
      "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6363399+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1860E104P150VM252358",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252358,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1923,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 81,
      "VoteAgainst": 34,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289",
      "ID": 3391
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1860,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda",
      "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7257524+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2033E20P141VM253857",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253857,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1923,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 81,
      "VoteAgainst": 34,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289",
      "ID": 3391
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2033,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain",
      "DisplayName": "Iain Gray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0238409+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324672",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324672,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1923,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 81,
      "VoteAgainst": 34,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289",
      "ID": 3391
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5042,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2330025+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259943",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 259943,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1923,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 81,
      "VoteAgainst": 34,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289",
      "ID": 3391
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick",
      "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6367157+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239255",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239255,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1923,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 81,
      "VoteAgainst": 34,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289",
      "ID": 3391
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2029,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh",
      "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7288735+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273773",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 273773,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1923,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 81,
      "VoteAgainst": 34,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289",
      "ID": 3391
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3758,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6350366+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304147",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 304147,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1923,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 81,
      "VoteAgainst": 34,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289",
      "ID": 3391
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4086,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Hume",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8516562+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221739",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221739,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1923,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 81,
      "VoteAgainst": 34,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289",
      "ID": 3391
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1773,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9456828+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1882E227P459VM241972",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241972,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1923,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 81,
      "VoteAgainst": 34,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289",
      "ID": 3391
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1882,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam",
      "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7882945+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223775",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223775,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1923,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 81,
      "VoteAgainst": 34,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289",
      "ID": 3391
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1893,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4732252+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307604",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307604,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1923,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 81,
      "VoteAgainst": 34,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289",
      "ID": 3391
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4934,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8367731+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272226",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 272226,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1923,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 81,
      "VoteAgainst": 34,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289",
      "ID": 3391
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4956,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Keir",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3204658+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244940",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244940,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1923,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 81,
      "VoteAgainst": 34,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289",
      "ID": 3391
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Kelly",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.585117+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315110",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315110,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1923,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 81,
      "VoteAgainst": 34,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289",
      "ID": 3391
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3129,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6747379+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2080E36P220VM251105",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251105,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1923,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 81,
      "VoteAgainst": 34,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289",
      "ID": 3391
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann",
      "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.227304+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4016E11P36VM274725",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274725,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1923,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 81,
      "VoteAgainst": 34,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289",
      "ID": 3391
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4016,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1190288+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255862",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255862,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1923,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 81,
      "VoteAgainst": 34,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289",
      "ID": 3391
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2180,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5602146+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4938E158P374VM277829",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277829,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1923,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 81,
      "VoteAgainst": 34,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289",
      "ID": 3391
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4938,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9702292+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2112E250P486VM252949",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252949,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1923,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 81,
      "VoteAgainst": 34,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289",
      "ID": 3391
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2112,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny",
      "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7601641+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4939E258P394VM277217",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277217,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1923,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 81,
      "VoteAgainst": 34,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289",
      "ID": 3391
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4939,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus",
      "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9387302+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325459",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 325459,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1923,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 81,
      "VoteAgainst": 34,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289",
      "ID": 3391
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5074,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon",
      "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5072921+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1828E3P10VM232863",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232863,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1923,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 81,
      "VoteAgainst": 34,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289",
      "ID": 3391
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1828,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo",
      "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8798631+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311449",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311449,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1923,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 81,
      "VoteAgainst": 34,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289",
      "ID": 3391
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4948,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike",
      "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.879309+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2117E90P107VM230475",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230475,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1923,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 81,
      "VoteAgainst": 34,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289",
      "ID": 3391
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2117,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis",
      "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3315326+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267387",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 267387,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1923,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 81,
      "VoteAgainst": 34,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289",
      "ID": 3391
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken",
      "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.017629+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313713",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313713,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1923,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 81,
      "VoteAgainst": 34,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289",
      "ID": 3391
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4966,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek",
      "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4074588+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3101E102P129VM295053",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295053,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1923,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 81,
      "VoteAgainst": 34,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289",
      "ID": 3391
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3101,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala",
      "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1901895+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319053",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319053,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1923,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 81,
      "VoteAgainst": 34,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289",
      "ID": 3391
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5034,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny",
      "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6903993+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306376",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306376,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1923,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 81,
      "VoteAgainst": 34,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289",
      "ID": 3391
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2159,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Martin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5494319+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5110E252P395VM311210",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311210,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1923,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 81,
      "VoteAgainst": 34,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289",
      "ID": 3391
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Mason",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8666794+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268216",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 268216,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1923,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 81,
      "VoteAgainst": 34,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289",
      "ID": 3391
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2133,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2538607+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2876E141P433VM286357",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286357,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1923,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 81,
      "VoteAgainst": 34,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289",
      "ID": 3391
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2876,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5753324+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4951E147P368VM258645",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258645,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1923,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 81,
      "VoteAgainst": 34,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289",
      "ID": 3391
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4951,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan",
      "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3164277+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3896E175P307VM264111",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264111,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1923,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 81,
      "VoteAgainst": 34,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289",
      "ID": 3391
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3896,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam",
      "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9246988+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308429",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 308429,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1923,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 81,
      "VoteAgainst": 34,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289",
      "ID": 3391
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0555423+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4964E143P375VM279292",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279292,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1923,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 81,
      "VoteAgainst": 34,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289",
      "ID": 3391
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4964,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.4955394+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279645",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279645,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1923,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 81,
      "VoteAgainst": 34,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289",
      "ID": 3391
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3824,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5165344+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2066E22P91VM261048",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261048,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1923,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 81,
      "VoteAgainst": 34,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289",
      "ID": 3391
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2066,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.1095629+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299643",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 299643,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1923,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 81,
      "VoteAgainst": 34,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289",
      "ID": 3391
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7065566+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306615",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306615,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1923,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 81,
      "VoteAgainst": 34,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289",
      "ID": 3391
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina",
      "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5596925+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2487E146P369VM301180",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 301180,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1923,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 81,
      "VoteAgainst": 34,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289",
      "ID": 3391
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2487,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0375091+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223859",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223859,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1923,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 81,
      "VoteAgainst": 34,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289",
      "ID": 3391
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.476849+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237427",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237427,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1923,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 81,
      "VoteAgainst": 34,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289",
      "ID": 3391
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1961,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David",
      "DisplayName": "David McLetchie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2037378+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305492",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 305492,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1923,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 81,
      "VoteAgainst": 34,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289",
      "ID": 3391
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2134,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3266506+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320373",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 320373,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1923,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 81,
      "VoteAgainst": 34,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289",
      "ID": 3391
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5041,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan",
      "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1636283+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315972",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315972,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1923,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 81,
      "VoteAgainst": 34,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289",
      "ID": 3391
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3763,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart",
      "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9402185+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1986E23P197VM236655",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 236655,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1923,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 81,
      "VoteAgainst": 34,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289",
      "ID": 3391
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1986,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan",
      "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9343717+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5047E100P130VM289849",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289849,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1923,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 81,
      "VoteAgainst": 34,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289",
      "ID": 3391
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5047,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne",
      "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4617035+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234578",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234578,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1923,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 81,
      "VoteAgainst": 34,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289",
      "ID": 3391
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1845,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette",
      "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3903391+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313542",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313542,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1923,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 81,
      "VoteAgainst": 34,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289",
      "ID": 3391
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3061,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.39987+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1768E19P265VM288600",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 288600,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1923,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 81,
      "VoteAgainst": 34,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289",
      "ID": 3391
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1768,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.150388+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225011",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225011,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1923,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 81,
      "VoteAgainst": 34,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289",
      "ID": 3391
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1894,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Neil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.740725+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3815E98P134VM270850",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270850,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1923,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 81,
      "VoteAgainst": 34,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289",
      "ID": 3391
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3815,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Park, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Park",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8258084+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265865",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265865,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1923,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 81,
      "VoteAgainst": 34,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289",
      "ID": 3391
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2010,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil",
      "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4638847+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283548",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283548,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1923,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 81,
      "VoteAgainst": 34,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289",
      "ID": 3391
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5057,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7127931+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2853E33P128VM251398",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251398,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1923,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 81,
      "VoteAgainst": 34,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289",
      "ID": 3391
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Pentland",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4618705+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317594",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317594,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1923,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 81,
      "VoteAgainst": 34,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289",
      "ID": 3391
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5009,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4291533+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254674",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254674,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1923,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 81,
      "VoteAgainst": 34,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289",
      "ID": 3391
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3745,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis",
      "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2667501+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1870E225P478VM295658",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295658,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1923,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 81,
      "VoteAgainst": 34,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289",
      "ID": 3391
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1870,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona",
      "DisplayName": "Shona Robison",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5303138+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2135E254P450VM234842",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234842,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1923,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 81,
      "VoteAgainst": 34,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289",
      "ID": 3391
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2135,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Russell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4020987+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1895E232P431VM257590",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257590,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1923,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 81,
      "VoteAgainst": 34,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289",
      "ID": 3391
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1895,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0630718+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228144",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 228144,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1923,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 81,
      "VoteAgainst": 34,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289",
      "ID": 3391
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1839,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5862438+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2345E10P55VM291661",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291661,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1923,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 81,
      "VoteAgainst": 34,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289",
      "ID": 3391
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2345,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1368703+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311079",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311079,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1923,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 81,
      "VoteAgainst": 34,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289",
      "ID": 3391
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2223,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish",
      "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.6045084+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246365",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 246365,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1923,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 81,
      "VoteAgainst": 34,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289",
      "ID": 3391
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2182,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1255872+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298142",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298142,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1923,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 81,
      "VoteAgainst": 34,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289",
      "ID": 3391
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5079,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew",
      "DisplayName": "Drew Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1400266+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234327",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234327,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1923,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 81,
      "VoteAgainst": 34,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289",
      "ID": 3391
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1769,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3724995+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4014E14P26VM269920",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269920,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1923,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 81,
      "VoteAgainst": 34,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289",
      "ID": 3391
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4014,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz",
      "DisplayName": "Liz Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5735408+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269554",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269554,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1923,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 81,
      "VoteAgainst": 34,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289",
      "ID": 3391
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2215,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5526276+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317421",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317421,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1923,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 81,
      "VoteAgainst": 34,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289",
      "ID": 3391
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3806,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.421379+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326371",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 326371,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1923,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 81,
      "VoteAgainst": 34,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289",
      "ID": 3391
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5106,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin",
      "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.755608+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241157",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241157,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1923,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 81,
      "VoteAgainst": 34,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289",
      "ID": 3391
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1848,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola",
      "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.4044876+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2098E237P531VM289685",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289685,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1923,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 81,
      "VoteAgainst": 34,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289",
      "ID": 3391
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2098,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Swinney",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4547986+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2674E247P401VM247716",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247716,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1923,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 81,
      "VoteAgainst": 34,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289",
      "ID": 3391
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2674,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave",
      "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4253634+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5075E234P371VM284833",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 284833,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1923,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 81,
      "VoteAgainst": 34,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289",
      "ID": 3391
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5075,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Torrance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0497029+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1793E151P362VM222411",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 222411,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1923,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 81,
      "VoteAgainst": 34,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289",
      "ID": 3391
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1793,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean",
      "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1877892+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5078E245P7VM307084",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307084,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1923,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 81,
      "VoteAgainst": 34,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289",
      "ID": 3391
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5078,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Walker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5865813+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1841E231P426VM239966",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239966,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1923,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 81,
      "VoteAgainst": 34,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289",
      "ID": 3391
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1841,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen",
      "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7669852+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283376",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283376,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1923,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 81,
      "VoteAgainst": 34,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289",
      "ID": 3391
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4952,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.6980298+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1865E263P500VM231874",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231874,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1923,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 81,
      "VoteAgainst": 34,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289",
      "ID": 3391
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1865,
      "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra",
      "DisplayName": "Sandra White",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6193102+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237837",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237837,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1923,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 81,
      "VoteAgainst": 34,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289",
      "ID": 3391
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2610,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Wilson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2282007+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309235",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 309235,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1923,
      "AgendaID": 2293,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 81,
      "VoteAgainst": 34,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Women's Representation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03289",
      "ID": 3391
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4941,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza",
      "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3205895+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1926E229P470VM253109",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253109,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1922,
      "AgendaID": 2048,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 47,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03278.1",
      "ID": 3393
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1926,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian",
      "DisplayName": "Brian Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7671763+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2615E213P388VM259468",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 259468,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1922,
      "AgendaID": 2048,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 47,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03278.1",
      "ID": 3393
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2615,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George",
      "DisplayName": "George Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6103942+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4940E159P373VM317818",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317818,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1922,
      "AgendaID": 2048,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 47,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03278.1",
      "ID": 3393
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4940,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare",
      "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4386881+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2641E256P403VM250164",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250164,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1922,
      "AgendaID": 2048,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 47,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03278.1",
      "ID": 3393
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2641,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair",
      "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9661528+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1783E21P273VM228457",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 228457,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1922,
      "AgendaID": 2048,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 47,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03278.1",
      "ID": 3393
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1783,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie",
      "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.7998973+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2633E97P136VM281153",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 281153,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1922,
      "AgendaID": 2048,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 47,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03278.1",
      "ID": 3393
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2633,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire",
      "DisplayName": "Claire Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.8082326+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2603E89P148VM263115",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 263115,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1922,
      "AgendaID": 2048,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 47,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03278.1",
      "ID": 3393
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2603,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6374126+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1759E91P115VM227544",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227544,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1922,
      "AgendaID": 2048,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 47,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03278.1",
      "ID": 3393
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia",
      "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5547059+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270713",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270713,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1922,
      "AgendaID": 2048,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 47,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03278.1",
      "ID": 3393
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3751,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8198842+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322450",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 322450,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1922,
      "AgendaID": 2048,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 47,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03278.1",
      "ID": 3393
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5109,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco",
      "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6891614+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5060E86P124VM297340",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 297340,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1922,
      "AgendaID": 2048,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 47,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03278.1",
      "ID": 3393
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5060,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.0957352+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242701",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242701,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1922,
      "AgendaID": 2048,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 47,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03278.1",
      "ID": 3393
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1866,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah",
      "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0318776+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1943E145P367VM236980",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 236980,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1922,
      "AgendaID": 2048,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 47,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03278.1",
      "ID": 3393
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1943,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic",
      "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9486+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2595E12P30VM301673",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 301673,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1922,
      "AgendaID": 2048,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 47,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03278.1",
      "ID": 3393
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2595,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin",
      "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.2725866+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2103E244P421VM262003",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262003,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1922,
      "AgendaID": 2048,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 47,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03278.1",
      "ID": 3393
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2103,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith",
      "DisplayName": "Keith Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3874199+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5108E221P387VM326573",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 326573,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1922,
      "AgendaID": 2048,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 47,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03278.1",
      "ID": 3393
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7705542+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277613",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277613,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1922,
      "AgendaID": 2048,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 47,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03278.1",
      "ID": 3393
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9608213+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264994",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264994,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1922,
      "AgendaID": 2048,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 47,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03278.1",
      "ID": 3393
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2673,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick",
      "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1635754+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2678E11P28VM249326",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 249326,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1922,
      "AgendaID": 2048,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 47,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03278.1",
      "ID": 3393
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2678,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson",
      "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9217489+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2123E27P233VM291154",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291154,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1922,
      "AgendaID": 2048,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 47,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03278.1",
      "ID": 3393
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2123,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm",
      "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7880192+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285466",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285466,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1922,
      "AgendaID": 2048,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 47,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03278.1",
      "ID": 3393
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3907,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3304631+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1735E248P405VM231404",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231404,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1922,
      "AgendaID": 2048,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 47,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03278.1",
      "ID": 3393
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1735,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela",
      "DisplayName": "Angela Constance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.5987103+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243170",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 243170,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1922,
      "AgendaID": 2048,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 47,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03278.1",
      "ID": 3393
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1932,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce",
      "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0571565+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1863E238P523VM253976",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253976,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1922,
      "AgendaID": 2048,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 47,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03278.1",
      "ID": 3393
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1863,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna",
      "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0291841+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4976E20P31VM321140",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 321140,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1922,
      "AgendaID": 2048,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 47,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03278.1",
      "ID": 3393
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4976,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth",
      "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.203994+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5107E223P379VM292432",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 292432,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1922,
      "AgendaID": 2048,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 47,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03278.1",
      "ID": 3393
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5107,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5335421+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3743E222P391VM273165",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 273165,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1922,
      "AgendaID": 2048,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 47,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03278.1",
      "ID": 3393
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3743,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel",
      "DisplayName": "Nigel Don",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3723939+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262863",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262863,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1922,
      "AgendaID": 2048,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 47,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03278.1",
      "ID": 3393
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3771,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob",
      "DisplayName": "Bob Doris",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6262164+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281740",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 281740,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1922,
      "AgendaID": 2048,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 47,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03278.1",
      "ID": 3393
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2826,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Dornan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1556141+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298539",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298539,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1922,
      "AgendaID": 2048,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 47,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03278.1",
      "ID": 3393
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3812,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia",
      "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3504908+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1778E28P260VM230617",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230617,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1922,
      "AgendaID": 2048,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 47,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03278.1",
      "ID": 3393
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1778,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen",
      "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3381139+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4955E240P389VM287185",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 287185,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1922,
      "AgendaID": 2048,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 47,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03278.1",
      "ID": 3393
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4955,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.6228175+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219695",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 219695,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1922,
      "AgendaID": 2048,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 47,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03278.1",
      "ID": 3393
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1742,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle",
      "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3105105+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1994E257P537VM239113",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239113,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1922,
      "AgendaID": 2048,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 47,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03278.1",
      "ID": 3393
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1994,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus",
      "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4958557+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1814E269P519VM226281",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 226281,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1922,
      "AgendaID": 2048,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 47,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03278.1",
      "ID": 3393
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1814,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda",
      "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2188132+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5059E85P123VM322010",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 322010,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1922,
      "AgendaID": 2048,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 47,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03278.1",
      "ID": 3393
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Fee",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4673848+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1853E35P216VM291821",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291821,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1922,
      "AgendaID": 2048,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 47,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03278.1",
      "ID": 3393
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia",
      "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1439191+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1892E12P64VM228181",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 228181,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1922,
      "AgendaID": 2048,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 47,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03278.1",
      "ID": 3393
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5878072+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5054E95P118VM304396",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 304396,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1922,
      "AgendaID": 2048,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 47,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03278.1",
      "ID": 3393
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5054,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.0364633+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4947E152P361VM257962",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257962,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1922,
      "AgendaID": 2048,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 47,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03278.1",
      "ID": 3393
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4947,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Finnie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0853865+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271691",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271691,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1922,
      "AgendaID": 2048,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 47,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03278.1",
      "ID": 3393
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3901,
      "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe",
      "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0873233+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2394E15P47VM274320",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274320,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1922,
      "AgendaID": 2048,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 47,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03278.1",
      "ID": 3393
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2394,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo",
      "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.0955136+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2110E220P414VM266487",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 266487,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1922,
      "AgendaID": 2048,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 47,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03278.1",
      "ID": 3393
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth",
      "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.7432791+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250779",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250779,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1922,
      "AgendaID": 2048,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 47,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03278.1",
      "ID": 3393
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2675,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob",
      "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.2131647+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221245",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221245,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1922,
      "AgendaID": 2048,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 47,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03278.1",
      "ID": 3393
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1741,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel",
      "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9210092+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1756E218P467VM226369",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 226369,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1922,
      "AgendaID": 2048,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 47,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03278.1",
      "ID": 3393
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1756,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine",
      "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2283615+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1860E104P150VM239797",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239797,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1922,
      "AgendaID": 2048,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 47,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03278.1",
      "ID": 3393
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1860,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda",
      "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7593173+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2033E20P141VM253178",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253178,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1922,
      "AgendaID": 2048,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 47,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03278.1",
      "ID": 3393
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2033,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain",
      "DisplayName": "Iain Gray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7700385+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324407",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324407,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1922,
      "AgendaID": 2048,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 47,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03278.1",
      "ID": 3393
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5042,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2154019+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2892E76P97VM260894",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 260894,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1922,
      "AgendaID": 2048,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 47,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03278.1",
      "ID": 3393
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick",
      "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.1025437+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2029E24P170VM246111",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 246111,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1922,
      "AgendaID": 2048,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 47,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03278.1",
      "ID": 3393
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2029,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh",
      "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8726905+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3758E268P409VM276189",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276189,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1922,
      "AgendaID": 2048,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 47,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03278.1",
      "ID": 3393
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3758,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.4143205+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4086E128P311VM303195",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 303195,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1922,
      "AgendaID": 2048,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 47,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03278.1",
      "ID": 3393
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4086,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Hume",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5633186+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1773E242P494VM222294",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 222294,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1922,
      "AgendaID": 2048,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 47,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03278.1",
      "ID": 3393
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1773,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1825197+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1882E227P459VM245579",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 245579,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1922,
      "AgendaID": 2048,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 47,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03278.1",
      "ID": 3393
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1882,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam",
      "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8495077+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1893E16P69VM224712",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 224712,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1922,
      "AgendaID": 2048,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 47,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03278.1",
      "ID": 3393
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1893,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.716694+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4934E77P103VM308122",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 308122,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1922,
      "AgendaID": 2048,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 47,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03278.1",
      "ID": 3393
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4934,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8656689+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272516",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 272516,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1922,
      "AgendaID": 2048,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 47,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03278.1",
      "ID": 3393
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4956,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Keir",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3387604+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244710",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244710,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1922,
      "AgendaID": 2048,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 47,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03278.1",
      "ID": 3393
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Kelly",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5749465+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3129E261P419VM314729",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 314729,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1922,
      "AgendaID": 2048,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 47,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03278.1",
      "ID": 3393
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3129,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6529699+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2080E36P220VM252502",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252502,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1922,
      "AgendaID": 2048,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 47,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03278.1",
      "ID": 3393
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann",
      "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7319072+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4016E11P36VM275614",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 275614,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1922,
      "AgendaID": 2048,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 47,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03278.1",
      "ID": 3393
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4016,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.3831033+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2180E246P463VM257098",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257098,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1922,
      "AgendaID": 2048,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 47,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03278.1",
      "ID": 3393
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2180,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.8232237+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4938E158P374VM282878",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 282878,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1922,
      "AgendaID": 2048,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 47,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03278.1",
      "ID": 3393
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4938,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.4382087+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2112E250P486VM254098",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254098,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1922,
      "AgendaID": 2048,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 47,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03278.1",
      "ID": 3393
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2112,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny",
      "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0344281+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4939E258P394VM278779",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 278779,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1922,
      "AgendaID": 2048,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 47,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03278.1",
      "ID": 3393
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4939,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus",
      "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2338913+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5074E251P385VM324878",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324878,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1922,
      "AgendaID": 2048,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 47,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03278.1",
      "ID": 3393
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5074,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon",
      "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2416767+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1828E3P10VM231979",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231979,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1922,
      "AgendaID": 2048,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 47,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03278.1",
      "ID": 3393
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1828,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo",
      "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6239997+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4948E153P363VM312121",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 312121,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1922,
      "AgendaID": 2048,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 47,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03278.1",
      "ID": 3393
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4948,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike",
      "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.914614+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2117E90P107VM233099",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 233099,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1922,
      "AgendaID": 2048,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 47,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03278.1",
      "ID": 3393
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2117,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis",
      "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8967851+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267598",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 267598,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1922,
      "AgendaID": 2048,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 47,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03278.1",
      "ID": 3393
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken",
      "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0267871+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313039",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313039,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1922,
      "AgendaID": 2048,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 47,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03278.1",
      "ID": 3393
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4966,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek",
      "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1609905+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3101E102P129VM294377",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 294377,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1922,
      "AgendaID": 2048,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 47,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03278.1",
      "ID": 3393
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3101,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala",
      "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1357252+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319259",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319259,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1922,
      "AgendaID": 2048,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 47,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03278.1",
      "ID": 3393
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5034,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny",
      "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9123369+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2159E25P205VM305785",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 305785,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1922,
      "AgendaID": 2048,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 47,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03278.1",
      "ID": 3393
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2159,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Martin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3452314+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5110E252P395VM309871",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 309871,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1922,
      "AgendaID": 2048,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 47,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03278.1",
      "ID": 3393
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Mason",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.354521+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268006",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 268006,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1922,
      "AgendaID": 2048,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 47,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03278.1",
      "ID": 3393
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2133,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0519285+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2876E141P433VM293049",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 293049,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1922,
      "AgendaID": 2048,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 47,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03278.1",
      "ID": 3393
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2876,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.569419+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4951E147P368VM271433",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271433,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1922,
      "AgendaID": 2048,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 47,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03278.1",
      "ID": 3393
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4951,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan",
      "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0756087+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3896E175P307VM269404",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269404,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1922,
      "AgendaID": 2048,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 47,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03278.1",
      "ID": 3393
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3896,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam",
      "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5460735+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5080E110P121VM307407",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307407,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1922,
      "AgendaID": 2048,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 47,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03278.1",
      "ID": 3393
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8281181+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4964E143P375VM280577",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280577,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1922,
      "AgendaID": 2048,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 47,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03278.1",
      "ID": 3393
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4964,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7731953+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3824E84P113VM281267",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 281267,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1922,
      "AgendaID": 2048,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 47,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03278.1",
      "ID": 3393
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3824,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1274614+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2066E22P91VM245178",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 245178,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1922,
      "AgendaID": 2048,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 47,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03278.1",
      "ID": 3393
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2066,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5954134+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299278",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 299278,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1922,
      "AgendaID": 2048,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 47,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03278.1",
      "ID": 3393
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.6905824+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3759E260P411VM302770",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 302770,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1922,
      "AgendaID": 2048,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 47,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03278.1",
      "ID": 3393
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina",
      "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5444251+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300105",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 300105,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1922,
      "AgendaID": 2048,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 47,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03278.1",
      "ID": 3393
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2487,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7365236+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1775E215P453VM224302",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 224302,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1922,
      "AgendaID": 2048,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 47,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03278.1",
      "ID": 3393
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.6930734+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237966",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237966,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1922,
      "AgendaID": 2048,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 47,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03278.1",
      "ID": 3393
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1961,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David",
      "DisplayName": "David McLetchie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2337736+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2134E34P201VM297711",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 297711,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1922,
      "AgendaID": 2048,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 47,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03278.1",
      "ID": 3393
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2134,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1215537+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320011",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 320011,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1922,
      "AgendaID": 2048,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 47,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03278.1",
      "ID": 3393
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5041,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan",
      "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9575366+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315352",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315352,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1922,
      "AgendaID": 2048,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 47,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03278.1",
      "ID": 3393
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3763,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart",
      "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9082825+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1986E23P197VM237546",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237546,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1922,
      "AgendaID": 2048,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 47,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03278.1",
      "ID": 3393
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1986,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan",
      "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2154764+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5047E100P130VM292573",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 292573,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1922,
      "AgendaID": 2048,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 47,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03278.1",
      "ID": 3393
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5047,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne",
      "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5486198+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1845E17P40VM233964",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 233964,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1922,
      "AgendaID": 2048,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 47,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03278.1",
      "ID": 3393
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1845,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette",
      "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1539833+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3061E19P43VM311633",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311633,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1922,
      "AgendaID": 2048,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 47,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03278.1",
      "ID": 3393
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3061,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.887576+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1768E19P265VM286850",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286850,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1922,
      "AgendaID": 2048,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 47,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03278.1",
      "ID": 3393
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1768,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.6035049+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225697",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225697,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1922,
      "AgendaID": 2048,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 47,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03278.1",
      "ID": 3393
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1894,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Neil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9864791+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3815E98P134VM271012",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271012,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1922,
      "AgendaID": 2048,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 47,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03278.1",
      "ID": 3393
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3815,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Park, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Park",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.838743+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265557",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265557,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1922,
      "AgendaID": 2048,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 47,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03278.1",
      "ID": 3393
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2010,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil",
      "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4443132+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283950",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283950,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1922,
      "AgendaID": 2048,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 47,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03278.1",
      "ID": 3393
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5057,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7304968+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2853E33P128VM258714",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258714,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1922,
      "AgendaID": 2048,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 47,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03278.1",
      "ID": 3393
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Pentland",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3194685+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317234",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317234,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1922,
      "AgendaID": 2048,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 47,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03278.1",
      "ID": 3393
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5009,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4096104+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3745E233P381VM256126",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 256126,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1922,
      "AgendaID": 2048,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 47,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03278.1",
      "ID": 3393
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3745,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis",
      "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5717381+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1870E225P478VM294514",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 294514,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1922,
      "AgendaID": 2048,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 47,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03278.1",
      "ID": 3393
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1870,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona",
      "DisplayName": "Shona Robison",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.141699+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2135E254P450VM235984",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235984,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1922,
      "AgendaID": 2048,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 47,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03278.1",
      "ID": 3393
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2135,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Russell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.7013766+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1895E232P431VM255997",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255997,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1922,
      "AgendaID": 2048,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 47,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03278.1",
      "ID": 3393
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1895,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5659258+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1839E21P87VM229356",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229356,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1922,
      "AgendaID": 2048,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 47,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03278.1",
      "ID": 3393
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1839,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0782203+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2345E10P55VM288398",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 288398,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1922,
      "AgendaID": 2048,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 47,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03278.1",
      "ID": 3393
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2345,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.133119+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2223E176P333VM310541",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 310541,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1922,
      "AgendaID": 2048,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 47,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03278.1",
      "ID": 3393
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2223,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish",
      "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5753252+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2182E87P175VM247113",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247113,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1922,
      "AgendaID": 2048,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 47,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03278.1",
      "ID": 3393
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2182,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1676177+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298701",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298701,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1922,
      "AgendaID": 2048,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 47,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03278.1",
      "ID": 3393
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5079,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew",
      "DisplayName": "Drew Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.368538+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1769E32P285VM235819",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235819,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1922,
      "AgendaID": 2048,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 47,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03278.1",
      "ID": 3393
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1769,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6943402+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4014E14P26VM275345",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 275345,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1922,
      "AgendaID": 2048,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 47,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03278.1",
      "ID": 3393
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4014,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz",
      "DisplayName": "Liz Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.3711996+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2215E224P447VM270074",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270074,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1922,
      "AgendaID": 2048,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 47,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03278.1",
      "ID": 3393
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2215,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5804166+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3806E103P127VM316888",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 316888,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1922,
      "AgendaID": 2048,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 47,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03278.1",
      "ID": 3393
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3806,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.1677673+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326106",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 326106,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1922,
      "AgendaID": 2048,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 47,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03278.1",
      "ID": 3393
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5106,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin",
      "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5401209+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241447",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241447,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1922,
      "AgendaID": 2048,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 47,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03278.1",
      "ID": 3393
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1848,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola",
      "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7583514+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2098E237P531VM288687",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 288687,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1922,
      "AgendaID": 2048,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 47,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03278.1",
      "ID": 3393
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2098,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Swinney",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1540998+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248236",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248236,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1922,
      "AgendaID": 2048,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 47,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03278.1",
      "ID": 3393
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2674,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave",
      "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6371736+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5075E234P371VM290071",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 290071,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1922,
      "AgendaID": 2048,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 47,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03278.1",
      "ID": 3393
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5075,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Torrance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4715196+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1793E151P362VM222788",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 222788,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1922,
      "AgendaID": 2048,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 47,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03278.1",
      "ID": 3393
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1793,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean",
      "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.2047315+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5078E245P7VM306867",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306867,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1922,
      "AgendaID": 2048,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 47,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03278.1",
      "ID": 3393
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5078,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Walker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5771336+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1841E231P426VM240828",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 240828,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1922,
      "AgendaID": 2048,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 47,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03278.1",
      "ID": 3393
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1841,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen",
      "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3840223+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4952E148P370VM284107",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 284107,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1922,
      "AgendaID": 2048,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 47,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03278.1",
      "ID": 3393
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4952,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7432974+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1865E263P500VM231050",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231050,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1922,
      "AgendaID": 2048,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 47,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03278.1",
      "ID": 3393
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1865,
      "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra",
      "DisplayName": "Sandra White",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3634737+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2610E160P413VM246750",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 246750,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1922,
      "AgendaID": 2048,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 47,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03278.1",
      "ID": 3393
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2610,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Wilson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1518237+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4941E150P382VM308868",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 308868,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1922,
      "AgendaID": 2048,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 47,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03278.1",
      "ID": 3393
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4941,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza",
      "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-13T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0815257+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252632",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252632,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1920,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 111,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163.1",
      "ID": 3293
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1926,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian",
      "DisplayName": "Brian Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7378253+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2615E213P388VM258825",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258825,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1920,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 111,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163.1",
      "ID": 3293
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2615,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George",
      "DisplayName": "George Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3295319+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319903",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319903,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1920,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 111,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163.1",
      "ID": 3293
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4940,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare",
      "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9463538+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249642",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 249642,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1920,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 111,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163.1",
      "ID": 3293
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2641,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair",
      "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9436169+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1783E21P273VM227737",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227737,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1920,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 111,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163.1",
      "ID": 3293
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1783,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie",
      "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5634703+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2633E97P136VM280739",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280739,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1920,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 111,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163.1",
      "ID": 3293
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2633,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire",
      "DisplayName": "Claire Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7803663+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262497",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262497,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1920,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 111,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163.1",
      "ID": 3293
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2603,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6044904+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1759E91P115VM229748",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229748,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1920,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 111,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163.1",
      "ID": 3293
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia",
      "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0950074+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270202",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270202,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1920,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 111,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163.1",
      "ID": 3293
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3751,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.7936235+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322702",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 322702,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1920,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 111,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163.1",
      "ID": 3293
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5109,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco",
      "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.7000149+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5060E86P124VM294728",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 294728,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1920,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 111,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163.1",
      "ID": 3293
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5060,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1757756+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242849",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242849,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1920,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 111,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163.1",
      "ID": 3293
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1866,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah",
      "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.038249+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235575",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235575,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1920,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 111,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163.1",
      "ID": 3293
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1943,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic",
      "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6837024+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302156",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 302156,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1920,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 111,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163.1",
      "ID": 3293
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2595,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin",
      "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.2996988+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244503",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244503,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1920,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 111,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163.1",
      "ID": 3293
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2103,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith",
      "DisplayName": "Keith Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5575942+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327228",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 327228,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1920,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 111,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163.1",
      "ID": 3293
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:46.0267599+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3775E216P435VM276680",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276680,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1920,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 111,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163.1",
      "ID": 3293
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6765276+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264337",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264337,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1920,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 111,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163.1",
      "ID": 3293
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2673,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick",
      "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1291567+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248810",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248810,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1920,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 111,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163.1",
      "ID": 3293
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2678,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson",
      "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.671026+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2123E27P233VM295834",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295834,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1920,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 111,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163.1",
      "ID": 3293
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2123,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm",
      "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5378596+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285158",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285158,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1920,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 111,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163.1",
      "ID": 3293
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3907,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.068933+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230177",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230177,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1920,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 111,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163.1",
      "ID": 3293
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1735,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela",
      "DisplayName": "Angela Constance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.1195363+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243870",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 243870,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1920,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 111,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163.1",
      "ID": 3293
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1932,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce",
      "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3234391+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254933",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254933,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1920,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 111,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163.1",
      "ID": 3293
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1863,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna",
      "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2900361+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323835",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 323835,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1920,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 111,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163.1",
      "ID": 3293
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4976,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth",
      "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9741366+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5107E223P379VM291369",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291369,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1920,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 111,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163.1",
      "ID": 3293
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5107,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1163471+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3743E222P391VM265329",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265329,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1920,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 111,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163.1",
      "ID": 3293
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3743,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel",
      "DisplayName": "Nigel Don",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4344841+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3771E149P417VM261751",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261751,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1920,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 111,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163.1",
      "ID": 3293
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3771,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob",
      "DisplayName": "Bob Doris",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3712556+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2826E262P384VM282002",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 282002,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1920,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 111,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163.1",
      "ID": 3293
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2826,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Dornan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1669838+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3812E94P117VM297970",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 297970,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1920,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 111,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163.1",
      "ID": 3293
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3812,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia",
      "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1327287+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231596",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231596,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1920,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 111,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163.1",
      "ID": 3293
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1778,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen",
      "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6074219+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4955E240P389VM285965",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285965,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1920,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 111,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163.1",
      "ID": 3293
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4955,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3521778+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219354",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 219354,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1920,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 111,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163.1",
      "ID": 3293
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1742,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle",
      "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.2949797+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238602",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 238602,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1920,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 111,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163.1",
      "ID": 3293
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1994,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus",
      "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4611766+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225448",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225448,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1920,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 111,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163.1",
      "ID": 3293
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1814,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda",
      "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9751607+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321757",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 321757,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1920,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 111,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163.1",
      "ID": 3293
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Fee",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4500981+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292923",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 292923,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1920,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 111,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163.1",
      "ID": 3293
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia",
      "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.564042+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1892E12P64VM226921",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 226921,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1920,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 111,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163.1",
      "ID": 3293
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2526205+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5054E95P118VM312672",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 312672,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1920,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 111,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163.1",
      "ID": 3293
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5054,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1383862+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4947E152P361VM257177",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257177,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1920,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 111,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163.1",
      "ID": 3293
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4947,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Finnie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.8266205+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271321",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271321,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1920,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 111,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163.1",
      "ID": 3293
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3901,
      "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe",
      "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0704471+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278447",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 278447,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1920,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 111,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163.1",
      "ID": 3293
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2394,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo",
      "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2192102+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2110E220P414VM286744",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286744,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1920,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 111,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163.1",
      "ID": 3293
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth",
      "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.598847+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250455",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250455,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1920,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 111,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163.1",
      "ID": 3293
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2675,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob",
      "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1902813+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1741E10P50VM220767",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220767,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1920,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 111,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163.1",
      "ID": 3293
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1741,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel",
      "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6561444+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220291",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220291,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1920,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 111,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163.1",
      "ID": 3293
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1756,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine",
      "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6349938+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1860E104P150VM252332",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252332,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1920,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 111,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163.1",
      "ID": 3293
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1860,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda",
      "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.724614+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2033E20P141VM266134",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 266134,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1920,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 111,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163.1",
      "ID": 3293
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2033,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain",
      "DisplayName": "Iain Gray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4757899+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324570",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324570,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1920,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 111,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163.1",
      "ID": 3293
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5042,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2286662+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259912",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 259912,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1920,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 111,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163.1",
      "ID": 3293
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick",
      "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6354001+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239295",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239295,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1920,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 111,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163.1",
      "ID": 3293
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2029,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh",
      "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7306627+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273808",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 273808,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1920,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 111,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163.1",
      "ID": 3293
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3758,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6365361+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304173",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 304173,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1920,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 111,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163.1",
      "ID": 3293
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4086,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Hume",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8529811+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221772",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221772,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1920,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 111,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163.1",
      "ID": 3293
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1773,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9471352+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1882E227P459VM242005",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242005,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1920,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 111,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163.1",
      "ID": 3293
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1882,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam",
      "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7897137+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223733",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223733,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1920,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 111,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163.1",
      "ID": 3293
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1893,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4714373+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307554",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307554,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1920,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 111,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163.1",
      "ID": 3293
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4934,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.834538+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272194",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 272194,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1920,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 111,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163.1",
      "ID": 3293
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4956,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Keir",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.1156275+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244858",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244858,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1920,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 111,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163.1",
      "ID": 3293
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Kelly",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5816353+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315029",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315029,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1920,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 111,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163.1",
      "ID": 3293
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3129,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6710094+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247973",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247973,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1920,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 111,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163.1",
      "ID": 3293
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann",
      "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4363019+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4016E11P36VM274765",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274765,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1920,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 111,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163.1",
      "ID": 3293
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4016,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.120784+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255823",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255823,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1920,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 111,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163.1",
      "ID": 3293
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2180,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5585969+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4938E158P374VM277480",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277480,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1920,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 111,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163.1",
      "ID": 3293
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4938,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9551667+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2112E250P486VM252989",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252989,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1920,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 111,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163.1",
      "ID": 3293
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2112,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny",
      "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7620651+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4939E258P394VM277185",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277185,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1920,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 111,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163.1",
      "ID": 3293
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4939,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus",
      "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.7048417+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325561",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 325561,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1920,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 111,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163.1",
      "ID": 3293
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5074,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon",
      "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5116474+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1828E3P10VM232837",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232837,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1920,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 111,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163.1",
      "ID": 3293
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1828,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo",
      "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8784993+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311401",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311401,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1920,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 111,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163.1",
      "ID": 3293
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4948,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike",
      "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8771743+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2117E90P107VM230445",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230445,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1920,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 111,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163.1",
      "ID": 3293
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2117,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis",
      "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.330139+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267337",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 267337,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1920,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 111,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163.1",
      "ID": 3293
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken",
      "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0151011+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313760",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313760,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1920,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 111,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163.1",
      "ID": 3293
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4966,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek",
      "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4094845+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3101E102P129VM295412",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295412,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1920,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 111,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163.1",
      "ID": 3293
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3101,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala",
      "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5110698+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319006",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319006,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1920,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 111,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163.1",
      "ID": 3293
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5034,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny",
      "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6883856+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306458",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306458,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1920,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 111,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163.1",
      "ID": 3293
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2159,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Martin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.552951+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5110E252P395VM311231",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311231,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1920,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 111,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163.1",
      "ID": 3293
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Mason",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8676388+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268266",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 268266,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1920,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 111,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163.1",
      "ID": 3293
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2133,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.259616+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2876E141P433VM286306",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286306,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1920,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 111,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163.1",
      "ID": 3293
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2876,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5731195+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4951E147P368VM260690",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 260690,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1920,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 111,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163.1",
      "ID": 3293
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4951,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan",
      "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.0880763+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3896E175P307VM264079",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264079,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1920,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 111,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163.1",
      "ID": 3293
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3896,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam",
      "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9232898+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308408",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 308408,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1920,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 111,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163.1",
      "ID": 3293
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0546439+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4964E143P375VM279324",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279324,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1920,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 111,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163.1",
      "ID": 3293
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4964,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.4972558+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279990",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279990,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1920,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 111,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163.1",
      "ID": 3293
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3824,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5315464+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2066E22P91VM261130",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261130,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1920,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 111,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163.1",
      "ID": 3293
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2066,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.1131094+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299693",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 299693,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1920,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 111,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163.1",
      "ID": 3293
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7185303+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306594",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306594,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1920,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 111,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163.1",
      "ID": 3293
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina",
      "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5587819+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2487E146P369VM301201",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 301201,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1920,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 111,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163.1",
      "ID": 3293
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2487,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.251632+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223672",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223672,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1920,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 111,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163.1",
      "ID": 3293
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4688449+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237467",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237467,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1920,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 111,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163.1",
      "ID": 3293
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1961,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David",
      "DisplayName": "David McLetchie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2118452+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2134E34P201VM297856",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 297856,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1920,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 111,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163.1",
      "ID": 3293
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2134,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1279414+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320420",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 320420,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1920,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 111,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163.1",
      "ID": 3293
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5041,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan",
      "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1656448+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3763E142P397VM316053",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 316053,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1920,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 111,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163.1",
      "ID": 3293
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3763,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart",
      "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.943933+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1986E23P197VM236311",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 236311,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1920,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 111,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163.1",
      "ID": 3293
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1986,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan",
      "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9109356+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5047E100P130VM291423",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291423,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1920,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 111,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163.1",
      "ID": 3293
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5047,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne",
      "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1186622+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234604",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234604,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1920,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 111,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163.1",
      "ID": 3293
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1845,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette",
      "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3914655+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313623",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313623,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1920,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 111,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163.1",
      "ID": 3293
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3061,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4033777+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1768E19P265VM288578",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 288578,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1920,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 111,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163.1",
      "ID": 3293
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1768,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1494408+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225052",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225052,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1920,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 111,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163.1",
      "ID": 3293
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1894,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Neil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.742459+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3815E98P134VM270891",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270891,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1920,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 111,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163.1",
      "ID": 3293
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3815,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Park, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Park",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.827647+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265890",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265890,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1920,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 111,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163.1",
      "ID": 3293
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2010,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil",
      "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4649779+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283516",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283516,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1920,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 111,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163.1",
      "ID": 3293
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5057,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7112689+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2853E33P128VM251429",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251429,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1920,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 111,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163.1",
      "ID": 3293
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Pentland",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4632264+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317640",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317640,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1920,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 111,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163.1",
      "ID": 3293
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5009,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4311033+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254708",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254708,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1920,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 111,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163.1",
      "ID": 3293
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3745,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis",
      "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.280327+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1870E225P478VM295637",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295637,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1920,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 111,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163.1",
      "ID": 3293
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1870,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona",
      "DisplayName": "Shona Robison",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5294113+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2135E254P450VM234872",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234872,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1920,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 111,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163.1",
      "ID": 3293
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2135,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Russell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4033772+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1895E232P431VM257409",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257409,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1920,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 111,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163.1",
      "ID": 3293
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1895,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0549714+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228111",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 228111,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1920,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 111,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163.1",
      "ID": 3293
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1839,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5848354+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2345E10P55VM291687",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291687,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1920,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 111,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163.1",
      "ID": 3293
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2345,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1379907+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2223E176P333VM310686",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 310686,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1920,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 111,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163.1",
      "ID": 3293
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2223,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish",
      "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5816811+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246332",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 246332,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1920,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 111,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163.1",
      "ID": 3293
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2182,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1241612+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298329",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298329,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1920,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 111,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163.1",
      "ID": 3293
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5079,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew",
      "DisplayName": "Drew Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3410636+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234361",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234361,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1920,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 111,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163.1",
      "ID": 3293
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1769,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3739662+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4014E14P26VM269952",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269952,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1920,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 111,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163.1",
      "ID": 3293
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4014,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz",
      "DisplayName": "Liz Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5749883+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269504",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269504,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1920,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 111,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163.1",
      "ID": 3293
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2215,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5504863+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317187",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317187,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1920,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 111,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163.1",
      "ID": 3293
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3806,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.1854409+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326269",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 326269,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1920,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 111,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163.1",
      "ID": 3293
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5106,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin",
      "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7511784+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241123",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241123,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1920,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 111,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163.1",
      "ID": 3293
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1848,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola",
      "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.4029964+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2098E237P531VM289602",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289602,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1920,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 111,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163.1",
      "ID": 3293
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2098,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Swinney",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4510976+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2674E247P401VM247746",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247746,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1920,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 111,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163.1",
      "ID": 3293
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2674,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave",
      "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4266428+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5075E234P371VM284864",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 284864,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1920,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 111,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163.1",
      "ID": 3293
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5075,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Torrance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0510107+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1793E151P362VM222453",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 222453,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1920,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 111,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163.1",
      "ID": 3293
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1793,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean",
      "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1896039+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5078E245P7VM307105",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307105,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1920,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 111,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163.1",
      "ID": 3293
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5078,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Walker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.587484+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1841E231P426VM240154",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 240154,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1920,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 111,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163.1",
      "ID": 3293
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1841,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen",
      "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7812657+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283416",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283416,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1920,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 111,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163.1",
      "ID": 3293
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4952,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.699765+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1865E263P500VM232227",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232227,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1920,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 111,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163.1",
      "ID": 3293
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1865,
      "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra",
      "DisplayName": "Sandra White",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8456204+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237807",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237807,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1920,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 111,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163.1",
      "ID": 3293
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2610,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Wilson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.226923+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309284",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 309284,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1920,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 111,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163.1",
      "ID": 3293
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4941,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza",
      "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3226825+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252633",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252633,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1921,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 109,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163",
      "ID": 3268
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1926,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian",
      "DisplayName": "Brian Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7378666+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2615E213P388VM258826",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258826,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1921,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 109,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163",
      "ID": 3268
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2615,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George",
      "DisplayName": "George Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3295729+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319902",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319902,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1921,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 109,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163",
      "ID": 3268
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4940,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare",
      "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9463126+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249641",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 249641,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1921,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 109,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163",
      "ID": 3268
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2641,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair",
      "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9435769+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1783E21P273VM227738",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227738,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1921,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 109,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163",
      "ID": 3268
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1783,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie",
      "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5635285+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2633E97P136VM280740",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280740,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1921,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 109,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163",
      "ID": 3268
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2633,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire",
      "DisplayName": "Claire Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7804068+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262498",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262498,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1921,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 109,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163",
      "ID": 3268
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2603,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6045308+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1759E91P115VM229749",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229749,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1921,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 109,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163",
      "ID": 3268
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia",
      "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0950476+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270201",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270201,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1921,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 109,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163",
      "ID": 3268
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3751,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.7935694+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322703",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 322703,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1921,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 109,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163",
      "ID": 3268
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5109,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco",
      "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.700055+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5060E86P124VM294729",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 294729,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1921,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 109,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163",
      "ID": 3268
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5060,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1758165+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242850",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242850,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1921,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 109,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163",
      "ID": 3268
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1866,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah",
      "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0382896+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235574",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235574,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1921,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 109,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163",
      "ID": 3268
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1943,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic",
      "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6836618+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302157",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 302157,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1921,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 109,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163",
      "ID": 3268
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2595,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin",
      "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.2997532+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244502",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244502,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1921,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 109,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163",
      "ID": 3268
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2103,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith",
      "DisplayName": "Keith Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.557552+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327229",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 327229,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1921,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 109,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163",
      "ID": 3268
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:46.0268205+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3775E216P435VM276681",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276681,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1921,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 109,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163",
      "ID": 3268
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6765923+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264336",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264336,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1921,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 109,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163",
      "ID": 3268
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2673,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick",
      "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1291159+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248809",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248809,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1921,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 109,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163",
      "ID": 3268
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2678,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson",
      "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6709849+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2123E27P233VM295833",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295833,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1921,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 109,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163",
      "ID": 3268
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2123,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm",
      "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5378+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285159",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285159,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1921,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 109,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163",
      "ID": 3268
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3907,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0689749+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230178",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230178,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1921,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 109,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163",
      "ID": 3268
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1735,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela",
      "DisplayName": "Angela Constance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.1195768+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243869",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 243869,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1921,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 109,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163",
      "ID": 3268
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1932,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce",
      "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3233987+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254932",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254932,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1921,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 109,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163",
      "ID": 3268
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1863,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna",
      "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2899944+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323836",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 323836,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1921,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 109,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163",
      "ID": 3268
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4976,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth",
      "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9743082+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5107E223P379VM291368",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291368,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1921,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 109,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163",
      "ID": 3268
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5107,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1162876+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3743E222P391VM265330",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265330,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1921,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 109,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163",
      "ID": 3268
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3743,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel",
      "DisplayName": "Nigel Don",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4345246+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262216",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262216,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1921,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 109,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163",
      "ID": 3268
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3771,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob",
      "DisplayName": "Bob Doris",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.5919328+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2826E262P384VM282001",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 282001,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1921,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 109,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163",
      "ID": 3268
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2826,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Dornan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1669241+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3812E94P117VM297971",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 297971,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1921,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 109,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163",
      "ID": 3268
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3812,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia",
      "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1327684+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231595",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231595,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1921,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 109,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163",
      "ID": 3268
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1778,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen",
      "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6073812+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4955E240P389VM285964",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285964,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1921,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 109,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163",
      "ID": 3268
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4955,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3521357+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219355",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 219355,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1921,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 109,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163",
      "ID": 3268
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1742,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle",
      "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.2950487+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238601",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 238601,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1921,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 109,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163",
      "ID": 3268
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1994,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus",
      "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4611365+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225447",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225447,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1921,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 109,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163",
      "ID": 3268
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1814,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda",
      "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.97512+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321756",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 321756,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1921,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 109,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163",
      "ID": 3268
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Fee",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4500564+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292922",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 292922,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1921,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 109,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163",
      "ID": 3268
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia",
      "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.564001+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1892E12P64VM226922",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 226922,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1921,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 109,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163",
      "ID": 3268
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2526633+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5054E95P118VM312673",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 312673,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1921,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 109,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163",
      "ID": 3268
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5054,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1384268+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4947E152P361VM257178",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257178,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1921,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 109,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163",
      "ID": 3268
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4947,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Finnie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.826662+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271320",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271320,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1921,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 109,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163",
      "ID": 3268
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3901,
      "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe",
      "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0704053+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278446",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 278446,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1921,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 109,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163",
      "ID": 3268
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2394,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo",
      "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2191676+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2110E220P414VM286745",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286745,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1921,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 109,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163",
      "ID": 3268
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth",
      "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5988874+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250456",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250456,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1921,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 109,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163",
      "ID": 3268
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2675,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob",
      "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1903229+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1741E10P50VM220768",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220768,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1921,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 109,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163",
      "ID": 3268
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1741,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel",
      "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6561848+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220290",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220290,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1921,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 109,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163",
      "ID": 3268
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1756,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine",
      "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6349502+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1860E104P150VM252333",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252333,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1921,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 109,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163",
      "ID": 3268
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1860,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda",
      "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7246565+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2033E20P141VM266133",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 266133,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1921,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 109,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163",
      "ID": 3268
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2033,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain",
      "DisplayName": "Iain Gray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4757495+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324569",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324569,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1921,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 109,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163",
      "ID": 3268
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5042,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.228626+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259911",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 259911,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1921,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 109,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163",
      "ID": 3268
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick",
      "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6353579+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239296",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239296,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1921,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 109,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163",
      "ID": 3268
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2029,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh",
      "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7307034+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273807",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 273807,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1921,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 109,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163",
      "ID": 3268
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3758,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6364948+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304172",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 304172,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1921,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 109,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163",
      "ID": 3268
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4086,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Hume",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8529288+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221771",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221771,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1921,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 109,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163",
      "ID": 3268
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1773,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9470947+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1882E227P459VM242004",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242004,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1921,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 109,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163",
      "ID": 3268
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1882,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam",
      "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7896724+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223732",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223732,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1921,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 109,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163",
      "ID": 3268
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1893,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4713962+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307555",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307555,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1921,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 109,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163",
      "ID": 3268
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4934,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8345799+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272195",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 272195,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1921,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 109,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163",
      "ID": 3268
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4956,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Keir",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.1156691+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244859",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244859,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1921,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 109,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163",
      "ID": 3268
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Kelly",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5816753+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315030",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315030,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1921,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 109,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163",
      "ID": 3268
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3129,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6710503+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247972",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247972,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1921,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 109,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163",
      "ID": 3268
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann",
      "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4362614+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4016E11P36VM274766",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274766,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1921,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 109,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163",
      "ID": 3268
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4016,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1208277+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255822",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255822,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1921,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 109,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163",
      "ID": 3268
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2180,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5585567+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4938E158P374VM277479",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277479,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1921,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 109,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163",
      "ID": 3268
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4938,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.955126+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2112E250P486VM252990",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252990,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1921,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 109,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163",
      "ID": 3268
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2112,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny",
      "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7621136+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4939E258P394VM277184",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277184,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1921,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 109,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163",
      "ID": 3268
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4939,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus",
      "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.704801+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325562",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 325562,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1921,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 109,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163",
      "ID": 3268
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5074,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon",
      "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5116882+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1828E3P10VM232838",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232838,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1921,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 109,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163",
      "ID": 3268
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1828,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo",
      "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.878643+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311402",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311402,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1921,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 109,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163",
      "ID": 3268
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4948,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike",
      "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8772271+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2117E90P107VM230444",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230444,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1921,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 109,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163",
      "ID": 3268
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2117,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis",
      "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3300971+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267338",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 267338,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1921,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 109,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163",
      "ID": 3268
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken",
      "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0151436+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313759",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313759,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1921,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 109,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163",
      "ID": 3268
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4966,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek",
      "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4094418+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3101E102P129VM295411",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295411,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1921,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 109,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163",
      "ID": 3268
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3101,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala",
      "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5110102+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319005",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319005,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1921,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 109,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163",
      "ID": 3268
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5034,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny",
      "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6883446+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306457",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306457,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1921,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 109,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163",
      "ID": 3268
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2159,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Martin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5528916+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5110E252P395VM311230",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311230,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1921,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 109,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163",
      "ID": 3268
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Mason",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8675976+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268265",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 268265,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1921,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 109,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163",
      "ID": 3268
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2133,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2559791+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2876E141P433VM286307",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286307,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1921,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 109,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163",
      "ID": 3268
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2876,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5731606+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4951E147P368VM260689",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 260689,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1921,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 109,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163",
      "ID": 3268
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4951,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan",
      "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.0880168+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3896E175P307VM264078",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264078,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1921,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 109,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163",
      "ID": 3268
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3896,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam",
      "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9232476+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308409",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 308409,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1921,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 109,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163",
      "ID": 3268
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0547034+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4964E143P375VM279325",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279325,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1921,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 109,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163",
      "ID": 3268
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4964,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.4972968+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279989",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279989,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1921,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 109,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163",
      "ID": 3268
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3824,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5315052+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2066E22P91VM261129",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261129,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1921,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 109,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163",
      "ID": 3268
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2066,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.1130682+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299692",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 299692,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1921,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 109,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163",
      "ID": 3268
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7184529+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306595",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306595,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1921,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 109,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163",
      "ID": 3268
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina",
      "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5588229+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2487E146P369VM301200",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 301200,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1921,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 109,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163",
      "ID": 3268
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2487,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.2515889+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223673",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223673,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1921,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 109,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163",
      "ID": 3268
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4688851+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237468",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237468,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1921,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 109,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163",
      "ID": 3268
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1961,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David",
      "DisplayName": "David McLetchie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2118869+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2134E34P201VM297857",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 297857,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1921,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 109,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163",
      "ID": 3268
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2134,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1279814+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320421",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 320421,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1921,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 109,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163",
      "ID": 3268
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5041,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan",
      "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.165686+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3763E142P397VM316052",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 316052,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1921,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 109,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163",
      "ID": 3268
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3763,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart",
      "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9438859+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1986E23P197VM236312",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 236312,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1921,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 109,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163",
      "ID": 3268
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1986,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan",
      "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9109774+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5047E100P130VM291422",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291422,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1921,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 109,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163",
      "ID": 3268
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5047,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne",
      "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1186212+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234603",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234603,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1921,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 109,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163",
      "ID": 3268
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1845,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette",
      "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3914229+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313622",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313622,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1921,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 109,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163",
      "ID": 3268
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3061,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4033368+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1768E19P265VM288579",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 288579,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1921,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 109,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163",
      "ID": 3268
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1768,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.149482+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225053",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225053,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1921,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 109,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163",
      "ID": 3268
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1894,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Neil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7424994+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3815E98P134VM270892",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270892,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1921,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 109,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163",
      "ID": 3268
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3815,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Park, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Park",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8276896+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265889",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265889,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1921,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 109,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163",
      "ID": 3268
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2010,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil",
      "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4649355+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283515",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283515,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1921,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 109,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163",
      "ID": 3268
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5057,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7112283+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2853E33P128VM251430",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251430,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1921,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 109,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163",
      "ID": 3268
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Pentland",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4632677+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317641",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317641,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1921,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 109,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163",
      "ID": 3268
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5009,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4311618+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254707",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254707,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1921,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 109,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163",
      "ID": 3268
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3745,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis",
      "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.280262+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1870E225P478VM295638",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295638,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1921,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 109,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163",
      "ID": 3268
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1870,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona",
      "DisplayName": "Shona Robison",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.529451+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2135E254P450VM234873",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234873,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1921,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 109,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163",
      "ID": 3268
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2135,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Russell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.403418+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1895E232P431VM257410",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257410,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1921,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 109,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163",
      "ID": 3268
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1895,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0550129+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228112",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 228112,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1921,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 109,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163",
      "ID": 3268
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1839,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5848773+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2345E10P55VM291686",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291686,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1921,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 109,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163",
      "ID": 3268
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2345,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1379497+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2223E176P333VM310687",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 310687,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1921,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 109,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163",
      "ID": 3268
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2223,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish",
      "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5817222+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246333",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 246333,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1921,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 109,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163",
      "ID": 3268
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2182,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1242021+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298328",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298328,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1921,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 109,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163",
      "ID": 3268
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5079,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew",
      "DisplayName": "Drew Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3410038+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234360",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234360,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1921,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 109,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163",
      "ID": 3268
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1769,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3739238+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4014E14P26VM269953",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269953,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1921,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 109,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163",
      "ID": 3268
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4014,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz",
      "DisplayName": "Liz Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5750306+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269505",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269505,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1921,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 109,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163",
      "ID": 3268
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2215,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5505278+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317188",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317188,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1921,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 109,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163",
      "ID": 3268
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3806,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.1854827+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326268",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 326268,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1921,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 109,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163",
      "ID": 3268
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5106,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin",
      "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7511353+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241124",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241124,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1921,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 109,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163",
      "ID": 3268
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1848,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola",
      "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.4030374+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2098E237P531VM289603",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289603,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1921,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 109,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163",
      "ID": 3268
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2098,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Swinney",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4511378+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2674E247P401VM247747",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247747,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1921,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 109,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163",
      "ID": 3268
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2674,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave",
      "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4266833+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5075E234P371VM284865",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 284865,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1921,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 109,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163",
      "ID": 3268
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5075,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Torrance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0510508+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1793E151P362VM222454",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 222454,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1921,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 109,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163",
      "ID": 3268
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1793,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean",
      "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1896452+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5078E245P7VM307104",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307104,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1921,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 109,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163",
      "ID": 3268
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5078,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Walker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5874435+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1841E231P426VM240153",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 240153,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1921,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 109,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163",
      "ID": 3268
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1841,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen",
      "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7812243+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283417",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283417,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1921,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 109,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163",
      "ID": 3268
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4952,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.6998072+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1865E263P500VM232226",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232226,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1921,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 109,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163",
      "ID": 3268
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1865,
      "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra",
      "DisplayName": "Sandra White",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8455769+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237806",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237806,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1921,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 109,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163",
      "ID": 3268
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2610,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Wilson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2268827+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309283",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 309283,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1921,
      "AgendaID": 2096,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 109,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Reform of the Common Fisheries Policy",
      "Reference": "S4M-03163",
      "ID": 3268
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4941,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza",
      "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-07T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.322641+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252656",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252656,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1919,
      "AgendaID": 2158,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 113,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Parliamentary Reform - Standing Orders Rule Changes",
      "Reference": "S4M-03141",
      "ID": 12615
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1926,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian",
      "DisplayName": "Brian Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7388493+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2615E213P388VM258852",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258852,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1919,
      "AgendaID": 2158,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 113,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Parliamentary Reform - Standing Orders Rule Changes",
      "Reference": "S4M-03141",
      "ID": 12615
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2615,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George",
      "DisplayName": "George Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.33067+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319846",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319846,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1919,
      "AgendaID": 2158,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 113,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Parliamentary Reform - Standing Orders Rule Changes",
      "Reference": "S4M-03141",
      "ID": 12615
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4940,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare",
      "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9439021+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249601",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 249601,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1919,
      "AgendaID": 2158,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 113,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Parliamentary Reform - Standing Orders Rule Changes",
      "Reference": "S4M-03141",
      "ID": 12615
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2641,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair",
      "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9338632+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1783E21P273VM227767",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227767,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1919,
      "AgendaID": 2158,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 113,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Parliamentary Reform - Standing Orders Rule Changes",
      "Reference": "S4M-03141",
      "ID": 12615
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1783,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie",
      "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5647651+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2633E97P136VM280770",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280770,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1919,
      "AgendaID": 2158,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 113,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Parliamentary Reform - Standing Orders Rule Changes",
      "Reference": "S4M-03141",
      "ID": 12615
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2633,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire",
      "DisplayName": "Claire Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7816695+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262729",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262729,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1919,
      "AgendaID": 2158,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 113,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Parliamentary Reform - Standing Orders Rule Changes",
      "Reference": "S4M-03141",
      "ID": 12615
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2603,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6143515+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1759E91P115VM229815",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229815,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1919,
      "AgendaID": 2158,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 113,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Parliamentary Reform - Standing Orders Rule Changes",
      "Reference": "S4M-03141",
      "ID": 12615
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia",
      "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0986009+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270175",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270175,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1919,
      "AgendaID": 2158,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 113,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Parliamentary Reform - Standing Orders Rule Changes",
      "Reference": "S4M-03141",
      "ID": 12615
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3751,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.584785+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322732",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 322732,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1919,
      "AgendaID": 2158,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 113,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Parliamentary Reform - Standing Orders Rule Changes",
      "Reference": "S4M-03141",
      "ID": 12615
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5109,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco",
      "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.7012762+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5060E86P124VM295266",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295266,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1919,
      "AgendaID": 2158,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 113,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Parliamentary Reform - Standing Orders Rule Changes",
      "Reference": "S4M-03141",
      "ID": 12615
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5060,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5046058+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242915",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242915,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1919,
      "AgendaID": 2158,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 113,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Parliamentary Reform - Standing Orders Rule Changes",
      "Reference": "S4M-03141",
      "ID": 12615
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1866,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah",
      "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0410175+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235548",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235548,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1919,
      "AgendaID": 2158,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 113,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Parliamentary Reform - Standing Orders Rule Changes",
      "Reference": "S4M-03141",
      "ID": 12615
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1943,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic",
      "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.682561+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302381",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 302381,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1919,
      "AgendaID": 2158,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 113,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Parliamentary Reform - Standing Orders Rule Changes",
      "Reference": "S4M-03141",
      "ID": 12615
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2595,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin",
      "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5219394+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244274",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244274,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1919,
      "AgendaID": 2158,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 113,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Parliamentary Reform - Standing Orders Rule Changes",
      "Reference": "S4M-03141",
      "ID": 12615
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2103,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith",
      "DisplayName": "Keith Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5476004+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327150",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 327150,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1919,
      "AgendaID": 2158,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 113,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Parliamentary Reform - Standing Orders Rule Changes",
      "Reference": "S4M-03141",
      "ID": 12615
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.8012953+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277068",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277068,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1919,
      "AgendaID": 2158,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 113,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Parliamentary Reform - Standing Orders Rule Changes",
      "Reference": "S4M-03141",
      "ID": 12615
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6997162+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264261",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264261,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1919,
      "AgendaID": 2158,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 113,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Parliamentary Reform - Standing Orders Rule Changes",
      "Reference": "S4M-03141",
      "ID": 12615
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2673,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick",
      "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1256642+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248773",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248773,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1919,
      "AgendaID": 2158,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 113,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Parliamentary Reform - Standing Orders Rule Changes",
      "Reference": "S4M-03141",
      "ID": 12615
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2678,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson",
      "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6694447+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2123E27P233VM295769",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295769,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1919,
      "AgendaID": 2158,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 113,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Parliamentary Reform - Standing Orders Rule Changes",
      "Reference": "S4M-03141",
      "ID": 12615
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2123,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm",
      "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5351187+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285233",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285233,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1919,
      "AgendaID": 2158,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 113,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Parliamentary Reform - Standing Orders Rule Changes",
      "Reference": "S4M-03141",
      "ID": 12615
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3907,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3141285+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230709",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230709,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1919,
      "AgendaID": 2158,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 113,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Parliamentary Reform - Standing Orders Rule Changes",
      "Reference": "S4M-03141",
      "ID": 12615
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1735,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela",
      "DisplayName": "Angela Constance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3421677+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243804",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 243804,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1919,
      "AgendaID": 2158,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 113,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Parliamentary Reform - Standing Orders Rule Changes",
      "Reference": "S4M-03141",
      "ID": 12615
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1932,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce",
      "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3204525+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254865",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254865,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1919,
      "AgendaID": 2158,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 113,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Parliamentary Reform - Standing Orders Rule Changes",
      "Reference": "S4M-03141",
      "ID": 12615
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1863,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna",
      "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.287117+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323757",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 323757,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1919,
      "AgendaID": 2158,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 113,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Parliamentary Reform - Standing Orders Rule Changes",
      "Reference": "S4M-03141",
      "ID": 12615
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4976,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth",
      "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9706025+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5107E223P379VM291330",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291330,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1919,
      "AgendaID": 2158,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 113,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Parliamentary Reform - Standing Orders Rule Changes",
      "Reference": "S4M-03141",
      "ID": 12615
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5107,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1143002+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3743E222P391VM265405",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265405,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1919,
      "AgendaID": 2158,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 113,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Parliamentary Reform - Standing Orders Rule Changes",
      "Reference": "S4M-03141",
      "ID": 12615
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3743,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel",
      "DisplayName": "Nigel Don",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.437771+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262251",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262251,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1919,
      "AgendaID": 2158,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 113,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Parliamentary Reform - Standing Orders Rule Changes",
      "Reference": "S4M-03141",
      "ID": 12615
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3771,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob",
      "DisplayName": "Bob Doris",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.59344+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281971",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 281971,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1919,
      "AgendaID": 2158,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 113,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Parliamentary Reform - Standing Orders Rule Changes",
      "Reference": "S4M-03141",
      "ID": 12615
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2826,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Dornan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1656549+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298001",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298001,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1919,
      "AgendaID": 2158,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 113,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Parliamentary Reform - Standing Orders Rule Changes",
      "Reference": "S4M-03141",
      "ID": 12615
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3812,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia",
      "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1340381+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231223",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231223,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1919,
      "AgendaID": 2158,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 113,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Parliamentary Reform - Standing Orders Rule Changes",
      "Reference": "S4M-03141",
      "ID": 12615
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1778,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen",
      "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.5857088+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4955E240P389VM285940",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285940,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1919,
      "AgendaID": 2158,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 113,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Parliamentary Reform - Standing Orders Rule Changes",
      "Reference": "S4M-03141",
      "ID": 12615
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4955,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3510911+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219389",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 219389,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1919,
      "AgendaID": 2158,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 113,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Parliamentary Reform - Standing Orders Rule Changes",
      "Reference": "S4M-03141",
      "ID": 12615
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1742,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle",
      "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.2965575+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238575",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 238575,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1919,
      "AgendaID": 2158,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 113,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Parliamentary Reform - Standing Orders Rule Changes",
      "Reference": "S4M-03141",
      "ID": 12615
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1994,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus",
      "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4600397+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225407",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225407,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1919,
      "AgendaID": 2158,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 113,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Parliamentary Reform - Standing Orders Rule Changes",
      "Reference": "S4M-03141",
      "ID": 12615
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1814,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda",
      "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9734088+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321728",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 321728,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1919,
      "AgendaID": 2158,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 113,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Parliamentary Reform - Standing Orders Rule Changes",
      "Reference": "S4M-03141",
      "ID": 12615
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Fee",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4488655+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292798",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 292798,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1919,
      "AgendaID": 2158,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 113,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Parliamentary Reform - Standing Orders Rule Changes",
      "Reference": "S4M-03141",
      "ID": 12615
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia",
      "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5585861+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227115",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227115,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1919,
      "AgendaID": 2158,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 113,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Parliamentary Reform - Standing Orders Rule Changes",
      "Reference": "S4M-03141",
      "ID": 12615
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2684616+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5054E95P118VM312740",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 312740,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1919,
      "AgendaID": 2158,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 113,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Parliamentary Reform - Standing Orders Rule Changes",
      "Reference": "S4M-03141",
      "ID": 12615
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5054,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1412901+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4947E152P361VM257219",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257219,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1919,
      "AgendaID": 2158,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 113,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Parliamentary Reform - Standing Orders Rule Changes",
      "Reference": "S4M-03141",
      "ID": 12615
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4947,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Finnie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0466931+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271295",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271295,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1919,
      "AgendaID": 2158,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 113,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Parliamentary Reform - Standing Orders Rule Changes",
      "Reference": "S4M-03141",
      "ID": 12615
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3901,
      "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe",
      "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0641251+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278416",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 278416,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1919,
      "AgendaID": 2158,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 113,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Parliamentary Reform - Standing Orders Rule Changes",
      "Reference": "S4M-03141",
      "ID": 12615
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2394,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo",
      "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2178576+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2110E220P414VM287276",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 287276,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1919,
      "AgendaID": 2158,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 113,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Parliamentary Reform - Standing Orders Rule Changes",
      "Reference": "S4M-03141",
      "ID": 12615
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth",
      "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8572194+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250497",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250497,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1919,
      "AgendaID": 2158,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 113,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Parliamentary Reform - Standing Orders Rule Changes",
      "Reference": "S4M-03141",
      "ID": 12615
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2675,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob",
      "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1920915+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1741E10P50VM220964",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220964,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1919,
      "AgendaID": 2158,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 113,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Parliamentary Reform - Standing Orders Rule Changes",
      "Reference": "S4M-03141",
      "ID": 12615
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1741,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel",
      "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6692376+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220254",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220254,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1919,
      "AgendaID": 2158,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 113,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Parliamentary Reform - Standing Orders Rule Changes",
      "Reference": "S4M-03141",
      "ID": 12615
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1756,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine",
      "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6304873+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1860E104P150VM252401",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252401,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1919,
      "AgendaID": 2158,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 113,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Parliamentary Reform - Standing Orders Rule Changes",
      "Reference": "S4M-03141",
      "ID": 12615
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1860,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda",
      "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7275679+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2033E20P141VM266103",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 266103,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1919,
      "AgendaID": 2158,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 113,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Parliamentary Reform - Standing Orders Rule Changes",
      "Reference": "S4M-03141",
      "ID": 12615
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2033,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain",
      "DisplayName": "Iain Gray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4744785+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324648",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324648,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1919,
      "AgendaID": 2158,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 113,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Parliamentary Reform - Standing Orders Rule Changes",
      "Reference": "S4M-03141",
      "ID": 12615
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5042,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2319811+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259720",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 259720,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1919,
      "AgendaID": 2158,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 113,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Parliamentary Reform - Standing Orders Rule Changes",
      "Reference": "S4M-03141",
      "ID": 12615
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick",
      "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6216251+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239322",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239322,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1919,
      "AgendaID": 2158,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 113,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Parliamentary Reform - Standing Orders Rule Changes",
      "Reference": "S4M-03141",
      "ID": 12615
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2029,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh",
      "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7318213+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273732",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 273732,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1919,
      "AgendaID": 2158,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 113,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Parliamentary Reform - Standing Orders Rule Changes",
      "Reference": "S4M-03141",
      "ID": 12615
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3758,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.633278+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304104",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 304104,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1919,
      "AgendaID": 2158,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 113,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Parliamentary Reform - Standing Orders Rule Changes",
      "Reference": "S4M-03141",
      "ID": 12615
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4086,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Hume",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.849853+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221731",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221731,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1919,
      "AgendaID": 2158,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 113,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Parliamentary Reform - Standing Orders Rule Changes",
      "Reference": "S4M-03141",
      "ID": 12615
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1773,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9453577+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1882E227P459VM241964",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241964,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1919,
      "AgendaID": 2158,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 113,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Parliamentary Reform - Standing Orders Rule Changes",
      "Reference": "S4M-03141",
      "ID": 12615
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1882,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam",
      "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7879624+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223707",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223707,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1919,
      "AgendaID": 2158,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 113,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Parliamentary Reform - Standing Orders Rule Changes",
      "Reference": "S4M-03141",
      "ID": 12615
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1893,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4703202+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307585",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307585,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1919,
      "AgendaID": 2158,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 113,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Parliamentary Reform - Standing Orders Rule Changes",
      "Reference": "S4M-03141",
      "ID": 12615
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4934,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.835855+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272234",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 272234,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1919,
      "AgendaID": 2158,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 113,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Parliamentary Reform - Standing Orders Rule Changes",
      "Reference": "S4M-03141",
      "ID": 12615
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4956,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Keir",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3208059+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244924",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244924,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1919,
      "AgendaID": 2158,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 113,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Parliamentary Reform - Standing Orders Rule Changes",
      "Reference": "S4M-03141",
      "ID": 12615
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Kelly",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5844283+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315086",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315086,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1919,
      "AgendaID": 2158,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 113,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Parliamentary Reform - Standing Orders Rule Changes",
      "Reference": "S4M-03141",
      "ID": 12615
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3129,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6734708+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247946",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247946,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1919,
      "AgendaID": 2158,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 113,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Parliamentary Reform - Standing Orders Rule Changes",
      "Reference": "S4M-03141",
      "ID": 12615
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann",
      "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.435148+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4016E11P36VM274790",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274790,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1919,
      "AgendaID": 2158,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 113,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Parliamentary Reform - Standing Orders Rule Changes",
      "Reference": "S4M-03141",
      "ID": 12615
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4016,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1218605+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255796",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255796,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1919,
      "AgendaID": 2158,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 113,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Parliamentary Reform - Standing Orders Rule Changes",
      "Reference": "S4M-03141",
      "ID": 12615
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2180,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5574329+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4938E158P374VM277455",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277455,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1919,
      "AgendaID": 2158,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 113,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Parliamentary Reform - Standing Orders Rule Changes",
      "Reference": "S4M-03141",
      "ID": 12615
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4938,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9541+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2112E250P486VM253016",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253016,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1919,
      "AgendaID": 2158,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 113,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Parliamentary Reform - Standing Orders Rule Changes",
      "Reference": "S4M-03141",
      "ID": 12615
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2112,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny",
      "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7632263+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4939E258P394VM276839",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276839,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1919,
      "AgendaID": 2158,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 113,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Parliamentary Reform - Standing Orders Rule Changes",
      "Reference": "S4M-03141",
      "ID": 12615
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4939,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus",
      "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6833201+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325483",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 325483,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1919,
      "AgendaID": 2158,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 113,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Parliamentary Reform - Standing Orders Rule Changes",
      "Reference": "S4M-03141",
      "ID": 12615
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5074,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon",
      "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5083354+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1828E3P10VM232904",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232904,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1919,
      "AgendaID": 2158,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 113,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Parliamentary Reform - Standing Orders Rule Changes",
      "Reference": "S4M-03141",
      "ID": 12615
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1828,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo",
      "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8816508+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311431",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311431,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1919,
      "AgendaID": 2158,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 113,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Parliamentary Reform - Standing Orders Rule Changes",
      "Reference": "S4M-03141",
      "ID": 12615
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4948,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike",
      "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8785099+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2117E90P107VM230407",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230407,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1919,
      "AgendaID": 2158,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 113,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Parliamentary Reform - Standing Orders Rule Changes",
      "Reference": "S4M-03141",
      "ID": 12615
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2117,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis",
      "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3284658+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267368",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 267368,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1919,
      "AgendaID": 2158,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 113,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Parliamentary Reform - Standing Orders Rule Changes",
      "Reference": "S4M-03141",
      "ID": 12615
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken",
      "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.016424+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313730",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313730,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1919,
      "AgendaID": 2158,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 113,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Parliamentary Reform - Standing Orders Rule Changes",
      "Reference": "S4M-03141",
      "ID": 12615
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4966,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek",
      "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4081914+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3101E102P129VM295073",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295073,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1919,
      "AgendaID": 2158,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 113,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Parliamentary Reform - Standing Orders Rule Changes",
      "Reference": "S4M-03141",
      "ID": 12615
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3101,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala",
      "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.19103+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5034E88P114VM318977",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 318977,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1919,
      "AgendaID": 2158,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 113,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Parliamentary Reform - Standing Orders Rule Changes",
      "Reference": "S4M-03141",
      "ID": 12615
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5034,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny",
      "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6871321+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306400",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306400,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1919,
      "AgendaID": 2158,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 113,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Parliamentary Reform - Standing Orders Rule Changes",
      "Reference": "S4M-03141",
      "ID": 12615
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2159,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Martin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5504596+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5110E252P395VM310800",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 310800,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1919,
      "AgendaID": 2158,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 113,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Parliamentary Reform - Standing Orders Rule Changes",
      "Reference": "S4M-03141",
      "ID": 12615
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Mason",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5865788+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268235",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 268235,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1919,
      "AgendaID": 2158,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 113,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Parliamentary Reform - Standing Orders Rule Changes",
      "Reference": "S4M-03141",
      "ID": 12615
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2133,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2546879+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2876E141P433VM286337",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286337,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1919,
      "AgendaID": 2158,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 113,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Parliamentary Reform - Standing Orders Rule Changes",
      "Reference": "S4M-03141",
      "ID": 12615
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2876,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5744743+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4951E147P368VM258637",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258637,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1919,
      "AgendaID": 2158,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 113,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Parliamentary Reform - Standing Orders Rule Changes",
      "Reference": "S4M-03141",
      "ID": 12615
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4951,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan",
      "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.316074+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3896E175P307VM263888",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 263888,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1919,
      "AgendaID": 2158,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 113,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Parliamentary Reform - Standing Orders Rule Changes",
      "Reference": "S4M-03141",
      "ID": 12615
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3896,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam",
      "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9151177+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308532",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 308532,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1919,
      "AgendaID": 2158,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 113,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Parliamentary Reform - Standing Orders Rule Changes",
      "Reference": "S4M-03141",
      "ID": 12615
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0599759+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4964E143P375VM279668",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279668,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1919,
      "AgendaID": 2158,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 113,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Parliamentary Reform - Standing Orders Rule Changes",
      "Reference": "S4M-03141",
      "ID": 12615
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4964,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5175101+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279604",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279604,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1919,
      "AgendaID": 2158,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 113,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Parliamentary Reform - Standing Orders Rule Changes",
      "Reference": "S4M-03141",
      "ID": 12615
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3824,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5148051+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2066E22P91VM261065",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261065,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1919,
      "AgendaID": 2158,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 113,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Parliamentary Reform - Standing Orders Rule Changes",
      "Reference": "S4M-03141",
      "ID": 12615
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2066,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.1102908+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299662",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 299662,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1919,
      "AgendaID": 2158,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 113,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Parliamentary Reform - Standing Orders Rule Changes",
      "Reference": "S4M-03141",
      "ID": 12615
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7073735+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306718",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306718,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1919,
      "AgendaID": 2158,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 113,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Parliamentary Reform - Standing Orders Rule Changes",
      "Reference": "S4M-03141",
      "ID": 12615
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina",
      "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5644265+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300616",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 300616,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1919,
      "AgendaID": 2158,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 113,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Parliamentary Reform - Standing Orders Rule Changes",
      "Reference": "S4M-03141",
      "ID": 12615
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2487,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0062686+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223867",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223867,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1919,
      "AgendaID": 2158,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 113,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Parliamentary Reform - Standing Orders Rule Changes",
      "Reference": "S4M-03141",
      "ID": 12615
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4771996+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237494",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237494,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1919,
      "AgendaID": 2158,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 113,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Parliamentary Reform - Standing Orders Rule Changes",
      "Reference": "S4M-03141",
      "ID": 12615
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1961,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David",
      "DisplayName": "David McLetchie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2130374+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305467",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 305467,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1919,
      "AgendaID": 2158,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 113,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Parliamentary Reform - Standing Orders Rule Changes",
      "Reference": "S4M-03141",
      "ID": 12615
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2134,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3253502+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320604",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 320604,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1919,
      "AgendaID": 2158,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 113,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Parliamentary Reform - Standing Orders Rule Changes",
      "Reference": "S4M-03141",
      "ID": 12615
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5041,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan",
      "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.173557+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315996",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315996,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1919,
      "AgendaID": 2158,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 113,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Parliamentary Reform - Standing Orders Rule Changes",
      "Reference": "S4M-03141",
      "ID": 12615
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3763,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart",
      "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9412546+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1986E23P197VM236696",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 236696,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1919,
      "AgendaID": 2158,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 113,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Parliamentary Reform - Standing Orders Rule Changes",
      "Reference": "S4M-03141",
      "ID": 12615
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1986,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan",
      "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9361238+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5047E100P130VM289808",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289808,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1919,
      "AgendaID": 2158,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 113,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Parliamentary Reform - Standing Orders Rule Changes",
      "Reference": "S4M-03141",
      "ID": 12615
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5047,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne",
      "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4599714+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234536",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234536,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1919,
      "AgendaID": 2158,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 113,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Parliamentary Reform - Standing Orders Rule Changes",
      "Reference": "S4M-03141",
      "ID": 12615
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1845,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette",
      "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3885228+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313566",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313566,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1919,
      "AgendaID": 2158,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 113,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Parliamentary Reform - Standing Orders Rule Changes",
      "Reference": "S4M-03141",
      "ID": 12615
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3061,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4009105+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1768E19P265VM289322",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289322,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1919,
      "AgendaID": 2158,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 113,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Parliamentary Reform - Standing Orders Rule Changes",
      "Reference": "S4M-03141",
      "ID": 12615
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1768,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4322714+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225078",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225078,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1919,
      "AgendaID": 2158,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 113,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Parliamentary Reform - Standing Orders Rule Changes",
      "Reference": "S4M-03141",
      "ID": 12615
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1894,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Neil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7435492+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3815E98P134VM270911",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270911,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1919,
      "AgendaID": 2158,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 113,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Parliamentary Reform - Standing Orders Rule Changes",
      "Reference": "S4M-03141",
      "ID": 12615
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3815,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Park, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Park",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8287591+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265822",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265822,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1919,
      "AgendaID": 2158,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 113,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Parliamentary Reform - Standing Orders Rule Changes",
      "Reference": "S4M-03141",
      "ID": 12615
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2010,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil",
      "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4559847+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283321",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283321,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1919,
      "AgendaID": 2158,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 113,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Parliamentary Reform - Standing Orders Rule Changes",
      "Reference": "S4M-03141",
      "ID": 12615
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5057,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.6956578+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2853E33P128VM251466",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251466,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1919,
      "AgendaID": 2158,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 113,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Parliamentary Reform - Standing Orders Rule Changes",
      "Reference": "S4M-03141",
      "ID": 12615
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Pentland",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.464876+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317823",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317823,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1919,
      "AgendaID": 2158,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 113,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Parliamentary Reform - Standing Orders Rule Changes",
      "Reference": "S4M-03141",
      "ID": 12615
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5009,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.438899+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254666",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254666,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1919,
      "AgendaID": 2158,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 113,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Parliamentary Reform - Standing Orders Rule Changes",
      "Reference": "S4M-03141",
      "ID": 12615
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3745,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis",
      "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2664187+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1870E225P478VM296223",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 296223,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1919,
      "AgendaID": 2158,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 113,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Parliamentary Reform - Standing Orders Rule Changes",
      "Reference": "S4M-03141",
      "ID": 12615
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1870,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona",
      "DisplayName": "Shona Robison",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8393618+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2135E254P450VM234910",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234910,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1919,
      "AgendaID": 2158,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 113,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Parliamentary Reform - Standing Orders Rule Changes",
      "Reference": "S4M-03141",
      "ID": 12615
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2135,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Russell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4050278+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1895E232P431VM257634",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257634,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1919,
      "AgendaID": 2158,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 113,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Parliamentary Reform - Standing Orders Rule Changes",
      "Reference": "S4M-03141",
      "ID": 12615
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1895,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0649586+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228152",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 228152,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1919,
      "AgendaID": 2158,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 113,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Parliamentary Reform - Standing Orders Rule Changes",
      "Reference": "S4M-03141",
      "ID": 12615
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1839,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5865939+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2345E10P55VM291618",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291618,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1919,
      "AgendaID": 2158,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 113,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Parliamentary Reform - Standing Orders Rule Changes",
      "Reference": "S4M-03141",
      "ID": 12615
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2345,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1350652+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311055",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311055,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1919,
      "AgendaID": 2158,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 113,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Parliamentary Reform - Standing Orders Rule Changes",
      "Reference": "S4M-03141",
      "ID": 12615
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2223,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish",
      "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.6034785+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246372",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 246372,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1919,
      "AgendaID": 2158,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 113,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Parliamentary Reform - Standing Orders Rule Changes",
      "Reference": "S4M-03141",
      "ID": 12615
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2182,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1259006+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298102",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298102,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1919,
      "AgendaID": 2158,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 113,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Parliamentary Reform - Standing Orders Rule Changes",
      "Reference": "S4M-03141",
      "ID": 12615
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5079,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew",
      "DisplayName": "Drew Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1383274+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234134",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234134,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1919,
      "AgendaID": 2158,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 113,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Parliamentary Reform - Standing Orders Rule Changes",
      "Reference": "S4M-03141",
      "ID": 12615
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1769,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1680938+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274578",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274578,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1919,
      "AgendaID": 2158,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 113,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Parliamentary Reform - Standing Orders Rule Changes",
      "Reference": "S4M-03141",
      "ID": 12615
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4014,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz",
      "DisplayName": "Liz Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1126677+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269535",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269535,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1919,
      "AgendaID": 2158,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 113,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Parliamentary Reform - Standing Orders Rule Changes",
      "Reference": "S4M-03141",
      "ID": 12615
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2215,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5518286+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317397",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317397,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1919,
      "AgendaID": 2158,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 113,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Parliamentary Reform - Standing Orders Rule Changes",
      "Reference": "S4M-03141",
      "ID": 12615
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3806,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4203582+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326347",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 326347,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1919,
      "AgendaID": 2158,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 113,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Parliamentary Reform - Standing Orders Rule Changes",
      "Reference": "S4M-03141",
      "ID": 12615
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5106,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin",
      "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7545348+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241165",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241165,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1919,
      "AgendaID": 2158,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 113,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Parliamentary Reform - Standing Orders Rule Changes",
      "Reference": "S4M-03141",
      "ID": 12615
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1848,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola",
      "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.4048395+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2098E237P531VM289667",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289667,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1919,
      "AgendaID": 2158,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 113,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Parliamentary Reform - Standing Orders Rule Changes",
      "Reference": "S4M-03141",
      "ID": 12615
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2098,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Swinney",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4538114+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2674E247P401VM247784",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247784,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1919,
      "AgendaID": 2158,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 113,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Parliamentary Reform - Standing Orders Rule Changes",
      "Reference": "S4M-03141",
      "ID": 12615
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2674,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave",
      "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4282961+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5075E234P371VM287389",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 287389,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1919,
      "AgendaID": 2158,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 113,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Parliamentary Reform - Standing Orders Rule Changes",
      "Reference": "S4M-03141",
      "ID": 12615
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5075,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Torrance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8621224+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1793E151P362VM222479",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 222479,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1919,
      "AgendaID": 2158,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 113,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Parliamentary Reform - Standing Orders Rule Changes",
      "Reference": "S4M-03141",
      "ID": 12615
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1793,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean",
      "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1907348+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5078E245P7VM306987",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306987,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1919,
      "AgendaID": 2158,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 113,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Parliamentary Reform - Standing Orders Rule Changes",
      "Reference": "S4M-03141",
      "ID": 12615
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5078,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Walker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5824399+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1841E231P426VM239958",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239958,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1919,
      "AgendaID": 2158,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 113,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Parliamentary Reform - Standing Orders Rule Changes",
      "Reference": "S4M-03141",
      "ID": 12615
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1841,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen",
      "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7666365+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283441",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283441,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1919,
      "AgendaID": 2158,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 113,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Parliamentary Reform - Standing Orders Rule Changes",
      "Reference": "S4M-03141",
      "ID": 12615
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4952,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7080071+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1865E263P500VM232197",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232197,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1919,
      "AgendaID": 2158,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 113,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Parliamentary Reform - Standing Orders Rule Changes",
      "Reference": "S4M-03141",
      "ID": 12615
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1865,
      "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra",
      "DisplayName": "Sandra White",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6389934+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237769",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237769,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1919,
      "AgendaID": 2158,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 113,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Parliamentary Reform - Standing Orders Rule Changes",
      "Reference": "S4M-03141",
      "ID": 12615
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2610,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Wilson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2253296+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309253",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 309253,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1919,
      "AgendaID": 2158,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 113,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Parliamentary Reform - Standing Orders Rule Changes",
      "Reference": "S4M-03141",
      "ID": 12615
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4941,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza",
      "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-06-06T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3213509+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1926E229P470VM253107",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253107,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1918,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113.3",
      "ID": 3246
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1926,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian",
      "DisplayName": "Brian Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.767074+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2615E213P388VM259466",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 259466,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1918,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113.3",
      "ID": 3246
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2615,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George",
      "DisplayName": "George Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6103112+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4940E159P373VM317820",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317820,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1918,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113.3",
      "ID": 3246
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4940,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare",
      "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4387723+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2641E256P403VM250166",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250166,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1918,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113.3",
      "ID": 3246
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2641,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair",
      "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9662753+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1783E21P273VM228455",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 228455,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1918,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113.3",
      "ID": 3246
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1783,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie",
      "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.7998141+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2633E97P136VM281149",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 281149,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1918,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113.3",
      "ID": 3246
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2633,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire",
      "DisplayName": "Claire Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.8080703+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2603E89P148VM263113",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 263113,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1918,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113.3",
      "ID": 3246
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2603,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6373309+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1759E91P115VM227542",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227542,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1918,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113.3",
      "ID": 3246
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia",
      "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5546245+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270715",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270715,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1918,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113.3",
      "ID": 3246
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3751,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8199673+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322458",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 322458,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1918,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113.3",
      "ID": 3246
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5109,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco",
      "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.689493+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5060E86P124VM297338",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 297338,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1918,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113.3",
      "ID": 3246
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5060,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.0956526+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242699",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242699,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1918,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113.3",
      "ID": 3246
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1866,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah",
      "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.031797+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1943E145P367VM236982",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 236982,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1918,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113.3",
      "ID": 3246
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1943,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic",
      "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9486841+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2595E12P30VM301671",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 301671,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1918,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113.3",
      "ID": 3246
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2595,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin",
      "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.2724855+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2103E244P421VM262005",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262005,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1918,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113.3",
      "ID": 3246
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2103,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith",
      "DisplayName": "Keith Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3875222+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5108E221P387VM326577",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 326577,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1918,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113.3",
      "ID": 3246
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7707247+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277611",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277611,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1918,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113.3",
      "ID": 3246
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9607408+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264996",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264996,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1918,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113.3",
      "ID": 3246
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2673,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick",
      "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1636596+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2678E11P28VM249328",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 249328,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1918,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113.3",
      "ID": 3246
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2678,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson",
      "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.921852+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2123E27P233VM291156",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291156,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1918,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113.3",
      "ID": 3246
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2123,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm",
      "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7881015+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285464",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285464,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1918,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113.3",
      "ID": 3246
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3907,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.330379+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1735E248P405VM231402",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231402,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1918,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113.3",
      "ID": 3246
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1735,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela",
      "DisplayName": "Angela Constance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.5986282+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243172",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 243172,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1918,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113.3",
      "ID": 3246
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1932,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce",
      "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0572385+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1863E238P523VM253978",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253978,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1918,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113.3",
      "ID": 3246
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1863,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna",
      "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0292654+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4976E20P31VM321144",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 321144,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1918,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113.3",
      "ID": 3246
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4976,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth",
      "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.2041599+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5107E223P379VM292434",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 292434,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1918,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113.3",
      "ID": 3246
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5107,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5336237+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3743E222P391VM273163",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 273163,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1918,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113.3",
      "ID": 3246
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3743,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel",
      "DisplayName": "Nigel Don",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3723107+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262861",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262861,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1918,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113.3",
      "ID": 3246
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3771,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob",
      "DisplayName": "Bob Doris",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6261345+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281744",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 281744,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1918,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113.3",
      "ID": 3246
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2826,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Dornan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1557962+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298535",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298535,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1918,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113.3",
      "ID": 3246
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3812,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia",
      "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3503037+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1778E28P260VM230619",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230619,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1918,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113.3",
      "ID": 3246
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1778,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen",
      "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3381958+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4955E240P389VM287187",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 287187,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1918,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113.3",
      "ID": 3246
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4955,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.6229012+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219693",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 219693,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1918,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113.3",
      "ID": 3246
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1742,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle",
      "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3104278+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1994E257P537VM239115",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239115,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1918,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113.3",
      "ID": 3246
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1994,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus",
      "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4959383+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1814E269P519VM226283",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 226283,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1918,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113.3",
      "ID": 3246
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1814,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda",
      "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2188965+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5059E85P123VM322002",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 322002,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1918,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113.3",
      "ID": 3246
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Fee",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4670375+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292665",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 292665,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1918,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113.3",
      "ID": 3246
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia",
      "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5525862+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227720",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227720,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1918,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113.3",
      "ID": 3246
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.562762+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5054E95P118VM304394",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 304394,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1918,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113.3",
      "ID": 3246
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5054,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.0363623+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4947E152P361VM257960",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257960,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1918,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113.3",
      "ID": 3246
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4947,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Finnie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.085305+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271693",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271693,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1918,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113.3",
      "ID": 3246
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3901,
      "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe",
      "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0874076+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2394E15P47VM274324",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274324,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1918,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113.3",
      "ID": 3246
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2394,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo",
      "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.0956818+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2110E220P414VM266485",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 266485,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1918,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113.3",
      "ID": 3246
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth",
      "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.7431915+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250777",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250777,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1918,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113.3",
      "ID": 3246
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2675,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob",
      "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.2130847+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221243",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221243,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1918,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113.3",
      "ID": 3246
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1741,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel",
      "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9209247+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1756E218P467VM226371",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 226371,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1918,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113.3",
      "ID": 3246
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1756,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine",
      "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2284665+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1860E104P150VM239795",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239795,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1918,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113.3",
      "ID": 3246
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1860,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda",
      "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7592351+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2033E20P141VM253182",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253182,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1918,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113.3",
      "ID": 3246
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2033,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain",
      "DisplayName": "Iain Gray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7702052+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324403",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324403,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1918,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113.3",
      "ID": 3246
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5042,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2152368+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2892E76P97VM260896",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 260896,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1918,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113.3",
      "ID": 3246
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick",
      "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.1026469+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2029E24P170VM246109",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 246109,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1918,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113.3",
      "ID": 3246
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2029,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh",
      "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8726097+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3758E268P409VM276191",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276191,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1918,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113.3",
      "ID": 3246
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3758,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.4144046+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4086E128P311VM303197",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 303197,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1918,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113.3",
      "ID": 3246
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4086,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Hume",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8043581+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1773E242P494VM222296",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 222296,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1918,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113.3",
      "ID": 3246
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1773,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1826402+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1882E227P459VM245581",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 245581,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1918,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113.3",
      "ID": 3246
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1882,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam",
      "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8496104+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1893E16P69VM224714",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 224714,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1918,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113.3",
      "ID": 3246
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1893,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7167773+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4934E77P103VM308118",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 308118,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1918,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113.3",
      "ID": 3246
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4934,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8655008+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272514",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 272514,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1918,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113.3",
      "ID": 3246
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4956,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Keir",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3386777+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244708",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244708,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1918,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113.3",
      "ID": 3246
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Kelly",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5748642+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3129E261P419VM314727",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 314727,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1918,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113.3",
      "ID": 3246
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3129,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6528865+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2080E36P220VM252504",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252504,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1918,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113.3",
      "ID": 3246
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann",
      "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7319898+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4016E11P36VM275612",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 275612,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1918,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113.3",
      "ID": 3246
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4016,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.3830205+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2180E246P463VM257100",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257100,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1918,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113.3",
      "ID": 3246
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2180,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.8233074+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4938E158P374VM282880",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 282880,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1918,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113.3",
      "ID": 3246
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4938,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.4383098+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2112E250P486VM254096",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254096,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1918,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113.3",
      "ID": 3246
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2112,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny",
      "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0343254+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4939E258P394VM278781",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 278781,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1918,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113.3",
      "ID": 3246
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4939,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus",
      "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2339926+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5074E251P385VM324882",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324882,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1918,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113.3",
      "ID": 3246
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5074,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon",
      "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2418592+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1828E3P10VM231977",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231977,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1918,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113.3",
      "ID": 3246
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1828,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo",
      "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.623917+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4948E153P363VM312117",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 312117,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1918,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113.3",
      "ID": 3246
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4948,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike",
      "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.9144488+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2117E90P107VM233101",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 233101,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1918,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113.3",
      "ID": 3246
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2117,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis",
      "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8968948+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267594",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 267594,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1918,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113.3",
      "ID": 3246
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken",
      "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0266164+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313043",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313043,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1918,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113.3",
      "ID": 3246
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4966,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek",
      "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1611757+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3101E102P129VM294381",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 294381,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1918,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113.3",
      "ID": 3246
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3101,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala",
      "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1358907+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319251",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319251,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1918,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113.3",
      "ID": 3246
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5034,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny",
      "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9119869+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2159E25P205VM305787",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 305787,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1918,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113.3",
      "ID": 3246
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2159,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Martin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3453134+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5110E252P395VM310365",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 310365,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1918,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113.3",
      "ID": 3246
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Mason",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5673751+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268010",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 268010,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1918,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113.3",
      "ID": 3246
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2133,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0520993+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2876E141P433VM293045",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 293045,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1918,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113.3",
      "ID": 3246
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2876,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5692524+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4951E147P368VM271435",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271435,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1918,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113.3",
      "ID": 3246
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4951,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan",
      "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0756917+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3896E175P307VM269406",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269406,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1918,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113.3",
      "ID": 3246
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3896,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam",
      "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5461767+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5080E110P121VM307230",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307230,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1918,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113.3",
      "ID": 3246
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8202586+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4964E143P375VM280575",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280575,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1918,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113.3",
      "ID": 3246
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4964,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7731137+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3824E84P113VM281269",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 281269,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1918,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113.3",
      "ID": 3246
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3824,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1275571+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2066E22P91VM245180",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 245180,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1918,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113.3",
      "ID": 3246
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2066,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.6076707+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299282",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 299282,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1918,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113.3",
      "ID": 3246
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.6907496+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3759E260P411VM301788",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 301788,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1918,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113.3",
      "ID": 3246
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina",
      "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.2832603+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300483",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 300483,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1918,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113.3",
      "ID": 3246
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2487,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.000129+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1775E215P453VM224300",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 224300,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1918,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113.3",
      "ID": 3246
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.6929866+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237964",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237964,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1918,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113.3",
      "ID": 3246
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1961,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David",
      "DisplayName": "David McLetchie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2336905+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2134E34P201VM297709",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 297709,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1918,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113.3",
      "ID": 3246
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2134,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1214351+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320019",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 320019,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1918,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113.3",
      "ID": 3246
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5041,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan",
      "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9579022+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315354",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315354,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1918,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113.3",
      "ID": 3246
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3763,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart",
      "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9083662+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1986E23P197VM237239",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237239,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1918,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113.3",
      "ID": 3246
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1986,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan",
      "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.1956564+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5047E100P130VM292575",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 292575,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1918,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113.3",
      "ID": 3246
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5047,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne",
      "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5487089+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1845E17P40VM233966",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 233966,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1918,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113.3",
      "ID": 3246
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1845,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette",
      "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1540683+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3061E19P43VM311635",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311635,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1918,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113.3",
      "ID": 3246
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3061,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8876609+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1768E19P265VM261302",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261302,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1918,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113.3",
      "ID": 3246
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1768,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3515191+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225695",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225695,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1918,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113.3",
      "ID": 3246
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1894,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Neil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9863968+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3815E98P134VM271010",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271010,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1918,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113.3",
      "ID": 3246
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3815,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Park, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Park",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8386592+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265559",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265559,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1918,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113.3",
      "ID": 3246
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2010,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil",
      "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4443964+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283952",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283952,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1918,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113.3",
      "ID": 3246
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5057,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.73058+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2853E33P128VM258712",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258712,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1918,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113.3",
      "ID": 3246
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Pentland",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3193842+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317242",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317242,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1918,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113.3",
      "ID": 3246
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5009,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4099645+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3745E233P381VM256128",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 256128,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1918,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113.3",
      "ID": 3246
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3745,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis",
      "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5718221+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1870E225P478VM293359",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 293359,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1918,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113.3",
      "ID": 3246
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1870,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona",
      "DisplayName": "Shona Robison",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8416093+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2135E254P450VM235982",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235982,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1918,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113.3",
      "ID": 3246
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2135,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Russell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.7012953+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1895E232P431VM255995",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255995,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1918,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113.3",
      "ID": 3246
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1895,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5658447+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1839E21P87VM229354",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229354,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1918,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113.3",
      "ID": 3246
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1839,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0781055+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2345E10P55VM288400",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 288400,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1918,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113.3",
      "ID": 3246
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2345,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1332206+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2223E176P333VM310539",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 310539,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1918,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113.3",
      "ID": 3246
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2223,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish",
      "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5752418+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2182E87P175VM247111",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247111,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1918,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113.3",
      "ID": 3246
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2182,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1675342+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298703",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298703,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1918,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113.3",
      "ID": 3246
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5079,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew",
      "DisplayName": "Drew Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3686206+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1769E32P285VM235821",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235821,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1918,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113.3",
      "ID": 3246
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1769,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6944221+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4014E14P26VM275343",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 275343,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1918,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113.3",
      "ID": 3246
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4014,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz",
      "DisplayName": "Liz Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.3660218+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2215E224P447VM270070",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270070,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1918,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113.3",
      "ID": 3246
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2215,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5802524+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3806E103P127VM316886",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 316886,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1918,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113.3",
      "ID": 3246
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3806,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.1676654+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326102",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 326102,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1918,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113.3",
      "ID": 3246
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5106,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin",
      "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5399571+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241445",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241445,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1918,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113.3",
      "ID": 3246
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1848,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola",
      "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7582683+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2098E237P531VM288685",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 288685,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1918,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113.3",
      "ID": 3246
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2098,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Swinney",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1540184+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248234",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248234,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1918,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113.3",
      "ID": 3246
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2674,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave",
      "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6370908+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5075E234P371VM290069",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 290069,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1918,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113.3",
      "ID": 3246
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5075,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Torrance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4714322+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1793E151P362VM222786",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 222786,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1918,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113.3",
      "ID": 3246
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1793,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean",
      "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.2046478+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5078E245P7VM306896",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306896,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1918,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113.3",
      "ID": 3246
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5078,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Walker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5782443+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1841E231P426VM240830",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 240830,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1918,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113.3",
      "ID": 3246
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1841,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen",
      "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3841056+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4952E148P370VM284105",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 284105,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1918,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113.3",
      "ID": 3246
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4952,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7432134+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1865E263P500VM231052",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231052,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1918,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113.3",
      "ID": 3246
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1865,
      "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra",
      "DisplayName": "Sandra White",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.363556+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2610E160P413VM246752",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 246752,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1918,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113.3",
      "ID": 3246
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2610,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Wilson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.151907+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4941E150P382VM308872",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 308872,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1918,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113.3",
      "ID": 3246
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4941,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza",
      "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0816938+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1926E229P470VM253108",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253108,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1917,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 69,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113",
      "ID": 3214
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1926,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian",
      "DisplayName": "Brian Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7671331+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2615E213P388VM259467",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 259467,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1917,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 69,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113",
      "ID": 3214
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2615,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George",
      "DisplayName": "George Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6103527+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4940E159P373VM317819",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317819,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1917,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 69,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113",
      "ID": 3214
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4940,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare",
      "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4387304+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2641E256P403VM250165",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250165,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1917,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 69,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113",
      "ID": 3214
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2641,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair",
      "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9662294+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1783E21P273VM228456",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 228456,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1917,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 69,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113",
      "ID": 3214
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1783,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie",
      "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.7998558+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2633E97P136VM281152",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 281152,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1917,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 69,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113",
      "ID": 3214
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2633,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire",
      "DisplayName": "Claire Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.8081924+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2603E89P148VM263114",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 263114,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1917,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 69,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113",
      "ID": 3214
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2603,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6373717+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1759E91P115VM227543",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227543,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1917,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 69,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113",
      "ID": 3214
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia",
      "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5546653+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270714",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270714,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1917,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 69,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113",
      "ID": 3214
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3751,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8199257+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322449",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 322449,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1917,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 69,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113",
      "ID": 3214
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5109,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco",
      "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6891188+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5060E86P124VM297339",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 297339,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1917,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 69,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113",
      "ID": 3214
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5060,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.0956935+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242700",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242700,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1917,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 69,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113",
      "ID": 3214
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1866,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah",
      "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0318368+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1943E145P367VM236981",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 236981,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1917,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 69,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113",
      "ID": 3214
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1943,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic",
      "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9486424+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2595E12P30VM301672",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 301672,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1917,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 69,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113",
      "ID": 3214
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2595,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin",
      "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.2725442+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2103E244P421VM262004",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262004,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1917,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 69,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113",
      "ID": 3214
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2103,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith",
      "DisplayName": "Keith Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3874615+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5108E221P387VM326572",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 326572,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1917,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 69,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113",
      "ID": 3214
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7705115+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277612",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277612,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1917,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 69,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113",
      "ID": 3214
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9607808+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264995",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264995,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1917,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 69,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113",
      "ID": 3214
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2673,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick",
      "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1636185+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2678E11P28VM249327",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 249327,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1917,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 69,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113",
      "ID": 3214
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2678,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson",
      "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9218093+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2123E27P233VM291155",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291155,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1917,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 69,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113",
      "ID": 3214
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2123,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm",
      "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7880602+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285465",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285465,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1917,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 69,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113",
      "ID": 3214
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3907,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3304204+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1735E248P405VM231403",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231403,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1917,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 69,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113",
      "ID": 3214
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1735,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela",
      "DisplayName": "Angela Constance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.598669+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243171",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 243171,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1917,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 69,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113",
      "ID": 3214
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1932,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce",
      "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0571973+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1863E238P523VM253977",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253977,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1917,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 69,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113",
      "ID": 3214
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1863,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna",
      "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0292245+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4976E20P31VM321139",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 321139,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1917,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 69,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113",
      "ID": 3214
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4976,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth",
      "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.2039532+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5107E223P379VM292433",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 292433,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1917,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 69,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113",
      "ID": 3214
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5107,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5335829+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3743E222P391VM273164",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 273164,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1917,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 69,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113",
      "ID": 3214
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3743,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel",
      "DisplayName": "Nigel Don",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3723528+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262862",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262862,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1917,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 69,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113",
      "ID": 3214
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3771,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob",
      "DisplayName": "Bob Doris",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6261753+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281741",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 281741,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1917,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 69,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113",
      "ID": 3214
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2826,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Dornan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1556548+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298538",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298538,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1917,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 69,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113",
      "ID": 3214
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3812,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia",
      "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3504489+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1778E28P260VM230618",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230618,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1917,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 69,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113",
      "ID": 3214
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1778,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen",
      "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3381548+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4955E240P389VM287186",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 287186,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1917,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 69,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113",
      "ID": 3214
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4955,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.6228602+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219694",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 219694,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1917,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 69,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113",
      "ID": 3214
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1742,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle",
      "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3104689+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1994E257P537VM239114",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239114,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1917,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 69,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113",
      "ID": 3214
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1994,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus",
      "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4958969+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1814E269P519VM226282",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 226282,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1917,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 69,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113",
      "ID": 3214
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1814,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda",
      "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2188548+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5059E85P123VM322011",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 322011,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1917,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 69,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113",
      "ID": 3214
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Fee",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.467427+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1853E35P216VM291822",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291822,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1917,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 69,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113",
      "ID": 3214
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia",
      "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1439784+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227721",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227721,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1917,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 69,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113",
      "ID": 3214
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5628026+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5054E95P118VM304395",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 304395,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1917,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 69,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113",
      "ID": 3214
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5054,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.0364031+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4947E152P361VM257961",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257961,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1917,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 69,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113",
      "ID": 3214
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4947,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Finnie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0853458+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271692",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271692,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1917,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 69,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113",
      "ID": 3214
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3901,
      "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe",
      "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.087365+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2394E15P47VM274321",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274321,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1917,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 69,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113",
      "ID": 3214
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2394,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo",
      "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.0955559+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2110E220P414VM266486",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 266486,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1917,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 69,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113",
      "ID": 3214
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth",
      "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.7432366+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250778",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250778,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1917,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 69,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113",
      "ID": 3214
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2675,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob",
      "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.2131246+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221244",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221244,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1917,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 69,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113",
      "ID": 3214
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1741,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel",
      "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9209671+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1756E218P467VM226370",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 226370,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1917,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 69,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113",
      "ID": 3214
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1756,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine",
      "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2284236+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1860E104P150VM239796",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239796,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1917,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 69,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113",
      "ID": 3214
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1860,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda",
      "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7592761+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2033E20P141VM253179",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253179,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1917,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 69,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113",
      "ID": 3214
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2033,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain",
      "DisplayName": "Iain Gray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7700803+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324408",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324408,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1917,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 69,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113",
      "ID": 3214
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5042,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2213168+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2892E76P97VM260895",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 260895,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1917,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 69,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113",
      "ID": 3214
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick",
      "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.1025853+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2029E24P170VM246110",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 246110,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1917,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 69,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113",
      "ID": 3214
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2029,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh",
      "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8726501+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3758E268P409VM276190",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276190,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1917,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 69,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113",
      "ID": 3214
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3758,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.4143633+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4086E128P311VM303196",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 303196,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1917,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 69,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113",
      "ID": 3214
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4086,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Hume",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5633689+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1773E242P494VM222295",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 222295,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1917,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 69,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113",
      "ID": 3214
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1773,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1825957+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1882E227P459VM245580",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 245580,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1917,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 69,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113",
      "ID": 3214
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1882,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam",
      "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8495492+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1893E16P69VM224713",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 224713,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1917,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 69,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113",
      "ID": 3214
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1893,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7167357+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4934E77P103VM308121",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 308121,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1917,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 69,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113",
      "ID": 3214
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4934,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8656267+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272515",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 272515,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1917,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 69,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113",
      "ID": 3214
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4956,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Keir",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3387194+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244709",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244709,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1917,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 69,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113",
      "ID": 3214
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Kelly",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5749059+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3129E261P419VM314728",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 314728,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1917,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 69,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113",
      "ID": 3214
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3129,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6529285+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2080E36P220VM252503",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252503,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1917,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 69,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113",
      "ID": 3214
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann",
      "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7319484+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4016E11P36VM275613",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 275613,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1917,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 69,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113",
      "ID": 3214
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4016,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.3830624+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2180E246P463VM257099",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257099,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1917,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 69,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113",
      "ID": 3214
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2180,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.8232659+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4938E158P374VM282879",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 282879,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1917,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 69,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113",
      "ID": 3214
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4938,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.4382678+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2112E250P486VM254097",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254097,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1917,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 69,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113",
      "ID": 3214
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2112,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny",
      "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0343661+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4939E258P394VM278780",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 278780,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1917,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 69,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113",
      "ID": 3214
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4939,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus",
      "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2339507+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5074E251P385VM324877",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324877,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1917,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 69,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113",
      "ID": 3214
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5074,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon",
      "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2416365+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1828E3P10VM231978",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231978,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1917,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 69,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113",
      "ID": 3214
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1828,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo",
      "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6239588+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4948E153P363VM312120",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 312120,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1917,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 69,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113",
      "ID": 3214
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4948,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike",
      "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.9145731+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2117E90P107VM233100",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 233100,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1917,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 69,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113",
      "ID": 3214
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2117,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis",
      "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.896828+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267597",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 267597,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1917,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 69,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113",
      "ID": 3214
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken",
      "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0267459+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313040",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313040,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1917,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 69,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113",
      "ID": 3214
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4966,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek",
      "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1610323+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3101E102P129VM294378",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 294378,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1917,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 69,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113",
      "ID": 3214
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3101,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala",
      "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1357671+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319260",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319260,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1917,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 69,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113",
      "ID": 3214
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5034,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny",
      "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9123787+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2159E25P205VM305786",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 305786,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1917,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 69,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113",
      "ID": 3214
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2159,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Martin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.345273+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5110E252P395VM309872",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 309872,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1917,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 69,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113",
      "ID": 3214
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Mason",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3545833+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268007",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 268007,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1917,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 69,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113",
      "ID": 3214
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2133,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.051973+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2876E141P433VM293048",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 293048,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1917,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 69,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113",
      "ID": 3214
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2876,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5693777+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4951E147P368VM271434",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271434,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1917,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 69,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113",
      "ID": 3214
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4951,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan",
      "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0756504+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3896E175P307VM269405",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269405,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1917,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 69,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113",
      "ID": 3214
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3896,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam",
      "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5461333+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5080E110P121VM307406",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307406,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1917,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 69,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113",
      "ID": 3214
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8280767+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4964E143P375VM280576",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280576,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1917,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 69,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113",
      "ID": 3214
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4964,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7731542+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3824E84P113VM281268",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 281268,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1917,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 69,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113",
      "ID": 3214
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3824,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1275029+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2066E22P91VM245179",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 245179,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1917,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 69,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113",
      "ID": 3214
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2066,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5954558+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299279",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 299279,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1917,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 69,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113",
      "ID": 3214
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.6906241+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3759E260P411VM302769",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 302769,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1917,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 69,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113",
      "ID": 3214
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina",
      "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5443837+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300106",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 300106,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1917,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 69,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113",
      "ID": 3214
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2487,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7365654+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1775E215P453VM224301",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 224301,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1917,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 69,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113",
      "ID": 3214
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.6930304+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237965",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237965,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1917,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 69,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113",
      "ID": 3214
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1961,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David",
      "DisplayName": "David McLetchie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2337324+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2134E34P201VM297710",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 297710,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1917,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 69,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113",
      "ID": 3214
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2134,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1215076+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320010",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 320010,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1917,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 69,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113",
      "ID": 3214
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5041,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan",
      "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9574939+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315353",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315353,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1917,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 69,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113",
      "ID": 3214
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3763,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart",
      "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9083243+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1986E23P197VM237545",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237545,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1917,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 69,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113",
      "ID": 3214
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1986,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan",
      "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.215435+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5047E100P130VM292574",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 292574,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1917,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 69,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113",
      "ID": 3214
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5047,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne",
      "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5486655+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1845E17P40VM233965",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 233965,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1917,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 69,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113",
      "ID": 3214
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1845,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette",
      "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1540251+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3061E19P43VM311634",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311634,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1917,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 69,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113",
      "ID": 3214
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3061,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8876187+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1768E19P265VM286849",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286849,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1917,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 69,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113",
      "ID": 3214
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1768,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.6034644+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225696",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225696,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1917,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 69,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113",
      "ID": 3214
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1894,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Neil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.986438+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3815E98P134VM271011",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271011,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1917,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 69,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113",
      "ID": 3214
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3815,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Park, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Park",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8387014+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265558",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265558,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1917,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 69,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113",
      "ID": 3214
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2010,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil",
      "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4443544+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283951",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283951,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1917,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 69,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113",
      "ID": 3214
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5057,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7305388+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2853E33P128VM258713",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258713,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1917,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 69,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113",
      "ID": 3214
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Pentland",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3194267+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317233",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317233,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1917,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 69,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113",
      "ID": 3214
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5009,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4095685+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3745E233P381VM256127",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 256127,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1917,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 69,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113",
      "ID": 3214
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3745,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis",
      "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5717801+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1870E225P478VM294513",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 294513,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1917,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 69,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113",
      "ID": 3214
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1870,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona",
      "DisplayName": "Shona Robison",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1416564+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2135E254P450VM235983",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235983,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1917,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 69,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113",
      "ID": 3214
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2135,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Russell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.7013357+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1895E232P431VM255996",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255996,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1917,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 69,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113",
      "ID": 3214
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1895,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5658853+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1839E21P87VM229355",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229355,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1917,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 69,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113",
      "ID": 3214
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1839,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0781473+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2345E10P55VM288399",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 288399,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1917,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 69,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113",
      "ID": 3214
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2345,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1331603+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2223E176P333VM310540",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 310540,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1917,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 69,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113",
      "ID": 3214
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2223,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish",
      "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5752839+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2182E87P175VM247112",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247112,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1917,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 69,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113",
      "ID": 3214
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2182,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1675762+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298702",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298702,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1917,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 69,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113",
      "ID": 3214
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5079,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew",
      "DisplayName": "Drew Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.36858+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1769E32P285VM235820",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235820,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1917,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 69,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113",
      "ID": 3214
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1769,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6943815+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4014E14P26VM275344",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 275344,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1917,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 69,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113",
      "ID": 3214
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4014,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz",
      "DisplayName": "Liz Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.3711301+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2215E224P447VM270073",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270073,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1917,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 69,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113",
      "ID": 3214
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2215,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5803761+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3806E103P127VM316887",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 316887,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1917,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 69,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113",
      "ID": 3214
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3806,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.1677254+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326107",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 326107,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1917,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 69,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113",
      "ID": 3214
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5106,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin",
      "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5401811+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241446",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241446,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1917,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 69,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113",
      "ID": 3214
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1848,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola",
      "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7583096+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2098E237P531VM288686",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 288686,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1917,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 69,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113",
      "ID": 3214
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2098,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Swinney",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1540591+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248235",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248235,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1917,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 69,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113",
      "ID": 3214
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2674,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave",
      "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6371319+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5075E234P371VM290070",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 290070,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1917,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 69,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113",
      "ID": 3214
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5075,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Torrance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4714788+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1793E151P362VM222787",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 222787,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1917,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 69,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113",
      "ID": 3214
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1793,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean",
      "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.2046899+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5078E245P7VM306868",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306868,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1917,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 69,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113",
      "ID": 3214
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5078,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Walker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.577175+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1841E231P426VM240829",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 240829,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1917,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 69,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113",
      "ID": 3214
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1841,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen",
      "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3840647+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4952E148P370VM284106",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 284106,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1917,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 69,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113",
      "ID": 3214
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4952,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7432554+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1865E263P500VM231051",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231051,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1917,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 69,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113",
      "ID": 3214
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1865,
      "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra",
      "DisplayName": "Sandra White",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3635149+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2610E160P413VM246751",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 246751,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1917,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 69,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113",
      "ID": 3214
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2610,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Wilson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1518661+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4941E150P382VM308869",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 308869,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1917,
      "AgendaID": 2464,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 69,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-03113",
      "ID": 3214
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4941,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza",
      "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-31T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0815679+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252274",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252274,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1913,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.3",
      "ID": 3215
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1926,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian",
      "DisplayName": "Brian Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7219326+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2615E213P388VM257542",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257542,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1913,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.3",
      "ID": 3215
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2615,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George",
      "DisplayName": "George Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0610269+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319948",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319948,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1913,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.3",
      "ID": 3215
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4940,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare",
      "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9483101+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249709",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 249709,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1913,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.3",
      "ID": 3215
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2641,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair",
      "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9465097+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1783E21P273VM227381",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227381,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1913,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.3",
      "ID": 3215
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1783,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie",
      "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5477+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2633E97P136VM280376",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280376,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1913,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.3",
      "ID": 3215
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2633,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire",
      "DisplayName": "Claire Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7580626+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262426",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262426,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1913,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.3",
      "ID": 3215
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2603,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6013099+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1759E91P115VM229223",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229223,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1913,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.3",
      "ID": 3215
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia",
      "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0673658+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270252",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270252,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1913,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.3",
      "ID": 3215
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3751,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.7959223+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322836",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 322836,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1913,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.3",
      "ID": 3215
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5109,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco",
      "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.7056563+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5060E86P124VM294658",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 294658,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1913,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.3",
      "ID": 3215
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5060,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1727396+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242806",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242806,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1913,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.3",
      "ID": 3215
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1866,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah",
      "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0363305+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235622",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235622,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1913,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.3",
      "ID": 3215
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1943,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic",
      "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6856754+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302091",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 302091,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1913,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.3",
      "ID": 3215
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2595,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin",
      "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.29667+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244574",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244574,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1913,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.3",
      "ID": 3215
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2103,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith",
      "DisplayName": "Keith Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5691552+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327341",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 327341,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1913,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.3",
      "ID": 3215
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:46.0316965+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3775E216P435VM276609",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276609,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1913,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.3",
      "ID": 3215
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6734976+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264561",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264561,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1913,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.3",
      "ID": 3215
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2673,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick",
      "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1391088+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248847",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248847,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1913,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.3",
      "ID": 3215
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2678,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson",
      "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6726143+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2123E27P233VM296339",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 296339,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1913,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.3",
      "ID": 3215
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2123,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm",
      "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.844768+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285087",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285087,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1913,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.3",
      "ID": 3215
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3907,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0658564+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230102",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230102,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1913,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.3",
      "ID": 3215
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1735,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela",
      "DisplayName": "Angela Constance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.1163289+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243913",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 243913,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1913,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.3",
      "ID": 3215
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1932,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce",
      "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3252923+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1863E238P523VM255304",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255304,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1913,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.3",
      "ID": 3215
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1863,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna",
      "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5251745+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323976",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 323976,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1913,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.3",
      "ID": 3215
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4976,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth",
      "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9806262+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5107E223P379VM291869",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291869,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1913,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.3",
      "ID": 3215
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5107,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1459784+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3743E222P391VM265102",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265102,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1913,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.3",
      "ID": 3215
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3743,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel",
      "DisplayName": "Nigel Don",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1685643+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3771E149P417VM261712",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261712,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1913,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.3",
      "ID": 3215
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3771,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob",
      "DisplayName": "Bob Doris",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3693737+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2826E262P384VM282054",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 282054,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1913,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.3",
      "ID": 3215
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2826,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Dornan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1736195+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3812E94P117VM297917",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 297917,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1913,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.3",
      "ID": 3215
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3812,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia",
      "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.130494+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231660",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231660,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1913,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.3",
      "ID": 3215
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1778,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen",
      "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6101298+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4955E240P389VM286170",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286170,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1913,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.3",
      "ID": 3215
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4955,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.366921+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219316",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 219316,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1913,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.3",
      "ID": 3215
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1742,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle",
      "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.2888556+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238649",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 238649,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1913,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.3",
      "ID": 3215
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1994,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus",
      "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4631729+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225513",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225513,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1913,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.3",
      "ID": 3215
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1814,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda",
      "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9779581+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321624",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 321624,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1913,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.3",
      "ID": 3215
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Fee",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4440896+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292909",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 292909,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1913,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.3",
      "ID": 3215
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia",
      "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5634401+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1892E12P64VM226884",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 226884,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1913,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.3",
      "ID": 3215
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2508555+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5054E95P118VM305100",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 305100,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1913,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.3",
      "ID": 3215
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5054,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.07215+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4947E152P361VM257112",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257112,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1913,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.3",
      "ID": 3215
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4947,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Finnie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.82382+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271525",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271525,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1913,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.3",
      "ID": 3215
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3901,
      "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe",
      "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0795803+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278499",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 278499,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1913,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.3",
      "ID": 3215
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2394,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo",
      "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2215166+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2110E220P414VM286680",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286680,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1913,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.3",
      "ID": 3215
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth",
      "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5961698+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250390",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250390,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1913,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.3",
      "ID": 3215
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2675,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob",
      "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1871472+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1741E10P50VM220703",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220703,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1913,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.3",
      "ID": 3215
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1741,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel",
      "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6534042+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220329",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220329,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1913,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.3",
      "ID": 3215
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1756,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine",
      "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6366315+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1860E104P150VM251809",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251809,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1913,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.3",
      "ID": 3215
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1860,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda",
      "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4897317+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2033E20P141VM266183",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 266183,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1913,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.3",
      "ID": 3215
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2033,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain",
      "DisplayName": "Iain Gray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4779237+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324457",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324457,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1913,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.3",
      "ID": 3215
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5042,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2235214+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259950",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 259950,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1913,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.3",
      "ID": 3215
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick",
      "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6370239+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239248",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239248,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1913,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.3",
      "ID": 3215
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2029,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh",
      "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7285634+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273879",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 273879,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1913,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.3",
      "ID": 3215
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3758,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6396078+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304238",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 304238,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1913,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.3",
      "ID": 3215
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4086,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Hume",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.0296705+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221837",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221837,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1913,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.3",
      "ID": 3215
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1773,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9499394+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1882E227P459VM242073",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242073,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1913,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.3",
      "ID": 3215
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1882,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam",
      "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7926746+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223782",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223782,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1913,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.3",
      "ID": 3215
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1893,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4735359+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307501",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307501,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1913,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.3",
      "ID": 3215
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4934,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8322568+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4956E241P386VM271973",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271973,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1913,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.3",
      "ID": 3215
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4956,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Keir",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.1058683+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244813",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244813,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1913,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.3",
      "ID": 3215
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Kelly",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5797235+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3129E261P419VM314984",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 314984,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1913,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.3",
      "ID": 3215
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3129,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6690719+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2080E36P220VM251112",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251112,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1913,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.3",
      "ID": 3215
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann",
      "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.2276112+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4016E11P36VM274716",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274716,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1913,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.3",
      "ID": 3215
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4016,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1186349+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255869",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255869,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1913,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.3",
      "ID": 3215
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2180,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5605168+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4938E158P374VM277838",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277838,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1913,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.3",
      "ID": 3215
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4938,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.970605+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2112E250P486VM252942",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252942,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1913,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.3",
      "ID": 3215
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2112,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny",
      "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7598598+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4939E258P394VM277224",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277224,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1913,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.3",
      "ID": 3215
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4939,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus",
      "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9390425+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325674",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 325674,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1913,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.3",
      "ID": 3215
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5074,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon",
      "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5164367+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1828E3P10VM232466",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232466,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1913,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.3",
      "ID": 3215
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1828,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo",
      "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8620554+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311347",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311347,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1913,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.3",
      "ID": 3215
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4948,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike",
      "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.874791+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2117E90P107VM230482",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230482,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1913,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.3",
      "ID": 3215
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2117,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis",
      "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3318483+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267288",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 267288,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1913,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.3",
      "ID": 3215
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken",
      "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.01297+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313814",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313814,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1913,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.3",
      "ID": 3215
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4966,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek",
      "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4118083+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3101E102P129VM295465",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295465,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1913,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.3",
      "ID": 3215
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3101,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala",
      "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5133056+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5034E88P114VM318874",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 318874,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1913,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.3",
      "ID": 3215
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5034,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny",
      "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6772078+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306503",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306503,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1913,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.3",
      "ID": 3215
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2159,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Martin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5548713+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5110E252P395VM311217",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311217,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1913,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.3",
      "ID": 3215
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Mason",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8670295+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268316",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 268316,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1913,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.3",
      "ID": 3215
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2133,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2618556+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2876E141P433VM286097",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286097,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1913,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.3",
      "ID": 3215
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2876,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.363531+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4951E147P368VM260755",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 260755,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1913,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.3",
      "ID": 3215
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4951,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan",
      "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.0909134+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3896E175P307VM264118",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264118,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1913,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.3",
      "ID": 3215
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3896,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam",
      "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.925015+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308422",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 308422,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1913,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.3",
      "ID": 3215
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0552558+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4964E143P375VM279285",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279285,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1913,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.3",
      "ID": 3215
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4964,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.4952459+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3824E84P113VM280061",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280061,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1913,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.3",
      "ID": 3215
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3824,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5397555+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2066E22P91VM261795",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261795,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1913,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.3",
      "ID": 3215
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2066,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3784926+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299746",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 299746,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1913,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.3",
      "ID": 3215
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7208482+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306608",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306608,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1913,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.3",
      "ID": 3215
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina",
      "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5593802+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2487E146P369VM301187",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 301187,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1913,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.3",
      "ID": 3215
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2487,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0378961+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223607",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223607,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1913,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.3",
      "ID": 3215
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.466001+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237420",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237420,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1913,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.3",
      "ID": 3215
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1961,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David",
      "DisplayName": "David McLetchie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2034483+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2134E34P201VM297811",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 297811,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1913,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.3",
      "ID": 3215
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2134,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1260227+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320707",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 320707,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1913,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.3",
      "ID": 3215
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5041,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan",
      "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1780104+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3763E142P397VM316098",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 316098,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1913,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.3",
      "ID": 3215
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3763,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart",
      "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9460703+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1986E23P197VM236240",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 236240,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1913,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.3",
      "ID": 3215
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1986,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan",
      "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9078373+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5047E100P130VM291494",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291494,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1913,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.3",
      "ID": 3215
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5047,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne",
      "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.12174+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234973",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234973,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1913,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.3",
      "ID": 3215
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1845,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette",
      "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4078657+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313668",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313668,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1913,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.3",
      "ID": 3215
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3061,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4053147+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1768E19P265VM288593",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 288593,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1913,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.3",
      "ID": 3215
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1768,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1500773+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225004",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225004,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1913,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.3",
      "ID": 3215
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1894,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Neil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7404198+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3815E98P134VM270841",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270841,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1913,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.3",
      "ID": 3215
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3815,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Park, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Park",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8254183+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265952",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265952,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1913,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.3",
      "ID": 3215
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2010,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil",
      "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4676333+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283555",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283555,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1913,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.3",
      "ID": 3215
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5057,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7133243+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2853E33P128VM251084",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251084,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1913,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.3",
      "ID": 3215
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Pentland",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.226331+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317926",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317926,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1913,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.3",
      "ID": 3215
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5009,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.443432+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254773",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254773,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1913,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.3",
      "ID": 3215
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3745,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis",
      "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.28312+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1870E225P478VM295651",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295651,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1913,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.3",
      "ID": 3215
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1870,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona",
      "DisplayName": "Shona Robison",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5300275+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2135E254P450VM234835",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234835,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1913,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.3",
      "ID": 3215
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2135,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Russell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4017936+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1895E232P431VM257348",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257348,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1913,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.3",
      "ID": 3215
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1895,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0522734+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228045",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 228045,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1913,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.3",
      "ID": 3215
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1839,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5819953+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2345E10P55VM292060",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 292060,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1913,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.3",
      "ID": 3215
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2345,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.154211+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2223E176P333VM310641",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 310641,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1913,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.3",
      "ID": 3215
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2223,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish",
      "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.579675+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2182E87P175VM245957",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 245957,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1913,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.3",
      "ID": 3215
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2182,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8660009+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298399",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298399,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1913,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.3",
      "ID": 3215
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5079,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew",
      "DisplayName": "Drew Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3440577+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234434",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234434,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1913,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.3",
      "ID": 3215
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1769,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3839925+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4014E14P26VM269913",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269913,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1913,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.3",
      "ID": 3215
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4014,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz",
      "DisplayName": "Liz Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5732135+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269144",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269144,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1913,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.3",
      "ID": 3215
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2215,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.3055475+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317142",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317142,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1913,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.3",
      "ID": 3215
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3806,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.183488+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326156",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 326156,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1913,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.3",
      "ID": 3215
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5106,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin",
      "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5422806+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241055",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241055,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1913,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.3",
      "ID": 3215
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1848,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola",
      "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3941404+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2098E237P531VM289557",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289557,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1913,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.3",
      "ID": 3215
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2098,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Swinney",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4492064+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2674E247P401VM247709",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247709,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1913,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.3",
      "ID": 3215
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2674,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave",
      "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.425056+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5075E234P371VM284826",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 284826,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1913,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.3",
      "ID": 3215
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5075,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Torrance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0494011+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1793E151P362VM222404",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 222404,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1913,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.3",
      "ID": 3215
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1793,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean",
      "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1875011+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5078E245P7VM307091",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307091,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1913,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.3",
      "ID": 3215
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5078,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Walker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5868895+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1841E231P426VM240223",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 240223,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1913,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.3",
      "ID": 3215
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1841,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen",
      "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3501775+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283367",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283367,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1913,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.3",
      "ID": 3215
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4952,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.697637+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1865E263P500VM232277",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232277,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1913,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.3",
      "ID": 3215
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1865,
      "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra",
      "DisplayName": "Sandra White",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8478101+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237844",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237844,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1913,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.3",
      "ID": 3215
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2610,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Wilson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2285118+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309337",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 309337,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1913,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.3",
      "ID": 3215
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4941,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza",
      "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3249563+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252275",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252275,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1914,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.1",
      "ID": 3203
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1926,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian",
      "DisplayName": "Brian Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7219751+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2615E213P388VM257543",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257543,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1914,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.1",
      "ID": 3203
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2615,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George",
      "DisplayName": "George Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.061068+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319947",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319947,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1914,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.1",
      "ID": 3203
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4940,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare",
      "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9482515+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249614",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 249614,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1914,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.1",
      "ID": 3203
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2641,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair",
      "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9344172+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1783E21P273VM227382",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227382,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1914,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.1",
      "ID": 3203
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1783,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie",
      "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5477411+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2633E97P136VM280377",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280377,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1914,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.1",
      "ID": 3203
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2633,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire",
      "DisplayName": "Claire Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7581048+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262427",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262427,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1914,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.1",
      "ID": 3203
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2603,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6013514+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1759E91P115VM229224",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229224,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1914,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.1",
      "ID": 3203
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia",
      "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0674079+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270251",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270251,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1914,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.1",
      "ID": 3203
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3751,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.7958803+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322837",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 322837,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1914,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.1",
      "ID": 3203
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5109,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco",
      "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.7056968+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5060E86P124VM294659",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 294659,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1914,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.1",
      "ID": 3203
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5060,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1728029+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242807",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242807,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1914,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.1",
      "ID": 3203
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1866,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah",
      "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0363711+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235621",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235621,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1914,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.1",
      "ID": 3203
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1943,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic",
      "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6856361+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302092",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 302092,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1914,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.1",
      "ID": 3203
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2595,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin",
      "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.2967113+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244573",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244573,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1914,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.1",
      "ID": 3203
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2103,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith",
      "DisplayName": "Keith Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.569115+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327342",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 327342,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1914,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.1",
      "ID": 3203
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:46.0317384+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3775E216P435VM276610",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276610,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1914,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.1",
      "ID": 3203
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6735389+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264560",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264560,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1914,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.1",
      "ID": 3203
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2673,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick",
      "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1390674+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248846",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248846,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1914,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.1",
      "ID": 3203
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2678,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson",
      "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6725727+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2123E27P233VM296338",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 296338,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1914,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.1",
      "ID": 3203
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2123,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm",
      "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8447136+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285088",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285088,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1914,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.1",
      "ID": 3203
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3907,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0659295+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230103",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230103,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1914,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.1",
      "ID": 3203
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1735,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela",
      "DisplayName": "Angela Constance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.1163883+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243912",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 243912,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1914,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.1",
      "ID": 3203
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1932,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce",
      "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3252515+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1863E238P523VM255303",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255303,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1914,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.1",
      "ID": 3203
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1863,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna",
      "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.525131+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323977",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 323977,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1914,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.1",
      "ID": 3203
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4976,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth",
      "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9806684+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5107E223P379VM291868",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291868,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1914,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.1",
      "ID": 3203
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5107,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1459387+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3743E222P391VM265103",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265103,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1914,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.1",
      "ID": 3203
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3743,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel",
      "DisplayName": "Nigel Don",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1686066+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3771E149P417VM261713",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261713,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1914,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.1",
      "ID": 3203
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3771,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob",
      "DisplayName": "Bob Doris",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3694207+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2826E262P384VM282053",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 282053,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1914,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.1",
      "ID": 3203
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2826,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Dornan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1735792+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3812E94P117VM297918",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 297918,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1914,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.1",
      "ID": 3203
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3812,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia",
      "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1305342+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231659",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231659,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1914,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.1",
      "ID": 3203
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1778,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen",
      "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6100895+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4955E240P389VM286169",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286169,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1914,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.1",
      "ID": 3203
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4955,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3668614+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219317",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 219317,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1914,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.1",
      "ID": 3203
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1742,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle",
      "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.2888973+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238648",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 238648,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1914,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.1",
      "ID": 3203
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1994,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus",
      "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.463132+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225512",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225512,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1914,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.1",
      "ID": 3203
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1814,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda",
      "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9779168+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321623",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 321623,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1914,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.1",
      "ID": 3203
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Fee",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.444049+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292908",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 292908,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1914,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.1",
      "ID": 3203
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia",
      "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5633796+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1892E12P64VM226885",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 226885,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1914,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.1",
      "ID": 3203
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2508975+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5054E95P118VM305101",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 305101,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1914,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.1",
      "ID": 3203
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5054,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.0721909+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4947E152P361VM257205",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257205,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1914,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.1",
      "ID": 3203
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4947,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Finnie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0460787+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271524",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271524,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1914,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.1",
      "ID": 3203
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3901,
      "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe",
      "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0795396+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278498",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 278498,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1914,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.1",
      "ID": 3203
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2394,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo",
      "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2214537+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2110E220P414VM286681",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286681,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1914,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.1",
      "ID": 3203
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth",
      "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5962106+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250483",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250483,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1914,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.1",
      "ID": 3203
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2675,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob",
      "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1914883+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1741E10P50VM220704",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220704,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1914,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.1",
      "ID": 3203
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1741,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel",
      "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6534455+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220328",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220328,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1914,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.1",
      "ID": 3203
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1756,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine",
      "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6365908+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1860E104P150VM251810",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251810,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1914,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.1",
      "ID": 3203
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1860,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda",
      "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4897733+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2033E20P141VM266182",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 266182,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1914,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.1",
      "ID": 3203
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2033,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain",
      "DisplayName": "Iain Gray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4778834+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324456",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324456,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1914,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.1",
      "ID": 3203
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5042,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2234806+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259949",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 259949,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1914,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.1",
      "ID": 3203
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick",
      "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6369831+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239249",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239249,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1914,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.1",
      "ID": 3203
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2029,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh",
      "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7286046+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273878",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 273878,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1914,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.1",
      "ID": 3203
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3758,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6395672+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304237",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 304237,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1914,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.1",
      "ID": 3203
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4086,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Hume",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.029629+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221836",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221836,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1914,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.1",
      "ID": 3203
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1773,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9498975+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1882E227P459VM241978",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241978,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1914,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.1",
      "ID": 3203
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1882,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam",
      "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.788565+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223781",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223781,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1914,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.1",
      "ID": 3203
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1893,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4734933+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307502",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307502,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1914,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.1",
      "ID": 3203
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4934,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8322982+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272220",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 272220,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1914,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.1",
      "ID": 3203
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4956,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Keir",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3201947+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244814",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244814,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1914,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.1",
      "ID": 3203
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Kelly",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5797642+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3129E261P419VM314985",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 314985,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1914,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.1",
      "ID": 3203
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3129,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6691134+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2080E36P220VM251111",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251111,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1914,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.1",
      "ID": 3203
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann",
      "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.2275699+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4016E11P36VM274717",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274717,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1914,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.1",
      "ID": 3203
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4016,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1186769+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255868",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255868,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1914,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.1",
      "ID": 3203
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2180,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5604771+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4938E158P374VM277837",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277837,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1914,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.1",
      "ID": 3203
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4938,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9705645+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2112E250P486VM252943",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252943,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1914,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.1",
      "ID": 3203
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2112,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny",
      "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7599007+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4939E258P394VM277223",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277223,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1914,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.1",
      "ID": 3203
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4939,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus",
      "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9389809+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325675",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 325675,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1914,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.1",
      "ID": 3203
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5074,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon",
      "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5164782+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1828E3P10VM232467",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232467,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1914,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.1",
      "ID": 3203
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1828,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo",
      "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8620966+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311348",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311348,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1914,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.1",
      "ID": 3203
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4948,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike",
      "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8748332+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2117E90P107VM230481",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230481,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1914,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.1",
      "ID": 3203
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2117,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis",
      "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3317868+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267289",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 267289,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1914,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.1",
      "ID": 3203
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken",
      "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0130109+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313813",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313813,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1914,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.1",
      "ID": 3203
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4966,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek",
      "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4117669+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3101E102P129VM295464",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295464,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1914,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.1",
      "ID": 3203
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3101,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala",
      "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5132651+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5034E88P114VM318873",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 318873,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1914,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.1",
      "ID": 3203
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5034,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny",
      "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6771655+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306502",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306502,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1914,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.1",
      "ID": 3203
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2159,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Martin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5548299+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5110E252P395VM311216",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311216,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1914,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.1",
      "ID": 3203
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Mason",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8669881+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268315",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 268315,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1914,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.1",
      "ID": 3203
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2133,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2618144+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2876E141P433VM286098",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286098,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1914,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.1",
      "ID": 3203
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2876,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3635736+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4951E147P368VM258651",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258651,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1914,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.1",
      "ID": 3203
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4951,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan",
      "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3166971+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3896E175P307VM264117",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264117,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1914,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.1",
      "ID": 3203
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3896,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam",
      "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9249742+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308423",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 308423,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1914,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.1",
      "ID": 3203
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0552975+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4964E143P375VM279286",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279286,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1914,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.1",
      "ID": 3203
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4964,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.4952889+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3824E84P113VM280060",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280060,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1914,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.1",
      "ID": 3203
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3824,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5397129+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2066E22P91VM261794",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261794,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1914,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.1",
      "ID": 3203
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2066,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3784522+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299745",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 299745,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1914,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.1",
      "ID": 3203
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7207894+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306609",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306609,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1914,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.1",
      "ID": 3203
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina",
      "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5594407+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2487E146P369VM301186",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 301186,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1914,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.1",
      "ID": 3203
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2487,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0378449+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223608",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223608,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1914,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.1",
      "ID": 3203
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4660677+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237421",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237421,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1914,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.1",
      "ID": 3203
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1961,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David",
      "DisplayName": "David McLetchie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2034901+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2134E34P201VM297812",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 297812,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1914,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.1",
      "ID": 3203
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2134,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1260858+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320708",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 320708,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1914,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.1",
      "ID": 3203
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5041,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan",
      "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1780518+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3763E142P397VM316097",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 316097,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1914,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.1",
      "ID": 3203
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3763,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart",
      "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9460285+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1986E23P197VM236241",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 236241,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1914,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.1",
      "ID": 3203
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1986,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan",
      "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9078983+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5047E100P130VM291493",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291493,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1914,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.1",
      "ID": 3203
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5047,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne",
      "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1216982+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234972",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234972,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1914,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.1",
      "ID": 3203
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1845,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette",
      "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4078237+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313667",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313667,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1914,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.1",
      "ID": 3203
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3061,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4052741+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1768E19P265VM288594",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 288594,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1914,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.1",
      "ID": 3203
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1768,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1501189+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225005",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225005,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1914,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.1",
      "ID": 3203
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1894,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Neil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7404792+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3815E98P134VM270842",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270842,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1914,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.1",
      "ID": 3203
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3815,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Park, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Park",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8254604+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265951",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265951,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1914,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.1",
      "ID": 3203
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2010,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil",
      "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4675924+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283554",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283554,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1914,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.1",
      "ID": 3203
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5057,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7132831+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2853E33P128VM251085",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251085,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1914,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.1",
      "ID": 3203
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Pentland",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.2263736+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317927",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317927,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1914,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.1",
      "ID": 3203
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5009,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4434982+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254680",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254680,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1914,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.1",
      "ID": 3203
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3745,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis",
      "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2670237+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1870E225P478VM295652",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295652,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1914,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.1",
      "ID": 3203
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1870,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona",
      "DisplayName": "Shona Robison",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.530071+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2135E254P450VM234836",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234836,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1914,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.1",
      "ID": 3203
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2135,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Russell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4018355+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1895E232P431VM257349",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257349,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1914,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.1",
      "ID": 3203
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1895,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.052315+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228046",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 228046,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1914,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.1",
      "ID": 3203
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1839,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5820373+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2345E10P55VM292059",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 292059,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1914,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.1",
      "ID": 3203
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2345,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1541704+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2223E176P333VM310642",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 310642,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1914,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.1",
      "ID": 3203
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2223,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish",
      "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5797176+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246359",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 246359,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1914,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.1",
      "ID": 3203
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2182,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1253366+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298398",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298398,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1914,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.1",
      "ID": 3203
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5079,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew",
      "DisplayName": "Drew Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3440159+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234433",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234433,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1914,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.1",
      "ID": 3203
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1769,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3839501+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4014E14P26VM269914",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269914,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1914,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.1",
      "ID": 3203
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4014,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz",
      "DisplayName": "Liz Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5732569+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269145",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269145,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1914,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.1",
      "ID": 3203
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2215,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.305618+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317143",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317143,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1914,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.1",
      "ID": 3203
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3806,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.1835301+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326155",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 326155,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1914,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.1",
      "ID": 3203
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5106,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin",
      "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5422403+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241151",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241151,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1914,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.1",
      "ID": 3203
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1848,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola",
      "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.4042391+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2098E237P531VM289558",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289558,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1914,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.1",
      "ID": 3203
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2098,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Swinney",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4492471+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2674E247P401VM247710",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247710,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1914,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.1",
      "ID": 3203
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2674,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave",
      "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.425097+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5075E234P371VM284827",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 284827,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1914,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.1",
      "ID": 3203
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5075,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Torrance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0494418+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1793E151P362VM222405",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 222405,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1914,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.1",
      "ID": 3203
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1793,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean",
      "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1875423+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5078E245P7VM307090",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307090,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1914,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.1",
      "ID": 3203
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5078,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Walker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5868488+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1841E231P426VM239972",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239972,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1914,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.1",
      "ID": 3203
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1841,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen",
      "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7672535+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283368",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283368,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1914,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.1",
      "ID": 3203
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4952,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.6976964+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1865E263P500VM232276",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232276,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1914,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.1",
      "ID": 3203
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1865,
      "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra",
      "DisplayName": "Sandra White",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8477686+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237843",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237843,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1914,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.1",
      "ID": 3203
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2610,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Wilson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.228471+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309336",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 309336,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1914,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 18,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078.1",
      "ID": 3203
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4941,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza",
      "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3249158+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252276",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252276,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1915,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 99,
      "VoteAgainst": 21,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078",
      "ID": 3181
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1926,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian",
      "DisplayName": "Brian Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7220444+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2615E213P388VM257544",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257544,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1915,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 99,
      "VoteAgainst": 21,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078",
      "ID": 3181
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2615,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George",
      "DisplayName": "George Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0611086+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319946",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319946,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1915,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 99,
      "VoteAgainst": 21,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078",
      "ID": 3181
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4940,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare",
      "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9482101+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249613",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 249613,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1915,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 99,
      "VoteAgainst": 21,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078",
      "ID": 3181
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2641,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair",
      "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9343754+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1783E21P273VM227383",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227383,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1915,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 99,
      "VoteAgainst": 21,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078",
      "ID": 3181
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1783,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie",
      "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5478026+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2633E97P136VM280378",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280378,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1915,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 99,
      "VoteAgainst": 21,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078",
      "ID": 3181
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2633,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire",
      "DisplayName": "Claire Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7581467+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262682",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262682,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1915,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 99,
      "VoteAgainst": 21,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078",
      "ID": 3181
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2603,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6123477+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1759E91P115VM229225",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229225,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1915,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 99,
      "VoteAgainst": 21,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078",
      "ID": 3181
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia",
      "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0674498+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270250",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270250,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1915,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 99,
      "VoteAgainst": 21,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078",
      "ID": 3181
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3751,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.7958379+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322838",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 322838,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1915,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 99,
      "VoteAgainst": 21,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078",
      "ID": 3181
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5109,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco",
      "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.7057376+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5060E86P124VM294757",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 294757,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1915,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 99,
      "VoteAgainst": 21,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078",
      "ID": 3181
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5060,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1770036+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242808",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242808,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1915,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 99,
      "VoteAgainst": 21,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078",
      "ID": 3181
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1866,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah",
      "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0364117+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235620",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235620,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1915,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 99,
      "VoteAgainst": 21,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078",
      "ID": 3181
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1943,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic",
      "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6855961+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302333",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 302333,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1915,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 99,
      "VoteAgainst": 21,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078",
      "ID": 3181
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2595,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin",
      "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5198801+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244474",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244474,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1915,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 99,
      "VoteAgainst": 21,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078",
      "ID": 3181
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2103,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith",
      "DisplayName": "Keith Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5563269+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327343",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 327343,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1915,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 99,
      "VoteAgainst": 21,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078",
      "ID": 3181
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:46.0317805+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277021",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277021,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1915,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 99,
      "VoteAgainst": 21,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078",
      "ID": 3181
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6976796+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264308",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264308,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1915,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 99,
      "VoteAgainst": 21,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078",
      "ID": 3181
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2673,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick",
      "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1277406+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248845",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248845,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1915,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 99,
      "VoteAgainst": 21,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078",
      "ID": 3181
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2678,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson",
      "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6725126+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2123E27P233VM296337",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 296337,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1915,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 99,
      "VoteAgainst": 21,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078",
      "ID": 3181
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2123,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm",
      "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8446719+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285186",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285186,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1915,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 99,
      "VoteAgainst": 21,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078",
      "ID": 3181
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3907,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0701411+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230104",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230104,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1915,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 99,
      "VoteAgainst": 21,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078",
      "ID": 3181
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1735,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela",
      "DisplayName": "Angela Constance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.1164313+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243911",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 243911,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1915,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 99,
      "VoteAgainst": 21,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078",
      "ID": 3181
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1932,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce",
      "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3252087+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1863E238P523VM255302",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255302,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1915,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 99,
      "VoteAgainst": 21,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078",
      "ID": 3181
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1863,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna",
      "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5250703+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323978",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 323978,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1915,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 99,
      "VoteAgainst": 21,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078",
      "ID": 3181
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4976,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth",
      "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9807113+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5107E223P379VM291867",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291867,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1915,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 99,
      "VoteAgainst": 21,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078",
      "ID": 3181
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5107,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1458978+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3743E222P391VM265358",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265358,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1915,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 99,
      "VoteAgainst": 21,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078",
      "ID": 3181
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3743,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel",
      "DisplayName": "Nigel Don",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4357291+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3771E149P417VM261714",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261714,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1915,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 99,
      "VoteAgainst": 21,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078",
      "ID": 3181
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3771,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob",
      "DisplayName": "Bob Doris",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3694619+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2826E262P384VM282052",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 282052,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1915,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 99,
      "VoteAgainst": 21,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078",
      "ID": 3181
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2826,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Dornan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1735377+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3812E94P117VM297919",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 297919,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1915,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 99,
      "VoteAgainst": 21,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078",
      "ID": 3181
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3812,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia",
      "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1305741+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231658",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231658,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1915,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 99,
      "VoteAgainst": 21,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078",
      "ID": 3181
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1778,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen",
      "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.610049+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4955E240P389VM286168",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286168,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1915,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 99,
      "VoteAgainst": 21,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078",
      "ID": 3181
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4955,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3668198+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219318",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 219318,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1915,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 99,
      "VoteAgainst": 21,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078",
      "ID": 3181
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1742,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle",
      "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.2889392+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238647",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 238647,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1915,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 99,
      "VoteAgainst": 21,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078",
      "ID": 3181
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1994,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus",
      "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4630718+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225420",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225420,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1915,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 99,
      "VoteAgainst": 21,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078",
      "ID": 3181
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1814,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda",
      "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9739702+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321622",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 321622,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1915,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 99,
      "VoteAgainst": 21,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078",
      "ID": 3181
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Fee",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4440076+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292907",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 292907,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1915,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 99,
      "VoteAgainst": 21,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078",
      "ID": 3181
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia",
      "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5633382+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1892E12P64VM226886",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 226886,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1915,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 99,
      "VoteAgainst": 21,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078",
      "ID": 3181
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2509406+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5054E95P118VM312693",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 312693,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1915,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 99,
      "VoteAgainst": 21,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078",
      "ID": 3181
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5054,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.139287+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4947E152P361VM257206",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257206,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1915,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 99,
      "VoteAgainst": 21,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078",
      "ID": 3181
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4947,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Finnie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0461202+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271523",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271523,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1915,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 99,
      "VoteAgainst": 21,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078",
      "ID": 3181
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3901,
      "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe",
      "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0794978+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278497",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 278497,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1915,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 99,
      "VoteAgainst": 21,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078",
      "ID": 3181
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2394,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo",
      "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2214094+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2110E220P414VM286765",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286765,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1915,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 99,
      "VoteAgainst": 21,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078",
      "ID": 3181
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth",
      "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.599728+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250484",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250484,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1915,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 99,
      "VoteAgainst": 21,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078",
      "ID": 3181
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2675,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob",
      "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1915307+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1741E10P50VM220951",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220951,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1915,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 99,
      "VoteAgainst": 21,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078",
      "ID": 3181
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1741,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel",
      "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6686774+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220327",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220327,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1915,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 99,
      "VoteAgainst": 21,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078",
      "ID": 3181
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1756,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine",
      "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.636549+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1860E104P150VM251811",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251811,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1915,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 99,
      "VoteAgainst": 21,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078",
      "ID": 3181
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1860,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda",
      "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4898155+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2033E20P141VM266181",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 266181,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1915,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 99,
      "VoteAgainst": 21,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078",
      "ID": 3181
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2033,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain",
      "DisplayName": "Iain Gray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4778419+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324455",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324455,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1915,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 99,
      "VoteAgainst": 21,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078",
      "ID": 3181
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5042,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2234361+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259948",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 259948,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1915,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 99,
      "VoteAgainst": 21,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078",
      "ID": 3181
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick",
      "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6369415+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239250",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239250,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1915,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 99,
      "VoteAgainst": 21,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078",
      "ID": 3181
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2029,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh",
      "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7286644+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273779",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 273779,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1915,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 99,
      "VoteAgainst": 21,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078",
      "ID": 3181
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3758,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6352993+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304152",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 304152,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1915,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 99,
      "VoteAgainst": 21,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078",
      "ID": 3181
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4086,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Hume",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8518903+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221744",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221744,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1915,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 99,
      "VoteAgainst": 21,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078",
      "ID": 3181
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1773,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9459187+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1882E227P459VM241977",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241977,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1915,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 99,
      "VoteAgainst": 21,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078",
      "ID": 3181
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1882,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam",
      "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7885225+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223780",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223780,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1915,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 99,
      "VoteAgainst": 21,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078",
      "ID": 3181
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1893,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4734319+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307503",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307503,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1915,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 99,
      "VoteAgainst": 21,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078",
      "ID": 3181
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4934,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8323394+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272221",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 272221,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1915,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 99,
      "VoteAgainst": 21,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078",
      "ID": 3181
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4956,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Keir",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3202362+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244815",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244815,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1915,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 99,
      "VoteAgainst": 21,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078",
      "ID": 3181
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Kelly",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5798055+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3129E261P419VM314986",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 314986,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1915,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 99,
      "VoteAgainst": 21,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078",
      "ID": 3181
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3129,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6691551+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2080E36P220VM251110",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251110,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1915,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 99,
      "VoteAgainst": 21,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078",
      "ID": 3181
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann",
      "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.227528+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4016E11P36VM274718",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274718,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1915,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 99,
      "VoteAgainst": 21,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078",
      "ID": 3181
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4016,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.118718+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255867",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255867,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1915,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 99,
      "VoteAgainst": 21,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078",
      "ID": 3181
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2180,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5604366+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4938E158P374VM277836",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277836,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1915,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 99,
      "VoteAgainst": 21,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078",
      "ID": 3181
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4938,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9705222+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2112E250P486VM252944",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252944,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1915,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 99,
      "VoteAgainst": 21,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078",
      "ID": 3181
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2112,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny",
      "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7599421+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4939E258P394VM277222",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277222,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1915,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 99,
      "VoteAgainst": 21,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078",
      "ID": 3181
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4939,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus",
      "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9389395+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325676",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 325676,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1915,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 99,
      "VoteAgainst": 21,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078",
      "ID": 3181
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5074,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon",
      "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5165188+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1828E3P10VM232468",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232468,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1915,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 99,
      "VoteAgainst": 21,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078",
      "ID": 3181
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1828,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo",
      "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8621385+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311349",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311349,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1915,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 99,
      "VoteAgainst": 21,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078",
      "ID": 3181
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4948,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike",
      "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.874876+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2117E90P107VM230480",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230480,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1915,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 99,
      "VoteAgainst": 21,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078",
      "ID": 3181
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2117,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis",
      "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3317429+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267290",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 267290,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1915,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 99,
      "VoteAgainst": 21,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078",
      "ID": 3181
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken",
      "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0130523+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313812",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313812,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1915,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 99,
      "VoteAgainst": 21,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078",
      "ID": 3181
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4966,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek",
      "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.411724+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3101E102P129VM295463",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295463,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1915,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 99,
      "VoteAgainst": 21,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078",
      "ID": 3181
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3101,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala",
      "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5132235+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5034E88P114VM318872",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 318872,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1915,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 99,
      "VoteAgainst": 21,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078",
      "ID": 3181
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5034,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny",
      "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6771213+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306501",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306501,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1915,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 99,
      "VoteAgainst": 21,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078",
      "ID": 3181
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2159,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Martin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5547687+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5110E252P395VM311215",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311215,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1915,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 99,
      "VoteAgainst": 21,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078",
      "ID": 3181
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Mason",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8669454+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268314",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 268314,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1915,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 99,
      "VoteAgainst": 21,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078",
      "ID": 3181
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2133,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.261773+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2876E141P433VM286099",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286099,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1915,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 99,
      "VoteAgainst": 21,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078",
      "ID": 3181
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2876,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3636151+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4951E147P368VM258650",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258650,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1915,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 99,
      "VoteAgainst": 21,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078",
      "ID": 3181
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4951,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan",
      "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3166365+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3896E175P307VM264116",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264116,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1915,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 99,
      "VoteAgainst": 21,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078",
      "ID": 3181
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3896,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam",
      "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9249321+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308424",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 308424,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1915,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 99,
      "VoteAgainst": 21,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078",
      "ID": 3181
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0553383+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4964E143P375VM279287",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279287,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1915,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 99,
      "VoteAgainst": 21,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078",
      "ID": 3181
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4964,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.495331+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279961",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279961,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1915,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 99,
      "VoteAgainst": 21,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078",
      "ID": 3181
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3824,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.530288+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2066E22P91VM261793",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261793,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1915,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 99,
      "VoteAgainst": 21,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078",
      "ID": 3181
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2066,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3784107+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299744",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 299744,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1915,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 99,
      "VoteAgainst": 21,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078",
      "ID": 3181
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7207479+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306610",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306610,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1915,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 99,
      "VoteAgainst": 21,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078",
      "ID": 3181
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina",
      "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5594842+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2487E146P369VM301185",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 301185,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1915,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 99,
      "VoteAgainst": 21,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078",
      "ID": 3181
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2487,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0377896+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223854",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223854,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1915,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 99,
      "VoteAgainst": 21,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078",
      "ID": 3181
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4766229+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237422",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237422,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1915,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 99,
      "VoteAgainst": 21,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078",
      "ID": 3181
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1961,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David",
      "DisplayName": "David McLetchie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2035321+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2134E34P201VM297813",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 297813,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1915,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 99,
      "VoteAgainst": 21,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078",
      "ID": 3181
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2134,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1261278+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320709",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 320709,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1915,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 99,
      "VoteAgainst": 21,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078",
      "ID": 3181
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5041,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan",
      "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1780931+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3763E142P397VM316096",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 316096,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1915,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 99,
      "VoteAgainst": 21,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078",
      "ID": 3181
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3763,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart",
      "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9459864+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1986E23P197VM236649",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 236649,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1915,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 99,
      "VoteAgainst": 21,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078",
      "ID": 3181
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1986,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan",
      "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9341045+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5047E100P130VM291395",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291395,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1915,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 99,
      "VoteAgainst": 21,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078",
      "ID": 3181
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5047,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne",
      "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1174634+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234971",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234971,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1915,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 99,
      "VoteAgainst": 21,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078",
      "ID": 3181
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1845,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette",
      "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4077814+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313666",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313666,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1915,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 99,
      "VoteAgainst": 21,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078",
      "ID": 3181
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3061,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4052326+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1768E19P265VM288595",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 288595,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1915,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 99,
      "VoteAgainst": 21,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078",
      "ID": 3181
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1768,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1501605+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225006",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225006,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1915,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 99,
      "VoteAgainst": 21,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078",
      "ID": 3181
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1894,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Neil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7405223+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3815E98P134VM270843",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270843,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1915,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 99,
      "VoteAgainst": 21,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078",
      "ID": 3181
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3815,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Park, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Park",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8255014+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265950",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265950,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1915,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 99,
      "VoteAgainst": 21,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078",
      "ID": 3181
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2010,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil",
      "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4675511+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283553",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283553,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1915,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 99,
      "VoteAgainst": 21,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078",
      "ID": 3181
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5057,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7132398+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2853E33P128VM251086",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251086,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1915,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 99,
      "VoteAgainst": 21,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078",
      "ID": 3181
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Pentland",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.2264148+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317928",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317928,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1915,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 99,
      "VoteAgainst": 21,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078",
      "ID": 3181
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5009,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4435458+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254679",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254679,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1915,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 99,
      "VoteAgainst": 21,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078",
      "ID": 3181
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3745,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis",
      "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2669821+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1870E225P478VM295653",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295653,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1915,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 99,
      "VoteAgainst": 21,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078",
      "ID": 3181
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1870,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona",
      "DisplayName": "Shona Robison",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5301118+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2135E254P450VM234837",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234837,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1915,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 99,
      "VoteAgainst": 21,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078",
      "ID": 3181
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2135,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Russell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4018768+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1895E232P431VM257350",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257350,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1915,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 99,
      "VoteAgainst": 21,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078",
      "ID": 3181
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1895,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0523564+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228139",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 228139,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1915,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 99,
      "VoteAgainst": 21,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078",
      "ID": 3181
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1839,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5860166+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2345E10P55VM291666",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291666,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1915,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 99,
      "VoteAgainst": 21,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078",
      "ID": 3181
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2345,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1370951+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2223E176P333VM310643",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 310643,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1915,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 99,
      "VoteAgainst": 21,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078",
      "ID": 3181
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2223,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish",
      "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5797606+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246360",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 246360,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1915,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 99,
      "VoteAgainst": 21,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078",
      "ID": 3181
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2182,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1253791+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298148",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298148,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1915,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 99,
      "VoteAgainst": 21,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078",
      "ID": 3181
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5079,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew",
      "DisplayName": "Drew Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1402756+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234333",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234333,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1915,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 99,
      "VoteAgainst": 21,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078",
      "ID": 3181
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1769,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.37275+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4014E14P26VM269915",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269915,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1915,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 99,
      "VoteAgainst": 21,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078",
      "ID": 3181
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4014,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz",
      "DisplayName": "Liz Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5732988+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269146",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269146,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1915,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 99,
      "VoteAgainst": 21,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078",
      "ID": 3181
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2215,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.3056842+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317144",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317144,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1915,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 99,
      "VoteAgainst": 21,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078",
      "ID": 3181
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3806,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.1835897+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326154",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 326154,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1915,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 99,
      "VoteAgainst": 21,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078",
      "ID": 3181
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5106,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin",
      "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.542199+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241152",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241152,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1915,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 99,
      "VoteAgainst": 21,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078",
      "ID": 3181
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1848,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola",
      "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.4042807+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2098E237P531VM289559",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289559,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1915,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 99,
      "VoteAgainst": 21,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078",
      "ID": 3181
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2098,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Swinney",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4492875+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2674E247P401VM247711",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247711,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1915,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 99,
      "VoteAgainst": 21,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078",
      "ID": 3181
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2674,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave",
      "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4251384+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5075E234P371VM284828",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 284828,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1915,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 99,
      "VoteAgainst": 21,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078",
      "ID": 3181
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5075,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Torrance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0494829+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1793E151P362VM222406",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 222406,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1915,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 99,
      "VoteAgainst": 21,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078",
      "ID": 3181
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1793,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean",
      "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.187584+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5078E245P7VM307089",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307089,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1915,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 99,
      "VoteAgainst": 21,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078",
      "ID": 3181
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5078,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Walker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5868071+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1841E231P426VM239971",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239971,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1915,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 99,
      "VoteAgainst": 21,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078",
      "ID": 3181
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1841,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen",
      "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7672104+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283369",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283369,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1915,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 99,
      "VoteAgainst": 21,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078",
      "ID": 3181
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4952,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.6977397+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1865E263P500VM232275",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232275,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1915,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 99,
      "VoteAgainst": 21,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078",
      "ID": 3181
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1865,
      "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra",
      "DisplayName": "Sandra White",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8477251+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237842",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237842,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1915,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 99,
      "VoteAgainst": 21,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078",
      "ID": 3181
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2610,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Wilson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.228429+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309335",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 309335,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1915,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 99,
      "VoteAgainst": 21,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Implications for the Scottish Economy of the Current Eurozone Situation",
      "Reference": "S4M-03078",
      "ID": 3181
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4941,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza",
      "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.324874+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252273",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252273,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1916,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 116,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Motion on the Diamond Jubilee",
      "Reference": "S4M-03077",
      "ID": 3180
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1926,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian",
      "DisplayName": "Brian Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7218893+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2615E213P388VM257515",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257515,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1916,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 116,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Motion on the Diamond Jubilee",
      "Reference": "S4M-03077",
      "ID": 3180
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2615,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George",
      "DisplayName": "George Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0598506+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319949",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319949,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1916,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 116,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Motion on the Diamond Jubilee",
      "Reference": "S4M-03077",
      "ID": 3180
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4940,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare",
      "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9483526+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249710",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 249710,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1916,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 116,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Motion on the Diamond Jubilee",
      "Reference": "S4M-03077",
      "ID": 3180
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2641,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair",
      "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9465824+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1783E21P273VM227380",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227380,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1916,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 116,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Motion on the Diamond Jubilee",
      "Reference": "S4M-03077",
      "ID": 3180
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1783,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie",
      "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5476596+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2633E97P136VM280375",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280375,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1916,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 116,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Motion on the Diamond Jubilee",
      "Reference": "S4M-03077",
      "ID": 3180
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2633,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire",
      "DisplayName": "Claire Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7580218+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262425",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262425,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1916,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 116,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Motion on the Diamond Jubilee",
      "Reference": "S4M-03077",
      "ID": 3180
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2603,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6012689+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1759E91P115VM229222",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229222,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1916,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 116,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Motion on the Diamond Jubilee",
      "Reference": "S4M-03077",
      "ID": 3180
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia",
      "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0673243+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270244",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270244,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1916,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 116,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Motion on the Diamond Jubilee",
      "Reference": "S4M-03077",
      "ID": 3180
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3751,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.7955607+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322835",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 322835,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1916,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 116,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Motion on the Diamond Jubilee",
      "Reference": "S4M-03077",
      "ID": 3180
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5109,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco",
      "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.7056164+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5060E86P124VM294657",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 294657,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1916,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 116,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Motion on the Diamond Jubilee",
      "Reference": "S4M-03077",
      "ID": 3180
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5060,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1726979+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242777",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242777,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1916,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 116,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Motion on the Diamond Jubilee",
      "Reference": "S4M-03077",
      "ID": 3180
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1866,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah",
      "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0350934+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235647",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235647,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1916,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 116,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Motion on the Diamond Jubilee",
      "Reference": "S4M-03077",
      "ID": 3180
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1943,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic",
      "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6868227+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302090",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 302090,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1916,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 116,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Motion on the Diamond Jubilee",
      "Reference": "S4M-03077",
      "ID": 3180
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2595,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin",
      "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.2966285+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244575",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244575,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1916,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 116,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Motion on the Diamond Jubilee",
      "Reference": "S4M-03077",
      "ID": 3180
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2103,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith",
      "DisplayName": "Keith Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.569196+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327340",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 327340,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1916,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 116,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Motion on the Diamond Jubilee",
      "Reference": "S4M-03077",
      "ID": 3180
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:46.0316555+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3775E216P435VM276608",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276608,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1916,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 116,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Motion on the Diamond Jubilee",
      "Reference": "S4M-03077",
      "ID": 3180
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6734572+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264562",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264562,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1916,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 116,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Motion on the Diamond Jubilee",
      "Reference": "S4M-03077",
      "ID": 3180
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2673,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick",
      "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1391502+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248873",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248873,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1916,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 116,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Motion on the Diamond Jubilee",
      "Reference": "S4M-03077",
      "ID": 3180
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2678,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson",
      "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6737177+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2123E27P233VM296340",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 296340,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1916,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 116,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Motion on the Diamond Jubilee",
      "Reference": "S4M-03077",
      "ID": 3180
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2123,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm",
      "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8448114+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285086",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285086,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1916,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 116,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Motion on the Diamond Jubilee",
      "Reference": "S4M-03077",
      "ID": 3180
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3907,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0658153+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230101",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230101,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1916,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 116,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Motion on the Diamond Jubilee",
      "Reference": "S4M-03077",
      "ID": 3180
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1735,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela",
      "DisplayName": "Angela Constance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.1162885+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243920",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 243920,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1916,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 116,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Motion on the Diamond Jubilee",
      "Reference": "S4M-03077",
      "ID": 3180
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1932,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce",
      "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3256025+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1863E238P523VM255305",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255305,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1916,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 116,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Motion on the Diamond Jubilee",
      "Reference": "S4M-03077",
      "ID": 3180
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1863,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna",
      "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.525217+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323975",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 323975,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1916,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 116,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Motion on the Diamond Jubilee",
      "Reference": "S4M-03077",
      "ID": 3180
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4976,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth",
      "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9805847+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5107E223P379VM291871",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291871,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1916,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 116,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Motion on the Diamond Jubilee",
      "Reference": "S4M-03077",
      "ID": 3180
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5107,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1460575+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3743E222P391VM265101",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265101,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1916,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 116,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Motion on the Diamond Jubilee",
      "Reference": "S4M-03077",
      "ID": 3180
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3743,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel",
      "DisplayName": "Nigel Don",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1685218+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3771E149P417VM261710",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261710,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1916,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 116,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Motion on the Diamond Jubilee",
      "Reference": "S4M-03077",
      "ID": 3180
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3771,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob",
      "DisplayName": "Bob Doris",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3692687+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2826E262P384VM282055",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 282055,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1916,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 116,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Motion on the Diamond Jubilee",
      "Reference": "S4M-03077",
      "ID": 3180
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2826,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Dornan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1736604+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3812E94P117VM297916",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 297916,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1916,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 116,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Motion on the Diamond Jubilee",
      "Reference": "S4M-03077",
      "ID": 3180
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3812,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia",
      "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.130454+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231661",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231661,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1916,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 116,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Motion on the Diamond Jubilee",
      "Reference": "S4M-03077",
      "ID": 3180
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1778,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen",
      "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.61017+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4955E240P389VM286162",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286162,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1916,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 116,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Motion on the Diamond Jubilee",
      "Reference": "S4M-03077",
      "ID": 3180
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4955,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3665729+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219287",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 219287,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1916,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 116,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Motion on the Diamond Jubilee",
      "Reference": "S4M-03077",
      "ID": 3180
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1742,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle",
      "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.2866714+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238674",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 238674,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1916,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 116,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Motion on the Diamond Jubilee",
      "Reference": "S4M-03077",
      "ID": 3180
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1994,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus",
      "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4642217+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225514",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225514,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1916,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 116,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Motion on the Diamond Jubilee",
      "Reference": "S4M-03077",
      "ID": 3180
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1814,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda",
      "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.977999+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321625",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 321625,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1916,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 116,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Motion on the Diamond Jubilee",
      "Reference": "S4M-03077",
      "ID": 3180
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Fee",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4441483+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292910",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 292910,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1916,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 116,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Motion on the Diamond Jubilee",
      "Reference": "S4M-03077",
      "ID": 3180
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia",
      "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5634834+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1892E12P64VM226858",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 226858,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1916,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 116,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Motion on the Diamond Jubilee",
      "Reference": "S4M-03077",
      "ID": 3180
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.249728+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5054E95P118VM305099",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 305099,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1916,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 116,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Motion on the Diamond Jubilee",
      "Reference": "S4M-03077",
      "ID": 3180
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5054,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.0721103+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4947E152P361VM257111",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257111,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1916,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 116,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Motion on the Diamond Jubilee",
      "Reference": "S4M-03077",
      "ID": 3180
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4947,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Finnie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.8237785+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271517",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271517,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1916,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 116,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Motion on the Diamond Jubilee",
      "Reference": "S4M-03077",
      "ID": 3180
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3901,
      "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe",
      "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0792473+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278500",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 278500,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1916,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 116,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Motion on the Diamond Jubilee",
      "Reference": "S4M-03077",
      "ID": 3180
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2394,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo",
      "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2215589+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2110E220P414VM286679",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286679,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1916,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 116,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Motion on the Diamond Jubilee",
      "Reference": "S4M-03077",
      "ID": 3180
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth",
      "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5961301+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250389",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250389,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1916,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 116,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Motion on the Diamond Jubilee",
      "Reference": "S4M-03077",
      "ID": 3180
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2675,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob",
      "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1871062+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1741E10P50VM220702",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220702,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1916,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 116,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Motion on the Diamond Jubilee",
      "Reference": "S4M-03077",
      "ID": 3180
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1741,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel",
      "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.653364+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220356",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220356,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1916,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 116,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Motion on the Diamond Jubilee",
      "Reference": "S4M-03077",
      "ID": 3180
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1756,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine",
      "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6378132+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1860E104P150VM251808",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251808,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1916,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 116,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Motion on the Diamond Jubilee",
      "Reference": "S4M-03077",
      "ID": 3180
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1860,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda",
      "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4896891+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2033E20P141VM266184",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 266184,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1916,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 116,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Motion on the Diamond Jubilee",
      "Reference": "S4M-03077",
      "ID": 3180
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2033,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain",
      "DisplayName": "Iain Gray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4779641+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324458",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324458,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1916,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 116,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Motion on the Diamond Jubilee",
      "Reference": "S4M-03077",
      "ID": 3180
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5042,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2235617+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259952",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 259952,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1916,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 116,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Motion on the Diamond Jubilee",
      "Reference": "S4M-03077",
      "ID": 3180
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick",
      "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6371063+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239223",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239223,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1916,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 116,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Motion on the Diamond Jubilee",
      "Reference": "S4M-03077",
      "ID": 3180
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2029,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh",
      "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7274822+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273880",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 273880,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1916,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 116,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Motion on the Diamond Jubilee",
      "Reference": "S4M-03077",
      "ID": 3180
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3758,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6396489+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304239",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 304239,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1916,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 116,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Motion on the Diamond Jubilee",
      "Reference": "S4M-03077",
      "ID": 3180
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4086,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Hume",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.0297118+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221838",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221838,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1916,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 116,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Motion on the Diamond Jubilee",
      "Reference": "S4M-03077",
      "ID": 3180
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1773,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9499803+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1882E227P459VM242074",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242074,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1916,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 116,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Motion on the Diamond Jubilee",
      "Reference": "S4M-03077",
      "ID": 3180
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1882,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam",
      "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7927172+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223807",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223807,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1916,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 116,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Motion on the Diamond Jubilee",
      "Reference": "S4M-03077",
      "ID": 3180
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1893,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4746075+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307500",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307500,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1916,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 116,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Motion on the Diamond Jubilee",
      "Reference": "S4M-03077",
      "ID": 3180
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4934,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8322158+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4956E241P386VM271972",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271972,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1916,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 116,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Motion on the Diamond Jubilee",
      "Reference": "S4M-03077",
      "ID": 3180
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4956,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Keir",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.1058277+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244810",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244810,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1916,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 116,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Motion on the Diamond Jubilee",
      "Reference": "S4M-03077",
      "ID": 3180
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Kelly",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.579601+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3129E261P419VM314983",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 314983,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1916,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 116,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Motion on the Diamond Jubilee",
      "Reference": "S4M-03077",
      "ID": 3180
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3129,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6690309+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2080E36P220VM251137",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251137,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1916,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 116,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Motion on the Diamond Jubilee",
      "Reference": "S4M-03077",
      "ID": 3180
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann",
      "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.2289109+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4016E11P36VM274724",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274724,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1916,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 116,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Motion on the Diamond Jubilee",
      "Reference": "S4M-03077",
      "ID": 3180
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4016,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1189867+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2180E246P463VM256202",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 256202,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1916,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 116,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Motion on the Diamond Jubilee",
      "Reference": "S4M-03077",
      "ID": 3180
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2180,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.7724067+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4938E158P374VM277830",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277830,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1916,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 116,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Motion on the Diamond Jubilee",
      "Reference": "S4M-03077",
      "ID": 3180
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4938,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.970272+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2112E250P486VM252612",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252612,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1916,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 116,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Motion on the Diamond Jubilee",
      "Reference": "S4M-03077",
      "ID": 3180
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2112,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny",
      "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7369633+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4939E258P394VM277226",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277226,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1916,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 116,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Motion on the Diamond Jubilee",
      "Reference": "S4M-03077",
      "ID": 3180
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4939,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus",
      "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9391263+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325673",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 325673,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1916,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 116,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Motion on the Diamond Jubilee",
      "Reference": "S4M-03077",
      "ID": 3180
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5074,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon",
      "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5163781+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1828E3P10VM232465",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232465,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1916,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 116,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Motion on the Diamond Jubilee",
      "Reference": "S4M-03077",
      "ID": 3180
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1828,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo",
      "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8620151+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311346",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311346,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1916,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 116,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Motion on the Diamond Jubilee",
      "Reference": "S4M-03077",
      "ID": 3180
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4948,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike",
      "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.87475+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2117E90P107VM230816",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230816,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1916,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 116,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Motion on the Diamond Jubilee",
      "Reference": "S4M-03077",
      "ID": 3180
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2117,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis",
      "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3467317+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267287",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 267287,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1916,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 116,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Motion on the Diamond Jubilee",
      "Reference": "S4M-03077",
      "ID": 3180
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken",
      "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0129292+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313815",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313815,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1916,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 116,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Motion on the Diamond Jubilee",
      "Reference": "S4M-03077",
      "ID": 3180
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4966,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek",
      "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4118494+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3101E102P129VM295466",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295466,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1916,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 116,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Motion on the Diamond Jubilee",
      "Reference": "S4M-03077",
      "ID": 3180
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3101,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala",
      "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5133463+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5034E88P114VM318875",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 318875,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1916,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 116,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Motion on the Diamond Jubilee",
      "Reference": "S4M-03077",
      "ID": 3180
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5034,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny",
      "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6772494+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306504",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306504,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1916,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 116,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Motion on the Diamond Jubilee",
      "Reference": "S4M-03077",
      "ID": 3180
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2159,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Martin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5549116+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5110E252P395VM311218",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311218,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1916,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 116,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Motion on the Diamond Jubilee",
      "Reference": "S4M-03077",
      "ID": 3180
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Mason",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8670718+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268317",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 268317,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1916,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 116,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Motion on the Diamond Jubilee",
      "Reference": "S4M-03077",
      "ID": 3180
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2133,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2618962+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2876E141P433VM286096",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286096,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1916,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 116,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Motion on the Diamond Jubilee",
      "Reference": "S4M-03077",
      "ID": 3180
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2876,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3634896+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4951E147P368VM260756",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 260756,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1916,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 116,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Motion on the Diamond Jubilee",
      "Reference": "S4M-03077",
      "ID": 3180
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4951,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan",
      "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.0909667+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3896E175P307VM264120",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264120,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1916,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 116,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Motion on the Diamond Jubilee",
      "Reference": "S4M-03077",
      "ID": 3180
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3896,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam",
      "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9250962+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308421",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 308421,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1916,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 116,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Motion on the Diamond Jubilee",
      "Reference": "S4M-03077",
      "ID": 3180
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0552148+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4964E143P375VM279283",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279283,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1916,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 116,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Motion on the Diamond Jubilee",
      "Reference": "S4M-03077",
      "ID": 3180
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4964,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.4951418+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3824E84P113VM280062",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280062,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1916,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 116,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Motion on the Diamond Jubilee",
      "Reference": "S4M-03077",
      "ID": 3180
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3824,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5397963+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2066E22P91VM261798",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261798,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1916,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 116,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Motion on the Diamond Jubilee",
      "Reference": "S4M-03077",
      "ID": 3180
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2066,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.378618+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299747",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 299747,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1916,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 116,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Motion on the Diamond Jubilee",
      "Reference": "S4M-03077",
      "ID": 3180
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7208904+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306607",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306607,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1916,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 116,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Motion on the Diamond Jubilee",
      "Reference": "S4M-03077",
      "ID": 3180
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina",
      "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5593388+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2487E146P369VM301188",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 301188,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1916,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 116,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Motion on the Diamond Jubilee",
      "Reference": "S4M-03077",
      "ID": 3180
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2487,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.037946+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223606",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223606,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1916,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 116,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Motion on the Diamond Jubilee",
      "Reference": "S4M-03077",
      "ID": 3180
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4656906+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237395",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237395,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1916,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 116,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Motion on the Diamond Jubilee",
      "Reference": "S4M-03077",
      "ID": 3180
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1961,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David",
      "DisplayName": "David McLetchie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2023411+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2134E34P201VM297810",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 297810,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1916,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 116,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Motion on the Diamond Jubilee",
      "Reference": "S4M-03077",
      "ID": 3180
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2134,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1259629+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320706",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 320706,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1916,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 116,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Motion on the Diamond Jubilee",
      "Reference": "S4M-03077",
      "ID": 3180
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5041,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan",
      "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1779689+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3763E142P397VM316099",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 316099,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1916,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 116,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Motion on the Diamond Jubilee",
      "Reference": "S4M-03077",
      "ID": 3180
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3763,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart",
      "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9461303+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1986E23P197VM236239",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 236239,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1916,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 116,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Motion on the Diamond Jubilee",
      "Reference": "S4M-03077",
      "ID": 3180
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1986,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan",
      "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9077958+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5047E100P130VM291495",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291495,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1916,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 116,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Motion on the Diamond Jubilee",
      "Reference": "S4M-03077",
      "ID": 3180
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5047,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne",
      "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1217816+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234974",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234974,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1916,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 116,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Motion on the Diamond Jubilee",
      "Reference": "S4M-03077",
      "ID": 3180
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1845,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette",
      "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4079183+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313669",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313669,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1916,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 116,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Motion on the Diamond Jubilee",
      "Reference": "S4M-03077",
      "ID": 3180
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3061,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4053562+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1768E19P265VM288592",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 288592,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1916,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 116,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Motion on the Diamond Jubilee",
      "Reference": "S4M-03077",
      "ID": 3180
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1768,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.150037+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1894E267P527VM224979",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 224979,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1916,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 116,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Motion on the Diamond Jubilee",
      "Reference": "S4M-03077",
      "ID": 3180
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1894,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Neil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7393568+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3815E98P134VM270849",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270849,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1916,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 116,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Motion on the Diamond Jubilee",
      "Reference": "S4M-03077",
      "ID": 3180
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3815,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Park, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Park",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8257663+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265953",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265953,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1916,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 116,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Motion on the Diamond Jubilee",
      "Reference": "S4M-03077",
      "ID": 3180
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2010,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil",
      "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4677656+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283557",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283557,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1916,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 116,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Motion on the Diamond Jubilee",
      "Reference": "S4M-03077",
      "ID": 3180
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5057,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7134067+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2853E33P128VM251058",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251058,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1916,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 116,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Motion on the Diamond Jubilee",
      "Reference": "S4M-03077",
      "ID": 3180
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Pentland",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.2252024+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317925",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317925,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1916,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 116,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Motion on the Diamond Jubilee",
      "Reference": "S4M-03077",
      "ID": 3180
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5009,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4433912+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254774",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254774,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1916,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 116,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Motion on the Diamond Jubilee",
      "Reference": "S4M-03077",
      "ID": 3180
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3745,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis",
      "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2831612+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1870E225P478VM295650",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295650,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1916,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 116,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Motion on the Diamond Jubilee",
      "Reference": "S4M-03077",
      "ID": 3180
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1870,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona",
      "DisplayName": "Shona Robison",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5299669+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2135E254P450VM234809",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234809,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1916,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 116,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Motion on the Diamond Jubilee",
      "Reference": "S4M-03077",
      "ID": 3180
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2135,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Russell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.400686+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1895E232P431VM257347",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257347,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1916,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 116,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Motion on the Diamond Jubilee",
      "Reference": "S4M-03077",
      "ID": 3180
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1895,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0522325+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228044",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 228044,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1916,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 116,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Motion on the Diamond Jubilee",
      "Reference": "S4M-03077",
      "ID": 3180
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1839,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5819513+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2345E10P55VM292061",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 292061,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1916,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 116,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Motion on the Diamond Jubilee",
      "Reference": "S4M-03077",
      "ID": 3180
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2345,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1542717+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2223E176P333VM310640",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 310640,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1916,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 116,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Motion on the Diamond Jubilee",
      "Reference": "S4M-03077",
      "ID": 3180
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2223,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish",
      "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5796324+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2182E87P175VM245956",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 245956,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1916,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 116,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Motion on the Diamond Jubilee",
      "Reference": "S4M-03077",
      "ID": 3180
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2182,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8659327+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298400",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298400,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1916,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 116,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Motion on the Diamond Jubilee",
      "Reference": "S4M-03077",
      "ID": 3180
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5079,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew",
      "DisplayName": "Drew Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3440979+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234435",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234435,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1916,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 116,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Motion on the Diamond Jubilee",
      "Reference": "S4M-03077",
      "ID": 3180
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1769,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3840948+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4014E14P26VM269911",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269911,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1916,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 116,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Motion on the Diamond Jubilee",
      "Reference": "S4M-03077",
      "ID": 3180
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4014,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz",
      "DisplayName": "Liz Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5731279+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269143",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269143,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1916,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 116,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Motion on the Diamond Jubilee",
      "Reference": "S4M-03077",
      "ID": 3180
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2215,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.3055064+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317141",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317141,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1916,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 116,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Motion on the Diamond Jubilee",
      "Reference": "S4M-03077",
      "ID": 3180
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3806,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.1834475+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326157",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 326157,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1916,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 116,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Motion on the Diamond Jubilee",
      "Reference": "S4M-03077",
      "ID": 3180
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5106,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin",
      "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5423216+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241054",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241054,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1916,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 116,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Motion on the Diamond Jubilee",
      "Reference": "S4M-03077",
      "ID": 3180
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1848,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola",
      "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3940982+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2098E237P531VM289555",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289555,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1916,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 116,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Motion on the Diamond Jubilee",
      "Reference": "S4M-03077",
      "ID": 3180
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2098,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Swinney",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4491244+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2674E247P401VM247379",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247379,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1916,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 116,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Motion on the Diamond Jubilee",
      "Reference": "S4M-03077",
      "ID": 3180
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2674,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave",
      "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4012914+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5075E234P371VM284824",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 284824,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1916,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 116,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Motion on the Diamond Jubilee",
      "Reference": "S4M-03077",
      "ID": 3180
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5075,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Torrance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0493208+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1793E151P362VM222379",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 222379,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1916,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 116,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Motion on the Diamond Jubilee",
      "Reference": "S4M-03077",
      "ID": 3180
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1793,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean",
      "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1864108+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5078E245P7VM307092",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307092,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1916,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 116,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Motion on the Diamond Jubilee",
      "Reference": "S4M-03077",
      "ID": 3180
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5078,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Walker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5869304+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1841E231P426VM240224",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 240224,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1916,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 116,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Motion on the Diamond Jubilee",
      "Reference": "S4M-03077",
      "ID": 3180
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1841,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen",
      "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3502189+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283375",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283375,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1916,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 116,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Motion on the Diamond Jubilee",
      "Reference": "S4M-03077",
      "ID": 3180
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4952,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.6979883+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1865E263P500VM232278",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232278,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1916,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 116,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Motion on the Diamond Jubilee",
      "Reference": "S4M-03077",
      "ID": 3180
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1865,
      "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra",
      "DisplayName": "Sandra White",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8478516+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2610E160P413VM245717",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 245717,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1916,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 116,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Motion on the Diamond Jubilee",
      "Reference": "S4M-03077",
      "ID": 3180
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2610,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Wilson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8554071+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309338",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 309338,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1916,
      "AgendaID": 2211,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 116,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Motion on the Diamond Jubilee",
      "Reference": "S4M-03077",
      "ID": 3180
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4941,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza",
      "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-30T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3249969+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252652",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252652,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1909,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 21,
      "VoteAgainst": 99,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.2",
      "ID": 3108
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1926,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian",
      "DisplayName": "Brian Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7386852+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2615E213P388VM258848",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258848,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1909,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 21,
      "VoteAgainst": 99,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.2",
      "ID": 3108
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2615,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George",
      "DisplayName": "George Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3305076+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319882",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319882,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1909,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 21,
      "VoteAgainst": 99,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.2",
      "ID": 3108
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4940,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare",
      "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9454468+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249657",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 249657,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1909,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 21,
      "VoteAgainst": 99,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.2",
      "ID": 3108
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2641,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair",
      "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9442394+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1783E21P273VM227763",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227763,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1909,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 21,
      "VoteAgainst": 99,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.2",
      "ID": 3108
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1783,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie",
      "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5645822+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2633E97P136VM280766",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280766,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1909,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 21,
      "VoteAgainst": 99,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.2",
      "ID": 3108
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2633,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire",
      "DisplayName": "Claire Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7815084+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262492",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262492,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1909,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 21,
      "VoteAgainst": 99,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.2",
      "ID": 3108
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2603,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.604268+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1759E91P115VM229742",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229742,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1909,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 21,
      "VoteAgainst": 99,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.2",
      "ID": 3108
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia",
      "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0947417+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270179",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270179,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1909,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 21,
      "VoteAgainst": 99,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.2",
      "ID": 3108
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3751,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5849504+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322728",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 322728,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1909,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 21,
      "VoteAgainst": 99,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.2",
      "ID": 3108
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5109,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco",
      "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.7010963+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5060E86P124VM294723",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 294723,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1909,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 21,
      "VoteAgainst": 99,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.2",
      "ID": 3108
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5060,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1755506+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242873",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242873,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1909,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 21,
      "VoteAgainst": 99,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.2",
      "ID": 3108
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1866,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah",
      "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0392494+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235552",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235552,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1909,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 21,
      "VoteAgainst": 99,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.2",
      "ID": 3108
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1943,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic",
      "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6827248+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302150",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 302150,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1909,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 21,
      "VoteAgainst": 99,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.2",
      "ID": 3108
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2595,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin",
      "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.2993687+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244508",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244508,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1909,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 21,
      "VoteAgainst": 99,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.2",
      "ID": 3108
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2103,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith",
      "DisplayName": "Keith Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5578032+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327249",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 327249,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1909,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 21,
      "VoteAgainst": 99,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.2",
      "ID": 3108
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:46.027679+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3775E216P435VM276675",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276675,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1909,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 21,
      "VoteAgainst": 99,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.2",
      "ID": 3108
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6763265+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264342",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264342,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1909,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 21,
      "VoteAgainst": 99,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.2",
      "ID": 3108
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2673,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick",
      "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1293826+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248777",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248777,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1909,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 21,
      "VoteAgainst": 99,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.2",
      "ID": 3108
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2678,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson",
      "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6696125+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2123E27P233VM295812",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295812,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1909,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 21,
      "VoteAgainst": 99,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.2",
      "ID": 3108
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2123,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm",
      "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.53691+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285153",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285153,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1909,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 21,
      "VoteAgainst": 99,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.2",
      "ID": 3108
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3907,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0687271+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230168",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230168,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1909,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 21,
      "VoteAgainst": 99,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.2",
      "ID": 3108
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1735,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela",
      "DisplayName": "Angela Constance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.119167+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243846",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 243846,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1909,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 21,
      "VoteAgainst": 99,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.2",
      "ID": 3108
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1932,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce",
      "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3224285+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254938",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254938,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1909,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 21,
      "VoteAgainst": 99,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.2",
      "ID": 3108
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1863,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna",
      "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.290242+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323884",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 323884,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1909,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 21,
      "VoteAgainst": 99,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.2",
      "ID": 3108
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4976,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth",
      "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.976561+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5107E223P379VM291338",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291338,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1909,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 21,
      "VoteAgainst": 99,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.2",
      "ID": 3108
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5107,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1147347+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3743E222P391VM265324",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265324,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1909,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 21,
      "VoteAgainst": 99,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.2",
      "ID": 3108
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3743,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel",
      "DisplayName": "Nigel Don",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.434258+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262247",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262247,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1909,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 21,
      "VoteAgainst": 99,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.2",
      "ID": 3108
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3771,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob",
      "DisplayName": "Bob Doris",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.5932758+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281975",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 281975,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1909,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 21,
      "VoteAgainst": 99,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.2",
      "ID": 3108
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2826,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Dornan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1658196+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3812E94P117VM297997",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 297997,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1909,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 21,
      "VoteAgainst": 99,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.2",
      "ID": 3108
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3812,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia",
      "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1338741+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231602",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231602,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1909,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 21,
      "VoteAgainst": 99,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.2",
      "ID": 3108
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1778,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen",
      "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6076879+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4955E240P389VM285944",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285944,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1909,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 21,
      "VoteAgainst": 99,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.2",
      "ID": 3108
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4955,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3512767+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219385",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 219385,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1909,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 21,
      "VoteAgainst": 99,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.2",
      "ID": 3108
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1742,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle",
      "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.2963578+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238579",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 238579,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1909,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 21,
      "VoteAgainst": 99,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.2",
      "ID": 3108
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1994,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus",
      "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4602047+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225462",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225462,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1909,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 21,
      "VoteAgainst": 99,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.2",
      "ID": 3108
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1814,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda",
      "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9757778+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321732",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 321732,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1909,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 21,
      "VoteAgainst": 99,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.2",
      "ID": 3108
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Fee",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4490284+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292802",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 292802,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1909,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 21,
      "VoteAgainst": 99,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.2",
      "ID": 3108
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia",
      "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5587495+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227111",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227111,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1909,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 21,
      "VoteAgainst": 99,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.2",
      "ID": 3108
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2682556+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5054E95P118VM312666",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 312666,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1909,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 21,
      "VoteAgainst": 99,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.2",
      "ID": 3108
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5054,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1381387+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4947E152P361VM257216",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257216,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1909,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 21,
      "VoteAgainst": 99,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.2",
      "ID": 3108
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4947,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Finnie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0465665+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271299",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271299,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1909,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 21,
      "VoteAgainst": 99,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.2",
      "ID": 3108
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3901,
      "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe",
      "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0642917+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278420",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 278420,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1909,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 21,
      "VoteAgainst": 99,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.2",
      "ID": 3108
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2394,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo",
      "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2180257+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2110E220P414VM286738",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286738,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1909,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 21,
      "VoteAgainst": 99,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.2",
      "ID": 3108
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth",
      "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5985855+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250494",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250494,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1909,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 21,
      "VoteAgainst": 99,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.2",
      "ID": 3108
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2675,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob",
      "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1919677+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1741E10P50VM220753",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220753,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1909,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 21,
      "VoteAgainst": 99,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.2",
      "ID": 3108
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1741,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel",
      "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6555541+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220258",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220258,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1909,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 21,
      "VoteAgainst": 99,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.2",
      "ID": 3108
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1756,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine",
      "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6306554+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1860E104P150VM252327",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252327,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1909,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 21,
      "VoteAgainst": 99,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.2",
      "ID": 3108
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1860,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda",
      "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7243686+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2033E20P141VM266107",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 266107,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1909,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 21,
      "VoteAgainst": 99,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.2",
      "ID": 3108
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2033,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain",
      "DisplayName": "Iain Gray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4746437+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324549",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324549,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1909,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 21,
      "VoteAgainst": 99,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.2",
      "ID": 3108
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5042,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2277696+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259724",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 259724,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1909,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 21,
      "VoteAgainst": 99,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.2",
      "ID": 3108
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick",
      "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.62181+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239318",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239318,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1909,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 21,
      "VoteAgainst": 99,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.2",
      "ID": 3108
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2029,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh",
      "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7316491+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273813",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 273813,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1909,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 21,
      "VoteAgainst": 99,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.2",
      "ID": 3108
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3758,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6367651+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304179",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 304179,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1909,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 21,
      "VoteAgainst": 99,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.2",
      "ID": 3108
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4086,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Hume",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.853285+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221786",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221786,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1909,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 21,
      "VoteAgainst": 99,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.2",
      "ID": 3108
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1773,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9477567+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1882E227P459VM242020",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242020,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1909,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 21,
      "VoteAgainst": 99,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.2",
      "ID": 3108
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1882,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam",
      "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7903717+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223711",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223711,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1909,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 21,
      "VoteAgainst": 99,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.2",
      "ID": 3108
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1893,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4705037+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307581",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307581,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1909,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 21,
      "VoteAgainst": 99,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.2",
      "ID": 3108
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4934,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8356887+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272231",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 272231,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1909,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 21,
      "VoteAgainst": 99,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.2",
      "ID": 3108
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4956,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Keir",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3206801+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244881",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244881,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1909,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 21,
      "VoteAgainst": 99,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.2",
      "ID": 3108
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Kelly",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5826086+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315050",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315050,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1909,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 21,
      "VoteAgainst": 99,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.2",
      "ID": 3108
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3129,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6719177+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247950",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247950,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1909,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 21,
      "VoteAgainst": 99,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.2",
      "ID": 3108
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann",
      "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4353326+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4016E11P36VM274786",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274786,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1909,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 21,
      "VoteAgainst": 99,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.2",
      "ID": 3108
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4016,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1216959+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255800",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255800,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1909,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 21,
      "VoteAgainst": 99,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.2",
      "ID": 3108
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2180,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5576366+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4938E158P374VM277459",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277459,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1909,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 21,
      "VoteAgainst": 99,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.2",
      "ID": 3108
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4938,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9542682+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2112E250P486VM253012",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253012,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1909,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 21,
      "VoteAgainst": 99,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.2",
      "ID": 3108
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2112,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny",
      "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7630606+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4939E258P394VM276843",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276843,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1909,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 21,
      "VoteAgainst": 99,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.2",
      "ID": 3108
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4939,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus",
      "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6834844+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325582",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 325582,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1909,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 21,
      "VoteAgainst": 99,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.2",
      "ID": 3108
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5074,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon",
      "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5125398+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1828E3P10VM232831",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232831,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1909,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 21,
      "VoteAgainst": 99,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.2",
      "ID": 3108
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1828,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo",
      "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8782125+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311427",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311427,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1909,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 21,
      "VoteAgainst": 99,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.2",
      "ID": 3108
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4948,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike",
      "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8783397+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2117E90P107VM230411",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230411,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1909,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 21,
      "VoteAgainst": 99,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.2",
      "ID": 3108
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2117,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis",
      "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3286607+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267364",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 267364,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1909,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 21,
      "VoteAgainst": 99,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.2",
      "ID": 3108
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken",
      "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0162589+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313734",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313734,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1909,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 21,
      "VoteAgainst": 99,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.2",
      "ID": 3108
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4966,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek",
      "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4083553+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3101E102P129VM295077",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295077,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1909,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 21,
      "VoteAgainst": 99,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.2",
      "ID": 3108
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3101,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala",
      "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1912151+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5034E88P114VM318981",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 318981,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1909,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 21,
      "VoteAgainst": 99,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.2",
      "ID": 3108
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5034,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny",
      "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6873175+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306436",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306436,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1909,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 21,
      "VoteAgainst": 99,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.2",
      "ID": 3108
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2159,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Martin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5519834+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5110E252P395VM310804",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 310804,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1909,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 21,
      "VoteAgainst": 99,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.2",
      "ID": 3108
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Mason",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5867635+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268239",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 268239,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1909,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 21,
      "VoteAgainst": 99,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.2",
      "ID": 3108
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2133,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2548641+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2876E141P433VM286333",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286333,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1909,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 21,
      "VoteAgainst": 99,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.2",
      "ID": 3108
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2876,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5743086+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4951E147P368VM258640",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258640,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1909,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 21,
      "VoteAgainst": 99,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.2",
      "ID": 3108
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4951,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan",
      "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.316218+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3896E175P307VM263892",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 263892,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1909,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 21,
      "VoteAgainst": 99,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.2",
      "ID": 3108
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3896,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam",
      "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9152833+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308528",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 308528,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1909,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 21,
      "VoteAgainst": 99,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.2",
      "ID": 3108
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0598094+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4964E143P375VM279664",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279664,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1909,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 21,
      "VoteAgainst": 99,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.2",
      "ID": 3108
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4964,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5173478+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279995",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279995,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1909,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 21,
      "VoteAgainst": 99,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.2",
      "ID": 3108
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3824,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5318308+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2066E22P91VM261107",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261107,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1909,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 21,
      "VoteAgainst": 99,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.2",
      "ID": 3108
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2066,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.1121151+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299666",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 299666,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1909,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 21,
      "VoteAgainst": 99,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.2",
      "ID": 3108
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7075376+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306714",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306714,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1909,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 21,
      "VoteAgainst": 99,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.2",
      "ID": 3108
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina",
      "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5642593+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300620",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 300620,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1909,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 21,
      "VoteAgainst": 99,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.2",
      "ID": 3108
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2487,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0064509+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223658",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223658,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1909,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 21,
      "VoteAgainst": 99,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.2",
      "ID": 3108
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.468258+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237490",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237490,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1909,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 21,
      "VoteAgainst": 99,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.2",
      "ID": 3108
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1961,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David",
      "DisplayName": "David McLetchie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2128514+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305431",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 305431,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1909,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 21,
      "VoteAgainst": 99,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.2",
      "ID": 3108
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2134,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3237195+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320445",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 320445,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1909,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 21,
      "VoteAgainst": 99,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.2",
      "ID": 3108
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5041,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan",
      "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.166708+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3763E142P397VM316032",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 316032,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1909,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 21,
      "VoteAgainst": 99,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.2",
      "ID": 3108
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3763,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart",
      "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9429024+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1986E23P197VM236306",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 236306,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1909,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 21,
      "VoteAgainst": 99,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.2",
      "ID": 3108
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1986,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan",
      "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9107272+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5047E100P130VM291428",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291428,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1909,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 21,
      "VoteAgainst": 99,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.2",
      "ID": 3108
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5047,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne",
      "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1188898+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234609",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234609,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1909,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 21,
      "VoteAgainst": 99,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.2",
      "ID": 3108
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1845,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette",
      "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3916927+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313602",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313602,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1909,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 21,
      "VoteAgainst": 99,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.2",
      "ID": 3108
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3061,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4024743+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1768E19P265VM289318",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289318,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1909,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 21,
      "VoteAgainst": 99,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.2",
      "ID": 3108
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1768,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4321067+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225074",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225074,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1909,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 21,
      "VoteAgainst": 99,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.2",
      "ID": 3108
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1894,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Neil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7433885+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3815E98P134VM270907",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270907,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1909,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 21,
      "VoteAgainst": 99,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.2",
      "ID": 3108
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3815,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Park, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Park",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8285716+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265895",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265895,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1909,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 21,
      "VoteAgainst": 99,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.2",
      "ID": 3108
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2010,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil",
      "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4651835+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283329",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283329,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1909,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 21,
      "VoteAgainst": 99,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.2",
      "ID": 3108
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5057,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.6960108+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2853E33P128VM251462",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251462,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1909,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 21,
      "VoteAgainst": 99,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.2",
      "ID": 3108
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Pentland",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4647069+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317666",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317666,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1909,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 21,
      "VoteAgainst": 99,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.2",
      "ID": 3108
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5009,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4322136+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254669",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254669,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1909,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 21,
      "VoteAgainst": 99,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.2",
      "ID": 3108
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3745,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis",
      "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2665424+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1870E225P478VM296219",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 296219,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1909,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 21,
      "VoteAgainst": 99,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.2",
      "ID": 3108
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1870,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona",
      "DisplayName": "Shona Robison",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8391948+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2135E254P450VM234906",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234906,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1909,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 21,
      "VoteAgainst": 99,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.2",
      "ID": 3108
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2135,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Russell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4048593+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1895E232P431VM257404",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257404,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1909,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 21,
      "VoteAgainst": 99,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.2",
      "ID": 3108
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1895,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0547435+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228096",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 228096,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1909,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 21,
      "VoteAgainst": 99,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.2",
      "ID": 3108
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1839,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5841791+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2345E10P55VM291693",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291693,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1909,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 21,
      "VoteAgainst": 99,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.2",
      "ID": 3108
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2345,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1382337+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2223E176P333VM310707",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 310707,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1909,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 21,
      "VoteAgainst": 99,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.2",
      "ID": 3108
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2223,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish",
      "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.582582+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246317",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 246317,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1909,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 21,
      "VoteAgainst": 99,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.2",
      "ID": 3108
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2182,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1234729+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298335",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298335,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1909,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 21,
      "VoteAgainst": 99,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.2",
      "ID": 3108
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5079,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew",
      "DisplayName": "Drew Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3413114+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234369",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234369,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1909,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 21,
      "VoteAgainst": 99,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.2",
      "ID": 3108
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1769,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3742964+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274574",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274574,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1909,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 21,
      "VoteAgainst": 99,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.2",
      "ID": 3108
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4014,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz",
      "DisplayName": "Liz Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.112502+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269531",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269531,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1909,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 21,
      "VoteAgainst": 99,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.2",
      "ID": 3108
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2215,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5516424+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317361",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317361,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1909,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 21,
      "VoteAgainst": 99,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.2",
      "ID": 3108
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3806,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4188231+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326248",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 326248,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1909,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 21,
      "VoteAgainst": 99,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.2",
      "ID": 3108
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5106,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin",
      "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7502552+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241108",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241108,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1909,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 21,
      "VoteAgainst": 99,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.2",
      "ID": 3108
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1848,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola",
      "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.396432+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2098E237P531VM289624",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289624,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1909,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 21,
      "VoteAgainst": 99,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.2",
      "ID": 3108
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2098,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Swinney",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4520184+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2674E247P401VM247780",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247780,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1909,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 21,
      "VoteAgainst": 99,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.2",
      "ID": 3108
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2674,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave",
      "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4281335+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5075E234P371VM284895",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 284895,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1909,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 21,
      "VoteAgainst": 99,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.2",
      "ID": 3108
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5075,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Torrance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0523239+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1793E151P362VM222475",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 222475,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1909,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 21,
      "VoteAgainst": 99,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.2",
      "ID": 3108
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1793,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean",
      "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1905492+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5078E245P7VM306991",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306991,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1909,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 21,
      "VoteAgainst": 99,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.2",
      "ID": 3108
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5078,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Walker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5826251+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1841E231P426VM240170",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 240170,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1909,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 21,
      "VoteAgainst": 99,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.2",
      "ID": 3108
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1841,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen",
      "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7819729+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283437",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283437,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1909,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 21,
      "VoteAgainst": 99,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.2",
      "ID": 3108
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4952,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7078399+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1865E263P500VM232201",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232201,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1909,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 21,
      "VoteAgainst": 99,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.2",
      "ID": 3108
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1865,
      "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra",
      "DisplayName": "Sandra White",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8444661+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237773",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237773,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1909,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 21,
      "VoteAgainst": 99,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.2",
      "ID": 3108
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2610,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Wilson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2254921+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309257",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 309257,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1909,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 21,
      "VoteAgainst": 99,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.2",
      "ID": 3108
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4941,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza",
      "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.321537+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252316",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252316,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1908,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.1",
      "ID": 3106
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1926,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian",
      "DisplayName": "Brian Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7238953+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2615E213P388VM258847",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258847,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1908,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.1",
      "ID": 3106
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2615,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George",
      "DisplayName": "George Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3304666+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319883",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319883,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1908,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.1",
      "ID": 3106
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4940,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare",
      "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9455076+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249658",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 249658,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1908,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.1",
      "ID": 3106
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2641,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair",
      "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9442798+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1783E21P273VM227729",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227729,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1908,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.1",
      "ID": 3106
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1783,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie",
      "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5631472+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2633E97P136VM280729",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280729,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1908,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.1",
      "ID": 3106
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2633,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire",
      "DisplayName": "Claire Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7799393+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262491",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262491,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1908,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.1",
      "ID": 3106
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2603,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6042267+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1759E91P115VM229741",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229741,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1908,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.1",
      "ID": 3106
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia",
      "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0947011+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270180",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270180,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1908,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.1",
      "ID": 3106
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3751,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5849917+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322727",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 322727,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1908,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.1",
      "ID": 3106
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5109,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco",
      "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.7010552+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5060E86P124VM294722",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 294722,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1908,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.1",
      "ID": 3106
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5060,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1755094+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242872",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242872,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1908,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.1",
      "ID": 3106
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1866,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah",
      "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0392088+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235553",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235553,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1908,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.1",
      "ID": 3106
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1943,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic",
      "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6827653+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302149",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 302149,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1908,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.1",
      "ID": 3106
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2595,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin",
      "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.299317+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244509",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244509,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1908,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.1",
      "ID": 3106
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2103,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith",
      "DisplayName": "Keith Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5578448+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327248",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 327248,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1908,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.1",
      "ID": 3106
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:46.0276371+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3775E216P435VM276674",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276674,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1908,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.1",
      "ID": 3106
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.676286+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264343",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264343,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1908,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.1",
      "ID": 3106
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2673,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick",
      "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1294236+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248778",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248778,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1908,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.1",
      "ID": 3106
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2678,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson",
      "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6696534+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2123E27P233VM295813",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295813,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1908,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.1",
      "ID": 3106
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2123,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm",
      "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5369697+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285152",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285152,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1908,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.1",
      "ID": 3106
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3907,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0686851+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230167",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230167,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1908,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.1",
      "ID": 3106
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1735,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela",
      "DisplayName": "Angela Constance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.1191064+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243847",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 243847,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1908,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.1",
      "ID": 3106
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1932,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce",
      "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.322469+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254939",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254939,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1908,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.1",
      "ID": 3106
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1863,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna",
      "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2902832+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323883",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 323883,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1908,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.1",
      "ID": 3106
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4976,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth",
      "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9765171+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5107E223P379VM291339",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291339,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1908,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.1",
      "ID": 3106
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5107,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1147788+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3743E222P391VM265323",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265323,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1908,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.1",
      "ID": 3106
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3743,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel",
      "DisplayName": "Nigel Don",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4342163+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262246",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262246,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1908,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.1",
      "ID": 3106
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3771,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob",
      "DisplayName": "Bob Doris",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.5932347+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2826E262P384VM282012",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 282012,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1908,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.1",
      "ID": 3106
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2826,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Dornan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.167396+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3812E94P117VM297961",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 297961,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1908,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.1",
      "ID": 3106
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3812,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia",
      "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1323458+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231603",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231603,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1908,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.1",
      "ID": 3106
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1778,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen",
      "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6077286+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4955E240P389VM285945",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285945,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1908,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.1",
      "ID": 3106
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4955,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3513191+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219384",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 219384,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1908,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.1",
      "ID": 3106
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1742,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle",
      "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.2963145+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238580",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 238580,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1908,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.1",
      "ID": 3106
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1994,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus",
      "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4602453+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225463",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225463,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1908,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.1",
      "ID": 3106
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1814,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda",
      "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9758191+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321765",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 321765,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1908,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.1",
      "ID": 3106
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Fee",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4504245+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292885",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 292885,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1908,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.1",
      "ID": 3106
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia",
      "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5622513+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227110",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227110,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1908,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.1",
      "ID": 3106
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2682138+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5054E95P118VM312665",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 312665,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1908,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.1",
      "ID": 3106
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5054,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1380754+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4947E152P361VM257162",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257162,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1908,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.1",
      "ID": 3106
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4947,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Finnie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.8259839+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271300",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271300,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1908,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.1",
      "ID": 3106
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3901,
      "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe",
      "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0643532+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278456",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 278456,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1908,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.1",
      "ID": 3106
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2394,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo",
      "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2196056+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2110E220P414VM286737",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286737,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1908,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.1",
      "ID": 3106
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth",
      "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5985451+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250440",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250440,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1908,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.1",
      "ID": 3106
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2675,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob",
      "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.189642+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1741E10P50VM220752",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220752,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1908,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.1",
      "ID": 3106
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1741,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel",
      "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.655513+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220259",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220259,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1908,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.1",
      "ID": 3106
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1756,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine",
      "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6307169+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1860E104P150VM252326",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252326,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1908,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.1",
      "ID": 3106
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1860,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda",
      "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.724326+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2033E20P141VM266142",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 266142,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1908,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.1",
      "ID": 3106
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2033,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain",
      "DisplayName": "Iain Gray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.476135+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324550",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324550,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1908,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.1",
      "ID": 3106
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5042,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2278115+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259725",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 259725,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1908,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.1",
      "ID": 3106
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick",
      "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6218526+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239317",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239317,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1908,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.1",
      "ID": 3106
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2029,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh",
      "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7316077+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273814",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 273814,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1908,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.1",
      "ID": 3106
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3758,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6368072+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304180",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 304180,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1908,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.1",
      "ID": 3106
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4086,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Hume",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8533547+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221787",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221787,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1908,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.1",
      "ID": 3106
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1773,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9478003+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1882E227P459VM242021",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242021,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1908,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.1",
      "ID": 3106
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1882,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam",
      "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7904131+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223712",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223712,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1908,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.1",
      "ID": 3106
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1893,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4705445+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307545",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307545,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1908,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.1",
      "ID": 3106
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4934,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8341486+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272179",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 272179,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1908,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.1",
      "ID": 3106
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4956,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Keir",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.1149673+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244880",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244880,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1908,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.1",
      "ID": 3106
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Kelly",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5825677+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315049",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315049,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1908,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.1",
      "ID": 3106
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3129,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6718764+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247951",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247951,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1908,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.1",
      "ID": 3106
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann",
      "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4353737+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4016E11P36VM274785",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274785,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1908,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.1",
      "ID": 3106
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4016,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1216542+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255801",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255801,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1908,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.1",
      "ID": 3106
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2180,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5576772+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4938E158P374VM277460",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277460,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1908,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.1",
      "ID": 3106
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4938,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9543094+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2112E250P486VM253011",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253011,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1908,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.1",
      "ID": 3106
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2112,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny",
      "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7630195+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4939E258P394VM276844",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276844,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1908,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.1",
      "ID": 3106
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4939,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus",
      "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6835468+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325581",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 325581,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1908,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.1",
      "ID": 3106
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5074,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon",
      "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5124989+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1828E3P10VM232830",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232830,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1908,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.1",
      "ID": 3106
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1828,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo",
      "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8781713+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311392",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311392,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1908,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.1",
      "ID": 3106
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4948,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike",
      "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8767386+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2117E90P107VM230412",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230412,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1908,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.1",
      "ID": 3106
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2117,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis",
      "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.328703+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267329",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 267329,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1908,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.1",
      "ID": 3106
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken",
      "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0147474+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313769",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313769,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1908,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.1",
      "ID": 3106
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4966,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek",
      "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4098863+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3101E102P129VM295421",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295421,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1908,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.1",
      "ID": 3106
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3101,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala",
      "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5114387+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319015",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319015,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1908,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.1",
      "ID": 3106
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5034,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny",
      "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.688776+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306437",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306437,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1908,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.1",
      "ID": 3106
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2159,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Martin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5520452+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5110E252P395VM310786",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 310786,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1908,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.1",
      "ID": 3106
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Mason",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5859895+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268275",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 268275,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1908,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.1",
      "ID": 3106
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2133,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2600441+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2876E141P433VM286140",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286140,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1908,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.1",
      "ID": 3106
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2876,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3656249+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4951E147P368VM260705",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 260705,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1908,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.1",
      "ID": 3106
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4951,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan",
      "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.0887201+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3896E175P307VM263893",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 263893,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1908,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.1",
      "ID": 3106
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3896,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam",
      "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9153247+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308546",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 308546,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1908,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.1",
      "ID": 3106
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.060561+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4964E143P375VM279663",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279663,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1908,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.1",
      "ID": 3106
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4964,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5173063+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279996",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279996,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1908,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.1",
      "ID": 3106
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3824,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5318833+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2066E22P91VM261108",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261108,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1908,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.1",
      "ID": 3106
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2066,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.1121571+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299702",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 299702,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1908,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.1",
      "ID": 3106
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7189081+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306733",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306733,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1908,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.1",
      "ID": 3106
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina",
      "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5650647+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2487E146P369VM301163",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 301163,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1908,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.1",
      "ID": 3106
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2487,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0366195+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223657",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223657,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1908,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.1",
      "ID": 3106
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4682162+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237489",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237489,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1908,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.1",
      "ID": 3106
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1961,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David",
      "DisplayName": "David McLetchie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2128087+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305430",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 305430,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1908,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.1",
      "ID": 3106
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2134,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3236786+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320411",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 320411,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1908,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.1",
      "ID": 3106
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5041,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan",
      "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1652547+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3763E142P397VM316033",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 316033,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1908,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.1",
      "ID": 3106
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3763,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart",
      "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9429437+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1986E23P197VM236305",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 236305,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1908,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.1",
      "ID": 3106
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1986,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan",
      "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9106841+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5047E100P130VM291429",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291429,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1908,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.1",
      "ID": 3106
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5047,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne",
      "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1189318+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234610",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234610,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1908,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.1",
      "ID": 3106
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1845,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette",
      "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3917339+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313603",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313603,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1908,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.1",
      "ID": 3106
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3061,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4025163+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1768E19P265VM288617",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 288617,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1908,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.1",
      "ID": 3106
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1768,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1511188+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225073",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225073,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1908,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.1",
      "ID": 3106
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1894,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Neil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7433471+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3815E98P134VM270906",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270906,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1908,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.1",
      "ID": 3106
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3815,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Park, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Park",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8285303+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265896",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265896,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1908,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.1",
      "ID": 3106
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2010,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil",
      "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4652257+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283330",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283330,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1908,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.1",
      "ID": 3106
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5057,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.6960527+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2853E33P128VM251461",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251461,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1908,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.1",
      "ID": 3106
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Pentland",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4646637+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317631",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317631,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1908,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.1",
      "ID": 3106
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5009,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4307346+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254723",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254723,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1908,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.1",
      "ID": 3106
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3745,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis",
      "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.280977+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1870E225P478VM295675",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295675,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1908,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.1",
      "ID": 3106
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1870,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona",
      "DisplayName": "Shona Robison",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5310417+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2135E254P450VM234905",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234905,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1908,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.1",
      "ID": 3106
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2135,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Russell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4047994+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1895E232P431VM257403",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257403,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1908,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.1",
      "ID": 3106
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1895,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0547013+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228095",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 228095,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1908,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.1",
      "ID": 3106
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1839,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.584138+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2345E10P55VM291694",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291694,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1908,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.1",
      "ID": 3106
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2345,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1382748+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2223E176P333VM310706",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 310706,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1908,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.1",
      "ID": 3106
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2223,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish",
      "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5825405+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246316",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 246316,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1908,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.1",
      "ID": 3106
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2182,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1234313+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298336",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298336,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1908,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.1",
      "ID": 3106
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5079,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew",
      "DisplayName": "Drew Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3413529+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234370",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234370,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1908,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.1",
      "ID": 3106
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1769,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3743564+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274573",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274573,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1908,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.1",
      "ID": 3106
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4014,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz",
      "DisplayName": "Liz Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1124601+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269495",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269495,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1908,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.1",
      "ID": 3106
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2215,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5500904+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317207",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317207,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1908,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.1",
      "ID": 3106
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3806,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4081006+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326249",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 326249,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1908,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.1",
      "ID": 3106
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5106,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin",
      "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7502988+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241107",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241107,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1908,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.1",
      "ID": 3106
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1848,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola",
      "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3963893+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2098E237P531VM289623",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289623,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1908,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.1",
      "ID": 3106
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2098,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Swinney",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4519781+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2674E247P401VM247779",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247779,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1908,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.1",
      "ID": 3106
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2674,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave",
      "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4280923+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5075E234P371VM284894",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 284894,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1908,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.1",
      "ID": 3106
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5075,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Torrance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0522816+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1793E151P362VM222474",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 222474,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1908,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.1",
      "ID": 3106
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1793,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean",
      "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1905076+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5078E245P7VM306973",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306973,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1908,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.1",
      "ID": 3106
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5078,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Walker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.581851+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1841E231P426VM240171",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 240171,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1908,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.1",
      "ID": 3106
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1841,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen",
      "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7820143+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283436",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283436,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1908,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.1",
      "ID": 3106
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4952,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7077976+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1865E263P500VM232235",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232235,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1908,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.1",
      "ID": 3106
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1865,
      "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra",
      "DisplayName": "Sandra White",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8459813+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237774",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237774,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1908,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.1",
      "ID": 3106
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2610,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Wilson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2255331+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309293",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 309293,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1908,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004.1",
      "ID": 3106
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4941,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza",
      "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3230742+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252653",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252653,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1910,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 85,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004",
      "ID": 3103
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1926,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian",
      "DisplayName": "Brian Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7387264+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2615E213P388VM258849",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258849,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1910,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 85,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004",
      "ID": 3103
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2615,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George",
      "DisplayName": "George Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3305485+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319881",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319881,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1910,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 85,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004",
      "ID": 3103
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4940,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare",
      "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9454043+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249604",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 249604,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1910,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 85,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004",
      "ID": 3103
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2641,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair",
      "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.933986+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1783E21P273VM227764",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227764,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1910,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 85,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004",
      "ID": 3103
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1783,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie",
      "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5646229+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2633E97P136VM280767",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280767,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1910,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 85,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004",
      "ID": 3103
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2633,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire",
      "DisplayName": "Claire Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7815494+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262493",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262493,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1910,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 85,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004",
      "ID": 3103
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2603,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6043087+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1759E91P115VM229743",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229743,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1910,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 85,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004",
      "ID": 3103
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia",
      "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0947833+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270178",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270178,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1910,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 85,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004",
      "ID": 3103
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3751,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5849094+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322729",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 322729,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1910,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 85,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004",
      "ID": 3103
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5109,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco",
      "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.7011367+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5060E86P124VM294724",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 294724,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1910,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 85,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004",
      "ID": 3103
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5060,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1755918+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242874",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242874,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1910,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 85,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004",
      "ID": 3103
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1866,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah",
      "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0392905+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235551",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235551,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1910,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 85,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004",
      "ID": 3103
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1943,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic",
      "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6826833+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302151",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 302151,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1910,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 85,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004",
      "ID": 3103
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2595,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin",
      "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.2994214+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244507",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244507,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1910,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 85,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004",
      "ID": 3103
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2103,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith",
      "DisplayName": "Keith Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5577604+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327250",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 327250,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1910,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 85,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004",
      "ID": 3103
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:46.0277408+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3775E216P435VM276676",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276676,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1910,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 85,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004",
      "ID": 3103
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6763665+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264341",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264341,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1910,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 85,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004",
      "ID": 3103
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2673,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick",
      "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1293414+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248776",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248776,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1910,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 85,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004",
      "ID": 3103
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2678,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson",
      "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6695711+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2123E27P233VM295811",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295811,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1910,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 85,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004",
      "ID": 3103
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2123,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm",
      "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5368688+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285154",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285154,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1910,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 85,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004",
      "ID": 3103
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3907,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.068768+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230169",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230169,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1910,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 85,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004",
      "ID": 3103
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1735,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela",
      "DisplayName": "Angela Constance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.1192095+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243845",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 243845,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1910,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 85,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004",
      "ID": 3103
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1932,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce",
      "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3223877+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254937",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254937,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1910,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 85,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004",
      "ID": 3103
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1863,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna",
      "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2902009+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323885",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 323885,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1910,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 85,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004",
      "ID": 3103
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4976,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth",
      "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.976604+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5107E223P379VM291337",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291337,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1910,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 85,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004",
      "ID": 3103
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5107,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1146804+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3743E222P391VM265325",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265325,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1910,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 85,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004",
      "ID": 3103
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3743,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel",
      "DisplayName": "Nigel Don",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4342991+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262248",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262248,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1910,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 85,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004",
      "ID": 3103
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3771,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob",
      "DisplayName": "Bob Doris",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.5933169+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281974",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 281974,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1910,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 85,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004",
      "ID": 3103
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2826,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Dornan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1657786+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3812E94P117VM297998",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 297998,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1910,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 85,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004",
      "ID": 3103
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3812,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia",
      "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1339165+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231601",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231601,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1910,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 85,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004",
      "ID": 3103
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1778,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen",
      "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6076464+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4955E240P389VM285943",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285943,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1910,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 85,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004",
      "ID": 3103
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4955,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3512338+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219386",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 219386,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1910,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 85,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004",
      "ID": 3103
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1742,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle",
      "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.2963997+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238578",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 238578,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1910,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 85,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004",
      "ID": 3103
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1994,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus",
      "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4601626+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225410",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225410,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1910,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 85,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004",
      "ID": 3103
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1814,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda",
      "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9735344+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321731",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 321731,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1910,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 85,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004",
      "ID": 3103
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Fee",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4489874+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292801",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 292801,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1910,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 85,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004",
      "ID": 3103
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia",
      "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.558708+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227112",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227112,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1910,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 85,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004",
      "ID": 3103
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.268298+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5054E95P118VM312667",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 312667,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1910,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 85,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004",
      "ID": 3103
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5054,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1381809+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4947E152P361VM257215",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257215,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1910,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 85,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004",
      "ID": 3103
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4947,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Finnie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0465228+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271298",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271298,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1910,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 85,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004",
      "ID": 3103
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3901,
      "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe",
      "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0642501+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278419",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 278419,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1910,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 85,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004",
      "ID": 3103
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2394,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo",
      "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.217983+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2110E220P414VM286739",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286739,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1910,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 85,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004",
      "ID": 3103
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth",
      "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.598626+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250493",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250493,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1910,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 85,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004",
      "ID": 3103
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2675,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob",
      "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1919246+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1741E10P50VM220961",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220961,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1910,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 85,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004",
      "ID": 3103
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1741,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel",
      "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6691133+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220257",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220257,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1910,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 85,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004",
      "ID": 3103
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1756,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine",
      "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.630613+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1860E104P150VM252328",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252328,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1910,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 85,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004",
      "ID": 3103
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1860,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda",
      "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7244104+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2033E20P141VM266106",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 266106,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1910,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 85,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004",
      "ID": 3103
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2033,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain",
      "DisplayName": "Iain Gray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4746028+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324548",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324548,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1910,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 85,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004",
      "ID": 3103
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5042,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2277285+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259723",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 259723,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1910,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 85,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004",
      "ID": 3103
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick",
      "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6217492+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239319",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239319,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1910,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 85,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004",
      "ID": 3103
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2029,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh",
      "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7316986+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273812",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 273812,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1910,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 85,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004",
      "ID": 3103
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3758,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6367221+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304178",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 304178,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1910,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 85,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004",
      "ID": 3103
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4086,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Hume",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8532334+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221734",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221734,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1910,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 85,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004",
      "ID": 3103
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1773,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9454804+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1882E227P459VM241967",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241967,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1910,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 85,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004",
      "ID": 3103
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1882,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam",
      "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7880885+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223710",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223710,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1910,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 85,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004",
      "ID": 3103
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1893,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4704627+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307582",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307582,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1910,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 85,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004",
      "ID": 3103
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4934,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8357309+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272230",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 272230,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1910,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 85,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004",
      "ID": 3103
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4956,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Keir",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3206373+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244882",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244882,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1910,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 85,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004",
      "ID": 3103
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Kelly",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5826668+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315051",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315051,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1910,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 85,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004",
      "ID": 3103
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3129,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6719592+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247949",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247949,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1910,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 85,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004",
      "ID": 3103
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann",
      "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4352892+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4016E11P36VM274787",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274787,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1910,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 85,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004",
      "ID": 3103
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4016,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1217373+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255799",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255799,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1910,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 85,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004",
      "ID": 3103
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2180,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5575939+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4938E158P374VM277458",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277458,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1910,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 85,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004",
      "ID": 3103
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4938,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9542268+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2112E250P486VM253013",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253013,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1910,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 85,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004",
      "ID": 3103
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2112,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny",
      "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.763102+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4939E258P394VM276842",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276842,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1910,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 85,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004",
      "ID": 3103
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4939,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus",
      "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6834434+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325583",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 325583,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1910,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 85,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004",
      "ID": 3103
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5074,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon",
      "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5125809+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1828E3P10VM232832",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232832,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1910,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 85,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004",
      "ID": 3103
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1828,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo",
      "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8782542+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311428",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311428,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1910,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 85,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004",
      "ID": 3103
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4948,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike",
      "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8783847+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2117E90P107VM230410",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230410,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1910,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 85,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004",
      "ID": 3103
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2117,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis",
      "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3286185+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267365",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 267365,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1910,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 85,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004",
      "ID": 3103
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken",
      "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0163001+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313733",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313733,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1910,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 85,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004",
      "ID": 3103
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4966,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek",
      "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4083143+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3101E102P129VM295076",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295076,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1910,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 85,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004",
      "ID": 3103
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3101,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala",
      "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1911736+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5034E88P114VM318980",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 318980,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1910,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 85,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004",
      "ID": 3103
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5034,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny",
      "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6872754+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306435",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306435,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1910,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 85,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004",
      "ID": 3103
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2159,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Martin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5519411+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5110E252P395VM310803",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 310803,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1910,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 85,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004",
      "ID": 3103
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Mason",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5867217+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268238",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 268238,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1910,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 85,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004",
      "ID": 3103
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2133,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2548217+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2876E141P433VM286334",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286334,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1910,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 85,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004",
      "ID": 3103
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2876,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5743501+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4951E147P368VM258641",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258641,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1910,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 85,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004",
      "ID": 3103
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4951,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan",
      "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3162617+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3896E175P307VM263891",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 263891,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1910,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 85,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004",
      "ID": 3103
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3896,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam",
      "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9152423+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308529",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 308529,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1910,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 85,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004",
      "ID": 3103
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0598514+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4964E143P375VM279665",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279665,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1910,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 85,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004",
      "ID": 3103
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4964,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5173889+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279994",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279994,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1910,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 85,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004",
      "ID": 3103
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3824,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5317129+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2066E22P91VM261106",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261106,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1910,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 85,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004",
      "ID": 3103
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2066,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.1120729+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299665",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 299665,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1910,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 85,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004",
      "ID": 3103
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7074962+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306715",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306715,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1910,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 85,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004",
      "ID": 3103
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina",
      "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5643025+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300619",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 300619,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1910,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 85,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004",
      "ID": 3103
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2487,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0064081+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223864",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223864,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1910,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 85,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004",
      "ID": 3103
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4770566+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237491",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237491,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1910,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 85,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004",
      "ID": 3103
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1961,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David",
      "DisplayName": "David McLetchie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2128932+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305432",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 305432,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1910,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 85,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004",
      "ID": 3103
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2134,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.323761+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320446",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 320446,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1910,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 85,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004",
      "ID": 3103
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5041,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan",
      "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1667501+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3763E142P397VM316031",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 316031,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1910,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 85,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004",
      "ID": 3103
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3763,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart",
      "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9428606+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1986E23P197VM236307",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 236307,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1910,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 85,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004",
      "ID": 3103
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1986,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan",
      "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.910769+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5047E100P130VM291427",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291427,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1910,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 85,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004",
      "ID": 3103
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5047,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne",
      "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.118848+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234608",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234608,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1910,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 85,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004",
      "ID": 3103
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1845,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette",
      "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3916506+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313601",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313601,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1910,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 85,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004",
      "ID": 3103
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3061,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.402432+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1768E19P265VM289319",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289319,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1910,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 85,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004",
      "ID": 3103
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1768,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.432148+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225075",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225075,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1910,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 85,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004",
      "ID": 3103
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1894,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Neil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7434292+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3815E98P134VM270908",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270908,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1910,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 85,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004",
      "ID": 3103
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3815,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Park, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Park",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8286132+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265894",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265894,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1910,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 85,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004",
      "ID": 3103
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2010,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil",
      "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4651418+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283328",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283328,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1910,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 85,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004",
      "ID": 3103
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5057,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.6959692+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2853E33P128VM251463",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251463,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1910,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 85,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004",
      "ID": 3103
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Pentland",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4647488+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317667",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317667,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1910,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 85,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004",
      "ID": 3103
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5009,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4322544+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254670",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254670,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1910,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 85,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004",
      "ID": 3103
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3745,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis",
      "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2665843+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1870E225P478VM296220",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 296220,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1910,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 85,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004",
      "ID": 3103
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1870,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona",
      "DisplayName": "Shona Robison",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8392365+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2135E254P450VM234907",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234907,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1910,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 85,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004",
      "ID": 3103
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2135,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Russell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4049026+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1895E232P431VM257405",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257405,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1910,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 85,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004",
      "ID": 3103
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1895,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0547849+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228149",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 228149,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1910,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 85,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004",
      "ID": 3103
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1839,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5864483+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2345E10P55VM291692",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291692,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1910,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 85,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004",
      "ID": 3103
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2345,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1381931+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2223E176P333VM310708",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 310708,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1910,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 85,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004",
      "ID": 3103
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2223,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish",
      "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5826243+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246369",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 246369,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1910,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 85,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004",
      "ID": 3103
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2182,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1257747+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298333",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298333,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1910,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 85,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004",
      "ID": 3103
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5079,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew",
      "DisplayName": "Drew Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3412291+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234368",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234368,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1910,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 85,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004",
      "ID": 3103
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1769,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.374255+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274575",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274575,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1910,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 85,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004",
      "ID": 3103
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4014,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz",
      "DisplayName": "Liz Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1125433+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269532",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269532,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1910,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 85,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004",
      "ID": 3103
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2215,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5516837+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317362",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317362,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1910,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 85,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004",
      "ID": 3103
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3806,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4188647+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326247",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 326247,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1910,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 85,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004",
      "ID": 3103
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5106,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin",
      "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7502114+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241162",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241162,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1910,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 85,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004",
      "ID": 3103
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1848,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola",
      "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.4047159+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2098E237P531VM289625",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289625,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1910,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 85,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004",
      "ID": 3103
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2098,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Swinney",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4520588+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2674E247P401VM247781",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247781,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1910,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 85,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004",
      "ID": 3103
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2674,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave",
      "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4281746+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5075E234P371VM284896",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 284896,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1910,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 85,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004",
      "ID": 3103
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5075,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Torrance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0523652+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1793E151P362VM222476",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 222476,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1910,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 85,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004",
      "ID": 3103
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1793,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean",
      "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1905911+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5078E245P7VM306990",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306990,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1910,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 85,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004",
      "ID": 3103
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5078,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Walker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5825837+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1841E231P426VM239961",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239961,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1910,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 85,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004",
      "ID": 3103
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1841,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen",
      "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7667785+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283438",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283438,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1910,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 85,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004",
      "ID": 3103
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4952,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7078829+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1865E263P500VM232200",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232200,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1910,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 85,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004",
      "ID": 3103
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1865,
      "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra",
      "DisplayName": "Sandra White",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8444065+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237772",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237772,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1910,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 85,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004",
      "ID": 3103
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2610,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Wilson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.225451+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309256",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 309256,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1910,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 85,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Why Languages Matter, Improving Young People’s Opportunities",
      "Reference": "S4M-03004",
      "ID": 3103
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4941,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza",
      "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3214954+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252654",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252654,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1911,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 37,
      "VoteAgainst": 82,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967.1",
      "ID": 3113
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1926,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian",
      "DisplayName": "Brian Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7387682+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2615E213P388VM258850",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258850,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1911,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 37,
      "VoteAgainst": 82,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967.1",
      "ID": 3113
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2615,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George",
      "DisplayName": "George Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3305891+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319880",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319880,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1911,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 37,
      "VoteAgainst": 82,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967.1",
      "ID": 3113
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4940,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare",
      "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9453623+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249603",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 249603,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1911,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 37,
      "VoteAgainst": 82,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967.1",
      "ID": 3113
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2641,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair",
      "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9339449+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1783E21P273VM227765",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227765,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1911,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 37,
      "VoteAgainst": 82,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967.1",
      "ID": 3113
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1783,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie",
      "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5646821+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2633E97P136VM280768",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280768,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1911,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 37,
      "VoteAgainst": 82,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967.1",
      "ID": 3113
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2633,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire",
      "DisplayName": "Claire Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7815896+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262727",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262727,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1911,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 37,
      "VoteAgainst": 82,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967.1",
      "ID": 3113
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2603,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6142698+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1759E91P115VM229744",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229744,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1911,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 37,
      "VoteAgainst": 82,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967.1",
      "ID": 3113
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia",
      "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0948233+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270177",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270177,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1911,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 37,
      "VoteAgainst": 82,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967.1",
      "ID": 3113
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3751,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5848672+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322730",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 322730,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1911,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 37,
      "VoteAgainst": 82,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967.1",
      "ID": 3113
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5109,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco",
      "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.7011766+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5060E86P124VM295264",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295264,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1911,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 37,
      "VoteAgainst": 82,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967.1",
      "ID": 3113
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5060,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5045238+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242875",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242875,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1911,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 37,
      "VoteAgainst": 82,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967.1",
      "ID": 3113
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1866,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah",
      "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.039331+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235550",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235550,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1911,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 37,
      "VoteAgainst": 82,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967.1",
      "ID": 3113
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1943,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic",
      "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6826426+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302152",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 302152,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1911,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 37,
      "VoteAgainst": 82,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967.1",
      "ID": 3113
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2595,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin",
      "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.299473+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244276",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244276,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1911,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 37,
      "VoteAgainst": 82,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967.1",
      "ID": 3113
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2103,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith",
      "DisplayName": "Keith Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5476839+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327251",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 327251,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1911,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 37,
      "VoteAgainst": 82,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967.1",
      "ID": 3113
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:46.0277839+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277066",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277066,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1911,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 37,
      "VoteAgainst": 82,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967.1",
      "ID": 3113
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6996283+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264263",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264263,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1911,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 37,
      "VoteAgainst": 82,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967.1",
      "ID": 3113
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2673,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick",
      "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1257652+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248775",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248775,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1911,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 37,
      "VoteAgainst": 82,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967.1",
      "ID": 3113
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2678,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson",
      "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6695289+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2123E27P233VM295810",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295810,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1911,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 37,
      "VoteAgainst": 82,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967.1",
      "ID": 3113
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2123,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm",
      "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5368274+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285231",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285231,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1911,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 37,
      "VoteAgainst": 82,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967.1",
      "ID": 3113
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3907,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3140388+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230173",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230173,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1911,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 37,
      "VoteAgainst": 82,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967.1",
      "ID": 3113
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1735,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela",
      "DisplayName": "Angela Constance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.1193735+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243844",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 243844,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1911,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 37,
      "VoteAgainst": 82,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967.1",
      "ID": 3113
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1932,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce",
      "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3223467+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254936",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254936,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1911,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 37,
      "VoteAgainst": 82,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967.1",
      "ID": 3113
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1863,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna",
      "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2901588+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323886",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 323886,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1911,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 37,
      "VoteAgainst": 82,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967.1",
      "ID": 3113
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4976,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth",
      "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9766452+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5107E223P379VM291336",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291336,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1911,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 37,
      "VoteAgainst": 82,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967.1",
      "ID": 3113
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5107,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1145485+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3743E222P391VM265403",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265403,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1911,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 37,
      "VoteAgainst": 82,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967.1",
      "ID": 3113
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3743,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel",
      "DisplayName": "Nigel Don",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4376872+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262249",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262249,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1911,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 37,
      "VoteAgainst": 82,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967.1",
      "ID": 3113
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3771,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob",
      "DisplayName": "Bob Doris",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.5933579+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281973",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 281973,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1911,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 37,
      "VoteAgainst": 82,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967.1",
      "ID": 3113
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2826,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Dornan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1657365+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3812E94P117VM297999",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 297999,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1911,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 37,
      "VoteAgainst": 82,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967.1",
      "ID": 3113
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3812,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia",
      "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1339574+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231600",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231600,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1911,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 37,
      "VoteAgainst": 82,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967.1",
      "ID": 3113
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1778,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen",
      "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6076049+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4955E240P389VM285942",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285942,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1911,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 37,
      "VoteAgainst": 82,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967.1",
      "ID": 3113
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4955,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3511734+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219387",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 219387,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1911,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 37,
      "VoteAgainst": 82,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967.1",
      "ID": 3113
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1742,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle",
      "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.2964691+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238577",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 238577,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1911,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 37,
      "VoteAgainst": 82,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967.1",
      "ID": 3113
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1994,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus",
      "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4601214+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225409",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225409,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1911,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 37,
      "VoteAgainst": 82,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967.1",
      "ID": 3113
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1814,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda",
      "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9734915+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321730",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 321730,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1911,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 37,
      "VoteAgainst": 82,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967.1",
      "ID": 3113
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Fee",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4489462+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292800",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 292800,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1911,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 37,
      "VoteAgainst": 82,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967.1",
      "ID": 3113
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia",
      "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.558667+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227113",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227113,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1911,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 37,
      "VoteAgainst": 82,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967.1",
      "ID": 3113
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2683392+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5054E95P118VM312668",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 312668,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1911,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 37,
      "VoteAgainst": 82,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967.1",
      "ID": 3113
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5054,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1382227+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4947E152P361VM257217",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257217,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1911,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 37,
      "VoteAgainst": 82,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967.1",
      "ID": 3113
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4947,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Finnie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.046609+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271297",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271297,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1911,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 37,
      "VoteAgainst": 82,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967.1",
      "ID": 3113
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3901,
      "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe",
      "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0642071+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278418",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 278418,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1911,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 37,
      "VoteAgainst": 82,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967.1",
      "ID": 3113
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2394,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo",
      "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2179405+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2110E220P414VM286740",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286740,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1911,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 37,
      "VoteAgainst": 82,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967.1",
      "ID": 3113
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth",
      "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.598666+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250495",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250495,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1911,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 37,
      "VoteAgainst": 82,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967.1",
      "ID": 3113
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2675,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob",
      "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1920088+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1741E10P50VM220962",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220962,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1911,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 37,
      "VoteAgainst": 82,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967.1",
      "ID": 3113
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1741,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel",
      "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6691548+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220256",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220256,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1911,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 37,
      "VoteAgainst": 82,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967.1",
      "ID": 3113
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1756,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine",
      "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6305708+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1860E104P150VM252329",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252329,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1911,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 37,
      "VoteAgainst": 82,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967.1",
      "ID": 3113
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1860,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda",
      "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7244514+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2033E20P141VM266105",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 266105,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1911,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 37,
      "VoteAgainst": 82,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967.1",
      "ID": 3113
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2033,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain",
      "DisplayName": "Iain Gray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4745615+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324547",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324547,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1911,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 37,
      "VoteAgainst": 82,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967.1",
      "ID": 3113
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5042,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2276872+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259722",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 259722,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1911,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 37,
      "VoteAgainst": 82,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967.1",
      "ID": 3113
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick",
      "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6217079+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239320",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239320,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1911,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 37,
      "VoteAgainst": 82,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967.1",
      "ID": 3113
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2029,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh",
      "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7317395+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273734",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 273734,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1911,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 37,
      "VoteAgainst": 82,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967.1",
      "ID": 3113
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3758,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6333787+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304177",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 304177,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1911,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 37,
      "VoteAgainst": 82,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967.1",
      "ID": 3113
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4086,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Hume",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8531835+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221733",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221733,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1911,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 37,
      "VoteAgainst": 82,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967.1",
      "ID": 3113
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1773,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9454389+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1882E227P459VM241966",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241966,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1911,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 37,
      "VoteAgainst": 82,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967.1",
      "ID": 3113
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1882,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam",
      "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7880465+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223709",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223709,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1911,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 37,
      "VoteAgainst": 82,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967.1",
      "ID": 3113
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1893,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4704215+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307583",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307583,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1911,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 37,
      "VoteAgainst": 82,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967.1",
      "ID": 3113
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4934,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8357719+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272232",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 272232,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1911,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 37,
      "VoteAgainst": 82,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967.1",
      "ID": 3113
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4956,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Keir",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3207216+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244883",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244883,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1911,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 37,
      "VoteAgainst": 82,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967.1",
      "ID": 3113
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Kelly",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5827105+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315052",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315052,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1911,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 37,
      "VoteAgainst": 82,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967.1",
      "ID": 3113
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3129,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6720194+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247948",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247948,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1911,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 37,
      "VoteAgainst": 82,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967.1",
      "ID": 3113
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann",
      "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4352289+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4016E11P36VM274788",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274788,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1911,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 37,
      "VoteAgainst": 82,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967.1",
      "ID": 3113
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4016,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1217787+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255798",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255798,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1911,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 37,
      "VoteAgainst": 82,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967.1",
      "ID": 3113
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2180,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.557528+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4938E158P374VM277457",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277457,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1911,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 37,
      "VoteAgainst": 82,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967.1",
      "ID": 3113
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4938,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9541856+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2112E250P486VM253014",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253014,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1911,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 37,
      "VoteAgainst": 82,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967.1",
      "ID": 3113
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2112,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny",
      "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7631433+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4939E258P394VM276841",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276841,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1911,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 37,
      "VoteAgainst": 82,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967.1",
      "ID": 3113
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4939,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus",
      "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6834019+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325584",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 325584,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1911,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 37,
      "VoteAgainst": 82,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967.1",
      "ID": 3113
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5074,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon",
      "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5126213+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1828E3P10VM232833",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232833,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1911,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 37,
      "VoteAgainst": 82,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967.1",
      "ID": 3113
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1828,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo",
      "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8782946+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311429",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311429,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1911,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 37,
      "VoteAgainst": 82,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967.1",
      "ID": 3113
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4948,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike",
      "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8784271+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2117E90P107VM230409",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230409,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1911,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 37,
      "VoteAgainst": 82,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967.1",
      "ID": 3113
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2117,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis",
      "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3285733+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267366",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 267366,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1911,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 37,
      "VoteAgainst": 82,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967.1",
      "ID": 3113
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken",
      "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0163419+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313732",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313732,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1911,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 37,
      "VoteAgainst": 82,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967.1",
      "ID": 3113
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4966,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek",
      "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4082735+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3101E102P129VM295075",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295075,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1911,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 37,
      "VoteAgainst": 82,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967.1",
      "ID": 3113
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3101,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala",
      "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1911319+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5034E88P114VM318979",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 318979,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1911,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 37,
      "VoteAgainst": 82,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967.1",
      "ID": 3113
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5034,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny",
      "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6872326+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306434",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306434,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1911,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 37,
      "VoteAgainst": 82,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967.1",
      "ID": 3113
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2159,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Martin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5518984+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5110E252P395VM310802",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 310802,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1911,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 37,
      "VoteAgainst": 82,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967.1",
      "ID": 3113
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Mason",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5866793+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268237",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 268237,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1911,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 37,
      "VoteAgainst": 82,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967.1",
      "ID": 3113
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2133,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2547796+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2876E141P433VM286335",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286335,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1911,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 37,
      "VoteAgainst": 82,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967.1",
      "ID": 3113
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2876,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5743914+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4951E147P368VM258639",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258639,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1911,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 37,
      "VoteAgainst": 82,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967.1",
      "ID": 3113
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4951,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan",
      "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3161565+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3896E175P307VM263890",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 263890,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1911,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 37,
      "VoteAgainst": 82,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967.1",
      "ID": 3113
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3896,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam",
      "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9152007+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308530",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 308530,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1911,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 37,
      "VoteAgainst": 82,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967.1",
      "ID": 3113
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0598925+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4964E143P375VM279666",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279666,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1911,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 37,
      "VoteAgainst": 82,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967.1",
      "ID": 3113
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4964,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.517429+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279606",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279606,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1911,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 37,
      "VoteAgainst": 82,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967.1",
      "ID": 3113
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3824,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5148849+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2066E22P91VM261105",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261105,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1911,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 37,
      "VoteAgainst": 82,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967.1",
      "ID": 3113
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2066,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.1120299+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299664",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 299664,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1911,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 37,
      "VoteAgainst": 82,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967.1",
      "ID": 3113
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7074545+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306716",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306716,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1911,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 37,
      "VoteAgainst": 82,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967.1",
      "ID": 3113
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina",
      "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5643439+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300618",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 300618,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1911,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 37,
      "VoteAgainst": 82,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967.1",
      "ID": 3113
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2487,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.006349+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223865",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223865,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1911,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 37,
      "VoteAgainst": 82,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967.1",
      "ID": 3113
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4770979+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237492",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237492,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1911,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 37,
      "VoteAgainst": 82,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967.1",
      "ID": 3113
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1961,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David",
      "DisplayName": "David McLetchie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2129343+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305433",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 305433,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1911,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 37,
      "VoteAgainst": 82,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967.1",
      "ID": 3113
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2134,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3238023+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320602",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 320602,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1911,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 37,
      "VoteAgainst": 82,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967.1",
      "ID": 3113
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5041,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan",
      "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.173475+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3763E142P397VM316030",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 316030,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1911,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 37,
      "VoteAgainst": 82,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967.1",
      "ID": 3113
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3763,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart",
      "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9428189+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1986E23P197VM236694",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 236694,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1911,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 37,
      "VoteAgainst": 82,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967.1",
      "ID": 3113
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1986,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan",
      "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.936041+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5047E100P130VM289810",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289810,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1911,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 37,
      "VoteAgainst": 82,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967.1",
      "ID": 3113
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5047,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne",
      "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4600513+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234607",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234607,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1911,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 37,
      "VoteAgainst": 82,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967.1",
      "ID": 3113
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1845,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette",
      "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3916084+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313600",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313600,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1911,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 37,
      "VoteAgainst": 82,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967.1",
      "ID": 3113
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3061,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4023886+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1768E19P265VM289320",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289320,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1911,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 37,
      "VoteAgainst": 82,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967.1",
      "ID": 3113
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1768,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4321886+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225076",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225076,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1911,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 37,
      "VoteAgainst": 82,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967.1",
      "ID": 3113
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1894,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Neil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7434691+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3815E98P134VM270909",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270909,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1911,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 37,
      "VoteAgainst": 82,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967.1",
      "ID": 3113
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3815,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Park, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Park",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8286553+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265893",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265893,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1911,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 37,
      "VoteAgainst": 82,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967.1",
      "ID": 3113
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2010,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil",
      "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4651001+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283327",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283327,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1911,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 37,
      "VoteAgainst": 82,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967.1",
      "ID": 3113
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5057,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.6959278+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2853E33P128VM251464",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251464,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1911,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 37,
      "VoteAgainst": 82,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967.1",
      "ID": 3113
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Pentland",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4647907+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317668",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317668,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1911,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 37,
      "VoteAgainst": 82,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967.1",
      "ID": 3113
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5009,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4322945+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254668",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254668,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1911,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 37,
      "VoteAgainst": 82,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967.1",
      "ID": 3113
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3745,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis",
      "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2665006+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1870E225P478VM296221",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 296221,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1911,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 37,
      "VoteAgainst": 82,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967.1",
      "ID": 3113
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1870,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona",
      "DisplayName": "Shona Robison",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8392779+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2135E254P450VM234908",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234908,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1911,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 37,
      "VoteAgainst": 82,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967.1",
      "ID": 3113
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2135,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Russell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4049453+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1895E232P431VM257406",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257406,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1911,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 37,
      "VoteAgainst": 82,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967.1",
      "ID": 3113
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1895,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0548267+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228150",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 228150,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1911,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 37,
      "VoteAgainst": 82,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967.1",
      "ID": 3113
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1839,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5864891+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2345E10P55VM291691",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291691,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1911,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 37,
      "VoteAgainst": 82,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967.1",
      "ID": 3113
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2345,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1381521+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2223E176P333VM310709",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 310709,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1911,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 37,
      "VoteAgainst": 82,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967.1",
      "ID": 3113
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2223,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish",
      "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5826651+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246370",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 246370,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1911,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 37,
      "VoteAgainst": 82,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967.1",
      "ID": 3113
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2182,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1258177+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298104",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298104,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1911,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 37,
      "VoteAgainst": 82,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967.1",
      "ID": 3113
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5079,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew",
      "DisplayName": "Drew Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.138408+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234365",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234365,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1911,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 37,
      "VoteAgainst": 82,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967.1",
      "ID": 3113
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1769,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3741308+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274576",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274576,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1911,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 37,
      "VoteAgainst": 82,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967.1",
      "ID": 3113
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4014,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz",
      "DisplayName": "Liz Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1125848+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269533",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269533,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1911,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 37,
      "VoteAgainst": 82,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967.1",
      "ID": 3113
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2215,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5517436+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317363",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317363,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1911,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 37,
      "VoteAgainst": 82,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967.1",
      "ID": 3113
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3806,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.418906+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326246",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 326246,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1911,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 37,
      "VoteAgainst": 82,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967.1",
      "ID": 3113
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5106,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin",
      "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.75015+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241163",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241163,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1911,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 37,
      "VoteAgainst": 82,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967.1",
      "ID": 3113
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1848,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola",
      "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.4047573+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2098E237P531VM289626",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289626,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1911,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 37,
      "VoteAgainst": 82,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967.1",
      "ID": 3113
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2098,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Swinney",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4520987+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2674E247P401VM247782",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247782,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1911,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 37,
      "VoteAgainst": 82,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967.1",
      "ID": 3113
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2674,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave",
      "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4282151+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5075E234P371VM284897",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 284897,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1911,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 37,
      "VoteAgainst": 82,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967.1",
      "ID": 3113
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5075,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Torrance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0524055+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1793E151P362VM222477",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 222477,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1911,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 37,
      "VoteAgainst": 82,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967.1",
      "ID": 3113
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1793,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean",
      "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.190651+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5078E245P7VM306989",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306989,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1911,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 37,
      "VoteAgainst": 82,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967.1",
      "ID": 3113
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5078,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Walker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5825411+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1841E231P426VM239960",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239960,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1911,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 37,
      "VoteAgainst": 82,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967.1",
      "ID": 3113
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1841,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen",
      "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7667184+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283439",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283439,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1911,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 37,
      "VoteAgainst": 82,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967.1",
      "ID": 3113
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4952,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7079246+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1865E263P500VM232199",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232199,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1911,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 37,
      "VoteAgainst": 82,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967.1",
      "ID": 3113
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1865,
      "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra",
      "DisplayName": "Sandra White",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8443358+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237771",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237771,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1911,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 37,
      "VoteAgainst": 82,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967.1",
      "ID": 3113
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2610,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Wilson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2254101+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309255",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 309255,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1911,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 37,
      "VoteAgainst": 82,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967.1",
      "ID": 3113
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4941,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza",
      "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3214537+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252655",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252655,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1912,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967",
      "ID": 3072
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1926,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian",
      "DisplayName": "Brian Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7388086+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2615E213P388VM258851",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258851,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1912,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967",
      "ID": 3072
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2615,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George",
      "DisplayName": "George Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3306295+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319878",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319878,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1912,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967",
      "ID": 3072
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4940,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare",
      "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9452806+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249602",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 249602,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1912,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967",
      "ID": 3072
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2641,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair",
      "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9339044+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1783E21P273VM227766",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227766,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1912,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967",
      "ID": 3072
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1783,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie",
      "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5647242+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2633E97P136VM280769",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280769,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1912,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967",
      "ID": 3072
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2633,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire",
      "DisplayName": "Claire Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7816296+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262728",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262728,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1912,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967",
      "ID": 3072
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2603,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6143109+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1759E91P115VM229745",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229745,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1912,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967",
      "ID": 3072
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia",
      "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0948642+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270176",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270176,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1912,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967",
      "ID": 3072
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3751,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5848262+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322731",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 322731,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1912,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967",
      "ID": 3072
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5109,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco",
      "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.7012344+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5060E86P124VM295265",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295265,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1912,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967",
      "ID": 3072
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5060,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5045646+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242876",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242876,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1912,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967",
      "ID": 3072
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1866,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah",
      "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0393711+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235549",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235549,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1912,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967",
      "ID": 3072
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1943,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic",
      "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6826021+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302380",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 302380,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1912,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967",
      "ID": 3072
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2595,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin",
      "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.521898+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244275",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244275,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1912,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967",
      "ID": 3072
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2103,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith",
      "DisplayName": "Keith Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5476427+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327202",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 327202,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1912,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967",
      "ID": 3072
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:46.0254008+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277067",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277067,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1912,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967",
      "ID": 3072
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6996695+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264262",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264262,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1912,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967",
      "ID": 3072
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2673,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick",
      "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1257054+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248774",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248774,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1912,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967",
      "ID": 3072
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2678,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson",
      "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6694875+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2123E27P233VM295808",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295808,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1912,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967",
      "ID": 3072
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2123,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm",
      "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5367471+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285232",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285232,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1912,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967",
      "ID": 3072
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3907,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3140801+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230708",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230708,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1912,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967",
      "ID": 3072
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1735,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela",
      "DisplayName": "Angela Constance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3420301+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243843",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 243843,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1912,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967",
      "ID": 3072
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1932,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce",
      "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3223066+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254866",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254866,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1912,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967",
      "ID": 3072
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1863,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna",
      "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2871587+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323809",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 323809,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1912,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967",
      "ID": 3072
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4976,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth",
      "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.972851+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5107E223P379VM291335",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291335,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1912,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967",
      "ID": 3072
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5107,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1145074+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3743E222P391VM265404",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265404,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1912,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967",
      "ID": 3072
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3743,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel",
      "DisplayName": "Nigel Don",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4377296+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262250",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262250,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1912,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967",
      "ID": 3072
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3771,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob",
      "DisplayName": "Bob Doris",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.5933991+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281972",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 281972,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1912,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967",
      "ID": 3072
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2826,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Dornan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1656955+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298000",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298000,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1912,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967",
      "ID": 3072
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3812,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia",
      "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1339976+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231599",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231599,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1912,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967",
      "ID": 3072
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1778,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen",
      "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6075636+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4955E240P389VM285941",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285941,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1912,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967",
      "ID": 3072
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4955,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3511325+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219388",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 219388,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1912,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967",
      "ID": 3072
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1742,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle",
      "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.2965134+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238576",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 238576,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1912,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967",
      "ID": 3072
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1994,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus",
      "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4600812+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225408",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225408,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1912,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967",
      "ID": 3072
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1814,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda",
      "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9734506+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321729",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 321729,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1912,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967",
      "ID": 3072
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Fee",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4489059+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292799",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 292799,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1912,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967",
      "ID": 3072
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia",
      "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5586262+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227114",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227114,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1912,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967",
      "ID": 3072
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2684161+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5054E95P118VM312739",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 312739,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1912,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967",
      "ID": 3072
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5054,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.141249+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4947E152P361VM257218",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257218,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1912,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967",
      "ID": 3072
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4947,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Finnie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0466509+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271296",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271296,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1912,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967",
      "ID": 3072
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3901,
      "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe",
      "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0641662+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278417",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 278417,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1912,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967",
      "ID": 3072
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2394,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo",
      "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2178991+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2110E220P414VM287275",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 287275,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1912,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967",
      "ID": 3072
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth",
      "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8571575+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250496",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250496,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1912,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967",
      "ID": 3072
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2675,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob",
      "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1920506+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1741E10P50VM220963",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220963,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1912,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967",
      "ID": 3072
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1741,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel",
      "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6691958+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220255",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220255,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1912,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967",
      "ID": 3072
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1756,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine",
      "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6305289+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1860E104P150VM252400",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252400,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1912,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967",
      "ID": 3072
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1860,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda",
      "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7275267+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2033E20P141VM266104",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 266104,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1912,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967",
      "ID": 3072
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2033,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain",
      "DisplayName": "Iain Gray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4745206+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324596",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324596,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1912,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967",
      "ID": 3072
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5042,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.229783+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259721",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 259721,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1912,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967",
      "ID": 3072
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick",
      "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6216668+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239321",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239321,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1912,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967",
      "ID": 3072
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2029,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh",
      "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7317803+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273733",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 273733,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1912,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967",
      "ID": 3072
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3758,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6333186+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304105",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 304105,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1912,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967",
      "ID": 3072
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4086,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Hume",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.849895+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221732",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221732,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1912,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967",
      "ID": 3072
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1773,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9453984+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1882E227P459VM241965",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241965,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1912,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967",
      "ID": 3072
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1882,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam",
      "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7880052+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223708",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223708,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1912,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967",
      "ID": 3072
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1893,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4703789+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307584",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307584,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1912,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967",
      "ID": 3072
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4934,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8358137+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272233",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 272233,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1912,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967",
      "ID": 3072
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4956,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Keir",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3207645+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244884",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244884,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1912,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967",
      "ID": 3072
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Kelly",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5827511+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315054",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315054,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1912,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967",
      "ID": 3072
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3129,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6721031+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247947",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247947,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1912,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967",
      "ID": 3072
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann",
      "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4351884+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4016E11P36VM274789",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274789,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1912,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967",
      "ID": 3072
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4016,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1218196+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255797",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255797,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1912,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967",
      "ID": 3072
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2180,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.557486+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4938E158P374VM277456",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277456,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1912,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967",
      "ID": 3072
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4938,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9541423+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2112E250P486VM253015",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253015,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1912,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967",
      "ID": 3072
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2112,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny",
      "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7631851+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4939E258P394VM276840",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276840,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1912,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967",
      "ID": 3072
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4939,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus",
      "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6833612+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325535",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 325535,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1912,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967",
      "ID": 3072
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5074,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon",
      "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5105492+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1828E3P10VM232834",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232834,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1912,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967",
      "ID": 3072
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1828,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo",
      "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8783694+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311430",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311430,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1912,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967",
      "ID": 3072
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4948,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike",
      "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8784684+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2117E90P107VM230408",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230408,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1912,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967",
      "ID": 3072
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2117,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis",
      "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3285071+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267367",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 267367,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1912,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967",
      "ID": 3072
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken",
      "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0163831+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313731",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313731,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1912,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967",
      "ID": 3072
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4966,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek",
      "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4082327+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3101E102P129VM295074",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295074,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1912,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967",
      "ID": 3072
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3101,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala",
      "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1910891+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5034E88P114VM318978",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 318978,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1912,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967",
      "ID": 3072
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5034,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny",
      "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6871729+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306432",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306432,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1912,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967",
      "ID": 3072
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2159,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Martin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5518168+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5110E252P395VM310801",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 310801,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1912,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967",
      "ID": 3072
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Mason",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.586619+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268236",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 268236,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1912,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967",
      "ID": 3072
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2133,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2547378+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2876E141P433VM286336",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286336,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1912,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967",
      "ID": 3072
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2876,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5744325+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4951E147P368VM258638",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258638,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1912,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967",
      "ID": 3072
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4951,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan",
      "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3161152+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3896E175P307VM263889",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 263889,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1912,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967",
      "ID": 3072
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3896,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam",
      "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9151587+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308531",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 308531,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1912,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967",
      "ID": 3072
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0599334+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4964E143P375VM279667",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279667,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1912,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967",
      "ID": 3072
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4964,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5174692+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279605",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279605,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1912,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967",
      "ID": 3072
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3824,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5148448+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2066E22P91VM261103",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261103,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1912,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967",
      "ID": 3072
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2066,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.1119475+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299663",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 299663,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1912,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967",
      "ID": 3072
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7074141+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306717",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306717,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1912,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967",
      "ID": 3072
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina",
      "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5643848+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300617",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 300617,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1912,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967",
      "ID": 3072
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2487,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0063091+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223866",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223866,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1912,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967",
      "ID": 3072
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4771573+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237493",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237493,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1912,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967",
      "ID": 3072
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1961,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David",
      "DisplayName": "David McLetchie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2129754+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305435",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 305435,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1912,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967",
      "ID": 3072
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2134,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3239032+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320603",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 320603,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1912,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967",
      "ID": 3072
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5041,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan",
      "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1735156+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3763E142P397VM316028",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 316028,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1912,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967",
      "ID": 3072
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3763,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart",
      "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9427354+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1986E23P197VM236695",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 236695,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1912,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967",
      "ID": 3072
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1986,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan",
      "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9360825+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5047E100P130VM289809",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289809,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1912,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967",
      "ID": 3072
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5047,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne",
      "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4600111+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234537",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234537,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1912,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967",
      "ID": 3072
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1845,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette",
      "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3885642+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313598",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313598,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1912,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967",
      "ID": 3072
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3061,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4022878+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1768E19P265VM289321",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289321,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1912,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967",
      "ID": 3072
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1768,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4322298+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225077",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225077,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1912,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967",
      "ID": 3072
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1894,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Neil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7435088+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3815E98P134VM270910",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270910,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1912,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967",
      "ID": 3072
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3815,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Park, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Park",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8286964+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265823",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265823,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1912,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967",
      "ID": 3072
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2010,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil",
      "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4560267+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283326",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283326,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1912,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967",
      "ID": 3072
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5057,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.6958858+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2853E33P128VM251465",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251465,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1912,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967",
      "ID": 3072
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Pentland",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.464834+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317669",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317669,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1912,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967",
      "ID": 3072
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5009,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4323351+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254667",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254667,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1912,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967",
      "ID": 3072
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3745,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis",
      "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2664599+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1870E225P478VM296222",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 296222,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1912,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967",
      "ID": 3072
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1870,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona",
      "DisplayName": "Shona Robison",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8393195+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2135E254P450VM234909",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234909,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1912,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967",
      "ID": 3072
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2135,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Russell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4049861+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1895E232P431VM257633",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257633,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1912,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967",
      "ID": 3072
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1895,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0649175+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228151",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 228151,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1912,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967",
      "ID": 3072
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1839,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5865509+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2345E10P55VM291619",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291619,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1912,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967",
      "ID": 3072
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2345,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1351247+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2223E176P333VM310711",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 310711,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1912,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967",
      "ID": 3072
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2223,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish",
      "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5827464+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246371",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 246371,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1912,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967",
      "ID": 3072
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2182,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1258589+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298103",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298103,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1912,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967",
      "ID": 3072
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5079,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew",
      "DisplayName": "Drew Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1383679+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234135",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234135,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1912,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967",
      "ID": 3072
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1769,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1681549+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274577",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274577,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1912,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967",
      "ID": 3072
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4014,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz",
      "DisplayName": "Liz Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.112626+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269534",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269534,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1912,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967",
      "ID": 3072
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2215,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5517872+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317365",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317365,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1912,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967",
      "ID": 3072
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3806,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.418988+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326295",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 326295,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1912,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967",
      "ID": 3072
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5106,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin",
      "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7522897+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241164",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241164,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1912,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967",
      "ID": 3072
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1848,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola",
      "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.404798+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2098E237P531VM289628",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289628,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1912,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967",
      "ID": 3072
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2098,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Swinney",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4521784+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2674E247P401VM247783",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247783,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1912,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967",
      "ID": 3072
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2674,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave",
      "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4282557+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5075E234P371VM284898",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 284898,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1912,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967",
      "ID": 3072
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5075,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Torrance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0524466+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1793E151P362VM222478",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 222478,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1912,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967",
      "ID": 3072
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1793,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean",
      "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1906936+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5078E245P7VM306988",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306988,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1912,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967",
      "ID": 3072
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5078,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Walker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5824819+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1841E231P426VM239959",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239959,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1912,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967",
      "ID": 3072
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1841,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen",
      "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.766677+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283440",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283440,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1912,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967",
      "ID": 3072
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4952,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7079656+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1865E263P500VM232198",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232198,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1912,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967",
      "ID": 3072
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1865,
      "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra",
      "DisplayName": "Sandra White",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6390342+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237770",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237770,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1912,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967",
      "ID": 3072
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2610,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Wilson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.22537+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309254",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 309254,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1912,
      "AgendaID": 2724,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 1,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02967",
      "ID": 3072
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4941,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza",
      "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-24T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3214113+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252684",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252684,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1902,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906.2",
      "ID": 3030
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1926,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian",
      "DisplayName": "Brian Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7491488+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2615E213P388VM258894",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258894,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1902,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906.2",
      "ID": 3030
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2615,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George",
      "DisplayName": "George Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3327996+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319637",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319637,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1902,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906.2",
      "ID": 3030
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4940,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare",
      "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9348638+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249531",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 249531,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1902,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906.2",
      "ID": 3030
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2641,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair",
      "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9308891+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1783E21P273VM227795",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227795,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1902,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906.2",
      "ID": 3030
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1783,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie",
      "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5659669+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2633E97P136VM280798",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280798,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1902,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906.2",
      "ID": 3030
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2633,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire",
      "DisplayName": "Claire Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7828461+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262705",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262705,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1902,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906.2",
      "ID": 3030
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2603,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6133312+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1759E91P115VM229789",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229789,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1902,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906.2",
      "ID": 3030
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia",
      "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0970983+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270133",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270133,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1902,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906.2",
      "ID": 3030
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3751,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5829817+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322666",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 322666,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1902,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906.2",
      "ID": 3030
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5109,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco",
      "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6984908+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5060E86P124VM294780",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 294780,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1902,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906.2",
      "ID": 3030
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5060,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1780022+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242907",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242907,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1902,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906.2",
      "ID": 3030
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1866,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah",
      "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0406766+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235197",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235197,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1902,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906.2",
      "ID": 3030
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1943,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic",
      "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.423566+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302354",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 302354,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1902,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906.2",
      "ID": 3030
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2595,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin",
      "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5207719+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244298",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244298,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1902,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906.2",
      "ID": 3030
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2103,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith",
      "DisplayName": "Keith Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5486365+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327182",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 327182,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1902,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906.2",
      "ID": 3030
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.8027074+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277044",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277044,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1902,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906.2",
      "ID": 3030
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6986583+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264285",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264285,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1902,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906.2",
      "ID": 3030
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2673,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick",
      "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1267074+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248730",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248730,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1902,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906.2",
      "ID": 3030
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2678,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson",
      "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6673426+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2123E27P233VM295718",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295718,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1902,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906.2",
      "ID": 3030
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2123,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm",
      "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5329472+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285209",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285209,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1902,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906.2",
      "ID": 3030
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3907,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3129607+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230685",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230685,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1902,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906.2",
      "ID": 3030
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1735,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela",
      "DisplayName": "Angela Constance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3407899+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243812",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 243812,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1902,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906.2",
      "ID": 3030
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1932,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce",
      "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3207905+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254892",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254892,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1902,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906.2",
      "ID": 3030
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1863,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna",
      "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2882797+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323789",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 323789,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1902,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906.2",
      "ID": 3030
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4976,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth",
      "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9719791+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5107E223P379VM291292",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291292,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1902,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906.2",
      "ID": 3030
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5107,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1126542+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3743E222P391VM265381",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265381,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1902,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906.2",
      "ID": 3030
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3743,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel",
      "DisplayName": "Nigel Don",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4367215+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262294",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262294,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1902,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906.2",
      "ID": 3030
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3771,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob",
      "DisplayName": "Bob Doris",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.5952853+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281942",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 281942,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1902,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906.2",
      "ID": 3030
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2826,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Dornan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1644143+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298184",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298184,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1902,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906.2",
      "ID": 3030
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3812,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia",
      "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1421128+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231248",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231248,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1902,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906.2",
      "ID": 3030
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1778,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen",
      "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.5867778+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4955E240P389VM285897",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285897,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1902,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906.2",
      "ID": 3030
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4955,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3492398+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219430",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 219430,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1902,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906.2",
      "ID": 3030
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1742,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle",
      "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.2986058+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238532",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 238532,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1902,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906.2",
      "ID": 3030
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1994,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus",
      "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4581582+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225185",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225185,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1902,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906.2",
      "ID": 3030
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1814,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda",
      "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7481206+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321794",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 321794,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1902,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906.2",
      "ID": 3030
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Fee",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4516532+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292865",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 292865,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1902,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906.2",
      "ID": 3030
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia",
      "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5614062+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227157",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227157,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1902,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906.2",
      "ID": 3030
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2702796+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5054E95P118VM312714",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 312714,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1902,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906.2",
      "ID": 3030
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5054,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1401959+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4947E152P361VM257751",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257751,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1902,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906.2",
      "ID": 3030
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4947,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Finnie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0760505+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271252",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271252,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1902,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906.2",
      "ID": 3030
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3901,
      "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe",
      "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0622634+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278079",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 278079,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1902,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906.2",
      "ID": 3030
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2394,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo",
      "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9861037+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2110E220P414VM287249",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 287249,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1902,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906.2",
      "ID": 3030
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth",
      "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8560508+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250568",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250568,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1902,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906.2",
      "ID": 3030
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2675,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob",
      "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1951882+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221032",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221032,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1902,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906.2",
      "ID": 3030
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1741,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel",
      "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6721434+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220213",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220213,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1902,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906.2",
      "ID": 3030
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1756,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine",
      "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3392172+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1860E104P150VM252374",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252374,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1902,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906.2",
      "ID": 3030
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1860,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda",
      "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7264264+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2033E20P141VM253848",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253848,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1902,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906.2",
      "ID": 3030
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2033,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain",
      "DisplayName": "Iain Gray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.023464+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324616",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324616,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1902,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906.2",
      "ID": 3030
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5042,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2306176+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259677",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 259677,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1902,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906.2",
      "ID": 3030
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick",
      "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6197525+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239364",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239364,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1902,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906.2",
      "ID": 3030
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2029,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh",
      "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7336311+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273756",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 273756,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1902,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906.2",
      "ID": 3030
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3758,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.634332+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304131",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 304131,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1902,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906.2",
      "ID": 3030
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4086,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Hume",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.850988+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221663",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221663,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1902,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906.2",
      "ID": 3030
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1773,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9424319+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1882E227P459VM241893",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241893,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1902,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906.2",
      "ID": 3030
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1882,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam",
      "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7845653+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223511",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223511,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1902,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906.2",
      "ID": 3030
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1893,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4615798+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307613",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307613,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1902,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906.2",
      "ID": 3030
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4934,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.837364+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272304",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 272304,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1902,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906.2",
      "ID": 3030
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4956,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Keir",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3239812+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244916",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244916,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1902,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906.2",
      "ID": 3030
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Kelly",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5841059+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315143",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315143,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1902,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906.2",
      "ID": 3030
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3129,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6761867+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247904",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247904,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1902,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906.2",
      "ID": 3030
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann",
      "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4333714+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4016E11P36VM274833",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274833,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1902,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906.2",
      "ID": 3030
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4016,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1237104+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255754",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255754,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1902,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906.2",
      "ID": 3030
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2180,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.555449+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4938E158P374VM277412",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277412,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1902,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906.2",
      "ID": 3030
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4938,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9522664+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2112E250P486VM253058",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253058,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1902,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906.2",
      "ID": 3030
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2112,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny",
      "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7650384+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4939E258P394VM276797",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276797,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1902,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906.2",
      "ID": 3030
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4939,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus",
      "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6814999+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325515",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 325515,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1902,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906.2",
      "ID": 3030
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5074,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon",
      "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5096929+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1828E3P10VM232879",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232879,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1902,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906.2",
      "ID": 3030
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1828,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo",
      "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8805391+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311458",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311458,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1902,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906.2",
      "ID": 3030
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4948,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike",
      "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8796839+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2117E90P107VM230365",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230365,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1902,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906.2",
      "ID": 3030
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2117,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis",
      "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3265672+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267396",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 267396,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1902,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906.2",
      "ID": 3030
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken",
      "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0180205+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313704",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313704,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1902,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906.2",
      "ID": 3030
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4966,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek",
      "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4069494+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3101E102P129VM295044",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295044,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1902,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906.2",
      "ID": 3030
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3101,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala",
      "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1898013+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319044",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319044,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1902,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906.2",
      "ID": 3030
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5034,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny",
      "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6900306+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306343",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306343,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1902,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906.2",
      "ID": 3030
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2159,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Martin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.548005+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5110E252P395VM311175",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311175,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1902,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906.2",
      "ID": 3030
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Mason",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.608936+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268207",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 268207,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1902,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906.2",
      "ID": 3030
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2133,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.253459+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2876E141P433VM286366",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286366,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1902,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906.2",
      "ID": 3030
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2876,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5758057+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4951E147P368VM258567",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258567,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1902,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906.2",
      "ID": 3030
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4951,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan",
      "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3128205+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3896E175P307VM263845",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 263845,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1902,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906.2",
      "ID": 3030
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3896,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam",
      "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9129905+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308464",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 308464,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1902,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906.2",
      "ID": 3030
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0570522+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4964E143P375VM279705",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279705,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1902,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906.2",
      "ID": 3030
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4964,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5191216+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279628",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279628,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1902,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906.2",
      "ID": 3030
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3824,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5158073+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2066E22P91VM261015",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261015,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1902,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906.2",
      "ID": 3030
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2066,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.1081231+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299634",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 299634,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1902,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906.2",
      "ID": 3030
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7061724+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306651",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306651,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1902,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906.2",
      "ID": 3030
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina",
      "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5613137+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2487E146P369VM301143",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 301143,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1902,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906.2",
      "ID": 3030
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2487,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0355639+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223935",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223935,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1902,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906.2",
      "ID": 3030
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4849159+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237535",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237535,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1902,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906.2",
      "ID": 3030
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1961,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David",
      "DisplayName": "David McLetchie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2150104+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305525",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 305525,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1902,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906.2",
      "ID": 3030
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2134,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3280906+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320382",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 320382,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1902,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906.2",
      "ID": 3030
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5041,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan",
      "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1640177+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315939",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315939,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1902,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906.2",
      "ID": 3030
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3763,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart",
      "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9387934+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1986E23P197VM236672",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 236672,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1902,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906.2",
      "ID": 3030
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1986,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan",
      "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9350915+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5047E100P130VM289832",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289832,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1902,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906.2",
      "ID": 3030
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5047,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne",
      "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4609669+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234562",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234562,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1902,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906.2",
      "ID": 3030
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1845,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette",
      "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3896389+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313198",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313198,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1902,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906.2",
      "ID": 3030
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3061,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1678894+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1768E19P265VM289253",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289253,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1902,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906.2",
      "ID": 3030
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1768,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4292707+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225276",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225276,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1902,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906.2",
      "ID": 3030
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1894,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Neil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9624147+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3815E98P134VM270937",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270937,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1902,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906.2",
      "ID": 3030
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3815,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Park, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Park",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8355129+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265849",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265849,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1902,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906.2",
      "ID": 3030
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2010,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil",
      "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.463207+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283283",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283283,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1902,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906.2",
      "ID": 3030
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5057,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.6938095+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2853E33P128VM251509",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251509,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1902,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906.2",
      "ID": 3030
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Pentland",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4667559+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317603",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317603,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1902,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906.2",
      "ID": 3030
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5009,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4295378+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254284",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254284,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1902,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906.2",
      "ID": 3030
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3745,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis",
      "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2489246+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1870E225P478VM295695",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295695,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1902,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906.2",
      "ID": 3030
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1870,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona",
      "DisplayName": "Shona Robison",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5318879+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2135E254P450VM235412",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235412,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1902,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906.2",
      "ID": 3030
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2135,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Russell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6696448+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1895E232P431VM257606",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257606,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1902,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906.2",
      "ID": 3030
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1895,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0637635+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228529",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 228529,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1902,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906.2",
      "ID": 3030
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1839,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.8030314+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2345E10P55VM291645",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291645,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1902,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906.2",
      "ID": 3030
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2345,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1362074+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311113",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311113,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1902,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906.2",
      "ID": 3030
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2223,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish",
      "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.6059583+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246444",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 246444,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1902,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906.2",
      "ID": 3030
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2182,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1289784+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298062",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298062,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1902,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906.2",
      "ID": 3030
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5079,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew",
      "DisplayName": "Drew Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1366209+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234157",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234157,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1902,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906.2",
      "ID": 3030
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1769,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1690989+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274620",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274620,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1902,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906.2",
      "ID": 3030
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4014,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz",
      "DisplayName": "Liz Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1144826+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269563",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269563,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1902,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906.2",
      "ID": 3030
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2215,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5530132+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317454",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317454,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1902,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906.2",
      "ID": 3030
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3806,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4227874+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326315",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 326315,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1902,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906.2",
      "ID": 3030
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5106,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin",
      "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7531576+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241235",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241235,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1902,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906.2",
      "ID": 3030
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1848,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola",
      "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7488236+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2098E237P531VM290334",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 290334,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1902,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906.2",
      "ID": 3030
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2098,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Swinney",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7423578+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2674E247P401VM247826",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247826,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1902,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906.2",
      "ID": 3030
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2674,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave",
      "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.430077+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5075E234P371VM287427",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 287427,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1902,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906.2",
      "ID": 3030
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5075,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Torrance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8637289+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1793E151P362VM222520",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 222520,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1902,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906.2",
      "ID": 3030
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1793,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean",
      "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1924993+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5078E245P7VM307054",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307054,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1902,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906.2",
      "ID": 3030
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5078,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Walker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5852935+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1841E231P426VM239889",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239889,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1902,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906.2",
      "ID": 3030
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1841,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen",
      "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.763693+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283484",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283484,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1902,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906.2",
      "ID": 3030
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4952,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7098891+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1865E263P500VM231865",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231865,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1902,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906.2",
      "ID": 3030
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1865,
      "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra",
      "DisplayName": "Sandra White",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6188701+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237727",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237727,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1902,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906.2",
      "ID": 3030
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2610,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Wilson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2232296+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309226",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 309226,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1902,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 39,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906.2",
      "ID": 3030
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4941,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza",
      "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3202019+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1926E229P470VM253110",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253110,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1903,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906",
      "ID": 3001
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1926,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian",
      "DisplayName": "Brian Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7672177+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2615E213P388VM258895",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258895,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1903,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906",
      "ID": 3001
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2615,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George",
      "DisplayName": "George Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3328403+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319636",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319636,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1903,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906",
      "ID": 3001
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4940,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare",
      "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9348225+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249530",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 249530,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1903,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906",
      "ID": 3001
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2641,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair",
      "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9308305+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1783E21P273VM228461",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 228461,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1903,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906",
      "ID": 3001
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1783,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie",
      "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.8000628+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2633E97P136VM280831",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280831,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1903,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906",
      "ID": 3001
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2633,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire",
      "DisplayName": "Claire Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.784252+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262771",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262771,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1903,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906",
      "ID": 3001
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2603,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6161477+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1759E91P115VM229790",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229790,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1903,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906",
      "ID": 3001
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia",
      "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0971579+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270132",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270132,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1903,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906",
      "ID": 3001
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3751,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5829405+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322637",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 322637,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1903,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906",
      "ID": 3001
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5109,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco",
      "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6972794+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5060E86P124VM295308",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295308,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1903,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906",
      "ID": 3001
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5060,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5064027+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242963",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242963,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1903,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906",
      "ID": 3001
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1866,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah",
      "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.04304+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235196",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235196,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1903,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906",
      "ID": 3001
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1943,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic",
      "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4235233+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302355",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 302355,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1903,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906",
      "ID": 3001
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2595,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin",
      "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5208318+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244232",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244232,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1903,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906",
      "ID": 3001
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2103,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith",
      "DisplayName": "Keith Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5457637+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327183",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 327183,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1903,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906",
      "ID": 3001
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.8027477+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277110",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277110,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1903,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906",
      "ID": 3001
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.7015223+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264064",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264064,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1903,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906",
      "ID": 3001
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2673,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick",
      "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9226485+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248729",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248729,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1903,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906",
      "ID": 3001
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2678,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson",
      "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6673011+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2123E27P233VM295717",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295717,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1903,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906",
      "ID": 3001
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2123,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm",
      "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5329063+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285275",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285275,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1903,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906",
      "ID": 3001
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3907,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3159647+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230752",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230752,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1903,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906",
      "ID": 3001
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1735,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela",
      "DisplayName": "Angela Constance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3440229+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243755",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 243755,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1903,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906",
      "ID": 3001
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1932,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce",
      "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.318411+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254891",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254891,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1903,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906",
      "ID": 3001
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1863,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna",
      "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2882384+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323790",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 323790,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1903,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906",
      "ID": 3001
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4976,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth",
      "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9720198+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5107E223P379VM291291",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291291,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1903,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906",
      "ID": 3001
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5107,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1126133+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3743E222P391VM265447",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265447,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1903,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906",
      "ID": 3001
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3743,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel",
      "DisplayName": "Nigel Don",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4395829+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262295",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262295,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1903,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906",
      "ID": 3001
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3771,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob",
      "DisplayName": "Bob Doris",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.5953261+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281909",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 281909,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1903,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906",
      "ID": 3001
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2826,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Dornan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.163004+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298217",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298217,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1903,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906",
      "ID": 3001
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3812,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia",
      "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3362167+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231247",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231247,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1903,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906",
      "ID": 3001
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1778,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen",
      "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.5867371+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4955E240P389VM285896",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285896,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1903,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906",
      "ID": 3001
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4955,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3491988+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219431",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 219431,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1903,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906",
      "ID": 3001
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1742,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle",
      "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.2986627+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238531",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 238531,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1903,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906",
      "ID": 3001
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1994,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus",
      "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4581179+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225184",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225184,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1903,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906",
      "ID": 3001
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1814,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda",
      "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7480798+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321823",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 321823,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1903,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906",
      "ID": 3001
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Fee",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4528884+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292864",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 292864,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1903,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906",
      "ID": 3001
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia",
      "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5613662+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227158",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227158,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1903,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906",
      "ID": 3001
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2703213+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5054E95P118VM312715",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 312715,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1903,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906",
      "ID": 3001
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5054,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1402361+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4947E152P361VM257752",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257752,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1903,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906",
      "ID": 3001
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4947,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Finnie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0760917+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271251",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271251,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1903,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906",
      "ID": 3001
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3901,
      "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe",
      "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0622213+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278046",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 278046,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1903,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906",
      "ID": 3001
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2394,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo",
      "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9846786+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2110E220P414VM287250",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 287250,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1903,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906",
      "ID": 3001
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth",
      "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8560916+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250569",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250569,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1903,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906",
      "ID": 3001
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2675,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob",
      "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1952306+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221033",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221033,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1903,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906",
      "ID": 3001
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1741,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel",
      "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6721835+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220212",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220212,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1903,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906",
      "ID": 3001
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1756,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine",
      "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3391764+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1860E104P150VM252375",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252375,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1903,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906",
      "ID": 3001
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1860,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda",
      "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.726467+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2033E20P141VM253176",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253176,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1903,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906",
      "ID": 3001
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2033,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain",
      "DisplayName": "Iain Gray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7699568+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324615",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324615,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1903,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906",
      "ID": 3001
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5042,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2305774+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259676",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 259676,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1903,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906",
      "ID": 3001
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick",
      "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.619712+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239365",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239365,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1903,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906",
      "ID": 3001
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2029,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh",
      "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7336718+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273690",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 273690,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1903,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906",
      "ID": 3001
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3758,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6311996+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304130",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 304130,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1903,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906",
      "ID": 3001
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4086,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Hume",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8509476+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221662",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221662,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1903,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906",
      "ID": 3001
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1773,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9423911+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1882E227P459VM241892",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241892,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1903,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906",
      "ID": 3001
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1882,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam",
      "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7845251+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223510",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223510,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1903,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906",
      "ID": 3001
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1893,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4615394+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307800",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307800,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1903,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906",
      "ID": 3001
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4934,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8454589+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272305",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 272305,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1903,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906",
      "ID": 3001
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4956,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Keir",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3240217+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244974",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244974,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1903,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906",
      "ID": 3001
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Kelly",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5865907+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315144",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315144,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1903,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906",
      "ID": 3001
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3129,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6762283+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247903",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247903,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1903,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906",
      "ID": 3001
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann",
      "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4333319+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4016E11P36VM274834",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274834,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1903,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906",
      "ID": 3001
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4016,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1237511+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255753",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255753,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1903,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906",
      "ID": 3001
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2180,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5554093+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4938E158P374VM277411",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277411,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1903,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906",
      "ID": 3001
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4938,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9522265+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2112E250P486VM253059",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253059,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1903,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906",
      "ID": 3001
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2112,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny",
      "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7650795+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4939E258P394VM276796",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276796,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1903,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906",
      "ID": 3001
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4939,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus",
      "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6814597+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325516",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 325516,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1903,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906",
      "ID": 3001
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5074,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon",
      "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5097327+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1828E3P10VM232880",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232880,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1903,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906",
      "ID": 3001
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1828,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo",
      "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8805795+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311644",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311644,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1903,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906",
      "ID": 3001
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4948,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike",
      "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8880567+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2117E90P107VM230364",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230364,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1903,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906",
      "ID": 3001
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2117,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis",
      "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3197979+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267600",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 267600,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1903,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906",
      "ID": 3001
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken",
      "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0268692+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313517",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313517,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1903,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906",
      "ID": 3001
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4966,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek",
      "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.3987928+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3101E102P129VM295010",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295010,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1903,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906",
      "ID": 3001
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3101,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala",
      "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1883392+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319073",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319073,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1903,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906",
      "ID": 3001
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5034,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny",
      "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6912604+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306342",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306342,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1903,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906",
      "ID": 3001
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2159,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Martin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5479633+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5110E252P395VM310867",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 310867,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1903,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906",
      "ID": 3001
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Mason",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.595077+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268004",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 268004,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1903,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906",
      "ID": 3001
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2133,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0518249+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2876E141P433VM286399",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286399,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1903,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906",
      "ID": 3001
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2876,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5774877+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4951E147P368VM258566",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258566,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1903,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906",
      "ID": 3001
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4951,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan",
      "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3127795+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3896E175P307VM263844",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 263844,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1903,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906",
      "ID": 3001
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3896,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam",
      "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.912948+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308465",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 308465,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1903,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906",
      "ID": 3001
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0570938+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4964E143P375VM279706",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279706,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1903,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906",
      "ID": 3001
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4964,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5191633+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279563",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279563,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1903,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906",
      "ID": 3001
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3824,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5130665+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2066E22P91VM261013",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261013,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1903,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906",
      "ID": 3001
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2066,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.1080167+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299601",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 299601,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1903,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906",
      "ID": 3001
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7046056+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306652",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306652,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1903,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906",
      "ID": 3001
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina",
      "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5613674+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2487E146P369VM301142",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 301142,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1903,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906",
      "ID": 3001
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2487,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0355117+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223936",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223936,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1903,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906",
      "ID": 3001
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4849566+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237536",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237536,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1903,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906",
      "ID": 3001
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1961,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David",
      "DisplayName": "David McLetchie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2150513+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305526",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 305526,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1903,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906",
      "ID": 3001
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2134,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3281307+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320353",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 320353,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1903,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906",
      "ID": 3001
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5041,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan",
      "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1627322+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315938",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315938,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1903,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906",
      "ID": 3001
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3763,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart",
      "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9387528+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1986E23P197VM236739",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 236739,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1903,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906",
      "ID": 3001
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1986,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan",
      "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9379721+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5047E100P130VM289766",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289766,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1903,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906",
      "ID": 3001
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5047,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne",
      "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4581971+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234561",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234561,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1903,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906",
      "ID": 3001
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1845,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette",
      "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.389598+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313197",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313197,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1903,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906",
      "ID": 3001
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3061,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1678482+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1768E19P265VM289254",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289254,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1903,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906",
      "ID": 3001
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1768,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4293121+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225277",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225277,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1903,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906",
      "ID": 3001
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1894,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Neil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9624569+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3815E98P134VM270938",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270938,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1903,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906",
      "ID": 3001
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3815,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Park, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Park",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8355535+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265848",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265848,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1903,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906",
      "ID": 3001
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2010,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil",
      "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4631656+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283282",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283282,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1903,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906",
      "ID": 3001
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5057,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.6937684+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2853E33P128VM251510",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251510,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1903,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906",
      "ID": 3001
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Pentland",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4667973+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317574",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317574,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1903,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906",
      "ID": 3001
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5009,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.428288+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254283",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254283,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1903,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906",
      "ID": 3001
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3745,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis",
      "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2488836+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1870E225P478VM295696",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295696,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1903,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906",
      "ID": 3001
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1870,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona",
      "DisplayName": "Shona Robison",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5319283+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2135E254P450VM235413",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235413,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1903,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906",
      "ID": 3001
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2135,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Russell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6696857+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1895E232P431VM257607",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257607,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1903,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906",
      "ID": 3001
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1895,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0638041+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228530",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 228530,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1903,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906",
      "ID": 3001
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1839,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.8030743+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2345E10P55VM291644",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291644,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1903,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906",
      "ID": 3001
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2345,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1361661+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311114",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311114,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1903,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906",
      "ID": 3001
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2223,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish",
      "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.6059986+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246445",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 246445,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1903,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906",
      "ID": 3001
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2182,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1290381+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298060",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298060,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1903,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906",
      "ID": 3001
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5079,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew",
      "DisplayName": "Drew Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1365389+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234089",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234089,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1903,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906",
      "ID": 3001
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1769,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1661564+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274621",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274621,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1903,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906",
      "ID": 3001
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4014,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz",
      "DisplayName": "Liz Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1145236+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2215E224P447VM270076",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270076,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1903,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906",
      "ID": 3001
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2215,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5804999+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317455",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317455,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1903,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906",
      "ID": 3001
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3806,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4228281+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326314",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 326314,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1903,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906",
      "ID": 3001
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5106,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin",
      "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7531168+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241236",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241236,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1903,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906",
      "ID": 3001
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1848,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola",
      "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7488949+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2098E237P531VM290335",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 290335,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1903,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906",
      "ID": 3001
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2098,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Swinney",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7424075+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2674E247P401VM247827",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247827,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1903,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906",
      "ID": 3001
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2674,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave",
      "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4301173+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5075E234P371VM287428",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 287428,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1903,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906",
      "ID": 3001
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5075,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Torrance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8637686+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1793E151P362VM222521",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 222521,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1903,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906",
      "ID": 3001
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1793,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean",
      "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1925412+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5078E245P7VM307053",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307053,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1903,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906",
      "ID": 3001
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5078,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Walker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5852532+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1841E231P426VM239888",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239888,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1903,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906",
      "ID": 3001
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1841,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen",
      "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7636525+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283485",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283485,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1903,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906",
      "ID": 3001
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4952,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7099303+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1865E263P500VM231046",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231046,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1903,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906",
      "ID": 3001
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1865,
      "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra",
      "DisplayName": "Sandra White",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3633096+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237726",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237726,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1903,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906",
      "ID": 3001
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2610,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Wilson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2231889+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309193",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 309193,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1903,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Justice",
      "Reference": "S4M-02906",
      "ID": 3001
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4941,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza",
      "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0963213+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252713",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252713,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1904,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905.1",
      "ID": 3031
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1926,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian",
      "DisplayName": "Brian Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7503589+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2615E213P388VM258947",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258947,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1904,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905.1",
      "ID": 3031
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2615,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George",
      "DisplayName": "George Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3351126+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319635",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319635,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1904,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905.1",
      "ID": 3031
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4940,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare",
      "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9347824+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249529",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 249529,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1904,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905.1",
      "ID": 3031
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2641,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair",
      "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9307899+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1783E21P273VM227831",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227831,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1904,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905.1",
      "ID": 3031
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1783,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie",
      "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5675231+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2633E97P136VM280832",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280832,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1904,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905.1",
      "ID": 3031
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2633,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire",
      "DisplayName": "Claire Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7842916+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262772",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262772,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1904,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905.1",
      "ID": 3031
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2603,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6161875+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1759E91P115VM229791",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229791,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1904,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905.1",
      "ID": 3031
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia",
      "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.097199+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3751E243P383VM269770",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269770,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1904,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905.1",
      "ID": 3031
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3751,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5622172+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322638",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 322638,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1904,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905.1",
      "ID": 3031
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5109,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco",
      "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6973195+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5060E86P124VM295309",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295309,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1904,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905.1",
      "ID": 3031
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5060,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5064439+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242964",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242964,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1904,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905.1",
      "ID": 3031
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1866,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah",
      "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0430801+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235144",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235144,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1904,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905.1",
      "ID": 3031
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1943,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic",
      "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4212836+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302427",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 302427,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1904,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905.1",
      "ID": 3031
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2595,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin",
      "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5239778+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244231",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244231,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1904,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905.1",
      "ID": 3031
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2103,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith",
      "DisplayName": "Keith Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5457211+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327184",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 327184,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1904,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905.1",
      "ID": 3031
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.8027885+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277111",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277111,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1904,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905.1",
      "ID": 3031
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.7015629+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264063",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264063,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1904,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905.1",
      "ID": 3031
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2673,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick",
      "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9226074+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248680",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248680,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1904,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905.1",
      "ID": 3031
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2678,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson",
      "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6652213+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2123E27P233VM295716",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295716,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1904,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905.1",
      "ID": 3031
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2123,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm",
      "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5328652+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285276",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285276,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1904,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905.1",
      "ID": 3031
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3907,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3160062+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230753",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230753,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1904,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905.1",
      "ID": 3031
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1735,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela",
      "DisplayName": "Angela Constance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3440646+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243754",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 243754,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1904,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905.1",
      "ID": 3031
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1932,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce",
      "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3183705+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254890",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254890,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1904,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905.1",
      "ID": 3031
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1863,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna",
      "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2881982+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323791",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 323791,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1904,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905.1",
      "ID": 3031
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4976,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth",
      "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9720603+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5107E223P379VM290930",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 290930,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1904,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905.1",
      "ID": 3031
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5107,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7781836+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3743E222P391VM265448",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265448,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1904,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905.1",
      "ID": 3031
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3743,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel",
      "DisplayName": "Nigel Don",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4396251+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262345",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262345,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1904,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905.1",
      "ID": 3031
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3771,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob",
      "DisplayName": "Bob Doris",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.5974743+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281908",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 281908,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1904,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905.1",
      "ID": 3031
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2826,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Dornan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1629635+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298218",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298218,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1904,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905.1",
      "ID": 3031
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3812,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia",
      "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3362819+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231246",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231246,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1904,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905.1",
      "ID": 3031
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1778,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen",
      "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.586696+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4955E240P389VM285015",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285015,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1904,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905.1",
      "ID": 3031
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4955,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.057566+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219434",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 219434,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1904,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905.1",
      "ID": 3031
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1742,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle",
      "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.2988078+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238480",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 238480,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1904,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905.1",
      "ID": 3031
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1994,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus",
      "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4559282+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225183",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225183,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1904,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905.1",
      "ID": 3031
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1814,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda",
      "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7480393+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321822",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 321822,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1904,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905.1",
      "ID": 3031
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Fee",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4528473+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292863",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 292863,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1904,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905.1",
      "ID": 3031
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia",
      "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5613267+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227209",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227209,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1904,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905.1",
      "ID": 3031
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.535529+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5054E95P118VM313249",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313249,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1904,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905.1",
      "ID": 3031
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5054,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.3845284+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4947E152P361VM257753",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257753,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1904,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905.1",
      "ID": 3031
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4947,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Finnie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.076132+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271147",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271147,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1904,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905.1",
      "ID": 3031
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3901,
      "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe",
      "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8444918+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278044",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 278044,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1904,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905.1",
      "ID": 3031
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2394,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo",
      "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9845777+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2110E220P414VM287322",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 287322,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1904,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905.1",
      "ID": 3031
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth",
      "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8591951+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250570",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250570,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1904,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905.1",
      "ID": 3031
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2675,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob",
      "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1952707+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221034",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221034,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1904,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905.1",
      "ID": 3031
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1741,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel",
      "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6722416+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220160",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220160,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1904,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905.1",
      "ID": 3031
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1756,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine",
      "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3369357+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1860E104P150VM252376",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252376,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1904,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905.1",
      "ID": 3031
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1860,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda",
      "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7265076+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2033E20P141VM253812",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253812,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1904,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905.1",
      "ID": 3031
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2033,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain",
      "DisplayName": "Iain Gray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0219649+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324614",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324614,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1904,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905.1",
      "ID": 3031
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5042,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2305374+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259627",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 259627,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1904,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905.1",
      "ID": 3031
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick",
      "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6176148+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239417",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239417,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1904,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905.1",
      "ID": 3031
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2029,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh",
      "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.735906+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273689",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 273689,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1904,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905.1",
      "ID": 3031
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3758,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6311598+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304058",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 304058,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1904,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905.1",
      "ID": 3031
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4086,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Hume",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8475623+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221661",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221661,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1904,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905.1",
      "ID": 3031
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1773,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9423508+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1882E227P459VM241891",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241891,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1904,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905.1",
      "ID": 3031
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1882,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam",
      "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7844848+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223456",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223456,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1904,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905.1",
      "ID": 3031
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1893,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4587817+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307801",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307801,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1904,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905.1",
      "ID": 3031
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4934,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8455003+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272306",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 272306,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1904,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905.1",
      "ID": 3031
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4956,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Keir",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3240623+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244975",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244975,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1904,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905.1",
      "ID": 3031
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Kelly",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5866311+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315145",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315145,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1904,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905.1",
      "ID": 3031
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3129,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6762694+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247851",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247851,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1904,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905.1",
      "ID": 3031
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann",
      "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4311482+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4016E11P36VM275093",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 275093,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1904,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905.1",
      "ID": 3031
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4016,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1409998+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255547",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255547,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1904,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905.1",
      "ID": 3031
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2180,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5360039+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4938E158P374VM276996",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276996,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1904,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905.1",
      "ID": 3031
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4938,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6966129+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2112E250P486VM253417",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253417,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1904,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905.1",
      "ID": 3031
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2112,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny",
      "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.9955217+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4939E258P394VM276744",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276744,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1904,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905.1",
      "ID": 3031
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4939,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus",
      "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6792469+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325517",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 325517,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1904,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905.1",
      "ID": 3031
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5074,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon",
      "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5097731+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1828E3P10VM232881",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232881,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1904,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905.1",
      "ID": 3031
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1828,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo",
      "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8806198+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311645",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311645,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1904,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905.1",
      "ID": 3031
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4948,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike",
      "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8880997+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2117E90P107VM229695",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229695,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1904,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905.1",
      "ID": 3031
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2117,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis",
      "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0927139+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267431",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 267431,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1904,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905.1",
      "ID": 3031
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken",
      "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0195232+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313516",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313516,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1904,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905.1",
      "ID": 3031
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4966,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek",
      "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.3987519+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3101E102P129VM295009",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295009,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1904,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905.1",
      "ID": 3031
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3101,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala",
      "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1882984+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319072",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319072,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1904,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905.1",
      "ID": 3031
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5034,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny",
      "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6912199+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306341",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306341,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1904,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905.1",
      "ID": 3031
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2159,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Martin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5479165+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5110E252P395VM310866",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 310866,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1904,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905.1",
      "ID": 3031
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Mason",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5950047+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268173",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 268173,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1904,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905.1",
      "ID": 3031
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2133,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.059355+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2876E141P433VM286400",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286400,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1904,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905.1",
      "ID": 3031
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2876,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5775282+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4951E147P368VM258565",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258565,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1904,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905.1",
      "ID": 3031
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4951,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan",
      "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3127384+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3896E175P307VM263792",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 263792,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1904,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905.1",
      "ID": 3031
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3896,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam",
      "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9049347+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308466",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 308466,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1904,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905.1",
      "ID": 3031
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0571352+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4964E143P375VM279758",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279758,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1904,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905.1",
      "ID": 3031
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4964,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.521344+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279562",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279562,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1904,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905.1",
      "ID": 3031
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3824,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.513025+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2066E22P91VM261012",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261012,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1904,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905.1",
      "ID": 3031
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2066,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.1079757+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299600",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 299600,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1904,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905.1",
      "ID": 3031
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7045647+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306653",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306653,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1904,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905.1",
      "ID": 3031
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina",
      "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5614102+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2487E146P369VM301141",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 301141,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1904,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905.1",
      "ID": 3031
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2487,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0354609+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223937",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223937,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1904,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905.1",
      "ID": 3031
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4849975+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237886",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237886,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1904,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905.1",
      "ID": 3031
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1961,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David",
      "DisplayName": "David McLetchie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2303167+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305527",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 305527,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1904,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905.1",
      "ID": 3031
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2134,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3281708+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320354",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 320354,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1904,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905.1",
      "ID": 3031
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5041,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan",
      "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1627776+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315937",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315937,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1904,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905.1",
      "ID": 3031
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3763,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart",
      "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9387109+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1986E23P197VM236740",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 236740,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1904,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905.1",
      "ID": 3031
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1986,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan",
      "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9380303+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5047E100P130VM289765",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289765,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1904,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905.1",
      "ID": 3031
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5047,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne",
      "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4581576+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234560",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234560,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1904,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905.1",
      "ID": 3031
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1845,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette",
      "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3895564+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313196",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313196,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1904,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905.1",
      "ID": 3031
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3061,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1678067+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1768E19P265VM289255",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289255,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1904,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905.1",
      "ID": 3031
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1768,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4293533+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225331",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225331,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1904,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905.1",
      "ID": 3031
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1894,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Neil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9699736+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3815E98P134VM270973",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270973,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1904,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905.1",
      "ID": 3031
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3815,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Park, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Park",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8370655+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265776",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265776,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1904,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905.1",
      "ID": 3031
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2010,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil",
      "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4539935+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283230",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283230,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1904,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905.1",
      "ID": 3031
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5057,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.6914802+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2853E33P128VM252020",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252020,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1904,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905.1",
      "ID": 3031
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Pentland",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4991161+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317575",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317575,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1904,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905.1",
      "ID": 3031
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5009,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.428329+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254282",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254282,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1904,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905.1",
      "ID": 3031
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3745,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis",
      "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2488431+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1870E225P478VM295697",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295697,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1904,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905.1",
      "ID": 3031
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1870,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona",
      "DisplayName": "Shona Robison",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5319679+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2135E254P450VM235463",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235463,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1904,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905.1",
      "ID": 3031
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2135,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Russell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6789386+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1895E232P431VM257608",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257608,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1904,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905.1",
      "ID": 3031
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1895,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0638448+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228531",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 228531,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1904,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905.1",
      "ID": 3031
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1839,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.8031152+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2345E10P55VM291572",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291572,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1904,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905.1",
      "ID": 3031
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2345,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1331385+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311115",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311115,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1904,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905.1",
      "ID": 3031
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2223,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish",
      "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.6060574+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246446",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 246446,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1904,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905.1",
      "ID": 3031
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2182,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1290799+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298059",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298059,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1904,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905.1",
      "ID": 3031
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5079,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew",
      "DisplayName": "Drew Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1364931+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234088",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234088,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1904,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905.1",
      "ID": 3031
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1769,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1661154+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274674",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274674,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1904,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905.1",
      "ID": 3031
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4014,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz",
      "DisplayName": "Liz Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1168162+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269597",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269597,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1904,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905.1",
      "ID": 3031
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2215,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5547107+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317456",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317456,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1904,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905.1",
      "ID": 3031
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3806,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4228687+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326313",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 326313,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1904,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905.1",
      "ID": 3031
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5106,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin",
      "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7530756+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241237",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241237,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1904,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905.1",
      "ID": 3031
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1848,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola",
      "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7489368+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2098E237P531VM290336",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 290336,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1904,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905.1",
      "ID": 3031
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2098,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Swinney",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7424479+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248029",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248029,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1904,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905.1",
      "ID": 3031
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2674,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave",
      "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4386983+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5075E234P371VM287481",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 287481,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1904,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905.1",
      "ID": 3031
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5075,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Torrance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8660207+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1793E151P362VM222575",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 222575,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1904,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905.1",
      "ID": 3031
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1793,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean",
      "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1948454+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5078E245P7VM307052",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307052,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1904,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905.1",
      "ID": 3031
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5078,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Walker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5852125+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1841E231P426VM239887",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239887,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1904,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905.1",
      "ID": 3031
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1841,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen",
      "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7636123+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283743",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283743,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1904,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905.1",
      "ID": 3031
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4952,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7215548+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1865E263P500VM231829",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231829,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1904,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905.1",
      "ID": 3031
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1865,
      "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra",
      "DisplayName": "Sandra White",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6173272+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237375",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237375,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1904,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905.1",
      "ID": 3031
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2610,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Wilson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2014752+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309192",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 309192,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1904,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905.1",
      "ID": 3031
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4941,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza",
      "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0962765+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252714",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252714,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1905,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905",
      "ID": 3000
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1926,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian",
      "DisplayName": "Brian Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7503988+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2615E213P388VM258948",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258948,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1905,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905",
      "ID": 3000
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2615,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George",
      "DisplayName": "George Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3351526+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319634",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319634,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1905,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905",
      "ID": 3000
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4940,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare",
      "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9347421+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249528",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 249528,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1905,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905",
      "ID": 3000
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2641,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair",
      "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9307487+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1783E21P273VM227832",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227832,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1905,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905",
      "ID": 3000
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1783,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie",
      "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5675642+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2633E97P136VM280833",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280833,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1905,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905",
      "ID": 3000
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2633,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire",
      "DisplayName": "Claire Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7843313+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262773",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262773,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1905,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905",
      "ID": 3000
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2603,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6162273+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1759E91P115VM229864",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229864,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1905,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905",
      "ID": 3000
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia",
      "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.100696+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3751E243P383VM269769",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269769,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1905,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905",
      "ID": 3000
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3751,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.562176+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322639",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 322639,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1905,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905",
      "ID": 3000
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5109,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco",
      "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6973593+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5060E86P124VM295310",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295310,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1905,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905",
      "ID": 3000
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5060,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5064846+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242965",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242965,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1905,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905",
      "ID": 3000
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1866,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah",
      "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0431204+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235143",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235143,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1905,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905",
      "ID": 3000
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1943,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic",
      "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4212427+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302429",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 302429,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1905,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905",
      "ID": 3000
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2595,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin",
      "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5240603+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244230",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244230,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1905,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905",
      "ID": 3000
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2103,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith",
      "DisplayName": "Keith Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5456754+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327185",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 327185,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1905,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905",
      "ID": 3000
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.8028299+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277112",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277112,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1905,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905",
      "ID": 3000
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.7016035+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264062",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264062,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1905,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905",
      "ID": 3000
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2673,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick",
      "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9225672+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248678",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248678,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1905,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905",
      "ID": 3000
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2678,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson",
      "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6651408+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2123E27P233VM295715",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295715,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1905,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905",
      "ID": 3000
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2123,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm",
      "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5328232+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285277",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285277,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1905,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905",
      "ID": 3000
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3907,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3160476+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230754",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230754,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1905,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905",
      "ID": 3000
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1735,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela",
      "DisplayName": "Angela Constance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3441049+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243753",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 243753,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1905,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905",
      "ID": 3000
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1932,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce",
      "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3183305+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254817",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254817,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1905,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905",
      "ID": 3000
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1863,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna",
      "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2850203+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323792",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 323792,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1905,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905",
      "ID": 3000
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4976,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth",
      "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9721017+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5107E223P379VM290928",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 290928,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1905,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905",
      "ID": 3000
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5107,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7781041+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3743E222P391VM265449",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265449,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1905,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905",
      "ID": 3000
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3743,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel",
      "DisplayName": "Nigel Don",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4396663+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262347",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262347,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1905,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905",
      "ID": 3000
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3771,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob",
      "DisplayName": "Bob Doris",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.5975546+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281907",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 281907,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1905,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905",
      "ID": 3000
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2826,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Dornan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1629226+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298219",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298219,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1905,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905",
      "ID": 3000
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3812,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia",
      "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3363247+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231187",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231187,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1905,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905",
      "ID": 3000
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1778,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen",
      "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3695892+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4955E240P389VM285014",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285014,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1905,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905",
      "ID": 3000
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4955,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0575243+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219486",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 219486,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1905,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905",
      "ID": 3000
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1742,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle",
      "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3013592+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238479",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 238479,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1905,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905",
      "ID": 3000
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1994,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus",
      "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4558876+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225182",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225182,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1905,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905",
      "ID": 3000
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1814,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda",
      "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7479992+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321821",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 321821,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1905,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905",
      "ID": 3000
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Fee",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4527882+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292862",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 292862,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1905,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905",
      "ID": 3000
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia",
      "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.561287+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227211",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227211,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1905,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905",
      "ID": 3000
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5356345+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5054E95P118VM313250",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313250,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1905,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905",
      "ID": 3000
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5054,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.3845714+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4947E152P361VM257754",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257754,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1905,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905",
      "ID": 3000
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4947,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Finnie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0761723+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271146",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271146,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1905,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905",
      "ID": 3000
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3901,
      "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe",
      "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8444516+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278043",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 278043,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1905,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905",
      "ID": 3000
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2394,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo",
      "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.984537+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2110E220P414VM287325",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 287325,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1905,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905",
      "ID": 3000
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth",
      "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8593197+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250571",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250571,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1905,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905",
      "ID": 3000
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2675,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob",
      "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1953118+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221035",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221035,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1905,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905",
      "ID": 3000
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1741,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel",
      "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6722837+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220158",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220158,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1905,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905",
      "ID": 3000
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1756,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine",
      "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3368518+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1860E104P150VM252450",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252450,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1905,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905",
      "ID": 3000
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1860,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda",
      "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7296716+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2033E20P141VM253811",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253811,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1905,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905",
      "ID": 3000
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2033,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain",
      "DisplayName": "Iain Gray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0219255+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324613",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324613,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1905,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905",
      "ID": 3000
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5042,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2304959+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259625",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 259625,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1905,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905",
      "ID": 3000
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick",
      "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6175309+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239418",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239418,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1905,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905",
      "ID": 3000
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2029,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh",
      "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7359463+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273688",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 273688,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1905,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905",
      "ID": 3000
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3758,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6311189+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304057",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 304057,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1905,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905",
      "ID": 3000
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4086,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Hume",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8475216+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221660",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221660,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1905,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905",
      "ID": 3000
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1773,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9423104+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1882E227P459VM241890",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241890,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1905,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905",
      "ID": 3000
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1882,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam",
      "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7844434+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223455",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223455,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1905,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905",
      "ID": 3000
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1893,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4587411+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307802",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307802,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1905,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905",
      "ID": 3000
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4934,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8455428+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272307",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 272307,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1905,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905",
      "ID": 3000
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4956,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Keir",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3241302+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244976",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244976,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1905,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905",
      "ID": 3000
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Kelly",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5866717+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315146",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315146,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1905,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905",
      "ID": 3000
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3129,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6763102+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247850",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247850,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1905,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905",
      "ID": 3000
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann",
      "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4310906+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4016E11P36VM275094",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 275094,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1905,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905",
      "ID": 3000
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4016,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1410411+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255546",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255546,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1905,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905",
      "ID": 3000
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2180,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5359628+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4938E158P374VM276995",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276995,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1905,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905",
      "ID": 3000
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4938,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6965526+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2112E250P486VM253418",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253418,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1905,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905",
      "ID": 3000
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2112,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny",
      "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.9955625+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4939E258P394VM276742",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276742,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1905,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905",
      "ID": 3000
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4939,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus",
      "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6791663+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325518",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 325518,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1905,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905",
      "ID": 3000
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5074,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon",
      "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5098129+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1828E3P10VM233253",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 233253,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1905,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905",
      "ID": 3000
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1828,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo",
      "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1160487+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311646",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311646,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1905,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905",
      "ID": 3000
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4948,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike",
      "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8881413+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2117E90P107VM229693",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229693,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1905,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905",
      "ID": 3000
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2117,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis",
      "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0926334+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267432",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 267432,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1905,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905",
      "ID": 3000
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken",
      "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0195643+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313515",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313515,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1905,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905",
      "ID": 3000
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4966,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek",
      "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.3987113+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3101E102P129VM295008",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295008,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1905,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905",
      "ID": 3000
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3101,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala",
      "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1882563+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319071",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319071,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1905,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905",
      "ID": 3000
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5034,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny",
      "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6911794+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306340",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306340,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1905,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905",
      "ID": 3000
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2159,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Martin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5478439+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5110E252P395VM310865",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 310865,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1905,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905",
      "ID": 3000
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Mason",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5949642+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268172",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 268172,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1905,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905",
      "ID": 3000
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2133,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.059313+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2876E141P433VM286401",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286401,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1905,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905",
      "ID": 3000
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2876,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5775691+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4951E147P368VM258564",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258564,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1905,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905",
      "ID": 3000
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4951,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan",
      "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3126972+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3896E175P307VM263790",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 263790,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1905,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905",
      "ID": 3000
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3896,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam",
      "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9048527+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308467",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 308467,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1905,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905",
      "ID": 3000
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0571773+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4964E143P375VM279760",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279760,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1905,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905",
      "ID": 3000
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4964,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5214835+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279561",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279561,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1905,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905",
      "ID": 3000
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3824,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5129843+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2066E22P91VM261011",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261011,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1905,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905",
      "ID": 3000
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2066,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.1079344+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299599",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 299599,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1905,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905",
      "ID": 3000
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7045233+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306654",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306654,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1905,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905",
      "ID": 3000
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina",
      "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5614508+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2487E146P369VM301140",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 301140,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1905,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905",
      "ID": 3000
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2487,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0354107+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223938",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223938,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1905,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905",
      "ID": 3000
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4850374+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237887",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237887,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1905,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905",
      "ID": 3000
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1961,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David",
      "DisplayName": "David McLetchie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2303573+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305528",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 305528,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1905,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905",
      "ID": 3000
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2134,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.328211+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320355",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 320355,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1905,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905",
      "ID": 3000
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5041,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan",
      "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1628209+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315936",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315936,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1905,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905",
      "ID": 3000
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3763,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart",
      "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9386703+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1986E23P197VM236741",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 236741,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1905,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905",
      "ID": 3000
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1986,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan",
      "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9380723+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5047E100P130VM289764",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289764,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1905,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905",
      "ID": 3000
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5047,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne",
      "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4581178+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234486",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234486,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1905,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905",
      "ID": 3000
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1845,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette",
      "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3863271+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313195",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313195,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1905,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905",
      "ID": 3000
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3061,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.167765+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1768E19P265VM289256",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289256,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1905,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905",
      "ID": 3000
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1768,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.429394+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225332",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225332,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1905,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905",
      "ID": 3000
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1894,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Neil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9700158+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3815E98P134VM270974",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270974,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1905,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905",
      "ID": 3000
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3815,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Park, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Park",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8371053+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265773",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265773,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1905,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905",
      "ID": 3000
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2010,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil",
      "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4538696+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283228",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283228,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1905,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905",
      "ID": 3000
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5057,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.6913971+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2853E33P128VM252022",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252022,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1905,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905",
      "ID": 3000
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Pentland",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.499197+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317576",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317576,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1905,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905",
      "ID": 3000
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5009,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4283696+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254281",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254281,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1905,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905",
      "ID": 3000
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3745,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis",
      "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2488019+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1870E225P478VM295698",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295698,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1905,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905",
      "ID": 3000
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1870,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona",
      "DisplayName": "Shona Robison",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5320076+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2135E254P450VM235465",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235465,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1905,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905",
      "ID": 3000
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2135,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Russell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6790198+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1895E232P431VM257682",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257682,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1905,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905",
      "ID": 3000
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1895,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0670326+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228532",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 228532,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1905,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905",
      "ID": 3000
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1839,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.8031558+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2345E10P55VM291570",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291570,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1905,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905",
      "ID": 3000
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2345,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1330571+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311116",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311116,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1905,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905",
      "ID": 3000
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2223,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish",
      "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.6060996+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246447",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 246447,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1905,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905",
      "ID": 3000
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2182,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1291208+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298058",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298058,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1905,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905",
      "ID": 3000
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5079,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew",
      "DisplayName": "Drew Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1364522+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234087",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234087,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1905,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905",
      "ID": 3000
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1769,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1660745+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274676",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274676,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1905,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905",
      "ID": 3000
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4014,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz",
      "DisplayName": "Liz Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1168978+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269598",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269598,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1905,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905",
      "ID": 3000
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2215,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5547739+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317457",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317457,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1905,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905",
      "ID": 3000
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3806,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4229089+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326312",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 326312,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1905,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905",
      "ID": 3000
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5106,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin",
      "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7530336+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241238",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241238,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1905,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905",
      "ID": 3000
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1848,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola",
      "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7489778+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2098E237P531VM290337",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 290337,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1905,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905",
      "ID": 3000
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2098,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Swinney",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7424884+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248031",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248031,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1905,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905",
      "ID": 3000
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2674,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave",
      "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4387803+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5075E234P371VM287483",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 287483,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1905,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905",
      "ID": 3000
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5075,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Torrance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8661015+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1793E151P362VM222576",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 222576,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1905,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905",
      "ID": 3000
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1793,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean",
      "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1948878+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5078E245P7VM307051",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307051,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1905,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905",
      "ID": 3000
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5078,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Walker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5851722+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1841E231P426VM239886",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239886,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1905,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905",
      "ID": 3000
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1841,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen",
      "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7635705+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283744",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283744,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1905,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905",
      "ID": 3000
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4952,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7215953+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1865E263P500VM231828",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231828,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1905,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905",
      "ID": 3000
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1865,
      "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra",
      "DisplayName": "Sandra White",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6172859+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237373",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237373,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1905,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905",
      "ID": 3000
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2610,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Wilson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2013937+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309191",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 309191,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1905,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 66,
      "VoteAgainst": 51,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Health",
      "Reference": "S4M-02905",
      "ID": 3000
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4941,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza",
      "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0962356+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252715",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252715,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1906,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.3",
      "ID": 3033
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1926,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian",
      "DisplayName": "Brian Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7504571+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2615E213P388VM258949",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258949,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1906,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.3",
      "ID": 3033
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2615,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George",
      "DisplayName": "George Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3351937+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319633",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319633,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1906,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.3",
      "ID": 3033
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4940,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare",
      "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9347013+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249527",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 249527,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1906,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.3",
      "ID": 3033
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2641,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair",
      "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9307079+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1783E21P273VM227833",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227833,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1906,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.3",
      "ID": 3033
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1783,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie",
      "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5676071+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2633E97P136VM280834",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280834,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1906,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.3",
      "ID": 3033
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2633,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire",
      "DisplayName": "Claire Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7843729+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262774",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262774,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1906,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.3",
      "ID": 3033
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2603,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6162683+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1759E91P115VM229865",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229865,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1906,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.3",
      "ID": 3033
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia",
      "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.1007374+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3751E243P383VM269768",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269768,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1906,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.3",
      "ID": 3033
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3751,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5621343+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322640",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 322640,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1906,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.3",
      "ID": 3033
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5109,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco",
      "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6974005+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5060E86P124VM295311",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295311,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1906,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.3",
      "ID": 3033
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5060,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5065265+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242966",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242966,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1906,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.3",
      "ID": 3033
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1866,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah",
      "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0431814+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235142",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235142,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1906,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.3",
      "ID": 3033
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1943,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic",
      "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4212015+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302430",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 302430,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1906,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.3",
      "ID": 3033
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2595,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin",
      "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5242479+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244229",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244229,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1906,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.3",
      "ID": 3033
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2103,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith",
      "DisplayName": "Keith Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5455997+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327186",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 327186,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1906,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.3",
      "ID": 3033
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.8028898+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277113",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277113,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1906,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.3",
      "ID": 3033
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.7016442+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264061",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264061,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1906,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.3",
      "ID": 3033
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2673,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick",
      "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9225268+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248677",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248677,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1906,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.3",
      "ID": 3033
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2678,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson",
      "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6651007+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2123E27P233VM295714",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295714,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1906,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.3",
      "ID": 3033
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2123,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm",
      "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5327638+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285278",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285278,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1906,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.3",
      "ID": 3033
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3907,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3160904+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230755",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230755,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1906,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.3",
      "ID": 3033
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1735,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela",
      "DisplayName": "Angela Constance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3441459+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243752",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 243752,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1906,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.3",
      "ID": 3033
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1932,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce",
      "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3182892+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254816",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254816,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1906,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.3",
      "ID": 3033
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1863,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna",
      "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2849798+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323793",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 323793,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1906,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.3",
      "ID": 3033
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4976,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth",
      "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9721644+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5107E223P379VM290927",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 290927,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1906,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.3",
      "ID": 3033
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5107,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7780641+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3743E222P391VM265450",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265450,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1906,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.3",
      "ID": 3033
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3743,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel",
      "DisplayName": "Nigel Don",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4397089+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262348",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262348,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1906,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.3",
      "ID": 3033
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3771,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob",
      "DisplayName": "Bob Doris",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.5975955+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281906",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 281906,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1906,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.3",
      "ID": 3033
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2826,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Dornan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1628816+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298220",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298220,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1906,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.3",
      "ID": 3033
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3812,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia",
      "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3363671+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231186",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231186,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1906,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.3",
      "ID": 3033
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1778,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen",
      "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3695478+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4955E240P389VM285013",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285013,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1906,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.3",
      "ID": 3033
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4955,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0574655+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219487",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 219487,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1906,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.3",
      "ID": 3033
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1742,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle",
      "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3014011+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238478",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 238478,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1906,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.3",
      "ID": 3033
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1994,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus",
      "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4558467+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225181",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225181,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1906,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.3",
      "ID": 3033
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1814,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda",
      "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7479589+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321820",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 321820,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1906,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.3",
      "ID": 3033
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Fee",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.452748+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292861",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 292861,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1906,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.3",
      "ID": 3033
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia",
      "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5612469+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227212",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227212,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1906,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.3",
      "ID": 3033
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5356769+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5054E95P118VM313251",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313251,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1906,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.3",
      "ID": 3033
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5054,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.3846149+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4947E152P361VM257755",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257755,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1906,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.3",
      "ID": 3033
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4947,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Finnie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0762141+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271145",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271145,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1906,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.3",
      "ID": 3033
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3901,
      "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe",
      "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8444114+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278042",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 278042,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1906,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.3",
      "ID": 3033
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2394,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo",
      "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9844966+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2110E220P414VM287326",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 287326,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1906,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.3",
      "ID": 3033
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth",
      "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8593612+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250572",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250572,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1906,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.3",
      "ID": 3033
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2675,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob",
      "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.195353+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221036",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221036,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1906,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.3",
      "ID": 3033
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1741,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel",
      "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6723257+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220157",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220157,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1906,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.3",
      "ID": 3033
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1756,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine",
      "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3368097+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1860E104P150VM252451",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252451,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1906,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.3",
      "ID": 3033
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1860,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda",
      "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7297139+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2033E20P141VM253810",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253810,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1906,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.3",
      "ID": 3033
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2033,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain",
      "DisplayName": "Iain Gray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0218843+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324612",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324612,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1906,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.3",
      "ID": 3033
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5042,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.230456+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259624",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 259624,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1906,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.3",
      "ID": 3033
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick",
      "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6174713+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239419",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239419,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1906,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.3",
      "ID": 3033
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2029,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh",
      "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7359877+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273687",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 273687,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1906,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.3",
      "ID": 3033
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3758,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6310784+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304056",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 304056,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1906,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.3",
      "ID": 3033
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4086,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Hume",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8474813+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221659",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221659,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1906,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.3",
      "ID": 3033
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1773,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9422685+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1882E227P459VM241889",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241889,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1906,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.3",
      "ID": 3033
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1882,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam",
      "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7844014+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223454",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223454,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1906,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.3",
      "ID": 3033
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1893,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4587002+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307803",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307803,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1906,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.3",
      "ID": 3033
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4934,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8456035+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272308",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 272308,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1906,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.3",
      "ID": 3033
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4956,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Keir",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3241802+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244977",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244977,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1906,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.3",
      "ID": 3033
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Kelly",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5867127+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315147",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315147,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1906,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.3",
      "ID": 3033
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3129,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6763515+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247849",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247849,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1906,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.3",
      "ID": 3033
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann",
      "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4310506+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4016E11P36VM275095",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 275095,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1906,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.3",
      "ID": 3033
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4016,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1410833+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255545",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255545,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1906,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.3",
      "ID": 3033
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2180,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5359224+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4938E158P374VM276994",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276994,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1906,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.3",
      "ID": 3033
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4938,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.696512+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2112E250P486VM253419",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253419,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1906,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.3",
      "ID": 3033
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2112,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny",
      "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.9956046+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4939E258P394VM276741",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276741,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1906,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.3",
      "ID": 3033
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4939,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus",
      "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6791264+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325519",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 325519,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1906,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.3",
      "ID": 3033
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5074,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon",
      "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.509854+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1828E3P10VM233254",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 233254,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1906,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.3",
      "ID": 3033
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1828,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo",
      "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1160905+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311647",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311647,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1906,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.3",
      "ID": 3033
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4948,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike",
      "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8881835+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2117E90P107VM229692",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229692,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1906,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.3",
      "ID": 3033
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2117,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis",
      "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0925918+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267433",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 267433,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1906,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.3",
      "ID": 3033
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken",
      "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0196068+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313514",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313514,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1906,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.3",
      "ID": 3033
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4966,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek",
      "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.3986691+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3101E102P129VM295007",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295007,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1906,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.3",
      "ID": 3033
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3101,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala",
      "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1881961+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319070",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319070,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1906,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.3",
      "ID": 3033
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5034,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny",
      "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6911385+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306339",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306339,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1906,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.3",
      "ID": 3033
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2159,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Martin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5478034+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5110E252P395VM310864",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 310864,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1906,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.3",
      "ID": 3033
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Mason",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5949229+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268171",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 268171,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1906,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.3",
      "ID": 3033
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2133,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0592718+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2876E141P433VM286402",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286402,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1906,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.3",
      "ID": 3033
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2876,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5776109+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4951E147P368VM258563",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258563,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1906,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.3",
      "ID": 3033
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4951,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan",
      "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.312654+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3896E175P307VM263789",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 263789,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1906,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.3",
      "ID": 3033
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3896,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam",
      "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9048105+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308468",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 308468,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1906,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.3",
      "ID": 3033
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0572189+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4964E143P375VM279761",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279761,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1906,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.3",
      "ID": 3033
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4964,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5215353+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279560",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279560,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1906,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.3",
      "ID": 3033
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3824,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5129438+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2066E22P91VM261010",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261010,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1906,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.3",
      "ID": 3033
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2066,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.1078927+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299598",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 299598,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1906,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.3",
      "ID": 3033
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7044801+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306655",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306655,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1906,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.3",
      "ID": 3033
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina",
      "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5614925+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2487E146P369VM301139",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 301139,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1906,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.3",
      "ID": 3033
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2487,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0353371+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223939",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223939,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1906,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.3",
      "ID": 3033
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4850788+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237888",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237888,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1906,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.3",
      "ID": 3033
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1961,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David",
      "DisplayName": "David McLetchie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2303989+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305529",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 305529,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1906,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.3",
      "ID": 3033
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2134,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3282522+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320356",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 320356,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1906,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.3",
      "ID": 3033
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5041,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan",
      "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.162863+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315935",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315935,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1906,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.3",
      "ID": 3033
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3763,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart",
      "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9386282+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1986E23P197VM236742",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 236742,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1906,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.3",
      "ID": 3033
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1986,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan",
      "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9381143+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5047E100P130VM289763",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289763,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1906,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.3",
      "ID": 3033
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5047,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne",
      "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4580776+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234485",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234485,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1906,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.3",
      "ID": 3033
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1845,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette",
      "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3862861+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313194",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313194,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1906,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.3",
      "ID": 3033
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3061,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1677236+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1768E19P265VM289257",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289257,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1906,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.3",
      "ID": 3033
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1768,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4294361+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225333",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225333,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1906,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.3",
      "ID": 3033
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1894,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Neil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9700576+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3815E98P134VM270975",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270975,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1906,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.3",
      "ID": 3033
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3815,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Park, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Park",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.837146+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265772",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265772,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1906,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.3",
      "ID": 3033
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2010,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil",
      "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4538284+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283227",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283227,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1906,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.3",
      "ID": 3033
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5057,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.6913555+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2853E33P128VM252023",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252023,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1906,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.3",
      "ID": 3033
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Pentland",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4992575+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317577",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317577,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1906,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.3",
      "ID": 3033
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5009,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.42843+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254280",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254280,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1906,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.3",
      "ID": 3033
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3745,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis",
      "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2487583+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1870E225P478VM295699",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295699,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1906,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.3",
      "ID": 3033
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1870,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona",
      "DisplayName": "Shona Robison",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5320487+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2135E254P450VM235466",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235466,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1906,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.3",
      "ID": 3033
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2135,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Russell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6790616+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1895E232P431VM257683",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257683,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1906,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.3",
      "ID": 3033
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1895,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0670736+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228533",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 228533,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1906,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.3",
      "ID": 3033
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1839,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.8031975+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2345E10P55VM291569",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291569,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1906,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.3",
      "ID": 3033
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2345,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1330162+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311117",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311117,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1906,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.3",
      "ID": 3033
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2223,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish",
      "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.6061407+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246448",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 246448,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1906,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.3",
      "ID": 3033
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2182,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1291632+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298057",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298057,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1906,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.3",
      "ID": 3033
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5079,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew",
      "DisplayName": "Drew Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1364119+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234086",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234086,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1906,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.3",
      "ID": 3033
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1769,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1660328+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274677",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274677,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1906,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.3",
      "ID": 3033
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4014,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz",
      "DisplayName": "Liz Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1169392+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269599",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269599,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1906,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.3",
      "ID": 3033
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2215,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5548172+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317458",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317458,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1906,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.3",
      "ID": 3033
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3806,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4230377+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326311",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 326311,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1906,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.3",
      "ID": 3033
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5106,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin",
      "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7529728+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241239",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241239,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1906,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.3",
      "ID": 3033
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1848,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola",
      "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7490208+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2098E237P531VM290338",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 290338,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1906,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.3",
      "ID": 3033
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2098,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Swinney",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7425296+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248032",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248032,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1906,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.3",
      "ID": 3033
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2674,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave",
      "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4388213+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5075E234P371VM287484",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 287484,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1906,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.3",
      "ID": 3033
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5075,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Torrance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.866161+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1793E151P362VM222577",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 222577,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1906,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.3",
      "ID": 3033
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1793,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean",
      "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1949289+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5078E245P7VM307050",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307050,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1906,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.3",
      "ID": 3033
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5078,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Walker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5851311+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1841E231P426VM239885",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239885,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1906,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.3",
      "ID": 3033
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1841,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen",
      "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.763511+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283745",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283745,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1906,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.3",
      "ID": 3033
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4952,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7216378+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1865E263P500VM231827",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231827,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1906,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.3",
      "ID": 3033
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1865,
      "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra",
      "DisplayName": "Sandra White",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6172436+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237372",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237372,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1906,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.3",
      "ID": 3033
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2610,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Wilson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2013532+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309190",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 309190,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1906,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 66,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.3",
      "ID": 3033
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4941,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza",
      "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0961903+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252716",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252716,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1907,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.2",
      "ID": 3017
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1926,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian",
      "DisplayName": "Brian Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7504992+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2615E213P388VM258950",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258950,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1907,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.2",
      "ID": 3017
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2615,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George",
      "DisplayName": "George Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3352349+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319632",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319632,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1907,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.2",
      "ID": 3017
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4940,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare",
      "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9346586+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249526",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 249526,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1907,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.2",
      "ID": 3017
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2641,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair",
      "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.930667+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1783E21P273VM227834",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227834,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1907,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.2",
      "ID": 3017
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1783,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie",
      "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5676487+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2633E97P136VM280835",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280835,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1907,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.2",
      "ID": 3017
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2633,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire",
      "DisplayName": "Claire Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7844139+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262775",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262775,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1907,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.2",
      "ID": 3017
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2603,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6163097+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1759E91P115VM229866",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229866,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1907,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.2",
      "ID": 3017
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia",
      "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.1007794+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3751E243P383VM269767",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269767,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1907,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.2",
      "ID": 3017
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3751,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5620759+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322641",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 322641,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1907,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.2",
      "ID": 3017
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5109,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco",
      "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.697442+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5060E86P124VM295312",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295312,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1907,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.2",
      "ID": 3017
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5060,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5065861+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242967",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242967,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1907,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.2",
      "ID": 3017
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1866,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah",
      "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0432233+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235141",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235141,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1907,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.2",
      "ID": 3017
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1943,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic",
      "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4211586+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302431",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 302431,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1907,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.2",
      "ID": 3017
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2595,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin",
      "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5242961+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244228",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244228,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1907,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.2",
      "ID": 3017
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2103,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith",
      "DisplayName": "Keith Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5455577+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327187",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 327187,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1907,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.2",
      "ID": 3017
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.8029325+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277114",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277114,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1907,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.2",
      "ID": 3017
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.7016862+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264060",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264060,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1907,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.2",
      "ID": 3017
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2673,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick",
      "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9224848+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248676",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248676,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1907,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.2",
      "ID": 3017
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2678,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson",
      "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6650598+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2123E27P233VM295713",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295713,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1907,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.2",
      "ID": 3017
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2123,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm",
      "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5327226+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285279",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285279,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1907,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.2",
      "ID": 3017
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3907,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3161322+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230756",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230756,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1907,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.2",
      "ID": 3017
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1735,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela",
      "DisplayName": "Angela Constance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.344187+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243751",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 243751,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1907,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.2",
      "ID": 3017
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1932,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce",
      "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.31823+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254815",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254815,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1907,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.2",
      "ID": 3017
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1863,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna",
      "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2849367+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323794",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 323794,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1907,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.2",
      "ID": 3017
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4976,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth",
      "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9722077+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5107E223P379VM290926",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 290926,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1907,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.2",
      "ID": 3017
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5107,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.778024+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3743E222P391VM265451",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265451,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1907,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.2",
      "ID": 3017
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3743,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel",
      "DisplayName": "Nigel Don",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4397503+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262349",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262349,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1907,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.2",
      "ID": 3017
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3771,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob",
      "DisplayName": "Bob Doris",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.5976367+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281905",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 281905,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1907,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.2",
      "ID": 3017
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2826,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Dornan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1628399+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298221",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298221,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1907,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.2",
      "ID": 3017
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3812,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia",
      "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3364092+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231185",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231185,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1907,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.2",
      "ID": 3017
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1778,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen",
      "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3694824+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4955E240P389VM285012",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285012,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1907,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.2",
      "ID": 3017
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4955,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0574241+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219488",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 219488,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1907,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.2",
      "ID": 3017
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1742,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle",
      "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3014431+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238477",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 238477,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1907,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.2",
      "ID": 3017
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1994,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus",
      "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.455805+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225180",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225180,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1907,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.2",
      "ID": 3017
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1814,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda",
      "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7479181+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321819",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 321819,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1907,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.2",
      "ID": 3017
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Fee",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4527069+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292860",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 292860,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1907,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.2",
      "ID": 3017
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia",
      "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5612059+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227213",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227213,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1907,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.2",
      "ID": 3017
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5357205+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5054E95P118VM313252",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313252,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1907,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.2",
      "ID": 3017
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5054,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.3846563+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4947E152P361VM257756",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257756,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1907,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.2",
      "ID": 3017
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4947,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Finnie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0762751+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271144",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271144,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1907,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.2",
      "ID": 3017
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3901,
      "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe",
      "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8443708+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278041",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 278041,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1907,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.2",
      "ID": 3017
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2394,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo",
      "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9844542+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2110E220P414VM287327",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 287327,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1907,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.2",
      "ID": 3017
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth",
      "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8594025+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250573",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250573,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1907,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.2",
      "ID": 3017
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2675,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob",
      "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1953957+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221037",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221037,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1907,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.2",
      "ID": 3017
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1741,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel",
      "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6723669+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220156",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220156,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1907,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.2",
      "ID": 3017
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1756,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine",
      "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3367501+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1860E104P150VM252452",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252452,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1907,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.2",
      "ID": 3017
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1860,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda",
      "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7297553+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2033E20P141VM253809",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253809,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1907,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.2",
      "ID": 3017
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2033,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain",
      "DisplayName": "Iain Gray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0218252+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324611",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324611,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1907,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.2",
      "ID": 3017
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5042,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2304147+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259623",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 259623,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1907,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.2",
      "ID": 3017
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick",
      "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6174293+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239420",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239420,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1907,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.2",
      "ID": 3017
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2029,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh",
      "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7360292+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273686",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 273686,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1907,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.2",
      "ID": 3017
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3758,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6310371+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304055",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 304055,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1907,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.2",
      "ID": 3017
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4086,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Hume",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8474398+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221658",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221658,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1907,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.2",
      "ID": 3017
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1773,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9422273+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1882E227P459VM241888",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241888,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1907,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.2",
      "ID": 3017
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1882,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam",
      "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7843413+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223453",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223453,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1907,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.2",
      "ID": 3017
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1893,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4586584+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307804",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307804,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1907,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.2",
      "ID": 3017
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4934,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8456484+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272309",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 272309,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1907,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.2",
      "ID": 3017
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4956,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Keir",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3242222+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244978",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244978,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1907,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.2",
      "ID": 3017
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Kelly",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5867547+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315148",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315148,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1907,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.2",
      "ID": 3017
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3129,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6763933+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247848",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247848,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1907,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.2",
      "ID": 3017
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann",
      "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4310097+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4016E11P36VM275096",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 275096,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1907,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.2",
      "ID": 3017
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4016,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1411256+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255544",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255544,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1907,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.2",
      "ID": 3017
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2180,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5358819+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4938E158P374VM276993",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276993,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1907,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.2",
      "ID": 3017
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4938,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6964708+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2112E250P486VM253420",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253420,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1907,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.2",
      "ID": 3017
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2112,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny",
      "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.9956635+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4939E258P394VM276740",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276740,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1907,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.2",
      "ID": 3017
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4939,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus",
      "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6790858+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325520",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 325520,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1907,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.2",
      "ID": 3017
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5074,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon",
      "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5098947+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1828E3P10VM233255",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 233255,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1907,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.2",
      "ID": 3017
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1828,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo",
      "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1161316+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311648",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311648,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1907,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.2",
      "ID": 3017
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4948,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike",
      "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8882263+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2117E90P107VM229691",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229691,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1907,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.2",
      "ID": 3017
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2117,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis",
      "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0925322+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267434",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 267434,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1907,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.2",
      "ID": 3017
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken",
      "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0196481+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313513",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313513,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1907,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.2",
      "ID": 3017
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4966,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek",
      "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.3986089+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3101E102P129VM295006",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295006,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1907,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.2",
      "ID": 3017
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3101,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala",
      "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1881549+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319069",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319069,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1907,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.2",
      "ID": 3017
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5034,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny",
      "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6910965+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306338",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306338,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1907,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.2",
      "ID": 3017
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2159,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Martin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5477623+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5110E252P395VM310863",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 310863,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1907,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.2",
      "ID": 3017
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Mason",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5948813+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268170",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 268170,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1907,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.2",
      "ID": 3017
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2133,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0592303+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2876E141P433VM286403",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286403,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1907,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.2",
      "ID": 3017
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2876,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5776524+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4951E147P368VM258562",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258562,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1907,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.2",
      "ID": 3017
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4951,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan",
      "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3125948+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3896E175P307VM263788",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 263788,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1907,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.2",
      "ID": 3017
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3896,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam",
      "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9047498+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308469",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 308469,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1907,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.2",
      "ID": 3017
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0572604+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4964E143P375VM279762",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279762,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1907,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.2",
      "ID": 3017
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4964,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5215773+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279559",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279559,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1907,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.2",
      "ID": 3017
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3824,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5129028+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2066E22P91VM261009",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261009,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1907,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.2",
      "ID": 3017
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2066,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.1078433+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299597",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 299597,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1907,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.2",
      "ID": 3017
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7044375+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306656",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306656,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1907,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.2",
      "ID": 3017
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina",
      "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5615344+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2487E146P369VM301138",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 301138,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1907,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.2",
      "ID": 3017
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2487,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0352824+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223940",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223940,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1907,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.2",
      "ID": 3017
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4851203+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237889",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237889,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1907,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.2",
      "ID": 3017
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1961,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David",
      "DisplayName": "David McLetchie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2304403+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305530",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 305530,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1907,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.2",
      "ID": 3017
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2134,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3282934+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320357",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 320357,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1907,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.2",
      "ID": 3017
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5041,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan",
      "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.162906+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315934",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315934,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1907,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.2",
      "ID": 3017
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3763,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart",
      "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9385685+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1986E23P197VM236743",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 236743,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1907,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.2",
      "ID": 3017
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1986,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan",
      "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9381557+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5047E100P130VM289762",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289762,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1907,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.2",
      "ID": 3017
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5047,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne",
      "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.458037+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234484",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234484,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1907,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.2",
      "ID": 3017
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1845,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette",
      "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3862436+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313193",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313193,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1907,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.2",
      "ID": 3017
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3061,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1676824+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1768E19P265VM289258",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289258,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1907,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.2",
      "ID": 3017
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1768,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4294964+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225334",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225334,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1907,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.2",
      "ID": 3017
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1894,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Neil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9700996+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3815E98P134VM270976",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270976,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1907,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.2",
      "ID": 3017
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3815,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Park, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Park",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8371869+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265771",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265771,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1907,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.2",
      "ID": 3017
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2010,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil",
      "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.453787+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283226",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283226,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1907,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.2",
      "ID": 3017
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5057,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.6913133+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2853E33P128VM252024",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252024,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1907,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.2",
      "ID": 3017
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Pentland",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4993009+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317578",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317578,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1907,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.2",
      "ID": 3017
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5009,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4284725+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254279",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254279,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1907,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.2",
      "ID": 3017
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3745,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis",
      "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.248697+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1870E225P478VM295700",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295700,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1907,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.2",
      "ID": 3017
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1870,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona",
      "DisplayName": "Shona Robison",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.53209+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2135E254P450VM235467",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235467,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1907,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.2",
      "ID": 3017
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2135,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Russell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6791023+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1895E232P431VM257684",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257684,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1907,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.2",
      "ID": 3017
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1895,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0671153+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228534",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 228534,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1907,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.2",
      "ID": 3017
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1839,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.8032395+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2345E10P55VM291568",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291568,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1907,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.2",
      "ID": 3017
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2345,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1329739+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311118",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311118,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1907,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.2",
      "ID": 3017
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2223,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish",
      "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.6061816+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246449",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 246449,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1907,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.2",
      "ID": 3017
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2182,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1292043+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298056",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298056,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1907,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.2",
      "ID": 3017
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5079,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew",
      "DisplayName": "Drew Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1363709+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234085",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234085,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1907,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.2",
      "ID": 3017
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1769,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1659918+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274678",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274678,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1907,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.2",
      "ID": 3017
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4014,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz",
      "DisplayName": "Liz Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1169808+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269600",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269600,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1907,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.2",
      "ID": 3017
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2215,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.554859+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317459",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317459,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1907,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.2",
      "ID": 3017
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3806,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4230815+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326310",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 326310,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1907,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.2",
      "ID": 3017
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5106,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin",
      "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7529313+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241240",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241240,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1907,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.2",
      "ID": 3017
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1848,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola",
      "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7490623+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2098E237P531VM290339",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 290339,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1907,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.2",
      "ID": 3017
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2098,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Swinney",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7426097+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248033",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248033,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1907,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.2",
      "ID": 3017
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2674,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave",
      "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4388624+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5075E234P371VM287485",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 287485,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1907,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.2",
      "ID": 3017
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5075,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Torrance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8662031+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1793E151P362VM222578",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 222578,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1907,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.2",
      "ID": 3017
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1793,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean",
      "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.19497+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5078E245P7VM307049",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307049,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1907,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.2",
      "ID": 3017
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5078,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Walker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5850903+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1841E231P426VM239884",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239884,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1907,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.2",
      "ID": 3017
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1841,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen",
      "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.76347+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283746",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283746,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1907,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.2",
      "ID": 3017
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4952,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.721679+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1865E263P500VM231826",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231826,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1907,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.2",
      "ID": 3017
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1865,
      "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra",
      "DisplayName": "Sandra White",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6171839+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237371",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237371,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1907,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.2",
      "ID": 3017
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2610,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Wilson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2013122+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309189",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 309189,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1907,
      "AgendaID": 2955,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 52,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Meeting the Challenge, Physical Activity and its Contribution to Tackling Obesity",
      "Reference": "S4M-02904.2",
      "ID": 3017
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4941,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza",
      "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-17T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0961171+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252696",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252696,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1901,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 38,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.3",
      "ID": 2998
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1926,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian",
      "DisplayName": "Brian Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7496592+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2615E213P388VM258901",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258901,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1901,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 38,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.3",
      "ID": 2998
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2615,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George",
      "DisplayName": "George Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3331127+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319654",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319654,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1901,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 38,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.3",
      "ID": 2998
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4940,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare",
      "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9356016+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249542",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 249542,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1901,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 38,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.3",
      "ID": 2998
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2641,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair",
      "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.931358+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1783E21P273VM227807",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227807,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1901,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 38,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.3",
      "ID": 2998
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1783,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie",
      "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5664851+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2633E97P136VM280810",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280810,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1901,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 38,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.3",
      "ID": 2998
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2633,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire",
      "DisplayName": "Claire Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7833465+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262714",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262714,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1901,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 38,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.3",
      "ID": 2998
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2603,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6136994+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1759E91P115VM229799",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229799,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1901,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 38,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.3",
      "ID": 2998
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia",
      "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0975273+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270126",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270126,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1901,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 38,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.3",
      "ID": 2998
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3751,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5826717+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322627",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 322627,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1901,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 38,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.3",
      "ID": 2998
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5109,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco",
      "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6968565+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5060E86P124VM295252",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295252,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1901,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 38,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.3",
      "ID": 2998
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5060,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5040127+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242946",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242946,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1901,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 38,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.3",
      "ID": 2998
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1866,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah",
      "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0423279+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235188",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235188,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1901,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 38,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.3",
      "ID": 2998
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1943,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic",
      "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4231759+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302364",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 302364,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1901,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 38,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.3",
      "ID": 2998
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2595,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin",
      "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5212047+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244289",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244289,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1901,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 38,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.3",
      "ID": 2998
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2103,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith",
      "DisplayName": "Keith Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5482459+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327165",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 327165,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1901,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 38,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.3",
      "ID": 2998
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.801985+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277053",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277053,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1901,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 38,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.3",
      "ID": 2998
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6990764+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264276",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264276,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1901,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 38,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.3",
      "ID": 2998
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2673,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick",
      "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1263213+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248723",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248723,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1901,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 38,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.3",
      "ID": 2998
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2678,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson",
      "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6670402+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2123E27P233VM295736",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295736,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1901,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 38,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.3",
      "ID": 2998
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2123,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm",
      "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5337005+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285218",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285218,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1901,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 38,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.3",
      "ID": 2998
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3907,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3134506+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230694",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230694,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1901,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 38,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.3",
      "ID": 2998
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1735,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela",
      "DisplayName": "Angela Constance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3411741+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243773",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 243773,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1901,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 38,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.3",
      "ID": 2998
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1932,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce",
      "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3191489+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254882",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254882,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1901,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 38,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.3",
      "ID": 2998
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1863,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna",
      "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2878543+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323772",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 323772,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1901,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 38,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.3",
      "ID": 2998
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4976,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth",
      "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9712626+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5107E223P379VM291283",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291283,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1901,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 38,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.3",
      "ID": 2998
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5107,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1122824+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3743E222P391VM265390",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265390,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1901,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 38,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.3",
      "ID": 2998
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3743,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel",
      "DisplayName": "Nigel Don",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4371109+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262301",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262301,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1901,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 38,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.3",
      "ID": 2998
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3771,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob",
      "DisplayName": "Bob Doris",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.5955872+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281930",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 281930,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1901,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 38,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.3",
      "ID": 2998
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2826,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Dornan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1639041+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298196",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298196,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1901,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 38,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.3",
      "ID": 2998
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3812,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia",
      "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1426633+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231238",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231238,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1901,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 38,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.3",
      "ID": 2998
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1778,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen",
      "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.5863494+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4955E240P389VM285888",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285888,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1901,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 38,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.3",
      "ID": 2998
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4955,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3488644+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219440",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 219440,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1901,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 38,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.3",
      "ID": 2998
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1742,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle",
      "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.2990815+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238524",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 238524,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1901,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 38,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.3",
      "ID": 2998
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1994,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus",
      "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4578125+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225196",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225196,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1901,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 38,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.3",
      "ID": 2998
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1814,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda",
      "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.748593+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321833",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 321833,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1901,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 38,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.3",
      "ID": 2998
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Fee",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4533108+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292848",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 292848,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1901,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 38,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.3",
      "ID": 2998
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia",
      "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5607061+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227165",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227165,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1901,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 38,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.3",
      "ID": 2998
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2706076+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5054E95P118VM312724",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 312724,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1901,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 38,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.3",
      "ID": 2998
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5054,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1406209+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4947E152P361VM257739",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257739,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1901,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 38,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.3",
      "ID": 2998
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4947,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Finnie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0755362+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271244",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271244,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1901,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 38,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.3",
      "ID": 2998
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3901,
      "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe",
      "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0619077+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278067",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 278067,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1901,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 38,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.3",
      "ID": 2998
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2394,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo",
      "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9855854+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2110E220P414VM287259",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 287259,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1901,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 38,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.3",
      "ID": 2998
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth",
      "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8564851+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250557",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250557,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1901,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 38,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.3",
      "ID": 2998
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2675,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob",
      "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1947125+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221021",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221021,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1901,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 38,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.3",
      "ID": 2998
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1741,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel",
      "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6716726+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220204",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220204,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1901,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 38,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.3",
      "ID": 2998
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1756,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine",
      "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3388285+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1860E104P150VM252384",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252384,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1901,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 38,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.3",
      "ID": 2998
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1860,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda",
      "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7268524+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2033E20P141VM253836",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253836,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1901,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 38,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.3",
      "ID": 2998
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2033,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain",
      "DisplayName": "Iain Gray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0229631+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324633",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324633,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1901,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 38,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.3",
      "ID": 2998
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5042,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.231352+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259670",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 259670,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1901,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 38,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.3",
      "ID": 2998
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick",
      "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6194673+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239372",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239372,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1901,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 38,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.3",
      "ID": 2998
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2029,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh",
      "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7339781+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273747",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 273747,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1901,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 38,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.3",
      "ID": 2998
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3758,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6339499+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304121",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 304121,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1901,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 38,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.3",
      "ID": 2998
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4086,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Hume",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8505633+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221674",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221674,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1901,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 38,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.3",
      "ID": 2998
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1773,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9429065+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1882E227P459VM241904",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241904,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1901,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 38,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.3",
      "ID": 2998
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1882,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam",
      "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7850381+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223502",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223502,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1901,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 38,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.3",
      "ID": 2998
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1893,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4611873+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307624",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307624,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1901,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 38,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.3",
      "ID": 2998
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4934,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8378461+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272292",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 272292,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1901,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 38,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.3",
      "ID": 2998
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4956,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Keir",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3233819+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244956",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244956,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1901,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 38,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.3",
      "ID": 2998
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Kelly",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5857981+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315126",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315126,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1901,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 38,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.3",
      "ID": 2998
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3129,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6754247+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247896",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247896,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1901,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 38,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.3",
      "ID": 2998
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann",
      "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4330519+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4016E11P36VM274842",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274842,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1901,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 38,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.3",
      "ID": 2998
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4016,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1241023+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255747",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255747,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1901,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 38,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.3",
      "ID": 2998
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2180,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5551692+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4938E158P374VM277403",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277403,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1901,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 38,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.3",
      "ID": 2998
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4938,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9518768+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2112E250P486VM253065",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253065,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1901,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 38,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.3",
      "ID": 2998
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2112,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny",
      "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7653539+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4939E258P394VM276789",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276789,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1901,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 38,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.3",
      "ID": 2998
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4939,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus",
      "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6811761+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325498",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 325498,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1901,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 38,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.3",
      "ID": 2998
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5074,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon",
      "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5089627+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1828E3P10VM232889",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232889,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1901,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 38,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.3",
      "ID": 2998
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1828,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo",
      "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8810085+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311469",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311469,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1901,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 38,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.3",
      "ID": 2998
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4948,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike",
      "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8801642+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2117E90P107VM230357",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230357,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1901,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 38,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.3",
      "ID": 2998
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2117,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis",
      "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3195105+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267408",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 267408,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1901,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 38,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.3",
      "ID": 2998
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken",
      "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0185346+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313540",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313540,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1901,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 38,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.3",
      "ID": 2998
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4966,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek",
      "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.3997859+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3101E102P129VM295032",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295032,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1901,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 38,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.3",
      "ID": 2998
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3101,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala",
      "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1892844+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319083",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319083,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1901,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 38,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.3",
      "ID": 2998
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5034,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny",
      "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6917107+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306361",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306361,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1901,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 38,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.3",
      "ID": 2998
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2159,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Martin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5488+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5110E252P395VM310851",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 310851,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1901,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 38,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.3",
      "ID": 2998
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Mason",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5887568+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268195",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 268195,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1901,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 38,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.3",
      "ID": 2998
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2133,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0603159+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2876E141P433VM286378",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286378,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1901,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 38,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.3",
      "ID": 2998
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2876,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.576575+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4951E147P368VM258579",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258579,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1901,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 38,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.3",
      "ID": 2998
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4951,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan",
      "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3133429+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3896E175P307VM263837",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 263837,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1901,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 38,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.3",
      "ID": 2998
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3896,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam",
      "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9125546+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308481",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 308481,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1901,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 38,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.3",
      "ID": 2998
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0577714+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4964E143P375VM279713",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279713,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1901,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 38,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.3",
      "ID": 2998
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4964,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5194428+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279619",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279619,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1901,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 38,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.3",
      "ID": 2998
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3824,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.515444+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2066E22P91VM261032",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261032,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1901,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 38,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.3",
      "ID": 2998
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2066,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.1088608+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299622",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 299622,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1901,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 38,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.3",
      "ID": 2998
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7056589+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306668",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306668,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1901,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 38,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.3",
      "ID": 2998
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina",
      "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5622226+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2487E146P369VM301126",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 301126,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1901,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 38,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.3",
      "ID": 2998
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2487,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0346391+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223924",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223924,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1901,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 38,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.3",
      "ID": 2998
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4796261+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237543",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237543,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1901,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 38,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.3",
      "ID": 2998
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1961,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David",
      "DisplayName": "David McLetchie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2153543+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305507",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 305507,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1901,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 38,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.3",
      "ID": 2998
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2134,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3273083+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320343",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 320343,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1901,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 38,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.3",
      "ID": 2998
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5041,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan",
      "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1559346+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315956",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315956,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1901,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 38,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.3",
      "ID": 2998
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3763,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart",
      "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9395181+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1986E23P197VM236681",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 236681,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1901,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 38,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.3",
      "ID": 2998
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1986,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan",
      "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9354837+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5047E100P130VM289823",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289823,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1901,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 38,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.3",
      "ID": 2998
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5047,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne",
      "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4605911+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234552",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234552,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1901,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 38,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.3",
      "ID": 2998
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1845,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette",
      "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3892272+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313216",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313216,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1901,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 38,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.3",
      "ID": 2998
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3061,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.3827392+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1768E19P265VM289270",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289270,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1901,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 38,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.3",
      "ID": 2998
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1768,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.430011+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225285",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225285,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1901,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 38,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.3",
      "ID": 2998
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1894,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Neil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9627859+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3815E98P134VM270945",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270945,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1901,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 38,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.3",
      "ID": 2998
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3815,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Park, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Park",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.83586+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265839",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265839,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1901,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 38,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.3",
      "ID": 2998
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2010,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil",
      "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4567256+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283275",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283275,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1901,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 38,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.3",
      "ID": 2998
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5057,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.6934622+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2853E33P128VM251516",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251516,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1901,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 38,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.3",
      "ID": 2998
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Pentland",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4670688+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317564",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317564,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1901,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 38,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.3",
      "ID": 2998
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5009,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4278652+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254295",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254295,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1901,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 38,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.3",
      "ID": 2998
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3745,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis",
      "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2494022+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1870E225P478VM296173",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 296173,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1901,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 38,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.3",
      "ID": 2998
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1870,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona",
      "DisplayName": "Shona Robison",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5525222+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2135E254P450VM235420",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235420,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1901,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 38,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.3",
      "ID": 2998
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2135,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Russell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6699982+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1895E232P431VM257617",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257617,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1901,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 38,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.3",
      "ID": 2998
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1895,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0642374+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228518",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 228518,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1901,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 38,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.3",
      "ID": 2998
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1839,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.8025519+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2345E10P55VM291635",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291635,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1901,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 38,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.3",
      "ID": 2998
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2345,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1357874+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311095",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311095,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1901,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 38,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.3",
      "ID": 2998
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2223,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish",
      "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.6052024+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246433",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 246433,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1901,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 38,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.3",
      "ID": 2998
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2182,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1285044+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298116",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298116,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1901,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 38,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.3",
      "ID": 2998
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5079,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew",
      "DisplayName": "Drew Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1389168+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234148",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234148,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1901,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 38,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.3",
      "ID": 2998
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1769,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1687108+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274628",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274628,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1901,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 38,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.3",
      "ID": 2998
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4014,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz",
      "DisplayName": "Liz Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1148303+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269575",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269575,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1901,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 38,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.3",
      "ID": 2998
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2215,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.553528+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317437",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317437,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1901,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 38,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.3",
      "ID": 2998
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3806,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4220757+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326332",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 326332,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1901,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 38,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.3",
      "ID": 2998
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5106,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin",
      "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.753879+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241224",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241224,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1901,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 38,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.3",
      "ID": 2998
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1848,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola",
      "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7483508+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2098E237P531VM289700",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289700,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1901,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 38,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.3",
      "ID": 2998
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2098,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Swinney",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4554254+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2674E247P401VM247833",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247833,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1901,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 38,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.3",
      "ID": 2998
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2674,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave",
      "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4303801+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5075E234P371VM287436",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 287436,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1901,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 38,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.3",
      "ID": 2998
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5075,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Torrance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8641139+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1793E151P362VM222529",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 222529,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1901,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 38,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.3",
      "ID": 2998
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1793,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean",
      "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1928687+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5078E245P7VM307037",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307037,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1901,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 38,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.3",
      "ID": 2998
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5078,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Walker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.584582+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1841E231P426VM239900",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239900,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1901,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 38,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.3",
      "ID": 2998
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1841,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen",
      "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7641644+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283493",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283493,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1901,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 38,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.3",
      "ID": 2998
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4952,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7102813+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1865E263P500VM231853",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231853,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1901,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 38,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.3",
      "ID": 2998
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1865,
      "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra",
      "DisplayName": "Sandra White",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6183575+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237719",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237719,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1901,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 38,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.3",
      "ID": 2998
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2610,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Wilson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2228866+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309215",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 309215,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1901,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 38,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.3",
      "ID": 2998
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4941,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza",
      "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3197247+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252697",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252697,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1900,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.1",
      "ID": 2994
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1926,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian",
      "DisplayName": "Brian Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7496997+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2615E213P388VM258902",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258902,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1900,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.1",
      "ID": 2994
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2615,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George",
      "DisplayName": "George Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3331553+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319629",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319629,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1900,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.1",
      "ID": 2994
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4940,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare",
      "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9345157+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249541",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 249541,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1900,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.1",
      "ID": 2994
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2641,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair",
      "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9312995+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1783E21P273VM227808",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227808,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1900,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.1",
      "ID": 2994
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1783,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie",
      "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5665267+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2633E97P136VM280813",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280813,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1900,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.1",
      "ID": 2994
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2633,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire",
      "DisplayName": "Claire Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7834676+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262715",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262715,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1900,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.1",
      "ID": 2994
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2603,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6137578+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1759E91P115VM229800",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229800,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1900,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.1",
      "ID": 2994
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia",
      "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0975684+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270125",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270125,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1900,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.1",
      "ID": 2994
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3751,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5826305+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322621",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 322621,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1900,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.1",
      "ID": 2994
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5109,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco",
      "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.69659+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5060E86P124VM295253",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295253,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1900,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.1",
      "ID": 2994
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5060,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5040538+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242947",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242947,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1900,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.1",
      "ID": 2994
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1866,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah",
      "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0423686+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235187",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235187,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1900,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.1",
      "ID": 2994
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1943,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic",
      "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.423134+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302365",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 302365,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1900,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.1",
      "ID": 2994
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2595,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin",
      "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5212459+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244288",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244288,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1900,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.1",
      "ID": 2994
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2103,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith",
      "DisplayName": "Keith Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5482044+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327118",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 327118,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1900,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.1",
      "ID": 2994
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7997484+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277054",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277054,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1900,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.1",
      "ID": 2994
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6991173+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264275",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264275,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1900,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.1",
      "ID": 2994
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2673,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick",
      "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1262795+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248722",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248722,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1900,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.1",
      "ID": 2994
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2678,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson",
      "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6669995+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2123E27P233VM295735",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295735,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1900,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.1",
      "ID": 2994
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2123,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm",
      "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5336603+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285219",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285219,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1900,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.1",
      "ID": 2994
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3907,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3134992+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230695",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230695,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1900,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.1",
      "ID": 2994
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1735,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela",
      "DisplayName": "Angela Constance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3412151+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243772",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 243772,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1900,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.1",
      "ID": 2994
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1932,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce",
      "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3191086+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254881",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254881,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1900,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.1",
      "ID": 2994
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1863,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna",
      "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2878138+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323725",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 323725,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1900,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.1",
      "ID": 2994
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4976,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth",
      "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9692089+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5107E223P379VM291282",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291282,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1900,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.1",
      "ID": 2994
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5107,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1122413+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3743E222P391VM265391",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265391,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1900,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.1",
      "ID": 2994
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3743,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel",
      "DisplayName": "Nigel Don",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4371526+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262302",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262302,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1900,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.1",
      "ID": 2994
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3771,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob",
      "DisplayName": "Bob Doris",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.5956282+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281927",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 281927,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1900,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.1",
      "ID": 2994
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2826,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Dornan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1637813+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298199",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298199,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1900,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.1",
      "ID": 2994
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3812,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia",
      "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3353118+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231237",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231237,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1900,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.1",
      "ID": 2994
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1778,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen",
      "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.5863079+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4955E240P389VM285887",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285887,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1900,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.1",
      "ID": 2994
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4955,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.348804+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219441",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 219441,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1900,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.1",
      "ID": 2994
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1742,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle",
      "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.2991966+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238523",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 238523,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1900,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.1",
      "ID": 2994
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1994,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus",
      "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4577718+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225195",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225195,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1900,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.1",
      "ID": 2994
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1814,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda",
      "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7485521+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321839",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 321839,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1900,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.1",
      "ID": 2994
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Fee",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4535572+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292847",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 292847,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1900,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.1",
      "ID": 2994
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia",
      "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5606656+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227166",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227166,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1900,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.1",
      "ID": 2994
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2706492+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5054E95P118VM312725",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 312725,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1900,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.1",
      "ID": 2994
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5054,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1406616+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4947E152P361VM257741",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257741,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1900,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.1",
      "ID": 2994
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4947,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Finnie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0756181+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271243",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271243,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1900,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.1",
      "ID": 2994
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3901,
      "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe",
      "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0618652+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278064",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 278064,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1900,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.1",
      "ID": 2994
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2394,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo",
      "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9854392+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2110E220P414VM287260",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 287260,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1900,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.1",
      "ID": 2994
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth",
      "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.856526+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250558",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250558,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1900,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.1",
      "ID": 2994
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2675,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob",
      "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1947552+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221022",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221022,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1900,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.1",
      "ID": 2994
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1741,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel",
      "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6717135+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220203",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220203,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1900,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.1",
      "ID": 2994
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1756,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine",
      "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3387877+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1860E104P150VM252385",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252385,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1900,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.1",
      "ID": 2994
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1860,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda",
      "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7268933+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2033E20P141VM253833",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253833,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1900,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.1",
      "ID": 2994
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2033,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain",
      "DisplayName": "Iain Gray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.022842+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324680",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324680,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1900,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.1",
      "ID": 2994
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5042,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.233325+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259669",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 259669,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1900,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.1",
      "ID": 2994
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick",
      "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6194249+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239373",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239373,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1900,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.1",
      "ID": 2994
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2029,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh",
      "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7340193+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273746",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 273746,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1900,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.1",
      "ID": 2994
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3758,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6339098+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304120",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 304120,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1900,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.1",
      "ID": 2994
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4086,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Hume",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8505229+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221673",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221673,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1900,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.1",
      "ID": 2994
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1773,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9428656+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1882E227P459VM241903",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241903,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1900,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.1",
      "ID": 2994
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1882,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam",
      "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7849971+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223501",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223501,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1900,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.1",
      "ID": 2994
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1893,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4611462+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307781",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307781,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1900,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.1",
      "ID": 2994
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4934,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8446496+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272294",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 272294,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1900,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.1",
      "ID": 2994
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4956,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Keir",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3234635+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244957",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244957,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1900,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.1",
      "ID": 2994
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Kelly",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5858388+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315151",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315151,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1900,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.1",
      "ID": 2994
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3129,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6765351+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247895",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247895,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1900,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.1",
      "ID": 2994
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann",
      "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.433011+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4016E11P36VM274843",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274843,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1900,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.1",
      "ID": 2994
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4016,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.124145+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255746",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255746,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1900,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.1",
      "ID": 2994
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2180,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5551289+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4938E158P374VM277402",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277402,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1900,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.1",
      "ID": 2994
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4938,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9518361+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2112E250P486VM253066",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253066,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1900,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.1",
      "ID": 2994
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2112,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny",
      "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7653957+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4939E258P394VM276788",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276788,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1900,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.1",
      "ID": 2994
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4939,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus",
      "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6811177+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325451",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 325451,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1900,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.1",
      "ID": 2994
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5074,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon",
      "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5069659+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1828E3P10VM232890",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232890,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1900,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.1",
      "ID": 2994
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1828,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo",
      "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8810493+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311472",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311472,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1900,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.1",
      "ID": 2994
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4948,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike",
      "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8803092+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2117E90P107VM230356",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230356,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1900,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.1",
      "ID": 2994
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2117,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis",
      "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.319469+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267411",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 267411,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1900,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.1",
      "ID": 2994
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken",
      "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0186574+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313537",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313537,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1900,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.1",
      "ID": 2994
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4966,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek",
      "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.3996555+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3101E102P129VM295029",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295029,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1900,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.1",
      "ID": 2994
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3101,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala",
      "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1891413+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319089",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319089,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1900,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.1",
      "ID": 2994
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5034,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny",
      "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.69198+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306360",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306360,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1900,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.1",
      "ID": 2994
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2159,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Martin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5487585+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5110E252P395VM310850",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 310850,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1900,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.1",
      "ID": 2994
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Mason",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5887166+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268192",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 268192,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1900,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.1",
      "ID": 2994
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2133,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0601886+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2876E141P433VM286381",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286381,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1900,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.1",
      "ID": 2994
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2876,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5767006+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4951E147P368VM258577",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258577,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1900,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.1",
      "ID": 2994
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4951,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan",
      "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3132602+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3896E175P307VM263836",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 263836,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1900,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.1",
      "ID": 2994
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3896,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam",
      "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9125136+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308482",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 308482,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1900,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.1",
      "ID": 2994
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0578126+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4964E143P375VM279714",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279714,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1900,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.1",
      "ID": 2994
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4964,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5194828+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279618",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279618,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1900,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.1",
      "ID": 2994
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3824,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5154028+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2066E22P91VM261031",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261031,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1900,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.1",
      "ID": 2994
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2066,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.1088196+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299619",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 299619,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1900,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.1",
      "ID": 2994
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7055368+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306669",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306669,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1900,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.1",
      "ID": 2994
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina",
      "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5622636+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2487E146P369VM301125",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 301125,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1900,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.1",
      "ID": 2994
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2487,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0345892+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223925",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223925,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1900,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.1",
      "ID": 2994
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4796677+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237544",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237544,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1900,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.1",
      "ID": 2994
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1961,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David",
      "DisplayName": "David McLetchie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2153949+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305508",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 305508,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1900,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.1",
      "ID": 2994
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2134,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3273504+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320337",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 320337,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1900,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.1",
      "ID": 2994
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5041,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan",
      "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1556647+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315931",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315931,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1900,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.1",
      "ID": 2994
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3763,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart",
      "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9384423+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1986E23P197VM236682",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 236682,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1900,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.1",
      "ID": 2994
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1986,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan",
      "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9355256+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5047E100P130VM289822",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289822,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1900,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.1",
      "ID": 2994
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5047,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne",
      "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4605506+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234551",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234551,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1900,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.1",
      "ID": 2994
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1845,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette",
      "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3891682+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313215",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313215,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1900,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.1",
      "ID": 2994
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3061,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.3826967+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1768E19P265VM289271",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289271,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1900,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.1",
      "ID": 2994
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1768,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4300806+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225286",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225286,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1900,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.1",
      "ID": 2994
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1894,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Neil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9628271+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3815E98P134VM270946",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270946,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1900,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.1",
      "ID": 2994
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3815,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Park, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Park",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8359018+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265838",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265838,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1900,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.1",
      "ID": 2994
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2010,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil",
      "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4566848+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283274",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283274,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1900,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.1",
      "ID": 2994
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5057,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.6934214+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2853E33P128VM251517",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251517,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1900,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.1",
      "ID": 2994
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Pentland",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4671119+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317558",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317558,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1900,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.1",
      "ID": 2994
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5009,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4276195+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254294",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254294,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1900,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.1",
      "ID": 2994
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3745,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis",
      "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2493611+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1870E225P478VM296174",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 296174,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1900,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.1",
      "ID": 2994
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1870,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona",
      "DisplayName": "Shona Robison",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5525633+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2135E254P450VM235421",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235421,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1900,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.1",
      "ID": 2994
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2135,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Russell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6700405+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1895E232P431VM257618",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257618,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1900,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.1",
      "ID": 2994
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1895,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0642786+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228519",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 228519,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1900,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.1",
      "ID": 2994
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1839,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.8025942+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2345E10P55VM291634",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291634,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1900,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.1",
      "ID": 2994
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2345,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1357475+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311096",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311096,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1900,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.1",
      "ID": 2994
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2223,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish",
      "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.6052433+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246434",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 246434,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1900,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.1",
      "ID": 2994
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2182,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1285637+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298115",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298115,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1900,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.1",
      "ID": 2994
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5079,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew",
      "DisplayName": "Drew Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1388764+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234147",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234147,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1900,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.1",
      "ID": 2994
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1769,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.168669+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274629",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274629,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1900,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.1",
      "ID": 2994
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4014,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz",
      "DisplayName": "Liz Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1148715+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269578",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269578,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1900,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.1",
      "ID": 2994
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2215,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5536712+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317462",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317462,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1900,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.1",
      "ID": 2994
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3806,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4232165+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326379",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 326379,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1900,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.1",
      "ID": 2994
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5106,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin",
      "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7559598+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241225",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241225,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1900,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.1",
      "ID": 2994
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1848,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola",
      "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7483915+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2098E237P531VM290317",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 290317,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1900,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.1",
      "ID": 2994
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2098,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Swinney",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7416177+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2674E247P401VM247834",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247834,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1900,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.1",
      "ID": 2994
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2674,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave",
      "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4304206+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5075E234P371VM287437",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 287437,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1900,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.1",
      "ID": 2994
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5075,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Torrance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8641542+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1793E151P362VM222530",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 222530,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1900,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.1",
      "ID": 2994
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1793,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean",
      "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1929096+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5078E245P7VM307036",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307036,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1900,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.1",
      "ID": 2994
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5078,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Walker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5845416+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1841E231P426VM239899",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239899,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1900,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.1",
      "ID": 2994
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1841,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen",
      "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7641235+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283494",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283494,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1900,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.1",
      "ID": 2994
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4952,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7103227+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1865E263P500VM231852",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231852,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1900,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.1",
      "ID": 2994
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1865,
      "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra",
      "DisplayName": "Sandra White",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6183167+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237718",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237718,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1900,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.1",
      "ID": 2994
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2610,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Wilson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2228467+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309212",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 309212,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1900,
      "AgendaID": 2513,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 55,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "National Parenting Strategy for Scotland",
      "Reference": "S4M-02888.1",
      "ID": 2994
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4941,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza",
      "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-16T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY2",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3195998+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252288",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252288,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1896,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.3",
      "ID": 2922
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1926,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian",
      "DisplayName": "Brian Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7226903+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2615E213P388VM257557",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257557,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1896,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.3",
      "ID": 2922
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2615,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George",
      "DisplayName": "George Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0616583+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319918",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319918,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1896,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.3",
      "ID": 2922
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4940,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare",
      "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9470113+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249692",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 249692,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1896,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.3",
      "ID": 2922
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2641,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair",
      "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9457143+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1783E21P273VM227395",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227395,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1896,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.3",
      "ID": 2922
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1783,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie",
      "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5483137+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2633E97P136VM280391",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280391,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1896,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.3",
      "ID": 2922
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2633,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire",
      "DisplayName": "Claire Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7587043+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262455",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262455,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1896,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.3",
      "ID": 2922
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2603,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6026764+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1759E91P115VM229241",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229241,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1896,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.3",
      "ID": 2922
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia",
      "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0681659+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270235",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270235,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1896,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.3",
      "ID": 2922
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3751,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.7951624+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322851",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 322851,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1896,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.3",
      "ID": 2922
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5109,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco",
      "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.7063036+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5060E86P124VM294687",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 294687,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1896,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.3",
      "ID": 2922
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5060,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1740083+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242821",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242821,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1896,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.3",
      "ID": 2922
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1866,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah",
      "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0370341+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235607",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235607,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1896,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.3",
      "ID": 2922
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1943,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic",
      "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.685052+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302110",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 302110,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1896,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.3",
      "ID": 2922
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2595,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin",
      "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.297469+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244545",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244545,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1896,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.3",
      "ID": 2922
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2103,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith",
      "DisplayName": "Keith Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.559654+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327371",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 327371,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1896,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.3",
      "ID": 2922
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:46.0333258+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3775E216P435VM276638",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276638,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1896,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.3",
      "ID": 2922
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6747474+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264532",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264532,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1896,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.3",
      "ID": 2922
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2673,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick",
      "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1375665+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248832",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248832,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1896,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.3",
      "ID": 2922
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2678,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson",
      "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6719603+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2123E27P233VM295849",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295849,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1896,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.3",
      "ID": 2922
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2123,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm",
      "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5384849+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285116",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285116,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1896,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.3",
      "ID": 2922
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3907,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0671327+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230132",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230132,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1896,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.3",
      "ID": 2922
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1735,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela",
      "DisplayName": "Angela Constance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.1176107+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243885",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 243885,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1896,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.3",
      "ID": 2922
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1932,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce",
      "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3240918+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1863E238P523VM255286",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255286,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1896,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.3",
      "ID": 2922
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1863,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna",
      "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5243858+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4976E20P31VM324006",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324006,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1896,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.3",
      "ID": 2922
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4976,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth",
      "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9819387+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5107E223P379VM291289",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291289,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1896,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.3",
      "ID": 2922
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5107,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1125304+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3743E222P391VM265131",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265131,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1896,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.3",
      "ID": 2922
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3743,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel",
      "DisplayName": "Nigel Don",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1698076+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3771E149P417VM261727",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261727,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1896,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.3",
      "ID": 2922
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3771,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob",
      "DisplayName": "Bob Doris",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3702122+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2826E262P384VM282040",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 282040,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1896,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.3",
      "ID": 2922
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2826,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Dornan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1686125+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3812E94P117VM297931",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 297931,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1896,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.3",
      "ID": 2922
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3812,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia",
      "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1310978+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231642",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231642,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1896,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.3",
      "ID": 2922
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1778,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen",
      "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6093614+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4955E240P389VM286153",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286153,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1896,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.3",
      "ID": 2922
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4955,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3661832+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219331",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 219331,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1896,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.3",
      "ID": 2922
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1742,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle",
      "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.2939648+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238634",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 238634,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1896,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.3",
      "ID": 2922
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1994,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus",
      "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4625298+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225495",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225495,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1896,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.3",
      "ID": 2922
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1814,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda",
      "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9771936+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321609",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 321609,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1896,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.3",
      "ID": 2922
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Fee",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4434526+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1853E35P216VM293307",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 293307,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1896,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.3",
      "ID": 2922
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia",
      "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8393529+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1892E12P64VM226899",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 226899,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1896,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.3",
      "ID": 2922
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2515228+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5054E95P118VM312626",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 312626,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1896,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.3",
      "ID": 2922
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5054,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1364242+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4947E152P361VM257129",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257129,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1896,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.3",
      "ID": 2922
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4947,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Finnie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.8245623+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271353",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271353,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1896,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.3",
      "ID": 2922
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3901,
      "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe",
      "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0719015+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278484",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 278484,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1896,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.3",
      "ID": 2922
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2394,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo",
      "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2208041+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2110E220P414VM286699",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286699,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1896,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.3",
      "ID": 2922
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth",
      "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.596948+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250407",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250407,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1896,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.3",
      "ID": 2922
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2675,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob",
      "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.188004+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1741E10P50VM220720",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220720,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1896,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.3",
      "ID": 2922
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1741,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel",
      "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6541492+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220314",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220314,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1896,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.3",
      "ID": 2922
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1756,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine",
      "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6359915+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1860E104P150VM251827",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251827,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1896,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.3",
      "ID": 2922
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1860,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda",
      "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4908539+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2033E20P141VM266169",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 266169,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1896,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.3",
      "ID": 2922
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2033,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain",
      "DisplayName": "Iain Gray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4772853+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324427",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324427,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1896,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.3",
      "ID": 2922
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5042,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2221865+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259935",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 259935,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1896,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.3",
      "ID": 2922
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick",
      "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6363889+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239263",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239263,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1896,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.3",
      "ID": 2922
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2029,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh",
      "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7292383+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273850",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 273850,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1896,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.3",
      "ID": 2922
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3758,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6383543+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304219",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 304219,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1896,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.3",
      "ID": 2922
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4086,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Hume",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.0288344+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221819",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221819,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1896,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.3",
      "ID": 2922
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1773,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9491783+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1882E227P459VM242055",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242055,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1896,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.3",
      "ID": 2922
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1882,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam",
      "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7918691+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223765",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223765,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1896,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.3",
      "ID": 2922
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1893,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4728+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307515",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307515,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1896,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.3",
      "ID": 2922
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4934,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8328571+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272146",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 272146,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1896,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.3",
      "ID": 2922
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4956,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Keir",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.113561+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244842",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244842,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1896,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.3",
      "ID": 2922
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Kelly",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.580969+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315014",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315014,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1896,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.3",
      "ID": 2922
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3129,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6703684+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2080E36P220VM251097",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251097,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1896,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.3",
      "ID": 2922
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann",
      "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.2268917+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4016E11P36VM274733",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274733,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1896,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.3",
      "ID": 2922
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4016,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1193773+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255854",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255854,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1896,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.3",
      "ID": 2922
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2180,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5598945+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4938E158P374VM277821",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277821,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1896,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.3",
      "ID": 2922
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4938,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9698837+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2112E250P486VM252957",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252957,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1896,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.3",
      "ID": 2922
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2112,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny",
      "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7605093+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4939E258P394VM277209",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277209,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1896,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.3",
      "ID": 2922
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4939,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus",
      "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9383728+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325704",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 325704,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1896,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.3",
      "ID": 2922
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5074,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon",
      "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5176825+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1828E3P10VM232792",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232792,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1896,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.3",
      "ID": 2922
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1828,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo",
      "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8764329+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311362",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311362,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1896,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.3",
      "ID": 2922
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4948,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike",
      "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8754358+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2117E90P107VM230467",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230467,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1896,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.3",
      "ID": 2922
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2117,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis",
      "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3311825+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267302",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 267302,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1896,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.3",
      "ID": 2922
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken",
      "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0135696+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313799",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313799,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1896,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.3",
      "ID": 2922
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4966,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek",
      "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4111526+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3101E102P129VM295451",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295451,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1896,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.3",
      "ID": 2922
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3101,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala",
      "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5127135+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5034E88P114VM318859",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 318859,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1896,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.3",
      "ID": 2922
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5034,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny",
      "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6764758+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306473",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306473,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1896,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.3",
      "ID": 2922
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2159,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Martin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5535846+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5110E252P395VM311304",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311304,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1896,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.3",
      "ID": 2922
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Mason",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8729124+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268302",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 268302,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1896,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.3",
      "ID": 2922
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2133,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2612527+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2876E141P433VM286111",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286111,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1896,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.3",
      "ID": 2922
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2876,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3641334+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4951E147P368VM260738",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 260738,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1896,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.3",
      "ID": 2922
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4951,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan",
      "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.0901308+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3896E175P307VM264103",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264103,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1896,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.3",
      "ID": 2922
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3896,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam",
      "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.924332+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308025",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 308025,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1896,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.3",
      "ID": 2922
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8611869+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4964E143P375VM279300",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279300,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1896,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.3",
      "ID": 2922
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4964,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.4959996+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3824E84P113VM280032",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280032,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1896,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.3",
      "ID": 2922
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3824,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5385038+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2066E22P91VM261765",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261765,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1896,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.3",
      "ID": 2922
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2066,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3718518+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299732",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 299732,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1896,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.3",
      "ID": 2922
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7202366+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3759E260P411VM303354",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 303354,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1896,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.3",
      "ID": 2922
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina",
      "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8113382+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2487E146P369VM301735",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 301735,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1896,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.3",
      "ID": 2922
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2487,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.2808616+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223625",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223625,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1896,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.3",
      "ID": 2922
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4668442+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237435",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237435,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1896,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.3",
      "ID": 2922
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1961,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David",
      "DisplayName": "David McLetchie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2040875+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2134E34P201VM297841",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 297841,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1896,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.3",
      "ID": 2922
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2134,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1273+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320722",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 320722,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1896,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.3",
      "ID": 2922
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5041,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan",
      "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.178652+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3763E142P397VM316068",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 316068,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1896,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.3",
      "ID": 2922
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3763,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart",
      "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9447925+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1986E23P197VM236269",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 236269,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1896,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.3",
      "ID": 2922
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1986,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan",
      "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9091064+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5047E100P130VM291465",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291465,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1896,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.3",
      "ID": 2922
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5047,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne",
      "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1204795+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234955",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234955,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1896,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.3",
      "ID": 2922
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1845,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette",
      "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4070713+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313638",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313638,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1896,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.3",
      "ID": 2922
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3061,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4040178+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1768E19P265VM288502",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 288502,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1896,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.3",
      "ID": 2922
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1768,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1376758+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225020",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225020,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1896,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.3",
      "ID": 2922
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1894,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Neil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7411114+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3815E98P134VM270858",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270858,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1896,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.3",
      "ID": 2922
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3815,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Park, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Park",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8261564+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265933",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265933,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1896,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.3",
      "ID": 2922
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2010,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil",
      "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.466832+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283540",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283540,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1896,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.3",
      "ID": 2922
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5057,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7122928+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2853E33P128VM251406",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251406,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1896,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.3",
      "ID": 2922
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Pentland",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4622049+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317941",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317941,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1896,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.3",
      "ID": 2922
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5009,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4500874+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254756",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254756,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1896,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.3",
      "ID": 2922
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3745,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis",
      "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2823841+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1870E225P478VM295562",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295562,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1896,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.3",
      "ID": 2922
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1870,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona",
      "DisplayName": "Shona Robison",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5174984+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2135E254P450VM234850",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234850,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1896,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.3",
      "ID": 2922
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2135,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Russell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4024291+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1895E232P431VM257367",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257367,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1896,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.3",
      "ID": 2922
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1895,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0531545+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228063",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 228063,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1896,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.3",
      "ID": 2922
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1839,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5827588+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2345E10P55VM292041",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 292041,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1896,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.3",
      "ID": 2922
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2345,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1533996+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2223E176P333VM310671",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 310671,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1896,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.3",
      "ID": 2922
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2223,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish",
      "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5810236+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2182E87P175VM245975",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 245975,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1896,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.3",
      "ID": 2922
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2182,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8667902+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298371",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298371,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1896,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.3",
      "ID": 2922
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5079,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew",
      "DisplayName": "Drew Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3428468+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234405",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234405,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1896,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.3",
      "ID": 2922
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1769,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3758692+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4014E14P26VM269928",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269928,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1896,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.3",
      "ID": 2922
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4014,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz",
      "DisplayName": "Liz Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5738941+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269158",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269158,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1896,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.3",
      "ID": 2922
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2215,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.3062041+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317172",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317172,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1896,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.3",
      "ID": 2922
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3806,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.1847903+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326126",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 326126,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1896,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.3",
      "ID": 2922
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5106,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin",
      "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5409867+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241073",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241073,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1896,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.3",
      "ID": 2922
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1848,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola",
      "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3949018+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2098E237P531VM289587",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289587,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1896,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.3",
      "ID": 2922
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2098,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Swinney",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4504746+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2674E247P401VM247724",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247724,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1896,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.3",
      "ID": 2922
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2674,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave",
      "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4257091+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5075E234P371VM287430",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 287430,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1896,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.3",
      "ID": 2922
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5075,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Torrance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8638712+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1793E151P362VM222421",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 222421,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1896,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.3",
      "ID": 2922
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1793,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean",
      "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1882213+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5078E245P7VM307179",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307179,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1896,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.3",
      "ID": 2922
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5078,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Walker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5906766+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1841E231P426VM240205",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 240205,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1896,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.3",
      "ID": 2922
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1841,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen",
      "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3493843+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283384",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283384,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1896,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.3",
      "ID": 2922
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4952,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.6983811+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1865E263P500VM232263",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232263,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1896,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.3",
      "ID": 2922
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1865,
      "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra",
      "DisplayName": "Sandra White",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8471812+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237829",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237829,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1896,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.3",
      "ID": 2922
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2610,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Wilson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2278524+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309323",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 309323,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1896,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.3",
      "ID": 2922
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4941,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza",
      "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3243567+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252289",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252289,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1897,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.2",
      "ID": 2915
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1926,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian",
      "DisplayName": "Brian Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7227305+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2615E213P388VM258810",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258810,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1897,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.2",
      "ID": 2915
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2615,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George",
      "DisplayName": "George Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3288842+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319916",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319916,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1897,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.2",
      "ID": 2915
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4940,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare",
      "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9469274+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249691",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 249691,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1897,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.2",
      "ID": 2915
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2641,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair",
      "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9456563+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1783E21P273VM227396",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227396,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1897,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.2",
      "ID": 2915
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1783,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie",
      "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5483543+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2633E97P136VM280392",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280392,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1897,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.2",
      "ID": 2915
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2633,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire",
      "DisplayName": "Claire Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.758745+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262456",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262456,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1897,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.2",
      "ID": 2915
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2603,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6027183+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1759E91P115VM229242",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229242,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1897,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.2",
      "ID": 2915
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia",
      "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0682082+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270217",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270217,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1897,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.2",
      "ID": 2915
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3751,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.7943727+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322852",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 322852,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1897,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.2",
      "ID": 2915
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5109,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco",
      "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.7063437+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5060E86P124VM294688",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 294688,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1897,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.2",
      "ID": 2915
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5060,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1740495+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242836",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242836,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1897,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.2",
      "ID": 2915
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1866,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah",
      "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.037701+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235589",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235589,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1897,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.2",
      "ID": 2915
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1943,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic",
      "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6842856+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302111",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 302111,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1897,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.2",
      "ID": 2915
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2595,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin",
      "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.2975283+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244544",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244544,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1897,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.2",
      "ID": 2915
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2103,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith",
      "DisplayName": "Keith Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5595857+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327373",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 327373,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1897,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.2",
      "ID": 2915
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:46.0334198+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3775E216P435VM276639",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276639,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1897,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.2",
      "ID": 2915
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6747881+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264531",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264531,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1897,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.2",
      "ID": 2915
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2673,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick",
      "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1375075+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248823",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248823,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1897,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.2",
      "ID": 2915
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2678,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson",
      "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6715737+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2123E27P233VM295847",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295847,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1897,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.2",
      "ID": 2915
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2123,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm",
      "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5384046+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285117",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285117,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1897,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.2",
      "ID": 2915
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3907,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0671732+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230133",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230133,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1897,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.2",
      "ID": 2915
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1735,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela",
      "DisplayName": "Angela Constance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.1176514+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243883",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 243883,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1897,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.2",
      "ID": 2915
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1932,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce",
      "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3240081+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1863E238P523VM255285",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255285,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1897,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.2",
      "ID": 2915
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1863,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna",
      "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5243449+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4976E20P31VM324008",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324008,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1897,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.2",
      "ID": 2915
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4976,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth",
      "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9820234+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5107E223P379VM291382",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291382,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1897,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.2",
      "ID": 2915
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5107,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1169033+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3743E222P391VM265132",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265132,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1897,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.2",
      "ID": 2915
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3743,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel",
      "DisplayName": "Nigel Don",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1698492+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3771E149P417VM261738",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261738,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1897,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.2",
      "ID": 2915
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3771,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob",
      "DisplayName": "Bob Doris",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3706887+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2826E262P384VM282039",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 282039,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1897,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.2",
      "ID": 2915
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2826,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Dornan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1685724+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3812E94P117VM297932",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 297932,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1897,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.2",
      "ID": 2915
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3812,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia",
      "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1311393+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231641",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231641,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1897,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.2",
      "ID": 2915
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1778,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen",
      "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6093216+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4955E240P389VM285979",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285979,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1897,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.2",
      "ID": 2915
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4955,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3527692+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219341",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 219341,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1897,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.2",
      "ID": 2915
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1742,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle",
      "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.2944115+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238616",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 238616,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1897,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.2",
      "ID": 2915
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1994,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus",
      "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4617815+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225494",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225494,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1897,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.2",
      "ID": 2915
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1814,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda",
      "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9771528+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321608",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 321608,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1897,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.2",
      "ID": 2915
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Fee",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4434125+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1853E35P216VM293306",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 293306,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1897,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.2",
      "ID": 2915
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia",
      "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8393114+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1892E12P64VM226908",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 226908,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1897,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.2",
      "ID": 2915
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2519016+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5054E95P118VM312627",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 312627,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1897,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.2",
      "ID": 2915
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5054,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1364651+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4947E152P361VM257130",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257130,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1897,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.2",
      "ID": 2915
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4947,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Finnie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.8246033+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271335",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271335,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1897,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.2",
      "ID": 2915
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3901,
      "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe",
      "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.071077+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278483",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 278483,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1897,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.2",
      "ID": 2915
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2394,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo",
      "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2207631+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2110E220P414VM286700",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286700,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1897,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.2",
      "ID": 2915
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth",
      "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5970073+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250408",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250408,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1897,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.2",
      "ID": 2915
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2675,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob",
      "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1880472+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1741E10P50VM220721",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220721,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1897,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.2",
      "ID": 2915
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1741,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel",
      "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6541904+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220304",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220304,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1897,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.2",
      "ID": 2915
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1756,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine",
      "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6355563+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1860E104P150VM251828",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251828,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1897,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.2",
      "ID": 2915
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1860,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda",
      "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4908956+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2033E20P141VM266168",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 266168,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1897,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.2",
      "ID": 2915
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2033,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain",
      "DisplayName": "Iain Gray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4772278+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324425",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324425,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1897,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.2",
      "ID": 2915
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5042,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2221038+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259925",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 259925,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1897,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.2",
      "ID": 2915
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick",
      "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6359557+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239281",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239281,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1897,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.2",
      "ID": 2915
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2029,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh",
      "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7300075+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273849",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 273849,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1897,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.2",
      "ID": 2915
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3758,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6383115+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304218",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 304218,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1897,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.2",
      "ID": 2915
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4086,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Hume",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.0287937+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221818",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221818,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1897,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.2",
      "ID": 2915
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1773,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9491367+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1882E227P459VM242054",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242054,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1897,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.2",
      "ID": 2915
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1882,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam",
      "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7918276+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223282",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223282,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1897,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.2",
      "ID": 2915
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1893,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4471007+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307516",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307516,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1897,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.2",
      "ID": 2915
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4934,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8328981+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272147",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 272147,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1897,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.2",
      "ID": 2915
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4956,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Keir",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.1136014+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244844",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244844,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1897,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.2",
      "ID": 2915
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Kelly",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5810506+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315016",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315016,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1897,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.2",
      "ID": 2915
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3129,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6704509+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247987",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247987,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1897,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.2",
      "ID": 2915
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann",
      "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4368953+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4016E11P36VM274751",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274751,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1897,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.2",
      "ID": 2915
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4016,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1201467+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255837",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255837,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1897,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.2",
      "ID": 2915
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2180,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5591767+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4938E158P374VM277803",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277803,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1897,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.2",
      "ID": 2915
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4938,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9690919+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2112E250P486VM252975",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252975,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1897,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.2",
      "ID": 2915
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2112,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny",
      "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7612572+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4939E258P394VM277198",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277198,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1897,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.2",
      "ID": 2915
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4939,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus",
      "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.937863+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325706",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 325706,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1897,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.2",
      "ID": 2915
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5074,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon",
      "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5178387+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1828E3P10VM232793",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232793,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1897,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.2",
      "ID": 2915
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1828,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo",
      "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8764739+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311363",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311363,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1897,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.2",
      "ID": 2915
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4948,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike",
      "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8754963+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2117E90P107VM230458",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230458,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1897,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.2",
      "ID": 2915
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2117,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis",
      "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3307823+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267303",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 267303,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1897,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.2",
      "ID": 2915
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken",
      "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.013611+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313798",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313798,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1897,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.2",
      "ID": 2915
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4966,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek",
      "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4111114+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3101E102P129VM295450",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295450,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1897,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.2",
      "ID": 2915
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3101,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala",
      "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5126731+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5034E88P114VM318858",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 318858,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1897,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.2",
      "ID": 2915
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5034,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny",
      "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6764354+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306471",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306471,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1897,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.2",
      "ID": 2915
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2159,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Martin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5535033+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5110E252P395VM311303",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311303,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1897,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.2",
      "ID": 2915
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Mason",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8728708+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268301",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 268301,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1897,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.2",
      "ID": 2915
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2133,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2612119+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2876E141P433VM286112",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286112,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1897,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.2",
      "ID": 2915
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2876,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3641749+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4951E147P368VM260737",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 260737,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1897,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.2",
      "ID": 2915
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4951,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan",
      "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.0900893+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3896E175P307VM264092",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264092,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1897,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.2",
      "ID": 2915
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3896,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam",
      "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9238603+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308026",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 308026,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1897,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.2",
      "ID": 2915
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.861228+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4964E143P375VM279311",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279311,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1897,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.2",
      "ID": 2915
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4964,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.4966775+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3824E84P113VM280031",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280031,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1897,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.2",
      "ID": 2915
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3824,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5384629+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2066E22P91VM261763",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261763,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1897,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.2",
      "ID": 2915
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2066,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3717684+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299731",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 299731,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1897,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.2",
      "ID": 2915
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7201968+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3759E260P411VM303355",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 303355,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1897,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.2",
      "ID": 2915
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina",
      "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8113793+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2487E146P369VM301734",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 301734,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1897,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.2",
      "ID": 2915
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2487,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.2808202+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223626",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223626,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1897,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.2",
      "ID": 2915
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4668851+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237453",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237453,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1897,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.2",
      "ID": 2915
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1961,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David",
      "DisplayName": "David McLetchie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2112429+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2134E34P201VM297843",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 297843,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1897,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.2",
      "ID": 2915
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2134,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1273812+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320723",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 320723,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1897,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.2",
      "ID": 2915
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5041,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan",
      "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1786924+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3763E142P397VM316066",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 316066,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1897,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.2",
      "ID": 2915
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3763,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart",
      "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9446865+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1986E23P197VM236270",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 236270,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1897,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.2",
      "ID": 2915
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1986,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan",
      "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9091475+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5047E100P130VM291464",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291464,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1897,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.2",
      "ID": 2915
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5047,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne",
      "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1204386+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234954",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234954,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1897,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.2",
      "ID": 2915
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1845,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette",
      "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.407029+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313636",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313636,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1897,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.2",
      "ID": 2915
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3061,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4039348+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1768E19P265VM288503",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 288503,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1897,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.2",
      "ID": 2915
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1768,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1377174+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225659",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225659,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1897,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.2",
      "ID": 2915
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1894,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Neil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9848644+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3815E98P134VM270876",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270876,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1897,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.2",
      "ID": 2915
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3815,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Park, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Park",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.826918+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265932",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265932,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1897,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.2",
      "ID": 2915
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2010,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil",
      "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4667909+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283529",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283529,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1897,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.2",
      "ID": 2915
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5057,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7118223+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2853E33P128VM251416",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251416,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1897,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.2",
      "ID": 2915
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Pentland",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4626454+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317942",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317942,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1897,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.2",
      "ID": 2915
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5009,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4501604+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254755",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254755,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1897,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.2",
      "ID": 2915
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3745,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis",
      "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2823436+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1870E225P478VM295563",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295563,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1897,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.2",
      "ID": 2915
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1870,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona",
      "DisplayName": "Shona Robison",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5175392+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2135E254P450VM234859",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234859,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1897,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.2",
      "ID": 2915
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2135,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Russell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4028222+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1895E232P431VM257368",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257368,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1897,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.2",
      "ID": 2915
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1895,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.053196+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228064",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 228064,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1897,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.2",
      "ID": 2915
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1839,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5827994+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2345E10P55VM292040",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 292040,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1897,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.2",
      "ID": 2915
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2345,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.153358+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2223E176P333VM310673",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 310673,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1897,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.2",
      "ID": 2915
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2223,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish",
      "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5811274+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2182E87P175VM245976",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 245976,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1897,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.2",
      "ID": 2915
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2182,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.866832+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298370",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298370,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1897,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.2",
      "ID": 2915
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5079,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew",
      "DisplayName": "Drew Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3428061+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234404",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234404,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1897,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.2",
      "ID": 2915
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1769,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3758278+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4014E14P26VM269939",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269939,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1897,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.2",
      "ID": 2915
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4014,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz",
      "DisplayName": "Liz Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5743695+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269159",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269159,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1897,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.2",
      "ID": 2915
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2215,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.3062455+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317174",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317174,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1897,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.2",
      "ID": 2915
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3806,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.1848725+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326124",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 326124,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1897,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.2",
      "ID": 2915
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5106,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin",
      "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5409038+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241074",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241074,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1897,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.2",
      "ID": 2915
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1848,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola",
      "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3949431+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2098E237P531VM289589",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289589,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1897,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.2",
      "ID": 2915
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2098,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Swinney",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4505548+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2674E247P401VM247733",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247733,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1897,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.2",
      "ID": 2915
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2674,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave",
      "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.426093+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5075E234P371VM284851",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 284851,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1897,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.2",
      "ID": 2915
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5075,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Torrance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0504673+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1793E151P362VM222750",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 222750,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1897,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.2",
      "ID": 2915
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1793,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean",
      "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.2027054+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5078E245P7VM307178",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307178,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1897,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.2",
      "ID": 2915
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5078,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Walker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5906348+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1841E231P426VM240204",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 240204,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1897,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.2",
      "ID": 2915
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1841,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen",
      "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3493427+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283402",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283402,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1897,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.2",
      "ID": 2915
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4952,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.6991674+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1865E263P500VM232262",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232262,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1897,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.2",
      "ID": 2915
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1865,
      "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra",
      "DisplayName": "Sandra White",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8471398+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237820",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237820,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1897,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.2",
      "ID": 2915
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2610,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Wilson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2274849+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309322",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 309322,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1897,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 93,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808.2",
      "ID": 2915
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4941,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza",
      "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3243148+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252290",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252290,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1898,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808",
      "ID": 2899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1926,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian",
      "DisplayName": "Brian Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7227709+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2615E213P388VM258811",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258811,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1898,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808",
      "ID": 2899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2615,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George",
      "DisplayName": "George Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3289252+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319915",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319915,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1898,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808",
      "ID": 2899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4940,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare",
      "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9468849+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249690",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 249690,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1898,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808",
      "ID": 2899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2641,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair",
      "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9456165+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1783E21P273VM227397",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227397,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1898,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808",
      "ID": 2899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1783,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie",
      "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5483952+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2633E97P136VM280393",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280393,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1898,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808",
      "ID": 2899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2633,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire",
      "DisplayName": "Claire Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.758786+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262457",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262457,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1898,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808",
      "ID": 2899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2603,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6027596+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1759E91P115VM229243",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229243,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1898,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808",
      "ID": 2899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia",
      "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0682499+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270216",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270216,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1898,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808",
      "ID": 2899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3751,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.7943283+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322853",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 322853,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1898,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808",
      "ID": 2899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5109,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco",
      "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.706384+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5060E86P124VM294689",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 294689,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1898,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808",
      "ID": 2899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5060,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1740905+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242837",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242837,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1898,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808",
      "ID": 2899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1866,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah",
      "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0377407+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235588",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235588,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1898,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808",
      "ID": 2899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1943,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic",
      "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6842458+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302112",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 302112,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1898,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808",
      "ID": 2899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2595,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin",
      "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.29757+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244543",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244543,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1898,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808",
      "ID": 2899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2103,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith",
      "DisplayName": "Keith Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5595321+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327374",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 327374,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1898,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808",
      "ID": 2899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:46.0334616+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3775E216P435VM276640",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276640,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1898,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808",
      "ID": 2899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.674829+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264530",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264530,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1898,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808",
      "ID": 2899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2673,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick",
      "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1374668+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248822",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248822,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1898,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808",
      "ID": 2899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2678,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson",
      "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6715328+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2123E27P233VM295846",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295846,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1898,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808",
      "ID": 2899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2123,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm",
      "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5383641+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285118",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285118,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1898,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808",
      "ID": 2899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3907,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0672145+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230134",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230134,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1898,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808",
      "ID": 2899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1735,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela",
      "DisplayName": "Angela Constance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.1176925+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243882",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 243882,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1898,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808",
      "ID": 2899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1932,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce",
      "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3239495+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1863E238P523VM255284",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255284,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1898,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808",
      "ID": 2899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1863,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna",
      "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5243043+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4976E20P31VM324009",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324009,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1898,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808",
      "ID": 2899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4976,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth",
      "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9820654+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5107E223P379VM291381",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291381,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1898,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808",
      "ID": 2899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5107,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1168619+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3743E222P391VM265133",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265133,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1898,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808",
      "ID": 2899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3743,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel",
      "DisplayName": "Nigel Don",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.16989+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3771E149P417VM261739",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261739,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1898,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808",
      "ID": 2899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3771,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob",
      "DisplayName": "Bob Doris",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3707486+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2826E262P384VM282038",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 282038,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1898,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808",
      "ID": 2899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2826,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Dornan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1685313+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3812E94P117VM297933",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 297933,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1898,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808",
      "ID": 2899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3812,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia",
      "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1311799+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231640",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231640,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1898,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808",
      "ID": 2899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1778,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen",
      "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6092808+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4955E240P389VM285978",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285978,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1898,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808",
      "ID": 2899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4955,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3527282+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219342",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 219342,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1898,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808",
      "ID": 2899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1742,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle",
      "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.2944531+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238615",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 238615,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1898,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808",
      "ID": 2899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1994,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus",
      "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4617228+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225493",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225493,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1898,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808",
      "ID": 2899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1814,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda",
      "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9771111+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321607",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 321607,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1898,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808",
      "ID": 2899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Fee",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4433726+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1853E35P216VM293267",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 293267,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1898,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808",
      "ID": 2899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia",
      "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8376246+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1892E12P64VM226909",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 226909,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1898,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808",
      "ID": 2899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2519429+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5054E95P118VM312628",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 312628,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1898,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808",
      "ID": 2899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5054,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1365055+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4947E152P361VM257131",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257131,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1898,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808",
      "ID": 2899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4947,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Finnie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.8246445+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271334",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271334,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1898,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808",
      "ID": 2899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3901,
      "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe",
      "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0710359+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278482",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 278482,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1898,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808",
      "ID": 2899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2394,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo",
      "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2207215+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2110E220P414VM286701",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286701,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1898,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808",
      "ID": 2899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth",
      "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5970483+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250409",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250409,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1898,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808",
      "ID": 2899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2675,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob",
      "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1881937+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1741E10P50VM220722",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220722,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1898,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808",
      "ID": 2899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1741,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel",
      "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6542311+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220303",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220303,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1898,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808",
      "ID": 2899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1756,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine",
      "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6355143+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1860E104P150VM251829",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251829,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1898,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808",
      "ID": 2899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1860,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda",
      "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4909365+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2033E20P141VM266167",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 266167,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1898,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808",
      "ID": 2899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2033,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain",
      "DisplayName": "Iain Gray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4771878+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324424",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324424,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1898,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808",
      "ID": 2899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5042,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2220632+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259924",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 259924,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1898,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808",
      "ID": 2899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick",
      "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6359149+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239282",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239282,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1898,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808",
      "ID": 2899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2029,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh",
      "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7300489+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273848",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 273848,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1898,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808",
      "ID": 2899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3758,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6382692+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304217",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 304217,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1898,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808",
      "ID": 2899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4086,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Hume",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.0287512+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221817",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221817,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1898,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808",
      "ID": 2899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1773,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9490939+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1882E227P459VM242053",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242053,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1898,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808",
      "ID": 2899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1882,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam",
      "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.791787+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223746",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223746,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1898,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808",
      "ID": 2899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1893,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4719902+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307517",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307517,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1898,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808",
      "ID": 2899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4934,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8329396+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272148",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 272148,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1898,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808",
      "ID": 2899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4956,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Keir",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.113642+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244845",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244845,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1898,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808",
      "ID": 2899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Kelly",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5810908+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315017",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315017,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1898,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808",
      "ID": 2899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3129,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6704928+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247986",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247986,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1898,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808",
      "ID": 2899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann",
      "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4368533+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4016E11P36VM274752",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274752,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1898,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808",
      "ID": 2899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4016,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1201877+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255836",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255836,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1898,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808",
      "ID": 2899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2180,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5591372+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4938E158P374VM277802",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277802,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1898,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808",
      "ID": 2899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4938,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9690503+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2112E250P486VM252976",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252976,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1898,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808",
      "ID": 2899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2112,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny",
      "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7612972+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4939E258P394VM277197",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277197,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1898,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808",
      "ID": 2899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4939,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus",
      "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9378049+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325707",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 325707,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1898,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808",
      "ID": 2899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5074,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon",
      "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5178829+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1828E3P10VM232794",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232794,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1898,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808",
      "ID": 2899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1828,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo",
      "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8765147+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311364",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311364,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1898,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808",
      "ID": 2899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4948,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike",
      "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8755392+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2117E90P107VM230457",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230457,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1898,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808",
      "ID": 2899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2117,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis",
      "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3307401+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267304",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 267304,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1898,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808",
      "ID": 2899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken",
      "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.013676+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313797",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313797,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1898,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808",
      "ID": 2899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4966,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek",
      "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4110699+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3101E102P129VM295449",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295449,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1898,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808",
      "ID": 2899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3101,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala",
      "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5126327+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5034E88P114VM318857",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 318857,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1898,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808",
      "ID": 2899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5034,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny",
      "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6763946+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306470",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306470,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1898,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808",
      "ID": 2899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2159,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Martin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5534628+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5110E252P395VM310843",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 310843,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1898,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808",
      "ID": 2899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Mason",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5884115+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268300",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 268300,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1898,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808",
      "ID": 2899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2133,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2611709+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2876E141P433VM286113",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286113,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1898,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808",
      "ID": 2899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2876,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.364216+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4951E147P368VM260736",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 260736,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1898,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808",
      "ID": 2899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4951,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan",
      "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.0900484+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3896E175P307VM264091",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264091,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1898,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808",
      "ID": 2899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3896,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam",
      "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9238179+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308489",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 308489,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1898,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808",
      "ID": 2899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0581246+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4964E143P375VM279312",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279312,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1898,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808",
      "ID": 2899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4964,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.4967264+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3824E84P113VM280030",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280030,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1898,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808",
      "ID": 2899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3824,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5384218+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2066E22P91VM261762",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261762,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1898,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808",
      "ID": 2899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2066,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3717276+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299730",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 299730,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1898,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808",
      "ID": 2899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7201568+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306560",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306560,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1898,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808",
      "ID": 2899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina",
      "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.557311+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2487E146P369VM301235",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 301235,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1898,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808",
      "ID": 2899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2487,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.2531362+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223627",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223627,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1898,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808",
      "ID": 2899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4669257+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237454",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237454,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1898,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808",
      "ID": 2899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1961,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David",
      "DisplayName": "David McLetchie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2112849+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2134E34P201VM297844",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 297844,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1898,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808",
      "ID": 2899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2134,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1274402+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320724",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 320724,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1898,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808",
      "ID": 2899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5041,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan",
      "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1787322+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3763E142P397VM316065",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 316065,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1898,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808",
      "ID": 2899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3763,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart",
      "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9446457+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1986E23P197VM236271",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 236271,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1898,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808",
      "ID": 2899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1986,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan",
      "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9091884+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5047E100P130VM291463",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291463,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1898,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808",
      "ID": 2899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5047,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne",
      "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1203975+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234953",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234953,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1898,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808",
      "ID": 2899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1845,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette",
      "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4069878+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313635",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313635,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1898,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808",
      "ID": 2899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3061,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4038925+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1768E19P265VM288542",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 288542,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1898,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808",
      "ID": 2899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1768,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1478975+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225039",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225039,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1898,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808",
      "ID": 2899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1894,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Neil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7419171+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3815E98P134VM270877",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270877,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1898,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808",
      "ID": 2899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3815,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Park, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Park",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8269595+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265931",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265931,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1898,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808",
      "ID": 2899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2010,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil",
      "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4667495+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283528",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283528,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1898,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808",
      "ID": 2899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5057,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.711781+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2853E33P128VM251417",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251417,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1898,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808",
      "ID": 2899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Pentland",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4626871+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317943",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317943,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1898,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808",
      "ID": 2899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5009,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4502038+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254754",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254754,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1898,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808",
      "ID": 2899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3745,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis",
      "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2823036+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1870E225P478VM295602",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295602,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1898,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808",
      "ID": 2899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1870,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona",
      "DisplayName": "Shona Robison",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5195192+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2135E254P450VM234860",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234860,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1898,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808",
      "ID": 2899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2135,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Russell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.402863+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1895E232P431VM257369",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257369,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1898,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808",
      "ID": 2899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1895,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0532368+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228065",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 228065,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1898,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808",
      "ID": 2899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1839,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.582859+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2345E10P55VM292039",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 292039,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1898,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808",
      "ID": 2899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2345,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1533143+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2223E176P333VM310674",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 310674,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1898,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808",
      "ID": 2899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2223,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish",
      "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5811688+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2182E87P175VM245977",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 245977,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1898,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808",
      "ID": 2899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2182,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8668745+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298369",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298369,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1898,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808",
      "ID": 2899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5079,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew",
      "DisplayName": "Drew Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3427655+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234403",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234403,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1898,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808",
      "ID": 2899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1769,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3757848+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4014E14P26VM269940",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269940,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1898,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808",
      "ID": 2899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4014,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz",
      "DisplayName": "Liz Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5744119+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269160",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269160,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1898,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808",
      "ID": 2899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2215,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.3062863+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317175",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317175,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1898,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808",
      "ID": 2899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3806,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.1849131+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326123",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 326123,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1898,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808",
      "ID": 2899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5106,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin",
      "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5408629+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241075",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241075,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1898,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808",
      "ID": 2899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1848,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola",
      "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3950029+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2098E237P531VM289590",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289590,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1898,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808",
      "ID": 2899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2098,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Swinney",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4505948+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2674E247P401VM247734",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247734,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1898,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808",
      "ID": 2899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2674,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave",
      "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.426135+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5075E234P371VM284852",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 284852,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1898,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808",
      "ID": 2899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5075,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Torrance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0505085+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1793E151P362VM222440",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 222440,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1898,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808",
      "ID": 2899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1793,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean",
      "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1890479+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5078E245P7VM307139",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307139,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1898,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808",
      "ID": 2899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5078,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Walker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5889424+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1841E231P426VM240203",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 240203,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1898,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808",
      "ID": 2899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1841,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen",
      "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3492998+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283403",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283403,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1898,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808",
      "ID": 2899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4952,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.6992081+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1865E263P500VM232261",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232261,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1898,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808",
      "ID": 2899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1865,
      "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra",
      "DisplayName": "Sandra White",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.847099+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237819",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237819,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1898,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808",
      "ID": 2899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2610,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Wilson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2274433+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309321",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 309321,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1898,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scottish Government Growth Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02808",
      "ID": 2899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4941,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza",
      "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3242737+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252286",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252286,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1899,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02800",
      "ID": 2893
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1926,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian",
      "DisplayName": "Brian Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7226071+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2615E213P388VM257555",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257555,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1899,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02800",
      "ID": 2893
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2615,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George",
      "DisplayName": "George Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.061577+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319935",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319935,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1899,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02800",
      "ID": 2893
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4940,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare",
      "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9477333+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249694",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 249694,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1899,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02800",
      "ID": 2893
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2641,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair",
      "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9457966+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1783E21P273VM227393",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227393,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1899,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02800",
      "ID": 2893
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1783,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie",
      "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5482126+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2633E97P136VM280389",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280389,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1899,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02800",
      "ID": 2893
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2633,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire",
      "DisplayName": "Claire Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7586214+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262453",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262453,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1899,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02800",
      "ID": 2893
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2603,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6025883+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1759E91P115VM229239",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229239,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1899,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02800",
      "ID": 2893
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia",
      "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0680823+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270237",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270237,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1899,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02800",
      "ID": 2893
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3751,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.7952673+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322849",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 322849,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1899,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02800",
      "ID": 2893
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5109,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco",
      "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.7062033+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5060E86P124VM294685",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 294685,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1899,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02800",
      "ID": 2893
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5060,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1739265+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242819",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242819,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1899,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02800",
      "ID": 2893
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1866,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah",
      "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0369527+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235609",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235609,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1899,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02800",
      "ID": 2893
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1943,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic",
      "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6851333+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302108",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 302108,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1899,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02800",
      "ID": 2893
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2595,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin",
      "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.297386+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244547",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244547,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1899,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02800",
      "ID": 2893
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2103,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith",
      "DisplayName": "Keith Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5679631+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327354",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 327354,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1899,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02800",
      "ID": 2893
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:46.0322576+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3775E216P435VM276636",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276636,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1899,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02800",
      "ID": 2893
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6746431+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264534",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264534,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1899,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02800",
      "ID": 2893
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2673,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick",
      "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1376521+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248834",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248834,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1899,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02800",
      "ID": 2893
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2678,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson",
      "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6720424+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2123E27P233VM296326",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 296326,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1899,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02800",
      "ID": 2893
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2123,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm",
      "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8441974+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285114",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285114,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1899,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02800",
      "ID": 2893
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3907,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0670497+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230130",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230130,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1899,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02800",
      "ID": 2893
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1735,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela",
      "DisplayName": "Angela Constance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.1175296+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243900",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 243900,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1899,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02800",
      "ID": 2893
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1932,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce",
      "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3247349+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1863E238P523VM255288",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255288,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1899,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02800",
      "ID": 2893
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1863,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna",
      "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5244684+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323989",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 323989,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1899,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02800",
      "ID": 2893
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4976,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth",
      "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9811883+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5107E223P379VM291394",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291394,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1899,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02800",
      "ID": 2893
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5107,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1174216+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3743E222P391VM265129",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265129,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1899,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02800",
      "ID": 2893
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3743,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel",
      "DisplayName": "Nigel Don",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.169725+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3771E149P417VM261725",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261725,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1899,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02800",
      "ID": 2893
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3771,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob",
      "DisplayName": "Bob Doris",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.370129+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2826E262P384VM282042",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 282042,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1899,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02800",
      "ID": 2893
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2826,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Dornan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1730908+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3812E94P117VM297929",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 297929,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1899,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02800",
      "ID": 2893
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3812,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia",
      "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1309986+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231644",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231644,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1899,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02800",
      "ID": 2893
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1778,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen",
      "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6094617+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4955E240P389VM286155",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286155,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1899,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02800",
      "ID": 2893
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4955,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3662651+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219329",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 219329,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1899,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02800",
      "ID": 2893
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1742,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle",
      "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.2938813+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238636",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 238636,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1899,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02800",
      "ID": 2893
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1994,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus",
      "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4626112+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225497",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225497,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1899,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02800",
      "ID": 2893
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1814,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda",
      "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9772753+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321611",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 321611,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1899,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02800",
      "ID": 2893
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Fee",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4435394+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1853E35P216VM293309",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 293309,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1899,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02800",
      "ID": 2893
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia",
      "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8394561+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1892E12P64VM226897",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 226897,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1899,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02800",
      "ID": 2893
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2514202+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5054E95P118VM312624",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 312624,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1899,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02800",
      "ID": 2893
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5054,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1363415+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4947E152P361VM257127",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257127,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1899,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02800",
      "ID": 2893
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4947,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Finnie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.8244784+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271510",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271510,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1899,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02800",
      "ID": 2893
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3901,
      "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe",
      "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0789365+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278486",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 278486,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1899,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02800",
      "ID": 2893
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2394,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo",
      "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2208863+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2110E220P414VM286697",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286697,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1899,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02800",
      "ID": 2893
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth",
      "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5968675+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250405",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250405,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1899,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02800",
      "ID": 2893
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2675,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob",
      "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1878648+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1741E10P50VM220718",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220718,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1899,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02800",
      "ID": 2893
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1741,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel",
      "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6540666+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220316",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220316,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1899,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02800",
      "ID": 2893
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1756,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine",
      "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.636074+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1860E104P150VM251825",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251825,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1899,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02800",
      "ID": 2893
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1860,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda",
      "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4907479+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2033E20P141VM266171",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 266171,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1899,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02800",
      "ID": 2893
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2033,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain",
      "DisplayName": "Iain Gray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.477368+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324444",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324444,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1899,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02800",
      "ID": 2893
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5042,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.222924+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259937",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 259937,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1899,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02800",
      "ID": 2893
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick",
      "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6364715+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239261",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239261,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1899,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02800",
      "ID": 2893
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2029,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh",
      "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.729147+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273852",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 273852,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1899,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02800",
      "ID": 2893
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3758,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6384559+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304221",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 304221,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1899,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02800",
      "ID": 2893
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4086,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Hume",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.028917+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221821",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221821,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1899,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02800",
      "ID": 2893
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1773,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9492605+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1882E227P459VM242057",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242057,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1899,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02800",
      "ID": 2893
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1882,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam",
      "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7919515+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223767",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223767,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1899,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02800",
      "ID": 2893
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1893,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4728809+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307513",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307513,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1899,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02800",
      "ID": 2893
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4934,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8327744+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272144",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 272144,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1899,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02800",
      "ID": 2893
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4956,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Keir",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.1134782+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244826",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244826,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1899,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02800",
      "ID": 2893
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Kelly",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5802711+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3129E261P419VM314997",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 314997,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1899,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02800",
      "ID": 2893
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3129,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6696252+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2080E36P220VM251099",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251099,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1899,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02800",
      "ID": 2893
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann",
      "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.2269741+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4016E11P36VM274731",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274731,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1899,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02800",
      "ID": 2893
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4016,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1192757+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255856",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255856,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1899,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02800",
      "ID": 2893
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2180,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5599748+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4938E158P374VM277823",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277823,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1899,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02800",
      "ID": 2893
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4938,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9699654+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2112E250P486VM252955",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252955,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1899,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02800",
      "ID": 2893
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2112,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny",
      "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7604263+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4939E258P394VM277211",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277211,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1899,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02800",
      "ID": 2893
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4939,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus",
      "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9384567+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325687",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 325687,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1899,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02800",
      "ID": 2893
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5074,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon",
      "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5169797+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1828E3P10VM232790",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232790,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1899,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02800",
      "ID": 2893
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1828,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo",
      "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8763504+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311360",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311360,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1899,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02800",
      "ID": 2893
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4948,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike",
      "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8753522+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2117E90P107VM230469",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230469,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1899,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02800",
      "ID": 2893
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2117,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis",
      "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3312653+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267300",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 267300,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1899,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02800",
      "ID": 2893
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken",
      "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0134872+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313801",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313801,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1899,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02800",
      "ID": 2893
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4966,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek",
      "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4112528+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3101E102P129VM295453",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295453,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1899,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02800",
      "ID": 2893
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3101,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala",
      "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5127951+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5034E88P114VM318861",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 318861,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1899,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02800",
      "ID": 2893
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5034,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny",
      "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6765761+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306490",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306490,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1899,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02800",
      "ID": 2893
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2159,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Martin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.554298+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5110E252P395VM311306",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311306,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1899,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02800",
      "ID": 2893
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Mason",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8729967+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268304",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 268304,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1899,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02800",
      "ID": 2893
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2133,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2613364+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2876E141P433VM286109",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286109,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1899,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02800",
      "ID": 2893
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2876,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3640509+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4951E147P368VM260740",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 260740,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1899,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02800",
      "ID": 2893
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4951,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan",
      "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.0902128+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3896E175P307VM264105",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264105,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1899,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02800",
      "ID": 2893
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3896,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam",
      "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9244535+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308023",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 308023,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1899,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02800",
      "ID": 2893
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8611044+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4964E143P375VM279298",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279298,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1899,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02800",
      "ID": 2893
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4964,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.4958904+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3824E84P113VM280034",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280034,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1899,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02800",
      "ID": 2893
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3824,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5385867+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2066E22P91VM261782",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261782,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1899,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02800",
      "ID": 2893
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2066,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3725956+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299734",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 299734,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1899,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02800",
      "ID": 2893
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7203174+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3759E260P411VM303352",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 303352,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1899,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02800",
      "ID": 2893
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina",
      "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.811254+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2487E146P369VM301737",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 301737,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1899,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02800",
      "ID": 2893
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2487,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.2809641+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223623",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223623,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1899,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02800",
      "ID": 2893
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4667608+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237433",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237433,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1899,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02800",
      "ID": 2893
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1961,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David",
      "DisplayName": "David McLetchie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2040044+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2134E34P201VM297824",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 297824,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1899,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02800",
      "ID": 2893
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2134,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1265966+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320720",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 320720,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1899,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02800",
      "ID": 2893
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5041,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan",
      "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1785699+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3763E142P397VM316085",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 316085,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1899,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02800",
      "ID": 2893
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3763,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart",
      "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9455104+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1986E23P197VM236267",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 236267,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1899,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02800",
      "ID": 2893
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1986,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan",
      "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9090228+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5047E100P130VM291467",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291467,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1899,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02800",
      "ID": 2893
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5047,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne",
      "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1205813+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234957",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234957,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1899,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02800",
      "ID": 2893
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1845,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette",
      "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4071547+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313655",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313655,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1899,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02800",
      "ID": 2893
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3061,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4047595+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1768E19P265VM288500",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 288500,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1899,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02800",
      "ID": 2893
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1768,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1375925+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225018",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225018,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1899,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02800",
      "ID": 2893
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1894,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Neil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.74103+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3815E98P134VM270856",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270856,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1899,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02800",
      "ID": 2893
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3815,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Park, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Park",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8260546+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265935",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265935,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1899,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02800",
      "ID": 2893
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2010,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil",
      "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4669147+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283542",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283542,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1899,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02800",
      "ID": 2893
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5057,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7124874+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2853E33P128VM251404",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251404,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1899,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02800",
      "ID": 2893
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Pentland",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4621214+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317939",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317939,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1899,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02800",
      "ID": 2893
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5009,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4500047+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254758",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254758,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1899,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02800",
      "ID": 2893
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3745,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis",
      "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2824659+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1870E225P478VM295560",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295560,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1899,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02800",
      "ID": 2893
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1870,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona",
      "DisplayName": "Shona Robison",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5174172+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2135E254P450VM234848",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234848,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1899,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02800",
      "ID": 2893
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2135,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Russell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4023466+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1895E232P431VM257365",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257365,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1899,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02800",
      "ID": 2893
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1895,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0530689+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228061",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 228061,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1899,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02800",
      "ID": 2893
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1839,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5826756+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2345E10P55VM292043",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 292043,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1899,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02800",
      "ID": 2893
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2345,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1534827+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2223E176P333VM310654",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 310654,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1899,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02800",
      "ID": 2893
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2223,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish",
      "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5802754+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2182E87P175VM245973",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 245973,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1899,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02800",
      "ID": 2893
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2182,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8667075+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298373",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298373,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1899,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02800",
      "ID": 2893
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5079,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew",
      "DisplayName": "Drew Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3429492+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234407",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234407,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1899,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02800",
      "ID": 2893
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1769,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3759507+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4014E14P26VM269926",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269926,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1899,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02800",
      "ID": 2893
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4014,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz",
      "DisplayName": "Liz Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5737914+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269156",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269156,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1899,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02800",
      "ID": 2893
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2215,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.3061002+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317155",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317155,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1899,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02800",
      "ID": 2893
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3806,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.1840682+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326143",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 326143,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1899,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02800",
      "ID": 2893
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5106,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin",
      "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5417269+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241071",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241071,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1899,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02800",
      "ID": 2893
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1848,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola",
      "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3948194+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2098E237P531VM289570",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289570,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1899,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02800",
      "ID": 2893
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2098,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Swinney",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4497488+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2674E247P401VM247722",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247722,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1899,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02800",
      "ID": 2893
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2674,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave",
      "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4256072+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5075E234P371VM284839",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 284839,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1899,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02800",
      "ID": 2893
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5075,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Torrance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0499446+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1793E151P362VM222419",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 222419,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1899,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02800",
      "ID": 2893
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1793,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean",
      "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1881395+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5078E245P7VM307181",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307181,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1899,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02800",
      "ID": 2893
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5078,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Walker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5907591+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1841E231P426VM240207",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 240207,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1899,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02800",
      "ID": 2893
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1841,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen",
      "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3494871+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283382",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283382,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1899,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02800",
      "ID": 2893
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4952,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.6982989+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1865E263P500VM232265",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232265,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1899,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02800",
      "ID": 2893
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1865,
      "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra",
      "DisplayName": "Sandra White",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.847284+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237831",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237831,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1899,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02800",
      "ID": 2893
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2610,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Wilson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2279539+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309325",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 309325,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1899,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 93,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02800",
      "ID": 2893
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4941,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza",
      "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3244394+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252683",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252683,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1894,
      "AgendaID": 2105,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Business Motion",
      "Reference": "S4M-02754",
      "ID": 12824
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1926,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian",
      "DisplayName": "Brian Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7491077+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2615E213P388VM258893",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258893,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1894,
      "AgendaID": 2105,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Business Motion",
      "Reference": "S4M-02754",
      "ID": 12824
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2615,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George",
      "DisplayName": "George Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3327596+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319847",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319847,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1894,
      "AgendaID": 2105,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Business Motion",
      "Reference": "S4M-02754",
      "ID": 12824
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4940,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare",
      "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.943943+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249532",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 249532,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1894,
      "AgendaID": 2105,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Business Motion",
      "Reference": "S4M-02754",
      "ID": 12824
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2641,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair",
      "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9309309+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1783E21P273VM227794",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227794,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1894,
      "AgendaID": 2105,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Business Motion",
      "Reference": "S4M-02754",
      "ID": 12824
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1783,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie",
      "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5659251+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2633E97P136VM280797",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280797,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1894,
      "AgendaID": 2105,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Business Motion",
      "Reference": "S4M-02754",
      "ID": 12824
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2633,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire",
      "DisplayName": "Claire Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7828063+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262703",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262703,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1894,
      "AgendaID": 2105,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Business Motion",
      "Reference": "S4M-02754",
      "ID": 12824
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2603,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6132314+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1759E91P115VM229788",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229788,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1894,
      "AgendaID": 2105,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Business Motion",
      "Reference": "S4M-02754",
      "ID": 12824
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia",
      "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0970575+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270134",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270134,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1894,
      "AgendaID": 2105,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Business Motion",
      "Reference": "S4M-02754",
      "ID": 12824
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3751,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5830229+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322665",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 322665,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1894,
      "AgendaID": 2105,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Business Motion",
      "Reference": "S4M-02754",
      "ID": 12824
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5109,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco",
      "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6984507+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5060E86P124VM294778",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 294778,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1894,
      "AgendaID": 2105,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Business Motion",
      "Reference": "S4M-02754",
      "ID": 12824
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5060,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1779124+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242906",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242906,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1894,
      "AgendaID": 2105,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Business Motion",
      "Reference": "S4M-02754",
      "ID": 12824
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1866,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah",
      "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0406367+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235198",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235198,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1894,
      "AgendaID": 2105,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Business Motion",
      "Reference": "S4M-02754",
      "ID": 12824
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1943,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic",
      "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4236073+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302353",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 302353,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1894,
      "AgendaID": 2105,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Business Motion",
      "Reference": "S4M-02754",
      "ID": 12824
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2595,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin",
      "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.520731+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244300",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244300,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1894,
      "AgendaID": 2105,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Business Motion",
      "Reference": "S4M-02754",
      "ID": 12824
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2103,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith",
      "DisplayName": "Keith Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5487201+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327149",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 327149,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1894,
      "AgendaID": 2105,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Business Motion",
      "Reference": "S4M-02754",
      "ID": 12824
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.8012539+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277042",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277042,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1894,
      "AgendaID": 2105,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Business Motion",
      "Reference": "S4M-02754",
      "ID": 12824
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6985773+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264287",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264287,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1894,
      "AgendaID": 2105,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Business Motion",
      "Reference": "S4M-02754",
      "ID": 12824
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2673,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick",
      "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1267899+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248731",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248731,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1894,
      "AgendaID": 2105,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Business Motion",
      "Reference": "S4M-02754",
      "ID": 12824
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2678,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson",
      "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6673828+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2123E27P233VM295777",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295777,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1894,
      "AgendaID": 2105,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Business Motion",
      "Reference": "S4M-02754",
      "ID": 12824
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2123,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm",
      "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5354441+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285207",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285207,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1894,
      "AgendaID": 2105,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Business Motion",
      "Reference": "S4M-02754",
      "ID": 12824
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3907,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3128554+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230684",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230684,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1894,
      "AgendaID": 2105,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Business Motion",
      "Reference": "S4M-02754",
      "ID": 12824
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1735,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela",
      "DisplayName": "Angela Constance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3407498+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243813",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 243813,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1894,
      "AgendaID": 2105,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Business Motion",
      "Reference": "S4M-02754",
      "ID": 12824
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1932,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce",
      "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3208301+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254893",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254893,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1894,
      "AgendaID": 2105,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Business Motion",
      "Reference": "S4M-02754",
      "ID": 12824
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1863,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna",
      "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2883197+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323756",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 323756,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1894,
      "AgendaID": 2105,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Business Motion",
      "Reference": "S4M-02754",
      "ID": 12824
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4976,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth",
      "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9705613+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5107E223P379VM291293",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291293,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1894,
      "AgendaID": 2105,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Business Motion",
      "Reference": "S4M-02754",
      "ID": 12824
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5107,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1127147+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3743E222P391VM265379",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265379,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1894,
      "AgendaID": 2105,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Business Motion",
      "Reference": "S4M-02754",
      "ID": 12824
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3743,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel",
      "DisplayName": "Nigel Don",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4366396+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262293",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262293,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1894,
      "AgendaID": 2105,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Business Motion",
      "Reference": "S4M-02754",
      "ID": 12824
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3771,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob",
      "DisplayName": "Bob Doris",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.5952453+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281943",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 281943,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1894,
      "AgendaID": 2105,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Business Motion",
      "Reference": "S4M-02754",
      "ID": 12824
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2826,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Dornan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.164455+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298183",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298183,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1894,
      "AgendaID": 2105,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Business Motion",
      "Reference": "S4M-02754",
      "ID": 12824
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3812,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia",
      "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1420695+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231249",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231249,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1894,
      "AgendaID": 2105,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Business Motion",
      "Reference": "S4M-02754",
      "ID": 12824
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1778,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen",
      "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.5868184+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4955E240P389VM285898",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285898,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1894,
      "AgendaID": 2105,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Business Motion",
      "Reference": "S4M-02754",
      "ID": 12824
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4955,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3492808+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219429",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 219429,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1894,
      "AgendaID": 2105,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Business Motion",
      "Reference": "S4M-02754",
      "ID": 12824
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1742,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle",
      "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.2984905+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238533",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 238533,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1894,
      "AgendaID": 2105,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Business Motion",
      "Reference": "S4M-02754",
      "ID": 12824
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1994,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus",
      "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4581986+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225186",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225186,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1894,
      "AgendaID": 2105,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Business Motion",
      "Reference": "S4M-02754",
      "ID": 12824
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1814,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda",
      "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7481615+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321795",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 321795,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1894,
      "AgendaID": 2105,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Business Motion",
      "Reference": "S4M-02754",
      "ID": 12824
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Fee",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4516933+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292866",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 292866,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1894,
      "AgendaID": 2105,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Business Motion",
      "Reference": "S4M-02754",
      "ID": 12824
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia",
      "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.561446+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227156",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227156,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1894,
      "AgendaID": 2105,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Business Motion",
      "Reference": "S4M-02754",
      "ID": 12824
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2702209+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5054E95P118VM312713",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 312713,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1894,
      "AgendaID": 2105,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Business Motion",
      "Reference": "S4M-02754",
      "ID": 12824
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5054,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1401554+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4947E152P361VM257750",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257750,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1894,
      "AgendaID": 2105,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Business Motion",
      "Reference": "S4M-02754",
      "ID": 12824
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4947,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Finnie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0760096+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271253",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271253,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1894,
      "AgendaID": 2105,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Business Motion",
      "Reference": "S4M-02754",
      "ID": 12824
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3901,
      "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe",
      "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0623054+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278080",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 278080,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1894,
      "AgendaID": 2105,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Business Motion",
      "Reference": "S4M-02754",
      "ID": 12824
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2394,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo",
      "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9861445+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2110E220P414VM287248",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 287248,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1894,
      "AgendaID": 2105,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Business Motion",
      "Reference": "S4M-02754",
      "ID": 12824
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth",
      "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8560107+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250567",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250567,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1894,
      "AgendaID": 2105,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Business Motion",
      "Reference": "S4M-02754",
      "ID": 12824
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2675,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob",
      "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1951288+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221031",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221031,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1894,
      "AgendaID": 2105,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Business Motion",
      "Reference": "S4M-02754",
      "ID": 12824
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1741,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel",
      "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6721023+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220214",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220214,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1894,
      "AgendaID": 2105,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Business Motion",
      "Reference": "S4M-02754",
      "ID": 12824
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1756,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine",
      "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3392586+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1860E104P150VM252373",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252373,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1894,
      "AgendaID": 2105,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Business Motion",
      "Reference": "S4M-02754",
      "ID": 12824
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1860,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda",
      "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7263861+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2033E20P141VM253849",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253849,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1894,
      "AgendaID": 2105,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Business Motion",
      "Reference": "S4M-02754",
      "ID": 12824
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2033,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain",
      "DisplayName": "Iain Gray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0235037+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324649",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324649,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1894,
      "AgendaID": 2105,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Business Motion",
      "Reference": "S4M-02754",
      "ID": 12824
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5042,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2320215+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259678",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 259678,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1894,
      "AgendaID": 2105,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Business Motion",
      "Reference": "S4M-02754",
      "ID": 12824
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick",
      "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6197943+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239363",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239363,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1894,
      "AgendaID": 2105,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Business Motion",
      "Reference": "S4M-02754",
      "ID": 12824
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2029,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh",
      "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7335905+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273758",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 273758,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1894,
      "AgendaID": 2105,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Business Motion",
      "Reference": "S4M-02754",
      "ID": 12824
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3758,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6344122+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304132",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 304132,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1894,
      "AgendaID": 2105,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Business Motion",
      "Reference": "S4M-02754",
      "ID": 12824
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4086,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Hume",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8510293+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221664",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221664,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1894,
      "AgendaID": 2105,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Business Motion",
      "Reference": "S4M-02754",
      "ID": 12824
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1773,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9424727+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1882E227P459VM241894",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241894,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1894,
      "AgendaID": 2105,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Business Motion",
      "Reference": "S4M-02754",
      "ID": 12824
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1882,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam",
      "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7846061+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223512",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223512,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1894,
      "AgendaID": 2105,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Business Motion",
      "Reference": "S4M-02754",
      "ID": 12824
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1893,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4616216+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307612",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307612,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1894,
      "AgendaID": 2105,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Business Motion",
      "Reference": "S4M-02754",
      "ID": 12824
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4934,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8373218+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272303",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 272303,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1894,
      "AgendaID": 2105,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Business Motion",
      "Reference": "S4M-02754",
      "ID": 12824
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4956,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Keir",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3239398+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244915",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244915,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1894,
      "AgendaID": 2105,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Business Motion",
      "Reference": "S4M-02754",
      "ID": 12824
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Kelly",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5840646+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315085",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315085,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1894,
      "AgendaID": 2105,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Business Motion",
      "Reference": "S4M-02754",
      "ID": 12824
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3129,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6734289+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247905",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247905,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1894,
      "AgendaID": 2105,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Business Motion",
      "Reference": "S4M-02754",
      "ID": 12824
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann",
      "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4334307+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4016E11P36VM274832",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274832,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1894,
      "AgendaID": 2105,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Business Motion",
      "Reference": "S4M-02754",
      "ID": 12824
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4016,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1236696+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255755",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255755,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1894,
      "AgendaID": 2105,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Business Motion",
      "Reference": "S4M-02754",
      "ID": 12824
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2180,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5555074+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4938E158P374VM277413",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277413,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1894,
      "AgendaID": 2105,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Business Motion",
      "Reference": "S4M-02754",
      "ID": 12824
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4938,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9523072+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2112E250P486VM253057",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253057,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1894,
      "AgendaID": 2105,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Business Motion",
      "Reference": "S4M-02754",
      "ID": 12824
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2112,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny",
      "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7649975+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4939E258P394VM276798",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276798,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1894,
      "AgendaID": 2105,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Business Motion",
      "Reference": "S4M-02754",
      "ID": 12824
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4939,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus",
      "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6815399+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325482",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 325482,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1894,
      "AgendaID": 2105,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Business Motion",
      "Reference": "S4M-02754",
      "ID": 12824
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5074,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon",
      "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5082932+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1828E3P10VM232878",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232878,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1894,
      "AgendaID": 2105,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Business Motion",
      "Reference": "S4M-02754",
      "ID": 12824
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1828,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo",
      "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8804986+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311457",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311457,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1894,
      "AgendaID": 2105,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Business Motion",
      "Reference": "S4M-02754",
      "ID": 12824
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4948,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike",
      "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8796419+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2117E90P107VM230366",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230366,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1894,
      "AgendaID": 2105,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Business Motion",
      "Reference": "S4M-02754",
      "ID": 12824
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2117,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis",
      "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3266325+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267395",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 267395,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1894,
      "AgendaID": 2105,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Business Motion",
      "Reference": "S4M-02754",
      "ID": 12824
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken",
      "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0179797+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313705",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313705,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1894,
      "AgendaID": 2105,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Business Motion",
      "Reference": "S4M-02754",
      "ID": 12824
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4966,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek",
      "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4069905+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3101E102P129VM295045",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295045,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1894,
      "AgendaID": 2105,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Business Motion",
      "Reference": "S4M-02754",
      "ID": 12824
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3101,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala",
      "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1898419+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319045",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319045,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1894,
      "AgendaID": 2105,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Business Motion",
      "Reference": "S4M-02754",
      "ID": 12824
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5034,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny",
      "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6900732+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306401",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306401,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1894,
      "AgendaID": 2105,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Business Motion",
      "Reference": "S4M-02754",
      "ID": 12824
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2159,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Martin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5504997+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5110E252P395VM311176",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311176,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1894,
      "AgendaID": 2105,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Business Motion",
      "Reference": "S4M-02754",
      "ID": 12824
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Mason",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.6089761+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268208",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 268208,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1894,
      "AgendaID": 2105,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Business Motion",
      "Reference": "S4M-02754",
      "ID": 12824
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2133,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2535005+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2876E141P433VM286365",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286365,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1894,
      "AgendaID": 2105,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Business Motion",
      "Reference": "S4M-02754",
      "ID": 12824
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2876,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5757633+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4951E147P368VM258568",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258568,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1894,
      "AgendaID": 2105,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Business Motion",
      "Reference": "S4M-02754",
      "ID": 12824
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4951,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan",
      "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3128623+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3896E175P307VM263846",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 263846,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1894,
      "AgendaID": 2105,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Business Motion",
      "Reference": "S4M-02754",
      "ID": 12824
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3896,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam",
      "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9130313+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308463",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 308463,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1894,
      "AgendaID": 2105,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Business Motion",
      "Reference": "S4M-02754",
      "ID": 12824
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0570093+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4964E143P375VM279704",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279704,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1894,
      "AgendaID": 2105,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Business Motion",
      "Reference": "S4M-02754",
      "ID": 12824
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4964,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5190632+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279630",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279630,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1894,
      "AgendaID": 2105,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Business Motion",
      "Reference": "S4M-02754",
      "ID": 12824
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3824,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5159068+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2066E22P91VM261073",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261073,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1894,
      "AgendaID": 2105,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Business Motion",
      "Reference": "S4M-02754",
      "ID": 12824
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2066,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.1106435+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299635",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 299635,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1894,
      "AgendaID": 2105,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Business Motion",
      "Reference": "S4M-02754",
      "ID": 12824
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7062127+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306650",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306650,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1894,
      "AgendaID": 2105,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Business Motion",
      "Reference": "S4M-02754",
      "ID": 12824
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina",
      "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5612071+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2487E146P369VM301144",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 301144,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1894,
      "AgendaID": 2105,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Business Motion",
      "Reference": "S4M-02754",
      "ID": 12824
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2487,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0356144+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223934",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223934,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1894,
      "AgendaID": 2105,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Business Motion",
      "Reference": "S4M-02754",
      "ID": 12824
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4848747+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237534",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237534,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1894,
      "AgendaID": 2105,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Business Motion",
      "Reference": "S4M-02754",
      "ID": 12824
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1961,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David",
      "DisplayName": "David McLetchie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2149699+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305466",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 305466,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1894,
      "AgendaID": 2105,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Business Motion",
      "Reference": "S4M-02754",
      "ID": 12824
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2134,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3252185+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320381",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 320381,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1894,
      "AgendaID": 2105,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Business Motion",
      "Reference": "S4M-02754",
      "ID": 12824
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5041,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan",
      "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1639578+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315997",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315997,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1894,
      "AgendaID": 2105,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Business Motion",
      "Reference": "S4M-02754",
      "ID": 12824
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3763,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart",
      "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9412953+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1986E23P197VM236670",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 236670,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1894,
      "AgendaID": 2105,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Business Motion",
      "Reference": "S4M-02754",
      "ID": 12824
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1986,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan",
      "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.935011+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5047E100P130VM289834",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289834,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1894,
      "AgendaID": 2105,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Business Motion",
      "Reference": "S4M-02754",
      "ID": 12824
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5047,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne",
      "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4610458+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234563",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234563,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1894,
      "AgendaID": 2105,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Business Motion",
      "Reference": "S4M-02754",
      "ID": 12824
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1845,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette",
      "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3896984+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313567",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313567,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1894,
      "AgendaID": 2105,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Business Motion",
      "Reference": "S4M-02754",
      "ID": 12824
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3061,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4009513+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1768E19P265VM289252",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289252,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1894,
      "AgendaID": 2105,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Business Motion",
      "Reference": "S4M-02754",
      "ID": 12824
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1768,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4292294+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225275",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225275,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1894,
      "AgendaID": 2105,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Business Motion",
      "Reference": "S4M-02754",
      "ID": 12824
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1894,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Neil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9623538+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3815E98P134VM270936",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270936,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1894,
      "AgendaID": 2105,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Business Motion",
      "Reference": "S4M-02754",
      "ID": 12824
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3815,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Park, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Park",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8354719+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265850",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265850,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1894,
      "AgendaID": 2105,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Business Motion",
      "Reference": "S4M-02754",
      "ID": 12824
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2010,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil",
      "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4632482+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283284",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283284,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1894,
      "AgendaID": 2105,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Business Motion",
      "Reference": "S4M-02754",
      "ID": 12824
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5057,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.6938506+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2853E33P128VM251508",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251508,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1894,
      "AgendaID": 2105,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Business Motion",
      "Reference": "S4M-02754",
      "ID": 12824
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Pentland",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4667144+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317602",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317602,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1894,
      "AgendaID": 2105,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Business Motion",
      "Reference": "S4M-02754",
      "ID": 12824
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5009,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4294974+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254285",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254285,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1894,
      "AgendaID": 2105,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Business Motion",
      "Reference": "S4M-02754",
      "ID": 12824
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3745,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis",
      "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2489663+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1870E225P478VM295694",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295694,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1894,
      "AgendaID": 2105,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Business Motion",
      "Reference": "S4M-02754",
      "ID": 12824
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1870,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona",
      "DisplayName": "Shona Robison",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5318462+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2135E254P450VM235411",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235411,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1894,
      "AgendaID": 2105,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Business Motion",
      "Reference": "S4M-02754",
      "ID": 12824
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2135,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Russell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6696036+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1895E232P431VM257605",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257605,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1894,
      "AgendaID": 2105,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Business Motion",
      "Reference": "S4M-02754",
      "ID": 12824
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1895,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0637222+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228528",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 228528,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1894,
      "AgendaID": 2105,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Business Motion",
      "Reference": "S4M-02754",
      "ID": 12824
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1839,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.8029886+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2345E10P55VM291646",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291646,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1894,
      "AgendaID": 2105,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Business Motion",
      "Reference": "S4M-02754",
      "ID": 12824
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2345,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1362477+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311054",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311054,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1894,
      "AgendaID": 2105,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Business Motion",
      "Reference": "S4M-02754",
      "ID": 12824
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2223,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish",
      "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.6034372+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246443",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 246443,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1894,
      "AgendaID": 2105,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Business Motion",
      "Reference": "S4M-02754",
      "ID": 12824
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2182,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1289375+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298126",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298126,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1894,
      "AgendaID": 2105,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Business Motion",
      "Reference": "S4M-02754",
      "ID": 12824
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5079,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew",
      "DisplayName": "Drew Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1393394+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234159",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234159,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1894,
      "AgendaID": 2105,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Business Motion",
      "Reference": "S4M-02754",
      "ID": 12824
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1769,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1691808+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274619",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274619,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1894,
      "AgendaID": 2105,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Business Motion",
      "Reference": "S4M-02754",
      "ID": 12824
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4014,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz",
      "DisplayName": "Liz Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1144411+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269562",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269562,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1894,
      "AgendaID": 2105,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Business Motion",
      "Reference": "S4M-02754",
      "ID": 12824
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2215,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5529731+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317396",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317396,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1894,
      "AgendaID": 2105,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Business Motion",
      "Reference": "S4M-02754",
      "ID": 12824
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3806,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4203173+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326348",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 326348,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1894,
      "AgendaID": 2105,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Business Motion",
      "Reference": "S4M-02754",
      "ID": 12824
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5106,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin",
      "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7545988+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241234",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241234,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1894,
      "AgendaID": 2105,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Business Motion",
      "Reference": "S4M-02754",
      "ID": 12824
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1848,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola",
      "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7487823+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2098E237P531VM289659",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289659,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1894,
      "AgendaID": 2105,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Business Motion",
      "Reference": "S4M-02754",
      "ID": 12824
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2098,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Swinney",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4534739+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2674E247P401VM247825",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247825,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1894,
      "AgendaID": 2105,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Business Motion",
      "Reference": "S4M-02754",
      "ID": 12824
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2674,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave",
      "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4300368+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5075E234P371VM287426",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 287426,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1894,
      "AgendaID": 2105,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Business Motion",
      "Reference": "S4M-02754",
      "ID": 12824
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5075,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Torrance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8636887+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1793E151P362VM222519",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 222519,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1894,
      "AgendaID": 2105,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Business Motion",
      "Reference": "S4M-02754",
      "ID": 12824
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1793,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean",
      "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1924401+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5078E245P7VM307055",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307055,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1894,
      "AgendaID": 2105,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Business Motion",
      "Reference": "S4M-02754",
      "ID": 12824
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5078,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Walker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5853513+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1841E231P426VM239890",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239890,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1894,
      "AgendaID": 2105,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Business Motion",
      "Reference": "S4M-02754",
      "ID": 12824
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1841,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen",
      "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7637351+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283483",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283483,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1894,
      "AgendaID": 2105,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Business Motion",
      "Reference": "S4M-02754",
      "ID": 12824
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4952,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7098481+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1865E263P500VM231866",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231866,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1894,
      "AgendaID": 2105,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Business Motion",
      "Reference": "S4M-02754",
      "ID": 12824
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1865,
      "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra",
      "DisplayName": "Sandra White",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.618911+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237728",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237728,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1894,
      "AgendaID": 2105,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Business Motion",
      "Reference": "S4M-02754",
      "ID": 12824
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2610,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Wilson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2232695+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309227",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 309227,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1894,
      "AgendaID": 2105,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 2,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Business Motion",
      "Reference": "S4M-02754",
      "ID": 12824
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4941,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza",
      "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3202432+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1926E229P470VM253105",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253105,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1892,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687.1",
      "ID": 2800
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1926,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian",
      "DisplayName": "Brian Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7669919+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2615E213P388VM259464",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 259464,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1892,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687.1",
      "ID": 2800
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2615,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George",
      "DisplayName": "George Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6102294+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4940E159P373VM317822",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317822,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1892,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687.1",
      "ID": 2800
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4940,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare",
      "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4388564+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2641E256P403VM250168",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250168,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1892,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687.1",
      "ID": 2800
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2641,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair",
      "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9663577+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1783E21P273VM228453",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 228453,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1892,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687.1",
      "ID": 2800
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1783,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie",
      "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.7997295+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2633E97P136VM281147",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 281147,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1892,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687.1",
      "ID": 2800
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2633,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire",
      "DisplayName": "Claire Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.8079902+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2603E89P148VM263111",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 263111,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1892,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687.1",
      "ID": 2800
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2603,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6372487+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1759E91P115VM227540",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227540,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1892,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687.1",
      "ID": 2800
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia",
      "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5545425+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270717",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270717,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1892,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687.1",
      "ID": 2800
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3751,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8200688+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322456",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 322456,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1892,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687.1",
      "ID": 2800
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5109,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco",
      "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6894099+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5060E86P124VM297336",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 297336,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1892,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687.1",
      "ID": 2800
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5060,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.0955696+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242697",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242697,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1892,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687.1",
      "ID": 2800
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1866,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah",
      "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0317169+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1943E145P367VM236984",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 236984,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1892,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687.1",
      "ID": 2800
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1943,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic",
      "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9487653+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2595E12P30VM301669",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 301669,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1892,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687.1",
      "ID": 2800
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2595,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin",
      "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.2724034+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2103E244P421VM262007",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262007,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1892,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687.1",
      "ID": 2800
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2103,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith",
      "DisplayName": "Keith Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3876063+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5108E221P387VM326575",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 326575,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1892,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687.1",
      "ID": 2800
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7706376+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277609",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277609,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1892,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687.1",
      "ID": 2800
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9606612+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264998",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264998,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1892,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687.1",
      "ID": 2800
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2673,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick",
      "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1637412+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2678E11P28VM249330",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 249330,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1892,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687.1",
      "ID": 2800
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2678,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson",
      "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9219354+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2123E27P233VM291158",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291158,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1892,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687.1",
      "ID": 2800
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2123,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm",
      "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7881841+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285462",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285462,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1892,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687.1",
      "ID": 2800
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3907,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3302951+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1735E248P405VM231400",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231400,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1892,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687.1",
      "ID": 2800
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1735,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela",
      "DisplayName": "Angela Constance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.5985466+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243174",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 243174,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1892,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687.1",
      "ID": 2800
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1932,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce",
      "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0573422+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1863E238P523VM253980",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253980,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1892,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687.1",
      "ID": 2800
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1863,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna",
      "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0293463+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4976E20P31VM321142",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 321142,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1892,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687.1",
      "ID": 2800
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4976,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth",
      "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.2040777+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5107E223P379VM292438",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 292438,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1892,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687.1",
      "ID": 2800
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5107,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5338068+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3743E222P391VM273161",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 273161,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1892,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687.1",
      "ID": 2800
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3743,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel",
      "DisplayName": "Nigel Don",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.37221+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262858",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262858,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1892,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687.1",
      "ID": 2800
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3771,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob",
      "DisplayName": "Bob Doris",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6260118+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281746",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 281746,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1892,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687.1",
      "ID": 2800
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2826,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Dornan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1558763+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298533",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298533,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1892,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687.1",
      "ID": 2800
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3812,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia",
      "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3502224+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1778E28P260VM230621",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230621,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1892,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687.1",
      "ID": 2800
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1778,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen",
      "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3382769+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4955E240P389VM287189",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 287189,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1892,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687.1",
      "ID": 2800
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4955,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.6230008+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219691",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 219691,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1892,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687.1",
      "ID": 2800
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1742,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle",
      "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.310345+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1994E257P537VM239117",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239117,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1892,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687.1",
      "ID": 2800
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1994,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus",
      "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.496021+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1814E269P519VM226285",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 226285,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1892,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687.1",
      "ID": 2800
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1814,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda",
      "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2190049+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5059E85P123VM322004",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 322004,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1892,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687.1",
      "ID": 2800
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Fee",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4671193+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292667",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 292667,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1892,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687.1",
      "ID": 2800
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia",
      "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5526694+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227718",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227718,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1892,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687.1",
      "ID": 2800
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5626806+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5054E95P118VM304392",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 304392,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1892,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687.1",
      "ID": 2800
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5054,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.0362804+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4947E152P361VM257958",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257958,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1892,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687.1",
      "ID": 2800
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4947,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Finnie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0852234+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271695",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271695,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1892,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687.1",
      "ID": 2800
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3901,
      "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe",
      "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0874899+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2394E15P47VM274326",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274326,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1892,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687.1",
      "ID": 2800
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2394,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo",
      "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.0957641+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2110E220P414VM266483",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 266483,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1892,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687.1",
      "ID": 2800
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth",
      "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.7430555+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250775",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250775,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1892,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687.1",
      "ID": 2800
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2675,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob",
      "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.213005+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221241",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221241,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1892,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687.1",
      "ID": 2800
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1741,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel",
      "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9208414+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1756E218P467VM226373",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 226373,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1892,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687.1",
      "ID": 2800
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1756,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine",
      "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2285503+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1860E104P150VM239793",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239793,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1892,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687.1",
      "ID": 2800
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1860,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda",
      "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7591525+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2033E20P141VM253184",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253184,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1892,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687.1",
      "ID": 2800
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2033,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain",
      "DisplayName": "Iain Gray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7702876+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324405",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324405,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1892,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687.1",
      "ID": 2800
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5042,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2153198+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2892E76P97VM260898",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 260898,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1892,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687.1",
      "ID": 2800
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick",
      "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.1027297+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2029E24P170VM246107",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 246107,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1892,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687.1",
      "ID": 2800
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2029,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh",
      "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.872506+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3758E268P409VM276193",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276193,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1892,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687.1",
      "ID": 2800
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3758,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.4145057+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4086E128P311VM303199",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 303199,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1892,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687.1",
      "ID": 2800
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4086,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Hume",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8044824+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1773E242P494VM222298",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 222298,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1892,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687.1",
      "ID": 2800
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1773,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1827257+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1882E227P459VM245583",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 245583,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1892,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687.1",
      "ID": 2800
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1882,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam",
      "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8496933+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1893E16P69VM224716",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 224716,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1892,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687.1",
      "ID": 2800
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1893,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7168598+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4934E77P103VM308116",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 308116,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1892,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687.1",
      "ID": 2800
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4934,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8654156+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272512",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 272512,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1892,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687.1",
      "ID": 2800
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4956,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Keir",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.338596+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244706",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244706,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1892,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687.1",
      "ID": 2800
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Kelly",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.574764+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3129E261P419VM314725",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 314725,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1892,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687.1",
      "ID": 2800
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3129,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6528039+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2080E36P220VM252506",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252506,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1892,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687.1",
      "ID": 2800
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann",
      "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7320718+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4016E11P36VM275610",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 275610,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1892,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687.1",
      "ID": 2800
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4016,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.3829387+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2180E246P463VM257102",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257102,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1892,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687.1",
      "ID": 2800
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2180,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.8233891+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4938E158P374VM282882",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 282882,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1892,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687.1",
      "ID": 2800
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4938,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.4383913+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2112E250P486VM254094",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254094,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1892,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687.1",
      "ID": 2800
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2112,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny",
      "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0342439+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4939E258P394VM278784",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 278784,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1892,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687.1",
      "ID": 2800
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4939,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus",
      "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2341206+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5074E251P385VM324880",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324880,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1892,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687.1",
      "ID": 2800
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5074,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon",
      "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2417762+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1828E3P10VM231975",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231975,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1892,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687.1",
      "ID": 2800
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1828,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo",
      "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6238353+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4948E153P363VM312115",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 312115,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1892,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687.1",
      "ID": 2800
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4948,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike",
      "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.9143674+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2117E90P107VM233103",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 233103,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1892,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687.1",
      "ID": 2800
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2117,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis",
      "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.896978+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267592",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 267592,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1892,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687.1",
      "ID": 2800
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken",
      "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0265337+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313045",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313045,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1892,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687.1",
      "ID": 2800
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4966,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek",
      "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1612587+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3101E102P129VM294383",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 294383,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1892,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687.1",
      "ID": 2800
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3101,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala",
      "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1359726+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319253",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319253,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1892,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687.1",
      "ID": 2800
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5034,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny",
      "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9120917+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2159E25P205VM305789",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 305789,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1892,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687.1",
      "ID": 2800
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2159,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Martin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3454187+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5110E252P395VM310367",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 310367,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1892,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687.1",
      "ID": 2800
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Mason",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5674563+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268012",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 268012,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1892,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687.1",
      "ID": 2800
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2133,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0521824+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2876E141P433VM293043",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 293043,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1892,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687.1",
      "ID": 2800
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2876,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5691705+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4951E147P368VM271437",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271437,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1892,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687.1",
      "ID": 2800
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4951,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan",
      "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.075774+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3896E175P307VM269409",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269409,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1892,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687.1",
      "ID": 2800
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3896,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam",
      "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5462998+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5080E110P121VM307228",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307228,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1892,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687.1",
      "ID": 2800
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8201535+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4964E143P375VM280265",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280265,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1892,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687.1",
      "ID": 2800
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4964,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.753233+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3824E84P113VM281271",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 281271,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1892,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687.1",
      "ID": 2800
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3824,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.127642+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2066E22P91VM245182",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 245182,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1892,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687.1",
      "ID": 2800
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2066,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.6077988+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299284",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 299284,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1892,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687.1",
      "ID": 2800
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.6908505+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3759E260P411VM301786",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 301786,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1892,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687.1",
      "ID": 2800
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina",
      "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.2831793+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300485",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 300485,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1892,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687.1",
      "ID": 2800
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2487,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0002105+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1775E215P453VM224298",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 224298,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1892,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687.1",
      "ID": 2800
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.6928791+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237962",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237962,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1892,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687.1",
      "ID": 2800
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1961,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David",
      "DisplayName": "David McLetchie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.233608+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2134E34P201VM297554",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 297554,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1892,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687.1",
      "ID": 2800
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2134,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1051874+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320017",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 320017,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1892,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687.1",
      "ID": 2800
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5041,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan",
      "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9578199+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315356",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315356,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1892,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687.1",
      "ID": 2800
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3763,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart",
      "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9084488+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1986E23P197VM237237",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237237,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1892,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687.1",
      "ID": 2800
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1986,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan",
      "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.1955752+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5047E100P130VM292577",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 292577,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1892,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687.1",
      "ID": 2800
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5047,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne",
      "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5487909+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1845E17P40VM233968",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 233968,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1892,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687.1",
      "ID": 2800
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1845,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette",
      "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1541501+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3061E19P43VM311637",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311637,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1892,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687.1",
      "ID": 2800
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3061,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.887744+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1768E19P265VM261300",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261300,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1892,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687.1",
      "ID": 2800
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1768,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3514375+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225693",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225693,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1892,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687.1",
      "ID": 2800
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1894,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Neil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9863157+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3815E98P134VM271008",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271008,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1892,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687.1",
      "ID": 2800
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3815,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Park, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Park",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8385582+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265561",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265561,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1892,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687.1",
      "ID": 2800
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2010,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil",
      "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4444782+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283955",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283955,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1892,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687.1",
      "ID": 2800
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5057,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7307038+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2853E33P128VM258710",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258710,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1892,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687.1",
      "ID": 2800
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Pentland",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3193008+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317240",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317240,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1892,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687.1",
      "ID": 2800
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5009,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.409859+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3745E233P381VM256130",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 256130,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1892,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687.1",
      "ID": 2800
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3745,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis",
      "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5719033+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1870E225P478VM293357",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 293357,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1892,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687.1",
      "ID": 2800
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1870,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona",
      "DisplayName": "Shona Robison",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8415263+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2135E254P450VM235980",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235980,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1892,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687.1",
      "ID": 2800
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2135,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Russell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.7012138+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1895E232P431VM255993",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255993,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1892,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687.1",
      "ID": 2800
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1895,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5657626+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1839E21P87VM229352",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229352,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1892,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687.1",
      "ID": 2800
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1839,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0780215+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2345E10P55VM288402",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 288402,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1892,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687.1",
      "ID": 2800
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2345,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1333032+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2223E176P333VM310537",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 310537,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1892,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687.1",
      "ID": 2800
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2223,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish",
      "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5751593+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2182E87P175VM247109",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247109,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1892,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687.1",
      "ID": 2800
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2182,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1674518+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298705",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298705,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1892,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687.1",
      "ID": 2800
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5079,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew",
      "DisplayName": "Drew Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3687011+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1769E32P285VM235823",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235823,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1892,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687.1",
      "ID": 2800
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1769,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6945023+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4014E14P26VM275340",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 275340,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1892,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687.1",
      "ID": 2800
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4014,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz",
      "DisplayName": "Liz Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.3658793+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2215E224P447VM270068",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270068,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1892,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687.1",
      "ID": 2800
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2215,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5801692+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3806E103P127VM316884",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 316884,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1892,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687.1",
      "ID": 2800
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3806,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.167584+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326104",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 326104,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1892,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687.1",
      "ID": 2800
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5106,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin",
      "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5400382+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241443",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241443,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1892,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687.1",
      "ID": 2800
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1848,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola",
      "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7581858+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2098E237P531VM288683",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 288683,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1892,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687.1",
      "ID": 2800
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2098,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Swinney",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1539165+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248232",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248232,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1892,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687.1",
      "ID": 2800
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2674,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave",
      "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6370081+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5075E234P371VM290065",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 290065,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1892,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687.1",
      "ID": 2800
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5075,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Torrance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4712683+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1793E151P362VM222784",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 222784,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1892,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687.1",
      "ID": 2800
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1793,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean",
      "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.2045657+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5078E245P7VM306898",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306898,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1892,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687.1",
      "ID": 2800
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5078,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Walker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5783638+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1841E231P426VM240832",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 240832,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1892,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687.1",
      "ID": 2800
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1841,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen",
      "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3842086+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4952E148P370VM284103",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 284103,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1892,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687.1",
      "ID": 2800
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4952,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7431315+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1865E263P500VM231054",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231054,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1892,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687.1",
      "ID": 2800
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1865,
      "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra",
      "DisplayName": "Sandra White",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3636368+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2610E160P413VM246754",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 246754,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1892,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687.1",
      "ID": 2800
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2610,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Wilson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1519891+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4941E150P382VM308874",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 308874,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1892,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 43,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687.1",
      "ID": 2800
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4941,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza",
      "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0817986+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1926E229P470VM253106",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253106,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1893,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 44,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687",
      "ID": 2784
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1926,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian",
      "DisplayName": "Brian Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.767033+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2615E213P388VM259465",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 259465,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1893,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 44,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687",
      "ID": 2784
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2615,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George",
      "DisplayName": "George Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6102702+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4940E159P373VM317821",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317821,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1893,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 44,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687",
      "ID": 2784
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4940,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare",
      "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4388139+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2641E256P403VM250167",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250167,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1893,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 44,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687",
      "ID": 2784
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2641,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair",
      "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9663171+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1783E21P273VM228454",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 228454,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1893,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 44,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687",
      "ID": 2784
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1783,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie",
      "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.7997719+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2633E97P136VM281148",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 281148,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1893,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 44,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687",
      "ID": 2784
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2633,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire",
      "DisplayName": "Claire Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.80803+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2603E89P148VM263112",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 263112,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1893,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 44,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687",
      "ID": 2784
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2603,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6372901+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1759E91P115VM227541",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227541,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1893,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 44,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687",
      "ID": 2784
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia",
      "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5545829+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270716",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270716,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1893,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 44,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687",
      "ID": 2784
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3751,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8200268+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322457",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 322457,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1893,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 44,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687",
      "ID": 2784
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5109,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco",
      "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6894514+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5060E86P124VM297337",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 297337,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1893,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 44,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687",
      "ID": 2784
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5060,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.0956112+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242698",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242698,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1893,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 44,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687",
      "ID": 2784
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1866,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah",
      "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.031757+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1943E145P367VM236983",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 236983,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1893,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 44,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687",
      "ID": 2784
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1943,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic",
      "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9487251+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2595E12P30VM301670",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 301670,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1893,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 44,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687",
      "ID": 2784
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2595,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin",
      "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.2724439+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2103E244P421VM262006",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262006,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1893,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 44,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687",
      "ID": 2784
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2103,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith",
      "DisplayName": "Keith Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3875651+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5108E221P387VM326576",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 326576,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1893,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 44,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687",
      "ID": 2784
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7706783+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277610",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277610,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1893,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 44,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687",
      "ID": 2784
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.960701+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264997",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264997,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1893,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 44,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687",
      "ID": 2784
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2673,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick",
      "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1637004+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2678E11P28VM249329",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 249329,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1893,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 44,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687",
      "ID": 2784
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2678,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson",
      "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9218935+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2123E27P233VM291157",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291157,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1893,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 44,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687",
      "ID": 2784
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2123,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm",
      "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7881425+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285463",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285463,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1893,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 44,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687",
      "ID": 2784
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3907,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3303373+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1735E248P405VM231401",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231401,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1893,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 44,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687",
      "ID": 2784
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1735,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela",
      "DisplayName": "Angela Constance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.5985873+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243173",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 243173,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1893,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 44,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687",
      "ID": 2784
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1932,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce",
      "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0572792+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1863E238P523VM253979",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253979,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1893,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 44,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687",
      "ID": 2784
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1863,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna",
      "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0293055+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4976E20P31VM321143",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 321143,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1893,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 44,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687",
      "ID": 2784
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4976,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth",
      "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.2041188+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5107E223P379VM292435",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 292435,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1893,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 44,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687",
      "ID": 2784
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5107,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5336648+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3743E222P391VM273162",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 273162,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1893,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 44,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687",
      "ID": 2784
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3743,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel",
      "DisplayName": "Nigel Don",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3722514+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262860",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262860,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1893,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 44,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687",
      "ID": 2784
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3771,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob",
      "DisplayName": "Bob Doris",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.626094+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281745",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 281745,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1893,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 44,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687",
      "ID": 2784
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2826,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Dornan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1558364+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298534",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298534,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1893,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 44,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687",
      "ID": 2784
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3812,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia",
      "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.350263+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1778E28P260VM230620",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230620,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1893,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 44,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687",
      "ID": 2784
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1778,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen",
      "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3382363+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4955E240P389VM287188",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 287188,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1893,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 44,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687",
      "ID": 2784
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4955,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.6229418+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219692",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 219692,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1893,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 44,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687",
      "ID": 2784
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1742,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle",
      "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3103867+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1994E257P537VM239116",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239116,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1893,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 44,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687",
      "ID": 2784
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1994,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus",
      "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4959798+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1814E269P519VM226284",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 226284,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1893,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 44,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687",
      "ID": 2784
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1814,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda",
      "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2189621+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5059E85P123VM322003",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 322003,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1893,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 44,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687",
      "ID": 2784
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Fee",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4670786+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292666",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 292666,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1893,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 44,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687",
      "ID": 2784
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia",
      "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5526282+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227719",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227719,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1893,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 44,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687",
      "ID": 2784
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5627214+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5054E95P118VM304393",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 304393,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1893,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 44,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687",
      "ID": 2784
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5054,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.0363211+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4947E152P361VM257959",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257959,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1893,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 44,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687",
      "ID": 2784
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4947,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Finnie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0852638+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271694",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271694,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1893,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 44,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687",
      "ID": 2784
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3901,
      "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe",
      "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0874491+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2394E15P47VM274325",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274325,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1893,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 44,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687",
      "ID": 2784
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2394,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo",
      "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.095723+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2110E220P414VM266484",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 266484,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1893,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 44,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687",
      "ID": 2784
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth",
      "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.7431171+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250776",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250776,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1893,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 44,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687",
      "ID": 2784
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2675,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob",
      "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.2130448+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221242",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221242,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1893,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 44,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687",
      "ID": 2784
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1741,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel",
      "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9208825+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1756E218P467VM226372",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 226372,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1893,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 44,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687",
      "ID": 2784
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1756,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine",
      "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2285089+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1860E104P150VM239794",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239794,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1893,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 44,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687",
      "ID": 2784
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1860,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda",
      "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7591934+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2033E20P141VM253183",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253183,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1893,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 44,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687",
      "ID": 2784
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2033,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain",
      "DisplayName": "Iain Gray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7702469+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324404",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324404,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1893,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 44,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687",
      "ID": 2784
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5042,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2152789+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2892E76P97VM260897",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 260897,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1893,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 44,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687",
      "ID": 2784
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick",
      "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.1026892+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2029E24P170VM246108",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 246108,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1893,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 44,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687",
      "ID": 2784
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2029,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh",
      "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8725676+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3758E268P409VM276192",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276192,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1893,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 44,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687",
      "ID": 2784
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3758,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.4144633+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4086E128P311VM303198",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 303198,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1893,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 44,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687",
      "ID": 2784
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4086,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Hume",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8044265+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1773E242P494VM222297",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 222297,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1893,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 44,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687",
      "ID": 2784
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1773,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1826831+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1882E227P459VM245582",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 245582,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1893,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 44,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687",
      "ID": 2784
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1882,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam",
      "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8496525+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1893E16P69VM224715",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 224715,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1893,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 44,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687",
      "ID": 2784
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1893,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7168191+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4934E77P103VM308117",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 308117,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1893,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 44,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687",
      "ID": 2784
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4934,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8654582+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272513",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 272513,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1893,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 44,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687",
      "ID": 2784
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4956,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Keir",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3386366+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244707",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244707,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1893,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 44,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687",
      "ID": 2784
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Kelly",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.574822+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3129E261P419VM314726",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 314726,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1893,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 44,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687",
      "ID": 2784
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3129,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6528448+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2080E36P220VM252505",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252505,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1893,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 44,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687",
      "ID": 2784
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann",
      "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7320312+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4016E11P36VM275611",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 275611,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1893,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 44,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687",
      "ID": 2784
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4016,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.3829792+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2180E246P463VM257101",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257101,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1893,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 44,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687",
      "ID": 2784
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2180,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.8233482+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4938E158P374VM282881",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 282881,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1893,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 44,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687",
      "ID": 2784
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4938,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.4383508+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2112E250P486VM254095",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254095,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1893,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 44,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687",
      "ID": 2784
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2112,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny",
      "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0342848+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4939E258P394VM278782",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 278782,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1893,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 44,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687",
      "ID": 2784
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4939,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus",
      "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2340327+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5074E251P385VM324881",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324881,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1893,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 44,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687",
      "ID": 2784
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5074,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon",
      "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2418176+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1828E3P10VM231976",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231976,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1893,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 44,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687",
      "ID": 2784
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1828,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo",
      "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6238755+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4948E153P363VM312116",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 312116,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1893,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 44,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687",
      "ID": 2784
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4948,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike",
      "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.9144082+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2117E90P107VM233102",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 233102,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1893,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 44,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687",
      "ID": 2784
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2117,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis",
      "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8969371+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267593",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 267593,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1893,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 44,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687",
      "ID": 2784
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken",
      "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0265753+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313044",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313044,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1893,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 44,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687",
      "ID": 2784
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4966,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek",
      "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1612173+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3101E102P129VM294382",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 294382,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1893,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 44,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687",
      "ID": 2784
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3101,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala",
      "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1359316+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319252",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319252,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1893,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 44,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687",
      "ID": 2784
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5034,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny",
      "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.912049+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2159E25P205VM305788",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 305788,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1893,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 44,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687",
      "ID": 2784
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2159,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Martin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3453756+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5110E252P395VM310366",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 310366,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1893,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 44,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687",
      "ID": 2784
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Mason",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5674155+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268011",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 268011,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1893,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 44,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687",
      "ID": 2784
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2133,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0521411+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2876E141P433VM293044",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 293044,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1893,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 44,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687",
      "ID": 2784
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2876,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5692112+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4951E147P368VM271436",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271436,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1893,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 44,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687",
      "ID": 2784
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4951,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan",
      "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0757328+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3896E175P307VM269407",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269407,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1893,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 44,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687",
      "ID": 2784
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3896,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam",
      "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5462177+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5080E110P121VM307229",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307229,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1893,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 44,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687",
      "ID": 2784
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8202148+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4964E143P375VM280574",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280574,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1893,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 44,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687",
      "ID": 2784
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4964,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7730732+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3824E84P113VM281270",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 281270,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1893,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 44,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687",
      "ID": 2784
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3824,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.127601+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2066E22P91VM245181",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 245181,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1893,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 44,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687",
      "ID": 2784
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2066,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.6077546+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299283",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 299283,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1893,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 44,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687",
      "ID": 2784
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.6907905+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3759E260P411VM301787",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 301787,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1893,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 44,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687",
      "ID": 2784
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina",
      "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.2832192+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300484",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 300484,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1893,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 44,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687",
      "ID": 2784
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2487,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0001697+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1775E215P453VM224299",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 224299,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1893,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 44,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687",
      "ID": 2784
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.6929202+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237963",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237963,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1893,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 44,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687",
      "ID": 2784
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1961,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David",
      "DisplayName": "David McLetchie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2336486+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2134E34P201VM297555",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 297555,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1893,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 44,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687",
      "ID": 2784
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2134,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1052278+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320018",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 320018,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1893,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 44,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687",
      "ID": 2784
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5041,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan",
      "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9578606+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315355",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315355,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1893,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 44,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687",
      "ID": 2784
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3763,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart",
      "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9084079+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1986E23P197VM237238",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237238,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1893,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 44,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687",
      "ID": 2784
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1986,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan",
      "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.1956155+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5047E100P130VM292576",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 292576,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1893,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 44,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687",
      "ID": 2784
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5047,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne",
      "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5487507+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1845E17P40VM233967",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 233967,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1893,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 44,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687",
      "ID": 2784
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1845,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette",
      "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1541097+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3061E19P43VM311636",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311636,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1893,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 44,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687",
      "ID": 2784
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3061,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8877029+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1768E19P265VM261301",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261301,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1893,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 44,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687",
      "ID": 2784
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1768,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3514781+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225694",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225694,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1893,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 44,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687",
      "ID": 2784
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1894,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Neil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9863559+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3815E98P134VM271009",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271009,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1893,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 44,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687",
      "ID": 2784
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3815,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Park, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Park",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.838598+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265560",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265560,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1893,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 44,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687",
      "ID": 2784
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2010,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil",
      "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4444375+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283953",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283953,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1893,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 44,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687",
      "ID": 2784
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5057,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7306215+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2853E33P128VM258711",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258711,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1893,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 44,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687",
      "ID": 2784
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Pentland",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3193423+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317241",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317241,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1893,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 44,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687",
      "ID": 2784
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5009,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4099219+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3745E233P381VM256129",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 256129,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1893,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 44,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687",
      "ID": 2784
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3745,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis",
      "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5718629+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1870E225P478VM293358",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 293358,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1893,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 44,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687",
      "ID": 2784
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1870,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona",
      "DisplayName": "Shona Robison",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8415674+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2135E254P450VM235981",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235981,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1893,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 44,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687",
      "ID": 2784
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2135,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Russell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.7012545+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1895E232P431VM255994",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255994,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1893,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 44,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687",
      "ID": 2784
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1895,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.565804+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1839E21P87VM229353",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229353,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1893,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 44,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687",
      "ID": 2784
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1839,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0780634+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2345E10P55VM288401",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 288401,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1893,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 44,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687",
      "ID": 2784
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2345,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1332626+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2223E176P333VM310538",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 310538,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1893,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 44,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687",
      "ID": 2784
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2223,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish",
      "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5751999+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2182E87P175VM247110",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247110,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1893,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 44,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687",
      "ID": 2784
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2182,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1674926+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298704",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298704,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1893,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 44,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687",
      "ID": 2784
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5079,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew",
      "DisplayName": "Drew Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3686609+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1769E32P285VM235822",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235822,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1893,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 44,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687",
      "ID": 2784
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1769,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6944623+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4014E14P26VM275342",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 275342,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1893,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 44,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687",
      "ID": 2784
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4014,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz",
      "DisplayName": "Liz Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.365961+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2215E224P447VM270069",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270069,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1893,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 44,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687",
      "ID": 2784
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2215,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.580211+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3806E103P127VM316885",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 316885,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1893,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 44,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687",
      "ID": 2784
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3806,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.1676239+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326103",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 326103,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1893,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 44,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687",
      "ID": 2784
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5106,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin",
      "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5399976+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241444",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241444,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1893,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 44,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687",
      "ID": 2784
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1848,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola",
      "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7582273+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2098E237P531VM288684",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 288684,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1893,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 44,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687",
      "ID": 2784
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2098,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Swinney",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.153977+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248233",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248233,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1893,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 44,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687",
      "ID": 2784
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2674,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave",
      "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6370491+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5075E234P371VM290068",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 290068,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1893,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 44,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687",
      "ID": 2784
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5075,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Torrance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4713912+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1793E151P362VM222785",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 222785,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1893,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 44,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687",
      "ID": 2784
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1793,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean",
      "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.2046064+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5078E245P7VM306897",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306897,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1893,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 44,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687",
      "ID": 2784
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5078,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Walker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5783197+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1841E231P426VM240831",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 240831,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1893,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 44,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687",
      "ID": 2784
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1841,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen",
      "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3841465+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4952E148P370VM284104",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 284104,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1893,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 44,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687",
      "ID": 2784
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4952,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7431723+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1865E263P500VM231053",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231053,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1893,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 44,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687",
      "ID": 2784
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1865,
      "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra",
      "DisplayName": "Sandra White",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3635964+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2610E160P413VM246753",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 246753,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1893,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 44,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687",
      "ID": 2784
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2610,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Wilson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1519476+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4941E150P382VM308873",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 308873,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1893,
      "AgendaID": 2420,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 44,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Localism",
      "Reference": "S4M-02687",
      "ID": 2784
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4941,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza",
      "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0817349+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252302",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252302,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1890,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639.3",
      "ID": 2747
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1926,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian",
      "DisplayName": "Brian Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7232837+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2615E213P388VM258828",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258828,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1890,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639.3",
      "ID": 2747
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2615,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George",
      "DisplayName": "George Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3296537+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319900",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319900,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1890,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639.3",
      "ID": 2747
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4940,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare",
      "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9462304+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249671",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 249671,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1890,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639.3",
      "ID": 2747
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2641,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair",
      "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9448377+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1783E21P273VM227409",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227409,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1890,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639.3",
      "ID": 2747
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1783,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie",
      "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5489036+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2633E97P136VM280404",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280404,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1890,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639.3",
      "ID": 2747
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2633,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire",
      "DisplayName": "Claire Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7655036+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262467",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262467,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1890,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639.3",
      "ID": 2747
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2603,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6032027+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1759E91P115VM229253",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229253,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1890,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639.3",
      "ID": 2747
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia",
      "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0686918+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270199",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270199,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1890,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639.3",
      "ID": 2747
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3751,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.7934578+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322680",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 322680,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1890,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639.3",
      "ID": 2747
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5109,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco",
      "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6990943+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5060E86P124VM294698",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 294698,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1890,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639.3",
      "ID": 2747
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5060,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.174478+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242852",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242852,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1890,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639.3",
      "ID": 2747
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1866,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah",
      "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0383689+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235572",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235572,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1890,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639.3",
      "ID": 2747
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1943,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic",
      "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6835814+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302122",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 302122,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1890,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639.3",
      "ID": 2747
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2595,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin",
      "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.2980172+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244533",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244533,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1890,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639.3",
      "ID": 2747
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2103,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith",
      "DisplayName": "Keith Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5588771+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327231",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 327231,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1890,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639.3",
      "ID": 2747
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:46.0269066+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3775E216P435VM276650",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276650,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1890,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639.3",
      "ID": 2747
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6752654+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264367",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264367,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1890,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639.3",
      "ID": 2747
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2673,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick",
      "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1304405+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248807",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248807,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1890,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639.3",
      "ID": 2747
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2678,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson",
      "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.670903+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2123E27P233VM295831",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295831,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1890,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639.3",
      "ID": 2747
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2123,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm",
      "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5377191+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285128",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285128,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1890,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639.3",
      "ID": 2747
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3907,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0676436+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230143",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230143,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1890,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639.3",
      "ID": 2747
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1735,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela",
      "DisplayName": "Angela Constance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.118078+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243867",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 243867,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1890,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639.3",
      "ID": 2747
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1932,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce",
      "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3233161+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1863E238P523VM255274",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255274,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1890,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639.3",
      "ID": 2747
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1863,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna",
      "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5238747+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323866",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 323866,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1890,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639.3",
      "ID": 2747
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4976,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth",
      "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9757301+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5107E223P379VM291366",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291366,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1890,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639.3",
      "ID": 2747
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5107,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1162045+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3743E222P391VM265143",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265143,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1890,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639.3",
      "ID": 2747
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3743,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel",
      "DisplayName": "Nigel Don",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1703209+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262218",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262218,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1890,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639.3",
      "ID": 2747
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3771,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob",
      "DisplayName": "Bob Doris",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.5920151+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2826E262P384VM282027",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 282027,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1890,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639.3",
      "ID": 2747
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2826,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Dornan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1680522+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3812E94P117VM297946",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 297946,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1890,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639.3",
      "ID": 2747
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3812,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia",
      "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1317217+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231630",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231630,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1890,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639.3",
      "ID": 2747
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1778,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen",
      "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6088583+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4955E240P389VM285958",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285958,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1890,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639.3",
      "ID": 2747
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4955,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3518713+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219315",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 219315,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1890,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639.3",
      "ID": 2747
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1742,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle",
      "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.2888147+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238599",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 238599,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1890,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639.3",
      "ID": 2747
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1994,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus",
      "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4610558+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225475",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225475,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1890,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639.3",
      "ID": 2747
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1814,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda",
      "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9763313+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321780",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 321780,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1890,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639.3",
      "ID": 2747
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Fee",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4510693+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1853E35P216VM293269",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 293269,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1890,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639.3",
      "ID": 2747
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia",
      "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8377065+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1892E12P64VM226925",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 226925,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1890,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639.3",
      "ID": 2747
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.252853+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5054E95P118VM312638",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 312638,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1890,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639.3",
      "ID": 2747
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5054,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1369331+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4947E152P361VM257150",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257150,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1890,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639.3",
      "ID": 2747
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4947,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Finnie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.8254651+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271314",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271314,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1890,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639.3",
      "ID": 2747
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3901,
      "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe",
      "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0701433+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278471",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 278471,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1890,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639.3",
      "ID": 2747
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2394,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo",
      "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2202463+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2110E220P414VM286711",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286711,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1890,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639.3",
      "ID": 2747
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth",
      "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.597465+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250428",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250428,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1890,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639.3",
      "ID": 2747
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2675,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob",
      "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.189129+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1741E10P50VM220740",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220740,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1890,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639.3",
      "ID": 2747
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1741,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel",
      "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6550032+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220330",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220330,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1890,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639.3",
      "ID": 2747
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1756,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine",
      "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.636672+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1860E104P150VM251839",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251839,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1890,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639.3",
      "ID": 2747
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1860,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda",
      "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.491368+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2033E20P141VM266156",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 266156,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1890,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639.3",
      "ID": 2747
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2033,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain",
      "DisplayName": "Iain Gray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4767227+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324567",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324567,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1890,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639.3",
      "ID": 2747
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5042,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2285446+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259909",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 259909,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1890,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639.3",
      "ID": 2747
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick",
      "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6352566+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239298",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239298,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1890,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639.3",
      "ID": 2747
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2029,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh",
      "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7307857+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273838",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 273838,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1890,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639.3",
      "ID": 2747
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3758,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.637844+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304207",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 304207,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1890,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639.3",
      "ID": 2747
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4086,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Hume",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.0283185+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221799",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221799,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1890,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639.3",
      "ID": 2747
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1773,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9483172+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1882E227P459VM242034",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242034,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1890,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639.3",
      "ID": 2747
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1882,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam",
      "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7909656+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223774",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223774,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1890,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639.3",
      "ID": 2747
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1893,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4731851+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307530",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307530,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1890,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639.3",
      "ID": 2747
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4934,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8334911+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272167",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 272167,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1890,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639.3",
      "ID": 2747
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4956,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Keir",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.114458+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244860",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244860,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1890,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639.3",
      "ID": 2747
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Kelly",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5817329+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315032",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315032,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1890,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639.3",
      "ID": 2747
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3129,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6711503+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247970",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247970,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1890,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639.3",
      "ID": 2747
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann",
      "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4361788+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4016E11P36VM274772",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274772,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1890,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639.3",
      "ID": 2747
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4016,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1210742+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255820",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255820,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1890,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639.3",
      "ID": 2747
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2180,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5584757+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4938E158P374VM277473",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277473,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1890,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639.3",
      "ID": 2747
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4938,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9548805+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2112E250P486VM252992",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252992,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1890,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639.3",
      "ID": 2747
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2112,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny",
      "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.762196+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4939E258P394VM277182",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277182,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1890,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639.3",
      "ID": 2747
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4939,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus",
      "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.7047147+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325564",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 325564,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1890,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639.3",
      "ID": 2747
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5074,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon",
      "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5117688+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1828E3P10VM232804",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232804,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1890,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639.3",
      "ID": 2747
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1828,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo",
      "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.876947+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311377",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311377,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1890,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639.3",
      "ID": 2747
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4948,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike",
      "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8760982+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2117E90P107VM230442",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230442,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1890,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639.3",
      "ID": 2747
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2117,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis",
      "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.330012+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267315",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 267315,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1890,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639.3",
      "ID": 2747
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken",
      "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0141505+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313784",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313784,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1890,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639.3",
      "ID": 2747
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4966,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek",
      "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4105207+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3101E102P129VM295436",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295436,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1890,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639.3",
      "ID": 2747
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3101,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala",
      "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5120819+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319030",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319030,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1890,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639.3",
      "ID": 2747
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5034,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny",
      "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6894094+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306455",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306455,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1890,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639.3",
      "ID": 2747
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2159,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Martin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5528097+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5110E252P395VM311266",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311266,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1890,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639.3",
      "ID": 2747
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Mason",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8712677+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268289",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 268289,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1890,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639.3",
      "ID": 2747
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2133,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2606935+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2876E141P433VM286125",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286125,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1890,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639.3",
      "ID": 2747
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2876,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3647306+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4951E147P368VM260717",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 260717,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1890,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639.3",
      "ID": 2747
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4951,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan",
      "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.0892319+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3896E175P307VM264076",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264076,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1890,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639.3",
      "ID": 2747
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3896,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam",
      "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9231588+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308063",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 308063,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1890,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639.3",
      "ID": 2747
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8629348+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4964E143P375VM279327",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279327,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1890,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639.3",
      "ID": 2747
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4964,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.4973969+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3824E84P113VM280020",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280020,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1890,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639.3",
      "ID": 2747
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3824,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5379903+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2066E22P91VM261128",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261128,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1890,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639.3",
      "ID": 2747
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2066,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.1130264+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299717",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 299717,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1890,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639.3",
      "ID": 2747
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7195846+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306558",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306558,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1890,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639.3",
      "ID": 2747
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina",
      "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5572289+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2487E146P369VM301237",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 301237,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1890,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639.3",
      "ID": 2747
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2487,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.2532178+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223645",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223645,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1890,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639.3",
      "ID": 2747
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4677035+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237470",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237470,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1890,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639.3",
      "ID": 2747
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1961,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David",
      "DisplayName": "David McLetchie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2119686+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2134E34P201VM297859",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 297859,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1890,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639.3",
      "ID": 2747
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2134,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1280604+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320396",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 320396,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1890,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639.3",
      "ID": 2747
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5041,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan",
      "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1646169+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3763E142P397VM316050",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 316050,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1890,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639.3",
      "ID": 2747
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3763,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart",
      "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9437676+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1986E23P197VM236281",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 236281,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1890,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639.3",
      "ID": 2747
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1986,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan",
      "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9096302+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5047E100P130VM291453",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291453,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1890,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639.3",
      "ID": 2747
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5047,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne",
      "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1199655+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234943",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234943,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1890,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639.3",
      "ID": 2747
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1845,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette",
      "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4065481+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313620",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313620,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1890,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639.3",
      "ID": 2747
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3061,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4032342+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1768E19P265VM288540",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 288540,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1890,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639.3",
      "ID": 2747
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1768,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1477967+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225012",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225012,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1890,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639.3",
      "ID": 2747
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1894,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Neil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7407657+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3815E98P134VM270894",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270894,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1890,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639.3",
      "ID": 2747
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3815,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Park, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Park",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8277721+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265921",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265921,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1890,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639.3",
      "ID": 2747
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2010,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil",
      "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4663231+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283513",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283513,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1890,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639.3",
      "ID": 2747
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5057,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7111458+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2853E33P128VM251432",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251432,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1890,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639.3",
      "ID": 2747
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Pentland",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.463351+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317616",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317616,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1890,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639.3",
      "ID": 2747
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5009,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4300856+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254735",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254735,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1890,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639.3",
      "ID": 2747
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3745,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis",
      "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2814895+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1870E225P478VM295600",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295600,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1890,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639.3",
      "ID": 2747
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1870,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona",
      "DisplayName": "Shona Robison",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5194392+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2135E254P450VM234875",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234875,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1890,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639.3",
      "ID": 2747
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2135,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Russell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4035236+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1895E232P431VM257379",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257379,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1890,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639.3",
      "ID": 2747
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1895,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0536681+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228083",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 228083,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1890,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639.3",
      "ID": 2747
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1839,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5836173+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2345E10P55VM292029",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 292029,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1890,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639.3",
      "ID": 2747
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2345,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1528275+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2223E176P333VM310689",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 310689,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1890,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639.3",
      "ID": 2747
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2223,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish",
      "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5818038+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2182E87P175VM245996",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 245996,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1890,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639.3",
      "ID": 2747
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2182,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8677207+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298360",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298360,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1890,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639.3",
      "ID": 2747
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5079,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew",
      "DisplayName": "Drew Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3423803+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234394",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234394,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1890,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639.3",
      "ID": 2747
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1769,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3753972+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4014E14P26VM269955",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269955,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1890,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639.3",
      "ID": 2747
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4014,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz",
      "DisplayName": "Liz Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5751133+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269171",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269171,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1890,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639.3",
      "ID": 2747
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2215,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.3067612+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317190",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317190,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1890,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639.3",
      "ID": 2747
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3806,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.1855643+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326266",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 326266,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1890,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639.3",
      "ID": 2747
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5106,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin",
      "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7510321+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241094",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241094,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1890,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639.3",
      "ID": 2747
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1848,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola",
      "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3958145+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2098E237P531VM289605",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289605,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1890,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639.3",
      "ID": 2747
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2098,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Swinney",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4512177+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2674E247P401VM247749",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247749,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1890,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639.3",
      "ID": 2747
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2674,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave",
      "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.426764+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5075E234P371VM284867",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 284867,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1890,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639.3",
      "ID": 2747
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5075,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Torrance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.051131+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1793E151P362VM222412",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 222412,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1890,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639.3",
      "ID": 2747
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1793,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean",
      "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1878308+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5078E245P7VM307141",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307141,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1890,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639.3",
      "ID": 2747
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5078,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Walker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5890233+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1841E231P426VM240184",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 240184,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1890,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639.3",
      "ID": 2747
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1841,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen",
      "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3484045+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283423",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283423,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1890,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639.3",
      "ID": 2747
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4952,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7000755+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1865E263P500VM232249",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232249,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1890,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639.3",
      "ID": 2747
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1865,
      "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra",
      "DisplayName": "Sandra White",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8465805+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237804",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237804,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1890,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639.3",
      "ID": 2747
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2610,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Wilson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2268021+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309308",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 309308,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1890,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639.3",
      "ID": 2747
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4941,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza",
      "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3237231+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252303",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252303,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1891,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639",
      "ID": 2731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1926,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian",
      "DisplayName": "Brian Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7233249+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2615E213P388VM258829",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258829,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1891,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639",
      "ID": 2731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2615,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George",
      "DisplayName": "George Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3296941+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319899",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319899,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1891,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639",
      "ID": 2731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4940,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare",
      "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.946189+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249670",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 249670,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1891,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639",
      "ID": 2731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2641,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair",
      "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9447791+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1783E21P273VM227410",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227410,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1891,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639",
      "ID": 2731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1783,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie",
      "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5489439+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2633E97P136VM280405",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280405,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1891,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639",
      "ID": 2731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2633,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire",
      "DisplayName": "Claire Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7655439+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262468",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262468,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1891,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639",
      "ID": 2731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2603,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6032438+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1759E91P115VM229254",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229254,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1891,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639",
      "ID": 2731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia",
      "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0687327+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270198",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270198,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1891,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639",
      "ID": 2731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3751,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.7933928+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322681",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 322681,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1891,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639",
      "ID": 2731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5109,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco",
      "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.699134+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5060E86P124VM294699",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 294699,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1891,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639",
      "ID": 2731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5060,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1745185+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242853",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242853,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1891,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639",
      "ID": 2731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1866,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah",
      "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0384081+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235571",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235571,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1891,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639",
      "ID": 2731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1943,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic",
      "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6835414+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302123",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 302123,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1891,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639",
      "ID": 2731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2595,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin",
      "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.2980581+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244532",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244532,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1891,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639",
      "ID": 2731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2103,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith",
      "DisplayName": "Keith Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5588361+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327232",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 327232,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1891,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639",
      "ID": 2731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:46.026948+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3775E216P435VM276651",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276651,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1891,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639",
      "ID": 2731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6753056+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264366",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264366,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1891,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639",
      "ID": 2731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2673,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick",
      "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1304+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248806",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248806,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1891,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639",
      "ID": 2731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2678,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson",
      "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6708627+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2123E27P233VM295830",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295830,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1891,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639",
      "ID": 2731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2123,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm",
      "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5376794+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285129",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285129,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1891,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639",
      "ID": 2731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3907,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0676848+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230144",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230144,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1891,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639",
      "ID": 2731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1735,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela",
      "DisplayName": "Angela Constance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.118118+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243866",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 243866,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1891,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639",
      "ID": 2731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1932,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce",
      "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3232758+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1863E238P523VM255273",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255273,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1891,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639",
      "ID": 2731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1863,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna",
      "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5238339+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323867",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 323867,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1891,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639",
      "ID": 2731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4976,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth",
      "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9757721+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5107E223P379VM291365",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291365,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1891,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639",
      "ID": 2731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5107,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1161637+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3743E222P391VM265144",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265144,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1891,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639",
      "ID": 2731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3743,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel",
      "DisplayName": "Nigel Don",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1703664+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262219",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262219,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1891,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639",
      "ID": 2731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3771,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob",
      "DisplayName": "Bob Doris",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.5920556+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2826E262P384VM282026",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 282026,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1891,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639",
      "ID": 2731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2826,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Dornan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1680105+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3812E94P117VM297947",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 297947,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1891,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639",
      "ID": 2731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3812,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia",
      "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1317619+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231629",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231629,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1891,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639",
      "ID": 2731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1778,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen",
      "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6088182+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4955E240P389VM285957",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285957,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1891,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639",
      "ID": 2731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4955,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3518309+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219358",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 219358,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1891,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639",
      "ID": 2731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1742,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle",
      "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.295173+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238598",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 238598,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1891,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639",
      "ID": 2731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1994,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus",
      "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4610148+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225474",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225474,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1891,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639",
      "ID": 2731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1814,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda",
      "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9762909+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321779",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 321779,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1891,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639",
      "ID": 2731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Fee",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4510291+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1853E35P216VM293268",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 293268,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1891,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639",
      "ID": 2731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia",
      "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8376657+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1892E12P64VM226926",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 226926,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1891,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639",
      "ID": 2731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2529057+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5054E95P118VM312639",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 312639,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1891,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639",
      "ID": 2731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5054,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.136974+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4947E152P361VM257151",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257151,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1891,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639",
      "ID": 2731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4947,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Finnie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.8255058+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271313",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271313,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1891,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639",
      "ID": 2731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3901,
      "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe",
      "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0701018+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278470",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 278470,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1891,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639",
      "ID": 2731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2394,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo",
      "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2202052+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2110E220P414VM286712",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286712,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1891,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639",
      "ID": 2731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth",
      "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5975057+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250429",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250429,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1891,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639",
      "ID": 2731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2675,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob",
      "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1891707+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1741E10P50VM220741",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220741,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1891,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639",
      "ID": 2731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1741,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel",
      "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6550434+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220287",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220287,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1891,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639",
      "ID": 2731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1756,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine",
      "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6347931+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1860E104P150VM251840",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251840,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1891,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639",
      "ID": 2731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1860,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda",
      "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4914084+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2033E20P141VM266155",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 266155,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1891,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639",
      "ID": 2731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2033,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain",
      "DisplayName": "Iain Gray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4766829+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324566",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324566,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1891,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639",
      "ID": 2731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5042,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2285049+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259908",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 259908,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1891,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639",
      "ID": 2731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick",
      "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6352161+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239299",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239299,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1891,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639",
      "ID": 2731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2029,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh",
      "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7308264+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273837",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 273837,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1891,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639",
      "ID": 2731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3758,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6378035+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304206",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 304206,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1891,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639",
      "ID": 2731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4086,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Hume",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.0282775+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221798",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221798,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1891,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639",
      "ID": 2731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1773,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9482771+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1882E227P459VM242033",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242033,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1891,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639",
      "ID": 2731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1882,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam",
      "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7909255+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223730",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223730,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1891,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639",
      "ID": 2731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1893,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4713143+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307531",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307531,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1891,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639",
      "ID": 2731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4934,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.833531+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272168",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 272168,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1891,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639",
      "ID": 2731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4956,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Keir",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.114498+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244861",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244861,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1891,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639",
      "ID": 2731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Kelly",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5817747+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315033",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315033,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1891,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639",
      "ID": 2731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3129,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6711917+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247969",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247969,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1891,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639",
      "ID": 2731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann",
      "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4361205+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4016E11P36VM274773",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274773,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1891,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639",
      "ID": 2731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4016,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1211355+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255819",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255819,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1891,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639",
      "ID": 2731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2180,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5584181+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4938E158P374VM277472",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277472,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1891,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639",
      "ID": 2731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4938,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9548212+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2112E250P486VM252993",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252993,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1891,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639",
      "ID": 2731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2112,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny",
      "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7622357+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4939E258P394VM277181",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277181,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1891,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639",
      "ID": 2731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4939,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus",
      "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.7046598+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325565",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 325565,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1891,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639",
      "ID": 2731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5074,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon",
      "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.511809+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1828E3P10VM232805",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232805,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1891,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639",
      "ID": 2731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1828,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo",
      "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8769872+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311378",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311378,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1891,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639",
      "ID": 2731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4948,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike",
      "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8761387+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2117E90P107VM230441",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230441,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1891,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639",
      "ID": 2731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2117,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis",
      "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3299691+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267316",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 267316,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1891,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639",
      "ID": 2731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken",
      "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0141924+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313783",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313783,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1891,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639",
      "ID": 2731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4966,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek",
      "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4104794+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3101E102P129VM295435",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295435,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1891,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639",
      "ID": 2731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3101,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala",
      "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5120415+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319029",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319029,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1891,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639",
      "ID": 2731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5034,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny",
      "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6893684+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306454",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306454,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1891,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639",
      "ID": 2731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2159,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Martin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5527688+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5110E252P395VM311265",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311265,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1891,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639",
      "ID": 2731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Mason",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8712074+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268288",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 268288,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1891,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639",
      "ID": 2731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2133,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2606514+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2876E141P433VM286126",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286126,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1891,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639",
      "ID": 2731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2876,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3647713+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4951E147P368VM260716",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 260716,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1891,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639",
      "ID": 2731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4951,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan",
      "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.0891917+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3896E175P307VM264075",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264075,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1891,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639",
      "ID": 2731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3896,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam",
      "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9231189+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308064",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 308064,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1891,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639",
      "ID": 2731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8629779+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4964E143P375VM279328",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279328,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1891,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639",
      "ID": 2731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4964,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.4974389+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3824E84P113VM280019",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280019,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1891,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639",
      "ID": 2731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3824,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5379495+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2066E22P91VM261127",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261127,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1891,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639",
      "ID": 2731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2066,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.1129853+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299716",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 299716,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1891,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639",
      "ID": 2731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7195451+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306559",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306559,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1891,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639",
      "ID": 2731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina",
      "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5572696+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2487E146P369VM301236",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 301236,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1891,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639",
      "ID": 2731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2487,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.253177+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223646",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223646,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1891,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639",
      "ID": 2731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.467744+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237471",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237471,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1891,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639",
      "ID": 2731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1961,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David",
      "DisplayName": "David McLetchie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.212009+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2134E34P201VM297860",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 297860,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1891,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639",
      "ID": 2731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2134,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1281003+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320397",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 320397,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1891,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639",
      "ID": 2731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5041,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan",
      "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1646578+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3763E142P397VM316049",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 316049,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1891,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639",
      "ID": 2731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3763,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart",
      "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.943727+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1986E23P197VM236282",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 236282,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1891,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639",
      "ID": 2731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1986,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan",
      "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9096709+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5047E100P130VM291452",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291452,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1891,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639",
      "ID": 2731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5047,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne",
      "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1199231+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234942",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234942,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1891,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639",
      "ID": 2731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1845,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette",
      "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4065056+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313619",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313619,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1891,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639",
      "ID": 2731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3061,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4031941+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1768E19P265VM288541",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 288541,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1891,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639",
      "ID": 2731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1768,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.147838+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225055",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225055,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1891,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639",
      "ID": 2731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1894,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Neil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7425804+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3815E98P134VM270895",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270895,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1891,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639",
      "ID": 2731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3815,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Park, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Park",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8278427+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265920",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265920,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1891,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639",
      "ID": 2731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2010,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil",
      "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4662644+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283512",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283512,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1891,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639",
      "ID": 2731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5057,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7111051+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2853E33P128VM251433",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251433,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1891,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639",
      "ID": 2731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Pentland",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4633917+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317617",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317617,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1891,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639",
      "ID": 2731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5009,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4301253+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254734",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254734,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1891,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639",
      "ID": 2731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3745,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis",
      "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.281449+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1870E225P478VM295601",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295601,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1891,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639",
      "ID": 2731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1870,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona",
      "DisplayName": "Shona Robison",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5194787+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2135E254P450VM234876",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234876,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1891,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639",
      "ID": 2731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2135,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Russell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4035646+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1895E232P431VM257380",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257380,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1891,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639",
      "ID": 2731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1895,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0537088+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228084",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 228084,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1891,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639",
      "ID": 2731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1839,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5836575+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2345E10P55VM292028",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 292028,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1891,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639",
      "ID": 2731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2345,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1527842+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2223E176P333VM310690",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 310690,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1891,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639",
      "ID": 2731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2223,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish",
      "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5818439+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2182E87P175VM245997",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 245997,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1891,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639",
      "ID": 2731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2182,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.867761+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298359",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298359,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1891,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639",
      "ID": 2731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5079,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew",
      "DisplayName": "Drew Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3423399+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234393",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234393,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1891,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639",
      "ID": 2731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1769,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3753558+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4014E14P26VM269956",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269956,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1891,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639",
      "ID": 2731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4014,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz",
      "DisplayName": "Liz Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5751913+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269172",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269172,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1891,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639",
      "ID": 2731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2215,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.3068019+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317191",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317191,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1891,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639",
      "ID": 2731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3806,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.1856051+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326265",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 326265,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1891,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639",
      "ID": 2731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5106,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin",
      "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7509903+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241095",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241095,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1891,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639",
      "ID": 2731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1848,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola",
      "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3958559+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2098E237P531VM289606",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289606,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1891,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639",
      "ID": 2731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2098,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Swinney",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4512574+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2674E247P401VM247750",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247750,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1891,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639",
      "ID": 2731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2674,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave",
      "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4268046+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5075E234P371VM284868",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 284868,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1891,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639",
      "ID": 2731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5075,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Torrance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0511709+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1793E151P362VM222457",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 222457,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1891,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639",
      "ID": 2731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1793,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean",
      "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1897865+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5078E245P7VM307140",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307140,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1891,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639",
      "ID": 2731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5078,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Walker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5889834+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1841E231P426VM240183",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 240183,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1891,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639",
      "ID": 2731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1841,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen",
      "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7825298+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283424",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283424,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1891,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639",
      "ID": 2731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4952,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7001163+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1865E263P500VM232248",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232248,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1891,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639",
      "ID": 2731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1865,
      "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra",
      "DisplayName": "Sandra White",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8465393+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237803",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237803,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1891,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639",
      "ID": 2731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2610,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Wilson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2267619+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309307",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 309307,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1891,
      "AgendaID": 2695,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 49,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-02639",
      "ID": 2731
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4941,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza",
      "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3236652+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252300",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252300,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1888,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 101,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.3",
      "ID": 2733
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1926,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian",
      "DisplayName": "Brian Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7232032+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2615E213P388VM257540",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257540,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1888,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 101,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.3",
      "ID": 2733
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2615,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George",
      "DisplayName": "George Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.060945+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319950",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319950,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1888,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 101,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.3",
      "ID": 2733
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4940,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare",
      "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9483936+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249673",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 249673,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1888,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 101,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.3",
      "ID": 2733
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2641,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair",
      "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9449192+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1783E21P273VM227407",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227407,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1888,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 101,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.3",
      "ID": 2733
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1783,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie",
      "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5488236+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2633E97P136VM280402",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280402,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1888,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 101,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.3",
      "ID": 2733
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2633,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire",
      "DisplayName": "Claire Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7654221+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262465",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262465,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1888,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 101,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.3",
      "ID": 2733
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2603,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6031211+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1759E91P115VM229251",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229251,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1888,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 101,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.3",
      "ID": 2733
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia",
      "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.06861+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270254",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270254,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1888,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 101,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.3",
      "ID": 2733
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3751,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.7960052+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322678",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 322678,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1888,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 101,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.3",
      "ID": 2733
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5109,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco",
      "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6990136+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5060E86P124VM294696",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 294696,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1888,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 101,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.3",
      "ID": 2733
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5060,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1743977+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242799",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242799,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1888,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 101,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.3",
      "ID": 2733
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1866,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah",
      "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0360269+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235624",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235624,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1888,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 101,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.3",
      "ID": 2733
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1943,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic",
      "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6857766+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302120",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 302120,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1888,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 101,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.3",
      "ID": 2733
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2595,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin",
      "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.2979138+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244535",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244535,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1888,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 101,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.3",
      "ID": 2733
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2103,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith",
      "DisplayName": "Keith Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5590422+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327339",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 327339,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1888,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 101,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.3",
      "ID": 2733
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:46.0316081+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3775E216P435VM276648",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276648,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1888,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 101,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.3",
      "ID": 2733
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6751831+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264369",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264369,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1888,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 101,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.3",
      "ID": 2733
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2673,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick",
      "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1305216+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248849",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248849,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1888,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 101,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.3",
      "ID": 2733
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2678,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson",
      "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6726966+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2123E27P233VM296341",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 296341,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1888,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 101,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.3",
      "ID": 2733
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2123,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm",
      "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8448532+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285126",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285126,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1888,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 101,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.3",
      "ID": 2733
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3907,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0675614+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230141",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230141,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1888,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 101,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.3",
      "ID": 2733
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1735,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela",
      "DisplayName": "Angela Constance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.1179969+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243921",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 243921,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1888,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 101,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.3",
      "ID": 2733
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1932,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce",
      "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3256432+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1863E238P523VM255276",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255276,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1888,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 101,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.3",
      "ID": 2733
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1863,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna",
      "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5239562+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323974",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 323974,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1888,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 101,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.3",
      "ID": 2733
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4976,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth",
      "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9805414+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5107E223P379VM291873",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291873,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1888,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 101,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.3",
      "ID": 2733
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5107,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1461375+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3743E222P391VM265141",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265141,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1888,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 101,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.3",
      "ID": 2733
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3743,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel",
      "DisplayName": "Nigel Don",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1702389+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3771E149P417VM261709",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261709,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1888,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 101,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.3",
      "ID": 2733
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3771,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob",
      "DisplayName": "Bob Doris",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3692286+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2826E262P384VM282029",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 282029,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1888,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 101,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.3",
      "ID": 2733
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2826,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Dornan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1681354+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3812E94P117VM297944",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 297944,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1888,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 101,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.3",
      "ID": 2733
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3812,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia",
      "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1316422+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231632",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231632,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1888,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 101,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.3",
      "ID": 2733
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1778,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen",
      "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6089563+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4955E240P389VM286172",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286172,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1888,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 101,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.3",
      "ID": 2733
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4955,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3670047+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219312",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 219312,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1888,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 101,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.3",
      "ID": 2733
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1742,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle",
      "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.288688+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238651",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 238651,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1888,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 101,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.3",
      "ID": 2733
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1994,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus",
      "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4632526+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225477",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225477,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1888,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 101,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.3",
      "ID": 2733
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1814,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda",
      "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9764123+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321782",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 321782,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1888,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 101,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.3",
      "ID": 2733
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Fee",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4511502+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1853E35P216VM293271",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 293271,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1888,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 101,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.3",
      "ID": 2733
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia",
      "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8377884+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1892E12P64VM226882",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 226882,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1888,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 101,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.3",
      "ID": 2733
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.250773+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5054E95P118VM312636",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 312636,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1888,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 101,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.3",
      "ID": 2733
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5054,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1368526+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4947E152P361VM257148",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257148,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1888,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 101,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.3",
      "ID": 2733
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4947,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Finnie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.8253637+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271527",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271527,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1888,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 101,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.3",
      "ID": 2733
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3901,
      "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe",
      "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0796866+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278473",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 278473,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1888,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 101,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.3",
      "ID": 2733
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2394,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo",
      "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.220329+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2110E220P414VM286709",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286709,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1888,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 101,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.3",
      "ID": 2733
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth",
      "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5973672+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250426",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250426,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1888,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 101,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.3",
      "ID": 2733
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2675,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob",
      "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1890296+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1741E10P50VM220738",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220738,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1888,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 101,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.3",
      "ID": 2733
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1741,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel",
      "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6549204+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220332",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220332,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1888,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 101,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.3",
      "ID": 2733
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1756,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine",
      "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6367761+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1860E104P150VM251837",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251837,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1888,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 101,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.3",
      "ID": 2733
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1860,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda",
      "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4912668+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2033E20P141VM266158",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 266158,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1888,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 101,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.3",
      "ID": 2733
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2033,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain",
      "DisplayName": "Iain Gray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4768208+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324459",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324459,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1888,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 101,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.3",
      "ID": 2733
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5042,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2236017+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259953",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 259953,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1888,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 101,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.3",
      "ID": 2733
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick",
      "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6371471+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239246",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239246,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1888,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 101,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.3",
      "ID": 2733
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2029,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh",
      "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7284802+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273840",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 273840,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1888,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 101,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.3",
      "ID": 2733
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3758,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6379245+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304209",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 304209,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1888,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 101,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.3",
      "ID": 2733
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4086,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Hume",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.0284007+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221801",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221801,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1888,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 101,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.3",
      "ID": 2733
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1773,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9483982+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1882E227P459VM242036",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242036,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1888,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 101,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.3",
      "ID": 2733
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1882,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam",
      "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7910478+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223784",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223784,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1888,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 101,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.3",
      "ID": 2733
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1893,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4736181+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307528",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307528,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1888,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 101,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.3",
      "ID": 2733
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4934,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.83341+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272165",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 272165,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1888,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 101,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.3",
      "ID": 2733
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4956,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Keir",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.1143766+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244809",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244809,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1888,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 101,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.3",
      "ID": 2733
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Kelly",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5795605+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3129E261P419VM314982",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 314982,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1888,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 101,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.3",
      "ID": 2733
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3129,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.668989+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2080E36P220VM251114",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251114,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1888,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 101,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.3",
      "ID": 2733
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann",
      "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.2276943+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4016E11P36VM274714",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274714,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1888,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 101,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.3",
      "ID": 2733
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4016,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1185544+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255871",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255871,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1888,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 101,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.3",
      "ID": 2733
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2180,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5605971+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4938E158P374VM277840",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277840,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1888,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 101,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.3",
      "ID": 2733
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4938,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9707054+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2112E250P486VM252940",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252940,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1888,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 101,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.3",
      "ID": 2733
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2112,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny",
      "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7597795+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4939E258P394VM277228",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277228,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1888,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 101,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.3",
      "ID": 2733
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4939,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus",
      "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.939211+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325672",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 325672,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1888,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 101,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.3",
      "ID": 2733
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5074,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon",
      "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5163378+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1828E3P10VM232802",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232802,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1888,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 101,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.3",
      "ID": 2733
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1828,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo",
      "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8768666+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311375",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311375,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1888,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 101,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.3",
      "ID": 2733
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4948,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike",
      "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8760153+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2117E90P107VM230484",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230484,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1888,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 101,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.3",
      "ID": 2733
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2117,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis",
      "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.331964+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267313",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 267313,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1888,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 101,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.3",
      "ID": 2733
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken",
      "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0140465+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313786",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313786,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1888,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 101,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.3",
      "ID": 2733
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4966,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek",
      "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.410602+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3101E102P129VM295438",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295438,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1888,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 101,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.3",
      "ID": 2733
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3101,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala",
      "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5121631+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319032",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319032,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1888,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 101,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.3",
      "ID": 2733
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5034,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny",
      "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6894989+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306505",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306505,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1888,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 101,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.3",
      "ID": 2733
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2159,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Martin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5549521+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5110E252P395VM311268",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311268,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1888,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 101,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.3",
      "ID": 2733
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Mason",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8713506+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268291",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 268291,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1888,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 101,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.3",
      "ID": 2733
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2133,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2607756+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2876E141P433VM286123",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286123,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1888,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 101,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.3",
      "ID": 2733
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2876,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3646498+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4951E147P368VM260719",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 260719,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1888,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 101,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.3",
      "ID": 2733
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4951,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan",
      "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.0893127+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3896E175P307VM264122",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264122,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1888,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 101,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.3",
      "ID": 2733
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3896,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam",
      "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9251783+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308061",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 308061,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1888,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 101,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.3",
      "ID": 2733
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8627665+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4964E143P375VM279281",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279281,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1888,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 101,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.3",
      "ID": 2733
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4964,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.4950594+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3824E84P113VM280022",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280022,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1888,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 101,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.3",
      "ID": 2733
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3824,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5380728+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2066E22P91VM261799",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261799,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1888,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 101,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.3",
      "ID": 2733
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2066,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3786588+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299719",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 299719,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1888,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 101,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.3",
      "ID": 2733
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.719665+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306556",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306556,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1888,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 101,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.3",
      "ID": 2733
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina",
      "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5571273+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2487E146P369VM301239",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 301239,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1888,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 101,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.3",
      "ID": 2733
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2487,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.2533214+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223643",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223643,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1888,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 101,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.3",
      "ID": 2733
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.467621+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237418",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237418,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1888,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 101,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.3",
      "ID": 2733
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1961,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David",
      "DisplayName": "David McLetchie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2033463+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2134E34P201VM297809",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 297809,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1888,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 101,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.3",
      "ID": 2733
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2134,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1259229+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320394",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 320394,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1888,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 101,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.3",
      "ID": 2733
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5041,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan",
      "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1645344+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3763E142P397VM316100",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 316100,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1888,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 101,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.3",
      "ID": 2733
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3763,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart",
      "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9461725+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1986E23P197VM236279",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 236279,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1888,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 101,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.3",
      "ID": 2733
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1986,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan",
      "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9095476+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5047E100P130VM291455",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291455,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1888,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 101,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.3",
      "ID": 2733
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5047,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne",
      "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1200473+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234945",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234945,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1888,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 101,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.3",
      "ID": 2733
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1845,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette",
      "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4066304+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313670",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313670,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1888,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 101,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.3",
      "ID": 2733
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3061,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4053973+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1768E19P265VM288538",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 288538,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1888,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 101,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.3",
      "ID": 2733
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1768,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1477145+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225002",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225002,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1888,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 101,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.3",
      "ID": 2733
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1894,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Neil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7403396+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3815E98P134VM270839",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270839,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1888,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 101,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.3",
      "ID": 2733
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3815,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Park, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Park",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8253368+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265923",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265923,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1888,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 101,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.3",
      "ID": 2733
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2010,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil",
      "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4664051+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283559",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283559,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1888,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 101,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.3",
      "ID": 2733
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5057,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7134889+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2853E33P128VM251082",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251082,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1888,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 101,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.3",
      "ID": 2733
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Pentland",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.2262312+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317614",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317614,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1888,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 101,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.3",
      "ID": 2733
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5009,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4300052+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254737",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254737,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1888,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 101,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.3",
      "ID": 2733
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3745,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis",
      "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2815712+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1870E225P478VM295598",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295598,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1888,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 101,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.3",
      "ID": 2733
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1870,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona",
      "DisplayName": "Shona Robison",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5193584+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2135E254P450VM234833",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234833,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1888,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 101,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.3",
      "ID": 2733
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2135,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Russell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4017127+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1895E232P431VM257377",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257377,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1888,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 101,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.3",
      "ID": 2733
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1895,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0535867+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228081",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 228081,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1888,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 101,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.3",
      "ID": 2733
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1839,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5835358+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2345E10P55VM292031",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 292031,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1888,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 101,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.3",
      "ID": 2733
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2345,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1529093+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2223E176P333VM310639",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 310639,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1888,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 101,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.3",
      "ID": 2733
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2223,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish",
      "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5795738+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2182E87P175VM245994",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 245994,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1888,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 101,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.3",
      "ID": 2733
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2182,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8676384+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298362",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298362,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1888,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 101,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.3",
      "ID": 2733
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5079,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew",
      "DisplayName": "Drew Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3424807+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234396",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234396,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1888,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 101,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.3",
      "ID": 2733
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1769,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3754788+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4014E14P26VM269909",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269909,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1888,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 101,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.3",
      "ID": 2733
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4014,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz",
      "DisplayName": "Liz Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5730251+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269169",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269169,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1888,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 101,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.3",
      "ID": 2733
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2215,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.3066794+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317140",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317140,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1888,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 101,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.3",
      "ID": 2733
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3806,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.1834059+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326158",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 326158,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1888,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 101,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.3",
      "ID": 2733
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5106,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin",
      "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5423635+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241092",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241092,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1888,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 101,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.3",
      "ID": 2733
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1848,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola",
      "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.395733+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2098E237P531VM289554",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289554,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1888,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 101,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.3",
      "ID": 2733
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2098,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Swinney",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4490831+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2674E247P401VM247707",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247707,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1888,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 101,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.3",
      "ID": 2733
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2674,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave",
      "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4249754+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5075E234P371VM284822",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 284822,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1888,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 101,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.3",
      "ID": 2733
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5075,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Torrance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0492399+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1793E151P362VM222402",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 222402,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1888,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 101,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.3",
      "ID": 2733
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1793,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean",
      "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1874188+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5078E245P7VM307143",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307143,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1888,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 101,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.3",
      "ID": 2733
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5078,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Walker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5891226+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1841E231P426VM240186",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 240186,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1888,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 101,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.3",
      "ID": 2733
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1841,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen",
      "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3485568+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283365",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283365,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1888,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 101,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.3",
      "ID": 2733
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4952,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.6975545+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1865E263P500VM232251",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232251,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1888,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 101,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.3",
      "ID": 2733
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1865,
      "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra",
      "DisplayName": "Sandra White",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8466646+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237846",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237846,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1888,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 101,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.3",
      "ID": 2733
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2610,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Wilson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2285948+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309310",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 309310,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1888,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 14,
      "VoteAgainst": 101,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.3",
      "ID": 2733
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4941,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza",
      "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3238055+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252299",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252299,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1887,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.2",
      "ID": 2732
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1926,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian",
      "DisplayName": "Brian Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7231627+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2615E213P388VM257539",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257539,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1887,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.2",
      "ID": 2732
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2615,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George",
      "DisplayName": "George Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0609039+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319951",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319951,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1887,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.2",
      "ID": 2732
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4940,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare",
      "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9484343+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249674",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 249674,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1887,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.2",
      "ID": 2732
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2641,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair",
      "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9449587+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1783E21P273VM227406",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227406,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1887,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.2",
      "ID": 2732
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1783,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie",
      "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5487831+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2633E97P136VM280401",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280401,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1887,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.2",
      "ID": 2732
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2633,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire",
      "DisplayName": "Claire Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.765381+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262464",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262464,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1887,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.2",
      "ID": 2732
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2603,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6030806+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1759E91P115VM229250",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229250,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1887,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.2",
      "ID": 2732
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia",
      "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0685682+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270255",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270255,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1887,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.2",
      "ID": 2732
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3751,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.7960465+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322675",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 322675,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1887,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.2",
      "ID": 2732
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5109,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco",
      "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6988763+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5060E86P124VM294695",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 294695,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1887,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.2",
      "ID": 2732
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5060,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1743573+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242798",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242798,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1887,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.2",
      "ID": 2732
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1866,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah",
      "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0359877+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235625",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235625,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1887,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.2",
      "ID": 2732
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1943,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic",
      "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6858168+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302119",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 302119,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1887,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.2",
      "ID": 2732
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2595,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin",
      "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.2978572+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244536",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244536,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1887,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.2",
      "ID": 2732
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2103,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith",
      "DisplayName": "Keith Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5590862+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327338",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 327338,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1887,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.2",
      "ID": 2732
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:46.0315668+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3775E216P435VM276647",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276647,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1887,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.2",
      "ID": 2732
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.675115+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264370",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264370,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1887,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.2",
      "ID": 2732
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2673,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick",
      "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1305621+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248850",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248850,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1887,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.2",
      "ID": 2732
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2678,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson",
      "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6727372+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2123E27P233VM296342",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 296342,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1887,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.2",
      "ID": 2732
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2123,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm",
      "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8448936+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285125",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285125,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1887,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.2",
      "ID": 2732
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3907,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0675208+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230140",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230140,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1887,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.2",
      "ID": 2732
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1735,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela",
      "DisplayName": "Angela Constance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.1179567+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243922",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 243922,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1887,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.2",
      "ID": 2732
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1932,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce",
      "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3256845+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1863E238P523VM255277",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255277,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1887,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.2",
      "ID": 2732
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1863,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna",
      "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5239973+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323973",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 323973,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1887,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.2",
      "ID": 2732
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4976,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth",
      "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.980479+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5107E223P379VM291874",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291874,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1887,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.2",
      "ID": 2732
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5107,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1461774+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3743E222P391VM265140",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265140,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1887,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.2",
      "ID": 2732
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3743,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel",
      "DisplayName": "Nigel Don",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1701981+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3771E149P417VM261708",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261708,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1887,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.2",
      "ID": 2732
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3771,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob",
      "DisplayName": "Bob Doris",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3691881+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2826E262P384VM282030",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 282030,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1887,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.2",
      "ID": 2732
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2826,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Dornan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1681755+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3812E94P117VM297941",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 297941,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1887,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.2",
      "ID": 2732
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3812,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia",
      "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1315011+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231633",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231633,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1887,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.2",
      "ID": 2732
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1778,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen",
      "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6089977+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4955E240P389VM286173",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286173,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1887,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.2",
      "ID": 2732
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4955,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3670453+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219311",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 219311,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1887,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.2",
      "ID": 2732
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1742,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle",
      "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.2886159+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238652",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 238652,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1887,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.2",
      "ID": 2732
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1994,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus",
      "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4632931+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225478",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225478,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1887,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.2",
      "ID": 2732
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1814,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda",
      "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9764527+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321785",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 321785,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1887,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.2",
      "ID": 2732
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Fee",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4512703+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1853E35P216VM293272",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 293272,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1887,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.2",
      "ID": 2732
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia",
      "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8378291+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1892E12P64VM226881",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 226881,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1887,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.2",
      "ID": 2732
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.25073+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5054E95P118VM312635",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 312635,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1887,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.2",
      "ID": 2732
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5054,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1368121+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4947E152P361VM257147",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257147,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1887,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.2",
      "ID": 2732
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4947,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Finnie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.825322+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271528",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271528,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1887,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.2",
      "ID": 2732
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3901,
      "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe",
      "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0797294+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278474",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 278474,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1887,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.2",
      "ID": 2732
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2394,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo",
      "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2203698+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2110E220P414VM286708",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286708,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1887,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.2",
      "ID": 2732
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth",
      "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5973279+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250425",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250425,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1887,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.2",
      "ID": 2732
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2675,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob",
      "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1889887+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1741E10P50VM220737",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220737,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1887,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.2",
      "ID": 2732
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1741,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel",
      "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6548619+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220333",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220333,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1887,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.2",
      "ID": 2732
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1756,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine",
      "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6368201+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1860E104P150VM251836",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251836,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1887,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.2",
      "ID": 2732
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1860,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda",
      "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4912267+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2033E20P141VM266159",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 266159,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1887,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.2",
      "ID": 2732
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2033,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain",
      "DisplayName": "Iain Gray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.476862+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324460",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324460,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1887,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.2",
      "ID": 2732
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5042,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2236415+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259954",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 259954,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1887,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.2",
      "ID": 2732
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick",
      "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6371885+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239245",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239245,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1887,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.2",
      "ID": 2732
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2029,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh",
      "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7284397+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273841",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 273841,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1887,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.2",
      "ID": 2732
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3758,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6379831+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304210",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 304210,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1887,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.2",
      "ID": 2732
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4086,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Hume",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.0284412+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221802",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221802,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1887,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.2",
      "ID": 2732
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1773,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9484391+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1882E227P459VM242037",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242037,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1887,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.2",
      "ID": 2732
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1882,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam",
      "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7910881+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223785",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223785,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1887,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.2",
      "ID": 2732
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1893,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4736595+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307525",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307525,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1887,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.2",
      "ID": 2732
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4934,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8332882+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272164",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 272164,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1887,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.2",
      "ID": 2732
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4956,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Keir",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.1143349+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244808",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244808,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1887,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.2",
      "ID": 2732
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Kelly",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.57952+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3129E261P419VM314981",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 314981,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1887,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.2",
      "ID": 2732
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3129,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6689482+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2080E36P220VM251115",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251115,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1887,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.2",
      "ID": 2732
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann",
      "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.2277357+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4016E11P36VM274713",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274713,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1887,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.2",
      "ID": 2732
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4016,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1185139+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255872",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255872,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1887,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.2",
      "ID": 2732
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2180,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5606367+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4938E158P374VM277841",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277841,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1887,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.2",
      "ID": 2732
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4938,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9707476+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2112E250P486VM252939",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252939,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1887,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.2",
      "ID": 2732
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2112,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny",
      "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7597386+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4939E258P394VM277229",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277229,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1887,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.2",
      "ID": 2732
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4939,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus",
      "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9392519+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325671",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 325671,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1887,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.2",
      "ID": 2732
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5074,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon",
      "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5162971+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1828E3P10VM232801",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232801,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1887,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.2",
      "ID": 2732
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1828,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo",
      "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8768261+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311372",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311372,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1887,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.2",
      "ID": 2732
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4948,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike",
      "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8758721+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2117E90P107VM230485",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230485,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1887,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.2",
      "ID": 2732
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2117,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis",
      "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3320067+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267312",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 267312,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1887,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.2",
      "ID": 2732
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken",
      "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0140063+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313789",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313789,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1887,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.2",
      "ID": 2732
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4966,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek",
      "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4107226+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3101E102P129VM295441",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295441,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1887,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.2",
      "ID": 2732
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3101,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala",
      "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5122846+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319035",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319035,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1887,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.2",
      "ID": 2732
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5034,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny",
      "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.689641+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306506",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306506,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1887,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.2",
      "ID": 2732
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2159,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Martin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.554993+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5110E252P395VM311269",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311269,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1887,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.2",
      "ID": 2732
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Mason",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8713926+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268292",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 268292,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1887,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.2",
      "ID": 2732
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2133,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2608176+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2876E141P433VM286121",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286121,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1887,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.2",
      "ID": 2732
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2876,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3645671+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4951E147P368VM260720",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 260720,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1887,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.2",
      "ID": 2732
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4951,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan",
      "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.0893532+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3896E175P307VM264123",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264123,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1887,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.2",
      "ID": 2732
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3896,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam",
      "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9252187+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308060",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 308060,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1887,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.2",
      "ID": 2732
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8627254+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4964E143P375VM279280",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279280,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1887,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.2",
      "ID": 2732
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4964,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.4950184+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3824E84P113VM280023",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280023,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1887,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.2",
      "ID": 2732
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3824,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5381136+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2066E22P91VM261800",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261800,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1887,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.2",
      "ID": 2732
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2066,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3786996+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299722",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 299722,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1887,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.2",
      "ID": 2732
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7198099+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306555",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306555,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1887,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.2",
      "ID": 2732
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina",
      "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5570868+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2487E146P369VM301240",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 301240,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1887,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.2",
      "ID": 2732
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2487,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.2533631+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223642",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223642,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1887,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.2",
      "ID": 2732
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4675613+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237417",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237417,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1887,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.2",
      "ID": 2732
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1961,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David",
      "DisplayName": "David McLetchie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2033056+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2134E34P201VM297808",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 297808,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1887,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.2",
      "ID": 2732
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2134,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1258829+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320391",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 320391,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1887,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.2",
      "ID": 2732
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5041,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan",
      "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1643914+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3763E142P397VM316101",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 316101,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1887,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.2",
      "ID": 2732
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3763,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart",
      "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9462138+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1986E23P197VM236278",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 236278,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1887,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.2",
      "ID": 2732
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1986,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan",
      "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.909507+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5047E100P130VM291456",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291456,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1887,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.2",
      "ID": 2732
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5047,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne",
      "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1201071+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234946",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234946,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1887,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.2",
      "ID": 2732
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1845,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette",
      "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4066708+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313671",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313671,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1887,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.2",
      "ID": 2732
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3061,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4054382+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1768E19P265VM288537",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 288537,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1887,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.2",
      "ID": 2732
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1768,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1476742+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225001",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225001,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1887,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.2",
      "ID": 2732
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1894,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Neil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7402993+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3815E98P134VM270838",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270838,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1887,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.2",
      "ID": 2732
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3815,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Park, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Park",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8252961+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265924",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265924,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1887,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.2",
      "ID": 2732
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2010,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil",
      "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4664459+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283560",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283560,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1887,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.2",
      "ID": 2732
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5057,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7135289+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2853E33P128VM251081",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251081,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1887,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.2",
      "ID": 2732
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Pentland",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.2261913+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317611",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317611,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1887,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.2",
      "ID": 2732
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5009,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4298846+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254738",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254738,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1887,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.2",
      "ID": 2732
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3745,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis",
      "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2816116+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1870E225P478VM295597",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295597,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1887,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.2",
      "ID": 2732
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1870,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona",
      "DisplayName": "Shona Robison",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5193164+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2135E254P450VM234832",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234832,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1887,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.2",
      "ID": 2732
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2135,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Russell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4016724+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1895E232P431VM257376",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257376,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1887,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.2",
      "ID": 2732
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1895,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0535453+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228080",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 228080,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1887,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.2",
      "ID": 2732
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1839,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5834953+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2345E10P55VM292032",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 292032,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1887,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.2",
      "ID": 2732
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2345,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1529501+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2223E176P333VM310638",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 310638,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1887,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.2",
      "ID": 2732
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2223,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish",
      "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.579532+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2182E87P175VM245993",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 245993,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1887,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.2",
      "ID": 2732
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2182,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8675979+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298363",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298363,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1887,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.2",
      "ID": 2732
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5079,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew",
      "DisplayName": "Drew Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3425216+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234397",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234397,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1887,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.2",
      "ID": 2732
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1769,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3755193+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4014E14P26VM269908",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269908,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1887,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.2",
      "ID": 2732
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4014,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz",
      "DisplayName": "Liz Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5681944+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269168",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269168,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1887,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.2",
      "ID": 2732
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2215,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.3066388+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317139",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317139,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1887,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.2",
      "ID": 2732
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3806,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.1833648+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326159",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 326159,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1887,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.2",
      "ID": 2732
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5106,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin",
      "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5424048+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241091",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241091,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1887,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.2",
      "ID": 2732
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1848,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola",
      "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3956922+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2098E237P531VM289553",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289553,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1887,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.2",
      "ID": 2732
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2098,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Swinney",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4490419+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2674E247P401VM247706",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247706,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1887,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.2",
      "ID": 2732
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2674,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave",
      "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.424935+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5075E234P371VM284821",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 284821,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1887,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.2",
      "ID": 2732
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5075,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Torrance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0491999+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1793E151P362VM222401",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 222401,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1887,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.2",
      "ID": 2732
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1793,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean",
      "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1873598+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5078E245P7VM307144",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307144,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1887,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.2",
      "ID": 2732
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5078,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Walker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5891646+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1841E231P426VM240187",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 240187,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1887,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.2",
      "ID": 2732
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1841,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen",
      "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3486029+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283364",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283364,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1887,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.2",
      "ID": 2732
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4952,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.6975127+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1865E263P500VM232252",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232252,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1887,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.2",
      "ID": 2732
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1865,
      "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra",
      "DisplayName": "Sandra White",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8467053+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237847",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237847,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1887,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.2",
      "ID": 2732
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2610,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Wilson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2286353+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309313",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 309313,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1887,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 70,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623.2",
      "ID": 2732
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4941,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza",
      "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3239263+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252301",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252301,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1889,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623",
      "ID": 2718
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1926,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian",
      "DisplayName": "Brian Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7232438+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2615E213P388VM257541",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257541,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1889,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623",
      "ID": 2718
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2615,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George",
      "DisplayName": "George Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0609862+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319901",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319901,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1889,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623",
      "ID": 2718
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4940,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare",
      "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9462713+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249672",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 249672,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1889,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623",
      "ID": 2718
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2641,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair",
      "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9448793+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1783E21P273VM227408",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227408,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1889,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623",
      "ID": 2718
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1783,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie",
      "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.548864+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2633E97P136VM280403",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280403,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1889,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623",
      "ID": 2718
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2633,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire",
      "DisplayName": "Claire Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.765463+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262466",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262466,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1889,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623",
      "ID": 2718
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2603,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6031614+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1759E91P115VM229252",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229252,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1889,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623",
      "ID": 2718
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia",
      "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0686506+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270253",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270253,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1889,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623",
      "ID": 2718
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3751,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.7959641+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322679",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 322679,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1889,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623",
      "ID": 2718
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5109,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco",
      "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6990545+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5060E86P124VM294697",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 294697,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1889,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623",
      "ID": 2718
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5060,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.174438+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242805",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242805,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1889,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623",
      "ID": 2718
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1866,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah",
      "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0362901+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235623",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235623,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1889,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623",
      "ID": 2718
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1943,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic",
      "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6857347+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302121",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 302121,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1889,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623",
      "ID": 2718
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2595,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin",
      "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.297956+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244534",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244534,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1889,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623",
      "ID": 2718
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2103,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith",
      "DisplayName": "Keith Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5589879+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327230",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 327230,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1889,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623",
      "ID": 2718
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:46.0268648+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3775E216P435VM276649",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276649,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1889,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623",
      "ID": 2718
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6752253+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264368",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264368,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1889,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623",
      "ID": 2718
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2673,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick",
      "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1304807+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248848",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248848,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1889,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623",
      "ID": 2718
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2678,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson",
      "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6726559+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2123E27P233VM295832",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295832,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1889,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623",
      "ID": 2718
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2123,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm",
      "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5377595+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285127",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285127,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1889,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623",
      "ID": 2718
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3907,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0676021+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230142",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230142,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1889,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623",
      "ID": 2718
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1735,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela",
      "DisplayName": "Angela Constance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.1180368+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243914",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 243914,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1889,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623",
      "ID": 2718
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1932,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce",
      "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3253334+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1863E238P523VM255275",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255275,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1889,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623",
      "ID": 2718
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1863,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna",
      "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5239155+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323865",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 323865,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1889,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623",
      "ID": 2718
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4976,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth",
      "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9756877+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5107E223P379VM291870",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291870,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1889,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623",
      "ID": 2718
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5107,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1460179+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3743E222P391VM265142",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265142,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1889,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623",
      "ID": 2718
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3743,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel",
      "DisplayName": "Nigel Don",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1702796+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3771E149P417VM261711",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261711,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1889,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623",
      "ID": 2718
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3771,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob",
      "DisplayName": "Bob Doris",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3693087+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2826E262P384VM282028",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 282028,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1889,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623",
      "ID": 2718
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2826,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Dornan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1680933+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3812E94P117VM297945",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 297945,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1889,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623",
      "ID": 2718
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3812,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia",
      "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1316821+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231631",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231631,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1889,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623",
      "ID": 2718
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1778,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen",
      "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6088983+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4955E240P389VM286171",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286171,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1889,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623",
      "ID": 2718
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4955,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3669632+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219313",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 219313,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1889,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623",
      "ID": 2718
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1742,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle",
      "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.2887305+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238650",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 238650,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1889,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623",
      "ID": 2718
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1994,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus",
      "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4632128+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225476",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225476,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1889,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623",
      "ID": 2718
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1814,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda",
      "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9763721+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321781",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 321781,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1889,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623",
      "ID": 2718
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Fee",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4511099+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1853E35P216VM293270",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 293270,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1889,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623",
      "ID": 2718
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia",
      "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8377481+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1892E12P64VM226883",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 226883,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1889,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623",
      "ID": 2718
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2508141+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5054E95P118VM312637",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 312637,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1889,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623",
      "ID": 2718
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5054,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1368926+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4947E152P361VM257149",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257149,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1889,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623",
      "ID": 2718
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4947,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Finnie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.8254237+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271526",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271526,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1889,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623",
      "ID": 2718
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3901,
      "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe",
      "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0796209+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278472",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 278472,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1889,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623",
      "ID": 2718
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2394,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo",
      "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2202871+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2110E220P414VM286710",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286710,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1889,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623",
      "ID": 2718
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth",
      "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5974065+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250427",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250427,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1889,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623",
      "ID": 2718
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2675,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob",
      "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.18907+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1741E10P50VM220739",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220739,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1889,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623",
      "ID": 2718
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1741,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel",
      "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6549626+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220331",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220331,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1889,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623",
      "ID": 2718
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1756,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine",
      "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6367134+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1860E104P150VM251838",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251838,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1889,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623",
      "ID": 2718
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1860,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda",
      "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4913265+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2033E20P141VM266157",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 266157,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1889,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623",
      "ID": 2718
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2033,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain",
      "DisplayName": "Iain Gray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4767627+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324568",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324568,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1889,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623",
      "ID": 2718
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5042,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2285852+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259951",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 259951,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1889,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623",
      "ID": 2718
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick",
      "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.637065+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239247",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239247,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1889,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623",
      "ID": 2718
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2029,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh",
      "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.728522+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273839",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 273839,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1889,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623",
      "ID": 2718
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3758,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6378841+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304208",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 304208,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1889,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623",
      "ID": 2718
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4086,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Hume",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.0283594+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221800",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221800,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1889,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623",
      "ID": 2718
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1773,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9483577+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1882E227P459VM242035",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242035,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1889,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623",
      "ID": 2718
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1882,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam",
      "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7910071+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223783",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223783,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1889,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623",
      "ID": 2718
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1893,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.473577+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307529",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307529,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1889,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623",
      "ID": 2718
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4934,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8334507+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272166",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 272166,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1889,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623",
      "ID": 2718
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4956,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Keir",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.1144177+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244812",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244812,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1889,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623",
      "ID": 2718
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Kelly",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5796824+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315031",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315031,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1889,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623",
      "ID": 2718
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3129,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6711084+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2080E36P220VM251113",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251113,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1889,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623",
      "ID": 2718
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann",
      "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.2276528+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4016E11P36VM274715",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274715,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1889,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623",
      "ID": 2718
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4016,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1185949+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255870",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255870,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1889,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623",
      "ID": 2718
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2180,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5605569+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4938E158P374VM277839",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277839,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1889,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623",
      "ID": 2718
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4938,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9706452+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2112E250P486VM252941",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252941,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1889,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623",
      "ID": 2718
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2112,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny",
      "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7598197+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4939E258P394VM277225",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277225,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1889,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623",
      "ID": 2718
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4939,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus",
      "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.939085+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325563",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 325563,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1889,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623",
      "ID": 2718
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5074,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon",
      "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5117289+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1828E3P10VM232803",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232803,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1889,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623",
      "ID": 2718
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1828,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo",
      "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8769069+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311376",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311376,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1889,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623",
      "ID": 2718
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4948,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike",
      "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8760563+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2117E90P107VM230483",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230483,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1889,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623",
      "ID": 2718
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2117,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis",
      "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3318936+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267314",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 267314,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1889,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623",
      "ID": 2718
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken",
      "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0140869+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313785",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313785,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1889,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623",
      "ID": 2718
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4966,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek",
      "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4105609+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3101E102P129VM295437",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295437,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1889,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623",
      "ID": 2718
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3101,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala",
      "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5121223+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319031",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319031,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1889,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623",
      "ID": 2718
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5034,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny",
      "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6894567+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306456",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306456,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1889,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623",
      "ID": 2718
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2159,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Martin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5528506+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5110E252P395VM311267",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311267,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1889,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623",
      "ID": 2718
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Mason",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8713098+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268290",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 268290,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1889,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623",
      "ID": 2718
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2133,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2607345+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2876E141P433VM286124",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286124,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1889,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623",
      "ID": 2718
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2876,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3646899+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4951E147P368VM260718",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 260718,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1889,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623",
      "ID": 2718
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4951,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan",
      "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.0892724+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3896E175P307VM264119",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264119,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1889,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623",
      "ID": 2718
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3896,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam",
      "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9250554+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308062",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 308062,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1889,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623",
      "ID": 2718
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8628815+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4964E143P375VM279284",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279284,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1889,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623",
      "ID": 2718
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4964,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.4952025+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3824E84P113VM280021",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280021,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1889,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623",
      "ID": 2718
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3824,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5380314+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2066E22P91VM261796",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261796,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1889,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623",
      "ID": 2718
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2066,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3785337+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299718",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 299718,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1889,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623",
      "ID": 2718
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7196249+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306557",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306557,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1889,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623",
      "ID": 2718
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina",
      "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5571866+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2487E146P369VM301238",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 301238,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1889,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623",
      "ID": 2718
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2487,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.2532777+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223644",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223644,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1889,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623",
      "ID": 2718
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4676629+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237419",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237419,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1889,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623",
      "ID": 2718
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1961,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David",
      "DisplayName": "David McLetchie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2034061+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2134E34P201VM297858",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 297858,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1889,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623",
      "ID": 2718
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2134,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1280211+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320395",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 320395,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1889,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623",
      "ID": 2718
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5041,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan",
      "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1645756+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3763E142P397VM316051",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 316051,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1889,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623",
      "ID": 2718
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3763,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart",
      "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9438093+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1986E23P197VM236280",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 236280,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1889,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623",
      "ID": 2718
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1986,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan",
      "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9095893+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5047E100P130VM291454",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291454,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1889,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623",
      "ID": 2718
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5047,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne",
      "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1200066+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234944",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234944,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1889,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623",
      "ID": 2718
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1845,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette",
      "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4065892+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313621",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313621,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1889,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623",
      "ID": 2718
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3061,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4032941+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1768E19P265VM288539",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 288539,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1889,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623",
      "ID": 2718
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1768,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1477566+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225003",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225003,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1889,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623",
      "ID": 2718
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1894,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Neil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7403799+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3815E98P134VM270840",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270840,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1889,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623",
      "ID": 2718
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3815,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Park, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Park",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8253775+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265922",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265922,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1889,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623",
      "ID": 2718
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2010,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil",
      "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4663647+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283556",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283556,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1889,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623",
      "ID": 2718
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5057,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.713365+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2853E33P128VM251083",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251083,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1889,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623",
      "ID": 2718
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Pentland",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.2262718+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317615",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317615,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1889,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623",
      "ID": 2718
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5009,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4300447+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254736",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254736,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1889,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623",
      "ID": 2718
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3745,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis",
      "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2815299+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1870E225P478VM295599",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295599,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1889,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623",
      "ID": 2718
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1870,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona",
      "DisplayName": "Shona Robison",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5193991+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2135E254P450VM234834",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234834,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1889,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623",
      "ID": 2718
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2135,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Russell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4017532+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1895E232P431VM257378",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257378,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1889,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623",
      "ID": 2718
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1895,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.053627+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228082",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 228082,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1889,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623",
      "ID": 2718
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1839,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5835768+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2345E10P55VM292030",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 292030,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1889,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623",
      "ID": 2718
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2345,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1528685+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2223E176P333VM310688",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 310688,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1889,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623",
      "ID": 2718
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2223,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish",
      "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5817632+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2182E87P175VM245995",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 245995,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1889,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623",
      "ID": 2718
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2182,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8676799+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298361",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298361,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1889,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623",
      "ID": 2718
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5079,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew",
      "DisplayName": "Drew Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3424392+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234395",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234395,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1889,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623",
      "ID": 2718
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1769,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3754374+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4014E14P26VM269912",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269912,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1889,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623",
      "ID": 2718
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4014,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz",
      "DisplayName": "Liz Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5731711+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269170",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269170,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1889,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623",
      "ID": 2718
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2215,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.3067205+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317189",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317189,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1889,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623",
      "ID": 2718
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3806,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.1855237+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326267",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 326267,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1889,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623",
      "ID": 2718
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5106,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin",
      "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7510728+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241093",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241093,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1889,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623",
      "ID": 2718
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1848,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola",
      "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.395774+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2098E237P531VM289604",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289604,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1889,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623",
      "ID": 2718
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2098,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Swinney",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4511779+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2674E247P401VM247708",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247708,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1889,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623",
      "ID": 2718
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2674,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave",
      "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4250155+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5075E234P371VM284825",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 284825,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1889,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623",
      "ID": 2718
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5075,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Torrance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0493608+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1793E151P362VM222403",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 222403,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1889,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623",
      "ID": 2718
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1793,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean",
      "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1874607+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5078E245P7VM307142",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307142,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1889,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623",
      "ID": 2718
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5078,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Walker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5890643+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1841E231P426VM240185",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 240185,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1889,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623",
      "ID": 2718
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1841,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen",
      "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3484638+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283366",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283366,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1889,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623",
      "ID": 2718
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4952,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.6975957+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1865E263P500VM232250",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232250,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1889,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623",
      "ID": 2718
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1865,
      "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra",
      "DisplayName": "Sandra White",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8466233+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237845",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237845,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1889,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623",
      "ID": 2718
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2610,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Wilson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2285537+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309309",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 309309,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1889,
      "AgendaID": 2292,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 100,
      "VoteAgainst": 15,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Project TransmiT",
      "Reference": "S4M-02623",
      "ID": 2718
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4941,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza",
      "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-04-18T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3237646+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252287",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252287,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1895,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 104,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02591",
      "ID": 2686
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1926,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian",
      "DisplayName": "Brian Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7226492+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2615E213P388VM257556",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257556,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1895,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 104,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02591",
      "ID": 2686
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2615,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George",
      "DisplayName": "George Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0616177+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319933",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319933,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1895,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 104,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02591",
      "ID": 2686
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4940,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare",
      "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9476511+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249693",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 249693,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1895,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 104,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02591",
      "ID": 2686
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2641,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair",
      "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9457559+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1783E21P273VM227394",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227394,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1895,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 104,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02591",
      "ID": 2686
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1783,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie",
      "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5482717+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2633E97P136VM280390",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280390,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1895,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 104,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02591",
      "ID": 2686
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2633,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire",
      "DisplayName": "Claire Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.758663+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262454",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262454,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1895,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 104,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02591",
      "ID": 2686
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2603,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6026341+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1759E91P115VM229240",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229240,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1895,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 104,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02591",
      "ID": 2686
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia",
      "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0681245+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270236",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270236,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1895,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 104,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02591",
      "ID": 2686
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3751,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.7952051+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322850",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 322850,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1895,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 104,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02591",
      "ID": 2686
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5109,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco",
      "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.7062622+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5060E86P124VM294686",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 294686,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1895,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 104,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02591",
      "ID": 2686
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5060,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1739678+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242820",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242820,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1895,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 104,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02591",
      "ID": 2686
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1866,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah",
      "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0369932+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235608",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235608,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1895,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 104,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02591",
      "ID": 2686
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1943,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic",
      "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6850934+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302109",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 302109,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1895,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 104,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02591",
      "ID": 2686
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2595,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin",
      "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.2974281+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244546",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244546,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1895,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 104,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02591",
      "ID": 2686
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2103,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith",
      "DisplayName": "Keith Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5678993+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327356",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 327356,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1895,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 104,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02591",
      "ID": 2686
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:46.0323414+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3775E216P435VM276637",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276637,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1895,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 104,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02591",
      "ID": 2686
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6747051+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264533",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264533,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1895,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 104,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02591",
      "ID": 2686
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2673,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick",
      "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.13761+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248833",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248833,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1895,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 104,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02591",
      "ID": 2686
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2678,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson",
      "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6720016+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2123E27P233VM295864",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295864,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1895,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 104,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02591",
      "ID": 2686
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2123,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm",
      "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5391104+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285115",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285115,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1895,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 104,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02591",
      "ID": 2686
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3907,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0670912+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230131",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230131,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1895,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 104,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02591",
      "ID": 2686
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1735,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela",
      "DisplayName": "Angela Constance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.1175703+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243899",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 243899,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1895,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 104,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02591",
      "ID": 2686
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1932,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce",
      "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3246947+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1863E238P523VM255287",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255287,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1895,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 104,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02591",
      "ID": 2686
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1863,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna",
      "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5244274+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323991",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 323991,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1895,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 104,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02591",
      "ID": 2686
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4976,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth",
      "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9812713+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5107E223P379VM291393",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291393,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1895,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 104,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02591",
      "ID": 2686
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5107,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1173804+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3743E222P391VM265130",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265130,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1895,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 104,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02591",
      "ID": 2686
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3743,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel",
      "DisplayName": "Nigel Don",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1697665+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3771E149P417VM261726",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261726,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1895,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 104,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02591",
      "ID": 2686
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3771,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob",
      "DisplayName": "Bob Doris",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3701702+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2826E262P384VM282041",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 282041,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1895,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 104,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02591",
      "ID": 2686
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2826,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Dornan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1730347+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3812E94P117VM297930",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 297930,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1895,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 104,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02591",
      "ID": 2686
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3812,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia",
      "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1310389+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231643",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231643,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1895,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 104,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02591",
      "ID": 2686
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1778,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen",
      "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6094201+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4955E240P389VM286154",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286154,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1895,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 104,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02591",
      "ID": 2686
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4955,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3662245+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219330",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 219330,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1895,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 104,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02591",
      "ID": 2686
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1742,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle",
      "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.2939226+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238635",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 238635,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1895,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 104,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02591",
      "ID": 2686
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1994,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus",
      "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4625713+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225496",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225496,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1895,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 104,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02591",
      "ID": 2686
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1814,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda",
      "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9772344+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321610",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 321610,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1895,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 104,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02591",
      "ID": 2686
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Fee",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4434991+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1853E35P216VM293308",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 293308,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1895,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 104,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02591",
      "ID": 2686
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia",
      "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8394137+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1892E12P64VM226898",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 226898,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1895,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 104,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02591",
      "ID": 2686
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2514621+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5054E95P118VM312625",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 312625,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1895,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 104,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02591",
      "ID": 2686
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5054,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1363836+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4947E152P361VM257128",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257128,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1895,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 104,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02591",
      "ID": 2686
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4947,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Finnie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.8245215+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271354",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271354,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1895,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 104,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02591",
      "ID": 2686
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3901,
      "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe",
      "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0720174+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278485",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 278485,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1895,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 104,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02591",
      "ID": 2686
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2394,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo",
      "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2208456+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2110E220P414VM286698",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286698,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1895,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 104,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02591",
      "ID": 2686
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth",
      "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5969081+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250406",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250406,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1895,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 104,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02591",
      "ID": 2686
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2675,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob",
      "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1879355+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1741E10P50VM220719",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220719,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1895,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 104,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02591",
      "ID": 2686
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1741,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel",
      "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6541087+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220315",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220315,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1895,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 104,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02591",
      "ID": 2686
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1756,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine",
      "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6360332+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1860E104P150VM251826",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251826,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1895,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 104,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02591",
      "ID": 2686
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1860,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda",
      "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4907888+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2033E20P141VM266170",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 266170,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1895,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 104,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02591",
      "ID": 2686
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2033,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain",
      "DisplayName": "Iain Gray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4773271+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324442",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324442,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1895,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 104,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02591",
      "ID": 2686
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5042,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.222821+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259936",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 259936,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1895,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 104,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02591",
      "ID": 2686
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick",
      "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6364308+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239262",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239262,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1895,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 104,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02591",
      "ID": 2686
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2029,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh",
      "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7291967+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273851",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 273851,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1895,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 104,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02591",
      "ID": 2686
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3758,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.638397+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304220",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 304220,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1895,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 104,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02591",
      "ID": 2686
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4086,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Hume",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.0288762+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221820",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221820,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1895,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 104,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02591",
      "ID": 2686
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1773,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9492196+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1882E227P459VM242056",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242056,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1895,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 104,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02591",
      "ID": 2686
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1882,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam",
      "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7919106+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223766",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223766,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1895,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 104,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02591",
      "ID": 2686
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1893,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4728406+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307514",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307514,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1895,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 104,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02591",
      "ID": 2686
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4934,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8328158+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272145",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 272145,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1895,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 104,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02591",
      "ID": 2686
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4956,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Keir",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.1135202+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244827",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244827,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1895,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 104,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02591",
      "ID": 2686
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Kelly",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5803313+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3129E261P419VM314999",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 314999,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1895,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 104,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02591",
      "ID": 2686
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3129,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6697257+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2080E36P220VM251098",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251098,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1895,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 104,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02591",
      "ID": 2686
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann",
      "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.2269331+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4016E11P36VM274732",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274732,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1895,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 104,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02591",
      "ID": 2686
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4016,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1193352+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255855",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255855,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1895,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 104,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02591",
      "ID": 2686
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2180,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5599348+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4938E158P374VM277822",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277822,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1895,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 104,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02591",
      "ID": 2686
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4938,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9699248+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2112E250P486VM252956",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252956,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1895,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 104,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02591",
      "ID": 2686
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2112,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny",
      "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7604686+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4939E258P394VM277210",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277210,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1895,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 104,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02591",
      "ID": 2686
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4939,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus",
      "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.938415+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325689",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 325689,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1895,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 104,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02591",
      "ID": 2686
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5074,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon",
      "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5170599+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1828E3P10VM232791",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232791,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1895,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 104,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02591",
      "ID": 2686
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1828,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo",
      "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8763916+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311361",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311361,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1895,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 104,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02591",
      "ID": 2686
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4948,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike",
      "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8753943+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2117E90P107VM230468",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230468,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1895,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 104,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02591",
      "ID": 2686
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2117,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis",
      "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3312238+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267301",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 267301,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1895,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 104,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02591",
      "ID": 2686
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken",
      "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0135286+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313800",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313800,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1895,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 104,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02591",
      "ID": 2686
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4966,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek",
      "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4111941+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3101E102P129VM295452",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295452,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1895,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 104,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02591",
      "ID": 2686
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3101,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala",
      "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.512755+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5034E88P114VM318860",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 318860,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1895,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 104,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02591",
      "ID": 2686
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5034,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny",
      "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6765347+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306488",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306488,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1895,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 104,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02591",
      "ID": 2686
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2159,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Martin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5542167+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5110E252P395VM311305",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311305,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1895,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 104,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02591",
      "ID": 2686
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Mason",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8729546+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268303",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 268303,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1895,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 104,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02591",
      "ID": 2686
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2133,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2612949+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2876E141P433VM286110",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286110,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1895,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 104,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02591",
      "ID": 2686
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2876,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3640927+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4951E147P368VM260739",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 260739,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1895,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 104,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02591",
      "ID": 2686
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4951,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan",
      "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.0901718+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3896E175P307VM264104",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264104,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1895,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 104,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02591",
      "ID": 2686
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3896,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam",
      "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9244091+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308024",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 308024,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1895,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 104,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02591",
      "ID": 2686
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8611462+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4964E143P375VM279299",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279299,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1895,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 104,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02591",
      "ID": 2686
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4964,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.4959318+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3824E84P113VM280033",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280033,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1895,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 104,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02591",
      "ID": 2686
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3824,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5385451+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2066E22P91VM261780",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261780,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1895,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 104,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02591",
      "ID": 2686
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2066,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3724935+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299733",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 299733,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1895,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 104,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02591",
      "ID": 2686
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7202771+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3759E260P411VM303353",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 303353,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1895,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 104,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02591",
      "ID": 2686
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina",
      "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8112967+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2487E146P369VM301736",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 301736,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1895,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 104,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02591",
      "ID": 2686
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2487,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.2809037+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223624",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223624,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1895,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 104,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02591",
      "ID": 2686
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4668029+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237434",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237434,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1895,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 104,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02591",
      "ID": 2686
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1961,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David",
      "DisplayName": "David McLetchie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2040468+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2134E34P201VM297826",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 297826,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1895,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 104,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02591",
      "ID": 2686
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2134,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1266767+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320721",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 320721,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1895,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 104,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02591",
      "ID": 2686
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5041,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan",
      "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1786106+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3763E142P397VM316083",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 316083,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1895,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 104,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02591",
      "ID": 2686
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3763,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart",
      "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9454271+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1986E23P197VM236268",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 236268,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1895,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 104,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02591",
      "ID": 2686
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1986,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan",
      "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9090651+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5047E100P130VM291466",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291466,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1895,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 104,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02591",
      "ID": 2686
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5047,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne",
      "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1205215+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234956",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234956,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1895,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 104,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02591",
      "ID": 2686
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1845,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette",
      "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4071131+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313653",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313653,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1895,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 104,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02591",
      "ID": 2686
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3061,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4046754+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1768E19P265VM288501",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 288501,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1895,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 104,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02591",
      "ID": 2686
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1768,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1376347+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225019",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225019,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1895,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 104,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02591",
      "ID": 2686
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1894,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Neil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.741071+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3815E98P134VM270857",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270857,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1895,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 104,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02591",
      "ID": 2686
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3815,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Park, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Park",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8261136+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265934",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265934,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1895,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 104,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02591",
      "ID": 2686
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2010,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil",
      "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4668739+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283541",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283541,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1895,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 104,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02591",
      "ID": 2686
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5057,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7123337+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2853E33P128VM251405",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251405,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1895,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 104,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02591",
      "ID": 2686
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Pentland",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4621632+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317940",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317940,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1895,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 104,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02591",
      "ID": 2686
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5009,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4500461+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254757",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254757,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1895,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 104,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02591",
      "ID": 2686
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3745,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis",
      "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2824253+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1870E225P478VM295561",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295561,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1895,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 104,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02591",
      "ID": 2686
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1870,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona",
      "DisplayName": "Shona Robison",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5174582+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2135E254P450VM234849",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234849,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1895,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 104,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02591",
      "ID": 2686
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2135,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Russell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.402388+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1895E232P431VM257366",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257366,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1895,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 104,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02591",
      "ID": 2686
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1895,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0531125+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228062",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 228062,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1895,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 104,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02591",
      "ID": 2686
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1839,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5827169+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2345E10P55VM292042",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 292042,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1895,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 104,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02591",
      "ID": 2686
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2345,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1534415+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2223E176P333VM310656",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 310656,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1895,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 104,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02591",
      "ID": 2686
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2223,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish",
      "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5803756+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2182E87P175VM245974",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 245974,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1895,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 104,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02591",
      "ID": 2686
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2182,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8667492+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298372",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298372,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1895,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 104,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02591",
      "ID": 2686
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5079,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew",
      "DisplayName": "Drew Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3429069+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234406",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234406,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1895,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 104,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02591",
      "ID": 2686
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1769,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3759106+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4014E14P26VM269927",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269927,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1895,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 104,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02591",
      "ID": 2686
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4014,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz",
      "DisplayName": "Liz Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5738333+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269157",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269157,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1895,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 104,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02591",
      "ID": 2686
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2215,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.3061617+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317157",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317157,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1895,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 104,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02591",
      "ID": 2686
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3806,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.1841533+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326141",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 326141,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1895,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 104,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02591",
      "ID": 2686
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5106,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin",
      "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5416455+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241072",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241072,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1895,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 104,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02591",
      "ID": 2686
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1848,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola",
      "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3948608+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2098E237P531VM289572",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289572,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1895,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 104,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02591",
      "ID": 2686
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2098,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Swinney",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4498289+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2674E247P401VM247723",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247723,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1895,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 104,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02591",
      "ID": 2686
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2674,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave",
      "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4256679+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5075E234P371VM284840",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 284840,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1895,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 104,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02591",
      "ID": 2686
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5075,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Torrance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0500043+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1793E151P362VM222420",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 222420,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1895,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 104,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02591",
      "ID": 2686
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1793,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean",
      "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1881805+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5078E245P7VM307180",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307180,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1895,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 104,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02591",
      "ID": 2686
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5078,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Walker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5907177+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1841E231P426VM240206",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 240206,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1895,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 104,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02591",
      "ID": 2686
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1841,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen",
      "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3494261+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283383",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283383,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1895,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 104,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02591",
      "ID": 2686
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4952,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.6983402+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1865E263P500VM232264",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232264,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1895,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 104,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02591",
      "ID": 2686
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1865,
      "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra",
      "DisplayName": "Sandra White",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.847242+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237830",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237830,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1895,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 104,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02591",
      "ID": 2686
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2610,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Wilson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2279117+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309324",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 309324,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1895,
      "AgendaID": 2396,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 104,
      "VoteAgainst": 5,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02591",
      "ID": 2686
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4941,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza",
      "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-05-10T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3243984+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1926E229P470VM253104",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253104,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1886,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 32,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Energy Companies",
      "Reference": "S4M-02523.1",
      "ID": 2626
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1926,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian",
      "DisplayName": "Brian Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7669513+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2615E213P388VM259463",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 259463,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1886,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 32,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Energy Companies",
      "Reference": "S4M-02523.1",
      "ID": 2626
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2615,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George",
      "DisplayName": "George Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6101876+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4940E159P373VM317978",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317978,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1886,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 32,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Energy Companies",
      "Reference": "S4M-02523.1",
      "ID": 2626
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4940,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare",
      "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4517139+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2641E256P403VM250169",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250169,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1886,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 32,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Energy Companies",
      "Reference": "S4M-02523.1",
      "ID": 2626
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2641,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair",
      "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9665051+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1783E21P273VM228452",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 228452,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1886,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 32,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Energy Companies",
      "Reference": "S4M-02523.1",
      "ID": 2626
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1783,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie",
      "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.7996696+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2633E97P136VM281146",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 281146,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1886,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 32,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Energy Companies",
      "Reference": "S4M-02523.1",
      "ID": 2626
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2633,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire",
      "DisplayName": "Claire Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.8079501+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2603E89P148VM263110",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 263110,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1886,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 32,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Energy Companies",
      "Reference": "S4M-02523.1",
      "ID": 2626
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2603,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6372062+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1759E91P115VM227449",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227449,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1886,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 32,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Energy Companies",
      "Reference": "S4M-02523.1",
      "ID": 2626
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia",
      "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5506518+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270718",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270718,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1886,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 32,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Energy Companies",
      "Reference": "S4M-02523.1",
      "ID": 2626
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3751,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8201103+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322455",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 322455,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1886,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 32,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Energy Companies",
      "Reference": "S4M-02523.1",
      "ID": 2626
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5109,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco",
      "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6893686+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5060E86P124VM297335",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 297335,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1886,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 32,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Energy Companies",
      "Reference": "S4M-02523.1",
      "ID": 2626
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5060,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.095529+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242696",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242696,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1886,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 32,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Energy Companies",
      "Reference": "S4M-02523.1",
      "ID": 2626
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1866,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah",
      "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0316772+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1943E145P367VM227061",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227061,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1886,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 32,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Energy Companies",
      "Reference": "S4M-02523.1",
      "ID": 2626
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1943,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic",
      "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2658182+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2595E12P30VM301027",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 301027,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1886,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 32,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Energy Companies",
      "Reference": "S4M-02523.1",
      "ID": 2626
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2595,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin",
      "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0294247+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2103E244P421VM262008",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262008,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1886,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 32,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Energy Companies",
      "Reference": "S4M-02523.1",
      "ID": 2626
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2103,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith",
      "DisplayName": "Keith Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.387647+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5108E221P387VM326574",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 326574,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1886,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 32,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Energy Companies",
      "Reference": "S4M-02523.1",
      "ID": 2626
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7705958+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277608",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277608,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1886,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 32,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Energy Companies",
      "Reference": "S4M-02523.1",
      "ID": 2626
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9606215+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264999",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264999,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1886,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 32,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Energy Companies",
      "Reference": "S4M-02523.1",
      "ID": 2626
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2673,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick",
      "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1637825+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2678E11P28VM249322",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 249322,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1886,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 32,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Energy Companies",
      "Reference": "S4M-02523.1",
      "ID": 2626
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2678,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson",
      "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.921583+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2123E27P233VM291159",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291159,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1886,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 32,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Energy Companies",
      "Reference": "S4M-02523.1",
      "ID": 2626
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2123,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm",
      "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7882253+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285461",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285461,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1886,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 32,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Energy Companies",
      "Reference": "S4M-02523.1",
      "ID": 2626
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3907,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3302525+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1735E248P405VM231399",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231399,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1886,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 32,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Energy Companies",
      "Reference": "S4M-02523.1",
      "ID": 2626
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1735,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela",
      "DisplayName": "Angela Constance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.5985063+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243175",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 243175,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1886,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 32,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Energy Companies",
      "Reference": "S4M-02523.1",
      "ID": 2626
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1932,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce",
      "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0573855+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254384",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254384,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1886,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 32,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Energy Companies",
      "Reference": "S4M-02523.1",
      "ID": 2626
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1863,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna",
      "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2533569+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4976E20P31VM321141",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 321141,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1886,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 32,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Energy Companies",
      "Reference": "S4M-02523.1",
      "ID": 2626
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4976,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth",
      "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.2040351+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5107E223P379VM292428",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 292428,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1886,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 32,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Energy Companies",
      "Reference": "S4M-02523.1",
      "ID": 2626
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5107,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5333769+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3743E222P391VM273160",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 273160,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1886,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 32,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Energy Companies",
      "Reference": "S4M-02523.1",
      "ID": 2626
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3743,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel",
      "DisplayName": "Nigel Don",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3721692+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262867",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262867,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1886,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 32,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Energy Companies",
      "Reference": "S4M-02523.1",
      "ID": 2626
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3771,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob",
      "DisplayName": "Bob Doris",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6263805+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281747",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 281747,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1886,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 32,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Energy Companies",
      "Reference": "S4M-02523.1",
      "ID": 2626
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2826,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Dornan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1559163+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298532",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298532,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1886,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 32,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Energy Companies",
      "Reference": "S4M-02523.1",
      "ID": 2626
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3812,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia",
      "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3501819+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231105",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231105,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1886,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 32,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Energy Companies",
      "Reference": "S4M-02523.1",
      "ID": 2626
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1778,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen",
      "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3658339+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4955E240P389VM287190",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 287190,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1886,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 32,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Energy Companies",
      "Reference": "S4M-02523.1",
      "ID": 2626
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4955,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.6230439+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219630",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 219630,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1886,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 32,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Energy Companies",
      "Reference": "S4M-02523.1",
      "ID": 2626
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1742,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle",
      "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3076776+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1994E257P537VM239119",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239119,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1886,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 32,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Energy Companies",
      "Reference": "S4M-02523.1",
      "ID": 2626
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1994,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus",
      "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4961029+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1814E269P519VM226286",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 226286,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1886,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 32,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Energy Companies",
      "Reference": "S4M-02523.1",
      "ID": 2626
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1814,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda",
      "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.219047+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5059E85P123VM322005",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 322005,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1886,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 32,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Energy Companies",
      "Reference": "S4M-02523.1",
      "ID": 2626
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Fee",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4671598+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292668",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 292668,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1886,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 32,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Energy Companies",
      "Reference": "S4M-02523.1",
      "ID": 2626
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia",
      "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5527102+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227658",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227658,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1886,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 32,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Energy Companies",
      "Reference": "S4M-02523.1",
      "ID": 2626
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5598204+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5054E95P118VM304590",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 304590,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1886,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 32,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Energy Companies",
      "Reference": "S4M-02523.1",
      "ID": 2626
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5054,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.0449265+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4947E152P361VM257957",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257957,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1886,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 32,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Energy Companies",
      "Reference": "S4M-02523.1",
      "ID": 2626
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4947,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Finnie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0851823+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271696",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271696,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1886,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 32,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Energy Companies",
      "Reference": "S4M-02523.1",
      "ID": 2626
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3901,
      "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe",
      "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.08753+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2394E15P47VM274327",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274327,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1886,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 32,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Energy Companies",
      "Reference": "S4M-02523.1",
      "ID": 2626
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2394,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo",
      "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.0958056+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2110E220P414VM266084",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 266084,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1886,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 32,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Energy Companies",
      "Reference": "S4M-02523.1",
      "ID": 2626
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth",
      "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.473668+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250774",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250774,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1886,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 32,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Energy Companies",
      "Reference": "S4M-02523.1",
      "ID": 2626
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2675,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob",
      "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.212965+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221240",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221240,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1886,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 32,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Energy Companies",
      "Reference": "S4M-02523.1",
      "ID": 2626
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1741,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel",
      "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9208003+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1756E218P467VM226434",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 226434,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1886,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 32,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Energy Companies",
      "Reference": "S4M-02523.1",
      "ID": 2626
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1756,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine",
      "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2312292+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1860E104P150VM239702",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239702,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1886,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 32,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Energy Companies",
      "Reference": "S4M-02523.1",
      "ID": 2626
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1860,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda",
      "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7552522+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2033E20P141VM253185",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253185,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1886,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 32,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Energy Companies",
      "Reference": "S4M-02523.1",
      "ID": 2626
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2033,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain",
      "DisplayName": "Iain Gray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7703285+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324406",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324406,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1886,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 32,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Energy Companies",
      "Reference": "S4M-02523.1",
      "ID": 2626
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5042,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2153608+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2892E76P97VM260890",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 260890,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1886,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 32,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Energy Companies",
      "Reference": "S4M-02523.1",
      "ID": 2626
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick",
      "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.1023801+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2029E24P170VM246105",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 246105,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1886,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 32,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Energy Companies",
      "Reference": "S4M-02523.1",
      "ID": 2626
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2029,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh",
      "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8724253+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3758E268P409VM276194",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276194,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1886,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 32,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Energy Companies",
      "Reference": "S4M-02523.1",
      "ID": 2626
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3758,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.4145463+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4086E128P311VM303688",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 303688,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1886,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 32,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Energy Companies",
      "Reference": "S4M-02523.1",
      "ID": 2626
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4086,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Hume",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8260695+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1773E242P494VM222299",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 222299,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1886,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 32,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Energy Companies",
      "Reference": "S4M-02523.1",
      "ID": 2626
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1773,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1827675+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1882E227P459VM245584",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 245584,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1886,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 32,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Energy Companies",
      "Reference": "S4M-02523.1",
      "ID": 2626
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1882,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam",
      "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8497348+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223348",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223348,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1886,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 32,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Energy Companies",
      "Reference": "S4M-02523.1",
      "ID": 2626
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1893,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4540147+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4934E77P103VM308115",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 308115,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1886,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 32,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Energy Companies",
      "Reference": "S4M-02523.1",
      "ID": 2626
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4934,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8653554+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272511",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 272511,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1886,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 32,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Energy Companies",
      "Reference": "S4M-02523.1",
      "ID": 2626
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4956,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Keir",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3385553+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244705",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244705,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1886,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 32,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Energy Companies",
      "Reference": "S4M-02523.1",
      "ID": 2626
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Kelly",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.574724+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3129E261P419VM314724",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 314724,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1886,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 32,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Energy Companies",
      "Reference": "S4M-02523.1",
      "ID": 2626
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3129,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6527637+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2080E36P220VM252508",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252508,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1886,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 32,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Energy Companies",
      "Reference": "S4M-02523.1",
      "ID": 2626
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann",
      "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7321532+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4016E11P36VM275609",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 275609,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1886,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 32,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Energy Companies",
      "Reference": "S4M-02523.1",
      "ID": 2626
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4016,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.3828981+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2180E246P463VM257103",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257103,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1886,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 32,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Energy Companies",
      "Reference": "S4M-02523.1",
      "ID": 2626
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2180,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.82343+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4938E158P374VM282883",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 282883,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1886,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 32,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Energy Companies",
      "Reference": "S4M-02523.1",
      "ID": 2626
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4938,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.4384318+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2112E250P486VM254092",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254092,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1886,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 32,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Energy Companies",
      "Reference": "S4M-02523.1",
      "ID": 2626
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2112,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny",
      "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0341622+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4939E258P394VM278775",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 278775,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1886,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 32,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Energy Companies",
      "Reference": "S4M-02523.1",
      "ID": 2626
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4939,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus",
      "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2337292+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5074E251P385VM324879",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324879,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1886,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 32,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Energy Companies",
      "Reference": "S4M-02523.1",
      "ID": 2626
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5074,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon",
      "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2417173+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1828E3P10VM231932",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231932,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1886,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 32,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Energy Companies",
      "Reference": "S4M-02523.1",
      "ID": 2626
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1828,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo",
      "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6219742+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4948E153P363VM312114",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 312114,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1886,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 32,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Energy Companies",
      "Reference": "S4M-02523.1",
      "ID": 2626
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4948,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike",
      "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.9143263+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2117E90P107VM233095",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 233095,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1886,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 32,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Energy Companies",
      "Reference": "S4M-02523.1",
      "ID": 2626
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2117,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis",
      "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8966188+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267591",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 267591,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1886,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 32,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Energy Companies",
      "Reference": "S4M-02523.1",
      "ID": 2626
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken",
      "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.026493+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313046",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313046,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1886,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 32,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Energy Companies",
      "Reference": "S4M-02523.1",
      "ID": 2626
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4966,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek",
      "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1613004+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3101E102P129VM294384",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 294384,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1886,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 32,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Energy Companies",
      "Reference": "S4M-02523.1",
      "ID": 2626
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3101,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala",
      "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1360131+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319254",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319254,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1886,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 32,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Energy Companies",
      "Reference": "S4M-02523.1",
      "ID": 2626
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5034,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny",
      "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9121327+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2159E25P205VM305790",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 305790,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1886,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 32,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Energy Companies",
      "Reference": "S4M-02523.1",
      "ID": 2626
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2159,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Martin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3454598+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5110E252P395VM310368",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 310368,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1886,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 32,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Energy Companies",
      "Reference": "S4M-02523.1",
      "ID": 2626
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Mason",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5674977+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268013",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 268013,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1886,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 32,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Energy Companies",
      "Reference": "S4M-02523.1",
      "ID": 2626
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2133,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0522233+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2876E141P433VM293042",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 293042,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1886,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 32,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Energy Companies",
      "Reference": "S4M-02523.1",
      "ID": 2626
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2876,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5691294+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4951E147P368VM271438",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271438,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1886,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 32,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Energy Companies",
      "Reference": "S4M-02523.1",
      "ID": 2626
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4951,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan",
      "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0758151+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3896E175P307VM269400",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269400,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1886,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 32,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Energy Companies",
      "Reference": "S4M-02523.1",
      "ID": 2626
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3896,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam",
      "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5459084+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5080E110P121VM307227",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307227,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1886,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 32,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Energy Companies",
      "Reference": "S4M-02523.1",
      "ID": 2626
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8201117+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4964E143P375VM280581",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280581,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1886,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 32,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Energy Companies",
      "Reference": "S4M-02523.1",
      "ID": 2626
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4964,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7733814+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3824E84P113VM281272",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 281272,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1886,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 32,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Energy Companies",
      "Reference": "S4M-02523.1",
      "ID": 2626
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3824,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.127683+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2066E22P91VM245183",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 245183,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1886,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 32,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Energy Companies",
      "Reference": "S4M-02523.1",
      "ID": 2626
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2066,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.6078638+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299285",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 299285,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1886,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 32,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Energy Companies",
      "Reference": "S4M-02523.1",
      "ID": 2626
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.6908932+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3759E260P411VM301785",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 301785,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1886,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 32,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Energy Companies",
      "Reference": "S4M-02523.1",
      "ID": 2626
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina",
      "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.2831384+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300486",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 300486,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1886,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 32,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Energy Companies",
      "Reference": "S4M-02523.1",
      "ID": 2626
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2487,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0002512+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1775E215P453VM224297",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 224297,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1886,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 32,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Energy Companies",
      "Reference": "S4M-02523.1",
      "ID": 2626
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.6928367+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237950",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237950,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1886,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 32,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Energy Companies",
      "Reference": "S4M-02523.1",
      "ID": 2626
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1961,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David",
      "DisplayName": "David McLetchie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2330922+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2134E34P201VM297553",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 297553,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1886,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 32,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Energy Companies",
      "Reference": "S4M-02523.1",
      "ID": 2626
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2134,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1051469+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320016",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 320016,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1886,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 32,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Energy Companies",
      "Reference": "S4M-02523.1",
      "ID": 2626
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5041,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan",
      "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9577791+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315357",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315357,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1886,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 32,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Energy Companies",
      "Reference": "S4M-02523.1",
      "ID": 2626
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3763,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart",
      "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9085134+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1986E23P197VM237236",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237236,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1886,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 32,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Energy Companies",
      "Reference": "S4M-02523.1",
      "ID": 2626
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1986,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan",
      "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.1955343+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5047E100P130VM292578",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 292578,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1886,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 32,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Energy Companies",
      "Reference": "S4M-02523.1",
      "ID": 2626
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5047,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne",
      "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5488315+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234212",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234212,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1886,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 32,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Energy Companies",
      "Reference": "S4M-02523.1",
      "ID": 2626
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1845,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette",
      "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3671044+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3061E19P43VM311638",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311638,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1886,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 32,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Energy Companies",
      "Reference": "S4M-02523.1",
      "ID": 2626
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3061,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8877857+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1768E19P265VM261299",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261299,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1886,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 32,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Energy Companies",
      "Reference": "S4M-02523.1",
      "ID": 2626
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1768,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3513973+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225593",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225593,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1886,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 32,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Energy Companies",
      "Reference": "S4M-02523.1",
      "ID": 2626
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1894,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Neil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9820328+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3815E98P134VM271007",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271007,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1886,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 32,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Energy Companies",
      "Reference": "S4M-02523.1",
      "ID": 2626
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3815,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Park, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Park",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8385175+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265652",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265652,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1886,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 32,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Energy Companies",
      "Reference": "S4M-02523.1",
      "ID": 2626
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2010,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil",
      "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4484614+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283946",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283946,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1886,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 32,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Energy Companies",
      "Reference": "S4M-02523.1",
      "ID": 2626
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5057,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7303107+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2853E33P128VM258718",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258718,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1886,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 32,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Energy Companies",
      "Reference": "S4M-02523.1",
      "ID": 2626
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Pentland",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3196553+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317239",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317239,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1886,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 32,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Energy Companies",
      "Reference": "S4M-02523.1",
      "ID": 2626
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5009,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4098185+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3745E233P381VM256131",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 256131,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1886,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 32,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Energy Companies",
      "Reference": "S4M-02523.1",
      "ID": 2626
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3745,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis",
      "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5719441+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1870E225P478VM293356",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 293356,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1886,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 32,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Energy Companies",
      "Reference": "S4M-02523.1",
      "ID": 2626
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1870,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona",
      "DisplayName": "Shona Robison",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8414845+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2135E254P450VM235988",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235988,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1886,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 32,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Energy Companies",
      "Reference": "S4M-02523.1",
      "ID": 2626
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2135,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Russell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.7015397+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1895E232P431VM255901",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255901,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1886,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 32,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Energy Companies",
      "Reference": "S4M-02523.1",
      "ID": 2626
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1895,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5618595+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1839E21P87VM229351",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229351,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1886,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 32,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Energy Companies",
      "Reference": "S4M-02523.1",
      "ID": 2626
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1839,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0779799+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2345E10P55VM289517",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289517,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1886,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 32,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Energy Companies",
      "Reference": "S4M-02523.1",
      "ID": 2626
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2345,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4406496+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2223E176P333VM310536",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 310536,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1886,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 32,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Energy Companies",
      "Reference": "S4M-02523.1",
      "ID": 2626
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2223,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish",
      "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5751187+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2182E87P175VM247108",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247108,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1886,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 32,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Energy Companies",
      "Reference": "S4M-02523.1",
      "ID": 2626
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2182,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.167411+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298706",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298706,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1886,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 32,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Energy Companies",
      "Reference": "S4M-02523.1",
      "ID": 2626
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5079,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew",
      "DisplayName": "Drew Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3687411+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1769E32P285VM235824",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235824,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1886,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 32,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Energy Companies",
      "Reference": "S4M-02523.1",
      "ID": 2626
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1769,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6945428+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4014E14P26VM275349",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 275349,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1886,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 32,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Energy Companies",
      "Reference": "S4M-02523.1",
      "ID": 2626
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4014,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz",
      "DisplayName": "Liz Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.371372+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2215E224P447VM270067",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270067,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1886,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 32,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Energy Companies",
      "Reference": "S4M-02523.1",
      "ID": 2626
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2215,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5801266+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3806E103P127VM316883",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 316883,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1886,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 32,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Energy Companies",
      "Reference": "S4M-02523.1",
      "ID": 2626
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3806,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.1675439+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326105",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 326105,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1886,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 32,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Energy Companies",
      "Reference": "S4M-02523.1",
      "ID": 2626
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5106,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin",
      "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.54008+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241442",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241442,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1886,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 32,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Energy Companies",
      "Reference": "S4M-02523.1",
      "ID": 2626
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1848,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola",
      "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7581455+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2098E237P531VM288682",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 288682,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1886,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 32,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Energy Companies",
      "Reference": "S4M-02523.1",
      "ID": 2626
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2098,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Swinney",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1538765+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248240",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248240,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1886,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 32,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Energy Companies",
      "Reference": "S4M-02523.1",
      "ID": 2626
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2674,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave",
      "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6373653+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5075E234P371VM290075",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 290075,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1886,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 32,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Energy Companies",
      "Reference": "S4M-02523.1",
      "ID": 2626
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5075,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Torrance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4717055+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1793E151P362VM222683",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 222683,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1886,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 32,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Energy Companies",
      "Reference": "S4M-02523.1",
      "ID": 2626
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1793,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean",
      "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1994427+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5078E245P15VM306899",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306899,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1886,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 32,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Energy Companies",
      "Reference": "S4M-02523.1",
      "ID": 2626
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5078,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Walker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5784057+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1841E231P426VM240833",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 240833,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1886,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 32,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Energy Companies",
      "Reference": "S4M-02523.1",
      "ID": 2626
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1841,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen",
      "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3842513+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4952E148P370VM284102",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 284102,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1886,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 32,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Energy Companies",
      "Reference": "S4M-02523.1",
      "ID": 2626
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4952,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7430907+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1865E263P500VM231055",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231055,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1886,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 32,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Energy Companies",
      "Reference": "S4M-02523.1",
      "ID": 2626
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1865,
      "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra",
      "DisplayName": "Sandra White",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3636964+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2610E160P413VM246746",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 246746,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1886,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 32,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Energy Companies",
      "Reference": "S4M-02523.1",
      "ID": 2626
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2610,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Wilson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1516435+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4941E150P382VM308875",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 308875,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1886,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 77,
      "VoteAgainst": 32,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Energy Companies",
      "Reference": "S4M-02523.1",
      "ID": 2626
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4941,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza",
      "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0818434+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1926E229P470VM253094",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253094,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1884,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 46,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.2",
      "ID": 2625
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1926,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian",
      "DisplayName": "Brian Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7665987+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2615E213P388VM259208",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 259208,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1884,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 46,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.2",
      "ID": 2625
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2615,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George",
      "DisplayName": "George Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.5989178+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4940E159P373VM317817",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317817,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1884,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 46,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.2",
      "ID": 2625
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4940,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare",
      "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4386468+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2641E256P403VM250171",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250171,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1884,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 46,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.2",
      "ID": 2625
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2641,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair",
      "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9665997+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1783E21P273VM228415",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 228415,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1884,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 46,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.2",
      "ID": 2625
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1783,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie",
      "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.7980289+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2633E97P136VM281114",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 281114,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1884,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 46,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.2",
      "ID": 2625
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2633,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire",
      "DisplayName": "Claire Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.8065942+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2603E89P148VM263023",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 263023,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1884,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 46,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.2",
      "ID": 2625
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2603,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6333449+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1759E91P115VM227447",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227447,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1884,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 46,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.2",
      "ID": 2625
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia",
      "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5505538+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3751E243P383VM269663",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269663,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1884,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 46,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.2",
      "ID": 2625
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3751,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5576408+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322495",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 322495,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1884,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 46,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.2",
      "ID": 2625
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5109,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco",
      "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6910914+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5060E86P124VM297356",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 297356,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1884,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 46,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.2",
      "ID": 2625
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5060,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.0964362+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1866E93P239VM243126",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 243126,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1884,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 46,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.2",
      "ID": 2625
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1866,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah",
      "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0500645+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1943E145P367VM227064",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227064,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1884,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 46,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.2",
      "ID": 2625
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1943,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic",
      "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2659507+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2595E12P30VM301025",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 301025,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1884,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 46,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.2",
      "ID": 2625
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2595,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin",
      "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0293433+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2103E244P421VM238430",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 238430,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1884,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 46,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.2",
      "ID": 2625
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2103,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith",
      "DisplayName": "Keith Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4461984+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5108E221P387VM326571",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 326571,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1884,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 46,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.2",
      "ID": 2625
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7704482+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277518",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277518,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1884,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 46,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.2",
      "ID": 2625
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9567948+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2673E236P377VM263967",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 263967,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1884,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 46,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.2",
      "ID": 2625
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2673,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick",
      "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9185017+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2678E11P28VM250974",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250974,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1884,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 46,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.2",
      "ID": 2625
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2678,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson",
      "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.2215567+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2123E27P233VM291153",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291153,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1884,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 46,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.2",
      "ID": 2625
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2123,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm",
      "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7879779+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285373",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285373,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1884,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 46,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.2",
      "ID": 2625
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3907,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3202193+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1735E248P405VM231311",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231311,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1884,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 46,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.2",
      "ID": 2625
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1735,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela",
      "DisplayName": "Angela Constance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.5894705+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243592",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 243592,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1884,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 46,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.2",
      "ID": 2625
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1932,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce",
      "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.311567+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254386",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254386,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1884,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 46,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.2",
      "ID": 2625
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1863,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna",
      "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2535088+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4976E20P31VM321138",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 321138,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1884,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 46,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.2",
      "ID": 2625
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4976,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth",
      "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.2039112+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5107E223P379VM300682",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 300682,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1884,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 46,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.2",
      "ID": 2625
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5107,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0090833+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3743E222P391VM273070",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 273070,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1884,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 46,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.2",
      "ID": 2625
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3743,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel",
      "DisplayName": "Nigel Don",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.368293+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262618",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262618,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1884,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 46,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.2",
      "ID": 2625
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3771,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob",
      "DisplayName": "Bob Doris",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.609623+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281779",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 281779,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1884,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 46,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.2",
      "ID": 2625
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2826,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Dornan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1572608+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298502",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298502,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1884,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 46,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.2",
      "ID": 2625
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3812,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia",
      "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3488864+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231107",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231107,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1884,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 46,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.2",
      "ID": 2625
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1778,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen",
      "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3659144+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4955E240P389VM284909",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 284909,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1884,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 46,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.2",
      "ID": 2625
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4955,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0529141+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219601",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 219601,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1884,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 46,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.2",
      "ID": 2625
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1742,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle",
      "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3064078+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238220",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 238220,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1884,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 46,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.2",
      "ID": 2625
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1994,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus",
      "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4369842+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1814E269P519VM226288",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 226288,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1884,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 46,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.2",
      "ID": 2625
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1814,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda",
      "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2191288+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321965",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 321965,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1884,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 46,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.2",
      "ID": 2625
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Fee",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4590529+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292670",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 292670,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1884,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 46,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.2",
      "ID": 2625
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia",
      "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.552792+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227629",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227629,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1884,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 46,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.2",
      "ID": 2625
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5584487+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5054E95P118VM304588",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 304588,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1884,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 46,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.2",
      "ID": 2625
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5054,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.0448468+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4947E152P361VM257955",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257955,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1884,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 46,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.2",
      "ID": 2625
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4947,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Finnie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0851003+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271041",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271041,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1884,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 46,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.2",
      "ID": 2625
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3901,
      "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe",
      "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8399727+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2394E15P47VM274359",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274359,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1884,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 46,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.2",
      "ID": 2625
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2394,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo",
      "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1026431+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2110E220P414VM266082",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 266082,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1884,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 46,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.2",
      "ID": 2625
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth",
      "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4735867+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250772",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250772,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1884,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 46,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.2",
      "ID": 2625
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2675,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob",
      "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.2128838+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221238",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221238,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1884,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 46,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.2",
      "ID": 2625
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1741,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel",
      "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9207167+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1756E218P467VM226463",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 226463,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1884,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 46,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.2",
      "ID": 2625
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1756,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine",
      "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2324983+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1860E104P150VM239700",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239700,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1884,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 46,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.2",
      "ID": 2625
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1860,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda",
      "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7551707+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2033E20P141VM253218",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253218,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1884,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 46,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.2",
      "ID": 2625
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2033,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain",
      "DisplayName": "Iain Gray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.9864676+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324409",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324409,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1884,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 46,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.2",
      "ID": 2625
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5042,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.221379+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2892E76P97VM261603",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261603,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1884,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 46,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.2",
      "ID": 2625
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick",
      "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3645951+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239523",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239523,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1884,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 46,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.2",
      "ID": 2625
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2029,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh",
      "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7474443+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273593",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 273593,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1884,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 46,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.2",
      "ID": 2625
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3758,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6270672+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4086E128P311VM303690",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 303690,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1884,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 46,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.2",
      "ID": 2625
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4086,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Hume",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.826151+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1773E242P494VM222301",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 222301,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1884,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 46,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.2",
      "ID": 2625
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1773,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1828505+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1882E227P459VM245586",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 245586,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1884,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 46,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.2",
      "ID": 2625
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1882,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam",
      "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8498165+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223351",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223351,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1884,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 46,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.2",
      "ID": 2625
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1893,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4541383+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307931",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307931,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1884,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 46,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.2",
      "ID": 2625
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4934,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8570991+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272509",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 272509,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1884,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 46,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.2",
      "ID": 2625
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4956,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Keir",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3384728+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2059E26P131VM245136",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 245136,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1884,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 46,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.2",
      "ID": 2625
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Kelly",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5935974+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3129E261P419VM314730",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 314730,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1884,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 46,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.2",
      "ID": 2625
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3129,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6530113+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247438",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247438,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1884,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 46,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.2",
      "ID": 2625
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann",
      "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4038171+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4016E11P36VM275509",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 275509,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1884,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 46,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.2",
      "ID": 2625
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4016,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.3783232+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255440",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255440,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1884,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 46,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.2",
      "ID": 2625
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2180,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5314466+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4938E158P374VM276890",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276890,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1884,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 46,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.2",
      "ID": 2625
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4938,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6855071+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2112E250P486VM253524",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253524,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1884,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 46,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.2",
      "ID": 2625
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2112,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny",
      "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0001336+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4939E258P394VM278872",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 278872,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1884,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 46,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.2",
      "ID": 2625
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4939,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus",
      "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2378697+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5074E251P385VM324876",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324876,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1884,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 46,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.2",
      "ID": 2625
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5074,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon",
      "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2415959+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1828E3P10VM231930",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231930,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1884,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 46,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.2",
      "ID": 2625
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1828,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo",
      "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6218915+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311775",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311775,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1884,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 46,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.2",
      "ID": 2625
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4948,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike",
      "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8937467+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2117E90P107VM233191",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 233191,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1884,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 46,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.2",
      "ID": 2625
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2117,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis",
      "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.9007916+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267559",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 267559,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1884,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 46,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.2",
      "ID": 2625
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken",
      "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0250997+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313077",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313077,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1884,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 46,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.2",
      "ID": 2625
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4966,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek",
      "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1626497+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3101E102P129VM294415",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 294415,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1884,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 46,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.2",
      "ID": 2625
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3101,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala",
      "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1373415+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319214",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319214,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1884,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 46,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.2",
      "ID": 2625
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5034,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny",
      "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9103639+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2159E25P205VM305784",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 305784,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1884,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 46,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.2",
      "ID": 2625
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2159,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Martin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.345189+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5110E252P395VM310370",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 310370,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1884,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 46,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.2",
      "ID": 2625
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Mason",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5676059+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268045",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 268045,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1884,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 46,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.2",
      "ID": 2625
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2133,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0536215+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2876E141P433VM293011",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 293011,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1884,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 46,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.2",
      "ID": 2625
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2876,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5677972+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4951E147P368VM271440",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271440,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1884,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 46,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.2",
      "ID": 2625
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4951,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan",
      "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0758973+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3896E175P307VM269806",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269806,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1884,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 46,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.2",
      "ID": 2625
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3896,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam",
      "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5637312+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5080E110P121VM307225",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307225,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1884,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 46,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.2",
      "ID": 2625
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8200281+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4964E143P375VM280183",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280183,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1884,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 46,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.2",
      "ID": 2625
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4964,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5449922+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279155",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279155,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1884,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 46,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.2",
      "ID": 2625
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3824,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2554119+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2066E22P91VM260384",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 260384,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1884,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 46,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.2",
      "ID": 2625
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2066,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.0745496+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299316",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 299316,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1884,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 46,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.2",
      "ID": 2625
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.6922227+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3759E260P411VM301783",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 301783,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1884,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 46,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.2",
      "ID": 2625
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina",
      "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.2830576+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300488",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 300488,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1884,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 46,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.2",
      "ID": 2625
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2487,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0003333+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1775E215P453VM224295",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 224295,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1884,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 46,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.2",
      "ID": 2625
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.6927543+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237948",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237948,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1884,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 46,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.2",
      "ID": 2625
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1961,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David",
      "DisplayName": "David McLetchie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2329899+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2134E34P201VM297712",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 297712,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1884,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 46,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.2",
      "ID": 2625
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2134,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1215945+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320056",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 320056,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1884,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 46,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.2",
      "ID": 2625
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5041,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan",
      "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9596188+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315351",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315351,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1884,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 46,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.2",
      "ID": 2625
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3763,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart",
      "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9082409+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1986E23P197VM237147",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237147,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1884,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 46,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.2",
      "ID": 2625
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1986,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan",
      "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9678097+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5047E100P130VM288899",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 288899,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1884,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 46,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.2",
      "ID": 2625
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5047,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne",
      "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1631604+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234214",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234214,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1884,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 46,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.2",
      "ID": 2625
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1845,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette",
      "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3671867+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3061E19P43VM311632",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311632,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1884,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 46,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.2",
      "ID": 2625
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3061,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8875324+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1768E19P265VM261297",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261297,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1884,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 46,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.2",
      "ID": 2625
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1768,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3512952+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225590",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225590,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1884,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 46,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.2",
      "ID": 2625
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1894,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Neil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9818887+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3815E98P134VM271004",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271004,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1884,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 46,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.2",
      "ID": 2625
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3815,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Park, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Park",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8383966+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265654",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265654,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1884,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 46,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.2",
      "ID": 2625
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2010,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil",
      "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4485427+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5057E92P116VM284199",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 284199,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1884,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 46,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.2",
      "ID": 2625
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5057,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0157234+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2853E33P128VM252135",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252135,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1884,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 46,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.2",
      "ID": 2625
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Pentland",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.5041018+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317279",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317279,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1884,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 46,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.2",
      "ID": 2625
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5009,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4115771+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3745E233P381VM256133",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 256133,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1884,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 46,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.2",
      "ID": 2625
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3745,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis",
      "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5720264+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1870E225P478VM293354",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 293354,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1884,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 46,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.2",
      "ID": 2625
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1870,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona",
      "DisplayName": "Shona Robison",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.841404+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2135E254P450VM235892",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235892,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1884,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 46,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.2",
      "ID": 2625
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2135,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Russell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6974196+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1895E232P431VM255899",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255899,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1884,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 46,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.2",
      "ID": 2625
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1895,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5617798+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1839E21P87VM229349",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229349,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1884,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 46,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.2",
      "ID": 2625
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1839,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0778941+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2345E10P55VM289519",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289519,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1884,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 46,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.2",
      "ID": 2625
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2345,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4407304+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2223E176P333VM310542",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 310542,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1884,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 46,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.2",
      "ID": 2625
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2223,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish",
      "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5753662+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2182E87P175VM247106",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247106,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1884,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 46,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.2",
      "ID": 2625
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2182,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.167309+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298685",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298685,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1884,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 46,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.2",
      "ID": 2625
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5079,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew",
      "DisplayName": "Drew Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3678422+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1769E32P285VM233839",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 233839,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1884,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 46,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.2",
      "ID": 2625
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1769,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.148561+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274945",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274945,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1884,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 46,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.2",
      "ID": 2625
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4014,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz",
      "DisplayName": "Liz Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1288214+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2215E224P447VM270035",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270035,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1884,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 46,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.2",
      "ID": 2625
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2215,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5787485+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3806E103P127VM316889",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 316889,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1884,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 46,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.2",
      "ID": 2625
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3806,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.1678084+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326108",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 326108,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1884,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 46,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.2",
      "ID": 2625
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5106,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin",
      "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5402232+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241440",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241440,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1884,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 46,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.2",
      "ID": 2625
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1848,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola",
      "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7580449+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2098E237P531VM291111",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291111,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1884,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 46,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.2",
      "ID": 2625
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2098,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Swinney",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7861745+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248144",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248144,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1884,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 46,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.2",
      "ID": 2625
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2674,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave",
      "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4447304+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5075E234P371VM289210",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289210,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1884,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 46,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.2",
      "ID": 2625
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5075,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Torrance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4271723+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1793E151P362VM222680",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 222680,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1884,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 46,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.2",
      "ID": 2625
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1793,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean",
      "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.19932+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5078E245P15VM306901",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306901,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1884,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 46,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.2",
      "ID": 2625
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5078,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Walker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5786209+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1841E231P426VM240835",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 240835,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1884,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 46,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.2",
      "ID": 2625
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1841,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen",
      "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3843317+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4952E148P370VM284002",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 284002,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1884,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 46,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.2",
      "ID": 2625
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4952,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.73275+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1865E263P500VM231092",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231092,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1884,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 46,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.2",
      "ID": 2625
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1865,
      "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra",
      "DisplayName": "Sandra White",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3652588+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2610E160P413VM247294",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247294,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1884,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 46,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.2",
      "ID": 2625
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2610,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Wilson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.3973983+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4941E150P382VM308906",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 308906,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1884,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 46,
      "VoteAgainst": 63,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.2",
      "ID": 2625
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4941,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza",
      "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0831682+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1926E229P470VM253095",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253095,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1885,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.1",
      "ID": 2613
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1926,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian",
      "DisplayName": "Brian Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7666581+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2615E213P388VM259209",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 259209,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1885,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.1",
      "ID": 2613
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2615,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George",
      "DisplayName": "George Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.5989602+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4940E159P373VM317979",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317979,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1885,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.1",
      "ID": 2613
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4940,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare",
      "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4517547+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2641E256P403VM250170",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250170,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1885,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.1",
      "ID": 2613
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2641,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair",
      "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9665524+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1783E21P273VM228417",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 228417,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1885,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.1",
      "ID": 2613
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1783,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie",
      "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.7981112+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2633E97P136VM281115",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 281115,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1885,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.1",
      "ID": 2613
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2633,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire",
      "DisplayName": "Claire Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.8066345+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2603E89P148VM263109",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 263109,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1885,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.1",
      "ID": 2613
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2603,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6371475+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1759E91P115VM227448",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227448,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1885,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.1",
      "ID": 2613
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia",
      "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5505937+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3751E243P383VM269662",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269662,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1885,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.1",
      "ID": 2613
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3751,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5575997+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322454",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 322454,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1885,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.1",
      "ID": 2613
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5109,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco",
      "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6893272+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5060E86P124VM297334",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 297334,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1885,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.1",
      "ID": 2613
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5060,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.0954865+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242695",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242695,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1885,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.1",
      "ID": 2613
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1866,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah",
      "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0316372+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1943E145P367VM227063",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227063,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1885,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.1",
      "ID": 2613
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1943,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic",
      "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2659081+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2595E12P30VM301026",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 301026,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1885,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.1",
      "ID": 2613
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2595,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin",
      "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0293841+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2103E244P421VM262009",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262009,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1885,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.1",
      "ID": 2613
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2103,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith",
      "DisplayName": "Keith Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3876875+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5108E221P387VM326580",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 326580,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1885,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.1",
      "ID": 2613
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7708487+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277607",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277607,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1885,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.1",
      "ID": 2613
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9605814+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2673E236P377VM265000",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265000,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1885,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.1",
      "ID": 2613
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2673,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick",
      "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.163823+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2678E11P28VM250973",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250973,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1885,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.1",
      "ID": 2613
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2678,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson",
      "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.2215167+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2123E27P233VM291160",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291160,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1885,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.1",
      "ID": 2613
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2123,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm",
      "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7882653+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285460",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285460,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1885,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.1",
      "ID": 2613
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3907,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3302067+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1735E248P405VM231398",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231398,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1885,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.1",
      "ID": 2613
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1735,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela",
      "DisplayName": "Angela Constance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.598465+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243176",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 243176,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1885,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.1",
      "ID": 2613
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1932,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce",
      "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0574262+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254385",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254385,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1885,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.1",
      "ID": 2613
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1863,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna",
      "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2533977+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4976E20P31VM321147",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 321147,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1885,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.1",
      "ID": 2613
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4976,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth",
      "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.2042829+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5107E223P379VM300681",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 300681,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1885,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.1",
      "ID": 2613
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5107,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0090428+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3743E222P391VM273159",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 273159,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1885,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.1",
      "ID": 2613
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3743,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel",
      "DisplayName": "Nigel Don",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3721282+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262619",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262619,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1885,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.1",
      "ID": 2613
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3771,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob",
      "DisplayName": "Bob Doris",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.609663+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281752",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 281752,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1885,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.1",
      "ID": 2613
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2826,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Dornan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1561159+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298528",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298528,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1885,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.1",
      "ID": 2613
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3812,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia",
      "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3500123+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231106",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231106,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1885,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.1",
      "ID": 2613
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1778,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen",
      "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3658742+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4955E240P389VM284908",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 284908,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1885,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.1",
      "ID": 2613
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4955,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0528739+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219602",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 219602,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1885,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.1",
      "ID": 2613
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1742,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle",
      "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3064677+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238219",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 238219,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1885,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.1",
      "ID": 2613
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1994,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus",
      "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4368115+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1814E269P519VM226287",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 226287,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1885,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.1",
      "ID": 2613
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1814,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda",
      "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2190879+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5059E85P123VM322006",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 322006,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1885,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.1",
      "ID": 2613
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Fee",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4672007+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292669",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 292669,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1885,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.1",
      "ID": 2613
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia",
      "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5527516+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227630",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227630,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1885,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.1",
      "ID": 2613
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5584929+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5054E95P118VM304589",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 304589,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1885,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.1",
      "ID": 2613
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5054,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.0448866+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4947E152P361VM257956",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257956,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1885,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.1",
      "ID": 2613
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4947,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Finnie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0851413+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271040",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271040,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1885,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.1",
      "ID": 2613
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3901,
      "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe",
      "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8399316+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2394E15P47VM274357",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274357,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1885,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.1",
      "ID": 2613
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2394,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo",
      "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1025571+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2110E220P414VM266083",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 266083,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1885,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.1",
      "ID": 2613
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth",
      "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4736271+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250773",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250773,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1885,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.1",
      "ID": 2613
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2675,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob",
      "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.2129247+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221239",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221239,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1885,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.1",
      "ID": 2613
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1741,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel",
      "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9207587+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1756E218P467VM226462",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 226462,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1885,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.1",
      "ID": 2613
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1756,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine",
      "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2324385+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1860E104P150VM239701",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239701,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1885,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.1",
      "ID": 2613
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1860,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda",
      "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7552113+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2033E20P141VM253216",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253216,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1885,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.1",
      "ID": 2613
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2033,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain",
      "DisplayName": "Iain Gray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.9863831+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324400",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324400,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1885,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.1",
      "ID": 2613
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5042,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2151135+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2892E76P97VM261602",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261602,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1885,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.1",
      "ID": 2613
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick",
      "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.364555+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239524",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239524,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1885,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.1",
      "ID": 2613
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2029,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh",
      "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7474842+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3758E268P409VM276195",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276195,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1885,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.1",
      "ID": 2613
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3758,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.4145873+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4086E128P311VM303689",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 303689,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1885,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.1",
      "ID": 2613
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4086,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Hume",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8261104+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1773E242P494VM222300",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 222300,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1885,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.1",
      "ID": 2613
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1773,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.182809+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1882E227P459VM245585",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 245585,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1885,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.1",
      "ID": 2613
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1882,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam",
      "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.849775+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223350",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223350,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1885,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.1",
      "ID": 2613
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1893,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4540971+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4934E77P103VM308111",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 308111,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1885,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.1",
      "ID": 2613
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4934,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8651892+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272510",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 272510,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1885,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.1",
      "ID": 2613
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4956,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Keir",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3385139+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244704",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244704,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1885,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.1",
      "ID": 2613
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Kelly",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.574684+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3129E261P419VM314723",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 314723,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1885,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.1",
      "ID": 2613
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3129,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.652723+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247437",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247437,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1885,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.1",
      "ID": 2613
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann",
      "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4037767+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4016E11P36VM275510",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 275510,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1885,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.1",
      "ID": 2613
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4016,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.3783636+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255439",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255439,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1885,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.1",
      "ID": 2613
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2180,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5313865+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4938E158P374VM276889",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276889,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1885,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.1",
      "ID": 2613
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4938,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6854666+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2112E250P486VM253525",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253525,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1885,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.1",
      "ID": 2613
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2112,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny",
      "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0001746+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4939E258P394VM278871",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 278871,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1885,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.1",
      "ID": 2613
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4939,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus",
      "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.23783+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5074E251P385VM324885",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324885,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1885,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.1",
      "ID": 2613
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5074,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon",
      "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2419809+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1828E3P10VM231931",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231931,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1885,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.1",
      "ID": 2613
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1828,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo",
      "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6219327+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4948E153P363VM312110",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 312110,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1885,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.1",
      "ID": 2613
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4948,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike",
      "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.9141415+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2117E90P107VM233190",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 233190,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1885,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.1",
      "ID": 2613
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2117,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis",
      "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.900751+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267561",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 267561,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1885,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.1",
      "ID": 2613
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken",
      "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0251817+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313050",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313050,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1885,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.1",
      "ID": 2613
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4966,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek",
      "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1614644+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3101E102P129VM294389",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 294389,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1885,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.1",
      "ID": 2613
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3101,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala",
      "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1362367+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319255",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319255,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1885,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.1",
      "ID": 2613
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5034,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny",
      "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9121734+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2159E25P205VM305791",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 305791,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1885,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.1",
      "ID": 2613
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2159,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Martin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3455009+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5110E252P395VM310369",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 310369,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1885,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.1",
      "ID": 2613
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Mason",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5675632+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268043",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 268043,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1885,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.1",
      "ID": 2613
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2133,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0535387+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2876E141P433VM293037",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 293037,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1885,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.1",
      "ID": 2613
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2876,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5689052+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4951E147P368VM271439",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271439,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1885,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.1",
      "ID": 2613
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4951,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan",
      "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0758562+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3896E175P307VM269805",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269805,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1885,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.1",
      "ID": 2613
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3896,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam",
      "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5636907+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5080E110P121VM307226",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307226,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1885,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.1",
      "ID": 2613
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8200698+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4964E143P375VM280184",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280184,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1885,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.1",
      "ID": 2613
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4964,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5450323+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3824E84P113VM281273",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 281273,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1885,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.1",
      "ID": 2613
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3824,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1277237+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2066E22P91VM245184",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 245184,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1885,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.1",
      "ID": 2613
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2066,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8235753+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299289",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 299289,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1885,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.1",
      "ID": 2613
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.6910567+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3759E260P411VM301784",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 301784,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1885,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.1",
      "ID": 2613
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina",
      "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.2830979+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300487",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 300487,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1885,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.1",
      "ID": 2613
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2487,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0002927+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1775E215P453VM224296",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 224296,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1885,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.1",
      "ID": 2613
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.6927953+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237949",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237949,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1885,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.1",
      "ID": 2613
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1961,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David",
      "DisplayName": "David McLetchie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2330505+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2134E34P201VM297552",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 297552,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1885,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.1",
      "ID": 2613
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2134,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1051062+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320015",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 320015,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1885,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.1",
      "ID": 2613
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5041,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan",
      "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9577371+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315358",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315358,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1885,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.1",
      "ID": 2613
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3763,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart",
      "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.908556+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1986E23P197VM237235",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237235,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1885,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.1",
      "ID": 2613
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1986,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan",
      "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.195492+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5047E100P130VM292579",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 292579,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1885,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.1",
      "ID": 2613
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5047,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne",
      "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5489185+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234213",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234213,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1885,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.1",
      "ID": 2613
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1845,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette",
      "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3671462+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3061E19P43VM311950",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311950,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1885,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.1",
      "ID": 2613
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3061,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.9072398+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1768E19P265VM261298",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261298,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1885,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.1",
      "ID": 2613
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1768,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3513547+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225591",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225591,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1885,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.1",
      "ID": 2613
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1894,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Neil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9819488+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3815E98P134VM271005",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271005,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1885,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.1",
      "ID": 2613
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3815,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Park, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Park",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8384371+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265653",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265653,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1885,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.1",
      "ID": 2613
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2010,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil",
      "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4485023+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5057E92P116VM284198",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 284198,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1885,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.1",
      "ID": 2613
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5057,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0156732+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2853E33P128VM252136",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252136,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1885,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.1",
      "ID": 2613
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Pentland",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.5041425+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317238",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317238,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1885,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.1",
      "ID": 2613
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5009,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4097767+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3745E233P381VM256132",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 256132,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1885,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.1",
      "ID": 2613
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3745,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis",
      "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5719857+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1870E225P478VM293355",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 293355,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1885,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.1",
      "ID": 2613
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1870,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona",
      "DisplayName": "Shona Robison",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8414443+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2135E254P450VM235893",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235893,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1885,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.1",
      "ID": 2613
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2135,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Russell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6974813+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1895E232P431VM255900",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255900,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1885,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.1",
      "ID": 2613
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1895,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5618197+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1839E21P87VM229350",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229350,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1885,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.1",
      "ID": 2613
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1839,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0779376+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2345E10P55VM289518",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289518,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1885,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.1",
      "ID": 2613
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2345,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4406901+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2223E176P333VM310535",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 310535,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1885,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.1",
      "ID": 2613
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2223,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish",
      "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.575078+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2182E87P175VM247107",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247107,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1885,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.1",
      "ID": 2613
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2182,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1673675+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298707",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298707,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1885,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.1",
      "ID": 2613
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5079,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew",
      "DisplayName": "Drew Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3687808+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1769E32P285VM235825",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235825,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1885,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.1",
      "ID": 2613
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1769,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6945828+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274946",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274946,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1885,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.1",
      "ID": 2613
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4014,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz",
      "DisplayName": "Liz Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1288625+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2215E224P447VM270037",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270037,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1885,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.1",
      "ID": 2613
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2215,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5788315+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3806E103P127VM316882",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 316882,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1885,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.1",
      "ID": 2613
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3806,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.1675032+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326099",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 326099,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1885,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.1",
      "ID": 2613
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5106,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin",
      "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5398341+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241441",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241441,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1885,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.1",
      "ID": 2613
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1848,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola",
      "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7581043+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2098E237P531VM288681",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 288681,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1885,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.1",
      "ID": 2613
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2098,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Swinney",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1538364+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248145",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248145,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1885,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.1",
      "ID": 2613
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2674,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave",
      "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4447843+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5075E234P371VM289211",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289211,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1885,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.1",
      "ID": 2613
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5075,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Torrance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4273331+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1793E151P362VM222681",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 222681,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1885,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.1",
      "ID": 2613
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1793,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean",
      "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1993604+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5078E245P15VM306900",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306900,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1885,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.1",
      "ID": 2613
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5078,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Walker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5785718+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1841E231P426VM240834",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 240834,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1885,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.1",
      "ID": 2613
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1841,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen",
      "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3842914+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4952E148P370VM284003",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 284003,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1885,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.1",
      "ID": 2613
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4952,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7327927+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1865E263P500VM231090",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231090,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1885,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.1",
      "ID": 2613
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1865,
      "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra",
      "DisplayName": "Sandra White",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3651771+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2610E160P413VM247293",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247293,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1885,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.1",
      "ID": 2613
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2610,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Wilson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.3973574+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4941E150P382VM308879",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 308879,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1885,
      "AgendaID": 2752,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Cycling",
      "Reference": "S4M-02522.1",
      "ID": 2613
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4941,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza",
      "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-29T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0820089+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252692",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252692,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1881,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 81,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.4",
      "ID": 2608
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1926,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian",
      "DisplayName": "Brian Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7494738+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2615E213P388VM258897",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258897,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1881,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 81,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.4",
      "ID": 2608
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2615,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George",
      "DisplayName": "George Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3329205+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319658",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319658,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1881,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 81,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.4",
      "ID": 2608
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4940,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare",
      "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9357659+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249587",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 249587,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1881,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 81,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.4",
      "ID": 2608
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2641,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair",
      "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9332749+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1783E21P273VM227803",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227803,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1881,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 81,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.4",
      "ID": 2608
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1783,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie",
      "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5662976+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2633E97P136VM280806",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280806,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1881,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 81,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.4",
      "ID": 2608
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2633,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire",
      "DisplayName": "Claire Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7831671+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262710",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262710,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1881,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 81,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.4",
      "ID": 2608
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2603,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6135347+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1759E91P115VM229795",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229795,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1881,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 81,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.4",
      "ID": 2608
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia",
      "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0973643+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270130",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270130,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1881,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 81,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.4",
      "ID": 2608
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3751,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5828364+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322674",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 322674,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1881,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 81,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.4",
      "ID": 2608
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5109,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco",
      "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6988364+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5060E86P124VM294785",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 294785,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1881,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 81,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.4",
      "ID": 2608
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5060,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1782302+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242942",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242942,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1881,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 81,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.4",
      "ID": 2608
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1866,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah",
      "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0421431+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235192",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235192,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1881,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 81,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.4",
      "ID": 2608
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1943,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic",
      "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4233403+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302360",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 302360,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1881,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 81,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.4",
      "ID": 2608
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2595,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin",
      "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5210399+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244293",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244293,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1881,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 81,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.4",
      "ID": 2608
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2103,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith",
      "DisplayName": "Keith Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.548411+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327161",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 327161,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1881,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 81,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.4",
      "ID": 2608
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.8017982+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277049",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277049,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1881,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 81,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.4",
      "ID": 2608
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6988608+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264280",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264280,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1881,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 81,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.4",
      "ID": 2608
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2673,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick",
      "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1264838+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248727",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248727,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1881,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 81,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.4",
      "ID": 2608
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2678,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson",
      "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6672005+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2123E27P233VM295740",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295740,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1881,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 81,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.4",
      "ID": 2608
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2123,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm",
      "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5338819+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285214",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285214,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1881,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 81,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.4",
      "ID": 2608
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3907,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3132202+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230690",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230690,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1881,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 81,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.4",
      "ID": 2608
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1735,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela",
      "DisplayName": "Angela Constance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3410117+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243777",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 243777,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1881,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 81,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.4",
      "ID": 2608
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1932,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce",
      "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.319328+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254886",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254886,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1881,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 81,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.4",
      "ID": 2608
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1863,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna",
      "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2880165+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323768",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 323768,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1881,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 81,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.4",
      "ID": 2608
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4976,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth",
      "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9710794+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5107E223P379VM291287",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291287,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1881,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 81,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.4",
      "ID": 2608
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5107,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1124465+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3743E222P391VM265386",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265386,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1881,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 81,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.4",
      "ID": 2608
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3743,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel",
      "DisplayName": "Nigel Don",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4369473+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262297",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262297,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1881,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 81,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.4",
      "ID": 2608
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3771,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob",
      "DisplayName": "Bob Doris",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.595407+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281934",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 281934,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1881,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 81,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.4",
      "ID": 2608
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2826,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Dornan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1640667+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298192",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298192,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1881,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 81,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.4",
      "ID": 2608
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3812,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia",
      "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1424806+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231242",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231242,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1881,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 81,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.4",
      "ID": 2608
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1778,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen",
      "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.5865341+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4955E240P389VM285892",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285892,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1881,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 81,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.4",
      "ID": 2608
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4955,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3490324+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219436",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 219436,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1881,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 81,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.4",
      "ID": 2608
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1742,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle",
      "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.2988963+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238528",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 238528,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1881,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 81,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.4",
      "ID": 2608
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1994,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus",
      "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4579743+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225240",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225240,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1881,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 81,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.4",
      "ID": 2608
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1814,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda",
      "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9608325+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321786",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 321786,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1881,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 81,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.4",
      "ID": 2608
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Fee",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4513108+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292852",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 292852,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1881,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 81,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.4",
      "ID": 2608
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia",
      "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5608665+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227161",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227161,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1881,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 81,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.4",
      "ID": 2608
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.270444+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5054E95P118VM312720",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 312720,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1881,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 81,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.4",
      "ID": 2608
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5054,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1404371+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4947E152P361VM257233",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257233,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1881,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 81,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.4",
      "ID": 2608
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4947,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Finnie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0472898+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271248",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271248,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1881,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 81,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.4",
      "ID": 2608
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3901,
      "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe",
      "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0620962+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278071",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 278071,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1881,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 81,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.4",
      "ID": 2608
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2394,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo",
      "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9857518+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2110E220P414VM287255",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 287255,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1881,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 81,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.4",
      "ID": 2608
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth",
      "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8563228+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250511",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250511,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1881,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 81,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.4",
      "ID": 2608
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2675,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob",
      "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1926828+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1741E10P50VM220977",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220977,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1881,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 81,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.4",
      "ID": 2608
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1741,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel",
      "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6697889+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220208",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220208,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1881,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 81,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.4",
      "ID": 2608
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1756,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine",
      "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3389928+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1860E104P150VM252380",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252380,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1881,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 81,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.4",
      "ID": 2608
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1860,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda",
      "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7266881+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2033E20P141VM253840",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253840,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1881,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 81,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.4",
      "ID": 2608
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2033,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain",
      "DisplayName": "Iain Gray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0231232+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324637",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324637,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1881,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 81,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.4",
      "ID": 2608
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5042,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2315144+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259674",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 259674,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1881,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 81,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.4",
      "ID": 2608
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick",
      "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6196308+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239368",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239368,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1881,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 81,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.4",
      "ID": 2608
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2029,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh",
      "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7337942+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273751",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 273751,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1881,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 81,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.4",
      "ID": 2608
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3758,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6341109+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304125",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 304125,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1881,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 81,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.4",
      "ID": 2608
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4086,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Hume",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8507251+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221718",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221718,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1881,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 81,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.4",
      "ID": 2608
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1773,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9447907+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1882E227P459VM241950",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241950,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1881,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 81,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.4",
      "ID": 2608
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1882,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam",
      "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7871518+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223506",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223506,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1881,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 81,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.4",
      "ID": 2608
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1893,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4613749+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307620",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307620,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1881,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 81,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.4",
      "ID": 2608
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4934,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8376818+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272248",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 272248,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1881,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 81,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.4",
      "ID": 2608
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4956,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Keir",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3214796+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244952",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244952,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1881,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 81,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.4",
      "ID": 2608
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Kelly",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5856329+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315122",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315122,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1881,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 81,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.4",
      "ID": 2608
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3129,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6752624+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247900",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247900,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1881,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 81,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.4",
      "ID": 2608
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann",
      "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4332125+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4016E11P36VM274838",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274838,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1881,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 81,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.4",
      "ID": 2608
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4016,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1239389+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255751",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255751,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1881,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 81,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.4",
      "ID": 2608
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2180,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5553295+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4938E158P374VM277407",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277407,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1881,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 81,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.4",
      "ID": 2608
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4938,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9520596+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2112E250P486VM253061",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253061,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1881,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 81,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.4",
      "ID": 2608
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2112,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny",
      "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7651618+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4939E258P394VM276793",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276793,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1881,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 81,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.4",
      "ID": 2608
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4939,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus",
      "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6813391+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325494",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 325494,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1881,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 81,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.4",
      "ID": 2608
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5074,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon",
      "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5088011+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1828E3P10VM232885",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232885,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1881,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 81,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.4",
      "ID": 2608
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1828,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo",
      "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.880803+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311465",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311465,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1881,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 81,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.4",
      "ID": 2608
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4948,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike",
      "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8799973+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2117E90P107VM230361",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230361,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1881,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 81,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.4",
      "ID": 2608
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2117,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis",
      "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3196739+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267404",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 267404,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1881,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 81,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.4",
      "ID": 2608
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken",
      "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0183681+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313697",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313697,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1881,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 81,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.4",
      "ID": 2608
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4966,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek",
      "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4066182+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3101E102P129VM295036",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295036,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1881,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 81,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.4",
      "ID": 2608
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3101,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala",
      "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1894485+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319036",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319036,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1881,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 81,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.4",
      "ID": 2608
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5034,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny",
      "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6896826+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306365",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306365,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1881,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 81,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.4",
      "ID": 2608
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2159,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Martin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5489614+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5110E252P395VM310855",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 310855,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1881,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 81,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.4",
      "ID": 2608
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Mason",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5889192+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268199",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 268199,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1881,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 81,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.4",
      "ID": 2608
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2133,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.253066+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2876E141P433VM286374",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286374,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1881,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 81,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.4",
      "ID": 2608
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2876,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5761736+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4951E147P368VM258623",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258623,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1881,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 81,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.4",
      "ID": 2608
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4951,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan",
      "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3153336+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3896E175P307VM263841",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 263841,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1881,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 81,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.4",
      "ID": 2608
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3896,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam",
      "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9127188+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308477",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 308477,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1881,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 81,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.4",
      "ID": 2608
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0576079+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4964E143P375VM279709",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279709,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1881,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 81,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.4",
      "ID": 2608
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4964,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5192829+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279623",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279623,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1881,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 81,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.4",
      "ID": 2608
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3824,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5156056+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2066E22P91VM261036",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261036,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1881,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 81,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.4",
      "ID": 2608
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2066,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.1090443+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299626",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 299626,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1881,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 81,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.4",
      "ID": 2608
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.705822+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306664",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306664,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1881,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 81,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.4",
      "ID": 2608
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina",
      "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.562058+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2487E146P369VM301130",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 301130,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1881,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 81,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.4",
      "ID": 2608
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2487,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0348643+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223880",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223880,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1881,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 81,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.4",
      "ID": 2608
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4777464+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237539",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237539,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1881,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 81,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.4",
      "ID": 2608
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1961,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David",
      "DisplayName": "David McLetchie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2151927+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305503",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 305503,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1881,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 81,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.4",
      "ID": 2608
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2134,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3271197+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320390",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 320390,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1881,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 81,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.4",
      "ID": 2608
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5041,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan",
      "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1643502+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315960",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315960,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1881,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 81,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.4",
      "ID": 2608
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3763,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart",
      "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9397016+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1986E23P197VM236677",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 236677,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1881,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 81,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.4",
      "ID": 2608
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1986,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan",
      "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9353181+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5047E100P130VM289827",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289827,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1881,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 81,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.4",
      "ID": 2608
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5047,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne",
      "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.460769+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234556",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234556,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1881,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 81,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.4",
      "ID": 2608
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1845,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette",
      "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3893916+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313220",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313220,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1881,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 81,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.4",
      "ID": 2608
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3061,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.3829059+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1768E19P265VM289266",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289266,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1881,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 81,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.4",
      "ID": 2608
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1768,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4298279+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225281",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225281,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1881,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 81,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.4",
      "ID": 2608
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1894,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Neil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9626219+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3815E98P134VM270941",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270941,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1881,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 81,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.4",
      "ID": 2608
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3815,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Park, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Park",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8356756+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265843",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265843,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1881,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 81,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.4",
      "ID": 2608
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2010,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil",
      "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4629113+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283279",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283279,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1881,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 81,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.4",
      "ID": 2608
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5057,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.693625+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2853E33P128VM251512",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251512,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1881,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 81,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.4",
      "ID": 2608
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Pentland",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4668813+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317610",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317610,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1881,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 81,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.4",
      "ID": 2608
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5009,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4298444+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254652",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254652,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1881,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 81,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.4",
      "ID": 2608
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3745,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis",
      "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.265791+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1870E225P478VM295708",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295708,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1881,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 81,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.4",
      "ID": 2608
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1870,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona",
      "DisplayName": "Shona Robison",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5325178+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2135E254P450VM235416",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235416,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1881,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 81,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.4",
      "ID": 2608
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2135,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Russell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6698106+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1895E232P431VM257613",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257613,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1881,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 81,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.4",
      "ID": 2608
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1895,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0640489+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228165",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 228165,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1881,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 81,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.4",
      "ID": 2608
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1839,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5871422+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2345E10P55VM291639",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291639,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1881,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 81,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.4",
      "ID": 2608
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2345,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1359474+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311091",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311091,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1881,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 81,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.4",
      "ID": 2608
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2223,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish",
      "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.6050173+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246386",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 246386,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1881,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 81,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.4",
      "ID": 2608
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2182,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1264938+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298120",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298120,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1881,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 81,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.4",
      "ID": 2608
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5079,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew",
      "DisplayName": "Drew Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1390975+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234152",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234152,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1881,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 81,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.4",
      "ID": 2608
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1769,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1688738+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274624",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274624,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1881,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 81,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.4",
      "ID": 2608
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4014,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz",
      "DisplayName": "Liz Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1146458+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269571",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269571,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1881,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 81,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.4",
      "ID": 2608
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2215,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5533649+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317433",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317433,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1881,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 81,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.4",
      "ID": 2608
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3806,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4218921+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326336",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 326336,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1881,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 81,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.4",
      "ID": 2608
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5106,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin",
      "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7540625+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241178",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241178,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1881,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 81,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.4",
      "ID": 2608
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1848,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola",
      "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.4053876+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2098E237P531VM289696",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289696,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1881,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 81,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.4",
      "ID": 2608
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2098,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Swinney",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4552646+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2674E247P401VM247829",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247829,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1881,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 81,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.4",
      "ID": 2608
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2674,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave",
      "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4302168+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5075E234P371VM287432",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 287432,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1881,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 81,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.4",
      "ID": 2608
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5075,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Torrance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.863952+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1793E151P362VM222525",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 222525,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1881,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 81,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.4",
      "ID": 2608
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1793,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean",
      "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1927049+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5078E245P15VM307041",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307041,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1881,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 81,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.4",
      "ID": 2608
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5078,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Walker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5847443+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1841E231P426VM239945",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239945,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1881,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 81,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.4",
      "ID": 2608
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1841,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen",
      "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7660865+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283489",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283489,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1881,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 81,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.4",
      "ID": 2608
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4952,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7101174+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1865E263P500VM231857",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231857,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1881,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 81,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.4",
      "ID": 2608
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1865,
      "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra",
      "DisplayName": "Sandra White",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6185212+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237723",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237723,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1881,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 81,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.4",
      "ID": 2608
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2610,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Wilson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2230681+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309219",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 309219,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1881,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 30,
      "VoteAgainst": 81,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.4",
      "ID": 2608
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4941,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza",
      "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3198883+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252693",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252693,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1882,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 16,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.3",
      "ID": 2604
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1926,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian",
      "DisplayName": "Brian Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7495365+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2615E213P388VM258898",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258898,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1882,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 16,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.3",
      "ID": 2604
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2615,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George",
      "DisplayName": "George Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3329611+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319657",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319657,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1882,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 16,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.3",
      "ID": 2604
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4940,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare",
      "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9357254+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249586",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 249586,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1882,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 16,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.3",
      "ID": 2604
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2641,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair",
      "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9332343+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1783E21P273VM227804",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227804,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1882,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 16,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.3",
      "ID": 2604
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1783,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie",
      "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.56636+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2633E97P136VM280807",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280807,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1882,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 16,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.3",
      "ID": 2604
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2633,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire",
      "DisplayName": "Claire Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7832256+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262711",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262711,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1882,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 16,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.3",
      "ID": 2604
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2603,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6135755+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1759E91P115VM229796",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229796,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1882,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 16,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.3",
      "ID": 2604
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia",
      "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0974052+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270129",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270129,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1882,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 16,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.3",
      "ID": 2604
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3751,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5827953+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322624",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 322624,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1882,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 16,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.3",
      "ID": 2604
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5109,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco",
      "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6967344+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5060E86P124VM295249",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295249,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1882,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 16,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.3",
      "ID": 2604
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5060,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5038891+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242943",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242943,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1882,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 16,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.3",
      "ID": 2604
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1866,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah",
      "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0422026+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235191",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235191,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1882,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 16,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.3",
      "ID": 2604
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1943,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic",
      "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4232996+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302361",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 302361,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1882,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 16,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.3",
      "ID": 2604
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2595,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin",
      "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5210817+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244292",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244292,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1882,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 16,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.3",
      "ID": 2604
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2103,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith",
      "DisplayName": "Keith Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5483699+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327162",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 327162,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1882,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 16,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.3",
      "ID": 2604
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.801839+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277050",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277050,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1882,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 16,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.3",
      "ID": 2604
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6989484+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264279",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264279,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1882,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 16,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.3",
      "ID": 2604
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2673,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick",
      "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1264428+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248726",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248726,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1882,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 16,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.3",
      "ID": 2604
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2678,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson",
      "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6671603+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2123E27P233VM295739",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295739,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1882,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 16,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.3",
      "ID": 2604
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2123,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm",
      "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5338415+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285215",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285215,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1882,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 16,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.3",
      "ID": 2604
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3907,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3132717+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230691",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230691,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1882,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 16,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.3",
      "ID": 2604
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1735,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela",
      "DisplayName": "Angela Constance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3410519+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243776",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 243776,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1882,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 16,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.3",
      "ID": 2604
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1932,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce",
      "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3192881+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254885",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254885,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1882,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 16,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.3",
      "ID": 2604
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1863,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna",
      "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2879764+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323769",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 323769,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1882,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 16,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.3",
      "ID": 2604
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4976,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth",
      "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.97112+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5107E223P379VM291286",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291286,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1882,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 16,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.3",
      "ID": 2604
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5107,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1124056+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3743E222P391VM265387",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265387,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1882,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 16,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.3",
      "ID": 2604
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3743,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel",
      "DisplayName": "Nigel Don",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4369881+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262298",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262298,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1882,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 16,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.3",
      "ID": 2604
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3771,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob",
      "DisplayName": "Bob Doris",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.5954652+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281933",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 281933,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1882,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 16,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.3",
      "ID": 2604
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2826,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Dornan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1640257+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298193",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298193,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1882,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 16,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.3",
      "ID": 2604
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3812,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia",
      "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1425209+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231241",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231241,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1882,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 16,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.3",
      "ID": 2604
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1778,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen",
      "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.5864919+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4955E240P389VM285891",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285891,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1882,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 16,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.3",
      "ID": 2604
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4955,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3489908+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219437",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 219437,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1882,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 16,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.3",
      "ID": 2604
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1742,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle",
      "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.2989417+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238527",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 238527,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1882,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 16,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.3",
      "ID": 2604
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1994,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus",
      "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4579338+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225239",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225239,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1882,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 16,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.3",
      "ID": 2604
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1814,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda",
      "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9607917+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321836",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 321836,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1882,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 16,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.3",
      "ID": 2604
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Fee",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4534341+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292851",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 292851,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1882,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 16,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.3",
      "ID": 2604
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia",
      "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5608262+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227162",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227162,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1882,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 16,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.3",
      "ID": 2604
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2704846+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5054E95P118VM312721",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 312721,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1882,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 16,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.3",
      "ID": 2604
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5054,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1404979+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4947E152P361VM257234",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257234,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1882,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 16,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.3",
      "ID": 2604
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4947,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Finnie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0473305+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271247",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271247,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1882,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 16,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.3",
      "ID": 2604
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3901,
      "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe",
      "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0620536+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278070",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 278070,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1882,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 16,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.3",
      "ID": 2604
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2394,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo",
      "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9857098+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2110E220P414VM287256",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 287256,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1882,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 16,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.3",
      "ID": 2604
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth",
      "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8563629+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250512",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250512,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1882,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 16,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.3",
      "ID": 2604
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2675,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob",
      "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1927243+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1741E10P50VM220978",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220978,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1882,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 16,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.3",
      "ID": 2604
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1741,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel",
      "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6698298+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220207",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220207,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1882,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 16,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.3",
      "ID": 2604
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1756,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine",
      "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3389519+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1860E104P150VM252381",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252381,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1882,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 16,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.3",
      "ID": 2604
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1860,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda",
      "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7267295+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2033E20P141VM253839",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253839,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1882,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 16,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.3",
      "ID": 2604
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2033,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain",
      "DisplayName": "Iain Gray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0230829+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324636",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324636,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1882,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 16,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.3",
      "ID": 2604
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5042,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2314739+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259673",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 259673,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1882,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 16,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.3",
      "ID": 2604
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick",
      "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6195904+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239369",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239369,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1882,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 16,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.3",
      "ID": 2604
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2029,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh",
      "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7338342+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273750",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 273750,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1882,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 16,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.3",
      "ID": 2604
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3758,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6340704+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304124",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 304124,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1882,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 16,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.3",
      "ID": 2604
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4086,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Hume",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.850685+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221717",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221717,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1882,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 16,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.3",
      "ID": 2604
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1773,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9447507+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1882E227P459VM241949",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241949,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1882,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 16,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.3",
      "ID": 2604
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1882,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam",
      "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7871106+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223505",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223505,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1882,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 16,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.3",
      "ID": 2604
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1893,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4613326+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307621",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307621,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1882,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 16,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.3",
      "ID": 2604
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4934,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8377227+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272249",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 272249,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1882,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 16,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.3",
      "ID": 2604
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4956,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Keir",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3215207+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244953",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244953,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1882,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 16,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.3",
      "ID": 2604
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Kelly",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5856751+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315123",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315123,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1882,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 16,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.3",
      "ID": 2604
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3129,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6753029+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247899",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247899,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1882,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 16,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.3",
      "ID": 2604
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann",
      "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4331727+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4016E11P36VM274839",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274839,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1882,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 16,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.3",
      "ID": 2604
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4016,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.12398+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255750",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255750,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1882,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 16,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.3",
      "ID": 2604
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2180,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5552896+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4938E158P374VM277406",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277406,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1882,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 16,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.3",
      "ID": 2604
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4938,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9519996+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2112E250P486VM253062",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253062,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1882,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 16,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.3",
      "ID": 2604
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2112,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny",
      "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7652028+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4939E258P394VM276792",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276792,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1882,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 16,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.3",
      "ID": 2604
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4939,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus",
      "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6812989+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325495",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 325495,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1882,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 16,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.3",
      "ID": 2604
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5074,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon",
      "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5088413+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1828E3P10VM232886",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232886,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1882,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 16,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.3",
      "ID": 2604
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1828,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo",
      "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8808439+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311466",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311466,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1882,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 16,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.3",
      "ID": 2604
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4948,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike",
      "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8800396+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2117E90P107VM230360",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230360,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1882,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 16,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.3",
      "ID": 2604
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2117,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis",
      "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3196333+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267405",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 267405,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1882,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 16,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.3",
      "ID": 2604
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken",
      "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0184099+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313696",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313696,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1882,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 16,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.3",
      "ID": 2604
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4966,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek",
      "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4065692+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3101E102P129VM295035",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295035,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1882,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 16,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.3",
      "ID": 2604
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3101,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala",
      "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1894075+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319086",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319086,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1882,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 16,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.3",
      "ID": 2604
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5034,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny",
      "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.691833+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306364",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306364,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1882,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 16,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.3",
      "ID": 2604
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2159,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Martin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5489208+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5110E252P395VM310854",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 310854,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1882,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 16,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.3",
      "ID": 2604
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Mason",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5888787+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268198",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 268198,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1882,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 16,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.3",
      "ID": 2604
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2133,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2530207+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2876E141P433VM286375",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286375,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1882,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 16,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.3",
      "ID": 2604
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2876,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5763474+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4951E147P368VM258622",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258622,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1882,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 16,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.3",
      "ID": 2604
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4951,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan",
      "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3152575+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3896E175P307VM263840",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 263840,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1882,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 16,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.3",
      "ID": 2604
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3896,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam",
      "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9126781+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308478",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 308478,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1882,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 16,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.3",
      "ID": 2604
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0576484+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4964E143P375VM279710",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279710,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1882,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 16,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.3",
      "ID": 2604
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4964,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5193226+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279622",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279622,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1882,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 16,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.3",
      "ID": 2604
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3824,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5155648+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2066E22P91VM261035",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261035,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1882,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 16,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.3",
      "ID": 2604
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2066,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.1089852+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299625",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 299625,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1882,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 16,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.3",
      "ID": 2604
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7057815+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306665",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306665,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1882,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 16,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.3",
      "ID": 2604
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina",
      "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5620989+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2487E146P369VM301129",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 301129,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1882,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 16,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.3",
      "ID": 2604
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2487,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0348117+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223881",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223881,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1882,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 16,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.3",
      "ID": 2604
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4777874+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237540",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237540,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1882,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 16,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.3",
      "ID": 2604
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1961,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David",
      "DisplayName": "David McLetchie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2152332+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305504",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 305504,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1882,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 16,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.3",
      "ID": 2604
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2134,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3271603+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320340",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 320340,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1882,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 16,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.3",
      "ID": 2604
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5041,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan",
      "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1558103+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315959",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315959,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1882,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 16,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.3",
      "ID": 2604
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3763,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart",
      "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9396605+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1986E23P197VM236678",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 236678,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1882,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 16,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.3",
      "ID": 2604
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1986,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan",
      "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9353595+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5047E100P130VM289826",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289826,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1882,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 16,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.3",
      "ID": 2604
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5047,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne",
      "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4607285+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234555",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234555,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1882,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 16,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.3",
      "ID": 2604
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1845,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette",
      "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3893508+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313219",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313219,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1882,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 16,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.3",
      "ID": 2604
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3061,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.3828641+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1768E19P265VM289267",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289267,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1882,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 16,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.3",
      "ID": 2604
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1768,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4298684+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225282",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225282,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1882,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 16,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.3",
      "ID": 2604
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1894,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Neil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9626627+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3815E98P134VM270942",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270942,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1882,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 16,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.3",
      "ID": 2604
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3815,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Park, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Park",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.835716+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265842",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265842,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1882,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 16,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.3",
      "ID": 2604
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2010,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil",
      "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4628669+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283278",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283278,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1882,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 16,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.3",
      "ID": 2604
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5057,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.6935845+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2853E33P128VM251513",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251513,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1882,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 16,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.3",
      "ID": 2604
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Pentland",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4669231+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317561",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317561,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1882,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 16,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.3",
      "ID": 2604
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5009,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4277423+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254651",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254651,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1882,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 16,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.3",
      "ID": 2604
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3745,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis",
      "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2657406+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1870E225P478VM295709",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295709,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1882,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 16,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.3",
      "ID": 2604
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1870,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona",
      "DisplayName": "Shona Robison",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.532558+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2135E254P450VM235417",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235417,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1882,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 16,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.3",
      "ID": 2604
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2135,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Russell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6698706+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1895E232P431VM257614",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257614,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1882,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 16,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.3",
      "ID": 2604
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1895,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0640896+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228166",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 228166,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1882,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 16,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.3",
      "ID": 2604
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1839,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5871824+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2345E10P55VM291638",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291638,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1882,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 16,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.3",
      "ID": 2604
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2345,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1359081+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311092",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311092,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1882,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 16,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.3",
      "ID": 2604
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2223,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish",
      "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.6050576+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246387",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 246387,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1882,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 16,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.3",
      "ID": 2604
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2182,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1265347+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298119",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298119,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1882,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 16,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.3",
      "ID": 2604
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5079,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew",
      "DisplayName": "Drew Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1390571+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234151",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234151,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1882,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 16,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.3",
      "ID": 2604
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1769,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1688325+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274625",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274625,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1882,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 16,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.3",
      "ID": 2604
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4014,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz",
      "DisplayName": "Liz Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1146866+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269572",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269572,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1882,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 16,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.3",
      "ID": 2604
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2215,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5534053+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317434",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317434,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1882,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 16,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.3",
      "ID": 2604
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3806,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4219329+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326335",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 326335,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1882,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 16,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.3",
      "ID": 2604
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5106,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin",
      "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7540222+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241179",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241179,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1882,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 16,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.3",
      "ID": 2604
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1848,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola",
      "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.4054284+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2098E237P531VM289697",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289697,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1882,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 16,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.3",
      "ID": 2604
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2098,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Swinney",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4553047+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2674E247P401VM247830",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247830,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1882,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 16,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.3",
      "ID": 2604
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2674,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave",
      "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4302583+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5075E234P371VM287433",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 287433,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1882,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 16,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.3",
      "ID": 2604
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5075,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Torrance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8639922+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1793E151P362VM222526",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 222526,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1882,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 16,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.3",
      "ID": 2604
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1793,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean",
      "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1927455+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5078E245P15VM307040",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307040,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1882,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 16,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.3",
      "ID": 2604
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5078,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Walker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.584704+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1841E231P426VM239944",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239944,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1882,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 16,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.3",
      "ID": 2604
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1841,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen",
      "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7660457+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283490",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283490,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1882,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 16,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.3",
      "ID": 2604
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4952,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7101582+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1865E263P500VM231856",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231856,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1882,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 16,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.3",
      "ID": 2604
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1865,
      "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra",
      "DisplayName": "Sandra White",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6184806+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237722",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237722,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1882,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 16,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.3",
      "ID": 2604
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2610,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Wilson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2230279+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309218",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 309218,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1882,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 16,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.3",
      "ID": 2604
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4941,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza",
      "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3198477+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252694",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252694,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1883,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.2",
      "ID": 2603
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1926,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian",
      "DisplayName": "Brian Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.749578+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2615E213P388VM258899",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258899,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1883,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.2",
      "ID": 2603
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2615,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George",
      "DisplayName": "George Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3330084+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319656",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319656,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1883,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.2",
      "ID": 2603
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4940,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare",
      "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9356851+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249585",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 249585,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1883,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.2",
      "ID": 2603
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2641,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair",
      "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9331923+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1783E21P273VM227805",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227805,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1883,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.2",
      "ID": 2603
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1783,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie",
      "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.566403+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2633E97P136VM280808",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280808,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1883,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.2",
      "ID": 2603
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2633,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire",
      "DisplayName": "Claire Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.783267+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262712",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262712,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1883,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.2",
      "ID": 2603
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2603,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6136164+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1759E91P115VM229797",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229797,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1883,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.2",
      "ID": 2603
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia",
      "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0974455+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270128",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270128,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1883,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.2",
      "ID": 2603
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3751,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5827533+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322625",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 322625,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1883,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.2",
      "ID": 2603
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5109,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco",
      "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.696775+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5060E86P124VM295250",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295250,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1883,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.2",
      "ID": 2603
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5060,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5039303+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242944",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242944,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1883,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.2",
      "ID": 2603
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1866,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah",
      "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0422445+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235190",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235190,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1883,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.2",
      "ID": 2603
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1943,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic",
      "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4232572+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302362",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 302362,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1883,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.2",
      "ID": 2603
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2595,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin",
      "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5211223+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244291",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244291,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1883,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.2",
      "ID": 2603
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2103,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith",
      "DisplayName": "Keith Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5483282+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327163",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 327163,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1883,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.2",
      "ID": 2603
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.8018798+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277051",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277051,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1883,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.2",
      "ID": 2603
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6989934+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264278",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264278,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1883,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.2",
      "ID": 2603
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2673,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick",
      "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1264024+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248725",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248725,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1883,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.2",
      "ID": 2603
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2678,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson",
      "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6671203+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2123E27P233VM295738",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295738,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1883,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.2",
      "ID": 2603
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2123,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm",
      "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5338012+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285216",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285216,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1883,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.2",
      "ID": 2603
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3907,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3133345+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230692",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230692,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1883,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.2",
      "ID": 2603
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1735,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela",
      "DisplayName": "Angela Constance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3410928+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243775",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 243775,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1883,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.2",
      "ID": 2603
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1932,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce",
      "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.319248+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254884",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254884,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1883,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.2",
      "ID": 2603
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1863,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna",
      "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2879353+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323770",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 323770,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1883,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.2",
      "ID": 2603
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4976,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth",
      "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9711607+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5107E223P379VM291285",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291285,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1883,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.2",
      "ID": 2603
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5107,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1123646+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3743E222P391VM265388",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265388,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1883,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.2",
      "ID": 2603
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3743,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel",
      "DisplayName": "Nigel Don",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4370289+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262299",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262299,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1883,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.2",
      "ID": 2603
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3771,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob",
      "DisplayName": "Bob Doris",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.5955069+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281932",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 281932,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1883,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.2",
      "ID": 2603
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2826,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Dornan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1639852+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298194",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298194,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1883,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.2",
      "ID": 2603
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3812,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia",
      "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1425617+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231240",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231240,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1883,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.2",
      "ID": 2603
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1778,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen",
      "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.5864307+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4955E240P389VM285890",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285890,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1883,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.2",
      "ID": 2603
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4955,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3489487+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219438",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 219438,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1883,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.2",
      "ID": 2603
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1742,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle",
      "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.2989881+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238526",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 238526,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1883,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.2",
      "ID": 2603
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1994,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus",
      "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4578938+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225238",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225238,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1883,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.2",
      "ID": 2603
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1814,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda",
      "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.96075+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321835",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 321835,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1883,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.2",
      "ID": 2603
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Fee",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4533934+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292850",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 292850,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1883,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.2",
      "ID": 2603
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia",
      "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5607863+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227163",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227163,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1883,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.2",
      "ID": 2603
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2705265+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5054E95P118VM312722",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 312722,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1883,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.2",
      "ID": 2603
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5054,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1405401+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4947E152P361VM257235",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257235,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1883,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.2",
      "ID": 2603
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4947,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Finnie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0473711+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271246",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271246,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1883,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.2",
      "ID": 2603
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3901,
      "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe",
      "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0620108+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278069",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 278069,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1883,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.2",
      "ID": 2603
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2394,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo",
      "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9856689+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2110E220P414VM287257",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 287257,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1883,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.2",
      "ID": 2603
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth",
      "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8564038+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250513",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250513,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1883,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.2",
      "ID": 2603
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2675,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob",
      "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1927653+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1741E10P50VM220979",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220979,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1883,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.2",
      "ID": 2603
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1741,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel",
      "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6698703+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220206",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220206,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1883,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.2",
      "ID": 2603
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1756,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine",
      "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3389111+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1860E104P150VM252382",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252382,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1883,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.2",
      "ID": 2603
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1860,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda",
      "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.72677+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2033E20P141VM253838",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253838,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1883,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.2",
      "ID": 2603
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2033,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain",
      "DisplayName": "Iain Gray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0230433+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324635",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324635,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1883,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.2",
      "ID": 2603
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5042,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2314332+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259672",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 259672,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1883,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.2",
      "ID": 2603
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick",
      "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.619549+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239370",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239370,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1883,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.2",
      "ID": 2603
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2029,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh",
      "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7338937+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273749",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 273749,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1883,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.2",
      "ID": 2603
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3758,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6340306+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304123",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 304123,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1883,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.2",
      "ID": 2603
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4086,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Hume",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8506448+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221716",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221716,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1883,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.2",
      "ID": 2603
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1773,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.944711+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1882E227P459VM241948",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241948,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1883,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.2",
      "ID": 2603
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1882,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam",
      "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7870698+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223504",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223504,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1883,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.2",
      "ID": 2603
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1893,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4612735+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307622",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307622,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1883,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.2",
      "ID": 2603
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4934,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8377636+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272250",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 272250,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1883,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.2",
      "ID": 2603
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4956,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Keir",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3215612+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244954",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244954,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1883,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.2",
      "ID": 2603
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Kelly",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5857157+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315124",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315124,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1883,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.2",
      "ID": 2603
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3129,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6753432+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247898",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247898,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1883,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.2",
      "ID": 2603
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann",
      "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4331329+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4016E11P36VM274840",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274840,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1883,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.2",
      "ID": 2603
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4016,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1240205+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255749",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255749,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1883,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.2",
      "ID": 2603
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2180,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5552493+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4938E158P374VM277405",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277405,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1883,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.2",
      "ID": 2603
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4938,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9519591+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2112E250P486VM253063",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253063,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1883,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.2",
      "ID": 2603
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2112,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny",
      "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.765262+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4939E258P394VM276791",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276791,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1883,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.2",
      "ID": 2603
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4939,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus",
      "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6812589+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325496",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 325496,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1883,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.2",
      "ID": 2603
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5074,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon",
      "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5088817+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1828E3P10VM232887",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232887,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1883,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.2",
      "ID": 2603
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1828,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo",
      "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8808845+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311467",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311467,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1883,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.2",
      "ID": 2603
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4948,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike",
      "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8800808+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2117E90P107VM230359",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230359,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1883,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.2",
      "ID": 2603
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2117,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis",
      "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3195928+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267406",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 267406,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1883,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.2",
      "ID": 2603
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken",
      "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0184515+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313695",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313695,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1883,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.2",
      "ID": 2603
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4966,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek",
      "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4065267+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3101E102P129VM295034",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295034,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1883,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.2",
      "ID": 2603
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3101,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala",
      "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1893668+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319085",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319085,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1883,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.2",
      "ID": 2603
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5034,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny",
      "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6917927+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306363",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306363,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1883,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.2",
      "ID": 2603
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2159,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Martin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5488805+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5110E252P395VM310853",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 310853,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1883,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.2",
      "ID": 2603
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Mason",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5888374+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268197",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 268197,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1883,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.2",
      "ID": 2603
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2133,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2529616+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2876E141P433VM286376",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286376,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1883,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.2",
      "ID": 2603
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2876,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5764863+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4951E147P368VM258621",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258621,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1883,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.2",
      "ID": 2603
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4951,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan",
      "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3152166+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3896E175P307VM263839",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 263839,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1883,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.2",
      "ID": 2603
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3896,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam",
      "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9126369+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308479",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 308479,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1883,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.2",
      "ID": 2603
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0576893+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4964E143P375VM279711",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279711,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1883,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.2",
      "ID": 2603
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4964,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5193628+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279621",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279621,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1883,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.2",
      "ID": 2603
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3824,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5155244+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2066E22P91VM261034",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261034,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1883,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.2",
      "ID": 2603
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2066,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.1089436+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299624",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 299624,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1883,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.2",
      "ID": 2603
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7057408+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306666",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306666,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1883,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.2",
      "ID": 2603
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina",
      "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5621399+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2487E146P369VM301128",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 301128,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1883,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.2",
      "ID": 2603
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2487,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0347421+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223882",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223882,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1883,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.2",
      "ID": 2603
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4778279+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237541",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237541,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1883,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.2",
      "ID": 2603
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1961,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David",
      "DisplayName": "David McLetchie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2152731+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305505",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 305505,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1883,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.2",
      "ID": 2603
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2134,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3272013+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320341",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 320341,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1883,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.2",
      "ID": 2603
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5041,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan",
      "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1558517+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315958",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315958,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1883,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.2",
      "ID": 2603
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3763,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart",
      "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9396184+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1986E23P197VM236679",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 236679,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1883,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.2",
      "ID": 2603
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1986,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan",
      "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9354006+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5047E100P130VM289825",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289825,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1883,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.2",
      "ID": 2603
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5047,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne",
      "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4606701+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234554",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234554,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1883,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.2",
      "ID": 2603
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1845,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette",
      "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3893103+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313218",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313218,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1883,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.2",
      "ID": 2603
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3061,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.3828229+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1768E19P265VM289268",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289268,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1883,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.2",
      "ID": 2603
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1768,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4299082+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225283",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225283,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1883,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.2",
      "ID": 2603
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1894,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Neil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.962704+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3815E98P134VM270943",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270943,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1883,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.2",
      "ID": 2603
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3815,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Park, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Park",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8357561+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265841",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265841,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1883,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.2",
      "ID": 2603
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2010,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil",
      "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4627951+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283277",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283277,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1883,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.2",
      "ID": 2603
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5057,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.6935435+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2853E33P128VM251514",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251514,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1883,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.2",
      "ID": 2603
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Pentland",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4669642+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317562",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317562,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1883,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.2",
      "ID": 2603
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5009,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4277836+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254650",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254650,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1883,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.2",
      "ID": 2603
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3745,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis",
      "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2656932+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1870E225P478VM295710",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295710,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1883,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.2",
      "ID": 2603
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1870,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona",
      "DisplayName": "Shona Robison",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5325984+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2135E254P450VM235418",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235418,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1883,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.2",
      "ID": 2603
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2135,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Russell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6699137+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1895E232P431VM257615",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257615,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1883,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.2",
      "ID": 2603
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1895,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0641542+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228167",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 228167,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1883,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.2",
      "ID": 2603
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1839,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5872228+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2345E10P55VM291637",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291637,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1883,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.2",
      "ID": 2603
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2345,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1358679+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311093",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311093,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1883,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.2",
      "ID": 2603
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2223,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish",
      "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.6051174+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246388",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 246388,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1883,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.2",
      "ID": 2603
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2182,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1265741+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298118",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298118,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1883,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.2",
      "ID": 2603
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5079,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew",
      "DisplayName": "Drew Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1390153+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234150",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234150,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1883,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.2",
      "ID": 2603
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1769,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1687921+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274626",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274626,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1883,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.2",
      "ID": 2603
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4014,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz",
      "DisplayName": "Liz Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.114746+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269573",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269573,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1883,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.2",
      "ID": 2603
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2215,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5534462+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317435",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317435,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1883,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.2",
      "ID": 2603
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3806,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4219732+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326334",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 326334,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1883,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.2",
      "ID": 2603
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5106,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin",
      "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.753982+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241180",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241180,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1883,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.2",
      "ID": 2603
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1848,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola",
      "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.4054682+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2098E237P531VM289698",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289698,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1883,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.2",
      "ID": 2603
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2098,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Swinney",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4553444+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2674E247P401VM247831",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247831,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1883,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.2",
      "ID": 2603
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2674,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave",
      "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4302989+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5075E234P371VM287434",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 287434,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1883,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.2",
      "ID": 2603
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5075,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Torrance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8640335+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1793E151P362VM222527",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 222527,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1883,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.2",
      "ID": 2603
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1793,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean",
      "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1927861+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5078E245P15VM307039",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307039,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1883,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.2",
      "ID": 2603
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5078,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Walker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5846638+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1841E231P426VM239943",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239943,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1883,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.2",
      "ID": 2603
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1841,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen",
      "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7660043+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283491",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283491,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1883,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.2",
      "ID": 2603
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4952,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7101985+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1865E263P500VM231855",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231855,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1883,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.2",
      "ID": 2603
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1865,
      "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra",
      "DisplayName": "Sandra White",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6184392+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237721",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237721,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1883,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.2",
      "ID": 2603
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2610,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Wilson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2229859+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309217",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 309217,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1883,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 12,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494.2",
      "ID": 2603
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4941,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza",
      "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.319807+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252695",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252695,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1880,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 48,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494",
      "ID": 2584
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1926,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian",
      "DisplayName": "Brian Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7496186+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2615E213P388VM258900",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258900,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1880,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 48,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494",
      "ID": 2584
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2615,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George",
      "DisplayName": "George Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3330498+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319655",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319655,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1880,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 48,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494",
      "ID": 2584
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4940,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare",
      "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9356439+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249584",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 249584,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1880,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 48,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494",
      "ID": 2584
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2641,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair",
      "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9331335+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1783E21P273VM227806",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227806,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1880,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 48,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494",
      "ID": 2584
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1783,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie",
      "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5664442+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2633E97P136VM280809",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280809,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1880,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 48,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494",
      "ID": 2584
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2633,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire",
      "DisplayName": "Claire Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7833066+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262713",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262713,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1880,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 48,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494",
      "ID": 2584
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2603,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6136564+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1759E91P115VM229798",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229798,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1880,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 48,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494",
      "ID": 2584
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia",
      "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0974859+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270127",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270127,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1880,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 48,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494",
      "ID": 2584
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3751,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5827126+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322626",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 322626,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1880,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 48,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494",
      "ID": 2584
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5109,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco",
      "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6968155+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5060E86P124VM295251",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295251,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1880,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 48,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494",
      "ID": 2584
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5060,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5039715+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242945",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242945,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1880,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 48,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494",
      "ID": 2584
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1866,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah",
      "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0422868+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235189",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235189,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1880,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 48,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494",
      "ID": 2584
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1943,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic",
      "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4232167+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302363",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 302363,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1880,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 48,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494",
      "ID": 2584
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2595,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin",
      "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5211631+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244290",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244290,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1880,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 48,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494",
      "ID": 2584
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2103,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith",
      "DisplayName": "Keith Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5482873+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327164",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 327164,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1880,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 48,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494",
      "ID": 2584
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.8019413+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277052",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277052,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1880,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 48,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494",
      "ID": 2584
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6990347+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264277",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264277,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1880,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 48,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494",
      "ID": 2584
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2673,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick",
      "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1263621+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248724",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248724,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1880,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 48,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494",
      "ID": 2584
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2678,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson",
      "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6670802+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2123E27P233VM295737",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295737,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1880,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 48,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494",
      "ID": 2584
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2123,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm",
      "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5337587+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285217",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285217,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1880,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 48,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494",
      "ID": 2584
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3907,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3133778+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230693",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230693,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1880,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 48,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494",
      "ID": 2584
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1735,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela",
      "DisplayName": "Angela Constance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3411333+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243774",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 243774,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1880,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 48,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494",
      "ID": 2584
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1932,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce",
      "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3192069+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254883",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254883,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1880,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 48,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494",
      "ID": 2584
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1863,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna",
      "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.287895+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323771",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 323771,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1880,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 48,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494",
      "ID": 2584
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4976,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth",
      "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9712199+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5107E223P379VM291284",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291284,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1880,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 48,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494",
      "ID": 2584
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5107,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1123234+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3743E222P391VM265389",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265389,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1880,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 48,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494",
      "ID": 2584
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3743,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel",
      "DisplayName": "Nigel Don",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4370695+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262300",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262300,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1880,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 48,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494",
      "ID": 2584
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3771,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob",
      "DisplayName": "Bob Doris",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.5955469+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281931",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 281931,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1880,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 48,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494",
      "ID": 2584
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2826,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Dornan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1639451+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298195",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298195,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1880,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 48,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494",
      "ID": 2584
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3812,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia",
      "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1426023+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231239",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231239,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1880,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 48,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494",
      "ID": 2584
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1778,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen",
      "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.5863898+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4955E240P389VM285889",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285889,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1880,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 48,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494",
      "ID": 2584
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4955,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3489074+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219439",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 219439,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1880,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 48,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494",
      "ID": 2584
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1742,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle",
      "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.2990352+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238525",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 238525,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1880,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 48,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494",
      "ID": 2584
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1994,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus",
      "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4578534+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225237",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225237,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1880,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 48,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494",
      "ID": 2584
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1814,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda",
      "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9607082+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321834",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 321834,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1880,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 48,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494",
      "ID": 2584
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Fee",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4533529+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292849",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 292849,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1880,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 48,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494",
      "ID": 2584
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia",
      "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5607466+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227164",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227164,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1880,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 48,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494",
      "ID": 2584
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2705669+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5054E95P118VM312723",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 312723,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1880,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 48,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494",
      "ID": 2584
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5054,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1405803+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4947E152P361VM257740",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257740,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1880,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 48,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494",
      "ID": 2584
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4947,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Finnie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0755772+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271245",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271245,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1880,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 48,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494",
      "ID": 2584
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3901,
      "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe",
      "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0619491+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278068",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 278068,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1880,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 48,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494",
      "ID": 2584
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2394,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo",
      "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9856277+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2110E220P414VM287258",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 287258,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1880,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 48,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494",
      "ID": 2584
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth",
      "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8564441+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250514",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250514,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1880,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 48,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494",
      "ID": 2584
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2675,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob",
      "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1928244+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1741E10P50VM220980",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220980,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1880,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 48,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494",
      "ID": 2584
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1741,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel",
      "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6699294+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220205",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220205,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1880,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 48,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494",
      "ID": 2584
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1756,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine",
      "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3388694+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1860E104P150VM252383",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252383,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1880,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 48,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494",
      "ID": 2584
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1860,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda",
      "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7268104+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2033E20P141VM253837",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253837,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1880,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 48,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494",
      "ID": 2584
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2033,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain",
      "DisplayName": "Iain Gray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0230027+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324634",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324634,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1880,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 48,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494",
      "ID": 2584
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5042,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2313922+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259671",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 259671,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1880,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 48,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494",
      "ID": 2584
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick",
      "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6195085+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239371",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239371,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1880,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 48,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494",
      "ID": 2584
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2029,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh",
      "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7339368+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273748",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 273748,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1880,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 48,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494",
      "ID": 2584
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3758,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6339902+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304122",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 304122,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1880,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 48,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494",
      "ID": 2584
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4086,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Hume",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8506041+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221715",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221715,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1880,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 48,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494",
      "ID": 2584
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1773,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9446696+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1882E227P459VM241947",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241947,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1880,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 48,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494",
      "ID": 2584
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1882,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam",
      "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7870285+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223503",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223503,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1880,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 48,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494",
      "ID": 2584
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1893,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4612305+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307623",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307623,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1880,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 48,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494",
      "ID": 2584
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4934,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8378044+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272293",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 272293,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1880,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 48,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494",
      "ID": 2584
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4956,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Keir",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3234226+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244955",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244955,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1880,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 48,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494",
      "ID": 2584
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Kelly",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5857562+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315125",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315125,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1880,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 48,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494",
      "ID": 2584
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3129,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6753838+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247897",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247897,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1880,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 48,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494",
      "ID": 2584
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann",
      "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4330926+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4016E11P36VM274841",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274841,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1880,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 48,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494",
      "ID": 2584
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4016,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1240608+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255748",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255748,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1880,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 48,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494",
      "ID": 2584
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2180,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5552093+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4938E158P374VM277404",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277404,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1880,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 48,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494",
      "ID": 2584
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4938,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9519183+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2112E250P486VM253064",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253064,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1880,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 48,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494",
      "ID": 2584
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2112,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny",
      "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7653048+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4939E258P394VM276790",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276790,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1880,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 48,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494",
      "ID": 2584
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4939,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus",
      "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.681218+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325497",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 325497,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1880,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 48,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494",
      "ID": 2584
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5074,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon",
      "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5089219+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1828E3P10VM232888",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232888,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1880,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 48,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494",
      "ID": 2584
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1828,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo",
      "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8809592+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311468",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311468,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1880,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 48,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494",
      "ID": 2584
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4948,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike",
      "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8801223+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2117E90P107VM230358",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230358,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1880,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 48,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494",
      "ID": 2584
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2117,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis",
      "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3195518+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267407",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 267407,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1880,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 48,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494",
      "ID": 2584
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken",
      "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0184927+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313694",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313694,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1880,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 48,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494",
      "ID": 2584
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4966,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek",
      "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4064236+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3101E102P129VM295033",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295033,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1880,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 48,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494",
      "ID": 2584
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3101,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala",
      "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1893253+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319084",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319084,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1880,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 48,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494",
      "ID": 2584
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5034,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny",
      "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6917516+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306362",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306362,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1880,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 48,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494",
      "ID": 2584
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2159,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Martin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5488401+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5110E252P395VM310852",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 310852,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1880,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 48,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494",
      "ID": 2584
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Mason",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.588797+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268196",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 268196,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1880,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 48,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494",
      "ID": 2584
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2133,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0603666+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2876E141P433VM286377",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286377,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1880,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 48,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494",
      "ID": 2584
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2876,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5765324+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4951E147P368VM258578",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258578,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1880,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 48,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494",
      "ID": 2584
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4951,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan",
      "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3133014+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3896E175P307VM263838",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 263838,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1880,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 48,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494",
      "ID": 2584
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3896,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam",
      "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9125951+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308480",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 308480,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1880,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 48,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494",
      "ID": 2584
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0577301+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4964E143P375VM279712",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279712,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1880,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 48,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494",
      "ID": 2584
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4964,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5194024+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279620",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279620,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1880,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 48,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494",
      "ID": 2584
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3824,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.515484+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2066E22P91VM261033",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261033,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1880,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 48,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494",
      "ID": 2584
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2066,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.1089024+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299623",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 299623,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1880,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 48,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494",
      "ID": 2584
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7056998+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306667",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306667,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1880,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 48,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494",
      "ID": 2584
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina",
      "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5621814+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2487E146P369VM301127",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 301127,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1880,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 48,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494",
      "ID": 2584
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2487,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0346928+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223883",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223883,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1880,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 48,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494",
      "ID": 2584
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4778683+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237542",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237542,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1880,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 48,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494",
      "ID": 2584
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1961,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David",
      "DisplayName": "David McLetchie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2153131+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305506",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 305506,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1880,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 48,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494",
      "ID": 2584
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2134,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3272616+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320342",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 320342,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1880,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 48,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494",
      "ID": 2584
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5041,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan",
      "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1558929+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315957",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315957,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1880,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 48,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494",
      "ID": 2584
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3763,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart",
      "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9395769+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1986E23P197VM236680",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 236680,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1880,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 48,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494",
      "ID": 2584
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1986,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan",
      "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.935442+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5047E100P130VM289824",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289824,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1880,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 48,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494",
      "ID": 2584
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5047,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne",
      "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4606306+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234553",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234553,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1880,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 48,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494",
      "ID": 2584
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1845,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette",
      "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3892695+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313217",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313217,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1880,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 48,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494",
      "ID": 2584
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3061,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.3827809+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1768E19P265VM289269",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289269,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1880,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 48,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494",
      "ID": 2584
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1768,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4299679+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225284",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225284,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1880,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 48,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494",
      "ID": 2584
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1894,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Neil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9627449+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3815E98P134VM270944",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270944,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1880,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 48,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494",
      "ID": 2584
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3815,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Park, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Park",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8358174+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265840",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265840,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1880,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 48,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494",
      "ID": 2584
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2010,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil",
      "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4567669+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283276",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283276,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1880,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 48,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494",
      "ID": 2584
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5057,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.6935027+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2853E33P128VM251515",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251515,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1880,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 48,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494",
      "ID": 2584
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Pentland",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4670252+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317563",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317563,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1880,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 48,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494",
      "ID": 2584
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5009,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4278244+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254649",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254649,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1880,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 48,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494",
      "ID": 2584
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3745,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis",
      "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2655666+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1870E225P478VM296172",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 296172,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1880,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 48,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494",
      "ID": 2584
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1870,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona",
      "DisplayName": "Shona Robison",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5524798+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2135E254P450VM235419",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235419,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1880,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 48,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494",
      "ID": 2584
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2135,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Russell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6699554+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1895E232P431VM257616",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257616,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1880,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 48,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494",
      "ID": 2584
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1895,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0641963+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228168",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 228168,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1880,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 48,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494",
      "ID": 2584
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1839,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5872629+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2345E10P55VM291636",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291636,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1880,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 48,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494",
      "ID": 2584
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2345,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1358281+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311094",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311094,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1880,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 48,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494",
      "ID": 2584
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2223,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish",
      "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.6051599+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246389",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 246389,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1880,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 48,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494",
      "ID": 2584
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2182,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1266155+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298117",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298117,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1880,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 48,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494",
      "ID": 2584
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5079,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew",
      "DisplayName": "Drew Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1389571+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234149",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234149,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1880,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 48,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494",
      "ID": 2584
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1769,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1687515+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274627",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274627,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1880,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 48,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494",
      "ID": 2584
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4014,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz",
      "DisplayName": "Liz Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1147878+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269574",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269574,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1880,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 48,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494",
      "ID": 2584
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2215,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5534867+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317436",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317436,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1880,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 48,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494",
      "ID": 2584
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3806,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4220324+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326333",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 326333,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1880,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 48,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494",
      "ID": 2584
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5106,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin",
      "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.75394+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241181",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241181,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1880,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 48,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494",
      "ID": 2584
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1848,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola",
      "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.405509+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2098E237P531VM289699",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289699,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1880,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 48,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494",
      "ID": 2584
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2098,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Swinney",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4553845+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2674E247P401VM247832",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247832,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1880,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 48,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494",
      "ID": 2584
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2674,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave",
      "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4303391+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5075E234P371VM287435",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 287435,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1880,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 48,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494",
      "ID": 2584
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5075,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Torrance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8640737+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1793E151P362VM222528",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 222528,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1880,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 48,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494",
      "ID": 2584
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1793,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean",
      "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1928267+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5078E245P15VM307038",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307038,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1880,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 48,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494",
      "ID": 2584
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5078,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Walker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5846235+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1841E231P426VM239942",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239942,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1880,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 48,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494",
      "ID": 2584
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1841,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen",
      "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7659638+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283492",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283492,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1880,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 48,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494",
      "ID": 2584
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4952,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7102389+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1865E263P500VM231854",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231854,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1880,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 48,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494",
      "ID": 2584
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1865,
      "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra",
      "DisplayName": "Sandra White",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6183981+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237720",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237720,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1880,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 48,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494",
      "ID": 2584
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2610,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Wilson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2229265+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309216",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 309216,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1880,
      "AgendaID": 2676,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 48,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "UK Government Budget",
      "Reference": "S4M-02494",
      "ID": 2584
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4941,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza",
      "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-28T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3197657+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1926E229P470VM253091",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253091,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1877,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 39,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.2",
      "ID": 2533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1926,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian",
      "DisplayName": "Brian Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7664755+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2615E213P388VM259205",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 259205,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1877,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 39,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.2",
      "ID": 2533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2615,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George",
      "DisplayName": "George Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.5987584+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319522",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319522,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1877,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 39,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.2",
      "ID": 2533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4940,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare",
      "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9295982+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2641E256P403VM250276",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250276,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1877,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 39,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.2",
      "ID": 2533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2641,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair",
      "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1822126+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1783E21P273VM228412",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 228412,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1877,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 39,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.2",
      "ID": 2533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1783,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie",
      "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.797903+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2633E97P136VM281107",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 281107,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1877,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 39,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.2",
      "ID": 2533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2633,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire",
      "DisplayName": "Claire Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.8062908+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2603E89P148VM263020",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 263020,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1877,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 39,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.2",
      "ID": 2533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2603,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6332027+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1759E91P115VM227444",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227444,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1877,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 39,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.2",
      "ID": 2533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia",
      "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5504324+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3751E243P383VM269666",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269666,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1877,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 39,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.2",
      "ID": 2533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3751,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5577725+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322488",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 322488,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1877,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 39,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.2",
      "ID": 2533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5109,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco",
      "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6907851+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5060E86P124VM295402",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295402,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1877,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 39,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.2",
      "ID": 2533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5060,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5106412+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1866E93P239VM243079",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 243079,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1877,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 39,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.2",
      "ID": 2533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1866,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah",
      "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0480126+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1943E145P367VM227067",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227067,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1877,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 39,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.2",
      "ID": 2533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1943,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic",
      "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.266075+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2595E12P30VM301022",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 301022,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1877,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 39,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.2",
      "ID": 2533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2595,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin",
      "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0292149+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2103E244P421VM238433",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 238433,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1877,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 39,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.2",
      "ID": 2533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2103,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith",
      "DisplayName": "Keith Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.446343+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327020",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 327020,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1877,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 39,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.2",
      "ID": 2533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7901406+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277515",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277515,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1877,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 39,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.2",
      "ID": 2533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9566535+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2673E236P377VM263970",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 263970,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1877,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 39,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.2",
      "ID": 2533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2673,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick",
      "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9186243+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2678E11P28VM250977",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250977,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1877,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 39,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.2",
      "ID": 2533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2678,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson",
      "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.2216972+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2123E27P233VM294832",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 294832,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1877,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 39,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.2",
      "ID": 2533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2123,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm",
      "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1802666+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285370",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285370,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1877,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 39,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.2",
      "ID": 2533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3907,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3200943+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1735E248P405VM231308",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231308,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1877,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 39,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.2",
      "ID": 2533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1735,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela",
      "DisplayName": "Angela Constance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.5893477+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243639",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 243639,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1877,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 39,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.2",
      "ID": 2533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1932,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce",
      "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3135368+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254389",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254389,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1877,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 39,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.2",
      "ID": 2533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1863,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna",
      "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2536474+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323473",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 323473,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1877,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 39,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.2",
      "ID": 2533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4976,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth",
      "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9578063+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5107E223P379VM300685",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 300685,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1877,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 39,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.2",
      "ID": 2533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5107,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0092251+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3743E222P391VM273067",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 273067,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1877,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 39,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.2",
      "ID": 2533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3743,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel",
      "DisplayName": "Nigel Don",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3681692+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262615",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262615,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1877,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 39,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.2",
      "ID": 2533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3771,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob",
      "DisplayName": "Bob Doris",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6094824+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281786",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 281786,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1877,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 39,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.2",
      "ID": 2533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2826,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Dornan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1575595+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298495",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298495,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1877,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 39,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.2",
      "ID": 2533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3812,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia",
      "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3485992+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231110",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231110,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1877,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 39,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.2",
      "ID": 2533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1778,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen",
      "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3660553+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4955E240P389VM284912",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 284912,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1877,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 39,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.2",
      "ID": 2533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4955,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0530368+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219598",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 219598,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1877,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 39,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.2",
      "ID": 2533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1742,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle",
      "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3062822+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238223",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 238223,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1877,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 39,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.2",
      "ID": 2533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1994,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus",
      "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.437124+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1814E269P519VM226702",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 226702,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1877,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 39,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.2",
      "ID": 2533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1814,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda",
      "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2429114+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321972",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 321972,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1877,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 39,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.2",
      "ID": 2533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Fee",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4593652+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292673",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 292673,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1877,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 39,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.2",
      "ID": 2533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia",
      "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5529142+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227626",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227626,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1877,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 39,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.2",
      "ID": 2533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5582548+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5054E95P118VM304585",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 304585,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1877,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 39,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.2",
      "ID": 2533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5054,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.0447263+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4947E152P361VM257850",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257850,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1877,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 39,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.2",
      "ID": 2533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4947,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Finnie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0802901+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271044",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271044,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1877,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 39,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.2",
      "ID": 2533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3901,
      "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe",
      "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8401153+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2394E15P47VM274366",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274366,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1877,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 39,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.2",
      "ID": 2533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2394,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo",
      "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1029574+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2110E220P414VM266079",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 266079,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1877,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 39,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.2",
      "ID": 2533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth",
      "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4734445+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250667",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250667,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1877,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 39,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.2",
      "ID": 2533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2675,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob",
      "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.2083579+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221134",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221134,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1877,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 39,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.2",
      "ID": 2533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1741,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel",
      "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6765338+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1756E218P467VM226466",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 226466,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1877,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 39,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.2",
      "ID": 2533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1756,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine",
      "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2326253+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1860E104P150VM239697",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239697,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1877,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 39,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.2",
      "ID": 2533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1860,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda",
      "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.75505+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2033E20P141VM253225",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253225,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1877,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 39,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.2",
      "ID": 2533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2033,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain",
      "DisplayName": "Iain Gray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.9867778+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324778",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324778,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1877,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 39,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.2",
      "ID": 2533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5042,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2374419+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2892E76P97VM261606",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261606,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1877,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 39,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.2",
      "ID": 2533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick",
      "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3647185+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239520",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239520,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1877,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 39,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.2",
      "ID": 2533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2029,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh",
      "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7473034+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273596",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 273596,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1877,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 39,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.2",
      "ID": 2533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3758,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6272095+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4086E128P311VM303693",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 303693,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1877,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 39,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.2",
      "ID": 2533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4086,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Hume",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.826292+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1773E242P494VM223180",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223180,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1877,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 39,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.2",
      "ID": 2533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1773,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.2320642+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1882E227P459VM245692",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 245692,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1877,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 39,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.2",
      "ID": 2533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1882,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam",
      "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8543626+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223354",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223354,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1877,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 39,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.2",
      "ID": 2533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1893,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4542618+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307924",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307924,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1877,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 39,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.2",
      "ID": 2533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4934,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.856812+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272403",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 272403,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1877,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 39,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.2",
      "ID": 2533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4956,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Keir",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3338431+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2059E26P131VM245090",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 245090,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1877,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 39,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.2",
      "ID": 2533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Kelly",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5915637+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315258",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315258,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1877,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 39,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.2",
      "ID": 2533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3129,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.900742+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247441",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247441,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1877,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 39,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.2",
      "ID": 2533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann",
      "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4039411+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4016E11P36VM275506",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 275506,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1877,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 39,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.2",
      "ID": 2533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4016,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.3782003+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255443",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255443,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1877,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 39,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.2",
      "ID": 2533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2180,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5315706+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4938E158P374VM276893",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276893,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1877,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 39,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.2",
      "ID": 2533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4938,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6856288+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2112E250P486VM253521",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253521,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1877,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 39,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.2",
      "ID": 2533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2112,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny",
      "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0000107+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4939E258P394VM279181",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279181,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1877,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 39,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.2",
      "ID": 2533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4939,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus",
      "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2565161+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325353",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 325353,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1877,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 39,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.2",
      "ID": 2533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5074,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon",
      "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.4950393+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1828E3P10VM231927",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231927,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1877,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 39,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.2",
      "ID": 2533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1828,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo",
      "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6217664+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311768",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311768,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1877,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 39,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.2",
      "ID": 2533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4948,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike",
      "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8934358+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2117E90P107VM233194",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 233194,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1877,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 39,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.2",
      "ID": 2533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2117,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis",
      "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.900916+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267552",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 267552,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1877,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 39,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.2",
      "ID": 2533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken",
      "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0247826+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313392",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313392,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1877,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 39,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.2",
      "ID": 2533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4966,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek",
      "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.3933926+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3101E102P129VM294422",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 294422,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1877,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 39,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.2",
      "ID": 2533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3101,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala",
      "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1376459+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319221",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319221,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1877,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 39,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.2",
      "ID": 2533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5034,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny",
      "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9106931+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306227",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306227,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1877,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 39,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.2",
      "ID": 2533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2159,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Martin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5430202+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5110E252P395VM310373",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 310373,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1877,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 39,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.2",
      "ID": 2533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Mason",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5677304+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268052",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 268052,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1877,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 39,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.2",
      "ID": 2533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2133,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0539311+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2876E141P433VM293004",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 293004,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1877,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 39,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.2",
      "ID": 2533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2876,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.567491+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4951E147P368VM271859",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271859,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1877,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 39,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.2",
      "ID": 2533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4951,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan",
      "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0944981+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3896E175P307VM269809",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269809,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1877,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 39,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.2",
      "ID": 2533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3896,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam",
      "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.563856+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5080E110P121VM307222",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307222,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1877,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 39,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.2",
      "ID": 2533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8199053+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4964E143P375VM280180",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280180,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1877,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 39,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.2",
      "ID": 2533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4964,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5448679+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279158",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279158,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1877,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 39,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.2",
      "ID": 2533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3824,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2555368+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2066E22P91VM260431",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 260431,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1877,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 39,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.2",
      "ID": 2533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2066,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.0765716+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299323",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 299323,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1877,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 39,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.2",
      "ID": 2533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.6925097+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3759E260P411VM301780",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 301780,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1877,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 39,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.2",
      "ID": 2533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina",
      "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.2829352+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300491",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 300491,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1877,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 39,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.2",
      "ID": 2533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2487,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0004782+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1775E215P453VM224191",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 224191,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1877,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 39,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.2",
      "ID": 2533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4964951+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237945",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237945,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1877,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 39,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.2",
      "ID": 2533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1961,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David",
      "DisplayName": "David McLetchie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2328652+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305640",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 305640,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1877,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 39,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.2",
      "ID": 2533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2134,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3330727+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320049",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 320049,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1877,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 39,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.2",
      "ID": 2533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5041,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan",
      "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9592819+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315825",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315825,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1877,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 39,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.2",
      "ID": 2533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3763,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart",
      "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9286689+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1986E23P197VM237144",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237144,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1877,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 39,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.2",
      "ID": 2533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1986,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan",
      "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9676908+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5047E100P130VM288902",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 288902,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1877,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 39,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.2",
      "ID": 2533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5047,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne",
      "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1632812+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234217",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234217,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1877,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 39,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.2",
      "ID": 2533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1845,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette",
      "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3673133+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313084",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313084,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1877,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 39,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.2",
      "ID": 2533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3061,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1629643+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1768E19P265VM261294",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261294,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1877,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 39,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.2",
      "ID": 2533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1768,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3511725+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225587",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225587,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1877,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 39,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.2",
      "ID": 2533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1894,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Neil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9817657+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3815E98P134VM271001",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271001,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1877,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 39,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.2",
      "ID": 2533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3815,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Park, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Park",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8382749+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265657",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265657,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1877,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 39,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.2",
      "ID": 2533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2010,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil",
      "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4486673+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5057E92P116VM284202",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 284202,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1877,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 39,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.2",
      "ID": 2533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5057,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0158552+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2853E33P128VM252132",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252132,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1877,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 39,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.2",
      "ID": 2533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Pentland",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.5039752+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317272",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317272,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1877,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 39,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.2",
      "ID": 2533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5009,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4112691+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3745E233P381VM256697",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 256697,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1877,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 39,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.2",
      "ID": 2533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3745,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis",
      "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.7938354+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1870E225P478VM293351",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 293351,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1877,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 39,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.2",
      "ID": 2533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1870,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona",
      "DisplayName": "Shona Robison",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8412806+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2135E254P450VM235889",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235889,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1877,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 39,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.2",
      "ID": 2533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2135,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Russell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6972966+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1895E232P431VM255896",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255896,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1877,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 39,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.2",
      "ID": 2533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1895,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5616392+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228629",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 228629,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1877,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 39,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.2",
      "ID": 2533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1839,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.807356+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2345E10P55VM289522",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289522,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1877,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 39,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.2",
      "ID": 2533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2345,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4476709+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311539",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311539,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1877,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 39,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.2",
      "ID": 2533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2223,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish",
      "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8832211+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246850",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 246850,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1877,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 39,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.2",
      "ID": 2533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2182,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1560848+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5079E101P119VM297656",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 297656,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1877,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 39,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.2",
      "ID": 2533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5079,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew",
      "DisplayName": "Drew Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1190633+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1769E32P285VM233842",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 233842,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1877,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 39,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.2",
      "ID": 2533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1769,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1486856+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274942",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274942,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1877,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 39,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.2",
      "ID": 2533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4014,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz",
      "DisplayName": "Liz Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.128678+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2215E224P447VM270028",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270028,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1877,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 39,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.2",
      "ID": 2533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2215,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5784429+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317723",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317723,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1877,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 39,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.2",
      "ID": 2533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3806,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.43461+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326477",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 326477,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1877,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 39,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.2",
      "ID": 2533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5106,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin",
      "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7663827+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241334",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241334,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1877,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 39,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.2",
      "ID": 2533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1848,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola",
      "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7534654+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2098E237P531VM290450",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 290450,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1877,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 39,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.2",
      "ID": 2533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2098,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Swinney",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7476027+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248141",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248141,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1877,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 39,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.2",
      "ID": 2533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2674,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave",
      "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4445515+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5075E234P371VM289207",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289207,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1877,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 39,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.2",
      "ID": 2533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5075,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Torrance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4269765+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1793E151P362VM222677",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 222677,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1877,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 39,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.2",
      "ID": 2533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1793,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean",
      "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1991966+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5078E245P15VM306904",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306904,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1877,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 39,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.2",
      "ID": 2533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5078,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Walker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5788452+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1841E231P426VM240941",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 240941,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1877,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 39,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.2",
      "ID": 2533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1841,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen",
      "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3889993+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283999",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283999,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1877,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 39,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.2",
      "ID": 2533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4952,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7326082+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1865E263P500VM231095",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231095,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1877,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 39,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.2",
      "ID": 2533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1865,
      "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra",
      "DisplayName": "Sandra White",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3654062+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2610E160P413VM247297",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247297,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1877,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 39,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.2",
      "ID": 2533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2610,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Wilson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.3975215+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4941E150P382VM308913",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 308913,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1877,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 39,
      "VoteAgainst": 61,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.2",
      "ID": 2533
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4941,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza",
      "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0834806+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1926E229P470VM253092",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253092,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1878,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.1",
      "ID": 2525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1926,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian",
      "DisplayName": "Brian Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7665166+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2615E213P388VM259206",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 259206,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1878,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.1",
      "ID": 2525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2615,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George",
      "DisplayName": "George Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.5988113+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319521",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319521,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1878,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.1",
      "ID": 2525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4940,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare",
      "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9295384+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2641E256P403VM250274",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250274,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1878,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.1",
      "ID": 2525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2641,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair",
      "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1821313+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1783E21P273VM228413",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 228413,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1878,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.1",
      "ID": 2525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1783,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie",
      "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.7979443+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2633E97P136VM281108",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 281108,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1878,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.1",
      "ID": 2525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2633,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire",
      "DisplayName": "Claire Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.8063315+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2603E89P148VM263021",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 263021,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1878,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.1",
      "ID": 2525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2603,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6332439+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1759E91P115VM227445",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227445,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1878,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.1",
      "ID": 2525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia",
      "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5504729+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3751E243P383VM269665",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269665,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1878,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.1",
      "ID": 2525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3751,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5577242+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322489",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 322489,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1878,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.1",
      "ID": 2525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5109,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco",
      "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6908259+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5060E86P124VM295866",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295866,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1878,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.1",
      "ID": 2525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5060,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5392103+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1866E93P239VM243080",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 243080,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1878,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.1",
      "ID": 2525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1866,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah",
      "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0480533+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1943E145P367VM227066",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227066,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1878,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.1",
      "ID": 2525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1943,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic",
      "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2660335+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2595E12P30VM301023",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 301023,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1878,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.1",
      "ID": 2525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2595,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin",
      "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0292597+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2103E244P421VM238432",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 238432,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1878,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.1",
      "ID": 2525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2103,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith",
      "DisplayName": "Keith Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4462993+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327015",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 327015,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1878,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.1",
      "ID": 2525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7899344+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277516",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277516,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1878,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.1",
      "ID": 2525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9567124+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2673E236P377VM263969",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 263969,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1878,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.1",
      "ID": 2525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2673,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick",
      "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9185831+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2678E11P28VM250976",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250976,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1878,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.1",
      "ID": 2525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2678,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson",
      "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.2216556+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2123E27P233VM294831",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 294831,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1878,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.1",
      "ID": 2525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2123,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm",
      "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1802256+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285371",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285371,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1878,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.1",
      "ID": 2525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3907,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3201356+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1735E248P405VM231309",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231309,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1878,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.1",
      "ID": 2525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1735,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela",
      "DisplayName": "Angela Constance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.5893889+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243638",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 243638,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1878,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.1",
      "ID": 2525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1932,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce",
      "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3134968+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254388",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254388,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1878,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.1",
      "ID": 2525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1863,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna",
      "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2536058+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323468",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 323468,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1878,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.1",
      "ID": 2525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4976,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth",
      "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.957487+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5107E223P379VM300684",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 300684,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1878,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.1",
      "ID": 2525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5107,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0091662+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3743E222P391VM273068",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 273068,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1878,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.1",
      "ID": 2525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3743,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel",
      "DisplayName": "Nigel Don",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3682115+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262616",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262616,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1878,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.1",
      "ID": 2525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3771,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob",
      "DisplayName": "Bob Doris",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6095406+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281785",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 281785,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1878,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.1",
      "ID": 2525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2826,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Dornan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1575182+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298496",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298496,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1878,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.1",
      "ID": 2525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3812,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia",
      "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3486411+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231109",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231109,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1878,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.1",
      "ID": 2525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1778,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen",
      "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3660135+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4955E240P389VM284911",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 284911,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1878,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.1",
      "ID": 2525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4955,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0529961+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219599",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 219599,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1878,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.1",
      "ID": 2525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1742,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle",
      "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3063239+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238222",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 238222,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1878,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.1",
      "ID": 2525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1994,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus",
      "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.437082+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1814E269P519VM226701",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 226701,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1878,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.1",
      "ID": 2525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1814,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda",
      "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2428694+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321971",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 321971,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1878,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.1",
      "ID": 2525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Fee",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4593228+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292672",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 292672,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1878,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.1",
      "ID": 2525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia",
      "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.552873+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227627",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227627,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1878,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.1",
      "ID": 2525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.558295+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5054E95P118VM304586",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 304586,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1878,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.1",
      "ID": 2525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5054,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.0447664+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4947E152P361VM257852",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257852,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1878,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.1",
      "ID": 2525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4947,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Finnie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0803718+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271043",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271043,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1878,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.1",
      "ID": 2525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3901,
      "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe",
      "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8400738+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2394E15P47VM274365",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274365,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1878,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.1",
      "ID": 2525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2394,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo",
      "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1029156+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2110E220P414VM266080",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 266080,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1878,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.1",
      "ID": 2525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth",
      "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4734851+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250669",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250669,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1878,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.1",
      "ID": 2525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2675,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob",
      "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.2084379+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221135",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221135,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1878,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.1",
      "ID": 2525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1741,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel",
      "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6765749+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1756E218P467VM226465",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 226465,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1878,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.1",
      "ID": 2525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1756,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine",
      "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2325831+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1860E104P150VM239698",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239698,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1878,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.1",
      "ID": 2525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1860,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda",
      "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7550903+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2033E20P141VM253224",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253224,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1878,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.1",
      "ID": 2525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2033,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain",
      "DisplayName": "Iain Gray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.9867368+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324783",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324783,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1878,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.1",
      "ID": 2525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5042,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2376622+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2892E76P97VM261605",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261605,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1878,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.1",
      "ID": 2525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick",
      "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.364677+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239521",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239521,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1878,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.1",
      "ID": 2525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2029,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh",
      "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7473441+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273595",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 273595,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1878,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.1",
      "ID": 2525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3758,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6271689+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4086E128P311VM303692",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 303692,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1878,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.1",
      "ID": 2525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4086,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Hume",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8262329+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1773E242P494VM223179",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223179,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1878,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.1",
      "ID": 2525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1773,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.2320228+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1882E227P459VM245690",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 245690,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1878,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.1",
      "ID": 2525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1882,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam",
      "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8542818+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223353",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223353,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1878,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.1",
      "ID": 2525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1893,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4542205+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307925",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307925,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1878,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.1",
      "ID": 2525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4934,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8568538+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272506",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 272506,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1878,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.1",
      "ID": 2525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4956,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Keir",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3383296+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2059E26P131VM245091",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 245091,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1878,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.1",
      "ID": 2525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Kelly",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5916231+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315259",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315259,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1878,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.1",
      "ID": 2525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3129,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9007831+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247440",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247440,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1878,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.1",
      "ID": 2525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann",
      "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4039004+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4016E11P36VM275507",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 275507,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1878,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.1",
      "ID": 2525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4016,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.3782411+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255442",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255442,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1878,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.1",
      "ID": 2525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2180,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.53153+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4938E158P374VM276892",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276892,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1878,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.1",
      "ID": 2525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4938,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6855882+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2112E250P486VM253522",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253522,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1878,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.1",
      "ID": 2525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2112,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny",
      "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0000516+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4939E258P394VM278874",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 278874,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1878,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.1",
      "ID": 2525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4939,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus",
      "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2379509+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325348",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 325348,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1878,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.1",
      "ID": 2525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5074,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon",
      "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.4948155+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1828E3P10VM231928",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231928,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1878,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.1",
      "ID": 2525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1828,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo",
      "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6218082+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311769",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311769,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1878,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.1",
      "ID": 2525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4948,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike",
      "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8934769+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2117E90P107VM233193",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 233193,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1878,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.1",
      "ID": 2525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2117,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis",
      "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.9008745+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267553",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 267553,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1878,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.1",
      "ID": 2525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken",
      "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0248238+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313391",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313391,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1878,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.1",
      "ID": 2525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4966,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek",
      "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.393352+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3101E102P129VM294421",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 294421,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1878,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.1",
      "ID": 2525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3101,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala",
      "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1376048+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319220",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319220,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1878,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.1",
      "ID": 2525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5034,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny",
      "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9106505+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306226",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306226,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1878,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.1",
      "ID": 2525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2159,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Martin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5429539+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5110E252P395VM310372",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 310372,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1878,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.1",
      "ID": 2525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Mason",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5676887+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268051",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 268051,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1878,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.1",
      "ID": 2525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2133,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0538897+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2876E141P433VM293005",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 293005,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1878,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.1",
      "ID": 2525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2876,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5675326+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4951E147P368VM271444",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271444,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1878,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.1",
      "ID": 2525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4951,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan",
      "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0760824+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3896E175P307VM269808",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269808,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1878,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.1",
      "ID": 2525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3896,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam",
      "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5638143+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5080E110P121VM307223",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307223,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1878,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.1",
      "ID": 2525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.819946+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4964E143P375VM280181",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280181,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1878,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.1",
      "ID": 2525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4964,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5449105+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279157",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279157,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1878,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.1",
      "ID": 2525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3824,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2554955+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2066E22P91VM260430",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 260430,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1878,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.1",
      "ID": 2525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2066,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.0765303+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299322",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 299322,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1878,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.1",
      "ID": 2525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.6924682+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3759E260P411VM301781",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 301781,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1878,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.1",
      "ID": 2525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina",
      "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.2829759+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300490",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 300490,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1878,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.1",
      "ID": 2525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2487,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0004365+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1775E215P453VM224192",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 224192,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1878,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.1",
      "ID": 2525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4965364+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237946",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237946,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1878,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.1",
      "ID": 2525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1961,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David",
      "DisplayName": "David McLetchie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2329073+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305641",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 305641,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1878,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.1",
      "ID": 2525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2134,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3331156+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320050",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 320050,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1878,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.1",
      "ID": 2525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5041,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan",
      "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9593232+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315824",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315824,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1878,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.1",
      "ID": 2525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3763,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart",
      "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9286265+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1986E23P197VM237145",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237145,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1878,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.1",
      "ID": 2525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1986,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan",
      "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.967731+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5047E100P130VM288901",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 288901,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1878,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.1",
      "ID": 2525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5047,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne",
      "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1632412+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234216",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234216,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1878,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.1",
      "ID": 2525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1845,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette",
      "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3672716+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313083",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313083,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1878,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.1",
      "ID": 2525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3061,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1629031+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1768E19P265VM261295",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261295,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1878,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.1",
      "ID": 2525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1768,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3512137+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225588",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225588,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1878,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.1",
      "ID": 2525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1894,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Neil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9818073+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3815E98P134VM271002",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271002,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1878,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.1",
      "ID": 2525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3815,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Park, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Park",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8383162+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265656",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265656,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1878,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.1",
      "ID": 2525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2010,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil",
      "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4486262+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5057E92P116VM284201",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 284201,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1878,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.1",
      "ID": 2525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5057,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.015812+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2853E33P128VM252133",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252133,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1878,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.1",
      "ID": 2525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Pentland",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.5040191+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317273",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317273,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1878,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.1",
      "ID": 2525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5009,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4113284+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3745E233P381VM256695",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 256695,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1878,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.1",
      "ID": 2525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3745,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis",
      "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.7937524+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1870E225P478VM293352",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 293352,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1878,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.1",
      "ID": 2525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1870,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona",
      "DisplayName": "Shona Robison",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8413217+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2135E254P450VM235890",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235890,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1878,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.1",
      "ID": 2525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2135,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Russell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6973375+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1895E232P431VM255897",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255897,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1878,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.1",
      "ID": 2525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1895,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5616979+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228630",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 228630,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1878,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.1",
      "ID": 2525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1839,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.807398+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2345E10P55VM289521",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289521,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1878,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.1",
      "ID": 2525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2345,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4408321+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311540",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311540,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1878,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.1",
      "ID": 2525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2223,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish",
      "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8832627+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246852",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 246852,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1878,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.1",
      "ID": 2525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2182,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1561659+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5079E101P119VM297655",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 297655,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1878,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.1",
      "ID": 2525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5079,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew",
      "DisplayName": "Drew Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1189896+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1769E32P285VM233841",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 233841,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1878,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.1",
      "ID": 2525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1769,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1486438+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274943",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274943,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1878,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.1",
      "ID": 2525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4014,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz",
      "DisplayName": "Liz Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1287374+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2215E224P447VM270029",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270029,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1878,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.1",
      "ID": 2525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2215,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5784838+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317724",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317724,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1878,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.1",
      "ID": 2525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3806,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4346506+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326482",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 326482,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1878,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.1",
      "ID": 2525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5106,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin",
      "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.766586+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241336",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241336,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1878,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.1",
      "ID": 2525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1848,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola",
      "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7535482+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2098E237P531VM290451",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 290451,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1878,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.1",
      "ID": 2525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2098,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Swinney",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7476433+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248142",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248142,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1878,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.1",
      "ID": 2525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2674,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave",
      "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4446277+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5075E234P371VM289208",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289208,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1878,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.1",
      "ID": 2525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5075,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Torrance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4270619+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1793E151P362VM222678",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 222678,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1878,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.1",
      "ID": 2525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1793,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean",
      "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.199238+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5078E245P15VM306903",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306903,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1878,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.1",
      "ID": 2525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5078,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Walker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5787961+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1841E231P426VM240939",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 240939,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1878,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.1",
      "ID": 2525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1841,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen",
      "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3889168+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4952E148P370VM284000",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 284000,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1878,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.1",
      "ID": 2525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4952,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7326498+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1865E263P500VM231094",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231094,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1878,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.1",
      "ID": 2525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1865,
      "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra",
      "DisplayName": "Sandra White",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3653656+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2610E160P413VM247296",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247296,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1878,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.1",
      "ID": 2525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2610,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Wilson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.3974805+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4941E150P382VM308912",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 308912,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1878,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 13,
      "VoteAgainst": 98,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431.1",
      "ID": 2525
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4941,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza",
      "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0834388+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1926E229P470VM253093",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253093,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1879,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 98,
      "VoteAgainst": 13,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431",
      "ID": 2511
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1926,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian",
      "DisplayName": "Brian Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7665575+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2615E213P388VM259207",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 259207,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1879,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 98,
      "VoteAgainst": 13,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431",
      "ID": 2511
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2615,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George",
      "DisplayName": "George Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.5988555+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319520",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319520,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1879,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 98,
      "VoteAgainst": 13,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431",
      "ID": 2511
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4940,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare",
      "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9294965+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2641E256P403VM250172",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250172,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1879,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 98,
      "VoteAgainst": 13,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431",
      "ID": 2511
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2641,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair",
      "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9666677+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1783E21P273VM228414",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 228414,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1879,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 98,
      "VoteAgainst": 13,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431",
      "ID": 2511
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1783,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie",
      "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.7979858+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2633E97P136VM281109",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 281109,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1879,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 98,
      "VoteAgainst": 13,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431",
      "ID": 2511
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2633,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire",
      "DisplayName": "Claire Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.8063719+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2603E89P148VM263022",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 263022,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1879,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 98,
      "VoteAgainst": 13,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431",
      "ID": 2511
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2603,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6332855+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1759E91P115VM227446",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227446,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1879,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 98,
      "VoteAgainst": 13,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431",
      "ID": 2511
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia",
      "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.550514+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3751E243P383VM269664",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269664,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1879,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 98,
      "VoteAgainst": 13,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431",
      "ID": 2511
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3751,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5576827+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322490",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 322490,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1879,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 98,
      "VoteAgainst": 13,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431",
      "ID": 2511
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5109,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco",
      "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6908675+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5060E86P124VM295867",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295867,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1879,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 98,
      "VoteAgainst": 13,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431",
      "ID": 2511
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5060,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5392528+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1866E93P239VM243081",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 243081,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1879,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 98,
      "VoteAgainst": 13,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431",
      "ID": 2511
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1866,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah",
      "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0480944+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1943E145P367VM227065",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227065,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1879,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 98,
      "VoteAgainst": 13,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431",
      "ID": 2511
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1943,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic",
      "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2659923+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2595E12P30VM301024",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 301024,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1879,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 98,
      "VoteAgainst": 13,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431",
      "ID": 2511
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2595,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin",
      "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0293019+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2103E244P421VM238431",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 238431,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1879,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 98,
      "VoteAgainst": 13,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431",
      "ID": 2511
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2103,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith",
      "DisplayName": "Keith Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4462406+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327016",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 327016,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1879,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 98,
      "VoteAgainst": 13,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431",
      "ID": 2511
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7899757+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277517",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277517,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1879,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 98,
      "VoteAgainst": 13,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431",
      "ID": 2511
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9567542+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2673E236P377VM263968",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 263968,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1879,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 98,
      "VoteAgainst": 13,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431",
      "ID": 2511
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2673,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick",
      "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9185423+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2678E11P28VM250975",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250975,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1879,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 98,
      "VoteAgainst": 13,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431",
      "ID": 2511
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2678,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson",
      "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.2215972+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2123E27P233VM294830",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 294830,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1879,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 98,
      "VoteAgainst": 13,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431",
      "ID": 2511
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2123,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm",
      "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1801845+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285372",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285372,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1879,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 98,
      "VoteAgainst": 13,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431",
      "ID": 2511
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3907,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3201772+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1735E248P405VM231310",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231310,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1879,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 98,
      "VoteAgainst": 13,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431",
      "ID": 2511
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1735,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela",
      "DisplayName": "Angela Constance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.5894297+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243637",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 243637,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1879,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 98,
      "VoteAgainst": 13,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431",
      "ID": 2511
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1932,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce",
      "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3134568+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254387",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254387,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1879,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 98,
      "VoteAgainst": 13,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431",
      "ID": 2511
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1863,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna",
      "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2535624+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323469",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 323469,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1879,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 98,
      "VoteAgainst": 13,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431",
      "ID": 2511
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4976,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth",
      "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9575289+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5107E223P379VM300683",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 300683,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1879,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 98,
      "VoteAgainst": 13,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431",
      "ID": 2511
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5107,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0091248+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3743E222P391VM273069",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 273069,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1879,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 98,
      "VoteAgainst": 13,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431",
      "ID": 2511
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3743,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel",
      "DisplayName": "Nigel Don",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3682525+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262617",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262617,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1879,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 98,
      "VoteAgainst": 13,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431",
      "ID": 2511
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3771,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob",
      "DisplayName": "Bob Doris",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6095825+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281784",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 281784,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1879,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 98,
      "VoteAgainst": 13,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431",
      "ID": 2511
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2826,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Dornan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1574599+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298497",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298497,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1879,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 98,
      "VoteAgainst": 13,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431",
      "ID": 2511
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3812,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia",
      "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3486821+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231108",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231108,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1879,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 98,
      "VoteAgainst": 13,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431",
      "ID": 2511
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1778,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen",
      "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3659546+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4955E240P389VM284910",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 284910,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1879,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 98,
      "VoteAgainst": 13,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431",
      "ID": 2511
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4955,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0529548+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219600",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 219600,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1879,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 98,
      "VoteAgainst": 13,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431",
      "ID": 2511
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1742,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle",
      "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3063663+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238221",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 238221,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1879,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 98,
      "VoteAgainst": 13,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431",
      "ID": 2511
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1994,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus",
      "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4370377+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1814E269P519VM226289",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 226289,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1879,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 98,
      "VoteAgainst": 13,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431",
      "ID": 2511
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1814,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda",
      "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2191708+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321970",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 321970,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1879,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 98,
      "VoteAgainst": 13,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431",
      "ID": 2511
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Fee",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4592813+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292671",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 292671,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1879,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 98,
      "VoteAgainst": 13,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431",
      "ID": 2511
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia",
      "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5528326+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227628",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227628,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1879,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 98,
      "VoteAgainst": 13,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431",
      "ID": 2511
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5583713+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5054E95P118VM304587",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 304587,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1879,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 98,
      "VoteAgainst": 13,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431",
      "ID": 2511
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5054,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.0448066+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4947E152P361VM257954",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257954,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1879,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 98,
      "VoteAgainst": 13,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431",
      "ID": 2511
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4947,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Finnie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.085058+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271042",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271042,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1879,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 98,
      "VoteAgainst": 13,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431",
      "ID": 2511
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3901,
      "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe",
      "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8400314+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2394E15P47VM274364",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274364,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1879,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 98,
      "VoteAgainst": 13,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431",
      "ID": 2511
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2394,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo",
      "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.102874+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2110E220P414VM266081",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 266081,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1879,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 98,
      "VoteAgainst": 13,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431",
      "ID": 2511
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth",
      "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4735448+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250771",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250771,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1879,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 98,
      "VoteAgainst": 13,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431",
      "ID": 2511
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2675,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob",
      "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.2128257+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221237",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221237,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1879,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 98,
      "VoteAgainst": 13,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431",
      "ID": 2511
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1741,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel",
      "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9206732+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1756E218P467VM226464",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 226464,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1879,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 98,
      "VoteAgainst": 13,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431",
      "ID": 2511
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1756,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine",
      "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2325409+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1860E104P150VM239699",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239699,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1879,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 98,
      "VoteAgainst": 13,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431",
      "ID": 2511
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1860,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda",
      "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7551306+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2033E20P141VM253223",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253223,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1879,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 98,
      "VoteAgainst": 13,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431",
      "ID": 2511
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2033,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain",
      "DisplayName": "Iain Gray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.9866956+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324782",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324782,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1879,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 98,
      "VoteAgainst": 13,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431",
      "ID": 2511
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5042,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2376204+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2892E76P97VM261604",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261604,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1879,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 98,
      "VoteAgainst": 13,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431",
      "ID": 2511
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick",
      "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3646362+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239522",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239522,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1879,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 98,
      "VoteAgainst": 13,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431",
      "ID": 2511
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2029,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh",
      "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7474033+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273594",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 273594,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1879,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 98,
      "VoteAgainst": 13,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431",
      "ID": 2511
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3758,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6271265+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4086E128P311VM303691",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 303691,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1879,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 98,
      "VoteAgainst": 13,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431",
      "ID": 2511
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4086,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Hume",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8261923+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1773E242P494VM222302",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 222302,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1879,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 98,
      "VoteAgainst": 13,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431",
      "ID": 2511
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1773,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1828924+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1882E227P459VM245587",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 245587,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1879,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 98,
      "VoteAgainst": 13,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431",
      "ID": 2511
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1882,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam",
      "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.849857+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223352",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223352,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1879,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 98,
      "VoteAgainst": 13,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431",
      "ID": 2511
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1893,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4541792+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307926",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307926,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1879,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 98,
      "VoteAgainst": 13,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431",
      "ID": 2511
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4934,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8568951+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272508",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 272508,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1879,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 98,
      "VoteAgainst": 13,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431",
      "ID": 2511
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4956,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Keir",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3384307+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2059E26P131VM245092",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 245092,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1879,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 98,
      "VoteAgainst": 13,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431",
      "ID": 2511
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Kelly",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5916651+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315260",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315260,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1879,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 98,
      "VoteAgainst": 13,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431",
      "ID": 2511
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3129,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9008447+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247439",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247439,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1879,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 98,
      "VoteAgainst": 13,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431",
      "ID": 2511
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann",
      "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4038589+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4016E11P36VM275508",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 275508,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1879,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 98,
      "VoteAgainst": 13,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431",
      "ID": 2511
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4016,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.3782827+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255441",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255441,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1879,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 98,
      "VoteAgainst": 13,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431",
      "ID": 2511
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2180,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.531489+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4938E158P374VM276891",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276891,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1879,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 98,
      "VoteAgainst": 13,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431",
      "ID": 2511
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4938,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6855479+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2112E250P486VM253523",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253523,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1879,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 98,
      "VoteAgainst": 13,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431",
      "ID": 2511
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2112,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny",
      "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0000932+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4939E258P394VM278873",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 278873,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1879,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 98,
      "VoteAgainst": 13,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431",
      "ID": 2511
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4939,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus",
      "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2379101+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325349",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 325349,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1879,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 98,
      "VoteAgainst": 13,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431",
      "ID": 2511
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5074,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon",
      "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.4948563+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1828E3P10VM231929",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231929,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1879,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 98,
      "VoteAgainst": 13,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431",
      "ID": 2511
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1828,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo",
      "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6218502+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311770",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311770,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1879,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 98,
      "VoteAgainst": 13,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431",
      "ID": 2511
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4948,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike",
      "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8935191+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2117E90P107VM233192",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 233192,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1879,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 98,
      "VoteAgainst": 13,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431",
      "ID": 2511
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2117,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis",
      "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.9008329+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267554",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 267554,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1879,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 98,
      "VoteAgainst": 13,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431",
      "ID": 2511
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken",
      "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0248651+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313390",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313390,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1879,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 98,
      "VoteAgainst": 13,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431",
      "ID": 2511
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4966,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek",
      "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.393311+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3101E102P129VM294420",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 294420,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1879,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 98,
      "VoteAgainst": 13,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431",
      "ID": 2511
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3101,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala",
      "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1375633+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319219",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319219,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1879,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 98,
      "VoteAgainst": 13,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431",
      "ID": 2511
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5034,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny",
      "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9106059+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306225",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306225,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1879,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 98,
      "VoteAgainst": 13,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431",
      "ID": 2511
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2159,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Martin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5429128+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5110E252P395VM310371",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 310371,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1879,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 98,
      "VoteAgainst": 13,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431",
      "ID": 2511
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Mason",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5676472+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268050",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 268050,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1879,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 98,
      "VoteAgainst": 13,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431",
      "ID": 2511
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2133,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0538479+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2876E141P433VM293006",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 293006,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1879,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 98,
      "VoteAgainst": 13,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431",
      "ID": 2511
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2876,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.567592+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4951E147P368VM271441",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271441,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1879,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 98,
      "VoteAgainst": 13,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431",
      "ID": 2511
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4951,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan",
      "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0759579+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3896E175P307VM269807",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269807,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1879,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 98,
      "VoteAgainst": 13,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431",
      "ID": 2511
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3896,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam",
      "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5637728+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5080E110P121VM307224",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307224,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1879,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 98,
      "VoteAgainst": 13,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431",
      "ID": 2511
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8199877+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4964E143P375VM280182",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280182,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1879,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 98,
      "VoteAgainst": 13,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431",
      "ID": 2511
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4964,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5449522+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279156",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279156,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1879,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 98,
      "VoteAgainst": 13,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431",
      "ID": 2511
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3824,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2554543+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2066E22P91VM260429",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 260429,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1879,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 98,
      "VoteAgainst": 13,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431",
      "ID": 2511
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2066,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.0764877+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299321",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 299321,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1879,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 98,
      "VoteAgainst": 13,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431",
      "ID": 2511
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.692427+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3759E260P411VM301782",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 301782,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1879,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 98,
      "VoteAgainst": 13,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431",
      "ID": 2511
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina",
      "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.2830175+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300489",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 300489,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1879,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 98,
      "VoteAgainst": 13,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431",
      "ID": 2511
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2487,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.000394+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1775E215P453VM224294",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 224294,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1879,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 98,
      "VoteAgainst": 13,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431",
      "ID": 2511
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.6927137+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237947",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237947,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1879,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 98,
      "VoteAgainst": 13,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431",
      "ID": 2511
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1961,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David",
      "DisplayName": "David McLetchie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2329488+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305642",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 305642,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1879,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 98,
      "VoteAgainst": 13,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431",
      "ID": 2511
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2134,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3331564+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320051",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 320051,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1879,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 98,
      "VoteAgainst": 13,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431",
      "ID": 2511
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5041,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan",
      "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9593644+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315823",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315823,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1879,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 98,
      "VoteAgainst": 13,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431",
      "ID": 2511
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3763,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart",
      "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9285853+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1986E23P197VM237146",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237146,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1879,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 98,
      "VoteAgainst": 13,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431",
      "ID": 2511
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1986,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan",
      "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9677704+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5047E100P130VM288900",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 288900,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1879,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 98,
      "VoteAgainst": 13,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431",
      "ID": 2511
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5047,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne",
      "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1632011+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234215",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234215,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1879,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 98,
      "VoteAgainst": 13,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431",
      "ID": 2511
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1845,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette",
      "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3672286+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313082",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313082,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1879,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 98,
      "VoteAgainst": 13,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431",
      "ID": 2511
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3061,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1628604+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1768E19P265VM261296",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261296,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1879,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 98,
      "VoteAgainst": 13,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431",
      "ID": 2511
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1768,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3512548+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225589",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225589,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1879,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 98,
      "VoteAgainst": 13,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431",
      "ID": 2511
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1894,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Neil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9818481+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3815E98P134VM271003",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271003,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1879,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 98,
      "VoteAgainst": 13,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431",
      "ID": 2511
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3815,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Park, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Park",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8383567+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265655",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265655,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1879,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 98,
      "VoteAgainst": 13,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431",
      "ID": 2511
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2010,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil",
      "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4485848+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5057E92P116VM284200",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 284200,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1879,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 98,
      "VoteAgainst": 13,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431",
      "ID": 2511
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5057,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0157681+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2853E33P128VM252134",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252134,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1879,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 98,
      "VoteAgainst": 13,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431",
      "ID": 2511
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Pentland",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.5040604+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317274",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317274,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1879,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 98,
      "VoteAgainst": 13,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431",
      "ID": 2511
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5009,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4113717+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3745E233P381VM256134",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 256134,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1879,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 98,
      "VoteAgainst": 13,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431",
      "ID": 2511
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3745,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis",
      "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5720866+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1870E225P478VM293353",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 293353,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1879,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 98,
      "VoteAgainst": 13,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431",
      "ID": 2511
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1870,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona",
      "DisplayName": "Shona Robison",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8413634+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2135E254P450VM235891",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235891,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1879,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 98,
      "VoteAgainst": 13,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431",
      "ID": 2511
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2135,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Russell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6973784+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1895E232P431VM255898",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255898,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1879,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 98,
      "VoteAgainst": 13,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431",
      "ID": 2511
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1895,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5617397+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1839E21P87VM229348",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229348,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1879,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 98,
      "VoteAgainst": 13,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431",
      "ID": 2511
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1839,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0778488+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2345E10P55VM289520",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289520,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1879,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 98,
      "VoteAgainst": 13,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431",
      "ID": 2511
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2345,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.44079+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311541",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311541,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1879,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 98,
      "VoteAgainst": 13,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431",
      "ID": 2511
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2223,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish",
      "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8833046+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2182E87P175VM247105",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247105,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1879,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 98,
      "VoteAgainst": 13,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431",
      "ID": 2511
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2182,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1672688+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5079E101P119VM297654",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 297654,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1879,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 98,
      "VoteAgainst": 13,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431",
      "ID": 2511
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5079,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew",
      "DisplayName": "Drew Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1094719+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1769E32P285VM233840",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 233840,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1879,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 98,
      "VoteAgainst": 13,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431",
      "ID": 2511
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1769,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1486023+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274944",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274944,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1879,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 98,
      "VoteAgainst": 13,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431",
      "ID": 2511
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4014,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz",
      "DisplayName": "Liz Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1287806+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2215E224P447VM270030",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270030,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1879,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 98,
      "VoteAgainst": 13,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431",
      "ID": 2511
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2215,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5785255+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317725",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317725,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1879,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 98,
      "VoteAgainst": 13,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431",
      "ID": 2511
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3806,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4346909+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326481",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 326481,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1879,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 98,
      "VoteAgainst": 13,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431",
      "ID": 2511
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5106,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin",
      "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7665443+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241439",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241439,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1879,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 98,
      "VoteAgainst": 13,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431",
      "ID": 2511
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1848,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola",
      "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7580046+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2098E237P531VM290452",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 290452,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1879,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 98,
      "VoteAgainst": 13,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431",
      "ID": 2511
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2098,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Swinney",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7476841+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248143",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248143,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1879,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 98,
      "VoteAgainst": 13,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431",
      "ID": 2511
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2674,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave",
      "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4446808+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5075E234P371VM289209",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289209,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1879,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 98,
      "VoteAgainst": 13,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431",
      "ID": 2511
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5075,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Torrance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4271206+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1793E151P362VM222679",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 222679,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1879,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 98,
      "VoteAgainst": 13,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431",
      "ID": 2511
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1793,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean",
      "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1992791+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5078E245P15VM306902",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306902,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1879,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 98,
      "VoteAgainst": 13,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431",
      "ID": 2511
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5078,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Walker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5787489+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1841E231P426VM240836",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 240836,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1879,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 98,
      "VoteAgainst": 13,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431",
      "ID": 2511
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1841,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen",
      "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3843727+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4952E148P370VM284001",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 284001,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1879,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 98,
      "VoteAgainst": 13,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431",
      "ID": 2511
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4952,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7326913+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1865E263P500VM231093",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231093,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1879,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 98,
      "VoteAgainst": 13,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431",
      "ID": 2511
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1865,
      "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra",
      "DisplayName": "Sandra White",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3653224+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2610E160P413VM247295",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247295,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1879,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 98,
      "VoteAgainst": 13,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431",
      "ID": 2511
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2610,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Wilson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.3974393+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4941E150P382VM308911",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 308911,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1879,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 98,
      "VoteAgainst": 13,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The UK Government Response on the Future of Remploy",
      "Reference": "S4M-02431",
      "ID": 2511
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4941,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza",
      "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.083398+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1926E229P470VM253089",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253089,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1875,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430.1",
      "ID": 2530
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1926,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian",
      "DisplayName": "Brian Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.766392+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2615E213P388VM259203",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 259203,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1875,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430.1",
      "ID": 2530
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2615,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George",
      "DisplayName": "George Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.5986555+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319524",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319524,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1875,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430.1",
      "ID": 2530
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4940,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare",
      "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9296806+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2641E256P403VM250278",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250278,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1875,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430.1",
      "ID": 2530
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2641,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair",
      "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1822938+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1783E21P273VM228410",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 228410,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1875,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430.1",
      "ID": 2530
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1783,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie",
      "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.7978199+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2633E97P136VM281105",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 281105,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1875,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430.1",
      "ID": 2530
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2633,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire",
      "DisplayName": "Claire Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.8062097+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2603E89P148VM263018",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 263018,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1875,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430.1",
      "ID": 2530
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2603,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6331201+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1759E91P115VM227442",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227442,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1875,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430.1",
      "ID": 2530
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia",
      "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5503512+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3751E243P383VM269668",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269668,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1875,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430.1",
      "ID": 2530
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3751,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5578551+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322484",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 322484,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1875,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430.1",
      "ID": 2530
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5109,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco",
      "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.690621+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5060E86P124VM295400",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295400,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1875,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430.1",
      "ID": 2530
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5060,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5105411+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1866E93P239VM243077",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 243077,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1875,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430.1",
      "ID": 2530
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1866,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah",
      "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0479311+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1943E145P367VM227069",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227069,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1875,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430.1",
      "ID": 2530
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1943,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic",
      "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2661562+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2595E12P30VM301020",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 301020,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1875,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430.1",
      "ID": 2530
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2595,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin",
      "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0289943+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2103E244P421VM238435",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 238435,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1875,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430.1",
      "ID": 2530
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2103,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith",
      "DisplayName": "Keith Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.446425+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327018",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 327018,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1875,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430.1",
      "ID": 2530
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7900591+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277513",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277513,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1875,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430.1",
      "ID": 2530
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9565722+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2673E236P377VM263972",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 263972,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1875,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430.1",
      "ID": 2530
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2673,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick",
      "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9187047+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2678E11P28VM250979",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250979,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1875,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430.1",
      "ID": 2530
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2678,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson",
      "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.2217776+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2123E27P233VM294834",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 294834,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1875,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430.1",
      "ID": 2530
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2123,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm",
      "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1803675+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285368",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285368,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1875,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430.1",
      "ID": 2530
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3907,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3200111+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1735E248P405VM231306",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231306,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1875,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430.1",
      "ID": 2530
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1735,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela",
      "DisplayName": "Angela Constance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.5892474+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243641",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 243641,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1875,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430.1",
      "ID": 2530
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1932,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce",
      "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3136166+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254391",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254391,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1875,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430.1",
      "ID": 2530
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1863,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna",
      "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2537718+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323471",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 323471,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1875,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430.1",
      "ID": 2530
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4976,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth",
      "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9576109+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5107E223P379VM300687",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 300687,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1875,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430.1",
      "ID": 2530
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5107,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0093071+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3743E222P391VM273065",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 273065,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1875,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430.1",
      "ID": 2530
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3743,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel",
      "DisplayName": "Nigel Don",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3680435+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262613",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262613,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1875,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430.1",
      "ID": 2530
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3771,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob",
      "DisplayName": "Bob Doris",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6094024+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281788",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 281788,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1875,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430.1",
      "ID": 2530
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2826,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Dornan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1576389+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298493",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298493,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1875,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430.1",
      "ID": 2530
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3812,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia",
      "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3485157+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231112",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231112,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1875,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430.1",
      "ID": 2530
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1778,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen",
      "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3661358+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4955E240P389VM284914",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 284914,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1875,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430.1",
      "ID": 2530
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4955,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0531174+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219596",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 219596,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1875,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430.1",
      "ID": 2530
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1742,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle",
      "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3061992+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238225",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 238225,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1875,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430.1",
      "ID": 2530
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1994,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus",
      "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4372067+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1814E269P519VM226704",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 226704,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1875,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430.1",
      "ID": 2530
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1814,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda",
      "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2429924+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321976",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 321976,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1875,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430.1",
      "ID": 2530
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Fee",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4595333+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292675",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 292675,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1875,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430.1",
      "ID": 2530
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia",
      "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5529942+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227624",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227624,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1875,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430.1",
      "ID": 2530
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5581732+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5054E95P118VM304583",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 304583,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1875,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430.1",
      "ID": 2530
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5054,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.0446439+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4947E152P361VM257848",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257848,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1875,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430.1",
      "ID": 2530
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4947,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Finnie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0802084+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271046",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271046,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1875,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430.1",
      "ID": 2530
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3901,
      "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe",
      "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8401959+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2394E15P47VM274368",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274368,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1875,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430.1",
      "ID": 2530
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2394,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo",
      "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1030416+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2110E220P414VM266077",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 266077,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1875,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430.1",
      "ID": 2530
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth",
      "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4733639+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250665",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250665,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1875,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430.1",
      "ID": 2530
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2675,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob",
      "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.2082765+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221132",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221132,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1875,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430.1",
      "ID": 2530
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1741,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel",
      "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.676451+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1756E218P467VM226468",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 226468,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1875,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430.1",
      "ID": 2530
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1756,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine",
      "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2327072+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1860E104P150VM239695",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239695,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1875,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430.1",
      "ID": 2530
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1860,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda",
      "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7549688+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2033E20P141VM253227",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253227,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1875,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430.1",
      "ID": 2530
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2033,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain",
      "DisplayName": "Iain Gray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.9868601+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324780",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324780,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1875,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430.1",
      "ID": 2530
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5042,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2375222+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2892E76P97VM261608",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261608,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1875,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430.1",
      "ID": 2530
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick",
      "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.364819+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239518",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239518,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1875,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430.1",
      "ID": 2530
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2029,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh",
      "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.747223+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273598",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 273598,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1875,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430.1",
      "ID": 2530
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3758,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6272904+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4086E128P311VM303695",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 303695,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1875,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430.1",
      "ID": 2530
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4086,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Hume",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8263743+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1773E242P494VM223182",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223182,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1875,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430.1",
      "ID": 2530
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1773,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.2321469+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1882E227P459VM245694",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 245694,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1875,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430.1",
      "ID": 2530
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1882,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam",
      "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8544423+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223356",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223356,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1875,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430.1",
      "ID": 2530
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1893,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4543619+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307922",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307922,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1875,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430.1",
      "ID": 2530
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4934,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8567102+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272401",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 272401,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1875,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430.1",
      "ID": 2530
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4956,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Keir",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3337613+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2059E26P131VM245088",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 245088,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1875,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430.1",
      "ID": 2530
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Kelly",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5914816+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315256",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315256,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1875,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430.1",
      "ID": 2530
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3129,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9006595+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247443",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247443,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1875,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430.1",
      "ID": 2530
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann",
      "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4040426+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4016E11P36VM275504",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 275504,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1875,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430.1",
      "ID": 2530
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4016,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.3781188+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255445",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255445,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1875,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430.1",
      "ID": 2530
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2180,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5316521+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4938E158P374VM276895",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276895,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1875,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430.1",
      "ID": 2530
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4938,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.68571+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2112E250P486VM253519",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253519,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1875,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430.1",
      "ID": 2530
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2112,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny",
      "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.9999282+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4939E258P394VM279183",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279183,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1875,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430.1",
      "ID": 2530
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4939,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus",
      "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2565968+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325351",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 325351,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1875,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430.1",
      "ID": 2530
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5074,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon",
      "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.494938+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1828E3P10VM231925",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231925,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1875,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430.1",
      "ID": 2530
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1828,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo",
      "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6216812+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311766",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311766,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1875,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430.1",
      "ID": 2530
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4948,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike",
      "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8933521+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2117E90P107VM233196",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 233196,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1875,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430.1",
      "ID": 2530
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2117,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis",
      "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.9009975+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267550",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 267550,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1875,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430.1",
      "ID": 2530
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken",
      "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0246995+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313394",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313394,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1875,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430.1",
      "ID": 2530
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4966,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek",
      "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.3934744+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3101E102P129VM294424",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 294424,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1875,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430.1",
      "ID": 2530
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3101,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala",
      "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1377275+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319225",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319225,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1875,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430.1",
      "ID": 2530
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5034,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny",
      "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9108613+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306229",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306229,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1875,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430.1",
      "ID": 2530
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2159,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Martin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5431041+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5110E252P395VM310375",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 310375,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1875,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430.1",
      "ID": 2530
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Mason",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5678113+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268054",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 268054,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1875,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430.1",
      "ID": 2530
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2133,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0540124+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2876E141P433VM293002",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 293002,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1875,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430.1",
      "ID": 2530
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2876,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5674095+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4951E147P368VM271861",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271861,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1875,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430.1",
      "ID": 2530
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4951,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan",
      "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0945995+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3896E175P307VM269811",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269811,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1875,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430.1",
      "ID": 2530
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3896,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam",
      "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5639583+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5080E110P121VM307220",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307220,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1875,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430.1",
      "ID": 2530
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8198222+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4964E143P375VM280178",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280178,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1875,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430.1",
      "ID": 2530
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4964,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.544762+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279160",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279160,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1875,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430.1",
      "ID": 2530
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3824,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2556184+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2066E22P91VM260433",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 260433,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1875,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430.1",
      "ID": 2530
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2066,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.0766546+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299325",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 299325,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1875,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430.1",
      "ID": 2530
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.6925901+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3759E260P411VM301778",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 301778,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1875,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430.1",
      "ID": 2530
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina",
      "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.282833+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300493",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 300493,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1875,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430.1",
      "ID": 2530
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2487,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0005599+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1775E215P453VM224189",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 224189,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1875,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430.1",
      "ID": 2530
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4964122+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237943",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237943,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1875,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430.1",
      "ID": 2530
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1961,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David",
      "DisplayName": "David McLetchie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2327811+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305638",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 305638,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1875,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430.1",
      "ID": 2530
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2134,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3329724+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320045",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 320045,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1875,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430.1",
      "ID": 2530
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5041,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan",
      "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9590165+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315827",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315827,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1875,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430.1",
      "ID": 2530
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3763,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart",
      "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9287717+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1986E23P197VM237142",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237142,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1875,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430.1",
      "ID": 2530
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1986,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan",
      "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.967611+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5047E100P130VM288904",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 288904,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1875,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430.1",
      "ID": 2530
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5047,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne",
      "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.163362+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234219",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234219,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1875,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430.1",
      "ID": 2530
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1845,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette",
      "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3673959+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313086",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313086,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1875,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430.1",
      "ID": 2530
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3061,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1630494+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1768E19P265VM261292",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261292,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1875,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430.1",
      "ID": 2530
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1768,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.351072+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225585",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225585,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1875,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430.1",
      "ID": 2530
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1894,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Neil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9816842+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3815E98P134VM270999",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270999,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1875,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430.1",
      "ID": 2530
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3815,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Park, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Park",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8381936+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265659",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265659,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1875,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430.1",
      "ID": 2530
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2010,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil",
      "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4487482+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5057E92P116VM284204",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 284204,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1875,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430.1",
      "ID": 2530
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5057,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0159385+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2853E33P128VM252130",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252130,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1875,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430.1",
      "ID": 2530
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Pentland",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.5038672+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317268",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317268,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1875,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430.1",
      "ID": 2530
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5009,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4111017+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3745E233P381VM256699",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 256699,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1875,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430.1",
      "ID": 2530
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3745,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis",
      "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.793916+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1870E225P478VM293349",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 293349,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1875,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430.1",
      "ID": 2530
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1870,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona",
      "DisplayName": "Shona Robison",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8411798+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2135E254P450VM235887",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235887,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1875,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430.1",
      "ID": 2530
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2135,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Russell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6972149+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1895E232P431VM255894",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255894,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1875,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430.1",
      "ID": 2530
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1895,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5615584+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228627",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 228627,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1875,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430.1",
      "ID": 2530
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1839,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.8072731+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2345E10P55VM289524",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289524,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1875,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430.1",
      "ID": 2530
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2345,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4477797+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311537",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311537,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1875,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430.1",
      "ID": 2530
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2223,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish",
      "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8831383+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246848",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 246848,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1875,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430.1",
      "ID": 2530
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2182,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.155985+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5079E101P119VM297658",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 297658,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1875,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430.1",
      "ID": 2530
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5079,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew",
      "DisplayName": "Drew Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1191505+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1769E32P285VM233844",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 233844,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1875,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430.1",
      "ID": 2530
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1769,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1487892+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274940",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274940,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1875,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430.1",
      "ID": 2530
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4014,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz",
      "DisplayName": "Liz Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1285947+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2215E224P447VM270026",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270026,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1875,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430.1",
      "ID": 2530
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2215,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5783601+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317721",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317721,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1875,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430.1",
      "ID": 2530
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3806,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4345298+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326479",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 326479,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1875,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430.1",
      "ID": 2530
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5106,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin",
      "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7664636+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241332",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241332,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1875,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430.1",
      "ID": 2530
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1848,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola",
      "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.753362+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2098E237P531VM290448",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 290448,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1875,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430.1",
      "ID": 2530
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2098,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Swinney",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7475206+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248139",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248139,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1875,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430.1",
      "ID": 2530
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2674,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave",
      "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4444438+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5075E234P371VM289205",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289205,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1875,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430.1",
      "ID": 2530
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5075,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Torrance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4268722+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1793E151P362VM222675",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 222675,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1875,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430.1",
      "ID": 2530
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1793,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean",
      "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1991149+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5078E245P15VM306906",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306906,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1875,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430.1",
      "ID": 2530
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5078,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Walker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5789295+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1841E231P426VM240943",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 240943,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1875,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430.1",
      "ID": 2530
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1841,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen",
      "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3890815+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283997",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283997,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1875,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430.1",
      "ID": 2530
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4952,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7325249+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1865E263P500VM231097",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231097,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1875,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430.1",
      "ID": 2530
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1865,
      "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra",
      "DisplayName": "Sandra White",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3654867+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2610E160P413VM247299",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247299,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1875,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430.1",
      "ID": 2530
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2610,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Wilson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.3976026+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4941E150P382VM308915",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 308915,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1875,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430.1",
      "ID": 2530
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4941,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza",
      "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0835622+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1926E229P470VM253090",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253090,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1876,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430",
      "ID": 2509
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1926,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian",
      "DisplayName": "Brian Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7664341+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2615E213P388VM259204",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 259204,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1876,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430",
      "ID": 2509
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2615,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George",
      "DisplayName": "George Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.5987068+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319523",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319523,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1876,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430",
      "ID": 2509
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4940,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare",
      "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9296398+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2641E256P403VM250277",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250277,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1876,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430",
      "ID": 2509
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2641,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair",
      "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1822534+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1783E21P273VM228411",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 228411,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1876,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430",
      "ID": 2509
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1783,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie",
      "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.7978618+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2633E97P136VM281106",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 281106,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1876,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430",
      "ID": 2509
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2633,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire",
      "DisplayName": "Claire Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.80625+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2603E89P148VM263019",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 263019,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1876,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430",
      "ID": 2509
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2603,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6331612+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1759E91P115VM227443",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227443,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1876,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430",
      "ID": 2509
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia",
      "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5503915+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3751E243P383VM269667",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269667,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1876,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430",
      "ID": 2509
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3751,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5578134+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322487",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 322487,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1876,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430",
      "ID": 2509
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5109,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco",
      "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6907439+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5060E86P124VM295401",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295401,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1876,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430",
      "ID": 2509
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5060,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5105996+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1866E93P239VM243078",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 243078,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1876,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430",
      "ID": 2509
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1866,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah",
      "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0479714+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1943E145P367VM227068",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227068,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1876,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430",
      "ID": 2509
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1943,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic",
      "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2661156+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2595E12P30VM301021",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 301021,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1876,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430",
      "ID": 2509
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2595,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin",
      "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0291371+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2103E244P421VM238434",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 238434,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1876,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430",
      "ID": 2509
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2103,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith",
      "DisplayName": "Keith Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4463837+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327019",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 327019,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1876,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430",
      "ID": 2509
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7900997+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277514",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277514,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1876,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430",
      "ID": 2509
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.956612+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2673E236P377VM263971",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 263971,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1876,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430",
      "ID": 2509
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2673,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick",
      "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9186646+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2678E11P28VM250978",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250978,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1876,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430",
      "ID": 2509
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2678,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson",
      "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.2217375+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2123E27P233VM294833",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 294833,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1876,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430",
      "ID": 2509
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2123,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm",
      "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1803074+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285369",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285369,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1876,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430",
      "ID": 2509
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3907,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.320053+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1735E248P405VM231307",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231307,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1876,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430",
      "ID": 2509
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1735,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela",
      "DisplayName": "Angela Constance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.5893059+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243640",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 243640,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1876,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430",
      "ID": 2509
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1932,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce",
      "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3135767+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254390",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254390,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1876,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430",
      "ID": 2509
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1863,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna",
      "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2537239+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323472",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 323472,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1876,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430",
      "ID": 2509
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4976,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth",
      "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9576532+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5107E223P379VM300686",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 300686,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1876,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430",
      "ID": 2509
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5107,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0092669+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3743E222P391VM273066",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 273066,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1876,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430",
      "ID": 2509
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3743,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel",
      "DisplayName": "Nigel Don",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3681246+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262614",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262614,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1876,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430",
      "ID": 2509
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3771,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob",
      "DisplayName": "Bob Doris",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6094423+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281787",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 281787,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1876,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430",
      "ID": 2509
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2826,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Dornan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1575994+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298494",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298494,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1876,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430",
      "ID": 2509
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3812,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia",
      "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3485578+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231111",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231111,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1876,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430",
      "ID": 2509
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1778,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen",
      "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3660958+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4955E240P389VM284913",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 284913,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1876,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430",
      "ID": 2509
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4955,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0530771+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219597",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 219597,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1876,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430",
      "ID": 2509
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1742,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle",
      "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3062407+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238224",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 238224,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1876,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430",
      "ID": 2509
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1994,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus",
      "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4371654+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1814E269P519VM226703",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 226703,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1876,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430",
      "ID": 2509
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1814,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda",
      "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.242952+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321973",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 321973,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1876,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430",
      "ID": 2509
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Fee",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4594086+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292674",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 292674,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1876,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430",
      "ID": 2509
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia",
      "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5529544+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227625",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227625,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1876,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430",
      "ID": 2509
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5582141+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5054E95P118VM304584",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 304584,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1876,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430",
      "ID": 2509
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5054,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.0446859+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4947E152P361VM257849",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257849,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1876,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430",
      "ID": 2509
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4947,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Finnie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0802495+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271045",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271045,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1876,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430",
      "ID": 2509
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3901,
      "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe",
      "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8401557+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2394E15P47VM274367",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274367,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1876,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430",
      "ID": 2509
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2394,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo",
      "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1029999+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2110E220P414VM266078",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 266078,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1876,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430",
      "ID": 2509
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth",
      "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4734039+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250666",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250666,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1876,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430",
      "ID": 2509
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2675,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob",
      "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.2083171+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221133",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221133,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1876,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430",
      "ID": 2509
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1741,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel",
      "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6764926+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1756E218P467VM226467",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 226467,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1876,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430",
      "ID": 2509
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1756,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine",
      "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2326661+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1860E104P150VM239696",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239696,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1876,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430",
      "ID": 2509
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1860,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda",
      "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7550091+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2033E20P141VM253226",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253226,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1876,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430",
      "ID": 2509
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2033,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain",
      "DisplayName": "Iain Gray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.9868194+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324779",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324779,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1876,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430",
      "ID": 2509
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5042,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2374816+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2892E76P97VM261607",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261607,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1876,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430",
      "ID": 2509
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick",
      "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3647772+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239519",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239519,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1876,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430",
      "ID": 2509
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2029,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh",
      "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.747263+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273597",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 273597,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1876,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430",
      "ID": 2509
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3758,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6272497+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4086E128P311VM303694",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 303694,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1876,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430",
      "ID": 2509
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4086,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Hume",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8263337+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1773E242P494VM223181",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223181,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1876,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430",
      "ID": 2509
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1773,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.2321051+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1882E227P459VM245693",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 245693,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1876,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430",
      "ID": 2509
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1882,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam",
      "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8544027+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223355",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223355,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1876,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430",
      "ID": 2509
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1893,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4543024+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307923",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307923,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1876,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430",
      "ID": 2509
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4934,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8567695+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272402",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 272402,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1876,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430",
      "ID": 2509
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4956,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Keir",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3338021+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2059E26P131VM245089",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 245089,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1876,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430",
      "ID": 2509
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Kelly",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5915221+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315257",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315257,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1876,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430",
      "ID": 2509
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3129,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9007008+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247442",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247442,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1876,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430",
      "ID": 2509
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann",
      "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4040008+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4016E11P36VM275505",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 275505,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1876,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430",
      "ID": 2509
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4016,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.3781593+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255444",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255444,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1876,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430",
      "ID": 2509
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2180,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5316119+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4938E158P374VM276894",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276894,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1876,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430",
      "ID": 2509
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4938,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6856694+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2112E250P486VM253520",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253520,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1876,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430",
      "ID": 2509
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2112,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny",
      "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.9999686+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4939E258P394VM279182",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279182,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1876,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430",
      "ID": 2509
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4939,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus",
      "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2565564+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325352",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 325352,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1876,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430",
      "ID": 2509
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5074,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon",
      "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.4949973+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1828E3P10VM231926",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231926,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1876,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430",
      "ID": 2509
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1828,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo",
      "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6217242+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311767",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311767,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1876,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430",
      "ID": 2509
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4948,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike",
      "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8933938+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2117E90P107VM233195",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 233195,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1876,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430",
      "ID": 2509
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2117,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis",
      "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.9009567+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267551",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 267551,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1876,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430",
      "ID": 2509
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken",
      "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0247402+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313393",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313393,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1876,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430",
      "ID": 2509
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4966,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek",
      "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.393433+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3101E102P129VM294423",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 294423,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1876,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430",
      "ID": 2509
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3101,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala",
      "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1376872+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319222",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319222,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1876,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430",
      "ID": 2509
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5034,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny",
      "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9107343+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306228",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306228,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1876,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430",
      "ID": 2509
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2159,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Martin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5430625+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5110E252P395VM310374",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 310374,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1876,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430",
      "ID": 2509
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Mason",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.567771+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268053",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 268053,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1876,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430",
      "ID": 2509
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2133,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0539715+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2876E141P433VM293003",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 293003,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1876,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430",
      "ID": 2509
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2876,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.56745+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4951E147P368VM271860",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271860,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1876,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430",
      "ID": 2509
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4951,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan",
      "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.094558+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3896E175P307VM269810",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269810,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1876,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430",
      "ID": 2509
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3896,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam",
      "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5638977+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5080E110P121VM307221",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307221,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1876,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430",
      "ID": 2509
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8198634+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4964E143P375VM280179",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280179,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1876,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430",
      "ID": 2509
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4964,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.544825+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279159",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279159,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1876,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430",
      "ID": 2509
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3824,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2555778+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2066E22P91VM260432",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 260432,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1876,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430",
      "ID": 2509
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2066,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.0766137+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299324",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 299324,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1876,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430",
      "ID": 2509
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.6925501+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3759E260P411VM301779",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 301779,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1876,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430",
      "ID": 2509
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina",
      "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.2828932+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300492",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 300492,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1876,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430",
      "ID": 2509
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2487,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0005194+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1775E215P453VM224190",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 224190,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1876,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430",
      "ID": 2509
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4964534+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237944",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237944,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1876,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430",
      "ID": 2509
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1961,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David",
      "DisplayName": "David McLetchie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2328234+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305639",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 305639,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1876,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430",
      "ID": 2509
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2134,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3330132+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320048",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 320048,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1876,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430",
      "ID": 2509
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5041,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan",
      "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9592399+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315826",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315826,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1876,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430",
      "ID": 2509
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3763,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart",
      "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9287294+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1986E23P197VM237143",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237143,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1876,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430",
      "ID": 2509
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1986,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan",
      "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9676508+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5047E100P130VM288903",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 288903,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1876,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430",
      "ID": 2509
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5047,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne",
      "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1633214+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234218",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234218,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1876,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430",
      "ID": 2509
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1845,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette",
      "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3673549+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313085",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313085,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1876,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430",
      "ID": 2509
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3061,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1630075+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1768E19P265VM261293",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261293,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1876,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430",
      "ID": 2509
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1768,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.35113+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225586",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225586,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1876,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430",
      "ID": 2509
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1894,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Neil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9817246+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3815E98P134VM271000",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271000,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1876,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430",
      "ID": 2509
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3815,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Park, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Park",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8382344+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265658",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265658,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1876,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430",
      "ID": 2509
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2010,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil",
      "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4487075+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5057E92P116VM284203",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 284203,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1876,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430",
      "ID": 2509
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5057,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0158971+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2853E33P128VM252131",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252131,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1876,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430",
      "ID": 2509
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Pentland",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.5039085+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317271",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317271,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1876,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430",
      "ID": 2509
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5009,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4112274+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3745E233P381VM256698",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 256698,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1876,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430",
      "ID": 2509
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3745,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis",
      "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.7938758+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1870E225P478VM293350",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 293350,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1876,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430",
      "ID": 2509
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1870,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona",
      "DisplayName": "Shona Robison",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8412384+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2135E254P450VM235888",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235888,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1876,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430",
      "ID": 2509
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2135,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Russell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6972559+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1895E232P431VM255895",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255895,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1876,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430",
      "ID": 2509
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1895,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5615981+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228628",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 228628,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1876,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430",
      "ID": 2509
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1839,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.8073136+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2345E10P55VM289523",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289523,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1876,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430",
      "ID": 2509
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2345,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4477349+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311538",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311538,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1876,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430",
      "ID": 2509
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2223,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish",
      "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8831794+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246849",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 246849,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1876,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430",
      "ID": 2509
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2182,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1560433+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5079E101P119VM297657",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 297657,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1876,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430",
      "ID": 2509
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5079,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew",
      "DisplayName": "Drew Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1191084+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1769E32P285VM233843",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 233843,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1876,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430",
      "ID": 2509
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1769,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1487262+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274941",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274941,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1876,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430",
      "ID": 2509
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4014,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz",
      "DisplayName": "Liz Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1286364+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2215E224P447VM270027",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270027,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1876,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430",
      "ID": 2509
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2215,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.578402+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317722",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317722,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1876,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430",
      "ID": 2509
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3806,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4345697+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326478",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 326478,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1876,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430",
      "ID": 2509
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5106,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin",
      "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7664233+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241333",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241333,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1876,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430",
      "ID": 2509
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1848,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola",
      "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7534218+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2098E237P531VM290449",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 290449,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1876,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430",
      "ID": 2509
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2098,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Swinney",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7475608+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248140",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248140,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1876,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430",
      "ID": 2509
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2674,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave",
      "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4444954+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5075E234P371VM289206",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289206,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1876,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430",
      "ID": 2509
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5075,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Torrance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4269244+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1793E151P362VM222676",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 222676,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1876,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430",
      "ID": 2509
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1793,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean",
      "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1991556+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5078E245P15VM306905",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306905,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1876,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430",
      "ID": 2509
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5078,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Walker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5788867+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1841E231P426VM240942",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 240942,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1876,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430",
      "ID": 2509
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1841,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen",
      "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3890409+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283998",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283998,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1876,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430",
      "ID": 2509
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4952,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.732566+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1865E263P500VM231096",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231096,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1876,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430",
      "ID": 2509
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1865,
      "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra",
      "DisplayName": "Sandra White",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3654467+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2610E160P413VM247298",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247298,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1876,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430",
      "ID": 2509
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2610,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Wilson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.3975622+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4941E150P382VM308914",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 308914,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1876,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Children",
      "Reference": "S4M-02430",
      "ID": 2509
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4941,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza",
      "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.083522+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252771",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252771,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1873,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421.1",
      "ID": 2528
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1926,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian",
      "DisplayName": "Brian Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7525873+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2615E213P388VM259126",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 259126,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1873,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421.1",
      "ID": 2528
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2615,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George",
      "DisplayName": "George Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3428348+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319526",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319526,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1873,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421.1",
      "ID": 2528
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4940,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare",
      "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9297622+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2641E256P403VM250280",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250280,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1873,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421.1",
      "ID": 2528
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2641,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair",
      "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1823944+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1783E21P273VM228395",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 228395,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1873,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421.1",
      "ID": 2528
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1783,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie",
      "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.7971504+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2633E97P136VM281090",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 281090,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1873,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421.1",
      "ID": 2528
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2633,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire",
      "DisplayName": "Claire Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.8055773+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2603E89P148VM263016",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 263016,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1873,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421.1",
      "ID": 2528
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2603,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6330379+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1759E91P115VM227440",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227440,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1873,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421.1",
      "ID": 2528
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia",
      "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5502702+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3751E243P383VM269744",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269744,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1873,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421.1",
      "ID": 2528
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3751,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5611043+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322511",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 322511,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1873,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421.1",
      "ID": 2528
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5109,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco",
      "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6917622+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5060E86P124VM295398",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295398,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1873,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421.1",
      "ID": 2528
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5060,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.51046+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1866E93P239VM243075",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 243075,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1873,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421.1",
      "ID": 2528
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1866,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah",
      "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0478308+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235119",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235119,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1873,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421.1",
      "ID": 2528
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1943,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic",
      "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4201884+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2595E12P30VM301018",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 301018,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1873,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421.1",
      "ID": 2528
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2595,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin",
      "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0289117+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2103E244P421VM238437",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 238437,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1873,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421.1",
      "ID": 2528
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2103,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith",
      "DisplayName": "Keith Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4465067+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327023",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 327023,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1873,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421.1",
      "ID": 2528
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7902639+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277511",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277511,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1873,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421.1",
      "ID": 2528
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9564923+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2673E236P377VM263974",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 263974,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1873,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421.1",
      "ID": 2528
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2673,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick",
      "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9188061+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248585",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248585,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1873,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421.1",
      "ID": 2528
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2678,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson",
      "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6526353+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2123E27P233VM294836",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 294836,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1873,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421.1",
      "ID": 2528
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2123,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm",
      "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1804511+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285366",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285366,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1873,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421.1",
      "ID": 2528
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3907,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.319929+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1735E248P405VM231304",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231304,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1873,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421.1",
      "ID": 2528
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1735,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela",
      "DisplayName": "Angela Constance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.5891667+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243643",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 243643,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1873,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421.1",
      "ID": 2528
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1932,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce",
      "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3137178+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254393",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254393,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1873,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421.1",
      "ID": 2528
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1863,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna",
      "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2538567+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323476",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 323476,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1873,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421.1",
      "ID": 2528
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4976,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth",
      "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9580107+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5107E223P379VM300671",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 300671,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1873,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421.1",
      "ID": 2528
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5107,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0086149+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3743E222P391VM273063",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 273063,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1873,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421.1",
      "ID": 2528
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3743,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel",
      "DisplayName": "Nigel Don",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3679596+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262594",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262594,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1873,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421.1",
      "ID": 2528
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3771,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob",
      "DisplayName": "Bob Doris",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6086109+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281804",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 281804,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1873,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421.1",
      "ID": 2528
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2826,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Dornan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1583054+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298323",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298323,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1873,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421.1",
      "ID": 2528
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3812,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia",
      "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3407985+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231114",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231114,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1873,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421.1",
      "ID": 2528
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1778,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen",
      "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3662169+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4955E240P389VM284736",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 284736,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1873,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421.1",
      "ID": 2528
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4955,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0455855+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219577",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 219577,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1873,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421.1",
      "ID": 2528
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1742,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle",
      "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.305366+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238301",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 238301,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1873,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421.1",
      "ID": 2528
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1994,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus",
      "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4404872+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1814E269P519VM226706",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 226706,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1873,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421.1",
      "ID": 2528
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1814,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda",
      "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2430744+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321949",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 321949,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1873,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421.1",
      "ID": 2528
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Fee",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4583655+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292677",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 292677,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1873,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421.1",
      "ID": 2528
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia",
      "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5530982+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227610",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227610,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1873,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421.1",
      "ID": 2528
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5575185+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5054E95P118VM304581",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 304581,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1873,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421.1",
      "ID": 2528
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5054,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.0445441+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4947E152P361VM257846",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257846,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1873,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421.1",
      "ID": 2528
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4947,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Finnie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0801271+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271023",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271023,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1873,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421.1",
      "ID": 2528
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3901,
      "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe",
      "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8392168+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2394E15P47VM274383",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274383,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1873,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421.1",
      "ID": 2528
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2394,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo",
      "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1036796+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2110E220P414VM266075",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 266075,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1873,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421.1",
      "ID": 2528
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth",
      "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4732827+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250663",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250663,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1873,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421.1",
      "ID": 2528
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2675,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob",
      "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.2081782+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221130",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221130,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1873,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421.1",
      "ID": 2528
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1741,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel",
      "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.676368+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220066",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220066,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1873,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421.1",
      "ID": 2528
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1756,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine",
      "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3328663+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1860E104P150VM239693",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239693,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1873,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421.1",
      "ID": 2528
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1860,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda",
      "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7548875+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2033E20P141VM253709",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253709,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1873,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421.1",
      "ID": 2528
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2033,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain",
      "DisplayName": "Iain Gray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0175989+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324775",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324775,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1873,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421.1",
      "ID": 2528
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5042,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2373216+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259376",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 259376,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1873,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421.1",
      "ID": 2528
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick",
      "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6064498+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239443",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239443,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1873,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421.1",
      "ID": 2528
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2029,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh",
      "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7370201+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273600",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 273600,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1873,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421.1",
      "ID": 2528
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3758,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.627371+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4086E128P311VM303697",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 303697,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1873,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421.1",
      "ID": 2528
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4086,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Hume",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.826455+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1773E242P494VM223184",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223184,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1873,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421.1",
      "ID": 2528
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1773,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.2322281+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1882E227P459VM245696",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 245696,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1873,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421.1",
      "ID": 2528
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1882,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam",
      "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8545212+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223432",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223432,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1873,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421.1",
      "ID": 2528
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1893,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4576695+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307905",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307905,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1873,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421.1",
      "ID": 2528
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4934,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8559923+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272399",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 272399,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1873,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421.1",
      "ID": 2528
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4956,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Keir",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3336771+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2059E26P131VM245086",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 245086,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1873,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421.1",
      "ID": 2528
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Kelly",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5913987+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315254",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315254,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1873,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421.1",
      "ID": 2528
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3129,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9005778+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247518",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247518,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1873,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421.1",
      "ID": 2528
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann",
      "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.407274+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4016E11P36VM275527",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 275527,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1873,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421.1",
      "ID": 2528
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4016,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.3791023+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255522",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255522,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1873,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421.1",
      "ID": 2528
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2180,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5349402+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4938E158P374VM276872",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276872,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1873,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421.1",
      "ID": 2528
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4938,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6847313+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2112E250P486VM253443",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253443,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1873,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421.1",
      "ID": 2528
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2112,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny",
      "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.9966536+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4939E258P394VM278862",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 278862,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1873,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421.1",
      "ID": 2528
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4939,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus",
      "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2374481+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325356",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 325356,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1873,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421.1",
      "ID": 2528
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5074,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon",
      "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.4951616+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1828E3P10VM231923",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231923,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1873,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421.1",
      "ID": 2528
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1828,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo",
      "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6215797+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311750",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311750,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1873,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421.1",
      "ID": 2528
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4948,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike",
      "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8926492+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2117E90P107VM229601",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229601,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1873,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421.1",
      "ID": 2528
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2117,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis",
      "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0887454+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267535",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 267535,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1873,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421.1",
      "ID": 2528
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken",
      "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0240239+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313410",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313410,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1873,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421.1",
      "ID": 2528
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4966,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek",
      "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.3941768+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3101E102P129VM294440",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 294440,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1873,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421.1",
      "ID": 2528
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3101,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala",
      "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1384065+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319198",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319198,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1873,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421.1",
      "ID": 2528
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5034,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny",
      "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6966474+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306231",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306231,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1873,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421.1",
      "ID": 2528
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2159,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Martin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5431844+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5110E252P395VM310377",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 310377,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1873,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421.1",
      "ID": 2528
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Mason",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5678921+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268069",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 268069,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1873,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421.1",
      "ID": 2528
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2133,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0546515+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2876E141P433VM292986",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 292986,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1873,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421.1",
      "ID": 2528
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2876,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.566737+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4951E147P368VM271863",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271863,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1873,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421.1",
      "ID": 2528
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4951,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan",
      "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0946803+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3896E175P307VM263544",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 263544,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1873,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421.1",
      "ID": 2528
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3896,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam",
      "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.8939794+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5080E110P121VM307218",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307218,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1873,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421.1",
      "ID": 2528
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8197375+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4964E143P375VM280193",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280193,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1873,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421.1",
      "ID": 2528
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4964,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5454193+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279162",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279162,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1873,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421.1",
      "ID": 2528
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3824,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2556992+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2066E22P91VM260435",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 260435,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1873,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421.1",
      "ID": 2528
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2066,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.0767569+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299341",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 299341,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1873,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421.1",
      "ID": 2528
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.6932905+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3759E260P411VM301776",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 301776,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1873,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421.1",
      "ID": 2528
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina",
      "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.2827511+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300495",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 300495,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1873,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421.1",
      "ID": 2528
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2487,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.000642+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1775E215P453VM224187",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 224187,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1873,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421.1",
      "ID": 2528
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4963302+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237911",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237911,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1873,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421.1",
      "ID": 2528
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1961,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David",
      "DisplayName": "David McLetchie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2313962+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305636",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 305636,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1873,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421.1",
      "ID": 2528
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2134,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.33289+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320072",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 320072,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1873,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421.1",
      "ID": 2528
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5041,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan",
      "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9604682+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315829",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315829,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1873,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421.1",
      "ID": 2528
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3763,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart",
      "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9288548+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1986E23P197VM237140",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237140,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1873,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421.1",
      "ID": 2528
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1986,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan",
      "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9675315+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5047E100P130VM288906",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 288906,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1873,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421.1",
      "ID": 2528
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5047,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne",
      "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1634429+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234221",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234221,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1873,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421.1",
      "ID": 2528
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1845,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette",
      "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3675028+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313088",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313088,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1873,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421.1",
      "ID": 2528
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3061,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1631331+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1768E19P265VM261290",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261290,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1873,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421.1",
      "ID": 2528
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1768,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.350991+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225355",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225355,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1873,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421.1",
      "ID": 2528
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1894,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Neil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9711415+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3815E98P134VM271006",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271006,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1873,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421.1",
      "ID": 2528
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3815,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Park, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Park",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8384769+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265661",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265661,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1873,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421.1",
      "ID": 2528
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2010,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil",
      "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4488288+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5057E92P116VM284188",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 284188,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1873,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421.1",
      "ID": 2528
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5057,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7468177+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2853E33P128VM252115",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252115,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1873,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421.1",
      "ID": 2528
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Pentland",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.5032362+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317294",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317294,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1873,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421.1",
      "ID": 2528
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5009,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4122162+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3745E233P381VM256701",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 256701,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1873,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421.1",
      "ID": 2528
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3745,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis",
      "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.793997+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1870E225P478VM293347",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 293347,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1873,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421.1",
      "ID": 2528
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1870,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona",
      "DisplayName": "Shona Robison",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8410977+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2135E254P450VM235868",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235868,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1873,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421.1",
      "ID": 2528
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2135,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Russell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6963996+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1895E232P431VM255892",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255892,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1873,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421.1",
      "ID": 2528
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1895,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5614786+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228625",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 228625,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1873,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421.1",
      "ID": 2528
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1839,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.8071886+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2345E10P55VM289526",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289526,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1873,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421.1",
      "ID": 2528
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2345,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4478646+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311535",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311535,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1873,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421.1",
      "ID": 2528
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2223,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish",
      "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8830536+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246846",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 246846,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1873,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421.1",
      "ID": 2528
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2182,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1559045+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5079E101P119VM297660",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 297660,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1873,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421.1",
      "ID": 2528
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5079,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew",
      "DisplayName": "Drew Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1192783+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1769E32P285VM233846",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 233846,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1873,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421.1",
      "ID": 2528
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1769,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1488729+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274921",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274921,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1873,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421.1",
      "ID": 2528
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4014,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz",
      "DisplayName": "Liz Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1277661+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2215E224P447VM270011",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270011,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1873,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421.1",
      "ID": 2528
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2215,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5776946+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317719",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317719,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1873,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421.1",
      "ID": 2528
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3806,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4344501+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326474",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 326474,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1873,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421.1",
      "ID": 2528
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5106,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin",
      "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7662402+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241330",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241330,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1873,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421.1",
      "ID": 2528
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1848,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola",
      "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7532799+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2098E237P531VM290446",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 290446,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1873,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421.1",
      "ID": 2528
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2098,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Swinney",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7474399+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248124",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248124,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1873,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421.1",
      "ID": 2528
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2674,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave",
      "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4430791+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5075E234P371VM289221",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289221,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1873,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421.1",
      "ID": 2528
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5075,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Torrance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4278834+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1793E151P362VM222599",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 222599,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1873,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421.1",
      "ID": 2528
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1793,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean",
      "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1958754+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5078E245P15VM306908",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306908,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1873,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421.1",
      "ID": 2528
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5078,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Walker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5790103+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1841E231P426VM240945",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 240945,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1873,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421.1",
      "ID": 2528
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1841,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen",
      "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3891633+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4952E148P370VM284020",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 284020,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1873,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421.1",
      "ID": 2528
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4952,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7335886+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1865E263P500VM231726",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231726,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1873,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421.1",
      "ID": 2528
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1865,
      "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra",
      "DisplayName": "Sandra White",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.612906+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237280",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237280,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1873,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421.1",
      "ID": 2528
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2610,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Wilson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.1974175+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4941E150P382VM308932",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 308932,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1873,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 61,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421.1",
      "ID": 2528
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4941,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza",
      "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0842984+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252772",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252772,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1874,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421",
      "ID": 2504
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1926,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian",
      "DisplayName": "Brian Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7526274+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2615E213P388VM259202",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 259202,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1874,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421",
      "ID": 2504
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2615,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George",
      "DisplayName": "George Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.5986042+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319525",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319525,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1874,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421",
      "ID": 2504
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4940,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare",
      "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9297218+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2641E256P403VM250279",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250279,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1874,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421",
      "ID": 2504
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2641,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair",
      "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1823525+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1783E21P273VM228396",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 228396,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1874,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421",
      "ID": 2504
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1783,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie",
      "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.7971915+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2633E97P136VM281091",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 281091,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1874,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421",
      "ID": 2504
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2633,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire",
      "DisplayName": "Claire Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.8056187+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2603E89P148VM263017",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 263017,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1874,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421",
      "ID": 2504
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2603,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6330785+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1759E91P115VM227441",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227441,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1874,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421",
      "ID": 2504
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia",
      "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5503108+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3751E243P383VM269669",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269669,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1874,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421",
      "ID": 2504
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3751,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5578957+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322497",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 322497,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1874,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421",
      "ID": 2504
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5109,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco",
      "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6911721+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5060E86P124VM295399",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295399,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1874,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421",
      "ID": 2504
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5060,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5105013+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1866E93P239VM243076",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 243076,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1874,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421",
      "ID": 2504
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1866,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah",
      "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0478891+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1943E145P367VM227070",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227070,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1874,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421",
      "ID": 2504
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1943,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic",
      "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2661966+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2595E12P30VM301019",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 301019,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1874,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421",
      "ID": 2504
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2595,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin",
      "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0289528+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2103E244P421VM238436",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 238436,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1874,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421",
      "ID": 2504
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2103,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith",
      "DisplayName": "Keith Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4464657+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327017",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 327017,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1874,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421",
      "ID": 2504
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7900173+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277512",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277512,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1874,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421",
      "ID": 2504
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9565326+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2673E236P377VM263973",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 263973,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1874,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421",
      "ID": 2504
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2673,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick",
      "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9187644+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2678E11P28VM250980",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250980,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1874,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421",
      "ID": 2504
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2678,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson",
      "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.2218174+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2123E27P233VM294835",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 294835,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1874,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421",
      "ID": 2504
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2123,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm",
      "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1804101+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285367",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285367,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1874,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421",
      "ID": 2504
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3907,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3199701+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1735E248P405VM231305",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231305,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1874,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421",
      "ID": 2504
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1735,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela",
      "DisplayName": "Angela Constance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.5892072+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243642",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 243642,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1874,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421",
      "ID": 2504
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1932,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce",
      "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.313676+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254392",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254392,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1874,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421",
      "ID": 2504
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1863,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna",
      "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2538142+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323470",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 323470,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1874,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421",
      "ID": 2504
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4976,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth",
      "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9575697+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5107E223P379VM300688",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 300688,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1874,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421",
      "ID": 2504
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5107,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0093471+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3743E222P391VM273064",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 273064,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1874,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421",
      "ID": 2504
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3743,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel",
      "DisplayName": "Nigel Don",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3680023+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262612",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262612,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1874,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421",
      "ID": 2504
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3771,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob",
      "DisplayName": "Bob Doris",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6093615+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281803",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 281803,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1874,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421",
      "ID": 2504
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2826,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Dornan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1582656+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298324",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298324,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1874,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421",
      "ID": 2504
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3812,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia",
      "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3408391+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231113",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231113,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1874,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421",
      "ID": 2504
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1778,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen",
      "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3661759+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4955E240P389VM284915",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 284915,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1874,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421",
      "ID": 2504
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4955,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0531577+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219595",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 219595,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1874,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421",
      "ID": 2504
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1742,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle",
      "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3061583+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238226",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 238226,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1874,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421",
      "ID": 2504
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1994,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus",
      "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.437248+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1814E269P519VM226705",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 226705,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1874,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421",
      "ID": 2504
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1814,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda",
      "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2430332+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321963",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 321963,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1874,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421",
      "ID": 2504
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Fee",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4589723+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292676",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 292676,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1874,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421",
      "ID": 2504
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia",
      "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5530561+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227623",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227623,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1874,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421",
      "ID": 2504
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5581328+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5054E95P118VM304582",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 304582,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1874,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421",
      "ID": 2504
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5054,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.0445847+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4947E152P361VM257847",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257847,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1874,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421",
      "ID": 2504
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4947,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Finnie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.080168+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271047",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271047,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1874,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421",
      "ID": 2504
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3901,
      "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe",
      "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8402365+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2394E15P47VM274382",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274382,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1874,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421",
      "ID": 2504
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2394,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo",
      "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1036383+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2110E220P414VM266076",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 266076,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1874,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421",
      "ID": 2504
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth",
      "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4733235+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250664",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250664,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1874,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421",
      "ID": 2504
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2675,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob",
      "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.2082182+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221131",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221131,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1874,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421",
      "ID": 2504
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1741,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel",
      "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6764099+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1756E218P467VM226469",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 226469,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1874,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421",
      "ID": 2504
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1756,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine",
      "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2327483+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1860E104P150VM239694",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239694,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1874,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421",
      "ID": 2504
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1860,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda",
      "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7549287+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2033E20P141VM253708",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253708,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1874,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421",
      "ID": 2504
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2033,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain",
      "DisplayName": "Iain Gray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0175592+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324781",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324781,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1874,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421",
      "ID": 2504
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5042,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2375617+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2892E76P97VM261609",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261609,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1874,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421",
      "ID": 2504
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick",
      "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3648596+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239517",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239517,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1874,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421",
      "ID": 2504
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2029,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh",
      "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7471839+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273599",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 273599,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1874,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421",
      "ID": 2504
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3758,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6273307+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4086E128P311VM303696",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 303696,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1874,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421",
      "ID": 2504
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4086,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Hume",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8264149+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1773E242P494VM223183",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223183,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1874,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421",
      "ID": 2504
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1773,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.2321875+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1882E227P459VM245695",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 245695,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1874,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421",
      "ID": 2504
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1882,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam",
      "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.854482+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223357",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223357,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1874,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421",
      "ID": 2504
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1893,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4544041+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307906",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307906,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1874,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421",
      "ID": 2504
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4934,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8560332+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272400",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 272400,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1874,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421",
      "ID": 2504
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4956,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Keir",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3337192+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2059E26P131VM245087",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 245087,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1874,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421",
      "ID": 2504
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Kelly",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.59144+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315255",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315255,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1874,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421",
      "ID": 2504
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3129,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9006189+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247444",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247444,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1874,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421",
      "ID": 2504
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann",
      "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4040834+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4016E11P36VM275503",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 275503,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1874,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421",
      "ID": 2504
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4016,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.3780768+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255446",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255446,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1874,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421",
      "ID": 2504
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2180,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5316928+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4938E158P374VM276896",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276896,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1874,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421",
      "ID": 2504
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4938,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6857506+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2112E250P486VM253518",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253518,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1874,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421",
      "ID": 2504
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2112,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny",
      "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.9998871+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4939E258P394VM279184",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279184,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1874,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421",
      "ID": 2504
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4939,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus",
      "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2566377+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325350",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 325350,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1874,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421",
      "ID": 2504
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5074,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon",
      "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.4948976+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1828E3P10VM231924",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231924,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1874,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421",
      "ID": 2504
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1828,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo",
      "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6216208+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311776",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311776,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1874,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421",
      "ID": 2504
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4948,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike",
      "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8937885+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2117E90P107VM233197",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 233197,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1874,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421",
      "ID": 2504
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2117,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis",
      "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.9010377+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267536",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 267536,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1874,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421",
      "ID": 2504
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken",
      "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0240657+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313076",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313076,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1874,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421",
      "ID": 2504
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4966,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek",
      "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1626085+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3101E102P129VM294439",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 294439,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1874,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421",
      "ID": 2504
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3101,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala",
      "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1383668+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319212",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319212,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1874,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421",
      "ID": 2504
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5034,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny",
      "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9102686+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306230",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306230,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1874,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421",
      "ID": 2504
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2159,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Martin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5431447+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5110E252P395VM310376",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 310376,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1874,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421",
      "ID": 2504
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Mason",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5678518+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268068",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 268068,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1874,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421",
      "ID": 2504
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2133,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0546104+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2876E141P433VM292987",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 292987,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1874,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421",
      "ID": 2504
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2876,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5667773+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4951E147P368VM271862",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271862,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1874,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421",
      "ID": 2504
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4951,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan",
      "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0946399+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3896E175P307VM269812",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269812,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1874,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421",
      "ID": 2504
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3896,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam",
      "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5640008+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5080E110P121VM307219",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307219,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1874,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421",
      "ID": 2504
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8197803+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4964E143P375VM280177",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280177,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1874,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421",
      "ID": 2504
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4964,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5447218+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279161",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279161,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1874,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421",
      "ID": 2504
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3824,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2556588+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2066E22P91VM260434",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 260434,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1874,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421",
      "ID": 2504
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2066,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.0767148+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299340",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 299340,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1874,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421",
      "ID": 2504
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.6932499+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3759E260P411VM301777",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 301777,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1874,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421",
      "ID": 2504
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina",
      "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.2827924+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300494",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 300494,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1874,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421",
      "ID": 2504
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2487,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0006006+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1775E215P453VM224188",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 224188,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1874,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421",
      "ID": 2504
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4963709+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237942",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237942,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1874,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421",
      "ID": 2504
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1961,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David",
      "DisplayName": "David McLetchie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2327347+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305637",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 305637,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1874,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421",
      "ID": 2504
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2134,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3329316+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320058",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 320058,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1874,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421",
      "ID": 2504
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5041,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan",
      "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9598578+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315828",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315828,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1874,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421",
      "ID": 2504
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3763,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart",
      "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9288128+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1986E23P197VM237141",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237141,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1874,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421",
      "ID": 2504
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1986,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan",
      "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9675711+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5047E100P130VM288905",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 288905,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1874,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421",
      "ID": 2504
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5047,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne",
      "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1634025+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234220",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234220,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1874,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421",
      "ID": 2504
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1845,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette",
      "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3674599+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313087",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313087,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1874,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421",
      "ID": 2504
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3061,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1630917+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1768E19P265VM261291",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261291,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1874,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421",
      "ID": 2504
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1768,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3510313+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225584",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225584,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1874,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421",
      "ID": 2504
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1894,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Neil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9816437+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3815E98P134VM270998",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270998,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1874,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421",
      "ID": 2504
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3815,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Park, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Park",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8381512+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265660",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265660,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1874,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421",
      "ID": 2504
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2010,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil",
      "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4487885+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5057E92P116VM284205",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 284205,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1874,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421",
      "ID": 2504
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5057,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0159807+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2853E33P128VM252129",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252129,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1874,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421",
      "ID": 2504
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Pentland",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.5038262+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317280",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317280,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1874,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421",
      "ID": 2504
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5009,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4116178+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3745E233P381VM256700",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 256700,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1874,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421",
      "ID": 2504
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3745,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis",
      "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.7939562+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1870E225P478VM293348",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 293348,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1874,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421",
      "ID": 2504
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1870,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona",
      "DisplayName": "Shona Robison",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8411384+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2135E254P450VM235886",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235886,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1874,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421",
      "ID": 2504
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2135,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Russell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6971746+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1895E232P431VM255893",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255893,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1874,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421",
      "ID": 2504
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1895,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5615183+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228626",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 228626,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1874,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421",
      "ID": 2504
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1839,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.8072313+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2345E10P55VM289525",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289525,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1874,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421",
      "ID": 2504
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2345,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4478231+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311536",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311536,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1874,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421",
      "ID": 2504
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2223,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish",
      "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8830958+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246847",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 246847,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1874,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421",
      "ID": 2504
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2182,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1559449+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5079E101P119VM297659",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 297659,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1874,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421",
      "ID": 2504
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5079,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew",
      "DisplayName": "Drew Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1191926+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1769E32P285VM233845",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 233845,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1874,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421",
      "ID": 2504
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1769,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1488319+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274939",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274939,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1874,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421",
      "ID": 2504
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4014,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz",
      "DisplayName": "Liz Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1285531+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2215E224P447VM270012",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270012,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1874,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421",
      "ID": 2504
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2215,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5777359+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317720",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317720,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1874,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421",
      "ID": 2504
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3806,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4344898+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326480",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 326480,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1874,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421",
      "ID": 2504
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5106,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin",
      "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7665037+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241331",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241331,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1874,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421",
      "ID": 2504
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1848,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola",
      "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7533205+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2098E237P531VM290447",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 290447,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1874,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421",
      "ID": 2504
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2098,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Swinney",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7474803+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248138",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248138,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1874,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421",
      "ID": 2504
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2674,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave",
      "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4443914+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5075E234P371VM289204",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289204,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1874,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421",
      "ID": 2504
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5075,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Torrance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4268182+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1793E151P362VM222674",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 222674,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1874,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421",
      "ID": 2504
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1793,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean",
      "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1990743+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5078E245P15VM306907",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306907,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1874,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421",
      "ID": 2504
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5078,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Walker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5789702+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1841E231P426VM240944",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 240944,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1874,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421",
      "ID": 2504
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1841,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen",
      "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3891222+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283996",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283996,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1874,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421",
      "ID": 2504
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4952,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7324829+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1865E263P500VM231725",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231725,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1874,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421",
      "ID": 2504
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1865,
      "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra",
      "DisplayName": "Sandra White",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6128656+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2610E160P413VM247300",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247300,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1874,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421",
      "ID": 2504
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2610,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Wilson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.3976423+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4941E150P382VM308931",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 308931,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1874,
      "AgendaID": 2104,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 74,
      "VoteAgainst": 35,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Ferries",
      "Reference": "S4M-02421",
      "ID": 2504
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4941,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza",
      "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-22T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0842577+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252647",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252647,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1869,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 84,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.3",
      "ID": 2510
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1926,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian",
      "DisplayName": "Brian Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7384601+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2615E213P388VM258842",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258842,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1869,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 84,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.3",
      "ID": 2510
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2615,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George",
      "DisplayName": "George Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3302443+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319886",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319886,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1869,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 84,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.3",
      "ID": 2510
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4940,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare",
      "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9456328+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249591",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 249591,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1869,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 84,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.3",
      "ID": 2510
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2641,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair",
      "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9334365+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1783E21P273VM227752",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227752,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1869,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 84,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.3",
      "ID": 2510
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1783,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie",
      "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5641189+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2633E97P136VM280755",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280755,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1869,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 84,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.3",
      "ID": 2510
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2633,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire",
      "DisplayName": "Claire Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7810472+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262706",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262706,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1869,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 84,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.3",
      "ID": 2510
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2603,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6133721+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1759E91P115VM229733",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229733,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1869,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 84,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.3",
      "ID": 2510
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia",
      "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0943097+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270185",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270185,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1869,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 84,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.3",
      "ID": 2510
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3751,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5852141+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322717",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 322717,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1869,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 84,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.3",
      "ID": 2510
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5109,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco",
      "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.700635+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5060E86P124VM294781",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 294781,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1869,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 84,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.3",
      "ID": 2510
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5060,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1780633+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242866",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242866,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1869,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 84,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.3",
      "ID": 2510
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1866,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah",
      "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0389682+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235558",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235558,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1869,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 84,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.3",
      "ID": 2510
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1943,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic",
      "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6829858+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302356",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 302356,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1869,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 84,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.3",
      "ID": 2510
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2595,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin",
      "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5208739+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244297",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244297,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1869,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 84,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.3",
      "ID": 2510
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2103,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith",
      "DisplayName": "Keith Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5485958+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327245",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 327245,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1869,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 84,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.3",
      "ID": 2510
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:46.0275117+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277045",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277045,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1869,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 84,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.3",
      "ID": 2510
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6986985+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264284",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264284,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1869,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 84,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.3",
      "ID": 2510
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2673,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick",
      "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.126648+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248784",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248784,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1869,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 84,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.3",
      "ID": 2510
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2678,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson",
      "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6699225+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2123E27P233VM295817",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295817,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1869,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 84,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.3",
      "ID": 2510
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2123,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm",
      "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5371324+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285210",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285210,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1869,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 84,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.3",
      "ID": 2510
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3907,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3130132+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230686",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230686,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1869,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 84,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.3",
      "ID": 2510
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1735,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela",
      "DisplayName": "Angela Constance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3408481+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243853",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 243853,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1869,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 84,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.3",
      "ID": 2510
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1932,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce",
      "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3227283+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254947",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254947,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1869,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 84,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.3",
      "ID": 2510
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1863,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna",
      "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2906332+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323880",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 323880,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1869,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 84,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.3",
      "ID": 2510
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4976,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth",
      "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9763874+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5107E223P379VM291343",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291343,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1869,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 84,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.3",
      "ID": 2510
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5107,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1149721+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3743E222P391VM265382",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265382,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1869,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 84,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.3",
      "ID": 2510
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3743,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel",
      "DisplayName": "Nigel Don",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4367806+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262241",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262241,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1869,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 84,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.3",
      "ID": 2510
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3771,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob",
      "DisplayName": "Bob Doris",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.593008+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281986",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 281986,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1869,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 84,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.3",
      "ID": 2510
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2826,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Dornan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1662901+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3812E94P117VM297986",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 297986,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1869,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 84,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.3",
      "ID": 2510
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3812,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia",
      "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1334099+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231611",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231611,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1869,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 84,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.3",
      "ID": 2510
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1778,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen",
      "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6080726+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4955E240P389VM285948",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285948,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1869,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 84,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.3",
      "ID": 2510
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4955,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3514427+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219379",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 219379,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1869,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 84,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.3",
      "ID": 2510
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1742,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle",
      "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.2961051+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238585",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 238585,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1869,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 84,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.3",
      "ID": 2510
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1994,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus",
      "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4604676+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225244",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225244,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1869,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 84,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.3",
      "ID": 2510
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1814,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda",
      "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9610255+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321742",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 321742,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1869,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 84,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.3",
      "ID": 2510
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Fee",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4494517+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292856",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 292856,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1869,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 84,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.3",
      "ID": 2510
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia",
      "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5610443+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1892E12P64VM226949",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 226949,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1869,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 84,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.3",
      "ID": 2510
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2539245+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5054E95P118VM312716",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 312716,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1869,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 84,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.3",
      "ID": 2510
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5054,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1402768+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4947E152P361VM257229",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257229,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1869,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 84,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.3",
      "ID": 2510
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4947,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Finnie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0471264+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271304",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271304,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1869,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 84,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.3",
      "ID": 2510
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3901,
      "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe",
      "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0696829+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278431",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 278431,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1869,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 84,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.3",
      "ID": 2510
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2394,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo",
      "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2185038+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2110E220P414VM287251",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 287251,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1869,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 84,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.3",
      "ID": 2510
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth",
      "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.856133+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250507",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250507,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1869,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 84,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.3",
      "ID": 2510
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2675,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob",
      "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1925203+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1741E10P50VM220973",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220973,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1869,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 84,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.3",
      "ID": 2510
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1741,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel",
      "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6696244+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220264",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220264,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1869,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 84,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.3",
      "ID": 2510
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1756,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine",
      "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6309271+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1860E104P150VM251856",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251856,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1869,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 84,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.3",
      "ID": 2510
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1860,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda",
      "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4920864+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2033E20P141VM266118",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 266118,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1869,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 84,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.3",
      "ID": 2510
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2033,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain",
      "DisplayName": "Iain Gray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4751115+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324553",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324553,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1869,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 84,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.3",
      "ID": 2510
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5042,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2279589+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259731",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 259731,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1869,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 84,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.3",
      "ID": 2510
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick",
      "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6221005+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239312",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239312,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1869,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 84,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.3",
      "ID": 2510
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2029,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh",
      "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7313822+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273755",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 273755,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1869,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 84,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.3",
      "ID": 2510
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3758,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6342899+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304129",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 304129,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1869,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 84,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.3",
      "ID": 2510
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4086,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Hume",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8509063+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221722",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221722,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1869,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 84,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.3",
      "ID": 2510
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1773,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.944975+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1882E227P459VM241954",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241954,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1869,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 84,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.3",
      "ID": 2510
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1882,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam",
      "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7875213+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223717",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223717,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1869,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 84,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.3",
      "ID": 2510
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1893,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4707444+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307570",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307570,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1869,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 84,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.3",
      "ID": 2510
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4934,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8352152+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272244",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 272244,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1869,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 84,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.3",
      "ID": 2510
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4956,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Keir",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3212778+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244874",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244874,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1869,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 84,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.3",
      "ID": 2510
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Kelly",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5823237+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315046",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315046,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1869,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 84,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.3",
      "ID": 2510
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3129,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6717528+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247956",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247956,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1869,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 84,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.3",
      "ID": 2510
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann",
      "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4355753+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4016E11P36VM274782",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274782,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1869,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 84,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.3",
      "ID": 2510
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4016,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1215058+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255806",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255806,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1869,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 84,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.3",
      "ID": 2510
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2180,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5578767+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4938E158P374VM277463",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277463,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1869,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 84,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.3",
      "ID": 2510
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4938,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9544522+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2112E250P486VM253006",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253006,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1869,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 84,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.3",
      "ID": 2510
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2112,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny",
      "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7627919+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4939E258P394VM276848",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276848,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1869,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 84,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.3",
      "ID": 2510
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4939,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus",
      "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6837083+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325578",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 325578,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1869,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 84,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.3",
      "ID": 2510
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5074,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon",
      "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5123761+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1828E3P10VM232822",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232822,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1869,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 84,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.3",
      "ID": 2510
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1828,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo",
      "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.877723+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311416",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311416,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1869,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 84,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.3",
      "ID": 2510
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4948,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike",
      "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8778594+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2117E90P107VM230418",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230418,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1869,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 84,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.3",
      "ID": 2510
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2117,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis",
      "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3289503+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267353",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 267353,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1869,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 84,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.3",
      "ID": 2510
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken",
      "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0157859+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313745",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313745,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1869,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 84,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.3",
      "ID": 2510
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4966,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek",
      "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4088384+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3101E102P129VM295088",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295088,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1869,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 84,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.3",
      "ID": 2510
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3101,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala",
      "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1916879+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5034E88P114VM318991",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 318991,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1869,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 84,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.3",
      "ID": 2510
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5034,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny",
      "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6877474+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306441",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306441,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1869,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 84,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.3",
      "ID": 2510
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2159,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Martin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5522108+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5110E252P395VM310859",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 310859,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1869,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 84,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.3",
      "ID": 2510
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Mason",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5947154+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268250",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 268250,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1869,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 84,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.3",
      "ID": 2510
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2133,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2553439+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2876E141P433VM286322",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286322,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1869,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 84,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.3",
      "ID": 2510
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2876,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5738297+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4951E147P368VM258627",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258627,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1869,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 84,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.3",
      "ID": 2510
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4951,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan",
      "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3156183+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3896E175P307VM263897",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 263897,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1869,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 84,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.3",
      "ID": 2510
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3896,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam",
      "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9155069+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308473",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 308473,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1869,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 84,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.3",
      "ID": 2510
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0574252+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4964E143P375VM279659",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279659,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1869,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 84,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.3",
      "ID": 2510
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4964,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5171252+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279627",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279627,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1869,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 84,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.3",
      "ID": 2510
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3824,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5157669+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2066E22P91VM261114",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261114,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1869,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 84,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.3",
      "ID": 2510
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2066,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.1124261+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299677",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 299677,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1869,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 84,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.3",
      "ID": 2510
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7080034+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306660",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306660,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1869,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 84,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.3",
      "ID": 2510
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina",
      "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5617337+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2487E146P369VM301134",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 301134,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1869,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 84,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.3",
      "ID": 2510
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2487,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0350735+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223876",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223876,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1869,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 84,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.3",
      "ID": 2510
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4775652+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237484",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237484,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1869,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 84,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.3",
      "ID": 2510
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1961,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David",
      "DisplayName": "David McLetchie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2125929+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305426",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 305426,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1869,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 84,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.3",
      "ID": 2510
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2134,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3235144+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320435",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 320435,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1869,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 84,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.3",
      "ID": 2510
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5041,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan",
      "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1662799+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3763E142P397VM316036",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 316036,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1869,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 84,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.3",
      "ID": 2510
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3763,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart",
      "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.943089+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1986E23P197VM236673",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 236673,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1869,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 84,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.3",
      "ID": 2510
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1986,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan",
      "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9351324+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5047E100P130VM289831",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289831,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1869,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 84,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.3",
      "ID": 2510
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5047,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne",
      "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4609276+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234618",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234618,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1869,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 84,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.3",
      "ID": 2510
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1845,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette",
      "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3920875+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313606",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313606,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1869,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 84,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.3",
      "ID": 2510
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3061,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4026385+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1768E19P265VM289262",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289262,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1869,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 84,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.3",
      "ID": 2510
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1768,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4296642+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225068",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225068,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1869,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 84,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.3",
      "ID": 2510
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1894,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Neil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7431235+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3815E98P134VM270903",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270903,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1869,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 84,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.3",
      "ID": 2510
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3815,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Park, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Park",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8284051+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265847",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265847,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1869,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 84,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.3",
      "ID": 2510
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2010,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil",
      "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4631227+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283334",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283334,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1869,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 84,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.3",
      "ID": 2510
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5057,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.6962151+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2853E33P128VM251455",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251455,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1869,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 84,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.3",
      "ID": 2510
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Pentland",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4643911+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317655",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317655,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1869,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 84,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.3",
      "ID": 2510
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5009,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4317497+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254656",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254656,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1869,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 84,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.3",
      "ID": 2510
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3745,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis",
      "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2659849+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1870E225P478VM295704",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295704,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1869,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 84,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.3",
      "ID": 2510
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1870,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona",
      "DisplayName": "Shona Robison",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5323248+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2135E254P450VM234899",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234899,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1869,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 84,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.3",
      "ID": 2510
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2135,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Russell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4045518+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1895E232P431VM257609",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257609,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1869,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 84,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.3",
      "ID": 2510
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1895,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0638856+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228161",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 228161,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1869,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 84,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.3",
      "ID": 2510
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1839,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5869605+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2345E10P55VM291643",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291643,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1869,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 84,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.3",
      "ID": 2510
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2345,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1361259+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2223E176P333VM310703",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 310703,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1869,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 84,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.3",
      "ID": 2510
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2223,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish",
      "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5823979+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246382",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 246382,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1869,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 84,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.3",
      "ID": 2510
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2182,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1263302+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298124",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298124,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1869,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 84,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.3",
      "ID": 2510
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5079,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew",
      "DisplayName": "Drew Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1392588+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234156",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234156,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1869,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 84,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.3",
      "ID": 2510
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1769,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1690562+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274569",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274569,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1869,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 84,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.3",
      "ID": 2510
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4014,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz",
      "DisplayName": "Liz Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1122719+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269520",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269520,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1869,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 84,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.3",
      "ID": 2510
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2215,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5511669+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317204",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317204,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1869,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 84,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.3",
      "ID": 2510
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3806,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4079393+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326252",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 326252,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1869,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 84,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.3",
      "ID": 2510
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5106,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin",
      "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7504233+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241174",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241174,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1869,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 84,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.3",
      "ID": 2510
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1848,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola",
      "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.4052258+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2098E237P531VM289619",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289619,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1869,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 84,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.3",
      "ID": 2510
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2098,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Swinney",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4518189+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2674E247P401VM247773",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247773,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1869,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 84,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.3",
      "ID": 2510
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2674,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave",
      "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.427822+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5075E234P371VM284890",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 284890,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1869,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 84,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.3",
      "ID": 2510
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5075,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Torrance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0521013+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1793E151P362VM222469",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 222469,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1869,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 84,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.3",
      "ID": 2510
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1793,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean",
      "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1903013+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5078E245P15VM307045",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307045,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1869,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 84,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.3",
      "ID": 2510
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5078,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Walker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.584926+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1841E231P426VM239949",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239949,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1869,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 84,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.3",
      "ID": 2510
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1841,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen",
      "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7662489+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283433",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283433,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1869,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 84,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.3",
      "ID": 2510
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4952,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7076664+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1865E263P500VM232212",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232212,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1869,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 84,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.3",
      "ID": 2510
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1865,
      "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra",
      "DisplayName": "Sandra White",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8449646+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237780",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237780,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1869,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 84,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.3",
      "ID": 2510
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2610,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Wilson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2257953+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309268",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 309268,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1869,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 84,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.3",
      "ID": 2510
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4941,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza",
      "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3220083+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252648",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252648,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1870,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 97,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.2",
      "ID": 2508
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1926,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian",
      "DisplayName": "Brian Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7385004+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2615E213P388VM258843",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258843,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1870,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 97,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.2",
      "ID": 2508
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2615,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George",
      "DisplayName": "George Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3302846+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319661",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319661,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1870,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 97,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.2",
      "ID": 2508
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4940,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare",
      "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9358891+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249590",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 249590,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1870,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 97,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.2",
      "ID": 2508
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2641,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair",
      "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9333965+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1783E21P273VM227753",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227753,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1870,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 97,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.2",
      "ID": 2508
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1783,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie",
      "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5641586+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2633E97P136VM280756",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280756,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1870,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 97,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.2",
      "ID": 2508
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2633,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire",
      "DisplayName": "Claire Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7810871+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262707",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262707,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1870,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 97,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.2",
      "ID": 2508
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2603,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6134131+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1759E91P115VM229792",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229792,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1870,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 97,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.2",
      "ID": 2508
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia",
      "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0972404+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270184",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270184,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1870,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 97,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.2",
      "ID": 2508
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3751,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5851723+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322718",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 322718,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1870,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 97,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.2",
      "ID": 2508
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5109,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco",
      "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.7006746+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5060E86P124VM294782",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 294782,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1870,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 97,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.2",
      "ID": 2508
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5060,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.178105+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242869",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242869,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1870,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 97,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.2",
      "ID": 2508
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1866,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah",
      "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0390889+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235557",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235557,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1870,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 97,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.2",
      "ID": 2508
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1943,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic",
      "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6829269+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302357",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 302357,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1870,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 97,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.2",
      "ID": 2508
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2595,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin",
      "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5209154+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244296",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244296,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1870,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 97,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.2",
      "ID": 2508
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2103,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith",
      "DisplayName": "Keith Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.548555+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327158",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 327158,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1870,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 97,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.2",
      "ID": 2508
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.8016741+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277046",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277046,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1870,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 97,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.2",
      "ID": 2508
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6987392+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264283",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264283,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1870,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 97,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.2",
      "ID": 2508
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2673,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick",
      "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1266065+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248783",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248783,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1870,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 97,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.2",
      "ID": 2508
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2678,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson",
      "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6698816+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2123E27P233VM295816",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295816,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1870,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 97,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.2",
      "ID": 2508
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2123,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm",
      "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5370927+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285211",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285211,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1870,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 97,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.2",
      "ID": 2508
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3907,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3130658+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230687",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230687,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1870,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 97,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.2",
      "ID": 2508
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1735,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela",
      "DisplayName": "Angela Constance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.34089+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243850",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 243850,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1870,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 97,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.2",
      "ID": 2508
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1932,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce",
      "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3225882+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254889",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254889,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1870,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 97,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.2",
      "ID": 2508
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1863,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna",
      "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2881581+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323765",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 323765,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1870,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 97,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.2",
      "ID": 2508
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4976,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth",
      "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.970957+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5107E223P379VM291342",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291342,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1870,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 97,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.2",
      "ID": 2508
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5107,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1149029+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3743E222P391VM265383",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265383,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1870,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 97,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.2",
      "ID": 2508
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3743,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel",
      "DisplayName": "Nigel Don",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4368232+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262242",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262242,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1870,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 97,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.2",
      "ID": 2508
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3771,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob",
      "DisplayName": "Bob Doris",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.5930486+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281985",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 281985,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1870,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 97,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.2",
      "ID": 2508
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2826,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Dornan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1662497+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3812E94P117VM297987",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 297987,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1870,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 97,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.2",
      "ID": 2508
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3812,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia",
      "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1334523+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231245",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231245,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1870,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 97,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.2",
      "ID": 2508
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1778,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen",
      "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.5866556+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4955E240P389VM285947",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285947,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1870,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 97,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.2",
      "ID": 2508
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4955,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3514021+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219380",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 219380,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1870,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 97,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.2",
      "ID": 2508
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1742,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle",
      "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.2961474+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238584",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 238584,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1870,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 97,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.2",
      "ID": 2508
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1994,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus",
      "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4604269+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225243",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225243,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1870,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 97,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.2",
      "ID": 2508
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1814,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda",
      "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9609831+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321741",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 321741,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1870,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 97,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.2",
      "ID": 2508
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Fee",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4494114+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292855",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 292855,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1870,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 97,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.2",
      "ID": 2508
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia",
      "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5609863+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1892E12P64VM226950",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 226950,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1870,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 97,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.2",
      "ID": 2508
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2604158+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5054E95P118VM312717",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 312717,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1870,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 97,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.2",
      "ID": 2508
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5054,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1403168+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4947E152P361VM257230",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257230,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1870,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 97,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.2",
      "ID": 2508
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4947,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Finnie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0471671+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271303",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271303,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1870,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 97,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.2",
      "ID": 2508
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3901,
      "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe",
      "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0696384+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278430",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 278430,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1870,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 97,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.2",
      "ID": 2508
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2394,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo",
      "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2184629+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2110E220P414VM287252",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 287252,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1870,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 97,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.2",
      "ID": 2508
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth",
      "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8561742+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250508",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250508,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1870,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 97,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.2",
      "ID": 2508
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2675,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob",
      "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1925615+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1741E10P50VM220974",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220974,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1870,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 97,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.2",
      "ID": 2508
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1741,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel",
      "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6696656+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220263",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220263,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1870,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 97,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.2",
      "ID": 2508
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1756,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine",
      "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6308846+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1860E104P150VM252377",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252377,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1870,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 97,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.2",
      "ID": 2508
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1860,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda",
      "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7265482+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2033E20P141VM266117",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 266117,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1870,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 97,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.2",
      "ID": 2508
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2033,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain",
      "DisplayName": "Iain Gray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4750711+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324640",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324640,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1870,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 97,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.2",
      "ID": 2508
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5042,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2316562+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259730",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 259730,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1870,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 97,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.2",
      "ID": 2508
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick",
      "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6220593+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239313",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239313,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1870,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 97,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.2",
      "ID": 2508
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2029,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh",
      "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7314225+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273754",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 273754,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1870,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 97,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.2",
      "ID": 2508
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3758,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.634231+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304128",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 304128,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1870,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 97,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.2",
      "ID": 2508
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4086,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Hume",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8508663+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221721",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221721,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1870,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 97,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.2",
      "ID": 2508
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1773,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9449353+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1882E227P459VM241953",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241953,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1870,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 97,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.2",
      "ID": 2508
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1882,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam",
      "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7874718+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223716",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223716,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1870,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 97,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.2",
      "ID": 2508
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1893,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4707044+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307571",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307571,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1870,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 97,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.2",
      "ID": 2508
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4934,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8352566+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272245",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 272245,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1870,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 97,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.2",
      "ID": 2508
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4956,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Keir",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3213213+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244877",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244877,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1870,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 97,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.2",
      "ID": 2508
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Kelly",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5824447+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315119",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315119,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1870,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 97,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.2",
      "ID": 2508
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3129,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6751397+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247955",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247955,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1870,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 97,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.2",
      "ID": 2508
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann",
      "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.435535+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4016E11P36VM274783",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274783,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1870,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 97,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.2",
      "ID": 2508
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4016,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1215469+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255805",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255805,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1870,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 97,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.2",
      "ID": 2508
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2180,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5578369+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4938E158P374VM277462",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277462,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1870,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 97,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.2",
      "ID": 2508
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4938,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9544105+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2112E250P486VM253007",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253007,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1870,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 97,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.2",
      "ID": 2508
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2112,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny",
      "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7628328+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4939E258P394VM276847",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276847,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1870,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 97,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.2",
      "ID": 2508
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4939,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus",
      "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6836682+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325491",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 325491,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1870,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 97,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.2",
      "ID": 2508
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5074,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon",
      "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5086595+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1828E3P10VM232882",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232882,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1870,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 97,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.2",
      "ID": 2508
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1828,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo",
      "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8806615+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311417",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311417,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1870,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 97,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.2",
      "ID": 2508
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4948,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike",
      "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8779027+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2117E90P107VM230417",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230417,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1870,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 97,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.2",
      "ID": 2508
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2117,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis",
      "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3289098+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267354",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 267354,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1870,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 97,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.2",
      "ID": 2508
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken",
      "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0158266+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313744",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313744,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1870,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 97,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.2",
      "ID": 2508
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4966,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek",
      "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.408798+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3101E102P129VM295087",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295087,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1870,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 97,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.2",
      "ID": 2508
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3101,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala",
      "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1916454+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5034E88P114VM318990",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 318990,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1870,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 97,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.2",
      "ID": 2508
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5034,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny",
      "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.687705+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306440",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306440,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1870,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 97,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.2",
      "ID": 2508
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2159,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Martin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.55217+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5110E252P395VM310858",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 310858,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1870,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 97,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.2",
      "ID": 2508
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Mason",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5946719+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268249",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 268249,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1870,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 97,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.2",
      "ID": 2508
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2133,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2553033+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2876E141P433VM286323",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286323,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1870,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 97,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.2",
      "ID": 2508
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2876,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5738705+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4951E147P368VM258626",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258626,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1870,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 97,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.2",
      "ID": 2508
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4951,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan",
      "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3154616+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3896E175P307VM263896",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 263896,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1870,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 97,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.2",
      "ID": 2508
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3896,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam",
      "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9154478+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308474",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 308474,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1870,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 97,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.2",
      "ID": 2508
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0574836+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4964E143P375VM279660",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279660,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1870,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 97,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.2",
      "ID": 2508
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4964,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5171655+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279626",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279626,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1870,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 97,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.2",
      "ID": 2508
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3824,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5157268+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2066E22P91VM261111",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261111,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1870,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 97,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.2",
      "ID": 2508
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2066,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.1123001+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299676",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 299676,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1870,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 97,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.2",
      "ID": 2508
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.707963+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306661",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306661,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1870,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 97,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.2",
      "ID": 2508
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina",
      "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5618992+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2487E146P369VM301133",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 301133,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1870,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 97,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.2",
      "ID": 2508
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2487,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0350249+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223877",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223877,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1870,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 97,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.2",
      "ID": 2508
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4776242+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237485",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237485,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1870,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 97,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.2",
      "ID": 2508
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1961,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David",
      "DisplayName": "David McLetchie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2126354+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305427",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 305427,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1870,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 97,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.2",
      "ID": 2508
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2134,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3235559+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320436",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 320436,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1870,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 97,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.2",
      "ID": 2508
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5041,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan",
      "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.16632+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315963",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315963,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1870,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 97,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.2",
      "ID": 2508
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3763,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart",
      "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9398236+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1986E23P197VM236674",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 236674,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1870,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 97,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.2",
      "ID": 2508
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1986,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan",
      "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9351732+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5047E100P130VM289830",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289830,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1870,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 97,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.2",
      "ID": 2508
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5047,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne",
      "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4608882+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234559",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234559,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1870,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 97,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.2",
      "ID": 2508
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1845,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette",
      "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3895156+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313223",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313223,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1870,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 97,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.2",
      "ID": 2508
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3061,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.3830524+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1768E19P265VM289263",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289263,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1870,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 97,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.2",
      "ID": 2508
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1768,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4297051+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225069",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225069,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1870,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 97,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.2",
      "ID": 2508
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1894,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Neil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.743163+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3815E98P134VM270904",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270904,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1870,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 97,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.2",
      "ID": 2508
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3815,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Park, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Park",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8284465+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265846",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265846,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1870,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 97,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.2",
      "ID": 2508
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2010,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil",
      "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4630798+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283333",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283333,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1870,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 97,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.2",
      "ID": 2508
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5057,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.6961748+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2853E33P128VM251456",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251456,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1870,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 97,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.2",
      "ID": 2508
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Pentland",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4644332+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317656",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317656,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1870,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 97,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.2",
      "ID": 2508
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5009,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4317901+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254655",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254655,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1870,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 97,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.2",
      "ID": 2508
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3745,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis",
      "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2659441+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1870E225P478VM295705",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295705,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1870,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 97,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.2",
      "ID": 2508
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1870,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona",
      "DisplayName": "Shona Robison",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5323934+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2135E254P450VM234900",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234900,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1870,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 97,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.2",
      "ID": 2508
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2135,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Russell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4045935+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1895E232P431VM257610",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257610,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1870,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 97,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.2",
      "ID": 2508
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1895,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0639266+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228162",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 228162,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1870,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 97,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.2",
      "ID": 2508
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1839,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5870189+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2345E10P55VM291642",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291642,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1870,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 97,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.2",
      "ID": 2508
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2345,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1360866+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311088",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311088,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1870,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 97,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.2",
      "ID": 2508
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2223,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish",
      "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.6048948+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246383",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 246383,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1870,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 97,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.2",
      "ID": 2508
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2182,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.126371+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298123",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298123,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1870,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 97,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.2",
      "ID": 2508
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5079,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew",
      "DisplayName": "Drew Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1392177+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234155",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234155,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1870,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 97,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.2",
      "ID": 2508
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1769,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1689964+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274570",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274570,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1870,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 97,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.2",
      "ID": 2508
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4014,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz",
      "DisplayName": "Liz Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1123132+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269521",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269521,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1870,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 97,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.2",
      "ID": 2508
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2215,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5512071+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317430",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317430,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1870,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 97,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.2",
      "ID": 2508
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3806,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4217686+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326339",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 326339,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1870,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 97,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.2",
      "ID": 2508
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5106,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin",
      "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7541855+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241175",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241175,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1870,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 97,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.2",
      "ID": 2508
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1848,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola",
      "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.4052663+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2098E237P531VM289620",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289620,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1870,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 97,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.2",
      "ID": 2508
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2098,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Swinney",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4518585+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2674E247P401VM247774",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247774,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1870,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 97,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.2",
      "ID": 2508
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2674,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave",
      "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4278621+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5075E234P371VM284891",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 284891,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1870,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 97,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.2",
      "ID": 2508
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5075,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Torrance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0521413+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1793E151P362VM222470",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 222470,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1870,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 97,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.2",
      "ID": 2508
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1793,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean",
      "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1903424+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5078E245P15VM307044",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307044,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1870,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 97,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.2",
      "ID": 2508
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5078,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Walker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.584884+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1841E231P426VM239948",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239948,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1870,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 97,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.2",
      "ID": 2508
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1841,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen",
      "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.766208+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283434",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283434,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1870,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 97,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.2",
      "ID": 2508
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4952,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7077113+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1865E263P500VM232211",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232211,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1870,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 97,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.2",
      "ID": 2508
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1865,
      "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra",
      "DisplayName": "Sandra White",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8449221+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237779",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237779,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1870,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 97,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.2",
      "ID": 2508
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2610,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Wilson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2257556+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309267",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 309267,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1870,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 97,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.2",
      "ID": 2508
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4941,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza",
      "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3219675+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252649",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252649,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1871,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 20,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.1",
      "ID": 2507
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1926,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian",
      "DisplayName": "Brian Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7385596+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2615E213P388VM258845",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258845,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1871,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 20,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.1",
      "ID": 2507
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2615,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George",
      "DisplayName": "George Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.330366+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319660",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319660,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1871,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 20,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.1",
      "ID": 2507
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4940,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare",
      "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9358484+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249589",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 249589,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1871,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 20,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.1",
      "ID": 2507
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2641,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair",
      "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9333561+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1783E21P273VM227754",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227754,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1871,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 20,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.1",
      "ID": 2507
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1783,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie",
      "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5641987+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2633E97P136VM280757",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280757,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1871,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 20,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.1",
      "ID": 2507
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2633,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire",
      "DisplayName": "Claire Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7811268+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262708",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262708,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1871,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 20,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.1",
      "ID": 2507
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2603,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6134536+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1759E91P115VM229793",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229793,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1871,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 20,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.1",
      "ID": 2507
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia",
      "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0972816+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270182",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270182,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1871,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 20,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.1",
      "ID": 2507
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3751,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5850737+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322719",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 322719,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1871,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 20,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.1",
      "ID": 2507
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5109,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco",
      "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.7007145+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5060E86P124VM294783",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 294783,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1871,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 20,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.1",
      "ID": 2507
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5060,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1781476+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242940",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242940,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1871,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 20,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.1",
      "ID": 2507
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1866,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah",
      "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0420622+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235555",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235555,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1871,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 20,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.1",
      "ID": 2507
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1943,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic",
      "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6828456+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302358",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 302358,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1871,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 20,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.1",
      "ID": 2507
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2595,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin",
      "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5209565+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244295",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244295,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1871,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 20,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.1",
      "ID": 2507
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2103,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith",
      "DisplayName": "Keith Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.548512+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327159",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 327159,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1871,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 20,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.1",
      "ID": 2507
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.801715+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277047",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277047,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1871,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 20,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.1",
      "ID": 2507
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6987802+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264282",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264282,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1871,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 20,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.1",
      "ID": 2507
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2673,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick",
      "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.126565+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248781",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248781,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1871,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 20,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.1",
      "ID": 2507
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2678,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson",
      "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.669776+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2123E27P233VM295742",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295742,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1871,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 20,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.1",
      "ID": 2507
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2123,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm",
      "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5339625+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285212",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285212,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1871,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 20,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.1",
      "ID": 2507
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3907,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3131173+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230688",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230688,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1871,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 20,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.1",
      "ID": 2507
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1735,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela",
      "DisplayName": "Angela Constance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3409301+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243779",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 243779,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1871,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 20,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.1",
      "ID": 2507
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1932,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce",
      "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3194078+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254888",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254888,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1871,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 20,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.1",
      "ID": 2507
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1863,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna",
      "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2881167+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323766",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 323766,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1871,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 20,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.1",
      "ID": 2507
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4976,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth",
      "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9709976+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5107E223P379VM291290",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291290,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1871,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 20,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.1",
      "ID": 2507
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5107,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1125714+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3743E222P391VM265384",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265384,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1871,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 20,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.1",
      "ID": 2507
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3743,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel",
      "DisplayName": "Nigel Don",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4368641+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262243",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262243,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1871,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 20,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.1",
      "ID": 2507
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3771,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob",
      "DisplayName": "Bob Doris",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.5931086+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281984",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 281984,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1871,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 20,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.1",
      "ID": 2507
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2826,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Dornan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1662084+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3812E94P117VM297988",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 297988,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1871,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 20,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.1",
      "ID": 2507
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3812,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia",
      "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1334929+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231244",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231244,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1871,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 20,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.1",
      "ID": 2507
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1778,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen",
      "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.5866152+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4955E240P389VM285895",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285895,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1871,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 20,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.1",
      "ID": 2507
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4955,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3491565+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219382",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 219382,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1871,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 20,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.1",
      "ID": 2507
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1742,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle",
      "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.296231+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238582",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 238582,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1871,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 20,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.1",
      "ID": 2507
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1994,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus",
      "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4603267+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225242",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225242,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1871,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 20,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.1",
      "ID": 2507
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1814,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda",
      "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.960915+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321740",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 321740,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1871,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 20,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.1",
      "ID": 2507
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Fee",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4493708+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292854",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 292854,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1871,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 20,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.1",
      "ID": 2507
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia",
      "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5609468+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1892E12P64VM226952",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 226952,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1871,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 20,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.1",
      "ID": 2507
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.260668+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5054E95P118VM312718",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 312718,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1871,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 20,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.1",
      "ID": 2507
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5054,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1403568+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4947E152P361VM257231",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257231,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1871,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 20,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.1",
      "ID": 2507
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4947,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Finnie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0472075+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271250",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271250,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1871,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 20,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.1",
      "ID": 2507
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3901,
      "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe",
      "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0621795+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278429",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 278429,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1871,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 20,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.1",
      "ID": 2507
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2394,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo",
      "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2184216+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2110E220P414VM287253",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 287253,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1871,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 20,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.1",
      "ID": 2507
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth",
      "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8562154+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250509",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250509,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1871,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 20,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.1",
      "ID": 2507
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2675,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob",
      "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1926021+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1741E10P50VM220975",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220975,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1871,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 20,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.1",
      "ID": 2507
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1741,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel",
      "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6697063+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220261",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220261,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1871,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 20,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.1",
      "ID": 2507
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1756,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine",
      "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6308012+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1860E104P150VM252378",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252378,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1871,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 20,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.1",
      "ID": 2507
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1860,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda",
      "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7265886+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2033E20P141VM266116",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 266116,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1871,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 20,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.1",
      "ID": 2507
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2033,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain",
      "DisplayName": "Iain Gray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4750303+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324639",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324639,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1871,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 20,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.1",
      "ID": 2507
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5042,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2316139+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259728",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 259728,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1871,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 20,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.1",
      "ID": 2507
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick",
      "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6219771+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239315",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239315,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1871,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 20,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.1",
      "ID": 2507
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2029,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh",
      "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7315247+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273753",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 273753,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1871,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 20,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.1",
      "ID": 2507
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3758,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6341908+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304127",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 304127,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1871,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 20,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.1",
      "ID": 2507
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4086,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Hume",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.850826+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221720",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221720,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1871,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 20,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.1",
      "ID": 2507
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1773,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9448949+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1882E227P459VM241952",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241952,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1871,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 20,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.1",
      "ID": 2507
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1882,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam",
      "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7873316+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223714",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223714,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1871,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 20,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.1",
      "ID": 2507
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1893,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4706245+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307572",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307572,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1871,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 20,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.1",
      "ID": 2507
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4934,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8352968+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272246",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 272246,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1871,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 20,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.1",
      "ID": 2507
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4956,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Keir",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3213694+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244950",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244950,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1871,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 20,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.1",
      "ID": 2507
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Kelly",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5855444+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315120",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315120,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1871,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 20,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.1",
      "ID": 2507
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3129,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6751808+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247953",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247953,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1871,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 20,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.1",
      "ID": 2507
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann",
      "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4354548+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4016E11P36VM274835",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274835,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1871,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 20,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.1",
      "ID": 2507
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4016,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1237916+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255803",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255803,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1871,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 20,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.1",
      "ID": 2507
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2180,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5577574+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4938E158P374VM277410",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277410,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1871,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 20,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.1",
      "ID": 2507
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4938,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9521861+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2112E250P486VM253009",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253009,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1871,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 20,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.1",
      "ID": 2507
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2112,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny",
      "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7629342+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4939E258P394VM276795",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276795,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1871,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 20,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.1",
      "ID": 2507
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4939,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus",
      "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6814196+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325492",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 325492,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1871,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 20,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.1",
      "ID": 2507
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5074,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon",
      "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5087184+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1828E3P10VM232883",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232883,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1871,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 20,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.1",
      "ID": 2507
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1828,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo",
      "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8807018+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311418",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311418,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1871,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 20,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.1",
      "ID": 2507
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4948,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike",
      "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8779443+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2117E90P107VM230415",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230415,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1871,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 20,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.1",
      "ID": 2507
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2117,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis",
      "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3288274+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267355",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 267355,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1871,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 20,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.1",
      "ID": 2507
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken",
      "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0158673+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313743",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313743,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1871,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 20,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.1",
      "ID": 2507
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4966,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek",
      "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4087579+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3101E102P129VM295086",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295086,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1871,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 20,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.1",
      "ID": 2507
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3101,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala",
      "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1916046+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5034E88P114VM318989",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 318989,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1871,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 20,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.1",
      "ID": 2507
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5034,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny",
      "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6876452+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306367",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306367,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1871,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 20,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.1",
      "ID": 2507
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2159,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Martin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5490431+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5110E252P395VM310857",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 310857,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1871,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 20,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.1",
      "ID": 2507
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Mason",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5946279+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268248",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 268248,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1871,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 20,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.1",
      "ID": 2507
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2133,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2552627+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2876E141P433VM286324",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286324,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1871,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 20,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.1",
      "ID": 2507
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2876,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5739119+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4951E147P368VM258625",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258625,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1871,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 20,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.1",
      "ID": 2507
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4951,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan",
      "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3154205+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3896E175P307VM263843",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 263843,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1871,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 20,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.1",
      "ID": 2507
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3896,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam",
      "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9128933+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308475",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 308475,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1871,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 20,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.1",
      "ID": 2507
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0575259+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4964E143P375VM279707",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279707,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1871,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 20,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.1",
      "ID": 2507
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4964,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5192031+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279625",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279625,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1871,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 20,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.1",
      "ID": 2507
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3824,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5156863+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2066E22P91VM261038",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261038,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1871,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 20,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.1",
      "ID": 2507
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2066,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.1091283+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299675",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 299675,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1871,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 20,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.1",
      "ID": 2507
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7079222+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306662",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306662,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1871,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 20,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.1",
      "ID": 2507
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina",
      "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5619714+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2487E146P369VM301132",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 301132,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1871,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 20,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.1",
      "ID": 2507
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2487,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.034975+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223878",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223878,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1871,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 20,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.1",
      "ID": 2507
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4776654+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237487",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237487,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1871,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 20,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.1",
      "ID": 2507
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1961,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David",
      "DisplayName": "David McLetchie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2127185+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305501",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 305501,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1871,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 20,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.1",
      "ID": 2507
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2134,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3270388+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320437",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 320437,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1871,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 20,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.1",
      "ID": 2507
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5041,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan",
      "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1663803+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315962",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315962,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1871,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 20,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.1",
      "ID": 2507
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3763,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart",
      "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9397834+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1986E23P197VM236675",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 236675,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1871,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 20,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.1",
      "ID": 2507
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1986,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan",
      "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9352338+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5047E100P130VM289829",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289829,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1871,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 20,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.1",
      "ID": 2507
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5047,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne",
      "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4608483+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234558",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234558,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1871,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 20,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.1",
      "ID": 2507
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1845,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette",
      "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3894743+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313222",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313222,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1871,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 20,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.1",
      "ID": 2507
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3061,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.3829885+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1768E19P265VM289264",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289264,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1871,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 20,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.1",
      "ID": 2507
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1768,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4297455+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225071",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225071,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1871,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 20,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.1",
      "ID": 2507
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1894,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Neil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7432645+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3815E98P134VM270939",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270939,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1871,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 20,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.1",
      "ID": 2507
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3815,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Park, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Park",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8355942+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265845",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265845,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1871,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 20,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.1",
      "ID": 2507
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2010,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil",
      "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.463037+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283281",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283281,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1871,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 20,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.1",
      "ID": 2507
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5057,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.6937271+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2853E33P128VM251458",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251458,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1871,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 20,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.1",
      "ID": 2507
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Pentland",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4645185+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317657",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317657,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1871,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 20,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.1",
      "ID": 2507
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5009,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4318312+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254654",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254654,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1871,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 20,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.1",
      "ID": 2507
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3745,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis",
      "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2659019+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1870E225P478VM295706",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295706,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1871,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 20,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.1",
      "ID": 2507
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1870,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona",
      "DisplayName": "Shona Robison",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.532436+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2135E254P450VM234902",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234902,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1871,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 20,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.1",
      "ID": 2507
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2135,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Russell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4046752+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1895E232P431VM257611",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257611,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1871,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 20,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.1",
      "ID": 2507
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1895,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0639676+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228163",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 228163,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1871,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 20,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.1",
      "ID": 2507
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1839,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5870607+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2345E10P55VM291641",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291641,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1871,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 20,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.1",
      "ID": 2507
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2345,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.136046+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311089",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311089,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1871,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 20,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.1",
      "ID": 2507
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2223,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish",
      "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.6049351+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246384",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 246384,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1871,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 20,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.1",
      "ID": 2507
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2182,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1264116+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298122",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298122,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1871,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 20,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.1",
      "ID": 2507
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5079,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew",
      "DisplayName": "Drew Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1391776+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234154",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234154,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1871,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 20,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.1",
      "ID": 2507
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1769,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1689557+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274622",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274622,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1871,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 20,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.1",
      "ID": 2507
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4014,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz",
      "DisplayName": "Liz Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1145641+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269522",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269522,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1871,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 20,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.1",
      "ID": 2507
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2215,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5512481+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317431",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317431,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1871,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 20,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.1",
      "ID": 2507
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3806,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4218099+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326338",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 326338,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1871,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 20,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.1",
      "ID": 2507
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5106,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin",
      "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7541449+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241176",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241176,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1871,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 20,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.1",
      "ID": 2507
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1848,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola",
      "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.4053065+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2098E237P531VM289694",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289694,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1871,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 20,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.1",
      "ID": 2507
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2098,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Swinney",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.455163+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2674E247P401VM247776",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247776,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1871,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 20,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.1",
      "ID": 2507
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2674,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave",
      "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4279682+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5075E234P371VM287429",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 287429,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1871,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 20,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.1",
      "ID": 2507
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5075,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Torrance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8638293+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1793E151P362VM222472",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 222472,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1871,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 20,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.1",
      "ID": 2507
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1793,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean",
      "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1904242+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5078E245P15VM307043",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307043,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1871,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 20,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.1",
      "ID": 2507
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5078,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Walker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5848257+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1841E231P426VM239947",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239947,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1871,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 20,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.1",
      "ID": 2507
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1841,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen",
      "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7661672+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283486",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283486,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1871,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 20,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.1",
      "ID": 2507
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4952,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7099718+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1865E263P500VM232210",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232210,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1871,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 20,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.1",
      "ID": 2507
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1865,
      "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra",
      "DisplayName": "Sandra White",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8448787+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237777",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237777,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1871,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 20,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.1",
      "ID": 2507
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2610,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Wilson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2256744+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309266",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 309266,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1871,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 20,
      "VoteAgainst": 95,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407.1",
      "ID": 2507
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4941,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza",
      "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3219263+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252650",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252650,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1872,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407",
      "ID": 2490
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1926,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian",
      "DisplayName": "Brian Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7386026+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2615E213P388VM258896",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258896,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1872,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407",
      "ID": 2490
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2615,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George",
      "DisplayName": "George Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3328803+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319659",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319659,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1872,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407",
      "ID": 2490
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4940,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare",
      "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.935807+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249588",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 249588,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1872,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407",
      "ID": 2490
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2641,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair",
      "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9333152+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1783E21P273VM227755",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227755,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1872,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407",
      "ID": 2490
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1783,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie",
      "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5642382+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2633E97P136VM280758",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280758,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1872,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407",
      "ID": 2490
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2633,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire",
      "DisplayName": "Claire Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7811669+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262709",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262709,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1872,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407",
      "ID": 2490
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2603,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6134942+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1759E91P115VM229794",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229794,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1872,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407",
      "ID": 2490
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia",
      "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.097323+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270131",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270131,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1872,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407",
      "ID": 2490
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3751,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5828986+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322673",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 322673,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1872,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407",
      "ID": 2490
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5109,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco",
      "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.698796+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5060E86P124VM294784",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 294784,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1872,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407",
      "ID": 2490
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5060,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.178189+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242941",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242941,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1872,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407",
      "ID": 2490
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1866,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah",
      "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0421028+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235193",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235193,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1872,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407",
      "ID": 2490
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1943,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic",
      "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4233825+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302359",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 302359,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1872,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407",
      "ID": 2490
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2595,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin",
      "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5209978+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244294",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244294,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1872,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407",
      "ID": 2490
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2103,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith",
      "DisplayName": "Keith Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5484524+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327160",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 327160,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1872,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407",
      "ID": 2490
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.8017567+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277048",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277048,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1872,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407",
      "ID": 2490
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6988204+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264281",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264281,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1872,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407",
      "ID": 2490
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2673,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick",
      "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1265243+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248728",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248728,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1872,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407",
      "ID": 2490
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2678,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson",
      "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6672414+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2123E27P233VM295741",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295741,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1872,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407",
      "ID": 2490
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2123,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm",
      "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5339221+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285213",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285213,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1872,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407",
      "ID": 2490
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3907,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3131687+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230689",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230689,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1872,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407",
      "ID": 2490
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1735,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela",
      "DisplayName": "Angela Constance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3409709+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243778",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 243778,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1872,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407",
      "ID": 2490
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1932,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce",
      "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3193681+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254887",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254887,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1872,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407",
      "ID": 2490
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1863,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna",
      "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2880573+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323767",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 323767,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1872,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407",
      "ID": 2490
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4976,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth",
      "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9710379+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5107E223P379VM291288",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291288,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1872,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407",
      "ID": 2490
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5107,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1124881+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3743E222P391VM265385",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265385,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1872,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407",
      "ID": 2490
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3743,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel",
      "DisplayName": "Nigel Don",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4369054+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262296",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262296,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1872,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407",
      "ID": 2490
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3771,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob",
      "DisplayName": "Bob Doris",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.595366+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281983",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 281983,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1872,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407",
      "ID": 2490
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2826,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Dornan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1661676+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3812E94P117VM297989",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 297989,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1872,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407",
      "ID": 2490
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3812,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia",
      "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1335334+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231243",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231243,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1872,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407",
      "ID": 2490
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1778,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen",
      "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.5865747+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4955E240P389VM285893",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285893,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1872,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407",
      "ID": 2490
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4955,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3490739+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219435",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 219435,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1872,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407",
      "ID": 2490
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1742,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle",
      "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.2988507+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238529",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 238529,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1872,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407",
      "ID": 2490
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1994,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus",
      "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4580342+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225241",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225241,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1872,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407",
      "ID": 2490
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1814,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda",
      "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9608736+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321787",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 321787,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1872,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407",
      "ID": 2490
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Fee",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4513516+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292853",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 292853,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1872,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407",
      "ID": 2490
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia",
      "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5609069+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227160",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227160,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1872,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407",
      "ID": 2490
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2704033+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5054E95P118VM312719",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 312719,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1872,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407",
      "ID": 2490
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5054,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1403967+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4947E152P361VM257232",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257232,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1872,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407",
      "ID": 2490
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4947,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Finnie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0472483+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271249",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271249,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1872,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407",
      "ID": 2490
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3901,
      "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe",
      "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.062138+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278428",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 278428,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1872,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407",
      "ID": 2490
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2394,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo",
      "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2183804+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2110E220P414VM287254",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 287254,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1872,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407",
      "ID": 2490
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth",
      "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.856281+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250510",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250510,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1872,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407",
      "ID": 2490
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2675,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob",
      "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1926425+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1741E10P50VM220976",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220976,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1872,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407",
      "ID": 2490
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1741,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel",
      "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6697479+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220209",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220209,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1872,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407",
      "ID": 2490
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1756,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine",
      "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.339051+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1860E104P150VM252379",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252379,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1872,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407",
      "ID": 2490
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1860,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda",
      "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7266292+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2033E20P141VM266115",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 266115,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1872,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407",
      "ID": 2490
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2033,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain",
      "DisplayName": "Iain Gray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4749901+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324638",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324638,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1872,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407",
      "ID": 2490
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5042,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2315547+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259675",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 259675,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1872,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407",
      "ID": 2490
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick",
      "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6196715+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239367",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239367,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1872,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407",
      "ID": 2490
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2029,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh",
      "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7337537+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273752",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 273752,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1872,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407",
      "ID": 2490
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3758,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6341509+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304126",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 304126,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1872,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407",
      "ID": 2490
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4086,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Hume",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8507836+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221719",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221719,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1872,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407",
      "ID": 2490
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1773,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9448528+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1882E227P459VM241951",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241951,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1872,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407",
      "ID": 2490
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1882,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam",
      "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7872848+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223507",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223507,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1872,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407",
      "ID": 2490
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1893,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4614153+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307573",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307573,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1872,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407",
      "ID": 2490
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4934,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8353377+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272247",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 272247,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1872,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407",
      "ID": 2490
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4956,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Keir",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3214362+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244951",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244951,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1872,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407",
      "ID": 2490
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Kelly",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.585586+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315121",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315121,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1872,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407",
      "ID": 2490
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3129,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6752212+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247901",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247901,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1872,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407",
      "ID": 2490
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann",
      "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4332526+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4016E11P36VM274837",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274837,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1872,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407",
      "ID": 2490
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4016,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1238981+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255752",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255752,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1872,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407",
      "ID": 2490
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2180,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5553693+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4938E158P374VM277408",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277408,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1872,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407",
      "ID": 2490
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4938,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9521031+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2112E250P486VM253060",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253060,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1872,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407",
      "ID": 2490
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2112,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny",
      "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7651204+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4939E258P394VM276794",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276794,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1872,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407",
      "ID": 2490
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4939,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus",
      "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6813795+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325493",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 325493,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1872,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407",
      "ID": 2490
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5074,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon",
      "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5087605+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1828E3P10VM232884",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232884,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1872,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407",
      "ID": 2490
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1828,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo",
      "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.880761+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311419",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311419,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1872,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407",
      "ID": 2490
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4948,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike",
      "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8779859+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2117E90P107VM230362",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230362,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1872,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407",
      "ID": 2490
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2117,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis",
      "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3197157+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267356",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 267356,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1872,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407",
      "ID": 2490
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken",
      "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0159082+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313742",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313742,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1872,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407",
      "ID": 2490
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4966,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek",
      "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.408717+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3101E102P129VM295085",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295085,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1872,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407",
      "ID": 2490
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3101,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala",
      "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1915621+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319037",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319037,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1872,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407",
      "ID": 2490
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5034,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny",
      "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6897234+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306366",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306366,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1872,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407",
      "ID": 2490
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2159,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Martin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5490028+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5110E252P395VM310856",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 310856,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1872,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407",
      "ID": 2490
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Mason",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5945682+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268247",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 268247,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1872,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407",
      "ID": 2490
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2133,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2552217+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2876E141P433VM286325",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286325,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1872,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407",
      "ID": 2490
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2876,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5739536+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4951E147P368VM258624",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258624,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1872,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407",
      "ID": 2490
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4951,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan",
      "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3153789+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3896E175P307VM263842",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 263842,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1872,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407",
      "ID": 2490
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3896,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam",
      "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9127597+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308476",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 308476,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1872,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407",
      "ID": 2490
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0575669+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4964E143P375VM279708",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279708,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1872,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407",
      "ID": 2490
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4964,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5192429+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279624",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279624,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1872,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407",
      "ID": 2490
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3824,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5156459+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2066E22P91VM261037",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261037,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1872,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407",
      "ID": 2490
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2066,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.1090869+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299674",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 299674,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1872,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407",
      "ID": 2490
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7078821+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306663",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306663,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1872,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407",
      "ID": 2490
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina",
      "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5620149+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2487E146P369VM301131",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 301131,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1872,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407",
      "ID": 2490
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2487,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0349222+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223879",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223879,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1872,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407",
      "ID": 2490
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.477706+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237538",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237538,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1872,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407",
      "ID": 2490
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1961,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David",
      "DisplayName": "David McLetchie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2151514+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305502",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 305502,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1872,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407",
      "ID": 2490
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2134,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.327079+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320389",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 320389,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1872,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407",
      "ID": 2490
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5041,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan",
      "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1643091+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315961",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315961,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1872,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407",
      "ID": 2490
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3763,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart",
      "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9397423+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1986E23P197VM236676",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 236676,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1872,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407",
      "ID": 2490
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1986,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan",
      "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9352767+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5047E100P130VM289828",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289828,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1872,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407",
      "ID": 2490
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5047,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne",
      "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4608087+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234557",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234557,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1872,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407",
      "ID": 2490
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1845,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette",
      "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3894332+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313221",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313221,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1872,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407",
      "ID": 2490
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3061,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.3829469+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1768E19P265VM289265",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289265,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1872,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407",
      "ID": 2490
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1768,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4297865+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225280",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225280,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1872,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407",
      "ID": 2490
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1894,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Neil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.962581+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3815E98P134VM270940",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270940,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1872,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407",
      "ID": 2490
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3815,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Park, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Park",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.835635+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265844",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265844,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1872,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407",
      "ID": 2490
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2010,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil",
      "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4629538+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283280",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283280,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1872,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407",
      "ID": 2490
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5057,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.6936843+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2853E33P128VM251511",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251511,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1872,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407",
      "ID": 2490
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Pentland",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4668391+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317658",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317658,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1872,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407",
      "ID": 2490
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5009,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4318708+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254653",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254653,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1872,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407",
      "ID": 2490
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3745,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis",
      "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2658335+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1870E225P478VM295707",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295707,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1872,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407",
      "ID": 2490
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1870,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona",
      "DisplayName": "Shona Robison",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5324773+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2135E254P450VM235415",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235415,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1872,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407",
      "ID": 2490
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2135,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Russell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6697697+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1895E232P431VM257612",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257612,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1872,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407",
      "ID": 2490
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1895,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0640082+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228164",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 228164,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1872,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407",
      "ID": 2490
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1839,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5871014+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2345E10P55VM291640",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291640,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1872,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407",
      "ID": 2490
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2345,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1359875+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311090",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311090,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1872,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407",
      "ID": 2490
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2223,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish",
      "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.6049766+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246385",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 246385,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1872,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407",
      "ID": 2490
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2182,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1264531+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298121",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298121,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1872,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407",
      "ID": 2490
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5079,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew",
      "DisplayName": "Drew Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1391376+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234153",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234153,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1872,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407",
      "ID": 2490
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1769,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1689146+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274623",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274623,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1872,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407",
      "ID": 2490
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4014,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz",
      "DisplayName": "Liz Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1146046+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269523",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269523,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1872,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407",
      "ID": 2490
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2215,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5513086+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317432",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317432,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1872,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407",
      "ID": 2490
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3806,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4218508+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326337",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 326337,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1872,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407",
      "ID": 2490
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5106,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin",
      "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7541037+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241177",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241177,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1872,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407",
      "ID": 2490
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1848,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola",
      "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.4053468+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2098E237P531VM289695",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289695,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1872,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407",
      "ID": 2490
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2098,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Swinney",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4552233+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2674E247P401VM247828",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247828,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1872,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407",
      "ID": 2490
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2674,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave",
      "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4301575+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5075E234P371VM287431",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 287431,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1872,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407",
      "ID": 2490
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5075,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Torrance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8639122+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1793E151P362VM222524",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 222524,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1872,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407",
      "ID": 2490
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1793,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean",
      "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1926643+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5078E245P15VM307042",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307042,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1872,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407",
      "ID": 2490
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5078,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Walker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5847847+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1841E231P426VM239946",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239946,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1872,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407",
      "ID": 2490
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1841,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen",
      "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.766127+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283488",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283488,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1872,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407",
      "ID": 2490
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4952,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7100737+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1865E263P500VM232209",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232209,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1872,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407",
      "ID": 2490
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1865,
      "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra",
      "DisplayName": "Sandra White",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8448125+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237724",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237724,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1872,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407",
      "ID": 2490
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2610,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Wilson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2231083+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309265",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 309265,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1872,
      "AgendaID": 2059,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 96,
      "VoteAgainst": 20,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Housing Benefit Reform",
      "Reference": "S4M-02407",
      "ID": 2490
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4941,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza",
      "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-21T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.321884+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252682",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252682,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1868,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 18,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.2",
      "ID": 2446
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1926,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian",
      "DisplayName": "Brian Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7490652+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2615E213P388VM258892",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258892,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1868,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 18,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.2",
      "ID": 2446
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2615,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George",
      "DisplayName": "George Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3327192+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319848",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319848,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1868,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 18,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.2",
      "ID": 2446
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4940,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare",
      "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.943984+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249615",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 249615,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1868,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 18,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.2",
      "ID": 2446
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2641,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair",
      "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9344578+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1783E21P273VM227793",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227793,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1868,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 18,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.2",
      "ID": 2446
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1783,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie",
      "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5658828+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2633E97P136VM280796",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280796,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1868,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 18,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.2",
      "ID": 2446
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2633,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire",
      "DisplayName": "Claire Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7827648+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262702",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262702,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1868,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 18,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.2",
      "ID": 2446
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2603,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6131892+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1759E91P115VM229787",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229787,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1868,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 18,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.2",
      "ID": 2446
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia",
      "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0970173+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270135",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270135,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1868,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 18,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.2",
      "ID": 2446
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3751,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5830631+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322664",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 322664,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1868,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 18,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.2",
      "ID": 2446
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5109,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco",
      "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6984103+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5060E86P124VM294777",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 294777,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1868,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 18,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.2",
      "ID": 2446
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5060,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1778705+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242905",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242905,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1868,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 18,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.2",
      "ID": 2446
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1866,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah",
      "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.040597+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235199",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235199,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1868,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 18,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.2",
      "ID": 2446
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1943,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic",
      "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6595918+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302352",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 302352,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1868,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 18,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.2",
      "ID": 2446
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2595,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin",
      "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5206889+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244301",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244301,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1868,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 18,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.2",
      "ID": 2446
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2103,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith",
      "DisplayName": "Keith Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5487613+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327220",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 327220,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1868,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 18,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.2",
      "ID": 2446
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:46.0264233+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277041",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277041,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1868,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 18,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.2",
      "ID": 2446
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.698537+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264288",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264288,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1868,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 18,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.2",
      "ID": 2446
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2673,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick",
      "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1268308+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248732",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248732,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1868,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 18,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.2",
      "ID": 2446
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2678,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson",
      "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6674235+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2123E27P233VM295778",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295778,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1868,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 18,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.2",
      "ID": 2446
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2123,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm",
      "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.535485+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285206",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285206,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1868,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 18,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.2",
      "ID": 2446
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3907,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3128024+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230683",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230683,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1868,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 18,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.2",
      "ID": 2446
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1735,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela",
      "DisplayName": "Angela Constance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3407098+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243814",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 243814,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1868,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 18,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.2",
      "ID": 2446
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1932,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce",
      "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3208698+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254894",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254894,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1868,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 18,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.2",
      "ID": 2446
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1863,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna",
      "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2883597+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323827",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 323827,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1868,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 18,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.2",
      "ID": 2446
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4976,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth",
      "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9737644+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5107E223P379VM291294",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291294,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1868,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 18,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.2",
      "ID": 2446
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5107,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1127573+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3743E222P391VM265378",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265378,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1868,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 18,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.2",
      "ID": 2446
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3743,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel",
      "DisplayName": "Nigel Don",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4365989+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262292",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262292,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1868,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 18,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.2",
      "ID": 2446
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3771,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob",
      "DisplayName": "Bob Doris",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.5952048+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281944",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 281944,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1868,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 18,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.2",
      "ID": 2446
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2826,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Dornan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1644955+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298182",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298182,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1868,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 18,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.2",
      "ID": 2446
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3812,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia",
      "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1420166+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231250",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231250,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1868,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 18,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.2",
      "ID": 2446
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1778,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen",
      "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.5868591+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4955E240P389VM285899",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285899,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1868,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 18,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.2",
      "ID": 2446
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4955,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3493396+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219428",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 219428,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1868,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 18,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.2",
      "ID": 2446
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1742,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle",
      "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.2984404+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238534",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 238534,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1868,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 18,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.2",
      "ID": 2446
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1994,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus",
      "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4582392+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225421",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225421,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1868,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 18,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.2",
      "ID": 2446
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1814,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda",
      "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9740111+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321796",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 321796,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1868,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 18,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.2",
      "ID": 2446
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Fee",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4517333+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292867",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 292867,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1868,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 18,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.2",
      "ID": 2446
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia",
      "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5615042+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227155",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227155,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1868,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 18,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.2",
      "ID": 2446
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2701805+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5054E95P118VM312712",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 312712,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1868,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 18,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.2",
      "ID": 2446
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5054,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.140114+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4947E152P361VM257204",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257204,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1868,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 18,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.2",
      "ID": 2446
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4947,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Finnie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0460363+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271254",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271254,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1868,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 18,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.2",
      "ID": 2446
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3901,
      "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe",
      "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.062346+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278081",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 278081,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1868,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 18,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.2",
      "ID": 2446
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2394,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo",
      "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9861854+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2110E220P414VM287247",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 287247,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1868,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 18,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.2",
      "ID": 2446
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth",
      "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.85597+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250482",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250482,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1868,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 18,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.2",
      "ID": 2446
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2675,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob",
      "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1914453+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1741E10P50VM220950",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220950,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1868,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 18,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.2",
      "ID": 2446
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1741,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel",
      "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6686359+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220215",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220215,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1868,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 18,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.2",
      "ID": 2446
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1756,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine",
      "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3392995+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1860E104P150VM252372",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252372,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1868,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 18,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.2",
      "ID": 2446
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1860,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda",
      "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7263457+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2033E20P141VM253850",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253850,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1868,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 18,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.2",
      "ID": 2446
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2033,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain",
      "DisplayName": "Iain Gray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0235432+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324578",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324578,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1868,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 18,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.2",
      "ID": 2446
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5042,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2290115+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259679",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 259679,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1868,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 18,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.2",
      "ID": 2446
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick",
      "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6198355+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239362",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239362,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1868,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 18,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.2",
      "ID": 2446
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2029,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh",
      "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7335504+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273759",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 273759,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1868,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 18,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.2",
      "ID": 2446
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3758,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.634453+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304133",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 304133,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1868,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 18,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.2",
      "ID": 2446
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4086,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Hume",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8510692+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221745",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221745,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1868,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 18,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.2",
      "ID": 2446
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1773,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9459588+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1882E227P459VM241979",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241979,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1868,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 18,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.2",
      "ID": 2446
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1882,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam",
      "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7886059+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223513",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223513,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1868,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 18,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.2",
      "ID": 2446
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1893,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4616622+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307611",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307611,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1868,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 18,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.2",
      "ID": 2446
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4934,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8372711+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272372",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 272372,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1868,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 18,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.2",
      "ID": 2446
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4956,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Keir",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3324999+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244914",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244914,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1868,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 18,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.2",
      "ID": 2446
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Kelly",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5840051+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315084",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315084,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1868,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 18,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.2",
      "ID": 2446
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3129,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6733705+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247906",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247906,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1868,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 18,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.2",
      "ID": 2446
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann",
      "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4334724+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4016E11P36VM274831",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274831,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1868,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 18,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.2",
      "ID": 2446
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4016,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1236284+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255756",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255756,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1868,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 18,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.2",
      "ID": 2446
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2180,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5555483+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4938E158P374VM277414",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277414,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1868,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 18,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.2",
      "ID": 2446
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4938,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9523483+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2112E250P486VM253056",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253056,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1868,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 18,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.2",
      "ID": 2446
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2112,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny",
      "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7649562+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4939E258P394VM276799",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276799,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1868,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 18,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.2",
      "ID": 2446
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4939,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus",
      "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6815807+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325553",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 325553,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1868,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 18,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.2",
      "ID": 2446
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5074,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon",
      "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5112994+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1828E3P10VM232877",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232877,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1868,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 18,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.2",
      "ID": 2446
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1828,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo",
      "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8804582+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311456",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311456,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1868,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 18,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.2",
      "ID": 2446
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4948,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike",
      "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8796008+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2117E90P107VM230367",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230367,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1868,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 18,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.2",
      "ID": 2446
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2117,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis",
      "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3266774+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267394",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 267394,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1868,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 18,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.2",
      "ID": 2446
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken",
      "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0179343+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313706",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313706,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1868,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 18,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.2",
      "ID": 2446
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4966,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek",
      "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4070562+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3101E102P129VM295046",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295046,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1868,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 18,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.2",
      "ID": 2446
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3101,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala",
      "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1898825+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319046",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319046,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1868,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 18,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.2",
      "ID": 2446
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5034,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny",
      "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.690114+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306402",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306402,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1868,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 18,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.2",
      "ID": 2446
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2159,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Martin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5505404+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5110E252P395VM311177",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311177,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1868,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 18,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.2",
      "ID": 2446
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Mason",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.6090174+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268209",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 268209,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1868,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 18,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.2",
      "ID": 2446
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2133,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2535418+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2876E141P433VM286364",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286364,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1868,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 18,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.2",
      "ID": 2446
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2876,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5757081+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4951E147P368VM258499",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258499,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1868,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 18,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.2",
      "ID": 2446
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4951,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan",
      "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.309889+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3896E175P307VM263847",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 263847,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1868,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 18,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.2",
      "ID": 2446
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3896,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam",
      "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9130717+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308462",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 308462,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1868,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 18,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.2",
      "ID": 2446
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0569484+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4964E143P375VM279703",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279703,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1868,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 18,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.2",
      "ID": 2446
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4964,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5190237+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279631",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279631,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1868,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 18,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.2",
      "ID": 2446
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3824,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5159472+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2066E22P91VM261074",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261074,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1868,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 18,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.2",
      "ID": 2446
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2066,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.1106849+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299636",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 299636,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1868,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 18,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.2",
      "ID": 2446
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7062541+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306649",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306649,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1868,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 18,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.2",
      "ID": 2446
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina",
      "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5611663+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2487E146P369VM301145",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 301145,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1868,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 18,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.2",
      "ID": 2446
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2487,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0356633+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223853",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223853,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1868,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 18,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.2",
      "ID": 2446
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4765816+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237533",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237533,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1868,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 18,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.2",
      "ID": 2446
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1961,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David",
      "DisplayName": "David McLetchie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2149284+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305465",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 305465,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1868,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 18,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.2",
      "ID": 2446
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2134,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3251783+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320380",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 320380,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1868,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 18,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.2",
      "ID": 2446
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5041,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan",
      "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1639172+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315998",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315998,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1868,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 18,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.2",
      "ID": 2446
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3763,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart",
      "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9413357+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1986E23P197VM236669",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 236669,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1868,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 18,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.2",
      "ID": 2446
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1986,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan",
      "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9349704+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5047E100P130VM289835",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289835,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1868,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 18,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.2",
      "ID": 2446
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5047,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne",
      "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.461085+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234564",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234564,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1868,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 18,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.2",
      "ID": 2446
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1845,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette",
      "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3897408+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313568",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313568,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1868,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 18,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.2",
      "ID": 2446
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3061,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4010108+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1768E19P265VM289251",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289251,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1868,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 18,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.2",
      "ID": 2446
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1768,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4291887+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225274",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225274,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1868,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 18,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.2",
      "ID": 2446
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1894,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Neil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9623129+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3815E98P134VM270935",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270935,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1868,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 18,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.2",
      "ID": 2446
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3815,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Park, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Park",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.835431+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265851",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265851,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1868,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 18,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.2",
      "ID": 2446
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2010,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil",
      "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4632893+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283285",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283285,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1868,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 18,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.2",
      "ID": 2446
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5057,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.6938914+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2853E33P128VM251507",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251507,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1868,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 18,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.2",
      "ID": 2446
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Pentland",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4666723+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317601",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317601,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1868,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 18,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.2",
      "ID": 2446
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5009,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4294571+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254681",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254681,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1868,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 18,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.2",
      "ID": 2446
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3745,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis",
      "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2670649+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1870E225P478VM295693",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295693,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1868,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 18,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.2",
      "ID": 2446
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1870,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona",
      "DisplayName": "Shona Robison",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5317863+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2135E254P450VM235410",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235410,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1868,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 18,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.2",
      "ID": 2446
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2135,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Russell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6695623+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1895E232P431VM257604",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257604,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1868,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 18,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.2",
      "ID": 2446
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1895,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0636805+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228138",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 228138,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1868,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 18,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.2",
      "ID": 2446
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1839,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.585975+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2345E10P55VM291647",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291647,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1868,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 18,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.2",
      "ID": 2446
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2345,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1362873+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311053",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311053,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1868,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 18,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.2",
      "ID": 2446
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2223,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish",
      "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.6033968+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246358",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 246358,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1868,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 18,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.2",
      "ID": 2446
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2182,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1252933+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298127",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298127,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1868,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 18,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.2",
      "ID": 2446
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5079,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew",
      "DisplayName": "Drew Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1393796+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234160",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234160,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1868,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 18,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.2",
      "ID": 2446
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1769,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1692212+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274618",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274618,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1868,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 18,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.2",
      "ID": 2446
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4014,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz",
      "DisplayName": "Liz Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1144002+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269561",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269561,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1868,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 18,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.2",
      "ID": 2446
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2215,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5529318+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317395",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317395,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1868,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 18,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.2",
      "ID": 2446
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3806,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4202765+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326277",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 326277,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1868,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 18,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.2",
      "ID": 2446
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5106,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin",
      "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7515094+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241150",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241150,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1868,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 18,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.2",
      "ID": 2446
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1848,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola",
      "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.4041961+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2098E237P531VM289658",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289658,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1868,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 18,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.2",
      "ID": 2446
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2098,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Swinney",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4534344+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2674E247P401VM247824",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247824,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1868,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 18,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.2",
      "ID": 2446
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2674,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave",
      "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4299964+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5075E234P371VM287425",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 287425,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1868,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 18,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.2",
      "ID": 2446
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5075,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Torrance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8636484+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1793E151P362VM222518",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 222518,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1868,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 18,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.2",
      "ID": 2446
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1793,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean",
      "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1923992+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5078E245P15VM307056",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307056,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1868,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 18,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.2",
      "ID": 2446
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5078,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Walker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.585394+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1841E231P426VM239973",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239973,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1868,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 18,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.2",
      "ID": 2446
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1841,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen",
      "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7672946+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283482",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283482,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1868,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 18,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.2",
      "ID": 2446
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4952,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7098068+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1865E263P500VM231867",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231867,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1868,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 18,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.2",
      "ID": 2446
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1865,
      "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra",
      "DisplayName": "Sandra White",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6189515+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237729",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237729,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1868,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 18,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.2",
      "ID": 2446
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2610,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Wilson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2233094+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309228",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 309228,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1868,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 65,
      "VoteAgainst": 18,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.2",
      "ID": 2446
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4941,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza",
      "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3202836+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252681",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252681,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1867,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.1",
      "ID": 2444
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1926,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian",
      "DisplayName": "Brian Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7490052+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2615E213P388VM258891",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258891,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1867,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.1",
      "ID": 2444
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2615,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George",
      "DisplayName": "George Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3326787+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319849",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319849,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1867,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.1",
      "ID": 2444
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4940,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare",
      "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9440244+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249616",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 249616,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1867,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.1",
      "ID": 2444
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2641,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair",
      "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9344985+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1783E21P273VM227792",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227792,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1867,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.1",
      "ID": 2444
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1783,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie",
      "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5658231+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2633E97P136VM280795",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280795,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1867,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.1",
      "ID": 2444
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2633,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire",
      "DisplayName": "Claire Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7827063+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262701",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262701,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1867,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.1",
      "ID": 2444
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2603,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6131491+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1759E91P115VM229786",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229786,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1867,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.1",
      "ID": 2444
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia",
      "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.096977+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270136",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270136,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1867,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.1",
      "ID": 2444
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3751,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5831035+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322663",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 322663,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1867,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.1",
      "ID": 2444
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5109,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco",
      "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.698371+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5060E86P124VM294776",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 294776,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1867,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.1",
      "ID": 2444
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5060,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1778294+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242904",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242904,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1867,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.1",
      "ID": 2444
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1866,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah",
      "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0405573+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235200",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235200,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1867,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.1",
      "ID": 2444
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1943,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic",
      "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.659663+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302351",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 302351,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1867,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.1",
      "ID": 2444
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2595,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin",
      "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5206485+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244302",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244302,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1867,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.1",
      "ID": 2444
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2103,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith",
      "DisplayName": "Keith Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.548802+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327219",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 327219,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1867,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.1",
      "ID": 2444
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:46.0263809+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277040",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277040,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1867,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.1",
      "ID": 2444
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6984967+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264289",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264289,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1867,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.1",
      "ID": 2444
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2673,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick",
      "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1268724+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248733",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248733,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1867,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.1",
      "ID": 2444
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2678,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson",
      "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6674635+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2123E27P233VM295779",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295779,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1867,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.1",
      "ID": 2444
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2123,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm",
      "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5355246+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285205",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285205,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1867,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.1",
      "ID": 2444
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3907,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3127479+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230682",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230682,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1867,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.1",
      "ID": 2444
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1735,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela",
      "DisplayName": "Angela Constance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3406687+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243815",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 243815,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1867,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.1",
      "ID": 2444
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1932,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce",
      "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3209094+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254895",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254895,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1867,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.1",
      "ID": 2444
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1863,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna",
      "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2883998+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323826",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 323826,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1867,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.1",
      "ID": 2444
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4976,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth",
      "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9737227+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5107E223P379VM291295",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291295,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1867,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.1",
      "ID": 2444
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5107,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1127984+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3743E222P391VM265377",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265377,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1867,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.1",
      "ID": 2444
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3743,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel",
      "DisplayName": "Nigel Don",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4365584+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262291",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262291,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1867,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.1",
      "ID": 2444
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3771,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob",
      "DisplayName": "Bob Doris",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.5951641+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281945",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 281945,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1867,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.1",
      "ID": 2444
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2826,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Dornan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.164536+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298181",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298181,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1867,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.1",
      "ID": 2444
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3812,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia",
      "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1418744+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231251",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231251,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1867,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.1",
      "ID": 2444
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1778,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen",
      "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.5868995+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4955E240P389VM285900",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285900,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1867,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.1",
      "ID": 2444
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4955,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.349383+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219427",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 219427,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1867,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.1",
      "ID": 2444
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1742,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle",
      "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.2983873+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238535",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 238535,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1867,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.1",
      "ID": 2444
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1994,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus",
      "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4582794+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225422",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225422,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1867,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.1",
      "ID": 2444
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1814,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda",
      "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9740523+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321797",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 321797,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1867,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.1",
      "ID": 2444
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Fee",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4517728+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292868",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 292868,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1867,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.1",
      "ID": 2444
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia",
      "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5615448+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227154",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227154,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1867,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.1",
      "ID": 2444
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2701395+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5054E95P118VM312711",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 312711,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1867,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.1",
      "ID": 2444
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5054,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1400663+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4947E152P361VM257203",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257203,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1867,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.1",
      "ID": 2444
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4947,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Finnie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0459921+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271255",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271255,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1867,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.1",
      "ID": 2444
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3901,
      "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe",
      "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0623868+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278082",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 278082,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1867,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.1",
      "ID": 2444
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2394,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo",
      "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9862335+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2110E220P414VM287246",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 287246,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1867,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.1",
      "ID": 2444
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth",
      "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8559298+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250481",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250481,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1867,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.1",
      "ID": 2444
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2675,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob",
      "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1913865+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1741E10P50VM220949",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220949,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1867,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.1",
      "ID": 2444
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1741,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel",
      "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6685949+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220216",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220216,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1867,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.1",
      "ID": 2444
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1756,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine",
      "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3393402+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1860E104P150VM252371",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252371,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1867,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.1",
      "ID": 2444
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1860,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda",
      "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7263052+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2033E20P141VM253851",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253851,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1867,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.1",
      "ID": 2444
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2033,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain",
      "DisplayName": "Iain Gray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0235832+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324579",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324579,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1867,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.1",
      "ID": 2444
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5042,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2290514+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259680",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 259680,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1867,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.1",
      "ID": 2444
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick",
      "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6198944+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239361",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239361,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1867,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.1",
      "ID": 2444
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2029,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh",
      "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7335091+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273760",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 273760,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1867,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.1",
      "ID": 2444
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3758,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.634493+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304134",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 304134,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1867,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.1",
      "ID": 2444
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4086,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Hume",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8511094+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221746",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221746,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1867,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.1",
      "ID": 2444
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1773,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9459986+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1882E227P459VM241980",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241980,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1867,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.1",
      "ID": 2444
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1882,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam",
      "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7886464+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223514",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223514,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1867,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.1",
      "ID": 2444
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1893,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4617029+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307610",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307610,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1867,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.1",
      "ID": 2444
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4934,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8371466+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272219",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 272219,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1867,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.1",
      "ID": 2444
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4956,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Keir",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3201525+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244913",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244913,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1867,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.1",
      "ID": 2444
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Kelly",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5839646+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315083",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315083,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1867,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.1",
      "ID": 2444
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3129,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6733303+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247907",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247907,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1867,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.1",
      "ID": 2444
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann",
      "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4335124+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4016E11P36VM274830",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274830,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1867,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.1",
      "ID": 2444
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4016,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1235879+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255757",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255757,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1867,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.1",
      "ID": 2444
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2180,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5555879+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4938E158P374VM277415",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277415,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1867,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.1",
      "ID": 2444
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4938,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9523891+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2112E250P486VM253055",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253055,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1867,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.1",
      "ID": 2444
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2112,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny",
      "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7649151+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4939E258P394VM276800",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276800,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1867,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.1",
      "ID": 2444
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4939,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus",
      "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6816386+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325552",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 325552,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1867,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.1",
      "ID": 2444
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5074,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon",
      "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5112589+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1828E3P10VM232876",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232876,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1867,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.1",
      "ID": 2444
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1828,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo",
      "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8804171+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311455",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311455,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1867,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.1",
      "ID": 2444
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4948,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike",
      "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8795593+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2117E90P107VM230368",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230368,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1867,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.1",
      "ID": 2444
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2117,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis",
      "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3267202+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267393",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 267393,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1867,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.1",
      "ID": 2444
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken",
      "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0178928+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313707",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313707,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1867,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.1",
      "ID": 2444
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4966,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek",
      "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4072019+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3101E102P129VM295047",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295047,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1867,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.1",
      "ID": 2444
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3101,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala",
      "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1899239+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319047",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319047,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1867,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.1",
      "ID": 2444
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5034,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny",
      "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6901541+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306403",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306403,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1867,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.1",
      "ID": 2444
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2159,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Martin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5506004+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5110E252P395VM311178",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311178,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1867,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.1",
      "ID": 2444
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Mason",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.6090578+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268210",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 268210,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1867,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.1",
      "ID": 2444
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2133,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2535831+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2876E141P433VM286363",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286363,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1867,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.1",
      "ID": 2444
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2876,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5755783+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4951E147P368VM258652",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258652,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1867,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.1",
      "ID": 2444
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4951,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan",
      "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3167401+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3896E175P307VM263848",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 263848,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1867,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.1",
      "ID": 2444
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3896,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam",
      "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9131414+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308461",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 308461,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1867,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.1",
      "ID": 2444
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0569068+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4964E143P375VM279702",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279702,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1867,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.1",
      "ID": 2444
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4964,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5189841+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279632",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279632,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1867,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.1",
      "ID": 2444
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3824,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5159874+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2066E22P91VM261075",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261075,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1867,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.1",
      "ID": 2444
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2066,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.1107261+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299637",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 299637,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1867,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.1",
      "ID": 2444
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7062941+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306648",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306648,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1867,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.1",
      "ID": 2444
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina",
      "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5611252+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2487E146P369VM301146",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 301146,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1867,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.1",
      "ID": 2444
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2487,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0357117+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223698",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223698,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1867,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.1",
      "ID": 2444
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4699546+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237532",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237532,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1867,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.1",
      "ID": 2444
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1961,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David",
      "DisplayName": "David McLetchie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2148882+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305464",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 305464,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1867,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.1",
      "ID": 2444
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2134,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.325138+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320379",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 320379,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1867,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.1",
      "ID": 2444
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5041,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan",
      "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1638755+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315999",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315999,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1867,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.1",
      "ID": 2444
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3763,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart",
      "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9413764+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1986E23P197VM236668",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 236668,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1867,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.1",
      "ID": 2444
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1986,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan",
      "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9349305+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5047E100P130VM289836",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289836,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1867,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.1",
      "ID": 2444
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5047,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne",
      "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4611242+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234565",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234565,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1867,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.1",
      "ID": 2444
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1845,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette",
      "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3897825+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313569",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313569,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1867,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.1",
      "ID": 2444
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3061,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4010538+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1768E19P265VM289250",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289250,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1867,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.1",
      "ID": 2444
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1768,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4291485+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225273",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225273,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1867,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.1",
      "ID": 2444
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1894,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Neil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9622712+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3815E98P134VM270934",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270934,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1867,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.1",
      "ID": 2444
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3815,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Park, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Park",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8353897+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265852",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265852,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1867,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.1",
      "ID": 2444
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2010,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil",
      "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4633301+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283286",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283286,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1867,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.1",
      "ID": 2444
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5057,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.6939323+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2853E33P128VM251506",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251506,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1867,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.1",
      "ID": 2444
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Pentland",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4666307+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317600",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317600,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1867,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.1",
      "ID": 2444
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5009,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4294168+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254682",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254682,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1867,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.1",
      "ID": 2444
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3745,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis",
      "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2671095+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1870E225P478VM295692",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295692,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1867,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.1",
      "ID": 2444
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1870,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona",
      "DisplayName": "Shona Robison",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5317466+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2135E254P450VM235409",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235409,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1867,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.1",
      "ID": 2444
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2135,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Russell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6695212+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1895E232P431VM257603",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257603,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1867,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.1",
      "ID": 2444
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1895,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0636225+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228137",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 228137,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1867,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.1",
      "ID": 2444
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1839,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5859349+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2345E10P55VM291648",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291648,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1867,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.1",
      "ID": 2444
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2345,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.136327+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311052",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311052,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1867,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.1",
      "ID": 2444
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2223,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish",
      "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.6033565+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246357",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 246357,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1867,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.1",
      "ID": 2444
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2182,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1252332+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298128",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298128,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1867,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.1",
      "ID": 2444
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5079,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew",
      "DisplayName": "Drew Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1394196+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234314",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234314,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1867,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.1",
      "ID": 2444
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1769,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3719254+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274617",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274617,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1867,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.1",
      "ID": 2444
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4014,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz",
      "DisplayName": "Liz Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1143596+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269560",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269560,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1867,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.1",
      "ID": 2444
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2215,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5528915+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317394",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317394,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1867,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.1",
      "ID": 2444
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3806,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4202362+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326278",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 326278,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1867,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.1",
      "ID": 2444
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5106,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin",
      "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7515509+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241149",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241149,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1867,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.1",
      "ID": 2444
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1848,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola",
      "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.4041359+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2098E237P531VM289657",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289657,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1867,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.1",
      "ID": 2444
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2098,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Swinney",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4533949+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2674E247P401VM247823",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247823,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1867,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.1",
      "ID": 2444
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2674,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave",
      "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4299563+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5075E234P371VM287424",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 287424,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1867,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.1",
      "ID": 2444
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5075,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Torrance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8636082+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1793E151P362VM222517",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 222517,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1867,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.1",
      "ID": 2444
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1793,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean",
      "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1923585+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5078E245P15VM307057",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307057,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1867,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.1",
      "ID": 2444
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5078,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Walker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5854347+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1841E231P426VM239974",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239974,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1867,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.1",
      "ID": 2444
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1841,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen",
      "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7673354+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283481",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283481,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1867,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.1",
      "ID": 2444
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4952,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.709766+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1865E263P500VM231868",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231868,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1867,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.1",
      "ID": 2444
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1865,
      "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra",
      "DisplayName": "Sandra White",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.618992+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237730",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237730,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1867,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.1",
      "ID": 2444
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2610,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Wilson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2233491+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309229",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 309229,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1867,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 31,
      "VoteAgainst": 80,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338.1",
      "ID": 2444
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4941,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza",
      "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3203241+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252680",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252680,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1866,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 94,
      "VoteAgainst": 17,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338",
      "ID": 2420
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1926,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian",
      "DisplayName": "Brian Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7489659+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2615E213P388VM258890",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258890,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1866,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 94,
      "VoteAgainst": 17,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338",
      "ID": 2420
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2615,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George",
      "DisplayName": "George Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3326366+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319850",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319850,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1866,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 94,
      "VoteAgainst": 17,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338",
      "ID": 2420
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4940,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare",
      "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.944091+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249617",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 249617,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1866,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 94,
      "VoteAgainst": 17,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338",
      "ID": 2420
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2641,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair",
      "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9345587+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1783E21P273VM227791",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227791,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1866,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 94,
      "VoteAgainst": 17,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338",
      "ID": 2420
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1783,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie",
      "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5657816+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2633E97P136VM280794",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280794,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1866,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 94,
      "VoteAgainst": 17,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338",
      "ID": 2420
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2633,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire",
      "DisplayName": "Claire Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7826663+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262700",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262700,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1866,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 94,
      "VoteAgainst": 17,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338",
      "ID": 2420
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2603,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6131087+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1759E91P115VM229785",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229785,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1866,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 94,
      "VoteAgainst": 17,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338",
      "ID": 2420
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia",
      "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0969362+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270137",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270137,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1866,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 94,
      "VoteAgainst": 17,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338",
      "ID": 2420
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3751,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.583144+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322662",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 322662,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1866,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 94,
      "VoteAgainst": 17,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338",
      "ID": 2420
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5109,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco",
      "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6983314+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5060E86P124VM294775",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 294775,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1866,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 94,
      "VoteAgainst": 17,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338",
      "ID": 2420
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5060,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1777886+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242903",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242903,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1866,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 94,
      "VoteAgainst": 17,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338",
      "ID": 2420
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1866,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah",
      "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0405178+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235201",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235201,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1866,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 94,
      "VoteAgainst": 17,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338",
      "ID": 2420
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1943,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic",
      "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6597197+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302350",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 302350,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1866,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 94,
      "VoteAgainst": 17,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338",
      "ID": 2420
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2595,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin",
      "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5206071+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244303",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244303,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1866,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 94,
      "VoteAgainst": 17,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338",
      "ID": 2420
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2103,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith",
      "DisplayName": "Keith Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5488431+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327218",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 327218,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1866,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 94,
      "VoteAgainst": 17,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338",
      "ID": 2420
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:46.0263382+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277039",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277039,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1866,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 94,
      "VoteAgainst": 17,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338",
      "ID": 2420
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6984548+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264290",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264290,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1866,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 94,
      "VoteAgainst": 17,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338",
      "ID": 2420
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2673,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick",
      "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1269138+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248734",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248734,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1866,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 94,
      "VoteAgainst": 17,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338",
      "ID": 2420
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2678,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson",
      "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6675032+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2123E27P233VM295780",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295780,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1866,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 94,
      "VoteAgainst": 17,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338",
      "ID": 2420
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2123,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm",
      "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5355829+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285204",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285204,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1866,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 94,
      "VoteAgainst": 17,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338",
      "ID": 2420
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3907,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3126513+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230681",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230681,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1866,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 94,
      "VoteAgainst": 17,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338",
      "ID": 2420
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1735,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela",
      "DisplayName": "Angela Constance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3406286+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243816",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 243816,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1866,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 94,
      "VoteAgainst": 17,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338",
      "ID": 2420
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1932,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce",
      "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.320949+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254896",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254896,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1866,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 94,
      "VoteAgainst": 17,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338",
      "ID": 2420
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1863,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna",
      "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2884399+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323825",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 323825,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1866,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 94,
      "VoteAgainst": 17,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338",
      "ID": 2420
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4976,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth",
      "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9736769+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5107E223P379VM291296",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291296,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1866,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 94,
      "VoteAgainst": 17,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338",
      "ID": 2420
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5107,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1128391+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3743E222P391VM265376",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265376,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1866,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 94,
      "VoteAgainst": 17,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338",
      "ID": 2420
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3743,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel",
      "DisplayName": "Nigel Don",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4365179+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262290",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262290,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1866,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 94,
      "VoteAgainst": 17,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338",
      "ID": 2420
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3771,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob",
      "DisplayName": "Bob Doris",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.5951236+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281946",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 281946,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1866,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 94,
      "VoteAgainst": 17,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338",
      "ID": 2420
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2826,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Dornan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1645766+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298180",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298180,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1866,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 94,
      "VoteAgainst": 17,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338",
      "ID": 2420
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3812,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia",
      "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1418316+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231252",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231252,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1866,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 94,
      "VoteAgainst": 17,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338",
      "ID": 2420
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1778,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen",
      "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.586964+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4955E240P389VM285901",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285901,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1866,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 94,
      "VoteAgainst": 17,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338",
      "ID": 2420
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4955,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3494241+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219426",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 219426,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1866,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 94,
      "VoteAgainst": 17,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338",
      "ID": 2420
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1742,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle",
      "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.298333+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238536",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 238536,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1866,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 94,
      "VoteAgainst": 17,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338",
      "ID": 2420
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1994,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus",
      "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4583197+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225423",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225423,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1866,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 94,
      "VoteAgainst": 17,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338",
      "ID": 2420
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1814,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda",
      "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.974094+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321798",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 321798,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1866,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 94,
      "VoteAgainst": 17,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338",
      "ID": 2420
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Fee",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4518126+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292869",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 292869,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1866,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 94,
      "VoteAgainst": 17,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338",
      "ID": 2420
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia",
      "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5615849+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227153",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227153,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1866,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 94,
      "VoteAgainst": 17,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338",
      "ID": 2420
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2700991+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5054E95P118VM312710",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 312710,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1866,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 94,
      "VoteAgainst": 17,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338",
      "ID": 2420
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5054,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1400237+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4947E152P361VM257202",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257202,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1866,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 94,
      "VoteAgainst": 17,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338",
      "ID": 2420
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4947,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Finnie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0459081+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271256",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271256,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1866,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 94,
      "VoteAgainst": 17,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338",
      "ID": 2420
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3901,
      "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe",
      "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0624289+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278083",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 278083,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1866,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 94,
      "VoteAgainst": 17,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338",
      "ID": 2420
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2394,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo",
      "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9862749+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2110E220P414VM287245",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 287245,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1866,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 94,
      "VoteAgainst": 17,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338",
      "ID": 2420
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth",
      "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8558894+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250480",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250480,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1866,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 94,
      "VoteAgainst": 17,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338",
      "ID": 2420
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2675,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob",
      "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1913459+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1741E10P50VM220948",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220948,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1866,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 94,
      "VoteAgainst": 17,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338",
      "ID": 2420
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1741,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel",
      "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6685521+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220217",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220217,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1866,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 94,
      "VoteAgainst": 17,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338",
      "ID": 2420
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1756,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine",
      "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6288325+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1860E104P150VM252370",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252370,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1866,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 94,
      "VoteAgainst": 17,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338",
      "ID": 2420
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1860,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda",
      "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7262638+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2033E20P141VM253852",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253852,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1866,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 94,
      "VoteAgainst": 17,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338",
      "ID": 2420
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2033,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain",
      "DisplayName": "Iain Gray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0236226+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324580",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324580,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1866,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 94,
      "VoteAgainst": 17,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338",
      "ID": 2420
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5042,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2290913+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259681",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 259681,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1866,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 94,
      "VoteAgainst": 17,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338",
      "ID": 2420
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick",
      "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6199364+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239360",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239360,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1866,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 94,
      "VoteAgainst": 17,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338",
      "ID": 2420
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2029,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh",
      "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7334686+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273761",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 273761,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1866,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 94,
      "VoteAgainst": 17,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338",
      "ID": 2420
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3758,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.634533+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304135",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 304135,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1866,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 94,
      "VoteAgainst": 17,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338",
      "ID": 2420
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4086,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Hume",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8511501+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221747",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221747,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1866,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 94,
      "VoteAgainst": 17,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338",
      "ID": 2420
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1773,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9460401+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1882E227P459VM241981",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241981,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1866,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 94,
      "VoteAgainst": 17,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338",
      "ID": 2420
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1882,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam",
      "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7886867+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223515",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223515,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1866,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 94,
      "VoteAgainst": 17,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338",
      "ID": 2420
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1893,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.461743+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307609",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307609,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1866,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 94,
      "VoteAgainst": 17,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338",
      "ID": 2420
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4934,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8370998+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272218",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 272218,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1866,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 94,
      "VoteAgainst": 17,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338",
      "ID": 2420
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4956,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Keir",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3201119+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244912",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244912,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1866,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 94,
      "VoteAgainst": 17,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338",
      "ID": 2420
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Kelly",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5839246+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315082",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315082,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1866,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 94,
      "VoteAgainst": 17,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338",
      "ID": 2420
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3129,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6732889+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247908",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247908,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1866,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 94,
      "VoteAgainst": 17,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338",
      "ID": 2420
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann",
      "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4335521+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4016E11P36VM274829",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274829,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1866,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 94,
      "VoteAgainst": 17,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338",
      "ID": 2420
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4016,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1235474+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255758",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255758,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1866,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 94,
      "VoteAgainst": 17,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338",
      "ID": 2420
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2180,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5556275+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4938E158P374VM277416",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277416,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1866,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 94,
      "VoteAgainst": 17,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338",
      "ID": 2420
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4938,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9524303+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2112E250P486VM253054",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253054,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1866,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 94,
      "VoteAgainst": 17,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338",
      "ID": 2420
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2112,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny",
      "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7648742+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4939E258P394VM276801",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276801,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1866,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 94,
      "VoteAgainst": 17,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338",
      "ID": 2420
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4939,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus",
      "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6816799+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325551",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 325551,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1866,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 94,
      "VoteAgainst": 17,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338",
      "ID": 2420
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5074,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon",
      "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5112192+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1828E3P10VM232875",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232875,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1866,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 94,
      "VoteAgainst": 17,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338",
      "ID": 2420
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1828,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo",
      "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8803769+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311454",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311454,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1866,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 94,
      "VoteAgainst": 17,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338",
      "ID": 2420
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4948,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike",
      "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8795182+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2117E90P107VM230369",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230369,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1866,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 94,
      "VoteAgainst": 17,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338",
      "ID": 2420
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2117,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis",
      "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3267619+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267392",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 267392,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1866,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 94,
      "VoteAgainst": 17,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338",
      "ID": 2420
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken",
      "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0178514+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313708",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313708,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1866,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 94,
      "VoteAgainst": 17,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338",
      "ID": 2420
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4966,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek",
      "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.407253+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3101E102P129VM295048",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295048,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1866,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 94,
      "VoteAgainst": 17,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338",
      "ID": 2420
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3101,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala",
      "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1899643+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319048",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319048,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1866,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 94,
      "VoteAgainst": 17,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338",
      "ID": 2420
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5034,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny",
      "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6901946+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306404",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306404,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1866,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 94,
      "VoteAgainst": 17,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338",
      "ID": 2420
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2159,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Martin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.550642+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5110E252P395VM311179",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311179,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1866,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 94,
      "VoteAgainst": 17,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338",
      "ID": 2420
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Mason",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.6090981+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268211",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 268211,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1866,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 94,
      "VoteAgainst": 17,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338",
      "ID": 2420
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2133,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2536237+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2876E141P433VM286362",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286362,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1866,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 94,
      "VoteAgainst": 17,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338",
      "ID": 2420
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2876,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5755377+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4951E147P368VM258653",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258653,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1866,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 94,
      "VoteAgainst": 17,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338",
      "ID": 2420
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4951,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan",
      "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3167809+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3896E175P307VM263849",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 263849,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1866,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 94,
      "VoteAgainst": 17,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338",
      "ID": 2420
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3896,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam",
      "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9131904+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308460",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 308460,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1866,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 94,
      "VoteAgainst": 17,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338",
      "ID": 2420
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0568661+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4964E143P375VM279701",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279701,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1866,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 94,
      "VoteAgainst": 17,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338",
      "ID": 2420
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4964,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.518944+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279633",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279633,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1866,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 94,
      "VoteAgainst": 17,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338",
      "ID": 2420
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3824,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5160274+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2066E22P91VM261076",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261076,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1866,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 94,
      "VoteAgainst": 17,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338",
      "ID": 2420
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2066,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.1107675+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299638",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 299638,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1866,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 94,
      "VoteAgainst": 17,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338",
      "ID": 2420
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7063341+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306647",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306647,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1866,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 94,
      "VoteAgainst": 17,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338",
      "ID": 2420
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina",
      "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5610849+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2487E146P369VM301147",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 301147,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1866,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 94,
      "VoteAgainst": 17,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338",
      "ID": 2420
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2487,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0357621+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223697",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223697,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1866,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 94,
      "VoteAgainst": 17,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338",
      "ID": 2420
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4699134+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237531",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237531,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1866,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 94,
      "VoteAgainst": 17,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338",
      "ID": 2420
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1961,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David",
      "DisplayName": "David McLetchie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2148478+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305463",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 305463,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1866,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 94,
      "VoteAgainst": 17,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338",
      "ID": 2420
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2134,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3250976+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320378",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 320378,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1866,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 94,
      "VoteAgainst": 17,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338",
      "ID": 2420
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5041,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan",
      "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1638339+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3763E142P397VM316000",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 316000,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1866,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 94,
      "VoteAgainst": 17,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338",
      "ID": 2420
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3763,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart",
      "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9414178+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1986E23P197VM236667",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 236667,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1866,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 94,
      "VoteAgainst": 17,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338",
      "ID": 2420
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1986,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan",
      "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9348905+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5047E100P130VM289837",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289837,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1866,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 94,
      "VoteAgainst": 17,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338",
      "ID": 2420
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5047,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne",
      "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4611812+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234566",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234566,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1866,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 94,
      "VoteAgainst": 17,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338",
      "ID": 2420
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1845,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette",
      "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3898234+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313570",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313570,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1866,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 94,
      "VoteAgainst": 17,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338",
      "ID": 2420
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3061,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4010946+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1768E19P265VM289249",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289249,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1866,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 94,
      "VoteAgainst": 17,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338",
      "ID": 2420
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1768,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.429108+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225272",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225272,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1866,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 94,
      "VoteAgainst": 17,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338",
      "ID": 2420
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1894,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Neil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9622304+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3815E98P134VM270933",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270933,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1866,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 94,
      "VoteAgainst": 17,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338",
      "ID": 2420
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3815,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Park, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Park",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8353476+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265853",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265853,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1866,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 94,
      "VoteAgainst": 17,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338",
      "ID": 2420
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2010,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil",
      "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4633715+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283287",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283287,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1866,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 94,
      "VoteAgainst": 17,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338",
      "ID": 2420
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5057,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.6939738+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2853E33P128VM251505",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251505,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1866,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 94,
      "VoteAgainst": 17,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338",
      "ID": 2420
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Pentland",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4665894+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317599",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317599,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1866,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 94,
      "VoteAgainst": 17,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338",
      "ID": 2420
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5009,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4293762+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254683",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254683,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1866,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 94,
      "VoteAgainst": 17,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338",
      "ID": 2420
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3745,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis",
      "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2671516+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1870E225P478VM295691",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295691,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1866,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 94,
      "VoteAgainst": 17,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338",
      "ID": 2420
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1870,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona",
      "DisplayName": "Shona Robison",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.531706+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2135E254P450VM235408",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235408,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1866,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 94,
      "VoteAgainst": 17,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338",
      "ID": 2420
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2135,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Russell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6694787+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1895E232P431VM257602",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257602,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1866,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 94,
      "VoteAgainst": 17,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338",
      "ID": 2420
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1895,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0635818+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228136",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 228136,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1866,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 94,
      "VoteAgainst": 17,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338",
      "ID": 2420
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1839,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5858941+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2345E10P55VM291649",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291649,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1866,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 94,
      "VoteAgainst": 17,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338",
      "ID": 2420
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2345,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1363665+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311051",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311051,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1866,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 94,
      "VoteAgainst": 17,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338",
      "ID": 2420
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2223,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish",
      "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.6033154+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246356",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 246356,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1866,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 94,
      "VoteAgainst": 17,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338",
      "ID": 2420
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2182,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1251924+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298129",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298129,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1866,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 94,
      "VoteAgainst": 17,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338",
      "ID": 2420
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5079,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew",
      "DisplayName": "Drew Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1394612+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234315",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234315,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1866,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 94,
      "VoteAgainst": 17,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338",
      "ID": 2420
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1769,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3719658+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274616",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274616,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1866,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 94,
      "VoteAgainst": 17,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338",
      "ID": 2420
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4014,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz",
      "DisplayName": "Liz Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1143185+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269559",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269559,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1866,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 94,
      "VoteAgainst": 17,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338",
      "ID": 2420
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2215,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5528514+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317393",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317393,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1866,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 94,
      "VoteAgainst": 17,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338",
      "ID": 2420
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3806,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4201951+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326279",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 326279,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1866,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 94,
      "VoteAgainst": 17,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338",
      "ID": 2420
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5106,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin",
      "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7516101+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241148",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241148,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1866,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 94,
      "VoteAgainst": 17,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338",
      "ID": 2420
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1848,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola",
      "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.4040955+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2098E237P531VM289656",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289656,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1866,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 94,
      "VoteAgainst": 17,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338",
      "ID": 2420
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2098,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Swinney",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4533556+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2674E247P401VM247822",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247822,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1866,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 94,
      "VoteAgainst": 17,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338",
      "ID": 2420
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2674,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave",
      "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4299161+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5075E234P371VM287423",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 287423,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1866,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 94,
      "VoteAgainst": 17,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338",
      "ID": 2420
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5075,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Torrance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8635682+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1793E151P362VM222516",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 222516,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1866,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 94,
      "VoteAgainst": 17,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338",
      "ID": 2420
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1793,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean",
      "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1923179+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5078E245P15VM307058",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307058,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1866,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 94,
      "VoteAgainst": 17,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338",
      "ID": 2420
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5078,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Walker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5854754+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1841E231P426VM239975",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239975,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1866,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 94,
      "VoteAgainst": 17,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338",
      "ID": 2420
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1841,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen",
      "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.767376+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283480",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283480,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1866,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 94,
      "VoteAgainst": 17,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338",
      "ID": 2420
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4952,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7097257+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1865E263P500VM231869",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231869,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1866,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 94,
      "VoteAgainst": 17,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338",
      "ID": 2420
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1865,
      "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra",
      "DisplayName": "Sandra White",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6190327+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237731",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237731,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1866,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 94,
      "VoteAgainst": 17,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338",
      "ID": 2420
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2610,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Wilson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2233886+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309230",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 309230,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1866,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 94,
      "VoteAgainst": 17,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Childcare",
      "Reference": "S4M-02338",
      "ID": 2420
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4941,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza",
      "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3203643+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252679",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252679,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1865,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 4,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prisons",
      "Reference": "S4M-02337.1",
      "ID": 2448
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1926,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian",
      "DisplayName": "Brian Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.748926+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2615E213P388VM258889",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258889,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1865,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 4,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prisons",
      "Reference": "S4M-02337.1",
      "ID": 2448
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2615,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George",
      "DisplayName": "George Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3325755+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319851",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319851,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1865,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 4,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prisons",
      "Reference": "S4M-02337.1",
      "ID": 2448
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4940,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare",
      "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9441332+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249618",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 249618,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1865,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 4,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prisons",
      "Reference": "S4M-02337.1",
      "ID": 2448
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2641,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair",
      "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9346008+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1783E21P273VM227790",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227790,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1865,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 4,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prisons",
      "Reference": "S4M-02337.1",
      "ID": 2448
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1783,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie",
      "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5657412+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2633E97P136VM280793",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280793,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1865,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 4,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prisons",
      "Reference": "S4M-02337.1",
      "ID": 2448
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2633,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire",
      "DisplayName": "Claire Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7826262+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262699",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262699,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1865,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 4,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prisons",
      "Reference": "S4M-02337.1",
      "ID": 2448
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2603,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6130684+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1759E91P115VM229784",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229784,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1865,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 4,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prisons",
      "Reference": "S4M-02337.1",
      "ID": 2448
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia",
      "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0968959+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270138",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270138,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1865,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 4,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prisons",
      "Reference": "S4M-02337.1",
      "ID": 2448
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3751,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.583185+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322661",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 322661,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1865,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 4,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prisons",
      "Reference": "S4M-02337.1",
      "ID": 2448
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5109,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco",
      "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6982915+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5060E86P124VM294774",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 294774,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1865,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 4,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prisons",
      "Reference": "S4M-02337.1",
      "ID": 2448
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5060,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1777479+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242902",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242902,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1865,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 4,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prisons",
      "Reference": "S4M-02337.1",
      "ID": 2448
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1866,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah",
      "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0404776+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235202",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235202,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1865,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 4,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prisons",
      "Reference": "S4M-02337.1",
      "ID": 2448
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1943,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic",
      "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6597741+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302349",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 302349,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1865,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 4,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prisons",
      "Reference": "S4M-02337.1",
      "ID": 2448
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2595,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin",
      "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5205667+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244304",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244304,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1865,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 4,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prisons",
      "Reference": "S4M-02337.1",
      "ID": 2448
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2103,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith",
      "DisplayName": "Keith Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5488846+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327217",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 327217,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1865,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 4,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prisons",
      "Reference": "S4M-02337.1",
      "ID": 2448
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:46.0262657+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277038",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277038,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1865,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 4,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prisons",
      "Reference": "S4M-02337.1",
      "ID": 2448
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6983951+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264291",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264291,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1865,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 4,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prisons",
      "Reference": "S4M-02337.1",
      "ID": 2448
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2673,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick",
      "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1269548+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248735",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248735,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1865,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 4,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prisons",
      "Reference": "S4M-02337.1",
      "ID": 2448
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2678,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson",
      "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6675432+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2123E27P233VM295781",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295781,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1865,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 4,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prisons",
      "Reference": "S4M-02337.1",
      "ID": 2448
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2123,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm",
      "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5356239+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285203",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285203,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1865,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 4,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prisons",
      "Reference": "S4M-02337.1",
      "ID": 2448
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3907,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3125988+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230680",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230680,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1865,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 4,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prisons",
      "Reference": "S4M-02337.1",
      "ID": 2448
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1735,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela",
      "DisplayName": "Angela Constance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3405883+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243817",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 243817,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1865,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 4,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prisons",
      "Reference": "S4M-02337.1",
      "ID": 2448
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1932,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce",
      "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3209888+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254897",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254897,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1865,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 4,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prisons",
      "Reference": "S4M-02337.1",
      "ID": 2448
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1863,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna",
      "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2884801+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323824",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 323824,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1865,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 4,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prisons",
      "Reference": "S4M-02337.1",
      "ID": 2448
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4976,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth",
      "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9735164+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5107E223P379VM291297",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291297,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1865,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 4,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prisons",
      "Reference": "S4M-02337.1",
      "ID": 2448
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5107,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.11288+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3743E222P391VM265375",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265375,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1865,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 4,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prisons",
      "Reference": "S4M-02337.1",
      "ID": 2448
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3743,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel",
      "DisplayName": "Nigel Don",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4364769+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262289",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262289,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1865,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 4,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prisons",
      "Reference": "S4M-02337.1",
      "ID": 2448
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3771,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob",
      "DisplayName": "Bob Doris",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.5950835+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281947",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 281947,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1865,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 4,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prisons",
      "Reference": "S4M-02337.1",
      "ID": 2448
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2826,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Dornan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1646176+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298179",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298179,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1865,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 4,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prisons",
      "Reference": "S4M-02337.1",
      "ID": 2448
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3812,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia",
      "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1417862+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231253",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231253,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1865,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 4,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prisons",
      "Reference": "S4M-02337.1",
      "ID": 2448
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1778,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen",
      "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.587006+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4955E240P389VM285902",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285902,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1865,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 4,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prisons",
      "Reference": "S4M-02337.1",
      "ID": 2448
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4955,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3494652+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219425",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 219425,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1865,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 4,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prisons",
      "Reference": "S4M-02337.1",
      "ID": 2448
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1742,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle",
      "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.2982841+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238537",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 238537,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1865,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 4,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prisons",
      "Reference": "S4M-02337.1",
      "ID": 2448
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1994,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus",
      "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4583605+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225424",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225424,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1865,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 4,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prisons",
      "Reference": "S4M-02337.1",
      "ID": 2448
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1814,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda",
      "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9741341+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321799",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 321799,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1865,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 4,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prisons",
      "Reference": "S4M-02337.1",
      "ID": 2448
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Fee",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4518527+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292870",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 292870,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1865,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 4,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prisons",
      "Reference": "S4M-02337.1",
      "ID": 2448
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia",
      "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5616248+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227152",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227152,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1865,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 4,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prisons",
      "Reference": "S4M-02337.1",
      "ID": 2448
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2700587+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5054E95P118VM312709",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 312709,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1865,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 4,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prisons",
      "Reference": "S4M-02337.1",
      "ID": 2448
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5054,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1399595+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4947E152P361VM257201",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257201,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1865,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 4,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prisons",
      "Reference": "S4M-02337.1",
      "ID": 2448
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4947,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Finnie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0458662+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271257",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271257,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1865,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 4,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prisons",
      "Reference": "S4M-02337.1",
      "ID": 2448
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3901,
      "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe",
      "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0624893+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278084",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 278084,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1865,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 4,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prisons",
      "Reference": "S4M-02337.1",
      "ID": 2448
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2394,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo",
      "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9863155+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2110E220P414VM287244",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 287244,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1865,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 4,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prisons",
      "Reference": "S4M-02337.1",
      "ID": 2448
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth",
      "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8558487+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250479",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250479,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1865,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 4,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prisons",
      "Reference": "S4M-02337.1",
      "ID": 2448
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2675,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob",
      "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.191305+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1741E10P50VM220947",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220947,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1865,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 4,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prisons",
      "Reference": "S4M-02337.1",
      "ID": 2448
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1741,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel",
      "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6684924+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220218",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220218,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1865,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 4,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prisons",
      "Reference": "S4M-02337.1",
      "ID": 2448
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1756,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine",
      "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6289123+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1860E104P150VM252369",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252369,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1865,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 4,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prisons",
      "Reference": "S4M-02337.1",
      "ID": 2448
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1860,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda",
      "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7262213+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2033E20P141VM253853",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253853,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1865,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 4,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prisons",
      "Reference": "S4M-02337.1",
      "ID": 2448
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2033,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain",
      "DisplayName": "Iain Gray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0236621+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324581",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324581,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1865,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 4,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prisons",
      "Reference": "S4M-02337.1",
      "ID": 2448
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5042,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2291317+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259682",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 259682,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1865,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 4,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prisons",
      "Reference": "S4M-02337.1",
      "ID": 2448
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick",
      "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.619978+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239359",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239359,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1865,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 4,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prisons",
      "Reference": "S4M-02337.1",
      "ID": 2448
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2029,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh",
      "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7334283+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273762",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 273762,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1865,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 4,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prisons",
      "Reference": "S4M-02337.1",
      "ID": 2448
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3758,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6345728+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304136",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 304136,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1865,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 4,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prisons",
      "Reference": "S4M-02337.1",
      "ID": 2448
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4086,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Hume",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8511908+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221748",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221748,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1865,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 4,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prisons",
      "Reference": "S4M-02337.1",
      "ID": 2448
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1773,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9460801+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1882E227P459VM241982",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241982,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1865,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 4,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prisons",
      "Reference": "S4M-02337.1",
      "ID": 2448
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1882,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam",
      "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7887279+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223516",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223516,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1865,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 4,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prisons",
      "Reference": "S4M-02337.1",
      "ID": 2448
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1893,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4618033+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307608",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307608,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1865,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 4,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prisons",
      "Reference": "S4M-02337.1",
      "ID": 2448
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4934,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8369674+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272217",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 272217,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1865,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 4,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prisons",
      "Reference": "S4M-02337.1",
      "ID": 2448
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4956,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Keir",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3200706+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244911",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244911,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1865,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 4,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prisons",
      "Reference": "S4M-02337.1",
      "ID": 2448
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Kelly",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5838841+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315081",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315081,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1865,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 4,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prisons",
      "Reference": "S4M-02337.1",
      "ID": 2448
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3129,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6732479+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247909",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247909,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1865,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 4,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prisons",
      "Reference": "S4M-02337.1",
      "ID": 2448
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann",
      "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4335915+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4016E11P36VM274828",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274828,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1865,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 4,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prisons",
      "Reference": "S4M-02337.1",
      "ID": 2448
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4016,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1235067+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255759",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255759,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1865,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 4,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prisons",
      "Reference": "S4M-02337.1",
      "ID": 2448
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2180,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5556673+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4938E158P374VM277417",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277417,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1865,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 4,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prisons",
      "Reference": "S4M-02337.1",
      "ID": 2448
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4938,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9524706+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2112E250P486VM253053",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253053,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1865,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 4,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prisons",
      "Reference": "S4M-02337.1",
      "ID": 2448
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2112,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny",
      "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7648329+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4939E258P394VM276802",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276802,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1865,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 4,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prisons",
      "Reference": "S4M-02337.1",
      "ID": 2448
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4939,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus",
      "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6817196+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325550",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 325550,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1865,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 4,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prisons",
      "Reference": "S4M-02337.1",
      "ID": 2448
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5074,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon",
      "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5111788+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1828E3P10VM232874",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232874,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1865,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 4,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prisons",
      "Reference": "S4M-02337.1",
      "ID": 2448
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1828,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo",
      "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8803361+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311453",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311453,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1865,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 4,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prisons",
      "Reference": "S4M-02337.1",
      "ID": 2448
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4948,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike",
      "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8794764+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2117E90P107VM230370",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230370,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1865,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 4,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prisons",
      "Reference": "S4M-02337.1",
      "ID": 2448
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2117,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis",
      "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3268056+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267391",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 267391,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1865,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 4,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prisons",
      "Reference": "S4M-02337.1",
      "ID": 2448
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken",
      "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0177917+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313709",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313709,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1865,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 4,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prisons",
      "Reference": "S4M-02337.1",
      "ID": 2448
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4966,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek",
      "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4072955+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3101E102P129VM295049",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295049,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1865,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 4,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prisons",
      "Reference": "S4M-02337.1",
      "ID": 2448
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3101,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala",
      "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1900051+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319049",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319049,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1865,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 4,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prisons",
      "Reference": "S4M-02337.1",
      "ID": 2448
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5034,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny",
      "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6902358+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306405",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306405,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1865,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 4,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prisons",
      "Reference": "S4M-02337.1",
      "ID": 2448
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2159,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Martin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5506821+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5110E252P395VM311180",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311180,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1865,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 4,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prisons",
      "Reference": "S4M-02337.1",
      "ID": 2448
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Mason",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.6091575+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268212",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 268212,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1865,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 4,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prisons",
      "Reference": "S4M-02337.1",
      "ID": 2448
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2133,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2536917+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2876E141P433VM286361",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286361,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1865,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 4,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prisons",
      "Reference": "S4M-02337.1",
      "ID": 2448
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2876,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5754974+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4951E147P368VM260667",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 260667,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1865,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 4,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prisons",
      "Reference": "S4M-02337.1",
      "ID": 2448
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4951,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan",
      "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.087068+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3896E175P307VM263850",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 263850,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1865,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 4,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prisons",
      "Reference": "S4M-02337.1",
      "ID": 2448
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3896,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam",
      "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9132377+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308459",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 308459,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1865,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 4,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prisons",
      "Reference": "S4M-02337.1",
      "ID": 2448
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0568252+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4964E143P375VM279700",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279700,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1865,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 4,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prisons",
      "Reference": "S4M-02337.1",
      "ID": 2448
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4964,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5189042+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279634",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279634,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1865,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 4,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prisons",
      "Reference": "S4M-02337.1",
      "ID": 2448
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3824,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5160677+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2066E22P91VM261077",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261077,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1865,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 4,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prisons",
      "Reference": "S4M-02337.1",
      "ID": 2448
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2066,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.1108084+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299639",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 299639,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1865,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 4,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prisons",
      "Reference": "S4M-02337.1",
      "ID": 2448
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7063924+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306646",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306646,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1865,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 4,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prisons",
      "Reference": "S4M-02337.1",
      "ID": 2448
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina",
      "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5610443+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2487E146P369VM301148",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 301148,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1865,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 4,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prisons",
      "Reference": "S4M-02337.1",
      "ID": 2448
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2487,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0358143+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223696",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223696,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1865,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 4,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prisons",
      "Reference": "S4M-02337.1",
      "ID": 2448
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4698552+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237530",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237530,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1865,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 4,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prisons",
      "Reference": "S4M-02337.1",
      "ID": 2448
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1961,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David",
      "DisplayName": "David McLetchie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2148072+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305462",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 305462,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1865,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 4,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prisons",
      "Reference": "S4M-02337.1",
      "ID": 2448
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2134,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3250575+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320377",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 320377,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1865,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 4,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prisons",
      "Reference": "S4M-02337.1",
      "ID": 2448
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5041,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan",
      "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1637928+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3763E142P397VM316001",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 316001,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1865,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 4,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prisons",
      "Reference": "S4M-02337.1",
      "ID": 2448
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3763,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart",
      "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9415646+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1986E23P197VM236666",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 236666,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1865,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 4,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prisons",
      "Reference": "S4M-02337.1",
      "ID": 2448
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1986,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan",
      "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9348491+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5047E100P130VM289838",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289838,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1865,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 4,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prisons",
      "Reference": "S4M-02337.1",
      "ID": 2448
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5047,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne",
      "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4612211+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234567",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234567,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1865,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 4,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prisons",
      "Reference": "S4M-02337.1",
      "ID": 2448
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1845,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette",
      "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3898644+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313571",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313571,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1865,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 4,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prisons",
      "Reference": "S4M-02337.1",
      "ID": 2448
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3061,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4011352+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1768E19P265VM289248",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289248,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1865,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 4,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prisons",
      "Reference": "S4M-02337.1",
      "ID": 2448
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1768,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4290672+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225271",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225271,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1865,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 4,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prisons",
      "Reference": "S4M-02337.1",
      "ID": 2448
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1894,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Neil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9621893+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3815E98P134VM270932",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270932,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1865,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 4,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prisons",
      "Reference": "S4M-02337.1",
      "ID": 2448
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3815,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Park, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Park",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.835287+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265854",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265854,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1865,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 4,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prisons",
      "Reference": "S4M-02337.1",
      "ID": 2448
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2010,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil",
      "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.463412+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283288",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283288,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1865,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 4,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prisons",
      "Reference": "S4M-02337.1",
      "ID": 2448
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5057,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.6940144+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2853E33P128VM251504",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251504,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1865,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 4,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prisons",
      "Reference": "S4M-02337.1",
      "ID": 2448
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Pentland",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4665463+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317598",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317598,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1865,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 4,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prisons",
      "Reference": "S4M-02337.1",
      "ID": 2448
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5009,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4293343+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254684",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254684,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1865,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 4,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prisons",
      "Reference": "S4M-02337.1",
      "ID": 2448
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3745,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis",
      "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2671927+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1870E225P478VM295690",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295690,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1865,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 4,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prisons",
      "Reference": "S4M-02337.1",
      "ID": 2448
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1870,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona",
      "DisplayName": "Shona Robison",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5316659+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2135E254P450VM235407",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235407,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1865,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 4,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prisons",
      "Reference": "S4M-02337.1",
      "ID": 2448
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2135,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Russell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6694366+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1895E232P431VM257601",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257601,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1865,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 4,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prisons",
      "Reference": "S4M-02337.1",
      "ID": 2448
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1895,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0635411+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228135",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 228135,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1865,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 4,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prisons",
      "Reference": "S4M-02337.1",
      "ID": 2448
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1839,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5858535+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2345E10P55VM291650",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291650,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1865,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 4,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prisons",
      "Reference": "S4M-02337.1",
      "ID": 2448
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2345,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1364071+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311050",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311050,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1865,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 4,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prisons",
      "Reference": "S4M-02337.1",
      "ID": 2448
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2223,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish",
      "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.6032751+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246355",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 246355,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1865,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 4,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prisons",
      "Reference": "S4M-02337.1",
      "ID": 2448
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2182,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1251512+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298130",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298130,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1865,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 4,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prisons",
      "Reference": "S4M-02337.1",
      "ID": 2448
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5079,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew",
      "DisplayName": "Drew Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1395194+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234316",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234316,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1865,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 4,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prisons",
      "Reference": "S4M-02337.1",
      "ID": 2448
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1769,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3720267+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274615",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274615,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1865,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 4,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prisons",
      "Reference": "S4M-02337.1",
      "ID": 2448
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4014,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz",
      "DisplayName": "Liz Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1142757+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269558",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269558,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1865,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 4,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prisons",
      "Reference": "S4M-02337.1",
      "ID": 2448
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2215,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.552811+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317392",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317392,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1865,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 4,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prisons",
      "Reference": "S4M-02337.1",
      "ID": 2448
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3806,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4201529+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326280",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 326280,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1865,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 4,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prisons",
      "Reference": "S4M-02337.1",
      "ID": 2448
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5106,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin",
      "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7516522+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241147",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241147,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1865,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 4,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prisons",
      "Reference": "S4M-02337.1",
      "ID": 2448
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1848,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola",
      "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.4040551+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2098E237P531VM289655",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289655,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1865,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 4,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prisons",
      "Reference": "S4M-02337.1",
      "ID": 2448
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2098,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Swinney",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4533161+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2674E247P401VM247821",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247821,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1865,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 4,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prisons",
      "Reference": "S4M-02337.1",
      "ID": 2448
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2674,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave",
      "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4298759+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5075E234P371VM287422",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 287422,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1865,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 4,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prisons",
      "Reference": "S4M-02337.1",
      "ID": 2448
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5075,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Torrance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8635281+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1793E151P362VM222515",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 222515,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1865,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 4,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prisons",
      "Reference": "S4M-02337.1",
      "ID": 2448
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1793,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean",
      "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1922768+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5078E245P15VM307059",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307059,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1865,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 4,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prisons",
      "Reference": "S4M-02337.1",
      "ID": 2448
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5078,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Walker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5855157+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1841E231P426VM239976",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239976,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1865,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 4,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prisons",
      "Reference": "S4M-02337.1",
      "ID": 2448
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1841,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen",
      "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7674166+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283479",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283479,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1865,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 4,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prisons",
      "Reference": "S4M-02337.1",
      "ID": 2448
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4952,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7096841+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1865E263P500VM231870",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231870,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1865,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 4,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prisons",
      "Reference": "S4M-02337.1",
      "ID": 2448
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1865,
      "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra",
      "DisplayName": "Sandra White",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.619133+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237732",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237732,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1865,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 4,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prisons",
      "Reference": "S4M-02337.1",
      "ID": 2448
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2610,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Wilson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2234466+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309231",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 309231,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1865,
      "AgendaID": 2113,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 107,
      "VoteAgainst": 4,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prisons",
      "Reference": "S4M-02337.1",
      "ID": 2448
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4941,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza",
      "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-15T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3204051+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252227",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252227,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1862,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305.1",
      "ID": 2418
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1926,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian",
      "DisplayName": "Brian Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7198331+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2615E213P388VM258822",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258822,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1862,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305.1",
      "ID": 2418
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2615,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George",
      "DisplayName": "George Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3293907+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319906",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319906,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1862,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305.1",
      "ID": 2418
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4940,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare",
      "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9464965+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249645",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 249645,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1862,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305.1",
      "ID": 2418
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2641,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair",
      "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9437378+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1783E21P273VM227334",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227334,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1862,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305.1",
      "ID": 2418
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1783,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie",
      "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5456788+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2633E97P136VM280332",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280332,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1862,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305.1",
      "ID": 2418
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2633,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire",
      "DisplayName": "Claire Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7561509+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262494",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262494,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1862,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305.1",
      "ID": 2418
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2603,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6043493+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1759E91P115VM229141",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229141,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1862,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305.1",
      "ID": 2418
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia",
      "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.8362644+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270205",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270205,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1862,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305.1",
      "ID": 2418
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3751,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.7938323+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322790",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 322790,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1862,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305.1",
      "ID": 2418
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5109,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco",
      "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.7037073+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5060E86P124VM294725",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 294725,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1862,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305.1",
      "ID": 2418
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5060,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1756514+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242846",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242846,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1862,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305.1",
      "ID": 2418
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1866,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah",
      "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0381211+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235578",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235578,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1862,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305.1",
      "ID": 2418
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1943,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic",
      "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6838237+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302153",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 302153,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1862,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305.1",
      "ID": 2418
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2595,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin",
      "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.2995227+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244506",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244506,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1862,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305.1",
      "ID": 2418
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2103,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith",
      "DisplayName": "Keith Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5577188+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327225",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 327225,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1862,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305.1",
      "ID": 2418
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:46.0266337+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3775E216P435VM276677",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276677,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1862,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305.1",
      "ID": 2418
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6764069+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264340",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264340,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1862,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305.1",
      "ID": 2418
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2673,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick",
      "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1292998+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248813",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248813,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1862,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305.1",
      "ID": 2418
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2678,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson",
      "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6711475+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2123E27P233VM295837",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295837,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1862,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305.1",
      "ID": 2418
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2123,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm",
      "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5379828+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285155",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285155,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1862,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305.1",
      "ID": 2418
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3907,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0688093+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230174",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230174,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1862,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305.1",
      "ID": 2418
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1735,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela",
      "DisplayName": "Angela Constance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.1194138+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243873",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 243873,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1862,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305.1",
      "ID": 2418
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1932,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce",
      "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3235804+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1863E238P523VM255386",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255386,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1862,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305.1",
      "ID": 2418
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1863,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna",
      "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5290923+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323832",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 323832,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1862,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305.1",
      "ID": 2418
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4976,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth",
      "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9739711+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5107E223P379VM291372",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291372,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1862,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305.1",
      "ID": 2418
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5107,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1164723+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3743E222P391VM265326",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265326,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1862,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305.1",
      "ID": 2418
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3743,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel",
      "DisplayName": "Nigel Don",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4343398+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3771E149P417VM261748",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261748,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1862,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305.1",
      "ID": 2418
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3771,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob",
      "DisplayName": "Bob Doris",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3711149+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2826E262P384VM282097",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 282097,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1862,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305.1",
      "ID": 2418
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2826,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Dornan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1755401+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3812E94P117VM297876",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 297876,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1862,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305.1",
      "ID": 2418
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3812,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia",
      "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1287835+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231898",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231898,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1862,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305.1",
      "ID": 2418
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1778,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen",
      "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6204987+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4955E240P389VM285968",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285968,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1862,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305.1",
      "ID": 2418
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4955,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3523008+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219351",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 219351,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1862,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305.1",
      "ID": 2418
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1742,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle",
      "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.2948553+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238605",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 238605,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1862,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305.1",
      "ID": 2418
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1994,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus",
      "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4613169+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225451",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225451,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1862,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305.1",
      "ID": 2418
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1814,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda",
      "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9753047+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321670",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 321670,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1862,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305.1",
      "ID": 2418
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Fee",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4460598+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292926",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 292926,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1862,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305.1",
      "ID": 2418
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia",
      "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5641635+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1892E12P64VM226918",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 226918,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1862,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305.1",
      "ID": 2418
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2523966+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5054E95P118VM312669",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 312669,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1862,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305.1",
      "ID": 2418
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5054,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1382639+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4947E152P361VM257174",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257174,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1862,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305.1",
      "ID": 2418
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4947,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Finnie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.8264972+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271324",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271324,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1862,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305.1",
      "ID": 2418
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3901,
      "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe",
      "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0705982+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278544",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 278544,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1862,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305.1",
      "ID": 2418
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2394,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo",
      "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2234724+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2110E220P414VM286741",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286741,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1862,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305.1",
      "ID": 2418
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth",
      "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5987061+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250452",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250452,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1862,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305.1",
      "ID": 2418
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2675,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob",
      "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1901574+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1741E10P50VM220764",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220764,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1862,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305.1",
      "ID": 2418
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1741,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel",
      "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6560236+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220294",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220294,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1862,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305.1",
      "ID": 2418
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1756,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine",
      "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6351192+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1860E104P150VM251727",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251727,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1862,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305.1",
      "ID": 2418
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1860,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda",
      "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4861168+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2033E20P141VM266230",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 266230,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1862,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305.1",
      "ID": 2418
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2033,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain",
      "DisplayName": "Iain Gray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.7318573+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324573",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324573,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1862,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305.1",
      "ID": 2418
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5042,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.228806+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259915",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 259915,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1862,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305.1",
      "ID": 2418
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick",
      "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.635524+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239292",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239292,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1862,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305.1",
      "ID": 2418
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2029,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh",
      "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.730515+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273811",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 273811,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1862,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305.1",
      "ID": 2418
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3758,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.63668+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304176",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 304176,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1862,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305.1",
      "ID": 2418
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4086,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Hume",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8531301+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221775",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221775,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1862,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305.1",
      "ID": 2418
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1773,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9472863+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1882E227P459VM242008",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242008,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1862,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305.1",
      "ID": 2418
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1882,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam",
      "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7898565+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223736",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223736,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1862,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305.1",
      "ID": 2418
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1893,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4715591+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4934E77P103VM305250",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 305250,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1862,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305.1",
      "ID": 2418
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4934,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3158293+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272191",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 272191,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1862,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305.1",
      "ID": 2418
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4956,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Keir",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.1154817+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244855",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244855,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1862,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305.1",
      "ID": 2418
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Kelly",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5815143+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315026",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315026,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1862,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305.1",
      "ID": 2418
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3129,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6708855+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247976",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247976,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1862,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305.1",
      "ID": 2418
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann",
      "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4364246+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4016E11P36VM274762",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274762,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1862,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305.1",
      "ID": 2418
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4016,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1206173+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255826",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255826,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1862,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305.1",
      "ID": 2418
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2180,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5587173+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4938E158P374VM277483",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277483,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1862,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305.1",
      "ID": 2418
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4938,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9553072+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2112E250P486VM252986",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252986,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1862,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305.1",
      "ID": 2418
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2112,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny",
      "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7617859+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4939E258P394VM277188",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277188,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1862,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305.1",
      "ID": 2418
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4939,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus",
      "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.7049666+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325558",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 325558,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1862,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305.1",
      "ID": 2418
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5074,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon",
      "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5115244+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1828E3P10VM232384",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232384,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1862,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305.1",
      "ID": 2418
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1828,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo",
      "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8525245+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4948E153P363VM310996",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 310996,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1862,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305.1",
      "ID": 2418
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4948,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike",
      "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.6009714+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2117E90P107VM230448",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230448,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1862,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305.1",
      "ID": 2418
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2117,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis",
      "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3302636+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267241",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 267241,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1862,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305.1",
      "ID": 2418
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken",
      "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0109183+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4966E214P378VM314123",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 314123,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1862,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305.1",
      "ID": 2418
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4966,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek",
      "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.430754+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3101E102P129VM295506",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295506,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1862,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305.1",
      "ID": 2418
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3101,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala",
      "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5150707+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5034E88P114VM318920",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 318920,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1862,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305.1",
      "ID": 2418
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5034,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny",
      "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6794203+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306461",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306461,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1862,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305.1",
      "ID": 2418
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2159,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Martin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5530754+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5110E252P395VM311234",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311234,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1862,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305.1",
      "ID": 2418
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Mason",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8677846+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268363",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 268363,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1862,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305.1",
      "ID": 2418
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2133,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2638967+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2876E141P433VM286055",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286055,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1862,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305.1",
      "ID": 2418
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2876,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3560543+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4951E147P368VM260693",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 260693,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1862,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305.1",
      "ID": 2418
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4951,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan",
      "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.0882+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3896E175P307VM264082",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264082,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1862,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305.1",
      "ID": 2418
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3896,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam",
      "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9234339+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308405",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 308405,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1862,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305.1",
      "ID": 2418
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0545214+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4964E143P375VM279321",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279321,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1862,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305.1",
      "ID": 2418
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4964,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.4971319+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279993",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279993,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1862,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305.1",
      "ID": 2418
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3824,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5316702+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2066E22P91VM261753",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261753,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1862,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305.1",
      "ID": 2418
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2066,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3713392+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299787",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 299787,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1862,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305.1",
      "ID": 2418
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7225724+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306591",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306591,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1862,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305.1",
      "ID": 2418
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina",
      "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5586578+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2487E146P369VM301204",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 301204,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1862,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305.1",
      "ID": 2418
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2487,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.2517598+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223669",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223669,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1862,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305.1",
      "ID": 2418
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4687242+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237464",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237464,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1862,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305.1",
      "ID": 2418
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1961,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David",
      "DisplayName": "David McLetchie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2117217+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2134E34P201VM297853",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 297853,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1862,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305.1",
      "ID": 2418
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2134,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1278018+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320661",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 320661,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1862,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305.1",
      "ID": 2418
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5041,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan",
      "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1760212+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3763E142P397VM316056",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 316056,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1862,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305.1",
      "ID": 2418
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3763,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart",
      "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.944081+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1986E23P197VM236308",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 236308,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1862,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305.1",
      "ID": 2418
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1986,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan",
      "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9108115+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5047E100P130VM291426",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291426,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1862,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305.1",
      "ID": 2418
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5047,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne",
      "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1188051+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1845E17P40VM235055",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235055,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1862,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305.1",
      "ID": 2418
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1845,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette",
      "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4117319+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313626",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313626,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1862,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305.1",
      "ID": 2418
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3061,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4035021+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1768E19P265VM288575",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 288575,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1862,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305.1",
      "ID": 2418
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1768,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1493165+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225049",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225049,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1862,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305.1",
      "ID": 2418
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1894,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Neil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7423367+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3815E98P134VM270888",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270888,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1862,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305.1",
      "ID": 2418
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3815,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Park, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Park",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8274302+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2010E219P514VM266032",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 266032,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1862,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305.1",
      "ID": 2418
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2010,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil",
      "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4714333+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283519",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283519,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1862,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305.1",
      "ID": 2418
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5057,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7113929+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2853E33P128VM251426",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251426,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1862,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305.1",
      "ID": 2418
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Pentland",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4630825+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317880",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317880,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1862,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305.1",
      "ID": 2418
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5009,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4413838+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254711",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254711,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1862,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305.1",
      "ID": 2418
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3745,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis",
      "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2804541+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1870E225P478VM295634",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295634,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1862,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305.1",
      "ID": 2418
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1870,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona",
      "DisplayName": "Shona Robison",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5292884+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2135E254P450VM234869",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234869,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1862,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305.1",
      "ID": 2418
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2135,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Russell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4032523+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1895E232P431VM257267",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257267,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1862,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305.1",
      "ID": 2418
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1895,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.048749+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228108",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 228108,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1862,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305.1",
      "ID": 2418
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1839,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5847102+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2345E10P55VM291690",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291690,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1862,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305.1",
      "ID": 2418
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2345,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1381118+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2223E176P333VM310683",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 310683,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1862,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305.1",
      "ID": 2418
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2223,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish",
      "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5815562+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246329",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 246329,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1862,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305.1",
      "ID": 2418
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2182,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1240364+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298332",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298332,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1862,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305.1",
      "ID": 2418
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5079,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew",
      "DisplayName": "Drew Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3411875+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234364",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234364,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1862,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305.1",
      "ID": 2418
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1769,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3740901+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4014E14P26VM269949",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269949,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1862,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305.1",
      "ID": 2418
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4014,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz",
      "DisplayName": "Liz Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5747842+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269098",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269098,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1862,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305.1",
      "ID": 2418
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2215,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.3034819+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317184",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317184,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1862,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305.1",
      "ID": 2418
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3806,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.1852992+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326272",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 326272,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1862,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305.1",
      "ID": 2418
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5106,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin",
      "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.751304+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241120",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241120,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1862,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305.1",
      "ID": 2418
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1848,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola",
      "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.4028717+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2098E237P531VM289599",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289599,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1862,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305.1",
      "ID": 2418
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2098,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Swinney",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4509767+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2674E247P401VM247743",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247743,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1862,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305.1",
      "ID": 2418
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2674,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave",
      "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4265007+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5075E234P371VM284861",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 284861,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1862,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305.1",
      "ID": 2418
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5075,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Torrance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0508708+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1793E151P362VM222450",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 222450,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1862,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305.1",
      "ID": 2418
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1793,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean",
      "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1894804+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5078E245P15VM307108",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307108,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1862,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305.1",
      "ID": 2418
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5078,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Walker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.587607+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1841E231P426VM240157",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 240157,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1862,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305.1",
      "ID": 2418
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1841,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen",
      "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7814099+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283413",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283413,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1862,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305.1",
      "ID": 2418
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4952,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.6996409+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1865E263P500VM232324",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232324,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1862,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305.1",
      "ID": 2418
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1865,
      "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra",
      "DisplayName": "Sandra White",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8499056+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237810",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237810,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1862,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305.1",
      "ID": 2418
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2610,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Wilson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2270642+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309379",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 309379,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1862,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 32,
      "VoteAgainst": 86,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305.1",
      "ID": 2418
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4941,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza",
      "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.326766+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252228",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252228,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1863,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305",
      "ID": 2390
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1926,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian",
      "DisplayName": "Brian Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7198743+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2615E213P388VM258823",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258823,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1863,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305",
      "ID": 2390
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2615,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George",
      "DisplayName": "George Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.329431+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319905",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319905,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1863,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305",
      "ID": 2390
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4940,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare",
      "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9464551+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249644",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 249644,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1863,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305",
      "ID": 2390
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2641,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair",
      "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9436974+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1783E21P273VM227335",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227335,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1863,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305",
      "ID": 2390
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1783,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie",
      "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5457197+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2633E97P136VM280333",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280333,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1863,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305",
      "ID": 2390
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2633,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire",
      "DisplayName": "Claire Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7561922+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262495",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262495,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1863,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305",
      "ID": 2390
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2603,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6044078+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1759E91P115VM229746",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229746,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1863,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305",
      "ID": 2390
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia",
      "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0949047+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270204",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270204,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1863,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305",
      "ID": 2390
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3751,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.7937308+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322791",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 322791,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1863,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305",
      "ID": 2390
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5109,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco",
      "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.7037474+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5060E86P124VM294726",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 294726,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1863,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305",
      "ID": 2390
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5060,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1756939+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242847",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242847,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1863,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305",
      "ID": 2390
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1866,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah",
      "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0381679+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235577",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235577,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1863,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305",
      "ID": 2390
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1943,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic",
      "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6837836+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302154",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 302154,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1863,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305",
      "ID": 2390
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2595,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin",
      "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.2995973+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244505",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244505,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1863,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305",
      "ID": 2390
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2103,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith",
      "DisplayName": "Keith Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5576776+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327226",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 327226,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1863,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305",
      "ID": 2390
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:46.0266766+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3775E216P435VM276678",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276678,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1863,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305",
      "ID": 2390
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6764471+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264339",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264339,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1863,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305",
      "ID": 2390
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2673,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick",
      "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.129258+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248812",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248812,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1863,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305",
      "ID": 2390
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2678,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson",
      "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6711071+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2123E27P233VM295836",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295836,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1863,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305",
      "ID": 2390
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2123,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm",
      "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5379426+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285156",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285156,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1863,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305",
      "ID": 2390
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3907,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0688506+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230175",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230175,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1863,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305",
      "ID": 2390
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1735,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela",
      "DisplayName": "Angela Constance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.1194547+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243872",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 243872,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1863,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305",
      "ID": 2390
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1932,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce",
      "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3235209+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254935",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254935,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1863,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305",
      "ID": 2390
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1863,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna",
      "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2901182+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323833",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 323833,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1863,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305",
      "ID": 2390
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4976,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth",
      "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9740503+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5107E223P379VM291371",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291371,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1863,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305",
      "ID": 2390
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5107,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1164305+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3743E222P391VM265327",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265327,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1863,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305",
      "ID": 2390
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3743,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel",
      "DisplayName": "Nigel Don",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4343987+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3771E149P417VM261749",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261749,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1863,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305",
      "ID": 2390
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3771,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob",
      "DisplayName": "Bob Doris",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.371156+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2826E262P384VM282096",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 282096,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1863,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305",
      "ID": 2390
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2826,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Dornan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1754989+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3812E94P117VM297877",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 297877,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1863,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305",
      "ID": 2390
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3812,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia",
      "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1288251+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231598",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231598,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1863,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305",
      "ID": 2390
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1778,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen",
      "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.607504+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4955E240P389VM285967",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285967,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1863,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305",
      "ID": 2390
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4955,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3522598+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219352",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 219352,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1863,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305",
      "ID": 2390
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1742,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle",
      "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.294897+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238604",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 238604,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1863,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305",
      "ID": 2390
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1994,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus",
      "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4612587+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225450",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225450,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1863,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305",
      "ID": 2390
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1814,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda",
      "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9752623+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321669",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 321669,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1863,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305",
      "ID": 2390
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Fee",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4460192+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292925",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 292925,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1863,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305",
      "ID": 2390
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia",
      "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5641234+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1892E12P64VM226919",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 226919,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1863,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305",
      "ID": 2390
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2524376+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5054E95P118VM312670",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 312670,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1863,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305",
      "ID": 2390
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5054,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1383047+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4947E152P361VM257175",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257175,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1863,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305",
      "ID": 2390
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4947,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Finnie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.8265384+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271323",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271323,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1863,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305",
      "ID": 2390
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3901,
      "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe",
      "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.070556+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278543",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 278543,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1863,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305",
      "ID": 2390
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2394,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo",
      "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.223431+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2110E220P414VM286742",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286742,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1863,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305",
      "ID": 2390
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth",
      "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5987457+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250453",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250453,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1863,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305",
      "ID": 2390
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2675,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob",
      "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1901987+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1741E10P50VM220765",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220765,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1863,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305",
      "ID": 2390
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1741,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel",
      "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6560643+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220293",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220293,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1863,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305",
      "ID": 2390
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1756,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine",
      "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6350774+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1860E104P150VM252330",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252330,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1863,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305",
      "ID": 2390
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1860,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda",
      "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7245196+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2033E20P141VM266229",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 266229,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1863,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305",
      "ID": 2390
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2033,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain",
      "DisplayName": "Iain Gray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.7318152+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324572",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324572,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1863,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305",
      "ID": 2390
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5042,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2287476+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259914",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 259914,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1863,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305",
      "ID": 2390
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick",
      "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6354825+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239293",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239293,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1863,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305",
      "ID": 2390
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2029,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh",
      "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.730556+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273810",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 273810,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1863,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305",
      "ID": 2390
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3758,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6366386+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304175",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 304175,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1863,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305",
      "ID": 2390
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4086,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Hume",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8530817+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221774",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221774,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1863,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305",
      "ID": 2390
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1773,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9472413+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1882E227P459VM242007",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242007,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1863,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305",
      "ID": 2390
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1882,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam",
      "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7898152+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223735",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223735,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1863,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305",
      "ID": 2390
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1893,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4715179+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4934E77P103VM305251",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 305251,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1863,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305",
      "ID": 2390
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4934,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3158712+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272192",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 272192,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1863,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305",
      "ID": 2390
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4956,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Keir",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.1155231+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244856",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244856,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1863,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305",
      "ID": 2390
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Kelly",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5815549+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315027",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315027,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1863,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305",
      "ID": 2390
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3129,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6709265+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247975",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247975,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1863,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305",
      "ID": 2390
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann",
      "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4363841+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4016E11P36VM274763",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274763,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1863,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305",
      "ID": 2390
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4016,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1206774+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255825",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255825,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1863,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305",
      "ID": 2390
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2180,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5586772+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4938E158P374VM277482",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277482,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1863,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305",
      "ID": 2390
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4938,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9552476+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2112E250P486VM252987",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252987,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1863,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305",
      "ID": 2390
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2112,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny",
      "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7618263+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4939E258P394VM277187",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277187,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1863,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305",
      "ID": 2390
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4939,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus",
      "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.7049245+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325559",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 325559,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1863,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305",
      "ID": 2390
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5074,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon",
      "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5115656+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1828E3P10VM232835",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232835,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1863,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305",
      "ID": 2390
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1828,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo",
      "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8784162+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4948E153P363VM310997",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 310997,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1863,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305",
      "ID": 2390
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4948,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike",
      "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.6010127+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2117E90P107VM230447",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230447,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1863,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305",
      "ID": 2390
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2117,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis",
      "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3302226+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267242",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 267242,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1863,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305",
      "ID": 2390
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken",
      "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0109639+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4966E214P378VM314122",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 314122,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1863,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305",
      "ID": 2390
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4966,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek",
      "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.430713+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3101E102P129VM295505",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295505,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1863,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305",
      "ID": 2390
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3101,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala",
      "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5150307+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5034E88P114VM318919",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 318919,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1863,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305",
      "ID": 2390
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5034,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny",
      "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.679379+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306460",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306460,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1863,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305",
      "ID": 2390
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2159,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Martin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5530342+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5110E252P395VM311233",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311233,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1863,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305",
      "ID": 2390
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Mason",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8677221+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268362",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 268362,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1863,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305",
      "ID": 2390
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2133,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2638364+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2876E141P433VM286056",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286056,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1863,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305",
      "ID": 2390
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2876,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3560951+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4951E147P368VM260692",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 260692,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1863,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305",
      "ID": 2390
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4951,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan",
      "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.088159+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3896E175P307VM264081",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264081,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1863,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305",
      "ID": 2390
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3896,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam",
      "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9233926+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308406",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 308406,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1863,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305",
      "ID": 2390
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0545621+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4964E143P375VM279322",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279322,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1863,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305",
      "ID": 2390
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4964,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.4971728+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279992",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279992,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1863,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305",
      "ID": 2390
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3824,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5316291+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2066E22P91VM261752",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261752,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1863,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305",
      "ID": 2390
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2066,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3712971+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299786",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 299786,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1863,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305",
      "ID": 2390
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7225313+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306592",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306592,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1863,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305",
      "ID": 2390
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina",
      "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5586989+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2487E146P369VM301203",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 301203,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1863,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305",
      "ID": 2390
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2487,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.2517179+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223670",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223670,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1863,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305",
      "ID": 2390
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.468764+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237465",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237465,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1863,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305",
      "ID": 2390
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1961,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David",
      "DisplayName": "David McLetchie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2117629+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2134E34P201VM297854",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 297854,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1863,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305",
      "ID": 2390
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2134,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1278589+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320662",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 320662,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1863,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305",
      "ID": 2390
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5041,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan",
      "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1760618+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3763E142P397VM316055",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 316055,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1863,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305",
      "ID": 2390
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3763,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart",
      "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9440166+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1986E23P197VM236309",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 236309,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1863,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305",
      "ID": 2390
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1986,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan",
      "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9108529+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5047E100P130VM291425",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291425,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1863,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305",
      "ID": 2390
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5047,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne",
      "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1187639+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234606",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234606,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1863,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305",
      "ID": 2390
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1845,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette",
      "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3915656+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313625",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313625,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1863,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305",
      "ID": 2390
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3061,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4034605+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1768E19P265VM288576",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 288576,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1863,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305",
      "ID": 2390
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1768,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1493587+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225050",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225050,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1863,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305",
      "ID": 2390
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1894,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Neil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7423783+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3815E98P134VM270889",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270889,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1863,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305",
      "ID": 2390
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3815,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Park, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Park",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8275499+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265892",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265892,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1863,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305",
      "ID": 2390
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2010,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil",
      "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4650594+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283518",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283518,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1863,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305",
      "ID": 2390
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5057,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7113516+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2853E33P128VM251427",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251427,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1863,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305",
      "ID": 2390
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Pentland",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4631239+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317881",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317881,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1863,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305",
      "ID": 2390
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5009,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4414416+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254710",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254710,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1863,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305",
      "ID": 2390
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3745,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis",
      "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2804129+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1870E225P478VM295635",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295635,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1863,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305",
      "ID": 2390
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1870,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona",
      "DisplayName": "Shona Robison",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5293297+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2135E254P450VM234870",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234870,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1863,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305",
      "ID": 2390
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2135,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Russell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4032933+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1895E232P431VM257407",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257407,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1863,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305",
      "ID": 2390
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1895,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0548682+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228109",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 228109,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1863,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305",
      "ID": 2390
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1839,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5847534+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2345E10P55VM291689",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291689,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1863,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305",
      "ID": 2390
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2345,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1380714+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2223E176P333VM310684",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 310684,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1863,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305",
      "ID": 2390
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2223,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish",
      "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5815993+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246330",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 246330,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1863,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305",
      "ID": 2390
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2182,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1240774+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298331",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298331,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1863,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305",
      "ID": 2390
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5079,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew",
      "DisplayName": "Drew Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.341146+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234363",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234363,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1863,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305",
      "ID": 2390
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1769,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3740488+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4014E14P26VM269950",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269950,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1863,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305",
      "ID": 2390
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4014,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz",
      "DisplayName": "Liz Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5748905+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269099",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269099,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1863,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305",
      "ID": 2390
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2215,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.3035231+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317185",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317185,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1863,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305",
      "ID": 2390
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3806,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.1853408+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326271",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 326271,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1863,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305",
      "ID": 2390
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5106,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin",
      "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7512626+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241121",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241121,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1863,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305",
      "ID": 2390
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1848,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola",
      "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.4029131+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2098E237P531VM289600",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289600,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1863,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305",
      "ID": 2390
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2098,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Swinney",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4510168+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2674E247P401VM247744",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247744,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1863,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305",
      "ID": 2390
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2674,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave",
      "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4265595+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5075E234P371VM284862",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 284862,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1863,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305",
      "ID": 2390
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5075,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Torrance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0509288+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1793E151P362VM222451",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 222451,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1863,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305",
      "ID": 2390
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1793,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean",
      "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1895218+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5078E245P15VM307107",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307107,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1863,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305",
      "ID": 2390
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5078,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Walker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5875665+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1841E231P426VM240156",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 240156,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1863,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305",
      "ID": 2390
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1841,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen",
      "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.781368+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283414",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283414,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1863,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305",
      "ID": 2390
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4952,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.6996817+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1865E263P500VM232323",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232323,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1863,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305",
      "ID": 2390
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1865,
      "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra",
      "DisplayName": "Sandra White",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8498637+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237809",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237809,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1863,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305",
      "ID": 2390
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2610,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Wilson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2270229+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309378",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 309378,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1863,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-02305",
      "ID": 2390
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4941,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza",
      "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3267251+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252645",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252645,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1860,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246.1",
      "ID": 2339
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1926,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian",
      "DisplayName": "Brian Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7383782+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2615E213P388VM258840",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258840,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1860,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246.1",
      "ID": 2339
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2615,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George",
      "DisplayName": "George Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3301636+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319888",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319888,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1860,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246.1",
      "ID": 2339
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4940,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare",
      "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9457153+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249593",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 249593,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1860,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246.1",
      "ID": 2339
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2641,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair",
      "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9335171+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1783E21P273VM227750",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227750,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1860,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246.1",
      "ID": 2339
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1783,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie",
      "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5640377+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2633E97P136VM280753",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280753,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1860,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246.1",
      "ID": 2339
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2633,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire",
      "DisplayName": "Claire Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7809669+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262482",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262482,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1860,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246.1",
      "ID": 2339
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2603,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6038395+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1759E91P115VM229731",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229731,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1860,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246.1",
      "ID": 2339
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia",
      "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0942295+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270187",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270187,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1860,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246.1",
      "ID": 2339
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3751,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5852965+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322715",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 322715,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1860,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246.1",
      "ID": 2339
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5109,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco",
      "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.7005543+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5060E86P124VM294713",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 294713,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1860,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246.1",
      "ID": 2339
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5060,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1751179+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242864",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242864,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1860,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246.1",
      "ID": 2339
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1866,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah",
      "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0388707+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235560",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235560,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1860,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246.1",
      "ID": 2339
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1943,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic",
      "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6830689+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302139",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 302139,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1860,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246.1",
      "ID": 2339
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2595,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin",
      "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.2987793+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244518",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244518,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1860,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246.1",
      "ID": 2339
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2103,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith",
      "DisplayName": "Keith Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5582369+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327243",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 327243,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1860,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246.1",
      "ID": 2339
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:46.02743+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3775E216P435VM276665",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276665,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1860,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246.1",
      "ID": 2339
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6759+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264352",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264352,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1860,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246.1",
      "ID": 2339
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2673,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick",
      "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1298086+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248786",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248786,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1860,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246.1",
      "ID": 2339
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2678,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson",
      "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6700031+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2123E27P233VM295819",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295819,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1860,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246.1",
      "ID": 2339
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2123,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm",
      "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.537213+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285143",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285143,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1860,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246.1",
      "ID": 2339
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3907,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0682998+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230158",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230158,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1860,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246.1",
      "ID": 2339
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1735,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela",
      "DisplayName": "Angela Constance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.1187354+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243855",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 243855,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1860,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246.1",
      "ID": 2339
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1932,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce",
      "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.322808+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254949",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254949,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1860,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246.1",
      "ID": 2339
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1863,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna",
      "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2907148+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323878",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 323878,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1860,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246.1",
      "ID": 2339
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4976,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth",
      "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9763009+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5107E223P379VM291345",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291345,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1860,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246.1",
      "ID": 2339
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5107,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1150601+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3743E222P391VM265314",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265314,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1860,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246.1",
      "ID": 2339
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3743,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel",
      "DisplayName": "Nigel Don",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4338243+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262239",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262239,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1860,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246.1",
      "ID": 2339
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3771,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob",
      "DisplayName": "Bob Doris",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.5929265+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281988",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 281988,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1860,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246.1",
      "ID": 2339
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2826,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Dornan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1663705+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3812E94P117VM297984",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 297984,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1860,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246.1",
      "ID": 2339
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3812,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia",
      "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1333108+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231613",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231613,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1860,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246.1",
      "ID": 2339
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1778,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen",
      "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6081521+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4955E240P389VM285950",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285950,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1860,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246.1",
      "ID": 2339
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4955,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3515236+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219377",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 219377,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1860,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246.1",
      "ID": 2339
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1742,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle",
      "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.2960207+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238587",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 238587,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1860,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246.1",
      "ID": 2339
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1994,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus",
      "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4605485+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225246",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225246,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1860,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246.1",
      "ID": 2339
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1814,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda",
      "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9611135+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321744",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 321744,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1860,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246.1",
      "ID": 2339
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Fee",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4495322+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292858",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 292858,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1860,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246.1",
      "ID": 2339
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia",
      "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5611255+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1892E12P64VM226947",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 226947,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1860,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246.1",
      "ID": 2339
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.253841+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5054E95P118VM312655",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 312655,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1860,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246.1",
      "ID": 2339
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5054,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1376656+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4947E152P361VM257227",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257227,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1860,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246.1",
      "ID": 2339
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4947,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Finnie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.047044+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271306",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271306,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1860,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246.1",
      "ID": 2339
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3901,
      "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe",
      "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0697677+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278433",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 278433,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1860,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246.1",
      "ID": 2339
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2394,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo",
      "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2185867+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2110E220P414VM286727",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286727,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1860,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246.1",
      "ID": 2339
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth",
      "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.598124+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250505",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250505,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1860,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246.1",
      "ID": 2339
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2675,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob",
      "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1924384+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1741E10P50VM220971",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220971,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1860,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246.1",
      "ID": 2339
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1741,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel",
      "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6695424+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220266",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220266,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1860,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246.1",
      "ID": 2339
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1756,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine",
      "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6310103+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1860E104P150VM251854",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251854,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1860,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246.1",
      "ID": 2339
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1860,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda",
      "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4920053+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2033E20P141VM266120",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 266120,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1860,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246.1",
      "ID": 2339
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2033,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain",
      "DisplayName": "Iain Gray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4751924+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324555",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324555,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1860,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246.1",
      "ID": 2339
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5042,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2280403+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259733",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 259733,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1860,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246.1",
      "ID": 2339
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick",
      "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6221829+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239310",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239310,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1860,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246.1",
      "ID": 2339
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2029,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh",
      "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7313011+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273823",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 273823,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1860,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246.1",
      "ID": 2339
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3758,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6372069+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304190",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 304190,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1860,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246.1",
      "ID": 2339
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4086,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Hume",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8538638+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221724",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221724,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1860,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246.1",
      "ID": 2339
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1773,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9450551+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1882E227P459VM241956",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241956,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1860,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246.1",
      "ID": 2339
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1882,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam",
      "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7876117+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223719",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223719,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1860,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246.1",
      "ID": 2339
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1893,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4708441+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307568",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307568,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1860,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246.1",
      "ID": 2339
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4934,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8351338+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272242",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 272242,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1860,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246.1",
      "ID": 2339
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4956,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Keir",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3211628+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244872",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244872,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1860,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246.1",
      "ID": 2339
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Kelly",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5822425+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315044",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315044,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1860,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246.1",
      "ID": 2339
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3129,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6716703+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247958",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247958,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1860,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246.1",
      "ID": 2339
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann",
      "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4356553+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4016E11P36VM274780",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274780,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1860,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246.1",
      "ID": 2339
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4016,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1214237+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255808",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255808,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1860,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246.1",
      "ID": 2339
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2180,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5579557+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4938E158P374VM277465",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277465,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1860,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246.1",
      "ID": 2339
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4938,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9545342+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2112E250P486VM253004",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253004,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1860,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246.1",
      "ID": 2339
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2112,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny",
      "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7627105+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4939E258P394VM276850",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276850,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1860,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246.1",
      "ID": 2339
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4939,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus",
      "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6837888+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325576",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 325576,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1860,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246.1",
      "ID": 2339
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5074,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon",
      "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5122773+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1828E3P10VM232820",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232820,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1860,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246.1",
      "ID": 2339
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1828,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo",
      "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8776423+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311414",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311414,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1860,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246.1",
      "ID": 2339
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4948,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike",
      "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8777572+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2117E90P107VM230420",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230420,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1860,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246.1",
      "ID": 2339
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2117,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis",
      "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3290559+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267351",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 267351,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1860,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246.1",
      "ID": 2339
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken",
      "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0157043+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313747",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313747,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1860,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246.1",
      "ID": 2339
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4966,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek",
      "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4089197+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3101E102P129VM295090",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295090,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1860,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246.1",
      "ID": 2339
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3101,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala",
      "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1917703+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5034E88P114VM318993",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 318993,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1860,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246.1",
      "ID": 2339
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5034,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny",
      "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6878296+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306443",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306443,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1860,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246.1",
      "ID": 2339
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2159,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Martin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5522914+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5110E252P395VM310861",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 310861,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1860,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246.1",
      "ID": 2339
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Mason",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5947977+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268252",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 268252,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1860,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246.1",
      "ID": 2339
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2133,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2554263+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2876E141P433VM286320",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286320,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1860,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246.1",
      "ID": 2339
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2876,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5737382+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4951E147P368VM258629",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258629,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1860,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246.1",
      "ID": 2339
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4951,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan",
      "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3157416+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3896E175P307VM263899",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 263899,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1860,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246.1",
      "ID": 2339
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3896,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam",
      "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9155896+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308471",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 308471,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1860,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246.1",
      "ID": 2339
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0573432+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4964E143P375VM279657",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279657,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1860,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246.1",
      "ID": 2339
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4964,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5170454+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3824E84P113VM280005",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280005,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1860,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246.1",
      "ID": 2339
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3824,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5322865+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2066E22P91VM261116",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261116,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1860,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246.1",
      "ID": 2339
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2066,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.1125084+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299679",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 299679,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1860,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246.1",
      "ID": 2339
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7080836+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306658",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306658,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1860,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246.1",
      "ID": 2339
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina",
      "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5616504+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2487E146P369VM301136",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 301136,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1860,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246.1",
      "ID": 2339
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2487,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0351776+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223874",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223874,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1860,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246.1",
      "ID": 2339
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4774841+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237482",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237482,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1860,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246.1",
      "ID": 2339
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1961,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David",
      "DisplayName": "David McLetchie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2124903+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305424",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 305424,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1860,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246.1",
      "ID": 2339
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2134,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3234312+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320433",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 320433,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1860,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246.1",
      "ID": 2339
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5041,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan",
      "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1661987+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3763E142P397VM316038",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 316038,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1860,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246.1",
      "ID": 2339
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3763,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart",
      "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9431715+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1986E23P197VM236296",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 236296,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1860,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246.1",
      "ID": 2339
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1986,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan",
      "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9102909+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5047E100P130VM291438",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291438,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1860,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246.1",
      "ID": 2339
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5047,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne",
      "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1193235+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234620",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234620,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1860,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246.1",
      "ID": 2339
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1845,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette",
      "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3921705+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313608",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313608,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1860,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246.1",
      "ID": 2339
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3061,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4027196+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1768E19P265VM289260",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289260,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1860,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246.1",
      "ID": 2339
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1768,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4295814+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225066",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225066,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1860,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246.1",
      "ID": 2339
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1894,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Neil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7430439+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3815E98P134VM270901",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270901,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1860,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246.1",
      "ID": 2339
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3815,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Park, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Park",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8283198+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265906",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265906,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1860,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246.1",
      "ID": 2339
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2010,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil",
      "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4656658+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283336",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283336,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1860,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246.1",
      "ID": 2339
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5057,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.6963172+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2853E33P128VM251453",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251453,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1860,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246.1",
      "ID": 2339
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Pentland",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4643043+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317653",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317653,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1860,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246.1",
      "ID": 2339
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5009,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4316696+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254658",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254658,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1860,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246.1",
      "ID": 2339
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3745,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis",
      "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2660671+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1870E225P478VM295702",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295702,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1860,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246.1",
      "ID": 2339
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1870,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona",
      "DisplayName": "Shona Robison",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5321718+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2135E254P450VM234897",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234897,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1860,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246.1",
      "ID": 2339
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2135,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Russell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.40447+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1895E232P431VM257394",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257394,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1860,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246.1",
      "ID": 2339
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1895,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0543088+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228159",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 228159,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1860,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246.1",
      "ID": 2339
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1839,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5868796+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2345E10P55VM292013",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 292013,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1860,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246.1",
      "ID": 2339
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2345,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1521195+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2223E176P333VM310701",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 310701,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1860,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246.1",
      "ID": 2339
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2223,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish",
      "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5823172+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246380",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 246380,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1860,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246.1",
      "ID": 2339
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2182,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1262456+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298345",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298345,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1860,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246.1",
      "ID": 2339
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5079,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew",
      "DisplayName": "Drew Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3417415+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234379",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234379,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1860,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246.1",
      "ID": 2339
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1769,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3747277+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274567",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274567,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1860,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246.1",
      "ID": 2339
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4014,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz",
      "DisplayName": "Liz Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1121883+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269518",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269518,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1860,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246.1",
      "ID": 2339
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2215,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.551085+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317202",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317202,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1860,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246.1",
      "ID": 2339
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3806,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4078125+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326254",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 326254,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1860,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246.1",
      "ID": 2339
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5106,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin",
      "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7505071+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241172",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241172,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1860,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246.1",
      "ID": 2339
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1848,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola",
      "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.4051437+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2098E237P531VM289617",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289617,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1860,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246.1",
      "ID": 2339
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2098,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Swinney",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4517204+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2674E247P401VM247771",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247771,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1860,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246.1",
      "ID": 2339
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2674,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave",
      "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4277395+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5075E234P371VM284888",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 284888,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1860,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246.1",
      "ID": 2339
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5075,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Torrance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0520203+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1793E151P362VM222467",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 222467,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1860,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246.1",
      "ID": 2339
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1793,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean",
      "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1902192+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5078E245P15VM307047",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307047,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1860,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246.1",
      "ID": 2339
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5078,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Walker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5850078+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1841E231P426VM239951",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239951,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1860,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246.1",
      "ID": 2339
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1841,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen",
      "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7663517+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283431",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283431,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1860,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246.1",
      "ID": 2339
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4952,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7075154+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1865E263P500VM232214",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232214,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1860,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246.1",
      "ID": 2339
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1865,
      "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra",
      "DisplayName": "Sandra White",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8450504+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237782",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237782,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1860,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246.1",
      "ID": 2339
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2610,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Wilson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.225876+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309270",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 309270,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1860,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246.1",
      "ID": 2339
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4941,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza",
      "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3220903+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252646",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252646,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1861,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246",
      "ID": 2320
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1926,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian",
      "DisplayName": "Brian Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7384192+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2615E213P388VM258841",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258841,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1861,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246",
      "ID": 2320
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2615,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George",
      "DisplayName": "George Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.330204+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319887",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319887,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1861,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246",
      "ID": 2320
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4940,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare",
      "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9456743+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249592",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 249592,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1861,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246",
      "ID": 2320
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2641,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair",
      "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9334767+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1783E21P273VM227751",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227751,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1861,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246",
      "ID": 2320
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1783,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie",
      "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5640786+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2633E97P136VM280754",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280754,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1861,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246",
      "ID": 2320
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2633,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire",
      "DisplayName": "Claire Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7810072+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262704",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262704,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1861,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246",
      "ID": 2320
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2603,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6132898+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1759E91P115VM229732",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229732,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1861,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246",
      "ID": 2320
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia",
      "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0942698+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270186",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270186,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1861,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246",
      "ID": 2320
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3751,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5852561+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322716",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 322716,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1861,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246",
      "ID": 2320
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5109,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco",
      "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.7005948+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5060E86P124VM294779",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 294779,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1861,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246",
      "ID": 2320
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5060,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1779607+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242865",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242865,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1861,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246",
      "ID": 2320
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1866,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah",
      "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0389102+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235559",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235559,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1861,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246",
      "ID": 2320
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1943,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic",
      "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.683027+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302141",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 302141,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1861,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246",
      "ID": 2320
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2595,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin",
      "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.298883+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244299",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244299,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1861,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246",
      "ID": 2320
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2103,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith",
      "DisplayName": "Keith Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5486777+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327244",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 327244,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1861,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246",
      "ID": 2320
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:46.0274709+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277043",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277043,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1861,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246",
      "ID": 2320
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6986182+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264286",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264286,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1861,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246",
      "ID": 2320
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2673,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick",
      "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1267492+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248785",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248785,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1861,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246",
      "ID": 2320
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2678,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson",
      "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6699629+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2123E27P233VM295818",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295818,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1861,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246",
      "ID": 2320
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2123,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm",
      "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.537173+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285208",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285208,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1861,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246",
      "ID": 2320
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3907,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3129082+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230159",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230159,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1861,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246",
      "ID": 2320
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1735,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela",
      "DisplayName": "Angela Constance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.1187761+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243854",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 243854,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1861,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246",
      "ID": 2320
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1932,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce",
      "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3227681+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254948",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254948,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1861,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246",
      "ID": 2320
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1863,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna",
      "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.290674+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323879",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 323879,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1861,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246",
      "ID": 2320
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4976,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth",
      "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9763458+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5107E223P379VM291344",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291344,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1861,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246",
      "ID": 2320
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5107,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1150187+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3743E222P391VM265380",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265380,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1861,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246",
      "ID": 2320
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3743,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel",
      "DisplayName": "Nigel Don",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4366807+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262240",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262240,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1861,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246",
      "ID": 2320
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3771,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob",
      "DisplayName": "Bob Doris",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.5929669+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281987",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 281987,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1861,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246",
      "ID": 2320
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2826,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Dornan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1663303+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3812E94P117VM297985",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 297985,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1861,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246",
      "ID": 2320
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3812,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia",
      "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1333513+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231612",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231612,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1861,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246",
      "ID": 2320
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1778,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen",
      "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6081123+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4955E240P389VM285949",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285949,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1861,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246",
      "ID": 2320
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4955,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3514833+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219378",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 219378,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1861,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246",
      "ID": 2320
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1742,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle",
      "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.2960634+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238586",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 238586,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1861,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246",
      "ID": 2320
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1994,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus",
      "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4605081+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225245",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225245,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1861,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246",
      "ID": 2320
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1814,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda",
      "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9610669+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321743",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 321743,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1861,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246",
      "ID": 2320
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Fee",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4494921+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292857",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 292857,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1861,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246",
      "ID": 2320
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia",
      "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5610857+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1892E12P64VM226948",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 226948,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1861,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246",
      "ID": 2320
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2538826+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5054E95P118VM312657",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 312657,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1861,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246",
      "ID": 2320
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5054,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1377482+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4947E152P361VM257228",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257228,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1861,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246",
      "ID": 2320
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4947,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Finnie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0470849+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271305",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271305,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1861,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246",
      "ID": 2320
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3901,
      "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe",
      "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0697253+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278432",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 278432,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1861,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246",
      "ID": 2320
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2394,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo",
      "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2185457+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2110E220P414VM286729",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286729,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1861,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246",
      "ID": 2320
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth",
      "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5982036+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250506",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250506,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1861,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246",
      "ID": 2320
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2675,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob",
      "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1924791+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1741E10P50VM220972",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220972,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1861,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246",
      "ID": 2320
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1741,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel",
      "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6695836+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220265",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220265,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1861,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246",
      "ID": 2320
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1756,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine",
      "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6309687+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1860E104P150VM251855",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251855,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1861,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246",
      "ID": 2320
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1860,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda",
      "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4920456+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2033E20P141VM266119",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 266119,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1861,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246",
      "ID": 2320
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2033,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain",
      "DisplayName": "Iain Gray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4751518+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324554",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324554,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1861,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246",
      "ID": 2320
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5042,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2279998+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259732",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 259732,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1861,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246",
      "ID": 2320
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick",
      "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6221413+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239311",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239311,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1861,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246",
      "ID": 2320
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2029,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh",
      "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7313417+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273757",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 273757,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1861,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246",
      "ID": 2320
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3758,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6343718+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304188",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 304188,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1861,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246",
      "ID": 2320
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4086,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Hume",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8537608+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221723",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221723,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1861,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246",
      "ID": 2320
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1773,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9450156+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1882E227P459VM241955",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241955,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1861,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246",
      "ID": 2320
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1882,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam",
      "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7875692+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223718",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223718,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1861,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246",
      "ID": 2320
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1893,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4708026+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307569",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307569,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1861,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246",
      "ID": 2320
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4934,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8351744+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272243",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 272243,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1861,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246",
      "ID": 2320
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4956,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Keir",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3212037+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244873",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244873,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1861,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246",
      "ID": 2320
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Kelly",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5822827+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315045",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315045,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1861,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246",
      "ID": 2320
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3129,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.671712+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247957",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247957,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1861,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246",
      "ID": 2320
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann",
      "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4356154+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4016E11P36VM274781",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274781,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1861,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246",
      "ID": 2320
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4016,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.121465+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255807",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255807,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1861,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246",
      "ID": 2320
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2180,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5579164+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4938E158P374VM277464",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277464,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1861,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246",
      "ID": 2320
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4938,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9544936+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2112E250P486VM253005",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253005,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1861,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246",
      "ID": 2320
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2112,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny",
      "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7627516+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4939E258P394VM276849",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276849,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1861,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246",
      "ID": 2320
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4939,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus",
      "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6837489+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325577",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 325577,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1861,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246",
      "ID": 2320
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5074,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon",
      "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5123173+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1828E3P10VM232821",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232821,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1861,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246",
      "ID": 2320
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1828,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo",
      "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8776826+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311415",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311415,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1861,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246",
      "ID": 2320
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4948,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike",
      "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8777986+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2117E90P107VM230419",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230419,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1861,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246",
      "ID": 2320
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2117,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis",
      "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3290126+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267352",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 267352,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1861,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246",
      "ID": 2320
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken",
      "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0157447+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313746",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313746,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1861,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246",
      "ID": 2320
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4966,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek",
      "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4088785+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3101E102P129VM295089",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295089,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1861,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246",
      "ID": 2320
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3101,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala",
      "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1917291+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5034E88P114VM318992",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 318992,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1861,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246",
      "ID": 2320
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5034,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny",
      "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6877883+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306442",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306442,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1861,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246",
      "ID": 2320
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2159,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Martin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5522514+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5110E252P395VM310860",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 310860,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1861,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246",
      "ID": 2320
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Mason",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5947568+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268251",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 268251,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1861,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246",
      "ID": 2320
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2133,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2553856+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2876E141P433VM286321",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286321,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1861,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246",
      "ID": 2320
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2876,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5737877+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4951E147P368VM258628",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258628,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1861,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246",
      "ID": 2320
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4951,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan",
      "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3156734+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3896E175P307VM263898",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 263898,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1861,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246",
      "ID": 2320
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3896,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam",
      "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9155491+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308472",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 308472,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1861,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246",
      "ID": 2320
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0573841+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4964E143P375VM279658",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279658,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1861,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246",
      "ID": 2320
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4964,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5170853+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279629",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279629,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1861,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246",
      "ID": 2320
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3824,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5158655+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2066E22P91VM261115",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261115,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1861,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246",
      "ID": 2320
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2066,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.1124672+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299678",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 299678,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1861,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246",
      "ID": 2320
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7080434+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306659",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306659,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1861,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246",
      "ID": 2320
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina",
      "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5616918+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2487E146P369VM301135",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 301135,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1861,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246",
      "ID": 2320
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2487,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0351287+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223875",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223875,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1861,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246",
      "ID": 2320
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4775244+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237483",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237483,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1861,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246",
      "ID": 2320
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1961,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David",
      "DisplayName": "David McLetchie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2125313+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305425",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 305425,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1861,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246",
      "ID": 2320
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2134,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3234728+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320434",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 320434,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1861,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246",
      "ID": 2320
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5041,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan",
      "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1662394+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3763E142P397VM316037",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 316037,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1861,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246",
      "ID": 2320
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3763,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart",
      "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9431299+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1986E23P197VM236671",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 236671,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1861,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246",
      "ID": 2320
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1986,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan",
      "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9350515+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5047E100P130VM289833",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289833,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1861,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246",
      "ID": 2320
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5047,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne",
      "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4610063+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234619",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234619,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1861,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246",
      "ID": 2320
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1845,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette",
      "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3921293+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313607",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313607,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1861,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246",
      "ID": 2320
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3061,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4026798+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1768E19P265VM289261",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289261,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1861,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246",
      "ID": 2320
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1768,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4296226+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225067",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225067,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1861,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246",
      "ID": 2320
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1894,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Neil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7430835+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3815E98P134VM270902",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270902,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1861,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246",
      "ID": 2320
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3815,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Park, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Park",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8283635+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265904",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265904,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1861,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246",
      "ID": 2320
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2010,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil",
      "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4655838+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283335",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283335,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1861,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246",
      "ID": 2320
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5057,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.6962748+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2853E33P128VM251454",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251454,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1861,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246",
      "ID": 2320
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Pentland",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4643486+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317654",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317654,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1861,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246",
      "ID": 2320
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5009,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4317098+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254657",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254657,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1861,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246",
      "ID": 2320
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3745,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis",
      "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2660257+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1870E225P478VM295703",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295703,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1861,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246",
      "ID": 2320
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1870,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona",
      "DisplayName": "Shona Robison",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5322123+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2135E254P450VM234898",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234898,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1861,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246",
      "ID": 2320
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2135,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Russell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4045107+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1895E232P431VM257395",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257395,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1861,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246",
      "ID": 2320
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1895,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0543495+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228160",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 228160,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1861,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246",
      "ID": 2320
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1839,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5869199+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2345E10P55VM291702",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291702,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1861,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246",
      "ID": 2320
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2345,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1386147+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2223E176P333VM310702",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 310702,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1861,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246",
      "ID": 2320
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2223,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish",
      "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5823576+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246381",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 246381,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1861,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246",
      "ID": 2320
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2182,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1262889+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298125",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298125,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1861,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246",
      "ID": 2320
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5079,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew",
      "DisplayName": "Drew Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1392992+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234158",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234158,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1861,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246",
      "ID": 2320
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1769,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1691398+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274568",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274568,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1861,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246",
      "ID": 2320
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4014,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz",
      "DisplayName": "Liz Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1122301+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269519",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269519,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1861,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246",
      "ID": 2320
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2215,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5511262+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317203",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317203,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1861,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246",
      "ID": 2320
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3806,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4078829+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326253",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 326253,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1861,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246",
      "ID": 2320
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5106,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin",
      "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7504646+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241173",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241173,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1861,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246",
      "ID": 2320
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1848,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola",
      "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.4051849+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2098E237P531VM289618",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289618,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1861,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246",
      "ID": 2320
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2098,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Swinney",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4517777+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2674E247P401VM247772",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247772,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1861,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246",
      "ID": 2320
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2674,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave",
      "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4277814+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5075E234P371VM284889",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 284889,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1861,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246",
      "ID": 2320
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5075,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Torrance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0520605+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1793E151P362VM222468",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 222468,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1861,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246",
      "ID": 2320
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1793,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean",
      "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1902602+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5078E245P15VM307046",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307046,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1861,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246",
      "ID": 2320
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5078,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Walker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5849664+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1841E231P426VM239950",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239950,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1861,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246",
      "ID": 2320
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1841,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen",
      "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7663093+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283432",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283432,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1861,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246",
      "ID": 2320
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4952,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7075627+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1865E263P500VM232213",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232213,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1861,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246",
      "ID": 2320
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1865,
      "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra",
      "DisplayName": "Sandra White",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8450084+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237781",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237781,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1861,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246",
      "ID": 2320
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2610,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Wilson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2258358+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309269",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 309269,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1861,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 83,
      "VoteAgainst": 37,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Aberdeen City Council",
      "Reference": "S4M-02246",
      "ID": 2320
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4941,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza",
      "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3220495+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252297",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252297,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1858,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242.3",
      "ID": 2338
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1926,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian",
      "DisplayName": "Brian Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.723081+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2615E213P388VM258838",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258838,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1858,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242.3",
      "ID": 2338
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2615,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George",
      "DisplayName": "George Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3300825+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319890",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319890,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1858,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242.3",
      "ID": 2338
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4940,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare",
      "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9457977+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249678",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 249678,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1858,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242.3",
      "ID": 2338
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2641,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair",
      "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9451182+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1783E21P273VM227404",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227404,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1858,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242.3",
      "ID": 2338
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1783,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie",
      "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5486823+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2633E97P136VM280400",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280400,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1858,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242.3",
      "ID": 2338
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2633,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire",
      "DisplayName": "Claire Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7653398+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262480",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262480,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1858,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242.3",
      "ID": 2338
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2603,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.603758+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1759E91P115VM229729",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229729,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1858,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242.3",
      "ID": 2338
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia",
      "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0941488+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270189",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270189,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1858,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242.3",
      "ID": 2338
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3751,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5853797+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322859",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 322859,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1858,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242.3",
      "ID": 2338
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5109,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco",
      "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.7066258+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5060E86P124VM294711",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 294711,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1858,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242.3",
      "ID": 2338
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5060,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1750362+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242862",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242862,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1858,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242.3",
      "ID": 2338
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1866,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah",
      "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.038791+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235562",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235562,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1858,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242.3",
      "ID": 2338
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1943,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic",
      "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6831503+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302137",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 302137,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1858,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242.3",
      "ID": 2338
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2595,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin",
      "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.2986737+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244520",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244520,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1858,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242.3",
      "ID": 2338
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2103,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith",
      "DisplayName": "Keith Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5583195+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327241",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 327241,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1858,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242.3",
      "ID": 2338
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:46.0273471+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3775E216P435VM276663",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276663,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1858,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242.3",
      "ID": 2338
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6758191+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264354",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264354,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1858,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242.3",
      "ID": 2338
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2673,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick",
      "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1298899+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248788",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248788,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1858,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242.3",
      "ID": 2338
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2678,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson",
      "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6700838+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2123E27P233VM295821",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295821,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1858,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242.3",
      "ID": 2338
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2123,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm",
      "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5372932+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285141",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285141,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1858,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242.3",
      "ID": 2338
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3907,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0682176+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230156",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230156,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1858,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242.3",
      "ID": 2338
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1735,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela",
      "DisplayName": "Angela Constance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.1186343+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243857",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 243857,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1858,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242.3",
      "ID": 2338
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1932,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce",
      "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3228884+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254951",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254951,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1858,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242.3",
      "ID": 2338
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1863,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna",
      "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2908158+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323876",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 323876,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1858,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242.3",
      "ID": 2338
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4976,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth",
      "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9761898+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5107E223P379VM291347",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291347,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1858,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242.3",
      "ID": 2338
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5107,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1151658+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3743E222P391VM265312",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265312,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1858,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242.3",
      "ID": 2338
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3743,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel",
      "DisplayName": "Nigel Don",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4337422+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262237",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262237,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1858,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242.3",
      "ID": 2338
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3771,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob",
      "DisplayName": "Bob Doris",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.5928451+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2826E262P384VM282031",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 282031,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1858,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242.3",
      "ID": 2338
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2826,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Dornan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1682226+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3812E94P117VM297940",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 297940,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1858,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242.3",
      "ID": 2338
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3812,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia",
      "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.131461+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231615",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231615,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1858,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242.3",
      "ID": 2338
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1778,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen",
      "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6082319+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4955E240P389VM285952",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285952,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1858,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242.3",
      "ID": 2338
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4955,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.351606+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219375",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 219375,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1858,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242.3",
      "ID": 2338
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1742,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle",
      "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.2959086+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238589",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 238589,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1858,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242.3",
      "ID": 2338
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1994,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus",
      "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4606289+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225482",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225482,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1858,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242.3",
      "ID": 2338
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1814,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda",
      "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9766159+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321601",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 321601,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1858,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242.3",
      "ID": 2338
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Fee",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4431065+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1853E35P216VM293266",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 293266,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1858,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242.3",
      "ID": 2338
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia",
      "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8375819+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1892E12P64VM226945",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 226945,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1858,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242.3",
      "ID": 2338
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2537576+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5054E95P118VM312653",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 312653,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1858,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242.3",
      "ID": 2338
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5054,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1375658+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4947E152P361VM257143",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257143,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1858,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242.3",
      "ID": 2338
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4947,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Finnie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.8251575+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271308",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271308,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1858,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242.3",
      "ID": 2338
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3901,
      "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe",
      "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0698517+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278475",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 278475,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1858,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242.3",
      "ID": 2338
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2394,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo",
      "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2204114+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2110E220P414VM286725",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286725,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1858,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242.3",
      "ID": 2338
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth",
      "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5980447+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250421",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250421,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1858,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242.3",
      "ID": 2338
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2675,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob",
      "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1888251+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1741E10P50VM220733",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220733,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1858,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242.3",
      "ID": 2338
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1741,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel",
      "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6546993+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220268",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220268,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1858,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242.3",
      "ID": 2338
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1756,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine",
      "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6310934+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1860E104P150VM251852",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251852,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1858,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242.3",
      "ID": 2338
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1860,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda",
      "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4919234+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2033E20P141VM266160",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 266160,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1858,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242.3",
      "ID": 2338
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2033,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain",
      "DisplayName": "Iain Gray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4769028+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324557",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324557,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1858,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242.3",
      "ID": 2338
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5042,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2281207+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259735",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 259735,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1858,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242.3",
      "ID": 2338
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick",
      "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6222643+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239308",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239308,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1858,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242.3",
      "ID": 2338
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2029,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh",
      "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7312188+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273825",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 273825,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1858,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242.3",
      "ID": 2338
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3758,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6372889+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304192",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 304192,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1858,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242.3",
      "ID": 2338
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4086,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Hume",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8539905+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221806",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221806,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1858,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242.3",
      "ID": 2338
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1773,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9486196+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1882E227P459VM242041",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242041,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1858,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242.3",
      "ID": 2338
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1882,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam",
      "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7912702+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223721",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223721,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1858,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242.3",
      "ID": 2338
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1893,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4709249+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307524",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307524,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1858,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242.3",
      "ID": 2338
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4934,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8332469+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272160",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 272160,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1858,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242.3",
      "ID": 2338
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4956,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Keir",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.1141521+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244870",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244870,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1858,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242.3",
      "ID": 2338
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Kelly",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5821428+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315042",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315042,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1858,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242.3",
      "ID": 2338
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3129,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6715864+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247960",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247960,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1858,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242.3",
      "ID": 2338
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann",
      "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4357534+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4016E11P36VM274778",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274778,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1858,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242.3",
      "ID": 2338
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4016,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.121342+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255810",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255810,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1858,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242.3",
      "ID": 2338
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2180,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5580547+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4938E158P374VM277467",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277467,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1858,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242.3",
      "ID": 2338
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4938,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.954615+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2112E250P486VM253002",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253002,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1858,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242.3",
      "ID": 2338
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2112,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny",
      "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7626281+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4939E258P394VM276852",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276852,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1858,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242.3",
      "ID": 2338
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4939,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus",
      "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6838692+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325574",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 325574,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1858,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242.3",
      "ID": 2338
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5074,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon",
      "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5121975+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1828E3P10VM232818",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232818,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1858,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242.3",
      "ID": 2338
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1828,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo",
      "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8775604+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311371",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311371,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1858,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242.3",
      "ID": 2338
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4948,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike",
      "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8758308+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2117E90P107VM230422",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230422,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1858,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242.3",
      "ID": 2338
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2117,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis",
      "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3291383+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267311",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 267311,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1858,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242.3",
      "ID": 2338
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken",
      "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0139648+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313790",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313790,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1858,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242.3",
      "ID": 2338
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4966,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek",
      "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4107639+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3101E102P129VM295442",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295442,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1858,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242.3",
      "ID": 2338
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3101,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala",
      "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5123247+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5034E88P114VM318850",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 318850,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1858,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242.3",
      "ID": 2338
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5034,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny",
      "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6761096+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306445",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306445,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1858,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242.3",
      "ID": 2338
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2159,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Martin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5523743+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5110E252P395VM310844",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 310844,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1858,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242.3",
      "ID": 2338
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Mason",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5884521+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268293",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 268293,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1858,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242.3",
      "ID": 2338
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2133,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2608591+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2876E141P433VM286120",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286120,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1858,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242.3",
      "ID": 2338
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2876,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3645267+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4951E147P368VM260724",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 260724,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1858,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242.3",
      "ID": 2338
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4951,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan",
      "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.0895369+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3896E175P307VM263901",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 263901,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1858,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242.3",
      "ID": 2338
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3896,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam",
      "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9156703+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308488",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 308488,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1858,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242.3",
      "ID": 2338
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0580837+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4964E143P375VM279655",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279655,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1858,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242.3",
      "ID": 2338
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4964,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5169647+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3824E84P113VM280007",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280007,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1858,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242.3",
      "ID": 2338
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3824,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5325718+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2066E22P91VM261118",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261118,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1858,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242.3",
      "ID": 2338
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2066,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.112591+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299723",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 299723,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1858,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242.3",
      "ID": 2338
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7198507+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306675",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306675,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1858,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242.3",
      "ID": 2338
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina",
      "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.562532+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2487E146P369VM301119",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 301119,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1858,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242.3",
      "ID": 2338
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2487,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0342839+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223638",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223638,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1858,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242.3",
      "ID": 2338
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4673968+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237480",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237480,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1858,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242.3",
      "ID": 2338
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1961,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David",
      "DisplayName": "David McLetchie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2124083+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305422",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 305422,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1858,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242.3",
      "ID": 2338
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2134,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.323331+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320731",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 320731,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1858,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242.3",
      "ID": 2338
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5041,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan",
      "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1790376+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3763E142P397VM316040",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 316040,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1858,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242.3",
      "ID": 2338
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3763,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart",
      "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.943253+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1986E23P197VM236294",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 236294,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1858,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242.3",
      "ID": 2338
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1986,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan",
      "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9101888+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5047E100P130VM291440",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291440,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1858,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242.3",
      "ID": 2338
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5047,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne",
      "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1194061+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234930",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234930,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1858,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242.3",
      "ID": 2338
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1845,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette",
      "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4059049+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313610",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313610,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1858,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242.3",
      "ID": 2338
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3061,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4028197+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1768E19P265VM288543",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 288543,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1858,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242.3",
      "ID": 2338
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1768,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1479396+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225064",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225064,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1858,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242.3",
      "ID": 2338
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1894,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Neil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7429637+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3815E98P134VM270899",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270899,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1858,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242.3",
      "ID": 2338
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3815,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Park, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Park",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8281044+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265908",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265908,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1858,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242.3",
      "ID": 2338
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2010,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil",
      "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4657468+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283338",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283338,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1858,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242.3",
      "ID": 2338
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5057,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.6963993+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2853E33P128VM251451",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251451,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1858,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242.3",
      "ID": 2338
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Pentland",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4642159+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317950",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317950,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1858,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242.3",
      "ID": 2338
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5009,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4504951+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254742",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254742,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1858,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242.3",
      "ID": 2338
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3745,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis",
      "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2817938+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1870E225P478VM295603",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295603,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1858,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242.3",
      "ID": 2338
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1870,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona",
      "DisplayName": "Shona Robison",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5195599+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2135E254P450VM234895",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234895,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1858,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242.3",
      "ID": 2338
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2135,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Russell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4043863+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1895E232P431VM257392",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257392,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1858,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242.3",
      "ID": 2338
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1895,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0542269+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228076",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 228076,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1858,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242.3",
      "ID": 2338
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1839,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5833305+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2345E10P55VM292015",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 292015,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1858,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242.3",
      "ID": 2338
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2345,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1522013+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2223E176P333VM310699",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 310699,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1858,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242.3",
      "ID": 2338
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2223,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish",
      "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5822355+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2182E87P175VM245989",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 245989,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1858,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242.3",
      "ID": 2338
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2182,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8674271+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298347",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298347,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1858,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242.3",
      "ID": 2338
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5079,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew",
      "DisplayName": "Drew Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3418227+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234381",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234381,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1858,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242.3",
      "ID": 2338
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1769,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3748364+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274565",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274565,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1858,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242.3",
      "ID": 2338
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4014,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz",
      "DisplayName": "Liz Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1121045+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269167",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269167,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1858,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242.3",
      "ID": 2338
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2215,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.3065963+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317200",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317200,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1858,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242.3",
      "ID": 2338
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3806,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.1860013+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326256",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 326256,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1858,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242.3",
      "ID": 2338
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5106,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin",
      "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7505893+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241087",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241087,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1858,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242.3",
      "ID": 2338
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1848,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola",
      "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3955273+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2098E237P531VM289615",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289615,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1858,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242.3",
      "ID": 2338
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2098,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Swinney",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4516409+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2674E247P401VM247769",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247769,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1858,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242.3",
      "ID": 2338
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2674,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave",
      "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4276481+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5075E234P371VM284886",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 284886,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1858,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242.3",
      "ID": 2338
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5075,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Torrance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0519402+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1793E151P362VM222465",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 222465,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1858,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242.3",
      "ID": 2338
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1793,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean",
      "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1901164+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5078E245P15VM307030",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307030,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1858,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242.3",
      "ID": 2338
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5078,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Walker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5842782+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1841E231P426VM240191",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 240191,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1858,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242.3",
      "ID": 2338
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1841,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen",
      "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3487722+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283429",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283429,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1858,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242.3",
      "ID": 2338
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4952,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7003231+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1865E263P500VM232254",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232254,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1858,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242.3",
      "ID": 2338
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1865,
      "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra",
      "DisplayName": "Sandra White",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8468076+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237784",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237784,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1858,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242.3",
      "ID": 2338
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2610,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Wilson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2259566+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309314",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 309314,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1858,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242.3",
      "ID": 2338
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4941,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza",
      "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3239673+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252298",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252298,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1859,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242",
      "ID": 2316
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1926,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian",
      "DisplayName": "Brian Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7231215+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2615E213P388VM258839",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258839,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1859,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242",
      "ID": 2316
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2615,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George",
      "DisplayName": "George Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3301234+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319889",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319889,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1859,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242",
      "ID": 2316
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4940,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare",
      "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9457565+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249595",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 249595,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1859,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242",
      "ID": 2316
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2641,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair",
      "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9335987+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1783E21P273VM227405",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227405,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1859,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242",
      "ID": 2316
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1783,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie",
      "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5487412+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2633E97P136VM280751",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280751,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1859,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242",
      "ID": 2316
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2633,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire",
      "DisplayName": "Claire Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.780867+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262481",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262481,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1859,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242",
      "ID": 2316
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2603,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6037988+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1759E91P115VM229730",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229730,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1859,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242",
      "ID": 2316
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia",
      "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0941887+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270188",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270188,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1859,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242",
      "ID": 2316
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3751,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.585339+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322714",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 322714,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1859,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242",
      "ID": 2316
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5109,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco",
      "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.7005136+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5060E86P124VM294712",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 294712,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1859,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242",
      "ID": 2316
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5060,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1750769+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242863",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242863,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1859,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242",
      "ID": 2316
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1866,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah",
      "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0388309+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235561",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235561,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1859,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242",
      "ID": 2316
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1943,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic",
      "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6831098+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302138",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 302138,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1859,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242",
      "ID": 2316
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2595,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin",
      "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.298726+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244519",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244519,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1859,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242",
      "ID": 2316
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2103,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith",
      "DisplayName": "Keith Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5582788+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327242",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 327242,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1859,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242",
      "ID": 2316
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:46.027389+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3775E216P435VM276664",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276664,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1859,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242",
      "ID": 2316
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6758589+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264353",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264353,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1859,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242",
      "ID": 2316
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2673,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick",
      "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1298496+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248787",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248787,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1859,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242",
      "ID": 2316
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2678,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson",
      "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6700437+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2123E27P233VM295820",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295820,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1859,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242",
      "ID": 2316
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2123,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm",
      "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5372531+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285142",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285142,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1859,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242",
      "ID": 2316
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3907,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0682591+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230157",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230157,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1859,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242",
      "ID": 2316
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1735,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela",
      "DisplayName": "Angela Constance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.1186939+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243856",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 243856,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1859,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242",
      "ID": 2316
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1932,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce",
      "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3228481+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254950",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254950,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1859,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242",
      "ID": 2316
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1863,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna",
      "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2907564+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323877",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 323877,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1859,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242",
      "ID": 2316
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4976,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth",
      "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9762327+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5107E223P379VM291346",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291346,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1859,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242",
      "ID": 2316
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5107,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1151014+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3743E222P391VM265313",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265313,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1859,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242",
      "ID": 2316
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3743,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel",
      "DisplayName": "Nigel Don",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4337841+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262238",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262238,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1859,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242",
      "ID": 2316
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3771,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob",
      "DisplayName": "Bob Doris",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.5928854+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281990",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 281990,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1859,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242",
      "ID": 2316
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2826,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Dornan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.166453+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3812E94P117VM297982",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 297982,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1859,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242",
      "ID": 2316
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3812,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia",
      "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1332306+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231614",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231614,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1859,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242",
      "ID": 2316
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1778,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen",
      "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6081917+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4955E240P389VM285951",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285951,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1859,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242",
      "ID": 2316
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4955,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3515646+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219376",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 219376,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1859,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242",
      "ID": 2316
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1742,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle",
      "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.2959774+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238588",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 238588,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1859,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242",
      "ID": 2316
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1994,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus",
      "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4605887+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225431",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225431,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1859,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242",
      "ID": 2316
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1814,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda",
      "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9744388+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321745",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 321745,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1859,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242",
      "ID": 2316
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Fee",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4495915+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292859",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 292859,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1859,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242",
      "ID": 2316
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia",
      "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5611654+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1892E12P64VM226946",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 226946,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1859,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242",
      "ID": 2316
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.253799+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5054E95P118VM312654",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 312654,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1859,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242",
      "ID": 2316
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5054,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1376063+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4947E152P361VM257225",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257225,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1859,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242",
      "ID": 2316
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4947,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Finnie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0469607+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271307",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271307,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1859,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242",
      "ID": 2316
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3901,
      "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe",
      "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0698101+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278435",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 278435,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1859,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242",
      "ID": 2316
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2394,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo",
      "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2186889+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2110E220P414VM286726",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286726,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1859,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242",
      "ID": 2316
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth",
      "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5980845+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250503",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250503,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1859,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242",
      "ID": 2316
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2675,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob",
      "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.192355+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1741E10P50VM220940",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220940,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1859,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242",
      "ID": 2316
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1741,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel",
      "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6682025+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220267",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220267,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1859,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242",
      "ID": 2316
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1756,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine",
      "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6310523+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1860E104P150VM251853",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251853,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1859,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242",
      "ID": 2316
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1860,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda",
      "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4919647+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2033E20P141VM266122",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 266122,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1859,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242",
      "ID": 2316
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2033,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain",
      "DisplayName": "Iain Gray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4752733+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324556",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324556,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1859,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242",
      "ID": 2316
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5042,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2280808+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259734",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 259734,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1859,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242",
      "ID": 2316
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick",
      "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6222236+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239309",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239309,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1859,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242",
      "ID": 2316
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2029,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh",
      "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7312598+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273824",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 273824,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1859,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242",
      "ID": 2316
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3758,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6372476+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304191",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 304191,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1859,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242",
      "ID": 2316
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4086,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Hume",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8539333+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221755",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221755,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1859,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242",
      "ID": 2316
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1773,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9463917+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1882E227P459VM241958",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241958,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1859,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242",
      "ID": 2316
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1882,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam",
      "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7876941+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223720",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223720,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1859,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242",
      "ID": 2316
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1893,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4708846+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307566",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307566,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1859,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242",
      "ID": 2316
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4934,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.835052+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272240",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 272240,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1859,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242",
      "ID": 2316
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4956,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Keir",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.321081+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244871",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244871,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1859,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242",
      "ID": 2316
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Kelly",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.582201+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315043",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315043,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1859,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242",
      "ID": 2316
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3129,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6716289+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247959",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247959,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1859,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242",
      "ID": 2316
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann",
      "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4356954+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4016E11P36VM274779",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274779,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1859,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242",
      "ID": 2316
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4016,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1213831+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255809",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255809,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1859,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242",
      "ID": 2316
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2180,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5580134+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4938E158P374VM277466",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277466,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1859,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242",
      "ID": 2316
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4938,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9545744+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2112E250P486VM253003",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253003,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1859,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242",
      "ID": 2316
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2112,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny",
      "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.76267+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4939E258P394VM276851",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276851,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1859,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242",
      "ID": 2316
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4939,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus",
      "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6838292+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325575",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 325575,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1859,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242",
      "ID": 2316
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5074,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon",
      "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5122372+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1828E3P10VM232819",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232819,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1859,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242",
      "ID": 2316
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1828,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo",
      "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8776017+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311413",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311413,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1859,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242",
      "ID": 2316
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4948,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike",
      "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8777159+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2117E90P107VM230421",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230421,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1859,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242",
      "ID": 2316
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2117,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis",
      "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3290974+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267349",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 267349,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1859,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242",
      "ID": 2316
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken",
      "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0156225+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313748",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313748,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1859,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242",
      "ID": 2316
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4966,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek",
      "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4089781+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3101E102P129VM295092",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295092,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1859,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242",
      "ID": 2316
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3101,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala",
      "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1918522+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5034E88P114VM318994",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 318994,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1859,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242",
      "ID": 2316
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5034,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny",
      "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.687872+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306444",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306444,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1859,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242",
      "ID": 2316
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2159,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Martin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5523329+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5110E252P395VM310862",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 310862,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1859,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242",
      "ID": 2316
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Mason",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5948391+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268254",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 268254,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1859,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242",
      "ID": 2316
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2133,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.255508+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2876E141P433VM286318",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286318,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1859,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242",
      "ID": 2316
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2876,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5736373+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4951E147P368VM258631",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258631,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1859,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242",
      "ID": 2316
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4951,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan",
      "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.315826+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3896E175P307VM263900",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 263900,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1859,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242",
      "ID": 2316
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3896,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam",
      "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9156301+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308470",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 308470,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1859,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242",
      "ID": 2316
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0573015+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4964E143P375VM279656",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279656,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1859,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242",
      "ID": 2316
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4964,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5170051+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3824E84P113VM280006",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280006,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1859,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242",
      "ID": 2316
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3824,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5324432+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2066E22P91VM261117",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261117,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1859,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242",
      "ID": 2316
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2066,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.1125493+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299681",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 299681,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1859,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242",
      "ID": 2316
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.708164+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306657",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306657,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1859,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242",
      "ID": 2316
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina",
      "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5616038+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2487E146P369VM301137",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 301137,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1859,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242",
      "ID": 2316
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2487,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0352313+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223689",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223689,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1859,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242",
      "ID": 2316
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.469574+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237481",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237481,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1859,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242",
      "ID": 2316
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1961,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David",
      "DisplayName": "David McLetchie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.212449+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305423",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 305423,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1859,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242",
      "ID": 2316
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2134,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3233718+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320432",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 320432,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1859,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242",
      "ID": 2316
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5041,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan",
      "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1661574+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3763E142P397VM316039",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 316039,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1859,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242",
      "ID": 2316
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3763,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart",
      "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9432121+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1986E23P197VM236295",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 236295,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1859,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242",
      "ID": 2316
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1986,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan",
      "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9102486+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5047E100P130VM291439",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291439,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1859,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242",
      "ID": 2316
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5047,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne",
      "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1193649+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234621",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234621,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1859,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242",
      "ID": 2316
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1845,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette",
      "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3922116+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313609",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313609,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1859,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242",
      "ID": 2316
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3061,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4027605+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1768E19P265VM289259",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289259,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1859,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242",
      "ID": 2316
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1768,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4295398+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225065",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225065,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1859,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242",
      "ID": 2316
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1894,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Neil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7430037+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3815E98P134VM270900",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270900,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1859,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242",
      "ID": 2316
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3815,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Park, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Park",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8282642+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265907",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265907,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1859,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242",
      "ID": 2316
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2010,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil",
      "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4657063+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283337",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283337,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1859,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242",
      "ID": 2316
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5057,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.6963582+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2853E33P128VM251452",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251452,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1859,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242",
      "ID": 2316
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Pentland",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4642612+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317652",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317652,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1859,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242",
      "ID": 2316
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5009,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4316288+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254660",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254660,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1859,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242",
      "ID": 2316
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3745,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis",
      "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2661485+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1870E225P478VM295701",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295701,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1859,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242",
      "ID": 2316
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1870,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona",
      "DisplayName": "Shona Robison",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5321308+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2135E254P450VM234896",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234896,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1859,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242",
      "ID": 2316
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2135,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Russell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4044291+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1895E232P431VM257393",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257393,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1859,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242",
      "ID": 2316
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1895,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0542679+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228128",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 228128,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1859,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242",
      "ID": 2316
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1839,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5855488+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2345E10P55VM292014",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 292014,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1859,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242",
      "ID": 2316
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2345,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1521601+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2223E176P333VM310700",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 310700,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1859,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242",
      "ID": 2316
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2223,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish",
      "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5822769+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246378",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 246378,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1859,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242",
      "ID": 2316
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2182,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1261462+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298346",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298346,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1859,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242",
      "ID": 2316
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5079,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew",
      "DisplayName": "Drew Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3417821+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234380",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234380,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1859,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242",
      "ID": 2316
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1769,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3747718+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274566",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274566,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1859,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242",
      "ID": 2316
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4014,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz",
      "DisplayName": "Liz Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1121466+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269516",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269516,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1859,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242",
      "ID": 2316
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2215,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5510036+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317201",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317201,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1859,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242",
      "ID": 2316
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3806,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.1860424+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326255",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 326255,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1859,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242",
      "ID": 2316
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5106,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin",
      "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7505483+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241140",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241140,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1859,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242",
      "ID": 2316
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1848,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola",
      "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.4037671+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2098E237P531VM289616",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289616,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1859,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242",
      "ID": 2316
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2098,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Swinney",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4516808+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2674E247P401VM247770",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247770,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1859,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242",
      "ID": 2316
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2674,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave",
      "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4276906+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5075E234P371VM284887",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 284887,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1859,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242",
      "ID": 2316
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5075,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Torrance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0519801+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1793E151P362VM222466",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 222466,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1859,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242",
      "ID": 2316
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1793,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean",
      "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1901769+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5078E245P15VM307048",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307048,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1859,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242",
      "ID": 2316
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5078,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Walker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5850486+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1841E231P426VM239983",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239983,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1859,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242",
      "ID": 2316
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1841,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen",
      "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7677231+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283430",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283430,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1859,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242",
      "ID": 2316
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4952,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7074226+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1865E263P500VM232253",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232253,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1859,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242",
      "ID": 2316
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1865,
      "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra",
      "DisplayName": "Sandra White",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8467655+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237783",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237783,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1859,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242",
      "ID": 2316
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2610,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Wilson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2259168+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309272",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 309272,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1859,
      "AgendaID": 2419,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 57,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Curriculum for Excellence",
      "Reference": "S4M-02242",
      "ID": 2316
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4941,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza",
      "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3221715+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252230",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252230,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1864,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02163",
      "ID": 2242
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1926,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian",
      "DisplayName": "Brian Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7199788+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2615E213P388VM258824",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258824,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1864,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02163",
      "ID": 2242
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2615,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George",
      "DisplayName": "George Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3294901+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319904",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319904,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1864,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02163",
      "ID": 2242
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4940,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare",
      "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9463953+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249643",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 249643,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1864,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02163",
      "ID": 2242
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2641,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair",
      "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9436569+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1783E21P273VM227337",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227337,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1864,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02163",
      "ID": 2242
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1783,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie",
      "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5458019+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2633E97P136VM280738",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280738,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1864,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02163",
      "ID": 2242
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2633,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire",
      "DisplayName": "Claire Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7803264+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262496",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262496,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1864,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02163",
      "ID": 2242
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2603,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6044499+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1759E91P115VM229747",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229747,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1864,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02163",
      "ID": 2242
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia",
      "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0949661+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270203",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270203,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1864,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02163",
      "ID": 2242
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3751,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.7936785+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322701",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 322701,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1864,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02163",
      "ID": 2242
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5109,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco",
      "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6999751+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5060E86P124VM294727",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 294727,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1864,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02163",
      "ID": 2242
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5060,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.175735+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242848",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242848,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1864,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02163",
      "ID": 2242
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1866,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah",
      "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0382085+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235576",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235576,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1864,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02163",
      "ID": 2242
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1943,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic",
      "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6837431+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302155",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 302155,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1864,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02163",
      "ID": 2242
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2595,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin",
      "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.2996494+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244504",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244504,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1864,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02163",
      "ID": 2242
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2103,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith",
      "DisplayName": "Keith Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5576367+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327227",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 327227,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1864,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02163",
      "ID": 2242
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:46.0267185+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3775E216P435VM276679",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276679,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1864,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02163",
      "ID": 2242
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6764874+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264338",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264338,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1864,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02163",
      "ID": 2242
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2673,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick",
      "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1291979+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248811",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248811,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1864,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02163",
      "ID": 2242
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2678,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson",
      "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6710667+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2123E27P233VM295835",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295835,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1864,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02163",
      "ID": 2242
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2123,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm",
      "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5379017+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285157",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285157,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1864,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02163",
      "ID": 2242
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3907,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0688921+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230176",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230176,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1864,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02163",
      "ID": 2242
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1735,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela",
      "DisplayName": "Angela Constance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.1194959+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243871",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 243871,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1864,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02163",
      "ID": 2242
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1932,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce",
      "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3234799+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254934",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254934,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1864,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02163",
      "ID": 2242
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1863,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna",
      "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2900776+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323834",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 323834,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1864,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02163",
      "ID": 2242
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4976,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth",
      "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9740946+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5107E223P379VM291370",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291370,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1864,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02163",
      "ID": 2242
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5107,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1163898+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3743E222P391VM265328",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265328,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1864,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02163",
      "ID": 2242
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3743,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel",
      "DisplayName": "Nigel Don",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4344428+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3771E149P417VM261750",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261750,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1864,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02163",
      "ID": 2242
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3771,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob",
      "DisplayName": "Bob Doris",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3712142+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2826E262P384VM282003",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 282003,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1864,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02163",
      "ID": 2242
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2826,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Dornan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1670263+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3812E94P117VM297969",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 297969,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1864,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02163",
      "ID": 2242
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3812,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia",
      "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1326887+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231597",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231597,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1864,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02163",
      "ID": 2242
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1778,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen",
      "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6074628+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4955E240P389VM285966",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285966,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1864,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02163",
      "ID": 2242
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4955,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.352219+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219353",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 219353,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1864,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02163",
      "ID": 2242
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1742,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle",
      "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.2949382+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238603",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 238603,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1864,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02163",
      "ID": 2242
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1994,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus",
      "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4612182+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225449",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225449,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1864,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02163",
      "ID": 2242
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1814,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda",
      "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9752014+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321758",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 321758,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1864,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02163",
      "ID": 2242
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Fee",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4501388+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292924",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 292924,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1864,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02163",
      "ID": 2242
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia",
      "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5640825+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1892E12P64VM226920",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 226920,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1864,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02163",
      "ID": 2242
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2525751+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5054E95P118VM312671",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 312671,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1864,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02163",
      "ID": 2242
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5054,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1383457+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4947E152P361VM257176",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257176,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1864,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02163",
      "ID": 2242
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4947,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Finnie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.8265794+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271322",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271322,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1864,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02163",
      "ID": 2242
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3901,
      "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe",
      "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.070512+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278541",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 278541,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1864,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02163",
      "ID": 2242
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2394,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo",
      "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2233289+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2110E220P414VM286743",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286743,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1864,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02163",
      "ID": 2242
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth",
      "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5988054+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250454",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250454,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1864,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02163",
      "ID": 2242
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2675,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob",
      "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1902401+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1741E10P50VM220766",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220766,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1864,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02163",
      "ID": 2242
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1741,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel",
      "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6561042+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220292",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220292,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1864,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02163",
      "ID": 2242
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1756,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine",
      "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6350361+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1860E104P150VM252331",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252331,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1864,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02163",
      "ID": 2242
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1860,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda",
      "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7245658+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2033E20P141VM266227",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 266227,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1864,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02163",
      "ID": 2242
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2033,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain",
      "DisplayName": "Iain Gray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.7317288+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324571",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324571,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1864,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02163",
      "ID": 2242
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5042,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2287065+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259913",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 259913,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1864,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02163",
      "ID": 2242
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick",
      "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6354417+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239294",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239294,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1864,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02163",
      "ID": 2242
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2029,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh",
      "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7306213+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273809",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 273809,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1864,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02163",
      "ID": 2242
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3758,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.636596+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304174",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 304174,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1864,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02163",
      "ID": 2242
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4086,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Hume",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.853032+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221773",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221773,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1864,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02163",
      "ID": 2242
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1773,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9471771+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1882E227P459VM242006",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242006,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1864,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02163",
      "ID": 2242
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1882,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam",
      "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7897727+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223734",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223734,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1864,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02163",
      "ID": 2242
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1893,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4714777+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307553",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307553,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1864,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02163",
      "ID": 2242
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4934,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8344779+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272193",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 272193,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1864,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02163",
      "ID": 2242
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4956,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Keir",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.1155857+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244857",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244857,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1864,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02163",
      "ID": 2242
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Kelly",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5815954+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315028",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315028,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1864,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02163",
      "ID": 2242
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3129,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6709681+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247974",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247974,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1864,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02163",
      "ID": 2242
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann",
      "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4363435+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4016E11P36VM274764",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274764,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1864,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02163",
      "ID": 2242
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4016,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.12072+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255824",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255824,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1864,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02163",
      "ID": 2242
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2180,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5586373+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4938E158P374VM277481",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277481,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1864,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02163",
      "ID": 2242
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4938,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9552076+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2112E250P486VM252988",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252988,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1864,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02163",
      "ID": 2242
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2112,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny",
      "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7620195+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4939E258P394VM277186",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277186,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1864,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02163",
      "ID": 2242
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4939,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus",
      "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.7048833+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325560",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 325560,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1864,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02163",
      "ID": 2242
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5074,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon",
      "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5116064+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1828E3P10VM232836",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232836,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1864,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02163",
      "ID": 2242
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1828,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo",
      "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8784584+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311400",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311400,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1864,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02163",
      "ID": 2242
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4948,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike",
      "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8770921+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2117E90P107VM230446",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230446,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1864,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02163",
      "ID": 2242
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2117,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis",
      "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.330181+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267244",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 267244,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1864,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02163",
      "ID": 2242
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken",
      "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0110496+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313761",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313761,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1864,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02163",
      "ID": 2242
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4966,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek",
      "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4095272+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3101E102P129VM295413",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295413,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1864,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02163",
      "ID": 2242
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3101,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala",
      "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.511112+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319007",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319007,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1864,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02163",
      "ID": 2242
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5034,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny",
      "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6884274+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306459",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306459,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1864,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02163",
      "ID": 2242
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2159,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Martin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5529931+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5110E252P395VM311232",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311232,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1864,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02163",
      "ID": 2242
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Mason",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.86768+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268360",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 268360,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1864,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02163",
      "ID": 2242
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2133,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2637559+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2876E141P433VM286305",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286305,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1864,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02163",
      "ID": 2242
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2876,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5730784+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4951E147P368VM260691",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 260691,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1864,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02163",
      "ID": 2242
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4951,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan",
      "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.0881183+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3896E175P307VM264080",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264080,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1864,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02163",
      "ID": 2242
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3896,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam",
      "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9233309+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308407",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 308407,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1864,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02163",
      "ID": 2242
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0546031+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4964E143P375VM279323",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279323,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1864,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02163",
      "ID": 2242
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4964,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.4972141+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279991",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279991,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1864,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02163",
      "ID": 2242
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3824,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5315881+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2066E22P91VM261131",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261131,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1864,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02163",
      "ID": 2242
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2066,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.1131505+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299694",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 299694,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1864,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02163",
      "ID": 2242
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7185769+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306593",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306593,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1864,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02163",
      "ID": 2242
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina",
      "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5587403+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2487E146P369VM301202",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 301202,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1864,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02163",
      "ID": 2242
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2487,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.2516759+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223671",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223671,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1864,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02163",
      "ID": 2242
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4688049+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237466",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237466,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1864,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02163",
      "ID": 2242
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1961,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David",
      "DisplayName": "David McLetchie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2118042+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2134E34P201VM297855",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 297855,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1864,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02163",
      "ID": 2242
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2134,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1279005+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320419",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 320419,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1864,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02163",
      "ID": 2242
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5041,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan",
      "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1656034+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3763E142P397VM316054",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 316054,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1864,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02163",
      "ID": 2242
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3763,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart",
      "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9439749+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1986E23P197VM236310",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 236310,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1864,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02163",
      "ID": 2242
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1986,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan",
      "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9108941+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5047E100P130VM291424",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291424,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1864,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02163",
      "ID": 2242
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5047,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne",
      "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1187218+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234605",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234605,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1864,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02163",
      "ID": 2242
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1845,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette",
      "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3915065+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313624",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313624,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1864,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02163",
      "ID": 2242
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3061,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4034188+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1768E19P265VM288577",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 288577,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1864,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02163",
      "ID": 2242
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1768,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1493997+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225051",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225051,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1864,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02163",
      "ID": 2242
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1894,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Neil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7424188+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3815E98P134VM270890",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270890,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1864,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02163",
      "ID": 2242
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3815,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Park, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Park",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.827604+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265891",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265891,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1864,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02163",
      "ID": 2242
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2010,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil",
      "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4650189+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283517",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283517,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1864,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02163",
      "ID": 2242
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5057,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7113104+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2853E33P128VM251428",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251428,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1864,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02163",
      "ID": 2242
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Pentland",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.463184+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317639",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317639,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1864,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02163",
      "ID": 2242
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5009,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4310626+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254709",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254709,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1864,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02163",
      "ID": 2242
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3745,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis",
      "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2803711+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1870E225P478VM295636",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295636,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1864,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02163",
      "ID": 2242
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1870,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona",
      "DisplayName": "Shona Robison",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5293708+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2135E254P450VM234871",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234871,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1864,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02163",
      "ID": 2242
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2135,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Russell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.403335+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1895E232P431VM257408",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257408,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1864,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02163",
      "ID": 2242
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1895,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0549294+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228110",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 228110,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1864,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02163",
      "ID": 2242
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1839,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5847945+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2345E10P55VM291688",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291688,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1864,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02163",
      "ID": 2242
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2345,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1380313+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2223E176P333VM310685",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 310685,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1864,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02163",
      "ID": 2242
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2223,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish",
      "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5816403+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246331",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 246331,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1864,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02163",
      "ID": 2242
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2182,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1241197+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298330",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298330,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1864,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02163",
      "ID": 2242
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5079,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew",
      "DisplayName": "Drew Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3411051+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234362",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234362,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1864,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02163",
      "ID": 2242
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1769,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3740076+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4014E14P26VM269951",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269951,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1864,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02163",
      "ID": 2242
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4014,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz",
      "DisplayName": "Liz Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5749441+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269101",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269101,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1864,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02163",
      "ID": 2242
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2215,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.3036062+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317186",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317186,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1864,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02163",
      "ID": 2242
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3806,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.1853823+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326270",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 326270,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1864,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02163",
      "ID": 2242
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5106,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin",
      "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.751221+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241122",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241122,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1864,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02163",
      "ID": 2242
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1848,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola",
      "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.402955+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2098E237P531VM289601",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289601,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1864,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02163",
      "ID": 2242
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2098,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Swinney",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.451057+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2674E247P401VM247745",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247745,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1864,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02163",
      "ID": 2242
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2674,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave",
      "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4266016+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5075E234P371VM284863",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 284863,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1864,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02163",
      "ID": 2242
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5075,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Torrance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0509704+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1793E151P362VM222452",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 222452,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1864,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02163",
      "ID": 2242
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1793,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean",
      "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1895628+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5078E245P15VM307106",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307106,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1864,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02163",
      "ID": 2242
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5078,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Walker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5875254+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1841E231P426VM240155",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 240155,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1864,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02163",
      "ID": 2242
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1841,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen",
      "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7813259+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283415",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283415,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1864,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02163",
      "ID": 2242
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4952,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.699723+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1865E263P500VM232321",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232321,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1864,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02163",
      "ID": 2242
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1865,
      "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra",
      "DisplayName": "Sandra White",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8497709+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237808",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237808,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1864,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02163",
      "ID": 2242
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2610,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Wilson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2269639+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309285",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 309285,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1864,
      "AgendaID": 2365,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 86,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution",
      "Reference": "S4M-02163",
      "ID": 2242
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4941,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza",
      "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-03-14T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3227237+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252311",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252311,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1851,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087.2",
      "ID": 2182
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1926,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian",
      "DisplayName": "Brian Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7236705+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2615E213P388VM257571",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257571,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1851,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087.2",
      "ID": 2182
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2615,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George",
      "DisplayName": "George Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0622492+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319919",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319919,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1851,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087.2",
      "ID": 2182
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4940,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare",
      "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9470529+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249663",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 249663,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1851,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087.2",
      "ID": 2182
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2641,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair",
      "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9444992+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1783E21P273VM227724",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227724,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1851,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087.2",
      "ID": 2182
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1783,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie",
      "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5629237+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2633E97P136VM280414",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280414,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1851,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087.2",
      "ID": 2182
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2633,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire",
      "DisplayName": "Claire Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7659516+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262486",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262486,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1851,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087.2",
      "ID": 2182
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2603,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.604023+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1759E91P115VM229736",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229736,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1851,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087.2",
      "ID": 2182
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia",
      "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0944948+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270220",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270220,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1851,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087.2",
      "ID": 2182
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3751,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.7945003+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322690",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 322690,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1851,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087.2",
      "ID": 2182
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5109,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco",
      "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.699514+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5060E86P124VM294717",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 294717,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1851,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087.2",
      "ID": 2182
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5060,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.175303+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242834",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242834,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1851,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087.2",
      "ID": 2182
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1866,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah",
      "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0376197+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235592",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235592,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1851,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087.2",
      "ID": 2182
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1943,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic",
      "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6844264+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302144",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 302144,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1851,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087.2",
      "ID": 2182
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2595,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin",
      "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.299059+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244514",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244514,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1851,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087.2",
      "ID": 2182
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2103,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith",
      "DisplayName": "Keith Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5580718+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327370",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 327370,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1851,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087.2",
      "ID": 2182
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:46.0331966+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3775E216P435VM276669",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276669,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1851,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087.2",
      "ID": 2182
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6760622+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264348",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264348,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1851,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087.2",
      "ID": 2182
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2673,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick",
      "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1296265+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248826",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248826,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1851,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087.2",
      "ID": 2182
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2678,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson",
      "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.671715+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2123E27P233VM295850",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295850,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1851,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087.2",
      "ID": 2182
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2123,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm",
      "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.538525+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285147",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285147,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1851,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087.2",
      "ID": 2182
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3907,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0684629+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230162",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230162,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1851,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087.2",
      "ID": 2182
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1735,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela",
      "DisplayName": "Angela Constance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.1188998+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243886",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 243886,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1851,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087.2",
      "ID": 2182
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1932,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce",
      "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3241387+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254944",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254944,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1851,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087.2",
      "ID": 2182
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1863,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna",
      "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2905093+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4976E20P31VM324005",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324005,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1851,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087.2",
      "ID": 2182
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4976,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth",
      "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9818789+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5107E223P379VM291385",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291385,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1851,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087.2",
      "ID": 2182
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5107,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1170282+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3743E222P391VM265318",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265318,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1851,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087.2",
      "ID": 2182
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3743,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel",
      "DisplayName": "Nigel Don",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.434009+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3771E149P417VM261735",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261735,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1851,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087.2",
      "ID": 2182
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3771,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob",
      "DisplayName": "Bob Doris",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3705663+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2826E262P384VM282017",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 282017,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1851,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087.2",
      "ID": 2182
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2826,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Dornan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.16762+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3812E94P117VM297956",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 297956,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1851,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087.2",
      "ID": 2182
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3812,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia",
      "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1321454+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231608",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231608,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1851,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087.2",
      "ID": 2182
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1778,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen",
      "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6079317+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4955E240P389VM285982",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285982,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1851,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087.2",
      "ID": 2182
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4955,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3528933+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219338",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 219338,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1851,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087.2",
      "ID": 2182
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1742,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle",
      "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.2942876+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238619",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 238619,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1851,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087.2",
      "ID": 2182
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1994,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus",
      "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4619056+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225468",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225468,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1851,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087.2",
      "ID": 2182
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1814,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda",
      "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9760251+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321770",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 321770,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1851,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087.2",
      "ID": 2182
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Fee",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4506476+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1853E35P216VM293250",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 293250,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1851,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087.2",
      "ID": 2182
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia",
      "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8368777+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1892E12P64VM226905",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 226905,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1851,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087.2",
      "ID": 2182
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2517763+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5054E95P118VM312660",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 312660,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1851,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087.2",
      "ID": 2182
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5054,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1378696+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4947E152P361VM257157",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257157,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1851,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087.2",
      "ID": 2182
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4947,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Finnie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.8257536+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271338",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271338,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1851,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087.2",
      "ID": 2182
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3901,
      "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe",
      "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0712009+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278461",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 278461,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1851,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087.2",
      "ID": 2182
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2394,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo",
      "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2198142+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2110E220P414VM286732",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286732,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1851,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087.2",
      "ID": 2182
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth",
      "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5983247+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250435",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250435,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1851,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087.2",
      "ID": 2182
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2675,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob",
      "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1894171+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1741E10P50VM220747",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220747,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1851,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087.2",
      "ID": 2182
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1741,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel",
      "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6552893+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220307",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220307,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1851,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087.2",
      "ID": 2182
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1756,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine",
      "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6356811+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1860E104P150VM252321",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252321,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1851,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087.2",
      "ID": 2182
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1860,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda",
      "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7241015+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2033E20P141VM266147",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 266147,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1851,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087.2",
      "ID": 2182
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2033,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain",
      "DisplayName": "Iain Gray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4763568+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324428",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324428,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1851,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087.2",
      "ID": 2182
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5042,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2222274+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259928",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 259928,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1851,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087.2",
      "ID": 2182
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick",
      "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6360798+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239278",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239278,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1851,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087.2",
      "ID": 2182
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2029,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh",
      "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.729885+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273819",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 273819,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1851,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087.2",
      "ID": 2182
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3758,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6370223+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304185",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 304185,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1851,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087.2",
      "ID": 2182
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4086,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Hume",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8536118+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221792",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221792,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1851,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087.2",
      "ID": 2182
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1773,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9480042+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1882E227P459VM242026",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242026,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1851,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087.2",
      "ID": 2182
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1882,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam",
      "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7906175+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223750",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223750,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1851,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087.2",
      "ID": 2182
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1893,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4721717+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307540",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307540,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1851,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087.2",
      "ID": 2182
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4934,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8339235+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272174",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 272174,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1851,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087.2",
      "ID": 2182
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4956,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Keir",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.1147642+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244841",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244841,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1851,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087.2",
      "ID": 2182
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Kelly",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5809289+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315013",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315013,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1851,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087.2",
      "ID": 2182
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3129,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6703276+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247990",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247990,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1851,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087.2",
      "ID": 2182
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann",
      "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4370194+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4016E11P36VM274748",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274748,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1851,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087.2",
      "ID": 2182
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4016,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1200236+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255840",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255840,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1851,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087.2",
      "ID": 2182
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2180,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.559297+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4938E158P374VM277806",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277806,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1851,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087.2",
      "ID": 2182
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4938,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9692172+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2112E250P486VM252972",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252972,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1851,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087.2",
      "ID": 2182
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2112,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny",
      "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7611364+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4939E258P394VM277201",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277201,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1851,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087.2",
      "ID": 2182
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4939,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus",
      "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9379958+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325703",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 325703,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1851,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087.2",
      "ID": 2182
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5074,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon",
      "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5176425+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1828E3P10VM232825",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232825,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1851,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087.2",
      "ID": 2182
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1828,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo",
      "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8778453+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311387",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311387,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1851,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087.2",
      "ID": 2182
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4948,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike",
      "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8765321+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2117E90P107VM230461",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230461,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1851,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087.2",
      "ID": 2182
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2117,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis",
      "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3309074+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267324",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 267324,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1851,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087.2",
      "ID": 2182
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken",
      "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0145206+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313774",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313774,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1851,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087.2",
      "ID": 2182
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4966,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek",
      "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4100929+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3101E102P129VM295426",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295426,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1851,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087.2",
      "ID": 2182
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3101,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala",
      "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5116595+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319020",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319020,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1851,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087.2",
      "ID": 2182
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5034,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny",
      "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6889805+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306474",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306474,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1851,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087.2",
      "ID": 2182
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2159,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Martin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5536258+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5110E252P395VM311250",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311250,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1851,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087.2",
      "ID": 2182
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Mason",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8705613+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268280",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 268280,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1851,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087.2",
      "ID": 2182
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2133,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2602968+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2876E141P433VM286135",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286135,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1851,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087.2",
      "ID": 2182
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2876,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.365375+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4951E147P368VM260710",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 260710,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1851,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087.2",
      "ID": 2182
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4951,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan",
      "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.0889258+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3896E175P307VM264095",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264095,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1851,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087.2",
      "ID": 2182
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3896,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam",
      "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9239843+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308079",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 308079,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1851,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087.2",
      "ID": 2182
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8637935+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4964E143P375VM279308",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279308,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1851,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087.2",
      "ID": 2182
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4964,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.4964774+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3824E84P113VM280001",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280001,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1851,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087.2",
      "ID": 2182
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3824,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5321173+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2066E22P91VM261766",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261766,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1851,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087.2",
      "ID": 2182
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2066,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.371893+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299707",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 299707,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1851,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087.2",
      "ID": 2182
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7191598+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306575",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306575,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1851,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087.2",
      "ID": 2182
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina",
      "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.557951+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2487E146P369VM301220",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 301220,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1851,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087.2",
      "ID": 2182
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2487,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.252492+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223652",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223652,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1851,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087.2",
      "ID": 2182
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4679912+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237450",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237450,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1851,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087.2",
      "ID": 2182
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1961,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David",
      "DisplayName": "David McLetchie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2110696+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2134E34P201VM297840",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 297840,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1851,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087.2",
      "ID": 2182
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2134,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.12726+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320406",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 320406,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1851,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087.2",
      "ID": 2182
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5041,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan",
      "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1650492+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3763E142P397VM316069",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 316069,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1851,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087.2",
      "ID": 2182
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3763,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart",
      "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.944834+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1986E23P197VM236300",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 236300,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1851,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087.2",
      "ID": 2182
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1986,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan",
      "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9104574+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5047E100P130VM291434",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291434,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1851,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087.2",
      "ID": 2182
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5047,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne",
      "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.119157+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234615",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234615,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1851,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087.2",
      "ID": 2182
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1845,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette",
      "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.391943+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313639",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313639,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1851,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087.2",
      "ID": 2182
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3061,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4040589+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1768E19P265VM288559",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 288559,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1851,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087.2",
      "ID": 2182
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1768,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.148616+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225035",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225035,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1851,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087.2",
      "ID": 2182
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1894,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Neil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.741737+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3815E98P134VM270873",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270873,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1851,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087.2",
      "ID": 2182
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3815,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Park, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Park",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8267934+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265901",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265901,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1851,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087.2",
      "ID": 2182
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2010,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil",
      "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4654603+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283532",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283532,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1851,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087.2",
      "ID": 2182
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5057,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7119653+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2853E33P128VM251413",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251413,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1851,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087.2",
      "ID": 2182
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Pentland",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4625202+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317626",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317626,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1851,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087.2",
      "ID": 2182
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5009,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4305105+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254728",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254728,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1851,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087.2",
      "ID": 2182
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3745,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis",
      "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2811803+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1870E225P478VM295618",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295618,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1851,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087.2",
      "ID": 2182
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1870,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona",
      "DisplayName": "Shona Robison",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.528571+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2135E254P450VM234856",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234856,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1851,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087.2",
      "ID": 2182
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2135,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Russell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4026974+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1895E232P431VM257398",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257398,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1851,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087.2",
      "ID": 2182
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1895,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0544944+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228090",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 228090,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1851,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087.2",
      "ID": 2182
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1839,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5839241+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2345E10P55VM291699",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291699,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1851,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087.2",
      "ID": 2182
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2345,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1384949+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2223E176P333VM310670",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 310670,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1851,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087.2",
      "ID": 2182
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2223,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish",
      "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5809826+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246004",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 246004,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1851,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087.2",
      "ID": 2182
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2182,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8680734+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298341",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298341,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1851,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087.2",
      "ID": 2182
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5079,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew",
      "DisplayName": "Drew Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3415776+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234375",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234375,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1851,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087.2",
      "ID": 2182
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1769,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3745647+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4014E14P26VM269936",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269936,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1851,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087.2",
      "ID": 2182
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4014,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz",
      "DisplayName": "Liz Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5742281+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269181",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269181,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1851,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087.2",
      "ID": 2182
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2215,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.3071917+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317171",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317171,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1851,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087.2",
      "ID": 2182
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3806,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.1847489+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326127",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 326127,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1851,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087.2",
      "ID": 2182
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5106,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin",
      "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5410279+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241102",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241102,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1851,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087.2",
      "ID": 2182
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1848,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola",
      "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3961641+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2098E237P531VM289586",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289586,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1851,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087.2",
      "ID": 2182
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2098,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Swinney",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4504343+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2674E247P401VM247730",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247730,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1851,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087.2",
      "ID": 2182
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2674,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave",
      "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4259532+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5075E234P371VM284848",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 284848,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1851,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087.2",
      "ID": 2182
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5075,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Torrance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0503294+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1793E151P362VM222436",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 222436,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1851,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087.2",
      "ID": 2182
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1793,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean",
      "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1888829+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5078E245P366VM307124",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307124,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1851,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087.2",
      "ID": 2182
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5078,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Walker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5883103+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1841E231P426VM240176",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 240176,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1851,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087.2",
      "ID": 2182
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1841,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen",
      "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7822399+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283399",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283399,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1851,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087.2",
      "ID": 2182
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4952,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.6990227+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1865E263P500VM232240",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232240,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1851,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087.2",
      "ID": 2182
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1865,
      "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra",
      "DisplayName": "Sandra White",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8461887+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237823",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237823,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1851,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087.2",
      "ID": 2182
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2610,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Wilson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2276057+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309298",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 309298,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1851,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087.2",
      "ID": 2182
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4941,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza",
      "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3232966+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252312",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252312,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1852,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087",
      "ID": 2159
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1926,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian",
      "DisplayName": "Brian Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7237119+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2615E213P388VM258808",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258808,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1852,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087",
      "ID": 2159
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2615,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George",
      "DisplayName": "George Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3288032+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319917",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319917,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1852,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087",
      "ID": 2159
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4940,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare",
      "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9469701+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249662",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 249662,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1852,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087",
      "ID": 2159
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2641,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair",
      "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9444588+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1783E21P273VM227725",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227725,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1852,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087",
      "ID": 2159
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1783,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie",
      "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5629641+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2633E97P136VM280415",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280415,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1852,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087",
      "ID": 2159
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2633,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire",
      "DisplayName": "Claire Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.765993+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262487",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262487,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1852,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087",
      "ID": 2159
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2603,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6040638+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1759E91P115VM229737",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229737,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1852,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087",
      "ID": 2159
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia",
      "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0945378+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270219",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270219,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1852,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087",
      "ID": 2159
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3751,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.7944572+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322691",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 322691,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1852,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087",
      "ID": 2159
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5109,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco",
      "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6995546+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5060E86P124VM294718",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 294718,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1852,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087",
      "ID": 2159
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5060,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1753449+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242835",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242835,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1852,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087",
      "ID": 2159
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1866,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah",
      "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0376605+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235591",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235591,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1852,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087",
      "ID": 2159
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1943,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic",
      "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6843856+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302145",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 302145,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1852,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087",
      "ID": 2159
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2595,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin",
      "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.2991109+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244513",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244513,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1852,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087",
      "ID": 2159
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2103,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith",
      "DisplayName": "Keith Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5580292+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327372",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 327372,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1852,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087",
      "ID": 2159
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:46.0333775+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3775E216P435VM276670",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276670,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1852,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087",
      "ID": 2159
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6761217+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264347",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264347,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1852,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087",
      "ID": 2159
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2673,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick",
      "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1295857+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248825",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248825,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1852,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087",
      "ID": 2159
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2678,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson",
      "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6716728+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2123E27P233VM295848",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295848,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1852,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087",
      "ID": 2159
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2123,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm",
      "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5384449+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285148",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285148,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1852,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087",
      "ID": 2159
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3907,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0685042+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230163",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230163,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1852,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087",
      "ID": 2159
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1735,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela",
      "DisplayName": "Angela Constance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.1189414+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243884",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 243884,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1852,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087",
      "ID": 2159
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1932,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce",
      "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3240505+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254943",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254943,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1852,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087",
      "ID": 2159
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1863,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna",
      "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2904686+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4976E20P31VM324007",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324007,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1852,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087",
      "ID": 2159
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4976,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth",
      "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9819817+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5107E223P379VM291384",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291384,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1852,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087",
      "ID": 2159
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5107,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1169861+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3743E222P391VM265319",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265319,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1852,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087",
      "ID": 2159
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3743,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel",
      "DisplayName": "Nigel Don",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4340517+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3771E149P417VM261736",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261736,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1852,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087",
      "ID": 2159
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3771,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob",
      "DisplayName": "Bob Doris",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3706072+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2826E262P384VM282016",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 282016,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1852,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087",
      "ID": 2159
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2826,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Dornan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1675791+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3812E94P117VM297957",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 297957,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1852,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087",
      "ID": 2159
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3812,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia",
      "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1321856+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231607",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231607,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1852,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087",
      "ID": 2159
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1778,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen",
      "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.607891+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4955E240P389VM285981",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285981,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1852,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087",
      "ID": 2159
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4955,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3528527+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219339",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 219339,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1852,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087",
      "ID": 2159
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1742,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle",
      "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.2943296+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238618",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 238618,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1852,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087",
      "ID": 2159
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1994,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus",
      "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.461864+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225467",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225467,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1852,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087",
      "ID": 2159
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1814,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda",
      "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9759834+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321769",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 321769,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1852,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087",
      "ID": 2159
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Fee",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4506073+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1853E35P216VM293249",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 293249,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1852,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087",
      "ID": 2159
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia",
      "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8368362+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1892E12P64VM226906",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 226906,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1852,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087",
      "ID": 2159
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2518177+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5054E95P118VM312661",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 312661,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1852,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087",
      "ID": 2159
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5054,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1379104+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4947E152P361VM257158",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257158,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1852,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087",
      "ID": 2159
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4947,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Finnie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.8257946+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271337",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271337,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1852,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087",
      "ID": 2159
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3901,
      "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe",
      "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0711599+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278460",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 278460,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1852,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087",
      "ID": 2159
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2394,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo",
      "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2197726+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2110E220P414VM286733",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286733,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1852,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087",
      "ID": 2159
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth",
      "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.598384+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250436",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250436,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1852,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087",
      "ID": 2159
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2675,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob",
      "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1894589+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1741E10P50VM220748",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220748,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1852,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087",
      "ID": 2159
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1741,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel",
      "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6553304+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220306",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220306,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1852,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087",
      "ID": 2159
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1756,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine",
      "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6356388+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1860E104P150VM252322",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252322,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1852,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087",
      "ID": 2159
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1860,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda",
      "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7241428+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2033E20P141VM266146",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 266146,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1852,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087",
      "ID": 2159
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2033,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain",
      "DisplayName": "Iain Gray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4762976+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324426",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324426,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1852,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087",
      "ID": 2159
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5042,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2221454+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259927",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 259927,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1852,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087",
      "ID": 2159
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick",
      "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6360379+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239279",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239279,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1852,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087",
      "ID": 2159
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2029,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh",
      "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7299258+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273818",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 273818,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1852,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087",
      "ID": 2159
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3758,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.636981+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304184",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 304184,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1852,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087",
      "ID": 2159
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4086,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Hume",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8535594+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221791",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221791,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1852,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087",
      "ID": 2159
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1773,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9479633+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1882E227P459VM242025",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242025,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1852,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087",
      "ID": 2159
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1882,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam",
      "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7905765+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223749",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223749,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1852,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087",
      "ID": 2159
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1893,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4721112+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307541",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307541,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1852,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087",
      "ID": 2159
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4934,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8339648+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272175",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 272175,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1852,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087",
      "ID": 2159
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4956,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Keir",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.1148053+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244843",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244843,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1852,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087",
      "ID": 2159
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Kelly",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5810105+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315015",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315015,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1852,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087",
      "ID": 2159
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3129,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6704095+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247989",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247989,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1852,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087",
      "ID": 2159
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann",
      "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4369777+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4016E11P36VM274749",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274749,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1852,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087",
      "ID": 2159
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4016,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1200654+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255839",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255839,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1852,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087",
      "ID": 2159
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2180,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5592562+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4938E158P374VM277805",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277805,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1852,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087",
      "ID": 2159
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4938,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9691761+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2112E250P486VM252973",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252973,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1852,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087",
      "ID": 2159
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2112,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny",
      "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7611768+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4939E258P394VM277200",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277200,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1852,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087",
      "ID": 2159
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4939,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus",
      "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9379528+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325705",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 325705,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1852,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087",
      "ID": 2159
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5074,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon",
      "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.517723+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1828E3P10VM232826",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232826,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1852,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087",
      "ID": 2159
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1828,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo",
      "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8778858+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311388",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311388,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1852,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087",
      "ID": 2159
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4948,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike",
      "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8765735+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2117E90P107VM230460",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230460,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1852,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087",
      "ID": 2159
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2117,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis",
      "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3308657+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267325",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 267325,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1852,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087",
      "ID": 2159
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken",
      "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0145617+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313773",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313773,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1852,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087",
      "ID": 2159
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4966,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek",
      "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4100515+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3101E102P129VM295425",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295425,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1852,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087",
      "ID": 2159
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3101,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala",
      "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5116192+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319019",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319019,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1852,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087",
      "ID": 2159
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5034,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny",
      "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6889395+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306472",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306472,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1852,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087",
      "ID": 2159
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2159,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Martin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5535441+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5110E252P395VM311249",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311249,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1852,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087",
      "ID": 2159
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Mason",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8705197+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268279",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 268279,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1852,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087",
      "ID": 2159
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2133,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2602547+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2876E141P433VM286136",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286136,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1852,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087",
      "ID": 2159
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2876,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3654236+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4951E147P368VM260709",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 260709,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1852,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087",
      "ID": 2159
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4951,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan",
      "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.0888837+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3896E175P307VM264094",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264094,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1852,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087",
      "ID": 2159
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3896,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam",
      "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9239431+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308080",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 308080,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1852,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087",
      "ID": 2159
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8638358+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4964E143P375VM279309",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279309,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1852,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087",
      "ID": 2159
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4964,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.4965191+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3824E84P113VM280000",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280000,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1852,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087",
      "ID": 2159
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3824,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5320531+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2066E22P91VM261764",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261764,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1852,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087",
      "ID": 2159
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2066,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3718102+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299706",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 299706,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1852,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087",
      "ID": 2159
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7191196+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306576",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306576,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1852,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087",
      "ID": 2159
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina",
      "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5579937+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2487E146P369VM301219",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 301219,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1852,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087",
      "ID": 2159
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2487,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.2524502+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223653",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223653,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1852,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087",
      "ID": 2159
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4680321+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237451",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237451,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1852,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087",
      "ID": 2159
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1961,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David",
      "DisplayName": "David McLetchie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2111533+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2134E34P201VM297842",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 297842,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1852,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087",
      "ID": 2159
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2134,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1273407+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320407",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 320407,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1852,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087",
      "ID": 2159
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5041,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan",
      "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.16509+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3763E142P397VM316067",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 316067,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1852,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087",
      "ID": 2159
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3763,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart",
      "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9447505+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1986E23P197VM236301",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 236301,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1852,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087",
      "ID": 2159
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1986,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan",
      "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9105+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5047E100P130VM291433",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291433,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1852,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087",
      "ID": 2159
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5047,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne",
      "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1190974+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234614",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234614,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1852,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087",
      "ID": 2159
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1845,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette",
      "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3919006+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313637",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313637,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1852,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087",
      "ID": 2159
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3061,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4039769+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1768E19P265VM288560",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 288560,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1852,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087",
      "ID": 2159
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1768,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1486567+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225036",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225036,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1852,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087",
      "ID": 2159
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1894,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Neil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7417775+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3815E98P134VM270874",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270874,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1852,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087",
      "ID": 2159
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3815,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Park, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Park",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8268353+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265900",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265900,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1852,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087",
      "ID": 2159
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2010,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil",
      "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4654174+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283531",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283531,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1852,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087",
      "ID": 2159
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5057,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7119221+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2853E33P128VM251414",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251414,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1852,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087",
      "ID": 2159
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Pentland",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4625618+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317627",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317627,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1852,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087",
      "ID": 2159
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5009,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4305509+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254727",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254727,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1852,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087",
      "ID": 2159
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3745,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis",
      "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2811393+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1870E225P478VM295619",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295619,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1852,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087",
      "ID": 2159
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1870,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona",
      "DisplayName": "Shona Robison",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5286493+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2135E254P450VM234857",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234857,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1852,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087",
      "ID": 2159
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2135,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Russell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4027388+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1895E232P431VM257399",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257399,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1852,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087",
      "ID": 2159
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1895,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0545361+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228091",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 228091,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1852,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087",
      "ID": 2159
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1839,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5839726+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2345E10P55VM291698",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291698,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1852,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087",
      "ID": 2159
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2345,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1384547+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2223E176P333VM310672",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 310672,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1852,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087",
      "ID": 2159
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2223,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish",
      "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5810847+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246005",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 246005,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1852,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087",
      "ID": 2159
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2182,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8681144+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298340",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298340,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1852,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087",
      "ID": 2159
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5079,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew",
      "DisplayName": "Drew Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3415357+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234374",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234374,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1852,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087",
      "ID": 2159
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1769,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3745233+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4014E14P26VM269937",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269937,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1852,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087",
      "ID": 2159
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4014,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz",
      "DisplayName": "Liz Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5742699+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269182",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269182,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1852,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087",
      "ID": 2159
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2215,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.3072327+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317173",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317173,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1852,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087",
      "ID": 2159
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3806,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.1848319+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326125",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 326125,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1852,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087",
      "ID": 2159
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5106,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin",
      "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5409458+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241103",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241103,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1852,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087",
      "ID": 2159
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1848,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola",
      "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3962065+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2098E237P531VM289588",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289588,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1852,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087",
      "ID": 2159
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2098,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Swinney",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4505147+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2674E247P401VM247731",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247731,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1852,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087",
      "ID": 2159
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2674,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave",
      "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4259941+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5075E234P371VM284849",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 284849,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1852,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087",
      "ID": 2159
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5075,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Torrance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0503694+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1793E151P362VM222437",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 222437,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1852,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087",
      "ID": 2159
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1793,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean",
      "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1889239+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5078E245P366VM307123",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307123,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1852,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087",
      "ID": 2159
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5078,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Walker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5882689+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1841E231P426VM240175",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 240175,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1852,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087",
      "ID": 2159
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1841,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen",
      "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7821803+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283400",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283400,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1852,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087",
      "ID": 2159
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4952,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.6990641+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1865E263P500VM232239",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232239,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1852,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087",
      "ID": 2159
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1865,
      "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra",
      "DisplayName": "Sandra White",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.846147+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237822",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237822,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1852,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087",
      "ID": 2159
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2610,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Wilson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2275656+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309297",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 309297,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1852,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Withdrawal of Road Equivalent Tariff from Commercial Vehicles",
      "Reference": "S4M-02087",
      "ID": 2159
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4941,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza",
      "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3232373+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252271",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252271,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1856,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086.1",
      "ID": 2183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1926,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian",
      "DisplayName": "Brian Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7217276+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2615E213P388VM257569",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257569,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1856,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086.1",
      "ID": 2183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2615,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George",
      "DisplayName": "George Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0621673+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319921",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319921,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1856,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086.1",
      "ID": 2183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4940,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare",
      "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.947135+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249665",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 249665,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1856,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086.1",
      "ID": 2183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2641,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair",
      "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9445788+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1783E21P273VM227378",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227378,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1856,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086.1",
      "ID": 2183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1783,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie",
      "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.547577+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2633E97P136VM280373",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280373,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1856,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086.1",
      "ID": 2183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2633,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire",
      "DisplayName": "Claire Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7579371+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262484",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262484,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1856,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086.1",
      "ID": 2183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2603,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6039405+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1759E91P115VM229734",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229734,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1856,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086.1",
      "ID": 2183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia",
      "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0943501+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270222",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270222,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1856,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086.1",
      "ID": 2183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3751,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.7945852+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322833",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 322833,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1856,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086.1",
      "ID": 2183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5109,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco",
      "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.7055344+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5060E86P124VM294715",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 294715,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1856,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086.1",
      "ID": 2183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5060,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1752205+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242832",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242832,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1856,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086.1",
      "ID": 2183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1866,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah",
      "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0375173+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235594",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235594,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1856,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086.1",
      "ID": 2183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1943,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic",
      "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6845075+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302142",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 302142,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1856,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086.1",
      "ID": 2183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2595,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin",
      "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.298935+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244516",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244516,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1856,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086.1",
      "ID": 2183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2103,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith",
      "DisplayName": "Keith Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5581537+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327368",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 327368,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1856,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086.1",
      "ID": 2183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:46.0330012+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3775E216P435VM276667",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276667,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1856,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086.1",
      "ID": 2183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6759809+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264350",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264350,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1856,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086.1",
      "ID": 2183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2673,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick",
      "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1297276+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248828",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248828,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1856,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086.1",
      "ID": 2183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2678,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson",
      "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6717962+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2123E27P233VM295852",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295852,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1856,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086.1",
      "ID": 2183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2123,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm",
      "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5386054+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285145",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285145,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1856,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086.1",
      "ID": 2183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3907,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.068382+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230160",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230160,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1856,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086.1",
      "ID": 2183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1735,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela",
      "DisplayName": "Angela Constance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.1188175+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243888",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 243888,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1856,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086.1",
      "ID": 2183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1932,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce",
      "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.324222+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254946",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254946,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1856,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086.1",
      "ID": 2183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1863,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna",
      "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2905913+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4976E20P31VM324003",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324003,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1856,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086.1",
      "ID": 2183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4976,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth",
      "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9817958+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5107E223P379VM291387",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291387,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1856,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086.1",
      "ID": 2183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5107,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1171103+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3743E222P391VM265316",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265316,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1856,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086.1",
      "ID": 2183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3743,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel",
      "DisplayName": "Nigel Don",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4339068+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3771E149P417VM261733",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261733,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1856,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086.1",
      "ID": 2183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3771,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob",
      "DisplayName": "Bob Doris",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3704841+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2826E262P384VM282057",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 282057,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1856,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086.1",
      "ID": 2183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2826,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Dornan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1737682+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3812E94P117VM297914",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 297914,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1856,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086.1",
      "ID": 2183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3812,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia",
      "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1303731+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231610",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231610,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1856,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086.1",
      "ID": 2183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1778,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen",
      "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6080317+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4955E240P389VM285984",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285984,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1856,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086.1",
      "ID": 2183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4955,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3529748+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219336",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 219336,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1856,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086.1",
      "ID": 2183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1742,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle",
      "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.2942057+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238621",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 238621,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1856,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086.1",
      "ID": 2183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1994,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus",
      "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4619852+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225470",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225470,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1856,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086.1",
      "ID": 2183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1814,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda",
      "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9761067+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321627",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 321627,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1856,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086.1",
      "ID": 2183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Fee",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4442312+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1853E35P216VM293252",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 293252,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1856,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086.1",
      "ID": 2183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia",
      "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8369602+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1892E12P64VM226903",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 226903,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1856,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086.1",
      "ID": 2183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2516923+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5054E95P118VM312658",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 312658,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1856,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086.1",
      "ID": 2183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5054,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1377885+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4947E152P361VM257155",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257155,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1856,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086.1",
      "ID": 2183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4947,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Finnie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.8256705+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271340",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271340,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1856,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086.1",
      "ID": 2183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3901,
      "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe",
      "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0713405+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278502",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 278502,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1856,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086.1",
      "ID": 2183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2394,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo",
      "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2216427+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2110E220P414VM286730",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286730,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1856,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086.1",
      "ID": 2183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth",
      "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5982438+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250433",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250433,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1856,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086.1",
      "ID": 2183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2675,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob",
      "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.189335+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1741E10P50VM220745",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220745,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1856,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086.1",
      "ID": 2183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1741,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel",
      "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6552074+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220309",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220309,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1856,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086.1",
      "ID": 2183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1756,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine",
      "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6357629+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1860E104P150VM251857",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251857,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1856,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086.1",
      "ID": 2183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1860,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda",
      "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4921272+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2033E20P141VM266186",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 266186,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1856,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086.1",
      "ID": 2183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2033,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain",
      "DisplayName": "Iain Gray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4780461+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324430",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324430,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1856,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086.1",
      "ID": 2183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5042,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.222309+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259930",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 259930,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1856,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086.1",
      "ID": 2183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick",
      "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6361631+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239276",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239276,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1856,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086.1",
      "ID": 2183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2029,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh",
      "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7298032+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273821",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 273821,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1856,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086.1",
      "ID": 2183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3758,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6371249+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304187",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 304187,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1856,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086.1",
      "ID": 2183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4086,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Hume",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8537118+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221794",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221794,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1856,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086.1",
      "ID": 2183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1773,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9480871+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1882E227P459VM242028",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242028,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1856,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086.1",
      "ID": 2183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1882,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam",
      "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7907198+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223752",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223752,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1856,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086.1",
      "ID": 2183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1893,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4722541+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307498",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307498,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1856,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086.1",
      "ID": 2183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4934,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8321123+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272172",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 272172,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1856,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086.1",
      "ID": 2183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4956,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Keir",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.1146811+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244839",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244839,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1856,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086.1",
      "ID": 2183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Kelly",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5808472+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315011",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315011,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1856,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086.1",
      "ID": 2183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3129,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6702449+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247992",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247992,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1856,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086.1",
      "ID": 2183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann",
      "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4371188+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4016E11P36VM274746",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274746,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1856,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086.1",
      "ID": 2183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4016,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1199419+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255842",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255842,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1856,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086.1",
      "ID": 2183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2180,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5593953+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4938E158P374VM277808",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277808,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1856,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086.1",
      "ID": 2183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4938,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9693187+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2112E250P486VM252970",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252970,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1856,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086.1",
      "ID": 2183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2112,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny",
      "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7610551+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4939E258P394VM277203",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277203,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1856,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086.1",
      "ID": 2183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4939,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus",
      "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9381196+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325701",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 325701,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1856,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086.1",
      "ID": 2183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5074,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon",
      "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5175615+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1828E3P10VM232823",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232823,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1856,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086.1",
      "ID": 2183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1828,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo",
      "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8777646+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311344",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311344,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1856,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086.1",
      "ID": 2183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4948,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike",
      "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8746656+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2117E90P107VM230463",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230463,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1856,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086.1",
      "ID": 2183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2117,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis",
      "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3310142+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267285",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 267285,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1856,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086.1",
      "ID": 2183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken",
      "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.012846+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313817",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313817,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1856,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086.1",
      "ID": 2183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4966,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek",
      "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4119324+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3101E102P129VM295468",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295468,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1856,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086.1",
      "ID": 2183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3101,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala",
      "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5134473+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5034E88P114VM318877",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 318877,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1856,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086.1",
      "ID": 2183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5034,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny",
      "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6773329+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306476",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306476,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1856,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086.1",
      "ID": 2183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2159,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Martin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5537067+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5110E252P395VM311252",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311252,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1856,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086.1",
      "ID": 2183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Mason",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8706445+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268319",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 268319,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1856,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086.1",
      "ID": 2183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2133,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2619789+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2876E141P433VM286094",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286094,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1856,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086.1",
      "ID": 2183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2876,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3634024+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4951E147P368VM260712",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 260712,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1856,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086.1",
      "ID": 2183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4951,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan",
      "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.0890276+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3896E175P307VM264097",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264097,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1856,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086.1",
      "ID": 2183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3896,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam",
      "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9240664+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308077",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 308077,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1856,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086.1",
      "ID": 2183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8637096+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4964E143P375VM279306",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279306,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1856,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086.1",
      "ID": 2183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4964,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.4963866+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3824E84P113VM280003",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280003,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1856,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086.1",
      "ID": 2183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3824,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5322048+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2066E22P91VM261768",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261768,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1856,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086.1",
      "ID": 2183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2066,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3719754+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299749",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 299749,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1856,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086.1",
      "ID": 2183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7209725+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306573",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306573,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1856,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086.1",
      "ID": 2183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina",
      "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5578684+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2487E146P369VM301222",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 301222,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1856,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086.1",
      "ID": 2183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2487,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.2525761+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223650",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223650,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1856,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086.1",
      "ID": 2183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4679079+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237448",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237448,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1856,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086.1",
      "ID": 2183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1961,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David",
      "DisplayName": "David McLetchie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2046436+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2134E34P201VM297838",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 297838,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1856,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086.1",
      "ID": 2183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2134,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1271792+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320704",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 320704,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1856,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086.1",
      "ID": 2183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5041,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan",
      "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1778678+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3763E142P397VM316071",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 316071,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1856,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086.1",
      "ID": 2183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3763,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart",
      "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9449157+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1986E23P197VM236298",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 236298,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1856,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086.1",
      "ID": 2183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1986,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan",
      "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9103743+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5047E100P130VM291436",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291436,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1856,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086.1",
      "ID": 2183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5047,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne",
      "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1192409+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234617",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234617,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1856,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086.1",
      "ID": 2183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1845,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette",
      "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.392046+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313641",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313641,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1856,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086.1",
      "ID": 2183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3061,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4041413+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1768E19P265VM288557",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 288557,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1856,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086.1",
      "ID": 2183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1768,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1485339+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225033",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225033,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1856,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086.1",
      "ID": 2183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1894,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Neil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7416563+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3815E98P134VM270871",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270871,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1856,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086.1",
      "ID": 2183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3815,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Park, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Park",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8267115+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265903",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265903,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1856,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086.1",
      "ID": 2183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2010,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil",
      "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4655426+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283534",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283534,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1856,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086.1",
      "ID": 2183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5057,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7120466+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2853E33P128VM251411",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251411,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1856,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086.1",
      "ID": 2183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Pentland",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4624369+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317923",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317923,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1856,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086.1",
      "ID": 2183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5009,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4432991+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254730",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254730,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1856,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086.1",
      "ID": 2183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3745,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis",
      "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2812848+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1870E225P478VM295616",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295616,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1856,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086.1",
      "ID": 2183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1870,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona",
      "DisplayName": "Shona Robison",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5284867+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2135E254P450VM234854",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234854,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1856,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086.1",
      "ID": 2183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2135,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Russell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4026144+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1895E232P431VM257396",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257396,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1856,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086.1",
      "ID": 2183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1895,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0543922+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228088",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 228088,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1856,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086.1",
      "ID": 2183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1839,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5838415+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2345E10P55VM291701",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291701,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1856,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086.1",
      "ID": 2183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2345,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1385749+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2223E176P333VM310668",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 310668,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1856,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086.1",
      "ID": 2183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2223,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish",
      "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5809002+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246002",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 246002,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1856,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086.1",
      "ID": 2183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2182,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8679916+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298343",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298343,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1856,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086.1",
      "ID": 2183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5079,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew",
      "DisplayName": "Drew Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3416595+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234377",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234377,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1856,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086.1",
      "ID": 2183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1769,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3746459+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4014E14P26VM269934",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269934,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1856,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086.1",
      "ID": 2183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4014,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz",
      "DisplayName": "Liz Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5741463+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269141",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269141,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1856,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086.1",
      "ID": 2183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2215,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.3054227+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317169",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317169,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1856,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086.1",
      "ID": 2183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3806,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.1846663+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326129",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 326129,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1856,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086.1",
      "ID": 2183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5106,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin",
      "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5411317+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241100",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241100,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1856,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086.1",
      "ID": 2183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1848,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola",
      "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3960817+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2098E237P531VM289584",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289584,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1856,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086.1",
      "ID": 2183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2098,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Swinney",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4503323+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2674E247P401VM247728",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247728,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1856,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086.1",
      "ID": 2183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2674,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave",
      "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4258717+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5075E234P371VM284846",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 284846,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1856,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086.1",
      "ID": 2183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5075,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Torrance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0502482+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1793E151P362VM222434",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 222434,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1856,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086.1",
      "ID": 2183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1793,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean",
      "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.188797+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5078E245P366VM307126",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307126,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1856,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086.1",
      "ID": 2183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5078,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Walker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5883925+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1841E231P426VM240178",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 240178,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1856,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086.1",
      "ID": 2183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1841,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen",
      "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7823228+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283397",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283397,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1856,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086.1",
      "ID": 2183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4952,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.6989401+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1865E263P500VM232280",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232280,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1856,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086.1",
      "ID": 2183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1865,
      "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra",
      "DisplayName": "Sandra White",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8479357+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237825",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237825,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1856,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086.1",
      "ID": 2183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2610,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Wilson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2276869+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309340",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 309340,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1856,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086.1",
      "ID": 2183
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4941,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza",
      "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3250807+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252278",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252278,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1857,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086",
      "ID": 2158
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1926,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian",
      "DisplayName": "Brian Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7221318+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2615E213P388VM257570",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257570,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1857,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086",
      "ID": 2158
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2615,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George",
      "DisplayName": "George Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0622079+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319920",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319920,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1857,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086",
      "ID": 2158
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4940,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare",
      "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9470944+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249664",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 249664,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1857,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086",
      "ID": 2158
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2641,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair",
      "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.944539+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1783E21P273VM227385",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227385,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1857,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086",
      "ID": 2158
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1783,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie",
      "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5478864+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2633E97P136VM280413",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280413,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1857,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086",
      "ID": 2158
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2633,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire",
      "DisplayName": "Claire Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7659107+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262485",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262485,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1857,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086",
      "ID": 2158
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2603,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6039817+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1759E91P115VM229735",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229735,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1857,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086",
      "ID": 2158
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia",
      "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0943907+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270221",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270221,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1857,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086",
      "ID": 2158
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3751,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.7945433+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322689",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 322689,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1857,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086",
      "ID": 2158
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5109,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco",
      "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6994723+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5060E86P124VM294716",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 294716,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1857,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086",
      "ID": 2158
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5060,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1752612+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242833",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242833,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1857,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086",
      "ID": 2158
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1866,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah",
      "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0375778+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235593",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235593,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1857,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086",
      "ID": 2158
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1943,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic",
      "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6844666+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302143",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 302143,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1857,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086",
      "ID": 2158
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2595,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin",
      "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.2990075+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244515",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244515,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1857,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086",
      "ID": 2158
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2103,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith",
      "DisplayName": "Keith Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5581131+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327369",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 327369,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1857,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086",
      "ID": 2158
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:46.0331465+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3775E216P435VM276668",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276668,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1857,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086",
      "ID": 2158
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6760213+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264349",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264349,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1857,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086",
      "ID": 2158
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2673,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick",
      "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1296855+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248827",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248827,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1857,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086",
      "ID": 2158
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2678,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson",
      "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6717553+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2123E27P233VM295851",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295851,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1857,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086",
      "ID": 2158
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2123,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm",
      "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.538565+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285146",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285146,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1857,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086",
      "ID": 2158
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3907,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0684222+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230161",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230161,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1857,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086",
      "ID": 2158
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1735,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela",
      "DisplayName": "Angela Constance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.1188581+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243887",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 243887,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1857,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086",
      "ID": 2158
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1932,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce",
      "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3241808+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254945",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254945,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1857,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086",
      "ID": 2158
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1863,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna",
      "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2905503+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4976E20P31VM324004",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324004,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1857,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086",
      "ID": 2158
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4976,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth",
      "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9818367+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5107E223P379VM291386",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291386,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1857,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086",
      "ID": 2158
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5107,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1170692+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3743E222P391VM265317",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265317,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1857,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086",
      "ID": 2158
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3743,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel",
      "DisplayName": "Nigel Don",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4339664+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3771E149P417VM261734",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261734,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1857,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086",
      "ID": 2158
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3771,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob",
      "DisplayName": "Bob Doris",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3705246+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2826E262P384VM282018",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 282018,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1857,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086",
      "ID": 2158
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2826,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Dornan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1676616+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3812E94P117VM297955",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 297955,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1857,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086",
      "ID": 2158
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3812,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia",
      "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1321042+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231609",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231609,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1857,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086",
      "ID": 2158
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1778,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen",
      "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6079723+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4955E240P389VM285983",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285983,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1857,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086",
      "ID": 2158
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4955,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3529337+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219337",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 219337,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1857,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086",
      "ID": 2158
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1742,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle",
      "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.2942465+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238620",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 238620,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1857,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086",
      "ID": 2158
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1994,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus",
      "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4619456+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225469",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225469,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1857,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086",
      "ID": 2158
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1814,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda",
      "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9760661+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321771",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 321771,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1857,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086",
      "ID": 2158
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Fee",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.450688+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1853E35P216VM293251",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 293251,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1857,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086",
      "ID": 2158
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia",
      "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8369191+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1892E12P64VM226904",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 226904,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1857,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086",
      "ID": 2158
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2517349+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5054E95P118VM312659",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 312659,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1857,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086",
      "ID": 2158
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5054,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1378288+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4947E152P361VM257156",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257156,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1857,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086",
      "ID": 2158
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4947,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Finnie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.8257115+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271339",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271339,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1857,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086",
      "ID": 2158
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3901,
      "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe",
      "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0712895+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278462",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 278462,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1857,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086",
      "ID": 2158
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2394,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo",
      "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2198551+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2110E220P414VM286731",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286731,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1857,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086",
      "ID": 2158
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth",
      "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5982836+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250434",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250434,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1857,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086",
      "ID": 2158
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2675,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob",
      "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1893758+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1741E10P50VM220746",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220746,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1857,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086",
      "ID": 2158
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1741,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel",
      "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6552487+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220308",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220308,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1857,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086",
      "ID": 2158
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1756,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine",
      "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.635722+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1860E104P150VM252320",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252320,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1857,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086",
      "ID": 2158
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1860,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda",
      "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7240606+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2033E20P141VM266179",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 266179,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1857,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086",
      "ID": 2158
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2033,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain",
      "DisplayName": "Iain Gray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4777336+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324429",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324429,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1857,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086",
      "ID": 2158
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5042,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2222679+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259929",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 259929,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1857,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086",
      "ID": 2158
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick",
      "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6361224+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239277",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239277,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1857,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086",
      "ID": 2158
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2029,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh",
      "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7298441+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273820",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 273820,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1857,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086",
      "ID": 2158
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3758,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6370818+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304186",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 304186,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1857,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086",
      "ID": 2158
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4086,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Hume",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8536604+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221793",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221793,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1857,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086",
      "ID": 2158
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1773,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9480459+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1882E227P459VM242027",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242027,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1857,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086",
      "ID": 2158
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1882,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam",
      "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7906768+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223751",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223751,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1857,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086",
      "ID": 2158
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1893,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4722136+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307539",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307539,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1857,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086",
      "ID": 2158
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4934,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8338821+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272173",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 272173,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1857,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086",
      "ID": 2158
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4956,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Keir",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.114723+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244840",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244840,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1857,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086",
      "ID": 2158
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Kelly",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.580888+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315012",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315012,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1857,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086",
      "ID": 2158
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3129,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6702861+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247991",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247991,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1857,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086",
      "ID": 2158
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann",
      "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4370601+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4016E11P36VM274747",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274747,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1857,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086",
      "ID": 2158
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4016,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1199829+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255841",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255841,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1857,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086",
      "ID": 2158
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2180,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5593373+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4938E158P374VM277807",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277807,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1857,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086",
      "ID": 2158
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4938,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9692581+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2112E250P486VM252971",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252971,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1857,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086",
      "ID": 2158
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2112,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny",
      "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7610954+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4939E258P394VM277202",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277202,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1857,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086",
      "ID": 2158
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4939,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus",
      "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9380745+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325702",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 325702,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1857,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086",
      "ID": 2158
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5074,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon",
      "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5176016+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1828E3P10VM232824",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232824,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1857,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086",
      "ID": 2158
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1828,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo",
      "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8778048+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311386",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311386,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1857,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086",
      "ID": 2158
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4948,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike",
      "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8764902+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2117E90P107VM230462",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230462,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1857,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086",
      "ID": 2158
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2117,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis",
      "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3309489+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267292",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 267292,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1857,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086",
      "ID": 2158
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken",
      "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0131343+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313775",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313775,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1857,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086",
      "ID": 2158
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4966,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek",
      "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4101339+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3101E102P129VM295427",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295427,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1857,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086",
      "ID": 2158
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3101,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala",
      "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5117+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319021",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319021,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1857,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086",
      "ID": 2158
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5034,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny",
      "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.689021+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306475",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306475,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1857,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086",
      "ID": 2158
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2159,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Martin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5536664+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5110E252P395VM311251",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311251,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1857,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086",
      "ID": 2158
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Mason",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8706023+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268312",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 268312,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1857,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086",
      "ID": 2158
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2133,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.261689+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2876E141P433VM286134",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286134,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1857,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086",
      "ID": 2158
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2876,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3652389+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4951E147P368VM260711",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 260711,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1857,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086",
      "ID": 2158
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4951,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan",
      "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.0889855+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3896E175P307VM264096",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264096,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1857,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086",
      "ID": 2158
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3896,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam",
      "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9240254+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308078",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 308078,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1857,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086",
      "ID": 2158
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8637519+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4964E143P375VM279307",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279307,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1857,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086",
      "ID": 2158
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4964,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.4964349+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3824E84P113VM280002",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280002,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1857,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086",
      "ID": 2158
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3824,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5321636+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2066E22P91VM261767",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261767,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1857,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086",
      "ID": 2158
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2066,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3719345+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299708",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 299708,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1857,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086",
      "ID": 2158
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7191996+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306574",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306574,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1857,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086",
      "ID": 2158
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina",
      "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5579093+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2487E146P369VM301221",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 301221,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1857,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086",
      "ID": 2158
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2487,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.2525335+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223651",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223651,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1857,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086",
      "ID": 2158
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4679487+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237449",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237449,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1857,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086",
      "ID": 2158
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1961,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David",
      "DisplayName": "David McLetchie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2109981+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2134E34P201VM297839",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 297839,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1857,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086",
      "ID": 2158
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2134,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1272194+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320405",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 320405,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1857,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086",
      "ID": 2158
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5041,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan",
      "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1650079+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3763E142P397VM316070",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 316070,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1857,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086",
      "ID": 2158
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3763,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart",
      "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9448749+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1986E23P197VM236299",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 236299,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1857,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086",
      "ID": 2158
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1986,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan",
      "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9104152+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5047E100P130VM291435",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291435,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1857,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086",
      "ID": 2158
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5047,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne",
      "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1191993+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234616",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234616,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1857,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086",
      "ID": 2158
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1845,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette",
      "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3920033+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313640",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313640,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1857,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086",
      "ID": 2158
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3061,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4041003+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1768E19P265VM288558",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 288558,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1857,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086",
      "ID": 2158
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1768,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1485753+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225034",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225034,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1857,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086",
      "ID": 2158
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1894,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Neil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7416964+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3815E98P134VM270872",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270872,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1857,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086",
      "ID": 2158
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3815,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Park, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Park",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8267523+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265902",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265902,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1857,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086",
      "ID": 2158
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2010,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil",
      "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4655021+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283533",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283533,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1857,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086",
      "ID": 2158
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5057,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7120059+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2853E33P128VM251412",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251412,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1857,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086",
      "ID": 2158
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Pentland",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4624784+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317625",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317625,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1857,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086",
      "ID": 2158
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5009,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4304699+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254729",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254729,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1857,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086",
      "ID": 2158
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3745,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis",
      "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2812421+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1870E225P478VM295617",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295617,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1857,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086",
      "ID": 2158
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1870,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona",
      "DisplayName": "Shona Robison",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5285286+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2135E254P450VM234855",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234855,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1857,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086",
      "ID": 2158
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2135,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Russell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4026551+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1895E232P431VM257397",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257397,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1857,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086",
      "ID": 2158
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1895,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0544518+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228089",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 228089,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1857,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086",
      "ID": 2158
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1839,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5838824+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2345E10P55VM291700",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291700,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1857,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086",
      "ID": 2158
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2345,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1385351+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2223E176P333VM310669",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 310669,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1857,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086",
      "ID": 2158
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2223,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish",
      "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5809416+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246003",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 246003,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1857,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086",
      "ID": 2158
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2182,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8680323+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298342",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298342,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1857,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086",
      "ID": 2158
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5079,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew",
      "DisplayName": "Drew Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3416185+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234376",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234376,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1857,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086",
      "ID": 2158
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1769,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3746059+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4014E14P26VM269935",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269935,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1857,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086",
      "ID": 2158
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4014,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz",
      "DisplayName": "Liz Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5741868+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269180",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269180,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1857,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086",
      "ID": 2158
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2215,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.3071502+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317170",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317170,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1857,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086",
      "ID": 2158
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3806,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.1847073+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326128",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 326128,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1857,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086",
      "ID": 2158
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5106,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin",
      "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5410883+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241101",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241101,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1857,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086",
      "ID": 2158
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1848,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola",
      "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3961229+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2098E237P531VM289585",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289585,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1857,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086",
      "ID": 2158
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2098,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Swinney",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4503916+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2674E247P401VM247729",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247729,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1857,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086",
      "ID": 2158
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2674,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave",
      "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4259122+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5075E234P371VM284847",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 284847,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1857,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086",
      "ID": 2158
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5075,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Torrance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0502889+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1793E151P362VM222435",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 222435,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1857,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086",
      "ID": 2158
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1793,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean",
      "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1888407+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5078E245P366VM307125",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307125,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1857,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086",
      "ID": 2158
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5078,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Walker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5883509+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1841E231P426VM240177",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 240177,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1857,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086",
      "ID": 2158
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1841,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen",
      "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7822815+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283398",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283398,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1857,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086",
      "ID": 2158
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4952,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.6989812+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1865E263P500VM232273",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232273,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1857,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086",
      "ID": 2158
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1865,
      "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra",
      "DisplayName": "Sandra White",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8476223+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237824",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237824,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1857,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086",
      "ID": 2158
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2610,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Wilson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2276466+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309299",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 309299,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1857,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 55,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Concerns about Rail Proposals",
      "Reference": "S4M-02086",
      "ID": 2158
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4941,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza",
      "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3233383+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252313",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252313,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1853,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 83,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.4",
      "ID": 2179
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1926,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian",
      "DisplayName": "Brian Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7237526+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2615E213P388VM258809",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258809,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1853,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 83,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.4",
      "ID": 2179
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2615,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George",
      "DisplayName": "George Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3288436+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319838",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319838,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1853,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 83,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.4",
      "ID": 2179
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4940,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare",
      "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9435535+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249661",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 249661,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1853,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 83,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.4",
      "ID": 2179
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2641,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair",
      "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9444184+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1783E21P273VM227726",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227726,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1853,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 83,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.4",
      "ID": 2179
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1783,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie",
      "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5630043+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2633E97P136VM280416",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280416,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1853,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 83,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.4",
      "ID": 2179
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2633,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire",
      "DisplayName": "Claire Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7660334+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262488",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262488,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1853,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 83,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.4",
      "ID": 2179
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2603,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6041049+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1759E91P115VM229738",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229738,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1853,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 83,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.4",
      "ID": 2179
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia",
      "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.094579+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270218",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270218,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1853,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 83,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.4",
      "ID": 2179
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3751,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.7944145+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322692",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 322692,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1853,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 83,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.4",
      "ID": 2179
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5109,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco",
      "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6995942+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5060E86P124VM294719",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 294719,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1853,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 83,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.4",
      "ID": 2179
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5060,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1753856+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242868",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242868,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1853,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 83,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.4",
      "ID": 2179
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1866,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah",
      "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0390494+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235590",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235590,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1853,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 83,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.4",
      "ID": 2179
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1943,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic",
      "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6843443+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302146",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 302146,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1853,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 83,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.4",
      "ID": 2179
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2595,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin",
      "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.2991608+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244512",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244512,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1853,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 83,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.4",
      "ID": 2179
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2103,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith",
      "DisplayName": "Keith Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5579686+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327148",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 327148,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1853,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 83,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.4",
      "ID": 2179
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.8012129+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3775E216P435VM276671",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276671,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1853,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 83,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.4",
      "ID": 2179
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6761637+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264346",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264346,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1853,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 83,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.4",
      "ID": 2179
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2673,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick",
      "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1295447+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248824",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248824,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1853,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 83,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.4",
      "ID": 2179
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2678,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson",
      "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.671614+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2123E27P233VM295767",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295767,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1853,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 83,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.4",
      "ID": 2179
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2123,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm",
      "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5350182+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285149",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285149,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1853,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 83,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.4",
      "ID": 2179
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3907,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0685449+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230164",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230164,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1853,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 83,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.4",
      "ID": 2179
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1735,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela",
      "DisplayName": "Angela Constance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.1189831+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243851",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 243851,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1853,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 83,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.4",
      "ID": 2179
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1932,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce",
      "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3226475+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254942",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254942,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1853,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 83,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.4",
      "ID": 2179
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1863,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna",
      "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2904274+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323755",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 323755,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1853,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 83,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.4",
      "ID": 2179
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4976,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth",
      "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9705155+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5107E223P379VM291383",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291383,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1853,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 83,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.4",
      "ID": 2179
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5107,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1169443+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3743E222P391VM265320",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265320,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1853,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 83,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.4",
      "ID": 2179
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3743,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel",
      "DisplayName": "Nigel Don",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4340926+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3771E149P417VM261737",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261737,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1853,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 83,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.4",
      "ID": 2179
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3771,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob",
      "DisplayName": "Bob Doris",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.370648+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2826E262P384VM282015",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 282015,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1853,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 83,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.4",
      "ID": 2179
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2826,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Dornan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1675381+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3812E94P117VM297958",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 297958,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1853,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 83,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.4",
      "ID": 2179
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3812,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia",
      "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1322252+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231606",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231606,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1853,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 83,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.4",
      "ID": 2179
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1778,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen",
      "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6078504+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4955E240P389VM285980",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285980,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1853,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 83,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.4",
      "ID": 2179
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4955,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3528107+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219340",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 219340,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1853,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 83,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.4",
      "ID": 2179
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1742,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle",
      "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.2943704+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238617",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 238617,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1853,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 83,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.4",
      "ID": 2179
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1994,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus",
      "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4618233+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225466",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225466,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1853,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 83,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.4",
      "ID": 2179
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1814,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda",
      "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9759422+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321768",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 321768,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1853,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 83,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.4",
      "ID": 2179
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Fee",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4505665+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1853E35P216VM293248",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 293248,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1853,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 83,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.4",
      "ID": 2179
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia",
      "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8367947+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1892E12P64VM226907",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 226907,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1853,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 83,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.4",
      "ID": 2179
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2518599+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5054E95P118VM312662",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 312662,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1853,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 83,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.4",
      "ID": 2179
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5054,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1379521+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4947E152P361VM257159",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257159,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1853,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 83,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.4",
      "ID": 2179
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4947,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Finnie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.8258358+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271336",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271336,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1853,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 83,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.4",
      "ID": 2179
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3901,
      "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe",
      "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0711184+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278459",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 278459,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1853,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 83,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.4",
      "ID": 2179
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2394,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo",
      "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2197308+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2110E220P414VM286734",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286734,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1853,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 83,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.4",
      "ID": 2179
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth",
      "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5984245+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250437",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250437,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1853,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 83,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.4",
      "ID": 2179
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2675,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob",
      "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1894997+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1741E10P50VM220749",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220749,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1853,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 83,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.4",
      "ID": 2179
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1741,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel",
      "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6553887+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220305",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220305,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1853,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 83,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.4",
      "ID": 2179
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1756,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine",
      "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6355974+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1860E104P150VM252323",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252323,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1853,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 83,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.4",
      "ID": 2179
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1860,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda",
      "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7241836+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2033E20P141VM266145",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 266145,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1853,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 83,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.4",
      "ID": 2179
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2033,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain",
      "DisplayName": "Iain Gray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4762566+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324650",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324650,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1853,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 83,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.4",
      "ID": 2179
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5042,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2320798+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259926",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 259926,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1853,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 83,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.4",
      "ID": 2179
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick",
      "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6359966+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239280",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239280,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1853,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 83,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.4",
      "ID": 2179
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2029,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh",
      "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7299671+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273817",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 273817,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1853,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 83,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.4",
      "ID": 2179
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3758,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6369394+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304183",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 304183,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1853,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 83,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.4",
      "ID": 2179
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4086,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Hume",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8535082+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221790",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221790,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1853,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 83,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.4",
      "ID": 2179
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1773,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9479229+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1882E227P459VM242024",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242024,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1853,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 83,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.4",
      "ID": 2179
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1882,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam",
      "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.790535+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223748",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223748,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1853,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 83,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.4",
      "ID": 2179
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1893,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4720704+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307542",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307542,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1853,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 83,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.4",
      "ID": 2179
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4934,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.834006+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272176",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 272176,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1853,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 83,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.4",
      "ID": 2179
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4956,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Keir",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.1148454+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244876",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244876,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1853,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 83,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.4",
      "ID": 2179
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Kelly",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5824041+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315094",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315094,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1853,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 83,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.4",
      "ID": 2179
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3129,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6737959+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247988",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247988,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1853,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 83,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.4",
      "ID": 2179
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann",
      "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4369362+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4016E11P36VM274750",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274750,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1853,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 83,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.4",
      "ID": 2179
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4016,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1201063+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255838",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255838,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1853,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 83,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.4",
      "ID": 2179
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2180,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5592164+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4938E158P374VM277804",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277804,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1853,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 83,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.4",
      "ID": 2179
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4938,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9691339+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2112E250P486VM252974",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252974,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1853,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 83,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.4",
      "ID": 2179
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2112,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny",
      "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7612165+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4939E258P394VM277199",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277199,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1853,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 83,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.4",
      "ID": 2179
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4939,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus",
      "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9379084+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325481",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 325481,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1853,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 83,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.4",
      "ID": 2179
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5074,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon",
      "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5082513+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1828E3P10VM232827",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232827,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1853,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 83,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.4",
      "ID": 2179
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1828,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo",
      "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8779258+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311389",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311389,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1853,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 83,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.4",
      "ID": 2179
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4948,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike",
      "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8766155+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2117E90P107VM230459",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230459,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1853,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 83,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.4",
      "ID": 2179
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2117,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis",
      "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3308231+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267326",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 267326,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1853,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 83,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.4",
      "ID": 2179
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken",
      "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0146217+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313772",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313772,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1853,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 83,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.4",
      "ID": 2179
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4966,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek",
      "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4100103+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3101E102P129VM295424",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295424,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1853,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 83,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.4",
      "ID": 2179
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3101,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala",
      "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5115781+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319018",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319018,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1853,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 83,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.4",
      "ID": 2179
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5034,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny",
      "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6888977+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306392",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306392,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1853,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 83,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.4",
      "ID": 2179
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2159,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Martin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5501324+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5110E252P395VM311248",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311248,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1853,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 83,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.4",
      "ID": 2179
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Mason",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8704775+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268278",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 268278,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1853,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 83,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.4",
      "ID": 2179
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2133,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2602123+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2876E141P433VM286137",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286137,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1853,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 83,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.4",
      "ID": 2179
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2876,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3654973+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4951E147P368VM260708",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 260708,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1853,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 83,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.4",
      "ID": 2179
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4951,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan",
      "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.0888428+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3896E175P307VM264093",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264093,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1853,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 83,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.4",
      "ID": 2179
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3896,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam",
      "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9239018+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308081",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 308081,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1853,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 83,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.4",
      "ID": 2179
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8638771+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4964E143P375VM279310",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279310,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1853,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 83,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.4",
      "ID": 2179
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4964,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.49656+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279999",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279999,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1853,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 83,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.4",
      "ID": 2179
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3824,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5320073+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2066E22P91VM261112",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261112,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1853,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 83,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.4",
      "ID": 2179
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2066,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.1123428+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299705",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 299705,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1853,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 83,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.4",
      "ID": 2179
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7190784+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306577",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306577,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1853,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 83,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.4",
      "ID": 2179
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina",
      "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5580355+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2487E146P369VM301218",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 301218,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1853,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 83,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.4",
      "ID": 2179
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2487,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.2524079+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223654",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223654,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1853,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 83,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.4",
      "ID": 2179
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4680919+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237452",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237452,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1853,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 83,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.4",
      "ID": 2179
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1961,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David",
      "DisplayName": "David McLetchie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2111991+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305476",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 305476,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1853,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 83,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.4",
      "ID": 2179
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2134,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3257522+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320408",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 320408,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1853,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 83,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.4",
      "ID": 2179
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5041,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan",
      "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1651317+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315988",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315988,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1853,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 83,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.4",
      "ID": 2179
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3763,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart",
      "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9409038+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1986E23P197VM236302",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 236302,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1853,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 83,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.4",
      "ID": 2179
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1986,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan",
      "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9105411+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5047E100P130VM291432",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291432,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1853,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 83,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.4",
      "ID": 2179
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5047,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne",
      "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.119056+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234613",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234613,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1853,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 83,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.4",
      "ID": 2179
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1845,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette",
      "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3918596+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313558",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313558,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1853,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 83,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.4",
      "ID": 2179
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3061,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4005765+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1768E19P265VM288561",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 288561,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1853,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 83,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.4",
      "ID": 2179
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1768,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.148697+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225037",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225037,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1853,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 83,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.4",
      "ID": 2179
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1894,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Neil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7418176+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3815E98P134VM270875",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270875,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1853,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 83,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.4",
      "ID": 2179
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3815,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Park, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Park",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8268768+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265899",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265899,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1853,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 83,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.4",
      "ID": 2179
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2010,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil",
      "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4653683+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283530",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283530,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1853,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 83,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.4",
      "ID": 2179
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5057,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7118627+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2853E33P128VM251415",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251415,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1853,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 83,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.4",
      "ID": 2179
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Pentland",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4626039+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317628",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317628,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1853,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 83,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.4",
      "ID": 2179
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5009,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4305909+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254726",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254726,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1853,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 83,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.4",
      "ID": 2179
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3745,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis",
      "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2810986+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1870E225P478VM295620",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295620,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1853,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 83,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.4",
      "ID": 2179
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1870,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona",
      "DisplayName": "Shona Robison",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5286924+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2135E254P450VM234858",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234858,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1853,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 83,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.4",
      "ID": 2179
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2135,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Russell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4027802+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1895E232P431VM257400",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257400,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1853,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 83,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.4",
      "ID": 2179
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1895,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0545782+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228092",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 228092,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1853,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 83,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.4",
      "ID": 2179
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1839,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5840138+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2345E10P55VM291697",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291697,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1853,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 83,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.4",
      "ID": 2179
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2345,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1384141+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311063",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311063,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1853,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 83,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.4",
      "ID": 2179
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2223,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish",
      "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.6038289+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246006",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 246006,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1853,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 83,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.4",
      "ID": 2179
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2182,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8681549+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298339",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298339,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1853,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 83,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.4",
      "ID": 2179
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5079,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew",
      "DisplayName": "Drew Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3414933+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234373",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234373,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1853,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 83,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.4",
      "ID": 2179
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1769,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3744822+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4014E14P26VM269938",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269938,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1853,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 83,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.4",
      "ID": 2179
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4014,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz",
      "DisplayName": "Liz Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5743103+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269183",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269183,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1853,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 83,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.4",
      "ID": 2179
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2215,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.3072737+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317405",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317405,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1853,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 83,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.4",
      "ID": 2179
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3806,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4207028+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326349",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 326349,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1853,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 83,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.4",
      "ID": 2179
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5106,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin",
      "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7546514+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241104",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241104,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1853,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 83,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.4",
      "ID": 2179
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1848,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola",
      "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3962476+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2098E237P531VM289669",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289669,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1853,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 83,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.4",
      "ID": 2179
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2098,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Swinney",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4538902+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2674E247P401VM247732",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247732,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1853,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 83,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.4",
      "ID": 2179
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2674,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave",
      "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4260344+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5075E234P371VM284850",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 284850,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1853,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 83,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.4",
      "ID": 2179
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5075,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Torrance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0504087+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1793E151P362VM222438",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 222438,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1853,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 83,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.4",
      "ID": 2179
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1793,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean",
      "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1889658+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5078E245P366VM307122",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307122,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1853,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 83,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.4",
      "ID": 2179
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5078,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Walker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5882272+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1841E231P426VM240174",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 240174,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1853,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 83,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.4",
      "ID": 2179
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1841,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen",
      "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7821384+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283401",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283401,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1853,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 83,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.4",
      "ID": 2179
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4952,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.6991258+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1865E263P500VM232238",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232238,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1853,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 83,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.4",
      "ID": 2179
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1865,
      "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra",
      "DisplayName": "Sandra White",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8461053+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237821",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237821,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1853,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 83,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.4",
      "ID": 2179
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2610,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Wilson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2275252+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309296",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 309296,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1853,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 83,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.4",
      "ID": 2179
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4941,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza",
      "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3231954+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252314",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252314,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1854,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.1",
      "ID": 2172
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1926,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian",
      "DisplayName": "Brian Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7237928+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2615E213P388VM258862",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258862,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1854,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.1",
      "ID": 2172
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2615,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George",
      "DisplayName": "George Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3312086+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319885",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319885,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1854,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.1",
      "ID": 2172
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4940,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare",
      "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9455917+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249660",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 249660,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1854,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.1",
      "ID": 2172
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2641,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair",
      "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9443776+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1783E21P273VM227727",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227727,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1854,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.1",
      "ID": 2172
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1783,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie",
      "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.563064+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2633E97P136VM280417",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280417,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1854,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.1",
      "ID": 2172
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2633,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire",
      "DisplayName": "Claire Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7660945+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262489",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262489,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1854,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.1",
      "ID": 2172
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2603,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6041452+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1759E91P115VM229739",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229739,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1854,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.1",
      "ID": 2172
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia",
      "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0946196+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270165",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270165,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1854,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.1",
      "ID": 2172
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3751,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.584356+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322693",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 322693,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1854,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.1",
      "ID": 2172
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5109,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco",
      "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6996339+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5060E86P124VM294720",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 294720,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1854,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.1",
      "ID": 2172
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5060,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1754268+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242870",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242870,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1854,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.1",
      "ID": 2172
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1866,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah",
      "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0391283+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235230",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235230,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1854,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.1",
      "ID": 2172
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1943,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic",
      "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6613949+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302147",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 302147,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1854,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.1",
      "ID": 2172
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2595,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin",
      "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.2992168+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244511",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244511,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1854,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.1",
      "ID": 2172
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2103,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith",
      "DisplayName": "Keith Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.557927+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327246",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 327246,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1854,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.1",
      "ID": 2172
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:46.0275539+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3775E216P435VM276672",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276672,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1854,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.1",
      "ID": 2172
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6762038+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264345",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264345,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1854,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.1",
      "ID": 2172
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2673,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick",
      "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1295042+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248780",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248780,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1854,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.1",
      "ID": 2172
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2678,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson",
      "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6697356+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2123E27P233VM295815",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295815,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1854,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.1",
      "ID": 2172
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2123,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm",
      "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5370521+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285150",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285150,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1854,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.1",
      "ID": 2172
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3907,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0685851+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230165",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230165,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1854,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.1",
      "ID": 2172
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1735,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela",
      "DisplayName": "Angela Constance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.119024+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243849",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 243849,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1854,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.1",
      "ID": 2172
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1932,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce",
      "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3225481+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254941",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254941,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1854,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.1",
      "ID": 2172
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1863,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna",
      "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2903854+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323881",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 323881,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1854,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.1",
      "ID": 2172
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4976,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth",
      "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9764312+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5107E223P379VM291341",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291341,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1854,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.1",
      "ID": 2172
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5107,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.114861+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3743E222P391VM265321",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265321,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1854,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.1",
      "ID": 2172
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3743,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel",
      "DisplayName": "Nigel Don",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4341332+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262244",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262244,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1854,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.1",
      "ID": 2172
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3771,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob",
      "DisplayName": "Bob Doris",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.5931506+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2826E262P384VM282014",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 282014,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1854,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.1",
      "ID": 2172
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2826,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Dornan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1674975+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3812E94P117VM297959",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 297959,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1854,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.1",
      "ID": 2172
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3812,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia",
      "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.132265+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231605",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231605,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1854,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.1",
      "ID": 2172
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1778,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen",
      "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6078093+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4955E240P389VM285922",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285922,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1854,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.1",
      "ID": 2172
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4955,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.350334+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219432",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 219432,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1854,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.1",
      "ID": 2172
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1742,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle",
      "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.2987164+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238564",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 238564,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1854,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.1",
      "ID": 2172
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1994,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus",
      "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.459573+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225465",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225465,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1854,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.1",
      "ID": 2172
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1814,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda",
      "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9759018+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321767",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 321767,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1854,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.1",
      "ID": 2172
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Fee",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4505247+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1853E35P216VM293247",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 293247,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1854,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.1",
      "ID": 2172
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia",
      "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8367534+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1892E12P64VM226953",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 226953,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1854,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.1",
      "ID": 2172
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2607144+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5054E95P118VM312663",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 312663,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1854,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.1",
      "ID": 2172
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5054,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1379931+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4947E152P361VM257160",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257160,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1854,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.1",
      "ID": 2172
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4947,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Finnie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.8258981+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271277",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271277,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1854,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.1",
      "ID": 2172
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3901,
      "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe",
      "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0633424+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278458",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 278458,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1854,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.1",
      "ID": 2172
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2394,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo",
      "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.219689+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2110E220P414VM286735",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286735,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1854,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.1",
      "ID": 2172
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth",
      "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5984643+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250438",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250438,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1854,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.1",
      "ID": 2172
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2675,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob",
      "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1895403+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1741E10P50VM220750",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220750,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1854,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.1",
      "ID": 2172
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1741,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel",
      "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6554309+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220211",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220211,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1854,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.1",
      "ID": 2172
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1756,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine",
      "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3391354+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1860E104P150VM252324",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252324,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1854,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.1",
      "ID": 2172
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1860,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda",
      "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7242246+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2033E20P141VM266144",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 266144,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1854,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.1",
      "ID": 2172
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2033,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain",
      "DisplayName": "Iain Gray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4762164+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324552",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324552,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1854,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.1",
      "ID": 2172
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5042,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2279168+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259727",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 259727,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1854,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.1",
      "ID": 2172
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick",
      "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6219351+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239332",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239332,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1854,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.1",
      "ID": 2172
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2029,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh",
      "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7322599+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273816",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 273816,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1854,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.1",
      "ID": 2172
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3758,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6368977+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304182",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 304182,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1854,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.1",
      "ID": 2172
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4086,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Hume",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8534587+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221789",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221789,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1854,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.1",
      "ID": 2172
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1773,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9478827+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1882E227P459VM242023",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242023,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1854,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.1",
      "ID": 2172
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1882,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam",
      "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7904935+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223747",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223747,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1854,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.1",
      "ID": 2172
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1893,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4720301+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307543",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307543,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1854,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.1",
      "ID": 2172
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4934,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8340652+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272177",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 272177,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1854,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.1",
      "ID": 2172
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4956,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Keir",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.1148855+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244878",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244878,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1854,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.1",
      "ID": 2172
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Kelly",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5824851+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315047",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315047,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1854,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.1",
      "ID": 2172
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3129,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6717933+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247936",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247936,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1854,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.1",
      "ID": 2172
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann",
      "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4347212+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4016E11P36VM274808",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274808,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1854,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.1",
      "ID": 2172
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4016,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1226434+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255786",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255786,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1854,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.1",
      "ID": 2172
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2180,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5567995+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4938E158P374VM277437",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277437,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1854,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.1",
      "ID": 2172
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4938,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9533343+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2112E250P486VM253026",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253026,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1854,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.1",
      "ID": 2172
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2112,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny",
      "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7636602+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4939E258P394VM276846",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276846,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1854,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.1",
      "ID": 2172
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4939,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus",
      "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6836284+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325579",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 325579,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1854,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.1",
      "ID": 2172
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5074,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon",
      "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5124177+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1828E3P10VM232828",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232828,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1854,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.1",
      "ID": 2172
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1828,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo",
      "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8780857+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311390",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311390,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1854,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.1",
      "ID": 2172
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4948,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike",
      "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8766568+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2117E90P107VM230414",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230414,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1854,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.1",
      "ID": 2172
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2117,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis",
      "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3287864+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267327",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 267327,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1854,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.1",
      "ID": 2172
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken",
      "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0146641+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313771",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313771,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1854,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.1",
      "ID": 2172
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4966,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek",
      "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.40997+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3101E102P129VM295423",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295423,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1854,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.1",
      "ID": 2172
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3101,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala",
      "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.511537+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319017",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319017,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1854,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.1",
      "ID": 2172
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5034,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny",
      "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6888571+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306439",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306439,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1854,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.1",
      "ID": 2172
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2159,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Martin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.552129+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5110E252P395VM311247",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311247,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1854,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.1",
      "ID": 2172
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Mason",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8704355+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268277",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 268277,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1854,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.1",
      "ID": 2172
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2133,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2601686+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2876E141P433VM286138",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286138,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1854,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.1",
      "ID": 2172
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2876,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3655413+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4951E147P368VM260707",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 260707,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1854,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.1",
      "ID": 2172
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4951,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan",
      "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.0888023+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3896E175P307VM263895",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 263895,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1854,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.1",
      "ID": 2172
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3896,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam",
      "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.915407+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308082",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 308082,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1854,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.1",
      "ID": 2172
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8639187+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4964E143P375VM279661",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279661,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1854,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.1",
      "ID": 2172
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4964,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5172055+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279998",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279998,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1854,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.1",
      "ID": 2172
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3824,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5319666+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2066E22P91VM261110",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261110,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1854,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.1",
      "ID": 2172
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2066,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.1122397+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299704",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 299704,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1854,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.1",
      "ID": 2172
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7190384+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306578",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306578,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1854,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.1",
      "ID": 2172
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina",
      "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5580957+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2487E146P369VM301217",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 301217,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1854,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.1",
      "ID": 2172
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2487,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.2523655+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223655",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223655,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1854,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.1",
      "ID": 2172
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4681346+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237503",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237503,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1854,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.1",
      "ID": 2172
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1961,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David",
      "DisplayName": "David McLetchie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2134074+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305428",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 305428,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1854,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.1",
      "ID": 2172
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2134,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3235967+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320409",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 320409,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1854,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.1",
      "ID": 2172
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5041,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan",
      "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1651724+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3763E142P397VM316035",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 316035,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1854,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.1",
      "ID": 2172
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3763,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart",
      "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9430481+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1986E23P197VM236303",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 236303,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1854,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.1",
      "ID": 2172
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1986,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan",
      "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9105824+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5047E100P130VM291431",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291431,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1854,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.1",
      "ID": 2172
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5047,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne",
      "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1190144+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234612",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234612,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1854,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.1",
      "ID": 2172
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1845,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette",
      "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3918185+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313605",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313605,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1854,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.1",
      "ID": 2172
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3061,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4025982+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1768E19P265VM288562",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 288562,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1854,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.1",
      "ID": 2172
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1768,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1487374+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225038",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225038,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1854,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.1",
      "ID": 2172
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1894,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Neil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.741876+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3815E98P134VM270914",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270914,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1854,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.1",
      "ID": 2172
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3815,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Park, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Park",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8288852+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265898",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265898,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1854,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.1",
      "ID": 2172
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2010,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil",
      "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4653088+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283332",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283332,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1854,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.1",
      "ID": 2172
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5057,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.6961337+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2853E33P128VM251459",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251459,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1854,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.1",
      "ID": 2172
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Pentland",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4645597+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317629",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317629,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1854,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.1",
      "ID": 2172
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5009,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4306315+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254725",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254725,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1854,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.1",
      "ID": 2172
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3745,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis",
      "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2810577+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1870E225P478VM295621",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295621,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1854,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.1",
      "ID": 2172
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1870,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona",
      "DisplayName": "Shona Robison",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5287336+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2135E254P450VM234903",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234903,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1854,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.1",
      "ID": 2172
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2135,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Russell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4047159+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1895E232P431VM257401",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257401,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1854,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.1",
      "ID": 2172
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1895,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0546192+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228093",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 228093,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1854,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.1",
      "ID": 2172
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1839,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5840555+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2345E10P55VM291696",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291696,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1854,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.1",
      "ID": 2172
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2345,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1383732+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2223E176P333VM310704",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 310704,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1854,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.1",
      "ID": 2172
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2223,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish",
      "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5824569+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246007",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 246007,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1854,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.1",
      "ID": 2172
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2182,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8681959+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298338",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298338,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1854,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.1",
      "ID": 2172
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5079,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew",
      "DisplayName": "Drew Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3414348+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234372",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234372,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1854,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.1",
      "ID": 2172
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1769,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3744407+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274571",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274571,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1854,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.1",
      "ID": 2172
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4014,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz",
      "DisplayName": "Liz Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1123539+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269493",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269493,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1854,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.1",
      "ID": 2172
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2215,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5500067+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317205",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317205,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1854,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.1",
      "ID": 2172
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3806,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4079931+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326251",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 326251,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1854,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.1",
      "ID": 2172
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5106,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin",
      "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7503818+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241105",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241105,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1854,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.1",
      "ID": 2172
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1848,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola",
      "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3962886+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2098E237P531VM289621",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289621,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1854,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.1",
      "ID": 2172
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2098,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Swinney",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4518981+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2674E247P401VM247777",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247777,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1854,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.1",
      "ID": 2172
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2674,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave",
      "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4280099+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5075E234P371VM284892",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 284892,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1854,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.1",
      "ID": 2172
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5075,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Torrance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0521815+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1793E151P362VM222439",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 222439,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1854,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.1",
      "ID": 2172
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1793,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean",
      "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1890066+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5078E245P366VM307121",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307121,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1854,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.1",
      "ID": 2172
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5078,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Walker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5881844+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1841E231P426VM240173",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 240173,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1854,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.1",
      "ID": 2172
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1841,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen",
      "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7820969+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283459",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283459,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1854,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.1",
      "ID": 2172
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4952,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7088065+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1865E263P500VM232237",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232237,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1854,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.1",
      "ID": 2172
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1865,
      "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra",
      "DisplayName": "Sandra White",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8460636+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237776",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237776,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1854,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.1",
      "ID": 2172
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2610,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Wilson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2256323+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309295",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 309295,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1854,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 15,
      "VoteAgainst": 103,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084.1",
      "ID": 2172
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4941,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza",
      "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3231553+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252315",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252315,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1855,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084",
      "ID": 2156
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1926,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian",
      "DisplayName": "Brian Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7238519+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2615E213P388VM258846",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258846,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1855,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084",
      "ID": 2156
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2615,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George",
      "DisplayName": "George Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3304247+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319884",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319884,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1855,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084",
      "ID": 2156
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4940,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare",
      "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9455502+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249659",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 249659,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1855,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084",
      "ID": 2156
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2641,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair",
      "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9443192+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1783E21P273VM227728",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227728,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1855,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084",
      "ID": 2156
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1783,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie",
      "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.563106+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2633E97P136VM280418",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280418,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1855,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084",
      "ID": 2156
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2633,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire",
      "DisplayName": "Claire Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7661369+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262490",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262490,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1855,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084",
      "ID": 2156
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2603,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6041856+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1759E91P115VM229740",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229740,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1855,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084",
      "ID": 2156
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia",
      "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0946599+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270181",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270181,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1855,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084",
      "ID": 2156
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3751,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5850323+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322694",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 322694,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1855,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084",
      "ID": 2156
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5109,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco",
      "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6996731+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5060E86P124VM294721",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 294721,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1855,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084",
      "ID": 2156
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5060,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1754676+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242871",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242871,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1855,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084",
      "ID": 2156
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1866,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah",
      "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.039168+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235554",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235554,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1855,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084",
      "ID": 2156
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1943,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic",
      "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6828055+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302148",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 302148,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1855,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084",
      "ID": 2156
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2595,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin",
      "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.299267+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244510",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244510,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1855,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084",
      "ID": 2156
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2103,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith",
      "DisplayName": "Keith Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5578861+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327247",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 327247,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1855,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084",
      "ID": 2156
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:46.027595+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3775E216P435VM276673",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276673,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1855,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084",
      "ID": 2156
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6762443+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264344",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264344,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1855,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084",
      "ID": 2156
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2673,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick",
      "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1294639+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248779",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248779,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1855,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084",
      "ID": 2156
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2678,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson",
      "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6696948+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2123E27P233VM295814",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295814,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1855,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084",
      "ID": 2156
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2123,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm",
      "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5370114+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285151",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285151,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1855,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084",
      "ID": 2156
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3907,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0686254+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230166",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230166,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1855,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084",
      "ID": 2156
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1735,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela",
      "DisplayName": "Angela Constance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.1190645+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243848",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 243848,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1855,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084",
      "ID": 2156
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1932,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce",
      "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3225088+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254940",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254940,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1855,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084",
      "ID": 2156
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1863,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna",
      "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2903246+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323882",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 323882,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1855,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084",
      "ID": 2156
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4976,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth",
      "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9764733+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5107E223P379VM291340",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291340,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1855,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084",
      "ID": 2156
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5107,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1148199+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3743E222P391VM265322",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265322,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1855,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084",
      "ID": 2156
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3743,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel",
      "DisplayName": "Nigel Don",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4341738+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262245",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262245,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1855,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084",
      "ID": 2156
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3771,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob",
      "DisplayName": "Bob Doris",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.5931926+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2826E262P384VM282013",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 282013,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1855,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084",
      "ID": 2156
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2826,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Dornan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1674545+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3812E94P117VM297960",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 297960,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1855,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084",
      "ID": 2156
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3812,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia",
      "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1323048+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231604",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231604,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1855,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084",
      "ID": 2156
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1778,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen",
      "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6077691+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4955E240P389VM285946",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285946,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1855,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084",
      "ID": 2156
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4955,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3513603+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219383",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 219383,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1855,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084",
      "ID": 2156
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1742,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle",
      "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.2962723+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238581",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 238581,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1855,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084",
      "ID": 2156
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1994,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus",
      "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4602863+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225464",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225464,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1855,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084",
      "ID": 2156
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1814,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda",
      "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9758611+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321766",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 321766,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1855,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084",
      "ID": 2156
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Fee",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4504645+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1853E35P216VM293246",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 293246,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1855,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084",
      "ID": 2156
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia",
      "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8367116+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227109",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227109,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1855,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084",
      "ID": 2156
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2681703+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5054E95P118VM312664",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 312664,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1855,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084",
      "ID": 2156
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5054,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1380334+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4947E152P361VM257161",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257161,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1855,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084",
      "ID": 2156
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4947,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Finnie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.8259418+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271301",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271301,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1855,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084",
      "ID": 2156
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3901,
      "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe",
      "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.069528+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278457",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 278457,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1855,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084",
      "ID": 2156
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2394,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo",
      "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.219648+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2110E220P414VM286736",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286736,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1855,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084",
      "ID": 2156
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth",
      "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5985045+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250439",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250439,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1855,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084",
      "ID": 2156
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2675,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob",
      "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1895988+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1741E10P50VM220751",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220751,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1855,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084",
      "ID": 2156
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1741,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel",
      "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.655472+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220260",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220260,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1855,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084",
      "ID": 2156
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1756,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine",
      "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6307596+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1860E104P150VM252325",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252325,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1855,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084",
      "ID": 2156
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1860,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda",
      "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.724265+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2033E20P141VM266143",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 266143,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1855,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084",
      "ID": 2156
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2033,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain",
      "DisplayName": "Iain Gray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4761756+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324551",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324551,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1855,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084",
      "ID": 2156
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5042,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.227853+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259726",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 259726,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1855,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084",
      "ID": 2156
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick",
      "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6218944+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239316",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239316,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1855,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084",
      "ID": 2156
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2029,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh",
      "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.731566+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273815",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 273815,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1855,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084",
      "ID": 2156
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3758,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6368564+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304181",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 304181,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1855,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084",
      "ID": 2156
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4086,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Hume",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8534076+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221788",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221788,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1855,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084",
      "ID": 2156
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1773,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9478408+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1882E227P459VM242022",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242022,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1855,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084",
      "ID": 2156
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1882,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam",
      "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7904534+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223713",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223713,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1855,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084",
      "ID": 2156
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1893,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4705844+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307544",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307544,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1855,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084",
      "ID": 2156
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4934,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.834107+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272178",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 272178,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1855,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084",
      "ID": 2156
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4956,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Keir",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.1149263+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244879",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244879,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1855,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084",
      "ID": 2156
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Kelly",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5825262+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315048",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315048,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1855,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084",
      "ID": 2156
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3129,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6718343+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247952",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247952,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1855,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084",
      "ID": 2156
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann",
      "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.435414+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4016E11P36VM274784",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274784,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1855,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084",
      "ID": 2156
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4016,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1216087+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255802",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255802,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1855,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084",
      "ID": 2156
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2180,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.557717+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4938E158P374VM277461",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277461,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1855,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084",
      "ID": 2156
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4938,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9543506+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2112E250P486VM253010",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253010,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1855,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084",
      "ID": 2156
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2112,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny",
      "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7629763+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4939E258P394VM276845",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276845,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1855,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084",
      "ID": 2156
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4939,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus",
      "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6835886+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325580",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 325580,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1855,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084",
      "ID": 2156
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5074,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon",
      "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5124577+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1828E3P10VM232829",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232829,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1855,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084",
      "ID": 2156
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1828,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo",
      "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8781296+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311391",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311391,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1855,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084",
      "ID": 2156
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4948,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike",
      "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8766973+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2117E90P107VM230413",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230413,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1855,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084",
      "ID": 2156
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2117,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis",
      "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3287445+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267328",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 267328,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1855,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084",
      "ID": 2156
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken",
      "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0147056+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313770",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313770,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1855,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084",
      "ID": 2156
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4966,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek",
      "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4099287+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3101E102P129VM295422",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295422,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1855,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084",
      "ID": 2156
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3101,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala",
      "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5114789+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319016",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319016,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1855,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084",
      "ID": 2156
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5034,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny",
      "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6888166+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306438",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306438,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1855,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084",
      "ID": 2156
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2159,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Martin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5520872+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5110E252P395VM311246",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311246,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1855,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084",
      "ID": 2156
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Mason",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8703941+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268276",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 268276,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1855,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084",
      "ID": 2156
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2133,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2600859+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2876E141P433VM286139",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286139,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1855,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084",
      "ID": 2156
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2876,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3655828+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4951E147P368VM260706",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 260706,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1855,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084",
      "ID": 2156
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4951,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan",
      "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.088762+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3896E175P307VM263894",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 263894,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1855,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084",
      "ID": 2156
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3896,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam",
      "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9153658+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308083",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 308083,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1855,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084",
      "ID": 2156
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8639597+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4964E143P375VM279662",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279662,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1855,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084",
      "ID": 2156
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4964,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5172638+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279997",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279997,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1855,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084",
      "ID": 2156
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3824,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5319256+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2066E22P91VM261109",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261109,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1855,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084",
      "ID": 2156
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2066,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.1121982+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299703",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 299703,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1855,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084",
      "ID": 2156
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7189962+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306579",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306579,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1855,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084",
      "ID": 2156
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina",
      "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5581388+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2487E146P369VM301216",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 301216,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1855,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084",
      "ID": 2156
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2487,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.2523227+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223656",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223656,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1855,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084",
      "ID": 2156
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4681751+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237488",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237488,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1855,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084",
      "ID": 2156
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1961,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David",
      "DisplayName": "David McLetchie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2127597+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305429",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 305429,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1855,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084",
      "ID": 2156
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2134,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3236368+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320410",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 320410,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1855,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084",
      "ID": 2156
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5041,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan",
      "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1652131+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3763E142P397VM316034",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 316034,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1855,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084",
      "ID": 2156
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3763,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart",
      "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9430055+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1986E23P197VM236304",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 236304,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1855,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084",
      "ID": 2156
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1986,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan",
      "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9106234+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5047E100P130VM291430",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291430,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1855,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084",
      "ID": 2156
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5047,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne",
      "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1189734+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234611",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234611,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1855,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084",
      "ID": 2156
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1845,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette",
      "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3917762+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313604",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313604,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1855,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084",
      "ID": 2156
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3061,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4025572+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1768E19P265VM288563",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 288563,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1855,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084",
      "ID": 2156
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1768,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1487788+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225072",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225072,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1855,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084",
      "ID": 2156
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1894,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Neil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7433049+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3815E98P134VM270905",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270905,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1855,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084",
      "ID": 2156
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3815,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Park, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Park",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8284874+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265897",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265897,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1855,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084",
      "ID": 2156
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2010,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil",
      "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4652676+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283331",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283331,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1855,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084",
      "ID": 2156
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5057,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.6960931+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2853E33P128VM251460",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251460,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1855,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084",
      "ID": 2156
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Pentland",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4646013+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317630",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317630,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1855,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084",
      "ID": 2156
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5009,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4306714+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254724",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254724,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1855,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084",
      "ID": 2156
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3745,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis",
      "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2810175+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1870E225P478VM295622",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295622,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1855,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084",
      "ID": 2156
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1870,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona",
      "DisplayName": "Shona Robison",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5287735+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2135E254P450VM234904",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234904,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1855,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084",
      "ID": 2156
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2135,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Russell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4047576+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1895E232P431VM257402",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257402,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1855,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084",
      "ID": 2156
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1895,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0546597+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228094",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 228094,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1855,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084",
      "ID": 2156
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1839,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5840959+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2345E10P55VM291695",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291695,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1855,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084",
      "ID": 2156
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2345,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1383148+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2223E176P333VM310705",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 310705,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1855,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084",
      "ID": 2156
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2223,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish",
      "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.582499+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246008",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 246008,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1855,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084",
      "ID": 2156
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2182,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8682363+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298337",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298337,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1855,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084",
      "ID": 2156
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5079,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew",
      "DisplayName": "Drew Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3413935+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234371",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234371,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1855,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084",
      "ID": 2156
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1769,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3743987+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274572",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274572,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1855,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084",
      "ID": 2156
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4014,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz",
      "DisplayName": "Liz Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1124168+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269494",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269494,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1855,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084",
      "ID": 2156
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2215,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5500479+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317206",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317206,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1855,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084",
      "ID": 2156
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3806,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4080471+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326250",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 326250,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1855,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084",
      "ID": 2156
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5106,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin",
      "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7503406+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241106",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241106,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1855,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084",
      "ID": 2156
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1848,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola",
      "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3963299+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2098E237P531VM289622",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289622,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1855,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084",
      "ID": 2156
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2098,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Swinney",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4519376+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2674E247P401VM247778",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247778,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1855,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084",
      "ID": 2156
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2674,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave",
      "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4280506+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5075E234P371VM284893",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 284893,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1855,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084",
      "ID": 2156
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5075,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Torrance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0522219+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1793E151P362VM222473",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 222473,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1855,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084",
      "ID": 2156
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1793,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean",
      "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1904657+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5078E245P366VM307120",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307120,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1855,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084",
      "ID": 2156
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5078,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Walker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5881249+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1841E231P426VM240172",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 240172,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1855,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084",
      "ID": 2156
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1841,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen",
      "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7820561+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283435",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283435,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1855,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084",
      "ID": 2156
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4952,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7077545+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1865E263P500VM232236",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232236,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1855,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084",
      "ID": 2156
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1865,
      "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra",
      "DisplayName": "Sandra White",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8460224+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237775",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237775,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1855,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084",
      "ID": 2156
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2610,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Wilson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2255734+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309294",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 309294,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1855,
      "AgendaID": 2948,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Economy and Recovery",
      "Reference": "S4M-02084",
      "ID": 2156
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4941,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza",
      "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-23T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3231151+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252767",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252767,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1847,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979.1",
      "ID": 2065
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1926,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian",
      "DisplayName": "Brian Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7524268+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2615E213P388VM258959",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258959,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1847,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979.1",
      "ID": 2065
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2615,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George",
      "DisplayName": "George Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3356235+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319600",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319600,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1847,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979.1",
      "ID": 2065
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4940,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare",
      "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9332772+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2641E256P403VM250284",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250284,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1847,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979.1",
      "ID": 2065
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2641,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair",
      "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.182559+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1783E21P273VM228391",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 228391,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1847,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979.1",
      "ID": 2065
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1783,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie",
      "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.7969845+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2633E97P136VM281086",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 281086,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1847,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979.1",
      "ID": 2065
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2633,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire",
      "DisplayName": "Claire Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.8053963+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262759",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262759,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1847,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979.1",
      "ID": 2065
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2603,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6156305+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1759E91P115VM229835",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229835,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1847,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979.1",
      "ID": 2065
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia",
      "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0994626+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3751E243P383VM269758",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269758,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1847,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979.1",
      "ID": 2065
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3751,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5617076+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322518",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 322518,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1847,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979.1",
      "ID": 2065
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5109,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco",
      "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6921332+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5060E86P124VM295295",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295295,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1847,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979.1",
      "ID": 2065
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5060,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5058522+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1866E93P239VM243001",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 243001,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1847,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979.1",
      "ID": 2065
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1866,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah",
      "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0446772+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235131",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235131,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1847,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979.1",
      "ID": 2065
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1943,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic",
      "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4207238+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302401",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 302401,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1847,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979.1",
      "ID": 2065
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2595,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin",
      "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.522792+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244244",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244244,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1847,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979.1",
      "ID": 2065
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2103,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith",
      "DisplayName": "Keith Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5462865+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327107",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 327107,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1847,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979.1",
      "ID": 2065
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7991473+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277098",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277098,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1847,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979.1",
      "ID": 2065
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.7010083+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264231",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264231,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1847,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979.1",
      "ID": 2065
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2673,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick",
      "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1243864+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248589",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248589,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1847,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979.1",
      "ID": 2065
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2678,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson",
      "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6528193+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2123E27P233VM294911",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 294911,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1847,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979.1",
      "ID": 2065
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2123,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm",
      "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1840502+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285262",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285262,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1847,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979.1",
      "ID": 2065
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3907,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3154002+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230738",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230738,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1847,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979.1",
      "ID": 2065
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1735,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela",
      "DisplayName": "Angela Constance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3434173+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243717",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 243717,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1847,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979.1",
      "ID": 2065
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1932,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce",
      "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3168085+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254845",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254845,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1847,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979.1",
      "ID": 2065
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1863,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna",
      "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.286225+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323714",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 323714,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1847,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979.1",
      "ID": 2065
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4976,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth",
      "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9687282+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5107E223P379VM290843",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 290843,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1847,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979.1",
      "ID": 2065
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5107,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.774528+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3743E222P391VM265435",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265435,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1847,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979.1",
      "ID": 2065
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3743,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel",
      "DisplayName": "Nigel Don",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4390524+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262590",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262590,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1847,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979.1",
      "ID": 2065
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3771,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob",
      "DisplayName": "Bob Doris",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6084303+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281808",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 281808,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1847,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979.1",
      "ID": 2065
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2826,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Dornan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1584863+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298319",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298319,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1847,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979.1",
      "ID": 2065
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3812,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia",
      "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.340634+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231203",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231203,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1847,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979.1",
      "ID": 2065
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1778,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen",
      "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.5847492+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4955E240P389VM284994",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 284994,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1847,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979.1",
      "ID": 2065
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4955,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0566672+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219573",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 219573,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1847,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979.1",
      "ID": 2065
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1742,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle",
      "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3052001+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238467",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 238467,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1847,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979.1",
      "ID": 2065
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1994,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus",
      "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4553435+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1814E269P519VM226710",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 226710,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1847,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979.1",
      "ID": 2065
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1814,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda",
      "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2432571+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321942",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 321942,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1847,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979.1",
      "ID": 2065
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Fee",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4580459+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292681",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 292681,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1847,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979.1",
      "ID": 2065
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia",
      "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5532604+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227606",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227606,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1847,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979.1",
      "ID": 2065
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5573559+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5054E95P118VM312760",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 312760,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1847,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979.1",
      "ID": 2065
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5054,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1421463+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4947E152P361VM257842",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257842,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1847,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979.1",
      "ID": 2065
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4947,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Finnie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0799341+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271127",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271127,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1847,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979.1",
      "ID": 2065
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3901,
      "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe",
      "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8436317+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2394E15P47VM274387",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274387,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1847,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979.1",
      "ID": 2065
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2394,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo",
      "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1038643+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2110E220P414VM287296",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 287296,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1847,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979.1",
      "ID": 2065
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth",
      "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8580575+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250659",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250659,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1847,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979.1",
      "ID": 2065
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2675,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob",
      "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.2080178+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221126",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221126,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1847,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979.1",
      "ID": 2065
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1741,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel",
      "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6761853+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220070",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220070,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1847,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979.1",
      "ID": 2065
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1756,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine",
      "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3330328+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1860E104P150VM252421",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252421,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1847,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979.1",
      "ID": 2065
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1860,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda",
      "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7284189+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2033E20P141VM253713",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253713,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1847,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979.1",
      "ID": 2065
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2033,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain",
      "DisplayName": "Iain Gray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0177942+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324691",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324691,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1847,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979.1",
      "ID": 2065
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5042,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2337881+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259380",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 259380,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1847,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979.1",
      "ID": 2065
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick",
      "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6066159+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239430",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239430,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1847,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979.1",
      "ID": 2065
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2029,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh",
      "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7364625+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273702",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 273702,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1847,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979.1",
      "ID": 2065
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3758,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6317901+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304084",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 304084,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1847,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979.1",
      "ID": 2065
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4086,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Hume",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8490006+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1773E242P494VM223188",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223188,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1847,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979.1",
      "ID": 2065
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1773,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.2324189+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1882E227P459VM245855",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 245855,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1847,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979.1",
      "ID": 2065
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1882,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam",
      "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8613171+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223444",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223444,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1847,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979.1",
      "ID": 2065
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1893,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4582607+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307901",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307901,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1847,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979.1",
      "ID": 2065
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4934,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8558254+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272395",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 272395,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1847,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979.1",
      "ID": 2065
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4956,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Keir",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3334951+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2059E26P131VM245012",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 245012,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1847,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979.1",
      "ID": 2065
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Kelly",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.588218+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315180",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315180,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1847,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979.1",
      "ID": 2065
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3129,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6777658+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247531",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247531,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1847,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979.1",
      "ID": 2065
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann",
      "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4078276+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4016E11P36VM275113",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 275113,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1847,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979.1",
      "ID": 2065
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4016,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1421501+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255535",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255535,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1847,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979.1",
      "ID": 2065
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2180,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5354917+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4938E158P374VM276976",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276976,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1847,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979.1",
      "ID": 2065
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4938,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6894456+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2112E250P486VM253430",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253430,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1847,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979.1",
      "ID": 2065
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2112,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny",
      "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.9960794+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4939E258P394VM276344",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276344,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1847,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979.1",
      "ID": 2065
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4939,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus",
      "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6554983+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325440",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 325440,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1847,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979.1",
      "ID": 2065
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5074,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon",
      "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5064899+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1828E3P10VM232924",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232924,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1847,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979.1",
      "ID": 2065
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1828,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo",
      "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.882507+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311746",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311746,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1847,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979.1",
      "ID": 2065
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4948,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike",
      "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8924693+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2117E90P107VM229605",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229605,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1847,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979.1",
      "ID": 2065
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2117,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis",
      "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0889258+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267531",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 267531,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1847,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979.1",
      "ID": 2065
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken",
      "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0238424+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313414",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313414,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1847,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979.1",
      "ID": 2065
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4966,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek",
      "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.3943414+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3101E102P129VM294444",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 294444,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1847,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979.1",
      "ID": 2065
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3101,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala",
      "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1385896+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319191",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319191,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1847,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979.1",
      "ID": 2065
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5034,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny",
      "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6963421+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306307",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306307,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1847,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979.1",
      "ID": 2065
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2159,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Martin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5464308+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5110E252P395VM310357",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 310357,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1847,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979.1",
      "ID": 2065
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Mason",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5670266+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268073",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 268073,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1847,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979.1",
      "ID": 2065
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2133,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0548413+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2876E141P433VM292982",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 292982,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1847,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979.1",
      "ID": 2065
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2876,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5665519+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4951E147P368VM271867",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271867,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1847,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979.1",
      "ID": 2065
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4951,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan",
      "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0948444+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3896E175P307VM263548",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 263548,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1847,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979.1",
      "ID": 2065
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3896,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam",
      "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.8941445+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5080E110P121VM307238",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307238,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1847,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979.1",
      "ID": 2065
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8205911+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4964E143P375VM280156",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280156,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1847,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979.1",
      "ID": 2065
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4964,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.543823+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279575",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279575,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1847,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979.1",
      "ID": 2065
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3824,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5135929+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2066E22P91VM260508",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 260508,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1847,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979.1",
      "ID": 2065
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2066,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.0799013+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299345",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 299345,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1847,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979.1",
      "ID": 2065
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.6934535+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3759E260P411VM301796",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 301796,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1847,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979.1",
      "ID": 2065
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina",
      "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.2836073+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300321",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 300321,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1847,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979.1",
      "ID": 2065
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2487,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.9931516+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1775E215P453VM224183",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 224183,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1847,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979.1",
      "ID": 2065
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4961392+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237899",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237899,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1847,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979.1",
      "ID": 2065
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1961,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David",
      "DisplayName": "David McLetchie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2308799+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305561",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 305561,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1847,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979.1",
      "ID": 2065
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2134,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3296818+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320079",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 320079,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1847,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979.1",
      "ID": 2065
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5041,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan",
      "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9607761+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315902",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315902,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1847,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979.1",
      "ID": 2065
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3763,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart",
      "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9321427+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1986E23P197VM236726",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 236726,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1847,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979.1",
      "ID": 2065
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1986,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan",
      "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9374238+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5047E100P130VM289779",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289779,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1847,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979.1",
      "ID": 2065
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5047,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne",
      "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4587468+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234516",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234516,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1847,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979.1",
      "ID": 2065
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1845,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette",
      "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3876429+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313162",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313162,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1847,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979.1",
      "ID": 2065
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3061,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1663331+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1768E19P265VM290208",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 290208,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1847,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979.1",
      "ID": 2065
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1768,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7369248+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225343",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225343,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1847,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979.1",
      "ID": 2065
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1894,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Neil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9704923+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3815E98P134VM270985",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270985,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1847,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979.1",
      "ID": 2065
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3815,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Park, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Park",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8375809+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265802",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265802,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1847,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979.1",
      "ID": 2065
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2010,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil",
      "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4551298+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5057E92P116VM282987",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 282987,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1847,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979.1",
      "ID": 2065
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5057,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.4429279+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2853E33P128VM252111",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252111,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1847,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979.1",
      "ID": 2065
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Pentland",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.5030723+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317301",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317301,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1847,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979.1",
      "ID": 2065
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5009,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4125228+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3745E233P381VM256705",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 256705,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1847,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979.1",
      "ID": 2065
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3745,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis",
      "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.7941597+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1870E225P478VM296954",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 296954,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1847,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979.1",
      "ID": 2065
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1870,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona",
      "DisplayName": "Shona Robison",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8811388+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2135E254P450VM235864",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235864,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1847,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979.1",
      "ID": 2065
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2135,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Russell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6962368+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1895E232P431VM257654",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257654,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1847,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979.1",
      "ID": 2065
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1895,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0658225+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228621",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 228621,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1847,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979.1",
      "ID": 2065
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1839,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.8070051+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2345E10P55VM291598",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291598,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1847,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979.1",
      "ID": 2065
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2345,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1342519+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311149",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311149,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1847,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979.1",
      "ID": 2065
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2223,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish",
      "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.607626+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246842",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 246842,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1847,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979.1",
      "ID": 2065
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2182,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1557433+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5079E101P119VM297665",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 297665,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1847,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979.1",
      "ID": 2065
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5079,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew",
      "DisplayName": "Drew Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1194851+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234104",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234104,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1847,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979.1",
      "ID": 2065
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1769,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1668157+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274917",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274917,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1847,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979.1",
      "ID": 2065
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4014,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz",
      "DisplayName": "Liz Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1276008+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2215E224P447VM270007",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270007,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1847,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979.1",
      "ID": 2065
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2215,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5775287+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317490",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317490,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1847,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979.1",
      "ID": 2065
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3806,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4246701+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326390",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 326390,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1847,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979.1",
      "ID": 2065
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5106,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin",
      "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7564406+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241326",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241326,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1847,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979.1",
      "ID": 2065
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1848,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola",
      "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7531151+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2098E237P531VM290371",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 290371,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1847,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979.1",
      "ID": 2065
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2098,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Swinney",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7439958+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248120",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248120,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1847,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979.1",
      "ID": 2065
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2674,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave",
      "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4428681+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5075E234P371VM288185",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 288185,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1847,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979.1",
      "ID": 2065
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5075,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Torrance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.9106234+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1793E151P362VM222587",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 222587,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1847,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979.1",
      "ID": 2065
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1793,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean",
      "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1953624+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5078E245P366VM306888",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306888,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1847,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979.1",
      "ID": 2065
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5078,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Walker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5778112+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1841E231P426VM240949",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 240949,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1847,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979.1",
      "ID": 2065
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1841,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen",
      "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.389348+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283763",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283763,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1847,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979.1",
      "ID": 2065
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4952,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7224262+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1865E263P500VM231730",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231730,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1847,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979.1",
      "ID": 2065
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1865,
      "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra",
      "DisplayName": "Sandra White",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6130843+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237284",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237284,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1847,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979.1",
      "ID": 2065
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2610,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Wilson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.1975815+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4941E150P382VM308936",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 308936,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1847,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 35,
      "VoteAgainst": 67,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979.1",
      "ID": 2065
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4941,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza",
      "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0844631+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252768",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252768,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1848,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979",
      "ID": 2045
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1926,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian",
      "DisplayName": "Brian Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7524677+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2615E213P388VM258960",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258960,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1848,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979",
      "ID": 2045
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2615,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George",
      "DisplayName": "George Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3356641+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319599",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319599,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1848,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979",
      "ID": 2045
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4940,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare",
      "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9332338+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2641E256P403VM250283",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250283,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1848,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979",
      "ID": 2045
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2641,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair",
      "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1825182+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1783E21P273VM228392",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 228392,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1848,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979",
      "ID": 2045
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1783,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie",
      "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.7970274+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2633E97P136VM281087",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 281087,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1848,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979",
      "ID": 2045
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2633,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire",
      "DisplayName": "Claire Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.8054375+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2603E89P148VM263013",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 263013,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1848,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979",
      "ID": 2045
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2603,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6329148+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1759E91P115VM229836",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229836,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1848,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979",
      "ID": 2045
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia",
      "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0995044+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3751E243P383VM269757",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269757,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1848,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979",
      "ID": 2045
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3751,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5616489+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322508",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 322508,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1848,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979",
      "ID": 2045
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5109,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco",
      "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6916411+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5060E86P124VM295395",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295395,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1848,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979",
      "ID": 2045
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5060,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5103396+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1866E93P239VM243002",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 243002,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1848,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979",
      "ID": 2045
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1866,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah",
      "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0447187+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235130",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235130,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1848,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979",
      "ID": 2045
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1943,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic",
      "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4206618+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302402",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 302402,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1848,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979",
      "ID": 2045
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2595,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin",
      "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5228333+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2103E244P421VM238440",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 238440,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1848,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979",
      "ID": 2045
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2103,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith",
      "DisplayName": "Keith Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4466302+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327108",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 327108,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1848,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979",
      "ID": 2045
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.799189+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277508",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277508,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1848,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979",
      "ID": 2045
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9563703+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2673E236P377VM263977",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 263977,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1848,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979",
      "ID": 2045
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2673,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick",
      "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9189302+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248588",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248588,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1848,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979",
      "ID": 2045
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2678,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson",
      "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6527598+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2123E27P233VM294910",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 294910,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1848,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979",
      "ID": 2045
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2123,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm",
      "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.184007+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285363",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285363,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1848,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979",
      "ID": 2045
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3907,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3197865+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1735E248P405VM231301",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231301,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1848,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979",
      "ID": 2045
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1735,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela",
      "DisplayName": "Angela Constance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.5890454+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243716",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 243716,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1848,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979",
      "ID": 2045
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1932,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce",
      "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3167686+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254844",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254844,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1848,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979",
      "ID": 2045
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1863,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna",
      "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2861837+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323715",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 323715,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1848,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979",
      "ID": 2045
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4976,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth",
      "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9687699+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5107E223P379VM290842",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 290842,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1848,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979",
      "ID": 2045
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5107,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7744877+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3743E222P391VM273060",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 273060,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1848,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979",
      "ID": 2045
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3743,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel",
      "DisplayName": "Nigel Don",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.367837+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262591",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262591,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1848,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979",
      "ID": 2045
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3771,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob",
      "DisplayName": "Bob Doris",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6084714+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281807",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 281807,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1848,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979",
      "ID": 2045
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2826,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Dornan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1584451+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298320",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298320,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1848,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979",
      "ID": 2045
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3812,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia",
      "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3406764+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231202",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231202,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1848,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979",
      "ID": 2045
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1778,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen",
      "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.5846951+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4955E240P389VM284993",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 284993,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1848,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979",
      "ID": 2045
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4955,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0566261+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219574",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 219574,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1848,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979",
      "ID": 2045
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1742,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle",
      "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3052418+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238466",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 238466,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1848,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979",
      "ID": 2045
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1994,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus",
      "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4552969+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1814E269P519VM226709",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 226709,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1848,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979",
      "ID": 2045
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1814,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda",
      "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2431971+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321952",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 321952,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1848,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979",
      "ID": 2045
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Fee",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4584899+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292680",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 292680,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1848,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979",
      "ID": 2045
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia",
      "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5532194+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227607",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227607,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1848,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979",
      "ID": 2045
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5573968+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5054E95P118VM312761",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 312761,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1848,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979",
      "ID": 2045
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5054,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1421875+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4947E152P361VM257843",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257843,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1848,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979",
      "ID": 2045
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4947,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Finnie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0799752+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271126",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271126,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1848,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979",
      "ID": 2045
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3901,
      "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe",
      "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8435912+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2394E15P47VM274386",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274386,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1848,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979",
      "ID": 2045
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2394,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo",
      "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1038226+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2110E220P414VM287297",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 287297,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1848,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979",
      "ID": 2045
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth",
      "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8580984+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250660",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250660,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1848,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979",
      "ID": 2045
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2675,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob",
      "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.2080588+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221127",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221127,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1848,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979",
      "ID": 2045
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1741,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel",
      "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6762264+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220069",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220069,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1848,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979",
      "ID": 2045
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1756,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine",
      "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3329908+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1860E104P150VM252422",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252422,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1848,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979",
      "ID": 2045
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1860,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda",
      "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7284611+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2033E20P141VM253712",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253712,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1848,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979",
      "ID": 2045
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2033,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain",
      "DisplayName": "Iain Gray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0177535+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324690",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324690,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1848,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979",
      "ID": 2045
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5042,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2337468+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259379",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 259379,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1848,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979",
      "ID": 2045
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick",
      "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6065743+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239431",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239431,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1848,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979",
      "ID": 2045
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2029,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh",
      "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7365047+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273603",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 273603,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1848,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979",
      "ID": 2045
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3758,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6274933+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304083",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 304083,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1848,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979",
      "ID": 2045
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4086,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Hume",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8489588+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1773E242P494VM223187",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223187,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1848,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979",
      "ID": 2045
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1773,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.2323774+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1882E227P459VM245854",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 245854,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1848,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979",
      "ID": 2045
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1882,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam",
      "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8612761+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223443",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223443,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1848,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979",
      "ID": 2045
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1893,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4582178+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307902",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307902,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1848,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979",
      "ID": 2045
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4934,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8558681+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272396",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 272396,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1848,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979",
      "ID": 2045
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4956,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Keir",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.333536+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2059E26P131VM245013",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 245013,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1848,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979",
      "ID": 2045
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Kelly",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5882592+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315181",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315181,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1848,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979",
      "ID": 2045
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3129,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6778079+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247530",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247530,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1848,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979",
      "ID": 2045
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann",
      "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4077866+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4016E11P36VM275114",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 275114,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1848,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979",
      "ID": 2045
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4016,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1421918+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255534",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255534,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1848,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979",
      "ID": 2045
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2180,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5354506+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4938E158P374VM276975",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276975,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1848,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979",
      "ID": 2045
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4938,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6894045+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2112E250P486VM253431",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253431,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1848,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979",
      "ID": 2045
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2112,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny",
      "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.9961402+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4939E258P394VM276343",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276343,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1848,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979",
      "ID": 2045
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4939,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus",
      "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6554565+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325441",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 325441,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1848,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979",
      "ID": 2045
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5074,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon",
      "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5065325+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1828E3P10VM232925",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232925,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1848,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979",
      "ID": 2045
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1828,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo",
      "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8825485+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311747",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311747,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1848,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979",
      "ID": 2045
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4948,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike",
      "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8925104+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2117E90P107VM229604",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229604,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1848,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979",
      "ID": 2045
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2117,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis",
      "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0888673+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267532",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 267532,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1848,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979",
      "ID": 2045
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken",
      "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0238837+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313413",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313413,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1848,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979",
      "ID": 2045
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4966,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek",
      "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.3942994+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3101E102P129VM294443",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 294443,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1848,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979",
      "ID": 2045
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3101,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala",
      "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1385477+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319201",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319201,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1848,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979",
      "ID": 2045
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5034,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny",
      "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6967706+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306306",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306306,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1848,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979",
      "ID": 2045
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2159,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Martin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5463893+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5110E252P395VM310380",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 310380,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1848,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979",
      "ID": 2045
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Mason",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5680348+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268072",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 268072,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1848,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979",
      "ID": 2045
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2133,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.054799+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2876E141P433VM292983",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 292983,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1848,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979",
      "ID": 2045
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2876,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5665934+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4951E147P368VM271866",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271866,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1848,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979",
      "ID": 2045
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4951,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan",
      "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.094804+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3896E175P307VM263547",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 263547,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1848,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979",
      "ID": 2045
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3896,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam",
      "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.8941025+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5080E110P121VM307215",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307215,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1848,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979",
      "ID": 2045
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8195924+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4964E143P375VM280157",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280157,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1848,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979",
      "ID": 2045
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4964,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5438825+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279165",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279165,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1848,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979",
      "ID": 2045
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3824,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2558221+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2066E22P91VM260507",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 260507,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1848,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979",
      "ID": 2045
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2066,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.0798596+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299344",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 299344,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1848,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979",
      "ID": 2045
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.6934128+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3759E260P411VM301773",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 301773,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1848,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979",
      "ID": 2045
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina",
      "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.2826277+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300498",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 300498,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1848,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979",
      "ID": 2045
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2487,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0007643+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1775E215P453VM224184",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 224184,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1848,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979",
      "ID": 2045
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4961815+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237900",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237900,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1848,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979",
      "ID": 2045
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1961,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David",
      "DisplayName": "David McLetchie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.230921+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305562",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 305562,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1848,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979",
      "ID": 2045
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2134,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3297231+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320069",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 320069,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1848,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979",
      "ID": 2045
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5041,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan",
      "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9603412+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315901",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315901,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1848,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979",
      "ID": 2045
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3763,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart",
      "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9321012+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1986E23P197VM237137",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237137,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1848,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979",
      "ID": 2045
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1986,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan",
      "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.967392+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5047E100P130VM288909",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 288909,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1848,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979",
      "ID": 2045
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5047,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne",
      "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.163583+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234515",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234515,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1848,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979",
      "ID": 2045
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1845,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette",
      "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.387601+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313161",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313161,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1848,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979",
      "ID": 2045
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3061,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.166292+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1768E19P265VM261287",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261287,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1848,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979",
      "ID": 2045
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1768,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3508693+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225344",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225344,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1848,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979",
      "ID": 2045
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1894,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Neil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9705342+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3815E98P134VM270986",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270986,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1848,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979",
      "ID": 2045
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3815,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Park, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Park",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8376223+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265801",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265801,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1848,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979",
      "ID": 2045
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2010,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil",
      "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4550693+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5057E92P116VM282986",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 282986,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1848,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979",
      "ID": 2045
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5057,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.4428854+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2853E33P128VM252112",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252112,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1848,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979",
      "ID": 2045
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Pentland",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.5031138+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317291",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317291,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1848,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979",
      "ID": 2045
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5009,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4120927+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3745E233P381VM256704",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 256704,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1848,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979",
      "ID": 2045
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3745,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis",
      "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.7941189+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1870E225P478VM293344",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 293344,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1848,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979",
      "ID": 2045
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1870,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona",
      "DisplayName": "Shona Robison",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8409748+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2135E254P450VM235865",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235865,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1848,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979",
      "ID": 2045
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2135,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Russell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6962777+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1895E232P431VM257655",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257655,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1848,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979",
      "ID": 2045
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1895,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0658638+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228622",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 228622,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1848,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979",
      "ID": 2045
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1839,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.8070466+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2345E10P55VM291597",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291597,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1848,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979",
      "ID": 2045
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2345,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1342101+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311150",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311150,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1848,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979",
      "ID": 2045
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2223,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish",
      "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.6077657+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246843",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 246843,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1848,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979",
      "ID": 2045
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2182,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1557847+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5079E101P119VM297663",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 297663,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1848,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979",
      "ID": 2045
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5079,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew",
      "DisplayName": "Drew Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1194045+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1769E32P285VM233849",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 233849,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1848,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979",
      "ID": 2045
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1769,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1489949+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274918",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274918,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1848,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979",
      "ID": 2045
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4014,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz",
      "DisplayName": "Liz Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1276419+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2215E224P447VM270008",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270008,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1848,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979",
      "ID": 2045
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2215,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5775697+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317491",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317491,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1848,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979",
      "ID": 2045
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3806,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4247133+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326389",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 326389,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1848,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979",
      "ID": 2045
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5106,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin",
      "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7563983+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241327",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241327,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1848,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979",
      "ID": 2045
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1848,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola",
      "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7531576+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2098E237P531VM290372",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 290372,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1848,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979",
      "ID": 2045
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2098,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Swinney",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7440372+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248121",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248121,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1848,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979",
      "ID": 2045
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2674,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave",
      "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4429114+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5075E234P371VM288186",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 288186,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1848,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979",
      "ID": 2045
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5075,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Torrance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.9106657+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1793E151P362VM222588",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 222588,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1848,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979",
      "ID": 2045
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1793,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean",
      "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1954043+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5078E245P366VM306911",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306911,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1848,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979",
      "ID": 2045
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5078,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Walker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5791817+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1841E231P426VM240948",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 240948,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1848,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979",
      "ID": 2045
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1841,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen",
      "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3893037+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283764",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283764,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1848,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979",
      "ID": 2045
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4952,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7224678+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1865E263P500VM231729",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231729,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1848,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979",
      "ID": 2045
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1865,
      "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra",
      "DisplayName": "Sandra White",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.613026+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237283",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237283,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1848,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979",
      "ID": 2045
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2610,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Wilson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.1975399+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4941E150P382VM308935",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 308935,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1848,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "The Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [draft]",
      "Reference": "S4M-01979",
      "ID": 2045
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4941,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza",
      "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0844209+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252770",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252770,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1850,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.3",
      "ID": 2064
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1926,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian",
      "DisplayName": "Brian Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7525474+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2615E213P388VM258962",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258962,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1850,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.3",
      "ID": 2064
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2615,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George",
      "DisplayName": "George Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3357446+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4940E159P373VM318741",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 318741,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1850,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.3",
      "ID": 2064
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4940,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare",
      "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6714153+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2641E256P403VM250281",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250281,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1850,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.3",
      "ID": 2064
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2641,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair",
      "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1824354+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1783E21P273VM228394",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 228394,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1850,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.3",
      "ID": 2064
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1783,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie",
      "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.7971096+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2633E97P136VM281089",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 281089,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1850,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.3",
      "ID": 2064
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2633,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire",
      "DisplayName": "Claire Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.8055184+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2603E89P148VM263015",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 263015,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1850,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.3",
      "ID": 2064
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2603,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6329975+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1759E91P115VM227439",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227439,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1850,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.3",
      "ID": 2064
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia",
      "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5502303+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3751E243P383VM269755",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269755,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1850,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.3",
      "ID": 2064
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3751,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5615677+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322510",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 322510,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1850,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.3",
      "ID": 2064
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5109,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco",
      "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6917222+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5060E86P124VM295397",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295397,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1850,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.3",
      "ID": 2064
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5060,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5104198+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1866E93P239VM243011",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 243011,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1850,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.3",
      "ID": 2064
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1866,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah",
      "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0451054+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235128",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235128,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1850,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.3",
      "ID": 2064
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1943,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic",
      "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4205792+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2595E12P30VM301017",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 301017,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1850,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.3",
      "ID": 2064
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2595,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin",
      "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0288642+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2103E244P421VM238438",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 238438,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1850,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.3",
      "ID": 2064
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2103,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith",
      "DisplayName": "Keith Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.446548+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5108E221P387VM326999",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 326999,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1850,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.3",
      "ID": 2064
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7892262+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277510",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277510,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1850,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.3",
      "ID": 2064
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9564513+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2673E236P377VM263975",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 263975,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1850,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.3",
      "ID": 2064
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2673,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick",
      "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.918848+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248586",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248586,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1850,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.3",
      "ID": 2064
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2678,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson",
      "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6526777+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2123E27P233VM294901",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 294901,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1850,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.3",
      "ID": 2064
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2123,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm",
      "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1836154+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285365",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285365,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1850,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.3",
      "ID": 2064
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3907,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3198866+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1735E248P405VM231303",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231303,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1850,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.3",
      "ID": 2064
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1735,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela",
      "DisplayName": "Angela Constance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.5891262+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243707",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 243707,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1850,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.3",
      "ID": 2064
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1932,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce",
      "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3163839+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254394",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254394,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1850,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.3",
      "ID": 2064
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1863,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna",
      "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2540165+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323452",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 323452,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1850,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.3",
      "ID": 2064
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4976,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth",
      "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9568012+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5107E223P379VM290839",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 290839,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1850,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.3",
      "ID": 2064
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5107,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7743666+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3743E222P391VM273062",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 273062,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1850,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.3",
      "ID": 2064
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3743,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel",
      "DisplayName": "Nigel Don",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3679184+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262593",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262593,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1850,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.3",
      "ID": 2064
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3771,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob",
      "DisplayName": "Bob Doris",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6085517+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281805",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 281805,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1850,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.3",
      "ID": 2064
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2826,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Dornan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.158345+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298322",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298322,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1850,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.3",
      "ID": 2064
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3812,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia",
      "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.340758+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231115",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231115,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1850,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.3",
      "ID": 2064
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1778,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen",
      "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3662576+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4955E240P389VM284989",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 284989,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1850,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.3",
      "ID": 2064
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4955,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0564412+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219576",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 219576,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1850,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.3",
      "ID": 2064
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1742,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle",
      "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3053239+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238464",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 238464,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1850,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.3",
      "ID": 2064
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1994,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus",
      "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4477598+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1814E269P519VM226707",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 226707,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1850,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.3",
      "ID": 2064
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1814,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda",
      "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2431152+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321950",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 321950,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1850,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.3",
      "ID": 2064
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Fee",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4584063+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292678",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 292678,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1850,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.3",
      "ID": 2064
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia",
      "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5531385+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227609",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227609,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1850,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.3",
      "ID": 2064
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5574782+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5054E95P118VM304580",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 304580,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1850,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.3",
      "ID": 2064
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5054,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.0445042+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4947E152P361VM257845",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257845,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1850,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.3",
      "ID": 2064
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4947,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Finnie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0800861+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271122",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271122,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1850,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.3",
      "ID": 2064
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3901,
      "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe",
      "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8434221+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2394E15P47VM274384",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274384,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1850,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.3",
      "ID": 2064
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2394,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo",
      "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1037399+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2110E220P414VM266074",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 266074,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1850,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.3",
      "ID": 2064
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth",
      "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4732426+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250662",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250662,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1850,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.3",
      "ID": 2064
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2675,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob",
      "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.2081384+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221129",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221129,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1850,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.3",
      "ID": 2064
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1741,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel",
      "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6763091+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220067",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220067,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1850,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.3",
      "ID": 2064
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1756,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine",
      "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.332908+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1860E104P150VM239692",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239692,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1850,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.3",
      "ID": 2064
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1860,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda",
      "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.754829+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2033E20P141VM253710",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253710,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1850,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.3",
      "ID": 2064
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2033,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain",
      "DisplayName": "Iain Gray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0176627+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324799",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324799,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1850,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.3",
      "ID": 2064
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5042,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2383252+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259377",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 259377,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1850,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.3",
      "ID": 2064
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick",
      "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6064912+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239433",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239433,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1850,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.3",
      "ID": 2064
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2029,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh",
      "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7365866+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273601",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 273601,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1850,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.3",
      "ID": 2064
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3758,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6274115+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4086E128P311VM303698",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 303698,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1850,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.3",
      "ID": 2064
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4086,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Hume",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8264968+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1773E242P494VM223185",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223185,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1850,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.3",
      "ID": 2064
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1773,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.2322933+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1882E227P459VM245697",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 245697,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1850,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.3",
      "ID": 2064
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1882,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam",
      "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8545617+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223441",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223441,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1850,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.3",
      "ID": 2064
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1893,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4581336+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307904",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307904,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1850,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.3",
      "ID": 2064
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4934,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.855951+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272398",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 272398,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1850,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.3",
      "ID": 2064
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4956,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Keir",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3336183+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2059E26P131VM245022",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 245022,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1850,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.3",
      "ID": 2064
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Kelly",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5886484+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315270",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315270,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1850,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.3",
      "ID": 2064
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3129,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9012836+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247528",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247528,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1850,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.3",
      "ID": 2064
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann",
      "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.407683+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4016E11P36VM275118",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 275118,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1850,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.3",
      "ID": 2064
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4016,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1423579+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255532",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255532,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1850,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.3",
      "ID": 2064
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2180,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5353687+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4938E158P374VM276971",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276971,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1850,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.3",
      "ID": 2064
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4938,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6892197+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2112E250P486VM253433",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253433,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1850,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.3",
      "ID": 2064
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2112,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny",
      "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.996224+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4939E258P394VM276340",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276340,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1850,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.3",
      "ID": 2064
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4939,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus",
      "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6553128+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325332",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 325332,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1850,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.3",
      "ID": 2064
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5074,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon",
      "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.4941337+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1828E3P10VM231922",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231922,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1850,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.3",
      "ID": 2064
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1828,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo",
      "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6215376+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311749",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311749,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1850,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.3",
      "ID": 2064
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4948,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike",
      "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8925906+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2117E90P107VM229602",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229602,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1850,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.3",
      "ID": 2064
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2117,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis",
      "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.088786+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267534",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 267534,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1850,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.3",
      "ID": 2064
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken",
      "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0239652+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313411",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313411,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1850,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.3",
      "ID": 2064
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4966,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek",
      "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.3942174+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3101E102P129VM294441",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 294441,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1850,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.3",
      "ID": 2064
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3101,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala",
      "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1384471+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319199",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319199,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1850,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.3",
      "ID": 2064
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5034,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny",
      "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6966881+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306215",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306215,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1850,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.3",
      "ID": 2064
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2159,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Martin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5424724+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5110E252P395VM310378",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 310378,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1850,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.3",
      "ID": 2064
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Mason",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5679337+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268070",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 268070,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1850,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.3",
      "ID": 2064
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2133,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0546924+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2876E141P433VM292985",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 292985,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1850,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.3",
      "ID": 2064
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2876,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5666957+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4951E147P368VM271864",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271864,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1850,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.3",
      "ID": 2064
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4951,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan",
      "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.094722+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3896E175P307VM263545",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 263545,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1850,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.3",
      "ID": 2064
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3896,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam",
      "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.8940199+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5080E110P121VM307217",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307217,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1850,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.3",
      "ID": 2064
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8196749+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4964E143P375VM280160",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280160,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1850,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.3",
      "ID": 2064
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4964,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5440065+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279163",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279163,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1850,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.3",
      "ID": 2064
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3824,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2557405+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2066E22P91VM260498",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 260498,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1850,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.3",
      "ID": 2064
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2066,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.0794861+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299342",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 299342,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1850,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.3",
      "ID": 2064
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.6933317+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3759E260P411VM301775",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 301775,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1850,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.3",
      "ID": 2064
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina",
      "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.2827108+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300496",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 300496,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1850,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.3",
      "ID": 2064
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2487,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0006825+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1775E215P453VM224186",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 224186,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1850,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.3",
      "ID": 2064
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4962882+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237902",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237902,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1850,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.3",
      "ID": 2064
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1961,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David",
      "DisplayName": "David McLetchie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.231003+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305652",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 305652,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1850,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.3",
      "ID": 2064
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2134,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3335902+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320071",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 320071,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1850,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.3",
      "ID": 2064
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5041,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan",
      "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9604263+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315813",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315813,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1850,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.3",
      "ID": 2064
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3763,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart",
      "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9281499+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1986E23P197VM237139",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237139,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1850,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.3",
      "ID": 2064
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1986,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan",
      "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9674913+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5047E100P130VM288907",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 288907,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1850,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.3",
      "ID": 2064
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5047,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne",
      "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1634834+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234222",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234222,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1850,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.3",
      "ID": 2064
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1845,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette",
      "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3675446+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3061E19P43VM312916",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 312916,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1850,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.3",
      "ID": 2064
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3061,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1554109+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1768E19P265VM261289",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261289,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1850,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.3",
      "ID": 2064
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1768,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3509506+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225346",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225346,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1850,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.3",
      "ID": 2064
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1894,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Neil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9706168+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3815E98P134VM270988",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270988,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1850,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.3",
      "ID": 2064
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3815,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Park, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Park",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8377233+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265662",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265662,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1850,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.3",
      "ID": 2064
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2010,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil",
      "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4488876+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5057E92P116VM282983",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 282983,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1850,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.3",
      "ID": 2064
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5057,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.4427423+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2853E33P128VM252114",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252114,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1850,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.3",
      "ID": 2064
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Pentland",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.5031958+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317293",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317293,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1850,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.3",
      "ID": 2064
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5009,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4121753+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3745E233P381VM256702",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 256702,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1850,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.3",
      "ID": 2064
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3745,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis",
      "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.7940376+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1870E225P478VM293346",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 293346,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1850,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.3",
      "ID": 2064
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1870,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona",
      "DisplayName": "Shona Robison",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.841057+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2135E254P450VM235867",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235867,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1850,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.3",
      "ID": 2064
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2135,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Russell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6963587+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1895E232P431VM255891",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255891,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1850,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.3",
      "ID": 2064
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1895,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5614383+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228624",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 228624,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1850,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.3",
      "ID": 2064
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1839,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.807129+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2345E10P55VM289527",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289527,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1850,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.3",
      "ID": 2064
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2345,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4479064+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311551",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311551,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1850,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.3",
      "ID": 2064
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2223,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish",
      "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8837399+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246845",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 246845,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1850,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.3",
      "ID": 2064
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2182,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1558646+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5079E101P119VM297661",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 297661,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1850,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.3",
      "ID": 2064
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5079,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew",
      "DisplayName": "Drew Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1193213+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1769E32P285VM233847",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 233847,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1850,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.3",
      "ID": 2064
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1769,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1489136+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274920",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274920,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1850,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.3",
      "ID": 2064
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4014,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz",
      "DisplayName": "Liz Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1277243+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2215E224P447VM270010",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270010,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1850,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.3",
      "ID": 2064
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2215,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5776522+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317735",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317735,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1850,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.3",
      "ID": 2064
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3806,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4351133+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326498",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 326498,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1850,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.3",
      "ID": 2064
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5106,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin",
      "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7672796+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241329",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241329,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1850,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.3",
      "ID": 2064
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1848,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola",
      "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7532394+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2098E237P531VM290381",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 290381,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1850,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.3",
      "ID": 2064
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2098,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Swinney",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7444906+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248123",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248123,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1850,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.3",
      "ID": 2064
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2674,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave",
      "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4430293+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5075E234P371VM288189",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 288189,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1850,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.3",
      "ID": 2064
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5075,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Torrance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.9107897+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1793E151P362VM222590",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 222590,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1850,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.3",
      "ID": 2064
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1793,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean",
      "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1954869+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5078E245P366VM306909",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306909,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1850,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.3",
      "ID": 2064
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5078,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Walker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5790512+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1841E231P426VM240946",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 240946,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1850,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.3",
      "ID": 2064
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1841,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen",
      "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3892041+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283768",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283768,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1850,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.3",
      "ID": 2064
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4952,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7226311+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1865E263P500VM231727",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231727,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1850,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.3",
      "ID": 2064
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1865,
      "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra",
      "DisplayName": "Sandra White",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6129457+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237281",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237281,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1850,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.3",
      "ID": 2064
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2610,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Wilson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.1974581+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4941E150P382VM308933",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 308933,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1850,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 51,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.3",
      "ID": 2064
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4941,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza",
      "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.084339+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252769",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252769,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1849,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 54,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.2",
      "ID": 2063
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1926,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian",
      "DisplayName": "Brian Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7525074+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2615E213P388VM258961",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258961,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1849,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 54,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.2",
      "ID": 2063
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2615,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George",
      "DisplayName": "George Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3357047+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319598",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319598,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1849,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 54,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.2",
      "ID": 2063
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4940,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare",
      "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9331696+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2641E256P403VM250282",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250282,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1849,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 54,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.2",
      "ID": 2063
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2641,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair",
      "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1824765+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1783E21P273VM228393",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 228393,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1849,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 54,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.2",
      "ID": 2063
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1783,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie",
      "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.7970686+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2633E97P136VM281088",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 281088,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1849,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 54,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.2",
      "ID": 2063
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2633,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire",
      "DisplayName": "Claire Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.8054781+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2603E89P148VM263014",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 263014,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1849,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 54,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.2",
      "ID": 2063
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2603,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6329567+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1759E91P115VM229838",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229838,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1849,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 54,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.2",
      "ID": 2063
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia",
      "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0995878+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3751E243P383VM269756",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269756,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1849,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 54,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.2",
      "ID": 2063
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3751,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5616078+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322509",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 322509,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1849,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 54,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.2",
      "ID": 2063
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5109,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco",
      "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6916814+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5060E86P124VM295396",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295396,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1849,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 54,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.2",
      "ID": 2063
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5060,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5103796+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1866E93P239VM243003",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 243003,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1849,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 54,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.2",
      "ID": 2063
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1866,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah",
      "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0447594+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235129",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235129,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1849,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 54,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.2",
      "ID": 2063
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1943,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic",
      "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4206208+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2595E12P30VM301016",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 301016,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1849,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 54,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.2",
      "ID": 2063
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2595,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin",
      "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0287845+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2103E244P421VM238439",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 238439,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1849,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 54,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.2",
      "ID": 2063
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2103,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith",
      "DisplayName": "Keith Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4465889+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327081",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 327081,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1849,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 54,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.2",
      "ID": 2063
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7980303+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277509",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277509,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1849,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 54,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.2",
      "ID": 2063
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9564108+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2673E236P377VM263976",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 263976,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1849,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 54,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.2",
      "ID": 2063
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2673,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick",
      "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9188886+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248587",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248587,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1849,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 54,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.2",
      "ID": 2063
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2678,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson",
      "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6527183+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2123E27P233VM294909",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 294909,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1849,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 54,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.2",
      "ID": 2063
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2123,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm",
      "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1839465+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285364",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285364,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1849,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 54,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.2",
      "ID": 2063
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3907,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3198272+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1735E248P405VM231302",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231302,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1849,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 54,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.2",
      "ID": 2063
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1735,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela",
      "DisplayName": "Angela Constance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.5890858+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243715",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 243715,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1849,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 54,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.2",
      "ID": 2063
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1932,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce",
      "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3167278+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254395",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254395,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1849,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 54,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.2",
      "ID": 2063
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1863,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna",
      "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2540684+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323688",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 323688,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1849,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 54,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.2",
      "ID": 2063
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4976,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth",
      "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9676083+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5107E223P379VM290841",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 290841,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1849,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 54,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.2",
      "ID": 2063
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5107,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7744473+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3743E222P391VM273061",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 273061,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1849,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 54,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.2",
      "ID": 2063
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3743,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel",
      "DisplayName": "Nigel Don",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3678778+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262592",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262592,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1849,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 54,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.2",
      "ID": 2063
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3771,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob",
      "DisplayName": "Bob Doris",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6085117+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281806",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 281806,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1849,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 54,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.2",
      "ID": 2063
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2826,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Dornan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1583848+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3812E94P117VM298321",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298321,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1849,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 54,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.2",
      "ID": 2063
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3812,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia",
      "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3407178+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231200",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231200,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1849,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 54,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.2",
      "ID": 2063
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1778,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen",
      "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.5845818+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4955E240P389VM284990",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 284990,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1849,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 54,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.2",
      "ID": 2063
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4955,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0564816+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219575",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 219575,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1849,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 54,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.2",
      "ID": 2063
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1742,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle",
      "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3052828+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238465",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 238465,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1849,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 54,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.2",
      "ID": 2063
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1994,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus",
      "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4552264+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1814E269P519VM226708",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 226708,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1849,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 54,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.2",
      "ID": 2063
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1814,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda",
      "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2431557+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321951",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 321951,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1849,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 54,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.2",
      "ID": 2063
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Fee",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4584477+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292679",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 292679,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1849,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 54,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.2",
      "ID": 2063
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia",
      "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5531788+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227608",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227608,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1849,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 54,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.2",
      "ID": 2063
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5574373+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5054E95P118VM304579",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 304579,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1849,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 54,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.2",
      "ID": 2063
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5054,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.0444637+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4947E152P361VM257844",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257844,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1849,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 54,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.2",
      "ID": 2063
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4947,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Finnie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0800433+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271123",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271123,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1849,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 54,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.2",
      "ID": 2063
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3901,
      "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe",
      "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8434618+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2394E15P47VM274385",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274385,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1849,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 54,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.2",
      "ID": 2063
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2394,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo",
      "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1037813+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2110E220P414VM266073",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 266073,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1849,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 54,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.2",
      "ID": 2063
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth",
      "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4732014+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250661",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250661,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1849,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 54,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.2",
      "ID": 2063
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2675,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob",
      "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.2080986+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1741E10P50VM221128",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221128,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1849,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 54,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.2",
      "ID": 2063
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1741,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel",
      "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6762679+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220068",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220068,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1849,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 54,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.2",
      "ID": 2063
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1756,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine",
      "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.3329491+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1860E104P150VM252423",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252423,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1849,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 54,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.2",
      "ID": 2063
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1860,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda",
      "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7285019+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2033E20P141VM253711",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253711,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1849,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 54,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.2",
      "ID": 2063
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2033,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain",
      "DisplayName": "Iain Gray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.0177047+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324717",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324717,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1849,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 54,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.2",
      "ID": 2063
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5042,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2348905+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259378",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 259378,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1849,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 54,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.2",
      "ID": 2063
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick",
      "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6065328+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239432",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239432,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1849,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 54,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.2",
      "ID": 2063
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2029,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh",
      "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7365454+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273602",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 273602,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1849,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 54,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.2",
      "ID": 2063
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3758,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6274524+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4086E128P311VM303699",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 303699,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1849,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 54,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.2",
      "ID": 2063
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4086,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Hume",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.826537+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1773E242P494VM223186",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223186,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1849,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 54,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.2",
      "ID": 2063
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1773,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.2323354+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1882E227P459VM245698",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 245698,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1849,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 54,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.2",
      "ID": 2063
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1882,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam",
      "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8546198+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223442",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223442,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1849,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 54,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.2",
      "ID": 2063
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1893,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4581758+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307903",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307903,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1849,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 54,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.2",
      "ID": 2063
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4934,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.85591+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272397",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 272397,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1849,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 54,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.2",
      "ID": 2063
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4956,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Keir",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3335775+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2059E26P131VM245014",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 245014,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1849,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 54,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.2",
      "ID": 2063
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Kelly",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5883185+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315182",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315182,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1849,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 54,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.2",
      "ID": 2063
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3129,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6778487+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247529",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247529,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1849,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 54,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.2",
      "ID": 2063
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann",
      "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4077443+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4016E11P36VM275117",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 275117,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1849,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 54,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.2",
      "ID": 2063
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4016,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1423168+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255533",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255533,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1849,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 54,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.2",
      "ID": 2063
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2180,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5354096+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4938E158P374VM276972",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276972,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1849,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 54,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.2",
      "ID": 2063
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4938,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6892603+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2112E250P486VM253432",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253432,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1849,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 54,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.2",
      "ID": 2063
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2112,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny",
      "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.9961826+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4939E258P394VM276342",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276342,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1849,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 54,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.2",
      "ID": 2063
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4939,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus",
      "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6554149+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325414",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 325414,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1849,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 54,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.2",
      "ID": 2063
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5074,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon",
      "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.4976539+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1828E3P10VM232927",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232927,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1849,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 54,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.2",
      "ID": 2063
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1828,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo",
      "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.882632+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311748",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311748,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1849,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 54,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.2",
      "ID": 2063
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4948,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike",
      "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8925502+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2117E90P107VM229603",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229603,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1849,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 54,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.2",
      "ID": 2063
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2117,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis",
      "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.088826+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267533",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 267533,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1849,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 54,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.2",
      "ID": 2063
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken",
      "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.023924+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313412",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313412,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1849,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 54,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.2",
      "ID": 2063
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4966,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek",
      "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.394258+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3101E102P129VM294442",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 294442,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1849,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 54,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.2",
      "ID": 2063
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3101,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala",
      "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1385055+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319200",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319200,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1849,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 54,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.2",
      "ID": 2063
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5034,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny",
      "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6967289+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306305",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306305,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1849,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 54,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.2",
      "ID": 2063
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2159,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Martin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5463481+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5110E252P395VM310379",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 310379,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1849,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 54,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.2",
      "ID": 2063
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Mason",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5679745+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268071",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 268071,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1849,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 54,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.2",
      "ID": 2063
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2133,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0547556+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2876E141P433VM292984",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 292984,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1849,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 54,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.2",
      "ID": 2063
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2876,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5666532+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4951E147P368VM271865",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271865,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1849,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 54,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.2",
      "ID": 2063
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4951,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan",
      "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0947622+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3896E175P307VM263546",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 263546,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1849,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 54,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.2",
      "ID": 2063
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3896,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam",
      "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.8940606+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5080E110P121VM307216",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307216,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1849,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 54,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.2",
      "ID": 2063
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8196337+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4964E143P375VM280158",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280158,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1849,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 54,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.2",
      "ID": 2063
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4964,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5439248+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279164",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279164,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1849,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 54,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.2",
      "ID": 2063
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3824,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2557811+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2066E22P91VM260506",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 260506,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1849,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 54,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.2",
      "ID": 2063
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2066,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.0798181+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299343",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 299343,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1849,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 54,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.2",
      "ID": 2063
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.693372+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3759E260P411VM301774",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 301774,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1849,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 54,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.2",
      "ID": 2063
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina",
      "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.2826697+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2487E146P369VM300497",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 300497,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1849,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 54,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.2",
      "ID": 2063
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2487,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0007232+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1775E215P453VM224185",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 224185,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1849,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 54,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.2",
      "ID": 2063
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4962454+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237901",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237901,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1849,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 54,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.2",
      "ID": 2063
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1961,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David",
      "DisplayName": "David McLetchie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2309623+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305563",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 305563,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1849,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 54,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.2",
      "ID": 2063
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2134,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3297631+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320070",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 320070,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1849,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 54,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.2",
      "ID": 2063
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5041,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan",
      "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9603831+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3763E142P397VM315900",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315900,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1849,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 54,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.2",
      "ID": 2063
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3763,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart",
      "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9320597+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1986E23P197VM237138",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237138,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1849,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 54,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.2",
      "ID": 2063
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1986,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan",
      "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9674319+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5047E100P130VM288908",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 288908,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1849,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 54,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.2",
      "ID": 2063
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5047,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne",
      "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1635236+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234513",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234513,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1849,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 54,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.2",
      "ID": 2063
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1845,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette",
      "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3875164+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313160",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313160,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1849,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 54,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.2",
      "ID": 2063
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3061,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1662504+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1768E19P265VM261288",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261288,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1849,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 54,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.2",
      "ID": 2063
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1768,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3509101+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225345",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225345,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1849,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 54,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.2",
      "ID": 2063
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1894,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Neil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9705757+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3815E98P134VM270987",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270987,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1849,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 54,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.2",
      "ID": 2063
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3815,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Park, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Park",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8376815+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265663",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265663,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1849,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 54,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.2",
      "ID": 2063
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2010,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil",
      "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4489306+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5057E92P116VM282985",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 282985,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1849,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 54,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.2",
      "ID": 2063
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5057,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.442825+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2853E33P128VM252113",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252113,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1849,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 54,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.2",
      "ID": 2063
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Pentland",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.5031552+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317292",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317292,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1849,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 54,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.2",
      "ID": 2063
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5009,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4121342+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3745E233P381VM256703",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 256703,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1849,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 54,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.2",
      "ID": 2063
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3745,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis",
      "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.7940777+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1870E225P478VM293345",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 293345,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1849,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 54,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.2",
      "ID": 2063
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1870,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona",
      "DisplayName": "Shona Robison",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.841016+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2135E254P450VM235866",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235866,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1849,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 54,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.2",
      "ID": 2063
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2135,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Russell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.696318+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1895E232P431VM255890",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255890,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1849,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 54,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.2",
      "ID": 2063
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1895,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5613989+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228623",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 228623,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1849,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 54,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.2",
      "ID": 2063
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1839,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.8070882+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2345E10P55VM289528",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289528,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1849,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 54,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.2",
      "ID": 2063
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2345,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4479467+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311151",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311151,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1849,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 54,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.2",
      "ID": 2063
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2223,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish",
      "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.6078929+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246844",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 246844,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1849,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 54,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.2",
      "ID": 2063
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2182,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.155825+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5079E101P119VM297662",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 297662,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1849,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 54,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.2",
      "ID": 2063
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5079,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew",
      "DisplayName": "Drew Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1193623+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1769E32P285VM233848",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 233848,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1849,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 54,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.2",
      "ID": 2063
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1769,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1489539+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274919",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274919,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1849,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 54,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.2",
      "ID": 2063
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4014,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz",
      "DisplayName": "Liz Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1276832+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2215E224P447VM270009",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270009,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1849,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 54,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.2",
      "ID": 2063
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2215,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.577611+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317492",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317492,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1849,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 54,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.2",
      "ID": 2063
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3806,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4247543+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326416",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 326416,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1849,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 54,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.2",
      "ID": 2063
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5106,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin",
      "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7576147+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241328",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241328,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1849,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 54,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.2",
      "ID": 2063
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1848,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola",
      "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7531987+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2098E237P531VM290373",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 290373,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1849,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 54,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.2",
      "ID": 2063
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2098,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Swinney",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.7440784+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2674E247P401VM248122",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248122,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1849,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 54,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.2",
      "ID": 2063
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2674,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave",
      "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4429769+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5075E234P371VM288187",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 288187,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1849,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 54,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.2",
      "ID": 2063
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5075,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Torrance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.9107072+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1793E151P362VM222589",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 222589,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1849,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 54,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.2",
      "ID": 2063
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1793,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean",
      "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1954452+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5078E245P366VM306910",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306910,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1849,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 54,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.2",
      "ID": 2063
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5078,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Walker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5790923+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1841E231P426VM240947",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 240947,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1849,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 54,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.2",
      "ID": 2063
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1841,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen",
      "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3892445+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283767",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283767,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1849,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 54,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.2",
      "ID": 2063
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4952,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7225901+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1865E263P500VM231728",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231728,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1849,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 54,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.2",
      "ID": 2063
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1865,
      "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra",
      "DisplayName": "Sandra White",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6129854+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237282",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237282,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1849,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 54,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.2",
      "ID": 2063
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2610,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Wilson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.1974989+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4941E150P382VM308934",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 308934,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1849,
      "AgendaID": 2723,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 54,
      "VoteAgainst": 62,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Youth Employment Strategy",
      "Reference": "S4M-01978.2",
      "ID": 2063
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4941,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza",
      "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-09T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0843797+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252296",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252296,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1846,
      "AgendaID": 3008,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 70,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01960",
      "ID": 2032
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1926,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian",
      "DisplayName": "Brian Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7230398+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2615E213P388VM258837",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258837,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1846,
      "AgendaID": 3008,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 70,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01960",
      "ID": 2032
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2615,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George",
      "DisplayName": "George Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.330042+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319891",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319891,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1846,
      "AgendaID": 3008,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 70,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01960",
      "ID": 2032
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4940,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare",
      "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9458394+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249680",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 249680,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1846,
      "AgendaID": 3008,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 70,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01960",
      "ID": 2032
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2641,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair",
      "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9451973+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1783E21P273VM227403",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227403,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1846,
      "AgendaID": 3008,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 70,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01960",
      "ID": 2032
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1783,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie",
      "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5486423+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2633E97P136VM280399",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280399,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1846,
      "AgendaID": 3008,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 70,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01960",
      "ID": 2032
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2633,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire",
      "DisplayName": "Claire Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7652975+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262479",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262479,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1846,
      "AgendaID": 3008,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 70,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01960",
      "ID": 2032
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2603,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6037165+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1759E91P115VM229728",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229728,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1846,
      "AgendaID": 3008,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 70,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01960",
      "ID": 2032
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia",
      "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0941088+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270190",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270190,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1846,
      "AgendaID": 3008,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 70,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01960",
      "ID": 2032
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3751,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5854209+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322858",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 322858,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1846,
      "AgendaID": 3008,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 70,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01960",
      "ID": 2032
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5109,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco",
      "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.7065857+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5060E86P124VM294710",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 294710,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1846,
      "AgendaID": 3008,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 70,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01960",
      "ID": 2032
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5060,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1749959+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242861",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242861,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1846,
      "AgendaID": 3008,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 70,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01960",
      "ID": 2032
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1866,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah",
      "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0387509+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235563",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235563,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1846,
      "AgendaID": 3008,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 70,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01960",
      "ID": 2032
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1943,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic",
      "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6831908+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302136",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 302136,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1846,
      "AgendaID": 3008,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 70,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01960",
      "ID": 2032
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2595,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin",
      "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.298614+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244521",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244521,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1846,
      "AgendaID": 3008,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 70,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01960",
      "ID": 2032
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2103,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith",
      "DisplayName": "Keith Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5583604+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327240",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 327240,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1846,
      "AgendaID": 3008,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 70,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01960",
      "ID": 2032
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:46.0273049+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3775E216P435VM276662",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276662,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1846,
      "AgendaID": 3008,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 70,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01960",
      "ID": 2032
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6757783+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264355",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264355,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1846,
      "AgendaID": 3008,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 70,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01960",
      "ID": 2032
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2673,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick",
      "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1299307+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248789",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248789,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1846,
      "AgendaID": 3008,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 70,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01960",
      "ID": 2032
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2678,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson",
      "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.670124+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2123E27P233VM295822",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295822,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1846,
      "AgendaID": 3008,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 70,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01960",
      "ID": 2032
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2123,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm",
      "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5373339+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285140",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285140,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1846,
      "AgendaID": 3008,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 70,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01960",
      "ID": 2032
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3907,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.068156+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230155",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230155,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1846,
      "AgendaID": 3008,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 70,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01960",
      "ID": 2032
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1735,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela",
      "DisplayName": "Angela Constance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.1185938+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243858",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 243858,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1846,
      "AgendaID": 3008,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 70,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01960",
      "ID": 2032
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1932,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce",
      "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.322929+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254952",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254952,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1846,
      "AgendaID": 3008,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 70,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01960",
      "ID": 2032
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1863,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna",
      "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2908575+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323875",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 323875,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1846,
      "AgendaID": 3008,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 70,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01960",
      "ID": 2032
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4976,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth",
      "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9761477+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5107E223P379VM291348",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291348,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1846,
      "AgendaID": 3008,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 70,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01960",
      "ID": 2032
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5107,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1153191+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3743E222P391VM265311",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265311,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1846,
      "AgendaID": 3008,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 70,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01960",
      "ID": 2032
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3743,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel",
      "DisplayName": "Nigel Don",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4337012+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262236",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262236,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1846,
      "AgendaID": 3008,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 70,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01960",
      "ID": 2032
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3771,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob",
      "DisplayName": "Bob Doris",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.5928044+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2826E262P384VM282032",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 282032,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1846,
      "AgendaID": 3008,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 70,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01960",
      "ID": 2032
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2826,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Dornan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1682644+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3812E94P117VM297939",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 297939,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1846,
      "AgendaID": 3008,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 70,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01960",
      "ID": 2032
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3812,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia",
      "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1314212+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231616",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231616,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1846,
      "AgendaID": 3008,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 70,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01960",
      "ID": 2032
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1778,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen",
      "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6082717+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4955E240P389VM285953",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285953,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1846,
      "AgendaID": 3008,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 70,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01960",
      "ID": 2032
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4955,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3516466+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219374",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 219374,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1846,
      "AgendaID": 3008,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 70,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01960",
      "ID": 2032
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1742,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle",
      "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.2958673+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238590",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 238590,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1846,
      "AgendaID": 3008,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 70,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01960",
      "ID": 2032
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1994,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus",
      "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4606691+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225483",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225483,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1846,
      "AgendaID": 3008,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 70,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01960",
      "ID": 2032
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1814,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda",
      "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9766792+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321602",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 321602,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1846,
      "AgendaID": 3008,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 70,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01960",
      "ID": 2032
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Fee",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4431472+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1853E35P216VM293287",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 293287,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1846,
      "AgendaID": 3008,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 70,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01960",
      "ID": 2032
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia",
      "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8384953+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1892E12P64VM226944",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 226944,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1846,
      "AgendaID": 3008,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 70,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01960",
      "ID": 2032
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2537163+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5054E95P118VM312652",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 312652,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1846,
      "AgendaID": 3008,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 70,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01960",
      "ID": 2032
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5054,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1375253+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4947E152P361VM257141",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257141,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1846,
      "AgendaID": 3008,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 70,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01960",
      "ID": 2032
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4947,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Finnie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.8250759+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271309",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271309,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1846,
      "AgendaID": 3008,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 70,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01960",
      "ID": 2032
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3901,
      "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe",
      "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.069893+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278476",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 278476,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1846,
      "AgendaID": 3008,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 70,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01960",
      "ID": 2032
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2394,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo",
      "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2204526+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2110E220P414VM286724",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286724,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1846,
      "AgendaID": 3008,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 70,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01960",
      "ID": 2032
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth",
      "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5980046+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250419",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250419,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1846,
      "AgendaID": 3008,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 70,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01960",
      "ID": 2032
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2675,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob",
      "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1887421+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1741E10P50VM220732",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220732,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1846,
      "AgendaID": 3008,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 70,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01960",
      "ID": 2032
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1741,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel",
      "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6546587+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220269",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220269,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1846,
      "AgendaID": 3008,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 70,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01960",
      "ID": 2032
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1756,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine",
      "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6311346+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1860E104P150VM251851",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251851,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1846,
      "AgendaID": 3008,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 70,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01960",
      "ID": 2032
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1860,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda",
      "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.491883+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2033E20P141VM266161",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 266161,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1846,
      "AgendaID": 3008,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 70,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01960",
      "ID": 2032
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2033,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain",
      "DisplayName": "Iain Gray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4769432+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324558",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324558,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1846,
      "AgendaID": 3008,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 70,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01960",
      "ID": 2032
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5042,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2281605+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259736",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 259736,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1846,
      "AgendaID": 3008,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 70,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01960",
      "ID": 2032
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick",
      "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.622324+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239307",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239307,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1846,
      "AgendaID": 3008,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 70,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01960",
      "ID": 2032
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2029,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh",
      "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.731178+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273826",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 273826,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1846,
      "AgendaID": 3008,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 70,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01960",
      "ID": 2032
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3758,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6373291+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304193",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 304193,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1846,
      "AgendaID": 3008,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 70,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01960",
      "ID": 2032
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4086,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Hume",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8540403+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221807",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221807,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1846,
      "AgendaID": 3008,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 70,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01960",
      "ID": 2032
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1773,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9486622+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1882E227P459VM242043",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242043,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1846,
      "AgendaID": 3008,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 70,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01960",
      "ID": 2032
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1882,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam",
      "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7913516+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223722",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223722,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1846,
      "AgendaID": 3008,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 70,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01960",
      "ID": 2032
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1893,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4709656+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307523",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307523,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1846,
      "AgendaID": 3008,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 70,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01960",
      "ID": 2032
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4934,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8332065+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272158",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 272158,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1846,
      "AgendaID": 3008,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 70,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01960",
      "ID": 2032
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4956,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Keir",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.1140708+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244869",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244869,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1846,
      "AgendaID": 3008,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 70,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01960",
      "ID": 2032
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Kelly",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.582102+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315041",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315041,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1846,
      "AgendaID": 3008,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 70,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01960",
      "ID": 2032
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3129,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6715261+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247961",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247961,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1846,
      "AgendaID": 3008,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 70,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01960",
      "ID": 2032
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann",
      "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4357952+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4016E11P36VM274777",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274777,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1846,
      "AgendaID": 3008,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 70,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01960",
      "ID": 2032
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4016,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1213015+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255811",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255811,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1846,
      "AgendaID": 3008,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 70,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01960",
      "ID": 2032
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2180,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5580951+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4938E158P374VM277468",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277468,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1846,
      "AgendaID": 3008,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 70,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01960",
      "ID": 2032
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4938,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9546557+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2112E250P486VM253001",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253001,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1846,
      "AgendaID": 3008,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 70,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01960",
      "ID": 2032
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2112,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny",
      "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7625869+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4939E258P394VM276853",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276853,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1846,
      "AgendaID": 3008,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 70,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01960",
      "ID": 2032
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4939,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus",
      "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6839098+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325573",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 325573,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1846,
      "AgendaID": 3008,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 70,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01960",
      "ID": 2032
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5074,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon",
      "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5121572+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1828E3P10VM232817",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232817,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1846,
      "AgendaID": 3008,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 70,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01960",
      "ID": 2032
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1828,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo",
      "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8775183+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311370",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311370,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1846,
      "AgendaID": 3008,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 70,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01960",
      "ID": 2032
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4948,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike",
      "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8757897+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2117E90P107VM230423",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230423,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1846,
      "AgendaID": 3008,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 70,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01960",
      "ID": 2032
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2117,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis",
      "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3291787+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267310",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 267310,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1846,
      "AgendaID": 3008,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 70,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01960",
      "ID": 2032
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken",
      "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.013924+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313791",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313791,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1846,
      "AgendaID": 3008,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 70,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01960",
      "ID": 2032
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4966,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek",
      "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.410822+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3101E102P129VM295443",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295443,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1846,
      "AgendaID": 3008,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 70,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01960",
      "ID": 2032
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3101,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala",
      "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5123657+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5034E88P114VM318851",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 318851,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1846,
      "AgendaID": 3008,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 70,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01960",
      "ID": 2032
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5034,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny",
      "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6761514+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306446",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306446,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1846,
      "AgendaID": 3008,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 70,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01960",
      "ID": 2032
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2159,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Martin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.552416+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5110E252P395VM311284",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311284,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1846,
      "AgendaID": 3008,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 70,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01960",
      "ID": 2032
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Mason",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.872032+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268294",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 268294,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1846,
      "AgendaID": 3008,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 70,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01960",
      "ID": 2032
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2133,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2608998+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2876E141P433VM286119",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286119,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1846,
      "AgendaID": 3008,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 70,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01960",
      "ID": 2032
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2876,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.364486+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4951E147P368VM260726",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 260726,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1846,
      "AgendaID": 3008,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 70,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01960",
      "ID": 2032
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4951,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan",
      "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.0896183+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3896E175P307VM263902",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 263902,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1846,
      "AgendaID": 3008,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 70,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01960",
      "ID": 2032
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3896,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam",
      "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.915711+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308045",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 308045,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1846,
      "AgendaID": 3008,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 70,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01960",
      "ID": 2032
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.862084+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4964E143P375VM279654",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279654,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1846,
      "AgendaID": 3008,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 70,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01960",
      "ID": 2032
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4964,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5169215+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3824E84P113VM280008",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280008,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1846,
      "AgendaID": 3008,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 70,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01960",
      "ID": 2032
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3824,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5326186+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2066E22P91VM261119",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261119,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1846,
      "AgendaID": 3008,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 70,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01960",
      "ID": 2032
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2066,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.1126318+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299724",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 299724,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1846,
      "AgendaID": 3008,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 70,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01960",
      "ID": 2032
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7199119+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3759E260P411VM303374",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 303374,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1846,
      "AgendaID": 3008,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 70,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01960",
      "ID": 2032
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina",
      "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8124448+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2487E146P369VM301715",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 301715,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1846,
      "AgendaID": 3008,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 70,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01960",
      "ID": 2032
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2487,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.2744423+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223637",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223637,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1846,
      "AgendaID": 3008,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 70,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01960",
      "ID": 2032
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4673561+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237479",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237479,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1846,
      "AgendaID": 3008,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 70,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01960",
      "ID": 2032
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1961,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David",
      "DisplayName": "David McLetchie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.212367+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305421",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 305421,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1846,
      "AgendaID": 3008,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 70,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01960",
      "ID": 2032
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2134,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3232897+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320730",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 320730,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1846,
      "AgendaID": 3008,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 70,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01960",
      "ID": 2032
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5041,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan",
      "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1789967+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3763E142P397VM316041",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 316041,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1846,
      "AgendaID": 3008,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 70,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01960",
      "ID": 2032
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3763,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart",
      "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9432943+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1986E23P197VM236293",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 236293,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1846,
      "AgendaID": 3008,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 70,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01960",
      "ID": 2032
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1986,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan",
      "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9101479+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5047E100P130VM291441",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291441,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1846,
      "AgendaID": 3008,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 70,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01960",
      "ID": 2032
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5047,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne",
      "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1194472+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234931",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234931,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1846,
      "AgendaID": 3008,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 70,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01960",
      "ID": 2032
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1845,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette",
      "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4059468+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313611",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313611,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1846,
      "AgendaID": 3008,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 70,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01960",
      "ID": 2032
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3061,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4028623+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1768E19P265VM288522",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 288522,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1846,
      "AgendaID": 3008,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 70,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01960",
      "ID": 2032
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1768,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1470341+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225063",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225063,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1846,
      "AgendaID": 3008,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 70,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01960",
      "ID": 2032
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1894,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Neil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7429234+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3815E98P134VM270898",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270898,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1846,
      "AgendaID": 3008,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 70,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01960",
      "ID": 2032
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3815,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Park, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Park",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8279727+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265909",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265909,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1846,
      "AgendaID": 3008,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 70,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01960",
      "ID": 2032
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2010,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil",
      "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4657877+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283339",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283339,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1846,
      "AgendaID": 3008,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 70,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01960",
      "ID": 2032
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5057,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.6964405+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2853E33P128VM251450",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251450,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1846,
      "AgendaID": 3008,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 70,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01960",
      "ID": 2032
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Pentland",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4641609+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317949",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317949,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1846,
      "AgendaID": 3008,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 70,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01960",
      "ID": 2032
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5009,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4504536+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254744",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254744,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1846,
      "AgendaID": 3008,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 70,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01960",
      "ID": 2032
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3745,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis",
      "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2818745+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1870E225P478VM295582",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295582,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1846,
      "AgendaID": 3008,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 70,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01960",
      "ID": 2032
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1870,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona",
      "DisplayName": "Shona Robison",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5184579+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2135E254P450VM234894",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234894,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1846,
      "AgendaID": 3008,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 70,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01960",
      "ID": 2032
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2135,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Russell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4043268+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1895E232P431VM257391",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257391,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1846,
      "AgendaID": 3008,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 70,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01960",
      "ID": 2032
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1895,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0541852+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228075",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 228075,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1846,
      "AgendaID": 3008,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 70,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01960",
      "ID": 2032
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1839,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5832708+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2345E10P55VM292016",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 292016,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1846,
      "AgendaID": 3008,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 70,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01960",
      "ID": 2032
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2345,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1522423+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2223E176P333VM310698",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 310698,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1846,
      "AgendaID": 3008,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 70,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01960",
      "ID": 2032
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2223,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish",
      "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5821944+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2182E87P175VM245987",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 245987,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1846,
      "AgendaID": 3008,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 70,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01960",
      "ID": 2032
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2182,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8673218+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298348",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298348,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1846,
      "AgendaID": 3008,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 70,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01960",
      "ID": 2032
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5079,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew",
      "DisplayName": "Drew Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3418636+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234382",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234382,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1846,
      "AgendaID": 3008,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 70,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01960",
      "ID": 2032
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1769,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3748787+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274564",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274564,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1846,
      "AgendaID": 3008,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 70,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01960",
      "ID": 2032
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4014,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz",
      "DisplayName": "Liz Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1120618+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269166",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269166,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1846,
      "AgendaID": 3008,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 70,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01960",
      "ID": 2032
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2215,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.3065318+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317199",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317199,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1846,
      "AgendaID": 3008,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 70,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01960",
      "ID": 2032
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3806,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.1859531+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326257",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 326257,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1846,
      "AgendaID": 3008,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 70,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01960",
      "ID": 2032
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5106,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin",
      "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7506489+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241085",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241085,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1846,
      "AgendaID": 3008,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 70,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01960",
      "ID": 2032
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1848,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola",
      "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3954165+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2098E237P531VM289614",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289614,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1846,
      "AgendaID": 3008,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 70,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01960",
      "ID": 2032
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2098,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Swinney",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4516008+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2674E247P401VM247768",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247768,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1846,
      "AgendaID": 3008,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 70,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01960",
      "ID": 2032
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2674,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave",
      "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4275783+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5075E234P371VM284885",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 284885,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1846,
      "AgendaID": 3008,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 70,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01960",
      "ID": 2032
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5075,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Torrance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0518996+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1793E151P362VM222464",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 222464,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1846,
      "AgendaID": 3008,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 70,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01960",
      "ID": 2032
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1793,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean",
      "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1900755+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5078E245P366VM307159",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307159,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1846,
      "AgendaID": 3008,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 70,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01960",
      "ID": 2032
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5078,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Walker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5897999+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1841E231P426VM240193",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 240193,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1846,
      "AgendaID": 3008,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 70,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01960",
      "ID": 2032
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1841,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen",
      "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3488556+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283428",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283428,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1846,
      "AgendaID": 3008,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 70,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01960",
      "ID": 2032
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4952,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7002818+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1865E263P500VM232255",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232255,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1846,
      "AgendaID": 3008,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 70,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01960",
      "ID": 2032
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1865,
      "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra",
      "DisplayName": "Sandra White",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8468497+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237785",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237785,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1846,
      "AgendaID": 3008,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 70,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01960",
      "ID": 2032
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2610,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Wilson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2259965+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309315",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 309315,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1846,
      "AgendaID": 3008,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 70,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01960",
      "ID": 2032
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4941,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza",
      "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-08T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.324008+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252294",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252294,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1844,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893.2",
      "ID": 1983
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1926,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian",
      "DisplayName": "Brian Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7229557+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2615E213P388VM257533",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257533,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1844,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893.2",
      "ID": 1983
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2615,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George",
      "DisplayName": "George Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0606396+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319893",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319893,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1844,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893.2",
      "ID": 1983
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4940,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare",
      "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9459226+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249682",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 249682,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1844,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893.2",
      "ID": 1983
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2641,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair",
      "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9452974+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1783E21P273VM227401",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227401,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1844,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893.2",
      "ID": 1983
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1783,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie",
      "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5485599+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2633E97P136VM280397",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280397,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1844,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893.2",
      "ID": 1983
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2633,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire",
      "DisplayName": "Claire Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7651935+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262477",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262477,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1844,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893.2",
      "ID": 1983
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2603,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6036345+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1759E91P115VM229726",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229726,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1844,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893.2",
      "ID": 1983
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia",
      "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0940265+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270261",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270261,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1844,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893.2",
      "ID": 1983
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3751,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.796318+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322856",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 322856,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1844,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893.2",
      "ID": 1983
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5109,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco",
      "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.7065047+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5060E86P124VM294708",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 294708,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1844,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893.2",
      "ID": 1983
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5060,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.174913+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242804",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242804,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1844,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893.2",
      "ID": 1983
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1866,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah",
      "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0362501+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235631",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235631,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1844,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893.2",
      "ID": 1983
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1943,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic",
      "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6860583+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302134",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 302134,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1844,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893.2",
      "ID": 1983
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2595,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin",
      "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.29853+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244523",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244523,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1844,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893.2",
      "ID": 1983
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2103,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith",
      "DisplayName": "Keith Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.558463+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327238",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 327238,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1844,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893.2",
      "ID": 1983
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:46.0272014+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3775E216P435VM276660",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276660,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1844,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893.2",
      "ID": 1983
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6756956+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264357",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264357,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1844,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893.2",
      "ID": 1983
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2673,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick",
      "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.130014+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248856",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248856,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1844,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893.2",
      "ID": 1983
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2678,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson",
      "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6729833+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2123E27P233VM295824",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295824,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1844,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893.2",
      "ID": 1983
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2123,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm",
      "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5374354+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285138",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285138,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1844,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893.2",
      "ID": 1983
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3907,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0680728+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230153",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230153,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1844,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893.2",
      "ID": 1983
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1735,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela",
      "DisplayName": "Angela Constance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.1185113+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243915",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 243915,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1844,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893.2",
      "ID": 1983
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1932,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce",
      "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.325375+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1863E238P523VM255264",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255264,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1844,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893.2",
      "ID": 1983
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1863,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna",
      "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.523441+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323873",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 323873,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1844,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893.2",
      "ID": 1983
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4976,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth",
      "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9760631+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5107E223P379VM291880",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291880,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1844,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893.2",
      "ID": 1983
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5107,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1464367+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3743E222P391VM265153",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265153,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1844,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893.2",
      "ID": 1983
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3743,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel",
      "DisplayName": "Nigel Don",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1707613+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3771E149P417VM261702",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261702,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1844,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893.2",
      "ID": 1983
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3771,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob",
      "DisplayName": "Bob Doris",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3688497+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2826E262P384VM282034",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 282034,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1844,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893.2",
      "ID": 1983
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2826,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Dornan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1683471+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3812E94P117VM297937",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 297937,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1844,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893.2",
      "ID": 1983
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3812,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia",
      "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1313402+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231618",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231618,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1844,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893.2",
      "ID": 1983
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1778,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen",
      "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6083531+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4955E240P389VM286179",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286179,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1844,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893.2",
      "ID": 1983
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4955,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3672989+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219305",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 219305,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1844,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893.2",
      "ID": 1983
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1742,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle",
      "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.288351+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238658",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 238658,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1844,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893.2",
      "ID": 1983
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1994,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus",
      "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4635337+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225485",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225485,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1844,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893.2",
      "ID": 1983
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1814,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda",
      "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9767643+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321604",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 321604,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1844,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893.2",
      "ID": 1983
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Fee",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4432502+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1853E35P216VM293289",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 293289,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1844,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893.2",
      "ID": 1983
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia",
      "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8385838+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1892E12P64VM226875",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 226875,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1844,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893.2",
      "ID": 1983
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2504581+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5054E95P118VM312650",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 312650,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1844,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893.2",
      "ID": 1983
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5054,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1374428+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4947E152P361VM257139",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257139,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1844,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893.2",
      "ID": 1983
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4947,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Finnie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.8249929+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271534",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271534,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1844,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893.2",
      "ID": 1983
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3901,
      "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe",
      "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0799772+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278478",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 278478,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1844,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893.2",
      "ID": 1983
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2394,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo",
      "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2205545+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2110E220P414VM286722",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286722,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1844,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893.2",
      "ID": 1983
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth",
      "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5979236+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250417",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250417,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1844,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893.2",
      "ID": 1983
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2675,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob",
      "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1886343+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1741E10P50VM220730",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220730,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1844,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893.2",
      "ID": 1983
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1741,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel",
      "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6545758+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220339",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220339,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1844,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893.2",
      "ID": 1983
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1756,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine",
      "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6370708+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1860E104P150VM251849",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251849,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1844,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893.2",
      "ID": 1983
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1860,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda",
      "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4917998+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2033E20P141VM266163",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 266163,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1844,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893.2",
      "ID": 1983
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2033,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain",
      "DisplayName": "Iain Gray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4770262+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324560",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324560,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1844,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893.2",
      "ID": 1983
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5042,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2282428+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259960",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 259960,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1844,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893.2",
      "ID": 1983
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick",
      "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6374546+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239239",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239239,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1844,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893.2",
      "ID": 1983
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2029,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh",
      "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7281884+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273828",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 273828,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1844,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893.2",
      "ID": 1983
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3758,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6374127+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304195",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 304195,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1844,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893.2",
      "ID": 1983
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4086,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Hume",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8541464+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221809",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221809,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1844,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893.2",
      "ID": 1983
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1773,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9487447+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1882E227P459VM242045",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242045,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1844,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893.2",
      "ID": 1983
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1882,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam",
      "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7914341+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223791",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223791,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1844,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893.2",
      "ID": 1983
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1893,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4739056+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307521",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307521,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1844,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893.2",
      "ID": 1983
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4934,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8331222+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272156",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 272156,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1844,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893.2",
      "ID": 1983
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4956,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Keir",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.1139887+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244811",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244811,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1844,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893.2",
      "ID": 1983
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Kelly",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5796424+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315039",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315039,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1844,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893.2",
      "ID": 1983
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3129,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6714428+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2080E36P220VM251121",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251121,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1844,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893.2",
      "ID": 1983
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann",
      "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.2282097+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4016E11P36VM274707",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274707,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1844,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893.2",
      "ID": 1983
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4016,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1182445+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255878",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255878,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1844,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893.2",
      "ID": 1983
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2180,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.560897+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4938E158P374VM277847",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277847,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1844,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893.2",
      "ID": 1983
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4938,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.970996+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2112E250P486VM252933",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252933,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1844,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893.2",
      "ID": 1983
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2112,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny",
      "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7594745+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4939E258P394VM277235",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277235,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1844,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893.2",
      "ID": 1983
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4939,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus",
      "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9395183+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325571",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 325571,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1844,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893.2",
      "ID": 1983
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5074,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon",
      "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5120753+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1828E3P10VM232815",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232815,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1844,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893.2",
      "ID": 1983
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1828,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo",
      "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8774158+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311368",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311368,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1844,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893.2",
      "ID": 1983
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4948,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike",
      "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.875706+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2117E90P107VM230799",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230799,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1844,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893.2",
      "ID": 1983
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2117,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis",
      "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3460173+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267308",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 267308,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1844,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893.2",
      "ID": 1983
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken",
      "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0138425+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313793",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313793,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1844,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893.2",
      "ID": 1983
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4966,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek",
      "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4109059+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3101E102P129VM295445",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295445,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1844,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893.2",
      "ID": 1983
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3101,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala",
      "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5124685+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5034E88P114VM318853",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 318853,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1844,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893.2",
      "ID": 1983
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5034,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny",
      "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.676233+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306448",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306448,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1844,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893.2",
      "ID": 1983
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2159,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Martin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5525198+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5110E252P395VM311286",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311286,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1844,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893.2",
      "ID": 1983
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Mason",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8721168+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268296",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 268296,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1844,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893.2",
      "ID": 1983
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2133,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.260984+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2876E141P433VM286117",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286117,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1844,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893.2",
      "ID": 1983
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2876,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3644026+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4951E147P368VM260728",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 260728,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1844,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893.2",
      "ID": 1983
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4951,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan",
      "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.0897005+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3896E175P307VM264129",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264129,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1844,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893.2",
      "ID": 1983
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3896,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam",
      "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.925484+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308043",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 308043,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1844,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893.2",
      "ID": 1983
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8620013+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4964E143P375VM279274",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279274,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1844,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893.2",
      "ID": 1983
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4964,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.4947689+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3824E84P113VM280010",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280010,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1844,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893.2",
      "ID": 1983
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3824,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5327117+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2066E22P91VM261797",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261797,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1844,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893.2",
      "ID": 1983
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2066,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3785763+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299726",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 299726,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1844,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893.2",
      "ID": 1983
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7199963+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3759E260P411VM303372",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 303372,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1844,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893.2",
      "ID": 1983
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina",
      "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8123606+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2487E146P369VM301717",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 301717,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1844,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893.2",
      "ID": 1983
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2487,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.274528+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223635",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223635,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1844,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893.2",
      "ID": 1983
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4672738+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237411",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237411,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1844,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893.2",
      "ID": 1983
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1961,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David",
      "DisplayName": "David McLetchie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2030582+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305419",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 305419,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1844,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893.2",
      "ID": 1983
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2134,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3232072+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320728",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 320728,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1844,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893.2",
      "ID": 1983
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5041,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan",
      "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1789118+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3763E142P397VM316043",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 316043,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1844,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893.2",
      "ID": 1983
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3763,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart",
      "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9433774+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1986E23P197VM236291",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 236291,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1844,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893.2",
      "ID": 1983
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1986,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan",
      "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9100647+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5047E100P130VM291443",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291443,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1844,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893.2",
      "ID": 1983
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5047,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne",
      "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1195307+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234933",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234933,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1844,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893.2",
      "ID": 1983
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1845,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette",
      "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4060319+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313613",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313613,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1844,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893.2",
      "ID": 1983
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3061,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4029457+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1768E19P265VM288520",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 288520,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1844,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893.2",
      "ID": 1983
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1768,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1469494+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1894E267P527VM224995",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 224995,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1844,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893.2",
      "ID": 1983
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1894,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Neil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7400545+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3815E98P134VM270832",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270832,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1844,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893.2",
      "ID": 1983
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3815,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Park, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Park",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8250316+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265911",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265911,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1844,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893.2",
      "ID": 1983
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2010,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil",
      "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4658923+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283566",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283566,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1844,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893.2",
      "ID": 1983
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5057,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7137941+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2853E33P128VM251075",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251075,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1844,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893.2",
      "ID": 1983
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Pentland",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.2259444+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317947",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317947,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1844,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893.2",
      "ID": 1983
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5009,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4503696+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254746",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254746,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1844,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893.2",
      "ID": 1983
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3745,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis",
      "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2819575+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1870E225P478VM295580",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295580,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1844,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893.2",
      "ID": 1983
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1870,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona",
      "DisplayName": "Shona Robison",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5183701+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2135E254P450VM234826",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234826,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1844,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893.2",
      "ID": 1983
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2135,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Russell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.401406+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1895E232P431VM257389",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257389,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1844,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893.2",
      "ID": 1983
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1895,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.054101+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228073",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 228073,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1844,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893.2",
      "ID": 1983
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1839,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5831885+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2345E10P55VM292018",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 292018,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1844,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893.2",
      "ID": 1983
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2345,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.152346+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2223E176P333VM310696",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 310696,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1844,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893.2",
      "ID": 1983
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2223,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish",
      "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5821118+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2182E87P175VM245985",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 245985,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1844,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893.2",
      "ID": 1983
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2182,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.867236+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298350",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298350,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1844,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893.2",
      "ID": 1983
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5079,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew",
      "DisplayName": "Drew Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3419701+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234384",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234384,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1844,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893.2",
      "ID": 1983
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1769,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3749618+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4014E14P26VM269902",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269902,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1844,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893.2",
      "ID": 1983
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4014,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz",
      "DisplayName": "Liz Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5679187+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269164",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269164,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1844,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893.2",
      "ID": 1983
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2215,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.30645+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317197",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317197,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1844,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893.2",
      "ID": 1983
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3806,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.1858518+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326259",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 326259,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1844,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893.2",
      "ID": 1983
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5106,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin",
      "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7507414+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241083",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241083,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1844,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893.2",
      "ID": 1983
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1848,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola",
      "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3953342+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2098E237P531VM289556",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289556,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1844,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893.2",
      "ID": 1983
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2098,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Swinney",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4491662+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2674E247P401VM247700",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247700,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1844,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893.2",
      "ID": 1983
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2674,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave",
      "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4246718+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5075E234P371VM284815",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 284815,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1844,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893.2",
      "ID": 1983
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5075,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Torrance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0489382+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1793E151P362VM222395",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 222395,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1844,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893.2",
      "ID": 1983
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1793,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean",
      "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1871117+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5078E245P366VM307161",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307161,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1844,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893.2",
      "ID": 1983
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5078,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Walker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5898881+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1841E231P426VM240195",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 240195,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1844,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893.2",
      "ID": 1983
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1841,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen",
      "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3489411+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283358",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283358,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1844,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893.2",
      "ID": 1983
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4952,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.6972635+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1865E263P500VM232257",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232257,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1844,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893.2",
      "ID": 1983
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1865,
      "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra",
      "DisplayName": "Sandra White",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8469338+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2610E160P413VM245700",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 245700,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1844,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893.2",
      "ID": 1983
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2610,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Wilson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8547022+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309317",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 309317,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1844,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 96,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893.2",
      "ID": 1983
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4941,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza",
      "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3240905+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252295",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252295,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1845,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893",
      "ID": 1963
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1926,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian",
      "DisplayName": "Brian Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7229987+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2615E213P388VM258836",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258836,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1845,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893",
      "ID": 1963
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2615,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George",
      "DisplayName": "George Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3300015+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319892",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319892,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1845,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893",
      "ID": 1963
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4940,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare",
      "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9458811+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249681",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 249681,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1845,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893",
      "ID": 1963
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2641,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair",
      "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.945256+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1783E21P273VM227402",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227402,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1845,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893",
      "ID": 1963
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1783,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie",
      "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5486019+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2633E97P136VM280398",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280398,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1845,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893",
      "ID": 1963
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2633,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire",
      "DisplayName": "Claire Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7652529+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262478",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262478,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1845,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893",
      "ID": 1963
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2603,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6036758+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1759E91P115VM229727",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229727,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1845,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893",
      "ID": 1963
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia",
      "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0940684+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270191",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270191,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1845,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893",
      "ID": 1963
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3751,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5854624+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322857",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 322857,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1845,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893",
      "ID": 1963
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5109,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco",
      "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.7065455+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5060E86P124VM294709",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 294709,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1845,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893",
      "ID": 1963
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5060,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.174955+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242860",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242860,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1845,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893",
      "ID": 1963
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1866,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah",
      "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0387108+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235564",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235564,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1845,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893",
      "ID": 1963
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1943,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic",
      "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6832319+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302135",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 302135,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1845,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893",
      "ID": 1963
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2595,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin",
      "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.2985726+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244522",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244522,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1845,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893",
      "ID": 1963
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2103,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith",
      "DisplayName": "Keith Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5584026+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327239",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 327239,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1845,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893",
      "ID": 1963
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:46.0272623+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3775E216P435VM276661",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276661,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1845,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893",
      "ID": 1963
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6757382+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264356",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264356,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1845,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893",
      "ID": 1963
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2673,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick",
      "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1299721+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248790",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248790,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1845,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893",
      "ID": 1963
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2678,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson",
      "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.670165+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2123E27P233VM295823",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295823,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1845,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893",
      "ID": 1963
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2123,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm",
      "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5373931+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285139",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285139,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1845,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893",
      "ID": 1963
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3907,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0681143+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230154",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230154,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1845,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893",
      "ID": 1963
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1735,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela",
      "DisplayName": "Angela Constance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.1185521+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243859",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 243859,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1845,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893",
      "ID": 1963
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1932,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce",
      "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3229704+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254953",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254953,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1845,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893",
      "ID": 1963
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1863,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna",
      "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.290899+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323874",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 323874,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1845,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893",
      "ID": 1963
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4976,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth",
      "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9761059+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5107E223P379VM291349",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291349,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1845,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893",
      "ID": 1963
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5107,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1154563+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3743E222P391VM265310",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265310,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1845,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893",
      "ID": 1963
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3743,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel",
      "DisplayName": "Nigel Don",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4336597+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262235",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262235,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1845,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893",
      "ID": 1963
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3771,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob",
      "DisplayName": "Bob Doris",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.5927634+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2826E262P384VM282033",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 282033,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1845,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893",
      "ID": 1963
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2826,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Dornan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1683059+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3812E94P117VM297938",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 297938,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1845,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893",
      "ID": 1963
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3812,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia",
      "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1313812+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231617",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231617,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1845,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893",
      "ID": 1963
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1778,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen",
      "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6083125+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4955E240P389VM285954",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285954,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1845,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893",
      "ID": 1963
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4955,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3517061+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219314",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 219314,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1845,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893",
      "ID": 1963
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1742,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle",
      "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.2887726+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238591",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 238591,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1845,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893",
      "ID": 1963
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1994,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus",
      "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4607101+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225484",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225484,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1845,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893",
      "ID": 1963
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1814,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda",
      "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9767218+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321603",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 321603,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1845,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893",
      "ID": 1963
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Fee",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4432076+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1853E35P216VM293288",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 293288,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1845,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893",
      "ID": 1963
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia",
      "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8385396+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1892E12P64VM226943",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 226943,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1845,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893",
      "ID": 1963
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2536746+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5054E95P118VM312651",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 312651,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1845,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893",
      "ID": 1963
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5054,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1374842+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4947E152P361VM257140",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257140,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1845,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893",
      "ID": 1963
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4947,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Finnie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.8250352+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271310",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271310,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1845,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893",
      "ID": 1963
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3901,
      "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe",
      "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0699362+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278477",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 278477,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1845,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893",
      "ID": 1963
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2394,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo",
      "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2204942+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2110E220P414VM286723",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286723,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1845,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893",
      "ID": 1963
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth",
      "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5979649+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250418",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250418,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1845,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893",
      "ID": 1963
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2675,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob",
      "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1886999+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1741E10P50VM220731",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220731,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1845,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893",
      "ID": 1963
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1741,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel",
      "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.654618+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220270",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220270,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1845,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893",
      "ID": 1963
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1756,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine",
      "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6311968+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1860E104P150VM251850",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251850,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1845,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893",
      "ID": 1963
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1860,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda",
      "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4918425+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2033E20P141VM266162",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 266162,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1845,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893",
      "ID": 1963
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2033,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain",
      "DisplayName": "Iain Gray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4769852+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324559",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324559,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1845,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893",
      "ID": 1963
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5042,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2282018+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259737",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 259737,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1845,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893",
      "ID": 1963
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick",
      "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6223681+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239306",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239306,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1845,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893",
      "ID": 1963
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2029,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh",
      "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7311367+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273827",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 273827,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1845,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893",
      "ID": 1963
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3758,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6373704+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304194",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 304194,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1845,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893",
      "ID": 1963
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4086,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Hume",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8540959+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221808",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221808,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1845,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893",
      "ID": 1963
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1773,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9487037+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1882E227P459VM242044",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242044,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1845,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893",
      "ID": 1963
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1882,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam",
      "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7913929+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223723",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223723,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1845,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893",
      "ID": 1963
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1893,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4710068+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307522",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307522,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1845,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893",
      "ID": 1963
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4934,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8331654+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272157",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 272157,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1845,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893",
      "ID": 1963
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4956,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Keir",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.1140305+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244868",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244868,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1845,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893",
      "ID": 1963
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Kelly",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5820613+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315040",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315040,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1845,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893",
      "ID": 1963
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3129,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6714854+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247962",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247962,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1845,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893",
      "ID": 1963
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann",
      "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4358364+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4016E11P36VM274776",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274776,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1845,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893",
      "ID": 1963
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4016,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1212602+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255812",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255812,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1845,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893",
      "ID": 1963
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2180,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5581359+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4938E158P374VM277469",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277469,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1845,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893",
      "ID": 1963
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4938,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9546974+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2112E250P486VM253000",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253000,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1845,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893",
      "ID": 1963
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2112,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny",
      "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7625456+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4939E258P394VM276854",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276854,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1845,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893",
      "ID": 1963
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4939,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus",
      "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6839708+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325572",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 325572,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1845,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893",
      "ID": 1963
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5074,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon",
      "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5121163+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1828E3P10VM232816",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232816,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1845,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893",
      "ID": 1963
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1828,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo",
      "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8774572+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311369",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311369,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1845,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893",
      "ID": 1963
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4948,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike",
      "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8757487+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2117E90P107VM230424",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230424,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1845,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893",
      "ID": 1963
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2117,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis",
      "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3292204+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267309",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 267309,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1845,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893",
      "ID": 1963
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken",
      "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0138836+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313792",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313792,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1845,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893",
      "ID": 1963
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4966,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek",
      "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4108647+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3101E102P129VM295444",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295444,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1845,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893",
      "ID": 1963
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3101,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala",
      "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5124077+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5034E88P114VM318852",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 318852,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1845,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893",
      "ID": 1963
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5034,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny",
      "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6761925+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306447",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306447,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1845,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893",
      "ID": 1963
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2159,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Martin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5524577+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5110E252P395VM311285",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311285,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1845,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893",
      "ID": 1963
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Mason",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.872074+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268295",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 268295,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1845,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893",
      "ID": 1963
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2133,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2609413+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2876E141P433VM286118",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286118,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1845,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893",
      "ID": 1963
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2876,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3644447+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4951E147P368VM260727",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 260727,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1845,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893",
      "ID": 1963
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4951,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan",
      "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.0896597+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3896E175P307VM263903",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 263903,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1845,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893",
      "ID": 1963
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3896,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam",
      "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9157529+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308044",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 308044,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1845,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893",
      "ID": 1963
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8620432+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4964E143P375VM279653",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279653,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1845,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893",
      "ID": 1963
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4964,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5168814+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3824E84P113VM280009",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280009,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1845,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893",
      "ID": 1963
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3824,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5326687+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2066E22P91VM261120",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261120,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1845,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893",
      "ID": 1963
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2066,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.1126738+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299725",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 299725,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1845,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893",
      "ID": 1963
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7199546+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3759E260P411VM303373",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 303373,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1845,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893",
      "ID": 1963
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina",
      "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8124031+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2487E146P369VM301716",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 301716,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1845,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893",
      "ID": 1963
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2487,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.2744868+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223636",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223636,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1845,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893",
      "ID": 1963
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4673156+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237478",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237478,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1845,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893",
      "ID": 1963
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1961,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David",
      "DisplayName": "David McLetchie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2123243+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305420",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 305420,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1845,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893",
      "ID": 1963
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2134,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3232487+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320729",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 320729,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1845,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893",
      "ID": 1963
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5041,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan",
      "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1789546+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3763E142P397VM316042",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 316042,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1845,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893",
      "ID": 1963
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3763,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart",
      "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9433355+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1986E23P197VM236292",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 236292,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1845,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893",
      "ID": 1963
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1986,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan",
      "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9101068+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5047E100P130VM291442",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291442,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1845,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893",
      "ID": 1963
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5047,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne",
      "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1194891+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234932",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234932,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1845,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893",
      "ID": 1963
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1845,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette",
      "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4059901+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313612",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313612,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1845,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893",
      "ID": 1963
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3061,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4029041+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1768E19P265VM288521",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 288521,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1845,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893",
      "ID": 1963
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1768,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1469925+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225062",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225062,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1845,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893",
      "ID": 1963
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1894,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Neil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7428834+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3815E98P134VM270897",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270897,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1845,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893",
      "ID": 1963
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3815,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Park, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Park",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8279313+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265910",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265910,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1845,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893",
      "ID": 1963
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2010,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil",
      "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4658498+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283340",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283340,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1845,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893",
      "ID": 1963
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5057,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.696482+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2853E33P128VM251449",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251449,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1845,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893",
      "ID": 1963
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Pentland",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4640983+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317948",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317948,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1845,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893",
      "ID": 1963
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5009,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4504116+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254745",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254745,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1845,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893",
      "ID": 1963
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3745,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis",
      "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2819159+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1870E225P478VM295581",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295581,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1845,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893",
      "ID": 1963
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1870,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona",
      "DisplayName": "Shona Robison",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5184167+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2135E254P450VM234893",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234893,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1845,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893",
      "ID": 1963
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2135,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Russell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4042858+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1895E232P431VM257390",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257390,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1845,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893",
      "ID": 1963
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1895,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0541431+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228074",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 228074,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1845,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893",
      "ID": 1963
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1839,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5832303+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2345E10P55VM292017",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 292017,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1845,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893",
      "ID": 1963
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2345,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1522854+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2223E176P333VM310697",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 310697,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1845,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893",
      "ID": 1963
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2223,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish",
      "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5821534+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2182E87P175VM245986",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 245986,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1845,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893",
      "ID": 1963
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2182,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8672812+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298349",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298349,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1845,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893",
      "ID": 1963
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5079,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew",
      "DisplayName": "Drew Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3419051+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234383",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234383,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1845,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893",
      "ID": 1963
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1769,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3749202+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274563",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274563,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1845,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893",
      "ID": 1963
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4014,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz",
      "DisplayName": "Liz Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1120205+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269165",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269165,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1845,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893",
      "ID": 1963
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2215,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.3064912+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317198",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317198,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1845,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893",
      "ID": 1963
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3806,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.1859114+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326258",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 326258,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1845,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893",
      "ID": 1963
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5106,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin",
      "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7506983+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241084",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241084,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1845,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893",
      "ID": 1963
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1848,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola",
      "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3953758+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2098E237P531VM289613",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289613,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1845,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893",
      "ID": 1963
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2098,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Swinney",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4515605+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2674E247P401VM247767",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247767,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1845,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893",
      "ID": 1963
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2674,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave",
      "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4275377+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5075E234P371VM284884",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 284884,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1845,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893",
      "ID": 1963
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5075,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Torrance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0518584+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1793E151P362VM222489",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 222489,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1845,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893",
      "ID": 1963
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1793,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean",
      "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1911671+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5078E245P366VM307160",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307160,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1845,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893",
      "ID": 1963
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5078,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Walker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5898411+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1841E231P426VM240194",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 240194,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1845,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893",
      "ID": 1963
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1841,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen",
      "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3488986+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283427",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283427,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1845,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893",
      "ID": 1963
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4952,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7002408+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1865E263P500VM232256",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232256,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1845,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893",
      "ID": 1963
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1865,
      "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra",
      "DisplayName": "Sandra White",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8468918+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237786",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237786,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1845,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893",
      "ID": 1963
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2610,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Wilson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2260373+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309316",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 309316,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1845,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 101,
      "VoteAgainst": 0,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland’s Next Generation Broadband Infrastructure Plan",
      "Reference": "S4M-01893",
      "ID": 1963
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4941,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza",
      "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3240493+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252292",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252292,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1842,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878.1",
      "ID": 1985
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1926,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian",
      "DisplayName": "Brian Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.722853+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2615E213P388VM257531",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257531,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1842,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878.1",
      "ID": 1985
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2615,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George",
      "DisplayName": "George Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0605576+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319959",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319959,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1842,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878.1",
      "ID": 1985
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4940,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare",
      "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9487807+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249684",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 249684,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1842,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878.1",
      "ID": 1985
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2641,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair",
      "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9453775+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1783E21P273VM227399",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227399,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1842,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878.1",
      "ID": 1985
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1783,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie",
      "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5484772+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2633E97P136VM280395",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280395,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1842,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878.1",
      "ID": 1985
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2633,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire",
      "DisplayName": "Claire Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7588877+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262475",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262475,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1842,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878.1",
      "ID": 1985
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2603,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6035518+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1759E91P115VM229724",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229724,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1842,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878.1",
      "ID": 1985
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia",
      "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0939254+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270263",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270263,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1842,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878.1",
      "ID": 1985
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3751,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.7964008+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322854",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 322854,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1842,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878.1",
      "ID": 1985
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5109,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco",
      "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.7064238+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5060E86P124VM294706",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 294706,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1842,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878.1",
      "ID": 1985
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5060,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.17483+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242791",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242791,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1842,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878.1",
      "ID": 1985
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1866,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah",
      "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0357+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235633",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235633,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1842,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878.1",
      "ID": 1985
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1943,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic",
      "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6861378+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302132",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 302132,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1842,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878.1",
      "ID": 1985
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2595,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin",
      "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.2984246+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244525",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244525,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1842,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878.1",
      "ID": 1985
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2103,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith",
      "DisplayName": "Keith Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5585462+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327330",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 327330,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1842,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878.1",
      "ID": 1985
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:46.0312144+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3775E216P435VM276658",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276658,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1842,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878.1",
      "ID": 1985
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6755908+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264359",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264359,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1842,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878.1",
      "ID": 1985
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2673,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick",
      "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1300947+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248858",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248858,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1842,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878.1",
      "ID": 1985
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2678,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson",
      "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6730839+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2123E27P233VM296350",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 296350,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1842,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878.1",
      "ID": 1985
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2123,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm",
      "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8452453+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285136",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285136,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1842,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878.1",
      "ID": 1985
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3907,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0679901+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230151",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230151,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1842,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878.1",
      "ID": 1985
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1735,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela",
      "DisplayName": "Angela Constance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.1184287+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243929",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 243929,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1842,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878.1",
      "ID": 1985
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1932,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce",
      "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3259918+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1863E238P523VM255266",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255266,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1842,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878.1",
      "ID": 1985
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1863,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna",
      "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5235241+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323965",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 323965,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1842,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878.1",
      "ID": 1985
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4976,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth",
      "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9801466+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5107E223P379VM291882",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291882,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1842,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878.1",
      "ID": 1985
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5107,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1465173+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3743E222P391VM265151",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265151,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1842,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878.1",
      "ID": 1985
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3743,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel",
      "DisplayName": "Nigel Don",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1706772+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3771E149P417VM261700",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261700,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1842,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878.1",
      "ID": 1985
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3771,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob",
      "DisplayName": "Bob Doris",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3687673+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2826E262P384VM282036",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 282036,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1842,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878.1",
      "ID": 1985
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2826,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Dornan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1684492+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3812E94P117VM297935",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 297935,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1842,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878.1",
      "ID": 1985
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3812,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia",
      "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1312594+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231620",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231620,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1842,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878.1",
      "ID": 1985
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1778,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen",
      "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6084327+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4955E240P389VM286181",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286181,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1842,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878.1",
      "ID": 1985
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4955,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3673993+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219303",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 219303,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1842,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878.1",
      "ID": 1985
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1742,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle",
      "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.2881987+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238660",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 238660,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1842,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878.1",
      "ID": 1985
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1994,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus",
      "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4636334+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225487",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225487,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1842,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878.1",
      "ID": 1985
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1814,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda",
      "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9768464+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321606",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 321606,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1842,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878.1",
      "ID": 1985
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Fee",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4433323+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1853E35P216VM293291",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 293291,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1842,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878.1",
      "ID": 1985
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia",
      "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8386668+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1892E12P64VM226873",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 226873,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1842,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878.1",
      "ID": 1985
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2503735+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5054E95P118VM312648",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 312648,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1842,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878.1",
      "ID": 1985
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5054,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1373607+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4947E152P361VM257137",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257137,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1842,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878.1",
      "ID": 1985
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4947,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Finnie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.8248908+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271536",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271536,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1842,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878.1",
      "ID": 1985
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3901,
      "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe",
      "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0800601+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278480",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 278480,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1842,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878.1",
      "ID": 1985
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2394,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo",
      "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2206389+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2110E220P414VM286720",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286720,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1842,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878.1",
      "ID": 1985
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth",
      "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5978257+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250415",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250415,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1842,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878.1",
      "ID": 1985
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2675,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob",
      "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1885506+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1741E10P50VM220728",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220728,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1842,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878.1",
      "ID": 1985
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1741,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel",
      "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6544936+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220341",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220341,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1842,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878.1",
      "ID": 1985
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1756,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine",
      "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.637153+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1860E104P150VM251847",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251847,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1842,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878.1",
      "ID": 1985
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1860,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda",
      "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4916951+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2033E20P141VM266165",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 266165,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1842,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878.1",
      "ID": 1985
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2033,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain",
      "DisplayName": "Iain Gray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4771071+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324468",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324468,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1842,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878.1",
      "ID": 1985
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5042,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2239944+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259962",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 259962,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1842,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878.1",
      "ID": 1985
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick",
      "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6375366+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239237",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239237,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1842,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878.1",
      "ID": 1985
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2029,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh",
      "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7280855+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273830",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 273830,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1842,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878.1",
      "ID": 1985
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3758,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6375129+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304197",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 304197,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1842,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878.1",
      "ID": 1985
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4086,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Hume",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.0277807+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221811",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221811,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1842,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878.1",
      "ID": 1985
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1773,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9488264+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1882E227P459VM242047",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242047,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1842,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878.1",
      "ID": 1985
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1882,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam",
      "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7915164+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223793",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223793,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1842,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878.1",
      "ID": 1985
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1893,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4740082+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307519",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307519,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1842,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878.1",
      "ID": 1985
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4934,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8330207+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272154",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 272154,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1842,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878.1",
      "ID": 1985
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4956,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Keir",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.1139075+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244800",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244800,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1842,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878.1",
      "ID": 1985
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Kelly",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5791692+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3129E261P419VM314973",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 314973,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1842,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878.1",
      "ID": 1985
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3129,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6685993+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2080E36P220VM251123",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251123,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1842,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878.1",
      "ID": 1985
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann",
      "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.2283063+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4016E11P36VM274705",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274705,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1842,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878.1",
      "ID": 1985
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4016,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.11816+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255880",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255880,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1842,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878.1",
      "ID": 1985
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2180,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5609774+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4938E158P374VM277849",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277849,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1842,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878.1",
      "ID": 1985
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4938,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9710774+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2112E250P486VM252626",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252626,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1842,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878.1",
      "ID": 1985
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2112,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny",
      "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7375592+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4939E258P394VM277237",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277237,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1842,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878.1",
      "ID": 1985
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4939,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus",
      "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9396024+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325663",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 325663,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1842,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878.1",
      "ID": 1985
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5074,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon",
      "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5159729+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1828E3P10VM232813",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232813,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1842,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878.1",
      "ID": 1985
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1828,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo",
      "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8773333+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311366",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311366,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1842,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878.1",
      "ID": 1985
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4948,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike",
      "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8756228+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2117E90P107VM230801",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230801,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1842,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878.1",
      "ID": 1985
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2117,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis",
      "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3460993+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267306",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 267306,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1842,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878.1",
      "ID": 1985
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken",
      "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0137595+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313795",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313795,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1842,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878.1",
      "ID": 1985
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4966,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek",
      "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4109878+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3101E102P129VM295447",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295447,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1842,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878.1",
      "ID": 1985
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3101,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala",
      "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5125517+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5034E88P114VM318855",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 318855,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1842,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878.1",
      "ID": 1985
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5034,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny",
      "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.676314+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306514",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306514,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1842,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878.1",
      "ID": 1985
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2159,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Martin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5553449+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5110E252P395VM311288",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311288,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1842,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878.1",
      "ID": 1985
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Mason",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8722191+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268298",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 268298,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1842,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878.1",
      "ID": 1985
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2133,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2610658+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2876E141P433VM286115",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286115,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1842,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878.1",
      "ID": 1985
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2876,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3642986+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4951E147P368VM260730",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 260730,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1842,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878.1",
      "ID": 1985
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4951,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan",
      "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.0897821+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3896E175P307VM264131",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264131,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1842,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878.1",
      "ID": 1985
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3896,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam",
      "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9255655+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308041",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 308041,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1842,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878.1",
      "ID": 1985
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8619174+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4964E143P375VM279272",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279272,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1842,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878.1",
      "ID": 1985
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4964,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.4946669+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3824E84P113VM280012",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280012,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1842,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878.1",
      "ID": 1985
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3824,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5327935+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2066E22P91VM261808",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261808,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1842,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878.1",
      "ID": 1985
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2066,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3790476+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299728",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 299728,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1842,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878.1",
      "ID": 1985
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7200764+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3759E260P411VM303370",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 303370,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1842,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878.1",
      "ID": 1985
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina",
      "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.812262+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2487E146P369VM301719",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 301719,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1842,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878.1",
      "ID": 1985
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2487,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.2746099+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223633",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223633,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1842,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878.1",
      "ID": 1985
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4671897+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237409",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237409,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1842,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878.1",
      "ID": 1985
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1961,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David",
      "DisplayName": "David McLetchie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2029731+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2134E34P201VM297800",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 297800,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1842,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878.1",
      "ID": 1985
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2134,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1255401+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320726",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 320726,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1842,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878.1",
      "ID": 1985
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5041,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan",
      "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1788125+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3763E142P397VM316109",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 316109,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1842,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878.1",
      "ID": 1985
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3763,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart",
      "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9465499+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1986E23P197VM236289",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 236289,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1842,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878.1",
      "ID": 1985
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1986,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan",
      "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.909981+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5047E100P130VM291445",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291445,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1842,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878.1",
      "ID": 1985
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5047,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne",
      "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1196322+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234935",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234935,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1842,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878.1",
      "ID": 1985
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1845,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette",
      "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4061149+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313679",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313679,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1842,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878.1",
      "ID": 1985
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3061,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4057871+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1768E19P265VM288518",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 288518,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1842,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878.1",
      "ID": 1985
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1768,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1468451+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1894E267P527VM224993",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 224993,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1842,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878.1",
      "ID": 1985
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1894,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Neil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7399463+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3815E98P134VM270830",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270830,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1842,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878.1",
      "ID": 1985
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3815,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Park, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Park",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8249489+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265913",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265913,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1842,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878.1",
      "ID": 1985
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2010,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil",
      "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4659754+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283568",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283568,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1842,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878.1",
      "ID": 1985
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5057,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7138747+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2853E33P128VM251073",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251073,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1842,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878.1",
      "ID": 1985
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Pentland",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.2258599+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317945",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317945,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1842,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878.1",
      "ID": 1985
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5009,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4502862+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254748",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254748,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1842,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878.1",
      "ID": 1985
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3745,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis",
      "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2820393+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1870E225P478VM295578",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295578,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1842,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878.1",
      "ID": 1985
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1870,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona",
      "DisplayName": "Shona Robison",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5182629+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2135E254P450VM234824",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234824,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1842,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878.1",
      "ID": 1985
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2135,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Russell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4013239+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1895E232P431VM257387",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257387,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1842,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878.1",
      "ID": 1985
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1895,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0540166+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228071",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 228071,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1842,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878.1",
      "ID": 1985
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1839,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5831062+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2345E10P55VM292020",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 292020,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1842,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878.1",
      "ID": 1985
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2345,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.152429+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2223E176P333VM310630",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 310630,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1842,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878.1",
      "ID": 1985
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2223,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish",
      "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5792007+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2182E87P175VM245983",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 245983,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1842,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878.1",
      "ID": 1985
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2182,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.867152+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298352",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298352,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1842,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878.1",
      "ID": 1985
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5079,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew",
      "DisplayName": "Drew Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3420539+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234386",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234386,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1842,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878.1",
      "ID": 1985
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1769,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3750429+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4014E14P26VM269900",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269900,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1842,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878.1",
      "ID": 1985
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4014,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz",
      "DisplayName": "Liz Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5678344+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269162",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269162,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1842,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878.1",
      "ID": 1985
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2215,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.3063676+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317131",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317131,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1842,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878.1",
      "ID": 1985
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3806,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.183011+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326167",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 326167,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1842,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878.1",
      "ID": 1985
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5106,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin",
      "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5427532+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241081",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241081,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1842,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878.1",
      "ID": 1985
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1848,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola",
      "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3952508+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2098E237P531VM288776",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 288776,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1842,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878.1",
      "ID": 1985
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2098,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Swinney",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1579+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2674E247P401VM247698",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247698,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1842,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878.1",
      "ID": 1985
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2674,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave",
      "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4245898+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5075E234P371VM284813",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 284813,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1842,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878.1",
      "ID": 1985
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5075,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Torrance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0488574+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1793E151P362VM222393",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 222393,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1842,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878.1",
      "ID": 1985
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1793,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean",
      "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1870291+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5078E245P366VM307163",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307163,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1842,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878.1",
      "ID": 1985
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5078,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Walker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.589972+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1841E231P426VM240197",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 240197,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1842,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878.1",
      "ID": 1985
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1841,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen",
      "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3490478+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283356",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283356,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1842,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878.1",
      "ID": 1985
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4952,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.6971607+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1865E263P500VM232259",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232259,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1842,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878.1",
      "ID": 1985
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1865,
      "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra",
      "DisplayName": "Sandra White",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8470174+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2610E160P413VM245702",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 245702,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1842,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878.1",
      "ID": 1985
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2610,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Wilson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8547841+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309319",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 309319,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1842,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878.1",
      "ID": 1985
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4941,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza",
      "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3241904+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252293",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252293,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1843,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878",
      "ID": 1960
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1926,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian",
      "DisplayName": "Brian Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7228938+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2615E213P388VM257532",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257532,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1843,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878",
      "ID": 1960
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2615,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George",
      "DisplayName": "George Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0605982+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319958",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319958,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1843,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878",
      "ID": 1960
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4940,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare",
      "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9487217+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249683",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 249683,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1843,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878",
      "ID": 1960
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2641,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair",
      "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9453377+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1783E21P273VM227400",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227400,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1843,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878",
      "ID": 1960
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1783,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie",
      "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5485183+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2633E97P136VM280396",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280396,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1843,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878",
      "ID": 1960
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2633,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire",
      "DisplayName": "Claire Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7589304+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262476",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262476,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1843,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878",
      "ID": 1960
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2603,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6035924+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1759E91P115VM229725",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229725,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1843,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878",
      "ID": 1960
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia",
      "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.093984+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270262",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270262,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1843,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878",
      "ID": 1960
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3751,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.7963595+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322855",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 322855,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1843,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878",
      "ID": 1960
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5109,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco",
      "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.7064636+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5060E86P124VM294707",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 294707,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1843,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878",
      "ID": 1960
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5060,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1748707+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242792",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242792,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1843,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878",
      "ID": 1960
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1866,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah",
      "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0357455+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235632",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235632,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1843,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878",
      "ID": 1960
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1943,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic",
      "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6860983+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302133",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 302133,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1843,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878",
      "ID": 1960
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2595,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin",
      "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.2984858+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244524",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244524,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1843,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878",
      "ID": 1960
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2103,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith",
      "DisplayName": "Keith Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5585051+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327331",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 327331,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1843,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878",
      "ID": 1960
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:46.0312553+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3775E216P435VM276659",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276659,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1843,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878",
      "ID": 1960
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6756528+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264358",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264358,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1843,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878",
      "ID": 1960
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2673,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick",
      "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1300546+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248857",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248857,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1843,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878",
      "ID": 1960
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2678,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson",
      "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.673042+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2123E27P233VM296349",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 296349,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1843,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878",
      "ID": 1960
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2123,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm",
      "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.845204+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285137",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285137,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1843,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878",
      "ID": 1960
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3907,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0680311+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230152",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230152,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1843,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878",
      "ID": 1960
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1735,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela",
      "DisplayName": "Angela Constance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.1184701+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243928",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 243928,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1843,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878",
      "ID": 1960
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1932,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce",
      "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3259506+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1863E238P523VM255265",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255265,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1843,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878",
      "ID": 1960
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1863,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna",
      "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.523483+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323966",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 323966,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1843,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878",
      "ID": 1960
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4976,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth",
      "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.980188+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5107E223P379VM291881",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291881,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1843,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878",
      "ID": 1960
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5107,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1464768+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3743E222P391VM265152",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265152,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1843,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878",
      "ID": 1960
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3743,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel",
      "DisplayName": "Nigel Don",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1707186+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3771E149P417VM261701",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261701,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1843,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878",
      "ID": 1960
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3771,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob",
      "DisplayName": "Bob Doris",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3688085+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2826E262P384VM282035",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 282035,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1843,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878",
      "ID": 1960
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2826,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Dornan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1684078+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3812E94P117VM297936",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 297936,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1843,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878",
      "ID": 1960
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3812,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia",
      "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1312992+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231619",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231619,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1843,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878",
      "ID": 1960
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1778,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen",
      "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6083929+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4955E240P389VM286180",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286180,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1843,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878",
      "ID": 1960
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4955,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3673396+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219304",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 219304,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1843,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878",
      "ID": 1960
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1742,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle",
      "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.2882726+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238659",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 238659,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1843,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878",
      "ID": 1960
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1994,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus",
      "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4635919+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225486",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225486,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1843,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878",
      "ID": 1960
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1814,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda",
      "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9768051+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321605",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 321605,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1843,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878",
      "ID": 1960
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Fee",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4432913+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1853E35P216VM293290",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 293290,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1843,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878",
      "ID": 1960
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia",
      "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.838626+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1892E12P64VM226874",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 226874,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1843,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878",
      "ID": 1960
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2504148+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5054E95P118VM312649",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 312649,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1843,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878",
      "ID": 1960
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5054,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1374011+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4947E152P361VM257138",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257138,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1843,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878",
      "ID": 1960
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4947,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Finnie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.8249499+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271535",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271535,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1843,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878",
      "ID": 1960
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3901,
      "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe",
      "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0800188+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278479",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 278479,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1843,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878",
      "ID": 1960
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2394,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo",
      "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2205977+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2110E220P414VM286721",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286721,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1843,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878",
      "ID": 1960
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth",
      "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5978653+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250416",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250416,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1843,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878",
      "ID": 1960
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2675,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob",
      "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1885924+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1741E10P50VM220729",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220729,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1843,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878",
      "ID": 1960
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1741,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel",
      "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6545345+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220340",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220340,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1843,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878",
      "ID": 1960
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1756,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine",
      "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6371118+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1860E104P150VM251848",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251848,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1843,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878",
      "ID": 1960
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1860,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda",
      "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4917359+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2033E20P141VM266164",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 266164,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1843,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878",
      "ID": 1960
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2033,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain",
      "DisplayName": "Iain Gray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4770666+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324467",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324467,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1843,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878",
      "ID": 1960
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5042,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.223954+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259961",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 259961,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1843,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878",
      "ID": 1960
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick",
      "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6374962+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239238",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239238,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1843,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878",
      "ID": 1960
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2029,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh",
      "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7281269+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273829",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 273829,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1843,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878",
      "ID": 1960
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3758,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6374529+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304196",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 304196,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1843,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878",
      "ID": 1960
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4086,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Hume",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8541953+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221810",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221810,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1843,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878",
      "ID": 1960
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1773,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9487861+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1882E227P459VM242046",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242046,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1843,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878",
      "ID": 1960
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1882,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam",
      "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.791475+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223792",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223792,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1843,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878",
      "ID": 1960
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1893,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4739643+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307520",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307520,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1843,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878",
      "ID": 1960
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4934,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8330611+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272155",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 272155,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1843,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878",
      "ID": 1960
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4956,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Keir",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.1139477+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244801",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244801,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1843,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878",
      "ID": 1960
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Kelly",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5792099+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3129E261P419VM314974",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 314974,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1843,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878",
      "ID": 1960
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3129,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6686401+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2080E36P220VM251122",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251122,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1843,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878",
      "ID": 1960
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann",
      "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.2282574+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4016E11P36VM274706",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274706,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1843,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878",
      "ID": 1960
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4016,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1182024+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255879",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255879,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1843,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878",
      "ID": 1960
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2180,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5609374+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4938E158P374VM277848",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277848,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1843,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878",
      "ID": 1960
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4938,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9710366+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2112E250P486VM252627",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252627,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1843,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878",
      "ID": 1960
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2112,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny",
      "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7375998+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4939E258P394VM277236",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277236,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1843,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878",
      "ID": 1960
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4939,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus",
      "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9395607+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325664",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 325664,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1843,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878",
      "ID": 1960
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5074,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon",
      "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5160145+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1828E3P10VM232814",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232814,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1843,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878",
      "ID": 1960
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1828,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo",
      "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8773738+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311367",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311367,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1843,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878",
      "ID": 1960
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4948,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike",
      "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.875664+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2117E90P107VM230800",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230800,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1843,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878",
      "ID": 1960
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2117,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis",
      "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3460585+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267307",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 267307,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1843,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878",
      "ID": 1960
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken",
      "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0138001+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313794",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313794,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1843,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878",
      "ID": 1960
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4966,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek",
      "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4109467+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3101E102P129VM295446",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295446,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1843,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878",
      "ID": 1960
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3101,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala",
      "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5125104+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5034E88P114VM318854",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 318854,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1843,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878",
      "ID": 1960
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5034,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny",
      "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.676274+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306513",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306513,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1843,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878",
      "ID": 1960
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2159,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Martin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5553024+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5110E252P395VM311287",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311287,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1843,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878",
      "ID": 1960
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Mason",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8721595+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268297",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 268297,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1843,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878",
      "ID": 1960
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2133,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2610249+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2876E141P433VM286116",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286116,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1843,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878",
      "ID": 1960
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2876,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3643591+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4951E147P368VM260729",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 260729,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1843,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878",
      "ID": 1960
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4951,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan",
      "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.0897408+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3896E175P307VM264130",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264130,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1843,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878",
      "ID": 1960
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3896,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam",
      "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9255251+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308042",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 308042,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1843,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878",
      "ID": 1960
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8619585+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4964E143P375VM279273",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279273,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1843,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878",
      "ID": 1960
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4964,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.4947259+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3824E84P113VM280011",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280011,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1843,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878",
      "ID": 1960
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3824,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.532753+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2066E22P91VM261807",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261807,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1843,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878",
      "ID": 1960
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2066,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.379007+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299727",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 299727,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1843,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878",
      "ID": 1960
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7200366+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3759E260P411VM303371",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 303371,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1843,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878",
      "ID": 1960
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina",
      "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8123105+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2487E146P369VM301718",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 301718,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1843,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878",
      "ID": 1960
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2487,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.2745689+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223634",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223634,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1843,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878",
      "ID": 1960
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4672323+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237410",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237410,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1843,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878",
      "ID": 1960
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1961,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David",
      "DisplayName": "David McLetchie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2030154+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2134E34P201VM297801",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 297801,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1843,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878",
      "ID": 1960
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2134,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1255981+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320727",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 320727,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1843,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878",
      "ID": 1960
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5041,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan",
      "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1788525+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3763E142P397VM316108",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 316108,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1843,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878",
      "ID": 1960
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3763,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart",
      "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9465079+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1986E23P197VM236290",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 236290,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1843,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878",
      "ID": 1960
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1986,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan",
      "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9100223+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5047E100P130VM291444",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291444,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1843,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878",
      "ID": 1960
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5047,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne",
      "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1195727+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234934",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234934,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1843,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878",
      "ID": 1960
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1845,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette",
      "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4060733+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313678",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313678,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1843,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878",
      "ID": 1960
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3061,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4057466+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1768E19P265VM288519",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 288519,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1843,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878",
      "ID": 1960
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1768,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1468856+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1894E267P527VM224994",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 224994,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1843,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878",
      "ID": 1960
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1894,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Neil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7400111+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3815E98P134VM270831",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270831,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1843,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878",
      "ID": 1960
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3815,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Park, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Park",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8249893+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265912",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265912,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1843,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878",
      "ID": 1960
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2010,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil",
      "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4659343+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283567",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283567,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1843,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878",
      "ID": 1960
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5057,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7138346+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2853E33P128VM251074",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251074,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1843,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878",
      "ID": 1960
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Pentland",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.2259022+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317946",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317946,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1843,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878",
      "ID": 1960
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5009,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4503276+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254747",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254747,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1843,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878",
      "ID": 1960
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3745,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis",
      "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2819981+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1870E225P478VM295579",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295579,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1843,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878",
      "ID": 1960
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1870,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona",
      "DisplayName": "Shona Robison",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5183042+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2135E254P450VM234825",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234825,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1843,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878",
      "ID": 1960
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2135,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Russell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4013645+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1895E232P431VM257388",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257388,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1843,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878",
      "ID": 1960
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1895,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0540589+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228072",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 228072,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1843,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878",
      "ID": 1960
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1839,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5831465+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2345E10P55VM292019",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 292019,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1843,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878",
      "ID": 1960
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2345,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1523882+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2223E176P333VM310631",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 310631,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1843,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878",
      "ID": 1960
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2223,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish",
      "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5792431+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2182E87P175VM245984",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 245984,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1843,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878",
      "ID": 1960
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2182,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8671925+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298351",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298351,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1843,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878",
      "ID": 1960
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5079,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew",
      "DisplayName": "Drew Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.342013+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234385",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234385,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1843,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878",
      "ID": 1960
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1769,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3750023+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4014E14P26VM269901",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269901,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1843,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878",
      "ID": 1960
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4014,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz",
      "DisplayName": "Liz Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5678758+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269163",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269163,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1843,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878",
      "ID": 1960
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2215,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.3064083+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317132",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317132,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1843,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878",
      "ID": 1960
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3806,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.1830519+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326166",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 326166,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1843,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878",
      "ID": 1960
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5106,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin",
      "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5427121+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241082",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241082,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1843,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878",
      "ID": 1960
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1848,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola",
      "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3952918+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2098E237P531VM289546",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289546,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1843,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878",
      "ID": 1960
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2098,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Swinney",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.448739+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2674E247P401VM247699",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247699,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1843,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878",
      "ID": 1960
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2674,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave",
      "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4246307+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5075E234P371VM284814",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 284814,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1843,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878",
      "ID": 1960
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5075,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Torrance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0488977+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1793E151P362VM222394",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 222394,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1843,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878",
      "ID": 1960
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1793,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean",
      "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1870705+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5078E245P366VM307162",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307162,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1843,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878",
      "ID": 1960
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5078,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Walker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5899315+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1841E231P426VM240196",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 240196,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1843,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878",
      "ID": 1960
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1841,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen",
      "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3489821+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283357",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283357,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1843,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878",
      "ID": 1960
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4952,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.6972206+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1865E263P500VM232258",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232258,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1843,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878",
      "ID": 1960
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1865,
      "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra",
      "DisplayName": "Sandra White",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8469753+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2610E160P413VM245701",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 245701,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1843,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878",
      "ID": 1960
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2610,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Wilson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.854743+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309318",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 309318,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1843,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Prison Visiting Committees",
      "Reference": "S4M-01878",
      "ID": 1960
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4941,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza",
      "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3241316+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252249",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252249,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1840,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876.1",
      "ID": 1986
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1926,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian",
      "DisplayName": "Brian Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7207821+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2615E213P388VM257529",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257529,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1840,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876.1",
      "ID": 1986
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2615,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George",
      "DisplayName": "George Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0604758+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319961",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319961,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1840,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876.1",
      "ID": 1986
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4940,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare",
      "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9488629+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249686",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 249686,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1840,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876.1",
      "ID": 1986
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2641,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair",
      "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9454573+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1783E21P273VM227356",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227356,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1840,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876.1",
      "ID": 1986
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1783,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie",
      "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5466304+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2633E97P136VM280353",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280353,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1840,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876.1",
      "ID": 1986
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2633,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire",
      "DisplayName": "Claire Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7570673+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262473",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262473,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1840,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876.1",
      "ID": 1986
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2603,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.60347+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1759E91P115VM229722",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229722,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1840,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876.1",
      "ID": 1986
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia",
      "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0938443+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270265",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270265,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1840,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876.1",
      "ID": 1986
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3751,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.7964855+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322811",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 322811,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1840,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876.1",
      "ID": 1986
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5109,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco",
      "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.7045955+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5060E86P124VM294704",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 294704,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1840,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876.1",
      "ID": 1986
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5060,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1747474+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242789",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242789,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1840,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876.1",
      "ID": 1986
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1866,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah",
      "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0356185+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235635",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235635,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1840,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876.1",
      "ID": 1986
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1943,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic",
      "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6863159+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302130",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 302130,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1840,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876.1",
      "ID": 1986
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2595,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin",
      "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.2983437+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244527",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244527,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1840,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876.1",
      "ID": 1986
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2103,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith",
      "DisplayName": "Keith Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5586288+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327328",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 327328,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1840,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876.1",
      "ID": 1986
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:46.0311313+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3775E216P435VM276656",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276656,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1840,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876.1",
      "ID": 1986
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6755097+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264361",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264361,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1840,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876.1",
      "ID": 1986
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2673,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick",
      "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1301954+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248860",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248860,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1840,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876.1",
      "ID": 1986
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2678,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson",
      "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6731664+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2123E27P233VM296352",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 296352,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1840,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876.1",
      "ID": 1986
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2123,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm",
      "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8453289+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285134",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285134,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1840,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876.1",
      "ID": 1986
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3907,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0679089+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230149",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230149,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1840,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876.1",
      "ID": 1986
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1735,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela",
      "DisplayName": "Angela Constance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.1183413+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243931",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 243931,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1840,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876.1",
      "ID": 1986
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1932,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce",
      "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3260748+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1863E238P523VM255268",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255268,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1840,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876.1",
      "ID": 1986
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1863,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna",
      "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5236057+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323963",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 323963,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1840,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876.1",
      "ID": 1986
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4976,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth",
      "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9800615+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5107E223P379VM291884",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291884,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1840,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876.1",
      "ID": 1986
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5107,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1465967+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3743E222P391VM265149",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265149,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1840,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876.1",
      "ID": 1986
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3743,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel",
      "DisplayName": "Nigel Don",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1705947+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3771E149P417VM261698",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261698,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1840,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876.1",
      "ID": 1986
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3771,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob",
      "DisplayName": "Bob Doris",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3686866+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2826E262P384VM282077",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 282077,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1840,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876.1",
      "ID": 1986
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2826,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Dornan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1746686+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3812E94P117VM297896",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 297896,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1840,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876.1",
      "ID": 1986
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3812,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia",
      "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1296084+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231622",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231622,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1840,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876.1",
      "ID": 1986
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1778,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen",
      "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6085318+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4955E240P389VM286183",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286183,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1840,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876.1",
      "ID": 1986
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4955,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3674819+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219301",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 219301,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1840,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876.1",
      "ID": 1986
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1742,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle",
      "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.2880259+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238662",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 238662,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1840,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876.1",
      "ID": 1986
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1994,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus",
      "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4637128+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225489",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225489,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1840,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876.1",
      "ID": 1986
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1814,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda",
      "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9769283+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321649",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 321649,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1840,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876.1",
      "ID": 1986
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Fee",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4451659+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1853E35P216VM293293",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 293293,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1840,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876.1",
      "ID": 1986
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia",
      "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8387485+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1892E12P64VM226871",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 226871,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1840,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876.1",
      "ID": 1986
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2502906+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5054E95P118VM312646",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 312646,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1840,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876.1",
      "ID": 1986
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5054,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1372794+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4947E152P361VM257135",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257135,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1840,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876.1",
      "ID": 1986
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4947,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Finnie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.8248089+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271538",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271538,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1840,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876.1",
      "ID": 1986
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3901,
      "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe",
      "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0801677+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278522",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 278522,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1840,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876.1",
      "ID": 1986
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2394,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo",
      "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2225162+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2110E220P414VM286718",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286718,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1840,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876.1",
      "ID": 1986
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth",
      "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5977465+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250413",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250413,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1840,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876.1",
      "ID": 1986
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2675,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob",
      "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1884687+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1741E10P50VM220726",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220726,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1840,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876.1",
      "ID": 1986
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1741,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel",
      "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6543935+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220343",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220343,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1840,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876.1",
      "ID": 1986
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1756,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine",
      "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6372553+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1860E104P150VM251845",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251845,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1840,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876.1",
      "ID": 1986
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1860,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda",
      "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4916142+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2033E20P141VM266208",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 266208,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1840,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876.1",
      "ID": 1986
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2033,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain",
      "DisplayName": "Iain Gray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.7287187+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324470",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324470,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1840,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876.1",
      "ID": 1986
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5042,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2240757+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259964",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 259964,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1840,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876.1",
      "ID": 1986
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick",
      "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6376185+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239235",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239235,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1840,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876.1",
      "ID": 1986
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2029,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh",
      "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7280023+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273832",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 273832,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1840,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876.1",
      "ID": 1986
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3758,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6375956+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304199",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 304199,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1840,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876.1",
      "ID": 1986
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4086,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Hume",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.0279098+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221813",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221813,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1840,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876.1",
      "ID": 1986
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1773,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9489072+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1882E227P459VM242049",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242049,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1840,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876.1",
      "ID": 1986
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1882,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam",
      "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7916198+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223795",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223795,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1840,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876.1",
      "ID": 1986
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1893,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4740896+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307479",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307479,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1840,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876.1",
      "ID": 1986
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4934,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8313043+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272152",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 272152,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1840,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876.1",
      "ID": 1986
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4956,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Keir",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.1138261+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244798",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244798,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1840,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876.1",
      "ID": 1986
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Kelly",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5790875+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3129E261P419VM314971",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 314971,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1840,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876.1",
      "ID": 1986
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3129,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6685117+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2080E36P220VM251125",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251125,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1840,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876.1",
      "ID": 1986
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann",
      "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.2283895+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4016E11P36VM274703",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274703,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1840,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876.1",
      "ID": 1986
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4016,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1180782+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2180E246P463VM256188",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 256188,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1840,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876.1",
      "ID": 1986
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2180,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5743987+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4938E158P374VM277851",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277851,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1840,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876.1",
      "ID": 1986
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4938,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.971177+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2112E250P486VM252624",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252624,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1840,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876.1",
      "ID": 1986
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2112,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny",
      "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7374773+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4939E258P394VM277239",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277239,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1840,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876.1",
      "ID": 1986
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4939,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus",
      "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9396845+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325661",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 325661,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1840,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876.1",
      "ID": 1986
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5074,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon",
      "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5158727+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1828E3P10VM232811",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232811,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1840,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876.1",
      "ID": 1986
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1828,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo",
      "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8772528+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311016",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311016,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1840,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876.1",
      "ID": 1986
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4948,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike",
      "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.6018111+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2117E90P107VM230803",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230803,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1840,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876.1",
      "ID": 1986
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2117,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis",
      "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3461807+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267263",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 267263,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1840,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876.1",
      "ID": 1986
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken",
      "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0119004+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313838",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313838,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1840,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876.1",
      "ID": 1986
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4966,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek",
      "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4128466+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3101E102P129VM295486",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295486,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1840,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876.1",
      "ID": 1986
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3101,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala",
      "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.514204+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5034E88P114VM318899",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 318899,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1840,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876.1",
      "ID": 1986
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5034,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny",
      "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6785111+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306516",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306516,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1840,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876.1",
      "ID": 1986
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2159,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Martin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5554265+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5110E252P395VM311290",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311290,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1840,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876.1",
      "ID": 1986
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Mason",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8723019+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268341",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 268341,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1840,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876.1",
      "ID": 1986
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2133,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2629252+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2876E141P433VM286075",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286075,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1840,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876.1",
      "ID": 1986
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2876,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.356918+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4951E147P368VM260732",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 260732,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1840,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876.1",
      "ID": 1986
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4951,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan",
      "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.0898637+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3896E175P307VM264133",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264133,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1840,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876.1",
      "ID": 1986
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3896,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam",
      "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9256458+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308039",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 308039,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1840,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876.1",
      "ID": 1986
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8618139+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4964E143P375VM279270",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279270,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1840,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876.1",
      "ID": 1986
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4964,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.4945843+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3824E84P113VM280014",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280014,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1840,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876.1",
      "ID": 1986
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3824,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.537701+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2066E22P91VM261810",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261810,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1840,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876.1",
      "ID": 1986
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2066,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3791296+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299768",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 299768,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1840,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876.1",
      "ID": 1986
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7217802+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3759E260P411VM303368",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 303368,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1840,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876.1",
      "ID": 1986
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina",
      "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.812076+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2487E146P369VM301721",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 301721,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1840,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876.1",
      "ID": 1986
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2487,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.2802334+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223631",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223631,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1840,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876.1",
      "ID": 1986
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4670884+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237407",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237407,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1840,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876.1",
      "ID": 1986
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1961,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David",
      "DisplayName": "David McLetchie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2028707+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2134E34P201VM297798",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 297798,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1840,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876.1",
      "ID": 1986
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2134,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.12546+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320682",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 320682,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1840,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876.1",
      "ID": 1986
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5041,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan",
      "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1769275+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3763E142P397VM316111",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 316111,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1840,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876.1",
      "ID": 1986
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3763,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart",
      "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9466515+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1986E23P197VM236287",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 236287,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1840,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876.1",
      "ID": 1986
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1986,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan",
      "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9098987+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5047E100P130VM291447",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291447,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1840,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876.1",
      "ID": 1986
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5047,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne",
      "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1197154+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234937",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234937,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1840,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876.1",
      "ID": 1986
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1845,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette",
      "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4061977+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313681",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313681,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1840,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876.1",
      "ID": 1986
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3061,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4058699+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1768E19P265VM288516",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 288516,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1840,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876.1",
      "ID": 1986
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1768,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1467626+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1894E267P527VM224991",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 224991,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1840,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876.1",
      "ID": 1986
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1894,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Neil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.739866+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3815E98P134VM270828",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270828,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1840,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876.1",
      "ID": 1986
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3815,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Park, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Park",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8248684+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265915",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265915,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1840,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876.1",
      "ID": 1986
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2010,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil",
      "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4660571+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283570",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283570,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1840,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876.1",
      "ID": 1986
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5057,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7139565+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2853E33P128VM251071",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251071,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1840,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876.1",
      "ID": 1986
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Pentland",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.22576+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317901",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317901,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1840,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876.1",
      "ID": 1986
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5009,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4423108+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254750",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254750,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1840,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876.1",
      "ID": 1986
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3745,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis",
      "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.282121+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1870E225P478VM295576",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295576,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1840,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876.1",
      "ID": 1986
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1870,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona",
      "DisplayName": "Shona Robison",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5181785+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2135E254P450VM234822",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234822,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1840,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876.1",
      "ID": 1986
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2135,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Russell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4012416+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1895E232P431VM257385",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257385,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1840,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876.1",
      "ID": 1986
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1895,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0539153+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228069",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 228069,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1840,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876.1",
      "ID": 1986
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1839,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5830245+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2345E10P55VM292022",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 292022,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1840,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876.1",
      "ID": 1986
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2345,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1525105+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2223E176P333VM310628",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 310628,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1840,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876.1",
      "ID": 1986
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2223,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish",
      "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5790989+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2182E87P175VM245981",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 245981,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1840,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876.1",
      "ID": 1986
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2182,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8670651+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298354",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298354,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1840,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876.1",
      "ID": 1986
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5079,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew",
      "DisplayName": "Drew Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3421357+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234388",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234388,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1840,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876.1",
      "ID": 1986
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1769,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3751241+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4014E14P26VM269898",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269898,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1840,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876.1",
      "ID": 1986
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4014,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz",
      "DisplayName": "Liz Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.567752+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269120",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269120,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1840,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876.1",
      "ID": 1986
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2215,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.3044393+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317129",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317129,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1840,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876.1",
      "ID": 1986
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3806,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.1829296+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326169",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 326169,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1840,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876.1",
      "ID": 1986
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5106,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin",
      "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5428348+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241079",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241079,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1840,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876.1",
      "ID": 1986
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1848,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola",
      "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3951694+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2098E237P531VM288774",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 288774,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1840,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876.1",
      "ID": 1986
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2098,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Swinney",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1578199+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2674E247P401VM247696",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247696,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1840,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876.1",
      "ID": 1986
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2674,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave",
      "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4245024+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5075E234P371VM284811",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 284811,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1840,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876.1",
      "ID": 1986
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5075,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Torrance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0487767+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1793E151P362VM222391",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 222391,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1840,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876.1",
      "ID": 1986
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1793,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean",
      "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1869458+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5078E245P366VM307165",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307165,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1840,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876.1",
      "ID": 1986
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5078,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Walker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5900737+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1841E231P426VM240199",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 240199,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1840,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876.1",
      "ID": 1986
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1841,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen",
      "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3491325+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283354",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283354,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1840,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876.1",
      "ID": 1986
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4952,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.6970777+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1865E263P500VM232302",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232302,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1840,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876.1",
      "ID": 1986
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1865,
      "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra",
      "DisplayName": "Sandra White",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8489036+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2610E160P413VM245704",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 245704,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1840,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876.1",
      "ID": 1986
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2610,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Wilson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8548635+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309359",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 309359,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1840,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876.1",
      "ID": 1986
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4941,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza",
      "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3259055+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252250",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252250,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1841,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876",
      "ID": 1958
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1926,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian",
      "DisplayName": "Brian Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7208421+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2615E213P388VM257530",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257530,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1841,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876",
      "ID": 1958
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2615,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George",
      "DisplayName": "George Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0605162+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319960",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319960,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1841,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876",
      "ID": 1958
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4940,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare",
      "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9488226+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249685",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 249685,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1841,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876",
      "ID": 1958
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2641,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair",
      "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9454175+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1783E21P273VM227357",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227357,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1841,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876",
      "ID": 1958
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1783,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie",
      "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.546671+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2633E97P136VM280354",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280354,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1841,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876",
      "ID": 1958
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2633,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire",
      "DisplayName": "Claire Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7571085+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262474",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262474,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1841,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876",
      "ID": 1958
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2603,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6035111+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1759E91P115VM229723",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229723,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1841,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876",
      "ID": 1958
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia",
      "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.093885+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270264",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270264,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1841,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876",
      "ID": 1958
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3751,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.7964438+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322677",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 322677,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1841,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876",
      "ID": 1958
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5109,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco",
      "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6989557+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5060E86P124VM294705",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 294705,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1841,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876",
      "ID": 1958
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5060,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1747886+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242790",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242790,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1841,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876",
      "ID": 1958
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1866,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah",
      "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.03566+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235634",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235634,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1841,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876",
      "ID": 1958
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1943,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic",
      "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6862661+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302131",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 302131,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1841,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876",
      "ID": 1958
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2595,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin",
      "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.298384+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244526",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244526,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1841,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876",
      "ID": 1958
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2103,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith",
      "DisplayName": "Keith Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5585871+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327329",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 327329,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1841,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876",
      "ID": 1958
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:46.0311724+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3775E216P435VM276657",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276657,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1841,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876",
      "ID": 1958
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6755505+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264360",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264360,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1841,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876",
      "ID": 1958
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2673,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick",
      "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1301534+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248859",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248859,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1841,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876",
      "ID": 1958
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2678,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson",
      "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6731248+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2123E27P233VM296351",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 296351,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1841,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876",
      "ID": 1958
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2123,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm",
      "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8452875+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285135",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285135,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1841,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876",
      "ID": 1958
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3907,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0679495+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230150",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230150,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1841,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876",
      "ID": 1958
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1735,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela",
      "DisplayName": "Angela Constance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.1183817+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243930",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 243930,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1841,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876",
      "ID": 1958
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1932,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce",
      "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.326033+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1863E238P523VM255267",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255267,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1841,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876",
      "ID": 1958
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1863,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna",
      "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.523565+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323964",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 323964,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1841,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876",
      "ID": 1958
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4976,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth",
      "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9801044+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5107E223P379VM291883",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291883,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1841,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876",
      "ID": 1958
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5107,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1465573+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3743E222P391VM265150",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265150,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1841,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876",
      "ID": 1958
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3743,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel",
      "DisplayName": "Nigel Don",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1706358+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3771E149P417VM261699",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261699,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1841,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876",
      "ID": 1958
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3771,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob",
      "DisplayName": "Bob Doris",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3687273+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2826E262P384VM282076",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 282076,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1841,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876",
      "ID": 1958
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2826,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Dornan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1746274+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3812E94P117VM297943",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 297943,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1841,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876",
      "ID": 1958
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3812,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia",
      "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1316024+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231621",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231621,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1841,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876",
      "ID": 1958
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1778,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen",
      "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6084905+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4955E240P389VM286182",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286182,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1841,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876",
      "ID": 1958
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4955,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.367441+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219302",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 219302,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1841,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876",
      "ID": 1958
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1742,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle",
      "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.2881286+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238661",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 238661,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1841,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876",
      "ID": 1958
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1994,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus",
      "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4636731+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225488",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225488,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1841,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876",
      "ID": 1958
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1814,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda",
      "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9768872+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321783",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 321783,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1841,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876",
      "ID": 1958
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Fee",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4511902+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1853E35P216VM293292",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 293292,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1841,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876",
      "ID": 1958
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia",
      "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8387079+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1892E12P64VM226872",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 226872,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1841,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876",
      "ID": 1958
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2503319+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5054E95P118VM312647",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 312647,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1841,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876",
      "ID": 1958
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5054,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1373195+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4947E152P361VM257136",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257136,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1841,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876",
      "ID": 1958
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4947,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Finnie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.8248503+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271537",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271537,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1841,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876",
      "ID": 1958
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3901,
      "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe",
      "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.080101+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278521",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 278521,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1841,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876",
      "ID": 1958
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2394,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo",
      "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2224734+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2110E220P414VM286719",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286719,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1841,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876",
      "ID": 1958
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth",
      "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5977864+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250414",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250414,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1841,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876",
      "ID": 1958
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2675,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob",
      "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1885097+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1741E10P50VM220727",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220727,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1841,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876",
      "ID": 1958
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1741,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel",
      "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6544524+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220342",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220342,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1841,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876",
      "ID": 1958
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1756,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine",
      "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6372126+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1860E104P150VM251846",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251846,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1841,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876",
      "ID": 1958
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1860,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda",
      "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4916547+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2033E20P141VM266207",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 266207,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1841,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876",
      "ID": 1958
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2033,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain",
      "DisplayName": "Iain Gray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.728666+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324469",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324469,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1841,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876",
      "ID": 1958
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5042,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.224035+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259963",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 259963,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1841,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876",
      "ID": 1958
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick",
      "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6375778+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239236",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239236,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1841,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876",
      "ID": 1958
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2029,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh",
      "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7280442+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273831",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 273831,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1841,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876",
      "ID": 1958
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3758,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6375548+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304198",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 304198,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1841,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876",
      "ID": 1958
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4086,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Hume",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.0278523+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221812",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221812,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1841,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876",
      "ID": 1958
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1773,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9488667+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1882E227P459VM242048",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242048,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1841,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876",
      "ID": 1958
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1882,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam",
      "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7915769+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223794",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223794,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1841,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876",
      "ID": 1958
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1893,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4740488+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307527",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307527,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1841,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876",
      "ID": 1958
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4934,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8333693+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272153",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 272153,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1841,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876",
      "ID": 1958
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4956,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Keir",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.1138672+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244799",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244799,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1841,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876",
      "ID": 1958
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Kelly",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5791284+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3129E261P419VM314972",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 314972,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1841,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876",
      "ID": 1958
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3129,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6685537+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2080E36P220VM251124",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251124,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1841,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876",
      "ID": 1958
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann",
      "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.2283488+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4016E11P36VM274704",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274704,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1841,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876",
      "ID": 1958
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4016,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1181191+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255881",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255881,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1841,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876",
      "ID": 1958
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2180,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.561017+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4938E158P374VM277850",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277850,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1841,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876",
      "ID": 1958
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4938,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9711191+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2112E250P486VM252625",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252625,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1841,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876",
      "ID": 1958
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2112,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny",
      "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7375185+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4939E258P394VM277238",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277238,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1841,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876",
      "ID": 1958
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4939,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus",
      "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9396433+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325662",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 325662,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1841,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876",
      "ID": 1958
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5074,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon",
      "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5159129+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1828E3P10VM232812",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232812,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1841,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876",
      "ID": 1958
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1828,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo",
      "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8772928+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311374",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311374,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1841,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876",
      "ID": 1958
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4948,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike",
      "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8759743+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2117E90P107VM230802",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230802,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1841,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876",
      "ID": 1958
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2117,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis",
      "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3461397+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267264",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 267264,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1841,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876",
      "ID": 1958
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken",
      "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0119407+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313787",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313787,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1841,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876",
      "ID": 1958
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4966,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek",
      "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4106421+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3101E102P129VM295439",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295439,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1841,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876",
      "ID": 1958
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3101,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala",
      "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5122034+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319033",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319033,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1841,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876",
      "ID": 1958
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5034,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny",
      "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6895584+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306515",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306515,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1841,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876",
      "ID": 1958
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2159,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Martin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5553858+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5110E252P395VM311289",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311289,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1841,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876",
      "ID": 1958
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Mason",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8722614+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268340",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 268340,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1841,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876",
      "ID": 1958
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2133,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2628843+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2876E141P433VM286122",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286122,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1841,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876",
      "ID": 1958
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2876,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3646081+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4951E147P368VM260731",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 260731,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1841,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876",
      "ID": 1958
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4951,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan",
      "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.0898224+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3896E175P307VM264132",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264132,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1841,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876",
      "ID": 1958
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3896,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam",
      "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9256056+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308040",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 308040,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1841,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876",
      "ID": 1958
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8618749+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4964E143P375VM279271",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279271,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1841,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876",
      "ID": 1958
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4964,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.4946254+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3824E84P113VM280013",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280013,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1841,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876",
      "ID": 1958
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3824,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5376418+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2066E22P91VM261809",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261809,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1841,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876",
      "ID": 1958
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2066,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3790887+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299720",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 299720,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1841,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876",
      "ID": 1958
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7197047+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3759E260P411VM303369",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 303369,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1841,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876",
      "ID": 1958
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina",
      "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8121171+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2487E146P369VM301720",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 301720,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1841,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876",
      "ID": 1958
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2487,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.2801831+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223632",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223632,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1841,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876",
      "ID": 1958
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4671295+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237408",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237408,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1841,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876",
      "ID": 1958
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1961,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David",
      "DisplayName": "David McLetchie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2029121+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2134E34P201VM297799",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 297799,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1841,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876",
      "ID": 1958
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2134,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1255003+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320393",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 320393,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1841,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876",
      "ID": 1958
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5041,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan",
      "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1644923+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3763E142P397VM316110",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 316110,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1841,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876",
      "ID": 1958
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3763,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart",
      "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9465907+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1986E23P197VM236288",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 236288,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1841,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876",
      "ID": 1958
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1986,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan",
      "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9099403+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5047E100P130VM291446",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291446,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1841,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876",
      "ID": 1958
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5047,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne",
      "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1196745+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234936",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234936,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1841,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876",
      "ID": 1958
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1845,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette",
      "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.406157+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313680",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313680,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1841,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876",
      "ID": 1958
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3061,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4058288+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1768E19P265VM288517",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 288517,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1841,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876",
      "ID": 1958
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1768,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1468035+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1894E267P527VM224992",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 224992,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1841,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876",
      "ID": 1958
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1894,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Neil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.739906+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3815E98P134VM270829",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270829,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1841,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876",
      "ID": 1958
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3815,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Park, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Park",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.824909+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265914",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265914,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1841,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876",
      "ID": 1958
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2010,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil",
      "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4660164+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283569",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283569,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1841,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876",
      "ID": 1958
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5057,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7139157+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2853E33P128VM251072",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251072,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1841,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876",
      "ID": 1958
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Pentland",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.2258005+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317613",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317613,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1841,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876",
      "ID": 1958
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5009,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4299655+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254749",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254749,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1841,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876",
      "ID": 1958
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3745,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis",
      "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2820804+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1870E225P478VM295577",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295577,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1841,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876",
      "ID": 1958
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1870,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona",
      "DisplayName": "Shona Robison",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5182215+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2135E254P450VM234823",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234823,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1841,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876",
      "ID": 1958
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2135,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Russell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4012831+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1895E232P431VM257386",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257386,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1841,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876",
      "ID": 1958
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1895,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0539743+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228070",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 228070,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1841,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876",
      "ID": 1958
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1839,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5830651+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2345E10P55VM292021",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 292021,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1841,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876",
      "ID": 1958
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2345,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1524702+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2223E176P333VM310629",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 310629,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1841,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876",
      "ID": 1958
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2223,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish",
      "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5791585+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2182E87P175VM245982",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 245982,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1841,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876",
      "ID": 1958
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2182,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8671063+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298353",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298353,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1841,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876",
      "ID": 1958
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5079,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew",
      "DisplayName": "Drew Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3420947+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234387",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234387,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1841,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876",
      "ID": 1958
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1769,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3750831+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4014E14P26VM269899",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269899,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1841,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876",
      "ID": 1958
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4014,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz",
      "DisplayName": "Liz Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5677931+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269121",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269121,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1841,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876",
      "ID": 1958
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2215,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.304481+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317130",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317130,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1841,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876",
      "ID": 1958
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3806,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.182971+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326168",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 326168,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1841,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876",
      "ID": 1958
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5106,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin",
      "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5427943+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241080",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241080,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1841,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876",
      "ID": 1958
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1848,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola",
      "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3952103+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2098E237P531VM288775",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 288775,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1841,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876",
      "ID": 1958
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2098,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Swinney",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1578597+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2674E247P401VM247697",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247697,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1841,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876",
      "ID": 1958
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2674,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave",
      "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4245493+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5075E234P371VM284812",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 284812,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1841,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876",
      "ID": 1958
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5075,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Torrance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0488168+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1793E151P362VM222392",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 222392,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1841,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876",
      "ID": 1958
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1793,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean",
      "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1869877+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5078E245P366VM307164",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307164,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1841,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876",
      "ID": 1958
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5078,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Walker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5900127+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1841E231P426VM240198",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 240198,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1841,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876",
      "ID": 1958
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1841,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen",
      "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3490912+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283355",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283355,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1841,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876",
      "ID": 1958
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4952,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.6971188+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1865E263P500VM232301",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232301,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1841,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876",
      "ID": 1958
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1865,
      "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra",
      "DisplayName": "Sandra White",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.848863+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2610E160P413VM245703",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 245703,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1841,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876",
      "ID": 1958
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2610,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Wilson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8548239+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309311",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 309311,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1841,
      "AgendaID": 2563,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 63,
      "VoteAgainst": 52,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "College Funding",
      "Reference": "S4M-01876",
      "ID": 1958
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4941,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza",
      "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-02-02T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3238456+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252642",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252642,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1836,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828.1",
      "ID": 1924
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1926,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian",
      "DisplayName": "Brian Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.738255+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2615E213P388VM257565",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257565,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1836,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828.1",
      "ID": 1924
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2615,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George",
      "DisplayName": "George Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0620043+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319854",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319854,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1836,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828.1",
      "ID": 1924
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4940,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare",
      "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9442565+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249621",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 249621,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1836,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828.1",
      "ID": 1924
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2641,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair",
      "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9426133+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1783E21P273VM227747",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227747,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1836,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828.1",
      "ID": 1924
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1783,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie",
      "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5638903+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2633E97P136VM280749",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280749,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1836,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828.1",
      "ID": 1924
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2633,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire",
      "DisplayName": "Claire Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7807875+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262696",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262696,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1836,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828.1",
      "ID": 1924
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2603,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6129464+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1759E91P115VM229781",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229781,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1836,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828.1",
      "ID": 1924
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia",
      "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.096774+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270227",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270227,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1836,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828.1",
      "ID": 1924
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3751,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.7948237+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322712",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 322712,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1836,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828.1",
      "ID": 1924
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5109,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco",
      "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.7004336+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5060E86P124VM294771",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 294771,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1836,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828.1",
      "ID": 1924
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5060,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1776233+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242867",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242867,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1836,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828.1",
      "ID": 1924
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1866,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah",
      "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0390096+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235599",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235599,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1836,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828.1",
      "ID": 1924
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1943,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic",
      "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6847084+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302346",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 302346,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1836,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828.1",
      "ID": 1924
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2595,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin",
      "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5204432+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244307",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244307,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1836,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828.1",
      "ID": 1924
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2103,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith",
      "DisplayName": "Keith Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5490308+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327214",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 327214,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1836,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828.1",
      "ID": 1924
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:46.0261119+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277035",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277035,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1836,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828.1",
      "ID": 1924
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.698273+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264294",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264294,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1836,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828.1",
      "ID": 1924
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2673,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick",
      "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1270765+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248791",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248791,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1836,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828.1",
      "ID": 1924
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2678,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson",
      "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6702058+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2123E27P233VM295784",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295784,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1836,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828.1",
      "ID": 1924
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2123,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm",
      "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5357435+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285200",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285200,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1836,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828.1",
      "ID": 1924
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3907,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3124375+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230677",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230677,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1836,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828.1",
      "ID": 1924
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1735,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela",
      "DisplayName": "Angela Constance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3404633+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243852",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 243852,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1836,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828.1",
      "ID": 1924
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1932,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce",
      "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3226886+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254900",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254900,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1836,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828.1",
      "ID": 1924
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1863,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna",
      "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2886226+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323821",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 323821,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1836,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828.1",
      "ID": 1924
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4976,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth",
      "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9733932+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5107E223P379VM291350",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291350,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1836,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828.1",
      "ID": 1924
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5107,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1155037+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3743E222P391VM265372",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265372,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1836,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828.1",
      "ID": 1924
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3743,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel",
      "DisplayName": "Nigel Don",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4363527+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262234",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262234,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1836,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828.1",
      "ID": 1924
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3771,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob",
      "DisplayName": "Bob Doris",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.5927216+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281992",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 281992,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1836,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828.1",
      "ID": 1924
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2826,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Dornan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1665535+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3812E94P117VM297980",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 297980,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1836,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828.1",
      "ID": 1924
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3812,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia",
      "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1331494+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231256",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231256,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1836,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828.1",
      "ID": 1924
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1778,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen",
      "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.5871279+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4955E240P389VM285989",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285989,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1836,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828.1",
      "ID": 1924
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4955,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3531986+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219373",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 219373,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1836,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828.1",
      "ID": 1924
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1742,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle",
      "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.2958258+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238626",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 238626,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1836,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828.1",
      "ID": 1924
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1994,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus",
      "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4622057+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225427",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225427,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1836,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828.1",
      "ID": 1924
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1814,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda",
      "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9742557+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321747",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 321747,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1836,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828.1",
      "ID": 1924
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Fee",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4496738+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292873",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 292873,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1836,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828.1",
      "ID": 1924
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia",
      "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5617444+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1892E12P64VM226942",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 226942,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1836,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828.1",
      "ID": 1924
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2536314+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5054E95P118VM312706",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 312706,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1836,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828.1",
      "ID": 1924
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5054,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1398392+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4947E152P361VM257198",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257198,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1836,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828.1",
      "ID": 1924
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4947,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Finnie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0457206+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271345",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271345,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1836,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828.1",
      "ID": 1924
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3901,
      "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe",
      "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0715717+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278437",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 278437,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1836,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828.1",
      "ID": 1924
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2394,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo",
      "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2187737+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2110E220P414VM287241",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 287241,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1836,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828.1",
      "ID": 1924
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth",
      "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8557045+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250476",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250476,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1836,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828.1",
      "ID": 1924
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2675,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob",
      "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1911827+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1741E10P50VM220944",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220944,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1836,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828.1",
      "ID": 1924
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1741,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel",
      "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6683704+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220271",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220271,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1836,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828.1",
      "ID": 1924
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1756,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine",
      "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6312402+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1860E104P150VM252366",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252366,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1836,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828.1",
      "ID": 1924
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1860,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda",
      "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7260806+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2033E20P141VM266124",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 266124,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1836,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828.1",
      "ID": 1924
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2033,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain",
      "DisplayName": "Iain Gray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4753535+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324584",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324584,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1836,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828.1",
      "ID": 1924
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5042,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2292702+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259738",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 259738,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1836,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828.1",
      "ID": 1924
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick",
      "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6224095+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239271",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239271,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1836,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828.1",
      "ID": 1924
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2029,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh",
      "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7295754+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273765",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 273765,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1836,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828.1",
      "ID": 1924
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3758,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6346933+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304139",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 304139,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1836,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828.1",
      "ID": 1924
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4086,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Hume",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8513313+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221751",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221751,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1836,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828.1",
      "ID": 1924
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1773,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9462019+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1882E227P459VM241985",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241985,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1836,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828.1",
      "ID": 1924
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1882,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam",
      "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7888679+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223757",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223757,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1836,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828.1",
      "ID": 1924
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1893,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4724564+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307564",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307564,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1836,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828.1",
      "ID": 1924
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4934,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8349696+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272214",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 272214,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1836,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828.1",
      "ID": 1924
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4956,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Keir",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3199199+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244875",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244875,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1836,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828.1",
      "ID": 1924
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Kelly",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5823639+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315078",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315078,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1836,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828.1",
      "ID": 1924
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3129,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6731264+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2080E36P220VM251089",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251089,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1836,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828.1",
      "ID": 1924
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann",
      "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.2265378+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4016E11P36VM274741",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274741,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1836,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828.1",
      "ID": 1924
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4016,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1197147+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255846",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255846,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1836,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828.1",
      "ID": 1924
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2180,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5595557+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4938E158P374VM277813",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277813,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1836,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828.1",
      "ID": 1924
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4938,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9695247+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2112E250P486VM252965",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252965,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1836,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828.1",
      "ID": 1924
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2112,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny",
      "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7608326+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4939E258P394VM276855",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276855,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1836,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828.1",
      "ID": 1924
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4939,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus",
      "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6840124+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325547",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 325547,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1836,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828.1",
      "ID": 1924
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5074,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon",
      "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5110571+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1828E3P10VM232871",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232871,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1836,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828.1",
      "ID": 1924
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1828,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo",
      "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8801912+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311411",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311411,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1836,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828.1",
      "ID": 1924
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4948,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike",
      "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8776316+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2117E90P107VM230425",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230425,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1836,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828.1",
      "ID": 1924
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2117,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis",
      "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3292619+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267347",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 267347,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1836,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828.1",
      "ID": 1924
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken",
      "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0155394+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313750",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313750,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1836,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828.1",
      "ID": 1924
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4966,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek",
      "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4090596+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3101E102P129VM295094",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295094,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1836,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828.1",
      "ID": 1924
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3101,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala",
      "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1919338+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5034E88P114VM318996",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 318996,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1836,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828.1",
      "ID": 1924
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5034,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny",
      "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.687953+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306408",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306408,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1836,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828.1",
      "ID": 1924
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2159,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Martin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5508033+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5110E252P395VM311183",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311183,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1836,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828.1",
      "ID": 1924
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Mason",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.6092813+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268256",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 268256,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1836,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828.1",
      "ID": 1924
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2133,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2556097+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2876E141P433VM286316",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286316,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1836,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828.1",
      "ID": 1924
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2876,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5735549+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4951E147P368VM260670",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 260670,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1836,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828.1",
      "ID": 1924
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4951,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan",
      "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.0872116+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3896E175P307VM263904",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 263904,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1836,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828.1",
      "ID": 1924
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3896,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam",
      "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9157934+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308456",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 308456,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1836,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828.1",
      "ID": 1924
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0567017+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4964E143P375VM279652",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279652,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1836,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828.1",
      "ID": 1924
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4964,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.51684+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279637",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279637,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1836,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828.1",
      "ID": 1924
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3824,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5161882+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2066E22P91VM261113",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261113,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1836,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828.1",
      "ID": 1924
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2066,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.1123841+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299683",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 299683,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1836,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828.1",
      "ID": 1924
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7082642+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306643",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306643,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1836,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828.1",
      "ID": 1924
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina",
      "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5609201+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2487E146P369VM301151",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 301151,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1836,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828.1",
      "ID": 1924
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2487,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0359826+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223693",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223693,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1836,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828.1",
      "ID": 1924
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4697351+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237443",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237443,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1836,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828.1",
      "ID": 1924
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1961,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David",
      "DisplayName": "David McLetchie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2044377+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305459",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 305459,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1836,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828.1",
      "ID": 1924
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2134,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3249358+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320430",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 320430,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1836,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828.1",
      "ID": 1924
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5041,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan",
      "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1660762+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3763E142P397VM316004",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 316004,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1836,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828.1",
      "ID": 1924
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3763,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart",
      "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9417009+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1986E23P197VM236663",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 236663,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1836,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828.1",
      "ID": 1924
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1986,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan",
      "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9347014+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5047E100P130VM289841",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289841,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1836,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828.1",
      "ID": 1924
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5047,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne",
      "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4613579+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234570",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234570,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1836,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828.1",
      "ID": 1924
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1845,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette",
      "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3899878+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313574",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313574,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1836,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828.1",
      "ID": 1924
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3061,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4012581+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1768E19P265VM289245",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289245,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1836,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828.1",
      "ID": 1924
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1768,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4289235+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225028",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225028,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1836,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828.1",
      "ID": 1924
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1894,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Neil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7414547+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3815E98P134VM270866",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270866,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1836,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828.1",
      "ID": 1924
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3815,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Park, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Park",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8264867+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265857",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265857,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1836,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828.1",
      "ID": 1924
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2010,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil",
      "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4635561+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283341",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283341,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1836,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828.1",
      "ID": 1924
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5057,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.6965231+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2853E33P128VM251448",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251448,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1836,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828.1",
      "ID": 1924
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Pentland",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4640551+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317650",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317650,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1836,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828.1",
      "ID": 1924
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5009,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.43153+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254687",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254687,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1836,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828.1",
      "ID": 1924
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3745,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis",
      "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2673366+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1870E225P478VM295687",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295687,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1836,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828.1",
      "ID": 1924
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1870,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona",
      "DisplayName": "Shona Robison",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5315454+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2135E254P450VM234892",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234892,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1836,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828.1",
      "ID": 1924
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2135,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Russell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.404244+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1895E232P431VM257598",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257598,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1836,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828.1",
      "ID": 1924
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1895,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0634196+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228132",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 228132,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1836,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828.1",
      "ID": 1924
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1839,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5857319+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2345E10P55VM291653",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291653,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1836,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828.1",
      "ID": 1924
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2345,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1365467+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311047",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311047,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1836,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828.1",
      "ID": 1924
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2223,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish",
      "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.6031341+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246352",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 246352,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1836,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828.1",
      "ID": 1924
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2182,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1250276+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298133",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298133,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1836,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828.1",
      "ID": 1924
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5079,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew",
      "DisplayName": "Drew Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1396421+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234319",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234319,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1836,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828.1",
      "ID": 1924
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1769,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3721526+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274562",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274562,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1836,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828.1",
      "ID": 1924
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4014,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz",
      "DisplayName": "Liz Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1119783+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269514",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269514,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1836,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828.1",
      "ID": 1924
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2215,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5509208+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317389",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317389,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1836,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828.1",
      "ID": 1924
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3806,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.42001+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326283",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 326283,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1836,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828.1",
      "ID": 1924
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5106,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin",
      "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.751776+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241144",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241144,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1836,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828.1",
      "ID": 1924
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1848,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola",
      "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.403933+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2098E237P531VM289652",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289652,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1836,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828.1",
      "ID": 1924
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2098,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Swinney",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4531969+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2674E247P401VM247766",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247766,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1836,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828.1",
      "ID": 1924
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2674,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave",
      "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4274959+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5075E234P371VM284883",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 284883,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1836,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828.1",
      "ID": 1924
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5075,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Torrance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0518162+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1793E151P362VM222429",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 222429,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1836,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828.1",
      "ID": 1924
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1793,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean",
      "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.188572+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5078E245P366VM307062",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307062,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1836,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828.1",
      "ID": 1924
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5078,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Walker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5856381+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1841E231P426VM239979",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239979,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1836,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828.1",
      "ID": 1924
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1841,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen",
      "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.767538+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283392",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283392,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1836,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828.1",
      "ID": 1924
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4952,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.6987317+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1865E263P500VM232217",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232217,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1836,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828.1",
      "ID": 1924
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1865,
      "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra",
      "DisplayName": "Sandra White",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8451753+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237787",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237787,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1836,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828.1",
      "ID": 1924
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2610,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Wilson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2260954+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309274",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 309274,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1836,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828.1",
      "ID": 1924
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4941,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza",
      "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3222524+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252643",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252643,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1837,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828",
      "ID": 1903
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1926,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian",
      "DisplayName": "Brian Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7382956+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2615E213P388VM258887",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258887,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1837,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828",
      "ID": 1903
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2615,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George",
      "DisplayName": "George Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.332495+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319853",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319853,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1837,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828",
      "ID": 1903
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4940,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare",
      "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9442158+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249620",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 249620,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1837,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828",
      "ID": 1903
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2641,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair",
      "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9425691+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1783E21P273VM227748",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227748,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1837,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828",
      "ID": 1903
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1783,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie",
      "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5639354+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2633E97P136VM280750",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280750,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1837,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828",
      "ID": 1903
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2633,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire",
      "DisplayName": "Claire Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.780827+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262697",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262697,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1837,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828",
      "ID": 1903
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2603,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6129867+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1759E91P115VM229782",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229782,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1837,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828",
      "ID": 1903
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia",
      "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0968145+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270140",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270140,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1837,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828",
      "ID": 1903
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3751,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5832662+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322713",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 322713,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1837,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828",
      "ID": 1903
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5109,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco",
      "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.700473+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5060E86P124VM294772",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 294772,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1837,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828",
      "ID": 1903
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5060,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1776651+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242900",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242900,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1837,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828",
      "ID": 1903
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1866,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah",
      "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.04039+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235598",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235598,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1837,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828",
      "ID": 1903
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1943,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic",
      "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.684669+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302347",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 302347,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1837,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828",
      "ID": 1903
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2595,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin",
      "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5204845+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244306",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244306,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1837,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828",
      "ID": 1903
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2103,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith",
      "DisplayName": "Keith Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5489878+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327215",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 327215,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1837,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828",
      "ID": 1903
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:46.0261634+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277036",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277036,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1837,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828",
      "ID": 1903
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6983131+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264293",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264293,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1837,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828",
      "ID": 1903
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2673,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick",
      "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1270365+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248782",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248782,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1837,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828",
      "ID": 1903
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2678,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson",
      "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6698162+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2123E27P233VM295783",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295783,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1837,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828",
      "ID": 1903
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2123,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm",
      "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5357033+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285201",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285201,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1837,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828",
      "ID": 1903
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3907,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3124909+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230678",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230678,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1837,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828",
      "ID": 1903
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1735,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela",
      "DisplayName": "Angela Constance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3405063+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243819",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 243819,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1837,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828",
      "ID": 1903
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1932,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce",
      "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3210869+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254899",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254899,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1837,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828",
      "ID": 1903
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1863,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna",
      "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2885797+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323822",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 323822,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1837,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828",
      "ID": 1903
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4976,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth",
      "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9734342+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5107E223P379VM291299",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291299,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1837,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828",
      "ID": 1903
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5107,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1129619+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3743E222P391VM265373",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265373,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1837,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828",
      "ID": 1903
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3743,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel",
      "DisplayName": "Nigel Don",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.436395+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262287",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262287,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1837,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828",
      "ID": 1903
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3771,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob",
      "DisplayName": "Bob Doris",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.595001+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281991",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 281991,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1837,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828",
      "ID": 1903
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2826,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Dornan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1664944+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3812E94P117VM297981",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 297981,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1837,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828",
      "ID": 1903
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3812,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia",
      "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1331901+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231255",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231255,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1837,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828",
      "ID": 1903
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1778,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen",
      "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.587087+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4955E240P389VM285904",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285904,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1837,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828",
      "ID": 1903
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4955,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3495472+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219381",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 219381,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1837,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828",
      "ID": 1903
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1742,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle",
      "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.2961888+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238625",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 238625,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1837,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828",
      "ID": 1903
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1994,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus",
      "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4621441+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225426",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225426,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1837,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828",
      "ID": 1903
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1814,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda",
      "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9742149+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321746",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 321746,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1837,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828",
      "ID": 1903
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Fee",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4496334+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292872",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 292872,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1837,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828",
      "ID": 1903
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia",
      "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5617044+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1892E12P64VM226951",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 226951,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1837,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828",
      "ID": 1903
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2604922+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5054E95P118VM312707",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 312707,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1837,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828",
      "ID": 1903
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5054,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1398796+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4947E152P361VM257199",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257199,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1837,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828",
      "ID": 1903
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4947,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Finnie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0457725+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271259",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271259,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1837,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828",
      "ID": 1903
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3901,
      "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe",
      "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0625734+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278436",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 278436,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1837,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828",
      "ID": 1903
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2394,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo",
      "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2187326+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2110E220P414VM287242",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 287242,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1837,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828",
      "ID": 1903
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth",
      "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8557446+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250477",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250477,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1837,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828",
      "ID": 1903
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2675,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob",
      "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1912235+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1741E10P50VM220945",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220945,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1837,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828",
      "ID": 1903
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1741,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel",
      "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6684107+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220262",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220262,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1837,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828",
      "ID": 1903
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1756,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine",
      "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6308424+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1860E104P150VM252367",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252367,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1837,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828",
      "ID": 1903
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1860,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda",
      "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7261214+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2033E20P141VM266123",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 266123,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1837,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828",
      "ID": 1903
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2033,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain",
      "DisplayName": "Iain Gray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4753132+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324583",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324583,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1837,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828",
      "ID": 1903
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5042,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2292126+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259729",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 259729,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1837,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828",
      "ID": 1903
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick",
      "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6220181+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239272",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239272,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1837,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828",
      "ID": 1903
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2029,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh",
      "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7296362+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273764",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 273764,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1837,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828",
      "ID": 1903
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3758,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6346529+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304138",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 304138,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1837,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828",
      "ID": 1903
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4086,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Hume",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8512912+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221750",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221750,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1837,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828",
      "ID": 1903
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1773,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9461616+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1882E227P459VM241984",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241984,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1837,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828",
      "ID": 1903
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1882,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam",
      "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7888089+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223756",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223756,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1837,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828",
      "ID": 1903
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1893,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.472416+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307565",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307565,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1837,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828",
      "ID": 1903
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4934,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8350115+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272215",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 272215,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1837,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828",
      "ID": 1903
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4956,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Keir",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3199861+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244909",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244909,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1837,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828",
      "ID": 1903
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Kelly",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5838031+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315079",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315079,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1837,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828",
      "ID": 1903
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3129,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6731668+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2080E36P220VM251088",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251088,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1837,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828",
      "ID": 1903
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann",
      "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.2264962+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4016E11P36VM274826",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274826,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1837,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828",
      "ID": 1903
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4016,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1234222+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255761",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255761,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1837,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828",
      "ID": 1903
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2180,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5557467+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4938E158P374VM277419",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277419,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1837,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828",
      "ID": 1903
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4938,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9525721+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2112E250P486VM252966",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252966,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1837,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828",
      "ID": 1903
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2112,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny",
      "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7608909+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4939E258P394VM276804",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276804,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1837,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828",
      "ID": 1903
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4939,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus",
      "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6818008+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325548",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 325548,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1837,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828",
      "ID": 1903
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5074,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon",
      "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5110978+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1828E3P10VM232872",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232872,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1837,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828",
      "ID": 1903
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1828,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo",
      "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8802521+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311412",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311412,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1837,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828",
      "ID": 1903
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4948,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike",
      "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8776739+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2117E90P107VM230416",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230416,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1837,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828",
      "ID": 1903
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2117,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis",
      "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3288682+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267348",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 267348,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1837,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828",
      "ID": 1903
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken",
      "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0155817+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313749",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313749,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1837,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828",
      "ID": 1903
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4966,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek",
      "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4090194+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3101E102P129VM295093",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295093,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1837,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828",
      "ID": 1903
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3101,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala",
      "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1918934+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5034E88P114VM318995",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 318995,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1837,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828",
      "ID": 1903
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5034,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny",
      "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6879124+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306407",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306407,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1837,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828",
      "ID": 1903
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2159,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Martin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5507622+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5110E252P395VM311182",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311182,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1837,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828",
      "ID": 1903
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Mason",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.6092409+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268255",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 268255,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1837,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828",
      "ID": 1903
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2133,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2555487+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2876E141P433VM286317",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286317,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1837,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828",
      "ID": 1903
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2876,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5735965+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4951E147P368VM260669",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 260669,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1837,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828",
      "ID": 1903
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4951,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan",
      "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.0871708+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3896E175P307VM263852",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 263852,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1837,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828",
      "ID": 1903
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3896,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam",
      "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9133213+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308457",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 308457,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1837,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828",
      "ID": 1903
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0567425+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4964E143P375VM279698",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279698,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1837,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828",
      "ID": 1903
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4964,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5188246+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279636",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279636,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1837,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828",
      "ID": 1903
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3824,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5161482+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2066E22P91VM261079",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261079,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1837,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828",
      "ID": 1903
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2066,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.1109086+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299682",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 299682,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1837,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828",
      "ID": 1903
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7082224+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306644",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306644,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1837,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828",
      "ID": 1903
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina",
      "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5609611+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2487E146P369VM301150",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 301150,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1837,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828",
      "ID": 1903
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2487,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0359143+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223694",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223694,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1837,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828",
      "ID": 1903
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4697753+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237444",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237444,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1837,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828",
      "ID": 1903
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1961,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David",
      "DisplayName": "David McLetchie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2044785+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305460",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 305460,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1837,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828",
      "ID": 1903
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2134,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3249763+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320431",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 320431,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1837,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828",
      "ID": 1903
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5041,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan",
      "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1661168+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3763E142P397VM316003",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 316003,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1837,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828",
      "ID": 1903
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3763,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart",
      "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9416584+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1986E23P197VM236664",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 236664,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1837,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828",
      "ID": 1903
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1986,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan",
      "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9347604+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5047E100P130VM289840",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289840,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1837,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828",
      "ID": 1903
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5047,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne",
      "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4613162+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234569",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234569,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1837,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828",
      "ID": 1903
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1845,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette",
      "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3899467+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313573",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313573,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1837,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828",
      "ID": 1903
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3061,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4012174+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1768E19P265VM289246",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289246,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1837,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828",
      "ID": 1903
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1768,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4289645+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225029",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225029,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1837,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828",
      "ID": 1903
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1894,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Neil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7414952+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3815E98P134VM270930",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270930,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1837,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828",
      "ID": 1903
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3815,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Park, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Park",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8352058+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265856",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265856,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1837,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828",
      "ID": 1903
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2010,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil",
      "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4635132+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283290",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283290,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1837,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828",
      "ID": 1903
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5057,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.694096+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2853E33P128VM251457",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251457,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1837,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828",
      "ID": 1903
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Pentland",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.464476+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317651",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317651,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1837,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828",
      "ID": 1903
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5009,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4315701+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254686",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254686,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1837,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828",
      "ID": 1903
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3745,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis",
      "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2672935+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1870E225P478VM295688",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295688,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1837,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828",
      "ID": 1903
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1870,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona",
      "DisplayName": "Shona Robison",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5315855+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2135E254P450VM234901",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234901,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1837,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828",
      "ID": 1903
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2135,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Russell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4046343+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1895E232P431VM257599",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257599,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1837,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828",
      "ID": 1903
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1895,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0634605+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228133",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 228133,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1837,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828",
      "ID": 1903
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1839,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5857721+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2345E10P55VM291652",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291652,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1837,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828",
      "ID": 1903
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2345,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1365054+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311048",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311048,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1837,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828",
      "ID": 1903
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2223,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish",
      "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.6031746+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246353",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 246353,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1837,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828",
      "ID": 1903
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2182,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1250691+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298132",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298132,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1837,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828",
      "ID": 1903
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5079,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew",
      "DisplayName": "Drew Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1396017+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234318",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234318,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1837,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828",
      "ID": 1903
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1769,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3721108+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274613",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274613,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1837,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828",
      "ID": 1903
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4014,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz",
      "DisplayName": "Liz Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1141736+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269515",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269515,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1837,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828",
      "ID": 1903
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2215,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5509622+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317390",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317390,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1837,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828",
      "ID": 1903
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3806,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4200502+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326282",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 326282,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1837,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828",
      "ID": 1903
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5106,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin",
      "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7517346+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241145",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241145,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1837,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828",
      "ID": 1903
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1848,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola",
      "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.4039737+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2098E237P531VM289653",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289653,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1837,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828",
      "ID": 1903
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2098,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Swinney",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4532368+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2674E247P401VM247775",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247775,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1837,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828",
      "ID": 1903
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2674,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave",
      "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4279023+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5075E234P371VM287420",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 287420,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1837,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828",
      "ID": 1903
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5075,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Torrance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.863448+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1793E151P362VM222430",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 222430,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1837,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828",
      "ID": 1903
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1793,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean",
      "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1886131+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5078E245P366VM307061",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307061,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1837,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828",
      "ID": 1903
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5078,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Walker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5855977+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1841E231P426VM239978",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239978,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1837,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828",
      "ID": 1903
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1841,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen",
      "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7674969+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283477",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283477,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1837,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828",
      "ID": 1903
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4952,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7096016+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1865E263P500VM232216",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232216,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1837,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828",
      "ID": 1903
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1865,
      "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra",
      "DisplayName": "Sandra White",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8451335+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237778",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237778,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1837,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828",
      "ID": 1903
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2610,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Wilson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2257153+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309273",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 309273,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1837,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 54,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Supporting Families",
      "Reference": "S4M-01828",
      "ID": 1903
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4941,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza",
      "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3222121+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252640",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252640,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1839,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824.4",
      "ID": 1921
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1926,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian",
      "DisplayName": "Brian Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7381727+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2615E213P388VM257563",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257563,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1839,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824.4",
      "ID": 1921
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2615,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George",
      "DisplayName": "George Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0619241+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319927",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319927,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1839,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824.4",
      "ID": 1921
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4940,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare",
      "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9474021+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249623",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 249623,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1839,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824.4",
      "ID": 1921
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2641,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair",
      "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9426958+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1783E21P273VM227745",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227745,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1839,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824.4",
      "ID": 1921
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1783,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie",
      "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5638109+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2633E97P136VM280747",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280747,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1839,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824.4",
      "ID": 1921
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2633,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire",
      "DisplayName": "Claire Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7807074+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262694",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262694,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1839,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824.4",
      "ID": 1921
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2603,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6128654+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1759E91P115VM229236",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229236,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1839,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824.4",
      "ID": 1921
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia",
      "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0679339+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270229",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270229,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1839,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824.4",
      "ID": 1921
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3751,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.7949092+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322710",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 322710,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1839,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824.4",
      "ID": 1921
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5109,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco",
      "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.7003528+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5060E86P124VM294769",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 294769,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1839,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824.4",
      "ID": 1921
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5060,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1775393+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242827",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242827,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1839,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824.4",
      "ID": 1921
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1866,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah",
      "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.037315+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235601",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235601,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1839,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824.4",
      "ID": 1921
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1943,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic",
      "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6848073+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302103",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 302103,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1839,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824.4",
      "ID": 1921
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2595,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin",
      "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.2971822+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244309",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244309,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1839,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824.4",
      "ID": 1921
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2103,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith",
      "DisplayName": "Keith Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5491148+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327362",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 327362,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1839,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824.4",
      "ID": 1921
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:46.0326898+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277033",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277033,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1839,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824.4",
      "ID": 1921
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6981915+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264296",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264296,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1839,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824.4",
      "ID": 1921
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2673,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick",
      "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1271756+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248793",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248793,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1839,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824.4",
      "ID": 1921
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2678,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson",
      "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6703048+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2123E27P233VM295858",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295858,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1839,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824.4",
      "ID": 1921
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2123,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm",
      "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5388662+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285198",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285198,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1839,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824.4",
      "ID": 1921
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3907,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.312324+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230675",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230675,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1839,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824.4",
      "ID": 1921
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1735,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela",
      "DisplayName": "Angela Constance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3403812+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243893",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 243893,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1839,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824.4",
      "ID": 1921
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1932,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce",
      "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3244262+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1863E238P523VM255291",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255291,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1839,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824.4",
      "ID": 1921
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1863,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna",
      "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5245921+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323997",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 323997,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1839,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824.4",
      "ID": 1921
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4976,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth",
      "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9815478+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5107E223P379VM291352",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291352,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1839,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824.4",
      "ID": 1921
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5107,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1155958+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3743E222P391VM265370",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265370,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1839,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824.4",
      "ID": 1921
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3743,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel",
      "DisplayName": "Nigel Don",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4362498+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262232",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262232,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1839,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824.4",
      "ID": 1921
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3771,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob",
      "DisplayName": "Bob Doris",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.5926384+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281994",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 281994,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1839,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824.4",
      "ID": 1921
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2826,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Dornan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1666368+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3812E94P117VM297978",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 297978,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1839,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824.4",
      "ID": 1921
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3812,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia",
      "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1330688+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231647",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231647,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1839,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824.4",
      "ID": 1921
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1778,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen",
      "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6095818+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4955E240P389VM286147",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286147,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1839,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824.4",
      "ID": 1921
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4955,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3659149+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219371",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 219371,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1839,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824.4",
      "ID": 1921
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1742,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle",
      "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.2957432+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238628",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 238628,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1839,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824.4",
      "ID": 1921
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1994,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus",
      "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.462286+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225429",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225429,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1839,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824.4",
      "ID": 1921
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1814,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda",
      "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9743561+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321749",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 321749,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1839,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824.4",
      "ID": 1921
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Fee",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4497537+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292875",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 292875,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1839,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824.4",
      "ID": 1921
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia",
      "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5618242+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1892E12P64VM226940",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 226940,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1839,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824.4",
      "ID": 1921
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2535269+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5054E95P118VM312619",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 312619,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1839,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824.4",
      "ID": 1921
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5054,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1361152+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4947E152P361VM257196",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257196,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1839,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824.4",
      "ID": 1921
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4947,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Finnie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0456129+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271347",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271347,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1839,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824.4",
      "ID": 1921
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3901,
      "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe",
      "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0716539+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278439",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 278439,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1839,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824.4",
      "ID": 1921
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2394,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo",
      "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2188566+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2110E220P414VM286692",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286692,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1839,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824.4",
      "ID": 1921
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth",
      "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5966689+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250474",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250474,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1839,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824.4",
      "ID": 1921
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2675,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob",
      "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.191101+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1741E10P50VM220942",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220942,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1839,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824.4",
      "ID": 1921
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1741,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel",
      "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6682876+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220273",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220273,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1839,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824.4",
      "ID": 1921
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1756,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine",
      "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6313229+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1860E104P150VM251822",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251822,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1839,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824.4",
      "ID": 1921
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1860,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda",
      "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4906265+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2033E20P141VM266126",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 266126,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1839,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824.4",
      "ID": 1921
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2033,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain",
      "DisplayName": "Iain Gray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4754639+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324436",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324436,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1839,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824.4",
      "ID": 1921
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5042,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2225728+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259895",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 259895,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1839,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824.4",
      "ID": 1921
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick",
      "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.634659+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239269",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239269,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1839,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824.4",
      "ID": 1921
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2029,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh",
      "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7294862+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273767",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 273767,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1839,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824.4",
      "ID": 1921
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3758,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6347923+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304226",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 304226,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1839,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824.4",
      "ID": 1921
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4086,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Hume",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.0291512+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221753",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221753,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1839,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824.4",
      "ID": 1921
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1773,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.946311+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1882E227P459VM241987",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241987,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1839,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824.4",
      "ID": 1921
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1882,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam",
      "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7889512+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223759",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223759,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1839,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824.4",
      "ID": 1921
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1893,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4725367+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307562",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307562,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1839,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824.4",
      "ID": 1921
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4934,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.834869+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272212",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 272212,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1839,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824.4",
      "ID": 1921
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4956,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Keir",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3198372+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244833",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244833,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1839,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824.4",
      "ID": 1921
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Kelly",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5805833+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315005",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315005,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1839,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824.4",
      "ID": 1921
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3129,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6699788+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2080E36P220VM251091",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251091,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1839,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824.4",
      "ID": 1921
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann",
      "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.2266187+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4016E11P36VM274739",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274739,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1839,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824.4",
      "ID": 1921
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4016,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1196236+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255848",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255848,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1839,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824.4",
      "ID": 1921
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2180,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5596343+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4938E158P374VM277815",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277815,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1839,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824.4",
      "ID": 1921
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4938,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.969611+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2112E250P486VM252963",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252963,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1839,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824.4",
      "ID": 1921
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2112,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny",
      "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7607523+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4939E258P394VM276857",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276857,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1839,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824.4",
      "ID": 1921
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4939,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus",
      "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6840933+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325695",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 325695,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1839,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824.4",
      "ID": 1921
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5074,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon",
      "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5173193+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1828E3P10VM232479",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232479,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1839,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824.4",
      "ID": 1921
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1828,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo",
      "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8626103+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311409",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311409,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1839,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824.4",
      "ID": 1921
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4948,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike",
      "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8775475+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2117E90P107VM230427",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230427,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1839,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824.4",
      "ID": 1921
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2117,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis",
      "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3293431+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267345",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 267345,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1839,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824.4",
      "ID": 1921
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken",
      "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0154351+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313752",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313752,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1839,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824.4",
      "ID": 1921
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4966,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek",
      "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4091402+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3101E102P129VM295404",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295404,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1839,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824.4",
      "ID": 1921
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3101,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala",
      "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5107234+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5034E88P114VM318998",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 318998,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1839,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824.4",
      "ID": 1921
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5034,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny",
      "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6880335+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306482",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306482,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1839,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824.4",
      "ID": 1921
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2159,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Martin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5539703+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5110E252P395VM311185",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311185,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1839,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824.4",
      "ID": 1921
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Mason",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.6093618+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268258",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 268258,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1839,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824.4",
      "ID": 1921
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2133,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2556921+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2876E141P433VM286314",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286314,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1839,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824.4",
      "ID": 1921
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2876,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5734732+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4951E147P368VM260672",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 260672,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1839,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824.4",
      "ID": 1921
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4951,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan",
      "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.0872932+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3896E175P307VM263906",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 263906,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1839,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824.4",
      "ID": 1921
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3896,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam",
      "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9158738+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308454",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 308454,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1839,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824.4",
      "ID": 1921
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0566202+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4964E143P375VM279650",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279650,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1839,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824.4",
      "ID": 1921
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4964,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5167399+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279639",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279639,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1839,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824.4",
      "ID": 1921
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3824,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5162688+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2066E22P91VM261774",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261774,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1839,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824.4",
      "ID": 1921
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2066,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3722426+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299685",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 299685,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1839,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824.4",
      "ID": 1921
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7083452+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306641",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306641,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1839,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824.4",
      "ID": 1921
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina",
      "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5608356+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2487E146P369VM301153",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 301153,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1839,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824.4",
      "ID": 1921
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2487,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0360875+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223691",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223691,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1839,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824.4",
      "ID": 1921
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4696555+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237441",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237441,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1839,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824.4",
      "ID": 1921
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1961,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David",
      "DisplayName": "David McLetchie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2043532+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2134E34P201VM297832",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 297832,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1839,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824.4",
      "ID": 1921
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2134,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1269183+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320428",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 320428,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1839,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824.4",
      "ID": 1921
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5041,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan",
      "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.165994+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3763E142P397VM316077",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 316077,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1839,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824.4",
      "ID": 1921
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3763,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart",
      "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9451609+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1986E23P197VM236661",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 236661,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1839,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824.4",
      "ID": 1921
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1986,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan",
      "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9346187+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5047E100P130VM289843",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289843,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1839,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824.4",
      "ID": 1921
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5047,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne",
      "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4614377+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234960",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234960,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1839,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824.4",
      "ID": 1921
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1845,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette",
      "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4072977+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313647",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313647,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1839,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824.4",
      "ID": 1921
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3061,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4044072+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1768E19P265VM289243",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289243,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1839,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824.4",
      "ID": 1921
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1768,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4288418+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225026",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225026,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1839,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824.4",
      "ID": 1921
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1894,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Neil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.741354+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3815E98P134VM270864",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270864,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1839,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824.4",
      "ID": 1921
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3815,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Park, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Park",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8264044+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265939",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265939,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1839,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824.4",
      "ID": 1921
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2010,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil",
      "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4670778+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283343",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283343,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1839,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824.4",
      "ID": 1921
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5057,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.6966044+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2853E33P128VM251446",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251446,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1839,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824.4",
      "ID": 1921
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Pentland",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4639675+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317648",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317648,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1839,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824.4",
      "ID": 1921
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5009,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4314497+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254689",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254689,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1839,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824.4",
      "ID": 1921
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3745,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis",
      "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2674183+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1870E225P478VM295685",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295685,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1839,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824.4",
      "ID": 1921
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1870,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona",
      "DisplayName": "Shona Robison",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5314655+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2135E254P450VM234890",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234890,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1839,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824.4",
      "ID": 1921
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2135,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Russell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4041615+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1895E232P431VM257361",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257361,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1839,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824.4",
      "ID": 1921
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1895,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0528802+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228130",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 228130,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1839,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824.4",
      "ID": 1921
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1839,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5856499+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2345E10P55VM292048",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 292048,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1839,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824.4",
      "ID": 1921
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2345,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.153688+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2223E176P333VM310662",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 310662,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1839,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824.4",
      "ID": 1921
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2223,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish",
      "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5806521+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246350",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 246350,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1839,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824.4",
      "ID": 1921
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2182,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1249453+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298135",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298135,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1839,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824.4",
      "ID": 1921
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5079,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew",
      "DisplayName": "Drew Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.139723+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234321",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234321,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1839,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824.4",
      "ID": 1921
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1769,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3722341+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274560",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274560,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1839,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824.4",
      "ID": 1921
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4014,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz",
      "DisplayName": "Liz Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1118757+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269512",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269512,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1839,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824.4",
      "ID": 1921
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2215,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5508375+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317163",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317163,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1839,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824.4",
      "ID": 1921
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3806,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.1844012+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326135",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 326135,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1839,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824.4",
      "ID": 1921
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5106,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin",
      "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5413777+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241142",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241142,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1839,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824.4",
      "ID": 1921
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1848,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola",
      "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.4038506+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2098E237P531VM289578",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289578,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1839,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824.4",
      "ID": 1921
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2098,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Swinney",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4500901+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2674E247P401VM247764",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247764,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1839,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824.4",
      "ID": 1921
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2674,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave",
      "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4273936+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5075E234P371VM284881",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 284881,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1839,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824.4",
      "ID": 1921
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5075,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Torrance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0517173+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1793E151P362VM222427",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 222427,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1839,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824.4",
      "ID": 1921
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1793,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean",
      "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1884908+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5078E245P366VM307064",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307064,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1839,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824.4",
      "ID": 1921
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5078,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Walker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5857187+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1841E231P426VM239981",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239981,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1839,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824.4",
      "ID": 1921
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1841,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen",
      "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7676184+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283390",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283390,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1839,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824.4",
      "ID": 1921
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4952,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.6986483+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1865E263P500VM232219",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232219,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1839,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824.4",
      "ID": 1921
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1865,
      "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra",
      "DisplayName": "Sandra White",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8452591+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237789",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237789,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1839,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824.4",
      "ID": 1921
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2610,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Wilson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.226176+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309276",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 309276,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1839,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824.4",
      "ID": 1921
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4941,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza",
      "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.322352+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252641",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252641,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1835,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824",
      "ID": 1899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1926,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian",
      "DisplayName": "Brian Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7382139+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2615E213P388VM257564",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257564,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1835,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824",
      "ID": 1899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2615,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George",
      "DisplayName": "George Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0619643+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319926",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319926,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1835,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824",
      "ID": 1899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4940,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare",
      "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9473591+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249622",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 249622,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1835,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824",
      "ID": 1899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2641,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair",
      "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9426547+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1783E21P273VM227746",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227746,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1835,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824",
      "ID": 1899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1783,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie",
      "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5638506+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2633E97P136VM280748",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280748,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1835,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824",
      "ID": 1899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2633,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire",
      "DisplayName": "Claire Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7807471+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262695",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262695,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1835,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824",
      "ID": 1899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2603,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6129062+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1759E91P115VM229780",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229780,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1835,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824",
      "ID": 1899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia",
      "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.096733+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270228",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270228,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1835,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824",
      "ID": 1899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3751,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.7948672+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322711",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 322711,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1835,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824",
      "ID": 1899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5109,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco",
      "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.7003938+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5060E86P124VM294770",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 294770,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1835,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824",
      "ID": 1899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5060,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1775819+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242828",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242828,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1835,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824",
      "ID": 1899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1866,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah",
      "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0373554+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235600",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235600,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1835,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824",
      "ID": 1899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1943,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic",
      "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6847481+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302345",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 302345,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1835,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824",
      "ID": 1899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2595,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin",
      "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5204012+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244308",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244308,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1835,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824",
      "ID": 1899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2103,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith",
      "DisplayName": "Keith Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5490724+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327363",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 327363,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1835,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824",
      "ID": 1899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:46.0327308+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277034",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277034,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1835,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824",
      "ID": 1899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6982324+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264295",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264295,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1835,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824",
      "ID": 1899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2673,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick",
      "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1271169+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248792",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248792,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1835,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824",
      "ID": 1899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2678,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson",
      "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6702462+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2123E27P233VM295857",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295857,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1835,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824",
      "ID": 1899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2123,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm",
      "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.538826+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285199",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285199,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1835,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824",
      "ID": 1899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3907,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3123817+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230676",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230676,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1835,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824",
      "ID": 1899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1735,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela",
      "DisplayName": "Angela Constance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3404225+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243892",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 243892,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1835,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824",
      "ID": 1899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1932,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce",
      "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3243852+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254901",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254901,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1835,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824",
      "ID": 1899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1863,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna",
      "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2886629+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323998",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 323998,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1835,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824",
      "ID": 1899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4976,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth",
      "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9815893+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5107E223P379VM291351",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291351,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1835,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824",
      "ID": 1899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5107,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1155526+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3743E222P391VM265371",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265371,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1835,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824",
      "ID": 1899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3743,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel",
      "DisplayName": "Nigel Don",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4363106+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262233",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262233,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1835,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824",
      "ID": 1899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3771,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob",
      "DisplayName": "Bob Doris",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.5926809+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281993",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 281993,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1835,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824",
      "ID": 1899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2826,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Dornan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1665957+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3812E94P117VM297979",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 297979,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1835,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824",
      "ID": 1899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3812,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia",
      "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1331088+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231257",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231257,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1835,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824",
      "ID": 1899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1778,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen",
      "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.5871689+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4955E240P389VM286146",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286146,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1835,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824",
      "ID": 1899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4955,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3658738+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219372",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 219372,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1835,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824",
      "ID": 1899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1742,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle",
      "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.295785+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238627",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 238627,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1835,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824",
      "ID": 1899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1994,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus",
      "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4622467+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225428",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225428,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1835,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824",
      "ID": 1899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1814,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda",
      "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9742961+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321748",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 321748,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1835,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824",
      "ID": 1899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Fee",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4497139+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292874",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 292874,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1835,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824",
      "ID": 1899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia",
      "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5617841+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1892E12P64VM226941",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 226941,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1835,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824",
      "ID": 1899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2535891+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5054E95P118VM312705",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 312705,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1835,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824",
      "ID": 1899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5054,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.139798+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4947E152P361VM257197",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257197,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1835,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824",
      "ID": 1899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4947,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Finnie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0456672+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271346",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271346,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1835,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824",
      "ID": 1899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3901,
      "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe",
      "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0716128+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278438",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 278438,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1835,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824",
      "ID": 1899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2394,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo",
      "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2188151+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2110E220P414VM287240",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 287240,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1835,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824",
      "ID": 1899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth",
      "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8556634+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250475",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250475,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1835,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824",
      "ID": 1899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2675,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob",
      "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1911414+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1741E10P50VM220943",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220943,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1835,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824",
      "ID": 1899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1741,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel",
      "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6683283+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220272",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220272,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1835,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824",
      "ID": 1899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1756,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine",
      "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6312815+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1860E104P150VM252365",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252365,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1835,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824",
      "ID": 1899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1860,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda",
      "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7260394+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2033E20P141VM266125",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 266125,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1835,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824",
      "ID": 1899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2033,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain",
      "DisplayName": "Iain Gray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4754206+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324435",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324435,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1835,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824",
      "ID": 1899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5042,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2225331+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259894",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 259894,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1835,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824",
      "ID": 1899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick",
      "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6346183+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239270",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239270,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1835,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824",
      "ID": 1899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2029,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh",
      "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7295266+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273766",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 273766,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1835,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824",
      "ID": 1899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3758,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.634751+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304140",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 304140,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1835,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824",
      "ID": 1899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4086,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Hume",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8513711+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221752",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221752,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1835,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824",
      "ID": 1899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1773,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9462705+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1882E227P459VM241986",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241986,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1835,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824",
      "ID": 1899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1882,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam",
      "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7889108+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223758",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223758,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1835,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824",
      "ID": 1899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1893,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4724963+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307563",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307563,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1835,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824",
      "ID": 1899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4934,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8349108+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272213",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 272213,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1835,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824",
      "ID": 1899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4956,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Keir",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3198786+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244834",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244834,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1835,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824",
      "ID": 1899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Kelly",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5806234+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315006",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315006,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1835,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824",
      "ID": 1899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3129,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6700191+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2080E36P220VM251090",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251090,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1835,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824",
      "ID": 1899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann",
      "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.2265781+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4016E11P36VM274740",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274740,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1835,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824",
      "ID": 1899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4016,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1196736+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255847",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255847,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1835,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824",
      "ID": 1899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2180,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.559595+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4938E158P374VM277814",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277814,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1835,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824",
      "ID": 1899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4938,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9695702+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2112E250P486VM252964",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252964,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1835,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824",
      "ID": 1899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2112,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny",
      "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7607928+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4939E258P394VM276856",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276856,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1835,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824",
      "ID": 1899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4939,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus",
      "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6840527+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325696",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 325696,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1835,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824",
      "ID": 1899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5074,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon",
      "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5173604+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1828E3P10VM232870",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232870,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1835,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824",
      "ID": 1899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1828,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo",
      "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8801503+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311410",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311410,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1835,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824",
      "ID": 1899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4948,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike",
      "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8775898+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2117E90P107VM230426",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230426,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1835,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824",
      "ID": 1899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2117,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis",
      "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3293026+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267346",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 267346,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1835,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824",
      "ID": 1899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken",
      "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0154762+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313751",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313751,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1835,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824",
      "ID": 1899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4966,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek",
      "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4091006+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3101E102P129VM295403",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295403,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1835,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824",
      "ID": 1899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3101,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala",
      "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5106822+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5034E88P114VM318997",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 318997,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1835,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824",
      "ID": 1899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5034,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny",
      "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6879934+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306481",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306481,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1835,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824",
      "ID": 1899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2159,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Martin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.55393+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5110E252P395VM311184",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311184,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1835,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824",
      "ID": 1899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Mason",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.6093219+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268257",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 268257,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1835,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824",
      "ID": 1899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2133,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2556516+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2876E141P433VM286315",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286315,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1835,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824",
      "ID": 1899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2876,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5735141+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4951E147P368VM260671",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 260671,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1835,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824",
      "ID": 1899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4951,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan",
      "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.0872521+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3896E175P307VM263905",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 263905,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1835,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824",
      "ID": 1899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3896,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam",
      "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9158335+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308455",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 308455,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1835,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824",
      "ID": 1899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0566612+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4964E143P375VM279651",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279651,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1835,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824",
      "ID": 1899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4964,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5167979+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279638",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279638,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1835,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824",
      "ID": 1899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3824,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5162283+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2066E22P91VM261773",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261773,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1835,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824",
      "ID": 1899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2066,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3722018+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299684",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 299684,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1835,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824",
      "ID": 1899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7083052+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306642",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306642,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1835,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824",
      "ID": 1899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina",
      "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5608786+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2487E146P369VM301152",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 301152,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1835,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824",
      "ID": 1899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2487,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0360353+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223692",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223692,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1835,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824",
      "ID": 1899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4696955+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237442",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237442,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1835,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824",
      "ID": 1899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1961,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David",
      "DisplayName": "David McLetchie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2043964+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2134E34P201VM297833",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 297833,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1835,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824",
      "ID": 1899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2134,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1269771+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320429",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 320429,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1835,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824",
      "ID": 1899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5041,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan",
      "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1660353+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3763E142P397VM316076",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 316076,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1835,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824",
      "ID": 1899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3763,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart",
      "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9451206+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1986E23P197VM236662",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 236662,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1835,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824",
      "ID": 1899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1986,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan",
      "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9346591+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5047E100P130VM289842",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289842,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1835,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824",
      "ID": 1899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5047,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne",
      "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4613971+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234571",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234571,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1835,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824",
      "ID": 1899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1845,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette",
      "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3900288+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313646",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313646,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1835,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824",
      "ID": 1899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3061,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4043662+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1768E19P265VM289244",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289244,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1835,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824",
      "ID": 1899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1768,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4288831+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225027",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225027,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1835,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824",
      "ID": 1899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1894,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Neil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.741413+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3815E98P134VM270865",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270865,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1835,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824",
      "ID": 1899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3815,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Park, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Park",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8264461+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265858",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265858,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1835,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824",
      "ID": 1899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2010,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil",
      "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4635965+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283342",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283342,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1835,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824",
      "ID": 1899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5057,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.6965642+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2853E33P128VM251447",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251447,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1835,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824",
      "ID": 1899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Pentland",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4640119+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317649",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317649,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1835,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824",
      "ID": 1899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5009,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4314899+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254688",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254688,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1835,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824",
      "ID": 1899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3745,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis",
      "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2673773+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1870E225P478VM295686",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295686,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1835,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824",
      "ID": 1899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1870,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona",
      "DisplayName": "Shona Robison",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5315056+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2135E254P450VM234891",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234891,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1835,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824",
      "ID": 1899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2135,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Russell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4042027+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1895E232P431VM257597",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257597,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1835,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824",
      "ID": 1899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1895,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0633782+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228131",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 228131,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1835,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824",
      "ID": 1899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1839,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5856915+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2345E10P55VM291654",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291654,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1835,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824",
      "ID": 1899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2345,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1365874+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2223E176P333VM310663",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 310663,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1835,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824",
      "ID": 1899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2223,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish",
      "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5806932+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246351",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 246351,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1835,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824",
      "ID": 1899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2182,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1249864+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298134",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298134,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1835,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824",
      "ID": 1899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5079,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew",
      "DisplayName": "Drew Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1396827+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234320",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234320,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1835,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824",
      "ID": 1899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1769,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3721936+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274561",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274561,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1835,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824",
      "ID": 1899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4014,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz",
      "DisplayName": "Liz Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1119355+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269513",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269513,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1835,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824",
      "ID": 1899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2215,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5508797+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317164",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317164,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1835,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824",
      "ID": 1899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3806,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.1844418+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326134",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 326134,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1835,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824",
      "ID": 1899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5106,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin",
      "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5413376+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241143",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241143,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1835,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824",
      "ID": 1899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1848,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola",
      "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.4038918+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2098E237P531VM289579",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289579,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1835,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824",
      "ID": 1899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2098,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Swinney",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4501309+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2674E247P401VM247765",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247765,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1835,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824",
      "ID": 1899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2674,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave",
      "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4274535+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5075E234P371VM284882",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 284882,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1835,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824",
      "ID": 1899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5075,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Torrance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0517575+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1793E151P362VM222428",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 222428,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1835,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824",
      "ID": 1899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1793,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean",
      "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1885315+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5078E245P366VM307063",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307063,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1835,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824",
      "ID": 1899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5078,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Walker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5856784+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1841E231P426VM239980",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239980,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1835,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824",
      "ID": 1899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1841,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen",
      "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.767578+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283391",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283391,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1835,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824",
      "ID": 1899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4952,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.6986909+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1865E263P500VM232218",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232218,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1835,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824",
      "ID": 1899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1865,
      "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra",
      "DisplayName": "Sandra White",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8452177+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237788",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237788,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1835,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824",
      "ID": 1899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2610,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Wilson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2261364+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309275",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 309275,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1835,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 62,
      "VoteAgainst": 38,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Public Transport",
      "Reference": "S4M-01824",
      "ID": 1899
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4941,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza",
      "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3222927+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252644",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252644,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1838,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Claim of Right",
      "Reference": "S4M-01822",
      "ID": 1897
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1926,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian",
      "DisplayName": "Brian Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7383369+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2615E213P388VM258888",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 258888,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1838,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Claim of Right",
      "Reference": "S4M-01822",
      "ID": 1897
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2615,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George",
      "DisplayName": "George Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.3325354+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319852",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319852,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1838,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Claim of Right",
      "Reference": "S4M-01822",
      "ID": 1897
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4940,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare",
      "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9441747+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249619",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 249619,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1838,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Claim of Right",
      "Reference": "S4M-01822",
      "ID": 1897
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2641,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair",
      "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9425102+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1783E21P273VM227749",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227749,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1838,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Claim of Right",
      "Reference": "S4M-01822",
      "ID": 1897
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1783,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie",
      "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5639964+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2633E97P136VM280752",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280752,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1838,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Claim of Right",
      "Reference": "S4M-01822",
      "ID": 1897
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2633,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire",
      "DisplayName": "Claire Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7809251+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262698",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262698,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1838,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Claim of Right",
      "Reference": "S4M-01822",
      "ID": 1897
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2603,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.613028+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1759E91P115VM229783",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229783,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1838,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Claim of Right",
      "Reference": "S4M-01822",
      "ID": 1897
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia",
      "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0968549+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270139",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270139,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1838,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Claim of Right",
      "Reference": "S4M-01822",
      "ID": 1897
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3751,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5832254+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322617",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 322617,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1838,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Claim of Right",
      "Reference": "S4M-01822",
      "ID": 1897
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5109,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco",
      "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6964224+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5060E86P124VM294773",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 294773,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1838,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Claim of Right",
      "Reference": "S4M-01822",
      "ID": 1897
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5060,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1777071+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242901",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242901,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1838,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Claim of Right",
      "Reference": "S4M-01822",
      "ID": 1897
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1866,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah",
      "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0404379+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235203",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235203,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1838,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Claim of Right",
      "Reference": "S4M-01822",
      "ID": 1897
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1943,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic",
      "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6598278+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302348",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 302348,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1838,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Claim of Right",
      "Reference": "S4M-01822",
      "ID": 1897
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2595,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin",
      "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.5205257+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244305",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244305,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1838,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Claim of Right",
      "Reference": "S4M-01822",
      "ID": 1897
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2103,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith",
      "DisplayName": "Keith Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5489269+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327216",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 327216,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1838,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Claim of Right",
      "Reference": "S4M-01822",
      "ID": 1897
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:46.0262143+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3775E216P435VM277037",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277037,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1838,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Claim of Right",
      "Reference": "S4M-01822",
      "ID": 1897
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6983542+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264292",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264292,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1838,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Claim of Right",
      "Reference": "S4M-01822",
      "ID": 1897
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2673,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick",
      "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1269951+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248736",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248736,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1838,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Claim of Right",
      "Reference": "S4M-01822",
      "ID": 1897
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2678,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson",
      "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6675839+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2123E27P233VM295782",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295782,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1838,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Claim of Right",
      "Reference": "S4M-01822",
      "ID": 1897
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2123,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm",
      "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5356634+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285202",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285202,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1838,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Claim of Right",
      "Reference": "S4M-01822",
      "ID": 1897
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3907,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.312544+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230679",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230679,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1838,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Claim of Right",
      "Reference": "S4M-01822",
      "ID": 1897
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1735,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela",
      "DisplayName": "Angela Constance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3405484+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243818",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 243818,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1838,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Claim of Right",
      "Reference": "S4M-01822",
      "ID": 1897
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1932,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce",
      "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3210461+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1863E238P523VM254898",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254898,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1838,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Claim of Right",
      "Reference": "S4M-01822",
      "ID": 1897
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1863,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna",
      "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2885204+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323823",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 323823,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1838,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Claim of Right",
      "Reference": "S4M-01822",
      "ID": 1897
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4976,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth",
      "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9734748+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5107E223P379VM291298",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291298,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1838,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Claim of Right",
      "Reference": "S4M-01822",
      "ID": 1897
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5107,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1129208+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3743E222P391VM265374",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265374,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1838,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Claim of Right",
      "Reference": "S4M-01822",
      "ID": 1897
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3743,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel",
      "DisplayName": "Nigel Don",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4364359+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3771E149P417VM262288",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262288,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1838,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Claim of Right",
      "Reference": "S4M-01822",
      "ID": 1897
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3771,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob",
      "DisplayName": "Bob Doris",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.5950432+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2826E262P384VM281989",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 281989,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1838,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Claim of Right",
      "Reference": "S4M-01822",
      "ID": 1897
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2826,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Dornan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1664113+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3812E94P117VM297983",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 297983,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1838,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Claim of Right",
      "Reference": "S4M-01822",
      "ID": 1897
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3812,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia",
      "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1332709+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231254",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231254,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1838,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Claim of Right",
      "Reference": "S4M-01822",
      "ID": 1897
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1778,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen",
      "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.5870463+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4955E240P389VM285903",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285903,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1838,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Claim of Right",
      "Reference": "S4M-01822",
      "ID": 1897
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4955,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3495062+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219424",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 219424,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1838,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Claim of Right",
      "Reference": "S4M-01822",
      "ID": 1897
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1742,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle",
      "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.2982348+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238538",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 238538,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1838,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Claim of Right",
      "Reference": "S4M-01822",
      "ID": 1897
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1994,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus",
      "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4584013+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225425",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225425,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1838,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Claim of Right",
      "Reference": "S4M-01822",
      "ID": 1897
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1814,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda",
      "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9741745+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321843",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 321843,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1838,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Claim of Right",
      "Reference": "S4M-01822",
      "ID": 1897
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Fee",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4537195+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1853E35P216VM292871",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 292871,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1838,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Claim of Right",
      "Reference": "S4M-01822",
      "ID": 1897
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia",
      "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.5616647+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1892E12P64VM227151",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227151,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1838,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Claim of Right",
      "Reference": "S4M-01822",
      "ID": 1897
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.270018+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5054E95P118VM312708",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 312708,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1838,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Claim of Right",
      "Reference": "S4M-01822",
      "ID": 1897
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5054,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1399194+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4947E152P361VM257200",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257200,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1838,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Claim of Right",
      "Reference": "S4M-01822",
      "ID": 1897
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4947,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Finnie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0458235+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271258",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271258,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1838,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Claim of Right",
      "Reference": "S4M-01822",
      "ID": 1897
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3901,
      "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe",
      "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0625319+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278434",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 278434,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1838,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Claim of Right",
      "Reference": "S4M-01822",
      "ID": 1897
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2394,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo",
      "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2186277+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2110E220P414VM287243",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 287243,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1838,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Claim of Right",
      "Reference": "S4M-01822",
      "ID": 1897
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth",
      "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8558069+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250478",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250478,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1838,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Claim of Right",
      "Reference": "S4M-01822",
      "ID": 1897
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2675,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob",
      "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1912637+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1741E10P50VM220946",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220946,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1838,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Claim of Right",
      "Reference": "S4M-01822",
      "ID": 1897
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1741,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel",
      "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6684513+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220219",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220219,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1838,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Claim of Right",
      "Reference": "S4M-01822",
      "ID": 1897
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1756,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine",
      "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6289573+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1860E104P150VM252368",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252368,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1838,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Claim of Right",
      "Reference": "S4M-01822",
      "ID": 1897
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1860,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda",
      "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7261617+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2033E20P141VM266121",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 266121,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1838,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Claim of Right",
      "Reference": "S4M-01822",
      "ID": 1897
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2033,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain",
      "DisplayName": "Iain Gray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4752326+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324582",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324582,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1838,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Claim of Right",
      "Reference": "S4M-01822",
      "ID": 1897
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5042,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2291717+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259683",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 259683,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1838,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Claim of Right",
      "Reference": "S4M-01822",
      "ID": 1897
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick",
      "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.62002+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239358",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239358,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1838,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Claim of Right",
      "Reference": "S4M-01822",
      "ID": 1897
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2029,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh",
      "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7333859+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273763",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 273763,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1838,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Claim of Right",
      "Reference": "S4M-01822",
      "ID": 1897
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3758,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6346124+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304137",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 304137,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1838,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Claim of Right",
      "Reference": "S4M-01822",
      "ID": 1897
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4086,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Hume",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8512499+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221749",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221749,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1838,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Claim of Right",
      "Reference": "S4M-01822",
      "ID": 1897
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1773,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9461212+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1882E227P459VM241983",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241983,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1838,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Claim of Right",
      "Reference": "S4M-01822",
      "ID": 1897
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1882,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam",
      "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7887682+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223517",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223517,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1838,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Claim of Right",
      "Reference": "S4M-01822",
      "ID": 1897
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1893,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4618506+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307567",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307567,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1838,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Claim of Right",
      "Reference": "S4M-01822",
      "ID": 1897
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4934,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.835093+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272216",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 272216,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1838,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Claim of Right",
      "Reference": "S4M-01822",
      "ID": 1897
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4956,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Keir",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.3200293+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244910",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244910,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1838,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Claim of Right",
      "Reference": "S4M-01822",
      "ID": 1897
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Kelly",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5838439+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3129E261P419VM315080",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 315080,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1838,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Claim of Right",
      "Reference": "S4M-01822",
      "ID": 1897
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3129,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6732068+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2080E36P220VM247910",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247910,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1838,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Claim of Right",
      "Reference": "S4M-01822",
      "ID": 1897
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann",
      "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4336321+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4016E11P36VM274827",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274827,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1838,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Claim of Right",
      "Reference": "S4M-01822",
      "ID": 1897
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4016,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1234648+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255760",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255760,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1838,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Claim of Right",
      "Reference": "S4M-01822",
      "ID": 1897
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2180,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5557071+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4938E158P374VM277418",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277418,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1838,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Claim of Right",
      "Reference": "S4M-01822",
      "ID": 1897
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4938,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9525303+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2112E250P486VM253052",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 253052,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1838,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Claim of Right",
      "Reference": "S4M-01822",
      "ID": 1897
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2112,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny",
      "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7647906+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4939E258P394VM276803",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276803,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1838,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Claim of Right",
      "Reference": "S4M-01822",
      "ID": 1897
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4939,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus",
      "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6817606+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325549",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 325549,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1838,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Claim of Right",
      "Reference": "S4M-01822",
      "ID": 1897
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5074,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon",
      "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5111385+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1828E3P10VM232873",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232873,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1838,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Claim of Right",
      "Reference": "S4M-01822",
      "ID": 1897
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1828,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo",
      "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.880295+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311480",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311480,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1838,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Claim of Right",
      "Reference": "S4M-01822",
      "ID": 1897
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4948,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike",
      "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8806482+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2117E90P107VM230371",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230371,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1838,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Claim of Right",
      "Reference": "S4M-01822",
      "ID": 1897
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2117,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis",
      "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3268476+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267350",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 267350,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1838,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Claim of Right",
      "Reference": "S4M-01822",
      "ID": 1897
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken",
      "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0156633+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313529",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313529,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1838,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Claim of Right",
      "Reference": "S4M-01822",
      "ID": 1897
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4966,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek",
      "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.3993052+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3101E102P129VM295091",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295091,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1838,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Claim of Right",
      "Reference": "S4M-01822",
      "ID": 1897
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3101,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala",
      "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1918108+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319093",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319093,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1838,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Claim of Right",
      "Reference": "S4M-01822",
      "ID": 1897
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5034,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny",
      "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6921443+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306406",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306406,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1838,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Claim of Right",
      "Reference": "S4M-01822",
      "ID": 1897
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2159,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Martin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.550722+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5110E252P395VM311181",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311181,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1838,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Claim of Right",
      "Reference": "S4M-01822",
      "ID": 1897
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Mason",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.6091989+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268253",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 268253,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1838,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Claim of Right",
      "Reference": "S4M-01822",
      "ID": 1897
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2133,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2554676+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2876E141P433VM286319",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286319,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1838,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Claim of Right",
      "Reference": "S4M-01822",
      "ID": 1897
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2876,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5736785+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4951E147P368VM260668",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 260668,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1838,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Claim of Right",
      "Reference": "S4M-01822",
      "ID": 1897
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4951,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan",
      "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.0871282+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3896E175P307VM263851",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 263851,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1838,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Claim of Right",
      "Reference": "S4M-01822",
      "ID": 1897
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3896,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam",
      "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9132798+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308458",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 308458,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1838,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Claim of Right",
      "Reference": "S4M-01822",
      "ID": 1897
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.0567838+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4964E143P375VM279699",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279699,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1838,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Claim of Right",
      "Reference": "S4M-01822",
      "ID": 1897
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4964,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5188644+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3824E84P113VM279635",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279635,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1838,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Claim of Right",
      "Reference": "S4M-01822",
      "ID": 1897
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3824,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5161079+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2066E22P91VM261078",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261078,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1838,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Claim of Right",
      "Reference": "S4M-01822",
      "ID": 1897
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2066,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.110849+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299680",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 299680,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1838,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Claim of Right",
      "Reference": "S4M-01822",
      "ID": 1897
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7081242+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306645",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306645,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1838,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Claim of Right",
      "Reference": "S4M-01822",
      "ID": 1897
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina",
      "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5610037+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2487E146P369VM301149",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 301149,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1838,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Claim of Right",
      "Reference": "S4M-01822",
      "ID": 1897
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2487,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.0358651+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223695",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223695,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1838,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Claim of Right",
      "Reference": "S4M-01822",
      "ID": 1897
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4698156+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237529",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237529,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1838,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Claim of Right",
      "Reference": "S4M-01822",
      "ID": 1897
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1961,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David",
      "DisplayName": "David McLetchie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2147662+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2134E34P201VM305461",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 305461,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1838,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Claim of Right",
      "Reference": "S4M-01822",
      "ID": 1897
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2134,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.3250165+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320333",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 320333,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1838,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Claim of Right",
      "Reference": "S4M-01822",
      "ID": 1897
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5041,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan",
      "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1554921+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3763E142P397VM316002",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 316002,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1838,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Claim of Right",
      "Reference": "S4M-01822",
      "ID": 1897
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3763,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart",
      "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9416147+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1986E23P197VM236665",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 236665,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1838,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Claim of Right",
      "Reference": "S4M-01822",
      "ID": 1897
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1986,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan",
      "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9348024+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5047E100P130VM289839",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289839,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1838,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Claim of Right",
      "Reference": "S4M-01822",
      "ID": 1897
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5047,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne",
      "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4612609+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234568",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234568,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1838,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Claim of Right",
      "Reference": "S4M-01822",
      "ID": 1897
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1845,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette",
      "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3899051+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313572",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313572,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1838,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Claim of Right",
      "Reference": "S4M-01822",
      "ID": 1897
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3061,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4011762+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1768E19P265VM289247",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289247,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1838,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Claim of Right",
      "Reference": "S4M-01822",
      "ID": 1897
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1768,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4290248+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225270",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225270,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1838,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Claim of Right",
      "Reference": "S4M-01822",
      "ID": 1897
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1894,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Neil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9621485+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3815E98P134VM270931",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270931,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1838,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Claim of Right",
      "Reference": "S4M-01822",
      "ID": 1897
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3815,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Park, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Park",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8352461+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265855",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265855,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1838,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Claim of Right",
      "Reference": "S4M-01822",
      "ID": 1897
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2010,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil",
      "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4634529+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283289",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283289,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1838,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Claim of Right",
      "Reference": "S4M-01822",
      "ID": 1897
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5057,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.6940551+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2853E33P128VM251503",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251503,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1838,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Claim of Right",
      "Reference": "S4M-01822",
      "ID": 1897
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Pentland",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4664869+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317554",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317554,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1838,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Claim of Right",
      "Reference": "S4M-01822",
      "ID": 1897
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5009,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4274348+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254685",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254685,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1838,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Claim of Right",
      "Reference": "S4M-01822",
      "ID": 1897
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3745,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis",
      "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2672338+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1870E225P478VM295689",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295689,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1838,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Claim of Right",
      "Reference": "S4M-01822",
      "ID": 1897
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1870,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona",
      "DisplayName": "Shona Robison",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5316255+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2135E254P450VM235406",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235406,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1838,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Claim of Right",
      "Reference": "S4M-01822",
      "ID": 1897
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2135,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Russell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.669392+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1895E232P431VM257600",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257600,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1838,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Claim of Right",
      "Reference": "S4M-01822",
      "ID": 1897
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1895,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0635009+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228134",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 228134,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1838,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Claim of Right",
      "Reference": "S4M-01822",
      "ID": 1897
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1839,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5858124+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2345E10P55VM291651",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291651,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1838,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Claim of Right",
      "Reference": "S4M-01822",
      "ID": 1897
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2345,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1364469+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2223E176P333VM311049",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311049,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1838,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Claim of Right",
      "Reference": "S4M-01822",
      "ID": 1897
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2223,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish",
      "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.6032334+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2182E87P175VM246354",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 246354,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1838,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Claim of Right",
      "Reference": "S4M-01822",
      "ID": 1897
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2182,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.1251102+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298131",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298131,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1838,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Claim of Right",
      "Reference": "S4M-01822",
      "ID": 1897
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5079,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew",
      "DisplayName": "Drew Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1395613+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234317",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234317,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1838,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Claim of Right",
      "Reference": "S4M-01822",
      "ID": 1897
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1769,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3720694+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4014E14P26VM274614",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274614,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1838,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Claim of Right",
      "Reference": "S4M-01822",
      "ID": 1897
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4014,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz",
      "DisplayName": "Liz Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1142153+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269517",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269517,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1838,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Claim of Right",
      "Reference": "S4M-01822",
      "ID": 1897
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2215,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5510443+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317391",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317391,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1838,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Claim of Right",
      "Reference": "S4M-01822",
      "ID": 1897
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3806,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4200903+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326281",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 326281,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1838,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Claim of Right",
      "Reference": "S4M-01822",
      "ID": 1897
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5106,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin",
      "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.7516935+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241146",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241146,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1838,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Claim of Right",
      "Reference": "S4M-01822",
      "ID": 1897
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1848,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola",
      "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.4040146+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2098E237P531VM289654",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289654,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1838,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Claim of Right",
      "Reference": "S4M-01822",
      "ID": 1897
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2098,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Swinney",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4532766+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2674E247P401VM247820",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247820,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1838,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Claim of Right",
      "Reference": "S4M-01822",
      "ID": 1897
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2674,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave",
      "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4298358+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5075E234P371VM287421",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 287421,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1838,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Claim of Right",
      "Reference": "S4M-01822",
      "ID": 1897
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5075,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Torrance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.8634881+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1793E151P362VM222514",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 222514,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1838,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Claim of Right",
      "Reference": "S4M-01822",
      "ID": 1897
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1793,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean",
      "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1922361+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5078E245P366VM307060",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307060,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1838,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Claim of Right",
      "Reference": "S4M-01822",
      "ID": 1897
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5078,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Walker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5855562+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1841E231P426VM239977",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239977,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1838,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Claim of Right",
      "Reference": "S4M-01822",
      "ID": 1897
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1841,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen",
      "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7674569+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283478",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283478,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1838,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Claim of Right",
      "Reference": "S4M-01822",
      "ID": 1897
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4952,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7096432+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1865E263P500VM232215",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232215,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1838,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Claim of Right",
      "Reference": "S4M-01822",
      "ID": 1897
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1865,
      "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra",
      "DisplayName": "Sandra White",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8450917+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237733",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237733,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1838,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Claim of Right",
      "Reference": "S4M-01822",
      "ID": 1897
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2610,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Wilson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2234878+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309271",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 309271,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1838,
      "AgendaID": 2091,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 102,
      "VoteAgainst": 14,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Claim of Right",
      "Reference": "S4M-01822",
      "ID": 1897
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4941,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza",
      "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-26T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3221311+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252258",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252258,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1834,
      "AgendaID": 2210,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01773",
      "ID": 1850
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1926,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian",
      "DisplayName": "Brian Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.721173+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2615E213P388VM257554",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257554,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1834,
      "AgendaID": 2210,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01773",
      "ID": 1850
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2615,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George",
      "DisplayName": "George Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0615364+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319936",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319936,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1834,
      "AgendaID": 2210,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01773",
      "ID": 1850
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4940,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare",
      "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9477742+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249695",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 249695,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1834,
      "AgendaID": 2210,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01773",
      "ID": 1850
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2641,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair",
      "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9458374+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1783E21P273VM227365",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227365,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1834,
      "AgendaID": 2210,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01773",
      "ID": 1850
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1783,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie",
      "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5470206+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2633E97P136VM280388",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280388,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1834,
      "AgendaID": 2210,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01773",
      "ID": 1850
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2633,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire",
      "DisplayName": "Claire Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7585794+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262452",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262452,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1834,
      "AgendaID": 2210,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01773",
      "ID": 1850
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2603,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6025194+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1759E91P115VM229238",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229238,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1834,
      "AgendaID": 2210,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01773",
      "ID": 1850
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia",
      "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0680395+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270238",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270238,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1834,
      "AgendaID": 2210,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01773",
      "ID": 1850
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3751,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.79531+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322848",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 322848,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1834,
      "AgendaID": 2210,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01773",
      "ID": 1850
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5109,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco",
      "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.7061619+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5060E86P124VM294684",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 294684,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1834,
      "AgendaID": 2210,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01773",
      "ID": 1850
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5060,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1738847+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242818",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242818,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1834,
      "AgendaID": 2210,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01773",
      "ID": 1850
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1866,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah",
      "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0369117+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235610",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235610,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1834,
      "AgendaID": 2210,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01773",
      "ID": 1850
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1943,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic",
      "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6851743+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302107",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 302107,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1834,
      "AgendaID": 2210,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01773",
      "ID": 1850
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2595,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin",
      "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.2973458+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244548",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244548,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1834,
      "AgendaID": 2210,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01773",
      "ID": 1850
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2103,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith",
      "DisplayName": "Keith Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5680092+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327353",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 327353,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1834,
      "AgendaID": 2210,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01773",
      "ID": 1850
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:46.0322166+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3775E216P435VM276635",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276635,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1834,
      "AgendaID": 2210,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01773",
      "ID": 1850
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6746021+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264535",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264535,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1834,
      "AgendaID": 2210,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01773",
      "ID": 1850
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2673,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick",
      "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1376931+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248835",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248835,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1834,
      "AgendaID": 2210,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01773",
      "ID": 1850
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2678,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson",
      "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6720831+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2123E27P233VM296327",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 296327,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1834,
      "AgendaID": 2210,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01773",
      "ID": 1850
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2123,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm",
      "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8442379+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285113",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285113,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1834,
      "AgendaID": 2210,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01773",
      "ID": 1850
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3907,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0670092+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230129",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230129,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1834,
      "AgendaID": 2210,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01773",
      "ID": 1850
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1735,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela",
      "DisplayName": "Angela Constance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.1174881+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243901",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 243901,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1834,
      "AgendaID": 2210,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01773",
      "ID": 1850
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1932,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce",
      "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3247764+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1863E238P523VM255289",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255289,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1834,
      "AgendaID": 2210,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01773",
      "ID": 1850
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1863,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna",
      "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5245096+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323988",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 323988,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1834,
      "AgendaID": 2210,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01773",
      "ID": 1850
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4976,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth",
      "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9811462+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5107E223P379VM291857",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291857,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1834,
      "AgendaID": 2210,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01773",
      "ID": 1850
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5107,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1454748+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3743E222P391VM265128",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265128,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1834,
      "AgendaID": 2210,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01773",
      "ID": 1850
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3743,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel",
      "DisplayName": "Nigel Don",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1696833+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3771E149P417VM261724",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261724,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1834,
      "AgendaID": 2210,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01773",
      "ID": 1850
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3771,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob",
      "DisplayName": "Bob Doris",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3700883+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2826E262P384VM282043",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 282043,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1834,
      "AgendaID": 2210,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01773",
      "ID": 1850
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2826,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Dornan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1731342+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3812E94P117VM297928",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 297928,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1834,
      "AgendaID": 2210,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01773",
      "ID": 1850
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3812,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia",
      "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1309579+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231645",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231645,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1834,
      "AgendaID": 2210,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01773",
      "ID": 1850
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1778,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen",
      "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.609502+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4955E240P389VM286156",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286156,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1834,
      "AgendaID": 2210,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01773",
      "ID": 1850
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4955,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3663065+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219328",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 219328,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1834,
      "AgendaID": 2210,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01773",
      "ID": 1850
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1742,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle",
      "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.2938398+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238637",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 238637,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1834,
      "AgendaID": 2210,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01773",
      "ID": 1850
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1994,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus",
      "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4626689+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225498",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225498,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1834,
      "AgendaID": 2210,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01773",
      "ID": 1850
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1814,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda",
      "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9773157+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321612",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 321612,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1834,
      "AgendaID": 2210,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01773",
      "ID": 1850
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Fee",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4435792+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1853E35P216VM293310",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 293310,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1834,
      "AgendaID": 2210,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01773",
      "ID": 1850
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia",
      "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8394969+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1892E12P64VM226896",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 226896,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1834,
      "AgendaID": 2210,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01773",
      "ID": 1850
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.251378+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5054E95P118VM312623",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 312623,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1834,
      "AgendaID": 2210,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01773",
      "ID": 1850
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5054,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1363006+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4947E152P361VM257126",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257126,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1834,
      "AgendaID": 2210,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01773",
      "ID": 1850
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4947,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Finnie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.8244192+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271511",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271511,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1834,
      "AgendaID": 2210,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01773",
      "ID": 1850
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3901,
      "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe",
      "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0789787+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278487",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 278487,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1834,
      "AgendaID": 2210,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01773",
      "ID": 1850
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2394,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo",
      "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2209278+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2110E220P414VM286696",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286696,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1834,
      "AgendaID": 2210,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01773",
      "ID": 1850
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth",
      "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5968276+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250404",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250404,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1834,
      "AgendaID": 2210,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01773",
      "ID": 1850
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2675,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob",
      "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1878232+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1741E10P50VM220717",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220717,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1834,
      "AgendaID": 2210,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01773",
      "ID": 1850
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1741,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel",
      "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6540245+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220317",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220317,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1834,
      "AgendaID": 2210,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01773",
      "ID": 1850
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1756,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine",
      "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6361148+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1860E104P150VM251824",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251824,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1834,
      "AgendaID": 2210,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01773",
      "ID": 1850
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1860,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda",
      "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4907075+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2033E20P141VM266199",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 266199,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1834,
      "AgendaID": 2210,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01773",
      "ID": 1850
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2033,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain",
      "DisplayName": "Iain Gray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.7282011+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324445",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324445,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1834,
      "AgendaID": 2210,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01773",
      "ID": 1850
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5042,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2229645+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259938",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 259938,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1834,
      "AgendaID": 2210,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01773",
      "ID": 1850
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick",
      "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.636512+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239260",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239260,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1834,
      "AgendaID": 2210,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01773",
      "ID": 1850
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2029,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh",
      "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7290869+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273853",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 273853,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1834,
      "AgendaID": 2210,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01773",
      "ID": 1850
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3758,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6384983+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304222",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 304222,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1834,
      "AgendaID": 2210,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01773",
      "ID": 1850
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4086,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Hume",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.0289641+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221822",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221822,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1834,
      "AgendaID": 2210,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01773",
      "ID": 1850
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1773,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9493012+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1882E227P459VM242058",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242058,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1834,
      "AgendaID": 2210,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01773",
      "ID": 1850
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1882,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam",
      "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7919927+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223768",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223768,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1834,
      "AgendaID": 2210,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01773",
      "ID": 1850
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1893,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4729209+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307512",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307512,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1834,
      "AgendaID": 2210,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01773",
      "ID": 1850
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4934,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8327325+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272143",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 272143,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1834,
      "AgendaID": 2210,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01773",
      "ID": 1850
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4956,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Keir",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.1134376+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244825",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244825,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1834,
      "AgendaID": 2210,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01773",
      "ID": 1850
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Kelly",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5802301+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3129E261P419VM314996",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 314996,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1834,
      "AgendaID": 2210,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01773",
      "ID": 1850
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3129,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.669584+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2080E36P220VM251100",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251100,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1834,
      "AgendaID": 2210,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01773",
      "ID": 1850
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann",
      "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.2270146+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4016E11P36VM274730",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274730,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1834,
      "AgendaID": 2210,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01773",
      "ID": 1850
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4016,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1192333+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255857",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255857,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1834,
      "AgendaID": 2210,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01773",
      "ID": 1850
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2180,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.560015+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4938E158P374VM277824",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277824,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1834,
      "AgendaID": 2210,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01773",
      "ID": 1850
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4938,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.970006+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2112E250P486VM252954",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252954,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1834,
      "AgendaID": 2210,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01773",
      "ID": 1850
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2112,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny",
      "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7603666+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4939E258P394VM277212",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277212,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1834,
      "AgendaID": 2210,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01773",
      "ID": 1850
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4939,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus",
      "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9384985+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325686",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 325686,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1834,
      "AgendaID": 2210,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01773",
      "ID": 1850
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5074,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon",
      "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5169395+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1828E3P10VM232789",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232789,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1834,
      "AgendaID": 2210,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01773",
      "ID": 1850
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1828,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo",
      "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8763097+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311359",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311359,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1834,
      "AgendaID": 2210,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01773",
      "ID": 1850
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4948,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike",
      "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.875311+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2117E90P107VM230470",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230470,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1834,
      "AgendaID": 2210,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01773",
      "ID": 1850
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2117,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis",
      "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3313066+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267272",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 267272,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1834,
      "AgendaID": 2210,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01773",
      "ID": 1850
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken",
      "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0122899+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313802",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313802,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1834,
      "AgendaID": 2210,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01773",
      "ID": 1850
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4966,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek",
      "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4112947+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3101E102P129VM295454",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295454,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1834,
      "AgendaID": 2210,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01773",
      "ID": 1850
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3101,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala",
      "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5128357+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5034E88P114VM318862",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 318862,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1834,
      "AgendaID": 2210,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01773",
      "ID": 1850
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5034,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny",
      "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6766168+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306491",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306491,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1834,
      "AgendaID": 2210,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01773",
      "ID": 1850
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2159,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Martin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5543569+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5110E252P395VM311307",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311307,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1834,
      "AgendaID": 2210,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01773",
      "ID": 1850
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Mason",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8730379+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268332",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 268332,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1834,
      "AgendaID": 2210,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01773",
      "ID": 1850
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2133,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2625555+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2876E141P433VM286108",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286108,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1834,
      "AgendaID": 2210,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01773",
      "ID": 1850
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2876,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3640094+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4951E147P368VM260741",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 260741,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1834,
      "AgendaID": 2210,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01773",
      "ID": 1850
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4951,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan",
      "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.0902534+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3896E175P307VM264106",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264106,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1834,
      "AgendaID": 2210,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01773",
      "ID": 1850
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3896,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam",
      "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9244946+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308022",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 308022,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1834,
      "AgendaID": 2210,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01773",
      "ID": 1850
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8610633+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4964E143P375VM279297",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279297,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1834,
      "AgendaID": 2210,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01773",
      "ID": 1850
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4964,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.4958489+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3824E84P113VM280035",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280035,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1834,
      "AgendaID": 2210,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01773",
      "ID": 1850
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3824,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5386276+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2066E22P91VM261783",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261783,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1834,
      "AgendaID": 2210,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01773",
      "ID": 1850
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2066,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3779397+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299735",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 299735,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1834,
      "AgendaID": 2210,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01773",
      "ID": 1850
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7203776+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3759E260P411VM303351",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 303351,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1834,
      "AgendaID": 2210,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01773",
      "ID": 1850
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina",
      "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8112106+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2487E146P369VM301738",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 301738,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1834,
      "AgendaID": 2210,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01773",
      "ID": 1850
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2487,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.2810063+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223622",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223622,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1834,
      "AgendaID": 2210,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01773",
      "ID": 1850
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4667175+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237432",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237432,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1834,
      "AgendaID": 2210,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01773",
      "ID": 1850
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1961,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David",
      "DisplayName": "David McLetchie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2039635+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2134E34P201VM297823",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 297823,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1834,
      "AgendaID": 2210,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01773",
      "ID": 1850
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2134,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1265552+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320719",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 320719,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1834,
      "AgendaID": 2210,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01773",
      "ID": 1850
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5041,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan",
      "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1785291+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3763E142P397VM316086",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 316086,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1834,
      "AgendaID": 2210,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01773",
      "ID": 1850
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3763,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart",
      "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9455508+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1986E23P197VM236266",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 236266,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1834,
      "AgendaID": 2210,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01773",
      "ID": 1850
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1986,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan",
      "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9089814+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5047E100P130VM291468",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291468,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1834,
      "AgendaID": 2210,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01773",
      "ID": 1850
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5047,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne",
      "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1206234+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234958",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234958,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1834,
      "AgendaID": 2210,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01773",
      "ID": 1850
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1845,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette",
      "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.407196+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313656",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313656,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1834,
      "AgendaID": 2210,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01773",
      "ID": 1850
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3061,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4048008+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1768E19P265VM288499",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 288499,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1834,
      "AgendaID": 2210,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01773",
      "ID": 1850
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1768,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1375517+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225017",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225017,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1834,
      "AgendaID": 2210,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01773",
      "ID": 1850
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1894,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Neil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7409896+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3815E98P134VM270855",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270855,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1834,
      "AgendaID": 2210,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01773",
      "ID": 1850
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3815,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Park, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Park",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8260132+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265936",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265936,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1834,
      "AgendaID": 2210,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01773",
      "ID": 1850
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2010,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil",
      "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4669554+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283543",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283543,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1834,
      "AgendaID": 2210,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01773",
      "ID": 1850
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5057,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7125339+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2853E33P128VM251403",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251403,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1834,
      "AgendaID": 2210,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01773",
      "ID": 1850
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Pentland",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4620794+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317938",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317938,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1834,
      "AgendaID": 2210,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01773",
      "ID": 1850
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5009,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4499622+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254759",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254759,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1834,
      "AgendaID": 2210,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01773",
      "ID": 1850
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3745,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis",
      "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.282506+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1870E225P478VM295559",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295559,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1834,
      "AgendaID": 2210,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01773",
      "ID": 1850
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1870,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona",
      "DisplayName": "Shona Robison",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5173768+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2135E254P450VM234847",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234847,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1834,
      "AgendaID": 2210,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01773",
      "ID": 1850
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2135,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Russell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4023051+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1895E232P431VM257364",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257364,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1834,
      "AgendaID": 2210,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01773",
      "ID": 1850
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1895,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0530045+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228060",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 228060,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1834,
      "AgendaID": 2210,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01773",
      "ID": 1850
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1839,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5826345+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2345E10P55VM292044",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 292044,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1834,
      "AgendaID": 2210,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01773",
      "ID": 1850
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2345,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1535238+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2223E176P333VM310653",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 310653,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1834,
      "AgendaID": 2210,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01773",
      "ID": 1850
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2223,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish",
      "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5801938+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2182E87P175VM245972",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 245972,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1834,
      "AgendaID": 2210,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01773",
      "ID": 1850
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2182,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.866667+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298374",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298374,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1834,
      "AgendaID": 2210,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01773",
      "ID": 1850
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5079,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew",
      "DisplayName": "Drew Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3429899+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234408",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234408,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1834,
      "AgendaID": 2210,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01773",
      "ID": 1850
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1769,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3759913+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4014E14P26VM269925",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269925,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1834,
      "AgendaID": 2210,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01773",
      "ID": 1850
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4014,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz",
      "DisplayName": "Liz Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5737493+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269155",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269155,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1834,
      "AgendaID": 2210,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01773",
      "ID": 1850
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2215,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.3060586+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317154",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317154,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1834,
      "AgendaID": 2210,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01773",
      "ID": 1850
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3806,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.1840081+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326144",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 326144,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1834,
      "AgendaID": 2210,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01773",
      "ID": 1850
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5106,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin",
      "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5417676+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241070",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241070,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1834,
      "AgendaID": 2210,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01773",
      "ID": 1850
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1848,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola",
      "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.394778+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2098E237P531VM289569",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289569,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1834,
      "AgendaID": 2210,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01773",
      "ID": 1850
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2098,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Swinney",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4497086+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2674E247P401VM247721",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247721,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1834,
      "AgendaID": 2210,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01773",
      "ID": 1850
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2674,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave",
      "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4255663+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5075E234P371VM284838",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 284838,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1834,
      "AgendaID": 2210,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01773",
      "ID": 1850
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5075,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Torrance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0499044+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1793E151P362VM222418",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 222418,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1834,
      "AgendaID": 2210,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01773",
      "ID": 1850
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1793,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean",
      "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1880987+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5078E245P366VM307182",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307182,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1834,
      "AgendaID": 2210,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01773",
      "ID": 1850
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5078,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Walker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5908001+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1841E231P426VM240208",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 240208,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1834,
      "AgendaID": 2210,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01773",
      "ID": 1850
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1841,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen",
      "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3495302+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283381",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283381,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1834,
      "AgendaID": 2210,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01773",
      "ID": 1850
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4952,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.6982578+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1865E263P500VM232293",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232293,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1834,
      "AgendaID": 2210,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01773",
      "ID": 1850
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1865,
      "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra",
      "DisplayName": "Sandra White",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.848496+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237832",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237832,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1834,
      "AgendaID": 2210,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01773",
      "ID": 1850
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2610,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Wilson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2279954+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309326",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 309326,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1834,
      "AgendaID": 2210,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 64,
      "VoteAgainst": 40,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Budget (Scotland) Bill",
      "Reference": "S4M-01773",
      "ID": 1850
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4941,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza",
      "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-25T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3244812+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252262",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252262,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1830,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.2",
      "ID": 1832
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1926,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian",
      "DisplayName": "Brian Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7213578+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2615E213P388VM257535",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257535,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1830,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.2",
      "ID": 1832
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2615,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George",
      "DisplayName": "George Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0607216+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319955",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319955,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1830,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.2",
      "ID": 1832
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4940,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare",
      "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9485986+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249679",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 249679,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1830,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.2",
      "ID": 1832
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2641,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair",
      "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9451579+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1783E21P273VM227369",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227369,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1830,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.2",
      "ID": 1832
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1783,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie",
      "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5471849+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2633E97P136VM280364",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280364,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1830,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.2",
      "ID": 1832
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2633,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire",
      "DisplayName": "Claire Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7575446+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262416",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262416,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1830,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.2",
      "ID": 1832
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2603,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6006472+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1759E91P115VM229199",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229199,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1830,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.2",
      "ID": 1832
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia",
      "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0662884+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270259",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270259,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1830,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.2",
      "ID": 1832
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3751,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.7962325+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322824",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 322824,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1830,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.2",
      "ID": 1832
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5109,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco",
      "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.7051458+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5060E86P124VM294648",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 294648,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1830,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.2",
      "ID": 1832
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5060,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.172303+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242794",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242794,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1830,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.2",
      "ID": 1832
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1866,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah",
      "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0358272+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235629",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235629,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1830,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.2",
      "ID": 1832
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1943,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic",
      "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6859774+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302070",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 302070,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1830,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.2",
      "ID": 1832
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2595,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin",
      "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.295773+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244584",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244584,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1830,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.2",
      "ID": 1832
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2103,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith",
      "DisplayName": "Keith Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5695814+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327334",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 327334,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1830,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.2",
      "ID": 1832
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:46.0313802+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3775E216P435VM276599",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276599,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1830,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.2",
      "ID": 1832
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.673065+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264571",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264571,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1830,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.2",
      "ID": 1832
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2673,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick",
      "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1395416+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248854",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248854,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1830,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.2",
      "ID": 1832
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2678,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson",
      "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.672901+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2123E27P233VM296346",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 296346,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1830,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.2",
      "ID": 1832
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2123,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm",
      "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8450809+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285077",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285077,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1830,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.2",
      "ID": 1832
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3907,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0604278+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230092",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230092,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1830,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.2",
      "ID": 1832
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1735,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela",
      "DisplayName": "Angela Constance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.1159179+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243926",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 243926,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1830,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.2",
      "ID": 1832
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1932,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce",
      "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3258483+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1863E238P523VM255328",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255328,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1830,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.2",
      "ID": 1832
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1863,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna",
      "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5262969+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323969",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 323969,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1830,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.2",
      "ID": 1832
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4976,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth",
      "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9803139+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5107E223P379VM291878",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291878,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1830,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.2",
      "ID": 1832
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5107,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1463568+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3743E222P391VM265092",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265092,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1830,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.2",
      "ID": 1832
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3743,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel",
      "DisplayName": "Nigel Don",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1681269+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3771E149P417VM261704",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261704,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1830,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.2",
      "ID": 1832
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3771,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob",
      "DisplayName": "Bob Doris",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3689322+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2826E262P384VM282066",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 282066,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1830,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.2",
      "ID": 1832
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2826,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Dornan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1741431+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3812E94P117VM297906",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 297906,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1830,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.2",
      "ID": 1832
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3812,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia",
      "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.130031+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231684",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231684,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1830,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.2",
      "ID": 1832
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1778,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen",
      "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6111343+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4955E240P389VM286177",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286177,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1830,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.2",
      "ID": 1832
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4955,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3672169+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219307",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 219307,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1830,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.2",
      "ID": 1832
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1742,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle",
      "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.2884511+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238656",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 238656,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1830,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.2",
      "ID": 1832
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1994,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus",
      "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4634528+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225524",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225524,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1830,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.2",
      "ID": 1832
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1814,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda",
      "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9784403+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321636",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 321636,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1830,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.2",
      "ID": 1832
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Fee",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4446191+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1853E35P216VM293276",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 293276,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1830,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.2",
      "ID": 1832
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia",
      "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8380016+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1892E12P64VM226877",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 226877,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1830,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.2",
      "ID": 1832
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2505406+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5054E95P118VM305079",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 305079,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1830,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.2",
      "ID": 1832
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5054,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.0712579+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4947E152P361VM257142",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257142,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1830,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.2",
      "ID": 1832
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4947,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Finnie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.825117+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271532",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271532,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1830,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.2",
      "ID": 1832
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3901,
      "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe",
      "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0798947+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278511",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 278511,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1830,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.2",
      "ID": 1832
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2394,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo",
      "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2220367+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2110E220P414VM286659",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286659,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1830,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.2",
      "ID": 1832
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth",
      "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5952872+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250420",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250420,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1830,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.2",
      "ID": 1832
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2675,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob",
      "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1887843+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1741E10P50VM220692",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220692,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1830,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.2",
      "ID": 1832
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1741,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel",
      "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6529315+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220337",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220337,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1830,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.2",
      "ID": 1832
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1756,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine",
      "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6369879+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1860E104P150VM251785",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251785,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1830,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.2",
      "ID": 1832
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1860,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda",
      "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4886049+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2033E20P141VM266195",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 266195,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1830,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.2",
      "ID": 1832
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2033,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain",
      "DisplayName": "Iain Gray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4784305+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324464",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324464,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1830,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.2",
      "ID": 1832
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5042,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2238057+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259958",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 259958,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1830,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.2",
      "ID": 1832
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick",
      "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6373722+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239241",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239241,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1830,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.2",
      "ID": 1832
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2029,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh",
      "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7282734+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273889",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 273889,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1830,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.2",
      "ID": 1832
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3758,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6400414+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304259",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 304259,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1830,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.2",
      "ID": 1832
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4086,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Hume",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.0305793+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221848",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221848,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1830,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.2",
      "ID": 1832
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1773,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9504125+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1882E227P459VM242042",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242042,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1830,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.2",
      "ID": 1832
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1882,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam",
      "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7913106+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223789",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223789,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1830,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.2",
      "ID": 1832
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1893,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4738234+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307489",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307489,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1830,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.2",
      "ID": 1832
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4934,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8317386+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272159",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 272159,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1830,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.2",
      "ID": 1832
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4956,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Keir",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.1141117+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244804",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244804,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1830,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.2",
      "ID": 1832
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Kelly",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5793332+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3129E261P419VM314977",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 314977,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1830,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.2",
      "ID": 1832
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3129,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6687823+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2080E36P220VM251119",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251119,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1830,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.2",
      "ID": 1832
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann",
      "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.2280355+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4016E11P36VM274709",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274709,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1830,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.2",
      "ID": 1832
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4016,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1183285+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255876",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255876,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1830,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.2",
      "ID": 1832
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2180,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5608166+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4938E158P374VM277845",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277845,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1830,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.2",
      "ID": 1832
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4938,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.970913+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2112E250P486VM252935",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252935,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1830,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.2",
      "ID": 1832
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2112,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny",
      "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7595762+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4939E258P394VM277233",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277233,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1830,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.2",
      "ID": 1832
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4939,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus",
      "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.939416+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325667",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 325667,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1830,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.2",
      "ID": 1832
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5074,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon",
      "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5161368+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1828E3P10VM232442",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232442,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1830,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.2",
      "ID": 1832
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1828,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo",
      "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8610289+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311335",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311335,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1830,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.2",
      "ID": 1832
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4948,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike",
      "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8742691+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2117E90P107VM230797",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230797,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1830,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.2",
      "ID": 1832
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2117,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis",
      "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.345934+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267276",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 267276,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1830,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.2",
      "ID": 1832
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken",
      "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0124541+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313826",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313826,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1830,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.2",
      "ID": 1832
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4966,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek",
      "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4123234+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3101E102P129VM295476",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295476,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1830,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.2",
      "ID": 1832
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3101,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala",
      "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5137736+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5034E88P114VM318886",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 318886,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1830,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.2",
      "ID": 1832
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5034,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny",
      "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6779441+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306510",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306510,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1830,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.2",
      "ID": 1832
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2159,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Martin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5551616+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5110E252P395VM311273",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311273,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1830,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.2",
      "ID": 1832
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Mason",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8715579+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268328",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 268328,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1830,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.2",
      "ID": 1832
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2133,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2623684+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2876E141P433VM286085",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286085,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1830,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.2",
      "ID": 1832
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2876,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3573705+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4951E147P368VM260725",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 260725,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1830,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.2",
      "ID": 1832
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4951,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan",
      "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.0895775+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3896E175P307VM264127",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264127,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1830,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.2",
      "ID": 1832
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3896,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam",
      "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.925402+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308056",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 308056,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1830,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.2",
      "ID": 1832
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8625588+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4964E143P375VM279276",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279276,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1830,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.2",
      "ID": 1832
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4964,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.4948529+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3824E84P113VM280071",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280071,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1830,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.2",
      "ID": 1832
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3824,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5401863+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2066E22P91VM261804",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261804,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1830,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.2",
      "ID": 1832
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2066,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3788842+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299758",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 299758,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1830,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.2",
      "ID": 1832
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7213572+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306551",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306551,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1830,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.2",
      "ID": 1832
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina",
      "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5569215+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2487E146P369VM301244",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 301244,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1830,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.2",
      "ID": 1832
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2487,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.2535285+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223596",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223596,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1830,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.2",
      "ID": 1832
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4652562+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237413",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237413,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1830,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.2",
      "ID": 1832
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1961,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David",
      "DisplayName": "David McLetchie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.203141+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2134E34P201VM297804",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 297804,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1830,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.2",
      "ID": 1832
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2134,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1257223+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320695",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 320695,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1830,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.2",
      "ID": 1832
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5041,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan",
      "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1774965+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3763E142P397VM316105",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 316105,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1830,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.2",
      "ID": 1832
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3763,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart",
      "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9463785+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1986E23P197VM236230",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 236230,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1830,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.2",
      "ID": 1832
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1986,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan",
      "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9074167+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5047E100P130VM291504",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291504,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1830,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.2",
      "ID": 1832
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5047,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne",
      "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1221809+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234997",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234997,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1830,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.2",
      "ID": 1832
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1845,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette",
      "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4091777+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313675",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313675,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1830,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.2",
      "ID": 1832
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3061,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4056226+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1768E19P265VM288533",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 288533,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1830,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.2",
      "ID": 1832
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1768,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1475077+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1894E267P527VM224997",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 224997,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1830,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.2",
      "ID": 1832
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1894,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Neil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7401367+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3815E98P134VM270834",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270834,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1830,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.2",
      "ID": 1832
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3815,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Park, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Park",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8251131+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265974",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265974,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1830,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.2",
      "ID": 1832
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2010,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil",
      "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4689321+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283564",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283564,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1830,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.2",
      "ID": 1832
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5057,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7137104+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2853E33P128VM251077",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251077,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1830,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.2",
      "ID": 1832
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Pentland",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.2260276+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317914",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317914,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1830,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.2",
      "ID": 1832
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5009,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4428628+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254743",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254743,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1830,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.2",
      "ID": 1832
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3745,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis",
      "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2818344+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1870E225P478VM295593",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295593,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1830,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.2",
      "ID": 1832
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1870,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona",
      "DisplayName": "Shona Robison",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5191287+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2135E254P450VM234828",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234828,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1830,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.2",
      "ID": 1832
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2135,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Russell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4014887+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1895E232P431VM257325",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257325,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1830,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.2",
      "ID": 1832
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1895,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0512854+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228034",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 228034,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1830,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.2",
      "ID": 1832
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1839,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.58152+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2345E10P55VM292081",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 292081,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1830,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.2",
      "ID": 1832
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2345,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1551305+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2223E176P333VM310634",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 310634,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1830,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.2",
      "ID": 1832
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2223,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish",
      "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5793673+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2182E87P175VM245988",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 245988,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1830,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.2",
      "ID": 1832
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2182,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8673622+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298409",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298409,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1830,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.2",
      "ID": 1832
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5079,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew",
      "DisplayName": "Drew Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3444872+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234444",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234444,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1830,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.2",
      "ID": 1832
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1769,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3844772+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4014E14P26VM269904",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269904,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1830,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.2",
      "ID": 1832
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4014,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz",
      "DisplayName": "Liz Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.568002+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269132",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269132,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1830,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.2",
      "ID": 1832
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2215,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.3049659+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317135",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317135,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1830,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.2",
      "ID": 1832
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3806,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.1831977+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326163",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 326163,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1830,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.2",
      "ID": 1832
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5106,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin",
      "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5425886+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241086",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241086,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1830,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.2",
      "ID": 1832
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1848,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola",
      "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.395485+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2098E237P531VM289549",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289549,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1830,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.2",
      "ID": 1832
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2098,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Swinney",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4488608+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2674E247P401VM247702",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247702,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1830,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.2",
      "ID": 1832
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2674,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave",
      "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4247731+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5075E234P371VM284817",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 284817,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1830,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.2",
      "ID": 1832
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5075,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Torrance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0490186+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1793E151P362VM222397",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 222397,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1830,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.2",
      "ID": 1832
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1793,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean",
      "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1871947+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5078E245P366VM307148",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307148,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1830,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.2",
      "ID": 1832
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5078,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Walker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5893285+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1841E231P426VM240192",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 240192,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1830,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.2",
      "ID": 1832
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1841,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen",
      "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3488139+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283360",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283360,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1830,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.2",
      "ID": 1832
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4952,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.697348+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1865E263P500VM232289",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232289,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1830,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.2",
      "ID": 1832
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1865,
      "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra",
      "DisplayName": "Sandra White",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8483295+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237851",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237851,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1830,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.2",
      "ID": 1832
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2610,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Wilson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2287996+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309349",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 309349,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1830,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 53,
      "VoteAgainst": 68,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.2",
      "ID": 1832
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4941,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza",
      "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3254746+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252263",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252263,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1831,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 104,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.1",
      "ID": 1826
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1926,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian",
      "DisplayName": "Brian Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7213986+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2615E213P388VM257536",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257536,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1831,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 104,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.1",
      "ID": 1826
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2615,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George",
      "DisplayName": "George Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0607634+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319954",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319954,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1831,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 104,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.1",
      "ID": 1826
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4940,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare",
      "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9485577+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249677",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 249677,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1831,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 104,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.1",
      "ID": 1826
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2641,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair",
      "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9450788+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1783E21P273VM227370",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227370,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1831,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 104,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.1",
      "ID": 1826
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1783,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie",
      "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.547226+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2633E97P136VM280365",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280365,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1831,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 104,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.1",
      "ID": 1826
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2633,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire",
      "DisplayName": "Claire Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7575864+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262462",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262462,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1831,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 104,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.1",
      "ID": 1826
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2603,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.602997+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1759E91P115VM229200",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229200,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1831,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 104,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.1",
      "ID": 1826
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia",
      "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0663324+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270258",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270258,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1831,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 104,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.1",
      "ID": 1826
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3751,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.7961714+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322825",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 322825,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1831,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 104,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.1",
      "ID": 1826
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5109,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco",
      "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.7051872+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5060E86P124VM294693",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 294693,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1831,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 104,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.1",
      "ID": 1826
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5060,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1742747+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242795",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242795,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1831,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 104,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.1",
      "ID": 1826
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1866,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah",
      "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0358675+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235628",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235628,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1831,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 104,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.1",
      "ID": 1826
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1943,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic",
      "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6859378+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302128",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 302128,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1831,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 104,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.1",
      "ID": 1826
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2595,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin",
      "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.2982625+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244538",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244538,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1831,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 104,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.1",
      "ID": 1826
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2103,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith",
      "DisplayName": "Keith Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5592046+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327335",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 327335,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1831,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 104,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.1",
      "ID": 1826
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:46.0314418+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3775E216P435VM276645",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276645,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1831,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 104,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.1",
      "ID": 1826
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6750337+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264372",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264372,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1831,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 104,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.1",
      "ID": 1826
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2673,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick",
      "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1306632+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248853",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248853,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1831,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 104,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.1",
      "ID": 1826
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2678,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson",
      "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6728603+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2123E27P233VM296345",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 296345,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1831,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 104,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.1",
      "ID": 1826
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2123,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm",
      "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8450386+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285123",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285123,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1831,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 104,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.1",
      "ID": 1826
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3907,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0674384+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230170",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230170,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1831,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 104,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.1",
      "ID": 1826
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1735,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela",
      "DisplayName": "Angela Constance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.1192504+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243925",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 243925,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1831,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 104,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.1",
      "ID": 1826
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1932,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce",
      "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3258077+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1863E238P523VM255327",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255327,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1831,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 104,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.1",
      "ID": 1826
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1863,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna",
      "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5262542+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323970",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 323970,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1831,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 104,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.1",
      "ID": 1826
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4976,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth",
      "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9803556+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5107E223P379VM291877",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291877,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1831,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 104,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.1",
      "ID": 1826
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5107,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1463169+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3743E222P391VM265138",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265138,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1831,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 104,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.1",
      "ID": 1826
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3743,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel",
      "DisplayName": "Nigel Don",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1701157+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3771E149P417VM261705",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261705,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1831,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 104,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.1",
      "ID": 1826
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3771,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob",
      "DisplayName": "Bob Doris",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3689727+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2826E262P384VM282065",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 282065,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1831,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 104,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.1",
      "ID": 1826
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2826,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Dornan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1741023+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3812E94P117VM297907",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 297907,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1831,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 104,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.1",
      "ID": 1826
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3812,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia",
      "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1300708+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231683",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231683,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1831,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 104,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.1",
      "ID": 1826
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1778,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen",
      "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6110939+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4955E240P389VM286176",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286176,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1831,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 104,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.1",
      "ID": 1826
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4955,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3671745+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219308",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 219308,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1831,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 104,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.1",
      "ID": 1826
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1742,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle",
      "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.2884925+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238655",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 238655,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1831,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 104,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.1",
      "ID": 1826
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1994,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus",
      "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4634128+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225481",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225481,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1831,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 104,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.1",
      "ID": 1826
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1814,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda",
      "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9765752+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321635",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 321635,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1831,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 104,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.1",
      "ID": 1826
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Fee",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4445554+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1853E35P216VM293275",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 293275,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1831,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 104,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.1",
      "ID": 1826
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia",
      "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8379603+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1892E12P64VM226878",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 226878,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1831,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 104,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.1",
      "ID": 1826
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2506025+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5054E95P118VM312644",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 312644,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1831,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 104,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.1",
      "ID": 1826
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5054,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1371965+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4947E152P361VM257144",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257144,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1831,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 104,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.1",
      "ID": 1826
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4947,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Finnie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.8251991+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271531",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271531,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1831,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 104,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.1",
      "ID": 1826
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3901,
      "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe",
      "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0798536+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278510",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 278510,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1831,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 104,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.1",
      "ID": 1826
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2394,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo",
      "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2219939+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2110E220P414VM286717",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286717,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1831,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 104,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.1",
      "ID": 1826
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth",
      "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5977066+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250422",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250422,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1831,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 104,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.1",
      "ID": 1826
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2675,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob",
      "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1888659+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1741E10P50VM220734",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220734,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1831,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 104,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.1",
      "ID": 1826
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1741,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel",
      "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6547399+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220336",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220336,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1831,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 104,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.1",
      "ID": 1826
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1756,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine",
      "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6369464+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1860E104P150VM251786",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251786,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1831,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 104,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.1",
      "ID": 1826
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1860,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda",
      "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4886464+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2033E20P141VM266194",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 266194,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1831,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 104,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.1",
      "ID": 1826
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2033,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain",
      "DisplayName": "Iain Gray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4783901+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324463",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324463,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1831,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 104,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.1",
      "ID": 1826
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5042,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.223764+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259957",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 259957,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1831,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 104,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.1",
      "ID": 1826
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick",
      "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6373309+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239242",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239242,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1831,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 104,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.1",
      "ID": 1826
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2029,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh",
      "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7283155+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273843",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 273843,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1831,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 104,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.1",
      "ID": 1826
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3758,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6380657+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304201",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 304201,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1831,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 104,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.1",
      "ID": 1826
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4086,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Hume",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.0280195+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221805",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221805,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1831,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 104,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.1",
      "ID": 1826
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1773,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9485599+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1882E227P459VM242040",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242040,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1831,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 104,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.1",
      "ID": 1826
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1882,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam",
      "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.79123+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223788",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223788,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1831,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 104,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.1",
      "ID": 1826
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1893,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4737819+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307490",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307490,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1831,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 104,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.1",
      "ID": 1826
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4934,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8317804+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272161",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 272161,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1831,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 104,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.1",
      "ID": 1826
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4956,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Keir",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.1142113+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244805",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244805,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1831,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 104,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.1",
      "ID": 1826
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Kelly",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5793971+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3129E261P419VM314978",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 314978,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1831,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 104,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.1",
      "ID": 1826
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3129,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6688244+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2080E36P220VM251118",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251118,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1831,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 104,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.1",
      "ID": 1826
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann",
      "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.2279872+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4016E11P36VM274710",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274710,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1831,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 104,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.1",
      "ID": 1826
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4016,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1183713+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255875",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255875,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1831,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 104,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.1",
      "ID": 1826
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2180,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5607756+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4938E158P374VM277844",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277844,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1831,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 104,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.1",
      "ID": 1826
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4938,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9708724+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2112E250P486VM252936",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252936,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1831,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 104,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.1",
      "ID": 1826
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2112,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny",
      "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7596172+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4939E258P394VM277232",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277232,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1831,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 104,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.1",
      "ID": 1826
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4939,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus",
      "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9393746+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325668",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 325668,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1831,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 104,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.1",
      "ID": 1826
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5074,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon",
      "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5161769+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1828E3P10VM232443",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232443,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1831,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 104,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.1",
      "ID": 1826
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1828,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo",
      "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8610694+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311336",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311336,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1831,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 104,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.1",
      "ID": 1826
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4948,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike",
      "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8743104+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2117E90P107VM230796",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230796,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1831,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 104,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.1",
      "ID": 1826
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2117,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis",
      "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3458918+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267277",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 267277,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1831,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 104,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.1",
      "ID": 1826
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken",
      "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0124948+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313825",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313825,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1831,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 104,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.1",
      "ID": 1826
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4966,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek",
      "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4122821+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3101E102P129VM295475",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295475,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1831,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 104,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.1",
      "ID": 1826
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3101,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala",
      "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5137332+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5034E88P114VM318885",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 318885,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1831,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 104,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.1",
      "ID": 1826
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5034,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny",
      "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6778897+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306509",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306509,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1831,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 104,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.1",
      "ID": 1826
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2159,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Martin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5551207+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5110E252P395VM311272",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311272,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1831,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 104,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.1",
      "ID": 1826
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Mason",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8715161+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268327",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 268327,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1831,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 104,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.1",
      "ID": 1826
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2133,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.262327+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2876E141P433VM286086",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286086,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1831,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 104,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.1",
      "ID": 1826
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2876,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3574133+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4951E147P368VM260723",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 260723,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1831,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 104,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.1",
      "ID": 1826
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4951,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan",
      "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.089496+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3896E175P307VM264126",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264126,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1831,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 104,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.1",
      "ID": 1826
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3896,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam",
      "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9253614+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308057",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 308057,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1831,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 104,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.1",
      "ID": 1826
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.862601+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4964E143P375VM279277",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279277,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1831,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 104,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.1",
      "ID": 1826
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4964,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.4948943+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3824E84P113VM280025",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280025,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1831,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 104,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.1",
      "ID": 1826
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3824,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.538195+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2066E22P91VM261803",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261803,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1831,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 104,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.1",
      "ID": 1826
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2066,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3788426+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299757",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 299757,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1831,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 104,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.1",
      "ID": 1826
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7213168+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306552",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306552,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1831,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 104,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.1",
      "ID": 1826
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina",
      "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5569627+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2487E146P369VM301243",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 301243,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1831,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 104,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.1",
      "ID": 1826
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2487,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.2534874+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223639",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223639,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1831,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 104,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.1",
      "ID": 1826
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4674379+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237414",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237414,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1831,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 104,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.1",
      "ID": 1826
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1961,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David",
      "DisplayName": "David McLetchie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2031822+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2134E34P201VM297805",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 297805,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1831,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 104,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.1",
      "ID": 1826
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2134,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1257627+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320696",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 320696,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1831,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 104,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.1",
      "ID": 1826
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5041,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan",
      "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1775392+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3763E142P397VM316104",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 316104,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1831,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 104,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.1",
      "ID": 1826
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3763,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart",
      "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9463366+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1986E23P197VM236276",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 236276,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1831,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 104,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.1",
      "ID": 1826
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1986,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan",
      "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.909424+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5047E100P130VM291458",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291458,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1831,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 104,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.1",
      "ID": 1826
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5047,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne",
      "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1201915+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234996",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234996,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1831,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 104,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.1",
      "ID": 1826
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1845,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette",
      "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4091363+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313674",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313674,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1831,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 104,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.1",
      "ID": 1826
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3061,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4055808+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1768E19P265VM288534",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 288534,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1831,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 104,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.1",
      "ID": 1826
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1768,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1475495+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1894E267P527VM224998",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 224998,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1831,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 104,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.1",
      "ID": 1826
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1894,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Neil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7401769+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3815E98P134VM270835",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270835,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1831,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 104,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.1",
      "ID": 1826
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3815,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Park, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Park",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8251726+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265973",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265973,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1831,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 104,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.1",
      "ID": 1826
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2010,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil",
      "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4688682+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283563",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283563,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1831,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 104,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.1",
      "ID": 1826
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5057,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7136496+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2853E33P128VM251078",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251078,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1831,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 104,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.1",
      "ID": 1826
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Pentland",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.2260686+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317915",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317915,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1831,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 104,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.1",
      "ID": 1826
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5009,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4429035+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254741",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254741,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1831,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 104,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.1",
      "ID": 1826
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3745,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis",
      "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2817528+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1870E225P478VM295594",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295594,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1831,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 104,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.1",
      "ID": 1826
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1870,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona",
      "DisplayName": "Shona Robison",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5191702+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2135E254P450VM234829",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234829,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1831,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 104,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.1",
      "ID": 1826
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2135,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Russell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4015298+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1895E232P431VM257326",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257326,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1831,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 104,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.1",
      "ID": 1826
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1895,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0513276+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228077",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 228077,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1831,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 104,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.1",
      "ID": 1826
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1839,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5833725+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2345E10P55VM292023",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 292023,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1831,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 104,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.1",
      "ID": 1826
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2345,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1525515+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2223E176P333VM310635",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 310635,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1831,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 104,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.1",
      "ID": 1826
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2223,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish",
      "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5794091+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2182E87P175VM245990",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 245990,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1831,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 104,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.1",
      "ID": 1826
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2182,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8674696+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298365",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298365,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1831,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 104,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.1",
      "ID": 1826
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5079,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew",
      "DisplayName": "Drew Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3426027+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234367",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234367,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1831,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 104,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.1",
      "ID": 1826
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1769,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.374213+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4014E14P26VM269905",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269905,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1831,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 104,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.1",
      "ID": 1826
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4014,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz",
      "DisplayName": "Liz Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5680437+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269133",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269133,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1831,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 104,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.1",
      "ID": 1826
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2215,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.3050584+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317136",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317136,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1831,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 104,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.1",
      "ID": 1826
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3806,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.1832407+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326162",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 326162,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1831,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 104,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.1",
      "ID": 1826
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5106,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin",
      "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5425472+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241088",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241088,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1831,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 104,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.1",
      "ID": 1826
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1848,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola",
      "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3955682+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2098E237P531VM289550",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289550,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1831,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 104,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.1",
      "ID": 1826
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2098,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Swinney",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4489011+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2674E247P401VM247703",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247703,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1831,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 104,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.1",
      "ID": 1826
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2674,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave",
      "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4248139+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5075E234P371VM284818",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 284818,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1831,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 104,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.1",
      "ID": 1826
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5075,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Torrance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0490769+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1793E151P362VM222398",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 222398,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1831,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 104,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.1",
      "ID": 1826
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1793,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean",
      "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1872368+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5078E245P366VM307147",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307147,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1831,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 104,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.1",
      "ID": 1826
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5078,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Walker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5892876+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1841E231P426VM240190",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 240190,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1831,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 104,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.1",
      "ID": 1826
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1841,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen",
      "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3487308+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283361",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283361,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1831,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 104,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.1",
      "ID": 1826
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4952,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.6973893+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1865E263P500VM232288",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232288,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1831,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 104,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.1",
      "ID": 1826
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1865,
      "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra",
      "DisplayName": "Sandra White",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8482883+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237850",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237850,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1831,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 104,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.1",
      "ID": 1826
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2610,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Wilson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2287587+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309348",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 309348,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1831,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 17,
      "VoteAgainst": 104,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741.1",
      "ID": 1826
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4941,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza",
      "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3254337+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252264",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252264,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1832,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 68,
      "VoteAgainst": 36,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741",
      "ID": 1813
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1926,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian",
      "DisplayName": "Brian Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7214394+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2615E213P388VM257537",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257537,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1832,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 68,
      "VoteAgainst": 36,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741",
      "ID": 1813
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2615,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George",
      "DisplayName": "George Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0608042+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319953",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319953,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1832,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 68,
      "VoteAgainst": 36,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741",
      "ID": 1813
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4940,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare",
      "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9485161+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249676",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 249676,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1832,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 68,
      "VoteAgainst": 36,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741",
      "ID": 1813
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2641,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair",
      "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9450392+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1783E21P273VM227371",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227371,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1832,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 68,
      "VoteAgainst": 36,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741",
      "ID": 1813
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1783,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie",
      "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.547267+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2633E97P136VM280366",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280366,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1832,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 68,
      "VoteAgainst": 36,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741",
      "ID": 1813
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2633,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire",
      "DisplayName": "Claire Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7576276+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262461",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262461,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1832,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 68,
      "VoteAgainst": 36,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741",
      "ID": 1813
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2603,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6029243+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1759E91P115VM229248",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229248,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1832,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 68,
      "VoteAgainst": 36,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741",
      "ID": 1813
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia",
      "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0684652+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270257",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270257,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1832,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 68,
      "VoteAgainst": 36,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741",
      "ID": 1813
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3751,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.7961301+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322826",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 322826,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1832,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 68,
      "VoteAgainst": 36,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741",
      "ID": 1813
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5109,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco",
      "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.7052279+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5060E86P124VM294692",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 294692,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1832,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 68,
      "VoteAgainst": 36,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741",
      "ID": 1813
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5060,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1742327+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242796",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242796,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1832,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 68,
      "VoteAgainst": 36,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741",
      "ID": 1813
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1866,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah",
      "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0359074+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235627",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235627,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1832,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 68,
      "VoteAgainst": 36,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741",
      "ID": 1813
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1943,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic",
      "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6858974+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302117",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 302117,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1832,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 68,
      "VoteAgainst": 36,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741",
      "ID": 1813
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2595,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin",
      "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.297776+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244539",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244539,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1832,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 68,
      "VoteAgainst": 36,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741",
      "ID": 1813
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2103,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith",
      "DisplayName": "Keith Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5592522+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327336",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 327336,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1832,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 68,
      "VoteAgainst": 36,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741",
      "ID": 1813
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:46.0314844+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3775E216P435VM276644",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276644,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1832,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 68,
      "VoteAgainst": 36,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741",
      "ID": 1813
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6749926+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264373",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264373,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1832,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 68,
      "VoteAgainst": 36,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741",
      "ID": 1813
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2673,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick",
      "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1307038+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248852",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248852,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1832,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 68,
      "VoteAgainst": 36,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741",
      "ID": 1813
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2678,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson",
      "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.672819+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2123E27P233VM296344",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 296344,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1832,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 68,
      "VoteAgainst": 36,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741",
      "ID": 1813
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2123,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm",
      "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8449763+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285122",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285122,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1832,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 68,
      "VoteAgainst": 36,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741",
      "ID": 1813
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3907,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0673977+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230138",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230138,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1832,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 68,
      "VoteAgainst": 36,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741",
      "ID": 1813
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1735,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela",
      "DisplayName": "Angela Constance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.1178759+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243924",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 243924,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1832,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 68,
      "VoteAgainst": 36,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741",
      "ID": 1813
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1932,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce",
      "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3257659+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1863E238P523VM255279",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255279,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1832,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 68,
      "VoteAgainst": 36,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741",
      "ID": 1813
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1863,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna",
      "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5240785+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323971",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 323971,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1832,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 68,
      "VoteAgainst": 36,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741",
      "ID": 1813
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4976,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth",
      "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.980397+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5107E223P379VM291876",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291876,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1832,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 68,
      "VoteAgainst": 36,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741",
      "ID": 1813
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5107,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1462752+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3743E222P391VM265137",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265137,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1832,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 68,
      "VoteAgainst": 36,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741",
      "ID": 1813
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3743,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel",
      "DisplayName": "Nigel Don",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1700746+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3771E149P417VM261706",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261706,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1832,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 68,
      "VoteAgainst": 36,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741",
      "ID": 1813
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3771,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob",
      "DisplayName": "Bob Doris",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.369093+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2826E262P384VM282064",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 282064,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1832,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 68,
      "VoteAgainst": 36,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741",
      "ID": 1813
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2826,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Dornan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1740608+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3812E94P117VM297908",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 297908,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1832,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 68,
      "VoteAgainst": 36,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741",
      "ID": 1813
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3812,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia",
      "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.130111+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231635",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231635,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1832,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 68,
      "VoteAgainst": 36,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741",
      "ID": 1813
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1778,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen",
      "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.609079+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4955E240P389VM286175",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286175,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1832,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 68,
      "VoteAgainst": 36,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741",
      "ID": 1813
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4955,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3671272+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219309",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 219309,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1832,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 68,
      "VoteAgainst": 36,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741",
      "ID": 1813
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1742,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle",
      "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.2885336+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238654",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 238654,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1832,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 68,
      "VoteAgainst": 36,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741",
      "ID": 1813
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1994,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus",
      "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4633729+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225480",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225480,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1832,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 68,
      "VoteAgainst": 36,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741",
      "ID": 1813
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1814,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda",
      "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9765336+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321634",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 321634,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1832,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 68,
      "VoteAgainst": 36,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741",
      "ID": 1813
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Fee",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4445149+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1853E35P216VM293274",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 293274,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1832,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 68,
      "VoteAgainst": 36,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741",
      "ID": 1813
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia",
      "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8379176+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1892E12P64VM226879",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 226879,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1832,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 68,
      "VoteAgainst": 36,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741",
      "ID": 1813
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2506467+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5054E95P118VM312633",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 312633,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1832,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 68,
      "VoteAgainst": 36,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741",
      "ID": 1813
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5054,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1367282+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4947E152P361VM257145",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257145,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1832,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 68,
      "VoteAgainst": 36,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741",
      "ID": 1813
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4947,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Finnie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.8252401+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271530",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271530,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1832,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 68,
      "VoteAgainst": 36,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741",
      "ID": 1813
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3901,
      "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe",
      "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0798117+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278509",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 278509,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1832,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 68,
      "VoteAgainst": 36,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741",
      "ID": 1813
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2394,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo",
      "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2219327+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2110E220P414VM286706",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286706,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1832,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 68,
      "VoteAgainst": 36,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741",
      "ID": 1813
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth",
      "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5972486+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250423",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250423,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1832,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 68,
      "VoteAgainst": 36,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741",
      "ID": 1813
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2675,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob",
      "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1889067+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1741E10P50VM220735",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220735,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1832,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 68,
      "VoteAgainst": 36,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741",
      "ID": 1813
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1741,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel",
      "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.654781+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220335",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220335,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1832,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 68,
      "VoteAgainst": 36,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741",
      "ID": 1813
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1756,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine",
      "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6369044+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1860E104P150VM251834",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251834,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1832,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 68,
      "VoteAgainst": 36,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741",
      "ID": 1813
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1860,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda",
      "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.491144+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2033E20P141VM266193",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 266193,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1832,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 68,
      "VoteAgainst": 36,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741",
      "ID": 1813
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2033,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain",
      "DisplayName": "Iain Gray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4783495+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324462",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324462,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1832,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 68,
      "VoteAgainst": 36,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741",
      "ID": 1813
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5042,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2237233+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259956",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 259956,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1832,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 68,
      "VoteAgainst": 36,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741",
      "ID": 1813
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick",
      "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6372894+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239243",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239243,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1832,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 68,
      "VoteAgainst": 36,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741",
      "ID": 1813
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2029,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh",
      "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7283568+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273844",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 273844,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1832,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 68,
      "VoteAgainst": 36,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741",
      "ID": 1813
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3758,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6381066+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304212",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 304212,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1832,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 68,
      "VoteAgainst": 36,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741",
      "ID": 1813
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4086,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Hume",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.0285448+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221804",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221804,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1832,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 68,
      "VoteAgainst": 36,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741",
      "ID": 1813
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1773,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9485198+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1882E227P459VM242039",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242039,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1832,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 68,
      "VoteAgainst": 36,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741",
      "ID": 1813
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1882,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam",
      "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7911888+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223787",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223787,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1832,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 68,
      "VoteAgainst": 36,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741",
      "ID": 1813
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1893,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4737413+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307491",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307491,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1832,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 68,
      "VoteAgainst": 36,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741",
      "ID": 1813
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4934,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8318217+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272162",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 272162,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1832,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 68,
      "VoteAgainst": 36,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741",
      "ID": 1813
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4956,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Keir",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.1142531+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244806",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244806,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1832,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 68,
      "VoteAgainst": 36,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741",
      "ID": 1813
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Kelly",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5794392+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3129E261P419VM314979",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 314979,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1832,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 68,
      "VoteAgainst": 36,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741",
      "ID": 1813
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3129,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6688659+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2080E36P220VM251117",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251117,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1832,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 68,
      "VoteAgainst": 36,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741",
      "ID": 1813
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann",
      "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.2278418+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4016E11P36VM274711",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274711,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1832,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 68,
      "VoteAgainst": 36,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741",
      "ID": 1813
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4016,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1184311+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255874",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255874,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1832,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 68,
      "VoteAgainst": 36,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741",
      "ID": 1813
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2180,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5607176+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4938E158P374VM277843",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277843,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1832,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 68,
      "VoteAgainst": 36,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741",
      "ID": 1813
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4938,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9708306+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2112E250P486VM252937",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252937,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1832,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 68,
      "VoteAgainst": 36,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741",
      "ID": 1813
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2112,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny",
      "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7596574+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4939E258P394VM277231",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277231,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1832,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 68,
      "VoteAgainst": 36,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741",
      "ID": 1813
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4939,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus",
      "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9393339+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325669",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 325669,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1832,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 68,
      "VoteAgainst": 36,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741",
      "ID": 1813
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5074,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon",
      "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.516217+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1828E3P10VM232799",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232799,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1832,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 68,
      "VoteAgainst": 36,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741",
      "ID": 1813
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1828,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo",
      "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8767449+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311337",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311337,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1832,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 68,
      "VoteAgainst": 36,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741",
      "ID": 1813
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4948,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike",
      "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8743515+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2117E90P107VM230487",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230487,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1832,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 68,
      "VoteAgainst": 36,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741",
      "ID": 1813
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2117,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis",
      "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3320905+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267278",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 267278,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1832,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 68,
      "VoteAgainst": 36,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741",
      "ID": 1813
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken",
      "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0125362+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313824",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313824,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1832,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 68,
      "VoteAgainst": 36,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741",
      "ID": 1813
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4966,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek",
      "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4122406+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3101E102P129VM295474",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295474,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1832,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 68,
      "VoteAgainst": 36,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741",
      "ID": 1813
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3101,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala",
      "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5136924+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5034E88P114VM318884",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 318884,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1832,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 68,
      "VoteAgainst": 36,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741",
      "ID": 1813
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5034,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny",
      "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6777245+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306508",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306508,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1832,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 68,
      "VoteAgainst": 36,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741",
      "ID": 1813
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2159,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Martin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5550803+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5110E252P395VM311271",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311271,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1832,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 68,
      "VoteAgainst": 36,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741",
      "ID": 1813
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Mason",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8714748+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268326",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 268326,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1832,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 68,
      "VoteAgainst": 36,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741",
      "ID": 1813
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2133,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2622862+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2876E141P433VM286087",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286087,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1832,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 68,
      "VoteAgainst": 36,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741",
      "ID": 1813
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2876,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3574551+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4951E147P368VM260722",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 260722,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1832,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 68,
      "VoteAgainst": 36,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741",
      "ID": 1813
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4951,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan",
      "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.0894538+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3896E175P307VM264125",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264125,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1832,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 68,
      "VoteAgainst": 36,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741",
      "ID": 1813
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3896,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam",
      "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9253199+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308058",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 308058,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1832,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 68,
      "VoteAgainst": 36,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741",
      "ID": 1813
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8626422+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4964E143P375VM279278",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279278,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1832,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 68,
      "VoteAgainst": 36,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741",
      "ID": 1813
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4964,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.4949354+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3824E84P113VM280026",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280026,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1832,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 68,
      "VoteAgainst": 36,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741",
      "ID": 1813
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3824,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5382366+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2066E22P91VM261802",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261802,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1832,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 68,
      "VoteAgainst": 36,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741",
      "ID": 1813
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2066,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3787816+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299756",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 299756,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1832,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 68,
      "VoteAgainst": 36,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741",
      "ID": 1813
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7212747+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306553",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306553,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1832,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 68,
      "VoteAgainst": 36,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741",
      "ID": 1813
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina",
      "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5570039+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2487E146P369VM301242",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 301242,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1832,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 68,
      "VoteAgainst": 36,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741",
      "ID": 1813
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2487,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.253446+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223640",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223640,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1832,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 68,
      "VoteAgainst": 36,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741",
      "ID": 1813
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4674792+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237415",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237415,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1832,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 68,
      "VoteAgainst": 36,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741",
      "ID": 1813
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1961,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David",
      "DisplayName": "David McLetchie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2032238+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2134E34P201VM297806",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 297806,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1832,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 68,
      "VoteAgainst": 36,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741",
      "ID": 1813
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2134,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1258023+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320697",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 320697,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1832,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 68,
      "VoteAgainst": 36,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741",
      "ID": 1813
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5041,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan",
      "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1775803+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3763E142P397VM316103",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 316103,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1832,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 68,
      "VoteAgainst": 36,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741",
      "ID": 1813
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3763,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart",
      "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9462959+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1986E23P197VM236275",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 236275,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1832,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 68,
      "VoteAgainst": 36,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741",
      "ID": 1813
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1986,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan",
      "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9093822+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5047E100P130VM291459",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291459,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1832,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 68,
      "VoteAgainst": 36,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741",
      "ID": 1813
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5047,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne",
      "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1202323+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234948",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234948,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1832,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 68,
      "VoteAgainst": 36,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741",
      "ID": 1813
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1845,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette",
      "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4067548+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313673",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313673,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1832,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 68,
      "VoteAgainst": 36,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741",
      "ID": 1813
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3061,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4055215+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1768E19P265VM288535",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 288535,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1832,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 68,
      "VoteAgainst": 36,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741",
      "ID": 1813
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1768,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1475913+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1894E267P527VM224999",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 224999,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1832,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 68,
      "VoteAgainst": 36,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741",
      "ID": 1813
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1894,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Neil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7402176+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3815E98P134VM270836",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270836,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1832,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 68,
      "VoteAgainst": 36,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741",
      "ID": 1813
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3815,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Park, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Park",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8252145+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265926",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265926,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1832,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 68,
      "VoteAgainst": 36,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741",
      "ID": 1813
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2010,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil",
      "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4665276+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283562",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283562,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1832,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 68,
      "VoteAgainst": 36,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741",
      "ID": 1813
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5057,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7136098+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2853E33P128VM251079",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251079,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1832,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 68,
      "VoteAgainst": 36,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741",
      "ID": 1813
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Pentland",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.2261094+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317916",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317916,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1832,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 68,
      "VoteAgainst": 36,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741",
      "ID": 1813
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5009,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4429444+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254740",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254740,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1832,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 68,
      "VoteAgainst": 36,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741",
      "ID": 1813
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3745,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis",
      "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2817111+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1870E225P478VM295595",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295595,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1832,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 68,
      "VoteAgainst": 36,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741",
      "ID": 1813
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1870,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona",
      "DisplayName": "Shona Robison",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5192119+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2135E254P450VM234830",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234830,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1832,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 68,
      "VoteAgainst": 36,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741",
      "ID": 1813
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2135,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Russell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4015706+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1895E232P431VM257374",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257374,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1832,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 68,
      "VoteAgainst": 36,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741",
      "ID": 1813
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1895,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0534409+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228078",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 228078,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1832,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 68,
      "VoteAgainst": 36,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741",
      "ID": 1813
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1839,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5834139+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2345E10P55VM292034",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 292034,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1832,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 68,
      "VoteAgainst": 36,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741",
      "ID": 1813
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2345,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.153033+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2223E176P333VM310636",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 310636,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1832,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 68,
      "VoteAgainst": 36,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741",
      "ID": 1813
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2223,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish",
      "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5794502+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2182E87P175VM245991",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 245991,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1832,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 68,
      "VoteAgainst": 36,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741",
      "ID": 1813
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2182,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8675121+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298366",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298366,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1832,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 68,
      "VoteAgainst": 36,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741",
      "ID": 1813
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5079,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew",
      "DisplayName": "Drew Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3426438+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234399",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234399,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1832,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 68,
      "VoteAgainst": 36,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741",
      "ID": 1813
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1769,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3756014+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4014E14P26VM269906",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269906,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1832,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 68,
      "VoteAgainst": 36,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741",
      "ID": 1813
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4014,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz",
      "DisplayName": "Liz Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5680908+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269134",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269134,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1832,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 68,
      "VoteAgainst": 36,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741",
      "ID": 1813
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2215,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.3051067+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317137",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317137,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1832,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 68,
      "VoteAgainst": 36,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741",
      "ID": 1813
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3806,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.1832823+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326161",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 326161,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1832,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 68,
      "VoteAgainst": 36,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741",
      "ID": 1813
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5106,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin",
      "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5425046+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241089",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241089,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1832,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 68,
      "VoteAgainst": 36,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741",
      "ID": 1813
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1848,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola",
      "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3956091+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2098E237P531VM289551",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289551,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1832,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 68,
      "VoteAgainst": 36,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741",
      "ID": 1813
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2098,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Swinney",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.448941+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2674E247P401VM247704",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247704,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1832,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 68,
      "VoteAgainst": 36,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741",
      "ID": 1813
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2674,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave",
      "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4248546+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5075E234P371VM284819",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 284819,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1832,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 68,
      "VoteAgainst": 36,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741",
      "ID": 1813
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5075,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Torrance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0491186+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1793E151P362VM222399",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 222399,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1832,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 68,
      "VoteAgainst": 36,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741",
      "ID": 1813
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1793,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean",
      "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1872778+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5078E245P366VM307146",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307146,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1832,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 68,
      "VoteAgainst": 36,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741",
      "ID": 1813
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5078,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Walker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.589247+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1841E231P426VM240189",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 240189,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1832,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 68,
      "VoteAgainst": 36,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741",
      "ID": 1813
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1841,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen",
      "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3486886+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283362",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283362,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1832,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 68,
      "VoteAgainst": 36,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741",
      "ID": 1813
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4952,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.6974303+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1865E263P500VM232287",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232287,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1832,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 68,
      "VoteAgainst": 36,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741",
      "ID": 1813
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1865,
      "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra",
      "DisplayName": "Sandra White",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8482467+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237849",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237849,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1832,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 68,
      "VoteAgainst": 36,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741",
      "ID": 1813
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2610,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Wilson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2287179+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309347",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 309347,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1832,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 68,
      "VoteAgainst": 36,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Local Government Elections 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01741",
      "ID": 1813
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4941,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza",
      "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3253922+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252265",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252265,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1833,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 118,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Agenda for Cities",
      "Reference": "S4M-01740",
      "ID": 1812
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1926,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian",
      "DisplayName": "Brian Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7214803+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2615E213P388VM257538",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257538,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1833,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 118,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Agenda for Cities",
      "Reference": "S4M-01740",
      "ID": 1812
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2615,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George",
      "DisplayName": "George Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0608444+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319952",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319952,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1833,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 118,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Agenda for Cities",
      "Reference": "S4M-01740",
      "ID": 1812
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4940,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare",
      "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9484751+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249675",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 249675,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1833,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 118,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Agenda for Cities",
      "Reference": "S4M-01740",
      "ID": 1812
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2641,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair",
      "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9449987+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1783E21P273VM227372",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227372,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1833,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 118,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Agenda for Cities",
      "Reference": "S4M-01740",
      "ID": 1812
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1783,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie",
      "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5473292+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2633E97P136VM280367",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280367,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1833,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 118,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Agenda for Cities",
      "Reference": "S4M-01740",
      "ID": 1812
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2633,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire",
      "DisplayName": "Claire Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7576685+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262463",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262463,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1833,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 118,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Agenda for Cities",
      "Reference": "S4M-01740",
      "ID": 1812
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2603,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.6030398+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1759E91P115VM229249",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229249,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1833,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 118,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Agenda for Cities",
      "Reference": "S4M-01740",
      "ID": 1812
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia",
      "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.0685257+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270256",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270256,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1833,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 118,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Agenda for Cities",
      "Reference": "S4M-01740",
      "ID": 1812
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3751,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.7960882+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322676",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 322676,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1833,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 118,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Agenda for Cities",
      "Reference": "S4M-01740",
      "ID": 1812
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5109,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco",
      "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.6989161+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5060E86P124VM294694",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 294694,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1833,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 118,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Agenda for Cities",
      "Reference": "S4M-01740",
      "ID": 1812
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5060,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1743163+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242797",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242797,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1833,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 118,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Agenda for Cities",
      "Reference": "S4M-01740",
      "ID": 1812
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1866,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah",
      "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0359479+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235626",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235626,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1833,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 118,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Agenda for Cities",
      "Reference": "S4M-01740",
      "ID": 1812
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1943,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic",
      "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6858573+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302118",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 302118,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1833,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 118,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Agenda for Cities",
      "Reference": "S4M-01740",
      "ID": 1812
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2595,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin",
      "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.2978171+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244537",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244537,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1833,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 118,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Agenda for Cities",
      "Reference": "S4M-01740",
      "ID": 1812
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2103,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith",
      "DisplayName": "Keith Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5591277+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327337",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 327337,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1833,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 118,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Agenda for Cities",
      "Reference": "S4M-01740",
      "ID": 1812
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:46.0315256+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3775E216P435VM276646",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276646,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1833,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 118,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Agenda for Cities",
      "Reference": "S4M-01740",
      "ID": 1812
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6750744+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264371",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264371,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1833,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 118,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Agenda for Cities",
      "Reference": "S4M-01740",
      "ID": 1812
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2673,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick",
      "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1306209+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248851",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248851,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1833,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 118,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Agenda for Cities",
      "Reference": "S4M-01740",
      "ID": 1812
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2678,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson",
      "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.672778+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2123E27P233VM296343",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 296343,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1833,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 118,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Agenda for Cities",
      "Reference": "S4M-01740",
      "ID": 1812
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2123,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm",
      "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8449351+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285124",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285124,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1833,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 118,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Agenda for Cities",
      "Reference": "S4M-01740",
      "ID": 1812
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3907,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0674794+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230139",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230139,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1833,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 118,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Agenda for Cities",
      "Reference": "S4M-01740",
      "ID": 1812
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1735,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela",
      "DisplayName": "Angela Constance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.1179162+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243923",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 243923,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1833,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 118,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Agenda for Cities",
      "Reference": "S4M-01740",
      "ID": 1812
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1932,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce",
      "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3257253+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1863E238P523VM255278",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255278,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1833,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 118,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Agenda for Cities",
      "Reference": "S4M-01740",
      "ID": 1812
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1863,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna",
      "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5240379+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323972",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 323972,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1833,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 118,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Agenda for Cities",
      "Reference": "S4M-01740",
      "ID": 1812
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4976,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth",
      "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9804379+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5107E223P379VM291875",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291875,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1833,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 118,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Agenda for Cities",
      "Reference": "S4M-01740",
      "ID": 1812
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5107,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1462175+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3743E222P391VM265139",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265139,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1833,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 118,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Agenda for Cities",
      "Reference": "S4M-01740",
      "ID": 1812
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3743,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel",
      "DisplayName": "Nigel Don",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1701567+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3771E149P417VM261707",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261707,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1833,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 118,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Agenda for Cities",
      "Reference": "S4M-01740",
      "ID": 1812
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3771,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob",
      "DisplayName": "Bob Doris",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.369145+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2826E262P384VM282063",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 282063,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1833,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 118,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Agenda for Cities",
      "Reference": "S4M-01740",
      "ID": 1812
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2826,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Dornan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1740186+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3812E94P117VM297942",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 297942,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1833,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 118,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Agenda for Cities",
      "Reference": "S4M-01740",
      "ID": 1812
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3812,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia",
      "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1315614+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231634",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231634,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1833,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 118,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Agenda for Cities",
      "Reference": "S4M-01740",
      "ID": 1812
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1778,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen",
      "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6090384+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4955E240P389VM286174",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286174,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1833,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 118,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Agenda for Cities",
      "Reference": "S4M-01740",
      "ID": 1812
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4955,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3670858+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219310",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 219310,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1833,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 118,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Agenda for Cities",
      "Reference": "S4M-01740",
      "ID": 1812
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1742,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle",
      "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.2885744+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238653",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 238653,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1833,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 118,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Agenda for Cities",
      "Reference": "S4M-01740",
      "ID": 1812
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1994,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus",
      "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4633331+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225479",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225479,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1833,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 118,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Agenda for Cities",
      "Reference": "S4M-01740",
      "ID": 1812
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1814,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda",
      "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.976493+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321784",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 321784,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1833,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 118,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Agenda for Cities",
      "Reference": "S4M-01740",
      "ID": 1812
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Fee",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4512303+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1853E35P216VM293273",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 293273,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1833,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 118,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Agenda for Cities",
      "Reference": "S4M-01740",
      "ID": 1812
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia",
      "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8378697+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1892E12P64VM226880",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 226880,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1833,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 118,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Agenda for Cities",
      "Reference": "S4M-01740",
      "ID": 1812
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2506881+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5054E95P118VM312634",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 312634,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1833,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 118,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Agenda for Cities",
      "Reference": "S4M-01740",
      "ID": 1812
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5054,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1367709+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4947E152P361VM257146",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257146,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1833,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 118,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Agenda for Cities",
      "Reference": "S4M-01740",
      "ID": 1812
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4947,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Finnie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.8252813+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271529",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271529,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1833,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 118,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Agenda for Cities",
      "Reference": "S4M-01740",
      "ID": 1812
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3901,
      "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe",
      "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0797707+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278508",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 278508,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1833,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 118,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Agenda for Cities",
      "Reference": "S4M-01740",
      "ID": 1812
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2394,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo",
      "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2218913+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2110E220P414VM286707",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286707,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1833,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 118,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Agenda for Cities",
      "Reference": "S4M-01740",
      "ID": 1812
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth",
      "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5972883+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250424",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250424,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1833,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 118,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Agenda for Cities",
      "Reference": "S4M-01740",
      "ID": 1812
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2675,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob",
      "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1889482+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1741E10P50VM220736",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220736,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1833,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 118,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Agenda for Cities",
      "Reference": "S4M-01740",
      "ID": 1812
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1741,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel",
      "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6548215+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220334",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220334,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1833,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 118,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Agenda for Cities",
      "Reference": "S4M-01740",
      "ID": 1812
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1756,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine",
      "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6368627+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1860E104P150VM251835",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251835,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1833,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 118,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Agenda for Cities",
      "Reference": "S4M-01740",
      "ID": 1812
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1860,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda",
      "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4911855+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2033E20P141VM266192",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 266192,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1833,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 118,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Agenda for Cities",
      "Reference": "S4M-01740",
      "ID": 1812
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2033,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain",
      "DisplayName": "Iain Gray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4783084+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324461",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324461,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1833,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 118,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Agenda for Cities",
      "Reference": "S4M-01740",
      "ID": 1812
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5042,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2236826+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259955",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 259955,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1833,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 118,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Agenda for Cities",
      "Reference": "S4M-01740",
      "ID": 1812
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick",
      "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6372471+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239244",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239244,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1833,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 118,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Agenda for Cities",
      "Reference": "S4M-01740",
      "ID": 1812
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2029,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh",
      "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7283983+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273842",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 273842,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1833,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 118,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Agenda for Cities",
      "Reference": "S4M-01740",
      "ID": 1812
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3758,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6380248+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304211",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 304211,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1833,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 118,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Agenda for Cities",
      "Reference": "S4M-01740",
      "ID": 1812
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4086,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Hume",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.028482+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221803",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221803,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1833,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 118,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Agenda for Cities",
      "Reference": "S4M-01740",
      "ID": 1812
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1773,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9484798+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1882E227P459VM242038",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242038,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1833,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 118,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Agenda for Cities",
      "Reference": "S4M-01740",
      "ID": 1812
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1882,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam",
      "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7911472+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223786",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223786,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1833,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 118,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Agenda for Cities",
      "Reference": "S4M-01740",
      "ID": 1812
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1893,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4737003+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307526",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307526,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1833,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 118,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Agenda for Cities",
      "Reference": "S4M-01740",
      "ID": 1812
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4934,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8333289+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272163",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 272163,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1833,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 118,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Agenda for Cities",
      "Reference": "S4M-01740",
      "ID": 1812
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4956,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Keir",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.1142943+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244807",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244807,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1833,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 118,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Agenda for Cities",
      "Reference": "S4M-01740",
      "ID": 1812
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Kelly",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5794797+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3129E261P419VM314980",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 314980,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1833,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 118,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Agenda for Cities",
      "Reference": "S4M-01740",
      "ID": 1812
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3129,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6689073+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2080E36P220VM251116",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251116,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1833,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 118,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Agenda for Cities",
      "Reference": "S4M-01740",
      "ID": 1812
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann",
      "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.2277988+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4016E11P36VM274712",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274712,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1833,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 118,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Agenda for Cities",
      "Reference": "S4M-01740",
      "ID": 1812
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4016,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1184726+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2180E246P463VM255873",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255873,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1833,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 118,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Agenda for Cities",
      "Reference": "S4M-01740",
      "ID": 1812
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2180,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5606771+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4938E158P374VM277842",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277842,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1833,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 118,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Agenda for Cities",
      "Reference": "S4M-01740",
      "ID": 1812
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4938,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9707895+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2112E250P486VM252938",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252938,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1833,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 118,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Agenda for Cities",
      "Reference": "S4M-01740",
      "ID": 1812
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2112,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny",
      "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7596983+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4939E258P394VM277230",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277230,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1833,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 118,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Agenda for Cities",
      "Reference": "S4M-01740",
      "ID": 1812
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4939,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus",
      "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9392928+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325670",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 325670,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1833,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 118,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Agenda for Cities",
      "Reference": "S4M-01740",
      "ID": 1812
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5074,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon",
      "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5162571+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1828E3P10VM232800",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232800,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1833,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 118,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Agenda for Cities",
      "Reference": "S4M-01740",
      "ID": 1812
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1828,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo",
      "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8767854+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311373",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311373,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1833,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 118,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Agenda for Cities",
      "Reference": "S4M-01740",
      "ID": 1812
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4948,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike",
      "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8759322+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2117E90P107VM230486",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230486,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1833,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 118,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Agenda for Cities",
      "Reference": "S4M-01740",
      "ID": 1812
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2117,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis",
      "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3320482+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267279",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 267279,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1833,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 118,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Agenda for Cities",
      "Reference": "S4M-01740",
      "ID": 1812
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken",
      "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0125769+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313788",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313788,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1833,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 118,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Agenda for Cities",
      "Reference": "S4M-01740",
      "ID": 1812
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4966,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek",
      "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4106826+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3101E102P129VM295440",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295440,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1833,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 118,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Agenda for Cities",
      "Reference": "S4M-01740",
      "ID": 1812
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3101,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala",
      "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5122437+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5034E88P114VM319034",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319034,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1833,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 118,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Agenda for Cities",
      "Reference": "S4M-01740",
      "ID": 1812
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5034,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny",
      "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6896003+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306507",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306507,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1833,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 118,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Agenda for Cities",
      "Reference": "S4M-01740",
      "ID": 1812
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2159,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Martin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5550333+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5110E252P395VM311270",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311270,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1833,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 118,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Agenda for Cities",
      "Reference": "S4M-01740",
      "ID": 1812
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Mason",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8714334+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268325",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 268325,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1833,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 118,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Agenda for Cities",
      "Reference": "S4M-01740",
      "ID": 1812
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2133,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2622456+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2876E141P433VM286088",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286088,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1833,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 118,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Agenda for Cities",
      "Reference": "S4M-01740",
      "ID": 1812
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2876,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3630844+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4951E147P368VM260721",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 260721,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1833,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 118,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Agenda for Cities",
      "Reference": "S4M-01740",
      "ID": 1812
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4951,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan",
      "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.089394+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3896E175P307VM264124",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264124,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1833,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 118,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Agenda for Cities",
      "Reference": "S4M-01740",
      "ID": 1812
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3896,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam",
      "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.925278+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308059",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 308059,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1833,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 118,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Agenda for Cities",
      "Reference": "S4M-01740",
      "ID": 1812
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8626834+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4964E143P375VM279279",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279279,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1833,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 118,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Agenda for Cities",
      "Reference": "S4M-01740",
      "ID": 1812
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4964,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.4949768+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3824E84P113VM280024",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280024,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1833,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 118,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Agenda for Cities",
      "Reference": "S4M-01740",
      "ID": 1812
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3824,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5381542+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2066E22P91VM261801",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261801,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1833,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 118,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Agenda for Cities",
      "Reference": "S4M-01740",
      "ID": 1812
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2066,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3787406+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299721",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 299721,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1833,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 118,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Agenda for Cities",
      "Reference": "S4M-01740",
      "ID": 1812
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7197664+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3759E260P411VM306554",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306554,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1833,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 118,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Agenda for Cities",
      "Reference": "S4M-01740",
      "ID": 1812
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina",
      "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5570459+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2487E146P369VM301241",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 301241,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1833,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 118,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Agenda for Cities",
      "Reference": "S4M-01740",
      "ID": 1812
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2487,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.2534045+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223641",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223641,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1833,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 118,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Agenda for Cities",
      "Reference": "S4M-01740",
      "ID": 1812
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4675199+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237416",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237416,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1833,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 118,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Agenda for Cities",
      "Reference": "S4M-01740",
      "ID": 1812
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1961,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David",
      "DisplayName": "David McLetchie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2032646+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2134E34P201VM297807",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 297807,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1833,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 118,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Agenda for Cities",
      "Reference": "S4M-01740",
      "ID": 1812
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2134,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1258425+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320392",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 320392,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1833,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 118,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Agenda for Cities",
      "Reference": "S4M-01740",
      "ID": 1812
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5041,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan",
      "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1644327+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3763E142P397VM316102",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 316102,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1833,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 118,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Agenda for Cities",
      "Reference": "S4M-01740",
      "ID": 1812
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3763,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart",
      "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9462549+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1986E23P197VM236277",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 236277,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1833,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 118,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Agenda for Cities",
      "Reference": "S4M-01740",
      "ID": 1812
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1986,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan",
      "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9094651+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5047E100P130VM291457",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291457,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1833,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 118,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Agenda for Cities",
      "Reference": "S4M-01740",
      "ID": 1812
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5047,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne",
      "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1201501+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1845E17P40VM234947",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234947,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1833,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 118,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Agenda for Cities",
      "Reference": "S4M-01740",
      "ID": 1812
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1845,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette",
      "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4067127+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313672",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313672,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1833,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 118,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Agenda for Cities",
      "Reference": "S4M-01740",
      "ID": 1812
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3061,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.40548+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1768E19P265VM288536",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 288536,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1833,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 118,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Agenda for Cities",
      "Reference": "S4M-01740",
      "ID": 1812
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1768,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1476332+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1894E267P527VM225000",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225000,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1833,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 118,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Agenda for Cities",
      "Reference": "S4M-01740",
      "ID": 1812
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1894,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Neil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7402587+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3815E98P134VM270837",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270837,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1833,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 118,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Agenda for Cities",
      "Reference": "S4M-01740",
      "ID": 1812
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3815,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Park, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Park",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8252555+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265925",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265925,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1833,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 118,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Agenda for Cities",
      "Reference": "S4M-01740",
      "ID": 1812
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2010,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil",
      "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4664864+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283561",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283561,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1833,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 118,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Agenda for Cities",
      "Reference": "S4M-01740",
      "ID": 1812
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5057,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7135691+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2853E33P128VM251080",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251080,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1833,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 118,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Agenda for Cities",
      "Reference": "S4M-01740",
      "ID": 1812
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Pentland",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.2261508+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317612",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317612,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1833,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 118,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Agenda for Cities",
      "Reference": "S4M-01740",
      "ID": 1812
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5009,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4299253+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254739",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254739,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1833,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 118,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Agenda for Cities",
      "Reference": "S4M-01740",
      "ID": 1812
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3745,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis",
      "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2816517+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1870E225P478VM295596",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295596,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1833,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 118,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Agenda for Cities",
      "Reference": "S4M-01740",
      "ID": 1812
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1870,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona",
      "DisplayName": "Shona Robison",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.519253+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2135E254P450VM234831",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234831,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1833,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 118,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Agenda for Cities",
      "Reference": "S4M-01740",
      "ID": 1812
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2135,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Russell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4016306+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1895E232P431VM257375",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257375,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1833,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 118,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Agenda for Cities",
      "Reference": "S4M-01740",
      "ID": 1812
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1895,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0534818+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228079",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 228079,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1833,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 118,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Agenda for Cities",
      "Reference": "S4M-01740",
      "ID": 1812
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1839,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.583455+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2345E10P55VM292033",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 292033,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1833,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 118,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Agenda for Cities",
      "Reference": "S4M-01740",
      "ID": 1812
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2345,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1529912+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2223E176P333VM310637",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 310637,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1833,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 118,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Agenda for Cities",
      "Reference": "S4M-01740",
      "ID": 1812
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2223,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish",
      "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5794915+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2182E87P175VM245992",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 245992,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1833,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 118,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Agenda for Cities",
      "Reference": "S4M-01740",
      "ID": 1812
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2182,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.867555+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298364",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298364,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1833,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 118,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Agenda for Cities",
      "Reference": "S4M-01740",
      "ID": 1812
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5079,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew",
      "DisplayName": "Drew Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.342562+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234398",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234398,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1833,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 118,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Agenda for Cities",
      "Reference": "S4M-01740",
      "ID": 1812
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1769,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3755606+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4014E14P26VM269907",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269907,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1833,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 118,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Agenda for Cities",
      "Reference": "S4M-01740",
      "ID": 1812
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4014,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz",
      "DisplayName": "Liz Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5681519+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269135",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269135,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1833,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 118,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Agenda for Cities",
      "Reference": "S4M-01740",
      "ID": 1812
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2215,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.3051482+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317138",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317138,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1833,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 118,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Agenda for Cities",
      "Reference": "S4M-01740",
      "ID": 1812
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3806,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.1833238+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326160",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 326160,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1833,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 118,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Agenda for Cities",
      "Reference": "S4M-01740",
      "ID": 1812
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5106,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin",
      "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5424453+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241090",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241090,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1833,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 118,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Agenda for Cities",
      "Reference": "S4M-01740",
      "ID": 1812
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1848,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola",
      "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3956511+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2098E237P531VM289552",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 289552,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1833,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 118,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Agenda for Cities",
      "Reference": "S4M-01740",
      "ID": 1812
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2098,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Swinney",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.4489815+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2674E247P401VM247705",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247705,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1833,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 118,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Agenda for Cities",
      "Reference": "S4M-01740",
      "ID": 1812
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2674,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave",
      "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4248953+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5075E234P371VM284820",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 284820,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1833,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 118,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Agenda for Cities",
      "Reference": "S4M-01740",
      "ID": 1812
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5075,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Torrance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0491591+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1793E151P362VM222400",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 222400,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1833,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 118,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Agenda for Cities",
      "Reference": "S4M-01740",
      "ID": 1812
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1793,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean",
      "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1873189+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5078E245P366VM307145",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307145,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1833,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 118,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Agenda for Cities",
      "Reference": "S4M-01740",
      "ID": 1812
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5078,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Walker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5892058+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1841E231P426VM240188",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 240188,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1833,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 118,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Agenda for Cities",
      "Reference": "S4M-01740",
      "ID": 1812
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1841,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen",
      "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.348646+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283363",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283363,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1833,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 118,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Agenda for Cities",
      "Reference": "S4M-01740",
      "ID": 1812
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4952,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.6974716+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1865E263P500VM232286",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232286,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1833,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 118,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Agenda for Cities",
      "Reference": "S4M-01740",
      "ID": 1812
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1865,
      "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra",
      "DisplayName": "Sandra White",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8482051+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2610E160P413VM237848",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237848,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1833,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 118,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Agenda for Cities",
      "Reference": "S4M-01740",
      "ID": 1812
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2610,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Wilson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2286762+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309312",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 309312,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1833,
      "AgendaID": 3007,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 118,
      "VoteAgainst": 3,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Agenda for Cities",
      "Reference": "S4M-01740",
      "ID": 1812
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4941,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza",
      "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-19T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3238863+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252245",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252245,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1826,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678.2",
      "ID": 1767
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1926,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian",
      "DisplayName": "Brian Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7206177+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2615E213P388VM257524",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257524,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1826,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678.2",
      "ID": 1767
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2615,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George",
      "DisplayName": "George Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0602485+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319965",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319965,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1826,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678.2",
      "ID": 1767
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4940,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare",
      "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9490279+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249750",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 249750,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1826,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678.2",
      "ID": 1767
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2641,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair",
      "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9484987+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1783E21P273VM227352",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227352,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1826,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678.2",
      "ID": 1767
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1783,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie",
      "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5464662+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2633E97P136VM280349",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280349,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1826,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678.2",
      "ID": 1767
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2633,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire",
      "DisplayName": "Claire Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7568796+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262381",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262381,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1826,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678.2",
      "ID": 1767
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2603,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.5990181+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1759E91P115VM229173",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229173,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1826,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678.2",
      "ID": 1767
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia",
      "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.8376455+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270270",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270270,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1826,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678.2",
      "ID": 1767
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3751,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.7967214+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322807",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 322807,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1826,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678.2",
      "ID": 1767
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5109,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco",
      "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.7044339+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5060E86P124VM294305",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 294305,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1826,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678.2",
      "ID": 1767
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5060,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1326088+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242801",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242801,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1826,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678.2",
      "ID": 1767
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1866,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah",
      "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0361267+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235684",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235684,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1826,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678.2",
      "ID": 1767
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1943,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic",
      "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6886129+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302046",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 302046,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1826,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678.2",
      "ID": 1767
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2595,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin",
      "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.2947264+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244619",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244619,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1826,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678.2",
      "ID": 1767
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2103,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith",
      "DisplayName": "Keith Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5710903+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327324",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 327324,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1826,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678.2",
      "ID": 1767
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:46.0309644+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3775E216P435VM276564",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276564,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1826,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678.2",
      "ID": 1767
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6715762+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264606",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264606,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1826,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678.2",
      "ID": 1767
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2673,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick",
      "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1410636+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248909",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248909,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1826,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678.2",
      "ID": 1767
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2678,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson",
      "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.675247+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2123E27P233VM296356",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 296356,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1826,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678.2",
      "ID": 1767
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2123,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm",
      "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8455144+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3907E217P423VM281329",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 281329,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1826,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678.2",
      "ID": 1767
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3907,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1301511+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230057",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230057,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1826,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678.2",
      "ID": 1767
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1735,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela",
      "DisplayName": "Angela Constance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.1144148+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243918",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 243918,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1826,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678.2",
      "ID": 1767
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1932,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce",
      "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3255199+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1863E238P523VM255354",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255354,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1826,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678.2",
      "ID": 1767
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1863,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna",
      "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5276872+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323959",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 323959,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1826,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678.2",
      "ID": 1767
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4976,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth",
      "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9798757+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5107E223P379VM291888",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291888,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1826,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678.2",
      "ID": 1767
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5107,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1467765+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3743E222P391VM265057",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265057,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1826,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678.2",
      "ID": 1767
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3743,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel",
      "DisplayName": "Nigel Don",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1665884+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3771E149P417VM261694",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261694,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1826,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678.2",
      "ID": 1767
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3771,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob",
      "DisplayName": "Bob Doris",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3685055+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2826E262P384VM282081",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 282081,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1826,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678.2",
      "ID": 1767
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2826,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Dornan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.17486+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3812E94P117VM297892",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 297892,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1826,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678.2",
      "ID": 1767
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3812,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia",
      "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1294478+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231710",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231710,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1826,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678.2",
      "ID": 1767
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1778,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen",
      "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6122398+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4955E240P389VM286188",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286188,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1826,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678.2",
      "ID": 1767
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4955,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3676877+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219251",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 219251,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1826,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678.2",
      "ID": 1767
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1742,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle",
      "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.2849034+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238711",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 238711,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1826,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678.2",
      "ID": 1767
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1994,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus",
      "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.465765+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225713",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225713,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1826,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678.2",
      "ID": 1767
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1814,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda",
      "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9872158+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321653",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 321653,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1826,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678.2",
      "ID": 1767
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Fee",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4453291+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1853E35P216VM293297",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 293297,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1826,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678.2",
      "ID": 1767
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia",
      "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8389153+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1892E12P64VM226822",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 226822,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1826,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678.2",
      "ID": 1767
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2481552+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5054E95P118VM305055",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 305055,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1826,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678.2",
      "ID": 1767
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5054,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.0702389+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4947E152P361VM256766",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 256766,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1826,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678.2",
      "ID": 1767
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4947,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Finnie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.8089591+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271543",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271543,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1826,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678.2",
      "ID": 1767
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3901,
      "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe",
      "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0803785+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278526",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 278526,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1826,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678.2",
      "ID": 1767
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2394,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo",
      "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.222683+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2110E220P414VM286634",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286634,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1826,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678.2",
      "ID": 1767
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth",
      "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5941942+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250349",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250349,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1826,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678.2",
      "ID": 1767
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2675,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob",
      "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1853798+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1741E10P50VM220657",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220657,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1826,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678.2",
      "ID": 1767
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1741,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel",
      "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6509916+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220392",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220392,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1826,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678.2",
      "ID": 1767
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1756,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine",
      "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6393634+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1860E104P150VM251759",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251759,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1826,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678.2",
      "ID": 1767
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1860,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda",
      "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4874814+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2033E20P141VM266212",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 266212,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1826,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678.2",
      "ID": 1767
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2033,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain",
      "DisplayName": "Iain Gray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.7288869+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324474",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324474,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1826,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678.2",
      "ID": 1767
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5042,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2242394+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259969",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 259969,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1826,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678.2",
      "ID": 1767
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick",
      "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.637846+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239186",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239186,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1826,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678.2",
      "ID": 1767
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2029,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh",
      "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.725815+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273924",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 273924,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1826,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678.2",
      "ID": 1767
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3758,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6415539+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304283",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 304283,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1826,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678.2",
      "ID": 1767
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4086,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Hume",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.0315985+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221882",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221882,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1826,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678.2",
      "ID": 1767
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1773,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9518899+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1882E227P459VM242114",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242114,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1826,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678.2",
      "ID": 1767
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1882,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam",
      "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.79445+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223844",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223844,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1826,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678.2",
      "ID": 1767
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1893,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.476189+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307475",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307475,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1826,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678.2",
      "ID": 1767
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4934,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8311178+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4956E241P386VM271932",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271932,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1826,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678.2",
      "ID": 1767
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4956,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Keir",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.1040339+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244794",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244794,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1826,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678.2",
      "ID": 1767
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Kelly",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.578905+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3129E261P419VM314967",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 314967,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1826,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678.2",
      "ID": 1767
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3129,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6683459+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2080E36P220VM251174",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251174,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1826,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678.2",
      "ID": 1767
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann",
      "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.230501+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4016E11P36VM274545",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274545,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1826,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678.2",
      "ID": 1767
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4016,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1112322+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2180E246P463VM256193",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 256193,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1826,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678.2",
      "ID": 1767
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2180,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.574605+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4938E158P374VM277856",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277856,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1826,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678.2",
      "ID": 1767
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4938,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.971384+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2112E250P486VM252575",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252575,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1826,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678.2",
      "ID": 1767
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2112,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny",
      "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7353832+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4939E258P394VM277243",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277243,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1826,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678.2",
      "ID": 1767
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4939,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus",
      "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9398498+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325657",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 325657,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1826,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678.2",
      "ID": 1767
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5074,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon",
      "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5157105+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1828E3P10VM232416",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232416,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1826,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678.2",
      "ID": 1767
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1828,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo",
      "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8599187+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311012",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311012,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1826,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678.2",
      "ID": 1767
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4948,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike",
      "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.6016468+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2117E90P107VM230852",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230852,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1826,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678.2",
      "ID": 1767
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2117,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis",
      "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3482952+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267259",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 267259,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1826,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678.2",
      "ID": 1767
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken",
      "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0117108+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313842",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313842,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1826,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678.2",
      "ID": 1767
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4966,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek",
      "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4130141+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3101E102P129VM295490",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295490,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1826,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678.2",
      "ID": 1767
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3101,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala",
      "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5143899+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5034E88P114VM318903",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 318903,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1826,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678.2",
      "ID": 1767
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5034,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny",
      "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6786762+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306520",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306520,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1826,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678.2",
      "ID": 1767
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2159,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Martin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5555909+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5110E252P395VM311294",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311294,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1826,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678.2",
      "ID": 1767
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Mason",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8724701+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268345",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 268345,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1826,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678.2",
      "ID": 1767
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2133,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2631136+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2876E141P433VM286071",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286071,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1826,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678.2",
      "ID": 1767
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2876,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.356734+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4951E147P368VM260796",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 260796,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1826,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678.2",
      "ID": 1767
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4951,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan",
      "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.0982642+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3896E175P307VM264137",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264137,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1826,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678.2",
      "ID": 1767
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3896,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam",
      "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9258299+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308035",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 308035,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1826,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678.2",
      "ID": 1767
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8616484+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4964E143P375VM279266",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279266,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1826,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678.2",
      "ID": 1767
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4964,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.49442+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3824E84P113VM280106",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280106,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1826,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678.2",
      "ID": 1767
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3824,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5417022+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2066E22P91VM261814",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261814,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1826,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678.2",
      "ID": 1767
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2066,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3793166+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299772",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 299772,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1826,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678.2",
      "ID": 1767
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7219419+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3759E260P411VM303364",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 303364,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1826,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678.2",
      "ID": 1767
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina",
      "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8117863+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2487E146P369VM301725",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 301725,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1826,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678.2",
      "ID": 1767
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2487,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.2804051+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223562",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223562,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1826,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678.2",
      "ID": 1767
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4637904+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237052",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237052,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1826,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678.2",
      "ID": 1767
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1961,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David",
      "DisplayName": "David McLetchie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9519253+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2134E34P201VM297794",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 297794,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1826,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678.2",
      "ID": 1767
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2134,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.125299+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320678",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 320678,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1826,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678.2",
      "ID": 1767
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5041,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan",
      "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1767627+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3763E142P397VM316115",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 316115,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1826,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678.2",
      "ID": 1767
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3763,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart",
      "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9468196+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1986E23P197VM236195",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 236195,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1826,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678.2",
      "ID": 1767
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1986,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan",
      "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9055162+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5047E100P130VM291539",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291539,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1826,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678.2",
      "ID": 1767
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5047,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne",
      "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1236975+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1845E17P40VM235023",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235023,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1826,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678.2",
      "ID": 1767
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1845,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette",
      "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4103206+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313685",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313685,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1826,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678.2",
      "ID": 1767
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3061,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4060541+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1768E19P265VM288512",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 288512,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1826,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678.2",
      "ID": 1767
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1768,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1465951+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1894E267P527VM224942",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 224942,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1826,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678.2",
      "ID": 1767
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1894,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Neil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7377916+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3815E98P134VM270823",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270823,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1826,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678.2",
      "ID": 1767
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3815,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Park, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Park",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8246388+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2010E219P514VM266000",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 266000,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1826,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678.2",
      "ID": 1767
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2010,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil",
      "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4700445+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283574",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283574,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1826,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678.2",
      "ID": 1767
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5057,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.714123+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2853E33P128VM251023",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251023,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1826,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678.2",
      "ID": 1767
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Pentland",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.2236636+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317897",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317897,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1826,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678.2",
      "ID": 1767
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5009,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4421257+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3745E233P381VM255124",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255124,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1826,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678.2",
      "ID": 1767
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3745,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis",
      "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2985277+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1870E225P478VM295572",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295572,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1826,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678.2",
      "ID": 1767
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1870,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona",
      "DisplayName": "Shona Robison",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5179265+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2135E254P450VM233240",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 233240,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1826,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678.2",
      "ID": 1767
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2135,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Russell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.1154876+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1895E232P431VM257299",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257299,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1826,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678.2",
      "ID": 1767
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1895,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0501499+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1839E21P87VM226775",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 226775,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1826,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678.2",
      "ID": 1767
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1839,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2460991+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2345E10P55VM292106",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 292106,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1826,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678.2",
      "ID": 1767
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2345,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1562199+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2223E176P333VM310624",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 310624,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1826,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678.2",
      "ID": 1767
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2223,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish",
      "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5789326+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2182E87P175VM245916",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 245916,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1826,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678.2",
      "ID": 1767
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2182,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8639588+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298443",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298443,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1826,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678.2",
      "ID": 1767
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5079,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew",
      "DisplayName": "Drew Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3463534+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234633",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234633,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1826,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678.2",
      "ID": 1767
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1769,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3927351+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4014E14P26VM269894",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269894,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1826,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678.2",
      "ID": 1767
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4014,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz",
      "DisplayName": "Liz Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5675661+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269116",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269116,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1826,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678.2",
      "ID": 1767
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2215,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.3042725+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317125",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317125,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1826,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678.2",
      "ID": 1767
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3806,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.1827657+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326173",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 326173,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1826,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678.2",
      "ID": 1767
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5106,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin",
      "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5430198+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241014",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241014,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1826,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678.2",
      "ID": 1767
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1848,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola",
      "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.392214+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2098E237P531VM288770",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 288770,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1826,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678.2",
      "ID": 1767
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2098,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Swinney",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1576555+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2674E247P401VM247343",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247343,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1826,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678.2",
      "ID": 1767
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2674,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave",
      "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.3995075+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5075E234P371VM284807",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 284807,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1826,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678.2",
      "ID": 1767
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5075,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Torrance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0486139+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1793E151P362VM222342",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 222342,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1826,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678.2",
      "ID": 1767
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1793,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean",
      "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.184811+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5078E245P366VM307169",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307169,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1826,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678.2",
      "ID": 1767
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5078,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Walker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5902408+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1841E231P426VM240264",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 240264,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1826,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678.2",
      "ID": 1767
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1841,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen",
      "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3519585+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283195",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283195,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1826,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678.2",
      "ID": 1767
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4952,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.4565113+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1865E263P500VM232306",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232306,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1826,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678.2",
      "ID": 1767
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1865,
      "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra",
      "DisplayName": "Sandra White",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8490698+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2610E160P413VM245753",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 245753,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1826,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678.2",
      "ID": 1767
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2610,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Wilson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8569674+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309363",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 309363,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1826,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678.2",
      "ID": 1767
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4941,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza",
      "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.326086+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252246",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252246,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1827,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678",
      "ID": 1746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1926,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian",
      "DisplayName": "Brian Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7206587+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2615E213P388VM257526",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257526,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1827,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678",
      "ID": 1746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2615,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George",
      "DisplayName": "George Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0603309+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319964",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319964,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1827,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678",
      "ID": 1746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4940,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare",
      "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9489866+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249749",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 249749,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1827,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678",
      "ID": 1746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2641,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair",
      "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9484578+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1783E21P273VM227353",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227353,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1827,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678",
      "ID": 1746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1783,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie",
      "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5465076+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2633E97P136VM280350",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280350,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1827,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678",
      "ID": 1746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2633,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire",
      "DisplayName": "Claire Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7569213+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262382",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262382,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1827,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678",
      "ID": 1746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2603,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.5990591+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1759E91P115VM229174",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229174,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1827,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678",
      "ID": 1746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia",
      "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.8376874+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270268",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270268,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1827,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678",
      "ID": 1746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3751,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.7966126+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322808",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 322808,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1827,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678",
      "ID": 1746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5109,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco",
      "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.7044744+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5060E86P124VM294306",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 294306,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1827,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678",
      "ID": 1746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5060,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1326499+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242786",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242786,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1827,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678",
      "ID": 1746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1866,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah",
      "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0354793+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235638",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235638,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1827,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678",
      "ID": 1746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1943,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic",
      "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.686439+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302047",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 302047,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1827,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678",
      "ID": 1746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2595,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin",
      "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.2947856+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244618",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244618,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1827,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678",
      "ID": 1746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2103,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith",
      "DisplayName": "Keith Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5710309+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327325",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 327325,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1827,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678",
      "ID": 1746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:46.0310068+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3775E216P435VM276565",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276565,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1827,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678",
      "ID": 1746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.671617+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264605",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264605,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1827,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678",
      "ID": 1746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2673,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick",
      "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1410228+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248863",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248863,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1827,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678",
      "ID": 1746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2678,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson",
      "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6732891+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2123E27P233VM296355",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 296355,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1827,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678",
      "ID": 1746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2123,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm",
      "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8454542+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3907E217P423VM281330",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 281330,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1827,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678",
      "ID": 1746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3907,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1301919+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230058",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230058,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1827,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678",
      "ID": 1746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1735,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela",
      "DisplayName": "Angela Constance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.1144551+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243934",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 243934,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1827,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678",
      "ID": 1746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1932,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce",
      "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3261988+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1863E238P523VM255353",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255353,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1827,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678",
      "ID": 1746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1863,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna",
      "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5276457+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323960",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 323960,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1827,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678",
      "ID": 1746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4976,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth",
      "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9799171+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5107E223P379VM291887",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291887,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1827,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678",
      "ID": 1746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5107,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.146735+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3743E222P391VM265058",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265058,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1827,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678",
      "ID": 1746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3743,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel",
      "DisplayName": "Nigel Don",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1666482+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3771E149P417VM261695",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261695,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1827,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678",
      "ID": 1746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3771,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob",
      "DisplayName": "Bob Doris",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3685635+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2826E262P384VM282080",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 282080,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1827,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678",
      "ID": 1746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2826,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Dornan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1748183+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3812E94P117VM297893",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 297893,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1827,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678",
      "ID": 1746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3812,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia",
      "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.129488+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231709",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231709,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1827,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678",
      "ID": 1746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1778,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen",
      "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6121987+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4955E240P389VM286186",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286186,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1827,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678",
      "ID": 1746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4955,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3676056+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219298",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 219298,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1827,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678",
      "ID": 1746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1742,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle",
      "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.2877278+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238665",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 238665,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1827,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678",
      "ID": 1746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1994,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus",
      "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.463833+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225557",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225557,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1827,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678",
      "ID": 1746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1814,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda",
      "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9800162+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321652",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 321652,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1827,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678",
      "ID": 1746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Fee",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4452884+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1853E35P216VM293296",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 293296,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1827,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678",
      "ID": 1746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia",
      "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8388738+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1892E12P64VM226868",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 226868,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1827,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678",
      "ID": 1746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2501632+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5054E95P118VM305056",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 305056,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1827,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678",
      "ID": 1746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5054,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.0702794+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4947E152P361VM256767",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 256767,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1827,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678",
      "ID": 1746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4947,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Finnie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.8089995+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271541",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271541,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1827,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678",
      "ID": 1746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3901,
      "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe",
      "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0802951+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278525",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 278525,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1827,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678",
      "ID": 1746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2394,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo",
      "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2226404+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2110E220P414VM286635",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286635,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1827,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678",
      "ID": 1746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth",
      "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5942545+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250350",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250350,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1827,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678",
      "ID": 1746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2675,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob",
      "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1854207+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1741E10P50VM220658",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220658,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1827,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678",
      "ID": 1746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1741,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel",
      "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6510327+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220346",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220346,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1827,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678",
      "ID": 1746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1756,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine",
      "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6373794+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1860E104P150VM251760",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251760,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1827,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678",
      "ID": 1746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1860,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda",
      "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4875221+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2033E20P141VM266211",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 266211,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1827,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678",
      "ID": 1746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2033,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain",
      "DisplayName": "Iain Gray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.7288457+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324473",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324473,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1827,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678",
      "ID": 1746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5042,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.224198+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259967",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 259967,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1827,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678",
      "ID": 1746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick",
      "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.637763+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239232",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239232,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1827,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678",
      "ID": 1746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2029,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh",
      "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7278775+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273923",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 273923,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1827,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678",
      "ID": 1746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3758,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6415126+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304282",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 304282,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1827,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678",
      "ID": 1746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4086,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Hume",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.0315579+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221881",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221881,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1827,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678",
      "ID": 1746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1773,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.951828+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1882E227P459VM242113",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242113,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1827,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678",
      "ID": 1746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1882,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam",
      "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7944087+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223798",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223798,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1827,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678",
      "ID": 1746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1893,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4742148+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307476",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307476,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1827,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678",
      "ID": 1746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4934,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8311601+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4956E241P386VM271933",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271933,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1827,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678",
      "ID": 1746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4956,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Keir",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.1041047+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244795",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244795,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1827,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678",
      "ID": 1746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Kelly",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5789607+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3129E261P419VM314968",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 314968,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1827,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678",
      "ID": 1746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3129,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.668387+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2080E36P220VM251128",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251128,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1827,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678",
      "ID": 1746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann",
      "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.2285411+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4016E11P36VM274547",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274547,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1827,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678",
      "ID": 1746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4016,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1113163+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2180E246P463VM256191",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 256191,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1827,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678",
      "ID": 1746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2180,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5745223+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4938E158P374VM277854",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277854,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1827,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678",
      "ID": 1746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4938,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9713011+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2112E250P486VM252621",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252621,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1827,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678",
      "ID": 1746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2112,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny",
      "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7373539+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4939E258P394VM277242",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277242,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1827,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678",
      "ID": 1746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4939,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus",
      "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9398086+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325658",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 325658,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1827,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678",
      "ID": 1746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5074,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon",
      "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.515752+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1828E3P10VM232417",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232417,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1827,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678",
      "ID": 1746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1828,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo",
      "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.859961+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311013",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311013,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1827,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678",
      "ID": 1746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4948,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike",
      "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.6016877+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2117E90P107VM230806",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230806,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1827,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678",
      "ID": 1746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2117,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis",
      "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3463035+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267260",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 267260,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1827,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678",
      "ID": 1746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken",
      "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0117755+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313841",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313841,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1827,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678",
      "ID": 1746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4966,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek",
      "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4129725+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3101E102P129VM295489",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295489,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1827,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678",
      "ID": 1746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3101,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala",
      "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5143474+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5034E88P114VM318902",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 318902,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1827,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678",
      "ID": 1746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5034,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny",
      "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6786352+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306519",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306519,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1827,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678",
      "ID": 1746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2159,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Martin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5555498+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5110E252P395VM311293",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311293,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1827,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678",
      "ID": 1746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Mason",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.872428+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268344",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 268344,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1827,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678",
      "ID": 1746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2133,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2630709+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2876E141P433VM286072",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286072,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1827,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678",
      "ID": 1746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2876,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3567921+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4951E147P368VM260795",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 260795,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1827,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678",
      "ID": 1746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4951,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan",
      "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.0982221+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3896E175P307VM264136",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264136,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1827,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678",
      "ID": 1746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3896,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam",
      "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9257892+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308036",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 308036,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1827,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678",
      "ID": 1746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.86169+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4964E143P375VM279267",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279267,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1827,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678",
      "ID": 1746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4964,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.4944609+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3824E84P113VM280105",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280105,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1827,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678",
      "ID": 1746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3824,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.541661+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2066E22P91VM261813",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261813,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1827,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678",
      "ID": 1746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2066,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3792562+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299771",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 299771,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1827,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678",
      "ID": 1746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.721901+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3759E260P411VM303365",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 303365,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1827,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678",
      "ID": 1746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina",
      "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8118288+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2487E146P369VM301724",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 301724,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1827,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678",
      "ID": 1746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2487,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.2803629+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223563",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223563,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1827,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678",
      "ID": 1746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4638316+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237404",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237404,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1827,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678",
      "ID": 1746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1961,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David",
      "DisplayName": "David McLetchie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2027377+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2134E34P201VM297795",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 297795,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1827,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678",
      "ID": 1746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2134,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1253391+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320679",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 320679,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1827,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678",
      "ID": 1746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5041,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan",
      "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1768036+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3763E142P397VM316114",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 316114,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1827,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678",
      "ID": 1746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3763,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart",
      "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9467778+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1986E23P197VM236196",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 236196,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1827,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678",
      "ID": 1746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1986,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan",
      "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9055611+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5047E100P130VM291538",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291538,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1827,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678",
      "ID": 1746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5047,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne",
      "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1236555+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1845E17P40VM235022",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235022,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1827,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678",
      "ID": 1746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1845,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette",
      "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4102606+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313684",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313684,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1827,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678",
      "ID": 1746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3061,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.406012+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1768E19P265VM288513",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 288513,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1827,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678",
      "ID": 1746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1768,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1466378+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1894E267P527VM224988",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 224988,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1827,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678",
      "ID": 1746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1894,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Neil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7397449+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3815E98P134VM270825",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270825,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1827,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678",
      "ID": 1746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3815,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Park, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Park",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8247441+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265999",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265999,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1827,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678",
      "ID": 1746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2010,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil",
      "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4700037+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283573",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283573,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1827,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678",
      "ID": 1746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5057,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7140808+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2853E33P128VM251068",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251068,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1827,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678",
      "ID": 1746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Pentland",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.2256361+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317898",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317898,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1827,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678",
      "ID": 1746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5009,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.442167+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3745E233P381VM255123",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255123,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1827,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678",
      "ID": 1746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3745,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis",
      "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.298486+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1870E225P478VM295573",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295573,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1827,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678",
      "ID": 1746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1870,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona",
      "DisplayName": "Shona Robison",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5179667+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2135E254P450VM234819",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234819,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1827,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678",
      "ID": 1746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2135,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Russell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4010985+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1895E232P431VM257300",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257300,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1827,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678",
      "ID": 1746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1895,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0502125+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1839E21P87VM226776",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 226776,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1827,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678",
      "ID": 1746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1839,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2461397+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2345E10P55VM292105",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 292105,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1827,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678",
      "ID": 1746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2345,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1561777+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2223E176P333VM310625",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 310625,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1827,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678",
      "ID": 1746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2223,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish",
      "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5789746+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2182E87P175VM245917",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 245917,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1827,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678",
      "ID": 1746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2182,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8639997+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298442",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298442,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1827,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678",
      "ID": 1746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5079,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew",
      "DisplayName": "Drew Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3463115+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234632",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234632,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1827,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678",
      "ID": 1746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1769,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3926934+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4014E14P26VM269895",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269895,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1827,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678",
      "ID": 1746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4014,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz",
      "DisplayName": "Liz Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5676074+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269117",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269117,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1827,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678",
      "ID": 1746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2215,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.3043141+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317126",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317126,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1827,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678",
      "ID": 1746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3806,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.1828066+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326172",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 326172,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1827,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678",
      "ID": 1746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5106,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin",
      "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5429776+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241015",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241015,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1827,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678",
      "ID": 1746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1848,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola",
      "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3922867+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2098E237P531VM288771",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 288771,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1827,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678",
      "ID": 1746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2098,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Swinney",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1576978+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2674E247P401VM247693",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247693,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1827,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678",
      "ID": 1746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2674,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave",
      "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4243788+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5075E234P371VM284808",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 284808,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1827,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678",
      "ID": 1746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5075,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Torrance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0486562+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1793E151P362VM222388",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 222388,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1827,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678",
      "ID": 1746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1793,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean",
      "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1868031+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5078E245P366VM307168",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307168,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1827,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678",
      "ID": 1746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5078,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Walker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5901996+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1841E231P426VM240263",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 240263,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1827,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678",
      "ID": 1746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1841,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen",
      "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3519174+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283197",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283197,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1827,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678",
      "ID": 1746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4952,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.6898622+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1865E263P500VM232305",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232305,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1827,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678",
      "ID": 1746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1865,
      "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra",
      "DisplayName": "Sandra White",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8490281+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2610E160P413VM245707",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 245707,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1827,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678",
      "ID": 1746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2610,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Wilson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8549854+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309362",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 309362,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1827,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Carried",
      "VoteFor": 67,
      "VoteAgainst": 56,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Scotland's Future",
      "Reference": "S4M-01678",
      "ID": 1746
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4941,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza",
      "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3260274+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252247",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252247,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1828,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 58,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.3",
      "ID": 1765
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1926,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian",
      "DisplayName": "Brian Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7206998+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2615E213P388VM257527",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257527,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1828,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 58,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.3",
      "ID": 1765
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2615,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George",
      "DisplayName": "George Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0603924+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319963",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319963,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1828,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 58,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.3",
      "ID": 1765
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4940,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare",
      "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9489455+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249688",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 249688,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1828,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 58,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.3",
      "ID": 1765
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2641,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair",
      "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9455375+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1783E21P273VM227354",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227354,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1828,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 58,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.3",
      "ID": 1765
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1783,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie",
      "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5465492+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2633E97P136VM280351",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280351,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1828,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 58,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.3",
      "ID": 1765
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2633,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire",
      "DisplayName": "Claire Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7569822+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262383",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262383,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1828,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 58,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.3",
      "ID": 1765
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2603,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.5991007+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1759E91P115VM229175",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229175,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1828,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 58,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.3",
      "ID": 1765
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia",
      "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.8377292+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270267",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270267,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1828,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 58,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.3",
      "ID": 1765
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3751,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.7965694+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322809",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 322809,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1828,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 58,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.3",
      "ID": 1765
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5109,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco",
      "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.7045153+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5060E86P124VM294307",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 294307,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1828,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 58,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.3",
      "ID": 1765
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5060,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1326923+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242787",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242787,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1828,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 58,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.3",
      "ID": 1765
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1866,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah",
      "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0355201+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235637",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235637,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1828,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 58,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.3",
      "ID": 1765
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1943,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic",
      "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.686399+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302048",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 302048,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1828,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 58,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.3",
      "ID": 1765
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2595,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin",
      "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.2948276+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244617",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244617,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1828,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 58,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.3",
      "ID": 1765
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2103,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith",
      "DisplayName": "Keith Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5709901+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327326",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 327326,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1828,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 58,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.3",
      "ID": 1765
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:46.031049+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3775E216P435VM276566",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276566,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1828,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 58,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.3",
      "ID": 1765
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6716577+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264604",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264604,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1828,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 58,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.3",
      "ID": 1765
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2673,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick",
      "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1409818+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248862",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248862,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1828,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 58,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.3",
      "ID": 1765
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2678,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson",
      "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6732482+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2123E27P233VM296354",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 296354,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1828,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 58,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.3",
      "ID": 1765
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2123,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm",
      "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8454128+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3907E217P423VM281331",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 281331,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1828,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 58,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.3",
      "ID": 1765
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3907,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1302333+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230059",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230059,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1828,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 58,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.3",
      "ID": 1765
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1735,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela",
      "DisplayName": "Angela Constance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.1145146+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243933",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 243933,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1828,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 58,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.3",
      "ID": 1765
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1932,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce",
      "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3261575+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1863E238P523VM255352",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255352,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1828,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 58,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.3",
      "ID": 1765
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1863,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna",
      "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5276037+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323961",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 323961,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1828,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 58,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.3",
      "ID": 1765
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4976,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth",
      "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.97996+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5107E223P379VM291886",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291886,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1828,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 58,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.3",
      "ID": 1765
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5107,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1466769+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3743E222P391VM265059",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265059,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1828,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 58,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.3",
      "ID": 1765
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3743,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel",
      "DisplayName": "Nigel Don",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1666918+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3771E149P417VM261696",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261696,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1828,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 58,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.3",
      "ID": 1765
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3771,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob",
      "DisplayName": "Bob Doris",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3686057+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2826E262P384VM282079",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 282079,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1828,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 58,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.3",
      "ID": 1765
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2826,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Dornan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1747758+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3812E94P117VM297894",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 297894,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1828,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 58,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.3",
      "ID": 1765
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3812,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia",
      "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1295288+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231708",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231708,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1828,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 58,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.3",
      "ID": 1765
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1778,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen",
      "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6121574+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4955E240P389VM286185",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286185,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1828,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 58,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.3",
      "ID": 1765
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4955,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3675647+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219299",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 219299,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1828,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 58,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.3",
      "ID": 1765
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1742,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle",
      "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.2878176+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238664",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 238664,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1828,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 58,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.3",
      "ID": 1765
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1994,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus",
      "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.4637932+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225555",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225555,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1828,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 58,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.3",
      "ID": 1765
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1814,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda",
      "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9799334+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321651",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 321651,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1828,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 58,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.3",
      "ID": 1765
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Fee",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4452475+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1853E35P216VM293295",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 293295,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1828,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 58,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.3",
      "ID": 1765
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia",
      "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8388325+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1892E12P64VM226869",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 226869,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1828,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 58,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.3",
      "ID": 1765
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2502064+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5054E95P118VM305057",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 305057,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1828,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 58,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.3",
      "ID": 1765
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5054,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.0703202+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4947E152P361VM257133",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257133,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1828,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 58,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.3",
      "ID": 1765
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4947,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Finnie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.8247271+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271540",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271540,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1828,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 58,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.3",
      "ID": 1765
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3901,
      "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe",
      "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0802534+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278524",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 278524,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1828,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 58,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.3",
      "ID": 1765
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2394,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo",
      "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2225991+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2110E220P414VM286636",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286636,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1828,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 58,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.3",
      "ID": 1765
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth",
      "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5942959+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250411",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250411,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1828,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 58,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.3",
      "ID": 1765
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2675,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob",
      "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1883835+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1741E10P50VM220660",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220660,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1828,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 58,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.3",
      "ID": 1765
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1741,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel",
      "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6511157+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220345",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220345,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1828,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 58,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.3",
      "ID": 1765
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1756,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine",
      "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6373379+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1860E104P150VM251761",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251761,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1828,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 58,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.3",
      "ID": 1765
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1860,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda",
      "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4875636+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2033E20P141VM266210",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 266210,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1828,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 58,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.3",
      "ID": 1765
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2033,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain",
      "DisplayName": "Iain Gray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.7288037+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324472",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324472,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1828,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 58,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.3",
      "ID": 1765
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5042,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2241571+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259966",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 259966,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1828,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 58,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.3",
      "ID": 1765
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick",
      "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6377193+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239233",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239233,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1828,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 58,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.3",
      "ID": 1765
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2029,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh",
      "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7279198+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273922",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 273922,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1828,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 58,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.3",
      "ID": 1765
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3758,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6414703+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304281",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 304281,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1828,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 58,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.3",
      "ID": 1765
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4086,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Hume",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.0315175+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221879",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221879,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1828,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 58,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.3",
      "ID": 1765
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1773,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.951745+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1882E227P459VM242051",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242051,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1828,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 58,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.3",
      "ID": 1765
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1882,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam",
      "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.791704+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223797",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223797,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1828,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 58,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.3",
      "ID": 1765
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1893,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4741739+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307477",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307477,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1828,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 58,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.3",
      "ID": 1765
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4934,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8312015+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272150",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 272150,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1828,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 58,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.3",
      "ID": 1765
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4956,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Keir",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.1137429+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244796",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244796,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1828,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 58,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.3",
      "ID": 1765
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Kelly",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5790046+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3129E261P419VM314969",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 314969,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1828,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 58,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.3",
      "ID": 1765
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3129,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6684283+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2080E36P220VM251127",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251127,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1828,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 58,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.3",
      "ID": 1765
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann",
      "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.2284991+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4016E11P36VM274701",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274701,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1828,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 58,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.3",
      "ID": 1765
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4016,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.117993+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2180E246P463VM256190",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 256190,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1828,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 58,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.3",
      "ID": 1765
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2180,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.5744808+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4938E158P374VM277853",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277853,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1828,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 58,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.3",
      "ID": 1765
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4938,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9712601+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2112E250P486VM252622",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252622,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1828,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 58,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.3",
      "ID": 1765
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2112,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny",
      "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7373952+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4939E258P394VM277241",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277241,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1828,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 58,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.3",
      "ID": 1765
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4939,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus",
      "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9397676+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325659",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 325659,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1828,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 58,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.3",
      "ID": 1765
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5074,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon",
      "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5157924+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1828E3P10VM232418",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232418,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1828,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 58,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.3",
      "ID": 1765
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1828,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo",
      "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8600029+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311014",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311014,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1828,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 58,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.3",
      "ID": 1765
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4948,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike",
      "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.6017291+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2117E90P107VM230805",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230805,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1828,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 58,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.3",
      "ID": 1765
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2117,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis",
      "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3462624+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267261",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 267261,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1828,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 58,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.3",
      "ID": 1765
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken",
      "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0118188+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313840",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313840,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1828,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 58,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.3",
      "ID": 1765
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4966,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek",
      "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4129305+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3101E102P129VM295488",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295488,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1828,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 58,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.3",
      "ID": 1765
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3101,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala",
      "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.514287+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5034E88P114VM318901",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 318901,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1828,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 58,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.3",
      "ID": 1765
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5034,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny",
      "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6785944+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306518",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306518,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1828,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 58,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.3",
      "ID": 1765
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2159,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Martin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5555082+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5110E252P395VM311292",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311292,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1828,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 58,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.3",
      "ID": 1765
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Mason",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8723859+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268343",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 268343,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1828,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 58,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.3",
      "ID": 1765
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2133,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.263029+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2876E141P433VM286073",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286073,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1828,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 58,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.3",
      "ID": 1765
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2876,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3568353+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4951E147P368VM260734",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 260734,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1828,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 58,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.3",
      "ID": 1765
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4951,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan",
      "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.0899671+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3896E175P307VM264135",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264135,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1828,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 58,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.3",
      "ID": 1765
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3896,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam",
      "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9257473+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308037",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 308037,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1828,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 58,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.3",
      "ID": 1765
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8617314+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4964E143P375VM279268",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279268,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1828,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 58,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.3",
      "ID": 1765
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4964,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.4945027+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3824E84P113VM280104",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280104,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1828,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 58,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.3",
      "ID": 1765
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3824,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.54162+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2066E22P91VM261812",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261812,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1828,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 58,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.3",
      "ID": 1765
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2066,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3792144+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299770",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 299770,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1828,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 58,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.3",
      "ID": 1765
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7218607+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3759E260P411VM303366",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 303366,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1828,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 58,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.3",
      "ID": 1765
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina",
      "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8119847+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2487E146P369VM301723",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 301723,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1828,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 58,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.3",
      "ID": 1765
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2487,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.2803201+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223565",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223565,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1828,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 58,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.3",
      "ID": 1765
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4639148+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237405",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237405,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1828,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 58,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.3",
      "ID": 1765
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1961,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David",
      "DisplayName": "David McLetchie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2027855+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2134E34P201VM297796",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 297796,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1828,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 58,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.3",
      "ID": 1765
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2134,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.12538+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320680",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 320680,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1828,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 58,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.3",
      "ID": 1765
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5041,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan",
      "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1768453+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3763E142P397VM316113",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 316113,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1828,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 58,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.3",
      "ID": 1765
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3763,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart",
      "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9467361+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1986E23P197VM236197",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 236197,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1828,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 58,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.3",
      "ID": 1765
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1986,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan",
      "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.905605+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5047E100P130VM291537",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291537,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1828,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 58,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.3",
      "ID": 1765
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5047,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne",
      "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1236131+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1845E17P40VM235021",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235021,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1828,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 58,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.3",
      "ID": 1765
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1845,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette",
      "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4102186+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313683",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313683,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1828,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 58,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.3",
      "ID": 1765
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3061,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4059521+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1768E19P265VM288514",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 288514,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1828,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 58,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.3",
      "ID": 1765
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1768,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1466799+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1894E267P527VM224989",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 224989,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1828,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 58,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.3",
      "ID": 1765
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1894,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Neil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7397852+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3815E98P134VM270826",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270826,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1828,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 58,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.3",
      "ID": 1765
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3815,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Park, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Park",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8247866+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265998",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265998,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1828,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 58,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.3",
      "ID": 1765
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2010,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil",
      "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4699627+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283572",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283572,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1828,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 58,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.3",
      "ID": 1765
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5057,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7140396+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2853E33P128VM251069",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251069,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1828,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 58,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.3",
      "ID": 1765
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Pentland",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.2256776+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317899",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317899,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1828,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 58,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.3",
      "ID": 1765
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5009,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4422273+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254752",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254752,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1828,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 58,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.3",
      "ID": 1765
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3745,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis",
      "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2822221+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1870E225P478VM295574",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295574,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1828,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 58,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.3",
      "ID": 1765
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1870,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona",
      "DisplayName": "Shona Robison",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5180079+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2135E254P450VM234820",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234820,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1828,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 58,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.3",
      "ID": 1765
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2135,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Russell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4011586+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1895E232P431VM257301",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257301,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1828,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 58,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.3",
      "ID": 1765
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1895,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0502554+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228067",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 228067,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1828,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 58,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.3",
      "ID": 1765
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1839,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.582943+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2345E10P55VM292104",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 292104,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1828,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 58,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.3",
      "ID": 1765
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2345,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1561185+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2223E176P333VM310626",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 310626,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1828,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 58,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.3",
      "ID": 1765
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2223,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish",
      "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5790159+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2182E87P175VM245979",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 245979,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1828,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 58,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.3",
      "ID": 1765
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2182,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8669825+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298441",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298441,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1828,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 58,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.3",
      "ID": 1765
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5079,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew",
      "DisplayName": "Drew Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3462699+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234631",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234631,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1828,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 58,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.3",
      "ID": 1765
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1769,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3926521+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4014E14P26VM269896",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269896,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1828,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 58,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.3",
      "ID": 1765
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4014,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz",
      "DisplayName": "Liz Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5676667+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269118",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269118,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1828,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 58,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.3",
      "ID": 1765
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2215,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.304356+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317127",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317127,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1828,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 58,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.3",
      "ID": 1765
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3806,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.1828479+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326171",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 326171,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1828,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 58,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.3",
      "ID": 1765
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5106,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin",
      "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5429175+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241077",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241077,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1828,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 58,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.3",
      "ID": 1765
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1848,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola",
      "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3950867+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2098E237P531VM288772",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 288772,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1828,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 58,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.3",
      "ID": 1765
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2098,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Swinney",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1577386+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2674E247P401VM247694",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247694,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1828,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 58,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.3",
      "ID": 1765
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2674,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave",
      "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4244202+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5075E234P371VM284809",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 284809,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1828,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 58,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.3",
      "ID": 1765
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5075,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Torrance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0486969+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1793E151P362VM222389",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 222389,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1828,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 58,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.3",
      "ID": 1765
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1793,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean",
      "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1868448+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5078E245P366VM307167",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307167,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1828,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 58,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.3",
      "ID": 1765
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5078,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Walker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.590158+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1841E231P426VM240201",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 240201,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1828,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 58,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.3",
      "ID": 1765
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1841,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen",
      "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.349217+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283198",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283198,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1828,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 58,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.3",
      "ID": 1765
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4952,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.6899328+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1865E263P500VM232304",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232304,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1828,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 58,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.3",
      "ID": 1765
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1865,
      "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra",
      "DisplayName": "Sandra White",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8489868+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2610E160P413VM245706",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 245706,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1828,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 58,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.3",
      "ID": 1765
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2610,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Wilson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.854945+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309361",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 309361,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1828,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 58,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.3",
      "ID": 1765
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4941,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza",
      "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3259871+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1926E229P470VM252248",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252248,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1829,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.1",
      "ID": 1748
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1926,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, Brian",
      "DisplayName": "Brian Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Donside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7207413+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2615E213P388VM257528",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257528,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1829,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.1",
      "ID": 1748
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2615,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adam, George",
      "DisplayName": "George Adam",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Paisley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0604348+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4940E159P373VM319962",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 319962,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1829,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.1",
      "ID": 1748
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4940,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Adamson, Clare",
      "DisplayName": "Clare Adamson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.9489045+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2641E256P403VM249687",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 249687,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1829,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.1",
      "ID": 1748
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2641,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Allan, Dr Alasdair",
      "DisplayName": "Alasdair Allan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Na h-Eileanan an Iar"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.9454977+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1783E21P273VM227355",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 227355,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1829,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.1",
      "ID": 1748
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1783,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baillie, Jackie",
      "DisplayName": "Jackie Baillie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumbarton"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5465901+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2633E97P136VM280352",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280352,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1829,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.1",
      "ID": 1748
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2633,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Claire",
      "DisplayName": "Claire Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.7570253+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2603E89P148VM262472",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 262472,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1829,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.1",
      "ID": 1748
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2603,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Baker, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Baker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.603409+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1759E91P115VM229176",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 229176,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1829,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.1",
      "ID": 1748
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beamish, Claudia",
      "DisplayName": "Claudia Beamish",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.8377704+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3751E243P383VM270266",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270266,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1829,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.1",
      "ID": 1748
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3751,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Beattie, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Beattie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian North and Musselburgh"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.7965272+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5109E249P380VM322810",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 322810,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1829,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.1",
      "ID": 1748
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5109,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Biagi, Marco",
      "DisplayName": "Marco Biagi",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.7045555+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5060E86P124VM294703",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 294703,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1829,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.1",
      "ID": 1748
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5060,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Bibby, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Bibby",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.1747036+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1866E93P239VM242788",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242788,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1829,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.1",
      "ID": 1748
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1866,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Boyack, Sarah",
      "DisplayName": "Sarah Boyack",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.0355604+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1943E145P367VM235636",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235636,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1829,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.1",
      "ID": 1748
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1943,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brodie, Chic",
      "DisplayName": "Chic Brodie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.6863584+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2595E12P30VM302129",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 302129,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1829,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.1",
      "ID": 1748
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2595,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Gavin",
      "DisplayName": "Gavin Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.2983031+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2103E244P421VM244528",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244528,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1829,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.1",
      "ID": 1748
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2103,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Brown, Keith",
      "DisplayName": "Keith Brown",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clackmannanshire and Dunblane"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5586702+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5108E221P387VM327327",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 327327,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1829,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.1",
      "ID": 1748
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Burgess, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Burgess",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:46.0310908+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3775E216P435VM276655",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 276655,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1829,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.1",
      "ID": 1748
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydesdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.6754691+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2673E236P377VM264362",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264362,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1829,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.1",
      "ID": 1748
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2673,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Campbell, Roderick",
      "DisplayName": "Roderick Campbell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1302367+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2678E11P28VM248861",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 248861,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1829,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.1",
      "ID": 1748
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2678,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Carlaw, Jackson",
      "DisplayName": "Jackson Carlaw",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.6732076+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2123E27P233VM296353",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 296353,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1829,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.1",
      "ID": 1748
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2123,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Chisholm, Malcolm",
      "DisplayName": "Malcolm Chisholm",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Northern and Leith"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.8453708+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3907E217P423VM285133",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 285133,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1829,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.1",
      "ID": 1748
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3907,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Coffey, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Coffey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0678688+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1735E248P405VM230148",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230148,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1829,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.1",
      "ID": 1748
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1735,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Constance, Angela",
      "DisplayName": "Angela Constance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Almond Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.1183004+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1932E239P485VM243932",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 243932,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1829,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.1",
      "ID": 1748
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1932,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Crawford, Bruce",
      "DisplayName": "Bruce Crawford",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Stirling"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.3261164+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1863E238P523VM255351",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 255351,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1829,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.1",
      "ID": 1748
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1863,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Cunningham, Roseanna",
      "DisplayName": "Roseanna Cunningham",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire South and Kinross-shire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.527562+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4976E20P31VM323962",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 323962,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1829,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.1",
      "ID": 1748
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4976,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Davidson, Ruth",
      "DisplayName": "Ruth Davidson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.9800018+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5107E223P379VM291885",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291885,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1829,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.1",
      "ID": 1748
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5107,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dey, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Dey",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1466366+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3743E222P391VM265148",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265148,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1829,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.1",
      "ID": 1748
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3743,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Don, Nigel",
      "DisplayName": "Nigel Don",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Angus North and Mearns"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.1705532+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3771E149P417VM261697",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261697,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1829,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.1",
      "ID": 1748
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3771,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Doris, Bob",
      "DisplayName": "Bob Doris",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3686463+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2826E262P384VM282078",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 282078,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1829,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.1",
      "ID": 1748
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2826,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dornan, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Dornan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Cathcart"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.1747335+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3812E94P117VM297895",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 297895,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1829,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.1",
      "ID": 1748
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3812,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Dugdale, Kezia",
      "DisplayName": "Kezia Dugdale",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1295687+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1778E28P260VM231707",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 231707,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1829,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.1",
      "ID": 1748
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1778,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Helen",
      "DisplayName": "Helen Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cowdenbeath"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.6120995+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4955E240P389VM286184",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286184,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1829,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.1",
      "ID": 1748
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4955,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Eadie, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Eadie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Southern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.3675231+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1742E154P364VM219300",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 219300,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1829,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.1",
      "ID": 1748
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1742,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Annabelle",
      "DisplayName": "Annabelle Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.2879085+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1994E257P537VM238663",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 238663,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1829,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.1",
      "ID": 1748
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1994,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ewing, Fergus",
      "DisplayName": "Fergus Ewing",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Inverness and Nairn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.463753+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1814E269P519VM225490",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 225490,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1829,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.1",
      "ID": 1748
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1814,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fabiani, Linda",
      "DisplayName": "Linda Fabiani",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Kilbride"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.9769695+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5059E85P123VM321650",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 321650,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1829,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.1",
      "ID": 1748
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fee, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Fee",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.4452072+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1853E35P216VM293294",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 293294,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1829,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.1",
      "ID": 1748
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ferguson, Patricia",
      "DisplayName": "Patricia Ferguson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.8387908+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1892E12P64VM226870",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 226870,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1829,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.1",
      "ID": 1748
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fergusson, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Fergusson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Galloway and West Dumfries"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.2502487+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5054E95P118VM312645",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 312645,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1829,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.1",
      "ID": 1748
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5054,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Findlay, Neil",
      "DisplayName": "Neil Findlay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.1372391+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4947E152P361VM257134",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257134,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1829,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.1",
      "ID": 1748
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4947,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Finnie, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Finnie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.8247678+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3901E226P428VM271539",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 271539,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1829,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.1",
      "ID": 1748
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3901,
      "ParliamentaryName": "FitzPatrick, Joe",
      "DisplayName": "Joe FitzPatrick",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.0802114+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2394E15P47VM278523",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 278523,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1829,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.1",
      "ID": 1748
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2394,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Fraser, Murdo",
      "DisplayName": "Murdo Fraser",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.2225578+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2110E220P414VM286637",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286637,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1829,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.1",
      "ID": 1748
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Kenneth",
      "DisplayName": "Kenneth Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cunninghame North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.5943361+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2675E255P440VM250412",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 250412,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1829,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.1",
      "ID": 1748
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2675,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gibson, Rob",
      "DisplayName": "Rob Gibson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Caithness, Sutherland and Ross"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.1884271+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1741E10P50VM220725",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220725,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1829,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.1",
      "ID": 1748
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1741,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Goldie, Annabel",
      "DisplayName": "Annabel Goldie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6543534+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1756E218P467VM220344",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 220344,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1829,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.1",
      "ID": 1748
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1756,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grahame, Christine",
      "DisplayName": "Christine Grahame",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.6372966+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1860E104P150VM251762",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251762,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1829,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.1",
      "ID": 1748
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1860,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Grant, Rhoda",
      "DisplayName": "Rhoda Grant",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.4876241+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2033E20P141VM266209",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 266209,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1829,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.1",
      "ID": 1748
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2033,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Gray, Iain",
      "DisplayName": "Iain Gray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "East Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.7287619+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5042E109P120VM324471",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 324471,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1829,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.1",
      "ID": 1748
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5042,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Griffin, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark Griffin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.2241166+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2892E76P97VM259965",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 259965,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1829,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.1",
      "ID": 1748
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2892,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Harvie, Patrick",
      "DisplayName": "Patrick Harvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.6376602+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2029E24P170VM239234",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 239234,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1829,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.1",
      "ID": 1748
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2029,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Henry, Hugh",
      "DisplayName": "Hugh Henry",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire South"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.7279612+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3758E268P409VM273833",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 273833,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1829,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.1",
      "ID": 1748
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3758,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hepburn, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie Hepburn",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Cumbernauld and Kilsyth"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.6376397+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4086E128P311VM304200",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 304200,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1829,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.1",
      "ID": 1748
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4086,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hume, Jim",
      "DisplayName": "Jim Hume",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.0279662+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1773E242P494VM221814",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 221814,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1829,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.1",
      "ID": 1748
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1773,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Hyslop, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona Hyslop",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Linlithgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:12.9489484+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1882E227P459VM242050",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 242050,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1829,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.1",
      "ID": 1748
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1882,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Ingram, Adam",
      "DisplayName": "Adam Ingram",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.7916619+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1893E16P69VM223796",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223796,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1829,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.1",
      "ID": 1748
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1893,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4741314+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4934E77P103VM307478",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307478,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1829,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Abstain",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.1",
      "ID": 1748
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4934,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Johnstone, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison Johnstone",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Green",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Green Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8312622+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4956E241P386VM272151",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 272151,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1829,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.1",
      "ID": 1748
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4956,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Keir, Colin",
      "DisplayName": "Colin Keir",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Western"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:30.1137854+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2059E26P131VM244797",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 244797,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1829,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.1",
      "ID": 1748
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2059,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kelly, James",
      "DisplayName": "James Kelly",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Rutherglen"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.5790461+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3129E261P419VM314970",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 314970,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1829,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.1",
      "ID": 1748
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3129,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Kidd, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Kidd",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Anniesland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.6684706+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2080E36P220VM251126",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251126,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1829,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.1",
      "ID": 1748
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, Johann",
      "DisplayName": "Johann Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Pollok"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.2284309+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4016E11P36VM274702",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 274702,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1829,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.1",
      "ID": 1748
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4016,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lamont, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Lamont",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.1180369+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2180E246P463VM256189",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 256189,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1829,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.1",
      "ID": 1748
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2180,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lochhead, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lochhead",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Moray"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.57444+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4938E158P374VM277852",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277852,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1829,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.1",
      "ID": 1748
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4938,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Lyle, Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Lyle",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9712193+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2112E250P486VM252623",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 252623,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1829,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.1",
      "ID": 1748
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2112,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacAskill, Kenny",
      "DisplayName": "Kenny MacAskill",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Eastern"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.7374361+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4939E258P394VM277240",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 277240,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1829,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.1",
      "ID": 1748
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4939,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Angus",
      "DisplayName": "Angus MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:31.9397258+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5074E251P385VM325660",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 325660,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1829,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.1",
      "ID": 1748
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5074,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Gordon",
      "DisplayName": "Gordon MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Edinburgh Pentlands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5158323+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1828E3P10VM232419",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232419,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1829,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.1",
      "ID": 1748
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1828,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacDonald, Margo",
      "DisplayName": "Margo MacDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Ind",
      "PartyName": "Independent",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8600435+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4948E153P363VM311015",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311015,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1829,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.1",
      "ID": 1748
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4948,
      "ParliamentaryName": "MacKenzie, Mike",
      "DisplayName": "Mike MacKenzie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.6017705+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2117E90P107VM230804",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 230804,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1829,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.1",
      "ID": 1748
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2117,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macdonald, Lewis",
      "DisplayName": "Lewis Macdonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.3462217+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2108E22P247VM267262",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 267262,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1829,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.1",
      "ID": 1748
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2108,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Macintosh, Ken",
      "DisplayName": "Ken Macintosh",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Eastwood"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.0118601+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4966E214P378VM313839",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313839,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1829,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.1",
      "ID": 1748
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4966,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mackay, Derek",
      "DisplayName": "Derek Mackay",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Renfrewshire North and West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4128884+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3101E102P129VM295487",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295487,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1829,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.1",
      "ID": 1748
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3101,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Malik, Hanzala",
      "DisplayName": "Hanzala Malik",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5142455+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5034E88P114VM318900",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 318900,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1829,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.1",
      "ID": 1748
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5034,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Marra, Jenny",
      "DisplayName": "Jenny Marra",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.6785531+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2159E25P205VM306517",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 306517,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1829,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.1",
      "ID": 1748
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2159,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Martin, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Martin",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Provan"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5554673+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5110E252P395VM311291",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 311291,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1829,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.1",
      "ID": 1748
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5110,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mason, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Mason",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Shettleston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.8723441+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2133E259P511VM268342",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 268342,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1829,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.1",
      "ID": 1748
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2133,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Matheson, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Matheson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Falkirk West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.2629866+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2876E141P433VM286074",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 286074,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1829,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.1",
      "ID": 1748
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2876,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Maxwell, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Maxwell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.356877+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4951E147P368VM260733",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 260733,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1829,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.1",
      "ID": 1748
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4951,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McAlpine, Joan",
      "DisplayName": "Joan McAlpine",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.0899241+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3896E175P307VM264134",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 264134,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1829,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.1",
      "ID": 1748
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3896,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McArthur, Liam",
      "DisplayName": "Liam McArthur",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Orkney Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.9257045+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5080E110P121VM308038",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 308038,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1829,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.1",
      "ID": 1748
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McCulloch, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McCulloch",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.8617725+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4964E143P375VM279269",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 279269,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1829,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.1",
      "ID": 1748
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4964,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDonald, Mark",
      "DisplayName": "Mark McDonald",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.4945436+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3824E84P113VM280015",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 280015,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1829,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.1",
      "ID": 1748
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3824,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McDougall, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret McDougall",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:32.5377458+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2066E22P91VM261811",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 261811,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1829,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.1",
      "ID": 1748
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2066,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McGrigor, Jamie",
      "DisplayName": "Jamie McGrigor",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:27.3791714+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4080E127P305VM299769",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 299769,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1829,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.1",
      "ID": 1748
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4080,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McInnes, Alison",
      "DisplayName": "Alison McInnes",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.7218207+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3759E260P411VM303367",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 303367,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1829,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.1",
      "ID": 1748
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3759,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McKelvie, Christina",
      "DisplayName": "Christina McKelvie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.8120331+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2487E146P369VM301722",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 301722,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1829,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.1",
      "ID": 1748
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2487,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Aileen",
      "DisplayName": "Aileen McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:39.2802777+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1775E215P453VM223630",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 223630,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1829,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.1",
      "ID": 1748
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1775,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLeod, Fiona",
      "DisplayName": "Fiona McLeod",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Strathkelvin and Bearsden"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.4670478+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1961E23P83VM237406",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 237406,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1829,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.1",
      "ID": 1748
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1961,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McLetchie, David",
      "DisplayName": "David McLetchie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Lothian"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:17.2028289+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2134E34P201VM297797",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 297797,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1829,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.1",
      "ID": 1748
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2134,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Uddingston and Bellshill"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.1254204+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5041E99P122VM320681",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 320681,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1829,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.1",
      "ID": 1748
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5041,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMahon, Siobhan",
      "DisplayName": "Siobhan McMahon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:44.1768873+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3763E142P397VM316112",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 316112,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1829,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.1",
      "ID": 1748
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3763,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McMillan, Stuart",
      "DisplayName": "Stuart McMillan",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "West Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.9466946+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1986E23P197VM236286",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 236286,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1829,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.1",
      "ID": 1748
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1986,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McNeil, Duncan",
      "DisplayName": "Duncan McNeil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Greenock and Inverclyde"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.9098572+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5047E100P130VM291448",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 291448,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1829,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.1",
      "ID": 1748
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5047,
      "ParliamentaryName": "McTaggart, Anne",
      "DisplayName": "Anne McTaggart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.119757+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1845E17P40VM235020",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 235020,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1829,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.1",
      "ID": 1748
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1845,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Milne, Nanette",
      "DisplayName": "Nanette Milne",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "North East Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.4101764+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3061E19P43VM313682",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 313682,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1829,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.1",
      "ID": 1748
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3061,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Mitchell, Margaret",
      "DisplayName": "Margaret Mitchell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:42.4059112+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1768E19P265VM288515",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 288515,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1829,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.1",
      "ID": 1748
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1768,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Murray, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Murray",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dumfriesshire"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1467212+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1894E267P527VM224990",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 224990,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1829,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.1",
      "ID": 1748
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1894,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Neil, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Neil",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Airdrie and Shotts"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.7398257+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3815E98P134VM270827",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 270827,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1829,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.1",
      "ID": 1748
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3815,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Park, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Park",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.8248272+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2010E219P514VM265997",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 265997,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1829,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.1",
      "ID": 1748
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2010,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Paterson, Gil",
      "DisplayName": "Gil Paterson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Clydebank and Milngavie"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:28.4699216+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5057E92P116VM283571",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283571,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1829,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.1",
      "ID": 1748
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5057,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pearson, Graeme",
      "DisplayName": "Graeme Pearson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.7139983+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2853E33P128VM251070",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 251070,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1829,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.1",
      "ID": 1748
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2853,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Pentland, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Pentland",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Motherwell and Wishaw"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:23.2257185+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5009E126P306VM317900",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317900,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1829,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.1",
      "ID": 1748
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5009,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Rennie, Willie",
      "DisplayName": "Willie Rennie",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.4422702+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3745E233P381VM254751",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 254751,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1829,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.1",
      "ID": 1748
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3745,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robertson, Dennis",
      "DisplayName": "Dennis Robertson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire West"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:24.2821809+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1870E225P478VM295575",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 295575,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1829,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.1",
      "ID": 1748
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1870,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Robison, Shona",
      "DisplayName": "Shona Robison",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dundee City East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:37.5181277+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2135E254P450VM234821",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234821,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1829,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.1",
      "ID": 1748
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2135,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Russell, Michael",
      "DisplayName": "Michael Russell",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Argyll and Bute"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.401201+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1895E232P431VM257302",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 257302,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1829,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.1",
      "ID": 1748
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1895,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Salmond, Alex",
      "DisplayName": "Alex Salmond",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeenshire East"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:25.0502966+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1839E21P87VM228068",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 228068,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1829,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.1",
      "ID": 1748
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1839,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scanlon, Mary",
      "DisplayName": "Mary Scanlon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:14.5829838+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2345E10P55VM292103",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 292103,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1829,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.1",
      "ID": 1748
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2345,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Ayr"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:36.1560768+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2223E176P333VM310627",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 310627,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1829,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.1",
      "ID": 1748
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2223,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Scott, Tavish",
      "DisplayName": "Tavish Scott",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "LD",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Liberal Democrats",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Shetland Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.5790581+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2182E87P175VM245980",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 245980,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1829,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.1",
      "ID": 1748
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2182,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Simpson, Dr Richard",
      "DisplayName": "Richard Simpson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.867024+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5079E101P119VM298355",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 298355,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1829,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.1",
      "ID": 1748
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5079,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Drew",
      "DisplayName": "Drew Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:38.3421767+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1769E32P285VM234389",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 234389,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1829,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.1",
      "ID": 1748
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1769,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Elaine",
      "DisplayName": "Elaine Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Coatbridge and Chryston"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:16.3751653+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4014E14P26VM269897",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269897,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1829,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "Yes"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.1",
      "ID": 1748
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4014,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Smith, Liz",
      "DisplayName": "Liz Smith",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Con",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Mid Scotland and Fife"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.5677098+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2215E224P447VM269119",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 269119,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1829,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.1",
      "ID": 1748
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2215,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stevenson, Stewart",
      "DisplayName": "Stewart Stevenson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Banffshire and Buchan Coast"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:29.3043981+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M3806E103P127VM317128",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 317128,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1829,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Yes",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.1",
      "ID": 1748
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 3806,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "Lab",
      "PartyName": "Scottish Labour",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:43.182889+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5106E228P372VM326170",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 326170,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1829,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.1",
      "ID": 1748
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5106,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Stewart, Kevin",
      "DisplayName": "Kevin Stewart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen Central"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:45.5428761+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1848E253P507VM241078",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 241078,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1829,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "Not Voted",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.1",
      "ID": 1748
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1848,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Sturgeon, Nicola",
      "DisplayName": "Nicola Sturgeon",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Southside"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3951279+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2098E237P531VM288773",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 288773,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1829,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.1",
      "ID": 1748
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2098,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Swinney, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Swinney",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Perthshire North"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:35.1577791+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2674E247P401VM247695",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 247695,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1829,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.1",
      "ID": 1748
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2674,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Thompson, Dave",
      "DisplayName": "Dave Thompson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:22.4244617+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5075E234P371VM284810",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 284810,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1829,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.1",
      "ID": 1748
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5075,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Torrance, David",
      "DisplayName": "David Torrance",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Kirkcaldy"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:34.0487372+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1793E151P362VM222390",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 222390,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1829,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.1",
      "ID": 1748
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1793,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Urquhart, Jean",
      "DisplayName": "Jean Urquhart",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Highlands and Islands"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:13.1868865+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M5078E245P366VM307166",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 307166,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1829,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.1",
      "ID": 1748
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 5078,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Walker, Bill",
      "DisplayName": "Bill Walker",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Dunfermline"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:40.5901163+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1841E231P426VM240200",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 240200,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1829,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.1",
      "ID": 1748
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1841,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Watt, Maureen",
      "DisplayName": "Maureen Watt",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Aberdeen South and North Kincardine"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:20.3491748+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4952E148P370VM283199",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 283199,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1829,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.1",
      "ID": 1748
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4952,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wheelhouse, Paul",
      "DisplayName": "Paul Wheelhouse",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "South Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:33.689991+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M1865E263P500VM232303",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 232303,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1829,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.1",
      "ID": 1748
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 1865,
      "ParliamentaryName": "White, Sandra",
      "DisplayName": "Sandra White",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow Kelvin"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:15.8489459+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M2610E160P413VM245705",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 245705,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1829,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.1",
      "ID": 1748
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 2610,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Wilson, John",
      "DisplayName": "John Wilson",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Central Scotland"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:21.8549047+00:00"
  },
  {
    "ID": "M4941E150P382VM309360",
    "Detail": {
      "ID": 309360,
      "MotionAgendaItemID": 1829,
      "AgendaID": 2907,
      "Decision": "Division",
      "DecisionID": 3,
      "VoteMSP": "No",
      "VoteResult": "Defeated",
      "VoteFor": 56,
      "VoteAgainst": 65,
      "VoteCasting": null,
      "MSPSharesParty": "No"
    },
    "Motion": {
      "Title": "Improving Learning Outcomes for All Young People in 2012",
      "Reference": "S4M-01677.1",
      "ID": 1748
    },
    "Person": {
      "ID": 4941,
      "ParliamentaryName": "Yousaf, Humza",
      "DisplayName": "Humza Yousaf",
      "PartyAbbreviation": "SNP",
      "PartyName": "Scottish National Party",
      "ConstituencyRegion": "Glasgow"
    },
    "Time": {
      "Start": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "End": "2012-01-12T00:00:00",
      "ParliamentaryYear": "S4-PY1",
      "Session": "S4"
    },
    "UpdatedElasticDate": "2026-10-16T11:47:41.3259467+00:00"
  }
]